1 

### K e ll y

, Thom asP

F r om: K e ll y

, T ho m a sP

S e nt: W edne s da y

, S epte m be r 07, 2016 2:13 PM

T o: 'Rong s heng Luo'

S ub jec t: T han k s

- R E : Inte r agen c y Con s u l tat i on r e. Updated Coa c he ll a & W MD O z one Con f o r m i t y

B udgets

F r o m: R o ng s h e ng L u o [ m ai l t o : L UO @ sca g. ca .g

ov ]

S en t: W e dn e s d a y

, S e p t e m b e r 0 7

, 2 0 16 2 :1 1 PM

T o: K e ll y

, T h o m as

P < K e ll y

. T h om a s

P @ e p a .g o v>

S ub j e c t: F W : In te ra g

e n c y C o n s u l t a t i o n r e

. U pd a te d C

o ac h e lla & W M D O z o n e C

o n f o r m i t y B udg et s

H i T o m

,

I t ’s n ic e t alki ng w i t h y o u. B e l o w is t h e e m ail t h a t I r

e f e rr e d t o

. I f y o u h a v e a n y q u e s

t i o n s

, p l e a s e l e t m e k n o

w

. T h a n ks

.



### Rongsheng

R o ng sh e n g L u o

Pr og r a m M

a n ag e r of

A i r Q u a l i ty a nd Co n fo r m i t y

S OUT H E R N C

A LI F OR N I A A SS

O C I A T I O N O F G O V E R N ME N T S

818 W e s t 7 t h S t ree t

, 12 t h Fl oor

, L o s A nge l e s

, C A 9001 7

T : (213) 236-1994 | F : (213) 236

- 1963

E: l uo @ s c ag

. c a

. gov

S t a y C o n n e c t ed

F r o m: R o ng s h e ng L u o

S en t: M o nd a y

, Augu s

t 1 8

, 2 0 14 8 : 4 5 A M

T o: M a n a S

a ng ka p ic h ai < s a ng ka p i @ sca g. ca .g

ov >

C c: G u o x i o ng Hu a ng

< H U A N G @ sca g. ca .g

ov > ; J o n a t h a n N a d l e r

< n a d l e r @ s c a g. ca .g ov > ; H si- H w

a Hu < H U @ sc a g. ca .g ov > ;

R o ng s h e ng L u o < L UO @ sc a g. ca .g ov >

Sub j e c t: RE : U pd a te d C

o ac h e lla & W M D C

o n f o r m i ty B udg

et s

T h e s e p r o p o s e d fi n al bud g

et s l o o k r e a s o n a b l e

. T h e “ A RB a d

j u s t m e n t s ” a r e p r et ty s m all e s p e cial l y f o r N O x i n 2 0 14

- 2 0 1 8

a nd ar e lik e l y t o b e e v e n s m all e r i n t h e f u t u r e ye ars

, s o i t s h o u l d b e n o i ss

u e t o b e o p t i o n al i n f

u t u r e y e ars

.

T h a n ks t o y o u al l f o r t aki n g car e o f t h e s e budg et s w h i l e I w a s a w a y ! V e r y m u c h a pp r e cia te d !



### Rongsheng

x 994

F r o m: M a n a S a n g k a p i ch a i

S e n t: F rid a y

, A u g u s t 1 5

, 2 01 4 4 : 3 4 P M

T o: J o n at h a n N a dl e r ; R o n g s h e n g Lu o

C c: Gu o xio n g H u a n g ; Hs i

- H wa H u

S u b j e c t: RE : U pd ate d Co a ch e ll a & W M D C o nf or m i t y B u dg et s

A ll,2 Ju s t t alk e d t o Cari ( A R B) a nd g

o t c o n fi r m a t i o n

t h a t t h e fi n al budg

et s, w h ic h i n cl u d e t h e s

af e t y m ar g i n

, e x te n d o u t t

o al l

f u t u r e m i l e s t o n e ye a r s

. H o we v e r t h e “o f f m o d e l r e d u c t i o n s ” ( “ A R B a d j u s t m e n t s ” i n t h e a t t ac h e d t a b l e ) i s o p t i o n al f

o r

t h e f u t u r e ye a r s

. An o t h e r w

o r d

, i f w e c o u l d p ass t h e budg et te s t w i t h o u t i t

, j u s

t l e a v e i t o u t

. A tt

a c h e d t a b l e r e fl e c t s t h e

c o n fi r m a t i o n. S

o we ar e o k w i t h a b i t m o r

e b r e a t h i ng r o o m f o r b o t h a r

e as

. P l e a s e l e t m e k n o

w if y o u h a v e a n y

qu e s t i o n s

.

T h a n k y o u

,

*** * ** * ** * ** * ** * * * *

M a n a S a ng ka p ic h ai

M o d e li ng & F o r

e c a s t i ng

x 8 94

F r o m: M a n a S a n g k a p i ch a i

S e n t: T hu rsd a y

, A u g u s t 1 4

, 2 0 14 6 : 53 P M

T o: J o n at h a n N a dl e r

C c: M a n a S a n g k a p i ch a i ; R o n gs h e n g L u o ; G u oxi o n g H u a n g ; Hs i -H wa H u

S u b j e c t: Re : U pd ate d Co a ch e ll a & W M D C o nf or m i t y B u dg et s

J o n a t h a n

, I w ill c o n fi r m w i t h Cari o n t h e e x

te n s i o n o f b o t h A RB a d

j u s t m e n t a nd saf

e t y m a r g i n f o r f u t u r e m i l e s t o n e y e ars

.

T h a n k y o u.

S e n t fr o m t h e MP h o n e

P l e a s e e xc u s e a n y t y p o

O n Aug 1 4

, 2 0 1 4

, a t 6 : 37 P M

, " J

o n a t h a n N a d l e r " < n a d l e r @ sca g. ca .g

ov > w r o t e:

T h a n ks f o r qu ick r e s p o n s e

, M a n a

. I b e l i e

v e t h e fi n al b udg

et s – w h ic h i n cl ud e t h e saf

et y m ar g i n

- e x te nd

o u t t o al l f u t u r e m il e s t o n e ye ars.

F r o m: M a n a S a n g k a p i ch a i

S e n t: T hu rsd a y

, A u g u s t 1 4

, 2 0 14 5 : 32 P M

T o: J o n at h a n N a dl e r ; R o n g s h e n g Lu o

C c: Gu o xio n g H u a n g ; Hs i

- H wa H u

S u b j e c t: RE : U pd ate d Co a ch e ll a & W M D C o nf or m i t y B u dg ets

J o n a t h a n,

T h e s e saf e t y m ar g i n s o b v i o u sl y g i v

e u s m o r e r o o m i n b o t h ar

e a s f o r t h e t h r e e ye ars

. H o w e v e r we ar e

s t ill n e r v o u s l y t i gh t f o r R O G i n 2 0 2 0

, 2 0 30 a nd 2 0 3 5

, e s p e ciall y C o ac h e lla Val l ey (s

ee r o w 4 8 a nd 49

, i n

a tt ac h e d “ Su m m a r

y

_ w S af e ty M ar g i n ” w o r ks h e e t )

.

T h a n k y o u,

*** * ** * ** * ** * ** * * **

M a n a S a ng ka p ic h ai

M o d e li ng & F o r

e c a s t i ng

x 8 94

F r o m: J o n at h a n N a dl e r

S e n t: T hu rsd a y

, A u g u s t 1 4

, 2 0 14 5 : 23 P M

T o: M a n a S a n g k a p i ch a i3

C c: Gu o xio n g H u a n g

S u b j e c t: RE : U pd ate d Co a ch e ll a & W M D C o nf or m i t y B u dg ets

T h a n ks

. T h ey a r e p o s t i ng o n M o nd a y

, s o a n y c o n c e r n s I w o u l d n ee d t

o k n o w t om o rr o w ( I p la n t o call

Cari b ack t

om o rr o w )

. I ’l l b e o u t o f

t h e o ffi c e bu t a v ai l a b l e b y c

e ll ph o n e o r e m ai l

.

F r o m: M a n a S a n g k a p i ch a i

S e n t: T hu rsd a y

, A u g u s t 1 4

, 2 0 14 3 : 49 P M

T o: J o n at h a n N a dl e r

C c: Gu o xio n g H u a n g

S u b j e c t: RE : U pd ate d Co a ch e ll a & W M D C o nf or m i t y B u dg ets

Will d o

.

*** * ** * ** * ** * ** * * **

M a n a S a ng ka p ic h ai

M o d e li ng & F o r

e c a s t i ng

x 8 94

F r o m: J o n at h a n N a dl e r

S e n t: T hu rsd a y

, A u g u s t 1 4

, 2 0 14 3 : 20 P M

T o: M a n a S a n g k a p i ch a i

C c: Gu o xio n g H u a n g

S u b j e c t: F W : U pd ate d Co a ch e ll a & W M D C o nf or m i t y B u dg ets

M a n a,

P l e a s e r e v i e w

. T h a n ks

.

J o n a t h an

F r o m: A n d e r

s o n , C a r i @ A R B [ ma il t

o : C a ri. A n d e rs

o n @ a rb. c

a .g ov ]

S e n t: T hu rsd a y

, A u g u s t 1 4

, 2 0 14 3 : 13 P M

T o: J o n at h a n N a dl e r

S u b j e c t: F W : U pd ate d Co a ch e ll a & W M D C o nf or m i t y B u dg ets

H i J o n a t h a n. I j u s

t r e c ’ d a b o un c

e b a c k f r o m R o ng s h e ng a nd l e f

t y o u a v o ic e m ail t o d i s c u ss

. Car i

F r o m: A n d e r

s o n , C a r i @ A R B

S e n t: T hu rsd a y

, A u g u s t 1 4

, 2 0 14 3 : 09 P M

T o: R o n g s h e n g L u o

C c: K a l a n d i yu r, N e s

ama n i @ A R B ; T a y lo r

, J o n at h a n @ A R B

S u b j e c t: U pd ate d Co a c h e l l a & WM D C o nf o r m i t y B u d g ets

H e ll o R o ng s h e ng. W e we r e a b l e t o i n c o r p o ra t e a sa f e ty m ar g i n i n b o t h s

e t s o f c o n f o r m i ty budg

e t s f o r

t h e C o ac h e lla a nd W

e s te r n M o h av

e O z o n e SI P upd a t

e s ; s e e a t t ac h e d e x c e r p t

. N o t e t h a t t h is i t

e m h as

n o t b e e n r

e l e as e d f o r pub l i c r

e v i e w a t t h is t i m e a nd t h e c

om p l ete upd a t

e / s t af f r e p o r t i s sc

h e du l e d t o

b e p o s t e d o n M o nd a y

, Augu s

t 1 8

. P l e a s e c o n t a c t m e i f y o u h a v e qu e s t i o n s o r c om m e n t s

. T h a n ks

.

Cari And e rs

o n

Calif o r n ia A ir R

e s o u rc e s B o ar d

A ir Q u ali ty P la nn i ng

& S ci e n c e D i v is i o n

9 1 6

. 3 22

. 60 074