2008 Decisions

Opinions of the United

States Court of Appeals

for the Third Circuit

2-21-2008

Gary v. Braddock Cemetery

Precedential or Non-Precedential: Precedential

Docket No. 06-3617

Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.law.villanova.edu/thirdcircuit_2008

This decision is brought to you for free and open access by the Opinions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit at Villanova

University School of Law Digital Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in 2008 Decisions by an authorized administrator of Villanova

University School of Law Digital Repository. For more information, please contact Benjamin.Carlson@law.villanova.edu.

Recommended Citation

"Gary v. Braddock Cemetery" (2008). 2008 Decisions. Paper 1491.

http://digitalcommons.law.villanova.edu/thirdcircuit_2008/1491
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT

No. 06-3469

KARL E. GARY; OSCAR R. IAMS; SHIRLEY J. IAMS; CHARLES W.

PHILLIPS; DAVID HIGGENBOTHAM; JUDITH HIGGENBOTHAM; MARY ANN

NEELY; CHARLES AMBROSE WHITLATCH, JR.; DEBRA ANN WHITLATCH;

DONALD WHITLATCH; FRANCIS E. WHITLATCH; HENRY ABNER

WHITLATCH;

NORMA JEAN WHITLATCH; ROBERT PHILLIPS; WILLIAM H. WHITLATCH;

KATHY L. WHITLATCH; ALFRED R. CHAMBERS, as power of Attorney for

Gary J. Pierson; ALFRED R. CHAMBERS, JR.; ALBERT R. CHAMBERS,

as Power of Attorney for Winifred J. Pierson; PAUL R. PHILLIPS;

BARBARA SWARTZMILLER; CHARLES E. WHITLATCH; PATRICIA

WHITLATCH;

NETTIE PHILLIPS MORRIS; EDNA PHILLIPS SCHRADER; VIRGINIA

KENNEDY; HELEN KELLY; MARY THORNE; KENNETH L. PHILLIPS

 Appellants

 v.

THE BRADDOCK CEMETERY; CONSOL ENERGY INC, the successor

and/or assign of Rheinbraun U.S. Corporation; CNX COAL,

the successor and/or assign of Consol Pennsylvania Coal

Company

No. 06-3617

KARL E. GARY; OSCAR R. IAMS; SHIRLEY J. IAMS; CHARLES W.

PHILLIPS; DAVID HIGGENBOTHAM; JUDITH HIGGENBOTHAM; MARY ANN

NEELY; CHARLES AMBROSE WHITLATCH, JR.; DEBRA ANN WHITLATCH;

DONALD WHITLATCH; FRANCIS E. WHITLATCH; HENRY ABNER

WHITLATCH;

NORMA JEAN WHITLATCH; ROBERT PHILLIPS; WILLIAM H. WHITLATCH;

KATHY L. WHITLATCH; ALFRED R. CHAMBERS, as power of Attorney

for Gary J. Pierson; ALFRED R. CHAMBERS, JR.; ALFRED R.

CHAMBERS, as Power of Attorney for Winifred J. Pierson;

PAUL R. PHILLIPS; BARBARA SWARTZMILLER; CHARLES E.

WHITLATCH; PATRICIA WHITLATCH; NETTIE PHILLIPS MORRIS; EDNA

PHILLIPS SCHRADER; VIRGINIA KENNEDY; HELEN KELLY; MARY THORNE;

KENNETH L. PHILLIPS
 v.

THE BRADDOCK CEMETERY; CONSOL ENERGY, the successor and/or

assign of Rheinbraun U.S. Corporation; CNX COAL, the successor

and/or assign of Consol Pennsylvania Coal Company

Consol Energy; CNX Coal,

 Appellants

No. 06-3680

KARL E. GARY; OSCAR R. IAMS; SHIRLEY J. IAMS; CHARLES W.

PHILLIPS; DAVID HIGGENBOTHAM; JUDITH HIGGENBOTHAM; MARY ANN

NEELY; CHARLES AMBROSE WHITLATCH, Jr.; DEBRA ANN WHITLATCH;

DONALD WHITLATCH; FRANCIS E. WHITLATCH; HENRY ABNER

WHITLATCH;

NORMA JEAN WHITLATCH; ROBERT PHILLIPS; WILLIAM H. WHITLATCH;

KATHY

L. WHITLATCH; ALFRED R. CHAMBERS, as power of Attorney for

Gary J. Pierson; ALFRED R. CHAMBERS, JR.; ALFRED R. CHAMBERS,

as Power of Attorney for Winifred J. Pierson; PAUL R. PHILLIPS;

BARBARA SWARTZMILLER; CHARLES E. WHITLATCH; PATRICIA

WHITLATCH; NETTIE PHILLIPS MORRIS; EDNA PHILLIPS SCHRADER;

VIRGINIA KENNEDY; HELEN KELLY; MARY THORNE; KENNETH L. PHILLIPS

 v.

BRADDOCK CEMETERY; CONSOL ENERGY, the successor and/or assign

of RHEINBRAUN U.S. Corporation; CNX COAL, the successor and/or

assign of Consol Pennsylvania Coal Company

CONSOL ENERGY, the successor and/or assign of Rheinbraun U.S.

Corporation; CNX COAL, the successor and/or assign of Consol

Pennsylvania Coal Company,

 Appellants

On Appeal from the United States District Court

for the Western District of Pennsylvania
D.C. No. 05-cv-01438

ORDER AMENDING OPINION

At the direction of the Court, Appellees CONSOL Energy and Consol

Pennsylvania Coal Company’s motion to amend the opinion to include Christopher P.

Furman, Esq. as counsel for Appellees is granted. The designation of attorneys for

Appellees CONSOL Energy and Consol Pennsylvania Coal Company is amended as

follows:

Joseph A. Katarincic

Jerri A. Ryan

Christopher P. Furman

Thorp, Reed & Armstrong

301 Grant Street

One Oxford Centre, 14th Floor

Pittsburgh, PA 15219

Attorneys for Consol Energy and CNX Coal

For the Court,

Marcia M. Waldron, Clerk

Dated: February 21, 2008

CRG/cc: Colm W. Kenny, Esq.

 Louis M. Tarasi, Esq.

 Rodger L. Puz, Esq.

 Christopher P. Furman, Esq.

 Joseph A. Katarincic, Esq.

 Jerri A. Ryan, Esq.