UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

REGION 2 

AUG 1 9 2014 

The Honorable Joseph J. Martens 

Commissioner 

290 BROADWAY 

NEWYORK, NY 10007-1866 

New York State Department of Environmental Conservation 

625 Broadway 

Albany, New York 12233-1010 

Dear Commissioner Martens: 

Thank you for your recommendation dated October 2, 2013 of air quality designations for the 2012 

revised primary annual fine particle (PM2.s) National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) 

throughout New York. I appreciate the information New York shared with the U.S. Environmental 

Protection Agency as we move forward to improve PM2.s air quality. This letter is to notify you of the 

EPA's preliminary response to New York's recommendation and to inform you of our approach for 

completing the initial area designations for the 2012 revised primary annual PM2.5 standard. 

On December 14, 2012, the EPA promulgated a revised primary annual PM2.5 NAAQS (78 FR 3086, 

January 15, 2013). In that action, the EPA revised the primary annual PM2.5 standard, strengthening it 

from 15.0 micrograms per cubic meter (~-tg/m ) to 12.0 ~-tg/m ; retained the existing 24-hour PM2.5 

standard at 35 ~-tg/m ; retained the existing 24-hour PM10 (coarse particle) standard at 150 ~-tg/m ; and 

retained the current suite of secondary PM standards. The EPA revised the primary annual PM2.5 

standard based on an integrated assessment of an extensive body of new scientific evidence, which 

substantially strengthens our body of knowledge regarding PM2.5-related health effects. The revised 

primary annual PM2.s standard will provide increased protection for children, older adults, persons with 

pre-existing heart and lung disease, and other at-risk populations against an array of PM2.5-related 

adverse health effects, including premature mortality, increased hospital admissions and emergency 

department visits, and development and exacerbation of chronic respiratory disease. 

History shows us that better health and cleaner air go hand-in-hand with economic growth. Working 

closely with the states and tribes, the EPA is implementing the standards using a commonsense approach 

that improves air quality and minimizes the burden on state, local, and tribal governments. As part of 

this routine process, the EPA is working with the states and tribes to identify areas in the country that 

meet the standards and those that need to take steps to reduce PM2.5 air pollution. Within one year of 

promulgating a new or revised air quality standard, the Clean Air Act requires the Governor of each 

state to submit to the EPA a list of all areas in the state, with a designation recommendation for each 

area. As a first step in implementing the 2012 annual PM2.5 standard, Governors were to submit their 

designation recommendations, including app~opriate area boundaries, by December 13, 2013. 

lntemet Address (URL) • http://www.epa.gov 

Recycled/Recyclable • Printed with Vegetable 011 Based Inks on Recycled Paper (Minimum 50% Postconsumer content) 
As required by the Clean Air Act, the EPA then promulgates designations for all areas across the 

country. The EPA designates an area as "nonattainment" if it is violating the 2012 annual PM2.s NAAQS 

or if it is contributing to a violation of the NAAQS in a nearby area. Consistent with designations for 

previous PM2.5 standards, the EPA intends to use a designation category of "unclassifiable/attainment" 

for areas that are monitoring attainment or do not have monitors, but for which the EPA has reason to 

believe are likely attainment and are not contributing to nearby violations. Additionally, the EPA intends 

to designate as "unclassifiable" those areas where the EPA cannot determine based on available 

information whether the area is meeting the NAAQS or where EPA has not determined that the area 

contributes to a nearby violation. At this time, the EPA is proceeding with intended initial area 

designations using quality-assured, certified air quality monitoring data from 2011 to 2013. 

We have considered the annual PM2.5 designation recommendations submitted by New York on October 

2, 2013, and have reviewed the relevant technical information, including 2011- 2013 air qu~lity data. 

These data do not indicate any violation ofthe 2012 annual PM2.5 NAAQS in New York or contribution 

to any nearby area. Accordingly, the EPA intends to designate the entire state ofNew York as 

unclassifiable/ attainment. 

The EPA will make its preliminary designation decisions and supporting documentation available to the 

general public for review and comment. We will be announcing a 30-day public comment period shortly 

in the Federal Register. After considering the additional information we receive, the EPA plans to 

promulgate final annual PM2.s designations in December of2014. 

The EPA is committed to working with the states and tribes to share the responsibility of reducing PM2.5 

air pollution. Current and upcoming federal standards and safeguards- including pollution reduction 

rules for power plants, vehicles, and fuels- will ensure steady progress to reduce PM2.5-forming 

pollution and will protect public health in communities across the country. We look forward to a 

continued dialogue with you and your staff as we work together to implement the 2012 annual PM2.5 

standard. Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me, or have your staff contact 

Richard Ruvo of our Air Programs Branch at 212-637-4014 or ruvo.richard@epa.gov. 

Sincerely, 

Judith A. Enck 

Regional Administrator 

cc: David Shaw, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation 

Robert Sliwinski, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation 

Janet G. McCabe, Acting Assistant Administrator for Air and Radiation 

Stephen D. Page, Director, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards 

•