~ EN~ 

Advanced Energy 

909 Capability Drive, Suite 2100 

Raleigh, NC 27606-3870 

919857-9000 I advancedenergy.org 

Navigant Consulting Three Phase 1 HP 

Efficiency Tests 

February 12, 2010 

This document was prepared by Advanced Energy. 

ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING I 1 
ELECTRIC TOREmClL~CY TEST REPORT 

Fo ... 101 

(Revision 3.3) 

Flleuae: AAI900AA DMe~T~ ____ ~I~~~F.~~~I~O ____ ~ 

DMeRR~~ ______ ~~10~ __ __ 

Condition <NewlU sed): ______ .....;.N;;:ew-=-____ __ Due Recei\'ed: ___ ---.:I::O'.::F..::e~=10~ __ _ 

". 

Tested Horsepower: 1 RPM: 1m 

Tested "oltage: 230 ~vnchronous Rn-t 1&00 

Tested Current: ~ Hz: 60 

Tested by: 

~p.~ . Approved by: ____________________ --" 

(sipaIun) (sipun) 

INlIIIIt: ~~mt Con~ Inc.. 

Addnss: 1801 K Street, NW Suite 500 

Wasbincton.DC 20006 

Icoatac:t: T edl- lanbew N. dotti 

-The results of this report relate only to the specific motor tested. 

-This report shall not be reproduced except in full, with out the written approval of 

Advanced Energy. 

-This report must not be used to claim product endorsement by Advanced Energy, NVLAP, 

or any agency of the US Govemment . 

AlJvan~ ENl~~ 

909 . Drive. sua 2100. R 

Pas_ 1of 2 

ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 

.-

12 
Electric Motor EmcleDCY Test Report 

rest Method: IEEE 112-2004.9.2 form A-MeChod A 

s..pae.: 

Manufacturer: 

Model: 

Serial: 

Rated Power: 

Tested Voltage: 

Tested Current: 

NEMA Design: 

Frame: 

Speed: 

Rated Efficiency: 

NEMAEncl.: 

Ins. class: 

File Number: 

lAiliai 

No LoacI (UIIC01Ip\ocl) 

NoL-,(C"""W) 

HuI1lua 

SpeciW Temperatu<e, "C 

'" lo.ad 

Te.Point 

Stator Winding Temp. tt ee) 

Ambient T eCI 

Une-to-Une Voltage, V 

Frequency (Hz) 

Observed Speed, rlmin 

ObselV&d Slip. rlmin 

ObselWd Slip. P.U 

Corrected SliP. p.U 

Corrected SpH(t 'Pm 

Torque. Nm 

IDvnamometer Correction Nm 

Correc.ted Torque Nm 

Shift Power, W 

Une Current. A • 

Stator Power, W 

Il Slator I2R Loss in W, at It 

b} Stator I2R Loss. in Watts 

Stator Power Correction W 

CorrKte9 Stator PI>_ W 

efficiency, % 

Power Factor % 

~ tat c.,~ l)ft $;8. 1100 AIIr.iitI III. • H.C.%lII011-.l&'O 

ENERGY ''''''' "W5H1000 

__ " ""H3%-26115 

1900 

1.00 (0.7 kW) 

nov 3 ph 

4.0 A 

B 

56 

1725 

0.74 

Onl'r 

B 

AAl900AA 

T_ 0 .... 

IS.6 'C 4.5933 

4O.6·C 4.9940 

41.2 'C 5.0033 

r--....",,;7~0 .s=-=·~c 5.5000 I n.8 'cl 

128 117 

2 

66.9 70.8 

1&.2 1&.4 

230.0 230.0 

60 60 1685.7 1695.0 

114.267 ~i- 17 

0.0&3 0.058 

0.066 0.060 

1681.6 169Z.6 

5.3 4.8 

0.0 0.0 

5.3 4.8 

926.8 857.3 

4.1 3.9 1243.1 1180.1 

138.1 124.7 

143.7 127.6 

5.0 2.9 

1249.1 1182.9 

74.3 72.5 

75.9 76.4 

T..t oa.: 12-...... 10 

~ D.1e: 12-...... 10 

Illi<iMcy (%) __ 

! 19.00 

I I --' &1 r ~e !2.00 

11 r-+--~! ! L---+--- e!OO 

I I I <> I I I • ---t-----I---.-II---["-----t-.--- SUI 

-- I • I -r-' 5t.OO : ! 00: i i : 

e, : I:: .-,---; ".00 

--~ ---I-- -t-t--j =: 3'.00 

,. ~ 

T ..... 

15.1 ·C 

17.0 ·C 

16.8 ·C 

IH'C 

101 

3 

70.8 

16.7 

2JO.0 

60 

1711.& 

88.417 

0.049 

0.050 

1709.& 

4.2 

0.0 

4.2 

146.6 

3.5 

1007.8 

104.0 

10&.4 

2.4 

10Hl.2 

73.9 

71.5 

o 20 ~.A-.s.. ~ 120 lC1 

T-.entlln Rirse'--___ -:"I 

Temp. riM Q.tunr.I), 'C ~---""54.;.;;.6'--=iCI Temp. riM (1Iy 1 "C ,-. __ .:..:S2:.:::S:....·C . 

15 '" 25 

" 5 6 

68.0 64.4 60.3 

16.6 16.2 16.3 

230.0 230.0 230.0 

60 60 60 

1736.7 1759.4 1179.1 

63.300 40.600 20.950 

0.035 0.023 0,012 

0.036 0.024 0.012 1134.7 1757.S 1m.8 

3.1 2.0 1.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 

3.1 2 . .Q 1.0 559.6 375.0 189.5 

3.1 2.5 

755.9 528.8 324.5 

n .5 59.9 49.8 

19.9 62.6 52.7 

2.5 3.0 758.4 531.5 321-4 

73.S 70.6 51.9 

61 .9 48.9 32.7 

Summary of Test Characteristics 

==M-----":"LO ad~. i-n -perc nt~of-:-rat":"ed-:T"'t--_-71~28~~=~=:"~1=-7~_ '"' + -_ -_ --: ~fO~t:==::::~ :::~==~~"'~;: ;:::~2?::5~::j Power Factor, in %1--;1i:-'5-=- 89=--+--;-=-6.'7 44=-t----=7-::= 9=--_+-_==='=BS~__t-....,4::8:.:;;90~-+_----'3::::2;:.:7::1:---1 

Efficiency. in %1-~7~-=.2~6'--+-7'-?2:'::4:.:8--+-...:.7::~90::__+-...:.7::3::_: 79::__+-~70=;:51:___+__:;;5r _-f Speed, in revlmin 1682 1693 1110 1735 1758 1na 

Line Current in ;wI~S 1--'47-.71 '---+--==-3.;:9'---t----'3=-,-==5 '---+---=::- =----t-......::,.:;~--1-......:: ~--f 

ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 13 
ELECTRIC MOTOR EmCIENCY TEST REPORT 

FonalOl 

(Revision 3.3) 

FiIeJwM: AAl901AA Date .fT est: _ _ --.;; l-Fe;..;b-~l;.;.O __ __' 

Date efRepeI1: __ --=.:.. 1-.:.. Fe;;.;: b- :.:. 0 __ _ 

l-It . · OOf _N " .PJ lit lido tio • r-.a • 

Sample Number: 1901 Serial No.: 

MIIIIlfac:turer: Phases: 3 

Modtl: - HL 60 

Rated VoJtqe: 2OS-13OJ460 RPM: 1725 

Rated HorSfpow~ 1 Sync. RPM lS00 

Rated Cumat: 3.9-"2 Type: 

Frame: ~ Eod. O~ 

INslA Desip: B 1m. Class: B 

IN_ eplate Eft'.(Nom): J.I.OO% SF: 1.15 

lNameplat. Eft'.(Min): Cod.: L 

Icc No; 

Condition (NewJUsed): ___ ~N;.;.ew~ __ _ Date Received: __ --.;;l~O"~;..;eb-~l;.;.O __ __' 

Test CoDllitioas' 

rr ested Honepow~ 1 !RPM: 1m 

'Tested VoJtqe: 230 SVDCbroDous RPM: 1800 

'Tested Cumnt: 4 1Hz: 60 

Notes: 

Tested by. 

~P.r Approy,db: _~ _________ _ 

N_: NiI\i,,_ ComuIIin~ Inc. 

Address: 1801 K Street,l'o"\\' Suite SOO 

W DC 20006 

Coatact: Tech -l\~' Nardotti 

-The results ofthis report relate only to the specific motor tested. 

-This report shall not be reproduced except in full, with out the written approval of 

Advanced Energy. 

-This report musl not be used to claim product endorsement by Advanced Energy, NVLAP, 

or any agency ofthe US Govemment . 

909 . Drive, Sli. 2J 00, A 

Pagel or 2 

ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 14 
I 

Electric :Motor Emcleacy Test Report 

Test Method: IEEE 112.2004, ~ Form A-Method A 

Sulplell: 1901 TtotDlt.: 11·1.10 

Manufacturer: - Itepoct Date: 12·1.10 

Model: 

Serial: - I!Iio'-Y~) 

1'S .,_ .... - --)!IDO 

. 1 Rated Power: 1.00 (0.7 kW) I ; i "-rr~ 

Tested Voltage: nov 3ph _~1--

I ! Y :!2-00 

l'CI ! i. I ! 

Tested Current: 4.D A 

--- O . !lUlD 

: : I j ! NEMA Design: B -+---r I I 

i I ,.-~

,Frame: 56 til 

-L- I I - I I I SUlD 

Speed: 1725 ' '0 

Rated Efficiency: 0.74 eo ... _+-+-t=t i ! ".00 

NEMAEncL: OPEN m lD 

Ins. class: B til 

-····t~··· I· ·... ·t=:- 3000 

File Number: AAl901AA 0 ZI 6.. ~ IZJ 140 

Resistaace &: Te.pentve M.....---ts 

T_ OJo.a I. ........ 

w tW 19.5 'C 4.6040 16.7 'C 

No l.oacI (UacoupW) 37.9 'C 4.9753 16.7 'C T UIpent1II'e Rise 

Hatltllft 

No l.oacI (c.",pW) 4O

64.9 

.2 'C 

'C 5.4

5.0

920 

103 16

16

.7 

.0 'C 

'C _"rioe _~ (1ly ~), 'C 

B1 

52.SOC 

~T~ .. 'C I 77.5 'ci 

'Ko l oad 128 117 109 75 .9 2. 

ToPo;nt 1 2 3 • 5 6 

Stator Windirl{l Temp, tt IC) 66.4 69.7 70.4 68.8 59.0 56.0 

Ambient T (C) 16.2 16.5 16.7 15.6 16.6 16.5 

Line-la-line Voltaoe. V 230.1 230.0 230.0 230.0 230.0 230.0 

F~uencYlHz) 60 60 60 60 60 60 

Observed SjIeed, r/min 1685.1 1694.1 1"711.5 1735.0 1160.1 1779.9 

Ob~ Slip. r/min 114.900 105.867 88.467 64.167 39.900 20.111 

Obs8M!d Slip. p.U 0.064 0.059 0.049 0,036 0.022 0.011 

Corrected SliP. p.U 0.066 0.060 0.050 0.037 0.024 0.012 

Corrected Speed. rpm 1680.8 1691.4 1109.5 1734.0 1757.6 1na.4 

TorQue, Nm 5.3 4.8 4.1 3.1 2.0 1.0 

Dvnamometer Correction Nm 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

Corrected TOrQue, Nm 5.3 4.8 4. 1 3.1 2.0 1.0 

Shalt Power W 926.5 657 5 741.0 560.5 374.7 188.2 

Line Current A 4.1 3.9 3.5 3.1 2.7 2.5 

Stator Power W 1268.7 116.5.6 988.7 76H 528.2 315.9 

~ Stator I2R Loss. in W at It 137.6 123.7 102.2 77.3 58.9 4B.4 

b) Stator l2R' Loss in watts 14H 126.9 104.6 79.6 62.6 52.0 

Stator Power Correction, W 5.1 32 2.4 L2 3,7 3.6 

Corr8cled' :Stator P~wer W 1273.8 1168.7 1001.0 771. 6 532.0 319.4 

Elliciency. % 12.7 73.4 74.0 72.6 70.4 58.9 

Power Factor. % n.6 7H 71.4 63.1 48.8 no 

~ IOIap...,::rw..$;II. ,91lO 

~ "'-9. >Ie l'IICIi~570 P",,,,' 91W151-410oo Summary of Test Characteristics --' I'I"I1H 3:':_ 

Load. in percent of rated 128 117 100 75 . , 2 • 

Power Factor, in % ·n.61 75.66 71.38 63.07 4B.80 3"2.01 

Efficiency, in % 72.74 73.37 14.02 72.63 70.43 58.92 

Speed, in revlmin 1681 1691 1709 1734 1758 1nB 

Line Current in amperes 4.1 3.9 3.5 3.1 2.7 2.5 

ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 15 
ELECI'RIC MOTOR EmCIL~CY TEST REPORT 

Fora 102 

(AItIrision 3.3) 

rD_: AAI902AA DMeefTest: II-Feb-IO --......;;.;~~--~ 

Ibn ., .. rt: __ --=..;II;.;; -F...;:.eb-;:;...:.;;IO __ _ 

_ . otor _ ..... lat. I DIormatJo. 

Sample Numb«: 1902 SeMI No.: 

Manufactum: Phases: 3 

Model: ~ 60 

ltIted Volta,ge: 20S-230/46O RPM: 172~ 

lIWed Hors t'power. 1 Syuc.RPM 1800 

lRated Cumnt: 3.9.J/2 T: ".: 

IFrame: ~6 End. OPEN 

INn-IA Design: B bu. Class: B 

amtplate E&'.(Nom): J.l.00% SF: 1.15 

N lIIIeplme E&'.(Min): COO: L 

Ii'C No.: 

Condition (NewlUsed): New Date Received: IO-Feb-IO 

Test CODdJtJoDS' 

Tested Horsepower. I RPM: 1725 

Tested Voltq e: 230 S us RPM: 1800 

Tested CuIrmt: J ~ 60 

Notes: 

Tested by: 

~p. ~ Approved b: _______~ ___ _ 

(oipar.n) (Ii ....... '

ame : NII\;pnt C-on~ Inc. 

IAddress: ro KSm~NW ~e ~ 

Was~OJl. DC 20006 

Contact: Tech - Matthew Nadoni 

-The results of this report relate only to the specific motor tested. 

-This report shall not be reproduced except in full, with out the written approval of 

Advanced Energy. 

-This report must not be used to claim product endorsement by Advanced Energy, NVLAP, 

or any agency of the US Govemment • 

~ .............. ~ ..... -~~ ~_ 

... ... "-c. ... .. - Drive. Suite 21 00. A NC 27606-3870 Phone 919-857·9W) Fall 919-832·2696 

Pqelof2 

ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 16 
I Electric Motor EmcleDcy Test Report 

Test Method: IEEE 112.2004, 9.2 Form A-MethodA 

S .... ell: 

Manufacturer: 

Model: 

Serial: 

Rated Power: 

Tested Voltage: 

Tested Current 

NEMA Design: 

Frame: 

Speed: 

Rated Efliciency: 

NEMAEncl.: 

Ins. class: 

File Number: 

Resistuce Ie T ........... Meas ......... 

t..itial 

No LoM (USICO\IPW) 

No L-' (CoapW) 

Heatltua 

'lfoLoad 

Te.Polnr 

Slator WindinQ Temp. tt ·eCI 

AmbientnC} 

Une-lo-liiieVoltage, V 

uency (Hz) 

ObseMld Speed, r/min 

Obs.MId Slip. r/min 

ObseMld Slip. p.U 

Corrected SliP. P.U 

Corrected Speed. rpm 

Torque. Nm 

1[Mllmometer Correction Nm 

Corrected Torque Nm 

Shaft Power W 

Line Curr.", A 

Stator P~er W 

I) Stator I2R Lou , in W. at tl 

b) Stator I2R Loss in W at Is 

Stator Power Correction, W 

Corrected $Ialor Power W 

Efficiencv. % 

Power Factor. % 

lllOl 

-

-

LOO (0.7 kW) 

nov 3pb 

4.0 A 

IS 

S6 

1725 

0.74 

OP!N 

B 

AAl90lAA 

t_ Olaal 

16.6 'C 4.5043 

39.9 'C 4.9547 

U2'C U993 

.----=-::6;.:.;7.3=-:·-=.C 5.4137 I BOYCI 

121 116 

1 2 

69.6 73.1 

15.6 15.7 

229.9 230.0 

60 60 

1689.1 1698.0 

110.900 102.017 

cr062 0.051 

0.064 0.05B 

16B5.3 1695.7 

3 4.B 

0.0 0.0 

5.3 4.B 

92n 853.4 

u 3.9 

12B1 .9 1169.6 

142.5 127.6 

147.4 130.5 

4.9 2.9 

1286.7 11 72.5 

72.1 12.B 

74.8 

t.-

14.8 ·C 

16.3 ·C 

15.9 ·C 

IS.7·C 

101 

J 

73.1 

15.8. 

230.0 

60 

1113,5 

86.500 

0.048 

0.049 

1711.5 

4.2 

0.0 

4.2 

748.0 

3.6 

1018.3 

10B.1 

110.5 

2.5 

1020.7 

73.3 

70.7 

• • 02.: 11-".10 

hport ~te: }2· ..... 10 

T-.entllft JU'F.e:....-__ -i. 

Temp. riM C>'t..unoI), 'Ct-1_--=-51:;,:,: .6:...'C=t1 

Temp. riM (by lteois-..), 'C 1L.. __ .:.; SS:.:.: .l:...'C~ . 

15 24 

" 6 

69.9 66.0 62.0 

15.8 15.B 15.7 

230.1 230.0 230.1 

60 60 60 

1738.5 1760.8 1779.9 

61 .500 39 233 20.150 

0.034 0.022 0.011 

0.035 0.023 0.012 

1736.5 1758.9 1778.6 

3.1 2.0 1.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 

3.1 2.0 1.0 

562.2 372.7 184.2 

3.2 2.8 2.6 

767.2 537.4 326.5 

i!2Al 63.9 54.1 

84.1 669 57.4 

2.7 3.Q 3.3 

770.0 540.3 329.8 

73.0 69.0 55.9 

60.9 31.5 

SumlMlY of Test Characteristics 

Load, in percent of rated f--:::1=2:.;.7~-+--:-:11:.:6:::-+---=1;::O~1 ~-+_-=-=7.;5-=--+_--:-::"~9,"=-~f-~;;4~---I 

Power Factor. in f--=77~,;.:2=-+-==74:=-:. 7:,:7,......+_-:7,;0.:.:, .7;,. 3 +---=6:;;0;;86;--+_..::4-::-:7;:99;--+_.;.31=-4=-:6~-I 

Elliciency. in f-.:.;72:;:,::::07~+-~2;:;. ~8:......f._..:7,;3:=;.8 +----=,7,::;;3~02;:_-+--=6~8,;:98::...--+-=:5 BV~~ 

Speed, in rwlmin l--....:1.=.; 68:::='--+-..:.,16~9;,.;.6-+ _ _ 1o,;.7-':' 12;;.....-+ __ 1'='73.;;,;6~-+_....:11J'='5:::=9'---+-_....:.1:'-'77~9_-I 

Lin. Curre!:l1. in amj)8r'p. 4.2 3.9 3.6 3 .. 2 2.B 2.6 

ADVANCED ENERGY REPORT PREPARED FOR NAVIGANT CONSULTING 17