### U.S . DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATIO

N R F C P ! V P F l OFFIC E O F HEARING S | \l—^ ^ •— k vI^L- f WASHINGTON . D.C . JA N 1 P , 201 1 

### I N TH E MATTE R O F FLIGHTSTA R AIRCRAF T SERVICES , INC .

FAA DOCKE T NO . CP10GL001 2 (Civi l Penalt

yAction ) 

## l^tEARlN G DOCKE T

.^ 3 DMSNO . FAA-2010-107 6 r'^S^ ^ FA A CAS E NO . 2008-GL-05-002 2 J S^Z: ^



## - S§ ^ Administrativ e La

w Judg e Richar

d C . Goodwi n J ^ tr > 

### REQUES T FO R DISCOVER Y Pursuan t t o Rule s 26(b ) an d 34(a) o f th e Federa l Rule s of Civi l Procedure , an d Sectio n 13.22 0 o f th e Rule s of Practic e i n FA A Civi l Penalt

yAction s Proceedings , th e Federa l Aviatio n Administration , b

ycounsel , herebyrequests that Respondent , withi n 3 0 day s afte rservice o

f thi s document , suppl yth e followin g data : 

### INTERROGATORIE S Interrogator yNo . 1 : Identify , b yprovidin g th e name , occupation , an d busines s o r hom e address , eac h perso n Responden t intend s t o cal l a s a witnes s i n thi s proceeding . Interrogator yNo . 2 : Provid e a summaryo f th e fact s t o whic h eac h intende d witnes s identifie d i n InterrogatoryNo . 1 i s expecte d t o testify , an d fo reac h exper t identifie d yo u propos e t o us e a s a n expert , stat e th e subjec t matte ro f his/he rtestimon yan d th e substanc e o f th e fact s an d opinion s t o whic h th e exper t i s expecte d t o testify . Interrogator yNo . 3 : Identif yan yan d al l document s i n th e possessio n o f Responden t tha t concern , refe rto , o rinvolv e th e circumstance s se t fort h i n th e Septembe r24 , 2010 , Fina l Notic e o f Propose d Civi l Penalty , includin g bu t no t limite d t o an ydocumentatio n yo u have .

### InterrogatoryNo . 4 : Stat e wit h specificit yan yfact whic h Responden t assert s supports th e allegation s i t make s i n affirmativ e defens e 1 . InterrogatoryNo . 5 : Stat e wit h specificityan yfact whic h Responden t assert s supports th e allegation s i t make s i n affirmativ e defens e 2 . InterrogatoryNo . 6 : Stat e wit h specificityan yfac t whic h Responden t assert s supports th e allegation s i t make s i n affirmativ e defens e 3 . InterrogatoryNo . 7 : Stat e wit h specificit yan yan d al l circumstance s surroundin g th e violation s that yo u asser

t th e Agenc

yfaile d t o take int o accoun t i n determinin g its fina l propose d civi l penalty . InterrogatoryNo . 8 : Stat e wit h specificit yan yan d al l fact s whic h yo u asser t suppor t a reductio n of th e propose d civi l penalt ybase d upo n Respondent s abilityt o pay . InterrogatoryNo . 9 : Stat e wit h specificit yan yfact whic h Responden t assert s supports th e allegation s i t make s as t o reasonabl e reliance . Interrogatory10 : Stat e wit h specificityan yfact whic h Responden t assert s supports th e allegation s i t make s i n affirmativ e defens e 8 , tha t th e Agency' s interpretatio n of its regulatio n i s arbitrary , capricious , and/ o a n abus e of discretion . Interrogatory11 : Stat e wit h specificityan yfact whic h Responden t assert s supports th e allegation s i t make s i n affirmativ e defens e 9 that th e FAA' s interpretatio n of its regulatio n i s unconstitutionall yvague , an d wh yyo u asser t thi s tribuna l has jurisdictio n ove rthat question . InterrogatoryNo . 12 : Stat e wit h specificit yan yfact whic h Responden t assert s supports th e allegation s i t make s i n affirmativ e defens e 1 0 that th e FA A applicatio n o

f its Federa l Aviatio n regulatio n i n thi s cas e i s contrar yt o th e regulation s plai n language . InterrogatoryNo . 13 : I f yo u inten d t o asser t a n inabilit

yt o pa yth e civi l penalt

yth e Administrato rhas propose d t o assess , stat e wit h specifi c detai l th e basi s of that assertion . 

### REQUEST FO R PRODUCTIO N O F DOCUMENTS Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 1 : Produce copie s of curren t curricul a vita e fo reac h exper

t witnes s Responden t identifie d i n Interrogator yNo . 1 .

-2 -Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 2 : Produc e copie s o f an ystatement s i n

you rpossessio n mad e an ywitnesses , referrin g to , o rinvolvin g th e circumstance s se t fort h i n th e Septembe r24 , 2010 , Notic e o f Propose d Civi l Penalty . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 3 : Produc e copie s o f al l document s an d othe rmaterial s tha t Responden t intend s t o introduc e int o evidence . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 4 : Produc e copie s o f al l document s tha t Responden t identifie d i n InterrogatoryNo . 3 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 5 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r1 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 6 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r2 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 7 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r3 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 8 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r4 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 9 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r5 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 10 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r6 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 11 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r7 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 12 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r8 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 13 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r9 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 14 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r10 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 15 : Provid e an yan d al l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r11 . Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 16 : Provid e an yan d ai l documentatio n i n Skyway' s possessio n tha t support s it s affirmativ e defens e numbe r12 .Reques t fo rProductio n o f Document s No . 1 7 t o th e exten t no t provide d i n

respons e t o Reques t fo rproductio n no . 1 0 an d 1 1 produc e copie s o f an yan d al l evidenc e you hav e t o suppor t you rassertio n base d o n a n inabilit yt o pay . A Departmen t o f Justic e financia l disclosur e for m i s provide d t o assis t yo u i n doin g so , shoul d yo u wis h t o utiliz e it . Fo rth e Agenc y Glen n L . Brow n Senio rAttorne y

-4 -FAA Docke t C P CP10GL001 2

(Civi l PenaltyAction ) SERVIC E SHEE T CERTIFICAT E O F SERVIC E I hereb ycertif ytha t th e foregoin g pleadin g ha s bee n maile d thi s dat e byCertifie d Mail , Retur n Receip t Requested , to : Origina l an d On e Copy : Hearin g Docke t Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S . W . Washington , D C 2059 1 Attn : Hearin g Docke t Cler k AGC-430 , Wilbe rWright Buildin g Suit e 2W100 0 On e Copy : GregoryS . Winton , Esq . Th e Aviatio n Law Fir m On e Researc h Court , Suit e 45 0 Rockville , M D 2085 0 An d vi a Facsimil e 30 1 29 4 252 5 Date d thi s 11t h da yo f January , 2011 . By : Tamm yGardne r Lega l Technicia n