## APPENDIX 5A. ENGINEERING RESULTS USED IN THE SHIPMENTS AND

NATIONAL IMPACTS ANALYSIS

TABLE OF CONTENTS

**5A.1 INTRODUCTION** 

**.................................................................................................. 5A­1** 

**5A.2 GENERAL**  **SERVICE FLUORESCENT**  **LAMPS................................................. 5A­1** 

**5A.2.1 4­foot**  **Medium Bipin**  **General Service**  **Fluorescent Lamps** 

**.................................... 5A­2** 

**5A.2.2 8­foot**  **Single Pin**  **Slimline General**  **Service Fluorescent**  **Lamps**

**............................ 5A­5** 

**5A.2.3 8­foot**  **Recessed Double**  **Contact HO**  **General Service**  **Fluorescent Lamps............**  **5A­7**

**5A.3 INCANDESCENT**  **REFLECTOR LAMPS............................................................**  **5A­8**

LIST OF TABLES

**Table 5A.2.1**  **4­foot T8**  **Medium Bipin**  **3­Lamps per**  **Ballast Lamp­and­Ballast**  **Designs........ 5A­2** 

**Table 5A.2.2**  **4­foot T8**  **Medium Bipin**  **2­Lamps per**  **Ballast Lamp­and­Ballast**  **Designs........ 5A­3** 

**Table 5A.2.3**  **4­foot T12**  **Medium Bipin**  **Lamp­and­Ballast Designs** 

**...................................... 5A­4** 

**Table 5A.2.4**  **8­foot T8**  **Single Pin**  **Slimline Lamp­and­Ballast**  **Designs**

**................................. 5A­5** 

**Table 5A.2.5**  **8­foot T12**  **Single Pin**  **Slimline Lamp­and­Ballast**  **Designs**

**.............................. 5A­6** 

**Table 5A.2.6**  **8­foot T12**  **Recessed Double**  **Contact High**  **Output Lamp­and­Ballast** 

**Designs........................................................................................................ 5A­7** 

**Table 5A.2.7**  **8­foot T8**  **Recessed Double**  **Contact High**  **Output Lamp­and­Ballast** 

**Designs........................................................................................................ 5A­8** 

**Table 5A.3.1**  **90W PAR38**  **Incandescent Reflector**  **Lamps**

**..................................................... 5A­8** 

**Table 5A.3.2**  **75W PAR38**  **Incandescent Reflector**  **Lamps**

**..................................................... 5A­9** 

**Table 5A.3.3**  **50W PAR30**  **Incandescent Reflector**  **Lamps**

**..................................................... 5A­9** 

**5A­i**

## APPENDIX 5A. ENGINEERING RESULTS USED IN THE SHIPMENTS AND

NATIONAL IMPACTS ANALYSIS

5A.1 INTRODUCTION

**This appendix**  **presents the**  **engineering results**  **used in**  **the shipments**  **and national**  **impact**

**analysis (NIA).**  **In addition**  **to many**  **of the**  **lamp and**  **lamp­and­ballast designs**  **considered in**  **the**

**life­cycle cost**  **(LCC) and**  **payback period**  **(PBP) analysis,**  **the shipments**  **analysis and**  **national**

**impact analysis**  **(NIA) includes**  **designs that**  **do not**  **save energy**  **or do**  **not emit**  **lumens within**  **10**

**percent of**  **the baseline**  **lamp­and­ballast system.**  **Product substitutions**  **like compact**  **fluorescent**

**lamps (CFLs)**  **and reflector**  **CFLs which**  **are not**  **included in**  **the LCC**  **and PBP**  **analysis are**  **also**

**considered in**  **the NIA**  **and shipments**  **analysis.**

5A.2 GENERAL SERVICE FLUORESCENT LAMPS

**The following**  **tables list**  **the lamp­and­ballast**  **designs used**  **in the**  **general service** 

**fluorescent (GSFL)**  **shipments analysis**  **and the**  **NIA. In**  **addition to**  **many of**  **the lamp­and­ballast** 

**designs considered**  **in the**  **LCC and**  **PBP analysis,**  **the shipments**  **analysis and**  **NIA include** 

**designs that**  **do not**  **save energy**  **or do**  **not emit**  **lumens within**  **10 percent**  **of the**  **baseline lamp** 

**and­ballast system.** 

**5A­1**

## 5A.2.1 4­foot Medium Bipin General Service Fluorescent Lamps

Table 5A.2.1 4­foot T8 Medium Bipin 3­Lamps per Ballast Lamp­and­Ballast DesignsCandidateStandardLevelRatedWattageRatedEfficacyInitialLightOutputMeanLightOutputLifeBallastTypeBallastFactorSystemPowerRating*SystemInitialLightOutputSystemMeanLightOutputWlm/WlmlmhrWlmlm

**2 32.5**  **86.2 2,800**  **2,520 20,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **87.5 7,392**  **6,653**

**3 32.5**  **90.8 2,950**  **2,710 20,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **87.5 7,788**  **7,154**

**4 32.5**  **92.3 3,000**  **2,850 24,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **87.5 7,920**  **7,524**

**4 30**  **95 2,850**  **2,680 18,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **80.5 7,524**  **7,075**

**5 32.5**  **95.4 3,100**  **2,915 24,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **87.5 8,184**  **7,696**

**5 28**  **97.3 2,725**  **2,560 18,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **71.1 7,194**  **6,758**

**5 25**  **96 2,400**  **2,280 24,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **66.8 6,336**  **6,019**

**2 32.5**  **86.2 2,800**  **2,520 20,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **78.5 6,552**  **5,897**

**3 32.5**  **90.8 2,950**  **2,710 20,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **78.5 6,903**  **6,341**

**4 32.5**  **92.3 3,000**  **2,850 24,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **78.5 7,020**  **6,669**

**4 30**  **95 2,850**  **2,680 18,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **72.4 6,669**  **6,271**

**5 32.5**  **95.4 3,100**  **2,915 24,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **78.5 7,254**  **6,821**

**5 28**  **97.3 2,725**  **2,560 18,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **63.3 6,377**  **5,990**

**5 25**  **96 2,400**  **2,280 24,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **58.1 5,616**  **5,335**

**2 32.5**  **86.2 2,800**  **2,520 20,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **75.9 6,300**  **5,670**

**3 32.5**  **90.8 2,950**  **2,710 20,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **75.9 6,638**  **6,098**

**4 32.5**  **92.3 3,000**  **2,850 24,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **75.9 6,750**  **6,413**

**4 30**  **95 2,850**  **2,680 18,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **70 6,413**  **6,030**

**5 32.5**  **95.4 3,100**  **2,915 24,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **75.9 6,975**  **6,559**

**5 28**  **97.3 2,725**  **2,560 18,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **60.9 6,131**  **5,760**

**5 25**  **96 2,400**  **2,280 24,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **55.5 5,400**  **5,130**



### * **All systems**  **use 3**  **lamps per**  **ballast.**

**5A­2**

## Table 5A.2.2 4­foot T8 Medium Bipin 2­Lamps per Ballast Lamp­and­Ballast DesignsCandidateStandardLevelRatedWattageRatedEfficacyInitialLightOutputMeanLightOutputLifeBallastTypeBallastFactorSystemPowerRating*SystemInitialLightOutputSystemMeanLightOutputWlm/WlmlmhrWlmlm

**2 32.5**  **86.2 2,800**  **2,520 20,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **58.5 5,600**  **5,040**

**3 32.5**  **90.8 2,950**  **2,710 20,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **58.5 5,900**  **5,420**

**4 32.5**  **92.3 3,000**  **2,850 24,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **58.5 6,000**  **5,700**

**4 30**  **95.0 2,850**  **2,680 18,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **54.7 5,700**  **5,360**

**5 32.5**  **95.4 3,100**  **2,915 24,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **58.5 6,200**  **5,830**

**5 28**  **97.3 2,725**  **2,560 18,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **47.8 5,450**  **5,120**

**5 25**  **96.0 2,400**  **2,280 24,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **44.0 4,800**  **4,560**

**2 32.5**  **86.2 2,800**  **2,520 20,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **51.9 5,600**  **5,040**

**3 32.5**  **90.8 2,950**  **2,710 20,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **51.9 5,900**  **5,420**

**4 32.5**  **92.3 3,000**  **2,850 24,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **51.9 6,000**  **5,700**

**4 30**  **95.0 2,850**  **2,680 18,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **49.1 5,700**  **5,360**

**5 32.5**  **95.4 3,100**  **2,915 24,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **51.9 6,200**  **5,830**

**5 28**  **97.3 2,725**  **2,560 18,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **42.5 5,450**  **5,120**

**5 25**  **96.0 2,400**  **2,280 24,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **38.9 4,800**  **4,560**

**2 32.5**  **86.2 2,800**  **2,520 20,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **49.9 5,600**  **5,040**

**3 32.5**  **90.8 2,950**  **2,710 20,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **49.9 5,900**  **5,420**

**4 32.5**  **92.3 3,000**  **2,850 24,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **49.9 6,000**  **5,700**

**4 30**  **95.0 2,850**  **2,680 18,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **47.4 5,700**  **5,360**

**5 32.5**  **95.4 3,100**  **2,915 24,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **49.9 6,200**  **5,830**

**5 28**  **97.3 2,725**  **2,560 18,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **41.0 5,450**  **5,120**

**5 25**  **96.0 2,400**  **2,280 24,000**  **Electronic 0.75**  **37.4 4,800**  **4,560**



### * **All systems**  **use 2**  **lamps per**  **ballast.**

**5A­3**

## Table 5A.2.3 4­foot T12 Medium Bipin Lamp­and­Ballast DesignsCandidateStandardLevelRatedWattageRatedEfficacyInitialLightOutputMeanLightOutputLifeBallastTypeBallastFactorSystemPowerRating*SystemInitialLightOutputSystemMeanLightOutputWlm/WlmlmhrWlmlm

**0 40**  **80 3,200**  **2,880 20,000**  **Magnetic 0.95**  **129 9,120**  **8,208**

**0 34**  **77.9 2,650**  **2,300 20,000**  **Magnetic 0.88**  **108 6,996**  **6,072**

**1 40**  **82.5 3,300**  **3,000 20,000**  **Magnetic 0.95**  **129 9,405**  **8,550**

**1 34**  **82.4 2,800**  **2,460 20,000**  **Magnetic 0.88**  **108 7,392**  **6,494**

**2 40**  **85 3,400**  **3,060 24,000**  **Magnetic 0.95**  **129 9,690**  **8,721**

**2 34**  **85.3 2,900**  **2,610 20,000**  **Magnetic 0.88**  **108 7,656**  **6,890**



### * **All systems**  **use a**  **2­lamp and**  **a 1­lamp**  **ballast.**

**5A­4**

## 5A.2.2 8­foot Single Pin Slimline General Service Fluorescent Lamps

Table 5A.2.4 8­foot T8 Single Pin Slimline Lamp­and­Ballast DesignsCandidateStandardLevelRatedWattageRatedEfficacyInitialLightOutputMeanLightOutputLifeBallastTypeBallastFactorSystemPowerRating*SystemInitialLightOutputSystemMeanLightOutputWlm/WlmlmhrWlmlm

**3 60.1**  **94.8 5,700**  **5,130 15,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **112.8 10,032**  **9,029**

**4 60.1**  **98.2 5,900**  **5,428 15,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **112.8 10,384**  **9,553**

**5 60.1**  **101.5 6,100**  **5,795 18,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **112.8 10,736**  **10,199**

**5 57**  **101.8 5,800**  **5,450 24,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **107.5 10,208**  **9,592**

**5 55**  **103.6 5,700**  **5,415 18,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **102 10,032**  **9,530**

**3 60.1**  **94.8 5,700**  **5,130 15,000**  **Electronic 0.85**  **109.1 9,690**  **8,721**

**4 60.1**  **98.2 5,900**  **5,428 15,000**  **Electronic 0.85**  **109.1 10,030**  **9,228**

**5 60.1**  **101.5 6,100**  **5,795 18,000**  **Electronic 0.85**  **109.1 10,370**  **9,852**

**5 57**  **101.8 5,800**  **5,450 24,000**  **Electronic 0.85**  **106 9,860**  **9,265**

**5 55**  **103.6 5,700**  **5,415 18,000**  **Electronic 0.85**  **98.5 9,690**  **9,206**

**3 60.1**  **94.8 5,700**  **5,130 15,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **100.4 8,892**  **8,003**

**4 60.1**  **98.2 5,900**  **5,428 15,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **100.4 9,204**  **8,468**

**5 60.1**  **101.5 6,100**  **5,795 18,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **100.4 9,516**  **9,040**

**5 57**  **101.8 5,800**  **5,450 24,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **102.5 9,048**  **8,502**

**5 55**  **103.6 5,700**  **5,415 18,000**  **Electronic 0.78**  **90.2 8,892**  **8,447**



### * **All systems**  **use 2**  **lamps per**  **ballast.**

**5A­5**

## Table 5A.2.5 8­foot T12 Single Pin Slimline Lamp­and­Ballast DesignsCandidateStandardLevelRatedWattageRatedEfficacyInitialLightOutputMeanLightOutputLifeBallastTypeBallastFactorSystemPowerRating*SystemInitialLightOutputSystemMeanLightOutputWlm/WlmlmhrWlmlm

**0 75**  **85.6 6,420**  **5,906 12,000**  **Magnetic 0.94**  **158 12,070**  **11,103**

**1 75**  **87.3 6,550**  **6,157 12,000**  **Magnetic 0.94**  **158 12,314**  **11,575**

**1 60.5**  **87.6 5,300**  **4,664 12,000**  **Magnetic 0.88**  **126 9,328**  **8,209**

**2 75**  **92 6,900**  **6,370 15,000**  **Magnetic 0.94**  **158 12,972**  **11,976**

**2 60.5**  **92.6 5,600**  **5,152 12,000**  **Magnetic 0.88**  **126 9,856**  **9,068**

**3 60.5**  **97.5 5,900**  **5,480 15,000**  **Magnetic 0.88**  **126 10,384**  **9,645**



### * **All systems**  **use 2**  **lamps per**  **ballast.**

**5A­6**

## 5A.2.3 8­foot Recessed Double Contact HO General Service Fluorescent Lamps

Table 5A.2.6 8­foot T12 Recessed Double Contact High Output Lamp­and­Ballast DesignsCandidateStandardLevelRatedWattageRatedEfficacyInitialLightOutputMeanLightOutputLifeBallastTypeBallastFactorSystemPowerRating*SystemInitialLightOutputSystemMeanLightOutputWlm/WlmlmhrWlmlm

**0 113**  **80.1 9,050**  **8,145 12,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **205.4 15,928**  **14,335**

**0 97**  **82.5 8,000**  **6,950 12,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **177 14,080**  **12,232**

**1 113**  **83.2 9,400**  **8,648 12,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **205.4 16,544**  **15,220**

**2 97**  **86.1 8,350**  **7,515 12,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **177 14,696**  **13,226**

**3 97**  **87.6 8,500**  **7,650 12,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **177 14,960**  **13,464**

**3 97**  **88.9 8,625**  **7,750 12,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **177 15,180**  **13,640**

**0 113**  **80.1 9,050**  **8,145 12,000**  **Electronic 0.89**  **208.4 16,109**  **14,498**

**0 97**  **82.5 8,000**  **6,950 12,000**  **Electronic 0.89**  **181.3 14,240**  **12,371**

**1 113**  **83.2 9,400**  **8,648 12,000**  **Electronic 0.89**  **208.4 16,732**  **15,393**

**2 97**  **86.1 8,350**  **7,515 12,000**  **Electronic 0.89**  **181.3 14,863**  **13,377**

**3 97**  **87.6 8,500**  **7,650 12,000**  **Electronic 0.89**  **181.3 15,130**  **13,617**

**3 97**  **88.9 8,625**  **7,750 12,000**  **Electronic 0.89**  **181.3 15,353**  **13,795**

**0 113**  **80.1 9,050**  **8,145 12,000**  **Electronic 0.90**  **211.5 16,290**  **14,661**

**0 97**  **82.5 8,000**  **6,950 12,000**  **Electronic 0.90**  **185.6 14,400**  **12,510**

**1 113**  **83.2 9,400**  **8,648 12,000**  **Electronic 0.90**  **211.5 16,920**  **15,566**

**2 97**  **86.1 8,350**  **7,515 12,000**  **Electronic 0.90**  **185.6 15,030**  **13,527**

**3 97**  **87.6 8,500**  **7,650 12,000**  **Electronic 0.90**  **185.6 15,300**  **13,770**

**3 97**  **88.9 8,625**  **7,750 12,000**  **Electronic 0.90**  **185.6 15,525**  **13,950**



### • **All systems**  **use 2**  **lamps per**  **ballast.**

**5A­7**

## Table 5A.2.7 8­foot T8 Recessed Double Contact High Output Lamp­and­Ballast DesignsCandidateStandardLevelRatedWattageRatedEfficacyInitialLightOutputMeanLightOutputLifeBallastTypeBallastFactorSystemPowerRating*SystemInitialLightOutputSystemMeanLightOutputWlm/WlmlmhrWlmlm

**3 86**  **91.9 7,900**  **7,100 24,000**  **Electronic 088**  **160.0 13,904**  **12,496**

**4 86**  **93.0 8,000**  **7,200 18,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **160.0 14,080**  **12,672**

**5 86**  **95.3 8,200**  **7,800 18,000**  **Electronic 0.88**  **160.0 14,432**  **13,728**

**3 86**  **91.9 7,900**  **7,100 24,000**  **Electronic 0.81**  **151.0 12,798**  **11,502**

**4 86**  **93.0 8,000**  **7,200 18,000**  **Electronic 0.81**  **151.0 12,960**  **11,664**

**5 86**  **95.3 8,200**  **7,800 18,000**  **Electronic 0.81**  **151.0 13,284**  **12,636**



### * **All systems**  **use 2**  **lamps per**  **ballast.**



## 5A.3 INCANDESCENT REFLECTOR LAMPS

**The following**  **tables list**  **the lamp**  **designs used**  **in the**  **shipments analysis**  **and NIA**  **for**

**incandescent reflector**  **lamps (IRL).**  **In addition**  **to the**  **lamp designs**  **considered in**  **the LCC**  **and**

**PBP analysis,**  **the shipments**  **analysis and**  **NIA include**  **65W BR40**  **IRL exempt**  **from coverage.** 

**The shipments**  **analysis and**  **NIA also**  **allow users**  **to include**  **reflector CFL**  **in the**  **analysis.**

Table 5A.3.1 90W PAR38 Incandescent Reflector Lamps

CSL Design

Option Lamp

Descriptor Wattage Initial

Light

Output Mean

Light

Output Efficacy Lamp

Life

W lm lm lm/W hr

**0 Halogen**  **PAR38 90.0**  **1,310 1,277**  **14.6 2,500** 

**1 Improved** 

**Halogen PAR38**  **79.0 1,310**  **1,277 16.6**  **3,000**

**2 HIR**  **PAR38 70.0**  **1,260 1,229**  **18.0 3,000** 

**2 HIR**  **PAR38 100.0**  **2,030 1,979**  **20.3 3,000** 

**3 Improved**  **HIR PAR38**  **66.0 1,310**  **1,277 19.8**  **4,000**

**3 Improved**  **HIR PAR38**  **90.0 2,030**  **1,979 22.6**  **4,000**

**3 Reflector**  **CFL Reflector** 

**CFL 26.0**  **1,300 1,040**  **50.0 8,000** 

**5A­8**

## Table 5A.3.2 75W PAR38 Incandescent Reflector Lamps

CSL Design

Option Lamp

Descriptor Wattage Initial

Light

Output Mean

Light

Output Efficacy Lamp

Life

W lm lm lm/W hr

**0 Halogen**  **PAR38 75.0**  **1,050 1,024**  **14.0 2,500** 

**1 Improved** 

**Halogen PAR38**  **66.0 1,050**  **1,024 15.9**  **3,000**

**1 Improved** 

**Halogen PAR38**  **79.0 1,310**  **1,277 16.6**  **3,000**

**2 HIR**  **PAR38 60.0**  **1,050 1,024**  **17.5 3,000** 

**2 HIR**  **PAR38 80.0**  **1,500 1,463**  **18.8 3,000** 

**3 Improved**  **HIR PAR38**  **55.0 1,050**  **1,024 19.1**  **4,000**

**3 Improved**  **HIR PAR38**  **90.0 2,030**  **1,979 22.6**  **4,000**

**3 Reflector**  **CFL Reflector** 

**CFL 26.0**  **1,300 1,040**  **50.0 8,000** 



## Table 5A.3.3 50W PAR30 Incandescent Reflector Lamps

CSL Design

Option Lamp

Descriptor Wattage Initial

Light

Output Mean

Light

Output Efficacy Lamp

Life

W lm lm lm/W hr

**0 Halogen**  **PAR30 50.0**  **580 566**  **11.6 3,000** 

**1 Improved** 

**Halogen PAR30**  **44.3 620**  **605 14.0**  **3,000**

**1 Improved** 

**Halogen PAR30**  **50.0 720**  **702 14.4**  **3,000**

**2 HIR**  **PAR30 41.3**  **620 605**  **15.0 3,000** 

**2 HIR**  **PAR30 50.0**  **825 804**  **16.5 4,000** 

**3 Improved**  **HIR PAR30**  **40.0 680**  **663 17.0**  **4,000**

**3 Improved**  **HIR PAR30**  **50.0 900**  **878 18.0**  **3,000**

**0 Incandescent**  **BR30 65.0**  **620 564**  **9.5 2,000** 

**3 Reflector**  **CFL Reflector** 

**CFL 16.0**  **750 600**  **46.9 8,000** 

**5A­9**