Interim Decision #2321 

MATTER OF TUITASI 

In Deportation Proceedings 

A-20053062 

Decided by Board September 26, 1974 

One born in Western Samoa in 1952 who was adopted in American Samoa in 1971 by two 

nationals of the United States does not acquire United States nationality under section 

308 of the Immigration and Nationality Act. One does not acquire United States 

nationality merely by asserting an allegiance to the Unites States. 

CHARGE: 

Order. Act of 1952—Section 241(a)(2) [8 U.S.C. 1251(a)(2)].—Nonimmigrant—remained 

longer. 

ON BEHALF U• RESFUNUENT: Byron B. Park, Esquire 

681 Market Street 

San Francisco, California 94105 

In a decision dated March 15, 1974, an immigration judge found the 

respondent deportable, but granted her the privilege of voluntary departure. The respondent, who contests the finding of deportability, has 

appealed from that decision. The appeal will be dismissed. 

The respondent, whose natural parents were natives of Western 

Samoa, was born in that country in 1952. When she was approximately 

one year old, the respondent was taken to American Samoa by a person 

she describes as her aunt. She was raised in American Samoa and 

formally adopted in 1971 by two nationals of the United States. The 

respondent has never returned to Western Samoa, and the record does 

not disclose the fate of her natural parents. 

The respondent testified that in 1969 she submitted a written request . 

to Western Samoan authorities for the issuance of a passport. This 

request evidently was denied, and respondent thereafter obtained a 

document entitled "Certificate of Identity" from the Office of the Attorney General in American Samoa. This document describes her birth, 

residence and adoption. It also contains the statement that "[s]he is not 

entitled to either a Western Samoan Passport or a United States National Certificate of Identity." 

The respondent entered the United States in August of 1972 as a 

102 
Interim Decision #2321 

visitor. She received a change of nonimmigrant status conditioned upon 

the posting of a maintenance of status bond. She failed to post the bond 

and overstayed her visit. The immigration judge found her deportable 

as a nonimmigrant who has remained beyond the authorized length of 

her stay. The only issue in the case is whether she is a noncitizen 

national of the United States, and thus not deportable. 

The respondent bases her claim to United States nationality upon 

section 101(a)(22) of the Immigration and Nationality Act. Section 101 

(a)(22) provides: 

The term "national of the United States" means (A) a citizen of the United States, or 

(B) a person who, though not a citizen of the United States, owes permanent allegiance 

to the United States. 

The respondent maintains that she owes permanent allegiance to the 

United States, and therefore qualifies as a national. The acquisition of 

nationality for a noncitizen national, however, is not governed by section 101(a)(22); it is governed instead by section 308. 1Section 308 of the 

Act provides: 

Unless otherwise provided in section 301 of this title, the following shall be nationals, 

but not citizens of the United States at birth; 

(1) A person born in an outlying possession of the United States on ur after the date 

of formal acquisition of such possession; 

(2) A person born outside the United States and its outlying possessions of parents 

both of whom are nationals, but not citizens, of the United States, and have had a 

residence in the United States, or one of its outlying possessions prior to the birth of 

such person; and 

(3) A person of unknown parentage found in an outlying possession of the United 

States while under the age of five years, until shown, prior to his attaining the age of 

twenty-one years, not to have been born in such outlying possession. 

American Samoa is an outlying possession of the United States. Section 

101(a)(29), Immigration and Nationality Act. The respondent, however, 

was not born in American Samoa, nor were her natural parents nationals of the United States. Accordingly, she did not acquire United 

States nationality at birth under the terms of section 308. Except for the 

acquisition of nationality in conjunction with the acquisition of citizenship, the Act provides no other means by which the respondent could 

have acquired United States nationality. 

Congress has established rigorous procedures which govern the acquisition of both lawful permanent resident status and United States 

citizenship for aliens. Nationality has attributes akin to each of these. 

See e.g. Matter of B—, 6 I. & N. Dec. 555 (BIA 1955). We cannot accept 

'We are not concerned in this case with special legislative enactments or with any 

acquisition of nationality which may occur upon the transfer of territory between nations. 

Seemat, cfg 9 I. &N_ Doe. 729 (R TA 1949); 8 M. Whiteman, Digest of International 

Law 104-113 (1967). 

103 
Interim De Asion #2321 

the respondent's unstated, but underlying, assumption that Congress 

would permit an alien to acquire United States nationality merely by 

asserting ar allegiance to the United States. 

The respondent is an alien; her deportability has been established by 

evidence that is clear, convincing, and unequivocal. The question of 

whether the respondent has a status in American Samoa which will 

permit her to reside there is not before us. 

ORDER: The appeal is dismissed. 

Further cyder: Pursuant to the immigration judge's order, the respondent is permitted to depart from the United States voluntarily 

within 31 days from the date of this order or any extension beyond that 

time as may be granted by the district director; and in the event of 

failure so to depart, the respondent shall be deported as proyided in the 

immigration judge's order. 

104