Attachment A-2. Variability Analysis for CO From Existing FB Units

Facility Name Unit ID Pollutant

Run 

No. Flag ND Raw Data

Raw Data 3-

run Test 

Averages

Random 

Numbers

Randomly 

Distributed 

Raw Data

Randomly 

Distributed 

Raw Data 3-

run Test 

Averages 

Lntransformed 

Data

Lntransformed 

Data 3-run 

Test Averages 

Lntransformed 

Randomly 

Distributed 

Data

3 Run Test 

Averages of Lntransformed 

Randomly 

Distributed Data

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 4.07 305829 31.01652893 1.403642999 3.434520254

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 4.55 223349 47.04615385 1.515127233 3.851129117

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 4.63 4.416666667 943219 20.016 32.69289426 1.532556868 1.4837757 2.996531954 3.427393775

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 0.6 887401 38.96212121 -0.510825624 3.662589923

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 1.2 495440 76.89361702 0.182321557 4.342422869

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 0.8 0.866666667 670932 56.92988204 57.59520676 -0.223143551 -0.183882539 4.041820371 4.015611055

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 6.77 269019 36.98165138 1.912501087 3.610421881

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 15.8 978023 48.51886792 2.76000994 3.881952752

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 11.6 11.39 425784 56.15567376 47.21873102 2.451005098 2.374505375 4.028127723 3.840167452

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 3.43 773653 68.70114943 1.232560261 4.22976593

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 0.255 85254 0.5 -1.366491734 -0.693147181

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 0.118 1.267666667 718853 29.26315789 32.82143577 -2.137070655 -0.757000709 3.376329315 2.304316022

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 34.09433962 808267 0.8 3.529131377 -0.223143551

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 33.46296296 582717 32.17592593 3.510439244 3.471218531

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 30.32727273 32.62819177 471841 11.6 14.85864198 3.412047398 3.483872673 2.451005098 1.899693359

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 26.73076923 508358 30.32727273 3.285815308 3.412047398

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 34.0106383 875725 30.75221239 3.526673367 3.425961939

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 32.07692308 30.93944354 265856 45.90825688 35.66258067 3.468136864 3.42687518 3.826644989 3.554884775

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 28.04385965 981047 5.94017094 3.333769701 1.781737911

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 31.77142857 350791 33.46296296 3.458567413 3.510439244

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 31.01652893 30.27727238 497394 11.27027027 16.89113472 3.434520254 3.408952456 2.422168309 2.571448488

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 28.04385965 366088 15.8 3.333769701 2.76000994

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 31.77142857 84374 49.05882353 3.458567413 3.893020058

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 31.01652893 30.27727238 616073 10.90196078 25.25359477 3.434520254 3.408952456 2.388942662 3.013990887

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 47.65714286 330981 15.13861386 3.864032521 2.717248689

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 49.05882353 48.35798319 651060 36.64545455 25.8920342 3.893020058 3.87852629 3.601289397 3.159269043

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 26.13675214 969267 36.71698113 3.263342452 3.603239349

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 17.82051282 854120 58.73139403 2.880350199 4.072974405

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 18.28947368 20.74891288 284164 12.8487395 36.09903822 2.906325686 3.016672779 2.553245713 3.409819822

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 33.62903226 580353 17.82051282 3.515389749 2.880350199

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 31.70175439 45883 1.34 3.456372023 0.292669614

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 38.96212121 34.76430262 360411 47.65714286 22.27255189 3.662589923 3.544783898 3.864032521 2.345684112

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 30.75221239 556511 14.02752294 3.425961939 2.641021324

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 32.17592593 486904 43.4375 3.471218531 3.771323123

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 29.26315789 30.73043207 225108 16.51485149 24.65995814 3.376329315 3.424503262 2.804260066 3.072201504

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 12.41071429 339117 17.82051282 2.518560155 2.880350199

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 14.02752294 915204 34.09433962 2.641021324 3.529131377

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 8.460869565 11.6330356 337948 16.77586207 22.89690484 2.135451954 2.431677811 2.819941072 3.076474216

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 10.90196078 734147 3.15669947 2.388942662 1.14952701

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 15.13861386 892700 21.20338983 2.717248689 3.054161067

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 5.94017094 10.66024853 303844 10.20183486 11.52064139 1.781737911 2.29597642 2.322567593 2.175418556

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 12.33064516 805705 18.25252525 2.51208764 2.90430344

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 12.33064516 387447 48.58252427 2.51208764 3.883263883

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 12.33064516 12.33064516 387371 31.77142857 32.86882603 2.51208764 2.51208764 3.458567413 3.415378246

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 1.67 440275 60.7224151 0.512823626 4.106312907

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 1.45 629990 8.460869565 0.371563556 2.135451954

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 1.34 1.486666667 475860 1.67 23.61776156 0.292669614 0.392352266 0.512823626 2.251529496

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 12.8487395 492758 39.13592233 2.553245713 3.667040775

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 17.82051282 505792 12.33064516 2.880350199 2.51208764

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 16.77586207 15.81503813 442405 0.255 17.2405225 2.819941072 2.751178995 -1.366491734 1.604212227

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 48.51886792 900081 12.33064516 3.881952752 2.51208764

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 45.90825688 98954 62.68733348 3.826644989 4.138159409

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 43.13793103 45.85501861 676743 21.56896552 32.19564805 3.76440268 3.824333474 3.0712555 3.24050085

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 59.17821782 187395 33.62903226 4.080553532 3.515389749

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 76.89361702 480347 28.04385965 4.342422869 3.333769701

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 71.64948454 69.24043979 800255 28.04385965 29.90558385 4.27178596 4.231587454 3.333769701 3.394309717

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 20.50819672 564476 0.6 3.020824646 -0.510825624

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 20.37068966 245412 54.00627483 3.014097086 3.98910024

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 21.56896552 20.81595063 629103 4.531377343 19.71255072 3.0712555 3.035392411 1.511025943 1.663100186

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 68.70114943 492554 49.05882353 4.22976593 3.893020058

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 71.89655172 636446 34.0106383 4.275228304 3.526673367

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 63.90804598 68.16858238 548888 35.38181818 39.48376 4.157445269 4.220813168 3.566198078 3.661963834

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 39.13592233 659160 26.13675214 3.667040775 3.263342452

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 36.71698113 676504 6.77 3.603239349 1.912501087

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 54.45360825 43.4355039 67049 34.14035088 22.34903434 3.997349114 3.755876413 3.530479995 2.902107845

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 8.460869565 266472 12.33064516 2.135451954 2.51208764

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 10.20183486 113360 48.4587156 2.322567593 3.880712211

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 11.27027027 9.977658233 318339 12.41071429 24.40002501 2.422168309 2.293395952 2.518560155 2.970453335

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 36.98165138 396161 54.45360825 3.610421881 3.997349114

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 39.33962264 260415 71.64948454 3.672232221 4.27178596

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 40.27102804 38.86410069 106480 2.908819133 43.00397064 3.695632303 3.659428802 1.067747203 3.112294092

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 1.269406393 55356 3.43 0.238549384 1.232560261

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 3.823624595 530781 19.05645161 1.34119882 2.947405712

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 2.823638042 2.638889677 201430 20.50819672 14.33154944 1.038026139 0.872591448 3.020824646 2.40026354

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 0.725 29751 40.54166667 -0.321583624 3.702330252

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 0.5 0.6125 863953 43.82882883 42.18524775 -0.693147181 -0.507365402 3.780291793 3.741311023

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 54.00627483 770608 37.56756757 3.98910024 3.626141113

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 56.92988204 413914 40.27102804 4.041820371 3.695632303

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 62.68733348 57.87449679 685836 20.37068966 32.73642842 4.138159409 4.056360007 3.014097086 3.445290168

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 60.7224151 485212 48.58252427 4.106312907 3.883263883

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 58.73139403 582410 59.17821782 4.072974405 4.080553532

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 56.15567376 58.5364943 598991 1.269406393 36.34338283 4.028127723 4.069138345 0.238549384 2.734122266

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 44.72173913 24613 4.633333333 3.800459717 1.533276551

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 43.4375 206837 2.823638042 3.771323123 1.038026139

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 47.04615385 45.06846433 471244 47.18348624 18.21348587 3.851129117 3.807637319 3.854043964 2.141782218

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 19.05645161 939242 3.823624595 2.947405712 1.34119882

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 20.016 330378 1.45 2.996531954 0.371563556

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 21.20338983 20.09194715 315770 1.2 2.157874865 3.054161067 2.999366244 0.182321557 0.631694644

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 42.24509804 269171 43.13793103 3.743488324 3.76440268

Page 1
Attachment A-2. Variability Analysis for CO From Existing FB Units

Facility Name Unit ID Pollutant

Run 

No. Flag ND Raw Data

Raw Data 3-

run Test 

Averages

Random 

Numbers

Randomly 

Distributed 

Raw Data

Randomly 

Distributed 

Raw Data 3-

run Test 

Averages 

Lntransformed 

Data

Lntransformed 

Data 3-run 

Test Averages 

Lntransformed 

Randomly 

Distributed 

Data

3 Run Test 

Averages of Lntransformed 

Randomly 

Distributed Data

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 41.28712871 498475 4.07 3.720550798 1.403642999

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 40.54166667 41.35796447 489369 41.28712871 29.49835325 3.702330252 3.722123125 3.720550798 2.962865493

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 34.14035088 892273 39.33962264 3.530479995 3.672232221

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 39.53211009 442863 63.90804598 3.677113255 4.157445269

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 37.56756757 37.08000951 191285 36.31531532 46.52099464 3.626141113 3.611244788 3.592239562 3.807305684

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 36.31531532 556968 26.73076923 3.592239562 3.285815308

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 36.64545455 523060 3.491365777 3.601289397 1.250293

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 35.38181818 36.11419601 636631 42.24509804 24.15574435 3.566198078 3.586575679 3.743488324 2.759865544

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 48.4587156 772042 31.77142857 3.880712211 3.458567413

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 43.82882883 355307 4.55 3.780291793 1.515127233

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 47.18348624 46.49034355 399713 4.63 13.65047619 3.854043964 3.838349322 1.532556868 2.168750505

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 48.58252427 206112 32.07692308 3.883263883 3.468136864

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 49.05882353 59087 0.725 3.893020058 -0.321583624

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 48.58252427 48.74129069 23884 18.28947368 17.03046559 3.883263883 3.886515942 2.906325686 2.017626309

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 16.51485149 148863 39.53211009 2.804260066 3.677113255

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 27.49450549 899463 31.01652893 3.313986185 3.434520254

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 18.25252525 20.75396074 142789 27.49450549 32.68104817 2.90430344 3.007516564 3.313986185 3.475206564

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 4.412698413 101645 4.412698413 1.484486387 1.484486387

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 4.531377343 571054 71.89655172 1.511025943 4.275228304

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 4.633333333 4.52580303 476953 0.118 25.47575005 1.533276551 1.509596294 -2.137070655 1.207548012

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 1 0 3.491365777 484428 8.460869565 1.250293 2.135451954

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 2.908819133 319151 31.70175439 1.067747203 3.456372023

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 3 0 3.15669947 3.185628127 960886 44.72173913 28.29478769 1.14952701 1.155855738 3.800459717 3.130761231

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Carbon Monoxide (CO) 2 0 151.1929825 5.01855705 outlier; removed from analysis.

Sample Size 112 38 112 38 112 38 112 38

Non-detects 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Average 27.63472 27.57947 27.63472 27.74707 2.80 2.78 2.80 2.81

Median 28.65351 30.27727 28.65351 25.68389 3.36 3.41 3.36 2.99

Standard Deviation 19.89487 19.97184 19.89487 11.23565 1.35 1.36 1.35 0.78

Minimum 0.11800 0.61250 0.11800 2.15787 -2.14 -0.76 -2.14 0.63

Maximum 76.89362 69.24044 76.89362 57.59521 4.34 4.23 4.34 4.02

Skewness 0.35 0.32 0.35 0.34 -1.44 -1.28 -1.44 -0.77

SE Skewness 0.23 0.40 0.23 0.40 0.23 0.40 0.23 0.40

Skewness Test Normal Normal Normal Normal Normal Normal Normal Normal

Kurtosis -0.76 -0.86 -0.76 0.43 1.71 0.78 1.71 0.30

SE Kurtosis 0.46 0.79 0.46 0.79 0.46 0.79 0.46 0.79

Kurtosis Test Normal Normal Normal Normal Non-normal Normal Non-normal Normal

99.0% t-statistic for UL 2.36 2.43 2.36 2.43 2.36 2.43 2.36 2.43

99.0% UL 74.5887 76.0824 74.5887 55.0336 394.16 435.12 394.16 110.19

99.0% t-statistic for UPL 2.36 2.36 2.36 2.36

99.0% UPL 55.1079 55.1079 105.3556 105.3556

Page 2
Attachment A-1. Variability Analysis for Cd from Existing FB Units

Facility Name Unit ID Pollutant

Run 

No. Flag ND Raw Data

Raw Data 3-

run Test 

Averages

Random 

Numbers

Randomly 

Distributed 

Raw Data

Randomly 

Distributed 

Raw Data 3-

run Test 

Averages 

Lntransformed 

Data

Lntransformed 

Data 3-run 

Test Averages 

Lntransformed 

Randomly 

Distributed 

Data

3 Run Test 

Averages of Lntransformed 

Randomly 

Distributed Data

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Cadmium (Cd) 1 ADL 0 0.000126 79631 0.000576 -8.979228651 -7.459402897

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Cadmium (Cd) 2 ADL 0 0.000157 544044 0.000043167 -8.759264753 -10.05043424

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Cadmium (Cd) 3 ADL 0 0.000241 0.000174667 478467 0.001051662 0.000556943 -8.330713624 -8.689735676 -6.85738304 -8.122406727

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 1 0 0.001014169 986466 0.00005796 -6.89368601 -9.755757441

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 2 0 0.001217613 436036 0.000388286 -6.710863032 -7.853767776

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 3 0 0.001010933 0.001080905 376750 0.000244959 0.000230402 -6.896881802 -6.833810281 -8.314420073 -8.641315097

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 1 0 0.000373531 668341 0.000054 -7.892508849 -9.826526511

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 2 0 0.000269772 606202 0.0000595 -8.217933566 -9.729534245

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 3 0 0.000290748 0.00031135 675067 0.00144 0.000517833 -8.143052992 -8.084498469 -6.543112165 -8.699724307

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 1 0 0.000237195 104815 0.000373531 -8.34662808 -7.892508849

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 2 0 0.000244959 249570 0.002112516 -8.314420073 -6.159875642

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 3 0 0.000315602 0.000265919 476053 0.000804588 0.001096878 -8.061028327 -8.24069216 -7.125180406 -7.059188299

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 1 0 5.14053E-05 32694 0.000237195 -9.875768783 -8.34662808

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 2 ND 1 0.000054 941462 0.000315602 -9.826526511 -8.061028327

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Cadmium (Cd) 3 ND 1 0.0000538 5.30684E-05 270650 0.000473851 0.000342216 -9.830237091 -9.844177462 -7.654617702 -8.020758036

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Cadmium (Cd) 1 ADL 0 0.0000765 556384 0.000633 -9.478219817 -7.365040136

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Cadmium (Cd) 2 ADL 0 0.0000373 208285 0.00005329 -10.19651723 -9.839761862

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Cadmium (Cd) 3 ADL 0 0.0000279 4.72333E-05 9576 0.000269772 0.000318687 -10.48688387 -10.05387364 -8.217933566 -8.474245188

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Cadmium (Cd) 1 ADL 0 0.000576 330346 0.000290748 -7.459402897 -8.143052992

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Cadmium (Cd) 2 ADL 0 0.000633 453880 0.001217613 -7.365040136 -6.710863032

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Cadmium (Cd) 3 ADL 0 0.00144 0.000883 210505 0.0000765 0.000528287 -6.543112165 -7.122518399 -9.478219817 -8.110711947

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Cadmium (Cd) 1 0 0.001647248 540893 0.000241 -6.408649036 -8.330713624

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Cadmium (Cd) 2 0 0.001051662 568138 0.001429987 -6.85738304 -6.550090161

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Cadmium (Cd) 3 0 0.000228754 0.000975888 395822 5.14053E-05 0.000574131 -8.382863947 -7.216298675 -9.875768783 -8.252190856

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Cadmium (Cd) 1 0 0.000473851 19118 0.001087277 -7.654617702 -6.824078455

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Cadmium (Cd) 2 0 0.000388286 95938 0.001014169 -7.853767776 -6.89368601

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Cadmium (Cd) 3 ND 1 0.0003704 0.000410846 708349 0.000157 0.000752815 -7.900927055 -7.803104178 -8.759264753 -7.492343073

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 1 0 0.001213444 775352 0.000228754 -6.714292755 -8.382863947

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 2 0 0.001087277 497628 0.0000538 -6.824078455 -9.830237091

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 3 0 0.000804588 0.001035103 864585 0.001010933 0.000431162 -7.125180406 -6.887850539 -6.896881802 -8.36999428

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 1 0 0.001429987 307214 0.00004911 -6.550090161 -9.921447878

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 2 0 0.002112516 653207 0.001647248 -6.159875642 -6.408649036

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 3 0 0.001990635 0.001844379 752725 0.001213444 0.000969934 -6.219301478 -6.30975576 -6.714292755 -7.681463223

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 1 ND 1 0.00005899 106205 0.0003704 -9.73814262 -7.900927055

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 2 ND 1 0.00004911 869638 0.00005899 -9.921447878 -9.73814262

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 3 ND 1 0.000043167 5.04223E-05 914579 0.001990635 0.000806675 -10.05043424 -9.90334158 -6.219301478 -7.952790384

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 1 ND 1 0.00005329 50911 0.000126 -9.839761862 -8.979228651

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 2 ND 1 0.0000595 727493 0.0000279 -9.729534245 -10.48688387

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Cadmium (Cd) 3 ND 1 0.00005796 5.69167E-05 121502 0.0000373 6.37333E-05 -9.755757441 -9.775017849 -10.19651723 -9.88754325

Sample Size 39 13 39 13 39 13 39 13

Non-detects 9 9 9 9 9 9 9 9

Average 0.00055 0.00055 0.00055 0.00055 -8.21 -8.21 -8.21 -8.21

Median 0.00029 0.00031 0.00029 0.00053 -8.14 -8.08 -8.14 -8.12

Standard Deviation 0.00059 0.00056 0.00059 0.00029 1.33 1.33 1.33 0.68

Minimum 0.00003 0.00005 0.00003 0.00006 -10.49 -10.05 -10.49 -9.89

Maximum 0.00211 0.00184 0.00211 0.00110 -6.16 -6.31 -6.16 -7.06

Skewness 1.17 1.07 1.17 0.32 -0.13 -0.22 -0.13 -0.88

SE Skewness 0.39 0.68 0.39 0.68 0.39 0.68 0.39 0.68

Skewness Test Non-normal Normal Non-normal Normal Normal Normal Normal Normal

Kurtosis 0.40 0.59 0.40 -0.27 -1.35 -1.50 -1.35 2.52

SE Kurtosis 0.78 1.36 0.78 1.36 0.78 1.36 0.78 1.36

Kurtosis Test Normal Normal Normal Normal Normal Normal Normal Normal

99.0% t-statistic for UL 2.43 2.65 2.43 2.65 2.43 2.65 2.43 2.65

99.0% UL 0.0020 0.0020 0.0020 0.0013 0.01 0.0092 0.01 0.0017

99.0% t-statistic for UPL 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43

99.0% UPL 0.0014 0.0014 0.0019 0.0019

Page 1
Attachment A-5. Variability Analysis for Hg From Existing FB Units

Facility Name Unit ID Pollutant

Run 

No. Flag ND Raw Data

Raw Data 3-

run Test 

Averages

Random 

Numbers

Randomly

Distributed 

Raw Data

Randomly

Distributed 

Raw Data 3-run 

Test Averages 

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000126364 50016 0.000582903

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 5.94017E-05 512913 0.000851935

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 6.09649E-05 8.2243E-05 55986 0.000189545 0.000541461

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000277626 836252 0.000716495

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000307123 32312 0.002516379

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000247054 0.00027727 463015 0.000342695 0.001191856

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 7.94286E-05 16990 0.00971251

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 7.94286E-05 344942 0.001948482

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 6.31818E-05 7.4013E-05 864183 7.94286E-05 0.003913474

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 6.46512E-05 258281 0.000216789

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 4.86014E-05 803698 0.007171809

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.0000556 5.6284E-05 679513 0.000108003 0.002498867

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 ND 1 0.00006556 603918 0.002290058

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 ND 1 0.00006435 647534 0.000156425

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 ND 1 0.000063181 6.4364E-05 434400 0.000317018 0.000921167

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000571409 146556 0.000951

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000630965 422669 0.00010902

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000527206 0.00057653 837378 0.001549271 0.000869763

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.001052429 404711 0.001472574

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.001560702 342533 0.000527206

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.001369559 0.00132756 881158 0.000158857 0.000719546

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000273248 100492 6.46512E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000297009 288435 0.000885784

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000317018 0.00029576 468348 0.000571409 0.000507281

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000258319 274279 0.000672581

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000296019 880813 0.0446

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000256053 0.00027013 399054 0.00190395 0.01572551

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000446786 818240 0.000101091

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000216789 941639 0.000421212

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000290087 0.00031789 465907 0.000277626 0.000266643

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000190784 560744 7.94286E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000110099 426033 0.000296019

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 9.50427E-05 0.00013198 84742 0.000539806 0.000305084

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000851935 189424 0.001485392

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000672581 179287 0.000943

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.001020081 0.0008482 794586 0.002396552 0.001608315

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Mercury (Hg) 1 DLL 1 0.000943 861664 0.000256053

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Mercury (Hg) 2 ADL 0 0.000951 524965 0.000385347

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Mercury (Hg) 3 ADL 0 0.00101 0.000968 100370 5.94017E-05 0.0002336

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Mercury (Hg) 1 ADL 0 9.6209E-05 104450 0.0000356

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Mercury (Hg) 2 ADL 0 0.000156425 297340 0.000444

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Mercury (Hg) 3 ADL 0 0.000245 0.00016588 321003 0.000957264 0.000478955

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 5.73196E-05 91202 0.000063181

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 3.79091E-05 892867 0.000297009

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 4.00962E-05 4.5108E-05 185596 0.000359911 0.000240033

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000158857 214654 0.000273248

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000101091 107856 0.000190784

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000189545 0.00014983 489388 0.000149233 0.000204422

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000459638 510717 0.0000556

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 ND 1 0.000444 786412 0.00006556

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000342695 0.00041544 675682 0.000126364 8.25079E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 9.63366E-05 390664 0.001020081

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.0000973 560032 0.000110099

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.00010902 0.00010089 804545 0.000245 0.000458393

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.001925596 146348 0.000344425

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.001948482 823835 0.000258319

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.00190395 0.00192601 125661 0.0345 0.011700914

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.006688515 836794 0.00058936

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.007171809 500775 0.001540579

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000730825 0.00486372 158728 4.86014E-05 0.00072618

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.00314459 558181 0.002087087

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.002396552 522106 0.000183297

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.002516379 0.00268584 355714 6.31818E-05 0.000777855

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.001447641 780841 0.002144786

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.001207152 357415 0.00314459

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.001540579 0.00139846 805854 0.000118435 0.001802604

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000539806 444960 0.000264762

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000524528 595867 0.000307123

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000716495 0.00059361 186162 0.001369559 0.000647148

Page 1
Attachment A-5. Variability Analysis for Hg From Existing FB Units

Facility Name Unit ID Pollutant

Run 

No. Flag ND Raw Data

Raw Data 3-

run Test 

Averages

Random 

Numbers

Randomly

Distributed 

Raw Data

Randomly

Distributed 

Raw Data 3-run 

Test Averages 

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.00015713 598070 6.09649E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.001683303 943515 0.000895481

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.001615405 0.00115195 956126 5.73196E-05 0.000337922

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 8.92661E-05 44547 0.001560702

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 6.5566E-05 927509 4.6372E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 3.8972E-05 6.4601E-05 598980 9.63366E-05 0.000567803

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000035398 515 6.5566E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.0000356 690523 0.001925596

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 3.23757E-05 3.4458E-05 707335 4.00962E-05 0.000677086

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000149233 589615 0.001683303

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.00016661 452287 0.000192462

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 4.6372E-05 0.00012074 830776 0.000471186 0.000782317

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.002290058 751747 9.50427E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.002144786 932357 0.000113092

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.002087087 0.00217398 28697 0.00101 0.000406045

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000327724 254144 0.0000973

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000298678 567097 9.6209E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000310077 0.00031216 615402 0.00006435 8.5953E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.00034419 143204 0.00016661

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000359911 346527 0.000124613

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000344425 0.00034951 405541 3.79091E-05 0.000109711

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000885784 225759 0.001447641

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000895481 994855 0.000247054

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000957264 0.00091284 568535 0.0443 0.015331565

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.00099179 642255 0.000630965

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000798075 366815 0.000446786

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000816331 0.00086873 305101 0.000524528 0.000534093

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000217565 466311 0.000327724

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000206328 27281 0.00034419

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000192462 0.00020545 786742 0.00017375 0.000281888

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000582903 826623 0.000730825

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.00058936 499265 0.00015713

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000471186 0.00054782 214371 0.001207152 0.000698369

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.001485392 622320 3.23757E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.001472574 445037 3.8972E-05

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.001549271 0.00150241 330756 0.009978852 0.003350067

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.00971251 733672 0.001615405

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.009978852 908427 0.000298678

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.005037009 0.00824279 301322 0.000290087 0.000734723

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000385347 82 0.001052429

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000183297 830575 0.000206328

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000421212 0.00032995 415371 8.92661E-05 0.000449341

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000264762 298951 0.005037009

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000124613 753789 0.000798075

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.00017375 0.00018771 355378 0.006688515 0.004174533

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 1 0 0.000113092 33513 0.000035398

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 2 0 0.000108003 155389 0.000816331

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Mercury (Hg) 3 0 0.000118435 0.00011318 485804 0.00099179 0.000614506

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Mercury (Hg) 1 DLL 1 0.0345 467217 0.000217565

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Mercury (Hg) 2 DLL 1 0.0443 90202 0.000310077

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Mercury (Hg) 3 DLL 1 0.0446 0.04113333 451988 0.000459638 0.000329093

Sample Size 120 40 120 40

Non-detects 8 8 8 8

Average 0.0019 0.0019 0.0019 0.0019

Median 0.0003 0.0003 0.0003 0.0006

Standard Deviation 0.0066 0.0065 0.0066 0.0037

Minimum 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0001

Maximum 0.0446 0.0411 0.0446 0.0157

Skewness 5.76 5.84 5.76 3.10

SE Skewness 0.22 0.39 0.22 0.39

Skewness Test Non-normal Non-normal Non-normal Non-normal

Kurtosis 33.78 35.55 33.78 8.94

SE Kurtosis 0.45 0.77 0.45 0.77

Kurtosis Test Non-normal Non-normal Non-normal Non-normal

99.0% t-statistic for UL 2.36 2.42 2.36 2.42

99.0% UL 0.0174 0.0177 0.0174 0.0109

99.0% t-statistic for UPL 2.36 2.36

99.0% UPL 0.0109 0.0109

Page 2
Attachment A-5. Variability Analysis for Hg From Existing FB Units

Lntransformed 

Data

Lntransformed 

Data 3-run 

Test Averages 

Lntransformed 

Randomly

Distributed 

Data

3 Run Test 

Averages of Lntransformed 

Randomly

Distributed Data

-8.976346805 -7.447489379

-9.731187554 -7.067999757

-9.705212068 -9.470915476 -8.570881697 -7.695456944

-8.189235205 -7.241139505

-8.088263297 -5.984934192

-8.305902906 -8.194467136 -7.978670237 -7.068247978

-9.440652413 -4.634340535

-9.440652413 -6.240704598

-9.669493985 -9.516932937 -9.440652413 -6.771899182

-9.646504467 -8.43658607

-9.93185825 -4.937597423

-9.797327357 -9.791896691 -9.133350553 -7.502511349

-9.632544804 -6.079177973

-9.651173624 -8.762931511

-9.669506935 -9.651075121 -8.056553442 -7.632887642

-7.46740616 -6.957996495

-7.36825996 -9.123982803

-7.547919188 -7.461195103 -6.469970889 -7.517316729

-6.85665486 -6.520743214

-6.462619716 -7.547919188

-6.593266618 -6.637513731 -8.747505232 -7.605389212

-8.205131251 -9.646504467

-8.121749642 -7.029037075

-8.056553442 -8.127811445 -7.46740616 -8.047649234

-8.261316913 -7.304388535

-8.125088543 -3.11002142

-8.270127543 -8.218844333 -6.263824824 -5.559411593

-7.713431465 -9.199490356

-8.43658607 -7.772374

-8.14532983 -8.098449122 -8.189235205 -8.387033187

-8.564367016 -9.440652413

-9.114130507 -8.125088543

-9.261183925 -8.979893816 -7.524301066 -8.363347341

-7.067999757 -6.512076463

-7.304388535 -6.966444275

-6.887873591 -7.086753961 -6.033724356 -6.504081698

-6.966444275 -8.270127543

-6.957996495 -7.861367539

-6.897804948 -6.940748573 -9.731187554 -8.620894212

-9.248987415 -10.24316492

-8.762931511 -7.719685996

-8.314252347 -8.775390424 -6.951431185 -8.3047607

-9.766868149 -9.669506935

-10.18031961 -8.121749642

-10.12423014 -10.02380597 -7.929654573 -8.57363705

-8.747505232 -8.205131251

-9.199490356 -8.564367016

-8.570881697 -8.839292428 -8.810000852 -8.526499706

-7.685071672 -9.797327357

-7.719685996 -9.632544804

-7.978670237 -7.794475968 -8.976346805 -9.468739655

-9.2476619 -6.887873591

-9.237711569 -9.114130507

-9.123982803 -9.203118757 -8.314252347 -8.105418815

-6.252519577 -7.97363484

-6.240704598 -8.261316913

-6.263824824 -6.252349666 -3.366795955 -6.533915903

-5.007363425 -7.436473356

-4.937597423 -6.475597236

-7.221336878 -5.722099242 -9.93185825 -7.947976281

-5.762071711 -6.171985923

-6.033724356 -8.604404389

-5.984934192 -5.926910086 -9.669493985 -8.148628099

-6.537820068 -6.144715542

-6.71949143 -5.762071711

-6.475597236 -6.577636245 -9.041143557 -6.982643603

-7.524301066 -8.236679608

-7.553011172 -8.088263297

-7.241139505 -7.439483914 -6.593266618 -7.639403174

Page 3
Attachment A-5. Variability Analysis for Hg From Existing FB Units

Lntransformed 

Data

Lntransformed 

Data 3-run 

Test Averages 

Lntransformed 

Randomly

Distributed 

Data

3 Run Test 

Averages of Lntransformed 

Randomly

Distributed Data

-8.758434303 -9.705212068

-6.386997491 -7.018149812

-6.428169329 -7.191200374 -9.766868149 -8.830076676

-9.323889265 -6.462619716

-9.632452714 -9.978815233

-10.15266808 -9.703003352 -9.2476619 -8.563032283

-10.24885524 -9.632452714

-10.24316492 -6.252519577

-10.33810242 -10.27670752 -10.12423014 -8.669734144

-8.810000852 -6.386997491

-8.699857273 -8.555614224

-9.978815233 -9.162891119 -7.660256702 -7.534289473

-6.079177973 -9.261183925

-6.144715542 -9.087311423

-6.171985923 -6.131959813 -6.897804948 -8.415433432

-8.023340057 -9.237711569

-8.116145539 -9.248987415

-8.078690152 -8.07272525 -9.651173624 -9.379290869

-7.974315344 -8.699857273

-7.929654573 -8.990298611

-7.97363484 -7.959201586 -10.18031961 -9.290158497

-7.029037075 -6.537820068

-7.018149812 -8.305902906

-6.951431185 -6.999539357 -3.116770602 -5.986831192

-6.915999257 -7.36825996

-7.133307519 -7.713431465

-7.110690089 -7.053332288 -7.553011172 -7.544900866

-8.433011902 -8.023340057

-8.486042817 -7.974315344

-8.555614224 -8.491556314 -8.657893074 -8.218516158

-7.447489379 -7.221336878

-7.436473356 -8.758434303

-7.660256702 -7.514739812 -6.71949143 -7.56642087

-6.512076463 -10.33810242

-6.520743214 -10.15266808

-6.469970889 -6.500930189 -4.607287178 -8.366019224

-4.634340535 -6.428169329

-4.607287178 -8.116145539

-5.290942735 -4.844190149 -8.14532983 -7.563214899

-7.861367539 -6.85665486

-8.604404389 -8.486042817

-7.772374 -8.079381976 -9.323889265 -8.222195647

-8.236679608 -5.290942735

-8.990298611 -7.133307519

-8.657893074 -8.628290431 -5.007363425 -5.810537893

-9.087311423 -10.24885524

-9.133350553 -7.110690089

-9.041143557 -9.087268511 -6.915999257 -8.091848194

-3.366795955 -8.433011902

-3.116770602 -8.078690152

-3.11002142 -3.197862659 -7.685071672 -8.065591242

120 40 120 40

8 8 8 8

-7.84 -7.84 -7.84 -7.84

-8.04 -8.08 -8.04 -8.06

1.53 1.51 1.53 0.91

-10.34 -10.28 -10.34 -9.47

-3.11 -3.20 -3.11 -5.56

0.72 0.75 0.72 0.67

0.22 0.39 0.22 0.39

Non-normal Normal Non-normal Normal

0.66 0.92 0.66 0.41

0.45 0.77 0.45 0.77

Normal Normal Normal Normal

2.36 2.42 2.36 2.42

0.0146 0.0153 0.0146 0.0036

2.36 2.36

0.0032 0.0032

Page 4
Attachment A-3. Variability Analysis for HCl from Existing FB Units

Facility Name Unit ID Pollutant Run No. Flag ND Raw Data Ln-transformed Data

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 BDL 1 0.0355 -3.338222583

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 BDL 1 0.0369 -3.299543728

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 BDL 1 0.0603 -2.808423175

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 BDL 1 0.23204 -1.460845508

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 BDL 1 0.2478 -1.39513331

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 BDL 1 0.2258 -1.488105627

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 BDL 1 0.23451 -1.450257048

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 BDL 1 0.211054 -1.555641254

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 BDL 1 0.2139 -1.542246663

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 BDL 1 0.0857 -2.456902453

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 BDL 1 0.0989 -2.31364604

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 BDL 1 0.0857 -2.456902453

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 BDL 1 0.072528 -2.623782585

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 BDL 1 0.0791 -2.537042404

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 BDL 1 0.07912 -2.536789592

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 ND 1 0.184 -1.692819521

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 ND 1 0.1689 -1.778448455

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 ND 1 0.16289 -1.814680153

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 ND 1 0.1866 -1.678787991

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 ND 1 0.19903 -1.614299712

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 ND 1 0.1935 -1.642477767

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 ND 1 0.18232 -1.701991894

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 ND 1 0.19237 -1.648334678

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 ND 1 0.19237 -1.648334678

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 0 0.18461876 -1.689462335

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 ND 1 0.07912 -2.536789592

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 ND 1 0.07912 -2.536789592

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 ND 1 0.21338 -1.544680665

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 ND 1 0.186397 -1.679876471

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 ND 1 0.193567 -1.642131573

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 ND 1 0.20163 -1.601320944

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 ND 1 0.21048 -1.558364642

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 ND 1 0.197362 -1.622715673

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 1 0 0.39641803 -0.925285989

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 2 0 0.26374109 -1.332787391

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Hydrogen Chloride (HCl) 3 0 0.18717301 -1.675721905

Sample Size 36 36

Non-detects 32 32

Average 0.17 -1.91

Median 0.19 -1.68

Standard Deviation 0.08 0.56

Minimum 0.04 -3.34

Maximum 0.40 -0.93

Skewness 0.25 -1.01

SE Skewness 0.41 0.41

Skewness Test Normal Normal

Kurtosis 0.98 0.37

SE Kurtosis 0.82 0.82

Kurtosis Test Normal Normal

99.0% t-statistic for UL 2.43 2.43

99.0% UL 0.35 0.58

99.0% t-statistic for UPL 2.44 2.44

99.0% UPL 0.28 0.34

3x highest DL less than average 0.48867

Page 1
Attachment A-4. Variability Analysis for PB from Existing FB Units

Facility Name Unit ID Pollutant Run No. Flag ND Raw Data Ln-transformed Data

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Lead (Pb) 1 ADL 0 0.000276 -8.195109692

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Lead (Pb) 2 ADL 0 0.000351 -7.954724334

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Lead (Pb) 3 ADL 0 0.000313 -8.069307367

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Lead (Pb) 1 0 0.00084213 -7.07957308

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Lead (Pb) 2 0 0.00077246 -7.165930251

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Lead (Pb) 3 0 0.00067711 -7.297674679

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Lead (Pb) 1 0 0.00766524 -4.871059949

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Lead (Pb) 2 0 0.00278272 -5.88432713

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Lead (Pb) 3 0 0.00165286 -6.40524691

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 1 0 0.00426544 -5.457210125

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 2 0 0.0028943 -5.845011317

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 3 0 0.00125158 -6.683347654

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 1 0 0.00077678 -7.160349681

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 2 0 0.00113614 -6.780116051

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 3 0 0.01466146 -4.222532911

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 1 0 0.000141 -8.866750668

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 2 0 0.00055256 -7.500945208

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 3 0 0.00074464 -7.202605841

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 1 0 0.0035283 -5.646939806

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 2 0 0.00046413 -7.675352956

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Lead (Pb) 3 0 0.00107815 -6.832510101

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 1 0 0.00131951 -6.630494958

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 2 0 0.00129581 -6.648620723

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 3 0 0.00107615 -6.834361445

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 1 0 0.00318146 -5.750416342

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 2 0 0.00311362 -5.77196989

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 3 0 0.00454014 -5.394796371

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 1 0 0.01666607 -4.094380488

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 2 0 0.00149554 -6.505268861

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 3 0 0.00121191 -6.715555961

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 1 0 0.00034956 -7.958846171

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 2 0 0.0001296 -8.951057774

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Lead (Pb) 3 0 0.0001292 -8.954148967

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Lead (Pb) 1 DLL 1 0.00054 -7.523941418

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Lead (Pb) 2 DLL 1 0.00057 -7.469874197

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Lead (Pb) 3 DLL 1 0.0000392 -10.14683381

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Lead (Pb) 1 ADL 0 0.01154 -4.461936018

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Lead (Pb) 2 ADL 0 0.01268 -4.36772933

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Lead (Pb) 3 ADL 0 0.0117 -4.448166437

Sample Size 39 39

Non-detects 3 3

Average 0.0030 -6.70

Median 0.0011 -6.78

Standard Deviation 0.0044 1.43

Minimum 0.0000 -10.15

Maximum 0.0167 -4.09

Skewness 1.98 -0.04

SE Skewness 0.39 0.39

Skewness Test Non-normal Normal

Kurtosis 2.91 -0.18

SE Kurtosis 0.78 0.78

Kurtosis Test Non-normal Normal

99.0% t-statistic for UL 2.43 2.43

99.0% UL 0.0137 0.04

99.0% t-statistic for UPL 2.4286 2.43

99.0% UPL 0.0094 0.0098

Page 1
Attachment A-6. Variability Analysis for NOx from Existing FB Units

Facility Name Unit ID Pollutant Run No. Flag ND Raw Data Ln-transformed Data

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 1 0 13.3 2.587764035

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 2 0 16.9 2.827313622

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 3 0 14.5 2.674148649

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 1 0 15 2.708050201

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 2 0 16.1 2.778819272

MNStPaulMetro FBR3 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 3 0 36.5 3.597312261

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 1 0 36.0526316 3.584979859

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 2 0 33.1165468 3.50003306

MIYpsilanti EU-FBSSI Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 3 0 20.1 3.000719815

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 1 0 25.7 3.246490992

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 2 0 25.7 3.246490992

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 3 0 34.3 3.535145354

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 1 0 30.7676609 3.426464168

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 2 0 34.490284 3.540677661

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 3 0 35.0393641 3.556472119

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 1 0 12.9 2.557227311

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 2 0 13.5 2.602689685

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 3 0 13.5 2.602689685

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 1 0 75.2757991 4.32115869

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 2 0 61.9652104 4.126573104

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) 3 0 71.4893813 4.269548926

Sample Size 21 21

Non-detects 0 0

Average 30.30 3.25

Median 25.70 3.25

Standard Deviation 18.74 0.57

Minimum 12.90 2.56

Maximum 75.28 4.32

Skewness 1.34 0.43

SE Skewness 0.53 0.53

Skewness Test Non-normal Normal

Kurtosis 1.15 -0.80

SE Kurtosis 1.07 1.07

Kurtosis Test Normal Normal

99.0% t-statistic for UL 2.52 2.52

99.0% UL 77.48 107.19

99.0% t-statistic for UPL 2.53 2.53

99.0% UPL 59.54 62.40

Page 1
Attachment A-7. Variability Analysis for SO2 from Existing FB Units.

Facility Name Unit ID Pollutant Run No. Flag ND Raw Data Ln-transformed Data

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) 1 0 0.55643642 -0.586202363

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) 2 0 0.88303438 -0.124391144

MNStPaulMetro FBR1 Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) 3 0 0.41037093 -0.890693818

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) 1 0 2.79269406 1.027006744

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) 2 0 0.22491909 -1.492014524

MNStPaulMetro FBR2 Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) 3 0 1.92520776 0.655033887

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) 1 0 4.84 1.576914721

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) 2 0 4.69 1.545432582

NCTZOsborne ES-1 Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) 3 0 13.4 2.595254707

Sample Size 9 9

Non-detects 0 0

Average 3.30 0.48

Median 1.93 0.66

Standard Deviation 4.18 1.34

Minimum 0.22 -1.49

Maximum 13.40 2.60

Skewness 2.08 0.04

SE Skewness 0.82 0.82

Skewness Test Non-normal Normal

Kurtosis 4.80 -1.03

SE Kurtosis 1.63 1.63

Kurtosis Test Non-normal Normal

99.0% t-statistic for UL 2.82 2.82

99.0% UL 15.09 71.20

99.0% t-statistic for UPL 2.90 2.90

99.0% UPL 11.37 21.55

Page 1
N LN N LN N LN

99% UPL (EPA) 55.1 105.4 0.0014 0.0019 0.0109 0.0032

99% UL with Actual 3-run Test 

Averages 76.1 435.1 0.0020 0.0092 0.0177 0.0153

99% UL with Randomly Distributed 

Data and 3-run Test Averages 55.0 110.2 0.0013 0.0017 0.0109 0.0036

CO Cd Hg

N = Normal statistics, LN = Log-normal statistics

MACT Floor Using...

Table 1. Summary of UPL and UL calculations