Abel AcosH

ORIGINAL-?O07S ^prlU^/5

RECEIVED IN Supreme Couri- blL^. COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS 1QC£M£.

ifo£W IZ3QSAPR 13 2015

JAusAuj 'Tet&LjzmihjtfL AbelAcosta,Clerk

ii^l

belom.

ple.fi S-C «f}v6& ZU>e\&seA ia* pre xf \iilkou> h>r U't Stress otohYy Kfrv>£^ <f&_

tWse ^AJ-^-^/sMp /fe (e-H-pr Atjd re\urM 14- 4-n ue atmu /A&ress xhnxuu

J yA/u \u uuij- /ac/cc/amu Atfd tjUAJplis 4-o qg-to MAi Ibop p&rs^jJAllyj &.

^Jfttir V\elf> Audi r.6UsidifexfrV*oM> is AppreeJA-tnaA . LkMsK yon

"*"" FILED IN

COUHI Oh CRIMINAL APHbALS

APR 17 ^

^cspecfRjAly^

Abel Acosta, Clerk l. & v^aOU>J2*»->

D,Q. SIamlDjutbjjl

^pp&tlAU-l- f?h 3c

182<Lza&.

KftMsfy

4J&cx£MJ&$-

^j$hA£^^tAS^Tl58^7&fe-
JjJoW Of CouWs

LSfL

nmi

i-mewf-fif tor't Qit€S-/-/oy.s Presetted Fo* flgWew

1, ^JAlyer fiPCouuse/

±^OAA-^LdJ^dLl£ML

_3i_VAJgt j£4fcteM^fc.

^jfe^ifaAL/YAhe/^ Corp

"5 Jury r.loA.rq€

dp, Jpei4y TriAJ

JiJL

7j (t/aI (Records

Pfkj^r For Kfc\k.Jt.

Aplm'rtM &¥ Fi'rsiCouA Of Appt?A\s £li&AHdha_plX^<k Copifsjl.

lKqe~ -F9

..Jfcbm—

£-3

J3_iif_

i^LilZ

11.-16

JtfL^ia

-LS^Zl

_£Li£L_

_22,^1

23-Z5

_£L
K|o. 0 Z60-\5

(j<D,\)MfcCWeH

^U

J&Ad&Ljefc^_

Jiy_k^^]J^.o^OAjii3^0oiC15jiiL£vMfeo:»^A-L6Aihfety_

JlAfittU^EB^ss.

_3ucbf:JSatEW_iaianf@c£L JLU&U .KA/ = LtUi-Co.Ufc«Sg./_

_pAcrj-^-L^c>Ltyi.y _6oV_^_/^_B-AK-Ji-uw.b^l

_4Jci.Atl_J_u^iT

.QewwJt/aias^^

Uid-^tJLsSkMM

t

-JtmyJfjE&l^^ . =

,,AraU£_^L€_M.Eft:b^^

jMljk&wba*.
JfarkvACM-f 6?-Hme, C^£ £>

fln^r/- g^jUHl by rWris C^uilty Sheriff-1 )eptAMieis\' AkkA IrtfeU okfl MH logifl^

ryq

di4

* au>y

AlS)c\ A\^9>5 KAs\sdl^i^£Attor>K o.omf/cJ-loAi AucJ gODV Or§AisugAuor DlNj. CHmtd-Jetis

JuA wife SezKl tog relie$L_jLys& A^-sr Tr; aI A^^/tpp&Aled, App^O Awd proc£akl £>u) App£A\ Vtp Se.

S±*bM£uf &p rrottdurAJ Uislo

LhdCkJroWr 3q, £.ftUA_ f

Oj

•?. MerhoM&r RfcKcAriv^^lAsAcWeA J/^uftry 1^

C^U&dUktS f^SKJfczfl far /foflW

If\NIaW»,c C$ dnuLLsd- prtg4z<, 8-13 fre/tf 4 heAnUg -for defendaklf fa isdrty

-n j T

roid .L^ir.W^ - u-5g ofprior Utsgk,M£AV4Dr ^.oA8vici-/oA/ a/^ Auflnntri^^!

Irvj ^M^ u^-fer >uWk prosecAjdrlmh a* 4^^ U lnAS€c|

aartuWy MAWUM . 4,Vk.4rli.\ V\(kWcA^ Corpus - do£3 Ad4&d*j^ hw*. Apra,-W\ rUrrf lo h&lofcA^

Cnrp<K5 h%Ar\m f

"fi, Jury CM Am <- \\&\h& M&mIaJ- U\IP, ACOHSflbtinttfil rM^ fo ACOWCc/\\juy_

,1.. _ Mn Jar/ . a .,.1 1 1 .„_ IVJJ,... IL.^Jj i PJ)atoa a4-4-1)* Quil4ymttnc.fcjuie£. hv^d puutsViMfevR p^A-sc +0 d^\ kp6 -fhc Cr>rr&icL

lA te_SZ i^_

IL^XtUJ-Jkaiist^^

j£mdL5_Mxl riQj^.o-.^.uApkj^.yi

0. J-tvDp-tUcJ-w^ Assist/wee. DtCouMtel -}n^5_couu^dl5_i>£A^y^AM^k^i^
-&># fid\ibc.trU 4of dMrfeuxe. TA £greo|ocj^ hghtwlnr,

%^MiueJier Lp&Wh^ coiM rti*e t&ues ?>3^35. 7,fi,% IO,t2~> 17. /&W.

&ALA €&i_

f\rQuu€junr'

|t|g?4ir>U) 0"£ .^a^ ^^4 F^W^A \^VS» 'H A\AiAy 4L| rstiff h'cdra Vtij-/) •/-/>* AppltCAkI £

<j&z\Stdmj <v? ^b^Cour-f u-PCrjujiw/ fflOPJ\\x AAJd rhk SuprPM6 Lcxj/4 bP-HkefLi-leA

cSW«gjfro Null '.

m^ . _ . „ _ . __ ^|bfe^ a AeWttj^ffclfecl-s fo rpprgseAj/- Iniu/h&rc&Jf lis APhiuhfrl lAiM^rjjh

Cmustrl. Flre.U* v. CA^nflli, </gg /V.5. ftrt^ 35J. 6r. Z^/fozs). T+ is error

IrM C!dllv4 \-n -forc^ Vlnfe A&14iJ)(Jkiii» Vn kccep/ I&qaI reprrSeAttA-hnu A4ha\

f1

^

/frA-lc/

•ft, Cj-e-t j4)& defLucJAii4 it.

-AA/scn Sc>YTri&L A-l- ^>\uk najas Ae+eudAkirAsked

A-WA frii.s YJAJ^r OfC^uHsJj 4"We <r> AM hltOUAtt ft) UfiA /a AQtlttAoAt

Tb-g AJr^Af^sX- uux4 Jh; /W^ Af-tilfe CO^klU&JlC&S cA_k<teA$lou ^6 \MAiV£ his

fira*^ M7.1 U.S. ^1/335 auc| K/fe5 v. fafeflg, /-5ft T. £f 16/5 (pt^Kmil

•A vk\^ _nM^j luurUrv^ kk>o<Ki[UQ-4JLflct.itixe^a^.

f mQ£C_QQLL 3^P

t

j£pmsm$±?!ti^

•^buj-taGS^a&^S-i^^
^

44iiA- V\£ \<vkSQ\KLs yabfeA- )r\E Is ^a'ikpg *3 &ad Ws eMntr.G /'a /U4^c W^» gygs gygjs a^/yvrAi.

-LXiOiiLJL loMfl4. flMMlkLJcu

U^fit j^i tt <fhty\- 41ierg- ^re TEchnlcAl ruks €ff&s)<\eiJ)c£ AnoJi p^oc^^u-v^ Axial /os vxill xj.nj- ^i

irAi4t4 A^V> sp€clk\ co^ijgrA-Jioid ^o/g/y beams* m Asserted hi

U> J, C k, t?oAAS-/. Au£/J<j, L.

-Cr'iMiuk\ L^J^i

J6- n

whrfh^r A-D^S

,£N| 177.6- TW 4-r\4 li^jboe %i3 respkigibife-for rlekryVtkfQ

&^ckv^T*> valvar fr£-4-lms r«oh4- lo Counsel ks ku^u/i/jug. /Vfe/l/c/r^ *$ IDfy lUT&ni&fTA

Here i/J /^/j P4<5g i^e demtdhitt -filed ktUM&roUS M&-hr\tfs 4-o dteM/s

Couuse/ upL/£L /q aaW /um //re firxfdAu ne cI/gx&tI -for -/t/a/, 7tg w/^r ^

•g»j. (q

)Aj pr&pArpd W//a/ aJmauciz fau\pfeSetjfetf A dQUMsd fo T2 — J ^£An/UQt Tfcjr -fr/'Al \(Aj-ft 444 O^U-Usk| 4b a4- -L NMAS U&V-EKSrVAUct -h

V>feVfe &*£y^ H-^4»^^>^ n^^1 pkifr5£ see Hie thaI J-rAVsorLj- •fl f3 Z\[r\i4 T^niAiri-LfPjJT- AppdUks-l- \MAs Arns^-hrct am \^\auy skhArrAM^

for .-U& -j^loUsi c4ftrJ&S4* o4 O, \KI, X 4 \<\Py5c.c^y\cdr\au NM4 s

W/rti^ Occurs OM 6r *$-&*• sSa^t '-J

J^laBgL-Ga^L^^ v>)lr\lcJb cWAv-y apaSeKi 4<sdglW 4W.

^SftL, ^,0^ (^J, PefaAAiA l)kA JilcJ Minuet^* pr6 Se, AJ/dfoM J-z>.

t
5,

c\gCAShtoS \&CAShtos frf &T flats rtae (,nMrf4Df Lnnd-Df Ctiu^kV Cr>M^fc\ fcnl)fck\s fcpgfckVs fifVVvE fifVVvE Supreme 5upr€MgC/xxr4-ftf-Mg (?/*»*)»< (Jur/ecf t I ill CX^pgs AuA APffiAys TM| '"fo 'iM^rprehtlnU do hk\i£ Kiis Ciwrfr/Jtsd A^JrA-ht^

...i .* \V . u> <*... //U ,^ /-i \ ...7 iL„<r:..- n /.•»/_

LlTHJQ ' ; ^

<SUXiAe* \w 1^ -**%• App- -iWs-U figyv, D;^l \<\<\z. C«»rts my w

L«jLs2-| : i

.%Jr,jA^ Key 19fi - ley,. Lp. ^u^u f/Vfr Asf1 199;? . Wb&L, v^rtk J

.^V^VxfeS Kfcy l^h- T^,. Lp. - Ai^u l^^l. L^oks* S-k-J-uVe i3 Aubioi/ouxj

L<Dur4s- Mus4- Yft\\fi\i^ '^ cAfe^r U^quMfe Aisd S££.K ii>gre^..,CfT....JjE9jWl!c!b*fY:fe^/S.

mmaul^L-

^.mxr*K Musi- YftnfiV^ 1^ CAfcAr \AKSquMfc. AIM S£Sl\ iKgftaST OT |€9iSl^tuy

4ftuvtJi ik pi aim Kuxfl CftuMAip MfeAu'^ ^T WorAs A_u\. j-erMS used, CJ)M

Cfstirl* fyf AppsAls \Kb\H uoV S-hrAi^ 4W-pUm UfcAktmo gn AW NMord mo iu Qidfcr fo

<3>i\ig ^-bj^p: A (jtoSirMt ' ir€AAino. ^4a4& V, LiiUA; f?£5 .S.W. JuT733.

^Akt^-A3_^tim^

j^^Ja£riLLLL,.AL^

^5 5.\f4^L2iia.

^r^/Wg ^ csA/zArJi rAuoe-^r T^6 rV/ldfi for wUri A/? /5 PMiHJck({t

Sj£M4e&c&^yJJ[^
Co,

KAfrjjMmA a^u,W>j ot-kskU-v, vAkkJi \-t \^r dt^s So, •Hie*wl'6U<'£ is V/S/W. C.Arkr V.

?%l*s 1915, W.3a Mft/n^Tey.^.-^/i^^a^).

LovtSTi4iAlQv»^\ L**fl l<F,y 2.5fiC£). "TTife void •rQ>,"VA<]ugafiSJ (fncfn'ue reoulres

ihkdr ApfeitJil AAj-4 jfetSue ^ rn'M^AJ 6TfeM€ wi'-j/i sufficite-iil' defjiifti£Ai&u -MaJor^liMrsj people CAK uk^W^ahc) NkbVuEsV eottAuc^ Is proWtloi4a^ /3mJ id AMAWLfer

4U4-Abes vir^ npruU- AtIdJjW^ Aud JisciMiMlfory Pmh\rr£M£4J IkD order \Xti4li

rmis4ikifyr>vul-La.mj>.IC&t 7Q.lfe).TTe^.CnuJ fipp.26069. Tke s^miaiaImJe

ry Q.6tt-STrueshrtN> t<S ft

_]jM-J^V\^>UflLJb:

kfefe 4L4- r» ZMAfihzl frt-L Iav$ .fry

Auem>4 rU ffhftuk, 4^ ^.6Xn 4& ,fa luLf.~ tS^4s n<. Vas.'/a.^ 1%7^,W, '"SJ

Po^^A;qua! Um ^ 7fl,3fQ.T^.CrJM, A.pp7jSfl5 T4\su,&v4bg ptAo^ ^P

jLudflES-jftMiM 4beJiudiLciA»vy tt> CAsWri/fc 4<$hduh£..bAz£d on rhi-\r vwArifiKta o^

ytpl/Uli i^ ^A^nLfcAVUr wkfelr M^VfeS QooA C6UU6M S&ILtty^ fl Jfel/f Y. J&4, JS7S.\M.

**)& ynjoi* nsuhuj I6b(n^\irlt^574 QjmjU&L^^ JWwXi-Qbb] UMX TrhLcmH-'aIms*

-J\drs <jitff£JimiuxjJmL^ (kdfiQti is Arbitrary or uf/F6ASofiJflitejHe

atjextiou id whether rite TT/aI COuA ^:md) tA)rbbftu4 yg/W.eM)ag 4o Ak&y ouepuo

ru\fS, ftf OnHflpUr«S, J/a^ V. Futyj /fi&>«5.W. 3A l^ pekknu^roir di'sc.rel'.nKfiAry

retif*i reused.

Teu r\w.-LorpnxC\risr-\ Zflftfo .iu AW.se oft dKsrm/you 3&£ttrs nhm W£
7,

r|)3Gf€4io4 NttbeM> j4s tk&siou lies ouA-side tif'tkc ZAfJ£ df CeAxntMe6-aLSLAftZ££r. <\i\kQ)

Ugnl. Q^4Vi^r H,SU4£j/^7J;K/,Sj(n9/.

Prlu. LJ^i. Kfcy 11 49 .n^i.. AfP" "^u^fi</ f\4.1Z6^t '1bs Ct>aA frf

/Up&a/s r&il&us &ttjaI CourH rubber &u a^f/yflon to auAzfi tm lucb'eJ-MeW'fo^

Abux£ r>-f Aiyrrxdiou) . 0Af*: rv. hh^airAj^y^ I$7.?. U/. 3d £>i?/,

Oefjlaf,

firfQiJe /^ VftMj 4^ fAt/3^ ADr> obikcJj-JAu Is r^Mjtr^ j-p preserve krircr oaJ

ApQEAl . rWk^r v. ^f^j |RQV<5. \a]. ^ pepttiTM far cttecrgf.QAtAy rev/fryi re/W

Ada4\4^ QoaA •j-hkr' &HierNk& hfc \uti sd)tjlnAp MAN klwAy? fJ/sfice 4/Jrj'oprr^nt

£« .. i? !*.(.L L, J_.l... ' ._fl L. lL^-L.1.1 J, I.J..U.. V.J. Li*.J.. ,. UJ-

. ^ 1 —]

S4kW^j£e^J^SiX\^-JS^

,Cou.d-_M.u^As.c^^^

QA^gg^ll,AI\J 3.11.0*1, 3\l.Q^3ti.A^5, -TL mU.C.C^l^AlM^

3£ft±.

1 1 y

l.£*..i2r:vM.._(W,J^o^^

^j?_AXso_^AiAxtfes_k&|_\.5^.. - : ——

IIia-*£*LijfcdjAf)^^
8.

ifi^jLW^-iJLBk^sgg hh^^hhh^J^jJBlL

.^^uks-jyg.^ 1P>1(^ •"Uj..^pr- F4.\K(.or4U 20o5, Courfe should kick A^ A

Cf^zdutdbiP tAa4 \Mftu\A y&sAer L\k\u or pmgUlnn MeKVAtHiQ^s, lilies Qs. f\. V

A\\lrA foloVs AsSrt^ \ft7 5.NM.^ ^ rel^*[ avcrro/al.

Maus-tJ&uAs—S:

^A»—UUAM-V

4ba4 4be feo fckYayfe C.t>u\A u<^r oossl V>Vy ^ e '*4euA r(^ .-^s N•St*kj I^^ J. \n|.?)d

JJ/7t fltf r^L\ £aok V4L 745757, :

'•^3$ °\\j rgAeAn'uQ overrule^

Aubi^aongj CotW* v^il\ s£fej< AAe iid-e^ s-f^lne. leajjltiure 4s Tou^d in Ht p>\a.'itk

rfc-S

kfoJ^luQ erf -Hvfe mnKJb ^> Uv& akkekj uu\bss pWiiaq s^ Mtflulj UaA It> ah absurd reSJiM

-HltvV Afe UqLsffrW, COuiA KOM- VlA-Mfe 'itJsWA^, Cfv fN*4"fe ^Y-MiH) \PsrJ 5, Wl-34

3flk. J

J4i£ [eiLLsf/AuJOE: feAUjsi- be uv^&raiaod Vp Hi^iLJ^fc^itiiJaJ^

Jj 17, »m reMM^ ijWo ^1-715751* :

"lei. App.~F4-.Woi4k 2-Q o5. LourLs A-r> N)ft4- h*=-^ 4o v=&6&r4Vo yak.s ^4

rftvkT4rJ(4-'ioKr> or BLTniASt^ h\\s -W> C6U^ru£ Ask^urre /A/tf is de<{r ^A/c/ 6fMAi^fii<i

IJ|,>e> Iks. Co , v. AlVi^A ri\o-Vs AssV^ \^7 J, Vi Sd °l\ ,in&WWiuo ^ferrule

be

jjgyrdiij^

.pAciLcuJAc_u.Eml^

_cLbj2-tdbL0.«^ty tBMi£M—rBJuA^^-^e^^Ajsa^duJms—Ke^—^D.
DO i/'/y/t j i i i . i • // / i (1 '0 «i

QftLSfn/aftod floU IS/^ fr>^ prE5UM£ presage flfrAf jjli T*ig the f^i/Afare hqpll&ute MeAwtEtdr WhAf wAaI ilif 5A«d $Aa& j«jjl i-M ^hfetriyvQ MUfcrtyvo 4qH^

ruW; d&urrs show thejr r^p€<d-fbr 4h£ IBpsUWe ku^ rftfrsaMizg tiiJ- rt- if euAchzi

QsmorM -& /•£? /ijfit^ Shie___YAAsiLs>_ 1

-Hi€ ttfkud of rne t&trsl&lijifc And y£> etfecf Ua\ lukJ-.

CbUri Uhj look AV fA& objfecb Sobu?b4 4o bs oblAmecJ^llfe letfiaAlive UkyIov-i^ dhe

J>i:Af-ui&vS-fte*-2J-2-.i^-.^^^

4A.Atik_kkn^fc&J^^

_sAfcW(pjryjA.u^

JsAftAi&ffijJ*^^

<d-t_>b>~i_A_

ci4jD^A^Miui^mr_we-CoiJ^

llfcWvuU^^JSfi^^

,j£fiCp.ris.o._bAc/w^

_^^|_i.MpA.ri3.4-J-x»A\.
^l4Luo_y^d:

-., , ..,- JM>4 ^ ravt'g.Vsi 4be 'iwKU&hkA€d4 \or \e[o\M Q . —^ T..^1

u)AXppr>A&J fcy {he shrub utider \kihi cJn rii€ d&feiidAwl-wAS p^^tad&i.

T^fe rrh\ C6iirf hhuLS-sd /4<? cdlscreiiofj} L UcA- QUAshiua JLdleUm JkldJcdutH^

16.

/ it. 1 .vi •—I T .11 ill

>C fraUfc.^4

-DAS or h.AS—hi£T QDffec^^^..:rrLAJ-dfeu

To dr> So, Ih

oAJ^saU TftOfc,

^,3< &»%• - CUJUj iTfljpef.

mri'sjiW/Vm/*/

E^Ui^p^Au^Llie ^6l3jj Ca\W^.,%I^ 17(o $>)fiL3A £31, g3(/7i*

Pmftf ^4 rfir'iftr ^QM/'ebWQ. ^AJs^fcUfc/yi^** W.NNC£-m ^ A \zSSer~ iudad&J ol'

JM,Mo^^b£JXLk\_J^^^—

^^^.JB:^-^^^^^-^- ^ gi^ JeuCtIh. ^J^L53jLW.
II*

£tib.p.o.rL4^me.tiA^

ii * l I ' I • I t I 0 ' i •! ' I • •V f) ' \\ t ' I ' /1

a<l4- Av€ A^s WaA- ^\re vvtA- A.urUorl?,eA by |kvu v^il* LTOBauUr A.db_^Ang 4crs ozl

_^W.J4yL_p.v±wasW

J2r^ppJA9i^^

J^^JCS_64lAJtrLk\££>^^

J^M_Jipp.A_ld.QSj_JjA^^

J4j_£/tf.Ac!^jEAi:>t.Jj^^

Aa&Upuccml&AjLj^
l£,

H/?r€;fAfe JrAruhs is ^Aiki. TWt ik4erprg//*4i okd /s ^irA/kied AKtJ wygflgVifc

4^ frtie*& 4b& 4r>t,\ CoULr& iufasd4. Qua-biso foM OUcKIs Lavj, fj/cAWiArt/-

for WAriflivtti.fl^O C/iva. Lanm. 4bfc reaulveAie»J*'fiAl>A C/ja/Jua/ fihhA*. Ae-

\l\$e Al\ frffTMS-^ Vst>]-fil gjUJOUob precision ^/\ 4btAr Ayg4^0Ai>AU>g ntmnUi r>.AU l<k

Qrln- LAw. /Cr-y 13.1

3. \t>ld Jeureuce - -(-he Cowrr-Af- Appeals' ArcUitu toufh'c-fc wity Afirdfer

r&urd- ^AppeA^ AtgASiftM* ftK\4b^- fifc**s tssagj 4-W& FtV^^-o^rf Af Appg^/.y

.s ofefci'ckj ah t^pariM Qu&stiokD df sMc* AiJ 4"&kjr4 Iav^ tVia4 sUu\d hz

441ed bu V-We (\mjlv4 fty ( *"*mV*a-1 A^pf

fAfe <5upreue Cg>ur/ bfrjie Qyi'k

£ejiuLoj4-^-M&0l bA-3_dsjpAid

}

4bkL_4k^...vs/^y sews, -/llso-Jt

^uas^4JL^ppj^dijt£ir 4 >5£aX

1 ° J^fiLJ3S4dUl4-^jt^l^

jjy Hi^Mcm^J^i^dus.ki-j' A^<j_£^ArJ^^.A^y^^^^^»^ 3^x6k^2nM,feppi_

^id^-^Li-W^i^^

fil£J!LUJZyj£^^

i • »^- — ^/ I — y | r J I

IDE*.j^^j^^i^^

J5_pAris^^