!"!
#$$$
%&

'"
%
&
 $
$$
(
 
   $ $ "    $$
%"
"
 $(
 
  $
$"
&%"
'
 )
  *
" 
# $ 
$$
%&! !&)
$$
*
" 
&  
$$
  $
 
)%$
5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,213XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU)LOH 1DPH DS
	*(+,-./'0,-!'+!1',222222222222222223$/(3 -229(5"	4$75,&,$+$'$%$8*+"
"
		56$$
 1/
3!/3 (
!777869:
"3;6<6$="==3
*<("==> <+?6">(@@/"
!(9."!;22222222222222222	
	  >
 : A" /!-(,,./,.'" A(0 B31"!"(" 6$$
. ;9"*6+9(C B 9.C'/ 99!" 3" ("  6$$
>!+
"/!-(,,./,.'"A(0B31"!"(" 6$$
.;9"*6+9(CB9.C'/99!"3"(" 6$$=	
		
	>(@@/";"&$ "+?6";"%!(9.";D$$	E"&
$

$$

$
>(@@/" ! ;  '  &  
 



 $$
$$"$
 
&
 

$$


  
 %  C 
  
#    
& %"   
$$
"   
    
)   
% 
 "

 
  
 
     
   
  
   $) &
 
  $
   C 
 
 
#  




$

  (   "   
  
#%"

$ 
$$
("
 
 



3
 -& 
 $   !&" (">3$




$,

 -&)$
"F  3$
"   
 
 $3 $"-&
$&"6/"&$$$  $   , 
 


<-&&
 #  $ 
  
  $ $$&$
$%:/ 	
		
	!"  
# % & 
 $ $$
) 
$$
  -
 
$$
 
 
$$
 
 



 

$ 
$
 )&  
"
&%
$$
 
(


#%&$$"
% 

'
"
%&


 $ 


,
%
$
%   
   
  $&&
$ 
&
&
$$
%C

" 
#   % &   
  $

 
$"

% 
,
% 

$$
)

  
   
    -&)
$
$&
>
 &&$  
"
&%   
+


"'$
) 
 "	
		
"=*/$$=	="	===
D/3(=E*
"  !   !& #  
&  !$
$$
%&

$$ $

-&"$
$$
%$$

#$
$$



 &   
& %   	 "
	1/
"
D77
EG!	"#	$"H*

"
==	D!777E-"
)
$
$


 


$
 $" "  $
 $

 $)  $    !   !&)	
		
	

	
+@1?!(9.";+"$
"$
,
$  &<DE     
    &
 
 
-&
 $ G DE      
 &
 
 -&)$
$
 
#  $$
 G DE    
  -&)$
$
 
#  

$$

G
D&E
%! !&
$$ $

,
% >
 '&

 
"

'
$ 
%)

  "'$

(   " 
   $$
%&
 
 $$
"

$$
$ 
   
$$
  ( %  

$$
 

 
 
 
 I$&& 
&
$
 J%&"=
*
		"
	7D!=E"'"1/9C
HD:
=H"==ED	=EG(	  
" 
 * 
" 
 D!77HEDI6 

 
 

$$
! 
$$
&&

$
 
$
 
&
 


JE3$

"
$$

$ 
&&
 
&
$
 8
# !  
 $    
	
		
	/
 "

/-&
$$&&
$%
/

#-&$ $ $ 
 -& 
  
  $ ,! >$&&
$$
/-&"$ 
 -& 
     $  $-&"$"! D

$ 

E
&
$
 

$$&-& " 
"  
 $ $" !4
#4
# ! 
$
$$&! 
 > 3$
/$! $ "$

C  
$
"/  4
#" 
 
 -& 
$$&  $  , !& 
" 4
+


" 
 /  -&      &
 
 &  &
 
 4
# 
4
#
 $&


"  !
 ' $%"   
$
/
#4
#
&
G4
# ,!
'

 
 
) 
 
    (>!,> -
 /
 
 
   $ 
G-& &
"     
F
  , $ 
 $$&-& +




&

& $-& "

 :>

7
&
C
 
$ $ 
  
 " /
 
 $
$/
$6
 "-&
& $  -& $#   >	
		
	3$
) 6& >
"   
 $   
 
 
" 
  3$
) $$$
-& 
@
K" 
 $$" 
3$


&
-&

$&) "  
    -&


$G
- 
 

 
 $&  -& 
 $ $
+



/
-&$>3$

 $$ 



$$&$
 $%  3 
  -& 
  

$$$
    I$  
  
 & J-&


%
%$
 F3$
$/
-&

$



,$
)$  G&"  
     -& 
$$$$

 



>3$

//-&/



/$
-&

-& /
/

 
"



 
/ "
-& 
/
,&
-&$/  " 
 
< I'  
#" ')#J'

 "-&
& 
$$
-
 
&
-&


&$$


    
G



#$

"
$

,$	
		
	

 

 
J)

7'
"

 
$$   
 

  

G 
  
 
   $
 
"  
   
   
%"

 

 

 &
  
 -&  '   $
" 


"
("
 


 


$$
$
&
&G 
$"




$ $




$
&$
"


 
 
G

$

&



,

&
C



 

 #$
&C

"


 $
"


<


 
#


$&
"&$
" $
 )$$

&    3$
 &
  !>
"
#%&)

 



 
)
&
*  
& 
"  
    )
 
      

"

 
$$
 
# %=	
		
	3! $$ $$
%

 L%&


)J("=
*

7"*
+'"7*	=
"	=HD!77E(<IMCN& 
   ) 
 
   MN   

 
    $$

 
  J)
3 




 -&   

  %& 


" 
 
 
 $ 

$&



$
 
(

 ("
 
)'(" 
 &  
 
 

$    
# 
 
 $

 

)


7,
$ 
 
  
 
     

 
 
 
I%& 


 DE
$

  
$
$GD=E $  
$G  
 DE  &  $   
 $J)
,
$$I  J" 

 

 

"

" 

 

"
  )   
 %   
 -&" 
( " 
   
  


$$

 "
  
 ,(

&
$$I   J 
 
 
 I  J 

 

  ,( $
 	 
(


$$


  )


77,(
 
$$

I%& $
  $ 
  ) 	
		
	$ 
&":/
#" 
-&
&#"
-&#

-&"-&
 "


 /
#
 

-&
&


" -& 
 
  , 
 
  
<DE 

#
GD=E  " 
" 
"  


$&GDE

$&G
D	E 
  $
 #    ,
 -& 
$$
"(
-&&

$$
!& /&!G 
$$
 


-&&
"

 
&
*6 $"$"
($$
-$


 &
 
,&
 
& 
%      
  G $
& 
%

$  $1$&

-&)$
"
 
  
 
 

 % 
 DE  $ 
   $GD=E
$G
DE 
)&

-&
I
  
      %  J  C $ -&)$
"

&
#
, 
) 
% 
 , 
 
 
  
& 
 -& &    
 
$$,&
 
 	
		
	
$$
 & 
 C  
$$
 
 $" -& & 
 &
 
)
$$
"


#%


$$


 



-&
&$
)$$
"
$



$$
    
$$
   &
 
, 
$
  ! "!#$%&& 'C

#
&%


$$
 
)
%
 "
#$
 ) 

"
 


 
)&


$C
;   
   =H 1/! O =7D77	EG

%

$$
 
 %      6 
   
%

 
%"=H*=7
D!==EG,,"

1/	"7 D77
E   -&"   
   
 

$$



DE 

$ 

  
 "
D=E
$$
 
$

$&"

 
&
 


('	 )
	 &	 "  1/ 
	 D7	7EG!'#"	=1/
D7H
E6 
#"/$!,,"
1/ 	 D77
E" 
     

 
&%&
$$
 

   
 %  
  G%      )  	
		
	$&
1$"
#%&
 

#
 


	"7H*
=H( 
#%!#'!)#*%
  !#+*6
&"/!
$
  
  
  $  
   '  
 $
 ) 
 
#  
 
&
"$



	
&
" = * 	=" 	H D ! =E  ,  



	#-
	"	
1/HD7H=E<

"$$ 
 "
I



 


$
&#J)

HH6

 


 



&

  >
     
$$
"  
& %  &  )     
 $    
 $,,"

1/	D77
E'
"
<+

 
"
3 

" 
"  
$" 
 $" 

$ $
#$
 
 
   $  &
  *66
#%&"$$
"
)


 
 
)&
 
 
" 
 % &  $ 
    




!	""H*

73 
(
(	"=
*
7	D! =E"   
 
  
 
 I
 MN 
$$
 
 
      	
		
	$


  
G  $   
 & 

 
 $

 
)

=H7  ,  
 &  
% 
 ," 

$$
)

=7,/!
"


 

 

 
) 


$

 
"
$$

  %        $
 )&
 
)&
)

=H'
" 





 -&) 
<  
 
  
  
 



/-&"&
$ &$
 

  

&
  
*"
 
  $
  
  / 
-&% -&)
>-&)$" / 
  $
 
" 

&

"


&
-&

/ 
""
 -& 

 
"
-&
$

"& "

 ,


*" & 
 



-&
$  
$ $
#$ 
    3$
  -& 
  $  
  $&)   - 


%%$
 $3$
) 
$
-&)



  
#
/ 


$$&"
 "

$,
&

 

 

&
 
 	
		
	 $ 
, " 


 
$$
 
 
&      
  G &"  
      $$
$
I


MN 


 

  
 
J"=H*
=7H"(	 
" 
 * 
" 
 D ! 77HE D



EIM@N& 
$ 
 "

 
 &

 
&




 


$
& #J 	  #-
	" 	
 1/ H" HHD7H=E' 
 
$$
" 
   

"     !'#"	=1/
"
= D7H
E,/!$
$$
 *""$
 ) 
"  
  
 
 &
/"
&
&&I
 
 
    

 $  
& #J '$ !'	"*
"
HD!77E,     
    
) &
 
 -&  '     
   $$"
  ' 
  
    
" $$,

   

 
 
     

 $ &  
 -&C
&

 

1'$"  
  
#    $
 ) 
 $  
 
&
"

&

  
 
 
 
 C


&%& 

H	
		
	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́ DSSHDODEOH XQGHU   WKLV ZDV GHVSLWH WKH IDFW WKDWUHYLHZ RI WKDW GHWHUPLQDWLRQ ZRXOG EH SXUHO\ OHJDO %HFDXVH ZH GR QRWEHOLHYH LQ WKLV FDVH WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW LQFRUUHFWO\ GHWHUPLQHG WKDWWKHUH ZDV D JHQXLQH LVVXH RI PDWHULDO IDFW ZH QRWH EXW GR QRW DQVZHU WKLVTXHVWLRQ
 


   

 
 
       

 
 &
  >
 
  
 



 

"
 
# %, 
  !#-#!,

#

 

$
 )

" "


&
-"==/!=
H D==E"*
 	'  %	-" 
 1/ 7	" =D=E-"-&



 
&
  $*6C$$





$$"#*"$
$('	"
*"HD!77HE/$$ 
% $"'$!"	1/H" 	 D7HEG &" % 
    $
 

 



'$
(
.
'"71/
"
HD7HEI'#

"    
 $) 
  $ 
 "	
		
	7 
 
 
      $"


#"$
$$"    
$   
 
     
 $J /	 	%"=	*
="
D!77	E/"  
) 
& 
   
%
#
$ 
 
$
&('"
*
H,"I
&
MN&


 $
 
 
 $       $
 )
J)
-"-&)$ 
 
F

$$$!&>3$
C
&
$ $
 "$



 $!	" # 	$" H * 

" 
= D ! 777ED 
$
 $
  $    * 6$E  6     "   $ 
    
)  
 

,


& 
   $  
 $   
!	""H*

=,$
 
*6$
# 
)&

-&C 
)   
 " I
 % $


$$$
J!	'/	$"H*="D!7HE6

#

    
 
 $   

&    
  
&  $$   
#  
('"
*
HH=C !)	
-"7H* =
 D ! 777E" $&    
&%


$$

)




 
  
  &  '	"