7KH +RQRUDEOH &KDUOHV 5 6LPSVRQ 

IRU WKH :HVWHUQ 'LVWULFW RI .HQWXFN\ VLW



5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	





1,7(' 	7$7(6 2) 0(5,&$

	






$55</ /($9(6

	



 !"#
$%"&	"

 "#*'" $%'" %("

,,-.,/0)%	1%2

 3)&4 %-

(%&&$&%&4

7 4
18$&+

	
+:	%'" %






	  2 "  7 ;' $"  #!' < : ; 		8+!#%'
- 

 

7KH GHIHQGDQW DOVR UDLVHV WKH SRVVLELOLW\ WKDW WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW PD\

UHYHUVH LWVHOI DQG H[WHQG $SSUHQGL WR UHTXLUH WKDW 3WKH IDFW RI D SULRU

FRQYLFWLRQ> @ PXVW EH VXEPLWWHG WR D MXU\ DQG SURYHG EH\RQG D UHDVRQDEOHGRXEW ́ ,Q RUGHU WR SUHVHUYH WKDW JURXQG IRU WKH IXWXUH LW KDV EHHQLQFOXGHG LQ KLV EULHI RQ DSSHDO


2 "7 ;'+!#%'$$''  $"  #!' < : ;  		
	 

		8+!#%'$$'' 







+
1 
18% ()%" 0)&3  #

&$&$" =>'?'%$&%("&$3?%"#'>$(&$&$"'%$'%$3()$"%$&%("!$"(# 3%$3($'% (="&%'" %2)"%$@(''%>;%3 !'((%$$&;%3 !'! %A)$?$""" %$ % ""# '"#	) !) "B'%$%$%$	





	66C-D$&?'($>%("&2=A) ="#"#&$"2$%$'" )("&"%$&%"# "#"= "#E)$"%"= ($" & ')2'"$(' %$>>& %$ "# ($'% (=  "'$"$(%$3"#&%'" %("() ")$&"#""# ( &F%$=G')'"%$&  ($'% (= " &%'" %2)" 2"?$ %> $& ;%3 !'((%$$&%!'&%'$"$(2'&$"#"%$&%$3$&$'"")" =$#$(!$" ')"%$3 !"#&$&$"B' % $=& )3($>%("%$'%"%$3	

$&
.5&-,C6"#% ,,,D"#&$&$"$?%$'%'"'"#"#%'')2A(""'$"$($! "#$"$= '"#'"")" =!@%!)! ($'% (="&%'" %2)" '' "#$  ;%3 !'  ! %A)$  #

3> $!$" '$&'2= 3)%$3"#""#&%'" %("() "&%&$"  %$ %$&%$3 "#" >' ?' %2   ($'% (= "&%'" %2)" ((%$ 2)" ($(&' "#" "# (' !)'" 2 !$&&   '$"$(%$3   " % $ "# $3"#  "#'$"$( " 2 %!'& 2()' "# A) = &%& $" !; '(%%(%$&%$3$"#E)$"%"=%$>>&%$"#($'% (=
 

  "# '$' '" )" 23> $!$"B''%"%$

	

	

!,,."# )3#,,, 

&$&$"'$&'> "# )$%$ & )3" %(;%$3  "%$ 2"?+!#%'$$''>' %$" &)(&"'& )3')% 	 &)= )H"# )3# %$&"# %2%%"=>'""#%$" !%""$"=%$>>&%$"#(")$&! %A)$

	# "= "  2%$3 %$" &)(& 

23$2)=%$3((%$ !#%!!&"'"%>$&''%2='!%$"#(!$=$"#  %$&(#"#'" %'>') (#((%$" %>')(#" $''$&%$3() % $&#F?( = ;%3 !'  ((%$   ! ' "+!#%'  >%$ "%$'#%?%"#	 &)= )H) '2)=%$3((%$%$"#"# (&$&$"'%$()&%$30"';& 	 &)= )H " ( "  ')"!2% "#) '" $'$&+!#%'	 &)= )(! "!$"%$"# "#@("="#'%H;%2(;" &%'(> &%"%$' (#

) %$3$"#" %'2"?$

$&$"#$== $ %'? '@'%(%( ?#)$&%$"#" )$;"#( ?#%(##&2%$+!#%'2=>'
 

 

"   ' %'  '"%$3  "%$' "# &$&$"' ? 

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

7()'"#? &%$3"#%$&%("!$""#&%'" %("() "

$&"# '()"  (3$%H&"#"'(%> &%("!%3#"2%$&%("&$"#"?)& E)% "#A) ="&" !%$?#";%$&($" &')2'"$(! %A)$ ((%$C 2"#D?'%$>>&%$"#($'% (=
"%!"="#() " '$&"#"2()'"# (%&%>%'!$#$(!$""#"?)&2%&">'B''$"$(%$"#>$"#%'($>%("%$"#!@%!)!'$"$(?)&2"#'! 3 &''"#"=  & )3 %$>>&  # () " "#   &(%$& "%$'" )(""#A) =" ") $'(%> &%("$&"#&$&$"($() &%$"#%'&(%'%$+ > ?%"#)""#2$%"	

"3)%&# "#&%'" %("A)&3'%&"%$'" )("

"# A) = "#" %" !)'" %$& "# E)$"%"=  "# ($" &')2'"$('%$>>&%$"#($'% (=2=$& '$2&)2"
$'"&"#A) =?'(# 3&4

<&%' $& 3$"!$ $ "#%$3 &&%"%$  #%$&%("!$"!$"%$' "%() E)$"%"=((%$$& "%() E)$"%"=! %A)$#3> $!$"&'$" #> " '"2%'# "# @(" E)$"%"=  ($" &')2'"$("#"%'3&%$"#%$&%("!$"
"%'')%(%$"

 

,W LV WHOOLQJ WKDW WKH SURVHFXWRU GH

DPRXQW LQ WKH LQGLFWPHQW UHTXHVWHG D MXU\ WKH MXU\ QHHG QRW ILQG DQ\ VSHFLILF GU&OHDYHV¶V JXLOW ,Q UHTXHVWLQJ WKH LQVWUH[SUHVVHG FRQFHUQ WKDW KH PLJKW QRW KDPRUH WKDQ ILYH NLORJUDPV RI FRFDLQH EH\R)"!2% $ 0$) = 5 ,,!)$"((%$ !A(;"%$ $"& 2= >' ?' (()%&($'% " '0" $& %'%(' (# >&"#">#%&&$ (! "!$" &'%3$&  #> &  '$2 A) = " (%$>>& %$  & )3 ($'% (= &" !%$"%$"#!)$"((%$&%("%$$"# ( &"#"$= >  (> &2="#)"# %"%' " %
 
 !

%$="#&$&$" 3)'"#

#>2$ E)% &"')2!%">%&" "# A) = %$  &  " '"2% '$2&)2"?> "#"# @%'"$(   %  ($>%("%&$&$"B' '$"$(   !"" '&%'" %("() " 
C6"#% -DC$2$(DC	

($>%("%$' !"#'(" '"#"2=$& '$2&)2"D



 "# '$''")"2>?

($>%("%$ ($'% (="&%'" %2L"#'$"$(%$3 & $&&%'" %("() "  '$"$(%$3%$(
 

 

"=?'%!  =&" !%$&2="#" %A)&3 "# "#$"#A) =D

(( &%$3="#&%'" %("() "B''"> &%("&" !%$"%$

"#& )3%$>>&"3"# %'"%!)3$"#% $''%$"3 %"= )2%( )""%$"#A)&%(% (&%$3'%$"#%'(''"#	) !) " ($"=@%$&%$
4

JK#% $''$&%$"3 %"="#( %!%$A)'"%('='"! &$&' $ !"%$3 )" "#' %$%("%$3 "#3 "'"# !$'(%"="#!'"'> )$%'#!$"'# "# ""#$""#M% $''%$"3 %"=$&)2%( )""%$  A)&%(%   (&%$3'B ?)& 2 % '$&$"' &'%" "# > ?#!%$3 $&)$($" > "&>%&$("#""#=? %$>>&%$>'"& )3($'% (=? " (%>'$"$( '( %2&  "#' (!!%""%$3 '' ')2'"$"% & )3 $''2()'$  "#"?'$> 2A("&""" %

-- 	" " ..  $( ? %$& $ > '%2    %$($$("%$ ?%"# "# &%'" %(" () "B' &(%'%$ "  3 '(%> &%("'""#& )3"=#$	% #


$ ($" '" ?%"#"#&%'" %(" () "B'&" !%$"%$"#

& )3"=#?> ?!)'"($()&"#""#&" !%$"%$"#& )3!)$"%' > '%2   E)% %$3 '$"$(%$3#"'"%!$=%$"# ( &($( $%$3"#!)$"((%$%$>>&%$"#($'% (=%' '()"%>+%3)	 &)= )H(($'% " $&"# %! =3> $!$"?%"$''""'"%= " "# !)$"  ((%$ #$&& 2= >' ?')$2" (?%"#$=&3 ( "%$"="#$)!2 " %'!&?%"#>' "#!)$"& )3') (#'&$(#" %

) "# "#A) =()&'%=#>&%'!%''&	 &)= )HB'

"'"%!$=$&'"% ") $&3)%"=> &%("2'&)$"#"'"%!$="# ?%"$'''%$()&%$3@':%(%( N$"7'%$3 ?#"'"%%&"#"#'"&7)%(;<	2 

 

7KH EXUGHQ RI UHTXHVWLQJ D VSHFLI

JRYHUQPHQW 6HH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y %DUQH

 KROGLQJ WKDW LW LV WKH JRYHUQPHQYHUGLFW 8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y *DUFLD  )G 

3:KHQ WKH LQIRUPDWLRQ VRXJKW LQ WKH VSVHQWHQFH WR EH LPSRVHG LW LV WKH GXW\ RI WKYHUGLFW DQG ZH ZLOO UHYLHZ WKH VHQWHQFH GWKH GHIHQGDQW ZDV DVNHG LI KH ZDV VDWLQFOLQDWLRQ WR QRW UHTXHVW D VSHFLILF YHUG+HQFH WKH GHIHQGDQW GLG QRW SURSHUO\ DSSHOODWH UHYLHZ  )G 

"#"%"#3> $!$"'"2%'#($" &')2'"$(?'%$(""#')2A(""#("'3&%$ (%'!)$"%$&%$3'""$('' =  =)"!;%$&&$&$" %' 3)%"=   $" 3)%?#%(##?'(# 3&?%$3"#3$ > &%(" 

($'% (="#&%'" %("() ")$&>%&$("#""#($" &')2'"%2?'((%$$&"#""#!;%3 !'7'&$#%'($>%("%$= & )3 ($>%("%$' # (%! %'$!$" )$&  - 
	 '#%''$"$(

	

	#$&'

>' 3)'$"#"%$

&%'" %("() "%!  =&" !%$%$"#($'% (=%$>%"%$5& -, 5 C6"# %  ,,,D  2A("""#A) =%$'" )("%$"#" "#%'" %%$&&#(E)%'&% %$  $= &


.
	.-
6 

 

 >%?%'$ ?%$'(%$>>%$3 CD %$&%$3  C-D"#"%'%$$&C5D"#"("'"#&$&$"B'')2'"$"% %3#"' 
-
	6C,,.D>$%"# "#'(" '  '$"??% > '$"#2'%'')(#  $=%%"F' %)'=("J'K"#% $'' %$"3 %"=   )2%( )""%$  A)&%(% (&%$3'G.
	".5-9  
5
	--	".C--D

%"-
	O6 >%&'"#""#&$&$" (%>

F"#'!$"%''"#' '( %2& "#$'"#(!!%''%$?#%(#?'"#2A(""#($'% (=G
$  
  ? #& "#" ?#$  ($'% (=

()$" 3' !  "#$ $ ')2'"$"%> $' $& "#> &%("%'3$  "# "#$'(%%("#&$&$"!=$"2 '$"$(&" !  "#$"# !@%!)! '$"$(  "#$'?%"#"#'# " '"")" =!@%!)!.5&"5-

""#"%!" %"#&%'" %("A)&3B'&(%'%$" 3

'(%> &%(" ')"& !#  (3$%"%$"#"3%>$"#!)$"  2"# ! %A)$ $& ((%$ 3& %$ "#%$&%("!$" ($>%("%$ ($'% (= "&" %"# & )3( %&"#'!'"")" =!@%!)!-
	O

C2DCDCDPC7D #%'&(%'%$?') "# %$ !&2="#

(""#"""#"%!"# )%$3"#" %A)&3?'(# 3&?%"#"# '$'%2%%"=&" !%$%$3"#!)$"& )3'%$>>&%$"#($'% (=(( &%$3=?%"#"#''$"2"#"# '()" $&"#&$&$""#&%'" %("() "#&"#"A) =&" !%$"%$"#'(%%(& )3%$>>&%$"#($'% (= ?' )$$('' =  ?>  #& "# &%'" %("() "B' )%$3(() &" "#	) !) "B'&(%'%$%$	

 
5
	66 C-D"# () "

?)& )$&)2"&= #> )$& "#" 2()' "# '"")" =!@%!)!        ! %A)$ $&((%$ &% & & !"%(= "# A) = '#)& #> 2$&% ("& " !;  '(%%( %$&%$3 ($( $%$3 "# & )3%$>>&%$"#$' 
-
	OC2DCDCDC%!%"%$3'$"$( $)$;$?$E)$"%"=((%$"5= 'D-
	OC2DCDCDC%!%"%$3'$"$( 

$)$;$?$E)$"%"=! %A)$""$= 'D

 

$V H[SODLQHG E\ WKH 6XSUHPH &RX

GHFLVLRQ WKDW 3μDIIHFWV VXEVWDQWLDO ULJKWV¶ DV D GHFLVLRQ WKDW DIIHFWHG WKH RXWFRPH RI  FLWLQJ 2ODQR  86 DW  ,Q D VHQWHQFLQJ RQ WKH FRFDLQH UDWKHU WKDQ WKRI WKH UHVXOWLQJ VHQWHQFH +RZHYHU LW VHHIDLOXUH WR VXEPLW WKH GHWHUPLQDWLRQ RI DIIHFWHG WKH RXWFRPH EHFDXVH RI WKH RYHUZSUHVHQWHG FRQFHUQLQJ GUXJ W\SH $FFRUDQDO\WLFDO DSSURDFK RI WKH 6XSUHPH &RXDQG LQ -RKQVRQ Y 8QLWHG 6WDWHV  83VXEVWDQWLDO ULJKWV ́ TXHVWLRQ DQG GLVPLVVIRU FRQVLGHUDWLRQ LI WKH HUURU DIIHFWHG WK

UHSXWDWLRQ RI MXGLFLDO SURFHHGLQJV


$& 	

%) "%$'" 

2"#"#"=& )3$&"#& )($'% (=!)$"&"%$  -
	66C,,.DCF" %?''""&$&( =($%"%'$)3#"#"$  " ($'%& "%$GD *#"#')2'"$"% %3#"'G%'''( 2)%'')2()'?%$&"#""#  "# % $'' %$"3 %"=   )2% (&%$3'G 


#>%&$("#">'?'%

&%'" %2)"((%$?'> ?#!"'"%!$=&"%%$3"#!$=" %$& "#2"?$"#') ((%"=%(;%$3) '> ;%3 !'( "&""#'( "(! "!$"%  ((%$ " $' " "# ( & >' ?'  ((%$ &  "'"%!$= '$"&"" %?($()&#>)$&"#">'?"&%'" %2)"! %A)$ "# "#$
 ! -- 5& 5- 5C> ?#!%$3 >%&$( ($( ')%(%$"")#&($>%("%$$