Printed 11/25/2016 Page 1/3

Type Briones

Austin

Buie

Beck

Swaffar

De Lima

 Favre (Chair)

Chapman

Seitz

Richardson

Behar

Sonnabend

Rice

Oakley

 Thicke 

Yes (Y)

No (N)

Abstain (A)

Recuse (R)

Absent (T)

Pass/Fail

NOSB Fall 2016 Proposals 

Subcom

mittee

Substance NL Section Doc type Motion by: Seconded 

by: 

HS Motion to remove Agar-agar 205.605(a) 2018 

Sunset 

Lisa de Lima Ashley 

Swaffar

 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 14 0 0 1 FAIL

HS Motion to remove Animal enzymes 205.605(a) 2018 

Sunset 

Lisa de Lima Ashley 

Swaffar

 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 14 0 0 1 FAIL

HS Motion to remove Calcium sulfatemined

205.605(a) 2018 

Sunset 

Tom 

Chapman

Ashley 

Swaffar

 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 14 0 0 1 FAIL

HS Motion to remove Carrageenan 205.605(a) 2018 

Sunset 

Zea 

Sonnabend

Ashley 

Swaffar

 2/3

T N N N Y Y Y Y Y Y Y A Y Y Y 10 3 1 0 1 PASS

HS Motion to remove Glucono deltalactone

205.605(a) 2018 

Sunset 

Tom 

Chapman

Ashley 

Swaffar

 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N A N 0 13 1 0 1 FAIL

HS Motion to remove Tartaric acid 205.605(a) 2018 

Sunset 

Ashley 

Swaffar

Zea 

Sonnabend

 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 14 0 0 1 FAIL

HS Motion to remove Cellulose 205.605(b) 2018 

Sunset 

Harold 

Austin

Lisa de 

Lima

 2/3

T N N N N N N N A N N N N Y Y 2 11 1 0 1 FAIL

HS Motion to remove Potassium 

hydroxide

205.605(b) 2018 

Sunset 

Ashley 

Swaffar

Scott Rice 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 14 0 0 1 FAIL

HS Motion to remove Silicon dioxide 205.605(b) 2018 

Sunset 

Lisa de Lima Tom 

Chapman

 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 14 0 0 1 FAIL

HS Motion to remove Colors: Betacarotene extract

205.606 2018 

Sunset 

Jean 

Richardson

Ashley 

Swaffar

 2/3

T N N N Y Y N N Y Y N N N Y Y 6 8 0 0 1 FAIL

HS Motion to classify sodium chlorite 

(chlorine dioxide gas) as non 

agricultural, synthetic

205.605 Proposal Scott Rice Jean 

Richardson

 2/3

T

NA

HS Motion to add sodium chlorite 

(chlorine dioxide gas) @

205.605(b) Proposal Scott Rice Ashley 

Swaffar

 2/3

T NA

Motion to refer sodium chlorite 

back to Subcommittee

Scott Rice Ashley 

Swaffar

 2/3

T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 14 0 0 0 1 PASS

HS Motion to classify oat protein 

concentrate as agricultural

205.606 Proposal Lisa de Lima Tom 

Chapman

 2/3

T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 14 0 0 0 1 PASS

HS Motion to add oat protein 

concentrate @

205.606 Proposal Lisa de Lima Scott Rice 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 14 0 0 1 FAIL

Motion to refer OAT PROTEIN 

CONCENTRATE back to 

Tracy Favre Harriet 

Behar T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 14 0 0 0 1 PASS

Motion to list Tocopherols @ 205.605(a) Proposal Scott Rice Jean 

Richardson NA

HS Motion to refer Tocopherols back to 

Subcommittee

205.605(a) Proposal Tracy Favre Harriet Behar 2/3

T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 14 0 0 0 1 PASS

Motion to amend the tocopherols 

annotation @ 205.605(b) to read: 

 

205.605(b) Proposal Tracy Favre Ashley 

Swaffar NA

HS Motion to refer Tocopherols back to 

Subcommittee

205.605(b) Proposal Tracy Favre Ashley 

Swaffar

 2/3

T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y

14 0 0 0 1 PASS
Printed 11/25/2016 Page 2/3

MS Motion to accept the 2016 Research 

Priorities 

NA Proposal Emily 

Oakley

Tracy Favre 2/3

T

YYYYYYYYYYYYYY 14

0001 PASS

MS Motion to accept the proposal on 

Excluded Methods terminology with 

 

NA Proposal Zea 

Sonnabend

Emily 

Oakley

 2/3

T

YYYYYYYYYYYYYY 14

0001 PASS

MS Motion to accept the report to the 

USDA Secretary on Progress to 

 

NA Report Zea 

Sonnabend

Tracy Favre 2/3

T

YYYYYYYYYYYYYY 14

0001 PASS

CS Motion to remove Copper sulfate 205.601(a) 

205.601(e)

2018 

Sunset 

Zea 

Sonnabend

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T

NNNNNNNNNNNNNN

0 14001 FAIL

CS Motion to remove Ozone gas 205.601(a) 2018 

Sunset 

Francis 

Thicke

Harold 

Austin

 2/3

T

NNNNNNNANNNNYN

1 12101 FAIL

CS Motion to remove Peracetic Acid 205.601(a) 

205.601(i)

2018 

Sunset 

Harold 

Austin

Emily 

Oakley

 2/3

T

NNNNNNNNNNNNNN

0 14001 FAIL

CS Motion to remove EPA List 3 Inerts 205.601(m) 2018 

Sunset 

Zea 

Sonnabend

Harold 

Austin

 2/3

T

NNNNNNNNNNNNNN

0 14001 FAIL

CS Motion to remove Calcium chloride 205.602(c) 2018 

Sunset 

Carmela 

Beck

Harold 

Austin

 2/3

T

NNNNNNNNNNNNNN

0 14001 FAIL

CS Motion to classify Aluminum sulfate 

as syntehtic 

205.601 Proposal Francis 

Thicke

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T

YYYYYYYYYYYYYY 14

0001 PASS

CS Motion to add Aluminum sulfate - as 

petitioned @

205.601 Proposal Francis 

Thicke

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T

NNNNNNNNNNNNNN

0 14001 FAIL

CS Motion to classify Soy Wax as 

synthetic

205.601 Proposal Francis 

Thicke

Harold 

Austin

 2/3

T

YYYYYYYYYYYYYY 14

0001 PASS

CS Motion to add Soy Wax - as 

petitioned @

205.601 Proposal Francis 

Thicke

Emily 

Oakley

 2/3

T

NNNNNNNYNYANYY

49101 FAIL

Motion to amend motion to read 

(see slide)

Francis 

Thicke

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T

NNNYYYYYYYYYYY 11

3001 PASS

CS Motion to classify 1-

methylcyclopropene (1-MCP) as 

205.601 Proposal Zea 

Sonnabend

Emily 

Oakley

 2/3

T

YYYYYYYYYYYYYY 14

0001 PASS

CS Motion to add 1-methylcyclopropene 

(1-MCP) - as petitioned @

205.601 Proposal Zea 

Sonnabend

Harold 

Austin

 2/3

T

YYYNNNNNNNNNNN

3 11001 FAIL

Motion to defer to Handling 

Subcomm for reconsideration

1 2/3

T

YYYNNYYNNNNNNN

59001 FAIL

CS Motion to classify Ammonium Citrate 

as synthetic

205.601 Proposal Emily 

Oakley

Francis 

Thicke

 2/3

T

YYYYYYYYYYYYYY 14

0001 PASS

CS Motion to add Ammonium Citrate @ 205.601 Proposal Emily 

Oakley

Francis 

Thicke

 2/3

T

NNNNNNNNNNNNNN

0 14001 FAIL

CS Motion to classify Ammonium 

Glycinate as synthetic

205.601 Proposal Emily 

Oakley

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T

YYYYYYYYYYYYYY 14

0001 PASS

CS Motion to add Ammonium Glycinate @

205.601 Proposal Emily 

Oakley

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T

NNNNNNNNNNNNNN

0 14001 FAIL

CS Motion to classify Potassium 

Cellulose Glycolate as synthetic

205.601 Proposal Emily 

Oakley

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T

YYYYYYYYYYYYYY 14

0001 PASS

CS Motion to add Potassium Cellulose 

Glycolate @

205.601 Proposal Emily 

Oakley

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T

NNNNNNNNNNNNNN

0 14001 FAIL
Printed 11/25/2016 Page 3/3

CS Hydroponics (Bioponics). Motion to 

allow bioponics (including 

hydroponics, aeroponics, or 

aquaponics) as consistent with 

organic production under the 

provisions and recommendations to 

Proposal Zea 

Sonnabend

Emily 

Oakley

 2/3

T

NA

Motion to refer Hydroponics 

(Bioponics) proposal back to 

Harold 

Austin

Ashley 

Swaffar T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y N A Y N N 10 3 1 0 1 PASS

Motion to accept the hydroponic 

resolution

Harriet 

Behar

Harold 

Austin T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y A A Y 12 0 2 0 1 PASS

Motion to accept the hydroponic 

resolution as amended

Francis 

Thicke

Emily 

Oakley T N Y N N Y N N Y Y Y N N Y Y 7 7 0 0 1 FAIL

PDS Motion to accept the PPM updates NA Proposal Tom 

Chapman

Tracy Favre 2/3

T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 14 0 0 0 1 PASS

PDS Motion ot accept the sunset review - 

efficient work load reorganization

NA Proposal Tom 

Chapman

Jean 

Richardson

 2/3

T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 14 0 0 0 1 PASS

LS Motion to remove Ivermectin @ 205.603 Proposal Jean 

Richardson

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 14 0 0 0 1 PASS

LS Motion to classify Aluminum sulfate 

as synthetic Classified in Crops

Proposal Ashley 

Swaffar

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T NA

LS Motion to add aluminum sulfate @ 205.603 Proposal Ashley 

Swaffar

Jean 

Richardson

 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 14 0 0 1 FAIL

LS Motion to classify sodium bisulfate 

as syntheric

Proposal Ashley 

Swaffar

Harriet 

Behar

 2/3

T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 14 0 0 0 1 PASS

LS Motion to add sodium bisulfate @ 205.603 Proposal Ashley 

Swaffar

Tracy Favre 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 14 0 0 1 FAIL

LS Motion to classify acid-activated 

bentonite as snythetic

Proposal Ashley 

Swaffar

Tracy Favre 2/3

T Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y Y 14 0 0 0 1 PASS

LS Motion to add acid-activated 

bentonite - as petitioned @

2053603 Proposal Ashley 

Swaffar

Tracy Favre 2/3

T N N N N N N N N N N N N N N 0 14 0 0 1 FAIL