p.1 

OAR Box 1828 

Prepped by Ollie Stewart 

Document Number: 

279) ll-K-(I)-92 

Docket Number: 

A-83-27 

Printed 11/12/200811:12:58 AM Sheet 279 of 325 
1990 PROJECTED NEM INDUSTRIAL FOSSIL FUEL-FIRED BOILER 

AIR EMISSIONS, FUEL DEMAND, AND COSTS 

(5TH ROUND S02 NSPS ANALYSIS — HIGHER OIL AND GAS PRICES) 

(DASE CASE AND OPTION CASES !-<•> 

PREPARED FOR: 

THE U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

PREPARED BY: 

ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS, INC. 

1655 NORTH FORT MYER DRIVE 

ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 22209 

07/26/0* I \ 

I 

A 

I r^ 

x—t 

9 - / 

I 

ID 

ro 

CO i 

u 

ho 
NOTES ON IFCAM PROJECTIONS 

1. REVISED NATH SCRUBBER COSTS 

LSD FGO RESTRICTED TO LOW SULFUR COAL TYPES (B AND D ONLY) 

INCLUDES ESTIMATES OF INTEREST DURING CONSTRUCTION. 

2. BASE CASE 

- S02: CURRENT NSPS 

- PM: PROPOSED NSPS (49 FR 25103) 

- NOX: LEA OR SCA REQUIRED (> 100 MMBTU/HR) 

3. OPTION CASE 1 

- COAL TYPE B, 0.3 AND 0.8 PERCENT SULFUR RESIDUAL FUEL OILS ARE 

IN COMPLIANCE 

- AT LEAST 50 PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED ON NON-COMPLIANCE FUELS 

Ct. OPTION CASE 2 

- NO COMPLIANCE COAL TYPES 

- 0.3 AND 0.8 PERCENT SULFUR RESIDUAL FUEL OIL ARE IN COMPLIANCE 

- AT LEAST 50 PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED ON NON-COMPLIANCE FUELS 

5. OPTION CASE 3 

- NO COMPLIANCE COAL TYPES 

- 0.3 PERCENT SULFUR RESIDUAL FUEL OIL IS IN COMPLIANCE 

- 70-90 PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED ON NON-COMPLIANCE FUELS 

6. OPTION CASE <t 

- COAL TYPES B AND D ARE COMPLIANCE FUELS FOR 100-250 MMBTU/HR 

- COAL TYPE B IS THE ONLY COMPLIANCE COAL TYPE FOR >250MMBTU/HR 

- 1.6, 0.8 ANO 0.3 PERCENT SULFUR RESIDUAL FUEL OILS ARE 

COMPLIANCE FUELS FOR 100-250 HI1BTU/HR 

- 0.8 AND 0.3 PERCENT SULFUR RESIDUAL FUEL OILS ARE COMPLIANCE 

FUELS FOR >250 MMBTU/HR 

- AT LEAST 50 PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED ON NON-COMPLIANCE 

FUELS 

7. OPTION CASES 5-7 

- PRESENTED IH A SEPERATE REPORT 

CO 
INDUSTRIAL BOILER NEW SOURCE PERFORMANCE STANDARDS ASSUMPTIONS 

OPTION CASE 1 (AR0132 ) 

BOILER SIZE CATEGORY (MMBTU/HR HEAT INPUT) 

NATURAL GAS 

SO2 CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

PM CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

S02 CEILING (LB/MM3TU) 

PM CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

S02 CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

Pri CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

NOX CEILDJG ( LB/MMBTU ) 

COAL 

T02 CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

;;l CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

- TCR <30Z CU 

NOX CEILING (LD/MMDTU) 

10-30 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

30-50 

NONE 

HONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

50-75 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

75-100 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

100-150 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

0.90 

NONE 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

150-200 

NONE 

NOfJE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

0.90 

NONE 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

200-250 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

0.90 

NONE 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

>250 

NONE 

NONE 

0.30 

NONE 

0.10 

0.30 

0.90 

0.10 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.05 

0.70 

MANDATORY SCRUBBING REGULATIONS 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

S02 FLOOR (LB/MMBTU) 

PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED 

MINIMUM PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIREO 

LOW SULFUR EXEMPTION FOR COAL (LB/MMBTU) 

COAL 

S.02 FLOOR (LB/MMBTU) 

PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED 

MINIMUM PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED 

LOW SULFUR EXEMPTION FOR COAL (LB/MMBTU) 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

HONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

0.65 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.20 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

0.05 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.20 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

0.05 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.20 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

0.85 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.20 
INDUSTRIAL BOILER NEM SOURCE PERFORMANCE STANDARDS ASSUMPTIONS 

NATURAL GAS 

S02 CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

PM CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

S02 CEILING (LD/MII3TU) 

PM CEILING ( LD/MtiaTU) 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

$02 CEILING (LB/MM3TU) 

PI1 CCILlf.'G ( LB/MMBTU) 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

COAL 

S02 CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

PM CEILING (LB/MM3TU) 

- FOR <30Z CU 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

S02 FLOOR (LB/MMBTU) 

PEPCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED 

MINIMUM PERCENT SOC REMOVAL REQUIRED 

LOW SULFUR EXEMPTION FOR COAL (LB/MMBTU) 

COAL 

S02 FLOOR (LB/MMBTU) 

PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED 

MINIMUM PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED 

LOW SULFUR EXEMPTION FOR COAL (LB/MMBTU) 

OPTION 

10-30 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

MANDATORY 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

CASE 2 (AR0133 ) 

BOILER SIZE CATEGORY (MMBTU/HR HEAT INPUT) 

30-50 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

SCRUBBING 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

50-75 75 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

REGULATIONS 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

-100 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

100-150 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

0.90 

NONE 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

0.85 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

NONE 

150-200 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

0.90 

NONE 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

0.85 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

NONE 

200-250 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

0.90 

NONE 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

0.85 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

NONE 

1 

>250 

NONE 

NONE 

0.30 

NONE 

0.10 

0.30 

0.90 

0.10 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.05 

0.70 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

0.85 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

NONE 

• • « 

-
INDUSTRIAL BOILER NEW SOURCE PERFORMANCE STANDARDS ASSUMPTIONS 

OPTION CASE 3 (AR0134 ) 

BOILER SIZE CATEGORY (MMBTU/HR HEAT INPUT) 

NATURAL GAS 

SOC CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

PM CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

502 CEILING < LB/MMBTU) 

FM CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

SOC CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

PM CEILING (LB/MM3TU) 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

COAL 

"02 CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

r,1 CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

- FOR <30Z CU 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

10-30 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

((ONE 

30-50 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

50-75 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

75-100 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

100-150 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

1.20 

NONE 

0.31 

1.20 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

150-200 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

1.20 

NONE 

0.31 

1.20 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

200-250 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

1.20 

NONE 

0.31 

1.20 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

>250 

NONE 

NONE 

0.30 

NONE 

0.10 

0.30 

1.20 

0.10 

0.31 

1.20 

0.05 

0.05 

0.70 

MANDATORY SCRUBBING REGULATIONS 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

so; rLOorc (LB/MMBTU) 

PERCENT SOC REMOVAL R.CQUIRE0 

MINIMUM PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED 

LOW SULFUR EXEMPTION FOR COAL (LB/MMBTU) 

COAL 

SOC FLOOR (LB/MMBTU) 

PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED 

MINIMUM PERCENT SOC REMOVAL REQUIRED 

LOW SULFUR EXCHPTION FOR COAL (LO/IIMBTU) 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

HONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE . 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

0.60 

90.00 

70.00 

0.35 

0.60 

90.00 

70.00 

NONE 

0.60 

90.00 

70.00 

0.35 

0.60 

90.00 

70.00 

NONE 

0.60 

90.00 

70.00 

0.35 

0.60 

90.00 

70.00 

NONE 

0.60 

90.00 

70.00 

0.35 

0.60 

90.00 

70.00 

NONE 
INDUSTRIAL BOILER NEW SOURCE PERFORMANCE STANDARDS ASSUMPTIONS 

OPTION CASE -> (AR0133 ) 

BOILER SIZE CATEGORY (MMBTU/HR HEAT INPUT) 

NATURAL GAS 

SOC CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

PM CEILING (LB/MM3TU) 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

SOC CEILING (LB/MM3TU) 

PM CEILING (LB/MM3TU) 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

SOC CEILING (LB/MM3TU) 

rn cri i inn urvnimTU) 

NOX CEILING ( LlVIIIIOrU) 

COAL 

SOC CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

FM CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

- FC? <.0/. CU 

NOX CEILING (LB/MMBTU) 

10-30 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NOI It 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

((ONE 

30-50 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NOIIC 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

50-75 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

HONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

75-100 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NOIIC 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

100-150 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

0.90 

NONE 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

150-200 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

0.90 

NONE 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

200-250 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

NONE 

NONE 

0.20 

0.90 

NONE 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.20 

0.60 

>250 

NONE 

NONE 

0.30 

NOHE 

0.10 

0.30 

0.90 

0.10 

0.31 

0.90 

0.05 

0.05 

0.70 

MANDATORY SCRUBBING REGULATIONS 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

SOC FLOOR (LB/MMBTU) 

rcRcr.NT soc REMOVAL REQUIREO 

MINIMUM PIPCCNT SOC RCMOVAL REQUIRED 

LOW SULFUR EXEMPTION TOR COAL (LD/MIIBTU) 

COAL 

SOC FLOOR (LB/MMBTU) 

PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED 

MINIMUM PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED 

LOW SULFUR EXEMPTION FOR COAL (LB/MMBTU) 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

HONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

((ONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

HONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.75 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.70 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.75 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.70 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.75 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.70 

NONE 

50.00 

HONE 

0.05 

NONE 

50.00 

NONE 

1.20 
LIST OF TABLES 

DESCRIPTION OF TADLE TABLE NUMBER 

FUEL DEMAND 

- NUMBER OF UNITS 

- BTUS OF FUEL CONSUMPTION 

POLLUTANT EMISSIONS 

COSTS 

3 

4 

NOX ONLY 

- CONTROL COSTS 

- EMISSIONS 

NATIONAL IMPACTS BY SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

- 10-50 

- 50-75 

- 75-100 

- 100-150 

- 150-200 

- 200-250 

- > 250 

- > 100 

- 100-250 

- > 50 

- TOTAL 

7 

8 

9 

10 

11 

12 

13 

14 

15 

16 

17 

bo 
TABLE 1 — 1990 FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

10-50 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

"TOTAL* 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OIU ION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

NATURAL GAS 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

COAL 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

CASE 

CASE 

CAGE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

4 

ANO OIL 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

4 

1 

2 

3 

4 

1412 

1412 

HilC 

1412 

1412 

1251 

1251 

1251-

1251 

1251 

161 

161 

161 

161 

161 

577. 

577. 

577. 

577. 

577. 

398. 

398. 

398. 

398. 

398. 

179. 

179. 

179. 

179. 

179. 

271. 

271. 

C7I . 

271. 

271. 

212. 

239. 

254. 

254. 

217. 

59. 

32. 

17. 

17. 

54. 

135. 

135. 

135. 

135. 

135. 

55. 

71. 

115. 

115. 

71. 

00. 

64. 

20. 

20. 

64. 

62. 

62. 

62. 

62. 

62. 

21. 

26. 

49. 

49. 

26. 

41. 

36. 

13. 

13. 

36. 

136. 

136. 

136. 

136. 

136. 

70. 

70. 

86. 

86. 

70. 

66. 

66. 

50. 

50. 

66. 

2593. 

2593. 

2593. 

2593. 

2593. 

2007. 

2055. 

2153. 

2153. 

2033. 

586. 

538. 

440. 

440. 

560. 

Tl 
TABLE 2 — 1990 FUEL 0EMANO 

(10**12 BTUS) 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

10-50 50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

"TOTAL* 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

NATURAL GAS 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

4 

1 

2 

3 

4 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

COAL 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

4 

1 

2 

3 

4 

132. 

132. 

132. 

132. 

132. 

86. 

86. 

86. 

06. 

86. 

9. 

9. 

9. 

9. 

9. 

36. 

36. 

36. 

36. 

36. 

136. 

136. 

136. 

136. 

136. 

59. 

59. 

59. 

59. 

59. 

6. 

6. 

6. 

6. 

6. 

72. 

72. 

72. 

72. 

72. 

129. 

129. 

129. 

129. 

129. 

82. 

105. 

117. 

117. 

92. 

7. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

40. 

23. 

12. 

12. 

37. 

111. 

111. 

111. 

IU. 

111. 

41. 

56. 

88. 

88. 

56. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

70. 

55. 

23. 

23. 

55. 

67. 

67. 

67. 

67. 

67. 

19. 

24. 

50. 

50. 

24. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

48. 

43. 

17. 

17. 

43. 

191. 

191. 

191. 

191. 

191. 

65. 

65. 

90. 

90. 

65. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

126. 

126. 

101. 

101. 

126. 

766. 

766. 

766. 

766. 

766. 

352. 

396. 

490. 

490. 

382. 

22. 

15. 

15. 

15. 

15. 

392. 

356. 

261. 

C61. 

369. 

o 
TADLE 3 — 1990 EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

10-50 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

S02 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OP1ION 

OPdON 

OPTION 

PM 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

NOX 

THE DASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

PMIO 

TIIE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CADE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

4 

1 

2 

3 

4 

1 

2 

3 

4 

1 

2 

3 

4 

6 8 . 

6 8 . 

6 8 . 

60. 

6 0 . 

1 1 . 

1 1 . 

1 1 . 

1 1 . 

1 1 . 

13. 

13. 

13. 

13. 

13. 

0. 

8 . 

8 . 

8 . 

8 . 

121. 

121. 

121. 

121. 

121. 

19. 

19. 

19. 

19. 

19. 

23. 

23. 

23. 

23. 

23. 

14. 

14. 

14. 

14. 

14. 

74. 

1 1 . 

4. 

3. 

24. 

2. 

1 . 

1 . 

1 . 

1 . 

17. 

14. 

12. 

12. 

16. 

O 

1 . 

1 . 

1 . 

1 . 

108. 

25. 

7. 

5. 

37. 

1. 

1 . 

1. 

I . 

1 . 

23. 

20. 

15. 

15. 

20. 

8 6. 

20. 

5. 

3. 

29. 

15. 

14. 

9. 

9. 

14. 

59. 

58. 

30. 

19. 

58. 

2. 

2 . 

2 . 

2 . 

2 . 

4 3 . 

43. 

37. 

37. 

43. 

- . a, 

2. 

2. 

2. 

2 . 

515 

304 

235 

219 

337 

36 

35 

34 

34 

35 

134 

127 

109 

109 

129 

20 

27 

26 

26 

27 
ANNUALIZED COSTS 

THE BASE CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

CAPITAL COSTS 

THE BASE CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

-

1 

2 

3 

4 

-

1 

2 

3 

4 

10-50 

TOTAL 

1322.7 

1322.7 

1322.7 

1322.7 

1322.7 

TOTAL 

1584.9 

1534.9 

1584.9 

1584.9 

1584.9 

TABLE 4 — 1990 COSTS 

(10**6, $1932) 

BOILER SIZE 

50-100 

1159.6 

1159.6 

1159.6 

1159.6 

1159.6 

1881.4 

1881.4 

1881.4 

1881.4 

1881.4 

100-150 

1008.0 

1008.7 

1010.6 

1010.9 

1013.0 

1294.3 

1021.1 

804.2 

884.3 

1231.4 

(MMBTU/HR) 

150-200 

837.6 

843.7 

832.1 

832.7 

836.1 

1521.2 

1300.4 

777.6 

777.8 

1296.6 

200-250 

493.1 

504.4 

500.4 

500.9 

499.7 

919.9 

838.8 

495.2 

495.3 

844.5 

> 250 

1386.3 

13S6.5 

1411.1 

1413.6 

1386.5 

2189.4 

2189.5 

1920.2 

1920.8 

2189.5 

TOTAL 

6207.3 

6225.6 

6236.6 

6240.4 

6217.7 

9391.2 

8816.1 

7543.5 

7544.5 

9028.2 

Tl 

r\> 
TABLE 5 — 1990 NOX CONTROL ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1900 

10-50 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

"TOTAL* 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

NATURAL GAS 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

COAL 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

4 

ANO OIL 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 n 

4 

1 

2 

3 

4 

-4.1 

-4.1 

-4.1 

-4.1 

-4.1 

-4.0 

-4.0 

-4.0 

-4.0 

-4.0 

-0.1 

-0.1 

-0.1 

-0.1 

-0.1 

-4.9 

-4.9 

-4.9 

-4.9 

-4.9 

-4.2 

-4.2 

-4.2 

-4.C 

-4.2 

-0.6 

-0.6 

-0.6 

-0.6 

-0.6 

1.3 

-2.5 

-3.6 

-3.6 

-1.1 

-1.4 

-3.8 

-4.1 

-4.1 

-3.5 

2.7 

1.3 

0.6 

0.6 

2.4 

3.6 

1.8 

-1.0 

-1.0 

1.8 

-1.1 

-1.0 

-2.7 

-2.7 

-1.8 

4.7 

3.6 

1.6 

1.8 

3.6 

0.4 

-0.4 

-5.6 

-5.6 

-0.4 

-2.4 

-3.0 

-6.6 

-6.6 

-3.0 

2.9 

2.6 

1.0 

1.0 

2.6 

-1.9 

-1.9 

-7.7 

-7.7 

-1.9 

-9.6 

-9.6 

-13.7 

-13.7 

-9.6 

7.7 

7.7 

6.0 

6.0 

7.7 

-5.5 

-11.9 

-26.7 

-26.7 

-10.5 

-22.a 

-26.4 

-35.4 

-35.4 

-26.2 

17.4 

14.6 

8.7 

8.7 

15.7 
TABLE 6 ~ 1990 NOX EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

10-50 50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

"TOTAL* 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

NATURAL GAS 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

4 

ANO OIL 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

4 

COAL 

THE BASE CASE 

OPTION CASE 1 

OPTION CASE 2 

OPTION CASE 3 

OPTION CASE 4 

13.4 

13.4 

13.4 

13.4 

13.4 

7.6 

7.6 

7.6 

7.6 

7.6 

5.8 

5.8 

5.8 

5.8 

5.8 

22.6 

22.6 

22.6 

22.6 

22.6 

4.7 

4.7 

4.7 

4.7 

4.7 

17.9 

17.9 

17.9 

17.9 

17.9 

17.1 

13.5 

11.5 

U.5 

16.0 

6.7 

7.4 

8.6 

0.6 

6.4 

10.4 

6.1 

2.9 

2.9 

9.6 

23.0 

20.1 

14.8 

14.8 

20.2 

3.9 

5.3 

8.4 

0.4 

5.3 

19.1 

14.8 

6.4 

6.4 

14.9 

15.0 

14.2 

9.4 

9.4 

14.2 

1.9 

2.3 

4.8 

4.0 

2.3 

13.1 

11.9 

4.6 

4.6 

11.9 

42.6 

42.6 

36.9 

36.9 

42.6 

6.2 

6.2 

8.6 

0.6 

6.2 

36.4 

36.4 

28.3 

28.3 

36.4 

133.7 

126.6 

108.6 

108.6 

129.2 

30.9 

33.6 

42.6 

42.6 

32.7 

102.8 

93.0 

66.0 

66.0 

96.5 
TABLE 7 — INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

10-50 THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

OPTION 

CASE 4 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL* 

1251. 

161. 

1412. 

1251. 

161. 

1412. 

1251. 

161. 

1412. 

1251. 

161. 

1412. 

1251. 

161. 

1412. 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIOUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

86. 

0. 

9. 

36. 

132. 

86. 

0. 

9. 

36. 

132. 

86. 

0. 

9. 

36. 

132. 

66. 

0. 

9. 

36. 

132. • 

86. 

0. 

9. 

36. 

132. 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

68.4 

10.9 

13.4 

8.0 

68.4 

10.9 

13.4 

8.0 

68.4 

10.9 

13.4 

8.0 

68.4 

10.9 

13.4 

8.0 

68.4 

10.9 

13.4 

8.0 

EMISSIONS 

.'/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $19821 

BOILER 

FGO AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

•TOTAL" 

651.3 

11.5 

-4.1 

664.0 

1322.7 

651.3 

U.S 

-4.1 

664.0 

1322.7 

651.3 

U.5 

-4.1 

664.0 

1322.7 

651.3 

11.5 

-4.1 

664.0 

1322.7 

651.3 

U.5 

-4.1 

664.0 

1322.7 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

{•/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

•TOTAL* 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGO AND PM 

NOX 

"TOTAL* 

1524. 

31. 

30. 

1585. 

1524. 

31. 

30. 

1585. 

1524. 

31. 

30. 

1585. 

1524. 

31. 

30.' 

1505. 

1524. 

31. 

30. 

1505. 

Tl 

CJi 
TABLE 8 INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE 

50-75 

(MMBTU/HR) 

THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

OPTION 

CASE 4 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

291. 

U l. 

402. 

291. 

U l. 

402. 

291. 

U l. 

402. 

291. 

U l. 

402. 

291. 

111. 

402. 

FUEL DEMAND 

( 10**1 2 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL" 

38. 

0. 

4. 

40. 

83. 

38. 

0. 

4. 

40. 

83. 

38. 

0. 

4. 

40. 

83. 

38. 

0. 

4. 

40. 

83. 

38 

0 

4 

40 

63 

EMISSIONS 

( 10**3 TONS) 

SOC 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

66.4 

10.8 

13.2 

7.8 

66.4 

10.8 

13.2 

7.8 

66.4 

10.6 

13.2 

7.8 

66.4 

10.0 

13.2 

7.8 

66.4 

10.8 

13.2 

7.8 

EMISSIONS 

(X CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PI1 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZEO COSTS 

(10**6, $1902) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

"TOTAL" 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

\.7. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

"TOTAL" 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

351.5 

13.2 

-2.9 

360.1 

721.9 

351.5 

13.2 

-2.9 

360.1 

721.9 

351.5 

13.2 

-2.9 

360.1 

721.9 

351.5 

13.2 

-2.9 

360.1 

721.9 

351.5 

13.2 

-2.9 

360.1 

721.9 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGO AND PM 

NOX 

"TOTAL" 

1084. 

34. 

10. 

1127. 

1084. 

34. 

10. 

1127. 

1084. 

34. 

10. 

1127. 

1084. 

34. 

10. 

1127. 

1084. 

34. 

10. 

1127. 

Tl 
TABLE 9 ~ INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

75-100 THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

OPTION 

CASE 4 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL" 

107. 

6 0 . 

175. 

107. 

6 0 . 

175. 

107. 

6 0 . 

175. 

107. 

6 0 . 

175. 

107. 

6 8 . 

175. 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

2 0 . 

0 . 

2 . 

3 1 . 

5 4 . 

2 0 . 

0 . 

2 . 

3 1 . 

5 4 . 

2 0 . 

0 . 

2 . 

3 1 . 

5 4 . 

2 0 . 

0 . 

2 . 

3 1 . 

5 4 . 

2 0 . 

0 . 

2 . 

3 1 . 

5 4 . 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

SOC 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

54.6 

8.6 

9.4 

6.3 

54.6 

8.6 

9.4 

6.3 

54.6 

8.6 

9.4 

6.3 

54.6 

8.6 

9.4 

6.3 

54.6 

8.6 

9.4 

6.3 

EMISSIONS 

(X CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

SOC 

PI I 

NOX 

FM10 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) ' 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

"TOTAL* 

213.8 

9.0 

-1. 9 

216.8 

437.7 

213.8 

9.0 

-1. 9 

216.8 

437.7 

213.0 

9.0 

-1. 9 

216.8 

437.7 

213.8 

9.0 

-1. 9 

216.8 

437.7 

213.8 

9.0 

-1. 9 

216.8 

437.7 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

iV. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

"TOTAL* 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

*TOTAL* 

725. 

2 4 . 

5 . 

754. 

725. 

2 4 . 

5 . 

754. 

725. 

2 4 . 

5 . 

754. 

725. 

2 4 . 

5 . 

754. 

725. 

2 4 . 

5 . 

754. 

Tl 
TABLE 10 — INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1906-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

100-150 THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

OPTION 

CASE 4 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL» 

212. 

59. 

271. 

239. 

32. 

271. 

254. 

17. 

271. 

254. 

17. 

271. 

217 

54 

271 

FUEL OEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL" 

82. 

0. 

7. 

40. 

129. 

105. 

0. 

0. 

23. 

129. 

117. 

0. 

0. 

12. 

129. 

117. 

0. 

0. 

12. 

129. 

92. 

0. 

0. 

37. 

129. 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

EMISSIONS 

(V. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

SOC 

PH 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGO ANO PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

"TOTAL* 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

{.-/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

"TOTAL* 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

•TOTAL" 

74.0 

1.8 

17.1 

1.8 

11.2 

0.9 

13.5 

0.9 

3.8 

0.8 

U.5 

0.8 

2.5 

0.8 

U.5 

0.8 

24.2 

1.0 

16.0 

1.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

-04.9 

-50.0 

-21.1 

-50.0 

-94.9 

-55.6 

-32.7 

-55.6 

-96.6 

-55.6 

-32.7 

-55.6 

-67.3 

-44.4 

-6.4 

-44.4 

354.5 

22.6 

1.3 

629.5 

008.0 

301.7 

12.6 

-2.5 

696.9 

1008.7 

270.9 

14.2 

-3.6 

729.0 

1010.6 

270.9 

14.5 

-3.6 

729.0 

1010.9 

343.1 

20.6 

-1.1 

650.3 

1013.0 

0.0 0.1 0.3 0.3 

1196. 

79. 

20. 

1294. 

964. 

43. 

15. 

1021. 

834. 

36. 

14. 

884. 

834. 

36. 

14. 

884. 

1145. 

72. 

15. 

1231. 

Tl 

00 
TABLE 11 INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMDTU/HR) 

150-200 THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

OPTION 

CASE 4 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL" 

55. 

60. 

35. 

71. 

64. 

135. 

115. 

20. 

135. 

115. 

20. 

135. 

71 

64 

135 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL" 

41. 

0. 

0. 

70. 

U l . 

56. 

0. 

0. 

55. 

U l . 

83. 

0. 

0. 

23. 

U l. 

00. 

0. 

0. 

23. 

U l. 

56. 

0. 

0. 

55. 

U l . 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

. SOC 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

107.8 

1.3 

23.0 

1.2 

25.2 

1.1 

20.1 

1.1 

7.1 

0.8 

14.8 

0.8 

4.7 

0.8 

14.8 

O.B 

36.9 

1.1 

20.2 

1.1 

EMISSIONS 

('/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

SOC 

PI I 

NOX 

PMIO 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

-76.6 

-15.4 

-12.6 

-0.3 

-93.4 

-30.5 

-1T>.7 

-33.3 

-95.6 

-30.5 

-35.7 

-33.3 

-65.8 

-15.4 

-ICC 

-8.3 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

TCO AIID PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

"TOTAL" 

365.9 

40.2 

3.6 

427.9 

837.6 

320.2 

33.9 

1.8 

487.8 

843.7 

221.4 

C3.0 

-1.0 

508.7 

632.1 

221.4 

23.6 

-1.0 

588.7 

832.7 

320.2 

31.9 

1.6 

482.1 

836.1 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

iV. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

"TOTAL" 0.0 0.7 -0. 7 -0. 6 -0. 2 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6 , $1982) 

BOILER 

FGO AIIO PM 

NOX 

"TOTAL" 

1369. 

140. 

12. 

1521. 

1173. 

116. 

12. 

1300. 

714. 

53. 

11. 

778. 

714. 

53. 

11. 

778. 

1173 

112 

12 

1297 

Tl 

CO 
TABLE 12 — 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

200-250 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL* 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL* 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

SOC 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

EMISSIONS 

,•/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

SOC 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGO AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

"TOTAL" 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

./. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

"TOTAL" 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGO AND PM 

NOX 

"TOTAL" 

INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 

THE BASE 

CASE 

21. 

41. 

62. 

19. 

0. 

0. 

48. 

67. 

85.5 

0.8 

15.0 

0.8 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

-

223.7 

26.4 

0.4 

242.5 

493.1 

0.0 

824. 

88. 

8. 

920. 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

26. 

36. 

62. 

24. 

0. 

0. 

43. 

67. 

20.1 

0.8 

14.2 

0.8 

-76.5 

0.0 

-5.3 

0.0 

209.6 

23.5 

-0.4 

271.6 

504.4 

2.3 

754. 

77. 

8. 

839. 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

49. 

13. 

62. 

50. 

0. 

0. 

17. 

67. 

5.2 

0.5 

9.4 

0.5 

-93.9 

-37.5 

-37.3 

-37.5 

141.9 

18.5 

-5.6 

345.6 

500.4 

1.5 

446. 

41. 

8. 

495. 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

49. 

13. 

62. 

50. 

0. 

0. 

17. 

67. 

3.4 

0.5 

9.4 

0.5 

-96.0 

-37.5 

-37.3 

-37.5 

141.9 

18.9 

-5.6 

345.6 

500.9 

1.6 

446. 

41. 

8. 

495. 

1986-1990 

OPTION 

CASE 4 

26. 

36. 

62. 

24. 

0. 

0. 

43. 

67. 

20.8 

0.6 

14.2 

0.8 

-66.3 

0.0 

-5.3 

0.0 

210.5 

23.8 

-0.4 

265.9 

499.7 

1-3 

-

760. 

77. 

8. 

844. 

t 
TABLE 13 IHDUSTRIA.L BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE 

> 250 

(MMBTU/HR) 

THE BASE OPTION OPTION OPTION OPTION 

CASE CASE 1 CASE 2 CASE 3 CASE 4 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL" 

70. 

66. 

136. 

70. 

66. 

136. 

86. 86. 70. 

50. 50. 66. 

136. 136. 136. 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL" 

65. 

0. 

0. 

126. 

191. 

65. 

0. 

0. . 

126. 

191. 

90. 

0. 

0. 

101. 

191. 

90. 

0. 

0. 

101. 

191. 

65. 

0. 

0. 

126. 

191. 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

. S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

58.6 

2.2 

42.6 

2.2 

57.8 

2.2 

42.6 

2.2 

29.5 

1.9 

36.9 

1.9 

19.1 

1.9 

36.9 

1.9 

57.8 

2.2 

42.6 

2.2 

EMISSIONS 

('/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

502 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

-1.4 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

-49.7 

-13.6 

-13.4 

-13.6 

-67.4 

-13.6 

-13.4 

-13.6 

-1.4 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGO ANO PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

•TOTAL" 

558.2 

63.0 

-1.9 

767.1 

1386.3 

558.2 

63.1 

-1.9 

767.1 

1386.5 

496.1 

87.4 

-7.7 

835.4 

1411.1 

496.1 

89.9 

-7.7 

835.4 

1413.6 

558.2 

63.1 

-1.9 

767.1 

1386.5 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(X CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

•TOTAL* 0.0 0.0 1.8 2.0 0.0 

CAPITAL COSTS 

I 10**6, 41982) 

DOILER 

FGO AND PM 

NOX 

•TOTAL* 

1981. 

168. 

20. 

2189. 

1981. 

188. 

20. 

2189. 

1695. 

205. 

20. 

1920. 

1695. 

206. 

20. 

1921. 

1981. 

188. 

20. 

2189. 

Tl 

ho 
TABLE 14 — INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

> 100 THE BASE OPTION OPTION OPTION OPTION 

CASE CASE 1 CASE 2 CASE 3 CASE 4 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL" 

358. 406. 

246. 198. 

604. 604. 

504. 504. 384. 

100. 100. 220. 

604. 604. 604. 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL" 

207. 

0. 

7. 

284. 

498. 

250. 

0. 

0. 

248. 

498. 

345. 

0. 

0. 

153. 

498. 

345. 

0. 

0. 

153. 

498. 

237. 

0. 

0. 

261. 

498. 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

502 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

325.9 

6.1 

97.7 

6.0 

114.3 

5.0 

90.4 

5.0 

45.6 

4.0 

72.6 

4.0 

29.7 

4.0 

72.6 

4.0 

147.7 

5.1 

93.0 

5.1 

EMISSIONS 

{•/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

-64.9 

-18.0 

-7.5 

-16.7 

-06.0 

-34.4 

-25.7 

-33.3 

-90.9 

-34.4 

-25.7 

-33.3 

-54.7 

-16.4 

-4.8 

-15.0 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

"TOTAL" 

1502.4 

152.2 

3.4 

2067.0 

3725.1 

1389.6 

133.2 

-3.0 

2223.4 

3743.3 

1130.3 

143.0 

-17.8 

2498.7 

3754.3 

1130.3 

146.9 

-17.8 

2490.7 

3758.1 

1432.0 

139.5 

-1.5 

2165.4 

3735.4 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

{'/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

"TOTAL" 0.0 0.5 0.6 0.9 0.3 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $19821 

BOILER 

FCD AND PM 

NOX 

*TOTAL* 

5371. 

494. 

60. 

5925. 

4872. 

4C3. 

S4. 

5350. 

3609. 

335. 

53. 

4077. 

3689. 

336. 

53. 

4078. 

5059. 

449. 

55. 

5562. 

ru 

ru 
TABLE 15 — INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

100-250 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL* 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL* 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

EMISSIONS 

{.'/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

"TOTAL* 

THE BASE 

CASE 

288. 

180. 

468. 

142. 

0. 

7. 

158. 

307. 

267.3 

3.9 

55.1 

3.8 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

944.2 

89.2 

5.3 

1299.9 

2338.7 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

336. 

132. 

468. 

185. 

0. 

0. 

122. 

307. 

56.5 

2.8 

47.8 

2.8 

-78.9 

-28.2 

-13.2 

-26.3 

831.5 

70.1 

-1.1 

1456.3 

2356.8 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

418. 

50. 

468. 

255. 

0. 

0. 

52. 

307. 

16.1 

2.1 

35.7 

2.1 

-94.0 

-46.2 

-35.2 

-44.7 

634.2 

55.7 

-10.1 

1663.4 

2343.2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

418. 

50. 

468. 

255. 

0. 

0. 

52. 

307. 

10.6 

2.1 

35.7 

2.1 

-96.0 

-46.2 

-35.2 

-44.7 

634.2 

57.0 

-10.1 

1663.4 

2344.5 

OPTION 

CASE 4 

314. 

154. 

468. 

172. 

0. 

0. 

135. 

307. 

89.9 

2.9 

50.4 

2.9 

-66.4 

-25.6 

-8.5 

-23.7 

873.9 

76.3 

0.3 

1398.4 

2348.9 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(X CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

"TOTAL" 0.0 0.8 0.2 0.2 0.4 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGO AND PM 

NOX 

•TOTAL* 

3390. 

306. 

40. 

3735. 

2891. 

235. 

34. 

3160. 

1994. 

130. 

33. 

2157. 

1994. 

130. 

33. 

2157. 

3077. 

261. 

34. 

3372. 
TABLE 16 — INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

> 50 THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

OPTION 

CASE 4 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL" 

756. 

425. 

1181. 

804. 

377. 

1181. 

902. 

279. 

1181. 

902. 

279. 

1181. 

782 

399 

1161 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RCSIOUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

"TOTAL" 

266. 

0. 

13. 

355. 

634. 

309. 

0. 

6. 

319. 

634. 

404. 

0. 

6 . 

225. 

634. 

404. 

0. 

6. 

225. 

634. 

296 

0 

6 

332 

634 

EMISSIONS 

( 10**3 TONS) 

SOC 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

446.9 

25.5 

120.3 

20.1 

235.3 

24.4 

113.0 

19.1 

166.6 

23.4 

95.2 

18.1 

150.7 

C3.4 

95.2 

18.1 

260.7 

24.5 

115.6 

19.2 

EMISSIONS 

(X CHANGE 

SOC 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

FROM BASE CASE) 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

47. 3 

-4. 3 

-6. 1 

-5. 0 

-62. 7 

-0. 2 

-20. 9 

-10. 0 

-66.3 

-8. 2 

-20.9 

-10.0 

-39. 9 

-3. 9 

-3. 9 

-4. 5 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

"TOTAL" 

2067.8 

174.4 

-1. 4 

2643.9 

4884.6 

1955.0 

155.4 

-7. 8 

2800.3 

4902.8 

1695.7 

165.2 

-22. 6 

3075.6 

4913.8 

1695.7 

169.1 

-22.6 

3075.6 

4917.7 

1997.4 

161.6 

-6. 4 

2742.3 

4894.9 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(X CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

•TOTAL" 0.0 0.4 0.6 0.7 0.2 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGO AND PM 

NOX 

•TOTAL* 

7179. 

552. 

75. 

7806. 

6681 . 

481 . 

69. 

7231. 

5498. 

393. 

6 0 . 

5959. 

5498. 

394. 

68. 

5960. 

6867. 

507. 

70. 

7443. 
TABLE 17 INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIOHAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

TOTAL THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTIOM 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE .3 

OPTION 

CASE 4 

FUEL OEMAHD 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS ANO OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL* 

2007. 

506. 

2593. 

2055. 

530. 

2593. 

2153. 

440. 

2593. 

2153. 

440. 

2593. 

2033. 

560. 

2593. 

FUEL OEMAHD 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

352. 

0. 

22. 

392. 

766. 

396. 

0. 

15. 

356. 

766. 

490. 

0. 

15. 

261. 

766. 

490. 

0. 

15. 

261. 

766. 

382. 

0. 

15. 

369. 

766. 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

EMISSIONS 

(X CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGO AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

•TOTAL* 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(X CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

*TOTAL» 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

DOILCR 

FGD ANO PM 

NOX 

"TOTAL" 

515.2 

36.4 

133.7 

26.2 

303.6 

35.2 

126.6 

27.0 

235.0 

34.2 

108.6 

26.1 

219.0 

34.2 

108.6 

26.1 

337.0 

35.4 

129.2 

27.2 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

-41.1 

-3.3 

-5.3 

-4.3 

-54.4 

-6.0 

-18.8 

-7.4 

-57.5 

-6.0 

-18.8 

-7.4 

-34.6 

-2.7 

-3.4 

-3.5 

2719.1 

165.9 

-5.5 

3307.9 

6207.3 

2606 

166 

-11 

3464 

6225 

3 

9 

9 

2 

6 

2347.0 

176.7 

-26.7 

3739.5 

6236.6 

2347.0 

180.5 

-26.7 

3739.5 

6240.4 

2648.7 

173.1 

-10.5 

3406.3 

6217.7 

0.0 0.3 0.5 0.5 0.2 

8703. 

583. 

105. 

9391. 

8205. 

512. 

99. 

8816. 

7022. 

424. 

98. 

7544. 

7022. 

425. 

98. 

7544. 

8391. 

537. 

100. 

9028.