06/18/201 0 15:3 6 FA X 907257781 4 1210002/000 7

DORSE Y & WHITNE Y LL P 103 1 Wes t Fointf a Avenu e Suit e 60 0 ^chorage.A K

99501 - 590 7 (907)276-455 7 

### '•';''K-:-':PpRIATiON JAHNA M . LINDEMUTH , AB A #971106 8 DORSE Y & WHITNE

Y LLP 2 103 1 Wes t Fourt h Avenu e Suit e 60 0 Anchorage . A K

99501-590 7 (907 ) 276^55 7 ATTORNEY S FO R ALASK A AIRLINES , INC. , STEPHE N CAMP andTI M COO K UNITE D STATE S DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC E O F HEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C . I N TH E MATTERO F SMIT H CABL E SYSTEMS , INC . FA A DOCKET NO . CP09AL001 2 (Civi l Penalt

y Action ) DM S NO . FAA-2009-097 6 MOTIO N T O QUAS H O RMODIF Y CIVI L PENALT Y SUBPOENA S

_Alask aAirlines , Inc. , an dit s employee s Ti mCoo k andStephen Cam

p (collectivel y "Movants") , mov e t o quas h o r modif y th e tw o subpoena s issue d b y th e Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n ('TAA" ) t o Coo k an dCamp , attache dhereto a s Exhibit s A an dB , imder

1 4 C.F.R . § 13.228(b) . Th e subpoena s require thirdpartie s Coo k an d Camp , Alask aAirlinesVemployee s wh o ILv ^ andiworkdn Ke(tchikan,;Alaska , to^^pear an dtestif y in perso n in Anchorag e at th e Jim e 25,201 0 hearin g schedule di n thi s matter . Ther e are n o non-stop , schedule dflint s betwee n Ketchika n an dAnchorage . Air

trave l betwew i thes e citie s require s stop s i n Sitkaan dJuneau , fo r ajoximey o f

nearl y five hours , o r aconnectio n i n Seattl e (70 0 nule s t o th e south) , fo r ajourpe y o f

a t leas t seve n hours . (Se e ht^://www.alaskaair.com/shopping/ssl/schedule.aspx. ) MOTIO N T O QUAS H O R MODIF Y CIVI L PENALT Y SUBPOENA S Pag e 1 of

4 I n th e Matte r o f Smit h Cabl e Systems , Inc . DM S NO . FAA-2009-097 606/18/201 0 15:3 6 FA X 907257781 4 110003/000 7

DORSE Y & WHITNE Y LL P 103 1 Wes t Fourt h Avcno e Suite 60 0 ^oohonieB , A

K 99501 - 590 7 (907)276-455 7 Movant s xmderstan dthat th e FA A ha s fileda

n expedite dmotio n t o allo w Coo k andCam p t o testif y telephonicail y imde

r th e subpoenas . I f

th e FAA' s motio n i s granted , Movant s withdra

w thi s motion . I n th e event i t i s no t granted . Movant s object

tha t th e subpoena s are unreasonabl e andburdensome t o Movants , an das k that the y eithe r b e quashe do r

modified , a s describe dbelow . Movant s understan dtha

t th e FAA want s t o solici t

testimon y fromCam

p and Coo k that they saw an dremove dtw o propan e fue l container s an don e can o f spra y paint from carg o shippe db y Smit

h Cabl e Systems . Given th e scop e o f possibl e testimony , eac h witnes s shoul dtestif

y fo r n o more than te n minutes . A s state di n th e FAA' s motio n t o permi t telephoni c participation , du e t o th e trave l tim e an ddistanc e involved . Cam p an d Coo k woul dlikel y mis s thre e day s o f wor k durin g Alask aAirlines ' bus y summe r season . Alask aAirlines ' Ketchika

n operatio n i s small , an di t woul db e adversely impacte d to hav e tw o o f

it s employee s gon e fo

r thre e day s a

t th e sam e time . Movant s want

t o accommodate th e FAA an dprovid e testimony , an dhav e worked diligentl y wit

h the^partie s i n thi s matte r

t o resolv e thi s issue . Movant s full y suppor t th e FAA' s expedite dmotio n t o allo w Cam p andCoo k

t o giv e telephoni c testimony . I n th e alternative , i f

tha t motio n i s no t

granted . Movant s reques t

on e o f th e following modifications , i n order

o f preference : li'^^'^Canipan dCoo k

only%erequiriEJ

dt o appear^and-testif

y at perpetuatio n deposition s i n Ketchikan , Alaska , o r appea r b y vide o conference , s o tha t they coul d b e subjec t t o examinatio n b y bot

h parties , i n lie u o f

appearin g a

t th e hearin g i n Anchorage . MOTIO N T O QUAS H O RMODIF Y CIVI L / „ th e Matte r

o f Smit h Cabl e Systems , Inc . PENALTDTiSJ^Q^A^xaji-sgwiCTiomiuuKa ^ NO . FAA-2009-097 6 Pag e 2 of 406/18/201 0 15:3 6 FA I 907257781 4 1210004/000 7

, I . • I ,

DORSE Y & WHTTNEYLL P 103 1 Wes t Fourt h Avenu e Suite 60 0 <Uichon8e.A K

99501 - 590 7 (907)276-455 7 2 . Tha t th e subpoen afo r

on e witnes s b e quashe do n th e ground s that th e testimon y sought

frombot h witnesse s i s duplicative , s o that only on e AlaskaAirlines ' employe e b e requhe dt o appea r andtestif y i n Anchorage . 3 . I f on e o r bot h witnes s ar

e require dt o appea

r an dtestif y i n Anchorage , tha

t th e partie s b e require dt o complete bot h witnesses ' examinatio n b y 11:0 0 a.m . on Jun e 2S , 2010 , s o that

the y ma y retur n t o Ketchika

n that sam e da y an donl y mis s tw o instea

d o f thre e day s o f

work . Movants ' preferenc e i s tha t Cam p andCook

b e allowe dt o testif

y telephonicaily . I f thi s i s no t allowed . Movant s as k

that th e subpoena s b e quashe do r modifie d a s set

fort h herein . DATED thi s 

# 1 1 da y o f June , 2010 , at

Anchorage , Alaska . .x^.,. ^ v . . i K-< : u. ^ v.. . t^^.,DORSE^ & WHITNE Y LLP Attorney s Fo r Alask aAirlines , Inc. , Stephen Camp , Ti mCook By: . • cf - Kf i ->TOt«vr Ja&p d M . Lindemuth , AB A #971106 8

n MOTIO N T O QUAS H O R MODIF Y CIVI L PENALT Y SUBPOENA S I n th e Matte r o f Smit h Cabl e Systems , Inc . DM S NO . FAA-2009-097 6 Pag e 3 of 406/18/201 0 15:3 6 FA X 907257781 4 1^0005/000 7

DORSEY & WHTTNEYLLP 103 1 Wes t

Fourt h Avenu e Siiite60 0 ^i>ctiocage,A K

99501 - 590 7 (907)276-455 7 CERTIFICATB O F SERVIC E

I certif y that o n thi s fj ; da

y o f June , 2010, 1 hav e serve dacop y o f th e forgoing b y postage-prepaid , certifie dmail , retur n receip t requested , facsimile , andemai l to ; Th e Honorabl e RichardC . Goodwin Administrativ e La

w Judg e Offic e o f Hearings , M-2 0 U.S . Departmen t

o f Transportatio n 1200 Ne w Jerse y Avenue , S-E . Eas t BuildingGroun dFloor , Roo mE12-32 0 Washington , D C 2059 0 Fax : (202)366-753 6 Email : Richard.Goodwin(a).dot.gp v I furthe r certif y that o n thi s f s da

y oTJune , 2010, 1 hav e serve dth e origina l an d tw o copie s o f th e forgoin g b y postage-prepaid , certifie dmail , retur n receip t requested , and facsimil e to : ' Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n ATTN : Docke t

Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wri^ t Buildin g - Roo m201 4 80 0 Independenc e Avenue , S W Washington , D C 2059 1 Fax : (202)493-502 0 I furthe r certif y that o n thi s [ 3 da

y o f Jxme, 2010, 1 hav e serve dacopy o f th e forgoing bypostage-prepaidjfirst-classjtnairan dfacsimil e ^to^ ^ ^^

- ^r Bren t R . Col e Marsto n & Cole , P.C . 82 1 N Street , Suit e 20 8 Anchorage , Alask a9950 1 Fax : (907)277-800 2 Crai g Wm . Blac k Fed^a l Aviation^Administratio n OfficeofRfigibhaiCounsel , , 22 2 West'7®Avenue , Bo x 14 , AAL- 7 Anchorage , Alask a99513-758 7 JaDh aM . Lindemuth , AB A #971106 8 > ..-v|X«i<i(yjc«i:Avenae, . t

i w •ton . Df^'2059 !

MOTIO N T O QUAS H O RMODIF Y CIVI L PENALT Y SUBPOENA S

. v > "..^ i ijiMey/¥t1»Sfcai5g»-y D 0 u » • I n th e Matte r o f Smit h Cabl e Systems . Inc . DM S NO . FAA-2009-097 606/18/201 0 15:3 6 FA X 907257781 4 12)0006/000 7

U,S . DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATIO N FEDERA L AVIATIO N ADMINISTRATIO N CIVI L PENALT Y SUBPOEN A I n th e Matte r

of : Docke t No. : CP09AL001 2 SV^;T " CABL E SYSTEM S INC . DM S No, : 2009-097 6 .j.^ . „ TI H COO K luuc don : 5/I2/2QI Q Under 1 4 C.F.R . § 13.228(8) , YO U AR E REQUIRKD : n T o appo v an dtestif

y before a n Administrativ e La

w Judg e o f

th o Departmen

t o f TtwispoitaUo n at : 1T, ° "Iffrl"* - ^""^«' , ">">" > «"•• » 7»t . A-iro^nc , __ _ t n th e cit y o f A^>,K»^,^^ ^ A 1 ,oV o ondi e 25t h d^o f Jun e 2ao . at Q'fi n a

m r i T O appear

an d test ) ( V a t adepositio n t o b e conducte d^ : at : ; i n tii e cit y o f , o n th e . da y o f 2 0 at a

m [~ | T O brin g wit

h yo u an d produc e tii e followin g documents , records , papers , boolcs , and tangibl e items :

I f yo u hav e an y question s abou t thi s subpoena , contac t

firwl B "m , ""'•"' ^ at thi s addres s an dtelephon e numbe r 99 9 »,«« • 7«-v A-ro^.. ^ <iA . An^T.nT-aya . AT C QQSI ^ '>n7.97i-^'i7 n : ^ 

# kjyL ^ t ^<MA ^ Stephani e McClai n Hearin g Doclcc

t Cler k Auttority : 1

4 C.F.R. { 13.228 ; 4 9 U.S.C.9SS12ran d L470)(l).or49U.S.CS946IO4an d I0ti(g)(1 ) AN Y PERSO N WH O DOE S NOT OBE Y THI S SUBPOEN

A I S SUBJEC T T O FINE O RIMPRISONMEN T O RBOT

H UNDE R4 9 U.S. C § 46313 .

!^7-0i-:y^7 n _ ' EXHIBIT / V Pag e _ ] o f _ X06/18/201 0 15:3 6 FA I 907257781 4 1210007/000 7

UJS . DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATIO N FEDERA L AVUTIO N ADMINISTRATIO N

• -_, . _; —. • • • • '. \•••' • -i - ' - .•-/- ' CIVI L PENALT Y SUBPOEN A l ath e Matte r

of : SMITH CABLE SYSTEM S INC . Docket No. : DM S No. : issue don : CP09AL001 2

2009-097 6 5/i2/201 Q To : qTBTOR W r.JM P 

# B Under

1 4 CF.R . § 13.228(a) , YO U AR E REQUIRED : T o appea r an d testif y befor e a n Administrativ e La

w Judg e o f

di e Departmen

t o f Transportatio n at : p.t ; T^jgrrlr t

^""^t , ^^ ^ Wotn

- 7^> 1 A^omi P ] i n th e cit y o f

A-nnt^nr-a^o , AlanTc a a t OiO n L_an i o n th e 7-Sf h day o f

Jun e r i T o appea

r andtestif y a t adepositio n t o b e conducte d by : at : : 201 0

i n th e cit y o f a t a

m on th e day o f Q T o brin g wit

h yo u an dproduc e th e followin g documents , records , papers , books , an d tai^ibl e items : 2 0

If yo u hav e any question s abou t thi s subpoena , contac t

r-rfl-f g Um , wi«o V at thi s addres s an dtelephon e number : 99 ? v^^t - 7^ ^ ^^T^r^„t ^ <1A . Anrhnrnp*.-A K Q^s n -"vi<;•>.' r• • , 907-27 1 ~.157 Q ^'^^' ^ ""'" • -'ap^-.nn-T <

- i • aras^&i^ALaaJta: ; -~ - o n the - . ?.sVvi - 

# -mf>hzzr^izy\{'il< ^ Stephani e McCIai n Hearin g Docke t

Cler k Authority : I4C.F.R. ; I3.228;4 9 U.S. C j j 512 1 on d1.47G) ( I ) > o r 4 9 U.S. C $

S 4610 4 an d 106(g)(1 ) AN Y PERSO N WH O DOE S NOT OBE Y THI S SUBPOEN

A I S SUBJEC T T O FINE O RIMPRISONMEN T O RBOT

H UNDE R4 9 U.S. C § 46313 .

rvi i I I T m\\ -

EXHIBI

T ;fe _ Page_ i ori[ _