2008 D e c i sion s O p inion s of the U nit e d S t at e s C our t of Appe al s for the Third C ircuit 2-21-2008 

# G ary v . B ra ddo ck C emete ry P re c e de nt i al or Non-P re c e de nt i al : P re c e de nt i al D ocke t No . 06-3617

F o llow thi s and a ddit ion al works at : http://digit alc ommon s .l a w . vill anova . e du/thirdc ircuit_2008

Thi s de c i sion i s brou ght t o you for f re e and ope n a c c e s s by the O p inion s of the U nit e d S t at e s C our t of Appe al s for the Third C ircuit at V ill anova U nive r sity S choo l of L a

w Digit al Reposit ory

. It h as be e n a c c ept e d for inclusion in 2008 D e c i sion s by an authori z e d a dmini s trat or of V ill anova U nive r sity S choo l of L a

w Digit al Reposit ory

. F or more inform at ion, p le as e c ont a ct Be n j amin . C arl s on@l a

w . vill anova . e du . Re c omme nde d C it at ion " G ary v . B ra ddock C e me t e ry " (2008). 2008 D e cisio n s . P ape r 1491. http://digit alc ommon s .l a

w . vill anova . e du/thirdc ircuit_2008/1491UN I TED STATES CO UR T OF A PP EALS F O R T H E T H IR D C IR C U IT N o. 06- 3469 K A R L E . G A R Y ; O S C A R R . I A MS ; S H I R L E Y J . I A MS ; C H A R L E S W. P HI L L I P S ; DAVI D HI GGE NB OT HAM; J UDI T H HI GGE NB OT HAM; M AR Y ANN NE E L Y; CH AR L E S AM BR OS E WHI T L AT CH , J R. ; DE BR A ANN WHI T L AT CH ; DO NA LD W HI TLATCH ; FRAN CI S E. W HI TLATCH ; HEN RY AB NER WHI T L AT CH ; NOR M A J E AN WHI T L AT CH ; RO BE RT P HI L L I P S ; WI L L I AM H. WHI T L AT CH ; K A T H Y L . W H I T L A T C H ; A L FR E D R . C H A M B E R S, as pow erof A tt orneyfor G a ryJ . Pi e r s on ; A LFR ED R. CH A M BE RS, J R. ; A LB ER T R . CH A M BE RS, a s Powerof

A tt orne yfo rW i ni fr e d J . Pi e r s on ; PA U L R . PH I LLI PS; B A R B A R A S W A R T Z M IL L E R ; C H A R L E S E . W H IT L A T C H ; PA T R IC IA WHI T L AT CH ; N E T T IE P H IL L IP S M O R R IS ; E D N A P H IL L IP S S C H R A D E R ; V IR G IN IA K EN N ED Y ; H ELE N K ELL Y ; M A RY TH O RN E; K EN N ETH L. PH I LLI PS A p p e llan ts v. T H E B R A D D O C K C E M E T E R Y ; C O N SO L E N E R G Y I N C , the s ucce s s or a n d / o ra s s i g n o f

Rhe i n b r a u n U. S. Corp o r a t i o n ; CN X C OA L, the s ucce s s orand/ oras s i gn of C ons ol Penns y l vani a C oal C om pany N o. 06- 3617 K A R L E . G A R Y ; O S C A R R . I A MS ; S H I R L E Y J . I A MS ; C H A R L E S W. P HI L L I P S ; DAVI D HI GGE NB OT HAM; J UDI T H HI GGE NB OT HAM; M AR Y ANN NE E L Y; CH AR L E S AM BR OS E WHI T L AT CH , J R. ; DE BR A ANN WHI T L AT CH ; DO NA LD W HI TLATCH ; FRAN CI S E. W HI TLATCH ; HEN RY AB NER WHI T L AT CH ; NOR M A J E AN WHI T L AT CH ; RO BE RT P HI L L I P S ; WI L L I AM H. WHI T L AT CH ; K A T H Y L . W H I T L A T C H ; A L FR E D R . C H A M B E R S, as pow erof A tt orney f o rGa ryJ . P i e r s o n ; ALF RED R. CHAM BER S , J R. ; ALF RED R. C H A M B E R S, as Pow erof A tt orneyforW i ni fr ed J . Pi er s on; PAU L R. PHI LLI PS ; BA RBA RA SW AR TZM I LLER; CH AR LES E . WHI T L AT CH ; P AT RI CI A WHI T L AT CH ; NE T T I E P HI L L I P S M OR RI S ; E DNA PHI LLI PS SCHRA DER ; VI RG I NI A K ENN EDY ; HELEN KELLY ; M AR Y TH OR NE; K EN N ETH L. PH I LLI PSv.

T H E B R A D D O C K C E M E T E R Y ; C O N SO L E N E R G Y , the s ucce s s orand/ or as s i gn of R hei nbr aun U . S. C orpor at i on; C N X C O A L , the s ucce s s or and/ oras s i gn of C ons ol Penns y l vani a C oal C om pany

C o n so l E n e rg y ; C N X C o a l, A p p e llan ts N o. 06- 3680 K A R L E . G A R Y ; O S C A R R . I A MS ; S H I R L E Y J . I A MS ; C H A R L E S W. P HI L L I P S ; DAVI D HI GGE NB OT HAM; J UDI T H HI GGE NB OT HAM; M AR Y ANN NE E L Y; CH AR L E S AM BR OS E WHI T L AT CH , J r . ; DE BR A ANN WHI T L AT CH ; DO NA LD W HI TLATCH ; FRAN CI S E. W HI TLATCH ; HEN RY AB NER WHI T L AT CH ; NOR M A J E AN WHI T L AT CH ; RO BE RT P HI L L I P S ; WI L L I AM H. WHI T L AT CH ; KAT HY L . W H I T L A T C H ; A L FR E D R . C H A M B E R S, as pow erof A tt orneyfor G a ryJ . Pi e r s on ; A LFR ED R. CH A M BE RS, J R. ; A LFR ED R. CH A M BE RS, a s Powerof

A tt orne yfo rW i ni fr e d J . Pi e r s on ; PA U L R . PH I LLI PS; B A R B A R A S W A R T Z M IL L E R ; C H A R L E S E . W H IT L A T C H ; PA T R IC IA W HI TL ATCH; NET TI E P HI LL I P S M ORRI S ; EDNA PHI LL I P S S CHRADER; V I RG I N I A K EN N ED Y ; H ELE N K ELL Y ; M A RY TH O RN E; K EN N ETH L. PH I LLI PS v. B R A D D O C K C E M E T E R Y ; C O N SO L E N E R G Y , the s ucce s s orand/ oras s i gn of R H E I N B R A U N U . S. C orpor at i on; C N X C O A L , the s ucce s s orand/ or

as s i gn of C ons ol Penns y l vani a C oal C om pany CO N SO L EN ER G Y , the s uc c e s s ora nd / ora s s i gn of Rhei nb r a un U . S. C orpor at i on; C N X C O A L , the s ucce s s orand/ oras s i gn of C ons ol

P e n n s yl v a n i a C o a l C o m p a n y, A p p e llan ts O n A p p ea l from the U n it ed S tat es D istri ct C o u rt f o r th e W e ste rn D istric t o f P e n n sy lv a n iaD . C . N o. 05- cv- 01438 OR DE R A M E NDI NG OP I NI ON A tthe di r ect i on of the C ourt , A ppel l ees C O N SO L E ner gyand C ons ol Pe nn s y l va ni a Coal Com pa ny ’ s mot i on t o a mendthe op i ni on t o i nc l ud e Chr i s t op he rP. Fur m an, E s q. as couns el forA ppel l ees i s gr ant ed. T he des i gnat i on of att orney s for A ppel l ees C O N SO L E ner gyand C ons ol Penns y l vani a C oal C om panyi s amended as foll ow s: Jo se p h A . K a tar in c ic J err i A . R y an C hr i s t opherP. Furm an T horp, R eed & A rm s tr ong 301 G r antStr eet O ne O xfor d C entr e, 14th Fl oor Pi tt s bur gh, PA 15219 A t tor neys f

orC ons olE ner

gy and C N X C oal F o r th e C o u rt, M arc ia M . W aldro n , C lerk D at ed: February21, 2008 C R G / cc: C ol m W . K enny , E s q. L oui s M . T ar as i , E s q. R odgerL . Puz, E s q. C hr i s t opherP. Furm an, E s q. J os eph A . K at ar i nci c, E s q. J err i A . R y an, E s q.