01/25/2011 15;31 FAX 2024935142 FAA + DMS @1001/01G 

r-RARTK^ENTOF 

Michael Selig. MD, FACC, CFi-H--MSf^lATl^ 

2816 Orefield Road ^ '^•- '• uPtRAllONb 

Allentown, PA. 18104 ^ ^^ 

m J'N ?S P 3^ ^ 

• ^ RECEIVED 

DEC 2 ? 2011 

HEARING D "OKET 

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

WASHINGTON, D.C. 

Federal Aviation Administration 

Laura Ponto, Cynthia Dorninik, 

Latonya Williams 

Complainants 

M & R Helicopters, LLC. 

Respondent 

Honorable Judge Ronnie Yoder 

Docket: 2010-1211 

RESPONDENT'S REPLY BY WAY OF OBJECTION TO COMPLAINANTS MOTION FOR 

PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE IMPOSITIONS 

AND NOW, comes respondent, MICHAEL B. SELIG, MD, FACC , 

principle for MR Helicopters, LLC, (MRH) whom avers and files the following Reply 

in demurrer OBJECTION to Complainants Request for an Order to Impose a 

Procedural Schedule for Filing Disposition Motions and Discovery on the basis 

that respondents pleadings have been reasonable and proper and in 

accordance and in reply to flawed fundamental premise for the violation and 

henceforth breaches by complainants failure to respond, filing of late replies or 

inadequate methods of late onswers that are cobbled together with colorable 

arguments that are impermissibly vague and inaccurate, thereby are attempts 
r t i + DMS @1002/01G 

01/25/2011 15:31 FAX 2024935U2 Fhft 

of prosecutorial overreaching, and thereby the complaint should be stricken 

and dismissed. 

1. On July 21, 2009, FAA Officers, Latonya Williams and Kimmy Poon 

appeared for an initial inspection of MR Helicopters, LLC. 

2. The alleged violation for Mr Baker according to Ms Williams Inspector 

Statement lOP 9 record, was due to "inability to find FAA approved drug and 

alcohol testing program information for Flight Methods". Mr Baker was no: 

employed by Flight Methods, but by Air Methods Corporation, therefore Ms 

Williams erred in this fundamental fact driving the violation. 

3. Ms Williams failed to perform with due diligence and in good faith an 

investigation confirming that Mr Baker was not on a drug and alcohol program, 

the sole premise for driving the violation. Counsel is bound by judicial estoppels 

for any other claims. 

4. On October 21, 2010, MRH was served with a Final Notice of Proposed 

Civil Penalty, citing a potential fine of $5400 (Fifty Four Hundred Dollars) since 

modified to $4400. This occurred over 1 year later, post the statue of limitations 

and therefore time barred. 

5. Once realizing and forced to cobble together color of law orguments 

for a better offense, that Mr Baker was always engaged in an FAA proved drug 

and alcohol testing program, complainants attempted to re-craft their offense 

by asserting that the testing program for a pilot is somehow different from that of 

a mechanic, when they both fall under safety sensitive functions to which there 
+ DMS 1003/01 6 

01/25/2011 15:31 FAX 2024935142 FAA 

is no different testing parameters. 

6. Once realizing and cobbling that Mr Baker was always engaged in 

an FAA approved drug and alcohol testing program, complainants attempted 

to re-craft their offense by asserting that Air Methods did not authorize Mr Baker 

to perform maintenance under their repair station certificate, knowing that Mr 

Baker under regulation is permitted to perform his safety sensitive functions 

under his own A/P cerlificaticn. 

7. Contrary to Judicial Estoppels, complainants attempted to redirect 

their offense concerning the new definition of "employer" appendices I and j , 

clauses hidden, not evident in the operation specifications by asserting that Mr 

Baker was not on MRH's own program, even ttiough on another compariies 

program and the complainants already released and withdrew all such 

violations against the other AP/IA, thereby showing prima facie legal 

inconsistency. 

8- Complainants became procedurally defective by failing to respond 

or filed late answers to 8 of respondents pleadings in breach of the FAA Rules of 

Civil Penalty Proceedings 14 C.F.R. §13.16 and subpart G, § Rules 13.218(d) ond § 

13.22G(d). The Office of Chief Counsel employs many attorneys, handles 

thousands of violations yearly and therefore alternatives are readily available to 

cover or substitute for vocation, illness or other reasons. This case does not have 

exclusive authority of only Ms Ponto, as there have already been other 

intervening attorneys that have reviewed or been involved in the case. 
. DMS @1004/01G 

01/25/201 1 15:3 2 FAX 2024935142 FftA 

including Peter Lynch, Esq., (letter October 21, 2010, (exhibit 1), Charles Raley, 

Esq. (October 1, 2010 telephone hearing, transcripts outstanding), Ms Cynthia 

Dorninik, Esq. [Telephone call Decembers, 2010), therefore, there is no excuse 

or reason for absent or late filing of objections or an.-jwers under any premise for 

all the obove 8 documents. 

9. When complainants finally came about to filing incomplete and lote 

answers thot bore insufficient specificity to respondents succincr numoerea 

pleadings, their answers were procedurally defective to the standard practices 

of directly answering enumerated paragraphs, breaching Rule §206.2 and 

thereby complainants avoided and failed to address items, thus accepting 

stated items of respondent as confirmed statements of material fact. 

An example of this is failure to respond to how the FAAs own 

Drug/Alcohol abatement officer Vincent Roots during his in camera audit of 

MRH in April 2004, failed to inform MRH or was informed himself, of the FAA 

changed definition of the word "employer" that occurred in February 2004, 

affecting appendices I and J. 

Complainants failed to respond to the fact that MRHs regular operations 

and maintenance inspectors, Frank Alotta and Gerry Henininger, the Allentown 

FSDO, which is across the street from where the aircraft has been inspected and 

hangared for 10 years, were also unaware of the regulation change, thereby 

holding MRH to a higher standard than their own FAA officers. 

10. Complainants having of best legal insufficiency, a case void ab 

4-
-> DMS @|005/016 

01/25/201 1 15:3 2 FAX 2024935142 FAA 

initio, making condusionary statements, compressing many questions, 

attempting to impair the dignity of the court, by wittingly and willfully making 

incredible allegations, not looking at the perspective in whole in regard to 

human aspects, namely the current state of the respondent under attack, who 

decided in good judgment, that because of his current 5 year (2006 to present) 

tragic divorce litigation, including financial devastation, complete alienation of 

his 3 children, emolional upheaval, having to defend againsT frauauieni 

medical disabilities of wife, litigation to regain property (Exhibit 1), the 

respondent believed in the best interests of the operation, to temporarily back 

off from performing services during the exact period violations are being sought. 

The respondent concurrently has a solo, private cardiology and internal 

medicine practice of 22 years, serving the community and assists pilots with 

medical certificates. These actions taken against the respondent mounts to 

"beating a man who is already down", behaviors that are unconscionable at 

any level. 

11. The complainants incredibly state that the respondent is filing 

unnecessary or redundant pleadings, when it is the complainants who have 

legal insufficiency and inconsistency, failed to file answers, filed answers past 

deadlines, failed to file answers coherently to specific numbered allegations, 

trying to hold MRH to a higher stondard than their own officers. 

12. The respondents filings are therefore, appropriate to the either nonresponse or to the false fundamental fact basis and assumption that Mr Baker 

5-
r,* •» QMS liOOG/OIG 

01/25/2011 15:32 FAX 2024935142 FAA 

was not on a drug/alcohol program that initiated and driving the violations and 

the moving target of shifting material facts and arguments presented by 

complainant to toll the insufficient violation fo fruition in a Internecine manner, to 

which no restrictions should be placed for respondent to proceed in equity. 

13. If is respondent's averment that the complainants are malfeasant, in 

abuse of discretion and process, in breach of duty and conduct and in 

attempting to obstruct justice for respondeni TO pursue This vioioiion. 

14. In all and best efforts for judicial economy, the case therefore should 

be dismissed to allow the administrations efforts be properly directed to other 

areas or high volume, large operation violation cases most pertinent to the 

public safety of our country. 

WHEREFORE, the respondent prays that this Honorable Court will not limit Ihe 

means for the respondent to defend himself or dismiss the case. 

Respectfully Submitted, 

\ ^ •- \ 

Michael B. Sellg, MD, FACC, CFI-H \ ^"' • -\ t 

Date . 

6-
01/25/2011 15:32 FAX 2024935142 FAA + DMS [g|007/016 

Page 1 of9 

l.oHCr.il f^'iV /'.i:/.'.uii^; ;-<e-i;m:li A;;:ni, New : I'l'd . l<.-'i.'!V- ,;.;,:i't 1 ''1. : 1 

REGISTER OF ACTIONS 

• i;r..':,iui, nj.'ik-i.'n Krii'orcl;.; IDiinift!;- l-ielo 

Gail FrancdE Roeehman Forinerly Known As Gail R Selig V$ Michael§ 

B Sellg ^ 

§ 

§ 

Case Type: Divorce 

Sublype: Divorce 

Date Filed: 10/10/2006 

Location: Civil Records 

PAHTY 1NFOH>IAT10N' 

Defendant Selig, Micriael B 

2616 Orefield Rd 

OrefiOld, P A 16104 

Lead Attorneys 

Joseph C Bernstein, Esq 

R&tmncd 

610-770-1-iOO(W) 

Plaintiff RosEhman. Gail Frances 

Formerlv Known Ax .Sclig, Gail R 

325 ^^ 20th St 

Allentown, PA 18104 

Anthony M Muir, Esq 

Retain&a 

610-4,34-7138(W) 

F.V|::NT?AORl3liRS Oi riVRCWKt 

12/20/2006 

03/06/2007 

05/08/2007 

05/10/2007 

05/22/2007 

05/22/2007 

01/30/2008 

Ce/11/2008 

07/31/2008 

09/03/2009 

10/20/2003 

12/22/2008 

01/21/2009 

06/03/2009 

06/03/2009 

lIE\niN(".S 

Petition for Special Relief/Divorce (9:30 AM) (Jiidicial Officer Johnsion, J. Briari) 

PLAINTIFF ANO DEFENDANTS PETITION 

Result: Final Order Emered 

NIediatlon (12;30 PM) (.Judicial Officer Klein, Don S, Esci) 

R<39ull. Wiedlation Held With Agieement 

Petition for Emergency Relief/Divorce (9:30 Af/) (Judicial Officer JoniiBDn, j , Brian) 

REMOVAL OF B££ HIVES FROM PROPERTY 

Result: Hearing Completed 

Custody Cotiterenee (lO.OO AM) (Judicial Officer VanGildcr, Donald L) 

Result: Conference Held - interim Order 

Custody Contempt (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Johnson. J. Brian) 

03^?S/2007 Continued to 05/09/2007 - Conf/oued t>y JudQS - Setig. Michsci B 

05/09/2007 Reset by Court to 05/22/2007 

Result: Hearing Completed 

Contennpt (9;00 At^d) (Judicial Officer Johnson, J. Brian) 

PLAINTIFF AND DEr-ENDANTS PETITION FOR CON TEMPT. 

Result: Matter lo be Settled/Withdiawn - Family 

Exceptions to Maewr's Report (9:i0 AM) (Judicial Officer Vairicchio, Micheic A) 

Resuli: Hearing Completed 

Petition tor Special Relief/Divorce (9:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Johnson, J. Brian) 

Result. Hearing Completed 

CANCELED Custody Conference (7,C0 PM) (Judicial Officar -lohnsoii J Brisni 

J7/23'200 S Continued to 07/2S/2008 - ConmuiiO 0 / Juage - Roe&hman, Gail Fro/ices 

07/25a00B ReS6t by Court m 07/31/2008 

CmCELED Custody Trial (9:30 AM) (Jiidiciai Officer Joimson, J. Brian) 

Cejc Stayed 

07/23/200% Continued to 07/25/2008 - Oontmued by JuOga - Roeshman. Gail Prance!: 

07/'^.b72008 Reset by Court lo 0$/03/200B 

Patition (or Emergency Relief/Custody (9:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Johnson, J. Brian) 

Result: Hearing Completed 

Custody Confereneo (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Johnson, J. Brian) 

Result: Custody Conference Held - Mailer to Proceed lo Trial 

Exceptions to Master's Ropon (9:30 AlVl) (Judicial Ofticer Johnson, J. Brian) 

Resull: Hearing Completed 

Custody Trial |i :30 PM) (Judidial Officer Johnson, J. Brian) 

12/22/2008 Reset by Court to 02/05/2009 

0?/0'J/2009 Reset by Court to 03/11/2009 

03/11/2009 Reset by Court to 06/03/2009 

Result: Trial Completed Dy Judge 

Custody Comompt (1:30 PM!) (Judicial Officer Johnson. J. Brian) 

TO BE COMPLETED (^^k^ \ 

hltp.V/publicacce.ss.lehiahcounlv.ortr/Ca.'^el )cMil fli:nv'>f ^•i^-^'i H^ADAQO-) 
01/25/2011 15:32 FAX 2024935142 FAA •> DMS gl008/01 G 

Page 2 of9 

07/22/2009 

07/22/200$ 

04/05/2010 

04/05/2010 

04/14/2010 

04/14/2010 

05/10/2010 

09/14/2010 

09/14/2010 

11/15/2010 

10/10/2006 

10/10/2006 

10/24/2006 

11/IS/2006 

11/30/2006 

12/05/2006 

12/08/2006 

'.2 Zz-2ZZz 

12/11/2006 

i:?/11/2006 

12/15/2006 

12/19/2006 

01/02/2007 

01/11/2007 

01/16/2007 

01/19/2007 

01/19/2007 

12/22/2008 Poaet by Court to 02/05/2009 

02/05/2009 Reset by Coun to 03/11/2009 

03/11/2009 R9S6t by Court to 06/03/2009 

Resull: Hearing Completed 

Hearing (9:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Jotinson, J, Brian) 

DEFENDANTS PETITION FOR REVIEW. 

Result. Matter to be Sellledrt/Vjlhdrgwn - Family 

n/iotion for Sanctions (9:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Johnson. J. Brian) 

Result; Hearing Completed 

Hearing (9:0O AM) (Judicial OfficerRolierts, John E, III) 

Hearing (100 HM) (Judicial OfficGf Roberts, John H, III) 

Petition for Special Relief/Divorce (9:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Johnson, J. Bnan) 

04/16/2010 Reset by Co m to 04/14/2010 

Result Hearing Completed 

Petition for Special Relief/Divorce (9:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Jol^nson, J. Brian) 

TRANSFER OWNERSHIP 

Result: Hearing Completed 

Hearing (1;00 PM) (Judicial Officer Roberts, John E, III) 

Petition for Bifurcation (10:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Johnson, J. Brian) 

07/09/2010 Reset by Coun [0 07/26/2010 

07/28/2010 RR.'.et by Cowl to 09/1M201D 

09/14/2010 Reset Dy Court to 05/14/2010 

09/14/2010 Reset by Court to Q9.'U/2010 

(Result: Hearing Completed 

Petition for Special Relief/Divorce (10:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Johnson, J. Brian) 

07/09/2010 Re-iet by Coun to 07/28/2010 

07/28/2010 Reset by Coun to 09/14/2010 

09/14/2010 Roset by Court to 09/14/2010 

09/14/2010 Reset by Court to 09/1^/2010 

RcsuH: Hearinti Completed 

Petition for Special Relief/Divorce (930 AM) (Judicial OffiCfar Johnson, J. Rrian) 

10/06/2010 Reset by Court to 11/19/2010 

11/19/2010 Reset by Court to 11/15/2010 

Resull. Hearing Completed 

oi'tuiB F.vrix rs 

Complaint Notion TO Dafend & ClaiiT) Riijhts 

Count I, 3301(c) divorce, Count II support, alimony pendente lite & alimony Count ill equitable distribution. Count iv counsel fees, 

sosts & expensss 

Penc for Appcuranco 

for dfl by C S Miller Esq 

Actopianors of Seivict! 

of complaint on behalf of dftbyC S Miller Esq on 10/17/06. 

Prto tor /ippitaranco 

lor Olt by Harold J Funi, Esq, 

Certificate of Completion of Cope Program for PItf on 

11/18/06 

Hriio for witlidrawnl of Appnnriin<:;c 

by S Miller Esq for dfi with cemficstion tnatH j Punt Esq hos antered his appeamnos for .'r.dmc 

l.v.titior liM' Spcr.i.il l<f.lio1' 

^•'00 t: ' ^N 

^i;,c iC spi)C.,r i s:':Oi'. caLiSn 

Now 12/6/06. upon motion of H j Funt Esq, etty for ah s rule is issued upon ptti to show cause why rne petition for spsa^i roh^f 

should not be grsnted Rule rsiumetbic on 12/20/06 m 930 am, OR 5B.LCCH By me court- /s/A M P.lack J. 

PnriCion toi-Special Rcllol 

and exclusive possession to reside in the montsi residence Filed by pttf 

Rule lo appour 8i slinw caueo 

Now 12/11/06, upon motion of A M Muir. attyfarpltl. a rule is issued upon dti to show csuse why the petition for special relief should 

notbegranted Rijl(> returnable on 12/20/05 er 9:30 aru OR 5B.LCCH By the com./S/A M BlecK J 

Answci - Reply - RC!»|JOtiSi; 

to dft's petition for speasi relief. Filed by pitf 

Answer 

ro petition lor specist relief end for exclusive possession to reside in the mantsl residence Filed by dft 

Cu:iTocly Ayrenmcnt 

and order: Now 12/20/06. the parties srs directed to comply with the terms of the attacn&d egreement which is hereby adopted as an 

order of court. By the court, /s/ J B Johnson J. Copies mld/di<td 1/2/07 

Motion for Appoiniin<>nt 0l a A/inscur 

filed by Harold Funt. Esq 

Ma.iTf!!';; AppoliUmont Oi'dor: 

John Roberts III Esq /s appointed Master in Divorce. /$/A M Black j 

Afdt of Consent, Wni^ier of Couii':olll)g & Nnn-IVIilir.iry Service 

forpltf 

W/fliver of Notice of Intention lu Request Entry of Div Dorrroc 

filed by pItf 

hUp://publicaccc.ss.lehighcounly-ovf>/CaseDc;iail.asDX?CasclD-49697.? ^'^>/^^nr\^(^ 
01/25/2011 15:32 FAX 2024935142 FAA + DMS gl009/01G 

Page 3 of9 

02/02/2007 

02/05/2007 

02/07/2007 

02/07/2007 

02/0712007 

02/13/200'/ 

02/23/2007 

02/23/2007 

02/26/2007 

02/27/2007 

02/28/2007 

03/14/2007 

03/15/2007 

03/22/2007 

03/26/2007 

03/29/2007 

04/16/2007 

Oil {712007 

04/17/2007 

04/17/2007 

04/17/2007 

05/03/2007 

05/15/2007 

05/18/2007 

'^ic'23'200"'' 

05/24/2007 

05/24/2007 

06/01/2007 

06/12/2007 

06/19/2007 

06/22/2007 

07/06/2007 

07/09/2007 

Ans\Aicr - Reply - Rcsponsy 

to petition for special relief Filed by pItf 

Peiilloii for Spcciul Rfilioi 

Hied by dft 

Dft'a anawor to complaint 

and coLinterciaim count I equitable distribution, count ii cugfody 

Scliodulina fJKlerTO Appr:nr Ro: CustoOy/Vlsitation 

Addressed Jo piif ondenng him/her to appear for a mediation on 3/6/07 et 12.30 pm By the Coun: /S/ EDR 

Older for Mediation with 

Don S Klein Esq on 3/6/07 at 12 30 pm Costs lo be as follows- Payment by PItftSO DO. Faymmt by Oft $50.00 Subsequent 

payment by PItf $30 00. Payment by Oft 130 00. 8y the Court. /S/EDR 

rr;^nr,(;ript c\ Sripiilatioii At)ioiimen'. 

and order No-w 2/S/07, ihe mthin sgrec/7)enr /s hereby adopted as i » order of cowl By the court. /$/ J B Johiiaon J. 

Petition 

Wed by dft regarding contempt for custody 

Ruir: X St^llcdiilliig Ordur 

Now Z/23/07. upon motion of H J Funt Esq. atty for dft a rule is issued upon the pitf to show cause ^hy tho petition for contempt 

snoutd not be granted Rule re(i;matite on 3/2B/07 at 930 am CR 58, LCCh, By the court- /s/E D Reibman J. 

Affidiwii of St-i'vice: 

of answer and counterclaim. Piled by H J Funt Esq 

IVlaElcr Ortlor; The following );>• rocoininciuleri 

by Muster In Divorce. See orig /S/EDR 

Afflil;!\'it oi S.^rvicf 

j / aetition fa civil contar.-irA Filed oy ,-i j runr EST, 

Petition lor Special Wt;lipl 

ana BWOigency relief and contempt tor disbodience of court order of 2/13/07 Piled by dft 

Certificate of Completion of Cope Program for Dft on 

3/7/07 

Sliohfft; Return 

Answor,. f^eply - Rn.iponsft 

to dft's petition for civil contempt Filod bypltf 

Applicaiioil for Continilanr.o 

3/28/07 contempt plus petition for emergency relief is grar-ited and case is continued ro next available list to 5/9/07 at 9.30 arn, CR 

5B. /s/J B JolMson J. 

Pfzia for Appearance 

for dft by L S Gardner Esq 

Motion 

to compel discovery. Filed by dft 

Order 

Now 4/17/07, dft's motion to compel forpttf's failure to answer ait's interragstoiies and request for production ot documents is granted 

and pItf shall answer dft's interrogatories and request for production of documents within 20 days ot the dale of this order. See orig 

By the court- /s/ L J Brenner J 

Moliuii 

to compel discovory. Filed by pttf 

Order 

Now 4/7 7/07, Pitt's motion to compel for dft's failure to answer pitf's first set ot interrogatnncs and requeist for production of documents 

is granted and dfl shell answer put's first set of mteirogatories and request for production of documents within 20 days of the date of 

thin order See orig By the coun /s/L J Brenner J. 

Piae for withdrawal ot Appcurancc 

by H J Funt ts q for dft 

Ayvne<l Final Orriftr 

Transcript of Agreement & Order Now, 5/9/07. the parties are directed to comply with the terms of said agreement which is hereby 

adopted as an order of court A heanrtg will be held on 5/22/07 at 9.00 sm, CR 5B.LCCH. Seeong. By the court-/s/J B Johnson J. 

Agreed Intniini Ordor; 

Now 5/18/07. the parties Shalt within i s days of the date of this order rnai<e orrangemonts to present themselves and the children for 

psychoioqiccil evfiiualion See ong. By r/ic coyrt /s/f.O Reihmon j 

f-.e- Cy pitf 

Order 

Now S/22/07, dft's pettion for civil contempt is denied See orig. By the r.oun. /s/ J B Jormson J. 

Aflrood Final Orrfor 

Transcffpt of Agreement & Order Now, 5/22/Q7. the parties are directed to comply with the terms of i-nid agreement, rne oral motion 

of pitf to wittidraw her petition for emergency relief is granted and said motion is withdrawn and dft's petition for special emergency 

relief and contempt is granted and said motion shall he marked withdrawn See orig. By the court: /s/ J B Jonnson J 

An.twor 

to dft's counterclaim filed bypltf 

Exhibits 

p-1 and D-1 to D-4 filed 

Notlcu of Appeal tij 

Superior Court by dft from the order enferec/ on 5/24/07. Afdt of sen/ice - witi-im mentioned documents sen/ad upon A M Muir Esq. Hon 

J B Johnson, court administration and court reporting Reqtiesi lor transcript directed to the off/cia/ court reporter Copy of docket 

entries attached. Copy mid on 6/19/07 to Appellate coun and Ckt l 547 in the amt of $60.00 by i S 

Ordf'i 

Now 6/22/0'/. dft is directed lo file of record and serve B copy on the trial judge within 14 days from the entry oi this order a concise 

sliitemeni of n-iatters complained of on appeal. Piff snail respond to the dit's statement within lOdaysof it being fiiod. Seeong. By 

the court: /s/ J E Johnson J 

Staiemcnl 

of matters complained Of on appeal Filed by dit. 

Petition to Withdraw Coun.'icl Si Ordor: 

Now 7/9/07, I. S Gardner ESQ is Withdrawn as Counsel for dft m the above captioned matter /S/ L J Brenner J. 

htlp://publicaccess.lehighcoiintY.or2/Casel.)clail.asnx'?C,a'sp,TT")=4Q6<-)9'> 1 T/l/i/THI n 
01/25/2011 15:32 FAX 2024935142 FAA •» DMS gioio/oie 

Page 4 of9 

07/09/2007 

07/18/2007 

07/27/2007 

07/27/2007 

07/27/2007 

07/27/2007 

07/30/2007 

Ofi/03/2007 

08/03/2007 

0«/06/2007 

C8/07/2007 

00/07/2007 

08/13/2007 

06/15/2007 

09/21/2007 

09/28/2007 

10/17/2007 

11/05/2007 

11/06/2007 

11/27/2007 

11/28/2007 

11/2S/2007 

11/2a/2007 

12/18/2007 

12/18/2007 

12/16/2007 

12/28/2007 

01/24/2008 

01/25(2000 

01/25/2008 

01/29/2008 

01/31/2008 

01/31/200S 

03/04/2008 

03/05/2008 

03/05/2008 

03/05/20C3 

Prao to; witlidrowiil n,'Appoiirnnci; 

tjyLS CS^rdrier Esq for dtt 

Priic for Appcaraiici.-

for dtt BS pro-se 

I'etition tor E-mcrgoncy Rcli©! 

filed by pitf 

Otiinx 

Now 7/25/07, pitt's petition for emergency relief is granted and the off is hereby enjoined from subpoenaing or otherwise requesting 

medical, psychological and/or psychiatnc reqor'ds of tne pitf and the minor children. The request for atty feos on r/xs petition is denied 

See orig By the court-/s/J B Johnson J 

Petition for t-mcijjiincy Ralici 

and contempt filed by pitf 

OI'CIL'INow 7/25/07, pitfs petition for en^ergency relief and contempt is granted. Dft is ordered to pay a fi/ie in the ami of $500 00. See ong. 

By the court: /s/J B Johnson J (footnote added) 

Appellate Court Docker Number Received 

No. 1793 EDA 2907 

Noto.s oi TRStiinoiiy filftci 

on 3/3/07 at 12 59 pm Testimony heard 5/22/0'/ before the Honorable J 8 Johnson J. Coun reporter/Mary S Miilsaps Cm/RPR 

Exhibits rnentionad but not filed 

St.ntcinant 

Pa. RCP . 1925(a) statement Sec orig. By the court. /s/J 6 Johnson J Copies mld/dk\d Q/y07 

PiMf. lor Apponninr.!'! 

'Or cJ'i. by J C Bemntei'-i Esq 

Case Transmitted to 

Superior Court of PA vie certified mail ft 7160 3901 9842 6660 1964 (1 envelope). 

LicT of DocKet entries for Case * mailed to 

Anthony M Muir Esq on 08/07/07. 

Rotuin Card 

NO. 7150 3901 9842 6660 1984 filed 

Acknowledgmuiit 

from Supeiior Court of receiving record on 8/8/07 

Masicr Ortlur: The following la recommended 

Dy master in divoKa. See orig /s/EDR 

IVlHiMcr Ordor; 'I'lio foHowinj) ii; locoiiimondfid 

by master in divorce. Sec ong. /s/EDR 

3301 (d) Affidavit 

& notice to pitf Filod by dft 

Off'v; 3301 (D) GoiMUnr-Afdt A Motico to Pllt 

Filed by Pitt 

lUlastcr Order: rtie foUowinri is recoinmoMdei': 

by rvaster in divorce See ong. /s/EDR 

Master's Hejriny Orclur: 

A Master's hearing is scheduled for 3/3/08 at 930 am. /s/EDR 

Appell.lto Court Docket Nlimboi Received 

1793 EDA ^.007 

Ordeitrom Superior Court. Now 9/14/07, dft has feilsd to comply with this Court's directives. Accoi-dmgly ih6 appeal atNo 1793 EDA 2007 

IS hereby dismissed Per Curiam 

ll/iastci'ii Notice scllint; hearinfj date on 

3/3/08 a 9:30 am 

Petition 

tiled by dft ivgarding appointment of guardian aa litem lor minor(s) 

Proposed Ordor (alter licarinfi) 

RC|Kirt ol Hearin;) Officer 

Lixr.rptioii? 

''led h-> d': 

/Vc.v, i2/2S/07 an ai^umanf/sschedu(e<fo/i 1/30/OS af 9;30 arn,Cft.ffl Sy (fie Court;/S/£ D Re/bman J copies served by C.A 

Office 

Brief 

in response to dffs brief in support of exceptions ro report of custody hearing office Filed by pitf 

Answor - Reply • l^csponsu 

ro dft's exceptions to Report & Ptopossd Order of Custody Hceiring Officer Filed by Pitf. 

Answer - Kaply • l>e.<!poriae 

to dft's Petition for Appointment of Guardian Ad Litem for minors. Filed by PItf 

Anawei' • i<Gply - Response 

to new matter to exceptions Filed by dft 

A|>plic.itlon for Continuance 

for 1/30/09 hearing is refused /a/J B Johnson J 

Aliiwor 

(amended^ to new matter to petition for GAL . and ej^ceptions to report of custody heonng officer. Filed by dft 

Il/lastcr I'iider: The followinfj is rocomirienrtcd 

by master in divorce. Seeong /s/EDR 

iVIastcr's Notice sctciiKi lioarlnrj dam on 

3/31/00 at 9.30 em 

Wlastor'a Hearing Order: 

A rvieisior-3 hearing is scheduled for 3/31/08 at 9.30 am. /s/EDR 

Final Ordor: 

Now 2/27/08, dft's petition for appointment of guardian ad litem is denied. Sec orig. By the court, /s/ M A Varricchio J. (footnote 

http://pubUcaccess.khighcounty.or£/CHtjeDetail.asDX?Casc:in==49rt097 lO/i/^/oni/ i 
01/25/2011 15:33 FAX 2024935142 FAA DMS aOII/OI G 

Page 5 of9 

04/03/2006 

04/03/2008 

04n 1/2008 

04/17/2008 

04/17/2008 

04/25/2008 

04/29/2008 

05/08/2008 

05/08/2008 

05/20'200fi 

05/27/2008 

06/06/2006 

06/20/2008 

06/25/2008 

06/25/200B 

D7/03/2O08 

07/08/2008 

07/14/2008 

07/14/2008 

07/25/2008 

07/25/2008 

07/30/2008 

07/31/2008 

08/04/2008 

09/08/2006 

09/08/2008 

09/24/2008 

09/26/2008 

10/03/2008 

10/03/2008 

10/03/2008 

10/03/2008 

10/03/2008 

10/03/2008 

10/03/2008 

added! 

CA to plucc: Kiattoi on ihe CuHtody TITJI I li t fnt i Irtj 

/S/ WEF 

Order 

Now 4/3/08, the official court reports, D/a/ie Snail is ro produce, certify and file the transcript in this matter, conduced on 1/30/06. See 

ong. By the court- /s/M A i/amcchio J 

Ordc;r of Cuao Wlaiiarjsmcfit/Ciistotty Trial AUiichinciit 

Now 4/10/08 A Pre-triai/Setciemont Conference s/is// take place on 7/23/08 sf 9.O0 am with Custody Trial immediately following at 

9 30 am. CR SB/S/ J 3 Johnson J 

IVIastor'si Notice scttlna tiearinci date on 

5/15/OB et 1:00 pm 

ft/iiiStur'.i I loariiiy Oi dor; 

A Master's tieaimg is scheduled for 5/15/08 at 1:00 pm /a/ WEF 

Notes of ToeTilliony filed 

on 4/25/08 at 1 33 pm Testimony haard 1/30/08 before the Honorable M A Varncchio J. Court reporter/Diane Snel! Pitt's exhihitn 1 & 

2 and dft's exhibits 1-3 attached. 

Application fprCnntinuanCl^ 

7/23/08 pre-trial conference and trial is granted and cyse /s continued to 7/25/08 at lO'OO am /s/JB Johnson j . 

Petition for Spocial Relief 

filed by dft 

Rule & Scheduling Ordor 

Now 5/8/08, a rule is issued upon pitf to show cause irmythe emergeiicy petition fai special ralirjl should nni /;e grunisrl ^w-. 

rewiriable on 6/11/08 at 93 0 am, CR SB By the ucur /s/J ,9 J-j'- -'=i - . 

:i,'(if.i rjj" i..'...i-.i'' ii'K ii.-yii.'nu.'ii,/("'...-^o',' r'.".. J l:,.:.,:-o:.. 

/\c,y 5/2C/08. A Pre-trial/tSertiement Conferenco shall take place on 731/08 at 2:00 pm with Cu.irody Trial immediately following on 

9/3/08St9.30am. S/J B Johnson J. 

Answer - Roply - Response 

10 petition for special relief and new matter Filed by pitf 

Answer 

to new matter in answer to petition for special relief Filed by dft. 

Older 

Now 6/20/06. Dft's petition for special relief is granted. See ong By the court: /s/JB Jotmson J. (footnote added) Copies mia 6/20/oa. 

Dktd 6/23/06 

Petition 

filed by pitl regarding reconsideixilion. 

Mnniuraiuluiv. 

of law in support of petition lor reconsideration of ihe court order entered 0/20/06 Filed by pitf 

Answer 

to petition far recons'doration, new rnattsr and motion for sanctions Filed by dft 

Order 

Now 7/7/08. pitf's petition for reconsideration is denied. By the court /s/J B Johnson J. Copies mid/dktd 7/8/08 

Notice of Appeal lo 

Superior Court tram the order dated 7/7/08 filed by pitf 

Aflldavit of Service; 

of notice of appeal Filed by A M Muir Esq 

l^clitioil tor Contcnipt: 

filed by dft 

Petition 

tiled by pitf regarding application for stay pending appe-al. 

Sfiitctnoni/OpinlOii 

Dated 7/29/08 /S/ J 6 JOtinson J Copies Mid 7/30/08. Dktd 7/31/08 

ivlojicc of ISockctinc) Appe.il in 

Superior Court under Dkt #2069 EDA 2008 

Order 

Wow 7/31/08, pitf's petition is granted snd the 6/20/08 order is stayed until me pending appeal is dosed. .9eo ong By the coun- /s/ J B 

.lohnson J. Copies mid 8/4/08' Dktd 8/5/Ols 

0|-,l-; 

'.z.: :-.=; 5'5':* :3=.':se',"; ;"i;.- e S^z-er.c- CZJ - z- ^irrs y /s,r.f. ;/:-se - cs:ec z<7&rC5, quasnectne appeal of rhe 7/7/03 ora&r 

; / /.'ue z' :ne a.Tarnsa Order. See OnginaL By the Coun /s/ J.S Johnson J. copies mid 9/8/OR, dkta 9/9/OB. 

Scnodulinfj Order: 

(Amended.) Now 9/5/08. pre-trial/settlement conference Is scheduled on 12/22/08 @ 9.00 a.m. before honorable J.B. Jotmson in 

courtroom 5B. custody triol scheduled 12/22/08 <^ 9.30 a.m. before honorable J.B. Johnson in courtroom 5B. /S/ J.B Johnson, J. 

Copies mid 9/6/09 dktd. 9/9/08. 

Petition for Emcraeiicy Relief 

(special) Filed by dft 

Schedulintj Order; 

4 hearing is scneduled for 10/20/08 ar 9:30 am CR 5S. /S/JBJ 

Appellate Court Docket Munibor Recolved 

2069 EDA 2008 

Order 

from Superior Court of PA Now dfi's motion to quash appeal IS granted Per Curiam. 

ExhIDil:: 

from date of separation hearings on 3/3./D6, 3/31/03 and 5/15/08 

Transcript of Mastor'.". Ilearlncj henrd on 

3/3/08 at 9-J7 em 

Transcript of IVIastcr's HnJirint| heard on 

3/31/08 af9.-J7 am. Volume i i 

irLinsci'tpt oi Masrer's Houring liciiid on 

5/15/08 at 1 15 pm. Volume ill 

Master Order: Ttie foHowinf; is rnr.oinmeriderl 

hUp;//pvjblicaccess.lehighcot.iT\tY.orii/Caser)ci-Ail.asnx?C.tisein=4<-M99? i7/i/^/'7mr t 
,1/25/2011 15:33 FAX 2024935142 

FAA 

•> QMS 1012/01 6 

Page 6 of9 

10/06/2006 

10/17/2008 

10/17/2006 

10/17/2008 

10/22/2006 

10/20/2008 

10/29/2006 

10/31/2008 

11/05/200R 

--;J5'20O 6 

11/05/3008 

11/14/2008 

12/22/2008 

12/24/2008 

01/06/2009 

01/07/2008 

01/16/2009 

02/03/2009 

02/11/2009 

02/19/2009 

03/03/2009 

03/04/2009 

03/19/2009 

,:3 •= 2;- ^ 

04/15/2009 

04/20/2009 

04/27/2009 

015/12/2009 

05/26/2009 

05/29/2009 

06/04/2009 

06/04/2009 

by master m divorce. See orig /£/ WBF 

Order 

Now. this 9/29,'08 It is oixiered that a transcript of the proceedings in the above captioned case on 7/31/08 shall be tranKnbed and 

providod ro (he requestor See Original. By the Coun, /s/J 8. Johnsnn, J 

Divorce Exception:-. 

to order of 10/3/O8 Filed by dfl 

Answer 

fo petition for emergency relief and nevt matter Filed by pitf 

Answci' to CusTody plcadinij 

ro new marrar fo petition for special relief Filed by dft. 

Oidfii 

Now 10/20/08, dft's petition for emergency special relief will be deferred for consideration until 12/22/08 Seeorig tiythecoun /s/J 

6 Johnson J Copies mid 10/22/08. Dktd 10/24/08 

Order 

Wow, this 10/20/08, upon consideration of tlie Dft 'j Patition for Brtiergenoey Special Relief. Pitf's reply thereto and New fvlattar, it is 

Ordered that said petitiori and reply wilt bs oofened for consideration until time of tnal on 12/22/08. See Original. By the Court, /s/ J. B. 

Johnson. J. Copies mid/dktd 10/29/09 

Notftii of Testimony filed 

on 10/29/08 at 0-57 am. Testimony heard 7/31/0'd before the Honorable J B Johnson Court reporter, Mary S Miiisaps 

Wlotion 

Filed by dft. Regarding reconsideration 

AITiwcr 

[0 moBon for recon.tidoration of order of 10/20/OS =''e" i.'/..";' 

U.l, ! • 

Wow, Tinis 11/5/08, It IS Ordered that Dft. 's motion lor contempt is deferred tor consldsiation until time of trial on 12/22/08 See 

Original By the Court. /3/J.B Johnson, J copies mid 11/&/0B. dnid 11/6/08 

Order 

Now. r/ii3 11/5/08 it is Ordered ttiaf Oft.'a Motion lor Reconsiderelio/i ofirm Order of 10/20/08, is Denied. See Original By the 

Courf. /s/J.B. Johnson, J. Copies mid 11/5/08 dktdil/6/0B 

l\ule & ScUodiiling Ordnr 

Now 11/14/08, upon motion of J C Bernstein Esq a rule is issued 'Jpon pitf to show cause why exceptions to tne order of 10/3/03 

should not be granted Rule mtumable on 1/21/09 at 9-30 am, CR SB. By the court- /s/JB Johnson J 

Findings of Fact r.nd Concuisiciis of Law 

and memorandum of law. Filed by dft (proposed) 

Interim Order 

Now. this 12/23/08 it is Ordered, PItf shall exercise sole legal custody of child See Original. By the Court /s/J.B Johnson, J Copies 

mid/dktd 12/24/08 

Brifti 

m support of exceptions Filed by dft 

Ordor of Cat-c tifl-iniiaemant/Cusiody Ti'iiil Attac.hmeiM 

Now 1/7/09, Custody trial shell resume on 2/b/09 @ 930 a m in courtroom 5b. See Original By the Coun. /s/J.B. Johnson, J 

Copies mid 1/7/09. dktd 1/8/09 

Brinf 

in opposition to exceptions to a 10/3/08 order Of court. Filed bypltf. 

Ordt'i 

Now. this2/2/09 it is Ordered dil.'s exceptions to order filed 10/17/08, are denied See Oiigirtal. By the Coun./s/J B Johnson, J 

Copies mid 2/3/09, dktd 2/2/09. 

Order 

Now. this 2/10/09, it IS Ordered, that a transcript ot trials held m above captioned case shall be transcribed and provided to the 

requestor See Original. By the Court /s/J.B Johnson, j . copies mid 2/11/09 dktd 2/12/09 

Master Oidur: The following is recommandod 

by master in divorce. See orig /s/ WEF 

Mastvr's Hearing Order; 

A Masterts hearing is scheduled for 5/19/09 AND 5/20/09 @ 9.30 A.M. /s/ WEF 

K/la.'.Tci-'a Wutici^ sertiiig hoarihfl date on 

5/19/09 and 5/20/09 ai 9-30 am 

ll.;.'.-!'.'L; Wiilici.' v.fjriiif; llf.'iTi,.n < :... •. i, 

z'28 09 =,- 3 3 : s -

.'.'rjr.:., s ned,'inr_; Oracr: 

A Master's neanng is scheduled for 5/28/09 at 9:30 am /s / WEF 

Order 

Now this 4/14/09 it is Ordered. PItf 'u petition for Reconsideration IS Denied. See Original By the Coun /s/ J B Johnson,J. Copies 

mid/dktd 4/15/09 

Chiiiiqe Ot Addfoas filed 

by dft 

Order 

Now, this 4/27/09. It IS omened. PItf. 'S motion is Denied and mis Coun's 4/1/09 Order denying Ihe pitf's petition at docket # 2006-FC1268 IS hereby vacated. See Original. By the court. /s/J.B Johnson, J. Copies mid 4/27/09 dktd 4/28/09. 

Pretrial Stiitemciit 

Filed by Dtt. 

n/lasloi Order: I'lie folluwlnr] in i^oominendud 

by master m divorce See ong. /t-/ WEF 

)Was7cr OiflOi'; 'I'hc followinij is itscommoiidod 

by master in drvorce. See ong /s/ 'WEF 

Notes of Testimony filod 

on 6/4/09 at 3:10 pm Testimony heard 12/22/08 before the Honorable J B Johnson J Court reporter Maiy R Milisaps, RPR-CMR. 

(volume 1) 

Notes of TesiiiTiony filed 

on 6/4/09 at 3-10 pm Testimony hisarcl 12/23/09 before the Honorable j B Johnson J. Coun reporter, Mary R Milisaps. HPR-CMR. 

CVoiume 2) 

hup;//pub]icacces3.lehighcouniy.or>i/Ca.'5eDtitail.asDx?Casel 10=49(^977 I •~> I t <;/•*)(••> I <-\ 
01/25/2011 15:33 FAX 2024935142 FAA 

DMS 12013/016 

Page 70(9 

06/04/2009 

06/17/2009 

06/26/2009 

06/26/2009 

06/28/20Qfi 

07/02/2000 

U7/07/2009 

07/07/2009 

07/07/2009 

07/07/2009 

37 ,7,2009 

07/20/2009 

07/21/2009 

07/22/2009 

07/24/2009 

07/29/2009 

07/31/2009 

08/07/2009 

09/04/2009 

09/16/2009 

09/16/2009 

09/23/2009 

10/05/2009 

10/21/2C09 

-:2-.'200& 

10/27/2009 

11/09/2009 

11/24/2009 

n/24/2009 

n/24/2009 

12/02/2009 

12/03/2009 

12/04/2009 

12/04/2009 

01/05/2010 

01/05/2010 

liiial CuatorJy Order; 

Novn this 6/3/09 it is Ordered mother shall exerc/se sole legal custody of the child Sea Ongmsl By the Court /s/J.B Johnson,;. 

copies mid 6/4/09 dktd 6/5A)9 

Ordor 

Now B/16/09, a transcript of the bench opinion held on 6/3/09 shall be transcribed and provided to ihe requestor See orig. By the 

court. /s/J 8 Johnson J Copie? mid 6/18/09. DKtd 6/19/09 

Wlasior's Hearirif) Order: 

A Master's hearing is sctieduled for 9/9/09, 9/10/09. 9/11/09 /s/ WEF 

!'i/l,'»i5ter's Notice ."^cttiDy heariny date on 

9/9/09, 9/10/09, 9/11/09 

WlinTcr Order; llie followinci is reconmendBd 

Ijy master rn divorce See orig. /s/ WEF copies mid 6,'29/09 dktd 7/1/09 

Note.=! otitstinion y tiled 

on 7/2/09 at 3:51 pm Testimony heard 6/3/09 before ilie I lonorobie J B Johnson J Court reporter Mary S Milisaps. RPR-CMR 

Rule i i Sclinduliiig Order 

Wow. this 7/7/09, upon motion ofJc , bemsiein. Esq a niie is issued upon the Pitf to show cause why Dft's motion for sanctions 

should not be granred. Rule Returnable on 7/27/09 @ 9.30 a.m in CR 1C By the Court /s/J B Johnson, J. 

Motion 

Filed by Dfr Regarding Motion for Sanctions 

Re(|uosl 

Demand for Review filod by Dft 

Rule & Srhodiiliiifj Order 

Now, this 7/7/09. upon motion of.I C Bemsrein Esc .= :^:ie is iss.-H -r;- -•"; - i'-^.: "j,i' = :- , .':: i ;e-='i - •:• i . e.-. s.-.z^.z 'c. 

be gr-antc-d Rule returnable on 7/22/S9 '^j^ 9.30 a rn m CR 1C Qy tne Court .'S/J B Jonnson. J. 

Aiijwoi ., .•<uply - ROMpon^ic 

(o Dft's demand tor review of a court order on 6/29/09 Fiiod by PItf 

Answer - Reply •• Respon.iO 

to Dft's motion for sanctions Filed by Pitf 

Tr.'jiiacript of Mlsster'? Hearing heard on 

5-27/09 

Answer - Reply - Kosponss 

to Pitt's New matter and Counter petition to demand for review Filed by Dfr 

Stipulation 

Ancf Order. Now this 7/22/09. it is Ordered attached agreement ol the parties is adopted and entered as an order of coun. See 

Original By the Coun/s/J 8 Johnson. J. Copies mid/dktd 7/24/09 

Order 

Wow 7/26/09, pitf is prohibited Irom presenting any evidence regarding the value of Uie marital residence until she allows dft's 

appraiser access. PItf is directed to file a pre-trial statement witiim todays of the dare of this order See ong. By the court: /&/J e 

Johnson J. Copies mid //29/09 TjMd 7/30/D9 

Pretrial Statrrinenl 

Filed by Pitf 

Transcript ol Nla«iler's IJearinij lioarri on 

5/28/2009 

Order 

Now. this 9/2/09 it IS Ordered, that a transcript of the proceedings in the above-ceptioned case on 7/22/09. shall be transcribed and 

provided to the requestor with conditions. See Original By the Coun /si J B Johnson. J copies mid 9/-W9 dktd 9/9/09 

NlasKir'."; Notico scllinn hearmo date on 

11/4/09, 11,/S/09. 12/2/09. 12/3/09. 

Nlastor'r. Hearing Order; 

A Masters hearing is scheduled for 11/4/0$. 11/5/09, 12/2/09. 12/3/09 @ 930 a m. /s/ W£F copies mid 9/16/09 dktd 9/17./09 

Notes ol Tftsiimony filod 

on 9/23/09 Testimony heard 7/22/09 before the l-tonorable J B Johnson. J Court reporter Elizaboth Rocchino. Exhibits listed but not 

attached 

Ivlolice of Eleclinn to RutaHe Naniu 

from Gail R Selig to Qaii Frances Reeshmen 

"rcinBCripf oi Wl.jal;ei's HonririH hcjirti on 

y/S/D9 Volume 3 

'i:g',nscii;)L r>i i/ij.'.a'r'?, :ira"ii,i, :T<.'iirc -", 

i -;,Cr Jcr-.e' -

Exhibits 

Dff's Ml,2 from iieenng on 7/22/09 

IVIaster Older: The following is rar.ommcnded 

by master m divorce. See orig. /s/ WEF copies mtd/aMd 11/9./09 

Nole-j of rtsTiiTiony tiled 

on 11/24/09 Testimony heard 6/3/09 before the Honorable JBJ Court reponer Mar/ Milisaps 

Notoo of rcstiniony tiled 

01711/24/09 Testimony heard 3/i i/09 before the Honorable JQj Coun reporter l/iary Milisaps 

Notes of Testimony lilcd 

Oil 11/24/09 Testimony neard 2/5/09 before the HonorabiQ JBJ Court reporter Mary iviiiisaps 

Tr.inscnpt of Wlastor's Hearing heurd en 

11/4/09, Volume 5 

TraiiBcript of IKlastor'r, lloariiig neurc) on 

11/5/09 Volume 6 

luliistcr's Notice i-.ettiny heariiifi d;,ite r>n 

1/13 ano 1/14/10 @ 9-30 a.m. 

Nlfti'-lor's tlearina Order; 

A Master's heering is scheduled tar 1/13 and 1/14/09 /s/WEF copies mid 12/4/09 dktd 12/7/09 

Transcript of rvlyscftr's t-leiirinci lianrd on 

12/2/09 Volume 7 

Transcript of Master's Hoariiig heard on 

htip://publicaccess.lchighcouriiy,ore/CaseDciiiil.asDX?Ca,seTl)-49f=iQ'^'7 10/1 £.iir\\i\ 
01/25/2011 15:33 FAX 2024935142 FAA * DMS gl014/016 

Page 8 Of 9 

02/16/2010 

02/17/2010 

03/01/2010 

03/01/2010 

03/23/2010 

03/23/2010 

03/30/2010 

04/06/2010 

04/07/2010 

04/07/2010 

04/12/2010 

C^/25/2010 

04/26/2010 

05/04/2010 

05/17/2010 

05/17/2010 

05/04/2010 

06/04/2010 

OG/07/2010 

06/07/2010 

06/22/2010 

C6/24/2010 

06/25/2010 

07/01/2010 

07/13/2010 

07/14/2010 

07/22/2010 

08/02/2010 

Zz '22Z'I 

08/17/2010 

08/17/2010 

08/20/2010 

09/10/2010 

09/15/2010 

09/22/2010 

10/01/2010 

10/05/2010 

10/07/2010 

12/3AJ9 volume 8 

Winstci's Henrina Ordt>r; 

A Mastar's iiearing is scheduled lor 4/5/10 (^ 9 30 a m /s/ WEF copies mid 2/16/10 dktd 2/17/io 

lUliisters NoUcp setting licariuij d,ile on 

4/5/10® 9-30am 

Transcript of H/iaster'.'-. Ho,^ririg henrd yn 

1/13/10 @ 9-40 s.m 

Transcript of il/lfliter's Hearinci lloaid on 

1/14/101^9-45 am. 

Petition 

to list marital home for sale Filed by put 

f<ule to Show CiiiSu 

Rule reiurnabiu for 4/16/10 at 9.30 a m./s/JBJ 

rtulcto Show Cause 

for 4/14/10 at 9 30 a.m. /s/ WEF copies mid by CA 

Answer to Paritlon for Special (tolief 

filed by dft 

Petition 

for transfer of ownership. Filed by dft 

Rule 10 Show Causo 

for 4/14/10 sf 9.30 a.m. /s/JBJ 

Anawer 

ro dft's petition tor transfer Filed by /I Muir Lsa 

uni):;-; 

I'vo'.v, April 26. 2010 the transcript of oral argument tie provided lo requester with said conditions See orig By Ihe court' /s/ JBJ copies 

mid & dktd 4/26/10 

Transcript of IVIastcr's l-leariniJ Iieflrd on 

April 5, 2010 at 935 a m. Volume II Court Reporter. Bonnie Becker 

ORDI-R 

Now. 5/3/10 ordered that Raymond C. (Seiger, Jr is appointed to perform res! estate appraisals for the real property See ong. By the 

court, /s/ JBJ copies mid & dktd 5/1/10 

Petition for Etiturc.'ijicin 

filed by dIL 

Rule S. ScliGdiitlnc) Order 

i'JoteB ot Te.';tlnionv filed 

heard on 4/14/10 before r/)S Horiorabie Judge Brian J Johnson. Court Reporter: Maiy R Milisaps, RPR-CMR 

Transcript of IWastur's Hearing lieard on 

May 10. 2010 at 1:10 p m before Master John Roberts, III Court Reporter Bonnie Becker. RPR 

Kuie & Scheduling Oidor 

Petition ior Special Kcliet 

for divorce Filed b-y atty Born.itcin. Exhibits attached. 

Anawer lo Petition for Special Relief 

arid New Matter tiled by pitf 

Answer - Rspiy - Hoaponsc 

to aff's petition for bifurcation and new matter. Filed by pitf. 

AffidavJL 

regarding divorce expenses Filed by dft 

Answer - Reply - Response 

by dft to new matter of pitt's reply to dit's petition for bifurcation. 

Hoaringi Scheduling Order 

(Amended) 

OKPF.F: 

Now. 7/9/10 ordered that dft is directed to sign agreement of sale along with the seller's disclosure fomi. See ong By the court: /s/ 

JBJ Copies rnid 7/14/10 dktd 7/15/10 

Affidlivit 

of legal expenses. Filed by pitf 

Hei.riiif, .••••c;ii,>i-iiili!i(i rii(,l2r 

'Ar'i"iec' ' 

Now, 8/12/10 ordered that order dated 7/30/10 is vacated. See orig. By the Court /s/JBJ. Copies mid 8/12/10 Dktd 8/13/10 

Petition for Special Relief 

Filed by atty Bemstem Exhibits attached 

fUils S. Schcdulinfj Order 

Aflidavit 

of Legal Expenses Filed by dft 

ORDER 

Now. 9/14/10 ordered that petition for bifurcation is denisd. See oriq. By the Court /s/'JBJ copies & 236 notice mid 9/15/10 & dktd 

9/16/10 

ORDt=.fi 

Now, 9/14/10 ordered that oral motion by pitf IS granted and Defendant's Petition for Special Relief la denied. See ong. By the 

Court. ./S/JBJ copies & 230 notice mid 9/15/10 d dktd 9/16/10 

ORDER 

Now. 8/70/70 ordered that a ti'ansoripi of the proceedings on 9/14/10 shall be tianacribed and pr-uvided to Requestor based on 

conditions See orig. By the Court: /s/jBJ . CopieF. and Rule 236 Nonce Mid 9/22/1U Dktd 9/23/10 

Answer to Petition lor Special Relief 

filed by atty Muir 

Prae lo Attacli/Sut5StiUirc 

exhibit lo Reply of Plaintiff filed on lO/l/IO. Filed by atty Muir 

CuHiody Hearing Scheduling 0«iur: 

(Amended) /S/JBJ Copies and Rule 236 Notice Mid 10/6/10 Dktd 10/8/10 

hUp://publicaccess.lehighcounty.org/C^L<;cDetaiLaspx?CaseTD-496922 17/1 ^/'7fn(i 
01/25/2011 15:33 FAX 2024935142 FAA + DMS gl015/01G 

Page 9 of 9 

10/11/2010 

10/25/2010 

11/17/2010 

ORDER 

Now, 10/6/10 ordsred t/ia( a ncaring on this petition Is coiitinued until 1 i/is/lO at 9 30 9 m See oog By (fie Court /.v JBJ . Copies 

and Rule 236 Notice Mid IO/11/10 Dktd 10/12/10 

tiate:- of Jrstirnony filed 

on 10/25/10 % 2-52 pm Testimony heard 9/14/10 before the Honorable Judge Brian Johnson Court reponer Msry R Milisaps 

OKDER 

Norn, 11/15/10, Ordered that upon agreeniont of the parties through counsel, the withm mentioned items shall be provided to the 

Divorce Master, John Roberts. Esquire, for his consideration. See ong By thB cnun. /s/ .!BJ. Copies S, 236 riofice mid 11/17/10 Dktd 

11/18/10. 

I'lNANflAl. tiMORMATION 

01/11/2007 

01/11/2007 

02/14/2007 

02'14/P007 

:2 23 2:!:7 

02/23/2007 

06/19/2007 

06/19/2007 

08/02/2007 

08/02/2007 

07/25/2008 

07/25/200^ 

Defendant Selig. Michael B 

Total Financial Assessment 

Total Payrnenis and Credits 

Balance Due as of 12/16/2010 

Transaaion Assessment 

Counter Payment Receipl # 20Q7-07S7 

Transaction Assessment 

Paymenl Receipt* X007-03''70 

T'ransaction Assessmeni 

Counter Payment Receipl« 2007-03793 

Transaction Assessment 

Payment Receipt« 2007-012420 

Transaction Assessment 

Counter Payment Receipt* 2007-01593S 

Transaction Assessment 

Counter Payment Receipl« 2008-016O23 

Mosebflch i^Liiit nayion K Uuckwcrin PC 

",'3S5.'3c." -^J'' : rsj" ; 

funt, Harold J 

Gardner, Linda Shay 

Liteline Cardiology 

Berrsiein, Joseph C 

J- SI 3„C-<,. 

Esq 

,0,-,-, .-c 

902.50 

902.00 

0.00 

250,00 

(250 no^ 

iiti.OOj 

24 75 

(24,75) 

55,00 

(55.00) 

500,00 

(500,00) 

22 75 

(22.75) 

10/10/2006 

10/1C/2006 

03/06/2007 

03/06/2007 

07/14/2008 

07/14/2008 

Plaintiff Roeshman, Gail Frances 

Trttal Financial Assessment 

Total Payments and Credits 

Balance Due as of 12/16/2010 

Transaction Assessmenl 

Counter Payment Receipt* 2006-021373 

Transaction A-iisessmerit 

Counter Payment Receipt* 2007-04510 

Transaction Assessment 

Counter Payment Receipt #2008-014791 

Scoblionkp 

Selig, Gail R 

Scoblionko & ScoblionKo Muir Bartholomew & 

Melrnan 

430.00 

4300C 

0.00 

325.00 

(325.00) 

50.00 

(50.00) 

55.00 

(55,00) 

hUp;//publicacces5i.leliighcouniy.org/CaseI,)ciiiil.aspx?C-ascID=496922 12/16/2010 
01/25/2011 15:34 FAX 2024935142 FAA * DMS l^Olb/Ulb 

U.S. DEPARTMENT Of TRANSPORTATION 

Federal Aviation Administration 

Cynthio Dorninik, Laura Ponto, Lotonyo Williams 

Complainants 

M i R Helicopters. LLC. 

_ Respondent 

Docl<et: 2010-1211 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I HEREBY CERlll Y that I have this day served the toregoing entile(.s): 

RESPONDENT'S REPLY BY WAY OF OBJECTION TO COMPLAINANTS MOTION FOR 

PROCEDURAL SCHEDULE IMPOSITIONS 

upon all porties ot record in this proceeding, In occordance with the requirements of Rule 29 

pursuant to 28U. S. C.§ 1746. 

Service by first-class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as followj: 

Federal Aviation Administration 

800 Independence Avenue, SW 

Wilbur Wright Avenue-Suite 2wi 000 

Washington, D.C. ::j0591 

Aft: Hearing Docket Clerk. AGC-43 0 

;XFAX20 2 493 514 2 

The Honorable Ronnie A, Yoder 

US Deportment ot Tronsportation 

Office of Hearings, M-20, Room El 2-320 

1200 Nev^' Jersey Avenue, S.E. 

Washington. DC 20590 

i- FAX 202^366 7536 

Cynthia Dorninik, F.<;q. 

E-.'c;rca,r,en: 3;v;5ion/AGC-300 

Office of the Chief Counsel 

FAA 

800 Independence Avenue, SW 

Washington ' » \* i j i II I l y I \^ i I,f \-~f\^ DC^ ^\j- 2059j f \ 1 1 , 

^ - FAX 202 267 5106 , , 'x^^ 'X^ ^ 

By;_. 

Michael B. Selig, MO. FACC, : , \ 

2816 Orefield Road ; ^ ^-\ '^" 

Allentown. Pa. 18104 . •s-'-y^'' 

610 360 3953 \ ^'^~" 

Date: