par - osT'Zoo o -(cr^-^ S Januar y18 , 201 2 1 T" ' > •\ ,-,::;TrTjr- M

n i^ M o rr > 1 : ? q Mr . Denni s Devan y. . - Chief , Essentia l Ai rServic e an d Domesti cAnalysi s Divisio n Wes tBuilding , 8t h Floo r 120 0 Ne wJerse yAvenue , S E Washington , DC 2059 0 Als o a tDennis.DeVanv(g)dot.go v Re : Docke tDOT-OST-2000-6773 , Notic e o fPetitio n fo r Reconsideratio n Dea rMr . D e Vany : Pacifi cWing s i s petitionin g th e awar d o fth e Essentia l Ai r Servic e subsid yt o anothe rairlin e citin g deficiencie s i n th e awar d process . Withou tgoin g int o exhaustin g detail , I woul d lik e thre e area s considere d i n you rdecision . 1 . Pacifi cWing' s lawyer s wer e 1 0 day s lat e i n filin g thei rpetition . Yo u hav e allowe d thei rclai m t o g o forwar d despit e thi s deficiency . Th e clai m wa s submitte d pas t publishe d deadline s an d therefor e

### shoul d no tb e considere d fo rfurthe rdiscussio n an d

th e awar d o fth e EA

S shoul d b e mad e a

s pe rth e Orde rSelectin g Carrier . 2 . Acomparativ e revie wo ftrip s fo rPacifi cWing s an d th e ne wEA

S carrie rfo rth e firs t2 0 days o fservic e i n Decembe rindicat e clearl ytha tPacifi cWing s wa s no t providin g servic e acceptabl e t o loca l users . I n th e Decembers previou s t o thi s year , I n th e Decembe r 1 0 t o Decembe r3 0 period . Pacifi cWing s carrie d les s tha n 5 0 individuals . Wit h th e ne wEA S service , tha t numbe rwa s 210 . Thi s indicate s tha tpen tu p deman d wa s almos t 4 time s tha t provid e byPacifi c Wing s an d i twa s Pacifi cWing s servic e tha t pre^nte d th e norma l an d accustome d us e by residents . Th e purpos e o fth e EA S i s t o allo wservic e availabl e t o norma l U

S citizen s i n norma l marke t situations . Pacifi cWing s prevente d that , th e ne w carrie rusin g th e EA

S subsid yallow s it . 3 . Informatio n cite d i n th e petitio n indicate s a lac k o f cooperatio n wit h th e airline , i n som e cases obstructio n wit h thei roperatio n an d a genera l lac k o fassistanc e t o allo wPacifi cWing s t o operate . I n poin to ffact . Pacifi cWing s remove d a whee l chai r lif tfro m th e Kalaupap a airport , impedin g th e trave l o fpatients , change d schedule s withou tnotificatio n a tleas ttwic e i n tw o years , an d modifie d far eschedule s an d ho wfare s wer e mad e availabl e o n th e

Interne tan d telephon e withou tnotice . Al l o fthes e thing s wer e counte rt o encouragin g ai rtrave l wit h th e sam e eas e an d acces s afforde d ai l othe rU S traveler s o n commercia l carriers . An d as a fina l note , th e servic e provide d b yth e ne wEA S carrie rha s bee n ver yadaptiv e t o loca l need s an d request s b ypatien tfamilie s an d visitor s t o b e abl e t o ge t t o an d fro m work , t o an d fro m tours , t o an d fro m famil y gathering s an d accommodate d i n th e amoun to fluggag e neede d b yth e travelin g public , al l wit h a consideratio n t o keepin g cost s lo wan d encourag e trip s o n th e airline . Th e Patient s an d Resident s o fKalaupap a Settlemen ta s Show n o n th e Attache d Pag ePatient s an d Resident s o fKalaupap a I n Suppor to f

Makan i Ka i EA

S Servic e fo rKalaupap a Airpor t PRIN T^]^mK}~ ^ SIG N - ^ / n

\JL 3 \ t ^ a s « ^ (-VA^^ ^

A 

### InJM^u^

d '^^/^^-^-^

^ ' ^ ^

pRijVJ J CUyi^^-i^

^ YtcJuJL-^^O ^

SIG N

Patient s an d Resident s o fKalaupap a I n Suppor t o fMakan i Ka i EA S Servic e fo rKalaupap a Airpor t ^nn t ^/:^e ^ ThejrejCi Q C^h/ov

y ^"^^^^^^ ^ gyul ^ /n . /cnv^t ^ z C , d-A^..^- ^ <g ^ ^i/^^f^' YIVr^fi^^

f ^gTg^ ^ y^g ^ Ai/yr/< ^ rr; ^ ^/^^Ai< 7 S^'^r- ^ LAN; ^Patient s an d Resident s o fKalaupap a I n Suppor t o fMakan i Ka i EA S Servic e fo rKalaupap a Airpor t ^f^^lP . ^ICd. ^ Ut?^ ^ X^w^ . d^^^.c*^ . Irt^yJ ^ . .<.\c-f^€:.y^^ce'i'y^4!*^z.<,* = 

## ^I^ip7P

% C€iu.-J - -^nJt - iOjuiPi ^ ?. o ^c> - u , YALH^U^/^P A^/- Z



## M,%77r ^ Cfzu.'j , ' ^Uz . jM ) 

# v ^ ao> ^

(;^ (