Skip to main content


U.S. flag
      An official website of the United States government
              Here’s how you know
        Here’s how you knowDot gov**Official websites use .gov**
                 A **.gov** website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
                  HTTPS**Secure .gov websites use HTTPS**
                 A **lock** (A locked padlock) or **https://** means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. 
  Menu Close
          HHS Search block
    Search
        








  
  
    

  
      

                                      About HHS
    
                        
                              
      
      
      Programs & Services
    
                        
                              
      
      
      Grants & Contracts
    
                        
                              
      
      
      Laws & Regulations Breadcrumb
    Home
                              About
                              Agencies
                              DAB
                              Decisions
                              ALJ Decisions
                              2019
                              Carraway Chiropractic Center, PLLC, DAB CR5454 (2019)
 Navigate to:
  Departmental Appeals Board (DAB)
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      About DAB
                                            
            
            Organizational Overview
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Who are the Judges?
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      DAB Divisions
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Contact DAB
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Filing an Appeal Online
                                            
            
            DAB E-File
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Medicare Operations Division (MOD) E-File
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Different Appeals at DAB
                                            
            
            Appeals to DAB Administrative Law Judges (ALJs)
                          
            
            Forms
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Procedures
    
                                                                
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Appeals to Board
                          
            
            Practice Manual
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Guidelines
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Regulations
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      National Coverage Determination Complaints
    
                                                                
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Appeals to the Medicare Appeals Council (Council)
                          
            
            Forms
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Fully Integrated Duals Advantage (FIDA) Demonstration Project
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Alternative Dispute Resolution Services
                                            
            
            Sharing Neutrals
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      ADR Training
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Other ADR Services
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      DAB Decisions
                                            
            
            Board Decisions
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      DAB Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Decisions
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Medicare Appeals Council (Council) Decisions
    
                                    
                              
            
      
      
      
      Stakeholder Feedback
    
                                                  
                                                    
            
      
      
      
      Careers
                                            
            
            Open Career Opportunities
    
                                                  
                              
            
      
      
      
      Internships & ExternshipsText resize icon

                    




Carraway Chiropractic Center, PLLC, DAB CR5454 (2019)








  
  
    

  
      
Department of Health and Human Services 
    DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS BOARD
          Civil Remedies Division





Carraway Chiropractic Center, PLLC
	(PTAN: NN2036H979),
	Petitioner,
v.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
Docket No. C-19-171Decision No. CR5454October 29, 2019

        
              
    

      DECISION
The effective date of Medicare enrollment and billing privileges of Petitioner, Carraway Chiropractic Center, PLLC, is April 23, 2018, with retrospective billing allowed beginning March 24, 2018.
I. Background and Procedural History
Petitioner, a clinic/group practice, submitted a Form CMS-855I enrollment application with supporting documents via the U.S. Postal Service on April 20, 2018, that was received on April 23, 2018. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Exhibit (Ex.) 1 at 4, 38 (postmark date of April 20, 2018, and stamped markings indicating receipt on the 113th day of 2018). On June 15, 2018, Palmetto GBA (Palmetto) approved Petitioner's application and assigned a March 24, 2018 effective date for Petitioner's Medicare billing privileges.1
 CMS Ex. 4 at 1.
**Page 2**
Petitioner submitted a request for reconsideration dated June 15, 2018. 2
 Petitioner (P.) Ex. 5. In its request, Petitioner stated the following:
We are respectfully requesting an effective date of 01/01/18 for the following reason: We incorporated our practice [and] required a new tax ID number. However, the IRS issued the number in the wrong practice name. We did not want to start the Medicare enrollment process with this incorrect tax ID document, so we waited until that issue was resolved, which required several requests to the IRS and was significantly delayed. [We] have attached copies of the IRS application, their response, and the corrected document, which we finally received on 4-16-18.
P. Ex. 5 at 1.
Palmetto issued a reconsidered determination on September 14, 2018, in which it stated that it had "reviewed the specific facts associated with [Petitioner's] enrollment application and the effective date established, and unfortunately, we are not able to make a change to the effective date of filing." P. Ex. 6 at 1.
Petitioner submitted a request for an administrative law judge (ALJ) hearing that was received on November 8, 2018. ALJ Leslie A. Weyn issued an Acknowledgment and Pre-Hearing Order (Pre-Hearing Order) on November 29, 2018, at which time she directed the parties to file their respective pre-hearing exchanges.3
 CMS filed a brief in support of summary judgment, along with four proposed exhibits (CMS Exs. 1-4). Petitioner filed a brief (P. Br) and six proposed exhibits (P. Exs. 1-6).  In the absence of any objections, I admit CMS Exs. 1-4 and P. Exs. 1-6 into the evidentiary record.
A hearing for the purpose of cross-examination is unnecessary because neither party has submitted written direct testimony. Pre-Hearing Order §§ 8-10. I consider the record in this case to be closed, and the matter is ready for a decision on the merits.4
**Page 3**
II. Issue
Whether the effective date of Petitioner's Medicare enrollment and billing privileges is April 23, 2018, with retrospective billing beginning March 24, 2018.
III. Jurisdiction
I have jurisdiction to hear and decide this case. 42 C.F.R § 498.3(b)(15); *Victor Alvarez, M.D.*, DAB No. 2325 at 8-12 (2010); *see also* 42 U.S.C. § 1395cc(j)(8).
IV. Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Analysis5
***Pursuant to 42 C.F.R. §§ 424.520(d) and 424.521(a)(1), Petitioner's Medicare enrollment and billing privileges were effective April 23, 2018, which is the date Palmetto received the enrollment application that it processed to approval, with retrospective billing allowed beginning on March 24, 2018.***
As a clinic/group practice, Petitioner is a "supplier" for purposes of the Medicare program. *See* CMS Ex. 1 at 20; *see also* 42 U.S.C. § 1395x(d); 42 C.F.R. §§ 400.202 (definition of supplier); 498.2.  A "supplier" furnishes items or services under Medicare, and the term applies to physicians or other practitioners who are not included within the definition of the phrase "provider of services." 42 U.S.C. § 1395x(d). A supplier must enroll in the Medicare program to receive payment for covered Medicare items or services. 42 C.F.R. § 424.505. The regulations at 42 C.F.R. Part 424, subpart P, establish the requirements for a supplier to enroll in the Medicare program. 42 C.F.R. §§ 424.510-424.516; *see also* 42 U.S.C. § 1395cc(j)(1)(A) (authorizing the Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to establish regulations addressing the enrollment of providers and suppliers in the Medicare program). A supplier who seeks billing privileges under Medicare "must submit enrollment information on the applicable enrollment application." 42 C.F.R. § 424.510(a)(1). "Once the provider or supplier successfully completes the enrollment process ... CMS enrolls the provider or supplier into the Medicare program." *Id.*; *see also* 42 C.F.R. § 424.510(d) (listing enrollment requirements). When the contractor approves an enrollment application, it sets the effective date for approval of billing privileges. *See Alexander C. Gatzimos, MD, JD, LLC*, DAB No. 2730 at 2 (2016). "The effective date of a physician's or physician organization's enrollment in Medicare is ‘the later of the date of filing of a Medicare enrollment application that was subsequently approved by a Medicare contractor or the
**Page 4**
date [the supplier] first began furnishing services at a new practice location.'" *Id.* at 2-3, *citing* 42 C.F.R. § 424.520(d).
The Departmental Appeals Board (DAB) has explained that "[t]he governing law on how CMS (and its Medicare contractors) determine the effective date for [suppliers] applying for Medicare billing privileges is set by regulation" at 42 C.F.R. § 424.520(d). *Willie Goffney, Jr., M.D.*, DAB No. 2763 at 7 (2017). Even though Petitioner argues that it should be able to bill for services rendered dating back to January 1, 2018, it did not submit an enrollment application to Palmetto until April 23, 2018. CMS Ex. 1 at 1. Therefore, the earliest possible effective date for Petitioner's enrollment and billing privileges is the later date of April 23, 2018, with retrospective billing allowed beginning on March 24, 2018. 42 C.F.R. §§ 424.520(d), 424.521(a)(1). Accordingly, I conclude that Petitioner's billing privileges began no earlier than March 24, 2018.
Petitioner does not contend that it submitted an enrollment application prior to April 23, 2018. Rather, Petitioner explains that when it reincorporated its business in December 2017, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) listed the wrong business name in its December 14, 2017 notice containing Petitioner's employer identification number (EIN). P. Br. at 1. Specifically, Petitioner explains that the IRS notice listed "LLC" in Petitioner's business name, when in fact "PLLC" is the business structure that it lists in its business name. P. Br. at 1; *see* P. Exs. 1, 2. Petitioner explained that it was reluctant to submit its Medicare enrollment application until it received corrected EIN documentation from the IRS.6
 P. Br. at 1.
Petitioner does not contend that Palmetto committed any error when it allowed Petitioner to begin billing Medicare effective March 24, 2018. P. Br. at 1. Rather, Petitioner acknowledges its own delay in submitting the enrollment application. P. Br. at 1 ("Since our document from the IRS did NOT contain our Legal Business Name, we were hesitant to submit the application and attest with information we knew to be false. We now understand that CMS will only establish an effective date 30 days prior to the application's receipt ...."). Regardless of the reason why Petitioner delayed in submitting a Medicare enrollment application, the simple fact is that it did not submit this application until April 23, 2018; therefore, the effective date of Petitioner's Medicare enrollment is April 23, 2018, with retrospective billing privileges beginning March 24,
**Page 5**
2018. Pursuant to 42 C.F.R. §§ 424.520(d) and 424.521(a)(1), Petitioner's billing privileges began no earlier than March 24, 2018.
To the extent that Petitioner's request for an earlier effective date is based on principles of equitable relief, I cannot grant such relief. *US Ultrasound*, DAB No. 2302 at 8 (2010) ("Neither the ALJ nor the [DAB] is authorized to provide equitable relief by reimbursing or enrolling a supplier who does not meet statutory or regulatory requirements."). Petitioner points to no authority by which I may grant it relief from the applicable regulatory requirements, and I have no authority to declare statutes or regulations invalid or ultra vires. *1866ICPayday.com, L.L.C*., DAB No. 2289 at 14 (2009) ("An ALJ is bound by applicable laws and regulations and may not invalidate either a law or regulation on any ground ....").
Palmetto had a legitimate basis to assign an April 23, 2018 effective date for Petitioner's Medicare enrollment and billing privileges, with retrospective billing privileges beginning March 24, 2018. *See* 42 C.F.R. §§ 424.520(d), 424.521(a)(1).
V. Conclusion
For the foregoing reasons, I uphold the April 23, 2018 effective date of Petitioner's Medicare enrollment and billing privileges, with retrospective billing allowed beginning March 24, 2018.


          /s/
        Leslie C. Rogall

                      Administrative Law Judge
      1. Palmetto did not provide an explanation for its determination that March 24, 2018, was the effective date of the application. It is apparent that Palmetto afforded Petitioner 30 days of retrospective billing privileges prior to the April 23, 2018 submission date of the application. In more precise terms, the actual effective date of the application is April 23, 2018, and the retrospective billing privileges are effective March 24, 2018. See 42 C.F.R. §§ 424.520(d), 424.521(a)(1). back to note 1
                      2. I reference the exhibit submitted by Petitioner, as CMS did not submit a copy of the request for reconsideration as a proposed exhibit. back to note 2
                      3. This case was reassigned to me on March 8, 2019. back to note 3
                      4. Because a hearing is unnecessary, I need not address whether summary judgment is appropriate. back to note 4
                      5. Findings of fact and conclusions of law are in italics and bold font. back to note 5
                      6. Petitioner has submitted evidence indicating that the IRS issued corrected documentation in response to March 3, 2018 correspondence from Petitioner. P. Ex. 3 at 1. March 3, 2018, is more than 11 weeks following the date of the IRS's initial notice of Petitioner's EIN. P. Ex. 3 at 1; see P. Ex. 2 at 1. Even assuming, for the sake of this discussion, that Petitioner took immediate action to obtain correct EIN documentation, this would have no bearing on my analysis because the effective date of Petitioner's billing privileges is controlled by the date it submitted its enrollment application that was processed to approval. back to note 6 Back to top
    Contact HHS
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Careers
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      HHS FAQs
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Nondiscrimination NoticeHHS Archive
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Accessibility Statement
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Privacy Policy
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Viewers & PlayersBudget/Performance
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Inspector General
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Web Site Disclaimers
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      EEO/No Fear ActFOIA
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      The White House
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      USA.gov
    
                        
                                            
      
      
      Vulnerability Disclosure Policy
        Sign Up for Email Updates

Receive the latest updates from the Secretary, Blogs, and News Releases.

Sign Up
  HHS Headquarters
          200 Independence Avenue, S.W.
                  Washington, D.C. 20201
                  Toll Free Call Center: 1-877-696-6775​ Disclaimer Policy: Links with this icon () mean that you are leaving the HHS website. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) cannot guarantee the accuracy of a non-federal website.
                  Linking to a non-federal website does not mean that HHS or its employees endorse the sponsors, information, or products presented on the website. HHS links outside of itself to provide you with further information.
                  You will be bound by the destination website's privacy policy and/or terms of service when you follow the link.
                  HHS is not responsible for Section 508 compliance (accessibility) on private websites. For more information on HHS's web notification policies, see Website Disclaimers.
 Continue
                  Go back