APPENDIX 5A. ENGINEERING RESULTS USED IN THE SHIPMENTS AND

NATIONAL IMPACTS ANALYSIS

TABLE OF CONTENTS

5A.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 5A­1

5A.2 GENERAL SERVICE FLUORESCENT LAMPS................................................. 5A­1

5A.2.1 4­foot Medium Bipin General Service Fluorescent Lamps.................................... 5A­2

5A.2.2 8­foot Single Pin Slimline General Service Fluorescent Lamps ............................ 5A­5

5A.2.3 8­foot Recessed Double Contact HO General Service Fluorescent Lamps............ 5A­7

5A.3 INCANDESCENT REFLECTOR LAMPS............................................................ 5A­8

LIST OF TABLES

Table 5A.2.1 4­foot T8 Medium Bipin 3­Lamps per Ballast Lamp­and­Ballast Designs........ 5A­2

Table 5A.2.2 4­foot T8 Medium Bipin 2­Lamps per Ballast Lamp­and­Ballast Designs........ 5A­3

Table 5A.2.3 4­foot T12 Medium Bipin Lamp­and­Ballast Designs...................................... 5A­4

Table 5A.2.4 8­foot T8 Single Pin Slimline Lamp­and­Ballast Designs ................................. 5A­5

Table 5A.2.5 8­foot T12 Single Pin Slimline Lamp­and­Ballast Designs .............................. 5A­6

Table 5A.2.6 8­foot T12 Recessed Double Contact High Output Lamp­and­Ballast

Designs........................................................................................................ 5A­7

Table 5A.2.7 8­foot T8 Recessed Double Contact High Output Lamp­and­Ballast

Designs........................................................................................................ 5A­8

Table 5A.3.1 90W PAR38 Incandescent Reflector Lamps ..................................................... 5A­8

Table 5A.3.2 75W PAR38 Incandescent Reflector Lamps ..................................................... 5A­9

Table 5A.3.3 50W PAR30 Incandescent Reflector Lamps ..................................................... 5A­9

5A­i

EERE-2007-BT-TP-0013 COMMENT 05
APPENDIX 5A. ENGINEERING RESULTS USED IN THE SHIPMENTS AND

NATIONAL IMPACTS ANALYSIS

5A.1 INTRODUCTION

This appendix presents the engineering results used in the shipments and national impact

analysis (NIA). In addition to many of the lamp and lamp­and­ballast designs considered in the

life­cycle cost (LCC) and payback period (PBP) analysis, the shipments analysis and national

impact analysis (NIA) includes designs that do not save energy or do not emit lumens within 10

percent of the baseline lamp­and­ballast system. Product substitutions like compact fluorescent

lamps (CFLs) and reflector CFLs which are not included in the LCC and PBP analysis are also

considered in the NIA and shipments analysis.

5A.2 GENERAL SERVICE FLUORESCENT LAMPS

The following tables list the lamp­and­ballast designs used in the general service

fluorescent (GSFL) shipments analysis and the NIA. In addition to many of the lamp­and­ballast

designs considered in the LCC and PBP analysis, the shipments analysis and NIA include

designs that do not save energy or do not emit lumens within 10 percent of the baseline lampand­ballast system.

5A­1

EERE-2007-BT-TP-0013 COMMENT 05
5A.2.1 4­foot Medium Bipin General Service Fluorescent Lamps

Table 5A.2.1 4­foot T8 Medium Bipin 3­Lamps per Ballast Lamp­and­Ballast Designs Candidate Standard Level Rated Wattage Rated Efficacy Initial Light Output Mean Light Output Life Ballast Type Ballast Factor System Power Rating* System Initial Light Output System Mean

Light Output

W

lm/W

lmlm

hr

W

lmlm

2 32.5 86.2 2,800 2,520 20,000 Electronic 0.88 87.5 7,392 6,653

3 32.5 90.8 2,950 2,710 20,000 Electronic 0.88 87.5 7,788 7,154

4 32.5 92.3 3,000 2,850 24,000 Electronic 0.88 87.5 7,920 7,524

4 30 95 2,850 2,680 18,000 Electronic 0.88 80.5 7,524 7,075

5 32.5 95.4 3,100 2,915 24,000 Electronic 0.88 87.5 8,184 7,696

5 28 97.3 2,725 2,560 18,000 Electronic 0.88 71.1 7,194 6,758

5 25 96 2,400 2,280 24,000 Electronic 0.88 66.8 6,336 6,019

2 32.5 86.2 2,800 2,520 20,000 Electronic 0.78 78.5 6,552 5,897

3 32.5 90.8 2,950 2,710 20,000 Electronic 0.78 78.5 6,903 6,341

4 32.5 92.3 3,000 2,850 24,000 Electronic 0.78 78.5 7,020 6,669

4 30 95 2,850 2,680 18,000 Electronic 0.78 72.4 6,669 6,271

5 32.5 95.4 3,100 2,915 24,000 Electronic 0.78 78.5 7,254 6,821

5 28 97.3 2,725 2,560 18,000 Electronic 0.78 63.3 6,377 5,990

5 25 96 2,400 2,280 24,000 Electronic 0.78 58.1 5,616 5,335

2 32.5 86.2 2,800 2,520 20,000 Electronic 0.75 75.9 6,300 5,670

3 32.5 90.8 2,950 2,710 20,000 Electronic 0.75 75.9 6,638 6,098

4 32.5 92.3 3,000 2,850 24,000 Electronic 0.75 75.9 6,750 6,413

4 30 95 2,850 2,680 18,000 Electronic 0.75 70 6,413 6,030

5 32.5 95.4 3,100 2,915 24,000 Electronic 0.75 75.9 6,975 6,559

5 28 97.3 2,725 2,560 18,000 Electronic 0.75 60.9 6,131 5,760

5 25 96 2,400 2,280 24,000 Electronic 0.75 55.5 5,400 5,130

* All systems use 3 lamps per ballast.

5A­2

EERE-2007-BT-TP-0013 COMMENT 05
Table 5A.2.2 4­foot T8 Medium Bipin 2­Lamps per Ballast Lamp­and­Ballast Designs Candidate Standard Level Rated Wattage Rated Efficacy Initial Light Output Mean Light Output Life Ballast Type Ballast Factor System Power Rating* System Initial Light Output System Mean

Light Output

W

lm/W

lmlm

hr

W

lmlm

2 32.5 86.2 2,800 2,520 20,000 Electronic 0.88 58.5 5,600 5,040

3 32.5 90.8 2,950 2,710 20,000 Electronic 0.88 58.5 5,900 5,420

4 32.5 92.3 3,000 2,850 24,000 Electronic 0.88 58.5 6,000 5,700

4 30 95.0 2,850 2,680 18,000 Electronic 0.88 54.7 5,700 5,360

5 32.5 95.4 3,100 2,915 24,000 Electronic 0.88 58.5 6,200 5,830

5 28 97.3 2,725 2,560 18,000 Electronic 0.88 47.8 5,450 5,120

5 25 96.0 2,400 2,280 24,000 Electronic 0.88 44.0 4,800 4,560

2 32.5 86.2 2,800 2,520 20,000 Electronic 0.78 51.9 5,600 5,040

3 32.5 90.8 2,950 2,710 20,000 Electronic 0.78 51.9 5,900 5,420

4 32.5 92.3 3,000 2,850 24,000 Electronic 0.78 51.9 6,000 5,700

4 30 95.0 2,850 2,680 18,000 Electronic 0.78 49.1 5,700 5,360

5 32.5 95.4 3,100 2,915 24,000 Electronic 0.78 51.9 6,200 5,830

5 28 97.3 2,725 2,560 18,000 Electronic 0.78 42.5 5,450 5,120

5 25 96.0 2,400 2,280 24,000 Electronic 0.78 38.9 4,800 4,560

2 32.5 86.2 2,800 2,520 20,000 Electronic 0.75 49.9 5,600 5,040

3 32.5 90.8 2,950 2,710 20,000 Electronic 0.75 49.9 5,900 5,420

4 32.5 92.3 3,000 2,850 24,000 Electronic 0.75 49.9 6,000 5,700

4 30 95.0 2,850 2,680 18,000 Electronic 0.75 47.4 5,700 5,360

5 32.5 95.4 3,100 2,915 24,000 Electronic 0.75 49.9 6,200 5,830

5 28 97.3 2,725 2,560 18,000 Electronic 0.75 41.0 5,450 5,120

5 25 96.0 2,400 2,280 24,000 Electronic 0.75 37.4 4,800 4,560

* All systems use 2 lamps per ballast.

5A­3

EERE-2007-BT-TP-0013 COMMENT 05
Table 5A.2.3 4­foot T12 Medium Bipin Lamp­and­Ballast Designs Candidate Standard Level Rated Wattage Rated Efficacy Initial Light Output Mean Light Output Life Ballast Type Ballast Factor

System Power

Rating*

System Initial

Light Output

System Mean

Light Output

W

lm/W

lmlm

hr

W

lmlm

0 40 80 3,200 2,880 20,000 Magnetic 0.95 129 9,120 8,208

0 34 77.9 2,650 2,300 20,000 Magnetic 0.88 108 6,996 6,072

1 40 82.5 3,300 3,000 20,000 Magnetic 0.95 129 9,405 8,550

1 34 82.4 2,800 2,460 20,000 Magnetic 0.88 108 7,392 6,494

2 40 85 3,400 3,060 24,000 Magnetic 0.95 129 9,690 8,721

2 34 85.3 2,900 2,610 20,000 Magnetic 0.88 108 7,656 6,890

* All systems use a 2­lamp and a 1­lamp ballast.

5A­4

EERE-2007-BT-TP-0013 COMMENT 05
5A.2.2 8­foot Single Pin Slimline General Service Fluorescent Lamps

Table 5A.2.4 8­foot T8 Single Pin Slimline Lamp­and­Ballast Designs Candidate Standard Level Rated Wattage Rated Efficacy Initial Light Output Mean Light Output Life Ballast Type Ballast Factor

System Power

Rating*

System Initial

Light Output

System Mean

Light Output

W

lm/W

lmlm

hr

W

lmlm

3 60.1 94.8 5,700 5,130 15,000 Electronic 0.88 112.8 10,032 9,029

4 60.1 98.2 5,900 5,428 15,000 Electronic 0.88 112.8 10,384 9,553

5 60.1 101.5 6,100 5,795 18,000 Electronic 0.88 112.8 10,736 10,199

5 57 101.8 5,800 5,450 24,000 Electronic 0.88 107.5 10,208 9,592

5 55 103.6 5,700 5,415 18,000 Electronic 0.88 102 10,032 9,530

3 60.1 94.8 5,700 5,130 15,000 Electronic 0.85 109.1 9,690 8,721

4 60.1 98.2 5,900 5,428 15,000 Electronic 0.85 109.1 10,030 9,228

5 60.1 101.5 6,100 5,795 18,000 Electronic 0.85 109.1 10,370 9,852

5 57 101.8 5,800 5,450 24,000 Electronic 0.85 106 9,860 9,265

5 55 103.6 5,700 5,415 18,000 Electronic 0.85 98.5 9,690 9,206

3 60.1 94.8 5,700 5,130 15,000 Electronic 0.78 100.4 8,892 8,003

4 60.1 98.2 5,900 5,428 15,000 Electronic 0.78 100.4 9,204 8,468

5 60.1 101.5 6,100 5,795 18,000 Electronic 0.78 100.4 9,516 9,040

5 57 101.8 5,800 5,450 24,000 Electronic 0.78 102.5 9,048 8,502

5 55 103.6 5,700 5,415 18,000 Electronic 0.78 90.2 8,892 8,447

* All systems use 2 lamps per ballast.

5A­5

EERE-2007-BT-TP-0013 COMMENT 05
Table 5A.2.5 8­foot T12 Single Pin Slimline Lamp­and­Ballast Designs Candidate Standard Level Rated Wattage Rated Efficacy Initial Light Output Mean Light Output Life Ballast Type Ballast Factor System Power

Rating*

System Initial

Light Output

System Mean

Light Output

W

lm/W

lmlm

hr

W

lmlm

0 75 85.6 6,420 5,906 12,000 Magnetic 0.94 158 12,070 11,103

1 75 87.3 6,550 6,157 12,000 Magnetic 0.94 158 12,314 11,575

1 60.5 87.6 5,300 4,664 12,000 Magnetic 0.88 126 9,328 8,209

2 75 92 6,900 6,370 15,000 Magnetic 0.94 158 12,972 11,976

2 60.5 92.6 5,600 5,152 12,000 Magnetic 0.88 126 9,856 9,068

3 60.5 97.5 5,900 5,480 15,000 Magnetic 0.88 126 10,384 9,645

* All systems use 2 lamps per ballast.

5A­6

EERE-2007-BT-TP-0013 COMMENT 05
5A.2.3 8­foot Recessed Double Contact HO General Service Fluorescent Lamps

Table 5A.2.6 8­foot T12 Recessed Double Contact High Output Lamp­and­Ballast Designs Candidate Standard Level Rated Wattage Rated Efficacy Initial Light Output Mean Light Output Life Ballast Type Ballast Factor System Power Rating* System Initial Light Output System Mean Light Output

W

lm/W

lmlm

hr

W

lmlm

0 113 80.1 9,050 8,145 12,000 Electronic 0.88 205.4 15,928 14,335

0 97 82.5 8,000 6,950 12,000 Electronic 0.88 177 14,080 12,232

1 113 83.2 9,400 8,648 12,000 Electronic 0.88 205.4 16,544 15,220

2 97 86.1 8,350 7,515 12,000 Electronic 0.88 177 14,696 13,226

3 97 87.6 8,500 7,650 12,000 Electronic 0.88 177 14,960 13,464

3 97 88.9 8,625 7,750 12,000 Electronic 0.88 177 15,180 13,640

0 113 80.1 9,050 8,145 12,000 Electronic 0.89 208.4 16,109 14,498

0 97 82.5 8,000 6,950 12,000 Electronic 0.89 181.3 14,240 12,371

1 113 83.2 9,400 8,648 12,000 Electronic 0.89 208.4 16,732 15,393

2 97 86.1 8,350 7,515 12,000 Electronic 0.89 181.3 14,863 13,377

3 97 87.6 8,500 7,650 12,000 Electronic 0.89 181.3 15,130 13,617

3 97 88.9 8,625 7,750 12,000 Electronic 0.89 181.3 15,353 13,795

0 113 80.1 9,050 8,145 12,000 Electronic 0.90 211.5 16,290 14,661

0 97 82.5 8,000 6,950 12,000 Electronic 0.90 185.6 14,400 12,510

1 113 83.2 9,400 8,648 12,000 Electronic 0.90 211.5 16,920 15,566

2 97 86.1 8,350 7,515 12,000 Electronic 0.90 185.6 15,030 13,527

3 97 87.6 8,500 7,650 12,000 Electronic 0.90 185.6 15,300 13,770

3 97 88.9 8,625 7,750 12,000 Electronic 0.90 185.6 15,525 13,950

• All systems use 2 lamps per ballast.

5A­7

EERE-2007-BT-TP-0013 COMMENT 05
Table 5A.2.7 8­foot T8 Recessed Double Contact High Output Lamp­and­Ballast Designs Candidate Standard Level Rated Wattage Rated Efficacy Initial Light Output Mean Light Output Life Ballast Type Ballast Factor System Power Rating* System Initial Light Output System Mean Light Output

W

lm/W

lmlm

hr

W

lmlm

3 86 91.9 7,900 7,100 24,000 Electronic 088 160.0 13,904 12,496

4 86 93.0 8,000 7,200 18,000 Electronic 0.88 160.0 14,080 12,672

5 86 95.3 8,200 7,800 18,000 Electronic 0.88 160.0 14,432 13,728

3 86 91.9 7,900 7,100 24,000 Electronic 0.81 151.0 12,798 11,502

4 86 93.0 8,000 7,200 18,000 Electronic 0.81 151.0 12,960 11,664

5 86 95.3 8,200 7,800 18,000 Electronic 0.81 151.0 13,284 12,636

* All systems use 2 lamps per ballast.

5A.3 INCANDESCENT REFLECTOR LAMPS

The following tables list the lamp designs used in the shipments analysis and NIA for

incandescent reflector lamps (IRL). In addition to the lamp designs considered in the LCC and

PBP analysis, the shipments analysis and NIA include 65W BR40 IRL exempt from coverage.

The shipments analysis and NIA also allow users to include reflector CFL in the analysis.

Table 5A.3.1 90W PAR38 Incandescent Reflector Lamps

CSL Design

Option

Lamp

Descriptor

Wattage

Initial

Light

Output

Mean

Light

Output

Efficacy Lamp

Life

W lm lm lm/W hr

0 Halogen PAR38 90.0 1,310 1,277 14.6 2,500

1 Improved

Halogen PAR38 79.0 1,310 1,277 16.6 3,000

2 HIR PAR38 70.0 1,260 1,229 18.0 3,000

2 HIR PAR38 100.0 2,030 1,979 20.3 3,000

3 Improved HIR PAR38 66.0 1,310 1,277 19.8 4,000

3 Improved HIR PAR38 90.0 2,030 1,979 22.6 4,000

3 Reflector CFL Reflector

CFL 26.0 1,300 1,040 50.0 8,000

5A­8

EERE-2007-BT-TP-0013 COMMENT 05
Table 5A.3.2 75W PAR38 Incandescent Reflector Lamps

CSL Design

Option

Lamp

Descriptor

Wattage

Initial

Light

Output

Mean

Light

Output

Efficacy Lamp

Life

W lm lm lm/W hr

0 Halogen PAR38 75.0 1,050 1,024 14.0 2,500

1 Improved

Halogen PAR38 66.0 1,050 1,024 15.9 3,000

1 Improved

Halogen PAR38 79.0 1,310 1,277 16.6 3,000

2 HIR PAR38 60.0 1,050 1,024 17.5 3,000

2 HIR PAR38 80.0 1,500 1,463 18.8 3,000

3 Improved HIR PAR38 55.0 1,050 1,024 19.1 4,000

3 Improved HIR PAR38 90.0 2,030 1,979 22.6 4,000

3 Reflector CFL Reflector

CFL 26.0 1,300 1,040 50.0 8,000

Table 5A.3.3 50W PAR30 Incandescent Reflector Lamps

CSL Design

Option

Lamp

Descriptor

Wattage

Initial

Light

Output

Mean

Light

Output

Efficacy Lamp

Life

W lm lm lm/W hr

0 Halogen PAR30 50.0 580 566 11.6 3,000

1 Improved

Halogen PAR30 44.3 620 605 14.0 3,000

1 Improved

Halogen PAR30 50.0 720 702 14.4 3,000

2 HIR PAR30 41.3 620 605 15.0 3,000

2 HIR PAR30 50.0 825 804 16.5 4,000

3 Improved HIR PAR30 40.0 680 663 17.0 4,000

3 Improved HIR PAR30 50.0 900 878 18.0 3,000

0 Incandescent BR30 65.0 620 564 9.5 2,000

3 Reflector CFL Reflector

CFL 16.0 750 600 46.9 8,000

5A­9

EERE-2007-BT-TP-0013 COMMENT 05