Seminole Electric 

,.)COOPERATIVE, INC. 

Seminole Electric Cooperative - Oral Testimony 

Clean Power Plan— EPA Listening Sessions 

Atlanta, GA 

July 29-30, 2014 

Good morning and thank you for your time. My namdis James Frauen. I am 

the Vice President of Technical Services and Development at Semino,li 

Electric Cooperative, located in Tampa, Florida. Seminole is one of the 

largest, not-for-profit generation and transmission cooperatives in the country. 

Seminole provides reliable, competitively priced, wholesale electric power to 

nine Member distribution electric cooperatives. Approximately 1.4 million 

consumers and businesses in parts of 42 Florida counties rely on Seminole's 

Member distribution cooperatives for electricity. 

On behalf of Seminole and its not-for-profit, Member-owned electric 

cooperatives, we would like to express our sincere and utmost concern 

regarding the EPA's Clean Power Plan aimed at regulating carbon dioxide 

emissions from existing power plants, specifically coal-fired facilities. 

Through the Clean Power Plan, the EPA is proposing that Florida reduce its 

overall carbon emissions by 38%.This value is based on the EPA's 2012 

"data" year versus the rule's "headline" year of 2005. EPA's calculations for 

Florida do not account for an approximate 20% reduction in CO2emissions 

that have already occurred in Florida since 2005. In order to achieve the 

38% goal, the EPA calculates that Florida will have to reduce its coalfired power generation by more than 90%. 

This is significant for Seminole. We generate more than 50% of the electricity 

our Members need from our own coal-fired resources. Based on the EPA's 

calculations contained in the proposed rule, Seminole's coal-fired generating 

For more information on Seminole Electric, visit www.seminole-electric.com. 

To voice concern regarding the EPA's Clean Power Plan, visit www.tellEPA.com or www.action.coop. 

IN PARTNERSHIP WITH THOSE WE SERVE 
facilities have been arbitrarily scheduled for retirement well before the end of 

their useful life and with no regard for the economic hardship it will cause our 

Members and consumers. 

In 1978, the U.S. enacted the Powerplant and Industrial Fuel Use Act, which 

restricted new power plants from using oil or natural gas for power generation 

and encouraged the use of coal. Seminole's coal-fired facility came online in 

1984. Seminole built coal because it did not have another viable option. Now 

the EPA proposes to punish consumers who buy power from electric utilities 

that burn coal. Seminole, our Members, and their member consumers 

should not be penalized for following the laws of our nation. 

One of Seminole's highest priorities is to ensure that all generating resources 

are operated in an environmentally-responsible manner. Seminole has 

invested more than $530 million in environmental control technology and 

recycling practices — $260 million of which was placed in service less than 5 

years ago. To reduce emissions, and as part of Seminole's commitment to our 

communities, approximately 70% of the byproducts produced at our coal 

facility are recycled for use in products that consumers use every day, 

including wallboard and concrete. These continued investments have made 

Seminole's facility one of the cleanest coal-based power plants in the country. 

The EPA must consider these expensive and extensive environmental 

controls installed to comply with other regulations implemented by the 

agency. Should the EPA's proposed carbon rule be finalized, these costly 

investments will become stranded assets and Seminole's coal-fired power 

plant will be forced to close — leaving 300 hard-working, skilled employees 

without a job. 

Additionally, Seminole would have to build or purchase new power 

generation to replace the electricity produced from its coal-fired facility. Such 

a drastic and sudden shift in Seminole's power portfolio will not only 

drive up the cost of electricity for our Member cooperatives and their 

For more information on Seminole Electric, visit www.seminole-electric.com. 

To voice concern regarding the EPA's Clean Power Plan, visit www.tellEPA.com or www.action.coop. 
member consumers, but it could have sweeping unintended consequences 

for our fragile, but recovering workforce and economy in Florida. 

Seminole believes it makes good business sense to have a diversified 

generation portfolio in Florida that includes coal, natural gas, and renewable 

energy. Fuel diversity reduces exposure to changing market conditions, helps 

keep rates competitive and provides much needed flexibility during extreme 

weather events such as hurricanes. Displacing existing coal-fired power 

plants, as proposed by the EPA, will lead to increased costs for consumers, 

will jeopardize reliability, and will place undue stress on gas and transmission 

infrastructure within the State. 

Seminole believes the EPA's Clean Power Plan poses significant legal 

challenges that will need to be litigated if it is finally enacted. Seminole has 

serious concerns about the EPA's flawed approach to establish national 

energy policy through expensive, unnecessary government regulation. 

Seminole supports rational energy and environmental policy that does not 

harm the affordability or reliability of power production and delivery. 

Thank you for your time and attention. 

For more information on Seminole Electric, visit www.seminole-electric.com. 

To voice concern regarding the EPA's Clean Power Plan, visit www.tellEPA.com or www.action.coop.