Skip to main content


U.S. flag
      An official website of the United States government
              Here’s how you know
        Here’s how you knowDot gov**Official websites use .gov**
                 A **.gov** website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
                  HTTPS**Secure .gov websites use HTTPS**
                 A **lock** (A locked padlock) or **https://** means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. 
  Menu Close
          HHS Search block
    Search
        








  
  
    

  
      

                                      About HHS
    
                        
                              
      
      
      Programs & Services
    
                        
                              
      
      
      Grants & Contracts
    
                        
                              
      
      
      Laws & Regulations Breadcrumb
    Home
                              About
                              Agencies
                              DAB
                              Decisions
                              ALJ Decisions
                              2020
                              David Lynch, M.D., DAB CR5682 (2020)
 Navigate to:
  Departmental Appeals Board (DAB)
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      About DAB
                                            
            
            Organizational Overview
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Who are the Judges?
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      DAB Divisions
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Contact DAB
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Filing an Appeal Online
                                            
            
            DAB E-File
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Medicare Operations Division (MOD) E-File
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Different Appeals at DAB
                                            
            
            Appeals to DAB Administrative Law Judges (ALJs)
                          
            
            Forms
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Procedures
    
                                                                
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Appeals to Board
                          
            
            Practice Manual
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Guidelines
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Regulations
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      National Coverage Determination Complaints
    
                                                                
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Appeals to the Medicare Appeals Council (Council)
                          
            
            Forms
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Fully Integrated Duals Advantage (FIDA) Demonstration Project
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Alternative Dispute Resolution Services
                                            
            
            Sharing Neutrals
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      ADR Training
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Other ADR Services
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      DAB Decisions
                                            
            
            Board Decisions
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      DAB Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Decisions
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Medicare Appeals Council (Council) Decisions
    
                                    
                              
            
      
      
      
      Stakeholder Feedback
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Careers
                                            
            
            Open Career Opportunities
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Internships & ExternshipsText resize icon

                    




David Lynch, M.D., DAB CR5682 (2020)








  
  
    

  
      
Department of Health and Human Services 
    DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS BOARD
          Civil Remedies Division





David Lynch, M.D.,
	(PTAN: 238414HEZ)
	(NPI: 1861609612)
	Petitioner,
v.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
Docket No. C-18-647Decision No. CR5682August 7, 2020

        
              
    

      DECISION
Petitioner, David Lynch, M.D., is a Pennsylvania physician, specializing in radiology, who participates in the Medicare program as a supplier of services.  After his Medicare billing privileges were deactivated, he applied to reenroll in the program.  The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) granted the application, effective October 5, 2017, resulting in a lengthy coverage lapse.  Petitioner now asks for an earlier effective date.
Because Petitioner filed his subsequently-approved enrollment application on October 5, 2017, I find that October 5 is the correct effective date for his enrollment.  *Howard M. Sokoloff, DPM, MS, Inc.*, DAB No. 2972 (2019); *Urology Grp. of NJ, LLC*, DAB No. 2860 (2018); *Willie Goffney, Jr., M.D.*, DAB No. 2763 at 7 (2017), *aff’d sub nom.* *Goffney v. Azar*, No. CV 17-8032 MRW (C.D. Cal. Sept. 25, 2019).
Background
In a notice letter dated October 30, 2017, the Medicare contractor, Novitas Solutions, advised Petitioner that it approved his revalidated Medicare enrollment.  CMS Ex. 3.  The letter does not mention the effective date of the revalidation or indicate that it resulted in
Page 2
a coverage gap.  Petitioner, nevertheless, understood that the revalidation resulted in a gap in coverage and requested reconsideration, complaining that he had not received the revalidation request and citing his lost revenue.  CMS Ex. 2.
In a reconsidered determination, dated January 30, 2018, the contractor affirmed the October 5 effective date, noting a coverage gap from August 11 through October 4, 2017.  CMS Ex. 1.  Petitioner appealed.
Petitioner moves for summary judgment, which CMS opposes.  However, because neither party proposes any witnesses, an in-person hearing would serve no purpose.  *See* Acknowledgment and Prehearing Order at 3, 5 (¶¶ 4(c)(iv), 8) (March 20, 2018).  I may therefore decide this case based on the written record, without considering whether the standards for summary judgment are satisfied.
CMS submits its motion and brief (CMS Br.) with eight exhibits (CMS Exs. 1-8).  Petitioner submits his brief (P. Br.) with two exhibits (P. Exs. 1-2).  In the absence of any objections, I admit into evidence CMS Exs. 1-8 and P. Exs. 1-2.  *See* Acknowledgment and Pre-hearing Order at 5 (¶ 7).
Discussion
***Petitioner filed his subsequently-approved enrollment application on October 5, 2017, and his reactivated Medicare enrollment can be no earlier than that date.  42 C.F.R. § 424.520(d).***1
**Enrollment**.  Petitioner Lynch participates in the Medicare program as a “supplier” of services.  Social Security Act § 1861(d); 42 C.F.R. § 498.2.  To receive Medicare payments for the services furnished to program beneficiaries, a prospective supplier must enroll in the program.  42 C.F.R. § 424.505.  “Enrollment” is the process by which CMS and its contractors:  1) identify the prospective supplier; 2) validate the supplier’s eligibility to provide items or services to Medicare beneficiaries; 3) identify and confirm a supplier’s owners and practice location; and 4) grant the supplier Medicare billing privileges.  42 C.F.R. § 424.502.
To enroll, a prospective supplier must complete and submit an enrollment application.  42 C.F.R. §§ 424.510(d)(1), 424.515(a).  An enrollment application is either a CMS-approved paper application or an electronic process approved by the Office of
Page 3
Management and Budget.  42 C.F.R. § 424.502.2
  When CMS determines that a prospective supplier meets the applicable enrollment requirements, it grants Medicare billing privileges, which means that the supplier can submit claims and receive payments from Medicare for covered services provided to program beneficiaries.  For a physician, the effective date for billing privileges “is the *later*of the date of filing” a subsequently-approved enrollment application or “[t]he date that the supplier first began furnishing services at a new practice location.”  42 C.F.R. § 424.520(d) (emphasis added).
**Revalidation and Deactivation**.  To maintain his billing privileges, a supplier must, at least every five years, resubmit and recertify the accuracy of its enrollment information, a process referred to as “revalidation.”  42 C.F.R. § 424.515.  In addition to periodic revalidations, CMS may, at other times and for its own reasons, ask a supplier to recertify the accuracy of his enrollment information.  42 C.F.R. § 424.515(d)-(e).  Within 60 days of receiving CMS’s notice to recertify, the supplier must submit an appropriate enrollment application with complete and accurate information and supporting documentation.  42 C.F.R. § 424.515(a)(2).
If, within 90 days from receipt of CMS’s notice, the supplier does not furnish complete and accurate information and all supporting documentation, or does not resubmit and certify the accuracy of its enrollment information, CMS may deactivate its billing privileges, and no Medicare payments will be made.  42 C.F.R. §§ 424.540(a)(3); 424.555(b).  To reactivate his billing privileges, the supplier must complete and submit a new enrollment application.  42 C.F.R. § 424.540(b)(1).  It is settled that, following deactivation, section 424.520(d) governs the effective date of reenrollment.  *Sokoloff*, DAB No. 2972 at 6-7; *Urology Grp.*, DAB No. 2860 at 7; *Goffney*, DAB No. 2763 at 7.
I have no authority to review a deactivation.  *Sokoloff*, DAB No. 2972 at 6; *Ark. Health Grp.*, DAB No. 2929 at 7-9 (2019).
**Petitioner’s deactivation and reenrollment**.  In a notice letter, dated December 12, 2016, the contractor directed Petitioner to revalidate his Medicare enrollment by updating or confirming the information in his record.  The letter directed Petitioner to submit, no later than **February 28, 2017**, an updated paper CMS-855 Medicare enrollment application or to review, update, and certify his information through the PECOS system.  The letter warned that Petitioner had to revalidate within 60 calendar days of the letter’s postmark date, or risk deactivation of his Medicare billing privileges.  CMS Ex. 7.
Although a copy of the letter was addressed to Petitioner’s correspondence address (*compare* CMS Ex. 4 at 6 *with* CMS Ex. 7 at 4), Petitioner maintains that he did not receive it.  Another copy was sent to what CMS asserts was one of Petitioner’s practice
Page 4
locations.  Petitioner, however, maintains that he is not “linked” to that location.  P. Br. at 2.
The contractor sent a second letter, dated July 27, 2017, stating that Petitioner did not revalidate his enrollment by February 28; the letter warned that, if his enrollment were deactivated, he would experience a gap in enrollment.  The contractor sent a copy of the letter to the same correspondence address and a copy to a post office box.  CMS Ex. 6.  Petitioner has not denied receiving this letter.  *See* P. Br.
In a letter dated August 11, 2017, the contractor advised Petitioner that his billing privileges were stopped, effective that date, because he had not revalidated his enrollment record.  To revalidate, the letter instructed him to submit an updated paper enrollment application, or to review, update, and certify his information via PECOS.  CMS Ex. 5.
No matter how compelling the circumstances, I have no authority to review a deactivation.  *Ark. Health Grp.*, DAB No. 2929 at 7-9 and cases cited therein.
On *October 5, 2017*, Petitioner filed a Medicare enrollment application (Form CMS-855I) and an application to assign benefits (CMS-855R) that the contractor subsequently approved.  CMS Exs. 3, 4.3
  Thus, pursuant to section 424.520(d), the date Petitioner filed its subsequently-approved enrollment application – October 5, 2017 – is the correct effective date of enrollment.  *Sokoloff*, DAB No. 2972 at 6-7; *Urology Grp.*, DAB No. 2860 at 7-9; *Goffney*, DAB 2763 at 7.
I have no authority to grant Petitioner an earlier effective date based on equitable and policy arguments.  *Sokoloff*, DAB No. 2972 at 9.
Conclusion
Because Petitioner filed his subsequently-approved reenrollment application on October 5, 2017, CMS properly granted his Medicare reenrollment effective that date.


          /s/
        Carolyn Cozad Hughes

                      Administrative Law Judge
      1. I make this one finding of fact/conclusion of law. back to note 1
                      2. CMS’s electronic process is referred to as PECOS (Provider Enrollment, Chain, and Ownership System). back to note 2
                      3. The first two digits stamped on the application (upper left corner) indicate the year – 2017.  The next four digits, 1005, indicate the date of receipt – October (the tenth month) 5.  CMS Ex. 4 at 1. back to note 3 Back to top
    Contact HHS
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Careers
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      HHS FAQs
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Nondiscrimination NoticeHHS Archive
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Accessibility Statement
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Privacy Policy
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Viewers & PlayersBudget/Performance
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Inspector General
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Web Site Disclaimers
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      EEO/No Fear ActFOIA
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      The White House
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      USA.gov
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Vulnerability Disclosure Policy
        Sign Up for Email Updates

Receive the latest updates from the Secretary, Blogs, and News Releases.

Sign Up
  HHS Headquarters
          200 Independence Avenue, S.W.
                  Washington, D.C. 20201
                  Toll Free Call Center: 1-877-696-6775​ Disclaimer Policy: Links with this icon () mean that you are leaving the HHS website. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) cannot guarantee the accuracy of a non-federal website.
                  Linking to a non-federal website does not mean that HHS or its employees endorse the sponsors, information, or products presented on the website. HHS links outside of itself to provide you with further information.
                  You will be bound by the destination website's privacy policy and/or terms of service when you follow the link.
                  HHS is not responsible for Section 508 compliance (accessibility) on private websites. For more information on HHS's web notification policies, see Website Disclaimers.
 Continue
                  Go back