U.S . DEPARTiMEN T O FTRANSFORrATlO N . Ori'JC n O FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C . I N THE MATTERO F SCENI C AVIATION , INC . F A A Docket

No . CP09NlVr00 1 (Civi l Penalt

y Action ) DMSNo . FAA-2009-097 4 Th e I lonorabl e RichardC . Goodwi n c 3 Administrativ e La

w Judg e ' Hearin g Location : Sal t

Lak e City , UT RESPONDENT' S FlfRS T SE T O FINTERROGATORIE S AND REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N O FDOCUME N I S Pursuant t o Rul e 1 .^.22

0 o f th e F^ule s o f Practic e (1 4 CF.R . Par

t 13) , Responden t

hereb y request s that

th e Complainant , on o r

befor e Apri l L 2010 , provid e th e followin g information: ' INTERROGATORIE S Intcrrogsitor y No . 1 : Identify , b y providin g th e name , occupation , an dbusines s address , o f

eac h perso n th e Complainan t

intend s t o cal l a s awitnes s i n thi s proceeding . Interrogator y No . 2 ; Provid e th e substanc e o f th e testimon y l o b e ol'lere db y eac h o f th e witnesse s identifie di n InieiTOgator y No . 1 .

^ Thi s i s a . continuin g reques t

fo r th e Complainan t

t o provid e all update do r

ne w record s o r

information , a s itemize di n thi s discover

y request , througl i th e dat e o f th e hearing . New evidenc e siioul db e provide di n accordanc e wit

h Rul e 26(e ) o f

th e Federa

l Rule s o f Civi l Procedure .

300/LOOi a SW O * VVd StLSGGtSO S XV d S2:e L OLOS/SS/E OInterrogator y No . 3 : Wit h respec t t o eac h exper

t that th e Complainan t

intend s t o cal l a s awitnes s i n thi s proceeding , se t

fort h th e subjec t

matte r upo n whic h eac h expert

witnes s i s expecte dt o testify , th e fact s an

dopinion s composin g th e testimon y o f eac h exper

t witness , an dasummar

y o f th e ground s fo

r eac h opinion . Interrogator y No . 4 : identif y an y an dal l document s andother material s i n th e possessio n o f the Complainan t

tha t concern , refe

r to , o r involv e the circumstance s .se t fort h i n th e Complain t

tile din thi s matter . Interrogator y No . 5 : Provid e aful l descriptio n o f

th e altimeter/encode r

dat acorrespondenc e erro r concernin g N3221 M betwee n July 28 , 200 7 an d.lanuar y 23 , 2008 , a s allege di

n th e Complaint . Interrogator y No . 6 : State i n detail , th e factua l basi s upo n whic h th e Complainan t relic s t o prov e a n altimcrcr/cncodc r

dat acorrespondenc e erro r eoneerain g N3221 M betwee n July 28 , 200 7 and Januar y 23 , 2008 , a s allege din th e Complaint . Interrogator y No . 7 : Provid e aful l descriptio n o f

th e altimeter/encode r

dat acorrespondenc e erro r concernin g N588S A betwee n July 10 , 200 7 an dDecember 10 , 2008 , a s allege di

n th e Complaint . Interrogator y No . 8 : State i n detail , th e factua l basi s upo n whic h th e Complainan t relie s to prov e a n oitimei;er/encode

r datacorrespondenc e erro r concernin g N588S A betwee n July 10 , 200 7 and December 10 , 2008 , a s allege din th e Complaint . Interrogator y No . 9 : Provid e aful l descriptio n o f

th e altimeter/encode r

dat acorrespondenc e erro r concernin g N617M M betwee n Octobe r 19 , 200 7 an dMarc h 29 , 2009 , a s allege di n th e Complaint . Interrogator y No . 10 : State i n detail , th e factua l basi s upo n whic h th e Complainan t relic s to prov e a n altimeter/encode r

dat acorrespondenc e erro r concemin g N617M M betwee n October 19 , 200 7 an dMarc h 29 , 2009 , a s allege din th e Complaint .

800/sooi asw o -i

- vv j stLseetso s xv dvz-z i OLOS/s3/e olaterrogator y No , 11 : Provid e aful l descriptio n o f

th e investigatio n performe db y Complainan t t o determin e tha

t Sceni c Aviatio n operate daircraf t N3221 M i n a

n unairworth y condition . Interrogator y No . 12 ; Provid e afiill descriptio n o f th e investigatio n performe dby Complainan t to determin e that

Sceni c Aviatio n operaitedaircraf t N588S A i n an unairworth y condition . interrogator y No . 13 : Provid e alul l descriptio n o f th e investigatio n performe db y Complainan t t o determin e tha

t Sceni c Aviatio n operate daircraftN6l7M M i n a n unairworth y condition . interrogator y No

- 14 : Stat e i n detail , th e specifi c procedur e require dt o b e performe din orde r to rende r eac h o f th e abov e aircraf

t airworth y under

th e circumstances . Interrogator y No . 15 : Provid e aful l descriptio n o f

th e investigatio n performe db y Complainan t t o determin e that

th e altinieier(s)/encodcr(s ) o f th e abov e aircraf

t experience ddat acorrespondenc e error(s ) a s allege din th e Complaint . Interrogator y No . 16 : Stal e wit h speeiticity , th e lega

l (i.e. , cas e law ) an dfactual basi s upo n whic h th e Ctjmplainant

relie s t o prov e tha

t Responden t

operate daircraf

t N3221 M i n an unairworth y conditio n i n violatio n o f 1 4 CF.R . § 135,25(a)(2) . Interrogator y No . 17 : State with specificity , th e legal (i.e. , cas e law ) an dfactua l basi s upo n whic h th e Complainan t

relie s l o prov e that

Responden t

operate daircraf

t N588S A i n a

n unairworth y conditio n i n violatio n o f 1 4 CF.R . § 135.25(a)(2) . Interrogator y No . 18 : State wit h specificity , th e lega

l (i.e. , cas e law ) an dfactua l basi s upo n whic h th e Complainan t

relie s l o prov e tlia

t Responden t

operate daircraf

t N617M M in a

n unairworth y conditio n in violatio n o f 1 4 C-F.R . § 135.25(a)(2) . Interrogator y No . 19 : Describe , wit h specificity , whethe r

aircraf t N3221 M me t

it s typ e certilicai e desig n durin g th e flight s allege di n th e Complaint .

900/GOOi asu a< • vv i stLseetso s XV dt?2:e LOLOS/SS/e OInterrogator y No , 20 : Describe , wit h specilicity , whether

aircraf t N588S A met

it s typ e certificate desig n durin g th e flight s allege di n th e Complaint . Interrogator y No . 21 : Describe , wit h .specificity , whether

aircraf t N617M M me t

it s typ e certificate desig n durin g th e flights allege di n tli c Complaint . Interrogator y No . 22 : TfComplainant allege s that

an y o f th e abov e aircraf

t faile dt o mee t

it s typ e cerlilicaU ; desig n durin g th e llighl s i n question , describ e i n detai l why eac h aircraf t di dnot . Interrogator y JSo , 23 : Describ e i n detail , whether eac h o f th e abov e aircraf

t wa s i n aconditio n tha t wa s saf e fo r lligh t durin g th e llighl s allege din the Complaint . Interrogator y No . 24 : I

f C^omplainan

t allege s that

th e abov e aircraf

t wer e not i n aconditio n thai wa s saf e for flight durin g th e flights allege din th e Complaint , describ e in detai l wh y eac h wa s not . REQUES T FO RPRODCUTIO N Reques t fo r Productio n o

f Document s No . 1 : Produc e copie s o f al l document s an dothe r material s tha

t th e Complainan t

intend s l o introduc e int o evidence . Reques t fo r Productio n o f

Document s No , 2 ; Produc e copie s o f an y statement s mad e b y wiinesscs . includin g expert witnesses , identilie di n Interrogator y No . 1 , concerning , referrin g to , or involvin g th e circumstance s set fonh i n th e Complaint , Reques t fo r Productio n o f

Document s No . 3 : Produc e copie s o f an y an dall document s an dothe r material s i

n th e possessio n o f

th e Complainan t

that concern , refer

to , o r involv e th e circumstance s se t fort h i n th e Complaint . Reques t fo r Productio n o f

Document s No . 4 : Produc e copie s o f curren t curricul avita e fo

r eac h expert witnes s th e Complainan t

identifie di

n Interrogator

y No . 1 ,

300/l700i a SW Q < • VV d St7LSS6tS0 S XV d t?2:e L OL02/3S/B OReques t fo r Productio n o f

Document s No . 5 : Provid e acop y o f all articles , treatises , moriograptts , or

othe r source s tha

t the Complainan t

ma y us e o r introduc e int o evidenc e a t th e hearing . Reques t fo r Productio n o f

Document s No . 6 : Provid e acop y o f al l handbooks , manuals , maintenanc e records , schematics , and/o r other source s tha

t th e Complainan t

ma y us e o r introduc e int o evidenc e a

t th e hearin g o r

otlierwi.s e rci y upo n t o detemiin e tha t th e altimeter(s)/encoder(s ) reference di

n th e Complain t

ha dexperience ddatacorrespondenc e error(s) . Reques t fo r Productio n o

f Document s No . 7 : Provid e acop y o f th e typ e certificate dat afo r eac h aircraf t identifie di

n the Complaint . Dated : Marc h 1,201 0 Respectfully/Suibmitted , QR^GOR-p^ . WI

N ION , ESQ . Ai^iation Law Experts , LL C -^3 0 Aviatio n Wa

y Frederick , M D 2170 1 Tel : (301 ) 294-855 0 Fax:(301)294-252 5 Grea(a!AviationLawLxperts.co m Counsel fo

r Responden t

900/500 0 SH O -i - VV d StLSCetSO S XV d t2:e L OLOg/SS/G OCF.RTTFTCAT FOFSERVIC E 1 hereb y certif

y tha t I hav e thi s date serve dby regula r U.S . mail , postag e prepaid , a n origina l an d on e (1 ) cop y o f

th e foregoin g discover

y request s addresse dto : Attention : Hearin g Docke t Clerk , AGC-43 0 Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S.W . Suite 2 W l 00 0 Washington , D. C 2059 1 And . further , tha

t I hav e thi s date serve dvi aregula r U.S . mail , postag e prepaid , acop y o f th e foregoin g discovery request s addresse dto :

Scot t R . Morris , Esq . Offic e o f Regiona l Counsel , ANM- 7 F A A Northwes t

Moimlai n Regio n 160 1 Lin dAvenue , S W Renton , W

A 9805 7 Tel : 42 5 227-141 7 Fax:42 5 227-100 7 Dated : Marc h 1,201 0 GREOORftTS . WINTON , ESQ . AviaiKi n La w Experts , U>

C 33p<Aviation Wa

y ly^derick , M

D 2170 1 [el : (301 ) 294-855 0 Fax : (301 ) 294-252 5

800/300i a SW Q VV d St?LSS6t20 2 XV dt?2:S L OLOS/SS/C O