_P. I -


# OAR Box 

# 1672 Prepped by Charmelle Mathews



### Document

Number: 

# ) ll-B-1 5 Docket Number: 

# A-98-1 3

Printed 9/30/2008 11:01:00 AM Sheet 21 of 132^ ___z\__w^n mum I M • P. 2

TO :

FROM : DATE : 

### MEMORANDU M
Air Docket A-98-1 3 Organi c Liquid s Distributio n MACT Rule ES D Project

No
. 96/0 5 Bernd Hanek

e an d Greg LaFlam , PES , Inc
. Decembe r 1 , 199 9 SUBJECT : Estimatio n o f th e Populatio n of

Refinerie s tha

t Conduct Organi c Liquid s Distributio n (OLD ) Operation s Purpos e Durin g th e Octobe

r 5,199 9 EP

A OL D Stakeholder s meeting , th e EP A indicate d tha

t it s 199 8 OL D surve y ha d capture d approximatel

y 3 0 percen

t of all petroleumrefinerie s tha t potentiall y hav e OLD-typ e operations
. Representative s ofth e America n PetroleumInstitute (API ) commente d tha

t the y believe d tha

t 10 0 percen t of such refinerie s wer

e capture d i n th e survey , and therefor

e th e EP A ma y b e overstatin g th e baselin e emission s an d potentia l contro l cost s fo r refinerie s tha

t belon g to th e OL

D operation s sourc e category . Based o n API' s comment , w e hav e reanalyze d th e OL D databas e to determine th e numbe r of refinerie s likely to conduc t OLD-typ e operation s a s defined fo r th e OL D category . Methodology T o develop arati o tha

t describe s ho w man

y refinerie s conduct

OLD-typ e operations , w e analyze d bot

h th e OL D databas e an

d th e negativ e declaration s receive d fromfacilities
. A negativ e declaratio n i s alette r from afacilit

y declarin g tha

t it doe s no t conduc t th e define d OLD

typ e operations , or

tha t it s annua l emission s d

o no t mee t th e surve y threshold s ( 5 tp y of

one HA P or 12. 5 tp y fo

r all HA P actua l emission s fo

r th e bas e yea

r 1997)
. Th e rati o wa s calculate d by dividin g th e numbe r o f refinerie s tha

t reporte d OLD-typ e operation s by th e tota

l numbe r of refinerie s tha

t responde d to the survey . Based upo n th e "Organi c Liquid s Distributio n Industr y Profile , Revised Draft" , a s o f 199 6 ther e wer e 17 3 operabl e refinerie s in th e nation
. Thi s numbe r wa s multiplie d b

y th e ratio/percentag e t o determin e th e tota

l numbe r o f refinerie s in th e U.S
. tha

t conduct OLD-typ e operations
. Result s Th e attache d tabl e summarize s al l ofth e refinerie s tha t submitte d informatio n t o th e EP A fo r th e OL D survey . Refinerie s submitte d avariet y of information
. Som

e refinerie s submitte d

/P. 3

Mem o o n Refinerie s wit

h OL D Decembe r 1,199 9 Pag e 2 onl y informatio n o n organi c liquids , whil e other s submitte d infonnatio n o n storag e tank s an d transfe r rack s tha t ar e expecte d to b e regulate d b y th e OL D MACT
. Som

e refinerie s submitte d survey s listin g only organi c liquid s tha t wil l no t b e regulate d b y th e OL

D MACT ; consequently , they wer e counte d a s no t

havin g OLD-typ e operations
. A tota l o f 5 8 refinerie s submitte d either : (a ) completed OL

D surveys , o

r (b ) letter s statin g tha t they d o no t conduc t an y OLD-typ e operations
. O f thes e 5 8 responses , 2 1 facilitie s (3 6 percent ) repor t tha t they d o no t conduc t an y OLD-typ e operations
. Therefore , approximately 6 4 percent (100-36 ) ofth e refinerie s tha t responde d to th e surve

y ma y conduc t som e typ e of organi c liquid s distributio n activit

y whic h wil l b e regulate d by th e OL D MACT
. Thi s ratio/percentag e wa s used t o determine , ho w man

y refinerie s i

n th e natio n potentially conduc t OLD-typ e operations
. Multiplyin g th e tota l numbe r of refinerie s (173 ) i

n th e natio n by 64 percent

indicate s tha t ther e ar e approximately 11 1 refinerie s tha t conduct OLD-typ e operations
. A s th e EP A receive d complete d survey s from3 7 refineries , acalculatio n base d o n th e tota l numbe r of refinerie s nationwide conducting som e sor t o f OLD-typ e operation s result s in a coverag e of

3 3 percen t (37/11 1 x 10

0 = 33)
. Thi s indicate s tha

t 6 7 percen t ofth e refinerie s conductin g OLD-typ e operation s wer e not surveyed o

r di d not respond to th e survey . Conclusion s I n calculatin g baselin e emission s an d contro l cost s fo

r th e OL D industry , th e EP

A ha d estimate d tha

t abou t 7 0 percent

ofth e refinerie s conducting OLD-typ e operation s wer e no t surveyed
. Thi s reanalysi s indicate s tha t amor e accurat e numbe r ma y b e 6 6 percent . Thus , th e EP A ma y hav e overestimate d th e OL D emission s an

d cost s fo r th e refiner

y segmen t ofth e OL D industr y by abou t 1 0 percen t [(l-0.67)/(l-0.7 ) - 1 = 1 0 percent]
. Thi s analysi s als o indicate s tha t sinc e th e surve

y di d not captur e all ofth e refinerie s wit

h OLD-typ e operations , arevise d extrapolatio n ofth e surveye d refinerie s will b e necessar y t o accurately estimat

e nationwid e baselin e emission s an

d contro l costs .



## 7 .P. 4

Mem o on Refinerie s wit

h OL D Decembe r 1,199 9 Pag e 3 Refineries tha tResponde

d t o the O.L.D . Surve

y
Lega l Owner Atlanti c Richfiel d Corporatio n B P Exploratio n an d Oi l Compan y B P Exploratio n an d Oi l Compan y B P Exploratio n an d Oi l Compan y Catlettsbur g Refinin g LL C Cene x Harves t

State s Chalmett e Refinin g L.L.C
. Chevro n Corporatio n Chevro n Corporatio n Chevro n Product s Compan y Chevro n Corporatio n Chevro n Product s Compan y Chevro n Corporatio n Crow n Centra l Petroleu m Corporatio n Crow n Centra l Petroleu m Corporatio n Dee r Par k Refinin g Limite d Partnershi p an d Equilo n Enterprises , LL C Diamon d Shamroc k

Refinin g Co. , L.P
. Equilo n Enterprise s L.L.C
. Exxo n Corporatio n Exxo n Corporatio n Exxo n Corporatio n Exxo n Corporatio n Fin aInc
. Fina , Inc
. Facilit y Nam e ARCO-Lo s Angele s Refiner y B P Oi l Lim aRefinery Allianc e Refinery B P Oi l Toled o Refiner

y Catlettsbur g Refiner

y Refinery (n o nam e provided ) Chalmett e Refiner y Sal t Lak e Cit y Refiner y Hawai i Refiner

y E l Segund o Refiner

y Chevro n E l Pas o Refiner

y (North Facility ) Chevro n Product s Company , Pascagoul aRefiner

y Chevro n Product s Richmon d Refinery L aGlori aOi l an d Ga s Co
. Crow n Refiner

y in Pasadena , CA
Shel l Dee r

Par k Plan t
McKe e Plant s Woo d Rive r

Refinin g Compan y Exxo n Compan y US A Bato n Roug e Refiner

y Exxo n Baytow n Refiner

y Exxo n Benici aRefiner

y Exxo n Co
. U.S.A
. Billing s Refinery Port Arthu r Refiner y Bi g Sprin g Refiner

y Typ e o f Dat a Submitte d Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y N o Surve y Surve y N o Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y N o Surve y Surve y N o Surve y N o Surve y
N o Surve y
Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y N o Surve y Surve y Facilit

y Reporte d Applicabl e OL D Operations ? Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s N o N o N o N o Ye s Ye s N o Ye s N o N o
N o
Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s N o Ye sP. 5

Mem o on Refinerie s wit

h OL D Decembe r 1 , 199 9 Pag e 4 Refineries thatResponded t o th e O.L.D . Surve

y (continued ) Lega l Owne r Koc h Refinin g Company , L.P
. Koc h Refinin g Company , L.P
. Koc h Refinin g Company , L.P
. Lyondell-Citg o Refinin

g Compan y Ltd
. Maratho n Oi l Company , formall

y USX fo r 199 7 Maratho n Ashland Petroleu

m LL C Marathon Ashland Petroleum , LL C Maratho n Ashlan d Petroleu m LL C Maratho n Ashlan d Petroleu m LL C Maratho n Ashlan d Petroleu m LL C Mobi l Oi l Corporation Mobi l Corporation PD V Midwes t

Refining , LL

C Peerles s Oi

l an d Chemicals , Inc
. Petroleo s D

e Venezuel aS.A
. Phillip s Petroleu

mCompan

y Phillip s Petroleu

mCompan

y Refiner y Holding Company , L.P
. Shel l Oi l Compan y Shel l Oi l Compan y Shel l Oi l Compan y Facilit y Nam e Corpu s Christ

i West Refiner y Corpu s Christ

i Eas t Refiner y Pine Ben d Facilit y Lyondell-Citg o Refinin

g Compan y Ltd
. Texa s Cit y Refiner y Ohi o Refinin

g Division Minnesot aRefinin g Division-St
. Pau l Par k Refiner y Michiga n Refinin g Division Louisian aRefinin

g Division Illinoi s Refinin

g Division

Robinson Refiner

y Mobi l Oi l Torranc e Refiner

y Mobi l Beaumon t Refiner y PD V Midwest

Refining , L.L.C , Lemon t Refiner y Peerles s Oi

l an d Chemicals , Inc
. Lak e Charle s Manufacturin

g Facilit y Sween y Refiner y an d Petrochemica

l Comple x Phillip s Borge

r Refiner y & NG L Cente r Refiner y Holdin g Co
. Refiner

y (Sout h Facility ) Shel l Norc o Chemica

l Compan y (West Site ) Shel l Norc o Refinin

g Compan y Dee r Par k Refiner y Type o

f Dat a Submitte d Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y N o Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Facilit

y Reported Applicabl e OL

D Operations ? Ye s Ye s Ye s .Ye s Ye s N o Ye s N o Ye s Ye s N o N o Ye s N o N o Ye s Ye s N o Ye s Ye s N o



# HP. 6

- V . 1

Mem o o n Refinerie s wit h OL D Decembe r

1 , 199 9 Pag e 5 Refinerie s tha tResponde d t o th e O.L.D . Surve y (concluded ) Lega l Owne r Shel l Oi l Compan y Sinclai r Oi l Corporation Sinclai r Oi l Corporation Sinclai r Oi l Corporation Th e Coasta l Corporation ' Ultrama r Diamon d Shamroc k Ultrama r Diamon d Shamroc k Corporation Ultrama r Diamon d Shamroc k Ultrama r Diamon d Shamroc k Corporation Valer o Energy Corporation Valer o Energy Corporation Valer o Energy Corporation Valer o Refinin g Company-Texa s Facilit y Nam e Shel l Norc o Chemica

l Compan y (Eas t Site ) Sinclair , Little Americ aRefiner y Sinclair , Wyomin

g Refiner y Tuls aRefiner

y Coasta l Refinin g an d Marketing , Inc
. Alm aRefiner y TR I Petroleum , Inc
. Ardmor

e Refiner y Colorad o Refinin g Compan y Three Rivers Refiner

y Valer o Refinin g Compan y - Louisian a Corpu s Christ

i Refiner y Valer o Refinin g Company-Texas Cit y Refiner y Housto n Refiner y Typ e o f Dat a Submitte d Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y N o Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Surve y Facilit

y Reporte d Applicabl e OLD Operations ? Ye s No Ye s No Ye s N o No No N o Ye s Ye s Ye s Ye s