Hogan Lovells US LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in the District of Columbia. “Hogan Lovells” is an international legal practice that includes Hogan Lovells US

LLP and Hogan Lovells International LLP, with offices in: Abu Dhabi Alicante Amsterdam Baltimore Beijing Berlin Brussels Caracas Colorado Springs Denver

Dubai Dusseldorf Frankfurt Hamburg Hanoi Ho Chi Minh City Hong Kong Houston London Los Angeles Madrid Miami Milan Moscow Munich New York

Northern Virginia Paris Philadelphia Prague Rome San Francisco Shanghai Silicon Valley Singapore Tokyo Ulaanbaatar Warsaw Washington DC Associated

offices: Budapest Jakarta Jeddah Riyadh Zagreb. For more information see www.hoganlovells.com

\\DC - 038245/000001 - 3496877 v2

Hogan Lovells US LLP

Columbia Square

555 Thirteenth Street, NW

Washington, DC 20004

T +1 202 637 5600

F +1 202 637 5910

www.hoganlovells.com

September 21, 2012

Lauralyn J. Remo

Chief, Air Carrier Fitness Division

Office of Aviation Analysis

U.S. Department of Transportation

1200 New Jersey Avenue, SE

Washington, DC 20590

Re: Application of Rhoades Aviation, Inc. d/b/a Transair for a Certificate of Public

Convenience and Necessity, Docket DOT-OST-2011-0216:

Petition for Partial Reconsideration of Confidential Treatment Ruling and

Submission of Public Version of Exhibit RDS-3, Page 3

Dear Ms. Remo:

Rhoades Aviation, Inc. d/b/a Transair (“Rhoades”) hereby files this petition for partial

reconsideration of your office’s September 19, 2012 letter (“September 19 Ruling”), to the

extent that it denies confidential treatment of all the rows within the “Cost per Flight Miles for

12 month” block of information on Exhibit RDS-7, Page 3.

In support of this petition, Rhoades states the following:

The September 19 Ruling determined, among other things, to only partially grant Rhoades’

motion for confidential treatment of Corrected Exhibit RDS-7, Page 3, and to publicly

disclose “the rows indicating ‘Cost per Flight Miles for 12 months,’ ‘Projected Related Cost

for 737,’ and ‘Landing Fees’” shown on Exhibit RDS-7, Page 3.

The Department’s previous ruling, dated August 23, 2012, regarding the identical

information, granted confidential treatment to the entirety of Exhibit RDS-7, Page 3. The

only difference between the two exhibits is that the title of the original exhibit incorrectly

referred to Rhoades’ sister carrier Trans Executive Airlines of Hawaii, Inc. when it should

have referred to Rhoades. Rhoades’ corrected Exhibit RDS-7, Page 3. The only change

was to change the title to clarify that this information in fact pertained to Rhoades. As

before, confidentiality was requested for the corrected exhibit. However, inconsistent with

the Department’s August 23 ruling, which granted confidential treatment to all of the

information on RDS-7, Page 3, the Department made the following determination:

Thus, confidential treatment of the corrected version of Exhibit RDS-7, Page 3, is

partially granted, solely to the rows indicating projected revenues: confidentiality is

granted only from the “737 Projected Daily Cargo Revenue” row through the “Total
Lauralyn J. Remo

Chief, Air Carrier Fitness Division

- 2 - September 21, 2012

\\DC - 038245/000001 - 3496877 v2

Projected Revenue from 737” row. Confidential treatment is denied for the rows

indicating “Cost per Flight Miles for 12 months,” “Projected Related Cost for 737,”

and “Landing Fees.”

September 19 Ruling, at 2.

Rhoades requests partial reconsideration of the September 19 Ruling to the extent that it

denies confidential treatment of all the rows within the “Cost per Flight Miles for 12 month”

block of information. Included in that block are rows indicating “Projected Annual Revenue”

and “Revenue per Mile.” Divulging this information will result in the disclosure of Rhoades’

projected first-year revenues, which is precisely the information on Exhibit RDS-7, Page 3

the Department agreed to accord confidentiality in the September 19 Ruling. Specifically,

the indicated “Projected Annual Revenue” amount is the grand total indicated on the “Total

Projected Revenue from 737” row, the entirety of which the Department granted confidential

treatment. The indicated “Revenue per Mile” is that same grand total divided by the “Total

Flight Miles” indicated in the “Cost per Flight Miles for 12 Months” block, and similarly

reveals projected revenue information that the Department has accorded confidential

treatment in the September 19 Ruling.

Therefore, to prevent disclosure of Rhoades’ projected annual revenue and to ensure that

its competitive position is not harmed, Rhoades requests that confidential treatment be

granted to the values indicated on the “Projected Annual Revenue” and “Revenue per Mile”

rows within the “Cost per Flight Miles for 12 Months” block of Corrected Exhibit RDS-7,

Page 3. A redacted/public version of this exhibit page, including redactions of the lines for

which confidential treatment has been granted in the September 19 Ruling, is enclosed for

the record.

Respectfully submitted,

Robert E. Cohn

Counsel for Rhoades Aviation, Inc. d/b/a Transair

Attachment

cc: Reese Davidson

Mary Ballard

Teimour Riahi