### RecBenTables_22MAR11.xls

Author: Abt Associates Inc. Created: 3/22/11

Worksheet Description

rec ben tables Tables summarizing recreational fishing benefits by region, species, and regulatory option Purpose: Output summary tables from the program for estimating recreational fishing benefits

File Info 1 of 36Table 1: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline CA

tag Species Name T_1 California halibut California halibut T_1 Flounders Flounders T_1Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_1 Striped bass Striped bass T_1Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_1 Cabezon Cabezon T_1 California scorpionfish California scorpionfish T_1 Croakers Croakers T_1 Rockfish Rockfish T_1 Sculpin Sculpin T_1 Sea bass Sea bass T_1 Smelts Smelts T_1 Sunfish Sunfish T_1 Surfperch Surfperch T_1Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_1Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_1Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 2: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline CA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_2_baselineIblank rowCA blank row . . . T_2_baselineIFlatfishCA Flatfish $1 $1 $2 T_2_baselineISmall GameCA Small Game . . . T_2_baselineIOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $72 $120 $198 T_2_baselineIUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $2 $3 $6 T_2_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $75 $124 $205 T_2_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $67 $110 $182 T_2_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $64 $106 $176 T_2_baselineEblank rowCA blank row . . . T_2_baselineEFlatfishCA Flatfish $197 $376 $718 T_2_baselineESmall GameCA Small Game $5 $9 $15 T_2_baselineEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $1,678 $2,775 $4,587 T_2_baselineEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $5 $8 $13 T_2_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $1,885 $3,168 $5,334 T_2_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,674 $2,812 $4,735 T_2_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,617 $2,717 $4,574 T_2_baselineIEblank rowCA blank row . . . T_2_baselineIEFlatfishCA Flatfish $198 $377 $720 T_2_baselineIESmall GameCA Small Game $5 $9 $15 T_2_baselineIEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $1,751 $2,895 $4,785 T_2_baselineIEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $7 $11 $19 T_2_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $1,960 $3,292 $5,539 T_2_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,740 $2,923 $4,917 T_2_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,681 $2,823 $4,750

Table 3: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 CA

tag Species Name T_3 California halibut California halibut T_3 Flounders Flounders T_3Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_3 Striped bass Striped bass T_3Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game)

rec ben tables 2 of 36T_3 Cabezon Cabezon

T_3 California scorpionfish California scorpionfish T_3 Croakers Croakers T_3 Rockfish Rockfish T_3 Sculpin Sculpin T_3 Sea bass Sea bass T_3 Smelts Smelts T_3 Sunfish Sunfish T_3 Surfperch Surfperch T_3Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_3Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_3Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 4: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 CA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_4_TMN1Iblank rowCA blank row . . . T_4_TMN1IFlatfishCA Flatfish $0 $1 $2 T_4_TMN1ISmall GameCA Small Game . . . T_4_TMN1IOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $63 $105 $173 T_4_TMN1IUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $2 $3 $5 T_4_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $66 $109 $180 T_4_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $51 $85 $141 T_4_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $46 $75 $125 T_4_TMN1Eblank rowCA blank row . . . T_4_TMN1EFlatfishCA Flatfish $0 $0 $0 T_4_TMN1ESmall GameCA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_4_TMN1EOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $0 $0 $0 T_4_TMN1EUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_4_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_4_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_4_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_4_TMN1IEblank rowCA blank row . . . T_4_TMN1IEFlatfishCA Flatfish $0 $1 $2 T_4_TMN1IESmall GameCA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_4_TMN1IEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $63 $105 $173 T_4_TMN1IEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $2 $3 $5 T_4_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $66 $109 $180 T_4_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $51 $85 $141 T_4_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $46 $75 $125

Table 5: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 CA

tag Species Name T_5 California halibut California halibut T_5 Flounders Flounders T_5Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_5 Striped bass Striped bass T_5Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_5 Cabezon Cabezon T_5 California scorpionfish California scorpionfish T_5 Croakers Croakers T_5 Rockfish Rockfish T_5 Sculpin Sculpin T_5 Sea bass Sea bass T_5 Smelts Smelts T_5 Sunfish Sunfish

rec ben tables 3 of 36T_5 Surfperch Surfperch

T_5Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_5Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_5Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 6: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 CA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_6_TMN2Iblank rowCA blank row . . . T_6_TMN2IFlatfishCA Flatfish $1 $1 $2 T_6_TMN2ISmall GameCA Small Game . . . T_6_TMN2IOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $71 $118 $195 T_6_TMN2IUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $2 $3 $6 T_6_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $74 $122 $202 T_6_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $47 $78 $129 T_6_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $36 $60 $99 T_6_TMN2Eblank rowCA blank row . . . T_6_TMN2EFlatfishCA Flatfish $168 $321 $612 T_6_TMN2ESmall GameCA Small Game $4 $7 $13 T_6_TMN2EOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $1,431 $2,365 $3,910 T_6_TMN2EUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $4 $7 $11 T_6_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $1,607 $2,700 $4,546 T_6_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $990 $1,663 $2,800 T_6_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $756 $1,270 $2,138 T_6_TMN2IEblank rowCA blank row . . . T_6_TMN2IEFlatfishCA Flatfish $169 $322 $614 T_6_TMN2IESmall GameCA Small Game $4 $7 $13 T_6_TMN2IEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $1,502 $2,483 $4,104 T_6_TMN2IEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $6 $10 $17 T_6_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $1,681 $2,822 $4,748 T_6_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,037 $1,741 $2,929 T_6_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $792 $1,330 $2,237

Table 7: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 CA

tag Species Name T_7 California halibut California halibut T_7 Flounders Flounders T_7Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_7 Striped bass Striped bass T_7Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_7 Cabezon Cabezon T_7 California scorpionfish California scorpionfish T_7 Croakers Croakers T_7 Rockfish Rockfish T_7 Sculpin Sculpin T_7 Sea bass Sea bass T_7 Smelts Smelts T_7 Sunfish Sunfish T_7 Surfperch Surfperch T_7Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_7Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_7Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 8: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 CA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit

rec ben tables 4 of 36T_8_TMN3Iblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_8_TMN3IFlatfishCA Flatfish $1 $1 $2 T_8_TMN3ISmall GameCA Small Game . . . T_8_TMN3IOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $72 $119 $196 T_8_TMN3IUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $2 $3 $6 T_8_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $74 $123 $204 T_8_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $46 $77 $127 T_8_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $35 $58 $97 T_8_TMN3Eblank rowCA blank row . . . T_8_TMN3EFlatfishCA Flatfish $176 $335 $640 T_8_TMN3ESmall GameCA Small Game $5 $8 $13 T_8_TMN3EOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $1,496 $2,474 $4,090 T_8_TMN3EUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $4 $7 $12 T_8_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $1,681 $2,825 $4,755 T_8_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,049 $1,763 $2,968 T_8_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $796 $1,338 $2,253 T_8_TMN3IEblank rowCA blank row . . . T_8_TMN3IEFlatfishCA Flatfish $176 $336 $642 T_8_TMN3IESmall GameCA Small Game $5 $8 $13 T_8_TMN3IEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $1,568 $2,593 $4,286 T_8_TMN3IEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $6 $10 $17 T_8_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $1,755 $2,948 $4,959 T_8_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,096 $1,840 $3,095 T_8_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $832 $1,396 $2,349

Table 9: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN4 CA

tag Species Name T_9 California halibut California halibut T_9 Flounders Flounders T_9Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_9 Striped bass Striped bass T_9Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_9 Cabezon Cabezon T_9 California scorpionfish California scorpionfish T_9 Croakers Croakers T_9 Rockfish Rockfish T_9 Sculpin Sculpin T_9 Sea bass Sea bass T_9 Smelts Smelts T_9 Sunfish Sunfish T_9 Surfperch Surfperch T_9Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_9Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_9Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 10: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN4 CA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_10_TMN4Iblank rowCA blank row . . . T_10_TMN4IFlatfishCA Flatfish $0 $1 $2 T_10_TMN4ISmall GameCA Small Game . . . T_10_TMN4IOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $61 $102 $168 T_10_TMN4IUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $2 $3 $5 T_10_TMN4ITotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $64 $106 $175 T_10_TMN4ITotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $50 $83 $137 T_10_TMN4ITotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $44 $73 $121

rec ben tables 5 of 36T_10_TMN4Eblank rowCA blank row . . .

T_10_TMN4EFlatfishCA Flatfish $0 $0 $0 T_10_TMN4ESmall GameCA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_10_TMN4EOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $0 $0 $0 T_10_TMN4EUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_10_TMN4ETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_10_TMN4ETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_10_TMN4ETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_10_TMN4IEblank rowCA blank row . . . T_10_TMN4IEFlatfishCA Flatfish $0 $1 $2 T_10_TMN4IESmall GameCA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_10_TMN4IEOther SaltwaterCA Other Saltwater $61 $102 $168 T_10_TMN4IEUnidentifiedCA Unidentified $2 $3 $5 T_10_TMN4IETotal (Undiscounted)CA Total (Undiscounted) $64 $106 $175 T_10_TMN4IETotal (3% Discount Rate)CA Total (3% Discount Rate) $50 $83 $137 T_10_TMN4IETotal (7% Discount Rate)CA Total (7% Discount Rate) $44 $73 $121

Table 12: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline NA

tag Species Name T_12 Winter flounder Winter flounder T_12Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_12 Atlantic mackerel Atlantic mackerel T_12 Bluefish Bluefish T_12 Striped bass Striped bass T_12 Weakfish Weakfish T_12Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_12 Atlantic cod Atlantic cod T_12 Cunner Cunner T_12 Pollock Pollock T_12 Sculpin Sculpin T_12 Scup Scup T_12 Searobin Searobin T_12 Tautog Tautog T_12 White perch White perch T_12Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_12Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_12Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 13: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline NA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_13_baselineIblank rowNA blank row . . . T_13_baselineIFlatfishNA Flatfish $5 $7 $12 T_13_baselineISmall GameNA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_13_baselineIOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $1 $2 $3 T_13_baselineIUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $0 $1 $1 T_13_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $6 $10 $16 T_13_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $6 $9 $15 T_13_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $5 $9 $14 T_13_baselineEblank rowNA blank row . . . T_13_baselineEFlatfishNA Flatfish $1,177 $1,843 $2,914 T_13_baselineESmall GameNA Small Game $2 $6 $16 T_13_baselineEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $798 $1,331 $2,218 T_13_baselineEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $5 $8 $13 T_13_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $1,982 $3,187 $5,160 T_13_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,759 $2,829 $4,581

rec ben tables 6 of 36T_13_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,699 $2,733 $4,426 T_13_baselineIEblank rowNA blank row . . . T_13_baselineIEFlatfishNA Flatfish $1,182 $1,850 $2,925 T_13_baselineIESmall GameNA Small Game $2 $6 $16 T_13_baselineIEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $799 $1,333 $2,222 T_13_baselineIEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $5 $8 $14 T_13_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $1,988 $3,197 $5,177 T_13_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,765 $2,838 $4,596 T_13_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,705 $2,742 $4,440

Table 14: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 NA

tag Species Name T_14 Winter flounder Winter flounder T_14Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_14 Atlantic mackerel Atlantic mackerel T_14 Bluefish Bluefish T_14 Striped bass Striped bass T_14 Weakfish Weakfish T_14Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_14 Atlantic cod Atlantic cod T_14 Cunner Cunner T_14 Pollock Pollock T_14 Sculpin Sculpin T_14 Scup Scup T_14 Searobin Searobin T_14 Tautog Tautog T_14 White perch White perch T_14Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_14Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_14Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 15: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 NA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_15_TMN1Iblank rowNA blank row . . . T_15_TMN1IFlatfishNA Flatfish $3 $5 $8 T_15_TMN1ISmall GameNA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_15_TMN1IOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $1 $1 $2 T_15_TMN1IUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $0 $1 $1 T_15_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $4 $7 $11 T_15_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $3 $5 $9 T_15_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $3 $5 $8 T_15_TMN1Eblank rowNA blank row . . . T_15_TMN1EFlatfishNA Flatfish $0 $0 $0 T_15_TMN1ESmall GameNA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_15_TMN1EOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $0 $0 $0 T_15_TMN1EUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_15_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_15_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_15_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_15_TMN1IEblank rowNA blank row . . . T_15_TMN1IEFlatfishNA Flatfish $3 $5 $8 T_15_TMN1IESmall GameNA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_15_TMN1IEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $1 $1 $2 T_15_TMN1IEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $0 $1 $1 T_15_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $4 $7 $11

rec ben tables 7 of 36T_15_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $3 $5 $9 T_15_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $3 $5 $8

Table 16: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 NA

tag Species Name T_16 Winter flounder Winter flounder T_16Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_16 Atlantic mackerel Atlantic mackerel T_16 Bluefish Bluefish T_16 Striped bass Striped bass T_16 Weakfish Weakfish T_16Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_16 Atlantic cod Atlantic cod T_16 Cunner Cunner T_16 Pollock Pollock T_16 Sculpin Sculpin T_16 Scup Scup T_16 Searobin Searobin T_16 Tautog Tautog T_16 White perch White perch T_16Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_16Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_16Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 17: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 NA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_17_TMN2Iblank rowNA blank row . . . T_17_TMN2IFlatfishNA Flatfish $5 $7 $11 T_17_TMN2ISmall GameNA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_17_TMN2IOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $1 $2 $3 T_17_TMN2IUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $0 $1 $1 T_17_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $6 $10 $16 T_17_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $4 $6 $10 T_17_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $3 $5 $7 T_17_TMN2Eblank rowNA blank row . . . T_17_TMN2EFlatfishNA Flatfish $960 $1,503 $2,375 T_17_TMN2ESmall GameNA Small Game $2 $5 $13 T_17_TMN2EOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $650 $1,085 $1,809 T_17_TMN2EUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $4 $6 $10 T_17_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $1,616 $2,598 $4,207 T_17_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $935 $1,504 $2,436 T_17_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $695 $1,118 $1,810 T_17_TMN2IEblank rowNA blank row . . . T_17_TMN2IEFlatfishNA Flatfish $964 $1,510 $2,387 T_17_TMN2IESmall GameNA Small Game $2 $5 $13 T_17_TMN2IEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $652 $1,087 $1,812 T_17_TMN2IEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $4 $7 $12 T_17_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $1,622 $2,608 $4,223 T_17_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $939 $1,510 $2,446 T_17_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $698 $1,122 $1,817

Table 18: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 NA

tag Species Name T_18 Winter flounder Winter flounder

rec ben tables 8 of 36T_18Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish)

T_18 Atlantic mackerel Atlantic mackerel T_18 Bluefish Bluefish T_18 Striped bass Striped bass T_18 Weakfish Weakfish T_18Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_18 Atlantic cod Atlantic cod T_18 Cunner Cunner T_18 Pollock Pollock T_18 Sculpin Sculpin T_18 Scup Scup T_18 Searobin Searobin T_18 Tautog Tautog T_18 White perch White perch T_18Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_18Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_18Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 19: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 NA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_19_TMN3Iblank rowNA blank row . . . T_19_TMN3IFlatfishNA Flatfish $5 $7 $11 T_19_TMN3ISmall GameNA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_19_TMN3IOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $1 $2 $3 T_19_TMN3IUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $0 $1 $1 T_19_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $6 $10 $16 T_19_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $4 $6 $10 T_19_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $3 $4 $7 T_19_TMN3Eblank rowNA blank row . . . T_19_TMN3EFlatfishNA Flatfish $1,007 $1,576 $2,492 T_19_TMN3ESmall GameNA Small Game $2 $5 $13 T_19_TMN3EOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $682 $1,138 $1,897 T_19_TMN3EUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $4 $6 $11 T_19_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $1,695 $2,726 $4,414 T_19_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,015 $1,632 $2,642 T_19_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $753 $1,212 $1,962 T_19_TMN3IEblank rowNA blank row . . . T_19_TMN3IEFlatfishNA Flatfish $1,012 $1,583 $2,503 T_19_TMN3IESmall GameNA Small Game $2 $5 $13 T_19_TMN3IEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $684 $1,140 $1,901 T_19_TMN3IEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $4 $7 $12 T_19_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $1,701 $2,736 $4,430 T_19_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,018 $1,638 $2,652 T_19_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $756 $1,216 $1,969

Table 20: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN4 NA

tag Species Name T_20 Winter flounder Winter flounder T_20Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_20 Atlantic mackerel Atlantic mackerel T_20 Bluefish Bluefish T_20 Striped bass Striped bass T_20 Weakfish Weakfish T_20Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_20 Atlantic cod Atlantic cod

rec ben tables 9 of 36T_20 Cunner Cunner

T_20 Pollock Pollock T_20 Sculpin Sculpin T_20 Scup Scup T_20 Searobin Searobin T_20 Tautog Tautog T_20 White perch White perch T_20Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_20Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_20Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 21: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN4 NA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_21_TMN4Iblank rowNA blank row . . . T_21_TMN4IFlatfishNA Flatfish $3 $5 $8 T_21_TMN4ISmall GameNA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_21_TMN4IOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $1 $1 $2 T_21_TMN4IUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $0 $1 $1 T_21_TMN4ITotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $4 $7 $11 T_21_TMN4ITotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $3 $5 $9 T_21_TMN4ITotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $3 $5 $8 T_21_TMN4Eblank rowNA blank row . . . T_21_TMN4EFlatfishNA Flatfish $0 $0 $0 T_21_TMN4ESmall GameNA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_21_TMN4EOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $0 $0 $0 T_21_TMN4EUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_21_TMN4ETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_21_TMN4ETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_21_TMN4ETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_21_TMN4IEblank rowNA blank row . . . T_21_TMN4IEFlatfishNA Flatfish $3 $5 $8 T_21_TMN4IESmall GameNA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_21_TMN4IEOther SaltwaterNA Other Saltwater $1 $1 $2 T_21_TMN4IEUnidentifiedNA Unidentified $0 $1 $1 T_21_TMN4IETotal (Undiscounted)NA Total (Undiscounted) $4 $7 $11 T_21_TMN4IETotal (3% Discount Rate)NA Total (3% Discount Rate) $3 $5 $9 T_21_TMN4IETotal (7% Discount Rate)NA Total (7% Discount Rate) $3 $5 $8

Table 23: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline MA

tag Species Name T_23 Summer flounder Summer flounder T_23 Winter flounder Winter flounder T_23Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_23 Black crappie Black crappie T_23 Bluegill Bluegill T_23 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead T_23 Bullhead Bullhead T_23 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_23 Crappie Crappie T_23 Menhaden Menhaden T_23 Sunfish Sunfish T_23Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_23 Bluefish Bluefish T_23 Red drum Red drum T_23 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout

rec ben tables 10 of 36T_23 Striped bass Striped bass

T_23 Weakfish Weakfish T_23Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_23 Northern pike Northern pike T_23Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_23 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker T_23 Atlantic herring Atlantic herring T_23 Black drum Black drum T_23 Cunner Cunner T_23 Scup Scup T_23 Searobin Searobin T_23 Silver perch Silver perch T_23 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_23 Spot Spot T_23 Striped mullet Striped mullet T_23 Tautog Tautog T_23 White perch White perch T_23 whitefish whitefish T_23Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_23Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_23Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 24: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline MA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_24_baselineIblank rowMA blank row . . . T_24_baselineIFlatfishMA Flatfish $22 $34 $51 T_24_baselineIPanfishMA Panfish $2 $4 $9 T_24_baselineISmall GameMA Small Game $373 $973 $2,558 T_24_baselineIWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_24_baselineIOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $827 $1,303 $2,055 T_24_baselineIUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $187 $318 $563 T_24_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $1,412 $2,633 $5,236 T_24_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,254 $2,337 $4,648 T_24_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,211 $2,258 $4,490 T_24_baselineEblank rowMA blank row . . . T_24_baselineEFlatfishMA Flatfish $16 $24 $37 T_24_baselineEPanfishMA Panfish $2 $4 $8 T_24_baselineESmall GameMA Small Game $1,054 $2,752 $7,235 T_24_baselineEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike . . . T_24_baselineEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $12,525 $19,730 $31,104 T_24_baselineEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $2,156 $3,660 $6,473 T_24_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $15,754 $26,170 $44,857 T_24_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $13,985 $23,232 $39,820 T_24_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $13,510 $22,443 $38,468 T_24_baselineIEblank rowMA blank row . . . T_24_baselineIEFlatfishMA Flatfish $38 $58 $87 T_24_baselineIEPanfishMA Panfish $4 $8 $17 T_24_baselineIESmall GameMA Small Game $1,427 $3,725 $9,793 T_24_baselineIEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_24_baselineIEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $13,353 $21,034 $33,159 T_24_baselineIEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $2,344 $3,978 $7,036 T_24_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $17,166 $28,803 $50,092 T_24_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $15,239 $25,569 $44,467 T_24_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $14,721 $24,701 $42,958

Table 25: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 MA

rec ben tables 11 of 36tag Species Name

T_25 Summer flounder Summer flounder T_25 Winter flounder Winter flounder T_25Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_25 Black crappie Black crappie T_25 Bluegill Bluegill T_25 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead T_25 Bullhead Bullhead T_25 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_25 Crappie Crappie T_25 Menhaden Menhaden T_25 Sunfish Sunfish T_25Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_25 Bluefish Bluefish T_25 Red drum Red drum T_25 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_25 Striped bass Striped bass T_25 Weakfish Weakfish T_25Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_25 Northern pike Northern pike T_25Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_25 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker T_25 Atlantic herring Atlantic herring T_25 Black drum Black drum T_25 Cunner Cunner T_25 Scup Scup T_25 Searobin Searobin T_25 Silver perch Silver perch T_25 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_25 Spot Spot T_25 Striped mullet Striped mullet T_25 Tautog Tautog T_25 White perch White perch T_25 whitefish whitefish T_25Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_25Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_25Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 26: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 MA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_26_TMN1Iblank rowMA blank row . . . T_26_TMN1IFlatfishMA Flatfish $17 $26 $39 T_26_TMN1IPanfishMA Panfish $2 $3 $7 T_26_TMN1ISmall GameMA Small Game $284 $742 $1,952 T_26_TMN1IWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_26_TMN1IOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $631 $994 $1,568 T_26_TMN1IUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $143 $243 $429 T_26_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $1,077 $2,009 $3,994 T_26_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $846 $1,577 $3,136 T_26_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $749 $1,396 $2,776 T_26_TMN1Eblank rowMA blank row . . . T_26_TMN1EFlatfishMA Flatfish $0 $0 $0 T_26_TMN1EPanfishMA Panfish $0 $0 $0 T_26_TMN1ESmall GameMA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_26_TMN1EWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike . . .

rec ben tables 12 of 36T_26_TMN1EOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $0 $0 $0

T_26_TMN1EUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_26_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_26_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_26_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_26_TMN1IEblank rowMA blank row . . . T_26_TMN1IEFlatfishMA Flatfish $17 $26 $39 T_26_TMN1IEPanfishMA Panfish $2 $3 $7 T_26_TMN1IESmall GameMA Small Game $284 $742 $1,952 T_26_TMN1IEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_26_TMN1IEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $631 $994 $1,568 T_26_TMN1IEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $143 $243 $429 T_26_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $1,077 $2,009 $3,994 T_26_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $846 $1,577 $3,136 T_26_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $749 $1,396 $2,776

Table 27: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 MA

tag Species Name T_27 Summer flounder Summer flounder T_27 Winter flounder Winter flounder T_27Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_27 Black crappie Black crappie T_27 Bluegill Bluegill T_27 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead T_27 Bullhead Bullhead T_27 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_27 Crappie Crappie T_27 Menhaden Menhaden T_27 Sunfish Sunfish T_27Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_27 Bluefish Bluefish T_27 Red drum Red drum T_27 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_27 Striped bass Striped bass T_27 Weakfish Weakfish T_27Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_27 Northern pike Northern pike T_27Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_27 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker T_27 Atlantic herring Atlantic herring T_27 Black drum Black drum T_27 Cunner Cunner T_27 Scup Scup T_27 Searobin Searobin T_27 Silver perch Silver perch T_27 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_27 Spot Spot T_27 Striped mullet Striped mullet T_27 Tautog Tautog T_27 White perch White perch T_27 whitefish whitefish T_27Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_27Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_27Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 28: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 MA

rec ben tables 13 of 36tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_28_TMN2Iblank rowMA blank row . . . T_28_TMN2IFlatfishMA Flatfish $22 $33 $50 T_28_TMN2IPanfishMA Panfish $2 $4 $9 T_28_TMN2ISmall GameMA Small Game $364 $949 $2,496 T_28_TMN2IWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_28_TMN2IOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $807 $1,272 $2,005 T_28_TMN2IUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $183 $310 $549 T_28_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $1,378 $2,569 $5,108 T_28_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $743 $1,384 $2,753 T_28_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $519 $968 $1,924 T_28_TMN2Eblank rowMA blank row . . . T_28_TMN2EFlatfishMA Flatfish $15 $22 $34 T_28_TMN2EPanfishMA Panfish $2 $4 $7 T_28_TMN2ESmall GameMA Small Game $966 $2,520 $6,626 T_28_TMN2EWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike . . . T_28_TMN2EOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $11,471 $18,069 $28,486 T_28_TMN2EUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $1,975 $3,352 $5,928 T_28_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $14,428 $23,967 $41,080 T_28_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $7,638 $12,688 $21,748 T_28_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $5,312 $8,824 $15,125 T_28_TMN2IEblank rowMA blank row . . . T_28_TMN2IEFlatfishMA Flatfish $36 $55 $83 T_28_TMN2IEPanfishMA Panfish $4 $8 $16 T_28_TMN2IESmall GameMA Small Game $1,329 $3,470 $9,122 T_28_TMN2IEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_28_TMN2IEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $12,278 $19,341 $30,490 T_28_TMN2IEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $2,158 $3,662 $6,477 T_28_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $15,805 $26,536 $46,188 T_28_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $8,381 $14,073 $24,501 T_28_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $5,831 $9,792 $17,049

Table 29: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 MA

tag Species Name T_29 Summer flounder Summer flounder T_29 Winter flounder Winter flounder T_29Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_29 Black crappie Black crappie T_29 Bluegill Bluegill T_29 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead T_29 Bullhead Bullhead T_29 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_29 Crappie Crappie T_29 Menhaden Menhaden T_29 Sunfish Sunfish T_29Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_29 Bluefish Bluefish T_29 Red drum Red drum T_29 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_29 Striped bass Striped bass T_29 Weakfish Weakfish T_29Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_29 Northern pike Northern pike T_29Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_29 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker

rec ben tables 14 of 36T_29 Atlantic herring Atlantic herring

T_29 Black drum Black drum T_29 Cunner Cunner T_29 Scup Scup T_29 Searobin Searobin T_29 Silver perch Silver perch T_29 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_29 Spot Spot T_29 Striped mullet Striped mullet T_29 Tautog Tautog T_29 White perch White perch T_29 whitefish whitefish T_29Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_29Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_29Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 30: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 MA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_30_TMN3Iblank rowMA blank row . . . T_30_TMN3IFlatfishMA Flatfish $22 $33 $50 T_30_TMN3IPanfishMA Panfish $2 $4 $9 T_30_TMN3ISmall GameMA Small Game $365 $953 $2,505 T_30_TMN3IWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_30_TMN3IOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $810 $1,276 $2,012 T_30_TMN3IUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $184 $311 $551 T_30_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $1,383 $2,577 $5,126 T_30_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $742 $1,383 $2,751 T_30_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $516 $963 $1,915 T_30_TMN3Eblank rowMA blank row . . . T_30_TMN3EFlatfishMA Flatfish $15 $22 $34 T_30_TMN3EPanfishMA Panfish $2 $4 $7 T_30_TMN3ESmall GameMA Small Game $978 $2,552 $6,710 T_30_TMN3EWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike . . . T_30_TMN3EOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $11,617 $18,300 $28,850 T_30_TMN3EUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $2,000 $3,395 $6,004 T_30_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $14,612 $24,273 $41,605 T_30_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $7,842 $13,026 $22,328 T_30_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $5,458 $9,067 $15,541 T_30_TMN3IEblank rowMA blank row . . . T_30_TMN3IEFlatfishMA Flatfish $37 $55 $84 T_30_TMN3IEPanfishMA Panfish $4 $8 $16 T_30_TMN3IESmall GameMA Small Game $1,343 $3,505 $9,215 T_30_TMN3IEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_30_TMN3IEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $12,427 $19,576 $30,861 T_30_TMN3IEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $2,183 $3,706 $6,555 T_30_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $15,995 $26,851 $46,731 T_30_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $8,584 $14,410 $25,078 T_30_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $5,975 $10,030 $17,456

Table 31: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN4 MA

tag Species Name T_31 Summer flounder Summer flounder T_31 Winter flounder Winter flounder T_31Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_31 Black crappie Black crappie

rec ben tables 15 of 36T_31 Bluegill Bluegill

T_31 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead T_31 Bullhead Bullhead T_31 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_31 Crappie Crappie T_31 Menhaden Menhaden T_31 Sunfish Sunfish T_31Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_31 Bluefish Bluefish T_31 Red drum Red drum T_31 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_31 Striped bass Striped bass T_31 Weakfish Weakfish T_31Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_31 Northern pike Northern pike T_31Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_31 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker T_31 Atlantic herring Atlantic herring T_31 Black drum Black drum T_31 Cunner Cunner T_31 Scup Scup T_31 Searobin Searobin T_31 Silver perch Silver perch T_31 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_31 Spot Spot T_31 Striped mullet Striped mullet T_31 Tautog Tautog T_31 White perch White perch T_31 whitefish whitefish T_31Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_31Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_31Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 32: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN4 MA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_32_TMN4Iblank rowMA blank row . . . T_32_TMN4IFlatfishMA Flatfish $17 $26 $39 T_32_TMN4IPanfishMA Panfish $2 $3 $7 T_32_TMN4ISmall GameMA Small Game $284 $742 $1,950 T_32_TMN4IWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_32_TMN4IOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $631 $993 $1,566 T_32_TMN4IUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $143 $243 $429 T_32_TMN4ITotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $1,076 $2,007 $3,991 T_32_TMN4ITotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $845 $1,576 $3,133 T_32_TMN4ITotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $748 $1,395 $2,773 T_32_TMN4Eblank rowMA blank row . . . T_32_TMN4EFlatfishMA Flatfish $0 $0 $0 T_32_TMN4EPanfishMA Panfish $0 $0 $0 T_32_TMN4ESmall GameMA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_32_TMN4EWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike . . . T_32_TMN4EOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $0 $0 $0 T_32_TMN4EUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_32_TMN4ETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_32_TMN4ETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_32_TMN4ETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_32_TMN4IEblank rowMA blank row . . .

rec ben tables 16 of 36T_32_TMN4IEFlatfishMA Flatfish $17 $26 $39

T_32_TMN4IEPanfishMA Panfish $2 $3 $7 T_32_TMN4IESmall GameMA Small Game $284 $742 $1,950 T_32_TMN4IEWalleye/PikeMA Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_32_TMN4IEOther SaltwaterMA Other Saltwater $631 $993 $1,566 T_32_TMN4IEUnidentifiedMA Unidentified $143 $243 $429 T_32_TMN4IETotal (Undiscounted)MA Total (Undiscounted) $1,076 $2,007 $3,991 T_32_TMN4IETotal (3% Discount Rate)MA Total (3% Discount Rate) $845 $1,576 $3,133 T_32_TMN4IETotal (7% Discount Rate)MA Total (7% Discount Rate) $748 $1,395 $2,773

Table 34: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline SA

tag Species Name T_34 Flounders Flounders T_34Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_34 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_34 Weakfish Weakfish T_34Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_34 Croakers Croakers T_34 Pinfish Pinfish T_34 Silver perch Silver perch T_34 Spot Spot T_34Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_34Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_34Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 35: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline SA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_35_baselineIblank rowSA blank row . . . T_35_baselineIFlatfishSA Flatfish $3 $4 $6 T_35_baselineISmall GameSA Small Game $1 $2 $4 T_35_baselineIOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $49 $66 $87 T_35_baselineIUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $2 $3 $4 T_35_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) $56 $75 $101 T_35_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $49 $66 $90 T_35_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $48 $64 $87 T_35_baselineEblank rowSA blank row . . . T_35_baselineEFlatfishSA Flatfish . . . T_35_baselineESmall GameSA Small Game $5 $11 $24 T_35_baselineEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $227 $301 $399 T_35_baselineEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $2 $3 $4 T_35_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted)$234 $315 $427 T_35_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $208 $280 $379 T_35_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $201 $270 $366 T_35_baselineIEblank rowSA blank row . . . T_35_baselineIEFlatfishSA Flatfish $3 $4 $6 T_35_baselineIESmall GameSA Small Game $6 $13 $28 T_35_baselineIEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $276 $367 $486 T_35_baselineIEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $4 $6 $7 T_35_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted)$290 $390 $529 T_35_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $257 $346 $469 T_35_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $249 $335 $453

Table 36: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 SA

tag Species Name

rec ben tables 17 of 36T_36 Flounders Flounders

T_36Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_36 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_36 Weakfish Weakfish T_36Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_36 Croakers Croakers T_36 Pinfish Pinfish T_36 Silver perch Silver perch T_36 Spot Spot T_36Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_36Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_36Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 37: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 SA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_37_TMN1Iblank rowSA blank row . . . T_37_TMN1IFlatfishSA Flatfish $2 $3 $4 T_37_TMN1ISmall GameSA Small Game $1 $1 $3 T_37_TMN1IOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $31 $41 $55 T_37_TMN1IUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $1 $2 $2 T_37_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) $35 $47 $64 T_37_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $28 $37 $50 T_37_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $24 $33 $45 T_37_TMN1Eblank rowSA blank row . . . T_37_TMN1EFlatfishSA Flatfish . . . T_37_TMN1ESmall GameSA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_37_TMN1EOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $0 $0 $0 T_37_TMN1EUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_37_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_37_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_37_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_37_TMN1IEblank rowSA blank row . . . T_37_TMN1IEFlatfishSA Flatfish $2 $3 $4 T_37_TMN1IESmall GameSA Small Game $1 $1 $3 T_37_TMN1IEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $31 $41 $55 T_37_TMN1IEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $1 $2 $2 T_37_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) $35 $47 $64 T_37_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $28 $37 $50 T_37_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $24 $33 $45

Table 38: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 SA

tag Species Name T_38 Flounders Flounders T_38Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_38 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_38 Weakfish Weakfish T_38Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_38 Croakers Croakers T_38 Pinfish Pinfish T_38 Silver perch Silver perch T_38 Spot Spot T_38Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_38Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_38Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

rec ben tables 18 of 36Table 39: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 SA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_39_TMN2Iblank rowSA blank row . . . T_39_TMN2IFlatfishSA Flatfish $3 $4 $5 T_39_TMN2ISmall GameSA Small Game $1 $2 $4 T_39_TMN2IOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $42 $56 $74 T_39_TMN2IUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $2 $2 $3 T_39_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) $47 $64 $86 T_39_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $27 $37 $50 T_39_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $20 $27 $37 T_39_TMN2Eblank rowSA blank row . . . T_39_TMN2EFlatfishSA Flatfish . . . T_39_TMN2ESmall GameSA Small Game $5 $10 $20 T_39_TMN2EOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $189 $251 $333 T_39_TMN2EUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $2 $2 $3 T_39_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted)$195 $263 $356 T_39_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $114 $153 $207 T_39_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $83 $112 $151 T_39_TMN2IEblank rowSA blank row . . . T_39_TMN2IEFlatfishSA Flatfish $3 $4 $5 T_39_TMN2IESmall GameSA Small Game $5 $11 $24 T_39_TMN2IEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $231 $307 $407 T_39_TMN2IEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $4 $5 $6 T_39_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted)$243 $327 $443 T_39_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $141 $190 $257 T_39_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $103 $139 $188

Table 40: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 SA

tag Species Name T_40 Flounders Flounders T_40Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_40 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_40 Weakfish Weakfish T_40Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_40 Croakers Croakers T_40 Pinfish Pinfish T_40 Silver perch Silver perch T_40 Spot Spot T_40Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_40Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_40Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 41: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 SA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_41_TMN3Iblank rowSA blank row . . . T_41_TMN3IFlatfishSA Flatfish $3 $4 $5 T_41_TMN3ISmall GameSA Small Game $1 $2 $4 T_41_TMN3IOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $42 $56 $74 T_41_TMN3IUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $2 $2 $3 T_41_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) $47 $64 $87 T_41_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $27 $37 $50 T_41_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $20 $27 $37 T_41_TMN3Eblank rowSA blank row . . . T_41_TMN3EFlatfishSA Flatfish . . .

rec ben tables 19 of 36T_41_TMN3ESmall GameSA Small Game $5 $10 $20

T_41_TMN3EOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $190 $252 $334 T_41_TMN3EUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $2 $2 $3 T_41_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted)$196 $263 $357 T_41_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $114 $153 $207 T_41_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $83 $112 $151 T_41_TMN3IEblank rowSA blank row . . . T_41_TMN3IEFlatfishSA Flatfish $3 $4 $5 T_41_TMN3IESmall GameSA Small Game $5 $11 $24 T_41_TMN3IEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $232 $308 $408 T_41_TMN3IEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $4 $5 $6 T_41_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted)$243 $327 $443 T_41_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $141 $190 $257 T_41_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $103 $139 $188

Table 42: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN4 SA

tag Species Name T_42 Flounders Flounders T_42Total (Flatfish) Total (Flatfish) T_42 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_42 Weakfish Weakfish T_42Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_42 Croakers Croakers T_42 Pinfish Pinfish T_42 Silver perch Silver perch T_42 Spot Spot T_42Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_42Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_42Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 43: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN4 SA

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_43_TMN4Iblank rowSA blank row . . . T_43_TMN4IFlatfishSA Flatfish $2 $3 $4 T_43_TMN4ISmall GameSA Small Game $1 $1 $3 T_43_TMN4IOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $31 $41 $55 T_43_TMN4IUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $1 $2 $2 T_43_TMN4ITotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) $35 $47 $64 T_43_TMN4ITotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $28 $37 $50 T_43_TMN4ITotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $24 $33 $45 T_43_TMN4Eblank rowSA blank row . . . T_43_TMN4EFlatfishSA Flatfish . . . T_43_TMN4ESmall GameSA Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_43_TMN4EOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $0 $0 $0 T_43_TMN4EUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_43_TMN4ETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_43_TMN4ETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_43_TMN4ETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_43_TMN4IEblank rowSA blank row . . . T_43_TMN4IEFlatfishSA Flatfish $2 $3 $4 T_43_TMN4IESmall GameSA Small Game $1 $1 $3 T_43_TMN4IEOther SaltwaterSA Other Saltwater $31 $41 $55 T_43_TMN4IEUnidentifiedSA Unidentified $1 $2 $2 T_43_TMN4IETotal (Undiscounted)SA Total (Undiscounted) $35 $47 $64 T_43_TMN4IETotal (3% Discount Rate)SA Total (3% Discount Rate) $28 $37 $50

rec ben tables 20 of 36T_43_TMN4IETotal (7% Discount Rate)SA Total (7% Discount Rate) $24 $33 $45

Table 45: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline GM

tag Species Name T_45 Mackerels Mackerels T_45 Red drum Red drum T_45 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_45Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_45 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker T_45 Black drum Black drum T_45 Pinfish Pinfish T_45 Sea bass Sea bass T_45 Searobin Searobin T_45 Sheepshead Sheepshead T_45 Silver perch Silver perch T_45 Spot Spot T_45 Striped mullet Striped mullet T_45Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_45Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_45Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 46: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline GM

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_46_baselineIblank rowGM blank row . . . T_46_baselineISmall GameGM Small Game $1,385 $2,718 $5,329 T_46_baselineIOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $651 $847 $1,101 T_46_baselineIUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $193 $298 $482 T_46_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $2,229 $3,863 $6,912 T_46_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $2,060 $3,571 $6,388 T_46_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $2,052 $3,557 $6,364 T_46_baselineEblank rowGM blank row . . . T_46_baselineESmall GameGM Small Game $165 $324 $635 T_46_baselineEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $4,003 $5,206 $6,770 T_46_baselineEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $118 $183 $296 T_46_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $4,286 $5,713 $7,701 T_46_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $3,962 $5,281 $7,118 T_46_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $3,947 $5,261 $7,091 T_46_baselineIEblank rowGM blank row . . . T_46_baselineIESmall GameGM Small Game $1,550 $3,042 $5,964 T_46_baselineIEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $4,654 $6,053 $7,871 T_46_baselineIEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $311 $482 $778 T_46_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $6,515 $9,576 $14,612 T_46_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $6,022 $8,852 $13,506 T_46_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $5,999 $8,818 $13,456

Table 47: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 GM

tag Species Name T_47 Mackerels Mackerels T_47 Red drum Red drum T_47 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_47Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_47 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker T_47 Black drum Black drum T_47 Pinfish Pinfish

rec ben tables 21 of 36T_47 Sea bass Sea bass

T_47 Searobin Searobin T_47 Sheepshead Sheepshead T_47 Silver perch Silver perch T_47 Spot Spot T_47 Striped mullet Striped mullet T_47Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_47Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_47Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 48: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 GM

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_48_TMN1Iblank rowGM blank row . . . T_48_TMN1ISmall GameGM Small Game $1,061 $2,082 $4,081 T_48_TMN1IOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $499 $648 $843 T_48_TMN1IUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $147 $228 $369 T_48_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $1,707 $2,959 $5,293 T_48_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,398 $2,422 $4,334 T_48_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,275 $2,210 $3,953 T_48_TMN1Eblank rowGM blank row . . . T_48_TMN1ESmall GameGM Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_48_TMN1EOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $0 $0 $0 T_48_TMN1EUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_48_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_48_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_48_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_48_TMN1IEblank rowGM blank row . . . T_48_TMN1IESmall GameGM Small Game $1,061 $2,082 $4,081 T_48_TMN1IEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $499 $648 $843 T_48_TMN1IEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $147 $228 $369 T_48_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $1,707 $2,959 $5,293 T_48_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,398 $2,422 $4,334 T_48_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,275 $2,210 $3,953

Table 49: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 GM

tag Species Name T_49 Mackerels Mackerels T_49 Red drum Red drum T_49 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_49Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_49 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker T_49 Black drum Black drum T_49 Pinfish Pinfish T_49 Sea bass Sea bass T_49 Searobin Searobin T_49 Sheepshead Sheepshead T_49 Silver perch Silver perch T_49 Spot Spot T_49 Striped mullet Striped mullet T_49Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_49Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_49Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 50: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 GM

rec ben tables 22 of 36tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_50_TMN2Iblank rowGM blank row . . . T_50_TMN2ISmall GameGM Small Game $1,376 $2,700 $5,292 T_50_TMN2IOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $646 $841 $1,093 T_50_TMN2IUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $191 $296 $478 T_50_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $2,214 $3,837 $6,864 T_50_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,417 $2,456 $4,395 T_50_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,098 $1,903 $3,404 T_50_TMN2Eblank rowGM blank row . . . T_50_TMN2ESmall GameGM Small Game $112 $219 $429 T_50_TMN2EOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $2,708 $3,522 $4,579 T_50_TMN2EUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $80 $124 $200 T_50_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $2,899 $3,865 $5,209 T_50_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,808 $2,410 $3,248 T_50_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,393 $1,857 $2,504 T_50_TMN2IEblank rowGM blank row . . . T_50_TMN2IESmall GameGM Small Game $1,488 $2,919 $5,722 T_50_TMN2IEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $3,354 $4,362 $5,673 T_50_TMN2IEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $271 $420 $679 T_50_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $5,113 $7,701 $12,073 T_50_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $3,225 $4,866 $7,642 T_50_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $2,491 $3,760 $5,908

Table 51: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 GM

tag Species Name T_51 Mackerels Mackerels T_51 Red drum Red drum T_51 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_51Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_51 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker T_51 Black drum Black drum T_51 Pinfish Pinfish T_51 Sea bass Sea bass T_51 Searobin Searobin T_51 Sheepshead Sheepshead T_51 Silver perch Silver perch T_51 Spot Spot T_51 Striped mullet Striped mullet T_51Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_51Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_51Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 52: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 GM

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_52_TMN3Iblank rowGM blank row . . . T_52_TMN3ISmall GameGM Small Game $1,377 $2,702 $5,296 T_52_TMN3IOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $647 $841 $1,094 T_52_TMN3IUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $191 $297 $479 T_52_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $2,215 $3,840 $6,869 T_52_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,409 $2,442 $4,369 T_52_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,086 $1,882 $3,367 T_52_TMN3Eblank rowGM blank row . . . T_52_TMN3ESmall GameGM Small Game $112 $220 $431 T_52_TMN3EOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $2,714 $3,530 $4,591 T_52_TMN3EUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $80 $124 $201

rec ben tables 23 of 36T_52_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $2,906 $3,874 $5,222 T_52_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,849 $2,464 $3,321 T_52_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,424 $1,899 $2,559 T_52_TMN3IEblank rowGM blank row . . . T_52_TMN3IESmall GameGM Small Game $1,489 $2,921 $5,727 T_52_TMN3IEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $3,361 $4,372 $5,685 T_52_TMN3IEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $272 $421 $680 T_52_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $5,122 $7,714 $12,091 T_52_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $3,258 $4,906 $7,690 T_52_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $2,510 $3,781 $5,926

Table 53: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN4 GM

tag Species Name T_53 Mackerels Mackerels T_53 Red drum Red drum T_53 Spotted seatrout Spotted seatrout T_53Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_53 Atlantic croaker Atlantic croaker T_53 Black drum Black drum T_53 Pinfish Pinfish T_53 Sea bass Sea bass T_53 Searobin Searobin T_53 Sheepshead Sheepshead T_53 Silver perch Silver perch T_53 Spot Spot T_53 Striped mullet Striped mullet T_53Total (Other Saltwater) Total (Other Saltwater) T_53Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_53Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 54: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN4 GM

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_54_TMN4Iblank rowGM blank row . . . T_54_TMN4ISmall GameGM Small Game $1,053 $2,066 $4,050 T_54_TMN4IOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $495 $644 $837 T_54_TMN4IUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $146 $227 $366 T_54_TMN4ITotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $1,694 $2,936 $5,253 T_54_TMN4ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,387 $2,404 $4,301 T_54_TMN4ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,265 $2,193 $3,923 T_54_TMN4Eblank rowGM blank row . . . T_54_TMN4ESmall GameGM Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_54_TMN4EOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $0 $0 $0 T_54_TMN4EUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_54_TMN4ETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_54_TMN4ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_54_TMN4ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_54_TMN4IEblank rowGM blank row . . . T_54_TMN4IESmall GameGM Small Game $1,053 $2,066 $4,050 T_54_TMN4IEOther SaltwaterGM Other Saltwater $495 $644 $837 T_54_TMN4IEUnidentifiedGM Unidentified $146 $227 $366 T_54_TMN4IETotal (Undiscounted)GM Total (Undiscounted) $1,694 $2,936 $5,253 T_54_TMN4IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GM Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,387 $2,404 $4,301 T_54_TMN4IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GM Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,265 $2,193 $3,923

Table 56: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline GL

rec ben tables 24 of 36tag Species Name

T_56 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_56 White bass White bass T_56Total (Bass) Total (Bass) T_56 Whitefish Whitefish T_56Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) T_56 Black crappie Black crappie T_56 Bluegill Bluegill T_56 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_56 Crappie Crappie T_56 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt T_56 Sculpin Sculpin T_56 Smelts Smelts T_56 Sunfish Sunfish T_56 Yellow perch Yellow perch T_56Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_56 Salmon Salmon T_56Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) T_56 Northern pike Northern pike T_56 Walleye Walleye T_56Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_56Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_56Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 57: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline GL

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_57_baselineIblank rowGL blank row . . . T_57_baselineIBassGL Bass $36 $69 $133 T_57_baselineIOther TroutGL Other Trout $424 $655 $1,018 T_57_baselineIPanfishGL Panfish $25 $47 $88 T_57_baselineISalmonGL Salmon $8 $13 $21 T_57_baselineIWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike $1 $1 $2 T_57_baselineIUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $298 $556 $1,048 T_57_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted)$790 $1,341 $2,310 T_57_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $731 $1,239 $2,135 T_57_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $728 $1,235 $2,127 T_57_baselineEblank rowGL blank row . . . T_57_baselineEBassGL Bass $69 $134 $260 T_57_baselineEOther TroutGL Other Trout $0 $0 $0 T_57_baselineEPanfishGL Panfish $20 $39 $73 T_57_baselineESalmonGL Salmon $2 $4 $6 T_57_baselineEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike . . . T_57_baselineEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $337 $629 $1,184 T_57_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted)$429 $806 $1,524 T_57_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $397 $745 $1,409 T_57_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $395 $742 $1,403 T_57_baselineIEblank rowGL blank row . . . T_57_baselineIEBassGL Bass $105 $203 $394 T_57_baselineIEOther TroutGL Other Trout $424 $655 $1,018 T_57_baselineIEPanfishGL Panfish $45 $85 $161 T_57_baselineIESalmonGL Salmon $10 $17 $27 T_57_baselineIEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike $1 $1 $2 T_57_baselineIEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $635 $1,185 $2,232 T_57_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) $1,219 $2,146 $3,834 T_57_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $1,127 $1,984 $3,544

rec ben tables 25 of 36T_57_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $1,123 $1,977 $3,530

Table 58: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 GL

tag Species Name T_58 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_58 White bass White bass T_58Total (Bass) Total (Bass) T_58 Whitefish Whitefish T_58Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) T_58 Black crappie Black crappie T_58 Bluegill Bluegill T_58 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_58 Crappie Crappie T_58 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt T_58 Sculpin Sculpin T_58 Smelts Smelts T_58 Sunfish Sunfish T_58 Yellow perch Yellow perch T_58Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_58 Salmon Salmon T_58Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) T_58 Northern pike Northern pike T_58 Walleye Walleye T_58Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_58Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_58Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 59: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 GL

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_59_TMN1Iblank rowGL blank row . . . T_59_TMN1IBassGL Bass $31 $60 $116 T_59_TMN1IOther TroutGL Other Trout $367 $567 $882 T_59_TMN1IPanfishGL Panfish $21 $40 $76 T_59_TMN1ISalmonGL Salmon $7 $11 $18 T_59_TMN1IWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike $0 $1 $2 T_59_TMN1IUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $258 $482 $908 T_59_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted)$685 $1,162 $2,001 T_59_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $561 $951 $1,638 T_59_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $511 $867 $1,495 T_59_TMN1Eblank rowGL blank row . . . T_59_TMN1EBassGL Bass $0 $0 $0 T_59_TMN1EOther TroutGL Other Trout $0 $0 $0 T_59_TMN1EPanfishGL Panfish $0 $0 $0 T_59_TMN1ESalmonGL Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_59_TMN1EWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike . . . T_59_TMN1EUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_59_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_59_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_59_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_59_TMN1IEblank rowGL blank row . . . T_59_TMN1IEBassGL Bass $31 $60 $116 T_59_TMN1IEOther TroutGL Other Trout $367 $567 $882 T_59_TMN1IEPanfishGL Panfish $21 $40 $76 T_59_TMN1IESalmonGL Salmon $7 $11 $18 T_59_TMN1IEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike $0 $1 $2

rec ben tables 26 of 36T_59_TMN1IEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $258 $482 $908

T_59_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted)$685 $1,162 $2,001 T_59_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $561 $951 $1,638 T_59_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $511 $867 $1,495

Table 60: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 GL

tag Species Name T_60 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_60 White bass White bass T_60Total (Bass) Total (Bass) T_60 Whitefish Whitefish T_60Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) T_60 Black crappie Black crappie T_60 Bluegill Bluegill T_60 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_60 Crappie Crappie T_60 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt T_60 Sculpin Sculpin T_60 Smelts Smelts T_60 Sunfish Sunfish T_60 Yellow perch Yellow perch T_60Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_60 Salmon Salmon T_60Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) T_60 Northern pike Northern pike T_60 Walleye Walleye T_60Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_60Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_60Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 61: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 GL

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_61_TMN2Iblank rowGL blank row . . . T_61_TMN2IBassGL Bass $35 $68 $132 T_61_TMN2IOther TroutGL Other Trout $419 $648 $1,007 T_61_TMN2IPanfishGL Panfish $24 $46 $87 T_61_TMN2ISalmonGL Salmon $8 $13 $21 T_61_TMN2IWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike $1 $1 $2 T_61_TMN2IUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $295 $550 $1,037 T_61_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted)$782 $1,326 $2,285 T_61_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $504 $855 $1,473 T_61_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $392 $664 $1,144 T_61_TMN2Eblank rowGL blank row . . . T_61_TMN2EBassGL Bass $55 $107 $208 T_61_TMN2EOther TroutGL Other Trout $0 $0 $0 T_61_TMN2EPanfishGL Panfish $16 $31 $58 T_61_TMN2ESalmonGL Salmon $2 $3 $5 T_61_TMN2EWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike . . . T_61_TMN2EUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $269 $502 $946 T_61_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted)$343 $644 $1,217 T_61_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $216 $406 $768 T_61_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $167 $315 $595 T_61_TMN2IEblank rowGL blank row . . . T_61_TMN2IEBassGL Bass $91 $175 $340 T_61_TMN2IEOther TroutGL Other Trout $419 $648 $1,007

rec ben tables 27 of 36T_61_TMN2IEPanfishGL Panfish $41 $77 $145

T_61_TMN2IESalmonGL Salmon $10 $16 $26 T_61_TMN2IEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike $1 $1 $2 T_61_TMN2IEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $564 $1,053 $1,982 T_61_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) $1,124 $1,970 $3,502 T_61_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $720 $1,261 $2,241 T_61_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $559 $979 $1,739

Table 62: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 GL

tag Species Name T_62 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_62 White bass White bass T_62Total (Bass) Total (Bass) T_62 Whitefish Whitefish T_62Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) T_62 Black crappie Black crappie T_62 Bluegill Bluegill T_62 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_62 Crappie Crappie T_62 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt T_62 Sculpin Sculpin T_62 Smelts Smelts T_62 Sunfish Sunfish T_62 Yellow perch Yellow perch T_62Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_62 Salmon Salmon T_62Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) T_62 Northern pike Northern pike T_62 Walleye Walleye T_62Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_62Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_62Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 63: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 GL

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_63_TMN3Iblank rowGL blank row . . . T_63_TMN3IBassGL Bass $35 $68 $132 T_63_TMN3IOther TroutGL Other Trout $420 $649 $1,009 T_63_TMN3IPanfishGL Panfish $24 $46 $87 T_63_TMN3ISalmonGL Salmon $8 $13 $21 T_63_TMN3IWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike $1 $1 $2 T_63_TMN3IUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $295 $552 $1,039 T_63_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted)$784 $1,329 $2,290 T_63_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $502 $852 $1,468 T_63_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $389 $660 $1,136 T_63_TMN3Eblank rowGL blank row . . . T_63_TMN3EBassGL Bass $56 $109 $211 T_63_TMN3EOther TroutGL Other Trout $0 $0 $0 T_63_TMN3EPanfishGL Panfish $17 $32 $59 T_63_TMN3ESalmonGL Salmon $2 $3 $5 T_63_TMN3EWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike . . . T_63_TMN3EUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $273 $510 $960 T_63_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted)$348 $653 $1,236 T_63_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $223 $419 $792 T_63_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $173 $324 $613

rec ben tables 28 of 36T_63_TMN3IEblank rowGL blank row . . .

T_63_TMN3IEBassGL Bass $91 $177 $343 T_63_TMN3IEOther TroutGL Other Trout $420 $649 $1,009 T_63_TMN3IEPanfishGL Panfish $41 $78 $146 T_63_TMN3IESalmonGL Salmon $10 $16 $26 T_63_TMN3IEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike $1 $1 $2 T_63_TMN3IEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $569 $1,062 $1,999 T_63_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) $1,131 $1,982 $3,526 T_63_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $725 $1,271 $2,261 T_63_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $561 $984 $1,750

Table 64: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN4 GL

tag Species Name T_64 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_64 White bass White bass T_64Total (Bass) Total (Bass) T_64 Whitefish Whitefish T_64Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) T_64 Black crappie Black crappie T_64 Bluegill Bluegill T_64 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_64 Crappie Crappie T_64 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt T_64 Sculpin Sculpin T_64 Smelts Smelts T_64 Sunfish Sunfish T_64 Yellow perch Yellow perch T_64Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_64 Salmon Salmon T_64Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) T_64 Northern pike Northern pike T_64 Walleye Walleye T_64Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_64Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_64Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 65: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN4 GL

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_65_TMN4Iblank rowGL blank row . . . T_65_TMN4IBassGL Bass $31 $59 $115 T_65_TMN4IOther TroutGL Other Trout $364 $563 $874 T_65_TMN4IPanfishGL Panfish $21 $40 $75 T_65_TMN4ISalmonGL Salmon $7 $11 $18 T_65_TMN4IWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike $0 $1 $2 T_65_TMN4IUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $256 $478 $900 T_65_TMN4ITotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted)$679 $1,152 $1,984 T_65_TMN4ITotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $556 $943 $1,624 T_65_TMN4ITotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $507 $860 $1,482 T_65_TMN4Eblank rowGL blank row . . . T_65_TMN4EBassGL Bass $0 $0 $0 T_65_TMN4EOther TroutGL Other Trout $0 $0 $0 T_65_TMN4EPanfishGL Panfish $0 $0 $0 T_65_TMN4ESalmonGL Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_65_TMN4EWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike . . . T_65_TMN4EUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $0 $0 $0

rec ben tables 29 of 36T_65_TMN4ETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0

T_65_TMN4ETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_65_TMN4ETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_65_TMN4IEblank rowGL blank row . . . T_65_TMN4IEBassGL Bass $31 $59 $115 T_65_TMN4IEOther TroutGL Other Trout $364 $563 $874 T_65_TMN4IEPanfishGL Panfish $21 $40 $75 T_65_TMN4IESalmonGL Salmon $7 $11 $18 T_65_TMN4IEWalleye/PikeGL Walleye/Pike $0 $1 $2 T_65_TMN4IEUnidentifiedGL Unidentified $256 $478 $900 T_65_TMN4IETotal (Undiscounted)GL Total (Undiscounted)$679 $1,152 $1,984 T_65_TMN4IETotal (3% Discount Rate)GL Total (3% Discount Rate) $556 $943 $1,624 T_65_TMN4IETotal (7% Discount Rate)GL Total (7% Discount Rate) $507 $860 $1,482

Table 67: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: baseline IN

tag Species Name T_67 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_67 White bass White bass T_67Total (Bass) Total (Bass) T_67 Whitefish Whitefish T_67Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) T_67 Black bullhead Black bullhead T_67 Black crappie Black crappie T_67 Bluegill Bluegill T_67 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead T_67 Bullhead Bullhead T_67 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_67 Crappie Crappie T_67 Menhaden Menhaden T_67 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt T_67 Smelts Smelts T_67 Sunfish Sunfish T_67 White perch White perch T_67 Yellow perch Yellow perch T_67Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_67 Salmon Salmon T_67Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) T_67 American shad American shad T_67 Striped bass Striped bass T_67 Sturgeon Sturgeon T_67Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_67 Northern pike Northern pike T_67 Sauger Sauger T_67 Walleye Walleye T_67Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_67Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_67Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 68: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: baseline IN

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_68_baselineIblank rowIN blank row . . . T_68_baselineIBassIN Bass $3,376 $7,101 $15,031 T_68_baselineIOther TroutIN Other Trout $3 $6 $10 T_68_baselineIPanfishIN Panfish $716 $1,432 $2,850 T_68_baselineISalmonIN Salmon $0 $0 $0

rec ben tables 30 of 36T_68_baselineISmall GameIN Small Game $37 $124 $417

T_68_baselineIWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $50 $103 $214 T_68_baselineIUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $3,223 $6,630 $13,671 T_68_baselineITotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $7,404 $15,396 $32,194 T_68_baselineITotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $6,844 $14,231 $29,757 T_68_baselineITotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $6,818 $14,177 $29,645 T_68_baselineEblank rowIN blank row . . . T_68_baselineEBassIN Bass $4,540 $9,549 $20,213 T_68_baselineEOther TroutIN Other Trout $0 $0 $1 T_68_baselineEPanfishIN Panfish $1,192 $2,384 $4,746 T_68_baselineESalmonIN Salmon . . . T_68_baselineESmall GameIN Small Game $2 $8 $27 T_68_baselineEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $723 $1,498 $3,113 T_68_baselineEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $4,061 $8,355 $17,227 T_68_baselineETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $10,518 $21,795 $45,326 T_68_baselineETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $9,722 $20,145 $41,896 T_68_baselineETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $9,686 $20,070 $41,738 T_68_baselineIEblank rowIN blank row . . . T_68_baselineIEBassIN Bass $7,916 $16,651 $35,244 T_68_baselineIEOther TroutIN Other Trout $3 $6 $11 T_68_baselineIEPanfishIN Panfish $1,908 $3,816 $7,596 T_68_baselineIESalmonIN Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_68_baselineIESmall GameIN Small Game $40 $132 $444 T_68_baselineIEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $773 $1,601 $3,327 T_68_baselineIEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $7,283 $14,985 $30,898 T_68_baselineIETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $17,923 $37,191 $77,520 T_68_baselineIETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $16,566 $34,376 $71,653 T_68_baselineIETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $16,504 $34,247 $71,384

Table 69: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN1 IN

tag Species Name T_69 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_69 White bass White bass T_69Total (Bass) Total (Bass) T_69 Whitefish Whitefish T_69Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) T_69 Black bullhead Black bullhead T_69 Black crappie Black crappie T_69 Bluegill Bluegill T_69 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead T_69 Bullhead Bullhead T_69 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_69 Crappie Crappie T_69 Menhaden Menhaden T_69 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt T_69 Smelts Smelts T_69 Sunfish Sunfish T_69 White perch White perch T_69 Yellow perch Yellow perch T_69Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_69 Salmon Salmon T_69Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) T_69 American shad American shad T_69 Striped bass Striped bass T_69 Sturgeon Sturgeon T_69Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game)

rec ben tables 31 of 36T_69 Northern pike Northern pike

T_69 Sauger Sauger T_69 Walleye Walleye T_69Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_69Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_69Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 70: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN1 IN

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_70_TMN1Iblank rowIN blank row . . . T_70_TMN1IBassIN Bass $2,824 $5,941 $12,575 T_70_TMN1IOther TroutIN Other Trout $2 $5 $9 T_70_TMN1IPanfishIN Panfish $599 $1,198 $2,385 T_70_TMN1ISalmonIN Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1ISmall GameIN Small Game $31 $103 $349 T_70_TMN1IWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $42 $86 $179 T_70_TMN1IUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $2,696 $5,547 $11,437 T_70_TMN1ITotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $6,194 $12,880 $26,933 T_70_TMN1ITotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $5,071 $10,545 $22,049 T_70_TMN1ITotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $4,626 $9,619 $20,115 T_70_TMN1Eblank rowIN blank row . . . T_70_TMN1EBassIN Bass $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1EOther TroutIN Other Trout $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1EPanfishIN Panfish $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1ESalmonIN Salmon . . . T_70_TMN1ESmall GameIN Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1EWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1EUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1ETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1ETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1ETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1IEblank rowIN blank row . . . T_70_TMN1IEBassIN Bass $2,824 $5,941 $12,575 T_70_TMN1IEOther TroutIN Other Trout $2 $5 $9 T_70_TMN1IEPanfishIN Panfish $599 $1,198 $2,385 T_70_TMN1IESalmonIN Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_70_TMN1IESmall GameIN Small Game $31 $103 $349 T_70_TMN1IEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $42 $86 $179 T_70_TMN1IEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $2,696 $5,547 $11,437 T_70_TMN1IETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $6,194 $12,880 $26,933 T_70_TMN1IETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $5,071 $10,545 $22,049 T_70_TMN1IETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $4,626 $9,619 $20,115

Table 71: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN2 IN

tag Species Name T_71 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_71 White bass White bass T_71Total (Bass) Total (Bass) T_71 Whitefish Whitefish T_71Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) T_71 Black bullhead Black bullhead T_71 Black crappie Black crappie T_71 Bluegill Bluegill T_71 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead T_71 Bullhead Bullhead

rec ben tables 32 of 36T_71 Channel catfish Channel catfish

T_71 Crappie Crappie T_71 Menhaden Menhaden T_71 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt T_71 Smelts Smelts T_71 Sunfish Sunfish T_71 White perch White perch T_71 Yellow perch Yellow perch T_71Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_71 Salmon Salmon T_71Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) T_71 American shad American shad T_71 Striped bass Striped bass T_71 Sturgeon Sturgeon T_71Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_71 Northern pike Northern pike T_71 Sauger Sauger T_71 Walleye Walleye T_71Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_71Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_71Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 72: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN2 IN

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_72_TMN2Iblank rowIN blank row . . . T_72_TMN2IBassIN Bass $3,263 $6,864 $14,529 T_72_TMN2IOther TroutIN Other Trout $3 $5 $10 T_72_TMN2IPanfishIN Panfish $692 $1,384 $2,755 T_72_TMN2ISalmonIN Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_72_TMN2ISmall GameIN Small Game $36 $120 $403 T_72_TMN2IWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $48 $100 $207 T_72_TMN2IUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $3,115 $6,409 $13,214 T_72_TMN2ITotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $7,157 $14,881 $31,118 T_72_TMN2ITotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $4,557 $9,475 $19,813 T_72_TMN2ITotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $3,531 $7,343 $15,355 T_72_TMN2Eblank rowIN blank row . . . T_72_TMN2EBassIN Bass $3,709 $7,803 $16,516 T_72_TMN2EOther TroutIN Other Trout $0 $0 $0 T_72_TMN2EPanfishIN Panfish $974 $1,948 $3,878 T_72_TMN2ESalmonIN Salmon . . . T_72_TMN2ESmall GameIN Small Game $2 $7 $22 T_72_TMN2EWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $591 $1,224 $2,543 T_72_TMN2EUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $3,318 $6,827 $14,076 T_72_TMN2ETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $8,595 $17,809 $37,036 T_72_TMN2ETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $5,021 $10,404 $21,636 T_72_TMN2ETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $3,829 $7,935 $16,501 T_72_TMN2IEblank rowIN blank row . . . T_72_TMN2IEBassIN Bass $6,973 $14,667 $31,045 T_72_TMN2IEOther TroutIN Other Trout $3 $6 $10 T_72_TMN2IEPanfishIN Panfish $1,666 $3,332 $6,633 T_72_TMN2IESalmonIN Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_72_TMN2IESmall GameIN Small Game $38 $126 $426 T_72_TMN2IEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $639 $1,323 $2,750 T_72_TMN2IEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $6,433 $13,236 $27,290 T_72_TMN2IETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $15,751 $32,690 $68,154 T_72_TMN2IETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $9,578 $19,879 $41,449

rec ben tables 33 of 36T_72_TMN2IETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $7,361 $15,277 $31,856

Table 73: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN3 IN

tag Species Name T_73 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_73 White bass White bass T_73Total (Bass) Total (Bass) T_73 Whitefish Whitefish T_73Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) T_73 Black bullhead Black bullhead T_73 Black crappie Black crappie T_73 Bluegill Bluegill T_73 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead T_73 Bullhead Bullhead T_73 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_73 Crappie Crappie T_73 Menhaden Menhaden T_73 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt T_73 Smelts Smelts T_73 Sunfish Sunfish T_73 White perch White perch T_73 Yellow perch Yellow perch T_73Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_73 Salmon Salmon T_73Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) T_73 American shad American shad T_73 Striped bass Striped bass T_73 Sturgeon Sturgeon T_73Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_73 Northern pike Northern pike T_73 Sauger Sauger T_73 Walleye Walleye T_73Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_73Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_73Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 74: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN3 IN

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_74_TMN3Iblank rowIN blank row . . . T_74_TMN3IBassIN Bass $3,295 $6,931 $14,670 T_74_TMN3IOther TroutIN Other Trout $3 $5 $10 T_74_TMN3IPanfishIN Panfish $699 $1,398 $2,782 T_74_TMN3ISalmonIN Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_74_TMN3ISmall GameIN Small Game $36 $121 $407 T_74_TMN3IWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $48 $100 $209 T_74_TMN3IUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $3,145 $6,471 $13,342 T_74_TMN3ITotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $7,226 $15,026 $31,420 T_74_TMN3ITotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $4,511 $9,381 $19,615 T_74_TMN3ITotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $3,447 $7,167 $14,987 T_74_TMN3Eblank rowIN blank row . . . T_74_TMN3EBassIN Bass $3,880 $8,162 $17,276 T_74_TMN3EOther TroutIN Other Trout $0 $0 $0 T_74_TMN3EPanfishIN Panfish $1,019 $2,038 $4,056 T_74_TMN3ESalmonIN Salmon . . . T_74_TMN3ESmall GameIN Small Game $2 $7 $23

rec ben tables 34 of 36T_74_TMN3EWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $618 $1,280 $2,660

T_74_TMN3EUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $3,471 $7,141 $14,724 T_74_TMN3ETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $8,990 $18,628 $38,740 T_74_TMN3ETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $5,455 $11,303 $23,507 T_74_TMN3ETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $4,145 $8,588 $17,860 T_74_TMN3IEblank rowIN blank row . . . T_74_TMN3IEBassIN Bass $7,175 $15,092 $31,946 T_74_TMN3IEOther TroutIN Other Trout $3 $6 $11 T_74_TMN3IEPanfishIN Panfish $1,718 $3,436 $6,838 T_74_TMN3IESalmonIN Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_74_TMN3IESmall GameIN Small Game $38 $128 $430 T_74_TMN3IEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $666 $1,381 $2,869 T_74_TMN3IEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $6,616 $13,612 $28,066 T_74_TMN3IETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $16,216 $33,654 $70,160 T_74_TMN3IETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $9,966 $20,684 $43,122 T_74_TMN3IETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $7,592 $15,755 $32,847

Table 75: Recreational I+E Reductions by Species: TMN4 IN

tag Species Name T_75 Smallmouth bass Smallmouth bass T_75 White bass White bass T_75Total (Bass) Total (Bass) T_75 Whitefish Whitefish T_75Total (Other Trout) Total (Other Trout) T_75 Black bullhead Black bullhead T_75 Black crappie Black crappie T_75 Bluegill Bluegill T_75 Brown bullhead Brown bullhead T_75 Bullhead Bullhead T_75 Channel catfish Channel catfish T_75 Crappie Crappie T_75 Menhaden Menhaden T_75 Rainbow smelt Rainbow smelt T_75 Smelts Smelts T_75 Sunfish Sunfish T_75 White perch White perch T_75 Yellow perch Yellow perch T_75Total (Panfish) Total (Panfish) T_75 Salmon Salmon T_75Total (Salmon) Total (Salmon) T_75 American shad American shad T_75 Striped bass Striped bass T_75 Sturgeon Sturgeon T_75Total (Small Game) Total (Small Game) T_75 Northern pike Northern pike T_75 Sauger Sauger T_75 Walleye Walleye T_75Total (Walleye/Pike) Total (Walleye/Pike) T_75Total (Unidentified) Total (Unidentified) T_75Total (All Species) Total (All Species)

Table 76: Recreational I+E Reductions by Region: TMN4 IN

tag Species GroupLow Benefit Mean Benefit

High Benefit T_76_TMN4Iblank rowIN blank row . . . T_76_TMN4IBassIN Bass $2,755 $5,796 $12,268

rec ben tables 35 of 36T_76_TMN4IOther TroutIN Other Trout $2 $5 $8

T_76_TMN4IPanfishIN Panfish $584 $1,169 $2,326 T_76_TMN4ISalmonIN Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4ISmall GameIN Small Game $30 $101 $340 T_76_TMN4IWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $41 $84 $175 T_76_TMN4IUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $2,630 $5,411 $11,157 T_76_TMN4ITotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $6,043 $12,566 $26,275 T_76_TMN4ITotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $4,947 $10,287 $21,511 T_76_TMN4ITotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $4,513 $9,384 $19,623 T_76_TMN4Eblank rowIN blank row . . . T_76_TMN4EBassIN Bass $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4EOther TroutIN Other Trout $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4EPanfishIN Panfish $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4ESalmonIN Salmon . . . T_76_TMN4ESmall GameIN Small Game $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4EWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4EUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4ETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4ETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4ETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4IEblank rowIN blank row . . . T_76_TMN4IEBassIN Bass $2,755 $5,796 $12,268 T_76_TMN4IEOther TroutIN Other Trout $2 $5 $8 T_76_TMN4IEPanfishIN Panfish $584 $1,169 $2,326 T_76_TMN4IESalmonIN Salmon $0 $0 $0 T_76_TMN4IESmall GameIN Small Game $30 $101 $340 T_76_TMN4IEWalleye/PikeIN Walleye/Pike $41 $84 $175 T_76_TMN4IEUnidentifiedIN Unidentified $2,630 $5,411 $11,157 T_76_TMN4IETotal (Undiscounted)IN Total (Undiscounted) $6,043 $12,566 $26,275 T_76_TMN4IETotal (3% Discount Rate)IN Total (3% Discount Rate) $4,947 $10,287 $21,511 T_76_TMN4IETotal (7% Discount Rate)IN Total (7% Discount Rate) $4,513 $9,384 $19,623

rec ben tables 36 of 36