III

106TH CONGRESS

1ST SESSION S. RES. 24

Expressing the sense of the Senate that the income tax should be eliminated

and replaced with a national sales tax.

IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES

JANUARY 19, 1999

Mr. LUGAR submitted the following resolution; which was referred to the

Committee on Finance

RESOLUTION

Expressing the sense of the Senate that the income tax

should be eliminated and replaced with a national sales tax.

Whereas the savings level in the United States has steadily

declined over the past 25 years, and lagged behind the

industrialized trading partners of the United States;

Whereas the economy of the United States cannot achieve

strong, sustained growth without adequate levels of savings to fuel productive activity;

Whereas the income tax, the accompanying capital gains tax,

and the estate and gift tax discourage savings and investment;

Whereas the methods necessary to enforce the income tax infringe on the privacy of the citizens of the United States

and, according to the Tax Foundation, divert an esti-
2

•SRES 24 IS

mated $225,000,000,000 of taxpayer resources to comply

with income tax rules and regulations;

Whereas the Internal Revenue Service estimates that each

year it fails to collect 17 per centum, or

$127,000,000,000, of the income tax owed to the Federal

Government;

Whereas the income tax system employs a withholding mechanism that limits the transparency of Federal taxes;

Whereas the most effective tax system is one that promotes

savings, fairness, simplicity, privacy, border adjustability,

and transparency;

Whereas it is estimated that the replacement of the income

tax system with a national sales tax would cause the savings rate of Americans to substantially increase;

Whereas the national sales tax would achieve fairness by employing a single tax rate, taxing the underground economy, and closing loopholes and deductions;

Whereas the national sales tax would achieve simplicity by

eliminating recordkeeping for most taxpayers and greatly

reducing the number of collection points;

Whereas the national sales tax would be the least intrusive

tax system because most taxpayers would not be required

to file returns or face audits from the Internal Revenue

Service;

Whereas the national sales tax is border adjustable and would

place exporting by Americans on a level playing field with

the foreign competitors of the United States;

Whereas a national sales tax is a transparent tax system that

would raise Americans’ awareness of the cost of the Federal Government; and
3

•SRES 24 IS

Whereas a national sales tax would best achieve the goals of

an effective tax system: Now, therefore, be it

1 Resolved, That it is the sense of the Senate that—

2 (1) the income tax system, both personal and

3 corporate, the estate and gift tax, and the accom4 panying capital gains tax be replaced with a broad5 based, single-rate national sales tax on goods and

6 services;

7 (2) the national sales tax rate be set at a level

8 that raises an equivalent level of revenue as the in9 come taxes replaced;

10 (3) the Federal Government work with the

11 States to develop a State-based system to administer

12 the national sales tax and that States be adequately

13 compensated for such administration; and

14 (4) the Congress and States work together in

15 an effort to repeal the sixteenth amendment of the

16 United States Constitution.

Æ