I

103D CONGRESS

1ST SESSION H. R. 3429

To provide relief to State and local governments from Federal regulation.

IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

NOVEMBER 3, 1993

Mr. HERGER introduced the following bill; which was referred to the

Committee on Government Operations

A BILL

To provide relief to State and local governments from

Federal regulation.

1 Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representa2 tives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

3 That this Act may be cited as the ‘‘Unfunded Federal

4 Mandates Relief Act of 1993’’.

5 FINDINGS AND PURPOSE

6 SEC. 2. (a) The Congress finds and declares that—

7 (1) Federal regulation of State and local gov8 ernments has become increasingly extensive and in9 trusive in recent years;
2

•HR 3429 IH

1 (2) such regulation has, adversely affected

2 State and local governments by placing excessive fis3 cal burdens on such governments;

4 (3) such excessive fiscal burdens have weakened

5 the foundation of the Federal system of government;

6 and

7 (4) there is a lack of adequate fiscal resources

8 to carry out necessary Federal regulation of State

9 and local governments in order to enable such gov10 ernments to comply with intergovernmental regula11 tions currently in effect.

12 (b) Therefore, it is the purpose of this Act to estab13 lish procedures to assure that the Federal Government

14 pays the total amount of additional direct costs incurred

15 by State and local governments in complying with any

16 intergovernmental regulation.

17 DEFINITIONS

18 SEC. 3. For purposes of this Act, the term—

19 (1) ‘‘additional direct costs’’ means the amount

20 of costs incurred by a State or local government

21 solely in complying with an intergovernmental regu22 lation promulgated pursuant to a Federal law con23 cerning a particular activity which is in excess of the

24 amount that such State or local government would

25 be required to expend in carrying out such activity

26 in the absence of such law, except that such term
3

•HR 3429 IH

1 does not include any amount which a State or local

2 government is required by law to contribute as a

3 non-Federal share under a Federal assistance pro4 gram;

5 (2) ‘‘Director’’ means the Director of the Office

6 of Management and Budget;

7 (3) ‘‘Federal agency’’ has the meaning given to

8 the term ‘‘executive agency’’ in section 6501(3) of

9 title 31, United States Code;

10 (4) ‘‘Federal assistance’’ means any assistance

11 provided by a Federal agency to State and local gov12 ernments or other recipients, in the form of grants,

13 loans, loan guarantees, property, cooperative agree14 ments, or technical assistance, except that such term

15 does not include direct cash assistance to individ16 uals, contracts for the procurement of goods or serv17 ices for the United States, or insurance;

18 (5) ‘‘intergovernmental regulation’’ means a

19 regulation promulgated by a Federal agency that re20 quires a State or local government to take certain

21 actions or requires a State or local government to

22 comply with certain specified conditions in order to

23 receive or continue to receive Federal assistance and

24 which requires the termination or reduction of such
4

•HR 3429 IH

1 assistance if such government fails to comply with

2 such conditions;

3 (6) ‘‘local government’’ has the same meaning

4 as in section 6501(6) of title 31, United States

5 Code;

6 (7) ‘‘significant law’’ means any Federal law

7 which is likely to result in additional direct costs to

8 State and local governments; and

9 (8) ‘‘State’’ means each of the several States,

10 the District of Columbia, Guam, the Commonwealth

11 of Puerto Rico, the Commonwealth of the Northern

12 Mariana Islands, the Virgin Islands, American

13 Samoa, and the Trust Territory of the Pacific Is14 lands.

15 TITLE I—REVIEW OF INTERGOVERNMENTAL

16 REGULATIONS

17 REPORT REQUIRED

18 SEC. 101. (a) Not later than thirty days after the

19 date on which the President transmits a budget for a fiscal

20 year to the Congress pursuant to section 1105 of title 31,

21 United States Code, the President shall submit to the

22 Congress a report specifying and evaluating the economic

23 costs, noneconomic costs, and additional direct costs which

24 have been incurred or which will be incurred by State gov25 ernments and local governments in complying with inter-
5

•HR 3429 IH

1 governmental regulations during the most recently com2 pleted fiscal year, the fiscal year in progress, and the first

3 two fiscal years immediately succeeding the fiscal year in

4 progress.

5 (b) Each report required under subsection (a) shall

6 include—

7 (1) a list of each intergovernmental regulation

8 in effect during each fiscal year for which the report

9 is made and a citation of statutory and administra10 tive authority for each such intergovernmental regu11 lation;

12 (2) an estimate, for each such intergovern13 mental regulation, of—

14 (A) the total amount of economic costs,

15 noneconomic costs, and additional direct costs

16 that have been incurred or will be incurred in

17 each such fiscal year by the government of each

18 State and all local governments in such State in

19 complying with such regulation in each such fis20 cal year; and

21 (B) the ratio (stated as a percentage)

22 which the total amount of additional direct

23 costs that have been incurred or will be in24 curred by all local governments in a State in

25 complying with such regulation in each such fis-
6

•HR 3429 IH

1 cal year bears to the total amount of additional

2 direct costs that have been incurred or will be

3 incurred by the government of such State and

4 all local governments in such State in comply5 ing with such regulation in such fiscal year;

6 (3) an estimate, for each such regulation, of the

7 economic and noneconomic benefits that will be pro8 vided in each such fiscal year to each State govern9 ment and all local governments in such State as a

10 result of compliance with such regulation during

11 each such fiscal year;

12 (4) recommendations for changes in laws and

13 regulations that will reduce the costs specified pur14 suant to paragraph (2), or that will achieve a more

15 favorable balance between the benefits specified pur16 suant to paragraph (3) and the costs specified pur17 suant to paragraph (2); and

18 (5) proposals for legislation, and a statement of

19 planned administrative actions, to implement the

20 recommendations specified pursuant to paragraph

21 (4).

22 PROCEDURES FOR PREPARATION OF REPORT

23 SEC. 102. (a) The President may delegate to the Di24 rector or to the head of any other Federal agency the re25 sponsibility for preparing the annual report required by

26 section 101.
7

•HR 3429 IH

1 (b)(1) In carrying out the provisions of this title, the

2 President, the Director, or the head of a Federal agency

3 to which a delegation is made under subsection (a), shall

4 prescribe standards to be used by Federal agencies in esti5 mating the costs of compliance with, and the benefits pro6 vided by, intergovernmental regulations administered by

7 such agencies.

8 (2) The President, the Director, or the head of a Fed9 eral agency to which a delegation is made under subsection

10 (a) shall prescribe the standards required under para11 graph (1)—

12 (A) after consultation with State and local gov13 ernments and the Comptroller General of the United

14 States; and

15 (B) after providing public notice and an oppor16 tunity for comment in accordance with section 553

17 of title 5, United States Code.

18 (3) Standards prescribed under paragraph (1) may

19 be revised from time to time to reflect changes in relevant

20 economic and social circumstances and advances in perti21 nent branches of knowledge.

22 (c) The standards prescribed under subsection (b)

23 shall provide, to the extent possible, for—
8

•HR 3429 IH

1 (1) uniform categories of costs of compliance

2 with, and benefits provided by, intergovernmental

3 regulations;

4 (2) methods to be used by the President, and

5 by Federal agencies, in estimating the additional di6 rect costs that will be incurred by State and local

7 governments in complying with each intergovern8 mental regulation, including methods to estimate the

9 amount of such costs that will be incurred for each

10 fiscal year in which each such regulation is in effect;

11 (3) methods to be used by Federal agencies in

12 compiling the information required to be submitted

13 under subsection (d) which shall be designed to—

14 (A) minimize the costs that will be in15 curred by the State and local governments and

16 the Federal assistance recipients from which

17 such information will be collected; and

18 (B) ensure the collection of reasonably ac19 curate information in a form that will be useful

20 to States in complying with section 204(c);

21 (4) methods for preventing disclosure of infor22 mation about individuals or businesses the confiden23 tiality of which is protected under Federal law;
9

•HR 3429 IH

1 (5) procedures to be followed by Federal agen2 cies in reporting the information required to be sub3 mitted under subsection (d); and

4 (6) such other procedures and guidelines as

5 may be necessary for the implementation of this

6 title.

7 (d) Each year, at a time prescribed by the President,

8 the Director, or the head of the Federal agency to which

9 a delegation is made under subsection (a), the head of

10 each Federal agency which administered any intergovern11 mental regulation during a fiscal year for which a report

12 is required under section 101, shall prepare and submit

13 to the President, the Director, or such agency head, a re14 port setting forth, for each such regulation, the informa15 tion required to be included for such regulation in the re16 port required under section 101.

17 TITLE II—COMPENSATION OF STATE AND

18 LOCAL GOVERNMENTS FOR ADDITIONAL

19 DIRECT COSTS

20 COMPENSATION REQUIRED

21 SEC. 201. (a) A Federal agency or a court of the

22 United States shall not require State governments or local

23 governments to comply, in any fiscal year, with any inter24 governmental regulation unless provisions of law have

25 been enacted which provide a sufficient amount of funds
10

•HR 3429 IH

1 for such fiscal year to reimburse such governments for the

2 total amount of additional direct costs that will be in3 curred by such governments in complying with such regu4 lation during such fiscal year.

5 (b) For purposes of this section, the total amount of

6 additional direct costs that will be incurred by State gov7 ernments and local governments in complying with an

8 intergovernmental regulation in any fiscal year shall be the

9 total amount of such costs for such regulation estimated

10 by the Director of the Congressional Budget Office for

11 such fiscal year in the report required under section 202

12 for such fiscal year.

13 REPORT BY THE DIRECTOR OF THE CONGRESSIONAL

14 BUDGET OFFICE

15 SEC. 202. (a) For each fiscal year in which an inter16 governmental regulation promulgated pursuant to a sig17 nificant law will be in effect, the Director of the Congres18 sional Budget Office shall prepare and transmit to the

19 President and the Congress a report specifying, for such

20 fiscal year and the fiscal year succeeding such fiscal year,

21 an estimate of the total amount of additional direct costs

22 that will be incurred by State governments and local gov23 ernments in complying with such regulation in each such

24 fiscal year.

25 (b) In preparing each report required by subsection

26 (a), the Director of the Congressional Budget Office shall
11

•HR 3429 IH

1 consider the estimate of additional direct costs for a fiscal

2 year resulting from compliance with an intergovernmental

3 regulation which are specified in the report submitted by

4 the President under title I during the fiscal year preceding

5 such fiscal year.

6 (c) The Director of the Congressional Budget Office

7 shall transmit each report required by subsection (a) for

8 a fiscal year to the President and the Congress by Septem9 ber 1 of the fiscal year preceding such fiscal year.

10 IMPLEMENTATION

11 SEC. 203. For each fiscal year in which an intergov12 ernmental regulation promulgated pursuant to a signifi13 cant law will be in effect, the chairman of the committees

14 of the Senate and of the House of Representatives having

15 legislative jurisdiction over such significant law shall pro16 pose, to an appropriate bill or resolution providing funds

17 for such fiscal year, an amendment containing provisions

18 to appropriate funds to reimburse State governments and

19 local governments for the additional direct costs incurred

20 in complying with such regulation. The amount of funds

21 proposed to be appropriated by such amendment shall be

22 equal to or in excess of the amount described in section

23 201(a).
12

•HR 3429 IH

1 PROCEDURES FOR REIMBURSEMENTS TO STATE AND

2 LOCAL GOVERNMENTS

3 SEC. 204. (a)(1) The head of each Federal agency

4 which administers an intergovernmental regulation pro5 mulgated pursuant to a significant law shall pay to each

6 State government in each fiscal year the amount deter7 mined pursuant to this section to reimburse the State gov8 ernment and local governments in the State for the addi9 tional direct costs incurred by such governments in com10 plying with such regulation in such fiscal year.

11 (2) A State government which receives payments

12 under this section for reimbursement for additional direct

13 costs incurred in complying with an intergovernmental

14 regulation in any fiscal year shall pay to each local govern15 ment in the State the amount determined pursuant to this

16 section to reimburse such local government for the addi17 tional direct costs incurred by such local government in

18 complying with such regulation in such fiscal year.

19 (b) The total amount to be paid to a State to reim20 burse the government of the State and local governments

21 in the State for additional direct costs incurred by such

22 governments in complying with an intergovernmental reg23 ulation in any fiscal year shall be an amount which bears

24 the same ratio to the total amount for reimbursement of

25 additional direct costs for all State governments and local
13

•HR 3429 IH

1 governments described in section 201(a) with respect to

2 such regulation for such fiscal year as the total amount

3 of additional direct costs with respect to such regulation

4 which is specified in the report submitted by the President

5 under title I for such fiscal year for such State government

6 and local governments in such State for such fiscal year

7 bears to the sum of the total amounts of additional direct

8 costs with respect to such regulation which are specified

9 in such report for all State governments and all local gov10 ernments for such fiscal year.

11 (c)(1) The total amount to be paid by a State govern12 ment to local governments in such State to reimburse such

13 governments for additional direct costs incurred by such

14 governments in complying with an intergovernmental reg15 ulation in any fiscal year shall be the amount which is

16 equal to the product of the amount paid to the State under

17 subsection (b) for such fiscal year multiplied by the ratio

18 determined by the President for such State with respect

19 to such regulation for such fiscal year pursuant to section

20 101(b)(2)(B).

21 (2)(A) A State government which receives payments

22 under this section to reimburse local governments in the

23 State for the additional direct costs incurred by such gov24 ernments in complying with an intergovernmental regula-
14

•HR 3429 IH

1 tion in any fiscal year shall pay to each such local govern2 ment an amount equal to the product of—

3 (i) the total amount determined under para4 graph (1) with respect to such regulation for such

5 fiscal year, multiplied by

6 (ii) the ratio (stated as a percentage and esti7 mated by the State in accordance with subparagraph

8 (B)) that the total amount of additional direct costs

9 incurred by such local government in complying with

10 such regulation in such fiscal year bears to the total

11 amount of additional direct costs incurred by all

12 local governments in such State in complying with

13 such regulation in such fiscal year.

14 (B) Each State government which receives payments

15 under this section for any fiscal year shall provide by law

16 for the estimation of the amount of additional direct costs

17 incurred by each local government in such State in com18 plying with an intergovernmental regulation for which

19 such payments are received. In providing for the esti20 mation of such costs, the State shall establish procedures

21 and methods for the estimation of such costs which are

22 reasonably related to the actual additional direct costs in23 curred by such governments in complying with such regu24 lation in such fiscal year.
15

•HR 3429 IH

1 EFFECT OF SUBSEQUENT ENACTMENTS

2 SEC. 205. No law enacted after the date of enactment

3 of this title shall supersede the provisions of this title un4 less such law does so in specific terms, referring to this

5 title, and declares that such law supersedes the provisions

6 of this title.

Æ