04/27/2012 10:33 

### FAX 2024935142 

### FAA + OMS @011/018 PAGE 11/15 04/20/2012 18:51 4252271 EIE17 ANM7

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 B 9 10 ' ll.

1:3 13 14· lS 10 11 19 l..9 20 :a 22 :2::> 24 25 .26 ' 27 26 29 .30 3l 32 33 34 35 36' 3:7 3.9 39 40 41 42 4l 44 45 4S 4.7 48 4g 

### so Sl S2 Sl JEFFREY M. H.AR:P:C:R FAA Ol=FICE OF REGIONAL COUNSEL 1601 LIND A VENUE SoutliWEST**.RENTO~,** WASHD'iJGTON 98057**~EP'HON£:** (425) 227-2161 FACSJMJL.E: (425) 227·1007 ' '



### UNITED STATES OF AMERICA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

### OFFICE OF HEARINGS



## W ASHJNGTON, D.C.

In 

### the Matter of:
Cornerstone Aviation. 

### Inc.

To: 

### Honorable Richard C. Q{)odwin: 

### DMS No. FAA-2011*0481 DMS 

### No. FAA-2011-0484 

### DMS No. FAA-2011-0489
MOTION TO SET BRIEFING**SC~DULE** Judge Richard C. Goodwin



### In accordance 

### with 14 Code of

### Federal RegulatioJlS (C.F 

### .R.) Section 13.218 (Rule 13.218) and the Federal**Rul~** 

### ofCivil Procedure, 1he Administrator (Complainant) 

### moves that 

### the Administrative Law Judge (AU) 

### to set a briefing schedule 

### fot post-tria1 briefs.



### Facts Atthe 

### consolidated hearing in 

### these.cases held on March 12. 

### 2012, 

## the ALJ requested that, 

### upon. Complainant's**recei~** 

### ofthe Transcript, 

### undersigned cotinsel contact**Res!Jon.d~nt** to 

### work out a.**bri.e~.schedule.** Transcript 65:6-7. ·The ALJ also stated that, 

### inthe event agreement on a 

### sched:\:lle could not be 

### reached, 

## !? :Inform the 

### court so it 

### could impose a sched:ule. T{"a(lSCript 

### 65:21-22. Undersigned ccunsel received his copy of

### the Transcript on**April~'** 2012. 

### On April 4, 

### 2012 be · sent an e-m.ail to ReSpondent• s ChiefExecutive Officer proposing a deadline ofthirty 

### (30) days from receipt of

### the Transcript to file 

### Com.plainanfs brief, thirty 

### (30) days ftom service of Complainant's Brleffol' Respolldent to :file its 

### Reply. and :fifteen (15) days from service ofthe Reply 

### for Compla.inmt

### to file a rebuttal, ifany. Exhibit 

### t. ·

Motioa tO Set Briefing SQhcdule Cornerstone Aviation,**J.e~e.-** FAA-201 H481, PAA.-2011-04S4, FAA-2011..0489 Page I of4 .**J~ttM.~PAAA~** T.EL: (425) .227-2161; FAX: (425) 227·.10()704/27/2012 10:33 FAX 2024835142 FAA -+ OMS lil012/018 PAGE 12/16 a412a12e12 16:51 4252271607 ""NM7

l 2 3 4 5 s 7 

### e 9 10 11**~2** 1J 14 15 16' 17 l9 1.9

. 20 21 !J.2 23 24**~s** ;:s 

### n 28 29 30 :u 

### n. 33 34 3.5 JS 37 l8 39

. 40 41 42 43 44 45 4-S" 47 .4f3 4.9 

### so Sl. 52 Sl 

### Respondent's ChiefExeom.ive**Offi~r** 

### (CEO) respo_nded proposing sixty (60) days 

### for the 

### initial brief; sixty (60) days for the reply, and thirty 

### (30) for the rebuttal. Exhibit 2. Complainant's Briefis being served 

### contemporaneously with 

### this Motion- seventeen (17). 

### days e.fter receipt ofthe 

### T!2llSCript.


### Argument
The Rules ofPractiee prOVide 

### that the parties shall have 1

### 'adequate**oppo~.ty"** 

### to pre.::em argument. Rule 13.61. Further, 

### Rule 13.231(c) provides that

### parties shouldbavenotmore 

### than. thirty 

### (30) days after receipt ofthe Transcri:pt to·prepare and submit briefs. Respondent's request. for sixty (60) days 

### is unreasonable when considered in 

### light ofRllle 13.231 

# and the deadlines established 

### in the rules 

## ·ofpractice for other matters. The Rules also provide:

• 30 

### days for arespondeo.t to 

### respond to a Notice ofhoposed Civil Penalty (Rule 13.16(£)),

• 15 days to 

### appeal a Final Notice ofProposed Civil Penalty (Rule 13.16(g(2)),

• 20 days fur the**compl~t** to file**th~** complaint 

### ifthe**Fin~** Notice 

### i6 appealed (Rule**13.208(a))~** 

### • 30 

### da:ys for a respondent to 

### answer the complaU:I.t 

### (Rule 13

..209(a)),



### • 10 days 

### for respondent 

### to file an 

### answer 

### ifa motion to 

### dismiss is not granted (Rule 13.21 

### S(t)(2)(fi)).

• 1:5 

### days to 

### file a more defmite co.mplaint or answer if

### a Motion for a More Definite Statement is granted (Rules 13.218(f)(3)(i) and (ii)),



### • 10 

### days to 

### 8D$Wer amotion (Rule 

### 13.218(e)),

• 30 days to respond to a discovery request 

### (RUles 13.220(d)) and (1)) 

### Respondent's CEO asserts that 

### she 

### will be «traveling" and "extremely busy at**school.'~** 

### Exhibit 2.**However~** 

### Respondent asserted at 

### tdal that the proposed 

### sanction woUld "hurt the flight school"· and that the school's 1

### 'profit margin

... is

... ve:ty 

### s:mil.l.j' Transcript**48~12-17.** 

### The CEO further states that 

### '"whenever an issue 

### has come to [her] 

### attention, [she] 

### put[s] forth a lot 

### ofeffort

... , Tran.Scri.pt 48:18-20. Ifthose 

### statements are true, then these eases are sufficiently important to Respondent that they should be a priority in 

### scheduling and :receive ''a lot of 

### effort." Respondent also asks for extra time on 

### the grounds that undersigned counsel has asked for "extra time because [his] wife is 

### ba-ring a baby." Exhibit 2. Ra1:l1cr 

### than seeking "'extra tinte," 1.1Ildersigned counsel seeks to complete brlefing 

### before the due date. Complainant's proposed briefing sohedule7 combined 

### 'With the eonteiQporaneous filing ofComplainant•s Briefwill 

### result

Motion to Set Brieflng Scbedllle Cotnmtone Aviatiol'l., lnc,- F AA·l011--0481, FA.A-20 114f.S4, FAA·20I I-0489

. J:>agel etf4 1BmU>YM.**~PAAAtTORNBY** T.EL: (425) 1..27-2161; PAx: (4::Z5)**227~.1007**04/27/2012 10:33 FAX 2024935142 FAA + OMS**~013/018** PAGE 13/16 04/20/2012 10:51 4252271 e!eJ7 ANM7

1 2 3 4 s 6 7 B .9 10 11 12**l.~** 14 15 lS 17 l.S 19 20 21 22 23 24

2 27 28. 29 JO 3l 32 .3.3

. 34 Js· 36' 37. J8 39 40 41 

# '2 43 44. 4.5**4~** 47· 4S 49 so

, Sl.

52 53 ..

### _ ....


### in the 

### completio:a. ofbriefing before the 

### child's due 

### date ofJ'Ulle 16. 2012 while allowing Respondent 

### ample and sufficient opportunity to 

### respond.



### Exhibits 1. 

### E-mail from 

### 'undersigned counsel to 

### CEO ofRespondent proposing briefing 

### schedule. 

### 2. E-mail from

### Respondent~ s CEO to uo.dersigned counsel

### propos~ alternate schedule.



### €onclusion Complainant m.cveg this court to

### s~:t a briefing schedule requiring filing ofRespondent's Reply 

### Brief'\\>ithil:t thirty 

### (30) days. of service of

### Complaint's brief, and :tiling ofComplainant's Rebuttal

### Brie~ if

### any~ within fifteen (15) days ofservice ofRespondent's 

### Reply 

### Brief:
.DATED 

### this 20th da; of April, 2012.

F.t\A.Attomey

Motion to Set Briefing Schedule Comerstt.neAviDtion.**Inc:.-PAA~201l~l,·FAA..·2011-0484,** :F'

AA.-20 11·0489 Page3 of4 J:a:FrkEY.M.**~ FMA~**  TEL: (42.5)227-2161; FAX: (425)**221~1007**04/J7/2012 10:34 FAX 2024935142 FAA B4/2B/2elz 1e:s1 <125227Hie17 ANM7

·· ... ·



## CERTDnCATEOFSERVICE -t OMS**~014/018** PAGE 14/16**~** 2 3 4 5 6 7 

### a .9 

### I hereby certify tha,t the 

### foregoing Motion to Set Briefing 

### Schedule has 

# been**~-rved** via facsimile and 

### Certified Mail

- 

### Return Receipt Requested. this date, to 

### the following:

l.O ll**~::!** B l4 l5 l6. 17 18 19 :10 :21 22: 23**~4** . 25 26 :<17**~e.** 01.9 30

. 3l 3::! Jl 34 35 36" 37 38 39 4.0 ·41

. 42

4.3 44 4S <1:& 47 49 49 50 51**5~** 53 Honorable Richard C. Goodwin 

### Office**ofHearlugs~** 

### M-20 1200 New Jersey Avenue, 

### S.E. East Buildmg Oround Floor, Rm 

### E12·320**Washingto~** 

### D.C. 20590 FAX: 202.366.7536


### Attn: He3ting Docket Clerk, Aqe-4.30 Wilbur Wright Building- Suite 2W1000 

### Federa.l 

### Aviation Administration 800 Independence Avenue SW 

### Washmgton. D.C. 20591 FAX: 202.493.5020

I hereby certify that the foregoing Motion to Set Briefing Schedule h.as

### ~n served via Over.o.ight Courier and 

### First-Class and Certified

- Retum Receipt Requested Mail this date, to the · 

### following:

Susan Horstman ChiefExecutive 

### Offi.cer Cornerstone Aviation, Inc, 337 North 

### 2370 West#130 Salt 

### Lake City. UT 84116



### Dated this 20th. day 

### of April" 

## 2ot2.

# }!~ MOIFAIR CHrN Office ·of

### Regional Co.unsel (ANM-7) Federal**AViati~n** 

### Adminis1ra.tion 1601 LindAve. SW**Ratto~** WA 98057 425:227.2160 '

Motion to Set Briefing Schedule

. Como:maue A.viG.tion, 

### me. -FAA-2D11-o481,**FAA-201'1~0484, FAA-2011~489** **J~:M,.** HARPER, FAA.Ant>RNEY TET

..: (4%5) 221·21 61.: FAX: (425) 227-1007**P~e4of4**04/27/2012 10:34 FAX 2024835142
B4/2a/2Bl2 16:51 4252271 Elf.l7

Transcript Available [l FAA
ANM7 + OMS**~015/018** PAGE 15/15

Jeffrey Harper to: Susan l-lotstmen ANM-Q07, Office of**Fh~gional** Counsel 04/04.12012 07:48AM
Ms. Horstman-

. I received my copy ofthe transcript yesterday. shortly before close of business. I propose 30· days for the FM to submit its brief (my brief due NLT 3 May), 30 days afterservice at my brief for you to 11le**Corn~rstone's** reply, and 15 days after you file for the FAA to submit its rebuttal, If any. Ifthat schedule is amenable to you. I will let Judge Goodwin krtow. V/r, Very respectfully, Jeff Harper ANM..07 W: (425) 227·2161 jeffrey.harper@faa.gov



# Exhibit 104/27/2012 10:34 FAX 2024835142**~~~~~~2~~~ l~:~l**  4252271887

·--·· FAA -> OMS ANM7**~018/018** PAGE 16/16 Page 1 ofl

Re: Transcript Available Susan Horstman to: Jeffrey Hazper 04/0412012 09:19AM Hide De:tails 

### ·From: Su.san Horstrnan -<:shorstmSJJ@comerstoneaviation.com.> To: Jeffi-ey Harpe.r/ANMfFAA@FAA., History: This message 

### has been replied to.

. I 

### will 

### ha,. a problem with that 

### as I 

### am ttaveling aud extttmely bwy at 

### the school.!

### was also told you have 

### aSked fur 

### extra 

### time 

### b<cmJse your wife is having a baby

.. I suggest 

### 60 day. fur your brief; 60 days · 

### fur my 

### tepiJI and 30 days 

### to subnUt 

### rebuttoJ. If lean 

### do it 

### &stet I Will, 

### but I

# don~ want to get C>Ugbt not having the ti.me. · ·**S~lSan**
On Wed, Apr 4, 2012 at 8:51 

### AM. <Jeffiey.Harper@faa.goV> wrote: 

### f Ms. Horstman-

o i 0 I 

### i I

# re~eived my copy ofthe

# tr~nscrtpt yesterday r ShOrtly before close of business. i 0

0

# ~ l propose 30 days for the FAA to submft 

### its brief (my brief due 

### NLT 3 May). 30 days after

# ~ service of my brief 

### for you 

### to fife Comel'$tone's reply, and 15 

### days after you file for the FM 

### ) to submit its 

### rebuttal, if

### any. · '

. 

### ! Ifthat schedufe is amenable to you, I will let Judge Goodwin know. 

### !

. . . 

### i V/r, 

### ; Very respectfully, : Jeff Harper l ANM-07 

## I W: C425t227-2161**:~** jeffrey,haO?er@faa.gov

# file:/~C:\Uscrs\ie:tlixy**h~er\A.ppData\Loca1\Temp\l\notes~.FF692\-web404G.h1m** 

# Exhibit 2

4/4/2012