If this opinion indicates that it is “FOR PUBLICATION,” it is subject to revision until final publication in the Michigan Appeals Reports.

- 1

- 

### S T A T E O F M I C H I G A N

C O U R T O F A P P E A L S

YANI SANHARIB WARDA,

Plaintiff

- Appellee,

and

GREAT LAKES PHARMACY,

Intervening Plaintiff, UNPUBLISHED January 25, 2024

v No. 362690

Macomb Circuit Court

FARM BUREAU GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF MICHIGAN, SCOTT ALLEN KOHMESCHER, MARTIN TRANSPORT SYSTEMS, and GREAT LAKES TRUCK
LEASING, LLC, LC No. 2021

- 002803

- NI

Defendants,

and

PAUL FLYNN and JAMAL HAMMOUD,

Appellants.

YANI SANHARIB WARDA,

Plaintiff

- Appellee,

and

GREAT LAKES PHARMACY,

Intervening Plaintiff,- 2

-

v No. 362698

Macomb Circuit Court

FARM BUREAU GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF MICHIGAN, LC No. 2021

- 002803

- NI

Defendant

- Appellant,

and

SCOTT ALLEN KOHMESCHER, MARTIN TRANSPORT SYSTEMS, and GREAT LAKES
TRUCK LEASING, LLC,

Defendants.

YANI SANHARIB WARDA,

Plaintiff

- Appell ee
,

and

GREAT LAKES PHARMACY,

Intervening Plaintiff,

v No. 362699

Macomb Circuit Court

FARM BUREAU GENERAL INSURANCE

COMPANY OF MICHIGAN, SCOTT ALLEN KOHMESCHER, MARTIN TRANSPORT SYSTEMS, and GREAT LAKES TRUCK
LEASING, LLC

, LC No. 2021

- 002803

- NI

Defendant s,

and

STEVEN KALKANIS and CHRISTIAN SCHUTTE,

Appellants.

Before: K. F. K ELLY

, P .J., and J ANSEN and H OOD , JJ.

J ANSEN

, J. ( dissenting )

.- 3

-

For the following reasons, I respectfully dissent. I would reverse the trial court’s order denying defendant Farm Bureau General Insurance Company’s motion to quash p laintiff Yani

Sanhar ib Warda’s subpoenas seeking production of tax documents from those individuals who performed insurance medical examinations (IMEs) of Warda, therefore precluding production of

the IME examiners’ 1099s 1 and W

- 2s for tax years 2019 to 2021

, in this no

- fault action . I believe the production of such documents invades the privacy of these nonparties, and the information sought could be sufficiently obtained by other means.

Although Michigan allows for a broad, liberal discovery policy, it does not allow for

fishin g expeditions. Micheli v Mich Auto Ins Placement Facility , 340 Mich App 360, 371; 986 NW2d 451 (2022). See also MCR 2.302(B)(1) (parties may obtain discovery of any nonprivileged, relevant matter proportional to the needs of the case). The Micheli Court determined that expert witness bias may be shown by whether the expert has a pecuniary interest in the outcome, and as such, a nonparty’s history of serving as an expert witness as well as their compensation bears on that person’s credibility and is there fore relevant. Id . at 373

- 374. However, nonparties clearly have a privacy interest in their personal tax documents. Micheli , 340 Mich App at 374 n 5.

Because Warda seeks this information from nonparties, and the main issue is one of bias,

it is suffic ient for the IME examiners to provide the information obtained and conclusions drawn from the IME itself. The IME examiners can be asked what amount or percentage of their total

income they receive from performing IMEs during a deposition. See MCR 2.305( A) (1) (allowing subpoenas to nonparties for depositions)

. This is sufficient evidence for the fact

- finder to determine whether bias exists. Even with the conditions imposed by the trial court limiting the tax information to be disclosed, in balancing the privacy interests of these nonparties, it is still overreaching. The IME examiners’ income from other sources, for example, which would be

available in their W

- 2s, is simply not relevant.

Therefore, I would reverse the trial court’s order denying the motion to quash, and remand the matter to the trial court to grant the motion, quash the subpoenas, and preclude production of

the IME examiners’ 1099s unrelated to performing IMEs and W

- 2s.

/s/ Kathleen Jansen

1 The IME examiners agreed to provide their 1099s relating to IMEs performed, which counsel confirmed at oral argument

. This conclusion relates to any 1099s outside that limitation.