Biomass

Pollutant(s) of 

Interest Control

Annual Control 

and Monitoring 

Cost

Annual Reductions 

(TPY)* Cost Effectiveness Units

Pb, Cd1

Fabric Filter $9,093,822 1.74 $5,215,993 $/ton

D/F2

ACI/FF $23,041,956 5.41529E-05 $212,748,879 $/lb

Hg3

ACI/FF $6,091,603 0.00224 $1,356,909 $/lb

SO24 DIFF $24,454,692 294 $83,183 $/ton

*From BTF_EmissionReductions file

Coal

HCl1 Wet Scrubber $2,758,652 10.87 $253,687 $/ton

HCl2 WS or DIFF, Caustic $43,753,881 10.87 $4,023,634 $/ton

Pb, Cd3

Fabric Filter $8,916,581 0.18 $49,781,125 $/ton

D/F4

ACI/FF $0 0 #DIV/0!

Hg5

ACI/FF $11,901,802 0.01602 $742,977,673 $/ton

CO LBMS6$76,508 246 $312 $/ton

CO Oxidation catalyst $3,142,085 341 $9,214 $/ton

1. For Pb, Cd, calculations represent cost effectiveness to comply with the MACT floor emission limit, which is based on the 

representative detection level (RDL) for these pollutants. Since the limits are set at the quantification level of the EPA reference 

method, further emission reductions cannot be quantified.

Annual control and monitoring cost includes only costs attributed to FF annual costs and monitoring; however, reductions also in

those resulting from DIFF installation for units wanting to control SO2. Reductions do not include PM reductions resulting from F

pollutant is not under consideration in this analysis.

Annual Reductions 

(TPY)* Cost Effectiveness 

2. For D/F, calculations represent cost effectiveness to comply with the MACT floor emission limit, which is based on the repres

detection level (RDL) for this pollutant.

Annual Control 

and Monitoring 

Control Cost

1. For this analysis, we assume that WS is applied to control HCl, since this is the limit that is less stringent now. However, cau

control of the scrubbing liquor will provide some co-control of SO2. For a conservative estimate, we estimated 25% control of S

be achieved using this route if co-control is considered. Actual amounts of co-control could be higher.

If SO2 control was the goal, however, it is likely that sources would opt to install a FGD-specific system, such as a DIFF system 

of a wet scrubber. However, the SO2 limit is not under question in this analysis.

Pollutant of 

Interest

3. Represents cost effectiveness to reduce Hg emissions to match 90% reduction in worst performing unit by applying ACI/FF 

combination to units having baseline emissions above this value.

4. Represents cost effectiveness to apply DIFF to any units that have not been assigned DIFF for MACT control and assuming a 

reduction in SO2 for these units.

Units

2. Eastman reports in a comment letter that a wet scrubber isn't feasible for their TN facility, so we have incorporated an estima

million capital cost, as reported in the letter, for the TN facility to control HCl using dry scrubber/fabric filter and caustic polishing 

scrubber. 
*From BTF_EmissionReductions file

4. For D/F, the MACT floor emission limit, which is based on the representative detection level (RDL) for this pollutant is at or ab

baseline data available for these units. Therefore, there is little uncertainty in estimating reductions possible below the MACT flo

emission limit.

3. For Pb, Cd, calculations represent cost effectiveness for units to install FF to control Pb and Cd beyond the MACT floor limit. 

reductions assume a 99% removal efficiency for FF, but uses the reference method detection limit of 0.013 for lead as the minim

emission, since further emission reductions cannot be quantified.

6.Cost represent total capital cost to apply advanced combustion controls (linkageless boiler management system) to all coal un

for this control are NOT annualized. Reductions assume a 54% efficiency, median of 33%-75% CO reduction range.

5. Represents cost effectiveness to apply ACI/FF to all units to reduce emissions beyond the MACT floor limits. Reduction is ba

beyond-the-floor emission level matching that of a 90% Hg reduction from each unit.
Pollutant Reduction Total Reduction Units

PM 949.47 951.2093441 $9,560 $/ton (this represent MACT F

Hg 0.011765 0.011819617 $974,734 $/lb (this represent MACT F

Pollutant Reduction Total Reduction Units

SO2 700.45 711.32 $3,878 $/ton Calculated using standa

SO2 700.45 711.32 $61,511 $/ton Adjusted to reflect cost 

PM 120.63 120.81 $73,808 $/ton (this is based on a 99% 

See below for Hg and D/F co-control.

D/F 0 0.01602 $371,489 $/lb Unable to quantify D/F c

Emission limit went up some due to new, longer period data set from Eastman that also reflects startup/shutdown modes of ope

Additonal reductions from co-control 

Cost effectiveness 

for all controlled 

pollutants

 limit, which is based on the 

ation level of the EPA reference test 

ring; however, reductions also include 

e PM reductions resulting from FF, as this 

Additonal reductions from co-control 

(tpy)

Cost effectiveness 

for all controlled 

pollutants

it, which is based on the representative 

ss stringent now. However, caustic 

 we estimated 25% control of SO2 could 

system, such as a DIFF system instead 

rming unit by applying ACI/FF 

or MACT control and assuming a 95% 

we have incorporated an estimated $250 

abric filter and caustic polishing 
RDL) for this pollutant is at or above the 

ons possible below the MACT floor 

Cd beyond the MACT floor limit. Emission 

mit of 0.013 for lead as the minimum BTF 

nagement system) to all coal units. Costs 

CO reduction range.

ACT floor limits. Reduction is based on a 
(this represent MACT Floor reductions, nothing beyond the floor)

(this represent MACT Floor reductions, nothing beyond the floor)

Calculated using standard algorithms

Adjusted to reflect cost information from Eastman facility

(this is based on a 99% reduction in PM for each of 4 units that would add FF to control beyond the floor)

Unable to quantify D/F co-control below baseline levels.

/shutdown modes of operation.
Secondary Impacts of ERU-Solid

FF ACI DIFF WS Total

elec (Mw) 0 0 6,060 6,060

water (gal/yr) 0 279,427 279,427

ACI (lb/yr) 0 0

Dust (tpy) 0 0 0 0

Natural Gas (Mmscf/yr) 0

Emission Factors

Electrcitya

Pollutant (lb/Mw-hr) (lb/106

 scf) lb/ft3 ton/ft3

CO2 1,329 120,000 0.12 0.00006

CO - 84 0.000084 0.000000042

NOx 1.9366 100 0.0001 0.00000005

SO2 5.2589 - - -

a. National emission factors from Egrid for EGUs

b. Natural gas emission factors from AP 42

Natural Gasb
Secondary Emissions from ERU-Solid

CO2 CO SO2 NOx

8,055,274 31,867 11,735

0 0 0

lbs/yr 8,055,274 0 31,867 11,735

tons/yr 4,028 0 16 6
Summary of MACT Compliance Costs for Energy Recovery Units -Solids

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

Total Capital 

Investment

($)

Total Annual 

Cost 

($/yr)

ALIPRiverdale

No. 2 Bark Boiler / 

BK02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator none $41,573,203 $12,454,205 $43,500 $38,400 $41,616,703 $12,492,605

ARDomtarIndustries PB1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, General fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI $7,841,943 $2,197,683 $18,000 $18,300 $7,859,943 $2,215,983

ARDomtarIndustries PB2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Wet Scrubber tune-up, ACI, fabric filter $23,783,390 $7,941,591 $25,500 $19,500 $23,808,890 $7,961,091

ARDomtarIndustries PB3

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI, LBMS $1,826,063 $570,254 $18,000 $19,600 $1,844,063 $589,854

LAInternationalPaperRedRiverMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power 

Boiler / EQT005

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI, LBMS $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

LAIPMansfield

2-78 - No. 2 Power 

Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, ACI, tune-up, wet scrubber $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, LBMS $4,528,035 $1,419,569 $18,000 $18,900 $4,546,035 $1,438,469

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, LBMS $6,675,092 $1,912,946 $18,000 $18,100 $6,693,092 $1,931,046

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Venturi 

Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

ORGPToledo

EU11 - Hog Fuel 

Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber, tune-up $6,662,068 $1,851,445 $18,000 $19,300 $6,680,068 $1,870,745

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 18

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up, ACI, fabric filter $11,078,468 $17,831,430 $67,800 $30,500 $11,146,268 $17,861,930

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 19

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up, ACI, fabric filter $9,624,504 $17,768,529 $67,800 $35,700 $9,692,304 $17,804,229

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 20

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up, ACI, fabric filter $9,497,525 $17,817,170 $67,800 $35,700 $9,565,325 $17,852,870

TNPackagingCorpCounce

Combination Boiler 

#2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator none #REF! #REF! #REF! #REF! #REF! #REF!

TNTempleInland2426 5000F

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Mechnical Dust Collector, Wet 

Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS, caustic $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

TXInternationalPaperQueenCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Venturi 

Scrubber fabric filter, ACI, tune-up $37,923,511 $9,988,693 $18,000 $18,900 $37,941,511 $10,007,593

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Wet 

Electrostatic Precipitator (General), Wet 

Impingement (General), Wet Scrubber CO oxidation, ACI, DIFF, caustic $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Wet 

Electrostatic Precipitator (General), Wet 

Impingement (General), Wet Scrubber CO oxidation, DIFF, ACI, caustic $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), Wet 

Electrostatic Precipitator (General), Wet 

Impingement (General), Wet Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular Filter, 

Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 

Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular Filter, 

Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction (NH3 

Or Urea Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

#REF! #REF! #REF! #REF! #REF! #REF!

Control Costs Monitoring, Reporting, and 

Recordkeeping Costs Total BTF Floor Control, 

Monitoring, Reporting, and 

Recordkeeping Costs

FacilityID UnitID Subcategory Existing Control Device Consolidated MACT Controls Beyond the Floor Options

1 of 1
Table 2B. Energy Recovery Units - Solids: Costs to Meet MACT Floor (1 of 5)

Dust Elec Elec Water

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm) tpy Mw

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm) Mw gal/yr

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

none

ARDomtarIndustries PB1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, 

General

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI

$5,849,908 $124 $1,338,783 $28 13 2,051 $1,016,100 $22 $353,297 $8 610 9,415 $2,574,348 $57.67

ARDomtarIndustries PB2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Wet Scrubber

tune-up

ARDomtarIndustries PB3

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

$7,524,066 $38 $6,020,268 $30 14,370 198,439 $3,279,785 $16.55

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS $1,366,567 $223 $414,794 $68 6 309 $282,403 $46 $195,282 $32 174 13,424 $1,946,715 $318.35

LAInternationalPaperRedRi

verMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

$9,646,284 $53 $6,741,269 $37 17,221 3,395,242 $3,152,249 $17.01

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / 

EQT005

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

$5,276,241 $49 $2,840,823 $26 6,934 712,329 $2,931,467 $23.06

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, tune-up, wet 

scrubber

$8,065,237 $49 $5,477,791 $33 13,977 1,448,630 $3,122,909 $18.03

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, LBMS

$380,063 $18 $212,501 $10 184 213

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, LBMS

$669,179 $18 $272,193 $7 309 385

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS

$3,257,491 $14.43

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber, 

tune-up $5,048,247 $127 $1,190,800 $30 4 1,860 $1,288,491 $32 $481,647 $12 1,106 429,066 $2,514,861 $84.41

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 18

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 19

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 20

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNTempleInland2426 5000F

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Mechnical Dust Collector, 

Wet Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS, caustic

$2,862,670 $29.93

TXInternationalPaperQuee

nCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

fabric filter, ACI, tune-up

$28,248,948 $110 $6,110,645 $24 437 11,625 $3,303,128 $18.68

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, ACI, DIFF, 

caustic

$2,871,864 $73.98

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, DIFF, ACI, 

caustic

$2,958,638 $72.68

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS

$2,903,061 $39.68

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

$2,937,220 $43 $1,365,937 $20 3,392 657,350 $2,739,053 $39.95

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

$3,009,184 $42 $1,379,347 $19 3,441 591,917 $2,754,779 $38.67

Biomass: $9,055,022

Subcategory

Add Packed Bed Scrubber

Improve Scrubber 

Performance

Improve Fabric Filter 

Performance

FacilityID UnitID ControlDevice Consolidated MACT 

Controls

Add Fabric Filter
Table 2B. Energy Recovery Units - Solids: Costs to Meet MACT Floor (2 of 5)

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

none

ARDomtarIndustries PB1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, 

General

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI

ARDomtarIndustries PB2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Wet Scrubber

tune-up

ARDomtarIndustries PB3

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAInternationalPaperRedRi

verMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / 

EQT005

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, tune-up, wet 

scrubber

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, LBMS

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, LBMS

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber, 

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 18

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 19

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 20

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNTempleInland2426 5000F

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Mechnical Dust Collector, 

Wet Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS, caustic

TXInternationalPaperQuee

nCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

fabric filter, ACI, tune-up

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, ACI, DIFF, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, DIFF, ACI, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

FacilityID UnitID Subcategory ControlDevice Consolidated MACT 

Controls

ACI Dust Elec Water

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm) lb/yr ton/yr

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm) Mw gal/yr

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

$669,484 $15.00 169,324 85

$1,382,015 $6.97 862,687 431

$228,931 $37.44 28,601 14

$1,305,686 $7.05 673,610 337

$1,027,728 $8.09 435,124 218

$1,222,784 $7.06 663,400 332

$1,428,194 $6.33 842,321 421

$524,047 $17.59 154,805 77

$838,803 $8.77 364,751 182

$1,294,348 $7.32 931,057 466

$655,167 $16.88 305,294 153 $2,056,030.48 $16.04 $1,050,648 8.20

$715,471 $17.58 372,310 186 $1,880,390.86 $17.28 $924,220 8.49

$1,014,148 $13.86 374,966 187

$745,021 $10.87 260,822 130

$754,409 $10.59 270,969 135

13,806,234.28

ACI SNCR CO Oxidation Catalyst
Table 2B. Energy Recovery Units - Solids: Costs to Meet MACT Floor (3 of 5)

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

none

ARDomtarIndustries PB1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, 

General

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI

ARDomtarIndustries PB2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Wet Scrubber

tune-up

ARDomtarIndustries PB3

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAInternationalPaperRedRi

verMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / 

EQT005

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, tune-up, wet 

scrubber

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, LBMS

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, LBMS

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber, 

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 18

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 19

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 20

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNTempleInland2426 5000F

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Mechnical Dust Collector, 

Wet Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS, caustic

TXInternationalPaperQuee

nCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

fabric filter, ACI, tune-up

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, ACI, DIFF, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, DIFF, ACI, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

FacilityID UnitID Subcategory ControlDevice Consolidated MACT 

Controls

Elec Dust Water

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm) Mw tpy gal/yr

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

$0 $0

$9,440,356 $204

$1,580.00 $0.008 $1,580 $0

$29,429,889.35 $148.52 $7,831,852 39.52 9550.47 1305.34 9,780,709,194 $40,233,740 $203

$19,127.00 $3.13 $3,614,812 $591

$27,018,642.28 $148.98 $7,193,387 39.66 8892.69 793.10 9,106,165,666 $39,817,175 $219

$16,486,313.76 $152.42 $4,796,674 44.35 5568.49 3079.52 5,697,628,364 $19,127.00 $0.15 $24,713,148 $224

$24,654,075.72 $149.44 $6,859,614 41.58 8481.31 2315.23 8,683,897,831 $1,580.00 $0.009 $35,843,802 $216

$19,127.00 $0.93 $399,190 $19

$19,127.00 $0.51 $688,306 $19

$33,392,770.73 $147.92 $8,786,598 38.92 11114.58 422.62 11,384,028,625 $19,127.00 $0.08 $36,669,389 $162

$1,580.00 $0.053 $8,853,180 $244

$1,580.00 $0.00 $1,580 $0

$1,580.00 $0.00 $1,580 $0

$1,580.00 $0.00 $1,580 $0

$14,815,117.71 $154.47 $4,102,661 42.78 4851.70 893.47 4,962,963,652 $19,127.00 $0.20 $433 $0.01 $17,696,914 $185

$1,580.00 $0.00 $31,553,656 $128

$14,957,491.53 $153.37 $3,767,202 38.63 4041.72 348.28 4,134,557,681 $353 $0.00 $19,885,386 $243

$18,035,511.95 $151.64 $4,499,339 37.83 4924.90 158.99 5,040,013,010 $445 $0.00 $22,874,541 $242

$15,979,589.51 $153.09 $4,201,652 40.25 4942.32 61.72 5,056,578,143 $19,127.00 $0.26 $18,901,778 $193

$10,798,843.26 $157.49 $2,887,654 42.11 3335.01 193.33 3,408,476,198 $16,475,116 $240

$11,213,274.36 $157.41 $3,018,475 42.37 3463.92 178.56 3,540,640,952 $16,977,238 $238

57,945,106.67 $344,644,047

Add advanced combustion 

DIFF controls (LBMS) Add Lime Add Caustic Tune-up Controls Subtotals
Table 2B. Energy Recovery Units - Solids: Costs to Meet MACT Floor (4 of 5)

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

none

ARDomtarIndustries PB1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, 

General

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI

ARDomtarIndustries PB2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Wet Scrubber

tune-up

ARDomtarIndustries PB3

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAInternationalPaperRedRi

verMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / 

EQT005

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, tune-up, wet 

scrubber

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, LBMS

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, LBMS

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber, 

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 18

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 19

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 20

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNTempleInland2426 5000F

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Mechnical Dust Collector, 

Wet Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS, caustic

TXInternationalPaperQuee

nCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

fabric filter, ACI, tune-up

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, ACI, DIFF, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, DIFF, ACI, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

FacilityID UnitID Subcategory ControlDevice Consolidated MACT 

Controls

Annual Stack 

Test

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

$0 $0 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$2,361,564 $51 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$0 $0 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$15,234,135 $77 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$839,007 $137 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $0 $0

$15,240,342 $84 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$8,665,225 $79 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$13,560,188 $82 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$212,501 $10 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $0 $0

$272,193 $7 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $0 $0

$10,214,792 $45 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$2,196,494 $60 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$0 $0 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $0 $0

$0 $0 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $0 $0

$0 $0 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $0 $0

$4,941,897 $52 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$7,404,993 $31 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$5,473,369 $64 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$6,139,475 $64 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$5,215,800 $54 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$4,998,612 $73 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$5,152,230 $72 $55,000 $6,039 $55,000 $9,826 $927 $158,000 $56,100

$108,122,816

Controls Subtotals Initial Stack Test O2 Monitor Add CPMS or PM CEMS
Table 2B. Energy Recovery Units - Solids: Costs to Meet MACT Floor (5 of 5)

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

none

ARDomtarIndustries PB1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, 

General

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI

ARDomtarIndustries PB2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Wet Scrubber

tune-up

ARDomtarIndustries PB3

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAInternationalPaperRedRi

verMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / 

EQT005

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, tune-up, wet 

scrubber

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, LBMS

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

wet scrubber, LBMS

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber, 

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 18

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 19

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 20

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator

tune-up

TNTempleInland2426 5000F

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Mechnical Dust Collector, 

Wet Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS, caustic

TXInternationalPaperQuee

nCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber

fabric filter, ACI, tune-up

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, ACI, DIFF, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, DIFF, ACI, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

DIFF, ACI, LBMS

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR)

ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

FacilityID UnitID Subcategory ControlDevice Consolidated MACT 

Controls

ACI Monitoring 

Costs

Annual Control 

Device 

Inspection

Reporting and 

Recordkeeping 

Requirements

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

$0 $0 $0 $0 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $223,076 $122,254 $223,076 $122,254

$9,300 $25,500 $9,700 $24,300 $5,600 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $272,876 $146,854 $9,713,232 $2,508,418

$0 $0 $0 $0 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $223,076 $122,254 $224,656 $122,254

$9,400 $0 $0 $24,300 $5,600 $18,000 $18,500 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $265,376 $155,754 $40,499,116 $15,389,890

$10,100 $25,500 $9,700 $24,300 $5,600 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $114,876 $91,554 $3,729,688 $930,561

$9,600 $0 $0 $24,300 $5,600 $18,000 $18,800 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $265,376 $156,254 $40,082,551 $15,396,596

$10,100 $0 $0 $24,300 $5,600 $18,000 $19,400 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $265,376 $157,354 $24,978,524 $8,822,579

$10,100 $0 $0 $24,300 $5,600 $18,000 $19,400 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $265,376 $157,354 $36,109,178 $13,717,542

$0 $0 $24,300 $5,600 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $89,376 $71,754 $488,566 $284,255

$0 $0 $24,300 $5,600 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $89,376 $71,754 $777,682 $343,947

$9,600 $0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $18,800 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $241,076 $150,654 $36,910,465 $10,365,446

$9,900 $25,500 $9,700 $24,300 $5,600 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $272,876 $147,454 $9,126,056 $2,343,948

$0 $0 $0 $0 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $65,076 $66,154 $66,656 $66,154

$0 $0 $0 $0 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $65,076 $66,154 $66,656 $66,154

$0 $0 $0 $0 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $65,076 $66,154 $66,656 $66,154

$9,900 $0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $19,100 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $241,076 $151,254 $17,937,990 $5,093,151

$9,800 $25,500 $9,700 $0 $0 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $248,576 $141,754 $31,802,232 $7,546,747

$8,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $16,500 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $241,076 $146,754 $20,126,462 $5,620,124

$8,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $16,500 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $241,076 $146,754 $23,115,617 $6,286,229

$9,300 $0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $18,100 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $241,076 $149,654 $19,142,854 $5,365,454

$9,400 $0 $0 $24,300 $5,600 $18,000 $18,100 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $265,376 $155,354 $16,740,492 $5,153,966

$9,400 $0 $0 $24,300 $5,600 $18,000 $18,100 $1,000 $250 $200 $2,989 $265,376 $155,354 $17,242,614 $5,307,584

$141,900 $38,800 $4,526,972 $2,796,594 $349,171,019 $110,919,410

Annual Visual Emissions 

Test of Ash Handling

Testing, Monitoring, and 

Recordkeeping Subtotals

Total MACT Floor Control, 

Monitoring, Reporting, and 

Recordkeeping Cost

Bag Leak Detection 

System

Wet Scrubber Monitoring 

System DIFF Monitoring
Table 2B. Energy Recovery Units - Solids: Costs to Meet MACT Floor (1 of 4)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator none

ACI/FF, DIFF

$17,602,551.77 $111 $3,876,760 $24 $119,351 $0.75 $2,195,342 $13.86

ARDomtarIndustries PB1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, 

General fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI

DIFF

ARDomtarIndustries PB2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Wet Scrubber tune-up ACI/FF $21,006,063 $4,639,048 $132,945 $0.70 $1,790,868 $9.45 $2,625,254.96 $13.11 $1,511,675

ARDomtarIndustries PB3

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

DIFF

LAInternationalPaperRedRi

verMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / 

EQT005

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, tune-up, wet 

scrubber

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, LBMS

DIFF

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, LBMS

DIFF

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber, 

tune-up

DIFF

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 18

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

Wet Scrubber or DIFF with 

Caustic; ACI/FF $7,536,974 $1,500,711 $2,110,493 $34 $993,122 $16 $67,665 $1.10 $337,390 $5.49 $1,344,209.26 $22.81 $586,207

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 19

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

Wet Scrubber; ACI/FF

$6,480,721 $1,371,506 $1,835,055 $35 $903,032 $17 $61,477 $1.17 $395,483 $7.54 $1,228,123.02 $24.58 $522,821

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 20

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

Wet Scrubber; ACI/FF

$6,456,466 $1,366,516 $1,735,193 $33 $862,498 $17 $61,328 $1.17 $434,580 $8.32 $1,225,411.64 $24.62 $521,383

TNTempleInland2426 5000F

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Mechnical Dust Collector, 

Wet Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS, caustic

TXInternationalPaperQuee

nCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber fabric filter, ACI, tune-up

DIFF

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, ACI, DIFF, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, DIFF, ACI, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

Add Packed Bed Scrubber ACI CO Oxidation Catalyst

FacilityID UnitID ControlDevice Consolidated MACT 

Controls

Add Fabric Filter

Subcategory Beyond the Floor Options
Table 2B. Energy Recovery Units - Solids: Costs to Meet MACT Floor (2 of 4)

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator none

ARDomtarIndustries PB1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, 

General fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI

ARDomtarIndustries PB2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Wet Scrubber tune-up

ARDomtarIndustries PB3

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAInternationalPaperRedRi

verMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / 

EQT005

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, tune-up, wet 

scrubber

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, LBMS

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, LBMS

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber, 

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 18

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 19

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 20

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

TNTempleInland2426 5000F

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Mechnical Dust Collector, 

Wet Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS, caustic

TXInternationalPaperQuee

nCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber fabric filter, ACI, tune-up

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, ACI, DIFF, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, DIFF, ACI, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

FacilityID UnitID ControlDevice Consolidated MACT 

Controls

Subcategory

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

7.55

9.95

10.46

10.48
Table 2B. Energy Recovery Units - Solids: Costs to Meet MACT Floor (3 of 4)

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator none

ARDomtarIndustries PB1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, 

General fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI

ARDomtarIndustries PB2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Wet Scrubber tune-up

ARDomtarIndustries PB3

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAInternationalPaperRedRi

verMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / 

EQT005

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, tune-up, wet 

scrubber

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, LBMS

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, LBMS

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber, 

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 18

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 19

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 20

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

TNTempleInland2426 5000F

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Mechnical Dust Collector, 

Wet Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS, caustic

TXInternationalPaperQuee

nCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber fabric filter, ACI, tune-up

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, ACI, DIFF, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, DIFF, ACI, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

FacilityID UnitID ControlDevice Consolidated MACT 

Controls

Subcategory

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TCI

($)

TCI 

($/dscfm)

TAC

($/yr)

TAC

($/yr/dscfm)

$23,851,300.50 $150.61 $6,382,102 40.30 $41,573,203 $263 $12,454,205 $79

$7,841,942.56 $166.82 $2,197,683 46.75 $7,841,943 $167 $2,197,683 $47

$19,127.00 $23,783,390 $14 $7,941,591 $17

$0 $0 $0 $0

$1,826,063.39 $298.62 $570,254 93.25 $1,826,063 $299 $570,254 $93

$0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0

$4,528,035.10 $220.38 $1,419,569 69.09 $4,528,035 $220 $1,419,569 $69

$6,675,092.40 $179.54 $1,912,946 51.45 $6,675,092 $180 $1,912,946 $51

$0 $0 $0 $0

$6,662,067.87 $167.26 $1,851,445 46.48 $6,662,068 $167 $1,851,445 $46

$14,413,824 234.36 $19,127.00 $176 $0.00 $11,078,468 $58 $17,831,430 $266

$14,575,451 278.06 $19,127.00 $237 $0.00 $9,624,504 $61 $17,768,529 $313

$14,631,983 280.27 $19,127.00 $210 $0.004 $9,497,525 $59 $17,817,170 $316

$0 $0 $0 $0

$37,923,510.98 $147.39 $9,988,693 38.82 $37,923,511 $147 $9,988,693 $39

$0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0

76,508.00

Tune-up Controls Subtotals

Add advanced combustion 

DIFF controls (LBMS) Add Lime Add Caustic
Table 2B. Energy Recovery Units - Solids: Costs to Meet MACT Floor (4 of 4)

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator none

ARDomtarIndustries PB1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator, 

General fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI

ARDomtarIndustries PB2

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Wet Scrubber tune-up

ARDomtarIndustries PB3

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, ACI, wet scrubber

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAInternationalPaperRedRi

verMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / 

EQT005

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, wet scrubber, ACI, 

LBMS

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator

DIFF, ACI, tune-up, wet 

scrubber

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Boiler No.1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, LBMS

MEHuberEngineeredWood

LLC Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Electrostatic Precipitator wet scrubber, LBMS

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator

fabric filter, ACI, wet scrubber, 

tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 18

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 19

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

TNEastman_NO_CBIDAT

A Boiler 20

Energy recovery unit - 

Coal Electrostatic Precipitator tune-up

TNTempleInland2426 5000F

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Mechnical Dust Collector, 

Wet Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS, caustic

TXInternationalPaperQuee

nCity PB02

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Venturi Scrubber fabric filter, ACI, tune-up

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, ACI, DIFF, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber

CO oxidation, DIFF, ACI, 

caustic

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Cyclone: Multiple (Multiclone), 

Wet Electrostatic Precipitator 

(General), Wet Impingement 

(General), Wet Scrubber DIFF, ACI, LBMS

WINSPWAshland B20

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

WINSPWAshland B21

Energy recovery unit - 

Biomass

Dry Electrostatic Granular 

Filter, Selective Non-Catalytic 

Reduction (NH3 Or Urea 

Injection) (SNCR) ACI, DIFF, wet scrubber

FacilityID UnitID ControlDevice Consolidated MACT 

Controls

Subcategory

ACI Monitoring 

Costs

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

TCI

($)

TAC

($/yr)

$9,800 $25,500 $9,700 $0 $0 $18,000 $18,900 $43,500 $38,400 $41,616,703 $12,492,605

$0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $18,300 $18,000 $18,300 $7,859,943 $2,215,983

$9,800 $25,500 $9,700 $0 $0 $25,500 $19,500 $23,808,890 $7,961,091

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $19,600 $18,000 $19,600 $1,844,063 $589,854

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $18,900 $18,000 $18,900 $4,546,035 $1,438,469

$0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $18,100 $18,000 $18,100 $6,693,092 $1,931,046

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $19,300 $18,000 $19,300 $6,680,068 $1,870,745

$4,300 $25,500 $9,700 $24,300 $5,600 $18,000 $10,900 $67,800 $30,500 $11,146,268 $17,861,930

$6,400 $25,500 $9,700 $24,300 $5,600 $18,000 $14,000 $67,800 $35,700 $9,692,304 $17,804,229

$6,400 $25,500 $9,700 $24,300 $5,600 $18,000 $14,000 $67,800 $35,700 $9,565,325 $17,852,870

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0 $18,000 $18,900 $18,000 $18,900 $37,941,511 $10,007,593

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0

$161,394,203 $92,026,416

Bag Leak Detection 

System

Total BTF Control, 

Monitoring, Reporting, and 

Recordkeeping Cost

Testing, Monitoring, and 

Recordkeeping Subtotals

Wet Scrubber Monitoring 

System DIFF Monitoring
PM Filt HCl SO2

ACI Adj 

Factor

gr/dscf ppmvd ppmvd

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02

No. 2 Bark Boiler / 

BK02

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8400 667 million Btu/hr 667 million Btu/hr 17.415 8.8022222 158368.5556 137835.0786 240472.3403 302.4183673 0.16 0.00142917 0.13066667 4.566667 -0.57

ARDomtarIndustries PB1 PB1

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8049 580 million Btu/hr 580 million Btu/hr 18.98598576 7.7 47008 44640.69065 70122.0823 400 0.65 0.00806062 1.84497627 52.27565 0.89

ARDomtarIndustries PB2 PB2

Energy recovery 

unit - Coal 8520 820 million Btu/hr 820 million Btu/hr 11.11271429 189561.5342 189561.5342 326271.2607 400 0.07 0.01434969 14.2598896 372.08 0.60

ARDomtarIndustries PB3 PB3

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8160 790 million Btu/hr 790 million Btu/hr 18.98598576 198150.8254 198150.8254 352404.8794 400 0.65 0.00806062 1.84497627 52.27565 0.89

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72) Boiler #3 (SN-72)

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8760 25 million Btu/hr 25 million Btu/hr 18.98598576 6115.018215 6115.018215 10883.17598 400 0.65 0.02816626 15.7394963 52.27565 0.89

LAInternationalPaperRedRiverMill EQT011 Hogged Fuel Boiler No. 2

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8300 940 million Btu/hr 940 million Btu/hr 21.7 6.7 181353.75 185267.8597 270526.224 312.6469858 0.16 0.00882849 36.7333333 57 0.62

LAIPMansfield 1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / EQT005

1-78 - No. 1 Power 

Boiler / EQT005

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8700 760 million Btu/hr 760 million Btu/hr 19.44666667 4.5666667 108161.3333 127096.0512 166714.1581 400 0.27 0.02816626 15.7394963 367.3517 0.52

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler

2-78 - No. 2 Power 

Boiler

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8700 760 million Btu/hr 760 million Btu/hr 19.81823899 6.3025641 164971.8868 173249.3915 254176.1459 400 0.27 0.02816626 15.7394963 173.9394 0.52

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Boiler No.1 Boiler No.1

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8400 84 million Btu/hr 84 million Btu/hr 18.98598576 20546.4612 20546.4612 30627.26337 400 0.16 0.00205066 0.5220955 2.028772 -3.53

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Dryer Furnace Dryer Furnace

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8000 152 million Btu/hr 152 million Btu/hr 18.98598576 37179.31075 37179.31075 55420.76229 400 0.16 0.00205066 0.5220955 2.028772 -3.53

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1 Bark Boiler EUG-D1

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8338 900 million Btu/hr 900 million Btu/hr 18.98598576 225741.4466 225741.4466 336739.7102 152.2666667 0.16 0.04800599 2.02443342 2.19 0.69

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4

EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler 

#4

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8600 296.6 million Btu/hr 296.6 million Btu/hr 17.09140756 10.502563 39830.39496 29793.81448 60002.07341 368.8095238 0.65 0.0030113 78.3 46.59334 0.89

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 18 Boiler 18

Energy recovery 

unit - Coal 3700 246 million Btu/hr 246 million Btu/hr 10.65 7.0675 61503.75 61205.08071 95487.13599 395.5 0.61 0.02832109 6.31735246 623.9019 0.74

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 19 Boiler 19

Energy recovery 

unit - Coal 5500 246 million Btu/hr 246 million Btu/hr 12.18 12.2 52418.25 32808.54496 81381.75811 400 0.61 0.03360944 7.35582135 623.9019 0.70

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 20 Boiler 20

Energy recovery 

unit - Coal 5500 246 million Btu/hr 246 million Btu/hr 12.63 10.325 52207 39718.63489 81053.65385 400 0.61 0.03047532 5.27888356 623.9019 0.78

TNPackagingCorpCounce Combination Boiler #2 Combination Boiler #2

Energy recovery 

unit - Coal 8566 860 million Btu/hr 860 million Btu/hr 11.52857143 6.925 180318.4167 181291.3578 277933.1413 363.1131313 0.27 0.00340902 4.99430965 235.8304 -1.17

TNTempleInland2426 5000F 5000F

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8544 527 million Btu/hr 527 million Btu/hr 26.06 7.0386364 95909 95642.41187 142303.0908 148.809375 0.98 0.09593332 0.64333333 79.16 0.35

TXInternationalPaperQueenCity PB02 PB02

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8400 487.075 million Btu/hr 19.9377551 11.347811 257292.2524 176813.2452 369467.0198 135.7777778 0.16 0.04720181 0.06813333 1.21365 0.89

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler #12 Power Boiler

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 7000 316.25 million Btu/hr 316.25 million Btu/hr 17.912 15.367 97527.65 38821.6178 145378.0689 139 0.16 0.0081248 0.38 55.4 1.00

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler #13 Power Boiler

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 7000 316.25 million Btu/hr 316.25 million Btu/hr 16.21071429 16.1425 118936.25 40707.85679 177290.3501 400 0.16 0.00725509 0.79 18.63333 0.99

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler #20 Power Boiler

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8000 900 million Btu/hr 900 million Btu/hr 17.28275862 11.158276 104383.1897 73156.27613 156235.7564 137 0.16 0.00590023 0.4 5.666667 0.13

WINSPWAshland B20 B20

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8200 275 million Btu/hr 275 million Btu/hr 18.98598576 68566.5 68566.5 106025.0668 400 0.26 0.01249413 0.09996935 33.83567 0.11

WINSPWAshland B21 B21

Energy recovery 

unit - Biomass 8200 275 million Btu/hr 275 million Btu/hr 18.98598576 71234.10227 71234.10227 110150.007 400 0.26 0.01249413 0.09996935 29.38667 0.11

Stack Gas 

Temp 

(°F)

FacilityID UnitID Fraction PM that is 

PM 2.5

Design 

Capacity 

Units

Average 

Moisture (%)

Average 

O2 (%)

Stack Gas Flow 

Rate (dscfm)

Emissions Unit ID Subcategory Stack Gas Flow 

Rate (acfm)

Operating Hours dscfm @ 7% O2

(hr/yr)

Design Capacity Design 

Capacity 

Units

Design 

Capacity
FACName Unit ID

Exhaust 

gas flow 

(acfm)

Temperat

ure (F)

Actual 

Exhaust 

Flow rate 

(scfm)

Unit Input 

Flow 

(scfm)

Equipmen

t Cost ($)

Additional 

Purchase 

Equipment 

Cost(Instruments, 

taxes, freight)

ALIPRiverdale

No. 2 Bark 

Boiler / BK02 240472.34 302.418367 166535.1 174861.8 794416.1 278045.6417

ARDomtarIndustries PB1 70122.0823 400 43051.7 45204.28 378981.8 132643.6311

ARDomtarIndustries PB2 326271.261 400 200315.4 210331.1 878881.2 307608.4148

ARDomtarIndustries PB3 352404.879 400 216360.2 227178.2 916722.4 320852.8264

ARPlantersCottonOil

Boiler #3 

(SN-72) 10883.176 400 6681.764 7015.852 136760.4 47866.12336

CAWheelabratorSha

sta Boiler#1 130661.45 358.506957 84286.69 88501.03 547324.7 191563.6408

CAWheelabratorSha

sta Boiler#2 122025.256 400 74917.83 78663.72 513154.1 179603.9503

CAWheelabratorSha

sta Boiler#3 128516.954 400 78903.43 82848.6 527914.3 184770.0117

LAInternationalPaper

RedRiverMill

EQT011 

Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2 270526.224 312.646986 184868.2 194111.6 841128.9 294395.1292

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 

Power Boiler 

/ EQT005 166714.158 400 102354.7 107472.5 608684.6 213039.6228

LAIPMansfield

2-78 - No. 2 

Power Boiler 254176.146 400 156052.3 163854.9 766655.8 268329.5377

MEHuberEngineered

WoodLLC Boiler No.1 30627.2634 400 18803.72 19743.9 240880.1 84308.04743

MEHuberEngineered

WoodLLC

Dryer 

Furnace 55420.7623 400 34025.77 35727.06 333207.2 116622.5305

OKIPValliant

Bark Boiler 

EUG-D1 336739.71 152.266667 290394 304913.7 1076869 376904.0988

ORGPToledo

EU11 - Hog 

Fuel Boiler 

#4 60002.0734 368.809524 38224.82 40136.06 355110.5 124288.6632

TNEastman_NO_CBI

DATA Boiler 18 95487.136 395.5 58933.03 61879.68 450013.5 157504.733

TNEastman_NO_CBI

DATA Boiler 19 81381.7581 400 49964.61 52462.84 411150.2 143902.5857

TNEastman_NO_CBI

DATA Boiler 20 81053.6539 400 49763.17 52251.33 410242.5 143584.8857

TNPackagingCorpCo

unce

Combination 

Boiler #2 277933.141 363.113131 178285 187199.2 824607.2 288612.5356

TNTempleInland2426 5000F 142303.091 148.809375 123414.7 129585.4 674293.7 236002.806

TXInternationalPaper

QueenCity PB02 369467.02 135.777778 327435.2 343806.9 1149972 402490.2588

WALongviewFPP

#12 Power 

Boiler 145378.069 139 128146.3 134553.6 688316.6 240910.8016
WALongviewFPP

#13 Power 

Boiler 177290.35 400 108848 114290.4 629516.1 220330.6196

WALongviewFPP

#20 Power 

Boiler 156235.756 137 138178.4 145087.3 717293.7 251052.7948

WINSPWAshland B20 106025.067 400 65094.46 68349.18 475173.5 166310.7259

WINSPWAshland B21 110150.007 400 67626.98 71008.33 485200.2 169820.054
Direct Installation 

Costs 

Indirect 

Installation Costs TCI $ $/scfm

 a. 

Catalyst 

CRF, 2-yr 

life, 7% 

interest

 c. 

Equipmen

t CRF, 20-

yr life, 7% 

interest Power of fan

302434.2166 235941.5874 $2,372,954.26 $14.25 0.553092 0.094393 204.5883327

144278.3724 112557.5955 $1,132,034.54 $26.29 0.553092 0.094393 52.8890098

334590.0672 261027.712 $2,625,254.96 $13.11 0.553092 0.094393 246.0874427

348996.2029 272266.5412 $2,738,288.14 $12.66 0.553092 0.094393 265.7985119

52064.66618 40617.82468 $408,508.91 $61.14 0.553092 0.094393 8.2085469

208366.5087 162555.4323 $1,634,881.80 $19.40 0.553092 0.094393 103.5462038

195357.7825 152406.7807 $1,532,812.95 $20.46 0.553092 0.094393 92.0365561

200976.9814 156790.5528 $1,576,902.21 $19.99 0.553092 0.094393 96.9328664

320217.7877 249815.2953 $2,512,487.42 $13.59 0.553092 0.094393 227.1105659

231726.2412 180779.3371 $1,818,166.54 $17.76 0.553092 0.094393 125.7427968

291865.8714 227696.7791 $2,290,033.09 $14.67 0.553092 0.094393 191.7102891

91703.06759 71541.40025 $719,519.07 $38.26 0.553092 0.094393 23.1003641

126851.9925 98962.54735 $995,303.97 $29.25 0.553092 0.094393 41.8006589

409963.9726 319830.0496 $3,216,652.43 $11.08 0.553092 0.094393 356.7490302

135190.5545 105467.8084 $1,060,729.85 $27.75 0.553092 0.094393 46.9591912

171320.1481 133654.0163 $1,344,209.26 $22.81 0.553092 0.094393 72.3992283

156524.8982 122111.6227 $1,228,123.02 $24.58 0.553092 0.094393 61.3815286

156179.3314 121842.0316 $1,225,411.64 $24.62 0.553092 0.094393 61.1340587

313927.978 244908.3516 $2,463,136.42 $13.82 0.553092 0.094393 219.0230837

256703.6235 200265.2382 $2,014,143.65 $16.32 0.553092 0.094393 151.6149702

437794.4044 341541.7339 $3,435,015.09 $10.49 0.553092 0.094393 402.2540827

262042.1205 204430.0231 $2,056,030.48 $16.04 0.553092 0.094393 157.4277022
239656.7625 186966.2686 $1,880,390.86 $17.28 0.553092 0.094393 133.7198035

273073.7114 213036.2288 $2,142,586.36 $15.51 0.553092 0.094393 169.7521121

180898.5524 141126.5302 $1,419,363.18 $21.80 0.553092 0.094393 79.9685437

184715.6987 144104.4458 $1,449,313.21 $21.43 0.553092 0.094393 83.0797462
Electricity

Cost $/yr

Operating 

Labor $/yr

Superviso

ry Labor

Maintenan

ce labor

Maintenan

ce 

Materials

Catalyst 

replacement 

Volume

Catalyst 

Replacem

ent Cost

Capital 

Recovery Overhead

120265.4 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 874.3 463865.6 176701.6 384810.5

31090.33 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 226.0 119915.9 94631.3 124935.6

144660.3 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 1051.7 557957.1 190924.9 455902.3

156247.3 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 1135.9 602648.2 197038.4 489669.2

4825.321 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 35.1 18611.3 36663.03 48393.85

60868.71 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 442.5 234771.6 130387.6 211716

54102.87 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 393.3 208675.6 123413.4 191998.9

56981.12 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 414.2 219777.1 126443.4 200386.8

133504.9 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 970.6 514930.6 184666.8 423393.1

73916.78 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 537.4 285098.2 142557.9 249740.8

112695.2 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 819.3 434667.1 171851.1 362749.2

13579.34 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 98.7 52375.7 62578.1 73904.9

24572.14 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 178.6 94775.1 84287.86 105940.2

209711.7 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 1524.6 808861.4 221170.4 645475.8

27604.54 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 200.7 106471.1 89271.26 114777.3

42559.24 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 309.4 164151.7 110149.5 158358.4

36082.58 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 262.3 139171.1 101738.4 139484.1

35937.11 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 261.3 138610.0 101539.7 139060.1

128750.8 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 936.0 496593.7 181877.7 409538.5

89125.51 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 647.9 343758.5 155076.7 294062.2

236461.5 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 1719.0 912035.6 231264.2 723430.1

92542.47 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 672.8 356937.8 157686.9 304020
78605.99 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 571.5 303184.5 146587.6 263406.2

99787.27 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 725.4 384881.0 163008.5 325132.8

47008.8 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 341.7 181313.7 115493.9 171325.3

48837.69 18165 2724.75 18165 18165 355.0 188367.7 117601.9 176655.1
Admin/Prope

rty

Taxes/Insura

nce

Total Annual 

costs $/yr $/scfm

$94,918.17 $1,297,781 7.79

$45,281.38 $473,074 10.99

$105,010.20 $1,511,675 7.55

$109,531.53 $1,612,354 7.45

$16,340.36 $182,054 27.25

$65,395.27 $760,359 9.02

$61,312.52 $696,723 9.30

$63,076.09 $723,884 9.17

$100,499.50 $1,414,215 7.65

$72,726.66 $881,260 8.61

$91,601.32 $1,230,784 7.89

$28,780.76 $288,439 15.34

$39,812.16 $406,607 11.95

$128,666.10 $2,071,105 7.13

$42,429.19 $437,773 11.45

$53,768.37 $586,207 9.95

$49,124.92 $522,821 10.46

$49,016.47 $521,383 10.48

$98,525.46 $1,372,506 7.70

$80,565.75 $1,019,808 8.26

$137,400.60 $2,297,812 7.02

$82,241.22 $1,050,648 8.20
$75,215.63 $924,220 8.49

$85,703.45 $1,115,733 8.07

$56,774.53 $629,136 9.66

$57,972.53 $646,655 9.56
MACT 

Floor 

Emission 

limit 

(mg/dscm

)

MACT Floor 

Emission limit 

(gr/dscf) Meets limit? Facility Name

9.20 0.00 Yes ALIPRiverdale

9.20 0.00 No ARDomtarIndustries

9.20 0.00 No ARDomtarIndustries

9.20 0.00 No ARDomtarIndustries

9.20 0.00 No ARPlantersCottonOil

CAWheelabratorShasta

CAWheelabratorShasta

CAWheelabratorShasta

9.20 0.00 No LAInternationalPaperRedRiverMill

9.20 0.00 No LAIPMansfield

9.20 0.00 No LAIPMansfield

9.20 0.00 Yes MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC

9.20 0.00 Yes MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC

9.20 0.00 No OKIPValliant

9.20 0.00 Yes ORGPToledo

9.20 0.00 No TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA

9.20 0.00 No TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA

9.20 0.00 No TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA

9.20 0.00 Yes TNPackagingCorpCounce

9.20 0.00 No TNTempleInland2426

9.20 0.00 No TXInternationalPaperQueenCity

9.20 0.00 No WALongviewFPP

9.20 0.00 No WALongviewFPP

9.20 0.00 No WALongviewFPP

9.20 0.00 No WINSPWAshland

9.20 0.00 No WINSPWAshland
Combustor ID

Design 

Capacity

(mmbtu/hr)

Annual 

operating 

hours, 

hr/yr (H)

Exhaust gas flow rate, 

dscfm (Q)

No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02 667 8400 158368.5556

PB1 580 8049 47008

PB2 820 8520 189561.5342

PB3 790 8160 198150.8254

Boiler #3 (SN-72) 25 8760 6115.018215

Boiler#1 339 8202 87594.98246

Boiler#2 339 8186 81539.6

Boiler#3 339 8035 85326.91304

EQT011 Hogged Fuel Boiler No. 2 940 8300 181353.75

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / EQT005 760 8700 108161.3333

2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler 760 8700 164971.8868

Boiler No.1 84 8400 20546.4612

Dryer Furnace 152 8000 37179.31075

Bark Boiler EUG-D1 900 8338 225741.4466

EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4 296.6 8600 39830.39496

Boiler 18 246 3700 61503.75

Boiler 19 246 5500 52418.25

Boiler 20 246 5500 52207

Combination Boiler #2 860 8566 180318.4167

5000F 527 8544 95909

PB02 487.075 8400 257292.2524

#12 Power Boiler 316.25 7000 97527.65

#13 Power Boiler 316.25 7000 118936.25

#20 Power Boiler 900 8000 104383.1897

B20 275 8200 68566.5

B21 275 8200 71234.10227

Input Parameters
Actual gas flow into fabric 

filter, acfm (AQ)

PM 

concentration, 

gr/dscf (PM)

 a. 

lb/min b. scfm

Operating 

labor rate, 

$/hr (LR)

Electricity

cost, 

$/kWh 

(EC)

Compress

ed air 

cost, 

$/1,000 

ft3 (CAC)

Dust 

disposal 

cost, $/ton 

(DDC)

240472.3403 0.001429166 846.9633 18115.6 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

70122.0823 0.008060621 251.4012 5377.193 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

326271.2607 0.014349692 1013.785 21683.73 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

352404.8794 0.008060621 1059.721 22666.25 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

10883.17598 0.028166263 32.70344 699.4901 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

130661.4498 1.04E-02 468.4625 10019.89 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

122025.2559 8.73E-03 436.078 9327.224 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

128516.9539 8.70E-03 456.3328 9760.451 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

270526.224 0.008828487 969.8893 20744.85 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

166714.1581 0.028166263 578.4524 12372.45 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

254176.1459 0.028166263 882.2782 18870.95 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

30627.26337 0.002050665 109.8835 2350.287 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

55420.76229 0.002050665 198.8369 4252.9 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

336739.7102 0.048005985 1207.277 25822.31 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

60002.07341 0.003011301 213.015 4556.155 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

95487.13599 0.028321089 328.9253 7035.346 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

81381.75811 0.03360944 280.3355 5996.065 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

81053.65385 0.03047532 279.2057 5971.901 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

277933.1413 0.00340902 964.3523 20626.42 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

142303.0908 0.095933317 512.9263 10970.92 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

369467.0198 0.047201814 1376.012 29431.37 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

145378.0689 0.008124801 521.5829 11156.08 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

177290.3501 0.007255094 636.0772 13604.99 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

156235.7564 0.005900227 558.2467 11940.28 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

106025.0668 0.012494133 366.6972 7843.246 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

110150.007 0.012494133 380.9637 8148.39 51.26 0.069981 0.31 42.14111

Water vapor in gas 

from incinerator 

nput Parameters (7.1% by weight)
 a. Bag 

CRF, 2-yr 

life, 7% 

interest

 b. 

Cage 

CRF, 4-yr 

life, 7% 

interest

 c. 

Equipmen

t CRF, 20-

yr life, 7% 

interest a. 2008 b. 1989

TCI

$ $/dscfm Electricity

Operating 

labor

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $17,602,551.77 111.1492853 501438.1 53824.05

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $5,849,907.62 124.4449374 143566.3 51574.97

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $21,006,062.75 110.813952 608497.5 54592.97

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $21,956,117.86 110.805079 609131.5 52286.22

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $1,366,566.59 223.4771091 21598.54 56130.8

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $10,685,510.70 121.9877029 271424.4 52555.34

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $9,924,736.95 121.7167726 252262.7 52452.82

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $10,413,845.61 122.0464357 259047.9 51485.27

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $20,066,843.93 110.6502839 567178.3 53183.29

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $13,619,071.58 125.9144203 355160.1 55746.34

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $18,314,980.15 111.0187954 540940.6 55746.34

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $2,926,136.44 142.415592 66276.94 53824.05

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $4,751,446.30 127.7981277 113136.9 51261

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $24,853,265.41 110.0961555 708890.9 53426.78

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $5,048,247.27 126.7435906 130192 55105.58

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $7,536,974.11 122.5449524 86155.37 23708.21

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $6,480,721.45 123.6348303 109285.9 35241.94

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $6,456,465.87 123.6705015 108849.1 35241.94

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $19,965,361.17 110.7228066 582021.8 54887.72

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $11,759,893.51 122.6151197 309442.9 54746.75

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $28,248,947.58 109.7932305 813780.9 53824.05

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $11,989,636.47 122.9357671 257781.9 44853.38

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $15,085,881.16 126.8400606 314111.7 44853.38

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $12,948,701.46 124.0496818 315222.9 51261

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $8,374,619.65 122.1386486 212708 52542.53

0.553092 0.295228 0.094393 575.4 357.5 $8,697,552.55 122.0981563 220930.2 52542.53

Capital recovery factors Cost Index Total Capital Investment
Supervisory

labor

Maintenance 

labor

Maintenance 

materials

Compressed 

air

Dust 

disposal

 a. Bag 

cost

 b. Bag 

replaceme

nt labor 

cost

 c. Bag 

replaceme

nt cost

8073.6075 29603.2275 352051.0353 75357.7993 343.3682 336297.6 29349.65 202236.5

7736.24604 28366.23549 116998.1523 21056.2255 550.8221 98064.87 8558.4 58972.46

8188.94475 30026.13075 420121.2551 103705.6 4185.637 456286.3 39821.41 274393.1

7842.933 28757.421 439122.3572 107279.283 2353.877 492833.9 43011.02 296371.4

8419.61925 30871.93725 27331.33186 3556.66981 272.4961 15219.99 1328.292 9152.717

7883.30104 28905.43714 213710.2139 39980.7585 1351.599 182728.4 15947.23 109885.9

7867.92274 28849.05004 198494.7391 37265.3546 1051.986 170650.8 14893.18 102622.9

7722.79003 28316.89678 208276.9122 38523.8866 1076.934 179729.4 15685.49 108082.4

7977.49313 29250.80813 401336.8785 83766.6706 2400.049 378327.6 33017.73 227511.7

8361.95063 30660.48563 272381.4317 54109.75 4786.848 233147.7 20347.46 140206.1

8361.95063 30660.48563 366299.6029 82496.9388 7301.088 355462.2 31022.2 213761.4

8073.6075 29603.2275 58522.72873 9597.7906 63.9205 42831.85 3738.057 25757.43

7689.15 28193.55 95028.92604 16540.4101 110.1578 77505.26 6764.104 46608.69

8014.01659 29384.72749 497065.3083 104746.619 16319.16 470926.3 41099.08 283197.1

8265.83625 30308.06625 100964.9455 19250.7875 186.2929 83912.16 7323.253 50461.56

3556.23188 13039.51688 150739.4823 13180.4544 1163.972 133537.6 11654.2 80304.39

5286.29063 19383.06563 129614.4289 16698.3496 1749.99 113811.4 9932.644 68441.81

5286.29063 19383.06563 129129.3174 16631.0274 1580.407 113352.5 9892.598 68165.87

8233.15736 30188.24366 399307.2234 88818.247 950.992 388686.1 33921.74 233740.9

8212.0122 30110.7114 235197.8703 45358.571 14197.74 199009.1 17368.09 119676.5

8073.6075 29603.2275 564978.9516 115781.389 18424.42 516695.1 45093.45 310720.6

6728.00625 24669.35625 239792.7293 37964.7659 1001.769 203309.4 17743.39 122262.5

6728.00625 24669.35625 301717.6233 46298.5009 1090.899 247938.4 21638.29 149100.6

7689.15 28193.55 258974.0292 46628.7972 889.8533 218493.8 19068.57 131393.8

7881.37875 28898.38875 167492.393 32434.4246 1268.706 148274.8 12940.36 89166.75

7881.37875 28898.38875 173951.0511 33696.2966 1318.066 154043.4 13443.81 92635.82

Direct Annual Operating Costs, $/yr

Bag replacement
 a. 

Number of 

bags

 b. 

Cage 

replaceme

nt labor 

cost

 c. 

Cage 

replaceme

nt cost Overhead

Property

taxes, 

insurance, 

and 

administra

tion

Capital 

recovery

TAC

$/yr

($/yr) / 

dscfm

Number of 

Ductlines

3817.021 29349.65 24752.61 266131.2 704102.1 1640130 3,876,760 24.47936 2

1113.049 8558.4 7217.897 122805.4 233996.3 545942 1,338,783 28.4799 1

5178.909 39821.41 33584.17 307757.6 840242.5 1953753 4,639,048 24.47252 2

5593.728 43011.02 36274.19 316805.4 878244.7 2041103 4,815,572 24.30256 2

172.7488 1328.292 1120.241 73652.21 54662.66 128024.5 414,794 67.83197 1

2073.991 15947.23 13449.41 181832.6 427420.4 996994.6 2,345,394 26.77544 1

1936.909 14893.18 12560.46 172598.7 396989.5 925952.5 2,188,969 26.84547 1

2039.952 15685.49 13228.67 177481.1 416553.8 971542.5 2,281,339 26.73645 1

4294.067 33017.73 27846.15 295049.1 802673.8 1870064 4,368,238 24.08684 2

2646.256 20347.46 17160.44 220290.1 544762.9 1270690 2,974,316 27.49889 1

4034.542 31022.2 26163.19 276641 732599.2 1706157 4,047,129 24.53224 2

486.147 3738.057 3152.565 90014.17 117045.5 273477.7 735,410 35.79252 1

879.6946 6764.104 5704.642 109303.6 190057.9 443564.9 1,107,200 29.78 1

5345.075 41099.08 34661.73 352734.5 994130.6 2315969 5,398,540 23.91471 2

952.4139 7323.253 6176.211 116786.7 201929.9 471172.6 1,190,800 29.89678 1

1515.669 11654.2 9828.805 114626.1 301479 702929.1 1,500,711 24.40031 1

1291.774 9932.644 8376.892 113715.4 259228.9 604483.1 1,371,506 26.16467 1

1286.566 9892.598 8343.119 113424.4 258258.6 602222.8 1,366,516 26.17496 1

4411.637 33921.74 28608.57 295569.8 798614.4 1859825 4,380,766 24.29461 2

2258.779 17368.09 14647.73 196960.4 470395.7 1097372 2,596,318 27.07064 1

5864.556 45093.45 38030.46 393887.9 1129958 2633581 6,110,645 23.74982 2

2307.588 17743.39 14964.24 189626.1 479585.5 1118784 2,538,014 26.02353 1

2814.133 21638.29 18249.08 226781 603435.2 1408204 3,145,239 26.44475 1

2479.933 19068.57 16081.86 207670.6 517948.1 1208345 2,790,299 26.7313 1

1682.938 12940.36 10913.51 154088.8 334984.8 781058 1,873,438 27.32293 1

1748.413 13443.81 11338.1 157964 347902.1 811173 1,940,231 27.23739 1

Cage replacement Indirect Annual Costs, $/yr Total Annual Cost
TAC - Duct

TCI - Duct - 

FRP

TCI - Duct - 

SS

TCI - Duct - 

CS

Duct 

Diameter CRF-DUCT elec (Mw) Dust disposal cost ($/yr)

 18,717 475,159 139,268 94,976 10.0991 0.09439293 7.16E+03 343

 24,238 638,958 180,352 118,874 5.4535 0.09439293 2.05E+03 551

 32,155 880,518 239,262 152,243 11.7635 0.09439293 8.69E+03 4,186

 37,585 1,049,722 279,661 174,681 12.2256 0.09439293 8.70E+03 2,354

 3,738 70,726 27,814 24,233 2.1485 0.09439293 3.09E+02 272

 96,435 3,000,218 717,558 405,991 7.4443 0.09439293 3.88E+03 1,352

 80,378 2,451,161 598,085 344,359 7.1940 0.09439293 3.60E+03 1,052

 92,206 2,854,601 686,095 389,837 7.3829 0.09439293 3.70E+03 1,077

 22,752 594,441 169,295 112,502 10.7116 0.09439293 8.10E+03 2,400

 197,964 6,672,476 1,473,023 782,886 8.4088 0.09439293 5.07E+03 4,787

 20,477 526,877 152,365 102,664 10.3828 0.09439293 7.73E+03 7,301

 7,931 173,992 59,011 45,590 3.6041 0.09439293 9.47E+02 64

 16,504 410,932 122,805 85,202 4.8482 0.09439293 1.62E+03 110

 34,244 945,300 254,802 160,912 11.9508 0.09439293 1.01E+04 16,319

 18,659 473,482 138,841 94,724 5.0447 0.09439293 1.86E+03 186

 44,650 1,273,459 332,234 203,466 6.3639 0.09439293 1.23E+03 1,164

 32,011 876,058 238,189 151,643 5.8751 0.09439293 1.56E+03 1,750

 31,758 868,240 236,306 150,589 5.8632 0.09439293 1.55E+03 1,580

 23,849 627,288 177,460 117,211 10.8572 0.09439293 8.31E+03 951

 122,491 3,912,171 911,438 504,523 7.7688 0.09439293 4.42E+03 14,198

 41,537 1,174,426 309,072 190,836 12.5180 0.09439293 1.16E+04 18,424

 130,328 4,191,053 969,757 533,866 7.8523 0.09439293 3.68E+03 1,002

 241,733 8,339,899 1,798,707 940,998 8.6714 0.09439293 4.49E+03 1,091

 161,645 5,324,253 1,202,781 650,008 8.1403 0.09439293 4.50E+03 890

 56,700 1,662,825 421,894 251,720 6.7058 0.09439293 3.04E+03 1,269

 62,131 1,841,154 462,312 273,195 6.8350 0.09439293 3.16E+03 1,318
Dust disposal unit cost ($/ton) Dust amount (tpy)

42 8.148059

42 13.0709

42 99.32432

42 55.85702

42 6.466277

42 32.07317

42 24.96342

42 25.55543

42 56.95268

42 113.5909

42 173.2533

42 1.516821

42 2.614022

42 387.2503

42 4.420694

42 27.62081

42 41.52692

42 37.50273

42 22.56685

42 336.9095

42 437.2078

42 23.77178

42 25.88681

42 21.11604

42 30.10615

42 31.27744
max test avg 

SO2

max test avg 

HCl

Baseline HCl 

conc 

(ppmvd@7%O

2)

HCl 

Emission 

Limit 

(ppmvd@7

% O2))

Meet HCl 

limit? Facility Name

4.56666667 0.13066667 4.6 0.45 no ALIPRiverdale

52.2756513 1.84497627 1.844976268 0.45 no ARDomtarIndustries

372.080019 14.2598896 14.25988955 0.45 no ARDomtarIndustries

52.2756513 1.84497627 1.844976268 0.45 no ARDomtarIndustries

52.2756513 15.7394963 15.73949633 0.45 no ARPlantersCottonOil

16.2 12.3733333 12.37333333 0.45 no CAWheelabratorShasta

12.98988 6.45 6.45 0.45 no CAWheelabratorShasta

18.93333 10.3966667 10.39666667 0.45 no CAWheelabratorShasta

57 36.7333333 36.73333333 0.45 no

LAInternationalPaperRedRiv

erMill

367.351746 15.7394963 15.73949633 0.45 no LAIPMansfield

173.939364 15.7394963 15.73949633 0.45 no LAIPMansfield

2.02877165 0.5220955 0.522095503 0.45 no

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLL

C

2.02877165 0.5220955 0.522095503 0.45 no

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLL

C

2.19 2.02443342 2.024433417 0.45 no OKIPValliant

46.5933449 78.3 78.3 0.45 no ORGPToledo

623.901948 6.31735246 6.317352457 0.45 no TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA

623.901948 7.35582135 7.355821354 0.45 no TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA

623.901948 5.27888356 5.27888356 0.45 no TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA

235.830388 4.99430965 4.994309645 0.45 no TNPackagingCorpCounce

79.16 0.64333333 79.16 0.45 no TNTempleInland2426

1.21364981 0.06813333 1.213649811 0.45 no

TXInternationalPaperQueen

City

55.4 0.38 55.4 0.45 no WALongviewFPP

18.6333333 0.79 0.79 0.45 no WALongviewFPP

5.66666667 0.4 5.666666667 0.45 no WALongviewFPP

33.8356667 0.09996935 33.83566667 0.45 no WINSPWAshland

29.3866667 0.09996935 29.38666667 0.45 no WINSPWAshland

1493892.468 20.9715911 732397.709 10.28156017
Combustor ID Flowrate (dscfm) Flowrate (acfm)

Efficiency

(%)

Temperatur

e (deg F)

No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02 158368.5556 240472.3403 90.2173913 302.418367

PB1 47008 70122.0823 75.6094424 400

PB2 189561.5342 326271.2607 96.8442953 400

PB3 198150.8254 352404.8794 75.6094424 400

Boiler #3 (SN-72) 6115.018215 10883.17598 97.1409504 400

Boiler#1 87594.98246 130661.4498 96.3631466 358.506957

Boiler#2 81539.6 122025.2559 93.0232558 400

Boiler#3 85326.91304 128516.9539 95.6716896 400

EQT011 Hogged Fuel Boiler No. 2 181353.75 270526.224 98.7749546 312.646986

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / EQT005 108161.3333 166714.1581 97.1409504 400

2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler 164971.8868 254176.1459 97.1409504 400

Boiler No.1 20546.4612 30627.26337 13.8088726 400

Dryer Furnace 37179.31075 55420.76229 13.8088726 400

Bark Boiler EUG-D1 225741.4466 336739.7102 77.7715584 152.266667

EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4 39830.39496 60002.07341 99.4252874 368.809524

Boiler 18 61503.75 95487.13599 92.8767628 395.5

Boiler 19 52418.25 81381.75811 93.8823963 400

Boiler 20 52207 81053.65385 91.4754702 400

Combination Boiler #2 180318.4167 277933.1413 90.9897457 363.113131

5000F 95909 142303.0908 99.4315311 148.809375

PB02 257292.2524 369467.0198 62.9217591 135.777778

#12 Power Boiler 97527.65 145378.0689 99.1877256 139

#13 Power Boiler 118936.25 177290.3501 43.0379747 400

#20 Power Boiler 104383.1897 156235.7564 92.0588235 137

B20 68566.5 106025.0668 98.6700425 400

B21 71234.10227 110150.007 98.4686933 400
Inlet Moisture 

(percent)

Inlet HCl 

Loading 

(lb/hr)

Inlet HCl 

Loading 

(mole 

fraction) TCI TCI - Pack TCI - Pump

17.415 4.132864702 0.000004 5,609,317 1,218,536 471,371

18.98598576 0.492024761 0.000002 835,748 53,919 34,363

11.11271429 15.33524707 0.000014 10,868,354 3,072,473 799,441

18.98598576 2.074011072 0.000002 7,139,697 1,354,887 863,474

18.98598576 0.546025577 0.000015 254,589 21,083 5,333

17 6.148799665 0.000013 2,593,218 471,962 128,060

17.25454545 2.983683083 0.000007 2,199,890 354,124 119,596

17.50847458 5.032740697 0.000011 2,488,322 439,835 125,959

21.7 37.79299245 0.000036 9,159,619 2,596,015 530,282

19.44666667 9.658001388 0.000017 4,289,225 968,868 245,093

19.81823899 14.73076064 0.000017 7,543,392 1,969,544 498,233

18.98598576 0.060857119 0.000001 321,052 2,480 15,009

18.98598576 0.110122405 0.000001 546,374 4,488 27,159

18.98598576 2.592621999 0.000002 7,047,494 1,379,830 825,091

17.09140756 17.6929714 0.000083 1,149,650 168,695 29,404

10.65 2.204251295 0.000007 1,778,259 274,946 93,586

12.18 2.187449783 0.000008 1,596,867 247,830 79,762

12.63 1.563490408 0.000006 1,498,887 217,521 79,440

11.52857143 5.109047623 0.000005 6,490,660 1,458,187 544,801

26.06 43.0714556 0.000062 3,580,115 801,863 139,470

19.9377551 1.771513646 0.000001 6,497,869 998,828 905,281

17.912 30.65221937 0.000043 3,490,275 762,643 142,484

16.21071429 0.533047282 0.000001 2,252,224 163,125 260,642

17.28275862 3.355696159 0.000004 3,358,029 647,034 229,688

18.98598576 13.1616737 3.609E-05 2,515,327 499,222 103,914

18.98598576 11.87579475 3.1344E-05 2,546,872 501,720 107,957
TCI - Tower TAC Fixed Capital Recovery

Overhead 

Cost

 2,107,154 3,990,406 2,891,320 2,463,491 203,456

 477,452 304,831 176,055 91,761 50,864

 3,485,097 8,876,877 6,655,488 5,966,434 254,320

 2,614,646 5,916,976 4,459,410 3,919,502 254,320

 145,921 187,807 89,000 27,953 50,864

 1,155,380 1,227,701 774,900 569,443 101,728

 1,015,431 1,061,224 672,796 483,072 101,728

 1,118,602 1,182,747 747,670 546,409 101,728

 3,074,036 6,610,487 4,592,549 4,022,708 203,456

 1,689,502 2,575,580 1,736,963 1,412,801 152,592

 2,638,499 5,337,554 3,818,087 3,312,895 203,456

 199,838 196,643 98,956 35,250 50,864

 338,205 239,191 132,708 59,989 50,864

 2,565,671 5,844,870 4,405,105 3,868,885 254,320

 580,123 444,336 223,075 126,225 50,864

 835,207 903,840 563,345 390,487 101,728

 753,360 839,023 516,258 350,655 101,728

 717,666 798,995 490,823 329,139 101,728

 2,390,673 4,553,740 3,313,641 2,850,558 203,456

 1,482,119 1,772,871 1,031,087 786,155 101,728

 2,494,432 5,432,891 4,081,390 3,567,155 254,320

 1,457,511 1,674,521 1,007,766 766,427 101,728

 1,100,809 1,469,966 984,527 741,846 152,592

 1,396,396 2,039,205 1,392,994 1,106,081 152,592

 1,099,540 1,252,561 754,680 552,339 101,728

 1,114,353 1,255,109 762,869 559,266 101,728
Administrative Cost Property Tax Insurance Variable

Cost of 

Caustic

Cost of WW 

disposal

 112,186 56,093 56,093 1,099,086 44,049 1,807.01

 16,715 8,357 8,357 128,777 1,239 50.84

 217,367 108,684 108,684 2,221,389 247,388 10,148.42

 142,794 71,397 71,397 1,457,566 26,122 1,071.57

 5,092 2,546 2,546 98,807 1,767 72.49

 51,864 25,932 25,932 452,802 37,575 1,541.41

 43,998 21,999 21,999 388,429 18,493 758.64

 49,766 24,883 24,883 435,077 32,082 1,316.08

 183,192 91,596 91,596 2,017,938 446,936 18,334.31

 85,784 42,892 42,892 838,617 93,768 3,846.58

 150,868 75,434 75,434 1,519,467 190,692 7,822.60

 6,421 3,211 3,211 97,687 28 1.15

 10,927 5,464 5,464 106,483 51 2.08

 140,950 70,475 70,475 1,439,765 23,912 980.93

 22,993 11,497 11,497 221,260 56,480 2,316.95

 35,565 17,783 17,783 340,496 13,570 556.65

 31,937 15,969 15,969 322,765 13,683 561.33

 29,978 14,989 14,989 308,172 9,530 390.93

 129,813 64,907 64,907 1,240,099 59,292 2,432.30

 71,602 35,801 35,801 741,783 202,009 8,286.87

 129,957 64,979 64,979 1,351,501 12,863 527.67

 69,805 34,903 34,903 666,755 141,099 5,788.18

 45,044 22,522 22,522 485,439 2,293 94.06

 67,161 33,580 33,580 646,211 21,433 879.24

 50,307 25,153 25,153 497,881 86,531 3,549.69

 50,937 25,469 25,469 492,240 77,918 3,196.35
Cost of 

solvent 

(water)

Cost of labor 

and 

supervisor

Cost of 

maintenance Electricity Cost (Total)

Number of 

Ductlines TAC - Duct TCI - Duct - FRP TCI - Duct - SS

 795.87 123,802 215,292 713,340 2 74,990 2,157,392 557,991

 5.60 30,950 53,823 42,707 1 24,238 638,958 180,352

 5,587.17 154,752 269,115 1,534,398 2 54,812 1,458,126 407,846

 589.95 154,752 269,115 1,005,916 2 51,656 1,348,158 384,369

 7.98 30,950 53,823 12,186 1 3,738 70,726 27,814

 339.45 61,901 107,646 243,799 1 96,435 3,000,218 717,558

 167.07 61,901 107,646 199,463 1 80,378 2,451,161 598,085

 289.82 61,901 107,646 231,843 1 92,206 2,854,601 686,095

 8,075.10 123,802 215,292 1,205,500 2 65,404 1,824,643 486,665

 1,270.63 92,851 161,469 485,412 1 132,648 4,236,857 987,016

 3,445.36 123,802 215,292 978,414 2 70,132 1,988,455 521,845

 0.13 30,950 53,823 12,884 1 7,931 173,992 59,011

 0.23 30,950 53,823 21,657 1 16,504 410,932 122,805

 540.04 154,752 269,115 990,465 2 53,448 1,410,702 397,698

 255.12 30,950 53,823 77,434 1 18,659 473,482 138,841

 122.58 61,901 107,646 156,700 1 44,650 1,273,459 332,234

 123.61 61,901 107,646 138,850 1 32,011 876,058 238,189

 86.09 61,901 107,646 128,619 1 31,758 868,240 236,306

 1,071.27 123,802 215,292 838,210 2 63,568 1,761,139 473,002

 1,824.92 61,901 107,646 360,116 1 122,491 3,912,171 911,438

 290.51 154,752 269,115 913,953 2 49,990 1,289,603 371,966

 1,274.66 61,901 107,646 349,047 1 130,328 4,191,053 969,757

 31.07 92,851 161,469 228,701 1 118,567 3,715,579 882,243

 290.44 92,851 161,469 369,288 1 150,476 4,909,041 1,119,675

 781.71 61,901 107,646 237,472 1 56,700 1,662,825 421,894

 703.90 61,901 107,646 240,875 1 62,131 1,841,154 462,312
TCI - Duct - 

CS

Duct 

Diameter

Wastewater 

Disposal 

Amount

Electricity

Amount (Fan)

Electricity Amount 

(Pump) TCI (Total) TCI ($/dscfm)

338,953 10.0991 332,225 2,170,804 377,527 6,167,308 39

118,874 5.4535 9,348 500,182 110,087 1,016,100 22

266,584 11.7635 1,865,826 3,872,954 512,226 11,276,199 59

255,678 12.2256 197,012 2,321,569 553,254 7,524,066 38

24,233 2.1485 13,328 157,051 17,086 282,403 46

405,991 7.4443 283,395 1,536,761 205,130 3,310,777 38

344,359 7.1940 139,480 1,233,546 191,572 2,797,975 34

389,837 7.3829 241,966 1,454,704 201,764 3,174,417 37

304,304 10.7116 3,370,832 3,881,811 424,709 9,646,284 53

546,329 8.4088 707,208 2,050,379 261,731 5,276,241 49

321,370 10.3828 1,438,215 3,096,239 399,041 8,065,237 49

45,590 3.6041 211 136,025 48,083 380,063 18

85,202 4.8482 382 222,463 87,007 669,179 18

261,839 11.9508 180,347 2,302,006 528,660 7,445,192 33

94,724 5.0447 425,981 1,012,303 94,200 1,288,491 32

203,466 6.3639 102,342 969,680 149,909 2,110,493 34

151,643 5.8751 103,202 864,290 127,764 1,835,055 35

150,589 5.8632 71,873 791,706 127,249 1,735,193 33

297,700 10.8572 447,188 2,558,078 436,338 6,963,663 39

504,523 7.7688 1,523,572 2,349,544 223,407 4,491,553 47

250,044 12.5180 97,015 2,031,959 580,040 6,869,835 27

533,866 7.8523 1,064,179 2,265,633 228,235 4,460,032 46

496,102 8.6714 17,293 811,012 278,335 3,134,467 26

609,509 8.1403 161,652 1,513,710 245,280 4,477,704 43

251,720 6.7058 652,624 1,530,237 166,453 2,937,220 43

273,195 6.8350 587,661 1,548,075 172,929 3,009,184 42
TAC (Total) TAC ($/dscfm)

Duct - Capital 

Recovery

Duct - 

Administrativ

e Cost

Duct - 

Property Tax

Duct - 

Insurance

Solvent (water) 

Amount

Ds (Scrubber 

Diameter)

 4,140,356 26 52,493 11,234 5,617 5,617 1,328,901 28.68789

 353,297 8 16,967 3,631 1,815 1,815 9,348 15.49150

 8,986,478 47 38,368 8,211 4,105 4,105 9,329,130 33.41608

 6,020,268 30 36,159 7,738 3,869 3,869 985,062 34.72858

 195,282 32 2,617 560 280 280 13,328 6.10301

 1,420,532 16 67,504 14,446 7,223 7,223 566,789 21.14656

 1,221,949 15 56,265 12,041 6,020 6,020 278,959 20.43577

 1,367,123 16 64,544 13,813 6,906 6,906 483,932 20.97231

 6,741,269 37 45,783 9,798 4,899 4,899 13,483,327 30.42782

 2,840,823 26 92,854 19,871 9,935 9,935 2,121,624 23.88649

 5,477,791 33 49,093 10,506 5,253 5,253 5,752,860 29.49399

 212,501 10 5,551 1,188 594 594 211 10.23812

 272,193 7 11,553 2,472 1,236 1,236 382 13.77217

 5,951,744 26 37,414 8,006 4,003 4,003 901,734 33.94793

 481,647 12 13,061 2,795 1,398 1,398 425,981 14.33010

 993,122 16 31,255 6,689 3,344 3,344 204,685 18.07751

 903,032 17 22,408 4,795 2,398 2,398 206,404 16.68897

 862,498 17 22,230 4,757 2,379 2,379 143,746 16.65530

 4,680,851 26 44,498 9,523 4,761 4,761 1,788,750 30.84155

 2,017,803 21 85,744 18,349 9,175 9,175 3,047,143 22.06852

 5,532,850 22 34,993 7,488 3,744 3,744 485,073 35.55936

 1,935,126 20 91,230 19,523 9,762 9,762 2,128,357 22.30568

 1,707,053 14 82,997 17,761 8,881 8,881 51,880 24.63251

 2,340,098 22 105,333 22,541 11,271 11,271 484,956 23.12365

 1,365,937 20 39,690 8,494 4,247 4,247 1,305,247 19.04892

 1,379,347 19 43,492 9,307 4,654 4,654 1,175,323 19.41594
Scrubber 

Diameter 

Exponent 

(S1)

Scrubber 

Diameter 

Exponent 

(S2)

Hpack 

(Packing 

Constant)

Number of 

Packed 

Scrubbers CRFduct Hpack - A Hpack - B Hpack D Hpack E

-1.32 4.40 5.346127 4 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 3.245018 1 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 7.948137 5 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 3.245018 5 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 8.175182 1 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 7.621775 2 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 6.123523 2 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 7.221471 2 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 10.124276 4 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 8.175177 3 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 8.175177 4 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 0.341764 1 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 0.341764 1 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 3.458498 5 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 11.864837 1 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 6.075734 2 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 6.425749 2 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 5.662717 2 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 5.535272 4 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 11.890006 2 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 2.281766 5 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 11.069256 2 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 1.294318 3 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 5.825748 3 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 9.935301 2 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052

-1.32 4.40 9.611092 2 0.0944 1,582.6156 2,271 1 1,052
Hpack F Elec (Mw) Water (gal/yr)

 339.37 1.02E+04 334631.086

 339.37 6.10E+02 9415.27275

 339.37 2.19E+04 1879337.44

 339.37 1.44E+04 198439.012

 339.37 1.74E+02 13424.1032

 339.37 3.48E+03 285446.786

 339.37 2.85E+03 140489.587

 339.37 3.31E+03 243718.17

 339.37 1.72E+04 3395241.79

 339.37 6.93E+03 712329.262

 339.37 1.40E+04 1448629.85

 339.37 1.84E+02 212.686302

 339.37 3.09E+02 384.860927

 339.37 1.41E+04 181652.821

 339.37 1.11E+03 429065.735

 339.37 2.24E+03 103083.618

 339.37 1.98E+03 103949.445

 339.37 1.84E+03 72393.5356

 339.37 1.20E+04 450425.947

 339.37 5.14E+03 1534604.71

 339.37 1.31E+04 97717.2381

 339.37 4.99E+03 1071885.02

 339.37 3.27E+03 17418.4187

 339.37 5.28E+03 162822.779

 339.37 3.39E+03 657349.519

 339.37 3.44E+03 591916.945
Activated Carbon Injection Model Costs

Unit-specific field Unit-specific field Unit-specific field Unit-specific field Unit-specific field

Facility name Combustion equipment Annual operating 

hours (H)

Exhaust gas flow 

rate (Q)

Operating labor 

rate (LR)

Activated carbon 

cost (ACC)

Dust disposal cost 

(DDC)

Capital recovery factor, 20-yr 

equipment life, 7% interest (CRF)

Cost Index 

2008

Cost Index 

1990

ACI Adjustment 

Factor (AF) Total Unit cost Operating labor Supervisory labor Maintenance

hr/yr dscfm $/hr $/lb $/ton $ $/dscfm $/yr $/yr $/yr

= [i x (1 + i)a] / [(1 + i)a - 1], where i = 

interest rate, a = equipment life

= 4,500 x (Q/1,976)0.6 x (1.2 

retrofit factor) x (575.4/361.3) = $ / Q = (0.25 hr/8-hr 

shift) x H x LR

= 0.15 x 

(operating labor) = 0.2 x TCI

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02 8400 158368.5556 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.90 $119,351 $0.75 $9,083 $1,362 $23,870

ARDomtarIndustries PB1 8049 47008 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.89 $57,587 $1.23 $8,703 $1,305 $11,517

ARDomtarIndustries PB2 8520 189561.5342 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.60 $132,945 $0.70 $9,212 $1,382 $26,589

ARDomtarIndustries PB3 8160 198150.8254 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.89 $136,528 $0.69 $8,823 $1,323 $27,306

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72) 8760 6115.018215 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.89 $16,938 $2.77 $9,472 $1,421 $3,388

LAInternationalPaperRedRiverMill EQT011 Hogged Fuel Boiler No. 2 8300 181353.75 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.62 $129,461 $0.71 $8,974 $1,346 $25,892

LAIPMansfield 1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / EQT005 8700 108161.3333 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.52 $94,944 $0.88 $9,407 $1,411 $18,989

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler 8700 164971.8868 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.52 $122,312 $0.74 $9,407 $1,411 $24,462

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Boiler No.1 8400 20546.4612 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 -3.53 $35,048 $1.71 $9,083 $1,362 $7,010

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Dryer Furnace 8000 37179.31075 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 -3.53 $50,027 $1.35 $8,650 $1,298 $10,005

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1 8338 225741.4466 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.69 $147,635 $0.65 $9,015 $1,352 $29,527

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4 8600 39830.39496 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.89 $52,138 $1.31 $9,299 $1,395 $10,428

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 18 3700 61503.75 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.74 $67,665 $1.10 $4,001 $600 $13,533

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 19 5500 52418.25 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.70 $61,477 $1.17 $5,947 $892 $12,295

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 20 5500 52207 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.78 $61,328 $1.17 $5,947 $892 $12,266

TNPackagingCorpCounce Combination Boiler #2 8566 180318.4167 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.90 $129,017 $0.72 $9,262 $1,389 $25,803

TNTempleInland2426 5000F 8544 95909 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.35 $88,336 $0.92 $9,238 $1,386 $17,667

TXInternationalPaperQueenCity PB02 8400 257292.2524 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.89 $159,691 $0.62 $9,083 $1,362 $31,938

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler 7000 97527.65 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 1.00 $89,228 $0.91 $7,569 $1,135 $17,846

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler 7000 118936.25 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.99 $100,511 $0.85 $7,569 $1,135 $20,102

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler 8000 104383.1897 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.13 $92,940 $0.89 $8,650 $1,298 $18,588

WINSPWAshland B20 8200 68566.5 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.11 $72,226 $1.05 $8,866 $1,330 $14,445

WINSPWAshland B21 8200 71234.10227 $34.60 $1.38 $34.29 0.09439 575.4 361.3 0.11 $73,899 $1.04 $8,866 $1,330 $14,780

Facility/Unit ID Capital Investment Direct Annual Costs
Activated carbon Dust disposal Overhead Property taxes, insurance, and 

administration Capital recovery

$/yr $/yr $/yr $/yr $/yr $/yr ($/yr) / dscfm Elec Water ACI Dust

= 0.00127 x Q x 

H x ACC x AF

= 0.00127 x Q x (1 ton/2,000 lb) x 

H x DDC x AF

= 0.6 x (labor + 

maintenance 

materials)

= 0.04 x TCI = CRF x TCI = Direct Annual Costs + 

Indirect Annual Costs = ($/yr) / Q

lb/yr ton/yr

$2,098,329 $26,069 $20,589 $4,774 $11,266 $2,195,342 $13.86 1,520,528 760.26 Note:

$592,746 $7,364 $12,916 $2,303 $5,436 $642,291 $13.66 429,526 214.76 Factor of 1.27 x 10-3 for activated carbon is based on injecting carbon at a rate to achieve a carbon concentration of 338

$1,692,481 $21,027 $22,310 $5,318 $12,549 $1,790,868 $9.45 1,226,436 613.22 mg/dscm (achieving reductions of 90% for Hg, 98% for CDD/CDF).

$2,533,035 $31,470 $22,471 $5,461 $12,887 $2,642,777 $13.34 1,835,533 917.77

$83,918 $1,043 $8,568 $678 $1,599 $110,085 $18.00 60,810 30.41 Sources:

$1,631,464 $20,269 $21,728 $5,178 $12,220 $1,727,072 $9.52 1,182,220 591.11 1. Cost equations: Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI) [EPA-HQ-OAR-2006-0534] Model Plant Description and Cost Report (II-A-112).

$862,722 $10,718 $17,884 $3,798 $8,962 $933,891 $8.63 625,161 312.58 2. Operating labor rate: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Statistics, May 2007 National Industry-Specific Occupational

$1,315,857 $16,348 $21,168 $4,892 $11,545 $1,405,092 $8.52 953,520 476.76 Employment and Wage Estimates.

-$1,069,161 -$13,283 $10,473 $1,402 $3,308 -$1,049,807 -$51.09 -774,754 -387.38 information from Norit, an activated carbon vendor.

-$1,842,545 -$22,892 $11,972 $2,001 $4,722 -$1,826,789 -$49.13 -1,335,178 -667.59 4. Dust disposal cost: NSWMA’s 2005 Tip Fee Survey.

$2,281,174 $28,341 $23,937 $5,905 $13,936 $2,393,188 $10.60 1,653,025 826.51

$536,622 $6,667 $12,673 $2,086 $4,921 $584,089 $14.66 388,856 194.43

$295,609 $3,673 $10,880 $2,707 $6,387 $337,390 $5.49 214,210 107.10

$352,230 $4,376 $11,481 $2,459 $5,803 $395,483 $7.54 255,239 127.62

$390,914 $4,857 $11,463 $2,453 $5,789 $434,580 $8.32 283,271 141.64

$2,436,371 $30,269 $21,873 $5,161 $12,178 $2,542,307 $14.10 1,765,486 882.74

$504,910 $6,273 $16,975 $3,533 $8,338 $568,321 $5.93 365,877 182.94

$3,385,799 $42,065 $25,430 $6,388 $15,074 $3,517,138 $13.67 2,453,477 1,226.74

$1,196,489 $14,865 $15,930 $3,569 $8,422 $1,265,825 $12.98 867,021 433.51

$1,441,332 $17,907 $17,284 $4,020 $9,487 $1,518,837 $12.77 1,044,444 522.22

$190,361 $2,365 $17,121 $3,718 $8,773 $250,873 $2.40 137,943 68.97

$108,661 $1,350 $14,785 $2,889 $6,818 $159,144 $2.32 78,740 39.37

$112,888 $1,403 $14,986 $2,956 $6,976 $164,184 $2.30 81,803 40.90

15,313,194

Total cost

Direct Annual Costs Indirect Annual Costs Total Annual Cost
cription and Cost Report (II-A-112).
Selective Noncatalytic Reduction Costs

Parameters/Costs Equation facname facname facname facname

unitid unitid unitid unitid

A. Parameters

1. Incinerator capacity, lb/hr (C) 1,500 500 100 125

2. Annual operating hours, hr/yr (H) 6,000 2,000 4,000 1,500

3. Exhaust gas flow rate, dscfm (Q) 4,000 1,800 900 600

4. NOX, lb/MMBtu 0.28 0.28 0.28 0.28

5. Heating value, Btu/lb (HV) 8,500 8,500 8,500 8,500

6. Urea solution cost, $/gal (U) $0.85 $0.85 $0.85 $0.85

7. Electricity cost, $/kWh (EC) $0.07 $0.07 $0.07 $0.07

8. Water cost, $/1,000 gal (WC) $0.20 $0.20 $0.20 $0.20

9. Capital recovery factor, 20-yr equipment life, 

7% interest (CRF)

= [i x (1 + i)a] / [(1 + i)a - 1], where i = interest rate, a = 

equipment life

0.09439 0.09439 0.09439 0.09439

10. Cost index

 a. 2008 575.4 575.4 575.4 575.4

 b. 1998 390.6 390.6 390.6 390.6

B. Total Capital Investment (TCI)

1. Total Direct Capital Cost, $ (DC) = [$950/(MMBtu/hr)] x [(C x HV) / 106

] x [(2,375 MMBtu/hr / (C 

x HV)]0.577 x (0.66 + 0.85 x 45% NOX removal efficiency) x (1.2 

retrofit factor) x (575.4/390.6)

$455,625 $286,276 $144,917 $159,263

2. Indirect Installation Costs, $ (IC) = 0.2 x DC $91,125 $57,255 $28,983 $31,853

3. Other Capital Costs, $ (OC) = [0.173 x (DC + IC)] + (119.3 gal x U) $94,689 $59,532 $30,186 $33,164

4. Total

 a. $ = DC + IC + OC $641,439 $403,064 $204,087 $224,279

 b. $/dscfm = $ / Q $160.36 $223.92 $226.76 $373.80

C. Direct Annual Costs, $/yr

1. Maintenance = 0.015 x TCI $9,622 $6,046 $3,061 $3,364

2. Reagent = (0.36 gal/hr) x H x U $1,836 $612 $1,224 $459

3. Electricity = kW [0.47 x NOX x (C x HV) / 106

] / 9.5 x H x EC $71 $8 $3 $1

4. Water = (1.62 gal/hr) x H x WC $1,944 $648 $1,296 $486

D. Indirect Annual Costs, $/yr

1. Capital recovery = CRF x TCI $60,547 $38,046 $19,264 $21,170

E. Total Annual Cost

1. $/yr = Direct Annual Costs + Indirect Annual Costs $74,020 $45,360 $24,849 $25,481

2. ($/yr) / dscfm = ($/yr) / Q $18.50 $25.20 $27.61 $42.47

Sources:

1. Cost equations, urea solution cost: OAQPS Control Cost Manual. Section 4.2: NOX Post-Combustion, Chapter 1: Selective Noncatalytic Reduction.

2. Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI) [EPA-HQ-OAR-2006-0534] Heating value: Process Description Report (II-A-110).

3. Electricity cost: Energy Information Administration. Average Industrial Retail Price of Electricity: October 2009.

4. Water cost: Air Compliance Advisor, version 7.5.

5. NOX removal efficiency: Clean Air Technology Center. EPA Technical Bulletin: Nitrogen Oxides (NOX)--Why and How They Are Controlled. 456/F-99-006R.

November 1999.
Energy Recovery Unit Selective Noncatalytic Reduction Costs

Facility Name Combustion Equipment 

Unit Heat 

Input Capacity

(HI)

Annual operating 

hours (H)

Exhaust gas 

flow rate (Q) NOX

MMBtu/hr hr/yr dscfm lb/MMBtu

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02 667 8400 161206.3333 0.28

ARDomtarIndustries PB1 580 8049 47008 0.28

ARDomtarIndustries PB2 820 8520 189561.5342

0.28

ARDomtarIndustries PB3 790 8160 198150.8254 0.28

ARPlantersCottonOil Boiler #3 (SN-72) 25 8760 6115.018215 0.28

CAWheelabratorShastaBoiler#1 339 8202 87592 0.28

CAWheelabratorShastaBoiler#2 339 8186 81802.52273 0.28

CAWheelabratorShastaBoiler#3 339 8035 86154.38636 0.28

LAInternationalPaperRedRiverMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel Boiler No. 

2 940 8300 181353.6667 0.28

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler / 

EQT005 760 8700 108161.3333 0.28

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler 760 8700 164905.1955 0.28

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Boiler No.1 84 8400 20546.4612 0.28

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Dryer Furnace 152 8000 37179.31075 0.28

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1 900 8338 225741.4466 0.28

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4 296.6 8600 40252.70748 0.28

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 18 246 3700 61503.66667 0.28

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 19 246 5500 52418.33333 0.28

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 20 246 5500 52207 0.28

TNPackagingCorpCounceCombination Boiler #2 860 8566 180318.3333 0.28

TNTempleInland2426 5000F 527 8544 95396.25 0.28

TXInternationalPaperQueenCity PB02 203.9795881 8400 247680.9744 0.28

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler 316.25 7000 97527.64444 0.28

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler 316.25 7000 118936.1667 0.28

WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler 900 8000 104811.5814 0.28

WINSPWAshland B20 275 8200 68566.5 0.28

WINSPWAshland B21 275 8200 71234.10227 0.28

Facility/Unit ID
Urea solution 

cost (U)

Electricity

cost (EC)

Water 

cost (WC)

Capital recovery factor, 20-yr 

equipment life, 7% interest (CRF)

Cost Index - 

2008

Cost Index - 

1998

$/gal $/kWh $/1000 gal

= [i x (1 + i)a] / [(1 + i)a - 1], where i 

= interest rate, a = equipment life

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

$0.85 $0.07 $0.20 0.09439 575.4 390.6

Parameters
Total Direct Capital Cost (DC) Indirect Installation 

Costs (IC)

Other Capital 

Costs (OC)

$ $ $

= [$950/(MMBtu/hr)] x (HI) x [2,375 MMBtu/hr / HI]0.577 x (0.66 

+ 0.85 x 45% NOX removal efficiency) x (1.2 retrofit factor) x 

(575.4/390.6)

= 0.2 x DC

= [0.173 x (DC 

+ IC)] + (119.3 

gal x U)

$2,429,862 $485,972 $504,541

$2,290,374 $458,075 $475,583

$2,651,671 $530,334 $550,588

$2,610,193 $522,039 $541,978

$605,766 $121,153 $125,858

$1,824,950 $364,990 $378,961

$1,824,950 $364,990 $378,961

$1,824,950 $364,990 $378,961

$2,809,374 $561,875 $583,327

$2,567,796 $513,559 $533,176

$2,567,796 $513,559 $533,176

$1,011,455 $202,291 $210,079

$1,299,859 $259,972 $269,952

$2,758,170 $551,634 $572,697

$1,724,665 $344,933 $358,142

$1,593,463 $318,693 $330,904

$1,593,463 $318,693 $330,904

$1,593,463 $318,693 $330,904

$2,705,635 $541,127 $561,791

$2,199,390 $439,878 $456,695

$1,472,081 $294,416 $305,705

$1,772,105 $354,421 $367,990

$1,772,105 $354,421 $367,990

$2,758,170 $551,634 $572,697

$1,670,376 $334,075 $346,871

$1,670,376 $334,075 $346,871

Total Capital Investment (TCI)
Total Capital 

Investment

Total Capital 

Investment/dscfm Maintenance Reagent Electricity

$ $/dscfm $/yr $/yr $/yr

= DC + IC + OC = $ / Q = 0.015 x TCI = (0.36 gal/hr) x H 

x U

= kW [0.47 x NOX x HI / 106] / 

9.5 x H x EC

$3,420,376 $21.22 $51,306 $2,570 $5,185

$3,224,032 $68.58 $48,360 $2,463 $4,320

$3,732,594 $19.69 $55,989 $2,607 $6,465

$3,674,210 $18.54 $55,113 $2,497 $5,965

$852,778 $139.46 $12,792 $2,681 $203

$2,568,901 $29.33 $38,534 $2,510 $2,573

$2,568,901 $31.40 $38,534 $2,505 $2,568

$2,568,901 $29.82 $38,534 $2,459 $2,521

$3,954,576 $21.81 $59,319 $2,540 $7,220

$3,614,532 $33.42 $54,218 $2,662 $6,118

$3,614,532 $21.92 $54,218 $2,662 $6,118

$1,423,825 $69.30 $21,357 $2,570 $653

$1,829,783 $49.22 $27,447 $2,448 $1,125

$3,882,501 $17.20 $58,238 $2,551 $6,944

$2,427,740 $60.31 $36,416 $2,632 $2,360

$2,243,060 $36.47 $33,646 $1,132 $842

$2,243,060 $42.79 $33,646 $1,683 $1,252

$2,243,060 $42.96 $33,646 $1,683 $1,252

$3,808,554 $21.12 $57,128 $2,621 $6,817

$3,095,963 $32.45 $46,439 $2,614 $4,167

$2,072,202 $8.37 $31,083 $2,570 $1,586

$2,494,516 $25.58 $37,418 $2,142 $2,049

$2,494,516 $20.97 $37,418 $2,142 $2,049

$3,882,501 $37.04 $58,238 $2,448 $6,663

$2,351,322 $34.29 $35,270 $2,509 $2,087

$2,351,322 $33.01 $35,270 $2,509 $2,087

Direct Annual Costs
Indirect Capital Costs

Water Capital recovery

$/yr $/yr $/yr ($/yr) / dscfm

= (1.62 gal/hr) x H x 

WC = CRF x TCI

= Direct Annual Costs 

+ Indirect Annual 

Costs

= ($/yr) / Q

$2,722 $322,859 $384,641 $2.39

$2,608 $304,326 $362,077 $7.70

$2,760 $352,330 $420,152 $2.22

$2,644 $346,819 $413,039 $2.08

$2,838 $80,496 $99,009 $16.19

$2,657 $242,486 $288,760 $3.30

$2,652 $242,486 $288,745 $3.53

$2,603 $242,486 $288,602 $3.35

$2,689 $373,284 $445,051 $2.45

$2,819 $341,186 $407,004 $3.76

$2,819 $341,186 $407,004 $2.47

$2,722 $134,399 $161,701 $7.87

$2,592 $172,719 $206,331 $5.55

$2,702 $366,481 $436,915 $1.94

$2,786 $229,162 $273,356 $6.79

$1,199 $211,729 $248,548 $4.04

$1,782 $211,729 $250,092 $4.77

$1,782 $211,729 $250,092 $4.79

$2,775 $359,501 $428,842 $2.38

$2,768 $292,237 $348,226 $3.65

$2,722 $195,601 $233,562 $0.94

$2,268 $235,465 $279,341 $2.86

$2,268 $235,465 $279,341 $2.35

$2,592 $366,481 $436,421 $4.16

$2,657 $221,948 $264,471 $3.86

$2,657 $221,948 $264,471 $3.71

Total Annual Costs

Total cost
Elec Water

Mw gal/yr

7.76E+01 13,608,000.00 Sources:

6.47E+01 13,039,380.00 1. Cost equations, urea solution cost: OAQPS Co

9.68E+01 13,802,400.00

2. Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators 

8.93E+01 13,219,200.00 3. Electricity cost: Energy Information Administra

3.03E+00 14,191,200.00 4. Water cost: Air Compliance Advisor, version 7

3.85E+01 13,287,240.00 5. NOX removal efficiency: Clean Air Technology 

3.84E+01 13,261,320.00 November 1999.

3.77E+01 13,016,700.00

1.08E+02 13,446,000.00

9.16E+01 14,094,000.00

9.16E+01 14,094,000.00

9.77E+00 13,608,000.00

1.68E+01 12,960,000.00

1.04E+02 13,507,560.00

3.53E+01 13,932,000.00

1.26E+01 5,994,000.00

1.87E+01 8,910,000.00

1.87E+01 8,910,000.00

1.02E+02 13,876,920.00

6.24E+01 13,841,280.00

2.37E+01 13,608,000.00

3.07E+01 11,340,000.00

3.07E+01 11,340,000.00

9.97E+01 12,960,000.00

3.12E+01 13,284,000.00

3.12E+01 13,284,000.00

1.37E+03 3.30E+08
ea solution cost: OAQPS Control Cost Manual. Section 4.2: NOX Post-Combustion, Chapter 1: Selective Noncatalytic Reduction.

nfectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI) [EPA-HQ-OAR-2006-0534] Heating value: Process Description Report (II-A-110).

ergy Information Administration. Average Industrial Retail Price of Electricity: October 2009.

mpliance Advisor, version 7.5.

ency: Clean Air Technology Center. EPA Technical Bulletin: Nitrogen Oxides (NOX)--Why and How They Are Controlled. 456/F-99-006R.
e Noncatalytic Reduction.

eport (II-A-110).

ey Are Controlled. 456/F-99-006R.
Energy Recovery Unit Incremental Control Model Costs

Facility name

Combustion 

equipment 

Annual 

operating hours 

(H)

Exhaust gas 

flow rate to FF 

(Qff)

Exhaust gas 

flow rate (Q)

Unc. HCl 

concentration 

(HClu)*

hr/yr acfm dscfm ppmvd

Used for bag 

replacement 

only

ALIPRiverdale No. 2 Bark Boiler / BK02 8400 240472.3403 158368.5556 0.130666667

ARDomtarIndustries PB1 8049 70122.0823 47008 1.844976268

ARDomtarIndustries PB2 8520 326271.2607 189561.5342 14.25988955

ARDomtarIndustries PB3 8160 352404.8794 198150.8254 1.844976268

ARPlantersCottonOi

l Boiler #3 (SN-72) 8760 10883.17598 6115.018215 15.73949633

CAWheelabratorSh

asta Boiler#1 8202 130661.4498 87594.98246 12.37333333

CAWheelabratorSh

asta Boiler#2 8186 122025.2559 81539.6 6.45

CAWheelabratorSh

asta Boiler#3 8035 128516.9539 85326.91304 10.39666667

LAInternationalPap

erRedRiverMill

EQT011 Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2 8300 270526.224 181353.75 36.73333333

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 Power Boiler 

/ EQT005 8700 166714.1581 108161.3333 15.73949633

LAIPMansfield 2-78 - No. 2 Power Boiler 8700 254176.1459 164971.8868 15.73949633

MEHuberEngineere

dWoodLLC Boiler No.1 8400 30627.26337 20546.4612 0.522095503

MEHuberEngineere

dWoodLLC Dryer Furnace 8000 55420.76229 37179.31075 0.522095503

OKIPValliant Bark Boiler EUG-D1 8338 336739.7102 225741.4466 2.024433417

ORGPToledo EU11 - Hog Fuel Boiler #4 8600 60002.07341 39830.39496 78.3

TNEastman_NO_C

BIDATA Boiler 18 3700 95487.13599 61503.75 6.317352457

TNEastman_NO_C

BIDATA Boiler 19 5500 81381.75811 52418.25 7.355821354

TNEastman_NO_C

BIDATA Boiler 20 5500 81053.65385 52207 5.27888356

TNPackagingCorpC

ounce Combination Boiler #2 8566 277933.1413 180318.4167 4.994309645

TNTempleInland24

26 5000F 8544 142303.0908 95909 0.643333333

TXInternationalPap

erQueenCity PB02 8400 369467.0198 257292.2524 0.068133333

WALongviewFPP #12 Power Boiler 7000 145378.0689 97527.65 0.38

WALongviewFPP #13 Power Boiler 7000 177290.3501 118936.25 0.79

Facility/Unit ID
WALongviewFPP #20 Power Boiler 8000 156235.7564 104383.1897 0.4

WINSPWAshland B20 8200 106025.0668 68566.5 0.099969347

WINSPWAshland B21 8200 110150.007 71234.10227 0.099969347
Cont. HCl 

concentration 

(HClc)**

Operating 

labor rate 

(LR)

Wastewater 

(blowdown) flow 

(B)

Caustic 

cost (CC)

Sewage 

disposal cost 

(SDC)

Water cost 

(WC)

Lime cost 

(LC)

Sodium

bicarbonate 

cost (SBC)

ppmvd $/hr gpm $/ton $/1,000 gal $/1,000 gal $/ton $/ton

0.5 $34.60 0.004 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.016 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.491 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.066 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.017 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.197 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.095 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.161 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 1.209 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.309 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.471 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.002 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.004 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.083 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.566 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.071 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.070 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.050 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.163 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.011 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.003 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.007 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.017 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440
0.5 $34.60 0.008 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.001 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440

0.5 $34.60 0.001 $357 $3.80 $0.20 $95 $440
Dust disposal 

cost (DDC)

Activated 

carbon cost 

(ACC)

Natural gas 

cost (NGC)

Electricity

cost (EC) Total bag cost

$/ton $/lb $/1,000 ft3 $/kWh

Bag CRF, 2-yr 

life, 7% interest

Cage CRF, 4-yr life, 

7% interest $/yr

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $336,298

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $98,065

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $456,286

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $492,834

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $15,220

$43.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $182,728

$44.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $170,651

$45.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $179,729

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $378,328

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $233,148

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $355,462

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $42,832

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $77,505

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $470,926

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $83,912

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $133,538

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $113,811

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $113,353

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $388,686

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $199,009

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $516,695

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $203,309

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $247,938

Capital recovery factors

= [i x (1 + i)a] / [(1 + i)a - 1], where i = 

interest rate, a = equipment life
$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $218,494

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $148,275

$42.14 $1.38 $9.58 $0.07 0.55309 0.29523 $154,043
Bag replacement 

labor cost 

Total cage 

cost 

Cage 

replacement 

labor cost

Urea solution 

cost (U) Caustic Sewage disposal

Makeup 

water

$/yr $/yr $/yr $/gal

= HCl x 

(3.117E9) x Q x H 

x CC

= B x (60 

min/hr) x H x 

SDC

= B x (60 

min/hr) x H x 

WC

$19,810

$21,936

$19,810 $0.85 $665 $7 $0

$5,777

$6,397

$5,777 $0.85 $189 $29 $2

$26,879

$29,763

$26,879 $0.85 $808 $953 $50

$29,031

$32,147

$29,031 $0.85 $809 $123 $6

$897

$993

$897 $0.85 $27 $35 $2

$10,764

$11,919

$10,764 $1.85 $359 $368 $19

$10,053

$11,131

$10,053 $2.85 $334 $178 $9

$10,587

$11,724

$10,587 $3.85 $343 $295 $16

$22,286

$24,678

$22,286 $0.85 $753 $2,288 $120

$13,734

$15,208

$13,734 $0.85 $471 $613 $32

$20,939

$23,186

$20,939 $0.85 $718 $935 $49

$2,523

$2,794

$2,523 $0.85 $86 $4 $0

$4,566

$5,056

$4,566 $0.85 $149 $6 $0

$27,741 $30,718 $27,741 $0.85 $941 $158 $8

$4,943

$5,474

$4,943 $0.85 $171 $1,110 $58

$7,866

$8,711

$7,866 $0.85 $114 $59 $3

$6,704

$7,424

$6,704 $0.85 $144 $88 $5

$6,677

$7,394

$6,677 $0.85 $144 $63 $3

$22,896

$25,354

$22,896 $0.85 $772 $319 $17

$11,723

$12,981

$11,723 $0.85 $410 $22 $1

$30,437

$33,703

$30,437 $0.85 $1,081 $6 $0

$11,976 $13,262 $11,976 $0.85 $341 $11 $1

$14,605 $16,173 $14,605 $0.85 $416 $27 $1

Increase Caustic Flow 
$12,871 $14,252 $12,871 $0.85 $418 $14 $1

$8,734 $9,672 $8,734 $0.85 $281 $2 $0

$9,074 $10,048 $9,074 $0.85 $292 $2 $0
Makeup lime Dust disposal

$/yr ($/yr) / dscfm $/yr

= Caustic + 

Sewage disposal + 

Makeup water

= ($/yr) / Q

= (2.4E-7 lb/dscf) x HCl x 

Q x (1 ton/2000 lb) x (60 

min/hr) x H x LC

= HCl x Q x (60 min/hr) x 

(2.86E-7 lb/dscf) x (1 

ton/2,000 lb) x H x DDC

= Makeup lime + 

Dust disposal

$673 $0.00 $119 $63 $182

$220 $0.005 $477 $252 $730

$1,811 $0.010 $15,753 $8,327 $24,080

$939 $0.00 $2,040 $1,079 $3,119

$64 $0.01 $577 $305 $882

$746 $0.01 $6,081 $3,290 $9,371

$521 $0.01 $2,945 $1,630 $4,575

$653 $0.01 $4,876 $2,761 $7,636

$3,161 $0.017 $37,820 $19,992 $57,812

$1,116 $0.010 $10,131 $5,355 $15,486

$1,702 $0.01 $15,452 $8,168 $23,619

$90 $0.004 $62 $33 $94

$156 $0.004 $106 $56 $162

$1,107 $0.00 $2,606 $1,378 $3,984

$1,339 $0.034 $18,346 $9,697 $28,043

$176 $0.00 $983 $520 $1,503

$237 $0.00 $1,451 $767 $2,217

$210 $0.004 $1,037 $548 $1,585

$1,108 $0.006 $5,277 $2,789 $8,066

$433 $0.00 $361 $191 $551

$1,087 $0.00 $101 $53 $154

$353 $0.004 $177 $94 $271

$445 $0.004 $450 $238 $688

Total cost

Increase Lime Flow 

Total cost

ncrease Caustic Flow 
$432 $0.00 $228 $121 $349

$284 $0.004 $38 $20 $59

$295 $0.004 $40 $21 $61
Makeup NaHCO3 Dust disposal

($/yr) / dscfm $/yr

= ($/yr) / Q

= (2.73E-7 lb/dscf x HCl x Q) x 

(1 ton/2000 lb) x (60 min/hr) x H 

x SBC

= [(HCl x Q x 60 min/hr x 2.10E-7 

lb/dscf)] x (1 ton/2,000 lb) x H x 

DDC

= Makeup NaHCO3 + 

Dust disposal

$0.00 $626 $46 $673

$0.02 $2,516 $185 $2,701

$0.13 $82,993 $6,114 $89,107

$0.02 $10,750 $792 $11,542

$0.14 $3,038 $224 $3,262

$0.11 $32,035 $2,416 $34,451

$0.06 $15,514 $1,197 $16,712

$0.09 $25,686 $2,027 $27,713

$0.32 $199,251 $14,679 $213,931

$0.14 $53,373 $3,932 $57,305

$0.14 $81,406 $5,997 $87,403

$0.00 $325 $24 $349

$0.00 $560 $41 $601

$0.02 $13,731 $1,012 $14,743

$0.70 $96,652 $7,120 $103,773

$0.02 $5,181 $382 $5,562

$0.04 $7,642 $563 $8,205

$0.03 $5,462 $402 $5,865

$0.04 $27,799 $2,048 $29,847

$0.01 $1,900 $140 $2,040

$0.00 $531 $39 $570

$0.00 $935 $69 $1,004

$0.01 $2,370 $175 $2,545

Increase NaHCO3 Flow

Total cost Total Cost
$0.00 $1,204 $89 $1,292

$0.00 $203 $15 $217

$0.00 $210 $16 $226
Activated carbon Dust disposal

($/yr) / dscfm $/yr

($/yr) / 

dscfm

= ($/yr) / Q = (1.27E-3) x Q x 

H x ACC

= (1.27E-3) x Q x (1 

ton/2,000 lb) x H x DDC

= Activated carbon + 

Dust disposal

= ($/yr) / 

Q

$0.00 $2,331,477 $35,597 $2,367,074 $14.95

$0.06 $663,127 $10,125 $673,251 $14.32

$0.47 $2,830,562 $43,217 $2,873,779 $15.16

$0.06 $2,833,798 $43,267 $2,877,065 $14.52

$0.53 $93,883 $1,433 $95,316 $15.59

$0.39 $1,259,163 $19,681 $1,278,844 $14.60

$0.20 $1,169,831 $18,709 $1,188,540 $14.58

$0.32 $1,201,586 $19,652 $1,221,238 $14.31

$1.18 $2,638,077 $40,278 $2,678,355 $14.77

$0.53 $1,649,203 $25,180 $1,674,383 $15.48

$0.53 $2,515,429 $38,406 $2,553,834 $15.48

$0.02 $302,482 $4,618 $307,100 $14.95

$0.02 $521,284 $7,959 $529,243 $14.23

$0.07 $3,298,800 $50,366 $3,349,167 $14.84

$2.61 $600,338 $9,166 $609,504 $15.30

$0.09 $398,828 $6,089 $404,918 $6.58

$0.16 $505,275 $7,715 $512,990 $9.79

$0.11 $503,239 $7,684 $510,922 $9.79

$0.17 $2,707,079 $41,332 $2,748,411 $15.24

$0.02 $1,436,162 $21,927 $1,458,089 $15.20

$0.00 $3,787,815 $57,833 $3,845,648 $14.95

$0.01 $1,196,489 $18,268 $1,214,757 $12.46

$0.02 $1,459,134 $22,278 $1,481,412 $12.46

Total cost

Increase Carbon Flow

Total Cost
$0.01 $1,463,536 $22,345 $1,485,881 $14.23

$0.00 $985,391 $15,045 $1,000,436 $14.59

$0.00 $1,023,728 $15,630 $1,039,358 $14.59
Fan electricity

$/yr ($/yr) / dscfm

= (0.32 Btu/lb/°F) x (28.5 lb/lbmole) x (100°F) x 

(lbmole/385 ft3) x (ft3/1,000 Btu) x (Q/0.9) x (60 min/hr) x H 

x NGC

= ($/yr) / Q = 0.746 x (0.0205 x 

Q) x H x EC

$2,012,596 $12.71 $1,358,994

$572,430 $12.18 $386,530

$2,443,420 $12.89 $1,649,905

$2,446,214 $12.35 $1,651,791

$81,042 $13.25 $54,723

$1,086,944 $12.41 $733,953

$1,009,831 $12.38 $681,882

$1,037,242 $12.16 $700,392

$2,277,262 $12.56 $1,537,708

$1,423,638 $13.16 $961,303

$2,171,389 $13.16 $1,466,217

$261,111 $12.71 $176,313

$449,987 $12.10 $303,851

$2,847,617 $12.61 $1,922,836

$518,229 $13.01 $349,931

$344,280 $5.60 $232,473

$436,168 $8.32 $294,520

$434,410 $8.32 $293,333

$2,336,827 $12.96 $1,577,928

$1,239,735 $12.93 $837,124

$3,269,749 $12.71 $2,207,878

$1,032,843 $10.59 $697,421

$1,259,565 $10.59 $850,514

Natural gas

Increase Natural Gas
$1,263,365 $12.10 $853,080

$850,617 $12.41 $574,374

$883,711 $12.41 $596,721
Pump electricity Bag replacement

$/yr

($/yr) / 

dscfm

=0.746 x (0.00267 x Q 

+ 4.554) x H x EC

= Fan electricity + 

pump electricity

= ($/yr) / 

Q

= Bag CRF x [(total bag cost) + (bag 

replacement labor cost)]

$178,907 $1,537,900 $9.71 $196,960

$52,170 $438,699 $9.33 $57,434

$216,824 $1,866,729 $9.85 $267,235

$216,988 $1,868,779 $9.43 $288,639

$9,115 $63,838 $10.44 $8,914

$97,454 $831,407 $9.49 $107,019

$90,669 $772,551 $9.47 $99,946

$93,045 $793,437 $9.30 $105,263

$202,161 $1,739,868 $9.59 $221,576

$127,178 $1,088,482 $10.06 $136,548

$192,940 $1,659,158 $10.06 $208,185

$24,870 $201,183 $9.79 $25,085

$41,390 $345,241 $9.29 $45,393

$252,330 $2,175,166 $9.64 $275,809

$47,528 $397,459 $9.98 $49,145

$31,118 $263,591 $4.29 $78,209

$39,608 $334,127 $6.37 $66,656

$39,453 $332,786 $6.37 $66,388

$207,460 $1,785,388 $9.90 $227,643

$110,969 $948,093 $9.89 $116,554

$289,469 $2,497,347 $9.71 $302,614

$92,423 $789,844 $8.10 $119,073

$112,363 $962,877 $8.10 $145,211

Increase Scrubber Horsepower

Total cost
$112,924 $966,004 $9.25 $127,966

$76,670 $651,044 $9.50 $86,840

$79,580 $676,301 $9.49 $90,219
Cage replacement

 $/yr ($/yr) / dscfm $/yr ($/yr)/dscfm

= Cage CRF x [(total cage cost) + 

(cage replacement labor cost)]

= Bag replacement + Cage 

replacement = ($/yr) / Q = (0.36 gal/hr) x H x U = ($/yr) / Q

$12,325 $209,285 $1.32 $2,570 $0.02

$3,594 $61,028 $1.30 $2,463 $0.05

$16,722 $283,957 $1.50 $2,607 $0.01

$18,062 $306,701 $1.55 $2,497 $0.01

$558 $9,472 $1.55 $2,681 $0.44

$6,697 $113,716 $1.30 $5,463 $0.06

$6,254 $106,200 $1.30 $8,399 $0.10

$6,587 $111,849 $1.31 $11,137 $0.13

$13,865 $235,441 $1.30 $2,540 $0.01

$8,545 $145,093 $1.34 $2,662 $0.02

$13,027 $221,212 $1.34 $2,662 $0.02

$1,570 $26,655 $1.30 $2,570 $0.13

$2,840 $48,233 $1.30 $2,448 $0.07

$17,259 $293,068 $1.30 $2,551 $0.01

$3,075 $52,220 $1.31 $2,632 $0.07

$4,894 $83,103 $1.35 $1,132 $0.02

$4,171 $70,827 $1.35 $1,683 $0.03

$4,154 $70,542 $1.35 $1,683 $0.03

$14,245 $241,888 $1.34 $2,621 $0.01

$7,293 $123,848 $1.29 $2,614 $0.03

$18,936 $321,550 $1.25 $2,570 $0.01

$7,451 $126,524 $1.30 $2,142 $0.02

$9,087 $154,297 $1.30 $2,142 $0.02

Increase NOX Reagent

Reagent

Improve FF Performance

Total cost
$8,007 $135,973 $1.30 $2,448 $0.02

$5,434 $92,275 $1.35 $2,509 $0.04

$5,645 $95,865 $1.35 $2,509 $0.04
Secondary IMPACTS

Sources:

1. Cost equations: Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI) [EPA-HQ-OAR-2006-0534] Model Plan

Memorandum (IV-B-32); and Secondary Chamber Retrofit Cost Memorandum (IV-B-33).

2. Operating labor rate: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Statistics, May 2008 National Industr

and Wage Estimates.

3. Lime cost: U.S. Geological Survey. Mineral Commodity Summaries 2008. Hydrated Lime Average Value, 2007

4. Dust disposal cost: NSWMA’s 2005 Tip Fee Survey.

5. Natural gas cost: Energy Information Administration. Natural Gas Prices: 2008.

7. Water cost, sewage disposal cost: Air Compliance Advisor, version 7.5.

8. Activated carbon cost: The Innovation Group. Chemical Profiles: Carbon, Activated. 2002. Assumed 20% price 

PA-HQ-OAR-2006-0534] Model Plant Description and Cost Report (II-A-112); Wet Scrubber Cost Memorandum (IV-B-30); Dry Injection Fab

Statistics, May 2008 National Industry-Specific Occupational Employment

Hydrated Lime Average Value, 2007.

ctivated. 2002. Assumed 20% price increase based on online information

randum (IV-B-30); Dry Injection Fabric Filter Cost
Maintenance and Inspection Costs

Parameters/Costs Equation Values

A. Parameters

1. Cost index

 a. 2008 575.4

 d. 1992 358.2

B. Maintenance/Inspection Cost, $/yr (rounded)

1. Company A = $500 x (575.4/358.2) $800

2. Company B = $350 x (575.4/358.2) $600

3. Company C = $800 x (575.4/358.2) $1,300

4. Company D = $750 x (575.4/358.2) $1,200

5. Average = ∑ (Companies A-D) / 4 $1,000

Note:

Maintenance/inspection costs have been rounded to the nearest $100 to be

consistent with level of rounding in original costs.

Source:

Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI) [EPA-HQ-OAR-2006-0534] Maintenance/Inspection Programs Memorandum (II-B-88).
Monitoring Costs

Parameters/Costs Equation FF WS SNCR

Bag leak 

detector

CO 

CEMS

HCl 

CEMS PM CEMS

Hg 

CEMS

Multimetal 

CEMS

Dioxin or Hg 

sorbent trap 

biweekly

monitoring

A. Parameters

1. Recording lime/carbon flow, min/4-hr 

period

2. Annual operating hours, hr/yr (H)

3. Cost index

 a. 2008 575.4 575.4 575.4 575.4 575.4 575.4 575.4 575.4 575.4 575.4

 b. 2006 499.6 499.6 499.6 499.6 499.6 499.6 499.6 499.6 499.6 499.6

 c. 1997 386.5 386.5 386.5 386.5 386.5 386.5 386.5 386.5 386.5 386.5

 d. 1993 359.2 359.2 359.2 359.2 359.2 359.2 359.2 359.2 359.2 359.2

 e. 1992 358.2 358.2 358.2 358.2 358.2 358.2 358.2 358.2 358.2 358.2

4. Operating labor wage rate, $/hr (LR) $34.60 $34.60 $34.60 $34.60 $34.60 $34.60 $34.60 $34.60 $34.60 $34.60

5. Capital recovery factor, 20-yr 

equipment life, 7% interest (CRF)

= [i x (1 + i)a] / [(1 + i)a - 1], where i = 

interest rate, a = equipment life

0.09439 0.09439 0.09439 0.09439 0.09439 0.09439 0.09439 0.09439 0.09439 0.09439

B. Total Capital Investment, $ (TCI)

1. Planning $700 $700 $700 $800 $4,000 $3,300 $900 $3,300

2. Select type of equipment $400 $400 $400 $4,500 $10,000 $16,100 $12,200 $16,100

3. Provide support facilities $1,500 $1,500 $1,500 $500 $20,600 $20,600 $500 $20,600

4. Purchased equipment cost (PEC) $13,000 $19,300 $5,300 $14,100 $48,400 $51,900 $73,500 $109,900

5. Install and check equipment $1,000 $1,000 $1,000 $4,800 $18,200 $19,300 $19,500 $21,500

6. Perf. spec. tests (certif.) $700 $700 $700 $0 $15,700 $12,800 $35,500 $42,300

7. Prepare QA/QC plan $700 $700 $700 $800 $17,500 $17,500 $15,400 $17,500

8. Total capital cost = Planning + selecting equipment + 

support facilities + PEC + installation + 

perf. spec. tests + QA/QC plan

$18,000 $24,300 $10,300 $25,500 $134,000 $142,000 $158,000 $231,000 $230,000 $115,000

C. Annual Costs, $/yr

1. Operating labor = (5 min to record lime/carbon flow/4-hr 

period) x (1 hr/60 min) x H x LR

2. Maintenance materials = 0.02 x TCI $400 $500 $200

3. Operation & maintenance = Day-to-day activities + annual RATA 

+ CGA + annual QA + O&M review and 

update

$6,000 $27,600 $24,600 $27,300 $78,100

4. Recordkeeping and reporting = $1,000 x (525.4/386.5) $1,500 $1,500 $1,500 $200 $1,200 $1,600 $6,300 $1,600

5. Overhead = 0.6 x (labor + maintenance materials) $200 $300 $100

6. Property taxes, insurance, and 

administration

= 0.04 x TCI $700 $1,000 $400

7. Capital recovery = CRF x TCI $1,700 $2,300 $1,000 $3,500 $12,600 $20,200 $22,500 $32,900

8. Total annual cost = Operating labor + maintenance 

materials + recordkeeping and reporting 

+ overhead + property taxes, insurance, 

and administration + capital recovery

$4,500 $5,600 $3,200 $9,700 $41,400 $46,400 $56,100 $112,600 $63,300 $41,500

All model sizes
Notes:

1. Monitoring costs have been rounded to the nearest $100 to be consistent with level of rounding in original costs.

2. Costs to be replaced include: (a) bag leak detector replacing opacity test; (b) CO CEMS replacing CO test and secondary chamber temperature monitor;

(c) HCl CEMS replacing HCl test, HCl sorbent monitor (dry scrubbers) and scrubber liquor pH monitor (wet scrubbers); (d) PM CEMS replacing PM and

opacity tests and and pressure drop monitor (wet scrubbers); (e) multi-metal/Hg CEMS replacing flue gas temperature monitor (wet scrubbers); (f) dioxin

sorbent trap biweekly monitoring replacing fabric filter inlet temperature monitor; and (g) Hg sorbent trap biweekly monitoring replacing flue gas temperature

monitor (wet scrubbers).

Sources:

1. Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI) [EPA-HQ-OAR-2006-0534] Testing and Monitoring Options and Costs Memo (IV-B-66).

2. E-mail and attachment from Peter Westlin, EPA, to Mary Johnson, EPA. August 19, 2008. Monitoring Options for SNCR on Medical Waste Incinerators.

3. E-mail from Dan Bivins, EPA, to Mary Johnson, EPA. September 27, 2006. Cost of CO CEMS.

4. E-mail from Dan Bivins, EPA, to Mary Johnson, EPA. July 28, 2006. Some Preliminary Thoughts on the HWI Monitoring.

5. O2 Monitor from in situ monitor in OAQPS Control Cost Manual, assuming 1997 dollars and annualized for 20 year life.
Monitoring Costs

Parameters/Costs

A. Parameters

1. Recording lime/carbon flow, min/4-hr 

period

2. Annual operating hours, hr/yr (H)

3. Cost index

 a. 2008

 b. 2006

 c. 1997

 d. 1993

 e. 1992

4. Operating labor wage rate, $/hr (LR)

5. Capital recovery factor, 20-yr 

equipment life, 7% interest (CRF)

B. Total Capital Investment, $ (TCI)

1. Planning

2. Select type of equipment

3. Provide support facilities

4. Purchased equipment cost (PEC)

5. Install and check equipment

6. Perf. spec. tests (certif.)

7. Prepare QA/QC plan

8. Total capital cost

C. Annual Costs, $/yr

1. Operating labor

2. Maintenance materials

3. Operation & maintenance

4. Recordkeeping and reporting

5. Overhead

6. Property taxes, insurance, and 

administration

7. Capital recovery

8. Total annual cost

O2 Monitor ACI

5

6,000 fill in unit-specific annual operating hours here

575.4 575.4

499.6 499.6

386.5 386.5

359.2 359.2

358.2 358.2

$34.60 $34.60

0.09439 0.09439

$9,826

$4,300

$2,600

$927

$6,900
Notes:

1. Monitoring costs have been rounded to the nearest $100 to be consistent with level of rounding in original costs.

2. Costs to be replaced include: (a) bag leak detector replacing opacity test; (b) CO CEMS replacing CO test and secondary chamber temperature monitor;

(c) HCl CEMS replacing HCl test, HCl sorbent monitor (dry scrubbers) and scrubber liquor pH monitor (wet scrubbers); (d) PM CEMS replacing PM and

opacity tests and and pressure drop monitor (wet scrubbers); (e) multi-metal/Hg CEMS replacing flue gas temperature monitor (wet scrubbers); (f) dioxin

sorbent trap biweekly monitoring replacing fabric filter inlet temperature monitor; and (g) Hg sorbent trap biweekly monitoring replacing flue gas temperature

monitor (wet scrubbers).

Sources:

1. Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI) [EPA-HQ-OAR-2006-0534] Testing and Monitoring Options and Costs Memo (IV-B-66).

2. E-mail and attachment from Peter Westlin, EPA, to Mary Johnson, EPA. August 19, 2008. Monitoring Options for SNCR on Medical Waste Incinerators.

3. E-mail from Dan Bivins, EPA, to Mary Johnson, EPA. September 27, 2006. Cost of CO CEMS.

4. E-mail from Dan Bivins, EPA, to Mary Johnson, EPA. July 28, 2006. Some Preliminary Thoughts on the HWI Monitoring.

5. O2 Monitor from in situ monitor in OAQPS Control Cost Manual, assuming 1997 dollars and annualized for 20 year life.
Recording lime/carbon 

flow, min/4-hr period

Annual operating 

hours, hr/yr (H)

Operating labor wage 

rate, $/hr (LR)

ALIPRiverdale

No. 2 Bark 

Boiler / BK02 5 8400 34.6

ARDomtarIndustries PB1 5 8049 34.6

ARDomtarIndustries PB2 5 8520 34.6

ARDomtarIndustries PB3 5 8160 34.6

ARPlantersCottonOil

Boiler #3 

(SN-72) 5 8760 34.6

LAInternationalPaperRedRiver

Mill

EQT011 

Hogged Fuel 

Boiler No. 2 5 8300 34.6

LAIPMansfield

1-78 - No. 1 

Power Boiler 

/ EQT005 5 8700 34.6

LAIPMansfield

2-78 - No. 2 

Power Boiler 5 8700 34.6

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC Boiler No.1 5 8400 34.6

MEHuberEngineeredWoodLLC

Dryer 

Furnace 5 8000 34.6

OKIPValliant

Bark Boiler 

EUG-D1 5 8338 34.6

ORGPToledo

EU11 - Hog 

Fuel Boiler 

#4 5 8600 34.6

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 18 5 3700 34.6

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 19 5 5500 34.6

TNEastman_NO_CBIDATA Boiler 20 5 5500 34.6

TNPackagingCorpCounce

Combination 

Boiler #2 5 8566 34.6

TNTempleInland2426 5000F 5 8544 34.6

TXInternationalPaperQueenCit

y PB02 5 8400 34.6

WALongviewFPP

#12 Power 

Boiler 5 7000 34.6

WALongviewFPP

#13 Power 

Boiler 5 7000 34.6

WALongviewFPP

#20 Power 

Boiler 5 8000 34.6

WINSPWAshland B20 5 8200 34.6

WINSPWAshland B21 5 8200 34.6

FacilityID UnitID

Input Parameters
Operating labor ($/yr) Overhead ($/yr) Total Annual Cost ($/yr)

= (5 min to record lime/carbon 

flow/4-hr period) x (1 hr/60 min) 

x H x LR

= 0.6 x (labor + 

maintenance materials)

=Operating labor + Overhead

$6,100 $3,700 $9,800

$5,800 $3,500 $9,300

$6,100 $3,700 $9,800

$5,900 $3,500 $9,400

$6,300 $3,800 $10,100

$6,000 $3,600 $9,600

$6,300 $3,800 $10,100

$6,300 $3,800 $10,100

$6,100 $3,700 $9,800

$5,800 $3,500 $9,300

$6,000 $3,600 $9,600

$6,200 $3,700 $9,900

$2,700 $1,600 $4,300

$4,000 $2,400 $6,400

$4,000 $2,400 $6,400

$6,200 $3,700 $9,900

$6,200 $3,700 $9,900

$6,100 $3,700 $9,800

$5,000 $3,000 $8,000

$5,000 $3,000 $8,000

$5,800 $3,500 $9,300

$5,900 $3,500 $9,400

$5,900 $3,500 $9,400
Stack Testing Costs

Parameters/Costs Equation Values

A. Parameters

1. Cost index

 a. 2008 575.4

 d. 1992 358.2

B. Testing Costs, $ Annual PM, HCl, opacity;

1. Method 5 (PM) = $8,000 x (575.4/358.2) $12,000 Annual everything except CO:

2. Method 9 (opacity) = $1,000 x (575.4/358.2) + $1,500 $2,500 Annual PM, HCl, CO, Nox, SO2, opacity:

3. Method 10 (CO) = $4,000 x (575.4/358.2) + $1,000 $7,000

4. Method 26 (HCl) = $5,000 x (575.4/358.2) $7,000 Annual everything:

5. Method 29 (metals) = $8,000 x (575.4/358.2) + $2,000 $14,000

6. Method 23 (CDD/CDF) = $21,000 x (575.4/358.2) - $5,000 $26,000

7. Method 7E (NOX) = $5,000 x (575.4/358.2) $7,000

8. Method 6C (SO2) = $5,000 x (575.4/358.2) $7,000

Note:

1. Initial testing costs to be annualized over 15 years at 7% interest.

2. Testing costs have been rounded to the nearest $1,000 (except for opacity) to be

consistent with level of rounding in original costs; costs also adjusted based on

additional information from EPA.

3. Multiple test costs adjusted by 2/3 in nationwide cost estimates to account for travel,

accommodations, methods/sampling trains, etc. common to the tests.

Sources:

1. Memorandum from R. Segall, EPA/EMB, to R. Copland, EPA/SDB. October 14, 1992.

Medical Waste Incinerator Study: Emission Measurement and Continuous Monitoring.

(II-B-89)

2. E-mail from Jason Dewees, EPA, to Peter Westlin, EPA. August 20, 2008.

Monitoring Options for SNCR & Test Cost Questions.

3. E-mail from Jason Dewees, EPA, to Mary Johnson, EPA. August 20, 2008.

Re: Monitoring Options for SNCR & Test Cost Questions.

CRF (15 yr, 7%): 0.109795
Initial Test annualized (TAC)

$14,333

$50,333

$28,333

$55,000 $6,039
Visible Emissions Testing Costs

Parameters/Costs Equation Values

A. Parameters

1. Operating labor rate, $/hr (LR) $34.60

2. Capital recovery factor, 5-yr equipment 

life, 7% interest (CRF)

= [i x (1 + i)a] / [(1 + i)a - 1], where i = interest rate, a = equipment life 0.24389

B. Total Capital Investment, $ (TCI) = Combination light meter/anemometer ($200) + digital stopwatches 

(2 each at $25)

$250

C. Direct Annual Costs, $/yr

1. Operating labor = (1 hr/reading) x (3 readings/test) x (1 test/yr) x LR $104

D. Indirect Annual Costs, $/yr

1. Overhead = 0.6 x (operating labor) $62

2. Property taxes, insurance, and 

administration

= 0.04 x TCI $10

3. Capital recovery = CRF x TCI $61

E. Total Annual Cost, $/yr (rounded) = Direct Annual Costs + Indirect Annual Costs $200

Sources:

1. Professional Equipment. 2008. Light Meters Industrial and Professional: Digital Light Meter. Website: http://www.professionalequipment.com.

Accessed July 24, 2008.

2. Cole-Parmer. 2008. Digital Stopwatches -Cole Parmer Instrument Catalog. Website: http://www.coleparmer.com. Accessed July 24, 2008.
Recordkeeping and Reporting Costs

(A) (B) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G)

Burden item

Personhours per 

occurrence

Number of 

occurrences 

per year

Technical 

person-hours 

per year (C = A 

x B)

Management 

person-hours 

per year (D = C 

x 0.05)

Clerical 

person-hours 

per year (E = 

C x 0.1)

Total personhours per 

year (F = C + 

D + E) Cost, $

A. Applications N/A 

B. Surveys and Studies N/A 

C. Reporting Requirements

1. Read instructions 1.0 1 1.0 0.05 0.1 1.2 $41

2. Required activities

 a. Perf. spec. tests (certif.) for CMS 17 1 17 0.9 1.7 20 $696

3. Write report

 a. Notification of initial performance test

 i. Pollutants, fugitive ash emissions 2.0 1 2.0 0.1 0.2 2.3 $82

 ii. Fugitive ash emissions 1.0 1 1.0 0.05 0.1 1.2 $41

 b. Notification of initial CMS demonstration 2.0 1 2.0 0.1 0.2 2.3 $82

 c. Report of initial performance test

 i. Pollutants, fugitive ash emissions 8.0 1 8.0 0.4 0.8 9.2 $328

 ii. Fugitive ash emissions 2.0 1 2.0 0.1 0.2 2.3 $82

 d. Report of initial CMS demonstration Incl. in C2

 e. Annual report

 i. Results of performance tests conducted during the year 40 1 40 2.0 4.0 46 $1,638

D. Recordkeeping Requirements

1. Read instructions Incl. in C1

2. Plan activities N/A 

3. Implement activities N/A 

4. Develop record system N/A 

5. Time to enter information

 a. Records of initial performance test Incl. in C3

 b. Records of annual and any subsequent compliance tests Incl. in C3

E. Total Labor Burden and Cost 73 3.7 7.3 84 $2,989

Notes:

1. Industry costs are based on the following hourly rates: technical at $34.60, management at $82.23, and clerical at $22.32 (see table below). The composite hourly labor rate is

($34.60/hr) + (0.05 x $82.23/hr) + (0.1 x $22.32/hr) = $40.94/hr. Labor rates were increased by 60% to account for overhead.

2. Person-hours per occurrence for CMS performance specification costs are based on the performance specification costs to certify CMS ($700) divided by the composite hourly

labor rate ($40.94/hr).

3. Control device inspection cost already accounted for under monitoring costs.

4. Assume 8 hours for each facility to review the report of the initial performance test for pollutants and fugitive ash.

5. Assume 2 hours for each facility to review the report of the initial performance test for fugitive ash.

6. Assume 40 hours to review report of annual PM, CO, and HCl compliance reports.

7. The average recurrent burden and cost in the first 3 years after promulgation for the sources with recurrent burden are equal to the person-hours added down each column for

technical, management, and clerical and the sum of the cost column.
Recordkeeping and Reporting Costs

(A) (B) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G)

Burden item

Personhours per 

occurrence

Number of 

occurrences 

per year

Technical 

person-hours 

per year (C = A 

x B)

Management 

person-hours 

per year (D = C 

x 0.05)

Clerical 

person-hours 

per year (E = 

C x 0.1)

Total personhours per 

year (F = C + 

D + E) Cost, $

Sources:

1. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment Statistics, May 2008 National Industry-Specific Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates.

2. Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI) [EPA-HQ-OAR2006-0534] Testing and Monitoring Options and Costs Memo (IV-B-66).

Labor Rates:

Parameter

Pulp, Paper 

and 

Paperboard 

Mills

Pipeline 

Transportation

Cement and 

Concrete 

Product 

Manufacturing

Pharmaceutical & 

Medicine 

Manufacturing Total Loaded

1. Technical - Stationary Engineers & Boiler Operators $19.14 $21.11 $18.88 $27.36 $21.62 $34.60

2. Management - Engineering Managers $41.41 $58.22 $43.90 $62.05 $51.40 $82.23

3. Clerical - Office Clerks, General $14.21 $14.15 $12.58 $14.85 $13.95 $22.32

4. Composite labor rate $40.94
Cost Factor (in 2008$) Reference/Note Year of Costs

Advanced Combustion Controls (Linkageless Boiler Management System) -- cost is per boiler - TCI

LBMS costs are based on a 2008 quote provided 

to the U.S. Department of Energy. The installed 

cost for a LBMS on a 20 mmBtu/hr unit was are 

$19,127. The DOE noted that costs are relatively 

fixed, regardless of the size of the unit. 

Assumed to represent $2008, since that was the 

year the quote was obtained.

Activated Carbon Injection

Received spreadsheet of HMIWI model costs 

from Tom Holloway of RTI International. Originally $2004

Received spreadsheet of HMIWI model costs 

from Tom Holloway of RTI International. Originally $2004

Packed Scrubber

Received spreadsheet of HMIWI model costs 

from Tom Holloway of RTI International. Originally $2004

Secondary Chamber/Afterburner Retrofit

Received spreadsheet of HMIWI model costs 

from Tom Holloway of RTI International. Originally $2004

Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction

Received spreadsheet of HMIWI model costs 

from Tom Holloway of RTI International. Originally $2004

Catalytic Oxidizer

Used catalytic oxidizer costing for all sizes, 

though some fell outside the appropriate sizerange for the equation. Originally $2004

Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI). [EPAHQ-OAR-2006-0534]

$ 19,127

Fabric Filter

Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI). [EPAHQ-OAR-2006-0534]

EPA Air Pollution Control Cost Manual, Sixth Edition EPA 452/B-02-

001

Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI). [EPAHQ-OAR-2006-0534]

Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI). [EPAHQ-OAR-2006-0534]

Hospital/Medical/Infectious Waste Incinerators (HMIWI). [EPAHQ-OAR-2006-0534]