*HomeU.S. Government Accountability Office*
Menu

      close


          
          
                          	
				
				
	
	
					Reports & Testimonies
									
																				
				
				
	
	
								Reports & Testimonies
													
																												
																						
							
																Recommendations Database
							
																												
																						
							
																Month in Review
							
																												
																						
							
																Order Copies
							
																												
																						
							
																Restricted Reports
							
																												
																						
							
																View Topics
							
																												
																						
							
																View Agencies
							
																												
																						
							
																Bid Protests & Appropriations Law
									
																				
				
				
	
	
								Bid Protests & Appropriations Law
													
																												
																						
							
																Bid Protests
							
																												
																						
							
																Appropriations Law
							
																												
																						
							
																Federal Vacancies Reform Act
							
																												
																						
							
																Other Legal
							
																												
																						
							
																About
									
																				
				
				
	
	
								About
													
																												
																						
							
																What GAO Does
							
																												
																						
							
																U.S. Comptroller General
							
																												
																						
							
																Careers
							
																												
																						
							
																Contact UsFor Congress
                                
                          
        
                Press Center
                                
                          
        
                Careers
                                
                          
        
                BlogSearch Breadcrumb
        Home
                            Reports & Testimonies
                            Pandemic Unemployment Assistance: Federal Program Supported Contingent Workers Amid Historic Demand, But DOL Should Examine Racial Disparities In Benefit Receipt
    Pandemic Unemployment Assistance:
                          Federal Program Supported Contingent Workers Amid Historic Demand, but DOL Should Examine Racial Disparities in Benefit Receipt **GAO-22-104438**
        Published: Jun 07, 2022. Publicly Released: Jun 07, 2022.Jump To:
    Jump ToElder Abuse
          Services for Older Adults
          State and Local-Level Drivers and Trends
          State and Local Fiscal Projections
          Federal Borrowing
          Managing the Debt
          Summary of Funding Provisions
          Auditing the Government's Books
          Unpacking the Financial Report
          Highlights
          Recommendations
          Background
          About This Work
          About This Work
          Trends
          About the Center
          Why It's High Risk
          What Remains To Be Done
          Key Reports
          Newest COVID-Related Reports
          AI Use Cases
          Flood Insurance
          Past Pandemic-Related Reports
          CARES Act Oversight Reports
          All COVID-19 Reports
          Report Suspected Fraud
          Subjects
          How to Get Notified
          Past Reports
          Public Health Threats
          Explore the FY 2022 and 2023 Funds
          Lessons Learned
          Agency Reports
          Recent Reports
          Recommendations
          Supplemental Material
          Full Report
          Additional Data
          View Decision
          Downloads
          Previously Identified Actions
          Related Pages
          Associated Agencies
          Tough Choices and Opportunities Ahead
          Americas Fiscal Future Key Areas
          Retirement Security Key Areas
          Current List
          About The High Risk List
          Area Ratings
          Previous High Risk Products
          Search Federal Vacancies
          Past Federal Vacancies
          Violation Letters
          About the Yellow Book
          Advisory Council
          Related Resources
          Comment Letters
          Related Publications
          Contacts and Resources
          Major Issues Facing the Nation
          Meeting Strategic Challenges
          Additional Resources
          Resources
          GAO Contacts
          Mission Teams
          Operations and Staff Offices
          Organization Chart
          Why a Career at GAO?
          Am I Qualified?
          Company Culture
          Reasonable Accommodations
          Video Gallery
          Paid Internships
          Student Volunteers
          Professional Development Program
          Advancement
          Executive Candidate Program
          Summer Associates
          Externships
          Benefits
          Contacts
                    Fast Facts
              To respond to historic job losses during the pandemic, a temporary federal program expanded unemployment benefits to typically-ineligible contingent workers and others.

Issues ramping up the new program to meet urgent, immense demand meant some claimants went months without income. We also found racial disparities in who received benefits in 3 of 4 states we analyzed, e.g., Black applicants were half as likely to obtain benefits as White applicants in 2 states.

Contingent workers who received benefits said the support was critical. We recommended that the Department of Labor assess options to support contingent workers in the future.
Skip to Highlights
Highlights
  What GAO Found

When the pandemic began, states faced historic demand and urgency to pay unemployment insurance (UI) benefits, and their experiences implementing the new Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA) program varied. According to data reported to the Department of Labor (DOL), most states started paying PUA claims by the end of May 2020. States faced high demand for PUA early in the pandemic and demand generally remained high through June 2021. As selected states implemented PUA, they faced IT and staffing challenges, among others, which contributed to payment delays. Selected states also had to balance paying PUA claims quickly with minimizing improper payments.

The 48 contingent workers GAO spoke with in two states experienced sudden unemployment, and those who reported receiving PUA generally said they relied on the benefits to meet their basic financial needs. These workers also faced challenges, such as long wait times for benefits, customer service difficulties, and having to draw on savings or borrow money. With PUA's expiration in September 2021, benefits are generally no longer available for self-employed and contingent workers. DOL does not have plans to comprehensively assess if there are ways for the UI system to support this substantial part of the workforce. Without doing so, DOL may not realize its stated vision for a UI system that provides a lifeline to workers in the modern economy and may limit information available to Congress and other policymakers considering options to support these workers.

GAO found substantial racial and ethnic disparities in PUA benefit receipt in three of four selected states (see table). For example, in two states, the percentage of Black applicants who received PUA was about half that of White applicants. Results from two national surveys show similar disparities in UI receipt. Various factors could explain these disparities, such as how states reviewed claims or whether fraudsters more frequently used certain demographics when filing. In its August 2021 modernization plan, DOL emphasized the need to create a more equitable UI system and subsequently made funds and technical assistance available to states to examine and address equity issues. However, DOL has not yet analyzed the extent and cause of racial disparities in PUA to determine whether such inequities were isolated or caused by broader issues in the system.

Percentage of PUA Applicants Receiving Benefits in Selected States, by Race and Ethnicity

**State**

			**(analyzed through):**
			**Louisiana**

			**(Oct. 2020)**
			**New York**

			**(Dec. 2020)**
			**North Dakota**

			**(Apr. 2021)**
			**Wisconsin**

			**(Apr. 2021)**White, non-Hispanic/Latino
			66.9%
			84.4%
			39.0%
			43.3%Black, non-Hispanic/Latino
			72.3%
			83.5%
			19.5% *
			21.9% *Asian, non-Hispanic/Latino
			91.7% *
			91.4%
			61.7% *
			41.8%American Indian/Alaskan Native, non-Hispanic/Latino
			73.7%
			82.6%
			39.6%
			27.2% *Hispanic/Latino
			67.4%
			85.5%
			36.8%
			24.8% *Source: GAO analysis of aggregated Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA) claimant data provided by states. | GAO22104438

Notes: GAO limited its analyses of Louisiana and New York PUA claims to those prior to influxes of potentially fraudulent claims. GAO excluded the fifth state, Arizona, due to large amounts of potential fraud in multiple months. Minority groups with substantial differences compared to White, non-Hispanic/Latino (the largest group of applicants in each state) are shown with an asterisk.

Why GAO Did This Study

In response to widespread unemployment caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, the CARES Act created the federal PUA program. The first program of its kind and scale, PUA temporarily expanded unemployment benefits to workers generally ineligible for UI, such as self-employed and contingent workers—those without traditional employment arrangements.

The CARES Act includes a provision for GAO to monitor federal efforts to respond to the COVID-19 pandemic. This report examines (1) how state implementation of PUA varied, (2) how the pandemic affected contingent workers in selected states, and to what extent the UI system assisted them, and (3) how PUA benefit receipt varied by demographic characteristics.

GAO interviewed officials from DOL and five states selected for variation in claims volume and implementation timing. GAO also analyzed PUA data obtained from the selected states and data DOL collects from all states. In two states, GAO held discussions with contingent workers who applied for PUA. GAO also reviewed relevant federal law and program guidance.

Recommendations
      
            GAO is making two recommendations to DOL to advise the Congress and other policymakers on future options to support unemployed contingent workers and examine the extent and causes of inequities in the receipt of PUA. DOL agreed with the first and partially agreed with the second recommendation, expressing concern that an analysis of PUA would compete with its other efforts to improve equity. GAO continues to see value in this analysis, as discussed in the report.
      Recommendations for Executive Action
        Agency Affected
                                                  Recommendation
                                                  StatusDepartment of Labor
                                                                                        The Secretary of Labor should study and advise the Congress and other policymakers on the costs, benefits, and risks of various options to systematically support self-employed and contingent workers during periods of involuntary unemployment outside of declared disasters, including considering options' feasibility and approach to fraud prevention. (Recommendation 1)
                                                                                        Open
DOL agreed with this recommendation. As of June 2023, DOL reiterated that the agency will continue to explore legislative action and will provide technical assistance on this topic to Congress, upon request. DOL also said that it plans to study how to improve efforts to provide benefits to non-covered workers quickly and securely in the case of a future mass unemployment event when such workers might be authorized to receive benefits. As part of that effort, DOL has interviewed subject matter experts, state workforce agencies, federal agencies, and external groups on this topic to discuss lessons learned from the pandemic. These efforts are important steps. However, this recommendation will remain open until DOL provides information publicly about options to systematically support self-employed and contingent workers outside of emergency events, and we will continue to monitor the agency's efforts to provide such technical assistance.Department of Labor
                                                                                        Priority Rec.The Secretary of Labor should ensure the Office of Unemployment Insurance examines and publicly reports on the extent of and potential causes of racial and ethnic inequities in the receipt of Pandemic Unemployment Assistance benefits, as part of the agency's efforts to modernize UI and improve equity in the system. The report should also address whether there is a need to examine racial, ethnic, or other inequities in regular UI benefit receipt, based on the PUA findings. (Recommendation 2)
                                                                                        Open
DOL partially agreed with this recommendation, noting that enhancing demographic data collection in the permanent UI programs to inform actions to improve equity is a higher priority than performing a complete retrospective review of the PUA program, which is no longer operating. As of June 2023, DOL's efforts to promote equity in UI programs have continued. DOL has provided grant awards to 41 states as of May 2023 to promote equitable access to UI programs. DOL has also continued its work to establish data partnerships with selected states to obtain claimant-level data to analyze the demographic and geographic characteristics of people who apply for, receive, and are denied UI benefits, including reasons for denial, if possible. DOL has received data from one partner state, has finalized an agreement with another state, and is working on agreements with three other states. DOL also plans to enhance its collection of demographic information in certain reports states submit with UI data to better understand and identify barriers to equitable access to the UI program and benefits. DOL plans to submit the proposed revisions for review by the Office of Management and Budget by the end of FY 2023. These ongoing efforts represent key steps to promoting equity in UI programs. We also maintain that examining and reporting on the extent and potential causes of racial and ethnic inequities in the receipt of PUA benefits would provide valuable information for DOL and policymakers to effectively monitor state practices for meeting its goals of advancing racial, geographic, and gender equity in the UI system. We appreciate DOL's commitment to improving equity in UI programs, and to consider the insights in our report as it advances its ongoing and planned efforts. We await the results of DOL's efforts and encourage the agency to pursue an analysis of the extent of and potential causes of inequities in the receipt of PUA benefits in tandem with the agency's other ongoing efforts. For example, DOL could consider obtaining and analyzing PUA data from the states with which DOL is establishing data partnerships, and then assessing the need for further study based on initial findings.Full Report
    Highlights Page (1 page)
              Full Report (77 pages)
              Accessible PDF (86 pages)
GAO Contacts
    
      Thomas Costa
            
            Director
      
            costat@gao.gov
      
            (202) 512-4769
Office of Public Affairs
    
      Chuck Young
            
            Managing Director
      
            youngc1@gao.gov
      
            (202) 512-4800
Topics
    
      Worker and Family AssistanceContingent workersInsurance claimsLabor forcepandemicsPublic health emergenciesTerritories and possessionsUnemploymentUnemployment assistanceUnemployment insuranceWorkers
                                                      MultimediaPhoto (staged) of a man holding a cardboard sign that says he lost his job due to COVID-19
          Blog Post
              Lessons Learned When a Pandemic Led to Rapidly Rising Unemployment Claims
            Tuesday, June 7, 2022
      
            The pandemic brought with it a major onslaught of new unemployment applications across the country...
Press Release
        GAO Designates Unemployment Insurance System as "High Risk"Date
              Tuesday, June 7, 2022

            Washington, D.C. (June 7, 2022) – The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) has added the Unemployment Insurance (UI) system to its list of federal areas at “High Risk” for waste, fraud, abuse...
 Receive GAO Updates
  Stay informed as we add new reports & testimonies.

    GAO Logo
      U.S. Government Accountability Office


                                   Column 1
                            Press Center
                              Contact Us
                              Inspector General
                              Restricted Reports
                              Column 2
                            Copyright & Terms of Use
                              Privacy Policy
                              Accessibility
                              Sitemap
                              Column 3
                            FOIA Requests
                              Scam Alerts
                              No FEAR Act Data
                              Health Care Advisory Committees