## 01/25/201 1 15;3 1 FAX 202493514 2 

# FA A + DM S @1001/01 G 

# r-RARTK^ENTO F Michae l Selig . MD , FACC , CFi-H--MSf^lATl ^ 281 6 Orefiel d Roa d ^ '^• - ' •uPtRAllON b Allentown , PA . 1810 4 ^ ^ ^ m J' N ? S P 3^ ^ • ^



# RECEIVE D DE C 2 ? 201 1 

# HEARIN G D "OKE T

U.S . DEPARTMEN TO F TRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O F HEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C . Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Laur a Ponto , Cynthi a Dorninik , Latony a William s Complainant s M & R Helicopters , LLC . Responden t Honorabl e Judg e Ronni e Yode r Docket : 2010-121 1

RESPONDENT' S REPL

YB YWA YO F OBJECTIO N T

O COMPLAINANT S MOTIO N FOR PROCEDURALSCHEDULE IMPOSITION S AN D NOW , come s respondent , MICHAE LB . SELIG , MD , FACC , 

# principl e fo rM R Helicopters , LLC , (MRH ) who m aver s an d file s th e followin g Repl y i n demurre rOBJECTIO N t o Complainant s Reques t fo ra n Orde rt o Impos e a Procedura l Schedul e fo rFilin g Dispositio n Motion s an d Discover yo n th e basi s tha t respondent s pleading s hav e bee n reasonabl e an d prope ran d i n accordanc e an d i n repl yt o flawe d fundamenta l premis e fo rth e violatio n an d hencefort h breache s b ycomplainant s failur e t o respond , filin g o flat e replie s o r inadequat e method s o flat e onswer s tha t ar e cobble d togethe rwit h colorabl e argument s tha t ar e impermissibl yvagu e an d inaccurate , thereb yar e attempt s

## r t i + DM S @1002/01 G 01/25/201 1 15:3 1 FA X2024935U 2 Fhft



# o fprosecutoria l overreaching , an d thereb yth e complain t shoul d b e stricke n an d dismissed . 1 . O n Jul y21 , 2009 , FA AOfficers , Latony a William s an d Kimm yPoo n appeare d fo ra n initia l inspectio n o fM R Helicopters , LLC . 2 . Th e allege d violatio n fo rM rBake raccordin g t o M s William s Inspecto r Statemen t lO P 9 record , wa s du e t o "inabilit yt o fin d FA Aapprove d dru g an d alcoho l testin g progra m informatio n fo rFligh t Methods" . M rBake rwa s no : employe d b yFligh t Methods , bu t b yAi rMethod s Corporation , therefor e M s William s erre d i n thi s fundamenta l fac t drivin g th e violation . 3 . M s William s faile d t o perfor m wit h du e diligenc e an d i n goo d fait h a n investigatio n confirmin g tha t M rBake rwa s no t o n a dru g an d alcoho l program , th e sol e premis e fo rdrivin g th e violation . Counse l i s boun d b yjudicia l estoppel s fo ran yothe rclaims . 4 . O n Octobe r21 , 2010 , MR H wa s serve d wit h a Fina l Notic e o fPropose d Civi l Penalty , citin g a potentia l fin e o f$540 0 (Fift yFou rHundre d Dollars ) sinc e modifie d t o $4400
. Thi s occurre d ove r1 yea rlater , pos t th e statu e o flimitation s an d therefor e tim e barred . 5 . Onc e realizin g an d force d t o cobbl e togethe rcolo ro fla worgument s fo ra bette roffense , tha t M rBake rwa s alway s engage d i n a n FA Aprove d dru g an d alcoho l testin g program , complainant s attempte d t o re-craf t thei roffens e b yassertin g tha t th e testin g progra m fo ra pilo t i s someho wdifferen t fro m tha to f a mechanic , whe n the ybot h fal l unde rsafet ysensitiv e function s t o whic h ther e

## + DM S 1003/01 6 01/25/201 1 15:3 1 FA X202493514 2 FA A



# i s n o differen t testin g parameters . 6 . Onc e realizin g an d cobblin g tha t MrBake rwa s alway s engage d i n a n FA Aapprove d dru g an d alcoho l testin g program , complainant s attempte d t o re-craf t thei roffens e b yassertin g tha t Ai rMethod s di d no t authoriz e M rBake r t o perfor m maintenanc e unde rthei rrepai rstatio n certificate , knowin g tha t Mr Bake runde rregulatio n i s permitte d t o perfor m hi s safet ysensitiv e function s unde rhi s ow n A/ P cerlificaticn . 7 . Contrar yt o Judicia l Estoppels, complainant s attempte d t o redirec t thei roffens e concernin g th e ne wdefinitio n o f"employer " appendice s I an d j , clause s hidden , no t eviden t i n th e operatio n specification s b yassertin g tha t M r Bake rwa s no t o n MRH' s ow n program , eve n ttioug h o n anothe rcompariie s progra m an d th e complainant s alread yrelease d an d withdre wal l suc h violation s agains t th e othe rAP/IA , thereb yshowin g prim a faci e lega l inconsistency . 8- Complainant s becam e procedurall ydefectiv e b yfailin g t o respon d o rfile d lat e answer s t o 8 o frespondent s pleading s i n breac h o fth e FA ARule s o f Civi l Penalt yProceeding s 1 4 C.F.R . §13.1 6 an d subpar t G , § Rule s 13.218(d ) on d § 13.22G(d) . Th e Offic e o fChie fCounse l employ s man yattorneys , handle s thousand s o fviolation s yearl yan d therefor e alternative s ar e readil yavailabl e t o cove ro rsubstitut e fo rvocation , illnes s o rothe rreasons . Thi s cas e doe s no thav e exclusiv e authorit yo fonl yM s Ponto , as ther e hav e alread ybee n othe r intervenin g attorney s tha t hav e reviewe d o rbee n involve d i n th e case .

### . DM S @1004/01 G 01/25/201 1 15:3 2 FAX202493514 2 Fft A



# includin g Pete rLynch , Esq. , (lette rOctobe r21 , 2010 , (exhibi t 1) , Charle s Raley , Esq . (Octobe r1 , 201 0 telephon e hearing , transcript s outstanding) , M s Cynthi a Dorninik , Esq . [Telephon e cal l Decembers , 2010) , therefore , ther e i s n o excus e o rreaso n fo rabsen t o rlat e filin g o fobjection s o ran.-jwer s unde ran ypremis e fo r al l th e obov e 8 documents . 9 . Whe n complainant s finall ycam e abou t t o filin g incomplet e an d lot e answer s tho t bor e insufficien t specificit yt o respondent s succinc rnumoere a pleadings , thei ranswer s wer e procedurall ydefectiv e t o th e standar d practice s o fdirectl yanswerin g enumerate d paragraphs , breachin g Rul e §206. 2 an d thereb ycomplainant s avoide d an d faile d t o addres s items , thu s acceptin g state d item s o fresponden t a s confirme d statement s o fmateria l fact . A n exampl e o fthi s is failur e t o respon d t o ho wth e FAA s ow n Drug/Alcoho l abatemen t office rVincen t Root s durin g hi s i n camer a audi to f MR H i n Apri l 2004 , faile d t o infor m MR H o rwa s informe d himself , o fth e FA A change d definitio n o fth e wor d "employer " tha t occurre d i n February2004 , affectin g appendice s I an d J . Complainant s faile d t o respon d t o th e fac t tha t MRH s regula roperation s an d maintenanc e inspectors , Fran k Alott a an d GerryHenininger , th e Allentow n FSDO , whic h i

s acros s th e stree tfro m wher e th e aircraf t ha s bee n inspecte d an d hangare d fo r1 0 years , wer e als o unawar e o fth e regulatio n change , thereb y holdin g MR H t o a highe rstandar d tha n thei row n FA Aofficers . 10 . Complainant s havin g o fbes t lega l insufficiency , a cas e voi d a b 4 -

### - > DM S @|005/01 6 01/25/201 1 15:3 2 FA X202493514 2 FA A



# initio , makin g condusionar ystatements , compressin g man yquestions , attemptin g t o impai rth e dignit yo fth e court , b ywittingl yan d willfull ymakin g incredibl e allegations , no t lookin g a t th e perspectiv e i n whol e i n regar d t o huma n aspects , namel yth e curren t stat e o fth e responden t unde rattack , wh o decide d i n goo d judgment , tha t becaus e o fhi s curren t 5 yea r(200 6 t o present ) tragi cdivorc e litigation , includin g financia l devastation , complet e alienatio n o f hi s 3 children , emoliona l upheaval , havin g t o defen d agains Tfrauauien i medica l disabilitie s o fwife , litigatio n t o regai n propert y(Exhibi t 1) , th e responden t believe d i n th e bes t interest s o fth e operation , t o temporaril ybac k of ffro m performin g service s durin g th e exac t perio d violation s ar e bein g sought . Th e responden t concurrentl yha s a solo , privat e cardiolog yan d interna l medicin e practic e o f2 2 years , servin g th e communit yan d assist s pilot s wit h medica l certificates . Thes e action s take n agains t th e responden t mount s t o "beatin g a ma n wh o is alread ydown" , behavior s tha t ar e unconscionabl e a t an ylevel . 11 . Th e complainant s incredibl ystat e tha t th e responden t i s filin g unnecessar yo rredundan t pleadings , whe n i t i s th e complainant s wh o hav e lega l insufficienc yan d inconsistency , faile d t o fil e answers , file d answer s pas t deadlines , faile d t o fil e answer s coherentl yt o specifi cnumbere d allegations , tryin g t o hol d MR H t o a highe rstondar d tha n thei row n officers . 12 . Th e respondent s filing s ar e therefore , appropriat e t o th e eithe rnon respons e o rt o th e fals e fundamenta l fac t basi s an d assumptio n tha t MrBake r 5 -

## r, * • » QM S liOOG/OI G 01/25/201 1 15:3 2 FAX 202493514 2 FA A



# wa s no t o n a drug/alcoho l progra m tha tinitiate d an d drivin g th e violation s an d th e movin g targe t o fshiftin g materia l fact s an d argument s presente d b y complainan t t o tol l th e insufficien t violatio n f o fruitio n i n a Internecin e manner , t o whic h n o restriction s shoul d b e place d fo rresponden tt o procee d i n equity . 13 . I fi s respondent' s avermen t tha t th e complainant s ar e malfeasant , i n abus e o fdiscretio n an d process , i n breac h o fdut yan d conduc t an d i n attemptin g t o obstruc t justic e fo rresponden i T O pursu e Thi

s vioioiion . 14 . I n al l an d bes t effort s fo rjudicia l economy , th e cas e therefor e shoul d b e dismisse d t o allo wth e administration s effort s b e properl ydirecte d t o othe r area s o rhig h volume , larg e operatio n violatio n case s mos t pertinen t t o th e publi csafet yo fou rcountry . WHEREFORE , th e responden t pray s tha t thi s Honorabl e Cour t wil l no t limi t Ih e mean s fo rth e responden t t o defen d himsel fo rdismis s th e case . Respectfull ySubmitted ,

\ ^

• - \ 

# Michae l B . Sellg , MD , FACC , CFI- H \ ^" ' •- \

t Dat e .

6 -

## 01/25/201 1 15:3 2 FA X 202493514 2 FA A 

## + DM S 

## [g|007/01 6



# Page 1 of 9

l.oHCr.i l f^'i

V/'.i:/.'.uii^ ; ;-<e-i;m:l i A;;:ni , Ne w: I'l'd . l<.-'i.'!V - ,;.;,:i' t1 ''1. : 1 

# REGISTE RO FACTION S •i;r..':,iui , nj.'ik-i.' n Krii'orcl;. ; IDiinift!; - l-iel o

Gai l Francd E Roeehma n Forinerl yKnow n A s Gai l R Seli g V $ Michael § B Sell g ^ § § Cas e Type : Divorc e Sublype : Divorc e Dat e Filed : 10/10/200 6 Location : Civi l Record s

PAHT Y1NFOH>IAT10N ' Defendan tSelig , Micriae l B

261 6 Orefiel d R d OrefiOld , P A1610 4 Lea d Attorney s Josep h C Bernstein , Es q R&tmnc d 610-770-1-iOO(W ) Plaintif fRosEhman . Gai l France s

Formerl vKnow n A x.Sclig , Gai l R 32 5 ^ ^ 20t h S t Allentown , P A1810 4 Anthon yM Muir , Es q Retain& a 610-4,34-7138(W ) F.V|::NT?AORl3liR S O i riVRCWK t 

### 12/20/200 6 03/06/200 7 05/08/200 7 05/10/200 7 05/22/200 7

05/22/200 7 01/30/200 8 Ce/11/200 8 07/31/200 8


### 09/03/200 9

10/20/200 3 12/22/200 8 01/21/200 9 06/03/200 9

06/03/200 9 

### lIE\niN(". S

Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (9:3 0 AM ) (Jiidicia l Office rJohnsion , J . Briari ) PLAINTIF F AN O DEFENDANT S PETITIO N Result : Fina l Orde rEmere d NIediatlo n (12;3 0 PM ) (.Judicia l Office rKlein , Do n S , Esci ) R<39ull . Wiedlatio n Hel d Wit h Agieemen t Petitio n fo rEmergenc yRelief/Divorc e (9:3 0 Af/ ) (Judicia l Office rJoniiBDn , j , Brian ) REMOVA LO F B£ £HIVE S FRO M PROPERT Y Result : Hearin g Complete d Custod yCotiterene e (lO.O O AM ) (Judicia l Office rVanGildcr , Donal d L) Result : Conferenc e Hel d - interi m Orde r Custod yContemp t (9:0 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson . J . Brian ) 03^?S/200 7 Continue d t o 05/09/200 7 - Conf/oue d t> yJudQ S - Setig . Michsc i B 05/09/200 7 Rese tb yCour tt o 05/22/200 7 Result : Hearin g Complete d Contennp t (9;0 0 At^d) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) PLAINTIF F AN D DEr-ENDANT S PETITIO N FO R CO N TEMPT . Result : Matte rl o b e Settled/Withdiaw n - Famil y Exception s t o Maewr' s Repor t (9:i 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rVairicchio , Michei cA ) Resuli : Hearin g Complete d Petitio n to rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) Result . Hearin g Complete d CANCELE D Custod yConferenc e (7,C 0 PM ) (Judicia l Offica r-lohnsoi i J Brisn i J7/23'200 S Continue d t o 07/2S/200 8 - Conmuii O 0 / Juag e - Roe&hman , Gai l Fro/ice s 07/25a00 B ReS6 tb yCour t m 07/31/200 8 CmCELE D Custod yTria l (9:3 0 AM ) (Jiidicia i Office rJoimson , J . Brian ) Cej cStaye d 07/23/200 % Continue d t o 07/25/200 8 - Oontmue d b yJuOg a - Roeshman . Gai l Prance! : 07/'^.b7200 8 Rese t b yCour tl o 0$/03/200 B Patitio n (o rEmergenc yRelief/Custod y(9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) Result : Hearin g Complete d Custod yConferene o (9:0 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) Result : Custod yConferenc e Hel d - Maile rt o Procee d l o Tria l Exception s t o Master' s Ropo n (9:3 0 AlVl ) (Judicia l Oftice rJohnson , J . Brian ) Resull : Hearin g Complete d Custod yTria l | i :3 0 PM ) (Judidia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) 12/22/200 8 Rese t b yCour tt o 02/05/200 9 0?/0'J/200 9 Rese t b yCour t t o 03/11/200 9 03/11/200 9 Rese t b yCour t t o 06/03/200 9 Result : Tria l Complete d D yJudg e Custod yComomp t(1:3 0 PM! ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson . J . Brian ) T O B E COMPLETE D 

# (^^k ^ 

# \ hltp.V/publicacce.ss.lehiahcounlv.ortr/Ca.'^e l )cMilfli:nv'>f ^•i^-^' i H^ADAQO- )

## 01/25/201 1 15:3 2 FA X 202493514 2 FA A • > DMS gl008/01 G



# Page 2 of 9

07/22/200 9 07/22/200 $ 04/05/201 0 04/05/201 0 04/14/201 0 04/14/201 0 05/10/201 0 09/14/201 0

09/14/201 0

11/15/201 0

10/10/200 6 10/10/200 6 10/24/200 6 11/IS/200 6 11/30/200 6 12/05/200 6 12/08/200 6 '. 2 Zz-2ZZ z 12/11/200 6 i:?/11/200 6 12/15/200 6 12/19/200 6 01/02/200 7 01/11/200 7 01/16/200 7 01/19/200 7 01/19/200 7 12/22/200 8 Poae tb yCour t t o 02/05/200 9

02/05/200 9 Rese t b yCou n t o 03/11/200 9 03/11/200 9 R9S6 tb yCour t t o 06/03/200 9 Resull : Hearin g Complete d Hearin g (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJotinson , J , Brian ) DEFENDANT S PETITIO N FO R REVIEW . Result . Matte rt o b e Sellledrt/Vjlhdrgw n - Famil y n/iotio n fo rSanction s (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson . J . Brian ) Result ; Hearin g Complete d Hearin g (9:0 O AM ) (Judicia l OfficerRolierts , Joh n E , III ) Hearin g (10 0 HM ) (Judicia l OfficG fRoberts , Joh n H , III ) Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Bnan ) 04/16/201 0 Rese t b yCo m t o 04/14/201 0 Resul t Hearin g Complete d Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (9:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJol^nson , J . Brian ) TRANSFE R OWNERSHI P Result : Hearin g Complete d Hearin g (1;0 0 PM ) (Judicia l Office rRoberts , Joh n E , III ) Petitio n fo rBifurcatio n (10:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) 07/09/201 0 Rese t b yCou n [ 0 07/26/201 0 07/28/201 0 RR.'.etb yCow l t o 09/1M201 D 09/14/201 0 Rese t DyCour t t o 05/14/201 0 09/14/201 0 Rese t b yCour tt o Q9.'U/201 0 (Result : Hearin g Complete d Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (10:3 0 AM ) (Judicia l Office rJohnson , J . Brian ) 07/09/201 0 Re-ie t b yCou n t o 07/28/201 0 07/28/201 0 Rese tb yCou n t o 09/14/201 0 09/14/201 0 Rose t b yCour t t o 09/14/201 0 09/14/201 0 Rese t b yCour tt o 09/1^/201 0 RcsuH : Hearint i Complete d Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relief/Divorc e (93 0 AM ) (Judicia l OffiCfa rJohnson , J . Rrian ) 10/06/201 0 Rese t b yCour t t o 11/19/201 0 11/19/201 0 Rese t b yCour tt o 11/15/201 0 Resull . Hearin g Complete d 

## oi'tui B F.vri

x r s Complain t Notio n T

O Dafen d & ClaiiT ) Riijht s Coun t I , 3301(c ) divorce , Coun t I I support , alimon ypendent e lit e & alimon yCoun t il l equitabl e distribution . Coun t i vcounse l fees , sost s & expenss s Pen cfo rAppcuranc o fo rdf l b yC S Mille rEs q Actopianor s o fSeivict ! o fcomplain t o n behal fo fdftbyC S Mille rEs q o n 10/17/06 . Prt o to r/ippitaranc o lo rOl t b yHarol d J Funi , Esq , Certificat e o fCompletio n o fCop e Progra m fo rPIt fo n 11/18/0 6 Hrii o fo rwitlidrawn l o fAppnnriin<:; c b yS Mille rEs q fo rdf i wit h cemficstio n tnat H j Pun t Es q ho s antere d hi s appeamno s fo r.'r.dm c l.v.titio rliM ' Spcr.i.i l l<f.lio1 ' ^•'0 0 t: ' ^ N ^i;, ci C spi)C., ri s:':Oi' . caLiS n No w12/6/06 . upo n motio n o fH j Fun tEsq , ett yfo ra h s rul e i s issue d upo n ptt i t o sho wcaus e wh yrn e petitio n fo rspsa^ i roh^ f shoul d no tb e grsnte d Rul e rsiumetbi co n 12/20/0 6 m 93 0 am , O R 5B.LCC H B ym e court - /s/ AM P.lac k J . PnriCio n toi-Specia l Rcllo l an d exclusiv e possessio n t o resid e i n th e monts i residenc e File d b yptt f Rul e l o appou r8 i slin wcaue o No w12/11/06 , upo n motio n o fAM Muir . attyfarpltl . a rul e i s issue d upo n dt i t o sho wcsus e wh yth e petitio n fo rspecia l relie fshoul d notbegrante d Rijl( > returnabl e o n 12/20/0 5 e r9:3 0 ar u O R 5B.LCC H B yth e com./S/ AM Blec KJ Answc i - Repl y- RC!»|JOtiSi ; to dft' s petitio n fo rspeas i relief . File d b ypit f Answe r r o petitio n lo rspecis trelie fen d fo rexclusiv e possessio n t o resid e i n th e mants l residenc e File d b ydf t Cu:iTocl yAyrenmcn t an d order : No w12/20/06 . th e partie s sr s directe d t o compl ywit h th e term s o fth e attacn& d egreemen t whic h i s hereb yadopte d a s a n orde ro fcourt . B yth e court , /s / J B Johnso n J . Copie s mld/di<td 1/2/0 7 Motio n fo rAppoiniin<>n t 0 l a A/inscu r file d b yHarol d Funt . Es q Ma.iTf!!'; ; AppoliUmon t Oi'dor : Joh n Robert s II I Es q /s appointe d Maste ri n Divorce . /$/ AM Blac k j Afd to fConsent , Wni^ie ro fCouii':olll) g & Nnn-IVIilir.ir yServic e forplt f W/flive ro fNotic e o fIntentio n l u Reques t Entr yo fDi vDorrro c file d b ypIt f 

# hUp://publicaccc.ss.lehighcounly-ovf>/CaseDc;iail.asDX?CasclD-49697. ? ^'^>/^^nr\^( ^

## 01/25/201 1 15:3 2 FA X202493514 2 FA A + DM S gl009/01 G



# Pag e3 of9
02/02/200 7 02/05/200 7 02/07/200 7 02/07/200 7 02/071200 7 02/13/200' / 02/23/200 7 02/23/200 7 02/26/200 7 02/27/200 7 02/28/200 7 03/14/200 7 03/15/200 7 

### 03/22/200 7 03/26/200 7 03/29/200 7 04/16/200 7 Oi l {712007 04/17/200 7
04/17/200 7 04/17/200 7 

### 05/03/200 7 05/15/200 7 05/18/200 7 

### '^ic'23'200"' ' 05/24/200 7 05/24/200 7 06/01/200 7 06/12/200 7 06/19/200 7 

### 06/22/200 7
07/06/200 7 07/09/200 7 Ans\Aic r- Repl y- Rcspons y

t o petitio n fo rspecia l relie fFile d b ypIt f Peiilloi i fo rSpcciu l Rfilio i Hie d b ydf t Dft' a anawo rt o complain t an d coLinterciai m coun tI equitabl e distribution , coun t i i cugfod y Scliodulin a fJKlerT O Appr:n rRo : CustoOy/Vlsitatio n Addresse d J o pii fondenn g him/he rt o appea rfo ra mediatio n o n 3/6/0 7 e t12.3 0 p m B yth e Coun : /S / ED R Olde rfo rMediatio n wit h Do n S Klei n Es q o n 3/6/0 7 a t1 2 3 0 p m Cost s l o b e a s follows - Paymen t b yPItftS O DO. Faymm t b yOf t $50.0 0 Subsequen t paymen t b yPIt f$3 0 00 . Paymen t b yOft 13 0 00 . 8 yth e Court . /S/ED R rr;^nr,(;rip t c \

Sripiilatioi i At)ioiimen' . an d orde rNo-

w2/S/07 , ih e mthi n sgrec/7)en r/ s hereb yadopte d a s i » orde ro fcow l B yth e court . /$ / J B Johiiao n J . Petitio n We d b ydf t regardin g contemp t fo rcustod y Ruir : XSt^llcdiillii g Ordu r No wZ/23/07 . upo n motio n o fH J Fun tEsq . att yfo rdf t a rul e i s issue d upo n th e pit ft o sho wcaus e ^h yth o petitio n fo rcontemp t snout d no t b e grante d Rul e re(i;matit e o n 3/2B/0 7 at93 0 a m C R 58 , LCCh , B yth e court - /s/E D Reibma n J . Affidiwi i o fSt-i'vice : o fanswe ran d counterclaim . Pile d b yH J Fun t Es q IVlaElc rOrtlor ; Th e followin g );> •rocoininciuler i b yMuste rI n Divorce . Se e ori g /S/ED R Afflil;!\'i to i S.^rvic f j / aetitio n f a civi l contar.-ir AFile d o y,- i j run rEST , Petitio n lo rSpecia l Wt;lip l an a BWOigenc yrelie fan d contemp tto rdisbodienc e o fcour t orde ro f2/13/0 7 Pile d b ydf t Certificat e o fCompletio n o fCop e Progra m fo rDf t o n 3/7/0 7 Sliohfft ; Retur n Answor, . f^epl y- Rn.iponsf t t o dft' s petitio n fo rcivi l contemp tFilo d byplt f Applicaiioi l fo rContinilanr. o 3/28/0 7 contemp t plu s petitio n fo remergenc yrelie fi s grar-ite d an d cas e i s continue d r o nex t availabl e lis t t o 5/9/0 7 a t 9.3 0 arn , C R 5B . /s/J B JolMso n J . Pfzi a fo rAppearanc e fo rdf t b yLS Gardne rEs q Motio n t o compe l discovery . File d b ydf t Orde r No w4/17/07 , dft' s motio n t o compe l forpttf' s failur e t o answe rait' s interragstoiie s an d reques tfo rproductio n o t document s i s grante d an d pIt fshal l answe rdft' s interrogatorie s an d reques t fo rproductio n o fdocument s withi n 2 0 day s o tth e dal e o fthi s order . Se e ori g B yth e court - /s /

LJ Brenne rJ Moliui i t o compe l discovory . File d b yptt f Orde r No w4/7 7/07 , Pitt' s motio n t o compe l fo rdft' s failur e t o answe rpitf' s firs tse t o tinterrogatnnc s an d requeis tfo rproductio n o fdocument s i s grante d an d df l shel l answe rput' s firs t se t o fmteirogatorie s an d reques t fo rproductio n o fdocument s withi n 2 0 day s o fth e dat e o f thi n orde rSe e ori g B yth e cou n /s/ LJ Brenne rJ . Pia e fo rwithdrawa l o t Appcuranc c b yH J Fun tts q fo rdf t Ayvne< l Fina l Orrift r Transcrip t o fAgreemen t & Orde rNow , 5/9/07 . th e partie s ar e directe d t o compl ywit h th e term s o fsai d agreemen t whic h i s hereb y adopte d a s a n orde ro fcour tAheanrt g wil l b e hel d o n 5/22/0 7 a t 9.0 0 sm , C R 5B.LCCH . Seeong . B yth e court-/s/ J B Johnso n J . Agree d Intniin i Ordor ; No w5/18/07 . th e partie s Shal t withi n i s day s o fth e dat e o fthi s orde rrnai< e orrangemont s t o presen t themselve s an d th e childre n fo r psychoioqicci l evfiiualio n Se e ong . B yr/i ccoyr t /s/f. O Reihmo n j f-.e - C ypit f Orde r No wS/22/07 , dft' s pettio n fo rcivi l contemp t i s denie d Se e orig . B yth e r.oun . /s/ J B Jormso n J . Aflroo d Fina l Orrfo r Transcffp t o fAgreemen t & Orde rNow , 5/22/Q7 . th e partie s ar e directe d t o compl ywit h th e term s o fi-ni d agreement , rn e ora l motio n o fpit ft o wittidra whe rpetitio n fo remergenc yrelie fi s grante d an d sai d motio n i s withdraw n an d dft' s petitio n fo rspecia l emergenc y relie fan d contemp t i s grante d an d sai d motio n shal l h e marke d withdraw n Se e orig . B yth e court : /s / J B Jonnso n J An.two r t o dft' s counterclai m file d byplt f Exhibit s p- 1 an d D- 1 t o D- 4 file d Notlc u o fAppea l ti j Superio rCour t b ydf tfro m th e orde renferec / o n 5/24/07 . Afd t o fsen/ic e - witi-i m mentione d document s sen/a d upo n AM Mui rEsq . Ho n J B Johnson , cour t administratio n an d cour t reportin g Reqties i lo rtranscrip t directe d t o th e off/cia/ cour t reporte rCop yo fdocke t entrie s attached . Cop ymi d o n 6/19/0 7 t o Appellat e cou n an d Ckt l 54 7 i n th e am t o f$60.0 0 b yi S Ordf' i No w6/22/0'/ . df t i s directe d l o fil e o frecor d an d serv e B cop yo n th e tria l judg e withi n 1 4 day s fro m th e entr yo i thi s orde ra concis e sliitemen i o fn-iatters complaine d o fo n appeal . Pif fsnai l respon d t o th e dit' s statemen t withi n lOdayso fi t bein g fiiod . Seeong . B y th e court : /s /

J E Johnso n J Staiemcn l o fmatter s complaine d O fo n appea l File d b ydit . Petitio n t o Withdra wCoun.'ic l S i Ordor : No w7/9/07 , I . S Gardne rES Q i s Withdraw n a s Counse l fo rdf t m th e abov e captione d matte r/S / LJ Brenne rJ . 

# htlp://publicaccess.lehighcoiintY.or2/Casel.)clail.asnx'?C,a'sp,TT")=4Q6<-)9' > 1 T/l/i/THI n

## 01/25/201 1 15:3 2 FA X 202493514 2 

# FA A • » DM S 

# gioio/oi e

Pag e 4 of 9

07/09/200 7 07/18/200 7 07/27/200 7 07/27/200 7
07/27/200 7 07/27/200 7 07/30/200 7 Ofi/03/200 7 08/03/200 7 0«/06/200 7 C8/07/200 7 00/07/200 7 08/13/200 7 06/15/200 7 09/21/200 7 09/28/200 7 10/17/200 7 11/05/200 7 11/06/200 7 11/27/200 7 11/28/200 7 11/2S/200 7 11/2a/200 7 12/18/200 7 12/18/200 7 12/16/200 7 12/28/200 7

01/24/200 8 01/25(200 0 01/25/200 8 01/29/200 8 01/31/200 8 01/31/200 S 03/04/200 8 03/05/200 8 03/05/200 8 03/05/20C 3 Pra o to ; witlidrowii l n,'Appoiirnnci ;

tjyL S CS^rdrie rEs q fo rdt t Prii cfo rAppcaraiici. - fo rdt t B S pro-s e I'etitio n to rE-mcrgonc yRcli© ! file d b ypit f Otiin x No w7/25/07 , pitt' s petitio n fo remergenc yrelie fi s grante d an d th e of fi s hereb yenjoine d fro m subpoenain g o rotherwis e requestin g medical , psychologica l and/o rpsychiatn creqor'd s o ftn e pit fan d th e mino rchildren . Th e reques t fo ratt yfeo s o n r/x s petitio n i s denie d Se e ori g B yth e court-/s/ J B Johnso n J Petitio n fo rt-mcijjiinc yRalic i an d contemp t file d b ypit f OI'CIL'I No w7/25/07 , pitf s petitio n fo ren^ergenc yrelie fan d contemp t i s granted . Df t i s ordere d t o pa ya fi/i e i n th e am i o f$50 0 00 . Se e ong . B yth e court : /s/ J B Johnso n J (footnot e added ) Appellat e Cour t Docke rNumbe rReceive d No . 179 3 ED A290 7 Noto. s o i TRStiinoii yfilftc i o n 3/3/0 7 a t 1 2 5 9 p m Testimon yhear d 5/22/0' / befor e th e Honorabl e J 8 Johnso n J . Cou n reporter/Mar yS Miilsap s Cm/RP R Exhibit s rnentiona d bu tno tfile d St.ntcinan t Pa . RCP . 1925(a ) statemen tSe corig . B yth e court . /s/ J 6 Johnso n J Copie s mld/dk\ d Q/y0 7 PiMf . lo rApponninr.!' ! 'O rcJ'i . b yJ C Bemntei'- i Es q Cas e Transmitte d t o Superio rCour t o fP Avi e certifie d mai l f t 716 0 390 1 984 2 666 0 196 4 ( 1 envelope) . LicTo fDocKe t entrie s fo rCas e * maile d t o Anthon yM Mui rEs q o n 08/07/07 . Rotui n Car d NO . 715 0 390 1 984 2 666 0 198 4 file d Acknowledgmuii t fro m Supeiio rCour t o freceivin g recor d o n 8/8/0 7 Masic rOrtlur : Th e followin g l a recommende d Dymaste ri n divoKa . Se e ori g /s/ED R IVlHiMc rOrdor ; 'I'li o foHowinj ) ii ; locoiiimondfi d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se cong . /s/ED R 330 1 (d ) Affidavi t & notic e t o pit fFilo d b ydf t Off'v ; 330 1 (D ) GoiMUnr-Afd t AMotic o t o Pll t File d b yPit t lUlastc rOrder : rti e foUowinr i i s recoinmoMdei' : b yrvaste ri n divorc e Se e ong . /s/ED R Master' s Hejrin yOrclur : AMaster' s hearin g i s schedule d fo r3/3/0 8 a t 93 0 am . /s/ED R Appell.lt o Cour t Docke t Nlimbo i Receive d 179 3 ED A^.00 7 Ordei tro m Superio rCourt . No w9/14/07 , df tha s feils d t o compl ywit h thi s Court' s directives . Accoi-dmgl yih 6 appea l atN o 179 3 ED A200 7 I S hereb ydismisse d Pe rCuria m ll/iastci'i i Notic e scllint ; hearinf j dat e o n 3/3/0 8 a 9:3 0 a m Petitio n tile d b ydf tivgardin g appointmen t o fguardia n a a lite m lo rminor(s ) Propose d Ordo r(alte rlicarinfi ) RC|Kir t o l Hearin; ) Office r Lixr.rptioii ? ''le d h- > d' : /Vc.v , i2/2S/0 7 a n ai^umanf/sschedu(e<fo/ i 1/30/O S a f9;3 0 arn,Cft.ff l S y(fi e Court;/S/ £D Re/bma n J copie s serve d b yC. A Offic e Brie f i n respons e t o dff s brie fi n suppor to fexception s r o repor t o fcustod yhearin g offic e File d b ypit f Answo r- Repl y•l^cspons u ro dft' s exception s t o Repor t& Ptoposs d Orde ro fCustod yHceirin g Office rFile d b yPitf . Answe r- Kapl y•l>e.<!poria e t o dft' s Petitio n fo rAppointmen to fGuardia n A d Lite m fo rminors . File d b yPIt f Anawei ' •i<Gpl y- Respons e t o ne wmatte rt o exception s File d b ydf t A|>plic.itlo n fo rContinuanc e fo r1/30/0 9 hearin g i s refuse d /a/ J B Johnso n J Aliiwo r (amended ^

t o ne wmatte rt o petitio n fo rGAL . an d ej^ception s t o repor t o fcustod yheonn g officer . File d b ydf t Il/lastc rI'iider : Th e followinf j i s rocomirienrtc d b ymaste ri n divorce . Seeon g /s/ED R iVIastcr' s Notic e sctciiK i lioarlnr j da m o n 3/31/0 0 a t 9.3 0 e m Wlastor' a Hearin g Order : Arvieisior- 3 hearin g i s schedule d fo r3/31/0 8 a t 9.3 0 am . /s/ED R Fina l Ordor : No w2/27/08 , dft' s petitio n fo rappointmen t o fguardia n a d lite m i s denied . Se corig . B yth e court , /s / M AVarricchi o J . (footnot e 

# http://pubUcaccess.khighcounty.or£/CHtjeDetail.asDX?Casc:in==49rt09 7 lO/i/^/oni/ i

### 01/25/201 1 15:3 3 FA X 202493514 2 FA A DM S aOII/OI G



# Pag e5 of9

04/03/200 6 04/03/200 8 04 n 1/200 8 

### 04/17/200 8 04/17/200 8 04/25/200 8 04/29/200 8 05/08/200 8 05/08/200 8 05/20'200f i 

### 05/27/200 8 06/06/200 6 06/20/200 8 06/25/200 8 06/25/200 B D7/03/2O0 8 07/08/200 8 07/14/200 8 07/14/200 8 07/25/200 8 07/25/200 8 07/30/200 8 07/31/200 8 08/04/200 8 09/08/200 6 09/08/200 8 09/24/200 8 09/26/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 10/03/200 8 added !

C At o plucc : Kiatto i o n ih e CuHtod yTITJ I I li t fn t i Irt j /S / WE F Orde r No w4/3/08 , th e officia l cour t reports, D/a/i e Snai l i s ro produce , certif yan d fil e th e transcrip t i n thi s matter , conduce d o n 1/30/06 . Se e ong . B yth e court - /s/ M Ai/amcchi o J Ordc; ro fCua o Wlaiiarjsmcfit/Ciistott yTria l AUiichincii t No w4/10/0 8 APre-triai/Setciemon tConferenc e s/is/ / tak e plac e o n 7/23/0 8 s f9.O 0 a m wit h Custod yTria l immediatel yfollowin g a t 9 3 0 am . C R SB/S/ J 3 Johnso n J IVIastor's i Notic e scttln a tiearinc i dat e o n 5/15/O B e t 1:0 0 p m ft/iiiStur'.i I loariii yO i dor ; AMaster' s tieaim g i s schedule d fo r5/15/0 8 a t 1:0 0 p m /a / WE F Note s o fToeTillion yfile d o n 4/25/0 8 a t 1 3 3 p m Testimon yhaar d 1/30/0 8 befor e th e Honorabl e M AVarncchi o J . Cour t reporter/Dian e Snel ! Pitt' s exhihit n 1 & 2 an d dft' s exhibit s 1- 3 attached . Applicatio n fprCnntinuanCl ^ 7/23/0 8 pre-tria l conferenc e an d tria l i s grante d an d cys e / s continue d t o 7/25/0 8 a t lO'O O a m /s/J B Johnso n j . Petitio n fo rSpocia l Relie f file d b ydf t Rul e & Schedulin g Ordo r No w5/8/08 , a rul e i s issue d upo n pit ft o sho wcaus e irmyth e emergeiic ypetitio n fa i specia l ralirj l shoul d nn i /; e grunisr l ^w- . rewiriabl e o n 6/11/0 8 a t 93 0 am , C R S B B yth e ucu r/s/ J , 9 J-j' - -'= i - . :i,'(if. i rjj " i..'...i-.i' ' ii' Kii.-yii.'nu.'ii,/("'...-^o', ' r'.". . J l:,.:.,:-o:. . /\c, y5/2C/08 . APre-trial/tSertiemen tConferenc o shal l tak e plac e o n 731/0 8 a t 2:0 0 p m wit h Cu.irod yTria l immediatel yfollowin g o n 9/3/08St9.30am . S/J B Johnso n J . Answe r- Ropl y- Respons e 1 0 petitio n fo rspecia l relie fan d ne wmatte rFile d b ypit f Answe r t o ne wmatte ri n answe rt o petitio n fo rspecia l relie fFile d b ydft . Olde r No w6/20/06 . Dft' s petitio n fo rspecia l relie fi s granted . Se e on g B yth e court : /s/J B Jotmso n J . (footnot e added ) Copie s mi a 6/20/oa . Dkt d 6/23/0 6 Petitio n file d b ypit l regardin g reconsideixilion . Mnniuraiuluiv . o fla wi n suppor t o fpetitio n lo rreconsideratio n o fih e cour t orde rentere d 0/20/0 6 File d b ypit f Answe r t o petitio n fa rrecons'doration , ne wrnatts ran d motio n fo rsanction s File d b ydf t Orde r No w7/7/08 . pitf' s petitio n fo rreconsideratio n i s denied . B yth e cour t /s/J B Johnso n J . Copie s mid/dkt d 7/8/0 8 Notic e o fAppea l l o Superio rCour t tra m th e orde rdate d 7/7/0 8 filed b ypit f Aflldavi t o fService ; o fnotic e o fappea l File d b yAM Mui rEs q l^clitioi l to rContcnipt : file d b ydf t Petitio n tile d b ypit fregardin g applicatio n fo rsta ypendin g appe-al . Sfiitctnoni/OpinlOi i Date d 7/29/0 8 /S/ J 6 JOtinso n J Copie s Mi d 7/30/08. Dkt d 7/31/0 8 ivlojic co fISockctinc ) Appe.i l i n Superio rCour t unde rDk t#206 9 ED A200 8 Orde r Wo w7/31/08 , pitf' s petitio n i s grante d sn d th e 6/20/0 8 orde ri s staye d unti l m e pendin g appea l i s dosed . .9e o on g B yth e coun - /s / J B .lohnso n J . Copie s mi d 8/4/08 ' Dkt d 8/5/Ol s 0|-,l- ; '.z. : :-.= ; 5'5': * :3=.':se'," ; ;"i;.- e S^z-er.c - CZJ - z - ^irrs y/s,r.f . ;/:-se - cs:e cz<7&rC5 , quasnectn e appea l o frh e 7/7/0 3 ora& r ; / /.'u e z ' :n e a.Tarns a Order . Se e Ongina LB yth e Cou n /s / J. S Johnso n J . copie s mi d 9/8/OR , dkt a 9/9/OB . Scnodulinf j Order : (Amended. ) No w9/5/08 . pre-trial/settlemen t conferenc e I s schedule d o n 12/22/0 8 @ 9.0 0 a.m . befor e honorabl e J.B . Jotmso n i n courtroo m 5B . custod ytrio l schedule d 12/22/0 8 <^ 9.3 0 a.m . befor e honorabl e J.B . Johnso n i n courtroo m 5B . /S / J. B Johnson , J . Copie s mi d 9/6/0 9 dktd . 9/9/08 . Petitio n fo rEmcraeiic yRelie f (special ) File d b ydf t Schedulint j Order ; 4 hearin g i s scnedule d fo r10/20/0 8 a r9:3 0 a m C R 5S . /S/JB J Appellat e Cour t Docke tMunibo rRecolve d 206 9 ED A200 8 Orde r fro m Superio rCour t o fP ANo wdfi' s motio n t o quas h appea l I S grante d Pe rCuriam . ExhIDil: : fro m dat e o fseparatio n hearing s o n 3/3./D6 , 3/31/0 3 an d 5/15/0 8 Transcrip t o fMastor'." . Ilearlnc j henr d o n 3/3/0 8 a t 9-J 7 e m Transcrip t o fIVIastcr' s HnJirint | hear d o n 3/31/0 8 af9.-J 7 am . Volum e i i irLinsci'tp t o i Masrer' s Hourin g liciii d o n 5/15/0 8 a t 1 1 5 pm . Volum e il l Maste rOrder : Tti e foHowinf ; i s rnr.oinmerider l 

# hUp;//pvjblicaccess.lehighcot.iT\tY.orii/Caser)ci-Ail.asnx?C.tisein=4<-M99 ? i7/i/^/'7mr t

### ,1/25/201 1 15:3 3 FA X202493514 2 FA A • > QM S 

### 1012/01 6



# Pag e6 of 9

10/06/200 6 10/17/200 8 10/17/200 6 10/17/200 8 10/22/200 6 10/20/200 8
10/29/200 6 10/31/200 8 11/05/200 R --;J5'20O 6 11/05/300 8 11/14/200 8 12/22/200 8 12/24/200 8 01/06/200 9 01/07/200 8 01/16/200 9 02/03/200 9 02/11/200 9 02/19/200 9 03/03/200 9 03/04/200 9 03/19/200 9 ,: 3 • = 2;- ^ 04/15/200 9 04/20/200 9 04/27/200 9 

### 015/12/2009 05/26/200 9 05/29/200 9 06/04/200 9 06/04/200 9 b ymaste rm divorce . Se e ori g /£ / WB F Orde r Now . thi s 9/29,'0 8 I t i s oixiere d tha t a transcrip t o fth e proceeding s i n th e abov e captione d cas e o n 7/31/0 8 shal l b e tranKnbe d an d provido d ro (h e requesto rSe e Original . B yth e Coun , /s/ J 8 . Johnsnn , J Divorc e Exception:- . t o orde ro f10/3/O 8 File d b ydf l Answe r f o petitio n fo remergenc yrelie fan d nev t matte rFile d b ypit f Answci ' t o CusTod yplcadini j r o ne wmarra rf o petitio n fo rspecia l relie fFile d b ydft . Oidfi i No w10/20/08 , dft' s petitio n fo remergenc yspecia l relie fwil l b e deferre d fo rconsideratio n unti l 12/22/0 8 Seeori g tiythecoun /s/ J 6 Johnso n J Copie s mi d 10/22/08 . Dkt d 10/24/0 8 Orde r Wow , thi s 10/20/08 , upo n consideratio n o ftli e Df t ' j Patitio n fo rBrtiergenoe ySpecia l Relief . Pitf' s repl ytheret o an d Ne wfvlattar , i t i s Ordere d tha t sai d petitior i an d repl ywil t b s oofene d fo rconsideratio n unti l tim e o ftna l o n 12/22/08 . Se e Original . B yth e Court , /s / J . B . Johnson . J . Copie s mid/dkt d 10/29/0 9 Notfti i o fTestimon yfile d o n 10/29/0 8 a t 0-5 7 am . Testimon yhear d 7/31/0' d befor e th e Honorabl e J B Johnso n Cour t reporter , Mar yS Miiisap s Wlotio n File d b ydft . Regardin g reconsideratio n AITiwc r [ 0 moBo n fo rrecon.tidoratio n o forde ro f10/20/O S =''e " i.'/.."; ' U.l, ! • Wow , Tini s 11/5/08 , I t I S Ordere d tha t Dft . ' s motio n lo rcontemp t i s deferre d to rconsldsiatio n unti l tim e o ftria l o n 12/22/0 8 Se e Origina l B yth e Court . /3/J. B Johnson , J copie s mi d 11/&/0B . dni d 11/6/0 8 Orde r Now . r/ii 3 11/5/0 8 i t i s Ordere d ttiafOft.' a Motio n lo rReconsiderelio/ i ofir m Orde ro f10/20/08 , i s Denied . Se e Origina l B yth e Courf . /s/J.B . Johnson , J . Copie s mi d 11/5/0 8 dktdil/6/0 B l\ul e & ScUodiilin g Ordn r No w11/14/08 , upo n motio n o fJ C Bernstei n Es q a rul e i s issue d 'Jpo n pit ft o sho wcaus e wh yexception s t o tn e orde ro f10/3/0 3 shoul d no t b e grante d Rul e mtumabl e o n 1/21/0 9 a t 9-3 0 am , C R SB . B yth e court - /s/J B Johnso n J Finding s o fFac t r.n d Concuisicii s o fLa w an d memorandu m o flaw . File d b ydf t (proposed ) Interi m Orde r Now . thi s 12/23/0 8 i t i s Ordered , PIt fshal l exercis e sol e lega l custod yo fchil d Se e Original . B yth e Cour t /s/J. B Johnson , J Copie s mid/dkt d 12/24/0 8 Brift i m suppor t o fexception s File d b ydf t Ordo ro fCat- ctifl-iniiaemant/Cusiod yTi'iii l Attac.hmei M No w1/7/09 , Custod ytria l shel l resum e o n 2/b/0 9 @ 93 0 a m i n courtroo m 5b . Se e Origina l B yth e Coun . /s/J.B . Johnson , J Copie s mi d 1/7/09 . dkt d 1/8/0 9 Brin f i n oppositio n t o exception s t o a 10/3/0 8 orde rOfcourt . File d bypltf . Ordt' i Now . this2/2/0 9 i t i s Ordere d dil.' s exception s t o orde rfile d 10/17/08 , ar e denie d Se e Oiigirtal . B yth e Coun./s/ J B Johnson , J Copie s mi d 2/3/09 , dkt d 2/2/09 . Orde r Now . thi s 2/10/09 , i t I S Ordered , tha t a transcrip t o t trial s hel d m abov e captione d cas e shal l b e transcribe d an d provide d t o th e requesto rSe e Original . B yth e Cour t /s/J. B Johnson , j . copie s mi d 2/11/0 9 dkt d 2/12/0 9 Maste rOidur : Th e followin g i s recommando d b ymaste ri n divorce . Se e ori g /s / WE F Mastvr' s Hearin g Order ; AMastert s hearin g i s schedule d fo r5/19/0 9 AN D 5/20/0 9 @ 9.3 0 A.M . /s / WE F K/la.'.Tci-' a Wutici ^

sertiii g hoarihf l dat e o n 

### 5/19/0 9 an d5/20/0 9 a i 9-3 0 am ll.;.'.-!'.'L ; Wiilici. ' v.fjriiif ; llf.'iTi,. n < :.. . • . i , z'2 8 0 9 =,- 3 3 : s - .'.'rjr.:. , s ned,'inr_ ; Oracr : AMaster' s neann g i s schedule d fo r5/28/0 9 a t 9:3 0 a m /s / WE F Orde r No wthi s 4/14/0 9 i t i s Ordered . PIt f' u petitio n fo rReconsideratio n I S Denied . Se e Origina l B yth e Cou n /s/ J B Johnson,J . Copie s mid/dkt d 4/15/0 9 Chiiiiq e O

t Addfoa s file d b ydf t Orde r Now , thi s 4/27/09 . I t I S omened . PItf . ' S motio n i s Denie d an d mi s Coun' s 4/1/0 9 Orde rdenyin g Ih e pitf' s petitio n a t docke t # 2006-FC 126 8 I S hereb yvacated . Se e Original . B yth e court . /s/J. B Johnson , J . Copie s mi d 4/27/0 9 dkt d 4/28/09 . Pretria l Stiitemcii t File d b yDtt . n/laslo i Order : I'li e folluwlnr ] i n i^oominendu d b ymaste rm divorc e Se e ong . /t- / WE F )Was7c rOiflOi' ; 'I'h cfollowini j i s itscommoiido d b ymaste ri n drvorce . Se e on g /s / 'WE F Note s o fTestimon yfilo d o n 6/4/0 9 a t 3:1 0 p m Testimon yhear d 12/22/0 8 befor e th e Honorabl e J B Johnso n J Cour t reporte rMai yR Milisaps , RPR-CMR . (volum e 1 ) Note s o fTesiiiTion yfile d o n 6/4/0 9 a t 3-1 0 p m Testimon yhisarc l 12/23/0 9 befor e th e Honorabl e j B Johnso n J . Cou n reporter , Mar yR Milisaps . HPR-CMR . CVoium e 2 ) 

# hup;//pub]icacces3.lehighcouniy.or>i/Ca.'5eDtitail.asDx?Casel 10=49(^97 7 I •~ > I t <;/•*)(•• > I <-

\

## 01/25/201 1 15:3 3 FA X 202493514 2 

# FA A DM S 12013/01 6

Pag e 70( 9
06/04/200 9 06/17/200 9 06/26/200 9 06/26/200 9 06/28/20Qf

i 07/02/200 0 U7/07/200 9 07/07/200 9 07/07/200 9 07/07/200 9 

### 3 7 ,7,200 9 07/20/200 9 07/21/200 9 07/22/200 9 07/24/200 9 07/29/200 9 

### 07/31/200 9 08/07/200 9 09/04/200 9 09/16/200 9 09/16/200 9 09/23/200 9 10/05/200 9 10/21/2C0 9 -:2-.'200 & 10/27/200 9 11/09/200 9 11/24/200 9 n/24/200 9 n/24/200 9 12/02/200 9 12/03/200 9 12/04/200 9 12/04/200 9 01/05/201 0 01/05/201 0 liiia l CuatorJ yOrder ;

Nov n thi s 6/3/0 9 i t i s Ordere d mothe rshal l exerc/s e sol e lega l custod yo fth e chil d Se a Ongms l B yth e Cour t /s/J. B Johnson,; . copie s mi d 6/4/0 9 dkt d 6/5A) 9 Ordo r No wB/16/09 , a transcrip to fth e benc h opinio n hel d o n 6/3/0 9 shal l b e transcribe d an d provide d t o ih e requesto rSe e orig . B yth e court . /s/ J 8 Johnso n J Copie ? mi d 6/18/09 . DKt d 6/19/0 9 Wlasior' s Hearirif ) Order : AMaster' s hearin g i s sctiedule d fo r9/9/09 , 9/10/09 . 9/11/0 9 /s / WE F !'i/l,'»i5ter' s Notic e ."^cttiD yhearin ydat e o n 9/9/09 , 9/10/09 , 9/11/0 9 WlinTc rOrder ; lli e followinc i i s reconmendB d Ij ymaste rr n divorc e Se e orig . /s / WE F copie s mi d 6,'29/0 9 dkt d 7/1/0 9 Note.= ! otitstinion ytile d o n 7/2/0 9 a t3:5 1 p m Testimon yhear d 6/3/0 9 befor e ili e I lonorobi e J B Johnso n J Cour t reporte rMar yS Milisaps . RPR-CM R Rul e i i Sclinduliii g Orde r Wow . thi s 7/7/09 , upo n motio n ofJc , bemsiein . Es q a nii e i s issue d upo n th e Pit ft o sho wcaus e wh yDft' s motio n fo rsanction s shoul d no t b e granred . Rul e Returnabl e o n 7/27/0 9 @ 9.3 0 a. m i n C R 1 C B yth e Cour t /s/J B Johnson , J . Motio n File d b yDf rRegardin g Motio n fo rSanction s Re(|uos l Deman d fo rRevie wfilo d b yDf t Rul e & Srhodiiliiif j Orde r Now , thi s 7/7/09 . upo n motio n of. I C Bemsrei n Es c. = :^:i e i s iss.- H -r; - -•"; - i'-^. : "j,i' = :- , .': : i ;e-='i - •: •i . e.- . s.-.z^. z 'c . b e gr-antc- d Rul e returnabl e o n 7/22/S 9 '^j ^ 9.3 0 a r n m C R 1 C Q ytn e Cour t .'S/J B Jonnson . J . Aiijwo i . , .•<upl y- ROMpon^i c ( o Dft' s deman d to rrevie wo fa cour torde ro n 6/29/0 9 Fiio d b yPIt f Answe r- Repl y•

•Respon.i O t o Dft' s motio n fo rsanction s File d b yPit f Tr.'jiiacrip t o fMlsster' ? Hearin g hear d o n 5-27/0 9 Answe r- Repl y- Kospons s t o Pitt' s Ne wmatte ran d Counte rpetitio n t o deman d fo rrevie wFile d b yDf r Stipulatio n Anc fOrder . No wthi s 7/22/09 . i ti s Ordere d attache d agreemen t o l th e partie s i s adopte d an d entere d a s a n orde ro fcoun . Se e Origina l B yth e Coun/s/ J 8 Johnson . J . Copie s mid/dkt d 7/24/0 9 

### Orde r Wow7/26/09 , pit fi s prohibite d Iro m presentin g an yevidenc e regardin g th e valu e o fUi e marita l residenc e unti l sh e allow s dft' s appraise raccess . PIt fi s directe d t o fil e a pre-tria l statemen t witii m today s o fth e dar e o fthi s orde rSe e ong . B yth e court : /&/J e Johnso n J . Copie s mi d //29/0 9 TjM d 7/30/D 9 Pretria l Statrrinen l File d b yPit f Transcrip t o l Nla«iler' s IJearini j lioarr i o n 

### 5/28/200 9 Orde r Now . thi s 9/2/0 9 i t I S Ordered , tha t a transcrip t o fth e proceeding s i n th e above-ceptione d cas e o n 7/22/09 . shal l b e transcribe d an d provide d t o th e requesto rwit h conditions . Se e Origina l B yth e Cou n /s i J B Johnson . J copie s mi d 9/-W 9 dkt d 9/9/0 9 NlasKir'." ; Notic o scllin n hearm o dat e o n 11/4/09 , 11,/S/09 . 12/2/09 . 12/3/09 . Nlastor'r . Hearin g Order ; AMaster s hearin g i s schedule d fo r11/4/0$
. 11/5/09 , 12/2/09 . 12/3/0 9 @ 93 0 a m . /s / W£ F copie s mi d 9/16/0 9 dkt d 9/17./0 9 Note s o l Tftsiimon yfilo d o n 9/23/0 9 Testimon yhear d 7/22/0 9 befor e th e l-tonorabl e J B Johnson . J Cour t reporte rElizabot h Rocchino . Exhibit s liste d bu t no t attache d Ivlolic e o fEleclin n t o RutaH e Nani u fro m Gai l R Seli g t o Qai i France s Reeshme n "rcinBCrip fo i Wl.jal;ei' s Honriri H hcjirt i o n y/S/D 9 Volum e 3 'i:g',nscii;) Lr>i i/ij.'.a'r'? , :ira"ii,i , :T<.'iir c-" , i -;,C rJcr-.e' - Exhibit s Dff' s Ml, 2 fro m iieenn g o n 7/22/0 9 IVIaste rOlder : Th e followin g i s rar.ommcnde d b ymaste rm divorce . Se e orig . /s / WE F copie s mtd/aM d 11/9./0 9 Nole- j o frtsTiiTion ytile d o n 11/24/0 9 Testimon yhear d 6/3/0 9 befor e th e Honorabl e JB J Cour t repone rMar / Milisap s Noto o o frcstinion ytile d 01711/24/0 9 Testimon yhear d 3/ i i/0 9 befor e th e Honorabl e JQ j Cou n reporte rl/iar yMilisap s Note s o fTestimon ylilc d Oi l 11/24/0 9 Testimon ynear d 2/5/0 9 befor e th e Honorabi Q JB J Cour t reporte rMar yiviiiisap s Tr.inscnp t o fWlastor' s Hearin g heur d e n 11/4/09 , Volum e 5 TraiiBcrip t o fIKlastor'r , lloariii g neurc ) o n 11/5/0 9 Volum e 6 luliistcr' s Notic e i-.ettin yheariiif i d;,it e r> n 1/1 3 an o 1/14/1 0 @ 9-3 0 a.m . Nlfti'-lor' s tlearin a Order ; AMaster' s heerin g i s schedule d ta r1/1 3 an d 1/14/0 9 /s/WE F copie s mi d 12/4/0 9 dkt d 12/7/0 9 Transcrip t o frvlyscftr' s t-leiirinc i lianr d o n 12/2/0 9 Volum e 7 Transcrip t o fMaster' s Hoariii g hear d o n 

# htip://publicaccess.lchighcouriiy,ore/CaseDciiiil.asDX?Ca,seTl)-49f=iQ'^'7 10/ 1 £.iir\\i \

## 01/25/201 1 15:3 3 FA X 202493514 2 FA A * DM S gl014/01 6



# Pag e 8 O f9

02/16/201 0 02/17/201 0 03/01/201 0 03/01/201 0 03/23/201 0 03/23/201 0 03/30/201 0 04/06/201 0 04/07/201 0 04/07/201 0 04/12/201 0 C^/25/201 0 04/26/201 0 05/04/201 0 05/17/201 0 05/17/201 0 05/04/201 0 

### 06/04/201 0 OG/07/201 0 06/07/201 0 

### 06/22/201 0 C6/24/201 0 06/25/201 0 07/01/201 0 07/13/201 0 07/14/201 0 

### 07/22/201 0 08/02/201 0 

### Z z '22Z' I 08/17/201 0 08/17/201 0 08/20/201 0 09/10/201 0 09/15/201 0 09/22/201 0 10/01/201 0 10/05/201 0 10/07/201 0 12/3AJ 9 volum e 8

Winstci' s Henrin a Ordt>r ; AMastar' s iiearin g i s schedule d lo r4/5/1 0 (^ 9 3 0 a m /s / WE F copie s mi d 2/16/1 0 dkt d 2/17/i o lUliister s NoUc p settin g licariui j d,il e o n 4/5/10 ®

9-30a m Transcrip to fH/iaster'.'- . Ho,^riri g henr d y n 1/13/1 0 @ 9-4 0 s. m Transcrip to fil/lfliter' s Hearinc i lloai d o n 1/14/101^9-4 5 am . Petitio n t o lis t marita l hom e fo rsal e File d b ypu t f<ul e t o Sho wCiiiS u Rul e reiurnabi u fo r4/16/1 0 a t9.3 0 a m./s/JB J rtulct o Sho wCaus e fo r4/14/1 0 a t 9 3 0 a.m . /s / WE F copie s mi d b yC A Answe rt o Paritlo n fo rSpecia l (tolie f file d b ydf t Petitio n fo rtransfe ro fownership . File d b ydf t Rul e 1 0 Sho wCaus o fo r4/14/1 0 s f9.3 0 a.m . /s/JB J Anawe r r o dft' s petitio n to rtransfe rFile d b y/ I Mui rLs a 

### uni):;- ; I'vo'.v , Apri l 26 . 201 0 th e transcrip to fora l argumen t ti e provide d l o requeste rwit h sai d condition s Se e ori g B yIh e court ' /s / JB J copie s mi d & dkt d 4/26/1 0 Transcrip t o fIVIastcr' s l-learini J Iieflr d o n Apri l 5 , 201 0 a t 93 5 a m . Volum e I I Cour t Reporter . Bonni e Becke r ORDI- R Now . 5/3/1 0 ordere d tha t Raymon d C . (Seiger , J ri s appointe d t o perfor m res ! estat e appraisal s fo rth e rea l propert ySe e ong . B yth e court , /s /

JB J copie s mi d & dkt d 5/1/1 0 Petitio n fo rEtiturc.'ijici n file d b ydI L Rul e S . ScliGdiitlnc ) Orde r i'Jote B o t Te.';tlnion vfile d hear d o n 4/14/1 0 befor e r/) S Horiorabi e Judg e Bria n J Johnson . Cour t Reporter : Mai yR Milisaps , RPR-CM R Transcrip t o fIWastur' s Hearin g liear d o n Ma y10 . 201 0 a t 1:1 0 p m befor e Maste rJoh n Roberts , II I Cour t Reporte rBonni e Becker . RP R Kui e & Schedulin g Oido r Petitio n io rSpecia l Kclie t fo rdivorc e File d b-

yatt yBorn.itcin . Exhibit s attached . Anawe rl o Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie f ari d Ne wMatte rtile d b ypit f Answe r- Rspi y- Hoapons c t o aff' s petitio n fo rbifurcatio n an d ne wmatter . File d b ypitf . AffidavJ L regardin g divorc e expense s File d b ydf t Answe r- Repl y- Respons e b ydf t t o ne wmatte ro fpitt' s repl yt o dit' s petitio n fo rbifurcation . Hoaring i Schedulin g Orde r (Amended ) OKPF.F : Now . 7/9/1 0 ordere d tha tdf ti s directe d t o sig n agreemen t o fsal e alon g wit h th e seller' s disclosur e fomi . Se e on g B yth e court : /s / JB J Copie s rni d 7/14/1 0 dkt d 7/15/1 0 Affidlivi t o flega l expenses . File d b ypit f Hei.riiif , .••••c;ii,>i-iiili!i( i rii(,l2 r 'Ar'i"iec' ' Now , 8/12/1 0 ordere d tha torde rdate d 7/30/1 0 i s vacated . Se e orig . B yth e Cour t/s/JBJ . Copie s mi d 8/12/1 0 Dkt d 8/13/1 0 Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie f File d b yatt yBemste m Exhibit s attache d fUil s S . Schcdulinf j Orde r Aflidavi t o fLega l Expense s File d b ydf t ORDE R Now . 9/14/1 0 ordere d tha tpetitio n fo rbifurcatio n i s denisd . Se e oriq . B yth e Cour t /s/'JB J copie s & 23 6 notic e mi d 9/15/1 0 & dkt d 9/16/1 0 ORDt=.f i Now , 9/14/1 0 ordere d tha t ora l motio n b ypit fI S grante d an d Defendant' s Petitio n fo rSpecia l Relie fl a denied . Se e ong . B yth e Court . ./S/JB J copie s & 23 0 notic e mi d 9/15/1 0 d dkt d 9/16/1 0 ORDE R Now . 8/70/7 0 ordere d tha t a ti'ansorip i o fth e proceeding s o n 9/14/1 0 shal l b e tianacribe d an d pr-uvide d t o Requesto rbase d o n condition s Se e orig . B yth e Court : /s/jBJ . CopieF . an d Rul e 23 6 Nonc e Mi d 9/22/1 U Dkt d 9/23/1 0 Answe rt o Petitio n lo rSpecia l Relie f file d b yatt yMui r Pra e l o Attacli/Sut5StiUir c exhibi tl o Repl yo fPlaintif ffile d o n lO/l/IO . File d b yatt yMui r CuHiod yHearin g Schedulin g 0«iur : (Amended ) /S/JB J Copie s an d Rul e 23 6 Notic e Mi d 10/6/1 0 Dkt d 10/8/1 0 

# hUp://publicaccess.lehighcounty.org/C^L<;cDetaiLaspx?CaseTD-49692 2 17/ 1 ^/'7fn( i

## 01/25/201 1 15:3 3 FA X202493514 2 FA A + DM S gl015/01 G



# Pag e9 of 9

10/11/201 0 10/25/201 0 11/17/201 0 ORDE R

Now , 10/6/1 0 ordsre d t/ia ( a ncarin g o n thi s petitio n I s coiitinue d unti l 1 i/is/l O a t 9 3 0 9 m Se e oo g B y(fi e Cour t /. vJBJ . Copie s an d Rul e 23 6 Notic e Mi d IO/11/1 0 Dkt d 10/12/1 0 tiate: - o fJrstirnon yfile d o n 10/25/1 0 % 2-5 2 p m Testimon yhear d 9/14/1 0 befor e th e Honorabl e Judg e Bria n Johnso n Cour t repone rMsr yR Milisap s OKDE R Norn , 11/15/10 , Ordere d tha t upo n agreenion t o fth e partie s throug h counsel , th e with m mentione d item s shal l b e provide d t o th e Divorc e Master , Joh n Roberts . Esquire , fo rhi s consideration . Se e on g B yth B cnun . /s / .!BJ . Copie s S, 23 6 riofic e mi d 11/17/1 0 Dkt d 11/18/10 . I'lNANflAl . tiMORMATIO N

01/11/200 7 01/11/200 7 02/14/200 7 02'14/P00 7 

### : 2 2 3 2:!: 7 02/23/200 7 06/19/200 7 06/19/200 7 08/02/200 7 08/02/200 7 07/25/200 8 07/25/200 ^ Defendan t Selig . Michae l B

Tota l Financia l Assessmen t Tota l Payrneni s an d Credit s Balanc e Du e a s o f12/16/201 0 Transaaio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen tReceip l # 20Q7-07S 7 Transactio n Assessmen t Paymen l Receipt * X007-03''7 0 T'ransactio n Assessmen i Counte rPaymen t Receipl « 2007-0379 3 Transactio n Assessmen t Paymen t Receipt « 2007-01242 0 Transactio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen tReceipt * 2007-01593 S Transactio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen tReceipl « 2008-016O2 3 

### Mosebflc h i^Liiit nayio n KUuckwcri n PC ",'3S5.'3c. " -^J'' : rsj" ; 

### funt , Harol d J Gardner , Lind a Sha

y Litelin e Cardiolog y Berrsiein , Josep h C J - S I 3„C-<, .



### Esq ,0,-,- , .- c 902.5 0 902.0 0 0.0 0 250,0 0 (25 0 no ^ iiti.OO j 

### 2 4 7 5 (24,75 ) 55,0 0 (55.00 ) 500,0 0 (500,00 ) 2 2 7 5 (22.75 )

10/10/200 6 10/1C/200 6 03/06/200 7 03/06/200 7 07/14/200 8 07/14/200 8 Plaintif fRoeshman , Gai l France s

Trtta l Financia l Assessmen t Tota l Payment s an d Credit s Balanc e Du e a s o f12/16/201 0 Transactio n Assessmen l Counte rPaymen t Receipt * 2006-02137 3 Transactio n A-iisessmeri t Counte rPaymen t Receipt * 2007-0451 0 Transactio n Assessmen t Counte rPaymen t Receip t #2008-01479 1 Scoblionk p Selig , Gai l R Scoblionk o & ScoblionK o Mui rBartholome w& Melrna n 430.0 0 4300 C 0.0 0 

### 325.0 0 (325.00 ) 50.0 0 (50.00 ) 55.0 0 (55,00 )



# hUp;//publicacces5i.leliighcouniy.org/CaseI,)ciiiil.aspx?C-ascID=49692 2 12/16/201 0

## 01/25/201 1 15:3 4 FA X 202493514 2 FA A* DM S l^Olb/Ul b

U.S . DEPARTMEN TO fTRANSPORTATIO N Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Cynthi o Dorninik , Laur a Ponto , Lotony o William s Complainant s M i R Helicopters . LLC .

_Responden t Docl<et : 2010-121 1

CERTIFICATE O F SERVIC E I HEREB YCERll l Ytha tI hav e thi s da yserve d th e toregoin g entile(.s) : 

# RESPONDENT' S REPL

YB YWA YO F OBJECTIO N T O COMPLAINANT S MOTIO N FO R PROCEDURA LSCHEDUL E IMPOSITION S upo n al l portie s o t recor d i n thi s proceeding , I n occordanc e wit h th e requirement s o fRul e 2 9 pursuan t t o 28U . S. C. § 1746 . Servic e b yfirst-clas s mail , postag e prepaid , addresse d a s followj : Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Wilbu rWrigh t Avenue-Suit e 2w i 00 0 Washington , D.C . ::j059 1 Aft : Hearin g Docke t Clerk . AGC-43 0 ;XFAX20 2 49 3 514 2 

## Th e Honorabl e Ronni e A , Yode r U S Deportmen t o t Tronsportatio n Offic e o fHearings , M-20 , Roo m E l 2-32 0 1200 Nev^

' Jerse yAvenue , S.E . Washington . D C 2059 0 i - FA X202^366 753 6 Cynthi a Dorninik , F.<;q. E-.'c;rca,r,en : 3;v;5ion/AGC-30 0 Offic e o fth e Chie fCounse l FA A 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Washington , D C 2059 1 ' » \* i j i II I l yI \^ i I f\-~f\^ ^ ^\j- j f\

1 , 

## ^ - FA X202 26 7 510 6 , , 'x^ ^ 'X^ ^ By;_ . Michae l B . Selig , MO . FACC , : , \ 281 6 Orefiel d Roa d ; ^ ^- \ '^ " Allentown . Pa . 18104 . •s-'-y^' ' 61 0 36 0 395 3 \ ^'^~ " Date :