06/18/2010 15:36 FAX 9072577814 1210002/0007 

DORSEY & 

WHITNEY LLP 

1031 West Fointfa 

Avenue 

Suite 600 

^chorage.AK 99501-

5907 

(907)276-4557 

'•';''K-:-':PpRIATiONJAHNA M. LINDEMUTH, ABA #9711068 

DORSEY & WHITNEY LLP 2 

1031 West Fourth Avenue 

Suite 600 

Anchorage. AK 99501-5907 

(907) 276^557 

ATTORNEYS FOR 

ALASKA AIRLINES, INC., STEPHEN CAMP and TIM COOK 

UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

WASHINGTON, D.C. 

IN THE MATTER OF 

SMITH CABLE SYSTEMS, INC. 

FAA DOCKET NO. CP09AL0012 

(Civil Penalty Action) 

DMS NO. FAA-2009-0976 

MOTION TO QUASH OR MODIFY CIVIL PENALTY SUBPOENAS 

_ Alaska Airlines, Inc., and its employees Tim Cook and Stephen Camp 

(collectively "Movants"), move to quash or modify the two subpoenas issued by the 

Federal Aviation Administration ('TAA") to Cook and Camp, attached hereto as Exhibits 

A and B, imder 14 C.F.R. § 13.228(b). The subpoenas require third parties Cook and 

Camp, Alaska AirlinesVemployees who ILv^ andiworkdn Ke(tchikan,;Alaska, to^^pear 

and testify in person in Anchorage at the Jime 25,2010 hearing scheduled in this matter. 

There are no non-stop, scheduled flints between Ketchikan and Anchorage. Air travel 

betwewi these cities requires stops in Sitka and Juneau, for a joximey of nearly five hours, 

or a connection in Seattle (700 nules to the south), for a jourpey of at least seven hours. 

(See ht^://www.alaskaair.com/shopping/ssl/schedule.aspx.) 

MOTION TO QUASH OR MODIFY CIVIL 

PENALTY SUBPOENAS 

Page 1 of4 

In the Matter of Smith Cable Systems, Inc. 

DMS NO. FAA-2009-0976 
06/18/2010 15:36 FAX 9072577814 110003/0007 

DORSEY & 

WHITNEY LLP 

1031 West Fourth 

Avcnoe 

Suite 600 

^oohonieB, AK 99501-

5907 

(907)276-4557 

Movants xmderstand that the FAA has filed an expedited motion to allow Cook 

and Camp to testify telephonicaily imder the subpoenas. If the FAA's motion is granted, 

Movants withdraw this motion. In the event it is not granted. Movants object that the 

subpoenas are unreasonable and burdensome to Movants, and ask that they either be 

quashed or modified, as described below. 

Movants understand that the FAA wants to solicit testimony from Camp and Cook 

that they saw and removed two propane fuel containers and one can of spray paint from 

cargo shipped by Smith Cable Systems. Given the scope of possible testimony, each 

witness should testify for no more than ten minutes. As stated in the FAA's motion to 

permit telephonic participation, due to the travel time and distance involved. Camp and 

Cook would likely miss three days of work during Alaska Airlines' busy summer season. 

Alaska Airlines' Ketchikan operation is small, and it would be adversely impacted to 

have two of its employees gone for three days at the same time. 

Movants want to accommodate the FAA and provide testimony, and have worked 

diligently with the^parties in this matter to resolve this issue. Movants fully support the 

FAA's expedited motion to allow Camp and Cook to give telephonic testimony. In the 

alternative, if that motion is not granted. Movants request one of the following 

modifications, in order of preference: 

li'^^'^Canipand Cook only%erequiriEJd to appear^and-testify at perpetuation 

depositions in Ketchikan, Alaska, or appear by video conference, so that they could be 

subject to examination by both parties, in lieu of appearing at the hearing in Anchorage. 

MOTION TO QUASH OR MODIFY CIVIL /„ the Matter of Smith Cable Systems, Inc. 

PENALTDTiSJ^Q^A^xaji-sgwiCTiomiuuKa^ NO. FAA-2009-0976 

Page 2 of4 
06/18/2010 15:36 FAI 9072577814 1210004/0007 

, I . • I , 

DORSEY & 

WHTTNEYLLP 

1031 West Fourth 

Avenue 

Suite 600 

<Uichon8e.AK 99501-

5907 

(907)276-4557 

2. That the subpoena for one witness be quashed on the grounds that the 

testimony sought from both witnesses is duplicative, so that only one Alaska Airlines' 

employee be requhed to appear and testify in Anchorage. 

3. If one or both witness are required to appear and testify in Anchorage, that 

the parties be required to complete both witnesses' examination by 11:00 a.m. on June 

2S, 2010, so that they may return to Ketchikan that same day and only miss two instead 

of three days of work. 

Movants' preference is that Camp and Cook be allowed to testify telephonicaily. 

If this is not allowed. Movants ask that the subpoenas be quashed or modified as set forth 

herein. 

DATED this 11 day of June, 2010, at Anchorage, Alaska. 

.x^.,.^ v. .i K-<: u.^ v... t^^.,DORSE^& WHITNEY LLP 

Attorneys For 

Alaska Airlines, Inc., Stephen Camp, 

Tim Cook 

By:. 

• cf- Kfi ->TOt«vrJa&pd M. Lindemuth, ABA #9711068 

n 

MOTION TO QUASH OR MODIFY CIVIL 

PENALTY SUBPOENAS 

In the Matter of Smith Cable Systems, Inc. 

DMS NO. FAA-2009-0976 

Page 3 of4 
06/18/2010 15:36 FAX 9072577814 1^0005/0007 

DORSEY& 

WHTTNEYLLP 

1031 West Fourth 

Avenue 

Siiite600 

^i>ctiocage,AK 99501-

5907 

(907)276-4557 

CERTIFICATB OF SERVICE 

I certify that on this fj; day of June, 2010,1 have served a copy of the forgoing by 

postage-prepaid, certified mail, return receipt requested, facsimile, and email to; 

The Honorable Richard C. Goodwin 

Administrative Law Judge 

Office of Hearings, M-20 

U.S. Department of Transportation 

1200 New Jersey Avenue, S-E. 

East BuildingGround Floor, Room E12-320 

Washington, DC 20590 

Fax: (202)366-7536 

Email: Richard.Goodwin(a).dot.gpv 

I further certify that on this fs day oTJune, 2010,1 have served the original and two 

copies of the forgoing by postage-prepaid, certified mail, return receipt requested, and 

facsimile to: ' 

Federal Aviation Administration 

ATTN: Docket Clerk, AGC-430 

Wilbur Wri^t Building - Room 2014 

800 Independence Avenue, SW 

Washington, DC 20591 

Fax: (202)493-5020 

I further certify that on this [ 3 day of Jxme, 2010,1 have served a copy of the forgoing 

bypostage-prepaidjfirst-classjtnairand facsimile ^to^^ ^^- ^r 

Brent R. Cole 

Marston & Cole, P.C. 

821 N Street, Suite 208 

Anchorage, Alaska 99501 

Fax: (907)277-8002 

Craig Wm. Black 

Fed^al Aviation^Administration 

OfficeofRfigibhaiCounsel, , 

222 West'7®Avenue, Box 14, AAL-7 

Anchorage, Alaska 99513-7587 

JaDha M. Lindemuth, ABA #9711068 

> ..-v|X«i<i(yjc«i:Avenae,. ti w 

•ton. Df^'2059! 

MOTION TO QUASH OR MODIFY CIVIL 

PENALTY SUBPOENAS 

. v> "..^ i ijiMey/¥t1»Sfcai5g»-yD 0 u » • 

In the Matter of Smith Cable Systems. Inc. 

DMS NO. FAA-2009-0976 
06/18/2010 15:36 FAX 9072577814 12)0006/0007 

U,S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION 

CIVIL PENALTY SUBPOENA 

In the Matter of: Docket No.: CP09AL0012 

SV^;T" CABLE SYSTEMS INC. DMS No,: 2009-0976 

.j.^ . „ TIH COOK 

luucd on: 5/I2/2QIQ 

Under 14 C.F.R. § 13.228(8), YOU ARE REQUIRKD: 

n To appov and testify before an Administrative Law Judge of tho Department of TtwispoitaUon 

at: 1T,° "Iffrl"* - ^""^«', ">">"> «"••» 7»t. A-iro^nc , ___ 

tn the city of A^>,K»^,^^^ A1 ,oVo ondie 25th d^o f June 2ao . 

at Q'fin am 

r i TO appear and test) (V at a deposition to be conducted ^ : 

at: ; 

in tiie city of , on the . day of 20 

at am 

[~| TO bring with you and produce tiie following documents, records, papers, boolcs, and tangible items: 

If you have any questions about this subpoena, contact firwlB "m, ""'•"'^ 

at this address and telephone number 999 »,««• 7«-v A-ro^..^ <iA. An^T.nT-aya. ATC QQSI ^ 

'>n7.97i-^'i7n :^ 

kjyL^ t ^<MA^ 

Stephanie McClain 

Hearing Doclcct Clerk 

Auttority: 14 C.F.R.{ 13.228; 49 U.S.C.9SS12rand L470)(l).or49U.S.CS946IO4and I0ti(g)(1) 

ANY PERSON WHO DOES NOT OBEY THIS SUBPOENA IS SUBJECT TO 

FINE OR IMPRISONMENT OR BOTH UNDER 49 U.S.C § 46313. 

!^7-0i-:y^7n _ 

' EXHIBIT /V 

Page _ ] of _X 
06/18/2010 15:36 FAI 9072577814 1210007/0007 

UJS. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 

FEDERAL AVUTION ADMINISTRATION 

• -_, . _ ; — . • • • • '. \ •••' • -i - ' - .•-/- ' 

CIVIL PENALTY SUBPOENA 

l a the Matter of: 

SMITH CABLE SYSTEMS INC. 

Docket No.: 

DMS No.: 

issued on: 

CP09AL0012 

2009-0976 

5/i2/201Q 

To: qTBTORW r.JMP 

B 

Under 14 CF.R. § 13.228(a), YOU ARE REQUIRED: 

To appear and testify before an Administrative Law Judge of die Department of Transportation 

at: p.t; T^jgrrlrt ^""^t, ^^^ Wotn- 7^>1 A^omiP ] 

in the city of A-nnt^nr-a^o, AlanTca 

at OiOn L_ani 

on the 7-Sfh day of June 

r i To appear and testify at a deposition to be conducted by: 

at: : 

2010 

in the city of 

at am 

on the day of 

Q To bring with you and produce the following documents, records, papers, books, and tai^ible items: 

20 

If you have any questions about this subpoena, contact r-rfl-fg Um, wi«oV 

at this address and telephone number: 99? v^^t- 7^^ ^^T^r^„t^ <1A. Anrhnrnp*.-AK Q^s n 

-"vi<;•>.'r • • , 907-27 1 ~.157Q ^'^^'^ ""'"• -'ap^-.nn-T< 

- i • aras^&i^ALaaJta:; -~- on the- . ?.sVvi--mf>hzzr^izy\{'il<^ 

Stephanie McCIain 

Hearing Docket Clerk 

Authority: I4C.F.R.; I3.228;49 U.S.C jj 5121 ond 1.47G)( I )> or 49 U.S.C $S 46104 and 106(g)(1) 

ANY PERSON WHO DOES NOT OBEY THIS SUBPOENA IS SUBJECT TO 

FINE OR IMPRISONMENT OR BOTH UNDER 49 U.S.C § 46313. 

rvii I IT m \ \-

EXHIBIT ;fe_ 

Page_ i ori[ _