BT_BenOutputs_02MAY14.xls

Author: Abt Associates Inc.

Created: 5/2/14

Worksheet Description

RESULTS_SUMMARY Presents annualized willingness-to-pay (WTP) results (i.e., 

benefits estimates) by region and regulatory option. The table 

includes both undiscounted annual benefits and annualized 

benefits using discount rates of 3 percent and 7 percent.

DISCOUNTING_OUT Presents benefits by period and regulatory option for the 

Northeast (North Atlantic plus Mid-Atlantic). Includes 

undiscounted benefits and benefits discounted using 3 and 7 

percent rates.

Purpose: Output from the Nonuse Benefit Transfer SAS Model. It includes annualized 

benefits results for the final rule and options considered.
RESULTS_SUMMARY

reg species_econ option WTPreg Ann_WTP_3 Ann_WTP_7 WTPreg_imp

midatlantic winter.flounder baseline 83099.58594 78887.39227 77173.93317 491.9427123

northatlantic winter.flounder baseline 21292.68057 20213.38645 19774.34531 126.0509173

midatlantic winter.flounder tmn1 337.6997411 248.1816586 199.9405254

northatlantic winter.flounder tmn1 86.52910403 63.5918064 51.23093806

midatlantic winter.flounder tmn2 1088.51061 805.0577791 651.4450485

northatlantic winter.flounder tmn2 278.9100386 206.2806684 166.9203423

midatlantic winter.flounder tmn3 63797.77151 40701.07843 29691.59935

northatlantic winter.flounder tmn3 16346.95955 10428.87341 7607.904823

Page 1
RESULTS_SUMMARY

WTPreg_ent

82607.64323

21166.62965

Page 2
DISCOUNTING_OUT

reg option WTPreg WTP0_1 WTP0_2 WTP0_3 WTP0_4 WTP0_5

northeast baseline 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665

northeast tmn1 424.2288451 0 0 0 0 76.16748706

northeast tmn2 1367.420649 0 0 0 0 287.3553073

northeast tmn3 80144.73106 0 0 0 0 2.124742402

Page 1
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP0_6 WTP0_7 WTP0_8 WTP0_9 WTP0_10 WTP0_11 WTP0_12

104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665

111.0806879 218.7303608 266.345286 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451

330.4413974 780.740569 980.6796557 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649

2.124742402 1225.810893 4763.059406 27976.707 28606.06642 54081.82745 63689.15832

Page 2
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP0_13 WTP0_14 WTP0_15 WTP0_16 WTP0_17 WTP0_18 WTP0_19

104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665

424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451

1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649

79818.60836 79818.60836 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106

Page 3
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP0_20 WTP0_21 WTP0_22 WTP0_23 WTP0_24 WTP0_25 WTP0_26

104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665

424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451

1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649

80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106

Page 4
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP0_27 WTP0_28 WTP0_29 WTP0_30 WTP0_31 WTP0_32 WTP0_33

104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665

424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451

1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649

80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106

Page 5
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP0_34 WTP0_35 WTP0_36 WTP0_37 WTP0_38 WTP0_39 WTP0_40

104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665

424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451

1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649

80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106

Page 6
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP0_41 WTP0_42 WTP0_43 WTP0_44 WTP0_45 WTP0_46 WTP0_47

104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 104392.2665 86645.58121

424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 424.2288451 352.1099415

1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1367.420649 1134.959139

80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 80144.73106 66520.12678

Page 7
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP0_48 WTP0_49 WTP0_50 WTP0_51 WTP0_52 WTP0_53 WTP0_54 WTP0_55

69942.81856 52196.13326 34449.44795 17746.68531 0 0 0 0

284.2333262 212.1144226 139.9955189 72.11890367 0 0 0 0

916.1718347 683.7103244 451.2488141 232.4615103 0 0 0 0

53696.96981 40072.36553 26447.76125 13624.60428 0 0 0 0

Page 8
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP0_56 WTP0_57 WTP0_58 WTP0_59 WTP0_60 WTP3_1 WTP3_2 WTP3_3

0 0 0 0 0 101351.7151 98399.72336 95533.712

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Page 9
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP3_4 WTP3_5 WTP3_6 WTP3_7 WTP3_8 WTP3_9 WTP3_10

92751.1767 90049.68612 87426.87972 84880.46575 82408.21918 80007.97978 77677.65027

0 65.70274342 93.02832738 177.8477996 210.2554282 325.1360853 315.6661022

0 247.8752124 276.7394681 634.8135292 774.1575761 1048.014065 1017.489384

0 1.83282146 1.779438311 996.6964319 3760.003079 21441.81636 21285.59995

Page 10
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP3_11 WTP3_12 WTP3_13 WTP3_14 WTP3_15 WTP3_16 WTP3_17

75415.19444 73218.63538 71086.05377 69015.58618 67005.42348 65053.8092 63159.03806

306.4719439 297.5455766 288.8792006 280.4652433 272.2963527 264.365391 256.6654281

987.8537708 959.0813309 931.1469232 904.026139 877.6952806 852.1313404 827.3119809

39069.86283 44670.29423 54352.58832 52769.50322 51441.85315 49943.54675 48488.88034

Page 11
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP3_18 WTP3_19 WTP3_20 WTP3_21 WTP3_22 WTP3_23 WTP3_24

61319.45443 59533.4509 57799.46689 56115.98727 54481.54104 52894.70004 51354.07771

249.189736 241.9317826 234.8852258 228.0439085 221.4018529 214.9532553 208.6924809

803.2155155 779.8208888 757.107659 735.0559797 713.6465822 692.8607594 672.6803489

47076.58285 45705.42024 44374.19441 43081.74215 41826.93412 40608.67391 39425.897

Page 12
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP3_25 WTP3_26 WTP3_27 WTP3_28 WTP3_29 WTP3_30 WTP3_31

49858.32787 48406.14357 46996.25589 45627.4329 44298.47855 43008.2316 41755.56466

202.6140591 196.7126787 190.9831832 185.4205662 180.0199672 174.7766672 169.6860847

653.0877174 634.0657451 615.5978107 597.6677774 580.2599781 563.359202 546.9506816

38277.5699 37162.68922 36080.2808 35029.39883 34009.12508 33018.56804 32056.86218

Page 13
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP3_32 WTP3_33 WTP3_34 WTP3_35 WTP3_36 WTP3_37 WTP3_38

40539.38316 39358.62443 38212.25673 37099.27838 36018.71687 34969.62803 33951.09518

164.7437715 159.9454092 155.2868051 150.7638884 146.3727072 142.1094245 137.970315

531.0200792 515.5534749 500.5373543 485.9585964 471.8044625 458.062585 444.7209563

31123.16716 30216.66715 29336.57004 28482.10684 27652.53091 26847.11739 26065.16252

Page 14
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP3_39 WTP3_40 WTP3_41 WTP3_42 WTP3_43 WTP3_44 WTP3_45

32962.22833 32002.16342 31070.06158 30165.10833 29286.51294 28433.50771 27605.34729

133.9517622 130.0502545 126.262383 122.5848379 119.0144057 115.5479667 112.182492

431.7679187 419.1921541 406.9826739 395.1288096 383.6202035 372.4467995 361.5988345

25305.98302 24568.91556 23853.31608 23158.5593 22484.03815 21829.16325 21193.36238

Page 15
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP3_46 WTP3_47 WTP3_48 WTP3_49 WTP3_50 WTP3_51 WTP3_52 WTP3_53

26801.30805 21597.17056 16926.07823 12263.49676 7858.162972 3930.237438 0 0

108.9150407 87.76648915 68.78412414 49.83634556 31.933969 15.97168205 0 0

351.0668296 282.8985132 221.7124855 160.6379405 102.9330492 51.48166629 0 0

20576.07998 16580.72465 12994.60231 9415.013989 6032.921585 3017.348248 0 0

Page 16
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP3_54 WTP3_55 WTP3_56 WTP3_57 WTP3_58 WTP3_59 WTP3_60 WTP7_1 WTP7_2

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 97562.8659 91180.2485

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Page 17
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP7_3 WTP7_4 WTP7_5 WTP7_6 WTP7_7 WTP7_8 WTP7_9

85215.18552 79640.3603 74430.24327 69560.97502 65010.25703 60757.24956 56782.47622

0 0 54.3063656 74.01775263 136.2142757 155.0153814 230.7523835

0 0 204.8803627 220.1870556 486.2059878 570.7644883 743.7862312

0 0 1.514911967 1.415805577 763.3734174 2772.14394 15217.47494

Page 18
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP7_10 WTP7_11 WTP7_12 WTP7_13 WTP7_14 WTP7_15 WTP7_16

53067.73479 49596.01382 46351.41478 43319.07924 40485.12078 37836.56148 35361.27241

215.6564331 201.5480683 188.3626807 176.0398885 164.5232603 153.7600563 143.7009872

695.1273189 649.6516999 607.1511214 567.4309546 530.3093033 495.6161714 463.1926835

14541.87361 25693.88664 28278.74797 33121.88475 30955.03248 29048.13877 27147.79324

Page 19
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP7_17 WTP7_18 WTP7_19 WTP7_20 WTP7_21 WTP7_22 WTP7_23

33047.91814 30885.9048 28865.33159 26976.94541 25212.09852 23562.70889 22021.22327

134.2999881 125.5140075 117.3028108 109.6287951 102.4568179 95.7540354 89.48975271

432.8903584 404.5704284 378.1032041 353.3674805 330.2499818 308.6448428 288.4531241

25371.76938 23711.934 22160.68598 20710.92148 19356.00138 18089.72092 16906.28123

Page 20
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP7_24 WTP7_25 WTP7_26 WTP7_27 WTP7_28 WTP7_29 WTP7_30

20580.58249 19234.18924 17975.8778 16799.88579 15700.82784 14673.67088 13713.71111

83.63528291 78.1638158 73.05029514 68.27130387 63.80495689 59.63080083 55.7297204

269.582359 251.9461299 235.4636728 220.0595073 205.6630909 192.2084962 179.6341086

15800.26283 14766.60078 13800.56148 12897.72101 12053.94487 11265.36903 10528.38227

Page 21
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP7_31 WTP7_32 WTP7_33 WTP7_34 WTP7_35 WTP7_36 WTP7_37

12816.55243 11978.08639 11194.47326 10462.12454 9777.686487 9138.024755 8540.210051

52.08385084 48.67649611 45.49205244 42.51593686 39.73452043 37.13506582 34.70566899

167.8823445 156.8993874 146.6349414 137.0420014 128.0766368 119.6977914 111.8670948

9839.609602 9195.896824 8594.296097 8032.052428 7506.591054 7015.505658 6556.547344

Page 22
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP7_38 WTP7_39 WTP7_40 WTP7_41 WTP7_42 WTP7_43 WTP7_44

7981.504721 7459.350206 6971.355333 6515.285358 6089.051736 5690.702557 5318.413605

32.43520467 30.31327539 28.33016392 26.47678871 24.74466234 23.12585266 21.61294641

104.5486867 97.70905297 91.31687194 85.34287097 79.7596925 74.54176869 69.66520438

6127.61434 5726.742374 5352.095676 5001.958576 4674.727641 4368.904338 4083.088166

Page 23
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP7_45 WTP7_46 WTP7_47 WTP7_48 WTP7_49 WTP7_50 WTP7_51

4970.480005 4645.308415 3603.370079 2718.452824 1895.977699 1169.481571 563.0469189

20.19901534 18.87758443 14.64335988 11.04723693 7.704866044 4.752534195 2.288107656

65.10766765 60.84828752 47.2000735 35.60865808 24.83516396 15.31888618 7.375277968

3815.970249 3566.327335 2766.403447 2087.028836 1455.592716 897.842236 432.2661572

Page 24
DISCOUNTING_OUT

WTP7_52 WTP7_53 WTP7_54 WTP7_55 WTP7_56 WTP7_57 WTP7_58 WTP7_59 WTP7_60

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Page 25