III

106TH CONGRESS

2D SESSION S. RES. 333

Expressing the sense of the Senate that there should be parity among the

countries that are parties to the North American Free Trade Agreement

with respect to the personal exemption allowance for merchandise purchased abroad by returning residents, and for other purposes.

IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES

JUNE 30, 2000

Ms. COLLINS (for herself, Mr. MOYNIHAN, Mr. KYL, Mr. GREGG, Mr. LEAHY,

and Ms. HUTCHISON) submitted the following resolution; which was referred to the Committee on Finance

JULY 27, 2000

Committee discharged; considered and agreed to

RESOLUTION

Expressing the sense of the Senate that there should be

parity among the countries that are parties to the North

American Free Trade Agreement with respect to the

personal exemption allowance for merchandise purchased

abroad by returning residents, and for other purposes.

Whereas the personal exemption allowance is a vital component of trade and tourism;

Whereas many border communities and retailers depend on

customers from both sides of the border;

Whereas a United States citizen traveling to Canada or Mexico for less than 24 hours is exempt from paying duties
2

•SRES 333 ATS

on the equivalent of $200 worth of merchandise on return to the United States, and for trips over 48 hours

United States citizens have an exemption of up to $400

worth of merchandise;

Whereas a Canadian traveling in the United States is allowed

a duty-free personal exemption allowance of only $50

worth of merchandise for a 24-hour visit, the equivalent

of $200 worth of merchandise for a 48-hour visit, and

the equivalent of $750 worth of merchandise for a visit

of over 7 days;

Whereas Mexico has a 2-tiered personal exemption allowance

for its returning residents, set at the equivalent of $50

worth of merchandise for residents returning by car and

the equivalent of $300 worth of merchandise for residents

returning by plane;

Whereas Canadian and Mexican retail businesses have an unfair competitive advantage over many American businesses because of the disparity between the personal exemption allowances among the 3 countries;

Whereas the State of Maine legislature passed a resolution

urging action on this matter;

Whereas the disparity in personal exemption allowances creates a trade barrier by making it difficult for Canadians

and Mexicans to shop in American-owned stores without

facing high additional costs;

Whereas the United States entered into the North American

Free Trade Agreement with Canada and Mexico with the

intent of phasing out tariff barriers among the 3 countries; and

Whereas it violates the spirit of the North American Free

Trade Agreement for Canada and Mexico to maintain re-
3

•SRES 333 ATS

strictive personal exemption allowance policies that are

not reciprocal: Now, therefore, be it

1 Resolved, That it is the sense of the Senate that—

2 (1) the United States Trade Representative and

3 the Secretary of the Treasury, in consultation with

4 the Secretary of Commerce, should initiate discus5 sions with officials of the Governments of Canada

6 and Mexico to achieve parity by harmonizing the

7 personal exemption allowance structure of the 3

8 NAFTA countries at or above United States exemp9 tion levels; and

10 (2) in the event that parity with respect to the

11 personal exemption allowance of the 3 countries is

12 not reached within 1 year after the date of the adop13 tion of this resolution, the United States Trade Rep14 resentative and the Secretary of the Treasury should

15 submit recommendations to Congress on whether

16 legislative changes are necessary to lower the United

17 States personal exemption allowance to conform to

18 the allowance levels established in the other coun19 tries that are parties to the North American Free

20 Trade Agreement.

Æ