5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,213XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU)LOH 1DPH DS	

			



$0(6 &85'<	

217*20(5<2817<+,2	

 !"#$
%&'	()&("&*+"!"$	+$"%)&("&*!$&),%-../0&*$"12&("+'2"2+'3,4...)*&''%'&'35"+",-4..6!"378	%'8&"*+&+'2(9*$9+%($&%+#5+($&!" %&*$ +((    :	

7;
;7;),%$&!" (
9*$9+%($&%+#5+($&!" %&*$+((  :	

7 ;  4

;  7; ),% $& !" (	  '&<"'$ &%&%!$ *+"&% =$&*$8  >&%'  78  ?  4-@ '&<"' ( "'&((%&%2 &%&%
8  	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	!"!+"$" "*'&%2(%+,--*+"',$('2"'+&% ",!"$&(% $=)=,%	#&$=$$'>+(2"'+'!"#D"&2$
%&<"(&,$ ",=($'$*+5$+(&%$ "#% *# E =$" *+"', $% "(&'' &%%"<& $&  $ ", %'' "+%' #&'%&2$ %'=$&#(!$ "%(=%$#$&#*+"',%'(<"$"(&%*+'&%2$&(5"$"&%=2"	#&$4-
*"&%2 $ C+&!&' &##+%&, '*"&% &%%''  ($55 &*!!&*"&%$*+"(!$&('+&(
%' *C+&%%* $ 7(5, =%  *+"',B( "#% , *"'(*+"',$' *%(+#' *$5$  $ *+5$+( ", %' $ *"' 2# &% $&( "#%"+%' !&<&%$#"%&%2*+"',%'$&((%#(*+"',"**# %&'	#&$%'7(5,$&"*"(($#!!$!+"#%=$"!"&*%#"&*%*%<"('!"5+!&!%#&%+(=$% &**"+&("'"<5,!!&*"  =$ =( % F"+&% "G %' %"( %'&%2%,( *&!&**# &%(*%*"%&%2*+"',B( "#%"$(+""+%'&%2"'"< (*+"',%'*# %, <", (=,  !" $&( &%&& '"&<5, !!&*"=&$+%, "<*&%!"#*+"',"$&(2"+ *&"*'5*H="'($#(!!&*"'"<5,$2"+ !"(*%'&#$&%$&(=%="'(F( '%'5("<' $# !" >+(  != (*%'( %' IJ 2&% $&"%&%(&'=$B(+ 2%#%KG-$&%!!&*""*'*+"',(H&%2&$"F=$B($ "5#KG"F*%
$ ,+KG!!&*"=$$' "H'$&(*"($"'&(%*=,!"#$#%*+'%$"*+"',%'(H'$&#" =$$$'(&'**"'&%2!!&*"*+"',$%'#%''F=$$!+LH',+=%KG!!&*  $% E&' $&( <$&* %'  "*$'*+"', **"'&%2 !!&*"$$%C+(&%'*+"',(=$,$+(' "!%%2+2&%''"((&%2$&#!"*+"',"&"'$&(C+"&(($"(%!"!!&*"B( "*$$!!&*"(("'$&=($&(>5F(=$B(2&%2%G&!F(#5',B((%'&%2+$"M3..&%$#"%&%2G-4**"'&%2!!&*"*+"',$%E*&#'F=$$!+LH&(,+">5KG%'!!&*"(H'$&#(=(	#&$7(5,%'*+"',"!"&'%&!&*&%*+"',"( %''$$=( (%'&%2 &% !"% ! $&( $# $ $ =( =&$+&'%&!&*&%%'$%&$"$%"$&(!"&%'(%'''&( ,%,
!!&*"%E(H'*+"',&!$$'5%'"&%H&%2$%&2$
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
%E&*&%%'5("+*&%2 !!&*& 6+(&%(( +%'" $& < 'AA4?6@?4@O44"( *&<,*+"',(+5(C+%,(+'!!&*"%'%2#",+%,(("&%2$$=(""('&%<&&%! 5$ $ &"( %' +"$ #%'#%(  )+"&%2 >+","*'&%2(*+"', *%%''$$+%,&2,E"*&('%!&( "# ",*$%2(%$5(&(!"*"&2&%,$"="$"5*H##5"(#%2$=%,(&E "(% <%&"     % 5*H<%&" "(% =( E*+(' !" *+( 5*+( $ =(*%%*'  $ +%, 	$"&!!B( !!&* %' $" =$&##5"(="(E*+('!"*+(D&$$('&(#&(((=%,= "(%( &%*+'&%2 = !"&*%#"&*%("#&%'&%$<%&"!"#=$&*$>+",!&2$%''5(*'
%&&,%&2$ "(%>+",=(('=&$+%,5*H##5"(!"*+"',E"*&('$(*%'!$&(= "# ",*$%2(%'!"$+%, (('
4M&+("($+%*"&% (+"!$=$&#!$<%(&%<<'$"6*+($!'"*+"("(&'&( +&%2$&((+!"&&%&%$*%E!%""(&*%$"',5(&'$&($+'$<5% "%!!&*"&%-$$*+'%""(%&%'&<&'+<%$+2$$$' "55*+(!!*$""(&!$&%'&<&'+P( "*'( *$$&#$'%,&# *%$!!&*"P('*&(&%""( *+%((!!&"#%*$"<%$+2$!!&*"#,&%!*$<5%&%!+%*'5,$!+%'5+(&<%2+2# ,'5,"*+"',:"&*+","<%&($ 	+ "# +"B( 5("<&% $ (# &%*&'%(&%<&5, "#&% % $ #&%'( ! $( "( %(&5 !"#H&%2'*&(&%(F"+!*+(&%=$&*$!*+(((,%=$$" "*' *%'+* ,'  " (+5(%&"$"=&(&%'*&(&%%"$&"*+' *%# ,&%  5" (&&% (  "(+ ! $ E"*&( ! *%(&+&%, "*' *%'+* $% $ =+' $<**+ &'$'$'%%$&%2G 4
	4/M ,&%2 $ "&%*&   $ *( $" &  &( <% #"'&(+"5&%2$'"+%H+(&%2!!%(&<%'!+%2+2&%$*+"(!!( *+'!"$"(%%+%'"$ "%(!&"(#%'#% "*'( *$&%&#&'%'2' &*!!&*"&%5&<&%2$$'"%'=$$*%*&<(5$&('+,((#$=$<&$'"+%HB(*%(&+&% "&2$(( +(&*$%C+&( ('3F$*%(&+&% "&%*& (H&((+!!&*&%,<&%'&*'&!(+*$%# ,&( *'&%%="( (&&%$%&!$$'%%22'&%$*%'+*G 4
	4/M/-  "&%, % &%'&<&'+ ($+' % 5 ""('5*+(!*%(&+&%, "*'!!%(&<%2+26+$(#&%'&<&'++2$%555,+(&%2!!%(&<%2+2  "<%  &* !!&*" !"# ((((&%2 $&(*%'+* %' "*$&%2  '*&(&%  ""( $&# (&# ,5*+($!!%(&<%2+2#H($ &*!!&*"#"*"&%!$*""*%((!$&('*&(&% 4
	4/-
'%5&<$$	+ "#+"&%4
5  "% &% $ &2$ ! "E&(&%2 =  ?*&&%2
"4
	MM4/ ?/M@@ 
&(%#"!",&%2!&2+"+$(*%>+(=$="'("$"  &$( #+%"'% #+% F!&2$&%2="'(G5,2 "*'%"'"#&%&%2&%>+'&*& (#"#=$$"$,($+'$"<% "E&(&%2=%$&((+!"&&%&(!+%'&% #$
4
	4?@ &%<<'(*$5"'P('*&(&%%  "$&"  *$" &% "&&% !" $&( E"*&( !*%(&+&%, "*'( *$6*+( '&'%&%<< &*!!&*"B('*&(&%""(%5&2&%$*"!$!!&*"B( "( %(&5&&&(%'%*(("&,#'%$( =&$+$+E+",!&%<(&2&%&=(%  "% $  =+' 2<"% $ &*!!&*"B(*%'+*D$$" &%&!!#,"*<"!"' "&<&%!&"(#%'#%"&2$(*+('5,%2',"&",""(=$&*$ $ !!&*" $' "55 *+(  !!* =( % #"!*",(5&($'=&%-
%''&&((&%&((+ $ &( (+5>*  '5 &% $ !'" *+"(  $#>"&,*&(%	+ "#+"" +5&($'	&E$&"*+&*(('&(*+((&%2"&&%*&#(&%$*%E!%""(%'
#="!%%$'!%'%("&('$"2+#%$ % "&&% *&# #, 5 5"+2$ &! $ ""( &((+ "'5, "55*+(&%$
#%-'..?-$&"@5+$<&'&,!$&( (&&%=(%"+'%5*+($"=( "<&+(!&%'&%2$$"=(% "55*+(.D'&'*%(&'"$&(&((+&%%+% +5&($'*(
&M4'4-?5@MD84-?-$&"M@
%=(+22('$&!$!!&*"($' "55*+((+ "$""($&"*+#&<(="&""<%L?C+&%2 
   ' /- 4' 4M ?-$ &" //@@*2%&1&%2$&(%#"+$"&&<$%#%,! $ *(( *&' 5, $ #>"&, & %%$(( =
M%E"*&(&%2&(!&"(!"&*%#"&*%	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
(
	
M'.?-$-
&"M@%'$'%&!#&% !"%="& !"%5+(!'&(*"&%#
%")
4.'/M/4.?-$&"4...@8&H$'&("&**+"=#+(!!&"#$>+",B(<"'&*F+%(($&(+"Q&(! =&$ $ '!&%& %' !&"# *%<&*&% $  #&(H"(+&%2&% &%&%>+(&*$(5%*##&'B"$<"'&* Q&( *%"",   "(%BG 
 
"%
'4?-$&"/@ ?*&&%#&'@ +'2#% ( #"!= F&( " "&%,=$%$"&(*# 5(%*!!*(+ "$<"'&*($% "(%5>+""*+'$<!+%'!"$%%#<&%2 ",G
%4.-'?-$&"4...@$+2$*+"',$(%(("'$&( *&#(&%$#("!+ !($&%$&( !&"(*&#((%&,*%%'($!!&*"'&'%$< "55*+(""($&#%'$$$"!"<&'$&(+"$#%'#%"&2$2&%(+%"(%5("*$(%'(&1+"(D$&$+"$#%'#%=(5"&!&%<(&2",'%&%("F"",G( (5>+(&!&'%$5(&(!F"(%5(+( &*&%G!
4
	444?-/@!+!'2'""(#+(5(+ "'5, "55*+(*)4.M'.?-$&"4...@:"55 *+( "C+&"( $ &* $< "(%5,"+(="$,&%!"#&% (+!!&*&% =""% % !!&*" !"(%5*+&%5&<$""(*##&'"&(&%$ "*((!*##&&%2%!!%(
$+(%M'M/M4?-$&"@?C+&%2#(

	/?-@@R$
#%-'....?-$&"@:"55*+( !+"$" "C+&"( $ !!&*"( "&*+ *%*" %'5>*&<!*(!"#=$&*$$,&%!"*"&#&%*%'+*+
('4M?-$&"/@"<"$5>*&<"(%5%((!$!*("<%  "55 *+( '"#&%&% &( "#+% %' $!!&*"B((+5>*&<&%%&%("&""<%,
+  M 
	 /.- / ?-@ ?F	+5>*&<
4'&(!" &%"&&%!"$ &%&!!(PE"*&(!$&"!&"(#%'#%"&2$*"&&*&1 +5&*!!&*&(-/D"<"('$'&("&**+"P(2"%!C+&!&'&##+%&,$ ($"&!! D "(%' $ $ "&2$  *"&&*&1 +5&*!!&*&(=(*",(5&($'(=($ "&%*& $+5&*!!&*&P("&&%2&%(%&%'&<&'+!"E"*&(&%2&"(#%'#%"&2$(&(<&&%!A/-/4/$" " = "5#( =&$ $ #>"&,P( "&%* %#&"(#$'%5%'*&''$&#!!&*"""('*+"',!!&*"P(""(!*+"',**+""'&%-#=(%'*&''+%&/
%'"$ '*"&% ! C+&!&' &##+%&, F2<"%#% !!&*&("!"#&%2 '&(*"&%", !+%*&%( 2%", " ($&''!"#&5&&,!"*&<&'#2(&%(!"($&"*%'+*'(%<&*",(5&($'(+","*%(&+&%"&2$(!=$&*$"(%5 "(%=+'$<H%=%G%
"-M
	/..//?/4@$&(#%($$ &*5=#+($<5%*",(5&($'$&#$ *&% **+""'   F
!$ = $&# =( %*", (5&($' % !!&*& *+' % "(%5, 5E *' %&*&  (+5(C+%2 '< #%( %"*+'$!&",5(&'QH%=B$$=!"5'*%'+*% "<&+(,&'%&!&'(+%=!+G*%'#&%<<'($"&!!P( "(("(
'&'%&%<<%""(<%&!=** '$$="&*+'&%#=(*",(5&($'&%-$"&",*&%2'&%#'&'%"&(&%$*%E!%""((%'&%
/
	-M?/@$  "&% ! $ C+&!&' &##+%&, (%'"' ' %'((+5(%&,+ %$<!2%"&,=$&*$$"<%F2"+G&(5&'%&!&'-$*%+"(!$"&2$ $ !!&*& &( 2'  $< <&' #+( 5(+!!&*&%,*"$"(%5!!&*&=+'+%'"(%'$=$$&('&%2<&($"&2$-.S+&!&'&##+%&,'(%+"%%=$$"$<",*&%&%C+(&%$( "<&+(,5%$'+%=!+5+$+%=!+%((#+(44
D$$"""("%&(>+'2#%*#'%$( 5,$!!&*"%'**"'&%2,$<&'%*(+ "&%2$!!&*"P( "55*+('"#&%&%'(% "C+&"$(# '2" ! ( *&!&*&, ( $ <&'%*  (+ " *%<&*&%5,%'"(%5'+5$ >+", &% $&( *( =( " ", &%("+*' % $#%(!"&(H! $,(&*$"#%'$'!&%&&%!"&(H((&2%&!&*%( ('"# ((&5&&,D$&$<&'%* ! '&("'", *%'+* #&2$ % $< 5% <",("%2$"=((#<&'%*6*+(&*%%5(&'$$"=(*# 5(%*!!*(+ "$>+",P(<"'&*$$""(=((+ "'5, "55*+($&(+"($+'!!&"#
%4.-'?-$&"4...@('&(2"=&$$#>"&,B(<&=&%:"6!$ &%&%$$'&("&**+"""'&%2"%&%2!!&*"B(#&%!"C+&!&'&##+%&,%$&"(#%'#%*&#!&%'$&(#"'&!!&*+C+(&%5+5&<&&(#'+5,$( *&!&*!&%'&%2(!$"&*+"%'$>+",&%<%($ #>"&, $'( $ $ '&("&* *+" ""' &% &(*%*+(&%$=$%!!&*"*'&=(%*",(5&($'$$&"(#%'#% "$&5&'%!!&*"!"#!!*+&%2%$"=&(<&'""(&!$!!&*"=(#&<'&% "5,'(&""&2&%($""(P((("&%!&"(#%'#%"&2$($#>"&,"(%($5*+(&=(=(5&($'$%$*+"',$'*%(&+&% "&2$  *$%2 <"5, !!&*" P((+"<&%*$'&("&**+"""'&%2"%&%2!!&*"C+&!&'&##+%&,%$"&&%*&#%(+ "!$&( (&&%$#>"&,"&(%#
.)M-'-?-$&"/@
%#" <&*&#%'$"$+(5%' !&' A/ "&&% *&# 2&%( ($"&!! =$ $, 2' $' <&' $&" *%(&+&%"&2$( 5, &((+&%2  "(( "( '&(*+((&%2 $ (%(&&<
,Q GLVVHQW -XGJH (QJHO REVHUYHV WKDW WKH3HQQLQJWRQDQG-HQNLQVFDVHV ZKLFK ZH KDYH FLWHG DUH XQSXEOLVKHG RSLQLRQV WKDW ZHUH ILOHG WZR\HDUV DIWHU 2IILFHU &ROH DUUHVWHG 0U 0F&XUG\ +H DUJXHV WKDW LW LV XQIDLUWR XWLOL]H WKHVH RSLQLRQV WR DQDO\]H 2IILFHU &ROH¶V FXOSDELOLW\EHFDXVHVXFK DQ DQDO\VLV UHTXLUHV 2IILFHU &ROH WR KDYH DQWLFLSDWHG ZKDW WKH ODZ&%%&%( , % " &% "'&%", "55*+( +"$#%'#%%,(&(G@R
+M
	-.--?-@?$'&%2$ "55*+(&((((('!"#$ "( *&<!%5>*&<,"(%5 &*!!&*"@% ((((&%2 5>*&< "(%5%(( $=<" = #+(**+%!"$5&&,!!!&*"('"=&%!"%*(5('%$&" "!((&%E "&%*(M
	.." !!&*"  ""(' *+"', !" )&("'",%'+*+%'"$&<'4?6@?4@$(+"<&'($3 "(% =$& <+%"&, &%E&*' ($   IJ%22&%*%'+*"*"*%'&&%$ "(%("&(H! $,(&*$"#$!!%'""%$""$" ",!%$"A4?6@?4@$(+$"!""C+&"(5$$ %&%'&<&'+&( F<+%"&,&%E&*'G$$&%'&<&'+ F "(%IJ  "&(H ! $,(&* $"#G &$" $&#(! %$" " %$"B( " ",   $&( (*%'#%"C+&"((#!!&"#&<($=&%2!'%2"+(%((($(!*$%&%'&<&'+&(&%E&*''(%2&<"&(A4?6@?4@&%!"*&%
/../D8//-4LL4?$& < - /@ ?% " "' &% 4'@ ?*&&%2A 4?6@?4@B( 2&(&< $&(", (("&%2 $ $"<&(&%F&(&#' "&*+"*%'+*"$"$%$*%'&&%I!&%E&*&%JG@R
/(8./D8 -.  L ?$&   "  /@ ?%" "'&%4'@?$'&%2$A4?6@?4@"C+&"(F(#!!&"#&<*%'+*%$ "!$'!%'%%'I'(%J "$&5&#",5&%2&%E&*'&% +5&*G@/
ZRXOG EH LQ WKH IXWXUH , DJUHHWKDW LW LV JHQHUDOO\ QRW IDLU WR KROG DQLQGLYLGXDO WR D OHJDO VWDQGDUG WKDW HPHUJHVDIWHU WKHIDFW +RZHYHU2IILFHU &ROH¶V FXOSDELOLW\ GRHV QRW WXUQ RQ WKH3HQQLQJWRQDQG-HQNLQVGHFLVLRQV DV WKH GLVVHQW VXJJHVWV 2IILFHU &ROH¶V FXOSDELOLW\ LV EDVHG RQWKH SODLQ ODQJXDJH RI WKH VWDWXWH WKDW KH UHOLHG XSRQ WR DIIHFW WKH DUUHVW RI0U 0F&XUG\ $V QRWHG DERYH  % GRHV QRW SURKLELW3YROXQWDULO\ LQWR[LFDWLRQ ́ LQ DQG RI LWVHOI ,Q RUGHU WR YLRODWH WKLV VWDWXWHDQLQGLYLGXDO PXVW DOVR 3SUHVHQW>@ D ULVN RI SK\VLFDOKDUP ́HLWKHU WRKLPVHOI DQRWKHU RU DQRWKHU¶V SURSHUW\ 6HH  % 2IILFHU&ROH GLG QRW KDYH SUREDEOH FDXVH WR EHOLHYH WKDW 0U 0F&XUG\ SUHVHQWHG3D ULVN RI SK\VLFDO KDUP ́ $FFRUGLQJO\ 2IILFHU &ROH LV JXLOW\ RI YLRODWLQJ0U 0F&XUG\¶V )RXUWK $PHQGPHQW ULJKWV 7KLV ZRXOG EH WUXH HYHQ LI WKH3HQQLQJWRQDQG-HQNLQVFDVHV KDG QHYHU EHHQ GHFLGHG$ (+ !+"$" "<&'($$'"#&%&%(=$$"%&%'&<&'+&(&%E&*'&('"#&%'!"#$"( *&<!%F"'&%",5("<"GA4?)@$+2$ A 4 '( % "<&'  '!&%&&% !&%E&*&%+%'"A4?6@?4@$'&("&**+" "<&''$>+",=&$$!=&%2&%("+*&%3 "(%&(&%E&*'=$&((!"+%'"$&%!+%*!&%E&*&%2&C+"=&%"5"$$&( $,(&*%'#%!*+&("&# &"'(+*$%E%$$!&(  +( $ '2" ! *" %' %&% &% $&(*%'+*=$&*$"(%5 "(%=+'$"=&(+(4*+"', "2+( $ $" =( &%(+!!&*&% <&'%* (+ "!&%'&%2$$=(&%E&*'" "(%'F"&(H! $,(&*$"#I$&#(!J%$""$ " ",!%$"G("C+&"'+%'"A4?6@?4@D&$"2"'$<+%",&%E&*&%#%!!&*"(&!&'$$ (#' *$ % *+"',B( 5"$ '+"&%2 $&(*%<"(&%=&$$&# %'$$5&<'*+"', =(&%E&*' ($<=$"$*+'H*"!$&#(!MR"/./''&&%,!!&*"(H'*+"',=$$"$$'5%'"&%H&%2$%&2$%'*+"',"( %''&%$!!&"#&<$+2$!!&*"
4$ =( ""(' +%'" &H 
 (92'( 11A4?6@?4@?$(+&((+&%$&(*(@"C+&"'F(# !!&"#&< *%'+*G % $ " ! $ '!%'%5,%'#",5&%2&%E&*'&% +5&*/(/D8-.L-$*+"( *&!&*,$'$F$!!&*"$'"55*+(""(%'("*$ %!"'&("'",*%'+*=$" % "H'$&(*"5("+*"!!&*!=&%*"",+(" %*"' "&(H!$"#$&#(! %' $"( ( = (  %, *" =$&*$ #, $<%"'$'"&<=,GL$+(%H&%(B*%<&*&%=(!!&"#'&%$*(&%<%(%
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

 $" =( &%(+!!&*&%<&'%*!'&("'",*%'+*5,&%E&*&%(*$"2'&%$*# &%=!&%'$ %B(""(=(%%$((=!+G4.
4$#>"&,(+'&+(,<&'(*%(&'"&%!*+"',P(5+(&< %2+2 &% $&" *%(&'"&% ! "55 *+(+%'"$(+;(%'&%
#M/4'/M?$& /@'!%'%P(+(! "!%&,#,5*%(&'"' !" +" ((!'"#&%&%2'&("'",*%'+*+%'"$(+#M/4'//
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
%/( $ '!%'% =(!+%' (('+%'(+# '<"$("&%2=$!*"=$&*$=( (%%'=(""(' !"'&("'",*%'+*+%'"M..?5@?4@$*+"5("<'$$(+
'&'% '#&%&(" %,H&%'! (5"&," *$"%*(($&((&#%,$$(#'F*$"("%2%$&#G-*+ '=&$*+"',B('#&((&%$$*%(+#' *$5$'+"&%2$&(% $=B( ", %'$*"'2#$&( "#% "<&''$&#=&$ "55*+(5&<$*+"',=(F<+%"&,&%E&*'G+%'"A4?6@?4@=<" $ >+",B( !&%'&%2 +%'" $ (*%' "%2 !A4?6@?4@ "(%(#+*$'&!!"%C+(&%%' = !&%' $ % "(%5 >+", *+' *%*+' $!!&*"  $' "55 *+(  5&< $*+"',"(%'"&(H! $,(&*$"#&$"$&#(!$"("$ " ",!$"(%$&(&((+!!&*"(&!&'$3IDJ$%  "(% &( &%E&*'  $ <  #,"&%&%2 %' E "&%* +%'" = $, ((%&,5*##,"( %(&5&&,%*
5*#&%*%*=&$$# 
! 
$ "(%2 
*%%,+=$B(2&%2  $ %  $#  
 *% %, +%!"+%,
 =$ *+' $ %  $#  $B( =$, &5*#(#, "( %(&5&&,#H (+"$'(%$ %$#  MM4R  "  /./ ?# $(&( '''@"<" !!&*"  (' $ FI5J, E$&5&&%2 $&(&%E&*'%+"IJ%%$ &%$I*+"',J=(%$"''#2$" ",!%$" "(%$&<'&%$"$B(=$,$=(""('G/?# $(&('''@!!&*"''&&%, (("' $ !" $  "*$' *+"',*+"',B(((*&(*#5&<,*$%2'$&(+$"&,6,!!&*"B(=%(&#%,$'&'%$< "55*+(""(*+"',+%'"A4?6@?4@%'$ '&("&* *+" $"!" ""' &% '%,&%2 *+"',B(#&%!">+'2#%(#"!=7%"+(,2"%&%2!!&*"$5%!&!&%!"%*(%''+5(!!&*".
  5( "(+#' $*+"', "(%'  "&(H !$"# &$"$&#(!%$""$ " ",!%$"(,5*+($ "'5&%E&*'=<"(%'5<$%2+2!$(+*", "<&'($&%E&*&% %'(%2&< "&( A4?6@?4@<&&%   / D8 //-4  LL4R/( / D8 -.  L  
% $&( "2"' %&$"!!&*"  %" $ +%, $( *&' %, 5>*&< %'"&*+5!*(!"#=$&*$!!&*"*+'"(%5,&%!"$*+"', "(%'"&(H! $,(&*$"#+%'"A4?6@?4@%''!!&*"(&!&'((%&,$$"="%5>*&< !*("&22" "55 *+( ($ *+'%,F( *+G%$F%!#&&%$&%2(G$#&2$**+"&!$'&'%""(*+"',"<"!!&*"('&%,$$""('*+"',5*+(F$"=(%=,$I$J*+'$I*+"',J=(%$"''#2$ " ",!%$" "(%$&<'&%$"G  /D$% %!!&*"&",$(%&'=$$" "(+# &<,=5&'&%2*&&1%$(<&'$= $ +"$ #%'#% *", *##%'( $2<"%#%$&%'&<&'+5
%''&!%,$&%2&(*"5+ $ +"$ #%'#% & &( $&(3 2<"%#% #,' "&<&(*&&1%(!&5",=$%%'%,=$%&$(<&5*&#$%&%'&<&'+$(*##&'*"&#%'$ *&# &( (+ "' # &"&*, 5, *%*" %'&'%&!&5!*(
(M./
	---?@R+
.4...D8--M/L4?-$&",44...@!!&*"'&'%(&(!,$(!+%'#%&# "&<(%'**"'&%2,="<"($'&("&**+"B('%&!*+"',B(#&%!">+'2#%%=&$(%'&%2$<"'&*(&"(!!&*"&%$&(&%'&<&'+* *&,6*+($'&("&**+"'&'%''"((( *&!&*,=$$"+%,*+(#" &*,2<"&(&$"+%,&5&&,
1%2(  
   
 - 
	  -M -/.?/@R#     #  
#% M4. 
	  ../ ?@ " &5&&, 2&%(
$,'&' " ","!*$&=$,'&'%'($&#!$<%$"
!$!!&*"B(*+ 5&&,&(5('+ %$&(+%'"(%'&%2!$&=$&#!$!!%(&&(,+%!&"*%*+'$$+2$"(%5,$<%&*& '$&(=+'5$==$&*$$($+'$%$<5,'=,"(5!"&(&((+%*%'=$&*$($+'$<"# '$&#%*($'&'$#>"&,#&2$5"$<H' +5&($'$&*(( !"2+&'%*%&%" "&%!$$&'&("'",*%'+* =$& &%E&*' (+  
% 
 ( M-4'?$& .@<""+'%$"2"+%'(
/(M/4'/4?$& @$*+"$' $ $ '!%'%P( * ! (&&%2 *5, &% $((%2"(!*"$=( "H'&%'"&<=,&%%&%E&*'('&'%*"$H&%'!"&(H! $,(&*$"#$&#(!$=(&%%''5%*# (('5,4?6@?4@$*+"">*'$(P("2+#%$$'!%'%P("!+(2+!$*" "(%'"&(H!$"#5*+($#&2$$<5%&%>+"'=$%$ &*((&('$&#+!$*"$*+"'"#&%'$$&(%&", ((&< *%'+* =( % $ H&%' ! !"(5*%(C+%*%<&(&%'5,$(+(M-4'M.%'" +5&($'$&=$!"(5&&,!$"&(H!$"# "C+&"( $ E"*&( ! "!((&% >+'2#%  
%'

 
 * M 4' 4 ?$&   /@ $'!%'% &* !!&*" =( (+' !" !&&%2  ""( %&%E&*' "(%+%'"$(+$*+"5("<'$T$ '+,  ""(  "(% !" '&("'", *%'+* =$&&%E&*'&(%*(("&,'&(*"&%",T44?6@?4@"C+&"($ &*!!&*"(((($ *%'&&%!$&%E&*' "(% %''"#&%=$$"$&(*%'&&% (("&(H!$"#$&#(!"$"(  $&( ((((#% "C+&"( % E"*&( !"!((&% >+'2#% $ &( ((%&  $ " "&# #%&%!$(+/
$&#!',&%%&%E&*'*%'&&%!"$<&%25%'"&%H&%2#(!$%&2$#&2$'=$$"$#&2$2&%!&2$=&$$&"' ",=$$"$#&2$(22"&%$("&%!"%!"+*H=$$"$#&2$!!!5"&'2"(!!&*"(&'F%,%!#&&%$&%2(G$ #>"&, &% $&( *( &( "C+&"&%2  $&2$ '2" !( *&!&*&, !"# $ !!&*"  (+ " $&( *%*+(&% $*+"', "(%'  "&(H ! $"#  ", 5*+( $!!&*"*+'% "'&*=$&*$!$#&&%$&%2(*+"',#&2$''(%"%'"$""(=&$+ "55*+(D$&*%<&*&%+%'"$$&'&("'",*%'+*=$&&%E&*' (+ *", "C+&"( (#$&%2 #" $%&%E&*&%%$<&'%*"C+&"'+%'"$&*(=%'%5(( *&!&*($#>"&,*%%'(%$&(""( *
# "&*+",*%*"%'5+$*+"B("&%*+ %
//../D8//-4?$& <-/@%'
/(  8. / D8 -. ?$&  "*$/@$#>"&,B("&%*%$(=*((&( ("&+(, !='  6$ %'/( ="+5&($'=,"($&%*&'%&%C+(&%%'=+'%5 " "+$"&,!">+'2&%2!!&*"B(C+&!&'&##+%&,&%%,<%	*%'%'/(="'*&(&%(!%&%"#'&*+"! (!8+*(+%,?/(@%'	"H+%, ?@=$%&% !*$&(*("(&%#&%+%,! <% #" ("&+( *%*"% *$ ! $ *&' *((*%&% "#&%%%&*$+4!$$&	+ "#+" +( !" $  "&%2 !  &%&%( &# (("("&*&%( %' &#&&%( % $ +( ! +% +5&($' &%&%(+4?7@?4@ "<&'($+% +5&($' &%&%("%*%"&%2<%&%$>+'&*&'&("&*&%=$&*$$ &%&%=("%'"'$&(&# *(+ %+"'*&(&%$"&%(="( *(&"(%&$"%"/(&(** 5+$"&,!"$ (+"!$&B(&%" "&%!$*&%C+(&%5,$<","#(!+4	*%'&!
$GGLWLRQDOO\0F&XUG\ FODLPV WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW HUUHG LQ QRWSURYLGLQJ WKH MXU\ ZLWK DVSHFLILFLQVWUXFWLRQ RQ WKH PHDQLQJ RI 3ULVN ́XQGHU 25&  % QRU SURYLGLQJ WKH MXU\ ZLWK WKH VSHFLILFGHILQLWLRQ RI 3ULVN ́ SURYLGHG E\ 0F&XUG\ )LUVW LW DSSHDUV WKDW 0F&XUG\GLG QRW REMHFW RQ WKLV EDVLV DW WULDOVHH-$ DW  0F&XUG\¶V 5HS %UDW  DQG WKDW WKHUHIRUH ZH PD\ RQO\ UHYLHZ WKLV FODLP IRU 3SODLQ HUURU ́6HH ((2& Y (0&&RUS RI0DVV 1R   :/  DW WK &LU )HE   XQSXEOLVKHG RSLQLRQ ,Q DQ\ HYHQW WULDOFRXUWV KDYH EURDG GLVFUHWLRQ LQ IRUPXODWLQJ MXU\ LQVWUXFWLRQV6HH .LQJ Y)RUG 0RWRU &R 1R   :/  DW 
 WK &LU $SU  %HFDXVH 0F&XUG\ KDV QRW PDGH D VKRZLQJ WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW¶VLQVWUXFWLRQV ZHUH HLWKHU PLVOHDGLQJ SUHMXGLFLDO RU XQGXO\ FRQIXVLQJ ZHPXVW UHMHFW WKLV FODLP!!&*"  &% $&( !!&*& * *&,   
)  MM.-M MD8 4/.  L ?-$ &")*M@?+% +5&($' &%&%@="#%'!"!+"$""*'&%2(*+"', ( *%%'( $ $ '&("&* *+" ""' &%2"%&%2!!&*"B(#&%!"C+&!&'&##+%&,%$&(&"(#%'#%"&&%*&#D"<&=$'&("&**+"B(2"%!C+&!&'&##+%&,
*4.M '  .  S+&!&'&##+%&, ($&'( 2<"%#%!!&*&( "!"#&%2'&(*"&%",!+%*&%(!"#&5&&,!"*&<& '#2( =$%$&" *%'+* '( % <& *",(5&($' (+", " *%(&+&% "&2$( ! =$&*$ "(%5 "(% ($+' $< H%=%  % 
"-M
	/..//?/4@D ,=(%,(&('"#&%=$$" +5&*!!&*&&(%&'C+&!&' &##+%&,3 !&"( = '"#&% =$$"  *",(5&($'*%(&+&%"(+","&2$$(5%<&'R%'(*%'=(*"&% +"(+%%5>*&<(%'"'=$$"$!!&*&*'+%"(%5,&%&2$!$*",(5&($'"&2$#
.)M-'--/?-$&"/@4
$'&("&**+"*%*+''$=$%!!&*"*'& =( % *", (5&($' $ $ &"( #%'#%"$&5&' % !!&*" !"# !!*+&%2 % $"=&( <&'""(&!$!!&*" =(#&<'5, '(&" "&2&%($""(B((("&%!&"(#%'#% "&2$(D$<$'$'<"((*&%F#&<'(&%" (  "( %(  $ E"*&( ! $ &%&!!B(*%(&+&% "&2$(G "(%( % *&%5 *&# !"&&%#M-'-/?*&&%2 #$
4
	4?@@&%*$',$&%H'"&'%$6&!&2$(FIJ$"&2$! % #"&*% *&&1%  *"&&*&1 +5&* !!&*&( %'&*&(&(Q$*%"#%&%2!$&"(#%'#%BG*
&
M/ 4'/. ?-$&"M@?C+&%21%2(!

-
	4M4 ?-@@  $" *% 5 % '+5 $ $ !"'# E "(( '&(2"#% =&$ ( *&% =&$+ !" !" "&(5('%$E "((&%&(+%C+&<*,#%2$"*&%( "<&''5,$&"(#%'#%R#M-'-/4R#
 .'4-4-?-$&"@?FIJ$&"(#%'#%"&2$*"&&*&1+5&*!!&*&(&(=(5&($'%'(+ "'5,# *(=+"$"#"&&(=(5&($'$  +5&*!!&*&B("&&%2&%(%&%'&<&'+E"*&(&%2$&("$"&"(#%'#%"&2$(&(<&&%!A/G@R
   . 4' 4 / ?$ &" .@?FI7J<"%#%!!&*&(&%2%" %' &*!!&*"(&%"&*+" #, % E"*&( $&" +$"&, !" "(%#&<( "&*+",&%"( %("" "*&<'(&2$($&"'&2%&,	+",%,%=$H(%$!!!&*H%=(U"($+'H%=U$#+*$G@ &( =(5&($' $% $ *+"', $' *%(&+&% "&2$  *$%2 <"5, !!&*" B((+"<&%* %' = $"!" "<"( $ '&("&* *+"B(2"%!C+&!&'&##+%&, !!&*"6*+($'&("&**+"'&'%''"((=$$"*+"',B(""(=(( "&,#&<'5, "*'*%'+*="#%'!"!+"$" "*'&%2(
78 &"*+& +'2 '&((%&%2  
 "( *!+, 5+("%2,'&((%,'&((%&(5('+ %(<" "#&((=$&*$
$&%H"!='&%$#>"&,B("&%&"( 
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
!!&*"  % *+"',B( &"( #%'#% "&&%*&#(&=(*",(5&($'$&#!!&*"*'$$*+'%"&2&%(*+"',!"(("&%2$&( &"( #%'#% "&2$( D&$ $( "+&%2( =	$'&("&* *+" !" !+"$" "*'&%2(%*+"',B(+"$#%'#%*&%($+%,%'$&(&"(#%'#%"&&%*&#
*+"',!&%,(("($$+%,&# " ",+('"# ",*$%2E*+'5*H>+""&%<&&%!$C+:"*&%+(*+"',( *&!&*,5>*($+%,B(+(! "# ",("&H!"&*%#"&*%,<& D&&#( !"# $ >+",  
% "( %( $ +%,*%%'($D&&#(B'#%"'+"&%2<&"'&"(+22('$($=('&(&%"('&%("<&%2(>+""
%$'&("&**+"$+%,B("%,('3I
J% #, <&= &% =*$&%2 ID&&#(J $" =( %"( %(%,!$C+(&%(%%''&%2!$$'>+(H&$($=(%B&%"('&%$*(%'$'$"*"(('!!!"#$52&%%&%2+'2(!"(%5&%2"( %(&<%'$B(#,"(%!"E"*&(&%2$ "# ",*$%2.D&$+C+(&%&%2D&&#("%22&%2&%*C+,=&$&$"*+"',B("$+%,B(*+%($'&("&**+"<""+'*+"',B(#5>*&% .  
%*+"',B( %= "& #&% $ "&"' $&(*$%2$ "# ",$'&("&**+"">*'$&("%=' *$%2 *%*+'&%2 $ ( D&&#( =(F ((&<G&%$!*!$ "&(BC+(&%&%2%'$$+%,$"!"$'"&*+'"*%+">+(&!&*&%!"&(E"*&(!$ "# ", '&("&* *+"B( "+&%2 % =$$" $ E"*&( ! "# ",*$%2<&(C+ "*&%&(%&'F2"'!"%*G%'=#,%'&(+"5&(>+'2#%+%((&&(*",""%+(+
#/M4...D8.4ML?-$&",444...@
&(('$$%(&+&%B(2+"%!C+ "*&%%(+"($ ",#,%E"*&( "# ",*$%2"#<%&%'&<&'+%**+%!$ "(%B("*# 
 '( - 
	  ?/-@R$ 
&
 M..
	--. ?@?E%'&%2#"+*&<&"&(@(5&($C+
"*&% <&&% +%'"# $ *&#% #+( !&"((5&($   *( ! "*& '&(*"&#&%&% +
.'-4?-$&"@! $ *&#% (5&($(   *( $ ",E"*&(&%2 $ "# ", #+( "!!"  "*%+"E %&%$&(%%"*&E %&%F%'%5"&*+", "(+(&< " <% +(&5 ( %2 ( & &(%+"G+
 4'M/.M/-?-$&"@  !" $ '!%'&%2 ", !!"( &( "*%+">+(&!&*&%$*$%2&%2 ",#+('#%("$$+" "' E %&% &( #",  "E !"  "*&#&<&%(=&$'&(*"&#&%&%*&#(2%",$++"'%! "(+(&%=,("((=&$$ ",*$%2&%2$ "# ",(
$M
	-M-/?M@D$&5',%2+2%''#%"" "#&((&5"*%+">+(&!&*&%( !"$ E"*&( !  "# ",+
'//.?$&"@?FI:J((&<&,&%%&<%(("&%5&&, "$">+""( I"J <&' "*%+" E %&%( !" E*+'&%2>+""(G@ '&("&* *+"( %<"$(( #+( FE &*&,'>+'&*IJ$*"'&5&&,!$%%#<&%2"*$%2&%2",B("*%+"E %&%(G/
&"
4.-'-4..?4'&"4...@R+
-M'-4--?(&"@?$'&%2$$"&*+"#+((((($*"'&5&&,!$"*%+"E %&%@$%' !" % E &*& %$"*"' %,(&( ! *$ !$#%(!#*$%2&(( *&,&# "%=$%$ +" "' "*%+" >+(&!&*&% &( "'&*' %(+5>*&<E %&%(&H5',%2+2"'#%"+
&-M-MD8-M-L4?-$&"*44@?+% +5&($' &%&%@?%&%2$*"'&&%2(+5>*&<E %&%(!" "# ",("&H(*+'= % &# " ", #&<' "%,  F*&"*+#<%G#@  6*+( $ "&#", '!%(  "E 5('<&&%(!#&($'&("&**+"B(5&&,(((($*"'&5&&,!%"%,B(" "(%&%(&&(*"&&*$$ '&("&* *+" &%' %'%, (((( $ "!!"'
M7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW LWVHOI DSSHDUV WR KDYH UHFRJQL]HGWKDW LWVLQLWLDOGLVSRVLWLRQ RI 0F&XUG\¶V%DWVRQFKDOOHQJH ZDV LQVXIILFLHQW ,QDGGUHVVLQJ 0F&XUG\¶V SRVWYHUGLFW QHZ WULDO PRWLRQ WKH FRXUW H[SODLQHGWKDW LW GLG QRW PRUH SURELQJO\ DVVHVV WKH &RXQW\¶V UDFHQHXWUDOMXVWLILFDWLRQ EHFDXVH 3QR RQH VXJJHVWHG >LW@ DW WKH WLPH DQG LW ZRXOG KDYHEHHQ DQ LPSURSHU LQWUXVLRQ RQ >'HIHQGDQW¶V FRXQVHO¶V@ MXGJPHQW ́ -$DW >+(&!&*&%( -
1%2(M..
	M4-M?@"5*+($'&("&**+"'&'%#",*"'&$E %&%!$+%,5+&(!!+%'$D&&#(=(((&<%''&(&%"('=*%*+'$*+"',$(%'#%("'$$'&("&**+"*",""'&%'&(#&((&%2$&(#*$%2<"$((=+%'"(*"$$'&("&**+"B(&%&&"*&%*+"',B(#*&#&%=$&*$ & "!+%*"&, ** ' $ +%,B( "*%+"E %&%   . '&' % *%!"#  $"C+&"#%$$'&("&**+"#HE "(('!&%'&%2(%*$!$#%(!#*&#/4.-'4..
=(%+%&*+"',B( (<"'&*#&%!"%= "& $ $ '&("&* *+" #' &( =% !&%'&%2("&%&%2D&&#(B'#%"%'$"5,*# &'=&$$ "C+&"#%( !#  7&<% $ = 2"% F2"'!"%*G  $ '&("&* *+"B(# !&%'&%2(# 4. '  M. %' $ $ *+" +&#,%22'&%$*%(&+&%,"C+&"'%,(&(=!!&"#$'&("&**+"B('%&!*+"',B(#**+(%"&%>+",*+'!&%'$!!&*"$'"55 *+(  ""( *+"', +%'" A4?6@?4@=$'&("&**+"B('%&!*+"',B(#&%!">+'2#%%=&$(%'&%2$<"'&*%'%">+'2#%!"*+"',%$&(+"$#%'#%*&%(!!&*"&%$&(&%'&<&'+* *&,D($'&("&**+"B(2"%!C+&!&'&##+%&,