### Com Ben Tables 22MAR11.xls

Author: Abt Associates Inc. Created: 3/22/11

Worksheet Description

com ben tables Presents tables summarizing estimated commercial fishing benefits by region and regulatory option Purpose: Output from the program for estimating commercial fishing benefits

File Info 1 of 23Table 8 : Imp Ent and I&E

California : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California American Shad . 0 0 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Anchovies 0.5 0.1 0.6 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Cabezon 0.1 54.3 54.4 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California California Halibut 0.3 126.2 126.4 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California California Scorpionfish 0 . 0 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Commercial Crabs 0 1.6 1.6 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Commercial Shrimp 0 0 0 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Drums and Croakers 0.8 4.1 4.9 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Dungeness Crabs 0.4 3.9 4.3 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Flounders 1 9.1 10.1 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Other 0.7 3.9 4.7 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Rockfishes 3 1165.7 1168.7 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Sculpins 0.1 2.5 2.6 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Sea Basses 0 . 0 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Smelts 0.1 0 0.2 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Surfperches 0.5 . 0.5 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Total 7.7 1371.4 1379

Table 9 : Econ Tables:

California : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California American Shad 75.1 $0.98 0 . Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Anchovies 22607.2 $0.05 0.6 $0.00 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Cabezon 55.6 $5.83 54.4 $166.50 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California California Halibut 629.9 $4.06 126.4 $298.80 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California California Scorpionfish 7.9 $3.40 0 $0.00 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Commercial Crabs 1290.8 $1.33 1.6 $1.50 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Commercial Shrimp 2552.2 $1.93 0 $0.00 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Drums and Croakers 77 $0.63 4.9 $1.30 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Dungeness Crabs 14370 $2.07 4.3 $6.60 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Flounders 474.8 $0.45 10.1 $2.90 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Other 57125.4 $0.89 4.7 $2.20 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Rockfishes 2668.4 $1.25 1168.7 $907.70 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Sculpins 3.5 $3.43 2.6 $5.70 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Sea Basses 6.5 $2.39 0 $0.00 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Smelts 319.5 $0.38 0.2 $0.00 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Surfperches 30.9 $1.92 0.5 $0.40 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline California Total 102294.7 . 1379 $1,393.90 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline CaliforniaTotal (3% Discount Rate) . . . $1,236.00 Table 8:baseline:California

baseline CaliforniaTotal (7% Discount Rate) . . . $1,195.00

Table 10 : Imp

Ent and I&E

California : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Anchovies 0.5 . 0.5 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Cabezon 0.1 . 0.1 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California California Halibut 0.2 . 0.2 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California California Scorpionfish 0 . 0 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Commercial Crabs 0 . 0 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Commercial Shrimp 0 . 0 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Drums and Croakers 0.7 . 0.7 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Dungeness Crabs 0.4 . 0.4 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Flounders 0.9 . 0.9 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Other 0.6 . 0.6 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Rockfishes 2.6 . 2.6

com ben tables 2 of 23Table 9:tmn1:California tmn1 California Sculpins 0.1 . 0.1 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Sea Basses 0 . 0 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Smelts 0.1 . 0.1 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Surfperches 0.5 . 0.5 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Total 6.7 . 6.7

Table 11 : Econ Tables:

California : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Anchovies 22607.2 $0.05 0.5 $0.00 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Cabezon 55.6 $5.83 0.1 $0.20 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California California Halibut 629.9 $4.06 0.2 $0.60 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California California Scorpionfish 7.9 $3.40 0 $0.00 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Commercial Crabs 1290.8 $1.33 0 $0.00 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Commercial Shrimp 2552.2 $1.93 0 $0.00 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Drums and Croakers 77 $0.63 0.7 $0.20 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Dungeness Crabs 14370 $2.07 0.4 $0.60 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Flounders 474.8 $0.45 0.9 $0.30 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Other 57125.4 $0.89 0.6 $0.30 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Rockfishes 2668.4 $1.25 2.6 $2.00 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Sculpins 3.5 $3.43 0.1 $0.20 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Sea Basses 6.5 $2.39 0 $0.00 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Smelts 319.5 $0.38 0.1 $0.00 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Surfperches 30.9 $1.92 0.5 $0.30 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 California Total 102219.7 . 6.7 $4.70 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 CaliforniaTotal (3% Discount Rate) . . . $3.70 Table 9:tmn1:California

tmn1 CaliforniaTotal (7% Discount Rate) . . . $3.30

Table 12 : Imp

Ent and I&E

California : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California American Shad . 0 0 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Anchovies 0.5 0 0.6 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Cabezon 0.1 46.3 46.4 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California California Halibut 0.3 107.5 107.8 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California California Scorpionfish 0 . 0 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Commercial Crabs 0 1.3 1.3 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Commercial Shrimp 0 0 0 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Drums and Croakers 0.8 3.5 4.3 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Dungeness Crabs 0.4 3.3 3.8 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Flounders 1 7.8 8.8 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Other 0.7 3.4 4.1 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Rockfishes 2.9 993.5 996.4 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Sculpins 0.1 2.1 2.2 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Sea Basses 0 . 0 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Smelts 0.1 0 0.1 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Surfperches 0.5 . 0.5 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Total 7.5 1168.8 1176.4

Table 13 : Econ Tables:

California : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California American Shad 75.1 $0.98 0 . Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Anchovies 22607.2 $0.05 0.6 $0.00 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Cabezon 55.6 $5.83 46.4 $142.00 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California California Halibut 629.9 $4.06 107.8 $254.80 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California California Scorpionfish 7.9 $3.40 0 $0.00 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Commercial Crabs 1290.8 $1.33 1.3 $1.30

com ben tables 3 of 23Table 10:tmn2:California tmn2 California Commercial Shrimp 2552.2 $1.93 0 $0.00 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Drums and Croakers 77 $0.63 4.3 $1.10 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Dungeness Crabs 14370 $2.07 3.8 $5.70 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Flounders 474.8 $0.45 8.8 $2.50 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Other 57125.4 $0.89 4.1 $1.90 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Rockfishes 2668.4 $1.25 996.4 $774.00 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Sculpins 3.5 $3.43 2.2 $4.90 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Sea Basses 6.5 $2.39 0 $0.00 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Smelts 319.5 $0.38 0.1 $0.00 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Surfperches 30.9 $1.92 0.5 $0.40 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 California Total 102294.7 . 1176.4 $1,188.70 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 CaliforniaTotal (3% Discount Rate) . . . $750.80 Table 10:tmn2:California

tmn2 CaliforniaTotal (7% Discount Rate) . . . $573.30

Table 14 : Imp

Ent and I&E

California : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California American Shad . 0 0 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Anchovies 0.5 0 0.6 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Cabezon 0.1 48.4 48.5 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California California Halibut 0.3 112.5 112.8 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California California Scorpionfish 0 . 0 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Commercial Crabs 0 1.4 1.4 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Commercial Shrimp 0 0 0 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Drums and Croakers 0.8 3.7 4.5 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Dungeness Crabs 0.4 3.5 3.9 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Flounders 1 8.1 9.1 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Other 0.7 3.5 4.2 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Rockfishes 3 1039.3 1042.2 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Sculpins 0.1 2.2 2.3 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Sea Basses 0 . 0 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Smelts 0.1 0 0.1 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Surfperches 0.5 . 0.5 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Total 7.6 1222.7 1230.3

Table 15 : Econ Tables:

California : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California American Shad 75.1 $0.98 0 . Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Anchovies 22607.2 $0.05 0.6 $0.00 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Cabezon 55.6 $5.83 48.5 $148.50 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California California Halibut 629.9 $4.06 112.8 $266.50 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California California Scorpionfish 7.9 $3.40 0 $0.00 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Commercial Crabs 1290.8 $1.33 1.4 $1.40 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Commercial Shrimp 2552.2 $1.93 0 $0.00 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Drums and Croakers 77 $0.63 4.5 $1.20 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Dungeness Crabs 14370 $2.07 3.9 $6.00 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Flounders 474.8 $0.45 9.1 $2.60 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Other 57125.4 $0.89 4.2 $2.00 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Rockfishes 2668.4 $1.25 1042.2 $809.60 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Sculpins 3.5 $3.43 2.3 $5.10 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Sea Basses 6.5 $2.39 0 $0.00 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Smelts 319.5 $0.38 0.1 $0.00 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Surfperches 30.9 $1.92 0.5 $0.40 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 California Total 102294.7 . 1230.3 $1,243.30 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 CaliforniaTotal (3% Discount Rate) . . . $776.00 Table 11:tmn3:California

tmn3 CaliforniaTotal (7% Discount Rate) . . . $589.00

Table 16 : Imp

Ent and I&E

com ben tables 4 of 23California : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Anchovies 0.5 . 0.5 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Cabezon 0.1 . 0.1 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California California Halibut 0.2 . 0.2 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California California Scorpionfish 0 . 0 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Commercial Crabs 0 . 0 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Commercial Shrimp 0 . 0 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Drums and Croakers 0.7 . 0.7 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Dungeness Crabs 0.4 . 0.4 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Flounders 0.9 . 0.9 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Other 0.6 . 0.6 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Rockfishes 2.5 . 2.5 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Sculpins 0.1 . 0.1 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Sea Basses 0 . 0 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Smelts 0.1 . 0.1 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Surfperches 0.4 . 0.4 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Total 6.5 . 6.5

Table 17 : Econ Tables:

California : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Anchovies 22607.2 $0.05 0.5 $0.00 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Cabezon 55.6 $5.83 0.1 $0.20 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California California Halibut 629.9 $4.06 0.2 $0.50 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California California Scorpionfish 7.9 $3.40 0 $0.00 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Commercial Crabs 1290.8 $1.33 0 $0.00 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Commercial Shrimp 2552.2 $1.93 0 $0.00 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Drums and Croakers 77 $0.63 0.7 $0.20 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Dungeness Crabs 14370 $2.07 0.4 $0.60 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Flounders 474.8 $0.45 0.9 $0.20 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Other 57125.4 $0.89 0.6 $0.30 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Rockfishes 2668.4 $1.25 2.5 $2.00 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Sculpins 3.5 $3.43 0.1 $0.20 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Sea Basses 6.5 $2.39 0 $0.00 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Smelts 319.5 $0.38 0.1 $0.00 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Surfperches 30.9 $1.92 0.4 $0.30 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 California Total 102219.7 . 6.5 $4.60 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 CaliforniaTotal (3% Discount Rate) . . . $3.60 Table 12:tmn4:California

tmn4 CaliforniaTotal (7% Discount Rate) . . . $3.20

Table 16 : Option Summary:

California

Obs optionname reg increase d3 d7 sortx 1 baseline California 1379 ######## ######## 1 2 tmn1 California 6.7 $3.70 $3.30 2 3 tmn2 California 1176.4 $750.80 $573.30 3 4 tmn3 California 1230.3 $776.00 $589.00 4 5 tmn4 California 6.5 $3.60 $3.20 5

Table 17 : Imp

Ent and I&E

North Atlantic : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic American Shad 0 . 0 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Atlantic Cod 0.1 2.3 2.4 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Atlantic Herring 0.6 17.4 18 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 0 4.9 5

com ben tables 5 of 23Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic baseline North Atlantic Bluefish 0 0 0 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Butterfish 0.2 0 0.2 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Commercial Crabs 0.4 . 0.4 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Flounders 1.9 385.1 386.9 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Mackerels 0 2.3 2.3 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Other 0.3 3.6 3.9 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Pollock 0 0 0 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Red Hake 0 . 0 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Sculpins 0 4 4 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Scup 0 0.1 0.1 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Searobin 0 0.1 0.1 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Silver Hake 0.2 0.4 0.6 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Skate Species 0.5 . 0.5 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Tautog 0 4.9 4.9 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Weakfish 0 0.2 0.2 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic White Perch 0 0 0 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Total 4.2 425.3 429.6

Table 18 : Econ Tables:

North Atlantic : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic American Shad 38.1 $0.69 0 $0.00 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Atlantic Cod 15427.3 $1.55 2.4 $2.50 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Atlantic Herring 106047.1 $0.12 18 $1.70 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 5548.6 $0.10 5 $0.40 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Bluefish 1077.2 $0.47 0 $0.00 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Butterfish 550.9 $0.66 0.2 $0.10 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Commercial Crabs 15107.8 $0.58 0.4 $0.10 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Flounders 17675.4 $1.87 386.9 $460.20 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Mackerels 38896.8 $0.14 2.3 $0.30 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Other 270552.6 $0.44 3.9 $1.00 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Pollock 14567.6 $0.55 0 $0.00 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Red Hake 576.9 $0.45 0 $0.00 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Sculpins 0 $0.25 4 . Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Scup 4531 $0.86 0.1 $0.10 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Searobin 23.9 $0.12 0.1 . Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Silver Hake 9613.2 $0.53 0.6 $0.20 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Skate Species 31638.4 $0.20 0.5 $0.10 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Tautog 147.1 $2.03 4.9 $4.50 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Weakfish 28.2 $1.48 0.2 $0.30 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic White Perch 6.6 $1.45 0 $0.00 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Total 532054.6 . 429.6 $471.20 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $417.90 Table 17:baseline:North Atlantic

baseline North Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $404.00

Table 19 : Imp

Ent and I&E

North Atlantic : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic American Shad 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Atlantic Cod 0.1 . 0.1 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Atlantic Herring 0.4 . 0.4 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Bluefish 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Butterfish 0.1 . 0.1 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Commercial Crabs 0.2 . 0.2 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Flounders 1.3 . 1.3 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Mackerels 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Other 0.2 . 0.2 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Pollock 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Red Hake 0 . 0

com ben tables 6 of 23Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic tmn1 North Atlantic Sculpins 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Scup 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Searobin 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Silver Hake 0.1 . 0.1 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Skate Species 0.4 . 0.4 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Tautog 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Weakfish 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic White Perch 0 . 0 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Total 2.9 . 2.9

Table 20 : Econ Tables:

North Atlantic : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic American Shad 38.1 $0.69 0 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Atlantic Cod 15427.3 $1.55 0.1 $0.10 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Atlantic Herring 106047.1 $0.12 0.4 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 5548.6 $0.10 0 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Bluefish 1077.2 $0.47 0 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Butterfish 550.9 $0.66 0.1 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Commercial Crabs 15107.8 $0.58 0.2 $0.10 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Flounders 17675.4 $1.87 1.3 $1.50 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Mackerels 38896.8 $0.14 0 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Other 270552.6 $0.44 0.2 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Pollock 14567.6 $0.55 0 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Red Hake 576.9 $0.45 0 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Sculpins 0 $0.25 0 . Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Scup 4531 $0.86 0 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Searobin 23.9 $0.12 0 . Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Silver Hake 9613.2 $0.53 0.1 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Skate Species 31638.4 $0.20 0.4 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Tautog 147.1 $2.03 0 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Weakfish 28.2 $1.48 0 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic White Perch 6.6 $1.45 0 $0.00 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Total 532054.6 . 2.9 $1.90 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $1.50 Table 18:tmn1:North Atlantic

tmn1 North Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $1.30

Table 21 : Imp

Ent and I&E

North Atlantic : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic American Shad 0 . 0 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Atlantic Cod 0.1 1.9 2 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Atlantic Herring 0.6 14.2 14.8 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 0 4 4.1 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Bluefish 0 0 0 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Butterfish 0.2 0 0.2 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Commercial Crabs 0.4 . 0.4 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Flounders 1.9 313.9 315.8 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Mackerels 0 1.8 1.8 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Other 0.3 3 3.2 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Pollock 0 0 0 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Red Hake 0 . 0 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Sculpins 0 4 4 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Scup 0 0.1 0.1 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Searobin 0 0.1 0.1 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Silver Hake 0.2 0.3 0.5 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Skate Species 0.5 . 0.5 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Tautog 0 4 4 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Weakfish 0 0.2 0.2 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic White Perch 0 0 0

com ben tables 7 of 23Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic tmn2 North Atlantic Total 4.2 347.5 351.7

Table 22 : Econ Tables:

North Atlantic : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic American Shad 38.1 $0.69 0 $0.00 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Atlantic Cod 15427.3 $1.55 2 $2.00 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Atlantic Herring 106047.1 $0.12 14.8 $1.40 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 5548.6 $0.10 4.1 $0.30 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Bluefish 1077.2 $0.47 0 $0.00 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Butterfish 550.9 $0.66 0.2 $0.10 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Commercial Crabs 15107.8 $0.58 0.4 $0.10 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Flounders 17675.4 $1.87 315.8 $375.50 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Mackerels 38896.8 $0.14 1.8 $0.20 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Other 270552.6 $0.44 3.2 $0.80 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Pollock 14567.6 $0.55 0 $0.00 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Red Hake 576.9 $0.45 0 $0.00 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Sculpins 0 $0.25 4 . Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Scup 4531 $0.86 0.1 $0.10 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Searobin 23.9 $0.12 0.1 . Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Silver Hake 9613.2 $0.53 0.5 $0.20 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Skate Species 31638.4 $0.20 0.5 $0.10 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Tautog 147.1 $2.03 4 $3.70 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Weakfish 28.2 $1.48 0.2 $0.20 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic White Perch 6.6 $1.45 0 $0.00 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Total 532054.6 . 351.7 $384.60 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $230.60 Table 19:tmn2:North Atlantic

tmn2 North Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $171.30

Table 23 : Imp

Ent and I&E

North Atlantic : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic American Shad 0 . 0 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Atlantic Cod 0.1 2 2.1 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Atlantic Herring 0.6 14.9 15.5 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 0 4.2 4.3 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Bluefish 0 0 0 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Butterfish 0.2 0 0.2 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Commercial Crabs 0.4 . 0.4 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Flounders 1.9 329.3 331.2 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Mackerels 0 1.9 1.9 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Other 0.3 3.1 3.4 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Pollock 0 0 0 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Red Hake 0 . 0 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Sculpins 0 4 4 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Scup 0 0.1 0.1 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Searobin 0 0.1 0.1 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Silver Hake 0.2 0.4 0.6 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Skate Species 0.5 . 0.5 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Tautog 0 4.1 4.2 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Weakfish 0 0.2 0.2 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic White Perch 0 0 0 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Total 4.2 364.4 368.6

Table 24 : Econ Tables:

North Atlantic : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic American Shad 38.1 $0.69 0 $0.00

com ben tables 8 of 23Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic tmn3 North Atlantic Atlantic Cod 15427.3 $1.55 2.1 $2.10 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Atlantic Herring 106047.1 $0.12 15.5 $1.40 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 5548.6 $0.10 4.3 $0.30 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Bluefish 1077.2 $0.47 0 $0.00 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Butterfish 550.9 $0.66 0.2 $0.10 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Commercial Crabs 15107.8 $0.58 0.4 $0.10 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Flounders 17675.4 $1.87 331.2 $393.90 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Mackerels 38896.8 $0.14 1.9 $0.20 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Other 270552.6 $0.44 3.4 $0.80 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Pollock 14567.6 $0.55 0 $0.00 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Red Hake 576.9 $0.45 0 $0.00 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Sculpins 0 $0.25 4 . Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Scup 4531 $0.86 0.1 $0.10 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Searobin 23.9 $0.12 0.1 . Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Silver Hake 9613.2 $0.53 0.6 $0.20 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Skate Species 31638.4 $0.20 0.5 $0.10 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Tautog 147.1 $2.03 4.2 $3.80 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Weakfish 28.2 $1.48 0.2 $0.20 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic White Perch 6.6 $1.45 0 $0.00 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Total 532054.6 . 368.6 $403.40 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $241.50 Table 20:tmn3:North Atlantic

tmn3 North Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $179.30

Table 25 : Imp

Ent and I&E

North Atlantic : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic American Shad 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Atlantic Cod 0.1 . 0.1 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Atlantic Herring 0.4 . 0.4 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Bluefish 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Butterfish 0.1 . 0.1 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Commercial Crabs 0.2 . 0.2 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Flounders 1.3 . 1.3 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Mackerels 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Other 0.2 . 0.2 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Pollock 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Red Hake 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Sculpins 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Scup 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Searobin 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Silver Hake 0.1 . 0.1 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Skate Species 0.4 . 0.4 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Tautog 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Weakfish 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic White Perch 0 . 0 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Total 2.9 . 2.9

Table 26 : Econ Tables:

North Atlantic : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic American Shad 38.1 $0.69 0 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Atlantic Cod 15427.3 $1.55 0.1 $0.10 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Atlantic Herring 106047.1 $0.12 0.4 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 5548.6 $0.10 0 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Bluefish 1077.2 $0.47 0 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Butterfish 550.9 $0.66 0.1 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Commercial Crabs 15107.8 $0.58 0.2 $0.10 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Flounders 17675.4 $1.87 1.3 $1.50 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Mackerels 38896.8 $0.14 0 $0.00

com ben tables 9 of 23Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic tmn4 North Atlantic Other 270552.6 $0.44 0.2 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Pollock 14567.6 $0.55 0 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Red Hake 576.9 $0.45 0 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Sculpins 0 $0.25 0 . Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Scup 4531 $0.86 0 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Searobin 23.9 $0.12 0 . Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Silver Hake 9613.2 $0.53 0.1 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Skate Species 31638.4 $0.20 0.4 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Tautog 147.1 $2.03 0 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Weakfish 28.2 $1.48 0 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic White Perch 6.6 $1.45 0 $0.00 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Total 532054.6 . 2.9 $1.90 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $1.50 Table 21:tmn4:North Atlantic

tmn4 North Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $1.30

Table 25 : Option Summary:

North Atlantic

Obs optionname reg increase d3 d7 sortx 21 baseline North Atlantic 429.6 $417.90 $404.00 1 22 tmn1 North Atlantic 2.9 $1.50 $1.30 2 23 tmn2 North Atlantic 351.7 $230.60 $171.30 3 24 tmn3 North Atlantic 368.6 $241.50 $179.30 4 25 tmn4 North Atlantic 2.9 $1.50 $1.30 5

Table 26 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Mid-Atlantic : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Alewife 0.4 0 0.4 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic American Shad 0 1.4 1.5 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Atlantic Herring 0.1 0 0.1 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 4291.2 624.2 4915.4 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Black Drum 0.3 . 0.3 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Blue Crab 13.3 1000.9 1014.2 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Bluefish 0.1 . 0.1 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Butterfish 0 . 0 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Commercial Crabs 0.4 . 0.4 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Drums and Croakers 21.7 1497.5 1519.2 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Flounders 4.5 4.3 8.7 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Other 166.4 1098 1264.4 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Red Hake 0.8 . 0.8 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Scup 0 . 0 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Searobin 0 0 0 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Silver Hake 0.1 . 0.1 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Spot 86 1025.4 1111.4 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Striped Bass 0.6 88 88.6 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Striped Mullet 0.3 . 0.3 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Tautog 0 0 0 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Weakfish 257.1 484.9 741.9 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic White Perch 0.4 3.6 4 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Total 4843.7 5828.2 10671.9

Table 27 : Econ Tables:

Mid-Atlantic : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Alewife 173.3 $0.21 0.4 $0.10 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic American Shad 111.4 $0.92 1.5 $1.10 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Atlantic Herring 1284.2 $0.11 0.1 $0.00 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 338097.3 $0.07 4915.4 $223.30

com ben tables 10 of 23Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic baselineMid-Atlantic Black Drum 93.8 $1.26 0.3 $0.30 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Blue Crab 62874 $1.17 1014.2 $678.00 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Bluefish 2906.3 $0.43 0.1 $0.00 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Butterfish 501.3 $0.85 0 $0.00 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Commercial Crabs 2240.2 $0.60 0.4 $0.10 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Drums and Croakers 11430.1 $0.49 1519.2 $549.30 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Flounders 6468 $2.01 8.7 $11.90 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Other 462429.6 $0.32 1264.4 $293.00 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Red Hake 150.7 $0.52 0.8 $0.30 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Scup 3225.6 $0.98 0 $0.00 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Searobin 12 $0.22 0 . Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Silver Hake 3867 $0.67 0.1 $0.00 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Spot 3286.9 $0.74 1111.4 $693.60 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Striped Bass 5413.8 $2.02 88.6 $119.20 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Striped Mullet 20.3 $0.53 0.3 $0.10 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Tautog 135.9 $2.64 0 $0.00 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Weakfish 497 $1.10 741.9 $619.30 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic White Perch 1190 $0.76 4 $2.50 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Total 906408.6 . 10671.9 $3,192.20 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $2,831.20 Table 26:baseline:Mid-Atlantic

baselineMid-Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $2,736.80

Table 28 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Mid-Atlantic : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Alewife 0.3 . 0.3 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic American Shad 0 . 0 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Herring 0.1 . 0.1 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 3273.9 . 3273.9 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Black Drum 0.2 . 0.2 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Blue Crab 10.2 . 10.2 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Bluefish 0.1 . 0.1 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Butterfish 0 . 0 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Commercial Crabs 0.3 . 0.3 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Drums and Croakers 16.5 . 16.5 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Flounders 3.4 . 3.4 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Other 126.9 . 126.9 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Red Hake 0.6 . 0.6 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Scup 0 . 0 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Searobin 0 . 0 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Silver Hake 0.1 . 0.1 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Spot 120 . 120 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Striped Bass 0.4 . 0.4 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Striped Mullet 0.2 . 0.2 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Tautog 0 . 0 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Weakfish 196.1 . 196.1 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic White Perch 0.3 . 0.3 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Total 3749.8 . 3749.8

Table 29 : Econ Tables:

Mid-Atlantic : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Alewife 173.3 $0.21 0.3 $0.10 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic American Shad 111.4 $0.92 0 $0.00 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Herring 1284.2 $0.11 0.1 $0.00 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 338097.3 $0.07 3273.9 $148.70 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Black Drum 93.8 $1.26 0.2 $0.20 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Blue Crab 62874 $1.17 10.2 $6.80 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Bluefish 2906.3 $0.43 0.1 $0.00 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Butterfish 501.3 $0.85 0 $0.00

com ben tables 11 of 23Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Commercial Crabs 2240.2 $0.60 0.3 $0.10 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Drums and Croakers 11430.1 $0.49 16.5 $6.00 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Flounders 6468 $2.01 3.4 $4.50 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Other 462429.6 $0.32 126.9 $29.40 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Red Hake 150.7 $0.52 0.6 $0.20 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Scup 3225.6 $0.98 0 $0.00 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Searobin 12 $0.22 0 . Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Silver Hake 3867 $0.67 0.1 $0.00 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Spot 3286.9 $0.74 120 $74.90 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Striped Bass 5413.8 $2.02 0.4 $0.60 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Striped Mullet 20.3 $0.53 0.2 $0.10 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Tautog 135.9 $2.64 0 $0.00 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Weakfish 497 $1.10 196.1 $163.70 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic White Perch 1190 $0.76 0.3 $0.20 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Total 906408.6 . 3749.8 $435.50 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $342.00 Table 27:tmn1:Mid-Atlantic

tmn1 Mid-Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $302.70

Table 30 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Mid-Atlantic : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Alewife 0.4 0 0.4 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic American Shad 0 1.3 1.3 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Herring 0.1 0 0.1 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 4186.7 571.7 4758.3 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Black Drum 0.3 . 0.3 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Blue Crab 13 916.6 929.6 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Bluefish 0.1 . 0.1 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Butterfish 0 . 0 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Commercial Crabs 0.3 . 0.3 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Drums and Croakers 21.1 1371.5 1392.6 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Flounders 4.4 3.9 8.3 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Other 162.3 1005.5 1167.9 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Red Hake 0.8 . 0.8 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Scup 0 . 0 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Searobin 0 0 0 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Silver Hake 0.1 . 0.1 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Spot 91.2 1020.3 1111.4 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Striped Bass 0.5 80.6 81.2 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Striped Mullet 0.3 . 0.3 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Tautog 0 0 0 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Weakfish 250.8 444 694.9 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic White Perch 0.4 3.3 3.7 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Total 4733 5418.7 10151.6

Table 31 : Econ Tables:

Mid-Atlantic : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Alewife 173.3 $0.21 0.4 $0.10 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic American Shad 111.4 $0.92 1.3 $1.00 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Herring 1284.2 $0.11 0.1 $0.00 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 338097.3 $0.07 4758.3 $216.10 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Black Drum 93.8 $1.26 0.3 $0.30 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Blue Crab 62874 $1.17 929.6 $621.50 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Bluefish 2906.3 $0.43 0.1 $0.00 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Butterfish 501.3 $0.85 0 $0.00 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Commercial Crabs 2240.2 $0.60 0.3 $0.10 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Drums and Croakers 11430.1 $0.49 1392.6 $503.50 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Flounders 6468 $2.01 8.3 $11.20 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Other 462429.6 $0.32 1167.9 $270.60

com ben tables 12 of 23Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Red Hake 150.7 $0.52 0.8 $0.30 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Scup 3225.6 $0.98 0 $0.00 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Searobin 12 $0.22 0 . Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Silver Hake 3867 $0.67 0.1 $0.00 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Spot 3286.9 $0.74 1111.4 $693.60 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Striped Bass 5413.8 $2.02 81.2 $109.20 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Striped Mullet 20.3 $0.53 0.3 $0.10 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Tautog 135.9 $2.64 0 $0.00 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Weakfish 497 $1.10 694.9 $580.00 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic White Perch 1190 $0.76 3.7 $2.30 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Total 906408.6 . 10151.6 $3,010.10 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $1,614.80 Table 28:tmn2:Mid-Atlantic

tmn2 Mid-Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $1,124.00

Table 32 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Mid-Atlantic : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Alewife 0.4 0 0.4 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic American Shad 0 1.3 1.4 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Herring 0.1 0 0.1 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 4201.2 579 4780.2 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Black Drum 0.3 . 0.3 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Blue Crab 13 928.3 941.4 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Bluefish 0.1 . 0.1 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Butterfish 0 . 0 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Commercial Crabs 0.3 . 0.3 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Drums and Croakers 21.2 1389 1410.2 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Flounders 4.4 4 8.3 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Other 162.9 1018.4 1181.3 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Red Hake 0.8 . 0.8 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Scup 0 . 0 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Searobin 0 0 0 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Silver Hake 0.1 . 0.1 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Spot 90.4 1021 1111.4 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Striped Bass 0.5 81.6 82.2 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Striped Mullet 0.3 . 0.3 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Tautog 0 0 0 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Weakfish 251.7 449.7 701.4 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic White Perch 0.4 3.3 3.7 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Total 4748.3 5475.7 10224

Table 33 : Econ Tables:

Mid-Atlantic : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Alewife 173.3 $0.21 0.4 $0.10 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic American Shad 111.4 $0.92 1.4 $1.00 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Herring 1284.2 $0.11 0.1 $0.00 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 338097.3 $0.07 4780.2 $217.10 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Black Drum 93.8 $1.26 0.3 $0.30 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Blue Crab 62874 $1.17 941.4 $629.30 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Bluefish 2906.3 $0.43 0.1 $0.00 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Butterfish 501.3 $0.85 0 $0.00 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Commercial Crabs 2240.2 $0.60 0.3 $0.10 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Drums and Croakers 11430.1 $0.49 1410.2 $509.90 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Flounders 6468 $2.01 8.3 $11.30 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Other 462429.6 $0.32 1181.3 $273.70 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Red Hake 150.7 $0.52 0.8 $0.30 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Scup 3225.6 $0.98 0 $0.00 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Searobin 12 $0.22 0 . Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Silver Hake 3867 $0.67 0.1 $0.00

com ben tables 13 of 23Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Spot 3286.9 $0.74 1111.4 $693.60 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Striped Bass 5413.8 $2.02 82.2 $110.60 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Striped Mullet 20.3 $0.53 0.3 $0.10 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Tautog 135.9 $2.64 0 $0.00 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Weakfish 497 $1.10 701.4 $585.50 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic White Perch 1190 $0.76 3.7 $2.30 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Total 906408.6 . 10224 $3,035.40 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $1,629.00 Table 29:tmn3:Mid-Atlantic

tmn3 Mid-Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $1,133.90

Table 34 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Mid-Atlantic : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Alewife 0.3 . 0.3 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic American Shad 0 . 0 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Herring 0.1 . 0.1 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 3270.8 . 3270.8 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Black Drum 0.2 . 0.2 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Blue Crab 10.2 . 10.2 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Bluefish 0.1 . 0.1 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Butterfish 0 . 0 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Commercial Crabs 0.3 . 0.3 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Drums and Croakers 16.5 . 16.5 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Flounders 3.4 . 3.4 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Other 126.8 . 126.8 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Red Hake 0.6 . 0.6 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Scup 0 . 0 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Searobin 0 . 0 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Silver Hake 0.1 . 0.1 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Spot 119.9 . 119.9 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Striped Bass 0.4 . 0.4 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Striped Mullet 0.2 . 0.2 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Tautog 0 . 0 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Weakfish 196 . 196 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic White Perch 0.3 . 0.3 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Total 3746.3 . 3746.3

Table 35 : Econ Tables:

Mid-Atlantic : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Alewife 173.3 $0.21 0.3 $0.10 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic American Shad 111.4 $0.92 0 $0.00 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Herring 1284.2 $0.11 0.1 $0.00 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 338097.3 $0.07 3270.8 $148.60 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Black Drum 93.8 $1.26 0.2 $0.20 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Blue Crab 62874 $1.17 10.2 $6.80 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Bluefish 2906.3 $0.43 0.1 $0.00 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Butterfish 501.3 $0.85 0 $0.00 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Commercial Crabs 2240.2 $0.60 0.3 $0.10 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Drums and Croakers 11430.1 $0.49 16.5 $6.00 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Flounders 6468 $2.01 3.4 $4.50 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Other 462429.6 $0.32 126.8 $29.40 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Red Hake 150.7 $0.52 0.6 $0.20 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Scup 3225.6 $0.98 0 $0.00 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Searobin 12 $0.22 0 . Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Silver Hake 3867 $0.67 0.1 $0.00 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Spot 3286.9 $0.74 119.9 $74.80 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Striped Bass 5413.8 $2.02 0.4 $0.60 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Striped Mullet 20.3 $0.53 0.2 $0.10 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Tautog 135.9 $2.64 0 $0.00

com ben tables 14 of 23Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Weakfish 497 $1.10 196 $163.60 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic White Perch 1190 $0.76 0.3 $0.20 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Total 906408.6 . 3746.3 $435.10 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $341.60 Table 30:tmn4:Mid-Atlantic

tmn4 Mid-Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $302.40

Table 34 : Option Summary:

Mid-Atlantic

Obs optionname reg increase d3 d7 sortx 16 baseline Mid-Atlantic 10671.9 ######## ######## 1 17 tmn1 Mid-Atlantic 3749.8 $342.00 $302.70 2 18 tmn2 Mid-Atlantic 10151.6 ######## ######## 3 19 tmn3 Mid-Atlantic 10224 ######## ######## 4 20 tmn4 Mid-Atlantic 3746.3 $341.60 $302.40 5

Table 35 : Imp

Ent and I&E

South Atlantic : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 49.8 5.9 55.7 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Blue Crab 4.2 . 4.2 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Commercial Crabs . 0 0 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Drums and Croakers 0.4 14.4 14.9 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Other 2.4 0.5 3 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Spot 13.6 6.8 20.4 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Stone Crab 0.5 . 0.5 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Weakfish 0.6 0.2 0.7 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Total 71.5 27.9 99.4

Table 36 : Econ Tables:

South Atlantic : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 3726.8 $0.11 55.7 $4.70 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Blue Crab 36414.4 $0.91 4.2 $2.20 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Commercial Crabs 518 $1.51 0 $0.00 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Drums and Croakers 8333.3 $0.40 14.9 $3.20 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Other 93761.3 $1.17 3 $2.10 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Spot 1167.6 $0.65 20.4 $9.30 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Stone Crab 101.1 $4.56 0.5 $1.40 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Weakfish 266.5 $0.93 0.7 $0.40 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Total 144289.1 . 99.4 $23.30 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $20.70 Table 35:baseline:South Atlantic

baselineSouth Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $20.00

Table 37 : Imp

Ent and I&E

South Atlantic : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 31.4 . 31.4 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Blue Crab 2.6 . 2.6 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Drums and Croakers 0.3 . 0.3 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Other 1.5 . 1.5 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Spot 8.6 . 8.6 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Stone Crab 0.3 . 0.3 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Weakfish 0.4 . 0.4 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Total 45.1 . 45.1

Table 38 : Econ Tables:

com ben tables 15 of 23South Atlantic : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 3726.8 $0.11 31.4 $2.70 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Blue Crab 36414.4 $0.91 2.6 $1.40 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Drums and Croakers 8333.3 $0.40 0.3 $0.10 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Other 93761.3 $1.17 1.5 $1.10 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Spot 1167.6 $0.65 8.6 $3.90 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Stone Crab 101.1 $4.56 0.3 $0.90 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Weakfish 266.5 $0.93 0.4 $0.20 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Total 143771.1 . 45.1 $10.20 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $8.00 Table 36:tmn1:South Atlantic

tmn1 South Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $7.10

Table 39 : Imp

Ent and I&E

South Atlantic : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 42.4 4.9 47.4 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Blue Crab 3.6 . 3.6 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Commercial Crabs . 0 0 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Drums and Croakers 0.4 12 12.4 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Other 2.1 0.5 2.5 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Spot 11.6 5.7 17.3 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Stone Crab 0.5 . 0.5 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Weakfish 0.5 0.1 0.6 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Total 61 23.3 84.2

Table 40 : Econ Tables:

South Atlantic : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 3726.8 $0.11 47.4 $4.00 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Blue Crab 36414.4 $0.91 3.6 $1.90 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Commercial Crabs 518 $1.51 0 $0.00 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Drums and Croakers 8333.3 $0.40 12.4 $2.70 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Other 93761.3 $1.17 2.5 $1.80 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Spot 1167.6 $0.65 17.3 $7.90 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Stone Crab 101.1 $4.56 0.5 $1.20 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Weakfish 266.5 $0.93 0.6 $0.40 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Total 144289.1 . 84.2 $19.80 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $11.50 Table 37:tmn2:South Atlantic

tmn2 South Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $8.40

Table 41 : Imp

Ent and I&E

South Atlantic : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 42.5 4.9 47.4 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Blue Crab 3.6 . 3.6 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Commercial Crabs . 0 0 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Drums and Croakers 0.4 12.1 12.4 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Other 2.1 0.5 2.5 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Spot 11.6 5.7 17.3 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Stone Crab 0.5 . 0.5 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Weakfish 0.5 0.1 0.6 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Total 61 23.3 84.3

Table 42 : Econ Tables:

com ben tables 16 of 23South Atlantic : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 3726.8 $0.11 47.4 $4.00 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Blue Crab 36414.4 $0.91 3.6 $1.90 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Commercial Crabs 518 $1.51 0 $0.00 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Drums and Croakers 8333.3 $0.40 12.4 $2.70 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Other 93761.3 $1.17 2.5 $1.80 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Spot 1167.6 $0.65 17.3 $7.90 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Stone Crab 101.1 $4.56 0.5 $1.20 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Weakfish 266.5 $0.93 0.6 $0.40 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Total 144289.1 . 84.3 $19.80 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $11.50 Table 38:tmn3:South Atlantic

tmn3 South Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $8.40

Table 43 : Imp

Ent and I&E

South Atlantic : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 31.4 . 31.4 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Blue Crab 2.6 . 2.6 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Drums and Croakers 0.3 . 0.3 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Other 1.5 . 1.5 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Spot 8.6 . 8.6 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Stone Crab 0.3 . 0.3 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Weakfish 0.4 . 0.4 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Total 45.1 . 45.1

Table 44 : Econ Tables:

South Atlantic : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Atlantic Menhaden 3726.8 $0.11 31.4 $2.70 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Blue Crab 36414.4 $0.91 2.6 $1.40 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Drums and Croakers 8333.3 $0.40 0.3 $0.10 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Other 93761.3 $1.17 1.5 $1.10 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Spot 1167.6 $0.65 8.6 $3.90 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Stone Crab 101.1 $4.56 0.3 $0.90 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Weakfish 266.5 $0.93 0.4 $0.20 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Total 143771.1 . 45.1 $10.20 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $8.00 Table 39:tmn4:South Atlantic

tmn4 South Atlantic Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $7.10

Table 43 : Option Summary:

South Atlantic

Obs optionname reg increase d3 d7 sortx 26 baselineSouth Atlantic 99.4 $20.70 $20.00 1 27 tmn1 South Atlantic 45.1 $8.00 $7.10 2 28 tmn2 South Atlantic 84.2 $11.50 $8.40 3 29 tmn3 South Atlantic 84.3 $11.50 $8.40 4 30 tmn4 South Atlantic 45.1 $8.00 $7.10 5

Table 43 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Gulf of Mexico : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Atlantic Menhaden 978.3 10.1 988.4 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Black Drum 4.1 1881.1 1885.2 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Blue Crab 52.5 176.1 228.5

com ben tables 17 of 23Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico baselineGulf of Mexico Drums and Croakers 40.2 0 40.3 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Leatherjacket 86.5 4.2 90.7 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Mackerels 0.3 . 0.3 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Other 215.2 25.3 240.5 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Pink Shrimp 201.6 126.1 327.7 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Sea Basses 0 . 0 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Sheepshead 0 0 0 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Spot 32.3 7.6 40 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Stone Crab 136 303.1 439 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Striped Mullet 158.6 1119.7 1278.3 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Total 1905.6 3653.3 5558.9

Table 44 : Econ Tables:

Gulf of Mexico : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Atlantic Menhaden 930460.2 $0.06 988.4 $44.10 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Black Drum 4397.3 $0.83 1885.2 $1,087.60 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Blue Crab 56804 $0.77 228.5 $126.30 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Drums and Croakers 81 $6.47 40.3 $140.70 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Leatherjacket 65.6 $1.40 90.7 . Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Mackerels 3967.4 $1.04 0.3 $0.20 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Other 1250334 $0.41 240.5 $45.70 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Pink Shrimp 8696.5 $2.06 327.7 $293.40 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Sea Basses 66.6 $0.97 0 $0.00 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Sheepshead 1366.3 $0.41 0 $0.00 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Spot 18.1 $0.43 40 $9.30 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Stone Crab 5313.9 $4.23 439 $1,323.10 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Striped Mullet 10347.7 $0.67 1278.3 $676.00 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Total 2271919 . 5558.9 $3,746.50 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $3,462.90 Table 44:baseline:Gulf of Mexico

baselineGulf of Mexico Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $3,449.90

Table 45 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Gulf of Mexico : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Atlantic Menhaden 749.3 . 749.3 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Black Drum 3.1 . 3.1 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Blue Crab 40.2 . 40.2 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Drums and Croakers 30.8 . 30.8 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Leatherjacket 66.2 . 66.2 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Mackerels 0.2 . 0.2 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Other 164.8 . 164.8 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Pink Shrimp 154.4 . 154.4 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Sea Basses 0 . 0 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Sheepshead 0 . 0 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Spot 24.8 . 24.8 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Stone Crab 104.1 . 104.1 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Striped Mullet 121.5 . 121.5 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Total 1459.4 . 1459.4

Table 46 : Econ Tables:

Gulf of Mexico : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Atlantic Menhaden 930460.2 $0.06 749.3 $33.50 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Black Drum 4397.3 $0.83 3.1 $1.80 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Blue Crab 56804 $0.77 40.2 $22.20 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Drums and Croakers 81 $6.47 30.8 $107.70 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Leatherjacket 65.6 $1.40 66.2 .

com ben tables 18 of 23Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Mackerels 3967.4 $1.04 0.2 $0.20 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Other 1250334 $0.41 164.8 $31.30 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Pink Shrimp 8696.5 $2.06 154.4 $138.30 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Sea Basses 66.6 $0.97 0 $0.00 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Sheepshead 1366.3 $0.41 0 $0.00 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Spot 18.1 $0.43 24.8 $5.80 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Stone Crab 5313.9 $4.23 104.1 $313.80 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Striped Mullet 10347.7 $0.67 121.5 $64.20 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Total 2271919 . 1459.4 $718.70 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $588.40 Table 45:tmn1:Gulf of Mexico

tmn1 Gulf of Mexico Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $536.80

Table 47 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Gulf of Mexico : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Atlantic Menhaden 971.6 6.8 978.5 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Black Drum 4.1 1272.5 1276.5 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Blue Crab 52.1 119.1 171.2 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Drums and Croakers 39.9 0 40 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Leatherjacket 85.9 2.9 88.7 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Mackerels 0.3 . 0.3 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Other 213.7 17.1 230.8 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Pink Shrimp 200.3 85.3 285.5 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Sea Basses 0 . 0 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Sheepshead 0 0 0 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Spot 32.1 5.2 37.3 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Stone Crab 135 205 340.1 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Striped Mullet 157.5 757.4 914.9 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Total 1892.5 2471.3 4363.8

Table 48 : Econ Tables:

Gulf of Mexico : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Atlantic Menhaden 930460.2 $0.06 978.5 $43.70 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Black Drum 4397.3 $0.83 1276.5 $736.50 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Blue Crab 56804 $0.77 171.2 $94.60 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Drums and Croakers 81 $6.47 40 $139.70 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Leatherjacket 65.6 $1.40 88.7 . Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Mackerels 3967.4 $1.04 0.3 $0.20 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Other 1250334 $0.41 230.8 $43.80 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Pink Shrimp 8696.5 $2.06 285.5 $255.70 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Sea Basses 66.6 $0.97 0 $0.00 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Sheepshead 1366.3 $0.41 0 $0.00 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Spot 18.1 $0.43 37.3 $8.70 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Stone Crab 5313.9 $4.23 340.1 $1,024.70 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Striped Mullet 10347.7 $0.67 914.9 $483.90 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Total 2271919 . 4363.8 $2,831.50 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $1,805.70 Table 46:tmn2:Gulf of Mexico

tmn2 Gulf of Mexico Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $1,394.20

Table 49 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Gulf of Mexico : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Atlantic Menhaden 972.3 6.9 979.2 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Black Drum 4.1 1275.6 1279.7 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Blue Crab 52.1 119.4 171.5 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Drums and Croakers 40 0 40 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Leatherjacket 85.9 2.9 88.8

com ben tables 19 of 23Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Mackerels 0.3 . 0.3 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Other 213.9 17.1 231 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Pink Shrimp 200.4 85.5 285.9 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Sea Basses 0 . 0 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Sheepshead 0 0 0 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Spot 32.1 5.2 37.3 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Stone Crab 135.1 205.5 340.7 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Striped Mullet 157.6 759.3 916.9 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Total 1893.9 2477.3 4371.3

Table 50 : Econ Tables:

Gulf of Mexico : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Atlantic Menhaden 930460.2 $0.06 979.2 $43.70 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Black Drum 4397.3 $0.83 1279.7 $738.30 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Blue Crab 56804 $0.77 171.5 $94.80 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Drums and Croakers 81 $6.47 40 $139.80 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Leatherjacket 65.6 $1.40 88.8 . Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Mackerels 3967.4 $1.04 0.3 $0.20 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Other 1250334 $0.41 231 $43.90 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Pink Shrimp 8696.5 $2.06 285.9 $256.00 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Sea Basses 66.6 $0.97 0 $0.00 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Sheepshead 1366.3 $0.41 0 $0.00 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Spot 18.1 $0.43 37.3 $8.70 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Stone Crab 5313.9 $4.23 340.7 $1,026.60 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Striped Mullet 10347.7 $0.67 916.9 $484.90 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Total 2271919 . 4371.3 $2,836.90 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $1,804.30 Table 47:tmn3:Gulf of Mexico

tmn3 Gulf of Mexico Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $1,390.40

Table 51 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Gulf of Mexico : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Atlantic Menhaden 743.6 . 743.6 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Black Drum 3.1 . 3.1 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Blue Crab 39.9 . 39.9 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Drums and Croakers 30.6 . 30.6 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Leatherjacket 65.7 . 65.7 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Mackerels 0.2 . 0.2 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Other 163.6 . 163.6 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Pink Shrimp 153.3 . 153.3 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Sea Basses 0 . 0 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Sheepshead 0 . 0 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Spot 24.6 . 24.6 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Stone Crab 103.3 . 103.3 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Striped Mullet 120.5 . 120.5 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Total 1448.4 . 1448.4

Table 52 : Econ Tables:

Gulf of Mexico : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Atlantic Menhaden 930460.2 $0.06 743.6 $33.20 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Black Drum 4397.3 $0.83 3.1 $1.80 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Blue Crab 56804 $0.77 39.9 $22.00 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Drums and Croakers 81 $6.47 30.6 $106.80 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Leatherjacket 65.6 $1.40 65.7 . Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Mackerels 3967.4 $1.04 0.2 $0.20 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Other 1250334 $0.41 163.6 $31.10

com ben tables 20 of 23Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Pink Shrimp 8696.5 $2.06 153.3 $137.20 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Sea Basses 66.6 $0.97 0 $0.00 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Sheepshead 1366.3 $0.41 0 $0.00 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Spot 18.1 $0.43 24.6 $5.70 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Stone Crab 5313.9 $4.23 103.3 $311.40 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Striped Mullet 10347.7 $0.67 120.5 $63.70 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Total 2271919 . 1448.4 $713.30 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $584.00 Table 48:tmn4:Gulf of Mexico

tmn4 Gulf of Mexico Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $532.70

Table 51 : Option Summary:

Gulf of Mexico

Obs optionname reg increase d3 d7 sortx 11 baselineGulf of Mexico 5558.9 ######## ######## 1 12 tmn1 Gulf of Mexico 1459.4 $588.40 $536.80 2 13 tmn2 Gulf of Mexico 4363.8 ######## ######## 3 14 tmn3 Gulf of Mexico 4371.3 ######## ######## 4 15 tmn4 Gulf of Mexico 1448.4 $584.00 $532.70 5

Table 53 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Great Lakes : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Bullhead 0.8 0.1 0.8 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Freshwater Drum 4.4 11.7 16.1 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Other 40.4 56.8 97.2 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Smelts 105.3 0.6 105.9 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes White Bass 7.4 14.6 22 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Whitefish 101.9 0 101.9 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Yellow Perch 1.8 0.5 2.3 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Total 262.1 84.1 346.2

Table 54 : Econ Tables:

Great Lakes : Option = baseline

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Bullhead 569.7 $0.41 0.8 $0.10 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Freshwater Drum 497.5 $0.16 16.1 $0.80 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Other 13819 $0.94 97.2 $26.60 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Smelts 522.2 $0.91 105.9 $27.80 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes White Bass 432.2 $0.68 22 $4.30 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Whitefish 9406.5 $0.87 101.9 $25.90 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Yellow Perch 1609.7 $2.08 2.3 $1.40 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Total 40675.8 . 346.2 $86.80 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $80.30 Table 53:baseline:Great Lakes

baselineGreat Lakes Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $80.00

Table 55 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Great Lakes : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Bullhead 0.7 . 0.7 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Freshwater Drum 3.8 . 3.8 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Other 35 . 35 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Smelts 91.2 . 91.2 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes White Bass 6.4 . 6.4 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Whitefish 88.3 . 88.3 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Yellow Perch 1.6 . 1.6 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Total 227 . 227

com ben tables 21 of 23Table 56 : Econ Tables:

Great Lakes : Option = tmn1

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Bullhead 569.7 $0.41 0.7 $0.10 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Freshwater Drum 497.5 $0.16 3.8 $0.20 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Other 13819 $0.94 35 $9.60 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Smelts 522.2 $0.91 91.2 $24.00 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes White Bass 432.2 $0.68 6.4 $1.30 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Whitefish 9406.5 $0.87 88.3 $22.40 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Yellow Perch 1609.7 $2.08 1.6 $0.90 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Total 40675.8 . 227 $58.40 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $47.80 Table 54:tmn1:Great Lakes

tmn1 Great Lakes Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $43.60

Table 57 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Great Lakes : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Bullhead 0.8 0 0.8 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Freshwater Drum 4.4 9.3 13.7 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Other 39.9 45.4 85.3 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Smelts 104.2 0.5 104.6 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes White Bass 7.4 11.6 19 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Whitefish 100.8 0 100.8 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Yellow Perch 1.8 0.4 2.2 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Total 259.2 67.2 326.4

Table 58 : Econ Tables:

Great Lakes : Option = tmn2

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Bullhead 569.7 $0.41 0.8 $0.10 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Freshwater Drum 497.5 $0.16 13.7 $0.60 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Other 13819 $0.94 85.3 $23.30 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Smelts 522.2 $0.91 104.6 $27.50 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes White Bass 432.2 $0.68 19 $3.70 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Whitefish 9406.5 $0.87 100.8 $25.60 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Yellow Perch 1609.7 $2.08 2.2 $1.30 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Total 40675.8 . 326.4 $82.20 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $52.90 Table 55:tmn2:Great Lakes

tmn2 Great Lakes Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $41.10

Table 59 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Great Lakes : Option = tmn3

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Bullhead 0.8 0 0.8 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Freshwater Drum 4.4 9.5 13.8 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Other 40 46 86.1 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Smelts 104.4 0.5 104.9 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes White Bass 7.4 11.8 19.2 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Whitefish 101 0 101.1 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Yellow Perch 1.8 0.4 2.2 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Total 259.8 68.2 328

Table 60 : Econ Tables:

Great Lakes : Option = tmn3

com ben tables 22 of 23Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Bullhead 569.7 $0.41 0.8 $0.10 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Freshwater Drum 497.5 $0.16 13.8 $0.60 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Other 13819 $0.94 86.1 $23.60 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Smelts 522.2 $0.91 104.9 $27.60 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes White Bass 432.2 $0.68 19.2 $3.80 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Whitefish 9406.5 $0.87 101.1 $25.60 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Yellow Perch 1609.7 $2.08 2.2 $1.30 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Total 40675.8 . 328 $82.60 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $53.00 Table 56:tmn3:Great Lakes

tmn3 Great Lakes Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $41.00

Table 61 : Imp

Ent and I&E

Great Lakes : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Increased Harvest from Reduced Impingment (thousand lbs) Increased Harvest from Reduced Entrainment (thousand lbs)

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs) Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Bullhead 0.7 . 0.7 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Freshwater Drum 3.8 . 3.8 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Other 34.7 . 34.7 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Smelts 90.5 . 90.5 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes White Bass 6.4 . 6.4 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Whitefish 87.6 . 87.6 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Yellow Perch 1.6 . 1.6 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Total 225.1 . 225.1

Table 62 : Econ Tables:

Great Lakes : Option = tmn4

Table Name of Option Region Name

Species Name Average Annual Harvest 2005-2009 (thousands lbs) Price Per Pound

Increased Harvest from Reduced I&E (thousand lbs)

Total Producer Surplus (thousands 2008$) Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Bullhead 569.7 $0.41 0.7 $0.10 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Freshwater Drum 497.5 $0.16 3.8 $0.20 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Other 13819 $0.94 34.7 $9.50 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Smelts 522.2 $0.91 90.5 $23.80 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes White Bass 432.2 $0.68 6.4 $1.30 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Whitefish 9406.5 $0.87 87.6 $22.20 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Yellow Perch 1609.7 $2.08 1.6 $0.90 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Total 40675.8 . 225.1 $57.90 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Total (3% Discount Rate) . . . $47.40 Table 57:tmn4:Great Lakes

tmn4 Great Lakes Total (7% Discount Rate) . . . $43.30

Table 61 : Option Summary:

Great Lakes

Obs optionname reg increase d3 d7 sortx 6 baselineGreat Lakes 346.2 $80.30 $80.00 1 7 tmn1 Great Lakes 227 $47.80 $43.60 2 8 tmn2 Great Lakes 326.4 $52.90 $41.10 3 9 tmn3 Great Lakes 328 $53.00 $41.00 4 10 tmn4 Great Lakes 225.1 $47.40 $43.30 5

com ben tables 23 of 23