Skip to main content


U.S. flag
      An official website of the United States government
              Here’s how you know
        Here’s how you knowDot gov**Official websites use .gov**
                 A **.gov** website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
                  HTTPS**Secure .gov websites use HTTPS**
                 A **lock** (A locked padlock) or **https://** means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. 
  Menu Close
          HHS Search block
    Search
        








  
  
    

  
      

                                      About HHS
    
                        
                              
      
      
      Programs & Services
    
                        
                              
      
      
      Grants & Contracts
    
                        
                              
      
      
      Laws & Regulations Breadcrumb
    Home
                              About
                              Agencies
                              DAB
                              Decisions
                              ALJ Decisions
                              2018
                              Bennybright Home Health Services, Inc., DAB CR5161 (2018)
 Navigate to:
  Departmental Appeals Board (DAB)
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      About DAB
                                            
            
            Organizational Overview
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Who are the Judges?
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      DAB Divisions
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Contact DAB
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Filing an Appeal Online
                                            
            
            DAB E-File
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Medicare Operations Division (MOD) E-File
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Different Appeals at DAB
                                            
            
            Appeals to DAB Administrative Law Judges (ALJs)
                          
            
            Forms
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Procedures
    
                                                                
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Appeals to Board
                          
            
            Practice Manual
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Guidelines
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Regulations
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      National Coverage Determination Complaints
    
                                                                
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Appeals to the Medicare Appeals Council (Council)
                          
            
            Forms
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Fully Integrated Duals Advantage (FIDA) Demonstration Project
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Alternative Dispute Resolution Services
                                            
            
            Sharing Neutrals
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      ADR Training
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Other ADR Services
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      DAB Decisions
                                            
            
            Board Decisions
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      DAB Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Decisions
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Medicare Appeals Council (Council) Decisions
    
                                    
                              
            
      
      
      
      Stakeholder Feedback
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Careers
                                            
            
            Open Career Opportunities
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Internships & ExternshipsText resize icon

                    




Bennybright Home Health Services, Inc., DAB CR5161 (2018)








  
  
    

  
      
Department of Health and Human Services 
    DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS BOARD
          Civil Remedies Division





Bennybright Home Health Services, Inc.,
	(CCN: 679369),
	Petitioner,
v.
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
Docket No. C-18-671Decision No. CR5161August 13, 2018

        
              
    

      DECISION
I grant summary judgment in favor of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) sustaining its determination to terminate the Medicare participation of Petitioner, Bennybright Home Health Services, Inc., a home health agency.
I. Background
CMS moved, alternatively, that I dismiss Petitioner's hearing request on the ground that it was not filed timely or that I enter summary judgment favorable to CMS on the merits. With its motion, CMS filed nine proposed exhibits that it identified as CMS Ex. 1-CMS Ex. 9. Petitioner did not reply to the motion.
I do not admit CMS's proposed exhibits as evidence inasmuch as I enter summary judgment based on undisputed material facts. I refer to some of these exhibits, but only to illustrate facts that are undisputed.
II. Ruling on CMS's Motion to Dismiss
CMS contends that Petitioner did not timely file a hearing request and did not offer good cause for its failure to do so. I deny this motion. On September 13, 2016, CMS sent a notice to Petitioner advising it that CMS was terminating Petitioner's Medicare
**Page 2**
participation on September 28, 2016, and informing Petitioner of its right to appeal CMS's determination. CMS Ex. 1. The notice advised Petitioner that it had 60 days within which to request a hearing and, further, instructed Petitioner to file its request electronically unless Petitioner requested a waiver. *Id.*
CMS contends that Petitioner did not file a hearing request until March 2018, about 16 months after its deadline for filing a request had expired.
The record establishes otherwise. Petitioner produced a letter that it contends that it sent to the Departmental Appeals Board (Board) on September 19, 2016. Petitioner's Hearing Request. CMS argues that this letter, if Petitioner sent it, violated instructions that it file its appeal request electronically. However, if Petitioner sent that letter in hard copy form, it is reasonable to infer that the letter itself constructively requested a waiver from electronic filing requirements.
CMS argues that there is no proof aside from the copy of the letter produced by Petitioner that it actually sent a hearing request to the Board. The Board never docketed the request. Petitioner did not produce a mailing receipt for the letter or a date-stamped copy of it. However, the record shows that Petitioner sent more than one inquiry to CMS in September and December 2016, inquiring about the status of its request. I infer from these communications that Petitioner filed a request and that the request was timely.
III. Issue, Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
**A. Issue**
The issue is whether undisputed facts establish that CMS was authorized to terminate Petitioner's participation in Medicare.
**B. Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law**
CMS terminated Petitioner's Medicare participation on the authority of 42 C.F.R. § 489.53(a)(18). This regulation states in relevant part that CMS may terminate a Medicare provider's or supplier's participation if it fails to grant immediate access to a representative of a state survey agency or other authorized entity in order that the representative may survey the provider or supplier for compliance with Medicare participation requirements.
The undisputed facts plainly establish that Petitioner failed to comply with this requirement, justifying CMS's determination to terminate Petitioner's Medicare participation. On July 25, 2016, at 8:50 a.m., a surveyor from the Texas state survey agency attempted to conduct a recertification survey at Petitioner's business address. CMS Ex. 9 at 1-2. The surveyor found Petitioner's facility to be locked, and she was
**Page 3**
unable to gain entry to it. *Id.* at 2; CMS Ex. 2 at 2. The surveyor eventually spoke with one of Petitioner's administrators, who told the surveyor that she was at a meeting but that she would attempt to return to the facility. CMS Ex. 2 at 2. The administrator told the surveyor that she lacked keys to Petitioner's facility and that she would have to call one of Petitioner's owners, in Chicago. *Id.* There then ensued a series of phone calls in which the surveyor attempted to find someone who could provide her with access to Petitioner's facility. *Id.* at 2-3. The person with whom the surveyor spoke told the surveyor that the person who had keys to the facility was traveling outside the country and was unavailable. *Id.* at 3. At 11:00 a.m., the surveyor gave up and left the facility without having been able to enter it. *Id.*
Petitioner admits that no one was available to allow the surveyor to enter the facility. It contends that the individuals who could have allowed entry were unavailable due to unforeseen family issues and emergencies. Petitioner's Hearing Request. That may be so, but that does not provide a defense for failure to provide access to the state agency surveyor. The regulation allows for no exceptions.
  
          /s/
        Steven T. Kessel

                      Administrative Law Judge Back to top
    Contact HHS
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Careers
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      HHS FAQs
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Nondiscrimination NoticeHHS Archive
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Accessibility Statement
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Privacy Policy
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Viewers & PlayersBudget/Performance
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Inspector General
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Web Site Disclaimers
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      EEO/No Fear ActFOIA
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      The White House
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      USA.gov
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Vulnerability Disclosure Policy
        Sign Up for Email Updates

Receive the latest updates from the Secretary, Blogs, and News Releases.

Sign Up
  HHS Headquarters
          200 Independence Avenue, S.W.
                  Washington, D.C. 20201
                  Toll Free Call Center: 1-877-696-6775​ Disclaimer Policy: Links with this icon () mean that you are leaving the HHS website. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) cannot guarantee the accuracy of a non-federal website.
                  Linking to a non-federal website does not mean that HHS or its employees endorse the sponsors, information, or products presented on the website. HHS links outside of itself to provide you with further information.
                  You will be bound by the destination website's privacy policy and/or terms of service when you follow the link.
                  HHS is not responsible for Section 508 compliance (accessibility) on private websites. For more information on HHS's web notification policies, see Website Disclaimers.
 Continue
                  Go back