# ~**EN ~**  Advanced Energy 909 Capability Drive , Suite 2100 Raleigh, NC 27606-3870 919857-9000 

## I advancedenergy.org 

# Navigant Consulting Three Phase 1 HP Efficiency Tests February 12, 2010 This document was prepared by Advanced Energy .

ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVI GANT CONSULTING 

## I 1

### ELECTRIC**TOREmClL~CY** 

### TEST REPORT Fo ... 101 (Revision 3.3) Flleuae: 

### AAI900AA**DMe~T~** 

### ____**~I~~~F.~~~I~O** 

### ____**~ DMeRR~~**  ______**~~10 ~**  __ __

Condition <New lU sed) : ______ .....;.

N;;:ew

-=- ____ __ Due Recei\'ed: ___**---.: I::O'.::F..::e~=10~**  __ _

" . T ested Hors ep ower: 1 RPM : 1m Tested "olta g e : 230**~vnchronous** 

### Rn-t 1&00 T ested Current :**~** Hz: 60

# ~p.~ Tested by: . Approved by: ____________________ --" (sipaIun ) ( sipun)

INlIIIIt :**~~mt Con** **~** Inc.. A ddnss : 1801 K Street, NW Suite 500 W asbinct on.DC 20006 

## Icoatac:t: T edl-**lanbew** N . dotti -The results of this report re late only to the specific motor tested . -This report shall not be reproduced except in full, with out the written approval of Advanced Energy . -This report must not be used to claim product endorsement by Advanced Energy, NVLAP , or any agency of the US Govemment .

# AlJvan~**ENl~ ~**  909 . Drive. 

## sua 2100. R Pas_ 1 of 2 

### ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 

# .-

1 2

## Electric Motor EmcleDCY Test Report rest Method: IEEE 112-2004.9.2 

### form A-MeChod A 

## s..pae.: Manufacturer : Model : Serial: Rated Power: Tested Voltage : Tested Current: NEMA Design: Frame : Speed : Rated Efficiency : NEMAEncl.: Ins. class: File Number:

lAiliai No LoacI (UIIC01Ip\ocl) NoL-, ( C"""W) HuI1lua SpeciW Temperatu< e, "C '" lo . ad Te.Po i nt Stator Windi ng Te mp . 

## tt ee ) Ambi ent 

### T eC I Une-to-Une Vo ltage , V Freq ue ncy (Hz ) Observed Speed , rlmin ObselV&d Slip . r l m i n ObselWd Slip . P . U Corrected SliP . p. U Corrected SpH ( t 'Pm Torque . Nm IDv na mometer Correct i on Nm Correc.ted Torqu e Nm Shift Power , 

### W Une Current. A • Stator Power , W I l S l ator I2R Loss in W , at It b } Stator I2R Loss . i n Watts Stat or P ower Correct i on W CorrKte9 Stator PI>_ W efficiency , 

### % Po wer F actor %

# ~ tat**c., ~**  l)ft $;8 . 1 100 

# AIIr.iitI III. • H.C. %lII011-.l&'O ENERGY ''''' '' "W5H1000



### __ " " "H3%-26115 1900

1.00 (0 . 7 kW) 

### nov 3 ph 4.0 A B 56 1725 0 . 74 Onl' r B AAl900AA T_ 0 .... IS . 6 'C 4 . 5933 4O.6·C 4 . 9940 41.2 'C 5.0033**r--....",,;7~0 .s=-=·~c**  5 . 5000 

# I n.8 

# 'cl 

# 1 28 117 

### 2 66.9 

### 70.8 1& . 2 1 & . 4 230 . 0 23 0 . 0

60 

### 60 

# 1 685 .7 1 695 . 0 1 14 . 267**~i- 17**  

### 0 . 0 &3 0. 058 0 . 066 

### 0 .060 1 68 1 . 6 169Z.6

5 . 3 

### 4 . 8 0 . 0 0 .0 5 .3 4 . 8 9 2 6 . 8 

### 857 . 3 4.1 3 . 9 

# 1243. 1 1 18 0 . 1 1 38.1 1 24. 7 1 4 3 . 7 1 2 7 .6 5 . 0 

### 2.9 124 9 . 1 1 182 . 9 

### 7 4 . 3 

# 7 2.5 75 . 9 76. 4 T..t 

## oa. : 12- ...... 1 0**~** D.1e: 12- ...... 10 Illi<iMcy (%) __ 

# ! 19.00 I 

## I --' &1 

# r**~e** !2.00 11

# r-+--~! 

# ! L- --+-- - e!OO I I I 

### <> I I I 

# • - --t-----I---.-II---["

-- ---t-.--- S UI



### -- I • I 

# -r -' 5t.OO : ! 00: 

## i i : e, : I:: 

### .-,---; ".00

# --~**---I-- -t-** **t--j** 

# =: 3'.00 

# ,.**~**

T ..... 15 . 1 ·C 17 . 0 ·C 16.8 ·C IH'C 101 

### 3 70 . 8 16 .7 

### 2 JO. 0

60 

### 1711 . & 88.4 17 0.049 0 . 05 0 17 09. &

4 . 2 0 . 0 4 . 2 14 6. 6 3 . 5 1 007 . 8 104. 0 

### 1 0& . 4 2. 4 

### 1 0Hl.2 7 3.9 

### 71. 5 o 20**~.A-.s.. ~**  120 lC1

T-.e ntlln Rirse'-- ___ -:"I Temp. riM Q.tunr.I), 'C

### ~---""54.;.;;.6'-**-=iCI** Temp . riM (1Iy**1** "C ,-. __**.:..:S2:.::: S:....·C** **.** 

### 1 5 

# '" 25 

# " 5 6 

### 68.0 

### 64.4 60 . 3 16 . 6 

# 1 6

. 2 1 6 . 3 

### 2 30 . 0 2 30 . 0 230 . 0 

### 60 60 60 

### 1736 . 7 1759 . 4 1 179 . 1 6 3 . 3 00 4 0 . 60 0 

### 2 0 . 950 0 . 03 5 0 . 023 0 ,012 0. 036 

### 0 . 024 0 . 012 

# 1134 . 7 1757 . S 1 m.8 

### 3 . 1 

### 2 . 0 1 . 0 0 . 0 

### 0 . 0 0 . 0 3 . 1 

### 2 . .Q 

### 1 . 0 

# 559 . 6 3 75 . 0 1 89 . 5 3 . 1 

# 2.5 755 . 9 5 28 . 8 324 . 5 

## n . 5 5 9 . 9 49 . 8 19 . 9 

### 62. 6 

# 52.7 2.5 3 . 0 

# 758 . 4 5 31. 5 

### 3 21-4 73.S 70 . 6 51 . 9 61 . 9 

### 48 . 9 

# 32 .7 Summary of Test Characteristics

## ==**M- ----** **":"LO ad~** **.** i-n

## -perc**nt~ of** **-:- rat** **":"ed-:T"'t- -_-** **71~28~~= ~=:"~1=-7~** **_** '"' +

- _

-_

--:

## ~fO~t**:==:: ::~** **:::~==~~"'~ ;:** **;:::~2?::5~::j** Power Factor , in

### %1-**-;1i:-'5 -=-** **89 =--** **+--; -=-6.'7** **44 =-t----=7-::=** **9=--_+-_= ==** **'= BS~__t-....,4::8:.:;;** **90~ -+_----'3::::2;:.:** **7::1:---1** Efficiency . i n

### %1-**~7~-=.2~6'--+-7 '-?** **2:':: 4:.:8--+-** **...:.7 ::** **~9 0::_** **_+-...:.7::3 ::_:** **79 ::__+-~70=** **;: 51** **:___+__ :;;5r** **_-f** Speed , in revlmin 

### 1 682 1 69 3 11 1 0 1735 1758 

## 1 n a Line Current in**;wI~S** 

### 1--' 4 7-

. 7 1 '---+--==-3 . ;: 9'--- t----'3=- , -==5**'---+---=::- =----t-......::** **,.:; ~--1-......::** **~--f**



### ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 

## 1 3

### ELECTRIC MO T OR EmCIENCY TEST REPORT 

### FonalOl (Revisio n 3 . 3 )

FiIeJwM: AAl901AA Date .fT est:

_ _**--.;; l-** **Fe ;..;** **b-~l;.;.O** __ __' Date efRepeI1: __**--= .:..** **1- .:..** **Fe ;;.;:** **b- :.:.** **0** __ _ 

### l-It 

### N li t lido tio . · OOf

_ " .PJ 

# • r-.a 

# • Sample N umber: 1901 S erial No .: M IIIIlfac:turer: Phases: 3 M odtl: 

# - HL 60 Rat ed VoJtqe : 2OS-13OJ460 

### RPM : 1725 Rat ed**Hor Sfp** **ow~** 1 Sync. RPM lS00 Rat ed Cumat: 3.9- "2 Type: F rame :**~** Eod.**O~** INs lA Desip: B 1m . Class: B IN

_ ep late Eft' .(N om ): J.I . OO% SF : 1.15 lNamep lat. Eft' . ( M in ): Cod. : L 

## Icc No ; Condition (N ewJU sed) : ___**~N;.;.ew~** __ _ Date Received: __**--.;;l~O"~ ;..;eb-~l;.;.O**  __ __' Test CoDlli tioas' 

# rr ested**Hon epow** **~** 1 

### !RPM : 1m 'Te sted VoJtqe : 230 SVDCbroDous RPM: 1800 'T ested Cumnt: 4 

## 1Hz : 60 Notes :

# ~P.r**~** Tested by . Approy,db:

_ _________ _ N_ : NiI\ i,,_**ComuIIin~** 

### Inc . Address : 1 801 K Street, l'o"\\ ' Suite SOO W DC 20006 Coatact: Tech**-l\~ '**  Nardotti -The re sults ofthis report relate only to the specific motor tested. -This report shall not be re produced except in full , with out the written approval of Advanced Energy. -This report mu s l not be used to claim product endorsement by Advanced Energy , NVLAP , or 

### any agency ofthe US Govemment .

909 . Drive , Sli. 

### 2J 00, A Pagel 

## or 2 

### ADVANCE D ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 

## 1 4I 

## Electric :Motor Emcleacy Test 

## Report Test Method: IEEE 112 . 2004,**~** Form A-Method A Sulplell: 

### 1901 TtotDlt. : 11·1.10 Manufacturer : 

# - Itepoct Date: 12 · 1.10 Model: 

# - Serial :**I!Iio'-Y~)** 

# - - 1'S )!I DO 

# . ,_ 

# . ... -

. 1**"-rr~** Rated Power: 1 . 00 ( 0 . 7 kW ) 

### I ; 

## i Tested Voltage : 

### nov 3ph**_~1--** I 

## ! 

# Y :!2-00 l'CI 

## ! i. I 

### ! Te s ted Current : 4 .D A 

# --- O . !lUlD 

## : : I j 

## ! NEMA Design : B 

## -+---r I I 

# i I**,.-~** 

# - , Frame : 56 til

## -L- I I 

# I I I SUlD Speed : 17 25 ' '0 Rated Effic ie ncy : 0. 7 4 eo 

# . .. _+-+ -t=t i ! ".00 NEMAEnc L : OPEN m lD Ins . class : B til

# -·**··· t~** **··· I·** **·...** 

# ·t =:- 3000 File Number: AAl901AA 0 ZI**6.. ~**  IZJ 140 Resistaac e &: Te.pentve M.....---ts T_ OJo.a I. ........ w tW 19 .5 'C 4 . 6040 1 6. 7 ' C No l.oacI (UacoupW) 3 7 .9 'C 4. 9 7 5 3 16 .7 'C T UIpent1II'e Rise No l.oacI ( c.",pW) 4O .2 'C 5. 0 1 03 16 .7 'C

# _"**_~** 

# B1

Hatltllft 64.9 'C 5.4 920 16 . 0 'C**rioe (1ly** **~),** 'C 5 2.SOC**~T~** .. 'C 

# I 77.5 'ci 

### 'Ko l oad 1 28 117 1 09 75 

### .9 2. ToPo;nt 1 

### 2 

### 3 

# • 5 6 Stato r W i nd irl{l Te mp , 

## tt I C ) 66 .4 69 . 7 70.4 68 . 8 59 . 0 56.0 Ambient T ( C ) 16. 2 1 6 . 5 1 6.7 1 5.6 16 . 6 16 . 5 Line-la-line Volt aoe . V 2 30 . 1 2 30 . 0 23 0 . 0 2 30 . 0 230 . 0 2 3 0 . 0**F~ uenc** **Yl Hz** **)** 60 60 60 60 60 

### 60 Observed SjIeed , r/ m i n 1685 . 1 1694 . 1 1"7 11 . 5 1 735 . 0 11 60 . 1 1779.9**Ob~** S lip . r/min 1 14.900 10 5 . 86 7 8 8 . 4 6 7 64.167 39 . 9 00 20.111 Obs8M!d Slip . p. U 0 . 064 0 .0 5 9 0 . 049 0 , 036 0 . 022 0 . 011 Corrected SliP . p. U 0 . 066 0 . 0 60 0.05 0 0 . 03 7 0 . 024 0 . 0 12 Corrected S peed . rpm 1680 . 8 1 69 1 . 4 1109. 5 1 734 . 0 1 7 57 . 6 

### 1 na . 4 To r Que, Nm 5 . 3 4 . 8 4 . 1 3 . 1 2 . 0 1 . 0 Dvnamometer Correction Nm 0. 0 0. 0 0 . 0 0 .0 0 . 0 0 .0 Corrected TOrQ u e , N m 5. 3 4. 8 4. 1 3 . 1 2 . 0 1 . 0 Shalt P ower W 92 6 . 5**657 5**  7 41 . 0 5 6 0 . 5 3 74 . 7 1 88 . 2 Line Cu rrent A 4 . 1 3.9 3 . 5 3 . 1 2.7 2 . 5 Stator Power W 1 268. 7 116 . 5 . 6 988.7 7 6H 5 28 . 2 3 15 . 9**~** Stator I2R Loss . in W at It 137 . 6 123.7 102 . 2 77 . 3 5 8 . 9 4B .4 b) Stator l2R ' Loss in 

## watt s 1 4H 126 . 9 104 . 6 7 9 . 6 62 . 6 52 . 0 Stator Power Correction , W 5 . 1 32 2.4 

### L2 3 ,7 3.6 Corr8cled' :Stator**P~wer** W 12 73. 8 1 168. 7 1 00 1 . 0 771 . 6 53 2 . 0 319 . 4 Elliciency . % 12. 7 73. 4 74.0 72.6 7 0 . 4 58.9 Power Factor . % n. 6 7H 7 1 . 4 63 . 1 48 . 8 

# no**~** IOIap ...,::rw..$;II . , 91lO 

# "'-9 . >Ie**l'IICIi~570**

# ~ P ",,,, ' 91W151-410 oo 

### Summary of 

### Test Chara cte ristics --' I'I "I1 H 3 :':_ Load . i n percent of rated 128 11 7 

### 100 7 5 

# . , 2 • Power Factor , i n % · n.61 75 . 66 71. 3 8 63 . 07 4 B . 8 0 3" 2.0 1 Efficiency , i n % 7 2. 74 73.3 7 14. 02 72 . 63 70.43 58 . 92 Speed , i n revlmin 1 6 8 1 1 691 1709 

### 17 34 1 758 1nB Line Current in ampere s 4 . 1 3 . 9 3 . 5 3 . 1 2 . 7 2 . 5



### ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 

## 1 5

### ELECI'RIC MOTOR**EmCIL~CY** 

### TEST REPORT Fora 102 ( AItIrision 3 . 3) 

## rD_: AAI902AA DMeefTes t: II-Feb-IO**--......;;.;~~--~** Ibn ., .. rt: __ --=..;II;.;;

- F...;:.eb-;:;...:.;;IO __ _



### _ . otor _ ... .. lat. I 

### DIormatJo. Samp le N umb«: 1902 S eMI No .: M anufactum: Pha se s: 3 M odel:**~** 60 ltIt ed Volt a,g e : 20S-230/46O 

### RPM:**172~** lIW ed Hors t'p ower. 1 Syuc .RPM 1800 lRat ed Cumnt : 3.9.J/2**T: ".:**  IF

rame :**~6** End. OPEN 

# INn-IA Design: 

### B bu. Class: 

### B**am tplat** **e** E&' .(N om ) : J.l. 00% 

### SF : 1.15 

### N

lIIIeplme E&'.(Min ): COO : L Ii'C N o .: Condition (NewlUsed) : N ew Date Received: IO-Feb-IO 

### Test CODdJtJoDS' T ested Hors ep ower. I 

### RP M : 1725 T e st ed V olt q e : 230 S us 

### RPM: 1800 T ested CuIrmt : J**~** 60 N otes :

# ~p.**~ ~**  Tested by: Approved 

### b:

_______ ___ _ ( oipar.n) (Ii ....... '**ame :**  N II\; pnt**C-on ~**  Inc. IAddress :**ro KSm~** **NW ~e** **~ Was~OJl.**  DC 20006 Contact: Tech

- Mat th ew Nadoni -The results of this report relate only to the specific motor tested. -This report s hall not be reproduced except in full , with out the written approval of Advanced Energy . -This report must not be used to claim product endorsement by Advanced Energy , NVLAP , or any agency of the US Govemment •**~** 

# ..............**~** 

## .....**-~~** 

### ... 

# "-

.. -**~_** ... c. ... D

rive. Suite 21 00. A NC 27606-3870 Phone 919-857·9W) Fall 919-832·2696 Pqelof2 

### ADVANCE D ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 

## 1 6

## I Electric Motor EmcleDcy Test Report Test Method: 

### IEEE 112.2004, 9.2 

### Form A-MethodA S .... ell: 

### Manufacture r: Model : 

### Serial : Rated Power: 

### Tested Voltage : Tested Current NEMA Design : Frame : Speed : Rated Efliciency : NEMAEncl. : Ins . class: File Number: Resistuce Ie T ........... Meas ......... t..itial No LoM (USICO\IPW) No L-' ( CoapW) Heatltua 

### 'lfoLoad Te.Polnr Slator WindinQ Temp . 

## tt · eCI AmbientnC} 

### Une-lo-liiieVoltage , V**uenc y**  ( Hz) 

### Ob seMld S peed , r / m

in O

bs.MId Sli p . r/min O bseMld Sli p . p . U Corrected S l iP . P . U Corrected Speed . rpm 

### Torq u e . Nm 1[Mllm ometer Correction Nm Corrected Torq u e N m Shaft Power W 

### L i ne C urr .", A 

### Stator**P~er** 

### W I) 

### Stator I2 R Lo u , 

### in W. at tl 

### b) Stator I2R Loss in W at I s Stator Power Correction , 

### W Corrected $Ialor Power W Efficiencv . % 

### P ower Factor . % lllOl 

# - - LOO ( 0.7 k W) 

### nov 3pb 4 . 0 A IS S6 172 5 0.74 OP!N B AAl90lAA t_ Olaal 16.6 'C 4 . 5043 39.9 'C 4.9547 U2'C U993 .----=-::6 ;.:.;7.3

=-:·-=.C 5 . 4137 

## I BOYCI 121 116 1 

### 2 69 . 6 73.1 15.6 1 5. 7 229 . 9 2 30 .0

6 0 60 1 689 . 1 16 98 . 0 110 . 900 1 02 . 0 1 7 cr062 0 . 0 51 0 . 064 0 . 05 B 16B 5 . 3 1 695 . 7**3** 

### 4 . B

0 . 0 0 . 0 5.3 4 . B 

### 9 2n 853 .4 

# u 3 . 9 1 2B1 . 9 1 169 . 6 142. 5 

### 127 . 6 1 4 7 . 4 13 0 . 5 4.9 2 . 9 1 286.7 11 72 . 5 72.1 12 .B 

### 74 . 8 t.- 14 . 8 · C 16 . 3 ·C 1 5. 9 · C IS.7·C 

### 10 1 J 

### 7 3 . 1 15 . 8 . 230 . 0

60 

### 1 1 13 , 5 86 . 500 0 . 048 0 . 049 17 1 1 . 5

4 . 2 0 . 0 4 . 2 748 . 0

3 . 6 1018 . 3 10B . 1 110 . 5 2 . 5 10 2 0 . 7 7 3 . 3 70 .7 • • 02. : 11-".10 hport**~t e:**  }2· ..... 10

T-.e ntllft JU'F.e:....- __ -i . Temp. riM C> ' t..unoI), 'Ct- 1_--=- 5 1

:;,:,: .6 :... 'C =t1 Temp . riM (by lteois-.. ), 'C 1 L.. __**.:.; SS** **:.:.: .l** **:... 'C~**  . 

### 15 24 

# " 6 

### 69 . 9 66 . 0 62.0 15 . 8 1 5 . B 15 . 7 230 . 1 230 . 0 23 0. 1

60 60 60 

### 1738 . 5 1760 . 8 

### 1 779 . 9 61 . 500 3 9 2 33 20. 150 0 . 034 0 .0 22 0 .0 1 1 0.035 0 . 023 0 . 0 12 

### 1736.5 1758 .9 

### 177 8 . 6

3 . 1 2 . 0 1 . 0 0 . 0 0 . 0 0 .0 

### 3 . 1 2 . 0 1 . 0 562 . 2 3 7 2.7 184 . 2 3.2 2 . 8 2.6 767.2 53 7 . 4 326 . 5 i!2Al 63 . 9 54.1 

### 84 . 1 669 

### 57 . 4 2 . 7 3 . Q 3 . 3 

### 770.0 540 . 3 329 . 8 

### 73.0 69 . 0 

### 55 . 9 60.9 31 . 5

SumlMlY of Test Characteristics L oad , i n percent of 

### rated**f--:::1=2:.;.7~-+--:-: 11** **:.:6:::-+---=1;::O~1 ~-+_-=-=7.;5-=--+_--:-::** **"~9 ,"=-~f-~** **;;4~---I** 

### Power Factor . i n**f--=77~ ,;.:** **2=-+- ==74** **:=-:.** 

### 7:,: 7 ,......+_-: 7,;0 .:.:,

. 7 ;,.

3**+---= 6:;;0** **;;86;--+_..::4-::-:7 ;:99;--+_.;.** **31 =-** **4=-:6 ~-I**  

### Elliciency . in**f-.:.; 72** **:;:, ::::0** **7~+-~ 2;:;** **. ~8:......f.** **_..:7 ,;3:=** **;. 8** **+----=,7,::;;3 ~02;:_-+--=6~8** **,;:98::...--+- =:5** **BV~ ~**  

### Speed , in**rwlmin l--....:1.=.;** **68 :::=** **'--+-..:., 16** **~9;,.;.6-+** 

### _ _ 1o,;.7 -':' 1 2;;..... -+ __**1'='73.;;,;6~-+_....:11J'='5:::=9'---+-_....:.1:'-'77~9_-I** 

### Lin. Curre!:l1. i n amj)8r'p . 4 . 2 3 . 9 3 . 6 3 . . 2 2.B 2.6

ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 

## 1 7