Appendix A-1: Control, Testing and Monitoring Costs for Option 1 at Existing Area Source Boilers

 SIC Code 

 Number of 

Affected 

Boilers in 

SIC Code 

 Total Annualized 

Cost Total Capital Costs 

 Number of 

Affected 

Facilities in 

SIC Code Fuel Savings ($/yr)

 Total Annualized 

Cost Considering 

Fuel Savings 

01 - - - - - -

02 656 139,348,688 461,401,410 328 8,389,091 130,959,597

07 - - - - - -

09 - - - - - -

14 165 28,150,560 81,394,705 83 290,893 27,859,667

16 - - - - - -

17 603 121,049,685 388,995,645 302 6,090,885 114,958,800

20 13,477 2,774,980,378 8,083,031,411 6,739 88,953,199 2,686,027,179

23 165 28,150,560 81,394,705 83 290,893 27,859,667

24 7,663 1,502,588,334 4,178,261,593 3,832 298,210 1,502,290,124

26 - - - - - -

40 658 112,602,234 325,578,819 329 1,147,764 111,454,470

41 - - - - - -

42 165 28,150,560 81,394,705 83 290,893 27,859,667

43 - - - - - -

44 - - - - - -

45 54 18,299,003 72,405,765 27 2,595,326 15,703,677

47 - - - - - -

48 1,481 253,355,028 732,552,343 741 2,582,195 250,772,833

50 548 112,649,786 355,020,114 275 3,172,886 109,476,900

51 951 218,365,056 740,516,234 476 12,504,495 205,860,561

52 - - - - - -

53 1,149 223,800,362 705,585,523 575 9,257,544 214,542,818

54 - - - - - -

55 1,601 280,813,365 838,918,362 801 3,501,778 277,311,587

56 - - - - - -

57 - - - - - -

58 1,809 309,656,145 895,341,751 905 3,159,755 306,496,390

59 576 104,638,050 268,813,081 288 - 104,638,050

60 658 112,602,234 325,578,819 329 1,147,764 111,454,470

64 54 18,299,003 72,405,765 27 2,595,326 15,703,677

65 5,953 1,029,203,622 3,051,399,669 2,977 13,261,865 1,015,941,757

70 9,947 1,735,966,337 5,044,133,840 4,974 23,614,338 1,712,351,999

72 4,547 823,409,540 2,478,291,149 2,274 20,233,410 803,176,130

73 329 56,301,118 162,789,409 165 577,560 55,723,558

75 3,212 566,979,947 1,704,104,188 1,606 7,295,558 559,684,389

76 - - - - - -

79 2,301 394,107,817 1,139,525,866 1,151 4,016,528 390,091,289

80 34,412 6,505,971,207 20,193,186,344 17,206 227,695,354 6,278,275,853

81 - - - - - -

82 68,103 11,989,863,984 34,940,928,242 34,052 178,944,394 11,810,919,590

83 - - - - - -

84 329 56,301,118 162,789,409 165 577,560 55,723,558

86 6,713 1,164,507,715 3,352,822,920 3,357 13,222,160 1,151,285,555

87 1,331 230,557,692 677,425,103 666 2,611,551 227,946,141

91 to 98 11,590 2,158,152,093 6,647,198,815 5,796 61,913,862 2,096,238,231

Unknown 1,477 306,847,932 1,004,197,524 739 17,377,776 289,470,156

TOTAL 182,677 33,405,669,153 99,247,383,228 91,351 717,610,814 32,688,058,339 
Appendix A-2: Control, Testing and Monitoring Costs for Option 2a at Existing Area Source Boilers

SIC

Number of 

Affected 

Boilers in SIC 

Code

Control, Testing and 

Monitoring: Total 

Annualized Cost Total Capital Costs

Number of 

Affected 

Facilities in 

SIC Code Fuel Savings ($/yr) Energy Audit - TAC

 Total TAC considering Fuel 

Savings 

 01 - - - - - - -

 02 656 45,994,814 205,067,971 328 8,389,091 280,112 37,885,835

 07 - - - - - - -

 09 - - - - - - -

 14 165 259,982 1,065,060 83 290,893 70,882 39,971

 16 - - - - - - -

 17 603 30,923,192 137,777,040 302 6,090,885 257,908 25,090,215

 20 13,477 781,144,439 2,317,874,407 6,739 88,953,199 5,755,106 697,946,346

 23 165 259,982 1,065,060 83 290,893 70,882 39,971

 24 7,663 1,599,857,233 1,712,207,943 3,832 298,210 70,094,944 1,669,653,967

 26 - - - - - - -

 40 658 1,039,929 4,260,234 329 1,147,764 280,966 173,131

 41 - - - - - - -

 42 165 259,982 1,065,060 83 290,893 70,882 39,971

 43 - - - - - - -

 44 - - - - - - -

 45 54 15,071,622 67,290,932 27 2,595,326 23,058 12,499,354

 47 - - - - - - -

 48 1,481 2,339,844 9,585,526 741 2,582,195 632,814 390,463

 50 548 129,262,800 189,245,988 275 3,172,886 234,850 126,324,764

 51 951 194,838,514 481,905,622 476 12,504,495 406,504 182,740,523

 52 - - - - - - -

 53 1,149 46,774,760 208,263,145 575 9,257,544 491,050 38,008,266

 54 - - - - - - -

 55 1,601 2,528,235 10,357,302 801 3,501,778 684,054 (289,489)

 56 - - - - - - -

 57 - - - - - - -

 58 1,809 2,859,807 11,715,643 905 3,159,755 772,870 472,922

 59 576 911,142 3,732,637 288 - 245,952 1,157,094

 60 658 1,039,929 4,260,234 329 1,147,764 280,966 173,131

 64 54 15,071,622 67,290,932 27 2,595,326 23,058 12,499,354

 65 5,953 49,716,884 234,747,214 2,977 13,261,865 2,542,358 38,997,377

 70 9,947 60,685,023 265,248,703 4,974 23,614,338 4,247,796 41,318,481

 72 4,547 82,117,652 364,146,176 2,274 20,233,410 1,941,996 63,826,238

 73 329 519,966 2,130,116 165 577,560 140,910 83,316

 75 3,212 5,079,827 20,810,303 1,606 7,295,558 1,371,524 (844,207)

 76 - - - - - - -

 79 2,301 3,639,753 14,910,818 1,151 4,016,528 982,954 606,179

 80 34,412 1,098,772,881 4,904,063,455 17,206 227,695,354 14,693,924 885,771,451

 81 - - - - - - -

 82 68,103 507,640,539 2,243,847,228 34,052 178,944,394 29,080,408 357,776,553

 83 - - - - - - -

 84 329 519,966 2,130,116 165 577,560 140,910 83,316

 86 6,713 25,602,113 110,430,730 3,357 13,222,160 2,866,878 15,246,831

 87 1,331 2,103,220 8,616,166 666 2,611,551 568,764 60,433

 91 to 98 11,590 525,224,779 1,579,808,577 5,796 61,913,862 4,949,784 468,260,701

 Unknown 1,477 92,249,607 411,200,999 739 17,377,776 631,106 75,502,937

 TOTAL 182,677 5,324,310,038 15,596,121,337 91,351 717,610,814 144,836,170 4,751,535,394 
Appendix A-3: Control, Testing and Monitoring Costs for Option 1 at New Area Source Boilers

Model Unit Sector

Number of 

Boilers 

Represented 

by Model

Design 

Capacity 

(mmBtu/hr)

Size 

Category

Fuel 

Category Baseline Control

TCI - Control Only 

($)

TAC - Control 

Only ($/yr) TCI - T&M ($) TAC - T&M ($/yr) TOTAL - TCI ($)

TOTAL - TAC 

($/yr)

Fuel Savings 

($/yr)

Total TAC 

Considering Fuel 

Savings ($/yr)

New Biomass Unit 1 Commercial 70 7.445966406 <= 10 Biomass Cyclone or Multiclone 62,678,412 21,519,070 3,452,279 1,902,618 66,130,690 23,421,688 - 23,421,688

New Biomass Unit 2 Industrial 70 7.445966406 <= 10 Biomass Cyclone or Multiclone 62,678,412 21,519,070 3,452,279 1,902,618 66,130,690 23,421,688 - 23,421,688

New Biomass Unit 4 Commercial 11 21.0354469 > 10 Biomass Cyclone or Multiclone 13,820,320 4,245,439 542,501 298,983 14,362,821 4,544,422 - 4,544,422

New Biomass Unit 3 Industrial 49 131 > 10 Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator 204,695,425 49,869,116 9,951,472 3,502,680 214,646,897 53,371,796 - 53,371,796

New Coal Unit 1 Commercial 62 6.681769841 <= 10 Coal Cyclone or Multiclone 56,902,514 19,335,496 2,992,125 1,666,723 59,894,639 21,002,219 - 21,002,219

New Coal Unit 2 Industrial 93 6.681769841 <= 10 Coal Cyclone or Multiclone 85,353,771 29,003,244 4,488,187 2,500,084 89,841,958 31,503,328 - 31,503,328

New Distillate Unit 1 Commercial 5435 6.760864885 <= 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 4,487,170,613 1,586,767,257 260,435,781 140,115,693 4,747,606,394 1,726,882,950 62,946,617 1,663,936,333

New Distillate Unit 2 Industrial 407 6.760864885 <= 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 336,021,792 118,825,073 19,502,735 10,492,564 355,524,527 129,317,638 4,832,845 124,484,792

New Distillate Unit 3 Commercial 352 25.31228613 > 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 414,237,612 129,395,183 16,867,230 9,074,650 431,104,842 138,469,833 15,263,166 123,206,668

New Distillate Unit 4 Industrial 90 25.31228613 > 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 105,913,026 33,083,996 4,312,644 2,320,223 110,225,670 35,404,219 4,001,106 31,403,112

New Residual Unit 1 Commercial 95 5.949970486 <= 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 76,866,912 27,412,087 4,552,235 2,449,124 81,419,147 29,861,211 553,816 29,307,396

New Residual Unit 2 Commercial 45 17.56020833 > 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 46,202,385 15,106,429 2,156,322 1,160,112 48,358,707 16,266,540 774,228 15,492,312

Total 6779 TOTALS: 5,952,541,194 2,056,081,461 332,705,789 177,386,071 6,285,246,983 2,233,467,532 88,371,779 2,145,095,753
Appendix A-4: Control, Testing and Monitoring Costs for Option 2a at New Area Source Boilers through 2013

Model Unit Sector

Number of 

Boilers 

Represented 

by Model

Design 

Capacity 

(mmBtu/hr)

Size 

Category

Fuel 

Category Baseline Control

TCI - Control 

Only ($)

TAC - Control 

Only ($/yr) TCI - T&M ($)

TAC - T&M 

($/yr)

Number of 

Facilities

Energy Audit 

Costs ($/yr) TOTAL - TCI ($)

TOTAL - TAC 

($/yr)

Fuel Savings 

($/yr)

Total TAC Considering 

Fuel Savings ($/yr)

New Biomass Unit 1 Commercial 70 7.44596641 <= 10 Biomass Cyclone or Multiclone 453,377 110,600 - - 35 29,890 453,377 140,490 - 140,490

New Biomass Unit 2 Industrial 70 7.44596641 <= 10 Biomass Cyclone or Multiclone 453,377 110,600 - - 35 640,220 453,377 750,820 - 750,820

New Biomass Unit 4 Commercial 11 21.0354469 > 10 Biomass Cyclone or Multiclone 13,820,320 4,245,439 542,501 298,983 6 5,124 14,362,821 4,549,546 - 4,549,546

New Biomass Unit 3 Industrial 49 131 > 10 Biomass Electrostatic Precipitator 204,695,425 49,869,116 9,951,472 3,502,680 25 457,300 214,646,897 53,829,096 - 53,829,096

New Coal Unit 1 Commercial 62 6.68176984 <= 10 Coal Cyclone or Multiclone - - - - 31 26,474 - 26,474 - 26,474

New Coal Unit 2 Industrial 93 6.68176984 <= 10 Coal Cyclone or Multiclone - - - - 47 859,724 - 859,724 - 859,724

New Distillate Unit 1 Commercial 5435 6.76086488 <= 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 35,201,475 8,587,300 - - 2,718 2,321,172 35,201,475 10,908,472 62,946,617 (52,038,145)

New Distillate Unit 2 Industrial 407 6.76086488 <= 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 2,636,063 643,060 - - 204 3,731,568 2,636,063 4,374,628 4,832,845 (458,217)

New Distillate Unit 3 Commercial 352 25.3122861 > 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 414,237,612 129,395,183 16,867,230 9,074,650 176 150,304 431,104,842 138,620,137 15,263,166 123,356,972

New Distillate Unit 4 Industrial 90 25.3122861 > 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 105,913,026 33,083,996 4,312,644 2,320,223 45 823,140 110,225,670 36,227,359 4,001,106 32,226,252

New Residual Unit 1 Commercial 95 5.94997049 <= 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 615,297 150,100 - - 48 40,992 615,297 191,092 553,816 (362,724)

New Residual Unit 2 Commercial 45 17.5602083 > 10 Liquid No HAP APCD Control 46,202,385 15,106,429 2,156,322 1,160,112 23 19,642 48,358,707 16,286,182 774,228 15,511,954

TOTALS 6779 TOTALS 824,228,357 241,301,823 33,830,169 16,356,647 3,393 858,058,526 858,058,526 266,764,021 88,371,779 178,392,242
Appendix B-1: Emission Reductions from Existing Area Source Boilers

SUMMARY - Baseline Emissions by Fuel Type SUMMARY - Option 1 Emission REDUCTIONS SUMMARY - Option 2a Emission REDUCTIONS

Existing Boilers at Area Sources Existing Boilers at Area Sources Existing Boilers at Area Sources

Fuel Category Pollutant

Baseline 

Emissions 

(tpy) Fuel Category Pollutant

Emission 

Reductions 

(tpy) Fuel Category Pollutant

Emission 

Reductions 

(tpy)

Biomass Hg 5.16E-01 Biomass Hg 1.81E-01 Biomass Hg 1.38E-01

10,958 boilers PM-filterable 112,387 10,958 boilers PM-filterable 59,296 10,958 boilers PM-filterable 41,112

PM 2.5 34,284 PM 2.5 20,561 PM 2.5 6,741

HCl 3,168 HCl 32 HCl 32

Total Hydrocarbons 2,659 Total Hydrocarbons 27 Total Hydrocarbons 27

VOC 1,526 VOC 15 VOC 15

CO 145,697 CO 45,780 CO 35,074

Dioxins/Furans 3.54E-04 Dioxins/Furans 3.54E-06 Dioxins/Furans 3.54E-06

HF 87 HF 1 HF 1

SO2 25,625 SO2 256 SO2 256

Non-Hg Metals 1,430 Non-Hg Metals 754 Non-Hg Metals 523

Coal Hg 3 Coal Hg 1 Coal Hg 8.77E-01

3,710 boilers PM-filterable 22,701 3,710 boilers PM-filterable 15,590 3,710 boilers PM-filterable 7,161

PM 2.5 4,451 PM 2.5 2,626 PM 2.5 1,917

HCl 10,086 HCl 101 HCl 101

Total Hydrocarbons 369 Total Hydrocarbons 4 Total Hydrocarbons 4

VOC 212 VOC 2 VOC 2

CO 15,347 CO 109 CO 153

Dioxins/Furans 3.77E-05 Dioxins/Furans 3.77E-07 Dioxins/Furans 3.77E-07

HF 274 HF 3 HF 3

SO2 77,970 SO2 780 SO2 780

Non-Hg Metals 111 Non-Hg Metals 76 Non-Hg Metals 35

Liquid Hg 18 Liquid Hg 1 Liquid Hg 7.14E-01

168,003 boilers PM-filterable 44,576 168,003 boilers PM-filterable 20,171 168,003 boilers PM-filterable 11,920

PM 2.5 6,552 PM 2.5 3,331 PM 2.5 1,536

HCl 28,412 HCl 284 HCl 284

Total Hydrocarbons 4,905 Total Hydrocarbons 49 Total Hydrocarbons 49

VOC 2,815 VOC 28 VOC 28

CO 38,533 CO 30,449 CO 16,939

Dioxins/Furans 4.76E-04 Dioxins/Furans 4.76E-06 Dioxins/Furans 4.76E-06

HF 519 HF 5 HF 5

SO2 146,772 SO2 1,468 SO2 1,468

Non-Hg Metals 35,872 Non-Hg Metals 15,657 Non-Hg Metals 9,932

TOTAL Hg 21 TOTAL Hg 3 TOTAL Hg 2

182,671 boilers PM-filterable 179,664 182,671 boilers PM-filterable 95,056 182,671 boilers PM-filterable 60,193

PM 2.5 45,287 PM 2.5 26,518 PM 2.5 10,194

HCl 41,666 HCl 417 HCl 417

Total Hydrocarbons 7,933 Total Hydrocarbons 79 Total Hydrocarbons 79

VOC 4,553 VOC 46 VOC 46

CO 199,578 CO 76,339 CO 52,167

Dioxins/Furans 8.67E-04 Dioxins/Furans 8.67E-06 Dioxins/Furans 8.67E-06

HF 880 HF 9 HF 9

SO2 250,368 SO2 2,504 SO2 2,504

Non-Hg Metals 37,413 Non-Hg Metals 16,488 Non-Hg Metals 10,491

[Proposed Option]
Appendix B-2: Emission Reductions from New Area Source Boilers

SUMMARY - Baseline Emissions by Fuel Type SUMMARY - Option 1 Emission REDUCTIONS SUMMARY - Option 2a Emission REDUCTIONS

Fuel 

Category Pollutant

Baseline 

Emissions 

(tpy)

Fuel 

Category Pollutant

Emission 

Reductions 

(tpy)

Fuel 

Category Pollutant

Emission 

Reductions 

(tpy)

Biomass Hg 3.85E-02 Biomass Hg 1.37E-02 Biomass Hg 1.19E-02

200 boilers PM-filterable 4,084 200 boilers PM-filterable 1,904 200 boilers PM-filterable 1,269

PM 2.5 3,104 PM 2.5 1,447 PM 2.5 964

HCl 236 HCl 2 HCl 2

Total Hydrocarbons 198 Total Hydrocarbons 2 Total Hydrocarbons 2

VOC 114 VOC 1 VOC 1

CO 1.09E+04 CO 5.28E+03 CO 4.58E+03

Dioxins/Furans 0 Dioxins/Furans 0 Dioxins/Furans 0

HF 7 HF 0 HF 0

SO2 1,912 SO2 19 SO2 19

Non-Hg Metals 26 Non-Hg Metals 13 Non-Hg Metals 4

Coal Hg 1.29E-01 Coal Hg 6.68E-02 Coal Hg 1.38E-08

155 boilers PM-filterable 1,101 155 boilers PM-filterable 546 155 boilers PM-filterable 11

PM 2.5 837 PM 2.5 415 PM 2.5 8

HCl 489 HCl 5 HCl 5

Total Hydrocarbons 18 Total Hydrocarbons 0 Total Hydrocarbons 0

VOC 10 VOC 0 VOC 0

CO 744 CO 5 CO 7

Dioxins/Furans 0 Dioxins/Furans 0 Dioxins/Furans 0

HF 13 HF 0 HF 0

SO2 3,781 SO2 38 SO2 38

Non-Hg Metals 5 Non-Hg Metals 3 Non-Hg Metals 0

Liquid Hg 2.01E+00 Liquid Hg 9.82E-01 Liquid Hg 2.21E-01

6,424 boilers PM-filterable 5,102 6,424 boilers PM-filterable 2,550 6,424 boilers PM-filterable 535

PM 2.5 3,878 PM 2.5 1,938 PM 2.5 407

HCl 3,209 HCl 32 HCl 32

Total Hydrocarbons 552 Total Hydrocarbons 6 Total Hydrocarbons 6

VOC 317 VOC 3 VOC 3

CO 4,319 CO 3,566 CO 841

Dioxins/Furans 0 Dioxins/Furans 0 Dioxins/Furans 0

HF 58 HF 1 HF 1

SO2 22,649 SO2 226 SO2 226

Non-Hg Metals 4,022 Non-Hg Metals 1,946 Non-Hg Metals 450

TOTAL Hg 2 TOTAL Hg 1 TOTAL Hg 2.33E-01

6,779 boilers PM-filterable 10,287 6,779 boilers PM-filterable 4,999 6,779 boilers PM-filterable 1,815

PM 2.5 7,818 PM 2.5 3,799 PM 2.5 1,379

HCl 3,935 HCl 39 HCl 39

Total Hydrocarbons 768 Total Hydrocarbons 8 Total Hydrocarbons 8

VOC 441 VOC 4 VOC 4

CO 15,933 CO 8,850 CO 5,427

Dioxins/Furans 0 Dioxins/Furans 0 Dioxins/Furans 0

HF 78 HF 1 HF 1

SO2 28,342 SO2 283 SO2 283

Non-Hg Metals 4,054 Non-Hg Metals 1,962 Non-Hg Metals 455

[Proposed Option]