RecBenTables_02MAY14.csv

Author: Abt Associates Inc.

Created: 5/2/14

Worksheet

RecBenTables_02MAY14

Purpose: This is an ouput file from the Recreational Fishing Benefits SAS Model. The file was originally

exported from the model in .csv format. 
2MAY14.csv

Description

Presents tables summarizing estimating recreational fishing benefits, 

harvest increases, and WTP per fish by region, species, and regulatory

option. Tmn1 is Proposal Option 4, tmn2 is the final rule, and tmn3 is 

Proposal Option 2. CA is the California benefits region, NA is North 

Atlantic, MA is Mid-Atlantic, SA is South Atlantic, GM is Gulf of Mexico, GL 

is Great Lakes, and IN is Inland. Benefits estimates are in the 1,000s of 

2011$.

n ouput file from the Recreational Fishing Benefits SAS Model. The file was originally

model in .csv format. 
Table 1: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline CA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_1 California halibut California halibut 115 53630 53746

T_1 Flounders Flounders 35 310 345

T_1Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 151 53940 54091

T_1 Salmon Salmon 0 . 0

T_1Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 0 . 0

T_1 Striped bass Striped bass. 1692 1692

T_1Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) . 1692 1692

T_1 Cabezon Cabezon 17 9998 10015

T_1 California scorpionfish California scorpionfish82 . 82

T_1 Croakers Croakers 7652 37433 45086

T_1 Rockfish Rockfish 1035 397574 398609

T_1 Sculpin Sculpin 5352 151120 156471

T_1 Sea bass Sea bass 463 716497 716959

T_1 Smelts Smelts 27 2 30

T_1 Sunfish Sunfish 2 17 19

T_1 Surfperch Surfperch 43011 . 43011

T_1Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 57641 1312641 1370282

T_1Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 1591 3515 5106

T_1Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 59383 1371787 1431170

Table 2: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline CA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_2_baselineIblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_2_baselineIFlatfishCA Flatfish 151 5.35 10.21

T_2_baselineISalmonCA Salmon 0 8.82 16.28

T_2_baselineISmall GameCA Small Game. 4.4 7.6

T_2_baselineIOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater57641 1.87 3.09

T_2_baselineIUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 1591 1.95 3.25

T_2_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) 59383 . .

T_2_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 59383 . .

T_2_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 59383 . .

T_2_baselineEblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_2_baselineEFlatfishCA Flatfish 53940 5.35 10.21

T_2_baselineESalmonCA Salmon . 8.82 16.28

T_2_baselineESmall GameCA Small Game 1692 4.4 7.6

T_2_baselineEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater 1312641 1.87 3.09

T_2_baselineEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 3515 1.95 3.25

T_2_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) 1371787 . .

T_2_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 1371787 . .

T_2_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 1371787 . .

T_2_baselineIEblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_2_baselineIEFlatfishCA Flatfish 54091 5.35 10.21

T_2_baselineIESalmonCA Salmon 0 8.82 16.28
T_2_baselineIESmall GameCA Small Game 1692 4.4 7.6

T_2_baselineIEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater 1370282 1.87 3.09

T_2_baselineIEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 5106 1.95 3.25

T_2_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) 1431170 . .

T_2_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 1431170 . .

T_2_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 1431170 . .

Table 3: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 CA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_3 California halibut California halibut 69 0 69

T_3 Flounders Flounders 21 0 21

T_3Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 90 0 90

T_3 Salmon Salmon 0 . 0

T_3Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 0 . 0

T_3 Striped bass Striped bass. 0 0

T_3Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) . 0 0

T_3 Cabezon Cabezon 10 0 10

T_3 California scorpionfish California scorpionfish49 . 49

T_3 Croakers Croakers 4564 0 4564

T_3 Rockfish Rockfish 618 0 618

T_3 Sculpin Sculpin 3192 0 3192

T_3 Sea bass Sea bass 276 0 276

T_3 Smelts Smelts 16 0 16

T_3 Sunfish Sunfish 1 0 1

T_3 Surfperch Surfperch 25654 . 25654

T_3Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 34381 0 34381

T_3Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified)949 0 949

T_3Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 35420 0 35420

Table 4: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 CA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_4_TMN1Iblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_4_TMN1IFlatfishCA Flatfish 90 5.35 10.21

T_4_TMN1ISalmonCA Salmon 0 8.82 16.28

T_4_TMN1ISmall GameCA Small Game. 4.4 7.6

T_4_TMN1IOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater34381 1.87 3.09

T_4_TMN1IUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 949 1.95 3.25

T_4_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) 35420 . .

T_4_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 35420 . .

T_4_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 35420 . .

T_4_TMN1Eblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_4_TMN1EFlatfishCA Flatfish 0 5.35 10.21

T_4_TMN1ESalmonCA Salmon . 8.82 16.28

T_4_TMN1ESmall GameCA Small Game 0 4.4 7.6

T_4_TMN1EOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater 0 1.87 3.09
T_4_TMN1EUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 0 1.95 3.25

T_4_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted)0 . .

T_4_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 0 . .

T_4_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 0 . .

T_4_TMN1IEblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_4_TMN1IEFlatfishCA Flatfish 90 5.35 10.21

T_4_TMN1IESalmonCA Salmon 0 8.82 16.28

T_4_TMN1IESmall GameCA Small Game 0 4.4 7.6

T_4_TMN1IEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater34381 1.87 3.09

T_4_TMN1IEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 949 1.95 3.25

T_4_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) 35420 . .

T_4_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 35420 . .

T_4_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 35420 . .

Table 5: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 CA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_5 California halibut California halibut 74 0 74

T_5 Flounders Flounders 23 0 23

T_5Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 97 0 97

T_5 Salmon Salmon 0 . 0

T_5Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 0 . 0

T_5 Striped bass Striped bass. 0 0

T_5Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) . 0 0

T_5 Cabezon Cabezon 11 0 11

T_5 California scorpionfish California scorpionfish53 . 53

T_5 Croakers Croakers 4917 0 4917

T_5 Rockfish Rockfish 665 0 665

T_5 Sculpin Sculpin 3439 0 3439

T_5 Sea bass Sea bass 297 0 297

T_5 Smelts Smelts 18 0 18

T_5 Sunfish Sunfish 1 0 1

T_5 Surfperch Surfperch 27638 . 27638

T_5Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 37040 0 37040

T_5Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 1022 0 1022

T_5Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 38159 0 38159

Table 6: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 CA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_6_TMN2Iblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_6_TMN2IFlatfishCA Flatfish 97 5.35 10.21

T_6_TMN2ISalmonCA Salmon 0 8.82 16.28

T_6_TMN2ISmall GameCA Small Game. 4.4 7.6

T_6_TMN2IOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater37040 1.87 3.09

T_6_TMN2IUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 1022 1.95 3.25

T_6_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) 38159 . .
T_6_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 38159 . .

T_6_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 38159 . .

T_6_TMN2Eblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_6_TMN2EFlatfishCA Flatfish 0 5.35 10.21

T_6_TMN2ESalmonCA Salmon . 8.82 16.28

T_6_TMN2ESmall GameCA Small Game 0 4.4 7.6

T_6_TMN2EOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater 0 1.87 3.09

T_6_TMN2EUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 0 1.95 3.25

T_6_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted)0 . .

T_6_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 0 . .

T_6_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 0 . .

T_6_TMN2IEblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_6_TMN2IEFlatfishCA Flatfish 97 5.35 10.21

T_6_TMN2IESalmonCA Salmon 0 8.82 16.28

T_6_TMN2IESmall GameCA Small Game 0 4.4 7.6

T_6_TMN2IEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater37040 1.87 3.09

T_6_TMN2IEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 1022 1.95 3.25

T_6_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) 38159 . .

T_6_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 38159 . .

T_6_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 38159 . .

Table 7: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 CA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_7 California halibut California halibut 79 32713 32791

T_7 Flounders Flounders 24 189 213

T_7Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 102 32902 33004

T_7 Salmon Salmon 0 . 0

T_7Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 0 . 0

T_7 Striped bass Striped bass. 1032 1032

T_7Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) . 1032 1032

T_7 Cabezon Cabezon 12 6098 6110

T_7 California scorpionfish California scorpionfish56 . 56

T_7 Croakers Croakers 5210 22833 28043

T_7 Rockfish Rockfish 705 242507 243212

T_7 Sculpin Sculpin 3643 92178 95822

T_7 Sea bass Sea bass 315 437039 437354

T_7 Smelts Smelts 19 1 20

T_7 Sunfish Sunfish 1 10 12

T_7 Surfperch Surfperch 29282 . 29282

T_7Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 39243 800668 839911

T_7Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 1083 2144 3227

T_7Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 40428 836745 877174

Table 8: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 CA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP
T_8_TMN3Iblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_8_TMN3IFlatfishCA Flatfish 102 5.35 10.21

T_8_TMN3ISalmonCA Salmon 0 8.82 16.28

T_8_TMN3ISmall GameCA Small Game. 4.4 7.6

T_8_TMN3IOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater39243 1.87 3.09

T_8_TMN3IUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 1083 1.95 3.25

T_8_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) 40428 . .

T_8_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 40428 . .

T_8_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 40428 . .

T_8_TMN3Eblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_8_TMN3EFlatfishCA Flatfish 32902 5.35 10.21

T_8_TMN3ESalmonCA Salmon . 8.82 16.28

T_8_TMN3ESmall GameCA Small Game 1032 4.4 7.6

T_8_TMN3EOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater800668 1.87 3.09

T_8_TMN3EUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 2144 1.95 3.25

T_8_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) 836745 . .

T_8_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 836745 . .

T_8_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 836745 . .

T_8_TMN3IEblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_8_TMN3IEFlatfishCA Flatfish 33004 5.35 10.21

T_8_TMN3IESalmonCA Salmon 0 8.82 16.28

T_8_TMN3IESmall GameCA Small Game 1032 4.4 7.6

T_8_TMN3IEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater839911 1.87 3.09

T_8_TMN3IEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified 3227 1.95 3.25

T_8_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) 877174 . .

T_8_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) 877174 . .

T_8_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) 877174 . .

Table 10: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline NA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_10 Winter flounder Winter flounder 1184 298168 299352

T_10Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 1184 298168 299352

T_10 Atlantic mackerel Atlantic mackerel 0 870 870

T_10 Bluefish Bluefish 1 0 1

T_10 Striped bass Striped bass 0 . 0

T_10 Weakfish Weakfish 0 32 32

T_10Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 1 902 903

T_10 Atlantic cod Atlantic cod 57 1178 1235

T_10 Cunner Cunner 27 103505 103533

T_10 Pollock Pollock 2 2 4

T_10 Sculpin Sculpin 489 311048 311537

T_10 Scup Scup 12 112 123

T_10 Searobin Searobin 64 730 794

T_10 Tautog Tautog 24 13793 13817

T_10 White perch White perch 0 0 0

T_10Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 675 430369 431044
T_10Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified)257 2429 2686

T_10Total (All Species) Total (All Species)2117 731868 733985

Table 11: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline NA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_11_baselineIblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_11_baselineIFlatfishNA Flatfish 1184 3.98 6.24

T_11_baselineISmall GameNA Small Game 1 2.23 6.22

T_11_baselineIOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater 675 1.87 3.12

T_11_baselineIUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 257 1.88 3.15

T_11_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 2117 . .

T_11_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 2117 . .

T_11_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 2117 . .

T_11_baselineEblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_11_baselineEFlatfishNA Flatfish 298168 3.98 6.24

T_11_baselineESmall GameNA Small Game 902 2.23 6.22

T_11_baselineEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater430369 1.87 3.12

T_11_baselineEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 2429 1.88 3.15

T_11_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 731868 . .

T_11_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 731868 . .

T_11_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 731868 . .

T_11_baselineIEblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_11_baselineIEFlatfishNA Flatfish 299352 3.98 6.24

T_11_baselineIESmall GameNA Small Game 903 2.23 6.22

T_11_baselineIEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater431044 1.87 3.12

T_11_baselineIEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 2686 1.88 3.15

T_11_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 733985 . .

T_11_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 733985 . .

T_11_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 733985 . .

Table 12: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 NA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_12 Winter flounder Winter flounder 765 0 765

T_12Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 765 0 765

T_12 Atlantic mackerel Atlantic mackerel 0 0 0

T_12 Bluefish Bluefish 1 0 1

T_12 Striped bass Striped bass 0 . 0

T_12 Weakfish Weakfish 0 0 0

T_12Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 1 0 1

T_12 Atlantic cod Atlantic cod 37 0 37

T_12 Cunner Cunner 18 0 18

T_12 Pollock Pollock 1 0 1

T_12 Sculpin Sculpin 316 0 316

T_12 Scup Scup 8 0 8

T_12 Searobin Searobin 41 0 41
T_12 Tautog Tautog 15 0 15

T_12 White perch White perch 0 0 0

T_12Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 436 0 436

T_12Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified)166 0 166

T_12Total (All Species) Total (All Species)1367 0 1367

Table 13: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 NA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_13_TMN1Iblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_13_TMN1IFlatfishNA Flatfish 765 3.98 6.24

T_13_TMN1ISmall GameNA Small Game 1 2.23 6.22

T_13_TMN1IOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater 436 1.87 3.12

T_13_TMN1IUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 166 1.88 3.15

T_13_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 1367 . .

T_13_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 1367 . .

T_13_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 1367 . .

T_13_TMN1Eblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_13_TMN1EFlatfishNA Flatfish 0 3.98 6.24

T_13_TMN1ESmall GameNA Small Game 0 2.23 6.22

T_13_TMN1EOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater 0 1.87 3.12

T_13_TMN1EUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 0 1.88 3.15

T_13_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted)0 . .

T_13_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 0 . .

T_13_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 0 . .

T_13_TMN1IEblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_13_TMN1IEFlatfishNA Flatfish 765 3.98 6.24

T_13_TMN1IESmall GameNA Small Game 1 2.23 6.22

T_13_TMN1IEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater 436 1.87 3.12

T_13_TMN1IEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 166 1.88 3.15

T_13_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 1367 . .

T_13_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 1367 . .

T_13_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 1367 . .

Table 14: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 NA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_14 Winter flounder Winter flounder 815 2656 3471

T_14Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 815 2656 3471

T_14 Atlantic mackerel Atlantic mackerel 0 8 8

T_14 Bluefish Bluefish 1 0 1

T_14 Striped bass Striped bass 0 . 0

T_14 Weakfish Weakfish 0 0 0

T_14Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 1 8 9

T_14 Atlantic cod Atlantic cod 39 10 50

T_14 Cunner Cunner 19 922 941

T_14 Pollock Pollock 1 0 1
T_14 Sculpin Sculpin 336 2771 3107

T_14 Scup Scup 8 1 9

T_14 Searobin Searobin 44 7 51

T_14 Tautog Tautog 16 123 139

T_14 White perch White perch 0 0 0

T_14Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 464 3834 4298

T_14Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified)177 22 198

T_14Total (All Species) Total (All Species)1456 6519 7975

Table 15: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 NA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_15_TMN2Iblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_15_TMN2IFlatfishNA Flatfish 815 3.98 6.24

T_15_TMN2ISmall GameNA Small Game 1 2.23 6.22

T_15_TMN2IOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater 464 1.87 3.12

T_15_TMN2IUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 177 1.88 3.15

T_15_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 1456 . .

T_15_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 1456 . .

T_15_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 1456 . .

T_15_TMN2Eblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_15_TMN2EFlatfishNA Flatfish 2656 3.98 6.24

T_15_TMN2ESmall GameNA Small Game 8 2.23 6.22

T_15_TMN2EOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater 3834 1.87 3.12

T_15_TMN2EUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 22 1.88 3.15

T_15_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 6519 . .

T_15_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 6519 . .

T_15_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 6519 . .

T_15_TMN2IEblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_15_TMN2IEFlatfishNA Flatfish 3471 3.98 6.24

T_15_TMN2IESmall GameNA Small Game 9 2.23 6.22

T_15_TMN2IEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater 4298 1.87 3.12

T_15_TMN2IEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 198 1.88 3.15

T_15_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 7975 . .

T_15_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 7975 . .

T_15_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 7975 . .

Table 16: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 NA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_16 Winter flounder Winter flounder 1099 228287 229386

T_16Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 1099 228287 229386

T_16 Atlantic mackerel Atlantic mackerel 0 666 666

T_16 Bluefish Bluefish 1 0 1

T_16 Striped bass Striped bass 0 . 0

T_16 Weakfish Weakfish 0 25 25

T_16Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 1 691 692
T_16 Atlantic cod Atlantic cod 53 902 955

T_16 Cunner Cunner 25 79247 79272

T_16 Pollock Pollock 1 2 3

T_16 Sculpin Sculpin 454 238148 238602

T_16 Scup Scup 11 86 96

T_16 Searobin Searobin 59 559 618

T_16 Tautog Tautog 22 10561 10583

T_16 White perch White perch 0 0 0

T_16Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 626 329504 330130

T_16Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified)239 1859 2098

T_16Total (All Species) Total (All Species)1965 560341 562305

Table 17: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 NA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_17_TMN3Iblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_17_TMN3IFlatfishNA Flatfish 1099 3.98 6.24

T_17_TMN3ISmall GameNA Small Game 1 2.23 6.22

T_17_TMN3IOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater 626 1.87 3.12

T_17_TMN3IUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 239 1.88 3.15

T_17_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 1965 . .

T_17_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 1965 . .

T_17_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 1965 . .

T_17_TMN3Eblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_17_TMN3EFlatfishNA Flatfish 228287 3.98 6.24

T_17_TMN3ESmall GameNA Small Game 691 2.23 6.22

T_17_TMN3EOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater329504 1.87 3.12

T_17_TMN3EUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 1859 1.88 3.15

T_17_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 560341 . .

T_17_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 560341 . .

T_17_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 560341 . .

T_17_TMN3IEblank rowNA blank row . . .

T_17_TMN3IEFlatfishNA Flatfish 229386 3.98 6.24

T_17_TMN3IESmall GameNA Small Game 692 2.23 6.22

T_17_TMN3IEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater330130 1.87 3.12

T_17_TMN3IEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified 2098 1.88 3.15

T_17_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) 562305 . .

T_17_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) 562305 . .

T_17_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) 562305 . .

Table 19: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline MA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_19 Summer flounder Summer flounder4092 . 4092

T_19 Winter flounder Winter flounder 504 2704 3209

T_19Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 4597 2704 7301

T_19 Black crappie Black crappie 3 . 3
T_19 Bluegill Bluegill 12 . 12

T_19 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead 795 1774 2569

T_19 Bullhead Bullhead 8 . 8

T_19 Channel catfish Channel catfish 2228 . 2228

T_19 Crappie Crappie 1 . 1

T_19 Menhaden Menhaden . 609 609

T_19 Sunfish Sunfish 170 . 170

T_19Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) 3217 2383 5600

T_19 Bluefish Bluefish 97 . 97

T_19 Red drum Red drum 2055 . 2055

T_19 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout1362 . 1362

T_19 Striped bass Striped bass 805 104519 105323

T_19 Weakfish Weakfish 122780 189302 312082

T_19Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 127099 293821 420920

T_19 Northern pike Northern pike 0 . 0

T_19Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 0 . 0

T_19 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker19595 1107450 1127044

T_19 Atlantic herring Atlantic herring 43 0 44

T_19 Black drum Black drum 197 . 197

T_19 Cunner Cunner 0 . 0

T_19 Scup Scup 1 . 1

T_19 Searobin Searobin 5 1 6

T_19 Silver perch Silver perch 1 . 1

T_19 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass 44 . 44

T_19 Spot Spot 321329 3132250 3453578

T_19 Striped mullet Striped mullet 9 . 9

T_19 Tautog Tautog 0 0 0

T_19 White perch White perch 2567 18845 21411

T_19 whitefish whitefish 328 . 328

T_19Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 344119 4258545 4602664

T_19Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 75614 711090 786704

T_19Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 554646 5268543 5823189

Table 20: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline MA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_20_baselineIblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_20_baselineIFlatfishMA Flatfish 4597 3.92 5.88

T_20_baselineIPanfishMA Panfish 3217 0.55 1.11

T_20_baselineISmall GameMA Small Game 127099 2.37 6.17

T_20_baselineIWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike 0 0 0

T_20_baselineIOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater344119 1.94 3.05

T_20_baselineIUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 75614 2 3.39

T_20_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 554646 . .

T_20_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 554646 . .

T_20_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 554646 . .

T_20_baselineEblank rowMA blank row . . .
T_20_baselineEFlatfishMA Flatfish 2704 3.92 5.88

T_20_baselineEPanfishMA Panfish 2383 0.55 1.11

T_20_baselineESmall GameMA Small Game 293821 2.37 6.17

T_20_baselineEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike. 0 0

T_20_baselineEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater 4258545 1.94 3.05

T_20_baselineEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 711090 2 3.39

T_20_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 5268543 . .

T_20_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 5268543 . .

T_20_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 5268543 . .

T_20_baselineIEblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_20_baselineIEFlatfishMA Flatfish 7301 3.92 5.88

T_20_baselineIEPanfishMA Panfish 5600 0.55 1.11

T_20_baselineIESmall GameMA Small Game 420920 2.37 6.17

T_20_baselineIEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike 0 0 0

T_20_baselineIEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater 4602664 1.94 3.05

T_20_baselineIEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 786704 2 3.39

T_20_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 5823189 . .

T_20_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 5823189 . .

T_20_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 5823189 . .

Table 21: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 MA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_21 Summer flounder Summer flounder3096 . 3096

T_21 Winter flounder Winter flounder 382 4 386

T_21Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 3478 4 3482

T_21 Black crappie Black crappie 2 . 2

T_21 Bluegill Bluegill 9 . 9

T_21 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead 602 3 604

T_21 Bullhead Bullhead 6 . 6

T_21 Channel catfish Channel catfish 1686 . 1686

T_21 Crappie Crappie 1 . 1

T_21 Menhaden Menhaden . 1 1

T_21 Sunfish Sunfish 129 . 129

T_21Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) 2434 4 2438

T_21 Bluefish Bluefish 74 . 74

T_21 Red drum Red drum 1555 . 1555

T_21 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout1031 . 1031

T_21 Striped bass Striped bass 609 164 773

T_21 Weakfish Weakfish 92899 297 93196

T_21Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 96167 461 96628

T_21 Northern pike Northern pike 0 . 0

T_21Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 0 . 0

T_21 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker14826 1737 16563

T_21 Atlantic herring Atlantic herring 33 0 33

T_21 Black drum Black drum 149 . 149

T_21 Cunner Cunner 0 . 0
T_21 Scup Scup 1 . 1

T_21 Searobin Searobin 4 0 4

T_21 Silver perch Silver perch 1 . 1

T_21 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass 34 . 34

T_21 Spot Spot 243127 4912 248039

T_21 Striped mullet Striped mullet 7 . 7

T_21 Tautog Tautog 0 0 0

T_21 White perch White perch 1942 30 1972

T_21 whitefish whitefish 248 . 248

T_21Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 260371 6679 267049

T_21Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 57211 1115 58327

T_21Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 419661 8263 427924

Table 22: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 MA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_22_TMN1Iblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_22_TMN1IFlatfishMA Flatfish 3478 3.92 5.88

T_22_TMN1IPanfishMA Panfish 2434 0.55 1.11

T_22_TMN1ISmall GameMA Small Game 96167 2.37 6.17

T_22_TMN1IWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike 0 0 0

T_22_TMN1IOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater260371 1.94 3.05

T_22_TMN1IUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 57211 2 3.39

T_22_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 419661 . .

T_22_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 419661 . .

T_22_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 419661 . .

T_22_TMN1Eblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_22_TMN1EFlatfishMA Flatfish 4 3.92 5.88

T_22_TMN1EPanfishMA Panfish 4 0.55 1.11

T_22_TMN1ESmall GameMA Small Game 461 2.37 6.17

T_22_TMN1EWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike. 0 0

T_22_TMN1EOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater 6679 1.94 3.05

T_22_TMN1EUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 1115 2 3.39

T_22_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 8263 . .

T_22_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 8263 . .

T_22_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 8263 . .

T_22_TMN1IEblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_22_TMN1IEFlatfishMA Flatfish 3482 3.92 5.88

T_22_TMN1IEPanfishMA Panfish 2438 0.55 1.11

T_22_TMN1IESmall GameMA Small Game 96628 2.37 6.17

T_22_TMN1IEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike 0 0 0

T_22_TMN1IEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater267049 1.94 3.05

T_22_TMN1IEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 58327 2 3.39

T_22_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 427924 . .

T_22_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 427924 . .

T_22_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 427924 . .
Table 23: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 MA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_23 Summer flounder Summer flounder3308 . 3308

T_23 Winter flounder Winter flounder 408 6 414

T_23Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 3716 6 3723

T_23 Black crappie Black crappie 2 . 2

T_23 Bluegill Bluegill 10 . 10

T_23 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead 643 4 647

T_23 Bullhead Bullhead 7 . 7

T_23 Channel catfish Channel catfish 1801 . 1801

T_23 Crappie Crappie 1 . 1

T_23 Menhaden Menhaden . 1 1

T_23 Sunfish Sunfish 138 . 138

T_23Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) 2601 6 2607

T_23 Bluefish Bluefish 79 . 79

T_23 Red drum Red drum 1661 . 1661

T_23 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout1101 . 1101

T_23 Striped bass Striped bass 650 247 897

T_23 Weakfish Weakfish 99258 447 99705

T_23Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 102749 694 103444

T_23 Northern pike Northern pike 0 . 0

T_23Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 0 . 0

T_23 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker15841 2618 18458

T_23 Atlantic herring Atlantic herring 35 0 35

T_23 Black drum Black drum 159 . 159

T_23 Cunner Cunner 0 . 0

T_23 Scup Scup 1 . 1

T_23 Searobin Searobin 4 0 4

T_23 Silver perch Silver perch 1 . 1

T_23 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass 36 . 36

T_23 Spot Spot 259769 7403 267172

T_23 Striped mullet Striped mullet 8 . 8

T_23 Tautog Tautog 0 0 0

T_23 White perch White perch 2075 45 2119

T_23 whitefish whitefish 265 . 265

T_23Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 278193 10065 288258

T_23Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 61128 1681 62808

T_23Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 448387 12453 460839

Table 24: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 MA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_24_TMN2Iblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_24_TMN2IFlatfishMA Flatfish 3716 3.92 5.88

T_24_TMN2IPanfishMA Panfish 2601 0.55 1.11

T_24_TMN2ISmall GameMA Small Game 102749 2.37 6.17
T_24_TMN2IWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike 0 0 0

T_24_TMN2IOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater278193 1.94 3.05

T_24_TMN2IUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 61128 2 3.39

T_24_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 448387 . .

T_24_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 448387 . .

T_24_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 448387 . .

T_24_TMN2Eblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_24_TMN2EFlatfishMA Flatfish 6 3.92 5.88

T_24_TMN2EPanfishMA Panfish 6 0.55 1.11

T_24_TMN2ESmall GameMA Small Game 694 2.37 6.17

T_24_TMN2EWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike. 0 0

T_24_TMN2EOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater10065 1.94 3.05

T_24_TMN2EUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 1681 2 3.39

T_24_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 12453 . .

T_24_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 12453 . .

T_24_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 12453 . .

T_24_TMN2IEblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_24_TMN2IEFlatfishMA Flatfish 3723 3.92 5.88

T_24_TMN2IEPanfishMA Panfish 2607 0.55 1.11

T_24_TMN2IESmall GameMA Small Game 103444 2.37 6.17

T_24_TMN2IEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike 0 0 0

T_24_TMN2IEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater288258 1.94 3.05

T_24_TMN2IEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 62808 2 3.39

T_24_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 460839 . .

T_24_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 460839 . .

T_24_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 460839 . .

Table 25: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 MA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_25 Summer flounder Summer flounder3781 . 3781

T_25 Winter flounder Winter flounder 466 2357 2823

T_25Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 4247 2357 6604

T_25 Black crappie Black crappie 2 . 2

T_25 Bluegill Bluegill 11 . 11

T_25 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead 735 1546 2281

T_25 Bullhead Bullhead 8 . 8

T_25 Channel catfish Channel catfish 2059 . 2059

T_25 Crappie Crappie 1 . 1

T_25 Menhaden Menhaden . 530 530

T_25 Sunfish Sunfish 157 . 157

T_25Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) 2973 2076 5049

T_25 Bluefish Bluefish 90 . 90

T_25 Red drum Red drum 1899 . 1899

T_25 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout1259 . 1259

T_25 Striped bass Striped bass 743 91079 91823

T_25 Weakfish Weakfish 113447 164962 278408
T_25Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 117438 256041 373479

T_25 Northern pike Northern pike 0 . 0

T_25Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 0 . 0

T_25 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker18105 965053 983158

T_25 Atlantic herring Atlantic herring 40 0 40

T_25 Black drum Black drum 182 . 182

T_25 Cunner Cunner 0 . 0

T_25 Scup Scup 1 . 1

T_25 Searobin Searobin 4 1 5

T_25 Silver perch Silver perch 1 . 1

T_25 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass 41 . 41

T_25 Spot Spot 296903 2729503 3026406

T_25 Striped mullet Striped mullet 9 . 9

T_25 Tautog Tautog 0 0 0

T_25 White perch White perch 2372 16422 18793

T_25 whitefish whitefish 303 . 303

T_25Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 317961 3710979 4028939

T_25Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 69866 619658 689524

T_25Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 512484 4591111 5103595

Table 26: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 MA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_26_TMN3Iblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_26_TMN3IFlatfishMA Flatfish 4247 3.92 5.88

T_26_TMN3IPanfishMA Panfish 2973 0.55 1.11

T_26_TMN3ISmall GameMA Small Game 117438 2.37 6.17

T_26_TMN3IWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike 0 0 0

T_26_TMN3IOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater317961 1.94 3.05

T_26_TMN3IUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 69866 2 3.39

T_26_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 512484 . .

T_26_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 512484 . .

T_26_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 512484 . .

T_26_TMN3Eblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_26_TMN3EFlatfishMA Flatfish 2357 3.92 5.88

T_26_TMN3EPanfishMA Panfish 2076 0.55 1.11

T_26_TMN3ESmall GameMA Small Game 256041 2.37 6.17

T_26_TMN3EWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike. 0 0

T_26_TMN3EOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater 3710979 1.94 3.05

T_26_TMN3EUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 619658 2 3.39

T_26_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 4591111 . .

T_26_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 4591111 . .

T_26_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 4591111 . .

T_26_TMN3IEblank rowMA blank row . . .

T_26_TMN3IEFlatfishMA Flatfish 6604 3.92 5.88

T_26_TMN3IEPanfishMA Panfish 5049 0.55 1.11

T_26_TMN3IESmall GameMA Small Game 373479 2.37 6.17
T_26_TMN3IEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike 0 0 0

T_26_TMN3IEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater 4028939 1.94 3.05

T_26_TMN3IEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified 689524 2 3.39

T_26_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) 5103595 . .

T_26_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) 5103595 . .

T_26_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) 5103595 . .

Table 28: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline SA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_28 Flounders Flounders 593 . 593

T_28Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 593 . 593

T_28 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout . 1604 1604

T_28 Weakfish Weakfish 270 85 355

T_28Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game)270 1689 1960

T_28 Croakers Croakers 2126 79551 81677

T_28 Pinfish Pinfish . 1283 1283

T_28 Silver perch Silver perch 58 . 58

T_28 Spot Spot 15369 8574 23943

T_28Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 17553 89408 106961

T_28Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified)753 809 1562

T_28Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 19169 91906 111075

Table 29: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline SA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_29_baselineIblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_29_baselineIFlatfishSA Flatfish 593 4.05 5.87

T_29_baselineISmall GameSA Small Game 270 2.84 5.99

T_29_baselineIOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater17553 2.24 2.98

T_29_baselineIUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 753 2.25 2.99

T_29_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 19169 . .

T_29_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 19169 . .

T_29_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 19169 . .

T_29_baselineEblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_29_baselineEFlatfishSA Flatfish . 4.05 5.87

T_29_baselineESmall GameSA Small Game 1689 2.84 5.99

T_29_baselineEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater89408 2.24 2.98

T_29_baselineEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 809 2.25 2.99

T_29_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 91906 . .

T_29_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 91906 . .

T_29_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 91906 . .

T_29_baselineIEblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_29_baselineIEFlatfishSA Flatfish 593 4.05 5.87

T_29_baselineIESmall GameSA Small Game 1960 2.84 5.99

T_29_baselineIEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater106961 2.24 2.98

T_29_baselineIEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 1562 2.25 2.99
T_29_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 111075 . .

T_29_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 111075 . .

T_29_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 111075 . .

Table 30: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 SA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_30 Flounders Flounders 402 . 402

T_30Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 402 . 402

T_30 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout . 0 0

T_30 Weakfish Weakfish 183 0 183

T_30Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game)183 0 183

T_30 Croakers Croakers 1440 0 1440

T_30 Pinfish Pinfish . 0 0

T_30 Silver perch Silver perch 39 . 39

T_30 Spot Spot 10409 0 10409

T_30Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 11888 0 11888

T_30Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified)510 0 510

T_30Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 12983 0 12983

Table 31: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 SA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_31_TMN1Iblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_31_TMN1IFlatfishSA Flatfish 402 4.05 5.87

T_31_TMN1ISmall GameSA Small Game 183 2.84 5.99

T_31_TMN1IOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater11888 2.24 2.98

T_31_TMN1IUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 510 2.25 2.99

T_31_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 12983 . .

T_31_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 12983 . .

T_31_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 12983 . .

T_31_TMN1Eblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_31_TMN1EFlatfishSA Flatfish . 4.05 5.87

T_31_TMN1ESmall GameSA Small Game 0 2.84 5.99

T_31_TMN1EOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater 0 2.24 2.98

T_31_TMN1EUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 0 2.25 2.99

T_31_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted)0 . .

T_31_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 0 . .

T_31_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 0 . .

T_31_TMN1IEblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_31_TMN1IEFlatfishSA Flatfish 402 4.05 5.87

T_31_TMN1IESmall GameSA Small Game 183 2.84 5.99

T_31_TMN1IEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater11888 2.24 2.98

T_31_TMN1IEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 510 2.25 2.99

T_31_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 12983 . .

T_31_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 12983 . .

T_31_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 12983 . .
Table 32: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 SA

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_32 Flounders Flounders 430 . 430

T_32Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 430 . 430

T_32 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout . 84 84

T_32 Weakfish Weakfish 196 4 201

T_32Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game)196 88 284

T_32 Croakers Croakers 1543 4161 5705

T_32 Pinfish Pinfish . 67 67

T_32 Silver perch Silver perch 42 . 42

T_32 Spot Spot 11159 449 11607

T_32Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 12744 4677 17421

T_32Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified)547 42 589

T_32Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 13918 4808 18725

Table 33: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 SA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_33_TMN2Iblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_33_TMN2IFlatfishSA Flatfish 430 4.05 5.87

T_33_TMN2ISmall GameSA Small Game 196 2.84 5.99

T_33_TMN2IOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater12744 2.24 2.98

T_33_TMN2IUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 547 2.25 2.99

T_33_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 13918 . .

T_33_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 13918 . .

T_33_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 13918 . .

T_33_TMN2Eblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_33_TMN2EFlatfishSA Flatfish . 4.05 5.87

T_33_TMN2ESmall GameSA Small Game 88 2.84 5.99

T_33_TMN2EOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater 4677 2.24 2.98

T_33_TMN2EUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 42 2.25 2.99

T_33_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 4808 . .

T_33_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 4808 . .

T_33_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 4808 . .

T_33_TMN2IEblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_33_TMN2IEFlatfishSA Flatfish 430 4.05 5.87

T_33_TMN2IESmall GameSA Small Game 284 2.84 5.99

T_33_TMN2IEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater17421 2.24 2.98

T_33_TMN2IEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 589 2.25 2.99

T_33_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 18725 . .

T_33_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 18725 . .

T_33_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 18725 . .

Table 34: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 SA
tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_34 Flounders Flounders 587 . 587

T_34Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) 587 . 587

T_34 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout . 1501 1501

T_34 Weakfish Weakfish 267 80 347

T_34Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game)267 1580 1848

T_34 Croakers Croakers 2105 74405 76510

T_34 Pinfish Pinfish . 1200 1200

T_34 Silver perch Silver perch 58 . 58

T_34 Spot Spot 15218 8019 23237

T_34Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 17381 83625 101006

T_34Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified)746 756 1502

T_34Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 18981 85962 104943

Table 35: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 SA

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_35_TMN3Iblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_35_TMN3IFlatfishSA Flatfish 587 4.05 5.87

T_35_TMN3ISmall GameSA Small Game 267 2.84 5.99

T_35_TMN3IOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater17381 2.24 2.98

T_35_TMN3IUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 746 2.25 2.99

T_35_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 18981 . .

T_35_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 18981 . .

T_35_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 18981 . .

T_35_TMN3Eblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_35_TMN3EFlatfishSA Flatfish . 4.05 5.87

T_35_TMN3ESmall GameSA Small Game 1580 2.84 5.99

T_35_TMN3EOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater83625 2.24 2.98

T_35_TMN3EUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 756 2.25 2.99

T_35_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 85962 . .

T_35_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 85962 . .

T_35_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 85962 . .

T_35_TMN3IEblank rowSA blank row . . .

T_35_TMN3IEFlatfishSA Flatfish 587 4.05 5.87

T_35_TMN3IESmall GameSA Small Game 1848 2.84 5.99

T_35_TMN3IEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater101006 2.24 2.98

T_35_TMN3IEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified 1502 2.25 2.99

T_35_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) 104943 . .

T_35_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) 104943 . .

T_35_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) 104943 . .

Table 37: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline GM

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_37 Mackerels Mackerels 1374 . 1374

T_37 Red drum Red drum 26946 4169 31114
T_37 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout 545555 55174 600729

T_37Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 573874 59343 633217

T_37 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker212578 187 212766

T_37 Black drum Black drum 3996 1587633 1591629

T_37 Pinfish Pinfish 8009 258968 266978

T_37 Sea bass Sea bass 142 . 142

T_37 Searobin Searobin 101020 34214 135234

T_37 Sheepshead Sheepshead 1 46 47

T_37 Silver perch Silver perch 91 1441 1532

T_37 Spot Spot 29153 5963 35116

T_37 Striped mullet Striped mullet 7344 45007 52351

T_37Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 362334 1933461 2295795

T_37Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 96865 51740 148605

T_37Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 1033073 2044544 3077617

Table 38: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline GM

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_38_baselineIblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_38_baselineISmall GameGM Small Game 573874 3 5.89

T_38_baselineIOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater362334 2.23 2.91

T_38_baselineIUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 96865 2.47 3.83

T_38_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 1033073 . .

T_38_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 1033073 . .

T_38_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 1033073 . .

T_38_baselineEblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_38_baselineESmall GameGM Small Game 59343 3 5.89

T_38_baselineEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater 1933461 2.23 2.91

T_38_baselineEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 51740 2.47 3.83

T_38_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 2044544 . .

T_38_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 2044544 . .

T_38_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 2044544 . .

T_38_baselineIEblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_38_baselineIESmall GameGM Small Game 633217 3 5.89

T_38_baselineIEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater 2295795 2.23 2.91

T_38_baselineIEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 148605 2.47 3.83

T_38_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 3077617 . .

T_38_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 3077617 . .

T_38_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 3077617 . .

Table 39: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 GM

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_39 Mackerels Mackerels 994 . 994

T_39 Red drum Red drum 19497 3 19500

T_39 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout 394735 45 394780

T_39Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 415225 48 415274
T_39 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker153811 0 153811

T_39 Black drum Black drum 2891 1294 4185

T_39 Pinfish Pinfish 5795 211 6006

T_39 Sea bass Sea bass 103 . 103

T_39 Searobin Searobin 73093 28 73120

T_39 Sheepshead Sheepshead 0 0 1

T_39 Silver perch Silver perch 66 1 67

T_39 Spot Spot 21093 5 21098

T_39 Striped mullet Striped mullet 5314 37 5350

T_39Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 262166 1576 263742

T_39Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 70087 42 70129

T_39Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 747478 1666 749144

Table 40: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 GM

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_40_TMN1Iblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_40_TMN1ISmall GameGM Small Game 415225 3 5.89

T_40_TMN1IOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater262166 2.23 2.91

T_40_TMN1IUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 70087 2.47 3.83

T_40_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 747478 . .

T_40_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 747478 . .

T_40_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 747478 . .

T_40_TMN1Eblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_40_TMN1ESmall GameGM Small Game 48 3 5.89

T_40_TMN1EOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater 1576 2.23 2.91

T_40_TMN1EUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 42 2.47 3.83

T_40_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 1666 . .

T_40_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 1666 . .

T_40_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 1666 . .

T_40_TMN1IEblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_40_TMN1IESmall GameGM Small Game 415274 3 5.89

T_40_TMN1IEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater263742 2.23 2.91

T_40_TMN1IEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 70129 2.47 3.83

T_40_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 749144 . .

T_40_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 749144 . .

T_40_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 749144 . .

Table 41: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 GM

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_41 Mackerels Mackerels 1032 . 1032

T_41 Red drum Red drum 20236 3 20239

T_41 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout 409703 45 409748

T_41Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 430970 48 431019

T_41 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker159643 0 159643

T_41 Black drum Black drum 3001 1294 4295
T_41 Pinfish Pinfish 6015 211 6226

T_41 Sea bass Sea bass 107 . 107

T_41 Searobin Searobin 75864 28 75892

T_41 Sheepshead Sheepshead 0 0 1

T_41 Silver perch Silver perch 68 1 70

T_41 Spot Spot 21893 5 21898

T_41 Striped mullet Striped mullet 5515 37 5552

T_41Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 272107 1576 273683

T_41Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 72744 42 72787

T_41Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 775822 1666 777488

Table 42: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 GM

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_42_TMN2Iblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_42_TMN2ISmall GameGM Small Game 430970 3 5.89

T_42_TMN2IOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater272107 2.23 2.91

T_42_TMN2IUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 72744 2.47 3.83

T_42_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 775822 . .

T_42_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 775822 . .

T_42_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 775822 . .

T_42_TMN2Eblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_42_TMN2ESmall GameGM Small Game 48 3 5.89

T_42_TMN2EOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater 1576 2.23 2.91

T_42_TMN2EUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 42 2.47 3.83

T_42_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 1666 . .

T_42_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 1666 . .

T_42_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 1666 . .

T_42_TMN2IEblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_42_TMN2IESmall GameGM Small Game 431019 3 5.89

T_42_TMN2IEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater273683 2.23 2.91

T_42_TMN2IEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 72787 2.47 3.83

T_42_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 777488 . .

T_42_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 777488 . .

T_42_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 777488 . .

Table 43: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 GM

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_43 Mackerels Mackerels 1237 . 1237

T_43 Red drum Red drum 24272 2462 26734

T_43 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout 491427 32580 524007

T_43Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 516936 35042 551978

T_43 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker191487 111 191598

T_43 Black drum Black drum 3600 937483 941083

T_43 Pinfish Pinfish 7215 152918 160133

T_43 Sea bass Sea bass 128 . 128
T_43 Searobin Searobin 90997 20203 111200

T_43 Sheepshead Sheepshead 1 27 28

T_43 Silver perch Silver perch 82 851 933

T_43 Spot Spot 26260 3521 29782

T_43 Striped mullet Striped mullet 6615 26576 33192

T_43Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) 326384 1141692 1468076

T_43Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 87255 30552 117807

T_43Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 930576 1207285 2137861

Table 44: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 GM

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_44_TMN3Iblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_44_TMN3ISmall GameGM Small Game 516936 3 5.89

T_44_TMN3IOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater326384 2.23 2.91

T_44_TMN3IUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 87255 2.47 3.83

T_44_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 930576 . .

T_44_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 930576 . .

T_44_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 930576 . .

T_44_TMN3Eblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_44_TMN3ESmall GameGM Small Game 35042 3 5.89

T_44_TMN3EOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater 1141692 2.23 2.91

T_44_TMN3EUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 30552 2.47 3.83

T_44_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 1207285 . .

T_44_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 1207285 . .

T_44_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 1207285 . .

T_44_TMN3IEblank rowGM blank row . . .

T_44_TMN3IESmall GameGM Small Game 551978 3 5.89

T_44_TMN3IEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater 1468076 2.23 2.91

T_44_TMN3IEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified 117807 2.47 3.83

T_44_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) 2137861 . .

T_44_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) 2137861 . .

T_44_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) 2137861 . .

Table 46: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline GL

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_46 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass2976 0 2976

T_46 White bass White bass 813130 174392 987522

T_46Total (Bass) Total (Bass) 816106 174392 990498

T_46 Whitefish Whitefish 52045 15 52059

T_46Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) 52045 15 52059

T_46 Black crappie Black crappie 138 . 138

T_46 Bluegill Bluegill 1299 94 1393

T_46 Channel catfish Channel catfish 16714 354 17068

T_46 Crappie Crappie 408 5524 5932

T_46 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt 5979 98577 104556
T_46 Sculpin Sculpin 249 4510 4759

T_46 Smelts Smelts 10873 49 10921

T_46 Sunfish Sunfish 857 13829 14686

T_46 Yellow perch Yellow perch 38486 5033 43518

T_46Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) 75003 127968 202970

T_46 Salmon Salmon 784 202 986

T_46Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 784 202 986

T_46 Northern pike Northern pike 4 2 5

T_46 Walleye Walleye 23168 92715 115883

T_46Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 23172 92717 115889

T_46Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 745557 124451 870008

T_46Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 1712665 519744 2232409

Table 47: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline GL

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_47_baselineIblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_47_baselineIBassGL Bass 816106 4.63 8.95

T_47_baselineIOther TroutGL Other Trout 52045 6.39 9.87

T_47_baselineIPanfishGL Panfish 75003 0.73 1.39

T_47_baselineISalmonGL Salmon 784 8.53 13.88

T_47_baselineIWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 23172 2.28 4.3

T_47_baselineIUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 745557 3.49 6.51

T_47_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 1712665 . .

T_47_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 1712665 . .

T_47_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 1712665 . .

T_47_baselineEblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_47_baselineEBassGL Bass 174392 4.63 8.95

T_47_baselineEOther TroutGL Other Trout 15 6.39 9.87

T_47_baselineEPanfishGL Panfish 127968 0.73 1.39

T_47_baselineESalmonGL Salmon 202 8.53 13.88

T_47_baselineEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 92717 2.28 4.3

T_47_baselineEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 124451 3.49 6.51

T_47_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 519744 . .

T_47_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 519744 . .

T_47_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 519744 . .

T_47_baselineIEblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_47_baselineIEBassGL Bass 990498 4.63 8.95

T_47_baselineIEOther TroutGL Other Trout 52059 6.39 9.87

T_47_baselineIEPanfishGL Panfish 202970 0.73 1.39

T_47_baselineIESalmonGL Salmon 986 8.53 13.88

T_47_baselineIEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 115889 2.28 4.3

T_47_baselineIEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 870008 3.49 6.51

T_47_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 2232409 . .

T_47_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 2232409 . .

T_47_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 2232409 . .
Table 48: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 GL

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_48 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass2314 0 2314

T_48 White bass White bass 632196 129 632325

T_48Total (Bass) Total (Bass) 634509 129 634639

T_48 Whitefish Whitefish 40464 0 40464

T_48Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) 40464 0 40464

T_48 Black crappie Black crappie 107 . 107

T_48 Bluegill Bluegill 1010 0 1010

T_48 Channel catfish Channel catfish 12995 0 12995

T_48 Crappie Crappie 317 4 321

T_48 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt 4649 73 4722

T_48 Sculpin Sculpin 194 3 197

T_48 Smelts Smelts 8453 0 8453

T_48 Sunfish Sunfish 666 10 676

T_48 Yellow perch Yellow perch 29922 4 29926

T_48Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) 58313 95 58408

T_48 Salmon Salmon 609 0 609

T_48Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 609 0 609

T_48 Northern pike Northern pike 3 0 3

T_48 Walleye Walleye 18013 69 18082

T_48Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 18016 69 18085

T_48Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 579659 92 579751

T_48Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 1331570 386 1331956

Table 49: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 GL

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_49_TMN1Iblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_49_TMN1IBassGL Bass 634509 4.63 8.95

T_49_TMN1IOther TroutGL Other Trout 40464 6.39 9.87

T_49_TMN1IPanfishGL Panfish 58313 0.73 1.39

T_49_TMN1ISalmonGL Salmon 609 8.53 13.88

T_49_TMN1IWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 18016 2.28 4.3

T_49_TMN1IUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 579659 3.49 6.51

T_49_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 1331570 . .

T_49_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 1331570 . .

T_49_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 1331570 . .

T_49_TMN1Eblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_49_TMN1EBassGL Bass 129 4.63 8.95

T_49_TMN1EOther TroutGL Other Trout 0 6.39 9.87

T_49_TMN1EPanfishGL Panfish 95 0.73 1.39

T_49_TMN1ESalmonGL Salmon 0 8.53 13.88

T_49_TMN1EWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 69 2.28 4.3

T_49_TMN1EUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 92 3.49 6.51

T_49_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 386 . .
T_49_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 386 . .

T_49_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 386 . .

T_49_TMN1IEblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_49_TMN1IEBassGL Bass 634639 4.63 8.95

T_49_TMN1IEOther TroutGL Other Trout 40464 6.39 9.87

T_49_TMN1IEPanfishGL Panfish 58408 0.73 1.39

T_49_TMN1IESalmonGL Salmon 609 8.53 13.88

T_49_TMN1IEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 18085 2.28 4.3

T_49_TMN1IEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 579751 3.49 6.51

T_49_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 1331956 . .

T_49_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 1331956 . .

T_49_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 1331956 . .

Table 50: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 GL

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_50 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass2546 0 2546

T_50 White bass White bass 695750 409 696159

T_50Total (Bass) Total (Bass) 698296 409 698705

T_50 Whitefish Whitefish 44532 0 44532

T_50Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) 44532 0 44532

T_50 Black crappie Black crappie 118 . 118

T_50 Bluegill Bluegill 1111 0 1112

T_50 Channel catfish Channel catfish 14301 1 14302

T_50 Crappie Crappie 349 13 362

T_50 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt 5116 231 5347

T_50 Sculpin Sculpin 213 11 224

T_50 Smelts Smelts 9303 0 9303

T_50 Sunfish Sunfish 733 32 766

T_50 Yellow perch Yellow perch 32930 12 32942

T_50Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) 64176 300 64475

T_50 Salmon Salmon 670 0 671

T_50Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 670 0 671

T_50 Northern pike Northern pike 3 0 3

T_50 Walleye Walleye 19824 217 20041

T_50Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 19827 217 20044

T_50Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 637932 292 638223

T_50Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 1465433 1218 1466650

Table 51: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 GL

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_51_TMN2Iblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_51_TMN2IBassGL Bass 698296 4.63 8.95

T_51_TMN2IOther TroutGL Other Trout 44532 6.39 9.87

T_51_TMN2IPanfishGL Panfish 64176 0.73 1.39

T_51_TMN2ISalmonGL Salmon 670 8.53 13.88
T_51_TMN2IWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 19827 2.28 4.3

T_51_TMN2IUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 637932 3.49 6.51

T_51_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 1465433 . .

T_51_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 1465433 . .

T_51_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 1465433 . .

T_51_TMN2Eblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_51_TMN2EBassGL Bass 409 4.63 8.95

T_51_TMN2EOther TroutGL Other Trout 0 6.39 9.87

T_51_TMN2EPanfishGL Panfish 300 0.73 1.39

T_51_TMN2ESalmonGL Salmon 0 8.53 13.88

T_51_TMN2EWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 217 2.28 4.3

T_51_TMN2EUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 292 3.49 6.51

T_51_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 1218 . .

T_51_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 1218 . .

T_51_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 1218 . .

T_51_TMN2IEblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_51_TMN2IEBassGL Bass 698705 4.63 8.95

T_51_TMN2IEOther TroutGL Other Trout 44532 6.39 9.87

T_51_TMN2IEPanfishGL Panfish 64475 0.73 1.39

T_51_TMN2IESalmonGL Salmon 671 8.53 13.88

T_51_TMN2IEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 20044 2.28 4.3

T_51_TMN2IEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 638223 3.49 6.51

T_51_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 1466650 . .

T_51_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 1466650 . .

T_51_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 1466650 . .

Table 52: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 GL

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_52 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass2902 0 2902

T_52 White bass White bass 792846 125515 918361

T_52Total (Bass) Total (Bass) 795748 125515 921263

T_52 Whitefish Whitefish 50746 11 50757

T_52Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) 50746 11 50757

T_52 Black crappie Black crappie 135 . 135

T_52 Bluegill Bluegill 1266 67 1334

T_52 Channel catfish Channel catfish 16297 254 16552

T_52 Crappie Crappie 398 3976 4373

T_52 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt 5830 70949 76779

T_52 Sculpin Sculpin 243 3246 3489

T_52 Smelts Smelts 10601 35 10636

T_52 Sunfish Sunfish 835 9953 10788

T_52 Yellow perch Yellow perch 37525 3622 41148

T_52Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) 73132 92102 165234

T_52 Salmon Salmon 764 146 910

T_52Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 764 146 910

T_52 Northern pike Northern pike 4 1 5
T_52 Walleye Walleye 22590 66730 89320

T_52Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 22594 66731 89325

T_52Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 726959 89571 816530

T_52Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 1669943 374075 2044018

Table 53: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 GL

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_53_TMN3Iblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_53_TMN3IBassGL Bass 795748 4.63 8.95

T_53_TMN3IOther TroutGL Other Trout 50746 6.39 9.87

T_53_TMN3IPanfishGL Panfish 73132 0.73 1.39

T_53_TMN3ISalmonGL Salmon 764 8.53 13.88

T_53_TMN3IWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 22594 2.28 4.3

T_53_TMN3IUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 726959 3.49 6.51

T_53_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 1669943 . .

T_53_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 1669943 . .

T_53_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 1669943 . .

T_53_TMN3Eblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_53_TMN3EBassGL Bass 125515 4.63 8.95

T_53_TMN3EOther TroutGL Other Trout 11 6.39 9.87

T_53_TMN3EPanfishGL Panfish 92102 0.73 1.39

T_53_TMN3ESalmonGL Salmon 146 8.53 13.88

T_53_TMN3EWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 66731 2.28 4.3

T_53_TMN3EUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 89571 3.49 6.51

T_53_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 374075 . .

T_53_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 374075 . .

T_53_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 374075 . .

T_53_TMN3IEblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_53_TMN3IEBassGL Bass 921263 4.63 8.95

T_53_TMN3IEOther TroutGL Other Trout 50757 6.39 9.87

T_53_TMN3IEPanfishGL Panfish 165234 0.73 1.39

T_53_TMN3IESalmonGL Salmon 910 8.53 13.88

T_53_TMN3IEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike 89325 2.28 4.3

T_53_TMN3IEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified 816530 3.49 6.51

T_53_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) 2044018 . .

T_53_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) 2044018 . .

T_53_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) 2044018 . .

Table 55: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline IN

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_55 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass10825 169868 180693

T_55 White bass White bass 734522 832536 1567058

T_55Total (Bass) Total (Bass) 745347 1002404 1747751

T_55 Whitefish Whitefish 1855 93 1947

T_55Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) 1855 93 1947
T_55 Black bullhead Black bullhead 28468 881 29349

T_55 Black crappie Black crappie 15910 121719 137629

T_55 Bluegill Bluegill 377836 32204 410040

T_55 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead 5395 8612 14007

T_55 Bullhead Bullhead 3668 1430 5099

T_55 Channel catfish Channel catfish258110 159709 417819

T_55 Crappie Crappie 27301 338640 365941

T_55 Menhaden Menhaden 291 . 291

T_55 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt 3502 5239 8741

T_55 Smelts Smelts 1 . 1

T_55 Sunfish Sunfish 219137 1211094 1430230

T_55 White perch White perch 4598 585 5183

T_55 Yellow perch Yellow perch 337721 254454 592175

T_55Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish)1281938 2134567 3416505

T_55 Salmon Salmon 5 . 5

T_55Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 5 . 5

T_55 American shad American shad 2905 . 2905

T_55 Striped bass Striped bass 18729 . 18729

T_55 Sturgeon Sturgeon 208 1433 1640

T_55Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 21842 1433 23274

T_55 Northern pike Northern pike 34 0 34

T_55 Sauger Sauger 8828 161681 170509

T_55 Walleye Walleye 14870 183647 198517

T_55Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 23732 345328 369060

T_55Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 2799199 3542610 6341808

T_55Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 4873917 7026434 11900351

Table 56: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline IN

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_56_baselineIblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_56_baselineIBassIN Bass 745347 4.48 9.43

T_56_baselineIOther TroutIN Other Trout 1855 1.59 2.96

T_56_baselineIPanfishIN Panfish 1281938 0.55 1.11

T_56_baselineISalmonIN Salmon 5 8.53 13.88

T_56_baselineISmall GameIN Small Game 21842 1.68 5.61

T_56_baselineIWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 23732 2.07 4.29

T_56_baselineIUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 2799199 1.13 2.33

T_56_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 4873917 . .

T_56_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 4873917 . .

T_56_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 4873917 . .

T_56_baselineEblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_56_baselineEBassIN Bass 1002404 4.48 9.43

T_56_baselineEOther TroutIN Other Trout 93 1.59 2.96

T_56_baselineEPanfishIN Panfish 2134567 0.55 1.11

T_56_baselineESalmonIN Salmon . 8.53 13.88

T_56_baselineESmall GameIN Small Game 1433 1.68 5.61
T_56_baselineEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 345328 2.07 4.29

T_56_baselineEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 3542610 1.13 2.33

T_56_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 7026434 . .

T_56_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 7026434 . .

T_56_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 7026434 . .

T_56_baselineIEblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_56_baselineIEBassIN Bass 1747751 4.48 9.43

T_56_baselineIEOther TroutIN Other Trout 1947 1.59 2.96

T_56_baselineIEPanfishIN Panfish 3416505 0.55 1.11

T_56_baselineIESalmonIN Salmon 5 8.53 13.88

T_56_baselineIESmall GameIN Small Game 23274 1.68 5.61

T_56_baselineIEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 369060 2.07 4.29

T_56_baselineIEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 6341808 1.13 2.33

T_56_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 11900351 . .

T_56_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 11900351 . .

T_56_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 11900351 . .

Table 57: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 IN

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_57 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass7907 234 8142

T_57 White bass White bass 536564 1148 537712

T_57Total (Bass) Total (Bass) 544472 1382 545853

T_57 Whitefish Whitefish 1355 0 1355

T_57Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) 1355 0 1355

T_57 Black bullhead Black bullhead 20796 1 20797

T_57 Black crappie Black crappie 11622 168 11790

T_57 Bluegill Bluegill 276007 44 276051

T_57 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead 3941 12 3953

T_57 Bullhead Bullhead 2680 2 2682

T_57 Channel catfish Channel catfish188548 220 188768

T_57 Crappie Crappie 19943 467 20410

T_57 Menhaden Menhaden 213 . 213

T_57 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt 2558 7 2565

T_57 Smelts Smelts 1 . 1

T_57 Sunfish Sunfish 160078 1669 161748

T_57 White perch White perch 3359 1 3360

T_57 Yellow perch Yellow perch 246703 351 247054

T_57Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish)936448 2942 939390

T_57 Salmon Salmon 4 . 4

T_57Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 4 . 4

T_57 American shad American shad 2122 . 2122

T_57 Striped bass Striped bass 13681 . 13681

T_57 Sturgeon Sturgeon 152 2 154

T_57Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 15955 2 15957

T_57 Northern pike Northern pike 25 0 25

T_57 Sauger Sauger 6449 223 6672
T_57 Walleye Walleye 10862 253 11116

T_57Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 17336 476 17812

T_57Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 2044798 4883 2049682

T_57Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 3560368 9685 3570053

Table 58: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 IN

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_58_TMN1Iblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_58_TMN1IBassIN Bass 544472 4.48 9.43

T_58_TMN1IOther TroutIN Other Trout 1355 1.59 2.96

T_58_TMN1IPanfishIN Panfish 936448 0.55 1.11

T_58_TMN1ISalmonIN Salmon 4 8.53 13.88

T_58_TMN1ISmall GameIN Small Game 15955 1.68 5.61

T_58_TMN1IWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 17336 2.07 4.29

T_58_TMN1IUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 2044798 1.13 2.33

T_58_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 3560368 . .

T_58_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 3560368 . .

T_58_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 3560368 . .

T_58_TMN1Eblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_58_TMN1EBassIN Bass 1382 4.48 9.43

T_58_TMN1EOther TroutIN Other Trout 0 1.59 2.96

T_58_TMN1EPanfishIN Panfish 2942 0.55 1.11

T_58_TMN1ESalmonIN Salmon . 8.53 13.88

T_58_TMN1ESmall GameIN Small Game 2 1.68 5.61

T_58_TMN1EWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 476 2.07 4.29

T_58_TMN1EUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 4883 1.13 2.33

T_58_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 9685 . .

T_58_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 9685 . .

T_58_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 9685 . .

T_58_TMN1IEblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_58_TMN1IEBassIN Bass 545853 4.48 9.43

T_58_TMN1IEOther TroutIN Other Trout 1355 1.59 2.96

T_58_TMN1IEPanfishIN Panfish 939390 0.55 1.11

T_58_TMN1IESalmonIN Salmon 4 8.53 13.88

T_58_TMN1IESmall GameIN Small Game 15957 1.68 5.61

T_58_TMN1IEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 17812 2.07 4.29

T_58_TMN1IEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 2049682 1.13 2.33

T_58_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 3570053 . .

T_58_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 3570053 . .

T_58_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 3570053 . .

Table 59: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 IN

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_59 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass8176 1216 9392

T_59 White bass White bass 554793 5958 560751
T_59Total (Bass) Total (Bass) 562969 7173 570143

T_59 Whitefish Whitefish 1401 1 1401

T_59Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) 1401 1 1401

T_59 Black bullhead Black bullhead 21502 6 21509

T_59 Black crappie Black crappie 12017 871 12888

T_59 Bluegill Bluegill 285384 230 285614

T_59 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead 4075 62 4136

T_59 Bullhead Bullhead 2771 10 2781

T_59 Channel catfish Channel catfish194953 1143 196096

T_59 Crappie Crappie 20621 2423 23044

T_59 Menhaden Menhaden 220 . 220

T_59 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt 2645 37 2683

T_59 Smelts Smelts 1 . 1

T_59 Sunfish Sunfish 165517 8667 174183

T_59 White perch White perch 3473 4 3477

T_59 Yellow perch Yellow perch 255084 1821 256905

T_59Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish)968263 15275 983538

T_59 Salmon Salmon 4 . 4

T_59Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 4 . 4

T_59 American shad American shad 2194 . 2194

T_59 Striped bass Striped bass 14146 . 14146

T_59 Sturgeon Sturgeon 157 10 167

T_59Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 16497 10 16507

T_59 Northern pike Northern pike 26 0 26

T_59 Sauger Sauger 6668 1157 7825

T_59 Walleye Walleye 11231 1314 12546

T_59Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 17925 2471 20396

T_59Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 2114267 25351 2139619

T_59Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 3681326 50282 3731608

Table 60: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 IN

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_60_TMN2Iblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_60_TMN2IBassIN Bass 562969 4.48 9.43

T_60_TMN2IOther TroutIN Other Trout 1401 1.59 2.96

T_60_TMN2IPanfishIN Panfish 968263 0.55 1.11

T_60_TMN2ISalmonIN Salmon 4 8.53 13.88

T_60_TMN2ISmall GameIN Small Game 16497 1.68 5.61

T_60_TMN2IWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 17925 2.07 4.29

T_60_TMN2IUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 2114267 1.13 2.33

T_60_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 3681326 . .

T_60_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 3681326 . .

T_60_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 3681326 . .

T_60_TMN2Eblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_60_TMN2EBassIN Bass 7173 4.48 9.43

T_60_TMN2EOther TroutIN Other Trout 1 1.59 2.96
T_60_TMN2EPanfishIN Panfish 15275 0.55 1.11

T_60_TMN2ESalmonIN Salmon . 8.53 13.88

T_60_TMN2ESmall GameIN Small Game 10 1.68 5.61

T_60_TMN2EWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 2471 2.07 4.29

T_60_TMN2EUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 25351 1.13 2.33

T_60_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 50282 . .

T_60_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 50282 . .

T_60_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 50282 . .

T_60_TMN2IEblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_60_TMN2IEBassIN Bass 570143 4.48 9.43

T_60_TMN2IEOther TroutIN Other Trout 1401 1.59 2.96

T_60_TMN2IEPanfishIN Panfish 983538 0.55 1.11

T_60_TMN2IESalmonIN Salmon 4 8.53 13.88

T_60_TMN2IESmall GameIN Small Game 16507 1.68 5.61

T_60_TMN2IEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 20396 2.07 4.29

T_60_TMN2IEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 2139619 1.13 2.33

T_60_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 3731608 . .

T_60_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 3731608 . .

T_60_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 3731608 . .

Table 61: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 IN

tag Species NameRduced I Reduced E Reduced I&E

T_61 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass9431 131948 141379

T_61 White bass White bass 639958 646685 1286644

T_61Total (Bass) Total (Bass) 649389 778633 1428023

T_61 Whitefish Whitefish 1616 72 1688

T_61Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) 1616 72 1688

T_61 Black bullhead Black bullhead 24803 684 25487

T_61 Black crappie Black crappie 13862 94547 108409

T_61 Bluegill Bluegill 329193 25015 354207

T_61 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead 4700 6690 11390

T_61 Bullhead Bullhead 3196 1111 4307

T_61 Channel catfish Channel catfish224880 124057 348937

T_61 Crappie Crappie 23786 263044 286830

T_61 Menhaden Menhaden 254 . 254

T_61 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt 3051 4070 7121

T_61 Smelts Smelts 1 . 1

T_61 Sunfish Sunfish 190925 940736 1131661

T_61 White perch White perch 4006 454 4461

T_61 Yellow perch Yellow perch 294242 197651 491893

T_61Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish)1116899 1658059 2774958

T_61 Salmon Salmon 4 . 4

T_61Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) 4 . 4

T_61 American shad American shad 2531 . 2531

T_61 Striped bass Striped bass 16318 . 16318

T_61 Sturgeon Sturgeon 181 1113 1294
T_61Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) 19030 1113 20143

T_61 Northern pike Northern pike 29 0 29

T_61 Sauger Sauger 7692 125588 133280

T_61 Walleye Walleye 12956 142651 155606

T_61Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) 20677 268239 288916

T_61Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) 2438824 2751779 5190603

T_61Total (All Species) Total (All Species) 4246439 5457895 9704334

Table 62: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 IN

tag Species GroupAnnual Reduction in # of Fish Lost Low WTP Mean WTP

T_62_TMN3Iblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_62_TMN3IBassIN Bass 649389 4.48 9.43

T_62_TMN3IOther TroutIN Other Trout 1616 1.59 2.96

T_62_TMN3IPanfishIN Panfish 1116899 0.55 1.11

T_62_TMN3ISalmonIN Salmon 4 8.53 13.88

T_62_TMN3ISmall GameIN Small Game 19030 1.68 5.61

T_62_TMN3IWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 20677 2.07 4.29

T_62_TMN3IUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 2438824 1.13 2.33

T_62_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 4246439 . .

T_62_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 4246439 . .

T_62_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 4246439 . .

T_62_TMN3Eblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_62_TMN3EBassIN Bass 778633 4.48 9.43

T_62_TMN3EOther TroutIN Other Trout 72 1.59 2.96

T_62_TMN3EPanfishIN Panfish 1658059 0.55 1.11

T_62_TMN3ESalmonIN Salmon . 8.53 13.88

T_62_TMN3ESmall GameIN Small Game 1113 1.68 5.61

T_62_TMN3EWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 268239 2.07 4.29

T_62_TMN3EUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 2751779 1.13 2.33

T_62_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 5457895 . .

T_62_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 5457895 . .

T_62_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 5457895 . .

T_62_TMN3IEblank rowIN blank row . . .

T_62_TMN3IEBassIN Bass 1428023 4.48 9.43

T_62_TMN3IEOther TroutIN Other Trout 1688 1.59 2.96

T_62_TMN3IEPanfishIN Panfish 2774958 0.55 1.11

T_62_TMN3IESalmonIN Salmon 4 8.53 13.88

T_62_TMN3IESmall GameIN Small Game 20143 1.68 5.61

T_62_TMN3IEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike 288916 2.07 4.29

T_62_TMN3IEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified 5190603 1.13 2.33

T_62_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) 9704334 . .

T_62_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) 9704334 . .

T_62_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) 9704334 . .
Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

19.49 1 2 3

30.14 0 0 0

13.01 . . .

5.11 108 178 295

5.42 3 5 9

. 112 185 306

. 94 155 257

. 84 139 230

. . . .

19.49 289 551 1051

30.14 . . .

13.01 7 13 22

5.11 2456 4062 6714

5.42 7 11 19

. 2759 4637 7806

. 2314 3888 6546

. 2069 3477 5854

. . . .

19.49 289 552 1054

30.14 0 0 0
13.01 7 13 22

5.11 2564 4240 7008

5.42 10 17 28

. 2871 4822 8112

. 2408 4044 6803

. 2153 3616 6084

Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

19.49 0 1 2

30.14 0 0 0

13.01 . . .

5.11 64 106 176

5.42 2 3 5

. 67 110 183

. 42 69 114

. 30 50 83

. . . .

19.49 0 0 0

30.14 . . .

13.01 0 0 0

5.11 0 0 0
5.42 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. . . .

19.49 0 1 2

30.14 0 0 0

13.01 0 0 0

5.11 64 106 176

5.42 2 3 5

. 67 110 183

. 42 69 114

. 30 50 83

Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

19.49 1 1 2

30.14 0 0 0

13.01 . . .

5.11 69 115 189

5.42 2 3 6

. 72 119 197
. 45 74 123

. 33 54 89

. . . .

19.49 0 0 0

30.14 . . .

13.01 0 0 0

5.11 0 0 0

5.42 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. . . .

19.49 1 1 2

30.14 0 0 0

13.01 0 0 0

5.11 69 115 189

5.42 2 3 6

. 72 119 197

. 45 74 123

. 33 54 89

Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit
. . . .

19.49 1 1 2

30.14 0 0 0

13.01 . . .

5.11 73 121 201

5.42 2 4 6

. 76 126 209

. 40 66 109

. 26 42 70

. . . .

19.49 176 336 641

30.14 . . .

13.01 5 8 13

5.11 1498 2477 4095

5.42 4 7 12

. 1683 2828 4761

. 879 1477 2486

. 567 952 1603

. . . .

19.49 177 337 643

30.14 0 0 0

13.01 5 8 13

5.11 1572 2599 4296

5.42 6 10 17

. 1759 2954 4970

. 919 1543 2595

. 592 994 1673

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

9.86 5 7 12

17.53 0 0 0

5.2 1 2 4

5.26 0 1 1

. 6 10 17

. 5 9 14

. 5 8 12

. . . .

9.86 1188 1859 2940

17.53 2 6 16

5.2 805 1343 2238

5.26 5 8 13

. 1999 3215 5206

. 1677 2696 4366

. 1499 2411 3904

. . . .

9.86 1192 1867 2951

17.53 2 6 16

5.2 806 1345 2242

5.26 5 8 14

. 2006 3226 5223

. 1682 2705 4380

. 1504 2419 3917

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

9.86 3 5 8

17.53 0 0 0

5.2 1 1 2

5.26 0 1 1

. 4 7 11

. 3 4 7

. 2 3 5

. . . .

9.86 0 0 0

17.53 0 0 0

5.2 0 0 0

5.26 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. . . .

9.86 3 5 8

17.53 0 0 0

5.2 1 1 2

5.26 0 1 1

. 4 7 11

. 3 4 7

. 2 3 5

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

9.86 3 5 8

17.53 0 0 0

5.2 1 1 2

5.26 0 1 1

. 4 7 11

. 3 4 7

. 2 3 5

. . . .

9.86 11 17 26

17.53 0 0 0

5.2 7 12 20

5.26 0 0 0

. 18 29 46

. 11 18 29

. 8 13 21

. . . .

9.86 14 22 34

17.53 0 0 0

5.2 8 13 22

5.26 0 1 1

. 22 36 58

. 14 23 36

. 10 16 27

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

9.86 4 7 11

17.53 0 0 0

5.2 1 2 3

5.26 0 1 1

. 6 10 15

. 3 5 9

. 2 4 6

. . . .

9.86 909 1424 2251

17.53 2 4 12

5.2 616 1028 1714

5.26 4 6 10

. 1531 2462 3986

. 849 1365 2211

. 570 917 1486

. . . .

9.86 914 1430 2261

17.53 2 4 12

5.2 617 1030 1717

5.26 4 7 11

. 1537 2471 4001

. 852 1371 2219

. 573 921 1491

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

8.92 18 27 41

2.2 2 4 7

16.23 301 785 2063

0 0 0 0

4.82 667 1051 1657

6 151 257 454

. 1139 2123 4222

. 955 1780 3541

. 854 1592 3166

. . . .
8.92 11 16 24

2.2 1 3 5

16.23 695 1814 4770

0 . . .

4.82 8257 13007 20505

6 1421 2413 4267

. 10385 17252 29571

. 8710 14469 24800

. 7789 12938 22177

. . . .

8.92 29 43 65

2.2 3 6 12

16.23 996 2599 6833

0 0 0 0

4.82 8924 14058 22162

6 1573 2669 4721

. 11524 19375 33793

. 9665 16249 28341

. 8643 14531 25343

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

8.92 14 20 31

2.2 1 3 5

16.23 228 594 1561

0 0 0 0

4.82 505 795 1254

6 114 194 343

. 862 1606 3194

. 521 972 1933

. 369 689 1370

. . . .

8.92 0 0 0

2.2 0 0 0

16.23 1 3 7

0 . . .

4.82 13 20 32

6 2 4 7

. 16 27 46

. 10 16 28

. 7 12 20

. . . .

8.92 14 20 31

2.2 1 3 5

16.23 229 597 1569

0 0 0 0

4.82 518 816 1286

6 117 198 350

. 878 1633 3241

. 531 988 1961

. 376 700 1389
Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

8.92 15 22 33

2.2 1 3 6

16.23 243 634 1668
0 0 0 0

4.82 539 850 1339

6 122 207 367

. 921 1716 3413

. 557 1039 2065

. 395 736 1463

. . . .

8.92 0 0 0

2.2 0 0 0

16.23 2 4 11

0 . . .

4.82 20 31 48

6 3 6 10

. 25 41 70

. 15 25 42

. 11 17 30

. . . .

8.92 15 22 33

2.2 1 3 6

16.23 245 639 1679

0 0 0 0

4.82 559 880 1388

6 126 213 377

. 945 1757 3483

. 572 1063 2108

. 405 753 1493

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

8.92 17 25 38

2.2 2 3 7

16.23 278 725 1906

0 0 0 0

4.82 616 971 1531

6 140 237 419

. 1052 1962 3901

. 535 996 1982

. 341 635 1264

. . . .

8.92 9 14 21

2.2 1 2 5

16.23 606 1581 4156

0 . . .

4.82 7195 11334 17868

6 1239 2103 3719

. 9050 15034 25769

. 4597 7637 13091

. 2932 4871 8348

. . . .

8.92 26 39 59

2.2 3 6 11

16.23 884 2306 6063
0 0 0 0

4.82 7812 12306 19399

6 1378 2340 4138

. 10102 16996 29670

. 5132 8634 15072

. 3273 5506 9612

Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

8.66 2 3 5

12.59 1 2 3

3.95 39 52 69

3.99 2 2 3

. 44 60 81

. 37 50 68

. 33 45 61

. . . .

8.66 . . .

12.59 5 10 21

3.95 201 266 353

3.99 2 2 3

. 207 279 378

. 174 234 317

. 155 209 283

. . . .

8.66 2 3 5

12.59 6 12 25

3.95 240 319 423

3.99 4 5 6
. 251 338 459

. 211 284 385

. 189 254 344

Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

8.66 2 2 3

12.59 1 1 2

3.95 27 35 47

3.99 1 2 2

. 30 40 55

. 18 24 33

. 13 17 23

. . . .

8.66 . . .

12.59 0 0 0

3.95 0 0 0

3.99 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. 0 0 0

. . . .

8.66 2 2 3

12.59 1 1 2

3.95 27 35 47

3.99 1 2 2

. 30 40 55

. 18 24 33

. 13 17 23
Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

8.66 2 3 4

12.59 1 1 2

3.95 29 38 50

3.99 1 2 2

. 32 43 59

. 19 26 35

. 14 18 25

. . . .

8.66 . . .

12.59 0 1 1

3.95 10 14 18

3.99 0 0 0

. 11 15 20

. 6 9 12

. 5 6 8

. . . .

8.66 2 3 4

12.59 1 2 4

3.95 39 52 69

3.99 1 2 2

. 43 58 78

. 26 35 47

. 18 24 33
Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

8.66 2 3 5

12.59 1 2 3

3.95 39 52 69

3.99 2 2 3

. 44 59 80

. 24 32 43

. 16 21 29

. . . .

8.66 . . .

12.59 4 9 20

3.95 188 249 330

3.99 2 2 3

. 194 261 353

. 105 141 191

. 70 94 127

. . . .

8.66 2 3 5

12.59 5 11 23

3.95 227 301 399

3.99 3 4 6

. 238 320 433

. 129 173 234

. 86 115 156

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

11.55 1723 3380 6626

3.78 809 1053 1369

6.18 239 371 599

. 2772 4804 8594

. 2419 4193 7502

. 2231 3867 6919

. . . .

11.55 178 350 685

3.78 4319 5618 7306

6.18 128 198 320

. 4625 6166 8311

. 4037 5382 7254

. 3724 4964 6691

. . . .

11.55 1901 3729 7312

3.78 5129 6671 8675

6.18 367 569 919

. 7397 10969 16905

. 6457 9575 14756

. 5955 8831 13610

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

11.55 1246 2446 4794

3.78 586 762 991

6.18 173 268 433

. 2005 3476 6219

. 1258 2180 3899

. 912 1581 2828

. . . .

11.55 0 0 1

3.78 4 5 6

6.18 0 0 0

. 4 5 7

. 2 3 4

. 2 2 3

. . . .

11.55 1247 2446 4795

3.78 589 766 997

6.18 173 269 434

. 2009 3481 6225

. 1260 2183 3904

. 914 1583 2831

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

11.55 1294 2538 4976

3.78 608 791 1028

6.18 180 279 450

. 2081 3608 6454

. 1305 2262 4047

. 947 1641 2935

. . . .

11.55 0 0 1

3.78 4 5 6

6.18 0 0 0

. 4 5 7

. 2 3 4

. 2 2 3

. . . .

11.55 1294 2539 4977

3.78 611 795 1034

6.18 180 279 450

. 2085 3613 6461

. 1308 2265 4051

. 948 1643 2938

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

11.55 1552 3045 5969

3.78 729 948 1233

6.18 216 334 540

. 2497 4327 7742

. 1603 2779 4971

. 1182 2049 3666

. . . .

11.55 105 206 405

3.78 2551 3317 4314

6.18 76 117 189

. 2731 3641 4907

. 1754 2338 3151

. 1294 1724 2324

. . . .

11.55 1657 3251 6373

3.78 3280 4266 5547

6.18 291 451 729

. 5228 7968 12649

. 3357 5116 8122

. 2476 3774 5991

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

17.38 3777 7308 14185

15.34 332 514 798

2.61 55 104 196

22.61 7 11 18

8.16 53 100 189

12.25 2598 4851 9136

. 6822 12888 24522

. 5955 11249 21404

. 5492 10376 19742

. . . .

17.38 807 1562 3031

15.34 0 0 0

2.61 94 178 334

22.61 2 3 5

8.16 211 399 757

12.25 434 810 1525

. 1548 2951 5652

. 1351 2576 4933

. 1246 2376 4550

. . . .

17.38 4584 8870 17216

15.34 332 514 799

2.61 148 282 530

22.61 8 14 22

8.16 264 498 946

12.25 3032 5661 10661

. 8370 15838 30174

. 7306 13825 26338

. 6738 12751 24292
Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

17.38 2937 5682 11029

15.34 258 399 621

2.61 43 81 152

22.61 5 8 14

8.16 41 77 147

12.25 2020 3772 7103

. 5304 10020 19066

. 3445 6508 12382

. 2561 4838 9206

. . . .

17.38 1 1 2

15.34 0 0 0

2.61 0 0 0

22.61 0 0 0

8.16 0 0 1

12.25 0 1 1

. 1 2 4
. 1 1 3

. 1 1 2

. . . .

17.38 2937 5683 11031

15.34 258 399 621

2.61 43 81 153

22.61 5 8 14

8.16 41 78 148

12.25 2020 3772 7104

. 5305 10022 19070

. 3446 6509 12385

. 2562 4839 9208

Reduced I&E

High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

17.38 3232 6253 12137

15.34 284 440 683

2.61 47 89 168

22.61 6 9 15
8.16 45 85 162

12.25 2223 4151 7817

. 5837 11027 20982

. 3791 7162 13627

. 2819 5324 10131

. . . .

17.38 2 4 7

15.34 0 0 0

2.61 0 0 1

22.61 0 0 0

8.16 0 1 2

12.25 1 2 4

. 4 7 13

. 2 4 9

. 2 3 6

. . . .

17.38 3234 6257 12144

15.34 284 440 683

2.61 47 90 168

22.61 6 9 15

8.16 46 86 164

12.25 2224 4153 7821

. 5841 11034 20995

. 3793 7166 13636

. 2820 5328 10138

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

17.38 3683 7126 13831

15.34 324 501 778

2.61 53 102 191

22.61 7 11 17

8.16 52 97 184

12.25 2533 4730 8908

. 6652 12566 23910

. 4040 7632 14522

. 2877 5436 10343

. . . .

17.38 581 1124 2182

15.34 0 0 0

2.61 67 128 241

22.61 1 2 3

8.16 152 287 545

12.25 312 583 1098

. 1114 2124 4068

. 677 1290 2471

. 482 919 1760

. . . .

17.38 4264 8250 16013

15.34 324 501 779

2.61 121 229 432

22.61 8 13 21

8.16 204 384 729

12.25 2846 5313 10006

. 7766 14690 27978

. 4717 8922 16993

. 3359 6354 12102

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

19.96 3341 7028 14876

5.53 3 5 10

2.2 709 1417 2821

22.61 0 0 0

18.9 37 122 413

8.92 49 102 212

4.81 3176 6534 13472

. 7314 15209 31804

. 6384 13275 27761

. 5889 12245 25605

. . . .

19.96 4493 9452 20007

5.53 0 0 1

2.2 1180 2360 4697

22.61 . . .

18.9 2 8 27
8.92 716 1482 3081

4.81 4019 8269 17050

. 10411 21572 44862

. 9087 18829 39158

. 8381 17367 36117

. . . .

19.96 7835 16480 34883

5.53 3 6 11

2.2 1889 3777 7519

22.61 0 0 0

18.9 39 130 440

8.92 765 1584 3292

4.81 7195 14803 30522

. 17725 36781 76666

. 15471 32105 66919

. 14270 29611 61722

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

19.96 2441 5134 10867

5.53 2 4 7

2.2 518 1035 2061

22.61 0 0 0

18.9 27 89 302

8.92 36 74 155

4.81 2320 4773 9841

. 5343 11110 23233

. 3494 7264 15191

. 2609 5425 11345

. . . .

19.96 6 13 28

5.53 0 0 0

2.2 2 3 6

22.61 . . .

18.9 0 0 0

8.92 1 2 4

4.81 6 11 24

. 14 30 62

. 9 19 40

. 7 15 30

. . . .

19.96 2447 5147 10894

5.53 2 4 7

2.2 519 1039 2067

22.61 0 0 0

18.9 27 89 302

8.92 37 76 159

4.81 2325 4784 9865

. 5357 11140 23295

. 3503 7284 15231

. 2616 5440 11375

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

19.96 2524 5308 11236

5.53 2 4 8

2.2 535 1071 2131

22.61 0 0 0

18.9 28 92 312

8.92 37 77 160

4.81 2399 4935 10176

. 5525 11488 24022

. 3613 7512 15708

. 2698 5610 11732

. . . .

19.96 32 68 143

5.53 0 0 0
2.2 8 17 34

22.61 . . .

18.9 0 0 0

8.92 5 11 22

4.81 29 59 122

. 74 154 321

. 49 101 210

. 36 75 157

. . . .

19.96 2556 5376 11379

5.53 2 4 8

2.2 544 1087 2164

22.61 0 0 0

18.9 28 93 312

8.92 42 88 182

4.81 2427 4994 10298

. 5599 11642 24343

. 3661 7613 15918

. 2735 5686 11889

Reduced I&E
High WTP Low BenefitMean Benefit High Benefit

. . . .

19.96 2911 6123 12961

5.53 3 5 9

2.2 617 1235 2458

22.61 0 0 0

18.9 32 107 360

8.92 43 89 184

4.81 2767 5693 11738

. 6373 13251 27710

. 3654 7597 15887

. 2524 5248 10973

. . . .

19.96 3490 7342 15540

5.53 0 0 0

2.2 917 1833 3649

22.61 . . .

18.9 2 6 21

8.92 556 1151 2393

4.81 3122 6423 13244

. 8087 16756 34847

. 4636 9607 19979

. 3202 6636 13800

. . . .

19.96 6401 13465 28501

5.53 3 5 9

2.2 1534 3068 6107

22.61 0 0 0

18.9 34 113 381

8.92 599 1240 2577

4.81 5889 12116 24981

. 14459 30007 62557

. 8290 17204 35865

. 5726 11883 24773