5 

 10 

 15 

 20 

 25 

 1 

2 

3 

4 

6 

7 

8 

9 

11 

12 

13 

14 

16 

17 

18 

19 

21 

22 

23 

24 

26 

27 

28 

Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 Filed 07/14/23 Page 1 of 20 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 

SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION 

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 

Case No. 3:23-cv-3516

Plaintiff, 

v. 

STIPULATED ORDER FOR 

VICEROY MEDIA SOLUTIONS, LLC, also CIVIL PENALTY JUDGMENT, 

d/b/a quick-jobs.com and localjobsindex.com, a PERMANENT INJUNCTION, 

California limited liability corporation; AND OTHER RELIEF 

VOLTRON INTERACTIVE, LLC, a Delaware 

limited liability corporation; 

SUNIL KANDA, individually and as an owner of 

VICEROY MEDIA SOLUTIONS, LLC and 

VOLTRON INTERACTIVE, LLC; and 

QUYNH TRAN, a/k/a/ Kayli Tran, individually 

and as an owner of VICEROY MEDIA 

SOLUTIONS, LLC and VOLTRON 

INTERACTIVE, LLC, 

Defendants. 

Plaintiff, the United States of America, acting upon notification and authorization to the 

Attorney General the Federal Trade Commission (“Commission” or “FTC”), filed its Complaint 

STIPULATED ORDER FOR CIVIL PENALTY JUDGMENT, PERMANENT INJUNCTION, 

AND OTHER RELIEF 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 

  
 






 

   		
	 
		
 



 

  
 
 	









 

	

*

$ � �( +

) 6 ((

� �

9 (

(

0 �� 1 + $ ( � ! ( $ � (� ( & *

' �&

�

26 26 � �

�

�

�

��

*$ � �

*

� )

��

� ((*

� + !#$ 4

& 0) $� � � � 1� ) / + � � � (/ � ) '� )( * �' +� 0 ! & 4 &

�

/

 ̆

� ̆ ̆ ̆�

>

� & ( 4 � K U )( ((

$�((�

# $1 �/ �

/

/

(

(

)( ! ,)* (

� & $ � � � & � + ! % + (�

#

�





�

��

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 ,4)&"32�!'$&'�

Filed 07/14/23 #'4�)�#"!�65*($ ,) Page 2 of 20  ̆ !"#�$%&�'()&*$'+�'#,)('*(-.(/*$"()0�*1'# ('(*�  $(-.(/*$"(�/$%$&�4'()&*$'+� 0�"*1'##'&$'!�$(�*1$+�,)*'#�4.#+.)(*�*"�'/*$"(+ ̇2)62 ̆ ˇ  ̇2,6 ̆26� ̆ˇ7� ̆ ̋2)6�)(0 ̆ ̃�"!�*1'�'0'#)&�#)0'�",,$+$"(�/*23/*56 ̆ ̇�888 �

ˆ

 ̋

 ̨

°

 ̇

�



$



)

(

9



$

�

0

%

�

0

ˆ

�

$

*

&

 ̇

+

1

�

4

2



'

)

.

'

�

6



*

(



'

�

)

"

ˆ

�$

&

,4 ̇

(

*;2

�

,6*1

&



)

.

$

�

+



2

$

0



(

 ̆

�

<

)

*

6

�

/

8

,'2



*





�

$



"

�

6

&

(



)

�

*

�

 ̇



$

7

(

ˇ



'

*

2

'

$

*

7

:

#

!

6

,)�



)

�

'

 ̇

(

 ̋

0

�

'

2

�

*

�

)

(

1

)

6

*

'

+

'



�

,8�

�



!

)

!

(

'

"

-.�

&

0

(

"

�

)

 ̇

/

:

(

 ̨

*

*

$

+

7

+

"

=

8

�

�

(

+



*

�

$

)

4

'

(

.

!

0

'

&)�

(

*

0

'

*

)

�

1

*

(

"

'

*

�

#

+

*

�

1

�

'

)

'

�'%

&$(

'

'

*

�

!

#

:

�

;

2

)

3

�"$%!�#

'

*

0

0

1

'

�

$

#

+

'

5

�#

6�%

*

*

$

"

4

/

�

.

'

#'�

&

"

)

+

*

!

"

'

�

&

*

0

%

1

�

'

'

�

�

)

+

#

.

0

&

,," '

�,)#�!"*

#

(

'

�

#

+

+

�

�

 ̃ >?� @>AB>ACD � ̆

�

$(�%$"&) ̆



*$8"

�

(�"!�'

1

/

$

'

*

+

�

$

�



"



(

"

"

�

,4 ̇

.

�

#

"

*

&

�

!

)

1

�

$

*

)

(

1

+

*

'

�-�

/

.

1

#



)

$+

#

0

<

�

$

'



/

+

*

/

�

$

*

"

*

1



(

�

)

 ̆

�

*

"

 ̇

�

%

�'

'

#

8

!

�



'

*1(

8$

0

+

8

)

�,)9

(

�

*

ˆ

+� ̇4

*'�#

)

#

8

*

�

$

0�$41

)

'

*

�

'



0

'

�$&(

'

�

,)0'/#E''

4

*$(%<

'

�)/)

*

&

+

'

�

+

"

�

#�4

.

#

&

)

'

/

�2**

$

1

/

'�

+� � ̆

 ̆

ˇ

ˆ

 ̇

 ̨

 ̃

°

 ̋

� 3

0

+



/

)

'



"

(

)

/

*

(

0



&

*

)

$



*

�

�

(

)

'

.



<

+

<

5

+

°

*

#

�

�

$

�

*

�

"

ˆ

ˇ

(

*



1

1

'

#

8

8

<

'

�

�

�

'

8

3

*

�



�

:

"

/

%

8

"

�



'

)

7

.

(

7

&

'

8

&

$

+

�

'

0

)

9

.

5

$

#

$

*

,''

'

6

*

�



'

*

;



!

!

+

1

ˆ

�

'

'

�

)

�

"

'

 ̆

(

(

#

4

+

�

$

!



0

0

�

.

#

�

)



�

)

*

)

#

,'"

1

4

(

(

/

*

:

$

)

"

"

*

*

+

+

�

#

�

(

(

*

�

*

"

)

:

0

�

'

/

�

(

'

#

'

0

*

)

"

0

#

1

0

&

$

(

+

;

'

�

%





*

#

$

�

#

�

'

+

(

 ̆

0

"

8

&

�

�

<

)

 ̋

)

�

4

!

$

�

�

(

(

*



'

)

1

0

;

#

*

8

$

'

�

*

�

)

/

(

$

�

'

!

4

8

&

<

�

*

)

+

:

#

"

�

8

$

"

/

8

,�#

�

)

�

"

+

(



$

'

(

'

%

)

*

/

+

;

1

'

#

.

.

*

)

�

�

!

*

)

,'*

ˇ

$

�

"

 ̆

*

&

'

1

�

(

+

#

#

'

$

8

+



"

�

<

;

�

�

$

-

!

1

(

"

�

,)*

*

�

7

+

1

/

�

�

"

$

*

"

;

+

"

#

�

�

�

1

(

)

'

/

)

'

0

*

%

/

$

4

.

"

*

'

'

$

/

�

(

"

)

.

)

�

(

&

*

*

(

�

$

1

�

"

"

0

:

#

#

(

'

"

�

$

#

"

�

*

.

"

�

1

*

*

<

1

�21

4

'

'

)

�

#

"

*

6

:

1

�

#

)

*

F

'

$

.

/

+

�

.

0

F

(

'

)

.

�

$

&

/

*

*

�

$

'

1



#

'

$

�

)

+

(

"



<

!

/

&

�)'

�

'

�

*

(

/

(

1

"

0

<

+

$+�

(

�

'

*

*

�

+

�

"

1

"

.

�

'

#



#

,'(

�

0

.

�

'

+

2

*

7

#

#

$



�

6

/

�

�

'� 

� ̆ˇ

ˆ

 ̇

 ̋

 ̨

�

"

.

4

(

*

)

$

,7"(+$

�



<



*".

"

1

8

�

"

#

'

4

�

.

�

*

#

!

1

+

"

"

�

'

%

)

�

&

3

 ̆

$

.

4

"

0

J

8

*

.

:

�

'

1

#

�

"

$

4

K

"

(

L

#

"

M

$

<

�

+

Y

NO:

�

'

)

0



�

(

*

"

"

*

$

!

P

"

'

!

'

L

�

+

1

(

Q

*

�

1

"

#

R

(

*

$

$

&

�

"

(

+

0

G

�

*

�

<

S

�

"

/

T

"

"

#

"

0

M

&'(

R

'

+

/

+

'

#

*

*



'

$

U

(

*

�

(

>

*

"

*

.

V

1

?



*

(

� B �

*

�

'

'

W

!

�

)

#

�

X

!



"

(

�

"

U

)

,�0

R

&

!

�

X

!

"

+

$

$

*

#

G

)

:

P

#

1

,)5

&

@

'

'

$

�

(

,'�



>

1

�

*

<

A

*

$

"

$

#

�

%

0

)

%

>

'

'

H

(

'

'

�

�

+

!

+

#

>

)

$

$



!

IAZ

(

/

�

(

'

.

*

4

$

<

#

�

4

*



/

#

�

$

�

"

"

'

"

D

(

%

#

,,. �

+

�

'

+

0

7

�

#

�



$

)

'



+

�

"

$

,./

4

(

&

<

"

&

+

$

;

�

/

*

'

+

4

$

)

=

.

(

�

#

*

#

*

'

<

$

=

'

(

+

�'

<

"

4

(

�

!

)

+

*

�

.

4



'0+

'

"

$

/

�

(

%

:

$!<

'

$

#



*

/

�

'

1

"



0

�

#

$

.

�

�



/

!

(

&

)

"

"

!

,

#

"

+

,'#

$

7

(

,)$

<

<

0

�

.



*

"

�

$

"

)

!

"

�

.

(

)

+

0

�

8� ��

°� 



�





�





�  �

� ��� 	

�



�

�

�

 

�

�

�

�� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 

)

� � 1/ ( %%

�

$ � 0$ �

� $

3� ) (

. ( 5

5

/

��

%

%� ( � 6

�� 0/ ( 00/

'

/ � &$ � *

�

�

(

(

�

�

� ̆ ̆ ̆�

( $ � �(( 5 % 6 % (1�1 �

$ ( $ /) ( / $ # �

�

�

 ̆

�

$�6 5 �

�$ % % $ ( 4 � && � $ � ((/

/

�

ˇ

ˇˇ

�

5

$ 1 �% 11

$

$

/

0/ �ˇ� 0/ �

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 0$ � 1(21

Filed 07/14/23 Page 3 of 20  ̆ !"#$%�&"$'$�)�'(%*$*�+,*-$�'(%./ ˇ ˇ3� +*4"%"%!�'(.$%*�*-(!-�4�/.$1�"%*$1)4'$�*-4*�-4.�*-$�.+.*4%*"45�$)$'*�()�  ./+#$1*"%!(1�"0&4"1"%!�/.$1�4/*(%(0,�6$'"."(%7048"%!�(1�'-("'3� � ̨ ̋

°

 ̃

ˆ

 ̇

�

*

0".

-$�)(�M"5

3

(

$

9

O

3�"$

%

4

!

.

�

"

O

5, ̆

&

:

4

;

�

3

1

%

�

,

$

<

(

.

.

=

P

$

*

*

>

�

�

"

%

+

'

?

*

$

@

$



�

<

4

%

6

04A

+

�

3

B

4

5

�

�

$

%

>



6

N

%

,

C

$

�

�

4

�

D

4

'

*

%

-

%

�

(

6

;

1

,

00/ �

�

$

E

'

/

4

C

(

!

.

F

00/ "

-

G

5

%

�

,

H

*

"

I

-

�

'

/

J

$

4

%

%

�

E

*

.

6

"

"

J

(

4

'

$

F

%

4

1

@

.

�

*

<

*

"

*

A

-

(

4

�0$B

4

%

K

*

6

�

�

040$"

4

4

.

+

%

�.5

6

.

4

$

(

�

$

%

*

�

5

�

+

-

$

.

*

,

1

-

�

5

*

,

(

�

1

-

(

�

/

4

#

1

!

/

*

"

6

�

.

-

!

4

"

/

�

-

%

�

O

1

4

4

$

+

5

1

-

�

L

(

,

(

"

/

'

*

�

1

'

-

"

�

-

1

.

�

$

#

(

*

%

6

-

"

5

.

.

$

�

$

/

6

/

5

�

,

0$'

"

4

.

�

(

5

4

'

�4/

5

1

(

%

.

6



.

6

"

�

/

+

"

�

%

4

1

5

%

$

/

$

'

"

�



5

'

"

�

/

*

.

"

4

-

6

+

�

*

6

$

"

5

"

%

$

(

"

�6�

!

%

)

0$"

�

"

�

.

"

'

"

%

'

.

/

4

�

5

�

5

4

(

%

*

.

�

.

5

*

/



�

�

(

1

�

$

)��

� ̆ˇ

� .

")/

"

�

0/*

'

-

-

$

�

5

4

�

*

1

4

.

$

�

%

&

4

$

�

1

*

(

$

$

.

/

5

$

$

.

%

5

#

,

*

"

4

�

.

"

*

"

%

"

(

(

�

%

+

%

�

(

4

�1*

6

$

-

#

L

�*$-

1

"

$

*

1

"

�

"

.

#

%

$

"

!

0$./*-4%

5

$

*

4



6

�

%

*

"

-

6

.'$

�45

�

(

6

/

.

"

6

.

/

"

'

+

1

5

$

5

(

$

�".

�

.

&

/

�

(

041$1

�

*

0/.

"

6

(

$

%

�

.

"%*

�

�

�

+

)

$

�

%

*

�

-

&

5,$

1$(

'

.

%

(

$

$

%

00/ �

*

0$$6�4%".

'

3

4

�

*"(%�$#$%� � ̆ˆ

 ̇

� ˇ

4

(

3

*

�

-

&

$14�#1."





.

�

/

4

�#4

%

5

"

6

�

.

$

/

(

5

4

$

*-5

0$�

$

6

1

"

�

%

.

'

'

*

-

.

5

4

�

(

.

1

.

4

/

�

'

*

1

*

-

$

$



4

1

�

*

+

"

�

.

"

,

*

�

"

"

'

"

*

.

.

.

�



�

$

�

.

0/.

4

"

.

Q

"

$

5



,

�

*

'

%

.

(

*

(

%

4

*

%

*

"

1

'

6

4

�

.

(

6

*/



�

�

5

*

1

(

�

$

)

'

4

1(4

6

*

0�

"(4%

4

%

%



6

�

,

*

�/-

�4%

$�65

'

$

$

(

%

1

0&.

!

*

*-4�

6

(

%

3

)

,

�

�

"

*

%

"0!�$

*$�"R

*�*�(1�  ̋ 3� %�4/6"+$�6".'5(./1$"'5/"%!�+,�*$5$&-($� .*$40"%!�#"6$(�0/.*+$�  ̆

 ̨

 ̃

° 6

ˆ



$

%

4

$

3�*

.

5

$

"#

1

5,%

$

�

$

1

-

*



$

�

6

%

(

4

�

�

1

"

1

4

�

%

�

.

%

4

�

(

4

%

,

)

�

6

�

*

#

'

O

�

(

/

4

5

00/ %

/

1

6

$

0$$

�1*

.

-



%

*

�

$

.

4

"'&

�

%

6

4

6

"

*

$

.

�

"

"

6

(

'

*3

5

%

(

4

�

.

%

/

.

6

"

1

�

%

$

'

�

!

4

0/.

�

6

4

$

%

%

�

*

"

'

�

%

+

$

*

$

�.1

/

4

%

'

)

4

*

"

"

'

#

"

(

$

$

"

�

%

6

$

*

5

4

�

$

)

+

(

'

5

*

1

1

�

3

(

�

%

16"'"%�0$41,6�'"/(

0%./�.0/'

$

-

1.�4�*.(

�*�-$� �ˇ ̆



ˆ

 ̋

�  ̇

'

1

 ̋

'

$

(

(

3

3

�

�

L

%

00/.

"

/

1

0$$.



%

�*"

1

-

-

-

'

.

$

$

4

�4�

*

6

6

"

%

(

"

"

"

6

.

.

.

%

�

'

'

'

0/.

.

5

5

3

(

�

.

.

.

/

*

1

�

$

4

�

�

4&$&

4

.

.

$

1

*

*��

4

/

'

"

1

%

(

.

.

�

0&3

$

�

�

4

6

'

"

5

'

-

,

*

�

�

"

5

O

(

4%"*!

�

-

4

/

�

%

*

4

6

-

!

�

$

.

.

,

�

$

"%�

*

�

$

4

O

L

R

-

/

�/"

"

'

1

%

-

$

6

0$�

$

*-1.$

%

*

�

4

*

1

.

$

%

&

6

"

1

4

$

�

+

$

.

5

4

$

'

%

�

-

*

*

(

4

�0$�

*"(16%

6

"

�

"

*

%

/

-

0�4

1

*

,

�

 ̇ *-1(/!-�O-"'-�"*".�1$'$"#$6�"%'5/6"%!�45�$5$'*1(%"'�6$#"'$.�4%6�)4'$7*(7)4'$� �ˇ�

°

 ̨

� 



�





�





�

 ̨



3



�

�

�

-�$



�6"



.



'

�

5(./



1$�



0/.

�

*�%(*	�+$

�



�

�'(

�

%

�



*146"'*

�

$6�(1

�

�



0"

�



*



"!4



*



$



6

�

�+,

��(1�"%'(%.".*$%*� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 


 





	













&

0� ��

) )

)

* * % � + � )� .) ))

� ) &+ ) /� .) .) � � � 2 2� + #)� % � � & ) &) 1 + �

) ���

#

#

�

��

��

� %&� &� � * ** * �

�

)

)

�

�

�

.) ) )

)

� ̆ ̆ ̆�

, 2 22

#

# )))

�

�

;.).) + + 0� : C ++

+

&

� , # ��

�

## � ) ) ) � 4 � �

�

� +

� # � # 1

2 1 $ �

�

, ))2 � � 4 +++

� �) ) � )))

,

,

� ̆�

ˇ

ˇˇ �

�

# �), &#�� 1 #

1 � �

�

&

&

) ��

)

�ˇ�

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 ../ � 0"#%

Filed 07/14/23 Page 4 of 20  ̆ !"#$�%&'#$"&(�)*+)�"&�#$�,- &", - ˇ ° $"+1"+,*-+/2�./+#�&-#�3)�42+)&#)1�#-�#$)�,-&+/ 2�#$2-/($�%�$'4)2*"&5� ˆ -2�$-6)23-70   ̃0� 8$)&�#$�242)+)&%#"-&�-2+*)+42%,#",)�#%2()#+�%�4),"9",%/1")&,+/,$�  ̇ %+�,$"*12&#$)�)*1)2*'-2�$)�#)2."&%*'�"*�:-21"&%2'�,-&+/.)2+;�"&,*/1)+� �

�

 ̆

 ̨

 ̋

°

 ̃

ˇ

�

�

,

&

+

I

,

9

/

-

"

%

J

2

,

&

.)�

,

%

$

+

/

(

/

�

.+%

�+

�

&

-

�



%

#

2

%

2

.

�

0

�

+



&

�

1

�

-

"

)

,

%

&

,

�

#

-

,

"

+

%

9

*

�

/

-

*

+

:

2

,

�

4

)

1

9

<

.)"

�

%

)

"

#

3

=

&

'

+

,

"

-

>

(

�

1

"

2

-

9

#

&

?

�

"

"

$

I

2

%

,

@

%

%

K

�

#

3

?

/

J

#

-

I

A

�

*

-

+

(

9

!

)

)

�

�

"

J

B

#

2

2

.).3

$

C

+

&

2



)

#

D

�

%

-

�

+

=

%

,

4

2

@

&

-

�

-

EF1

L

&

K

)

"

�

+

�

4

*

2

I

/

%

+

�

1

)

G

+

,

.)

�

H

�

J

-

#

=

-

#

�

�

-

%

9

C

&

1

�

�

2

%

#

;

%

#



$

)

�

.)K

�

&

+

�

%

*

I

'

/

)

#

,

�

�

4

,

K

J

+

(

%

$

$

�

/

I

2

%

&

�

3

-

-

2

%

+

J

6

&

/

+

�

�

"

)

%

�

4

&

'

.%�

�

0

&

$

1

9

�

�

-

-

/

-

/

2

"

2

.3.),

.%*

�

%

�

./%

#"�

)

#

-

-

1

"

2

*

-



#

2

�

�

"

&

)

"

-

4

*

&

�

)

#

*

9

,

$

+

6

2

�

*

)

M

-

)

-

/

,

*

.�2

1

$



�

4

"

-

-

)

&

$

-

#

.4"

(

$

'

,

2��

)

)

+

%

.-"

2

�

*

3

,

N

�

-

-

-

%

/

'

3

&

*

/

)

.)�

"

*

#

%

+

*

"

�

#

1

)

&

%

"

�

&

1

&

)

-

&

�

#

2

�

&

/

,

"

)

+

&

-

.3%

#

1

+

&

%

3

"



#

#

-

�

6

/

%

)

"

"

&

,

+

2

1

#

K



#

,

�

�

/

*

I

-

"

/

%

)

&

2

*

1

J

�

9

�

�

-

"

(

&

2

)

.%(

&

�+1

#

)

2

"

2

-

K

)

&

�

#

� � ̆ˆ

 ̇

 ̋

� $-)

/

9)+)&

$

1

-

%

 ̆

*

&

0

1

0

�

#

�

�

+

1

�)"

3

&

#

1

:

:

K

"

�

O

<

-

6

2

"

?

=

1

�

D

@

I

/

?

$

Q

C

%

J

=

�

A

%

*

@

'

F

&

F



C

'

G

�,?

�

G

"

-

P

&

O

;

9

*

�

?

)

-

.)D

2

?

.%#"C

%

6

&

A

)

#

+

F

"

*

-

�

'

C

%

&



G

�

*

�

-

P

,

�-2

-

�

9

"

.3�

&

#$�

%

)

"&&

�'

)

+

&

1

�

,

1



�

-

"

!

"

6

.3,

"

)

#

1

$

2

/

"

-

�

&

%

'

%

*

&

�

�

#

)'

"-�

)

-

&

9

9

1

0

)

�

�

"

I

&

%

%

1

�

J



�

%

#

-

&

$

*

#

2

/

+

-

�

#

/

%

"-&

(

&

1

$

+

�%

I

�(

*

J

�



0

-

�

9



�#$

�)�-



*

-

#22-

4

&

-

�

2%#)� 

�

 ̆

ˇ

 ̨

 ̃

 ̆

°

ˆ



 ̇

�



4

-

+

+

&

)

/

2

#

-

)

$

#

-

3

2

)

6

9

)

+

�

M

)

2

"

4

2

4

%

&

,

+

/

2

,

)

1

�

-

2

,

"

#

K

%

4

&

ˇ

"

,

#

�

6

-

"

&

-

�

)

0

6

-

)

2

�

#+

�

3



)

I

�

X

�

-

#



,

+

,

%

1

�

J

2

/



"

-

�

+

"

&

+

4

2

�

9



:

#

#

"

)

�

2

V

B

-

$

&

#

-



,

$

C

�

.)%

(

?

6

#

%

"

A

"



F

+

&

"

�

-

�

I

H



A

1

2

&

1

>

%

"

+

�

�

-

&

�

J

)

H

#

W?X

-

A

�

$

9

6

(

�

4

2

"

"

R

)

)

�

�

&

&

2

%

#

"

C

2

F

-

#

"

-

2

&

)

#

S

?

6

�

"

1

'

�

+

2

1

@

-

"

O

/

)

�

1

F

&

+



+

?

&

G

/



#

,

)

D

H

�

�

9

,

+

#

=

?

"

)

,

-

$

&

)

C

#

2



2

�

�

+

.%A

�

;



%

6

�

-

4

#

�

F

"

)

.)-

#

2

2

,

$

C

+

)

2

#

6

"

.�

�

6

G

)

%

-

+

2

P

%

)

1

2

�

&

&

;

&

#

&

)

:

1

-

�

�

+

4

1

#

#

-

�

$



�

%

%

�

9

I



"

-

2

�

%

2

&

4

#

)

%

+

2

J

1

'

9

2

�

9

�

"

&

�

-

"

/

(

X

)

4

2

+

&

�

%

6

�

.%"

4



1

+

2

&

)

)

0

#

/

%

2

(

+

�

'

-

,

&

&

#

#

�

;

"

1

"

.%#

"

"

-

(

�

+

*

/

6

1

�

&

K

%

T

,

)

�

-

�

#

2

I

#

-

)

5

3

%

,

-

9

+

&

)

J

/

+

�

2

#

4

1

+

&

/

�

"

#

+

2

%

&

-

+

-

-

)

/

�

(

#

%

.)2

+

2

�

�

"

6

&

4

-

"

#

&

#

)

"

1

)

2

'

,

,

2

�

+

2

*

)

U

$

"

#

/

)

�

K

&

"

9

&

�

1

/

6

-

,

I

"

)

'

3

N

"

2

"

1

�

&

J

/

6

+

%

,

)

$

)

-

�

/

#

�

2

+

�

3

+

$





6

�

#

+

#

"

-

2

"

%

-

-

2

,

%

-

1

.)"

�

6

&

"

2

M

)

1

�

"

4

0

4

9

�

&

)

%

2

)

2

+

(

&

%

2

-

1

�



#

/

#

6

�

�

'

"

-

-



9

"

X

&

�

'

1

2



+

%

�

9

-

�

%

-

-

4

#

2

$

2

+

2

�

+

�

.%-

"

�

%

"

2

-

-

+

1

2

�

#

/

�

#

2

"

4

"

&

%

,

$

-

%

,

#

(

)

&

�

2

#

-

"

#

�

2

'

%

2

�

�

#

0

�

� 

�ˇ�°

 ̋

 ̨

� 



�

,

#$-





)

.4

�





�



-

*



'



6



�



)

!



2)"#1

$

�

�2&

)

9



(

-



/

2

*

.%%

�

#

�

-

#

2

"

'

-

�

&

-

�

�

3

4



*

2



"

-

(



6



%

"

�

#

1



"-)1&



�

+



3

K�'



%

�



&



1

)

�

�



I

9



,

)

J

&

�

1



%

-

	&

�&#



+

-

�



0

�

#

�



4

�

%

�



'�-2�2),

�

)"6



)

�

�



4



%

�



'



.)&



#



�

�

%



+�,

�

-&+"1)2%#"-&�9-2� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 








		
 
 

3

4

5

6

7

8

3

4

5

6

7

8

3

4

5

6

7

4

5

6

7

8

9

4

5

6

7

8

5

6

7

8

9

, 8

;

� 7 : 57 � � � 4� A �; ; �

7 �

�

�

;

�

5� �;;7; �

�

45 6 ; ; �

�

4� 3 � , �4 36 � � 5 3 � 6 � ;D A ;

��

8 ;

,P0 ;; ��

6

;

;

3 DD7 7 ;

6� ���;;73 3� A ; 3� �

�

3� ; � : 8

7 �; 7 ;�;

;;;

� ̆ ̆ ̆�

7 8 3

�

8

: 566688C 3 >> ��

66 ;5 ��� � 5 ; ; 57��;

7 � 3 ; ;

;

A 8 3� < � ;63 �73� 8 77

7

3

3

6 ;5 ��; � �� 7 � > 7:3� � 23 3 3 24 ; 7 � 3

� �66

 ̆

6

4 3 ; 4 A �

5 3 3A6� � 6 E

; 7 �

�

<

8 8 �

XX

�

ˇ

ˇˇ

�

�ˇ�

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 23 �84�359383��6

Filed 07/14/23 3�4@?�374Page 5 of 20  ̆ !� "#$%&'$()�*+,+-.'(+/0,1 45 ; < === > 8324AB373A� ˇ 7;�=5>C<37:3�9CA<:463�;DE;>6�;A�63AF=<36�;A�7;6;8=<=7�<:4=7?83<57A=?C7=5!� ˆ !� "G+HI'(J�'H�K-+HI'(I1�=<8C>64�547CA48�93A6;5�45�;AE45=L4=;5�;A�;7:3A83E48�  ̇ 357=7@�=5<8C>=5E�4�<;A9;A47=;94A753A6:=968�9A;9A=3 A6:=9�8=2=73>�8=4?=8=7@<;29 @� �



 ̋

 ̨

°

 ̃

�

4

9

3OA

6

;

<

;

F

:

<

=

4

>

=

5

4

3

E

7





6

=

!

3

;



�

�

!

5

D;�DA

<

3

�<A

;

6

;

"

"

�

9

5

M

*

7;6

+

+

=

�

A

9

>

4

,

+

+

A

3

7=;

H

A

F

4

1

F

3

7

�

=

=

23

H

>

;

�

Q

;

3

5

A



+

4

!

�

�

%

�

;

4

5

+

A

5

6

H

�

@

4

1

�

�

5

;

23A4@

7:5

�93

4

E

A

5

3

�

A

E

6

�

�

A

;

4

D;5

5

C

A

@

�

N

9

�

;

9

�

:

7

3

:

;

A

A

3

�



6

<

A

�

;

=

;

6

5

5

�

2?7

�

;

<

N

;

�9=

:

A

;

5

4



3

7

F

�

=

=

<

=

;

5

7

>

=

5

�

3

;

<

�

�

;

4

5

E

<

5

�N7=53=

>

7

<

E

:

6

7

�

=

4

;

6

�

A

5



�

4

6

�N5

3

8

�

A

3

=

F

7

245

:

=<7

�

=



3

7

A

6

@

3

B

�

8

3

7

�

3

;

7

24=

�

5

7:E3

AB7

�

A

<

3

4

C

7

5

=

6

5

7;E

4<23�7=;A5

�=5� � ̆� =5=7=4736

�

!

;

�

A�A3<3"

=F*3

+

6

,

�

+

7

P03839H

:

Q+5%R3(

�<S4

1�8236�7;4

�

5

;A�4D

5

A;@2�98�

5

<



C

�97A;23EA4A2�A�

�

;

>

A

;

�<54

;

29A!�4=E5�N:=<:�=6<5>C< >�7;� � ̆ˇ

ˆ

 ̇



�

=

7

=

>

5

3

5

3

8

>

<

6

3

8

C

<

9

C

A

<

:

>

=

3

9

;

3

�

7

7

5

�

=

:

3

;

:

6

5

3

�

9

�

4

6

;

C

5

A

A

>

�

8

<

=

�

<

:

N

=7:

6

4

6

=

3

7

<

A

=

�

;

4

:

;

7

5

�

D

=

=

�

�

;

5

E

5

F

D

�;6

8

>

4

D

F

�

6

8

7

3

3

�

:

;

6

6

�

A

2;7

�

:

E

63A

A

;

F

3

C

>

�

=

E

7

6

<

:

3

;

4

�

6

A

5

�

:

�

�

6

;

A

3

�

�

24A

4

F

3

<

�

=

=

<

:

=

5

8

3

4

=

7

6

3

A

�

=

A

E

;

7

6

4

�;D

?

4

3

8

7

�

A

3

4

3

�

�

<

7

>

<

3

;

4

�

8

D

5

7

3

;

4

7

9

A

A

8

:

;

=?;

E

4

C

5

�

8

N

7

3

3

=

U

�

;

:

�

<

=

5

=

4

5

<

�

<

?

:

8

8

!

@

T

C

�

�

<

>



C

;

3

6

:

5

6

3

�

�

7

4

;

7

=

3

D

5

3

�

A

;

�

6

2�?

5

�4C

3

>

�

6

�

N

;

=

3

A

A

3

=

�

6

2

�

7

5

3

�

;

5

4

A

7

�

3

�

A36  ̋ ;D�7:3�38AU�=5<8C>36�2C87=983�94E6�;D�NA=735� 73A=48�A�=8C7A4=;56U45>�:46�?35�=6C3>�5;7�  ̆

 ̨

°

 ̃

 ̆

8

<

4

6

=

3

5

3

C

5

D

5

6

>

7

�

�

;

3

A

>

D

245

A

23C

3

<

A

V

3

=

7

5

A

C



=

6

�

;

E

3

7:

5

5

?

�73

�

7

@

:

4

8

�

�

;

@

7

?

7

3

3

6

�

;

7

A

3

8

:

C

2��

4

<

9



4

�

:

"

;

�

D

;

8

A

C

6

5

�

�

A

4

3

<

4

:

�

7

3

?

B

3

�

C

4

29A�7

@

6

�

;

3

7

5

=

A

8

4

5

=

>

8

A

<

@

E



3

=

�

�

A

N

7

4

6

3

;

�

7

:

<

=

�6;

3

3

5

5

=

8

F

�

@

1

8

7

3



:

�

>

N

6

4

3

�

;

5

<

=

9

3

7

@

4

:

6

3

�;8

A

5

C

�

;

;

:

=

7

5

3

D

�

=

A

=

�

C

7

245

=

A

=

<

4

7

7

3

:

7

B

C

2�3

>

=

>

A

5

�

3

=

6

?

E

5

�

;

9

@

�78

A

�

:

8

=

;

C

<

3

C

F

=

>

�

7

6

=

3

4

7

>

;

=

8

�

235

;

=

=

<

5

E

5

=

�

!

7

A

7

4

:

6

7

�

3

=

=

;

�

5

6

<

A

5

4

C

�

A

�

9

233

>

6

C

6

7

;

;

9

A

3

�

9

<

6

;

5

4

�

6

7

A

4

3

;

�

8

6

N

;

7

�

6

;

=

E

7

D

�

:

�

8

N

:

7

=

�

:

<

:

3

=

=

7

<

�

<

�

9

4

:

A

7

�

4

3

8

F

;

=

E

;

�

C6� 

 4A3�93A243578@�A36A4=53>�45>�35_;=5>�DA;2�=5=7=47=5E�<4C6=5E�;7: 7;�=5=7=473�;A46=7=5� �ˇˆ ̇

 ̋

�

9

;

A

7:;3

29A6�7

=

3

5

>

�=�

�

5

7



:

=



7

3

=

�

�

4

<

7

C

=5E7;�4235@A�

W6�C

�

<

7

7

:

4

?;8

7

�

C

�

;

5

A�>=

D

5

�3

X

�

Y

4

5

3

� Z �

>

8

6

3

4

C

5

?

:

7

6

6

;

7

[



4

5

�N5

\

3

7

�

:

�

=



#\4

3

4

7

8

:

@

3

�

�

]

7

6

A

:

�

=

4

#Z#/ 2=4

<

7�7

8

=

4

5

8

A

4

E

�

@

<

�>6

4

[

=

�

7

;

A

4

^

3

A

8

<

�

;

^

>

7

E

3

M

@

!

8

�

=

;

F

A

3

�

A

7

6

:

�

A

4�9CA

E

3

:

A

�

3<5;

�=A5

>

7

3

3

>�2323

>=64

4

A

E

@

3



!� �ˇ�

°

 ̨

� 



�





�

�





�  �

� ��� 	

�



�

�

�

 

�

�

�

�� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 


  	
		
 
 
 










4

5

6

7

8

5

6

7

8

9

8 7

�

4 D

� 4 7 4 4 4

45 � @ � ? > > 7

9

9

�

@7 �

�

�

D D @ ;7 ? � @ @ � �87 = � ;

� 9 99

��

��

@7 � �

�

� ̆ ̆ ̆�

D �

 ̆�

ˇ

ˇˇ

�

�ˇ� K

�

D @

?4 � 7@@7: 57�77

@ ; ��;

D

�

4 � � 4457�96B7 � 5� >

D

;

���

�

�

�

;

@ ;@@

�

6 7 � D 7 �

D D

;C >

@

@

� �45 @7 �� D D � 7 >

�

@

@

@

@

@

D D �

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 /�0% )$*�1%�

Filed 07/14/23 �1$%2 /$ 3!�Page 6 of 20  ̆ !"#� $%&'!$%(%)*+�$%,-*%.�* * +-, - + .+ ,/+'$%� ˇ /2�3/"%$%.�!)2/$(-*!/) ˆ ��  � 56� 87:69;�7879:69;<�=8>?7@;�6A79;�7BCD=E7;�  ̇ 69:�64=@97E;69:�6D�= 7@C7;=9;>9�6?4>F7�=?7@4�=@�C6@4>?C64=9�G>45�69E�=8�4 B�G5=�  ̋ ?7>F7�6?4H6D9=4>?7�=845>;�@:7@�G57457@�6?4>9A�:>@7?4DE�=@�>9:>@7?4DE�6@7�C7@B69794DE�

 @7;4@6>97:69:�7I=>7:�8@=BJ�

�

�

 ̆

 ̨

°

 ̃

�

�

=

A

5

4

6

5

F

=

7

7

:

@

J

G

�

=@>



�;K7

�

�

:

@F>;>?7D



=



9

�

;

G

�

>

?

9

5

=

A

7

�

4

6

9

5

9

7

7

E

?

@�4

?

:

>==

>@9

9

7

�

;

?

G

H

4D>

B7E

45�=�@

<

�

7

;

4

�

6



:

@==

�H

F

A

7@

5

9

7

�

7

:

6

@

9

�

6



�

4

9

>

>

9

=

8=4

9

7



@

B6�

B7?=4>:

D

=

7

>

?

9

6

4

@

�

>

=

E

9

@

�

A

4=C

�6�

@

6

9

=

9

B=:

E

�;�7

4>79

D

@

>

A

;

9

=

�

A

=

9



@

�



4

�

=

@

H

6

9

9

8

D

;

7

@

8

>

7

9

;�A

@>�9

8

7

=

A

8

@

7



�

9

;

=

6

:

@

D

�

6

7

9

�64;9

�

E� � ̆ˇ

ˆ

 ̇

�  ̆K� 

6

:

6

9

K

=

D

�

E

7

?

6

�

H

L

@

B7C

DE@�

>

9

6

F

9

4

6

J

:

?

�

�

E

;



�

C

C

=

=

9

?

D

;

>

>

8

C

?

>

E

>

?

?



�

M

C

H

�

H

=

L

H

4

C

7

;

=

@

DEB;�

7

:

N

�

>

;

6

;

O

9

?

�8D

:

=

=

�?;

@

7

=

G

:

9

5

�

:

4

>

=

>

?

4

�

>

5

4

=

5

�

9

4

7

5

;

�

7

?

M�

=



�

9

L

=

;

47H

F

@

B77

B;@7@

:

�



=

�

�



;

8

9

�

7

;

8

C

7

=

6

@

@

F

B66

>

4

?74

�

>



6

M

=

9

�

9

=

:

�

@

>

�=�

C

P

4

6

5

7

@

7

>

4

9

@

8

�

A

;

@

�

=

>B>B�D6@�  ̋ ?=D7 :�=

=D:=49=8 =�=:>?D==7:� = = =

°   ̨

 ̆ ̃  ̆

�ˇˆ ̇�

 ̋   ̨

�ˇ�

°� 







�





� 

PK� ?K� :K� 7� 8K� AK� �  57�?647A;@>7;�@8�;F7@7:�9@8@B6;4>;9�4Q564�G>D�P7�;D:�4@69;87@7:�@� :>;?D;7:Q  =8�F7@E7@=9�G =?=D7?4;�57=F7@7:98=@B6=9�G57@7� 457A7�>

9

4

6

7

B77::>;R?D=;Q7

�

:�BH4�P7�4564�=8�6�964H@6D�C7@=9�D7A6D�9>4E�=@� 57�96B7�=8�7F7@E�7@;=9�4=�G5=B�457�=F7@7:�98=@B64>=9�G>D�P7;=D:� 4@9;87@:�=@:>;?=;:�G577�457�96B7:>;?D=;7:�BH;4�P7�4564�=8�6� 964H@6D�7=9�D7A6D�794>4E�=�7A;47@7:�RQ� DCHC=;7;�=@�G5>?5�6?5�@7?>C>794�G DH;7 7�=F7 :�9=@B64>=9Q 57�?647A=>7;�=8�=F7@7:�98=B64>=9�>8�69E�4564�457�@7?>C>794�G>D�;7D� 4@69;87@�=@�:>;?D=;7�4=�45>@:C6@4>7;Q� �

�

5�7



�96

B7�

�=8



�76



?



5

�

�







7@;=

	9�4�

=



�G�

�



5=B�457

�

�@7?>

�

C



>7�



9



4



�G>



D��;



7

�D�4@6;87@�=@� � 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 




	






� ( �

� � �&+ �� ��

)

�

�& / + % (

& �� � �( %

(

(

��

%% + ( �& 1 + & %( , ././ ��

(, , (, � - # %

� � ( �$ �& � (& � ./ � ̆ ̆ ̆

�

� � ( #

%

% , /

& �

(

, #��! , 7 #/ ! # ## % ()� #

�

�� ( + � � �#

7�% �

�

# #� , ##�, ## ( �

�

�

)��

� ̆�

ˇ

ˇˇ + ( ! �1 ( ,� ,

,

�ˇ�

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 ./ ')(�''0&"

Filed 07/14/23 /.' �!'#&%$#"!� .1 Page 7 of 20  ̆ !"#$%&#'�)'&*'+'!�,-&+ , + , #(�2'�()/(� ˇ &-/�,/(1+/%�3'+#&,�%'4/%',("(5 +'4"#('+'!�67 ˆ )7� �#".3%'�'/#"%5%$/('!�.',#�-&+�()'�$&,#1.'+�(&�0"()!+/0� �

 ̇

 ̨



°

 ̋

� "7� /



$





,

1

&

&

,

-

(

&

*

)

5

%'+

'

&

�

$

%

+

"

(

'

.""

"

8

!

&

(

/

�

,

"

(



&

/



,

"

�

&

,

(

#

-

"

,

:

/

&

�

�

%

/

+

,

(

'

./,

&

#

�!

�

(

&

$

+

(

&

�

,

/

"&�

,

(

%

,

)

#

'

:

-

$

'

'

(

�

"

+

$

&



&

�

,

&

,



+

#

�

�

#

1

!

/

.'"

%

#

'

(



+

+

�

"

(

9

2

+

#

/

1

�/,

("2

#

&

-

"

,

%

'

"

�

+

(

&



5

�

-

&

�(+

&

)

�

�

!

'

0

"

�

#

$

"(&

+

)

"

,

!

2

#

+

1

1

/

(

.'0

"&�,

/

+

�

1

9

&

#

(

-

�

)

�



(

&

)

&

+

'

"

*

8

�

'

$

/

+

&

(

'

"

,

&

!

#

,

�

1

�

.'(&�+9#�  ̃ ;7�  �&)'+�"-&+./("&,� ('"/%�&�()'�3+&*"#"&, -�/()&"8/(",�(&�

� ̆ˇ

� ˇ7�� 2/"'$



!

,

&



-

�

&

/

%'-

+

(

$

'

("+&

�

(

./,

"&�,

#

<

:

/

"

�

,

%'4��(

(

+

)

/

'

,

�!#-"#'$

+%�

&

&

#

+

1

�!+'"##(

�

+

#

"

'

2

(

1

�-(&

"&+(,

)

�

�

&

"

-��(



)

1

'�2$

#

&

'

,

$

#

"

1

&

.'�+9=#

 ̆

�>�&&

-

*

�

'

()+'"#

!

�

�

� ̆ ̇ˆ

 ̋

� ˆ7� (



+

'

/

2

$

,

(

(

/

#

"

-

"

&

,

'

,

+

'



!

�

�

&

�

(

/

)

+

�

'

#

!

�

"

"

$

4

#

&

,

$

,

%

'

&

#

!

#

1

�

1

/

.',

+'!

+

�

&

9

!

#

-

/

�

�(

)

'

'

!

-

�

"

$

+

&

'

./,

+(#"

(

1

-

"

"

.'*

$

'

/

�

(

+

"

9

&

?

#

,

3



�

+

-

'

+&*

#

.�'

�+'(&

)

!

,

'



�

#

,

+

'

'

-

,

$

&

(

"

+

�

3

./(&"'�(,

)

"

(

'

�&�

,

$

-

:

�

&

(

/

)

%

,

'

'

!

�

$



�

("&&

*

,

'

�/+',

!

!

�

�#/%'�  ̨ ,-&+./("&,�#(/(",4@�  /7� ',/.'/,!,/1+'�&-()'�+'$"3"',(9#�21#",'#='#>�",$%1!",4�)'�

° 31+3&#'=#>�-&+�&2(/",",4$.'+9&*'+'�,-&+./("&:� �

 ̆

ˇ

 ̆

 ̃

ˆ

 ̇

 ̋

 ̨

� 2

$

!

'

-7

7

7

� 

�  � �,

2

&

/

1

-

)

)

�

.'!

#

%

%

4

'

/

�

�

"

'

&

&

(

,

+

�

#

-

-

&



'

#

'

$

�

�



$

!

(

+

&

�

)

#

"

&

"

#

*

3

3

:

'

'

�

+

&

'

"

�

(

'

+

+

/

"

+

'

'

&

,

'

�

%

#

"

$

$

,

!

(

/

'

"

"

9

�

�

#

3

3

#

+

&



'

*

�

,

"

"

-

3

'

'

#

"

�

-

(

$

)

�

,

,

&

)

1

'

5

(

+

'

,

9

9

#

./

#

#

�

!

"

+

#

�

$

(

2

'

'

&

+

$

1

/

%

"

�

%

"

!

&

#

0

�

!

3

/

"

�

,

'

/

,

"

)

'

�

�

'

0

"

!

,

$

!

+

/

(

"

)

#

'

�

9

.'(

'

�

%

#

)

(

�

�

#

)

,

'

2

=

=

%

'

&

�

'

1

#

"

,

�

(

$

#

>

#

+

�

/



>

'

'

"

2

�

(

,

$

/

1

'

-

'

&

"

%

#

�

+

3

(

1

'

'

+

'

#

"

�

#

�

+

'

$



&

'

�

�

,

&

'

"

-

/

,

(

,

4

�

#

�

$

-

!

$

&

/

!

&

&

1

#

%

1

�

+

'



2

,

$

�

!

�

@

/

1

(

!

�

"

"

,

#

1

,

6

5

"

4

$

4

,



�

(

�

3

'

!

#

2

�

'

1

,

&

+

#

#

/

�

+

3

$

+

"

�

.'

&

'

)

+

,

"

4

#

/

'

2

'

"

#

"

#

�

�

,



&

$

(

:

+

4

-

(

�

&

/

"

)

�

,

$

(

'

"

)

(

!

&

+

"

'

1

(

�

,

"

�

$

&

)

,

#

(

1

:

/

'

�

(

#

!

1

�

(

+

)

'

'

�

�

�ˇ�°



� 



�





�





�  �

�

#3�'$"



-



"



$��31+3



&



#



'



=#�>�#(/('	!�"

�



,

�



�()

�

�



'�+'A1"+

�

'!�!"

�

#



$

�



%&#



1



+



'�1

�

,



!

�'+�12#'$("&,�= ̆>� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 

	

	






	


  	
		
 
 
 


  	
		
 
 





 
 
 

4

% # � � 4 4

( &

!50,� 2+#%)�0 0 0 % )!

!

!

!

)

!

" &

" &

0 & ++)

)

� � + � 3

�

" &

'

)

)

��

��

" '

# �

�

) 4 #$ � 0 )� () % % !� 0 (

(

� � �,% � #�

) ! 4 4

#� 44 )

) & % & 4 �� �

�

+ � � % � � &� " 3

 ̆

� ̆ ̆ ̆�

"

# "

4 � �

� � # �� �

�

' ), %) / � 4+

�

ˇ

ˇˇ

�

�� 4� ,

)

)

)

�ˇ�

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 Filed 07/14/23 Page 8 of 20  ̆ !"�#$&�'(%)*+), ˇ -.�$'�%,')#%#/�"�'+($�'0&!�1%#$�1$!2�#$'�0'%3%')#�1%4�$+0'�#$'� ˆ '' " +),�+4�363!&'&�"!�1$($�'+($�'0&!)�1%4�6&'�#$'�  ̇ !5'0',�"02+#%)�!7#+%)',�"0!2�#$'�0'(%3%'#*�!0�  ̋ 8.� +9%)-�+)/�+(#% �#!�30!5!9'�')(!60+-'�(!23'4�!0�2%&4'+,�+)/�(!)&62'0�#!� �

�

 ̆

 ̨

°



 ̃

ˇ

�

�

30!5%,'�"%02+ ̆

&

3

ˇ

#!'

.

6

.

#

=

���

%

0

3

5

5

(

>

0

'

�

%

$

!

(

�

+

5

'

&

%

:

'

,

�

3

!

?@

'

'

7

�

0

)

'

�

<

'

#

+

�

6

�

0

%

(

&

%

A

)

0

�

4

/



%

%

'



B

)

)

�

+

!

!

1

-

-

@

0

0

)

�

�

'

!





C

<

&

7

3

'

6

DE&

)

#

"

"

+

%

%

%

%

#

#

!

4

0

0



'

%

�

2+2+)

"

�

%

F

/

!

)

�#�

1

�

(

!

"

#

#

B

4

%

%

!

�

)

6

5

5

3

G

0

'

,

'

'

0

H

�+,

!

�

�

%

I

)

)

�

(

!

-

/

:

:

J

0

;

'

�

3

3

�

DH!

,

0

0

'

'

3

�11

'

K

&

&

0

%

�

+

�

#

E





$

0

#

,

'

!

!

L

,

*

6

)

)

�

�

!

#

DA&

&

7

�

0

'

'

3

/

�

)

)

0

�

!

#

#

�

�

�

L

5

+

#

'

$

&

%

?M"

,

0

�

'

+

!

%

)

)

�

6

(

,

-

J

-

!

+

�

$

)

DF?L (

)

�

!

,

+

#&)

%

�

#

�

6

&

%

!

!

&

'

0

'

)

)

�#0

#

�

$

�

!

.

A

%

�

'

)

"

C

�

#

!

6

'

�

&

0

H

'

"

3

G

+

�

!

C

!

(

0

"

'

L

#

�

6

�

#

#

H

$

)

$

�

'

%

+

#

�

#

/

�"�#+

!

%4�&� � ̆

 ̆

ˆ

 ̇

 ̨

 ̋

 ̆

 ̃

°



�

+

0

'

2+'

)

23&

(

,

#

'

�

0

%

+

4

)

+

5

!

%

'

#

'

)

/

0

!

�

'

�





P

'

2'=

+

0

#





,



2

)

$

(

G

�

�

#

'

+

$

>



+



3

)

6

� S

/

#





%

4

�

+

&

&

%

!

�

�

,

�

4

#



&

/

$

�

�

)

+

%



'



5

'

+

#

!

)

%

'

0

#

K

&

�

#

.

,

O

%

%

!

(

B





�

�

7

!



+

!

%

'

4



)



T?L )

!

'

�

4

'

!

'

�

#

�

�

!

,

1

+

(

"

%

�

#

#

)

"

&

3

$

#

�

0

&

�

'

$

!



4

%

A

�

0

/

&

!

+

2�!

�

C

3

�

6

#

4

5

'

#

!

%

�

"

�

&

0

'

U

+

�

,

#

&

+

0

(

%

DE'

!

'

4

�

!

0

&

%

,

0

!

"

)

3



�

�

&

�

-

#



'

1

4

�

$

I

%



%

(

�

)

)

"

$

%

�

�

0

G

!

#

"

-

�

'

,

)

$

$

+

=

%

0

;

#

(

Q

(

�

+

+

2+$

+

3

�

G

#

#

O

'

J

%

�

;

+

!

4

5

0

0

�

#

7

'

3

#

%

M

+

'

/



!

�

+

�

(

"

L

5

)

-

'

#

O

!

%

%



!

A

)

'

�

)

&

#

7

&

,

%

-

!

@

(

�

#

+

!

�

'

3

�

#

J

)

,

0

"

$

!

#

�

%

C

'

+

&

&

�

0

&

!

'

#



�

(

)

F

�

%

'

0

(

4

/

)

�

23!

#

�

3

�

-

4

@

'

&



/

+

&

'

"

A

0

'

�

�

4

'

�

!

+

#

!



+

)

%

B

)

0

/

(

,

,

4

,

%

'

'

�

�

+

3

)



M

�

0

+

%

)

,

+

N

0

@

'

&

#

4

%

&

)

�

/

0

)

E

1

!

N

'

'

�

!

�

+

)

(

C

!

0

'

#

)

+

#

�

�

7

1

G

4

+

#

,

"

/

@

&

%

%

�

!

%



%

(

"



#

�

#

J

%

)

'

$

+

'

4

!

�

0

%

0

�

�

.

1

+

+

H

&

R

'

)



#

)

�

�

K

&

�

'

'

3

+

/

3

7

,

'

H

-

�

%

&

�

0

!

(

M

'

1

%

2+"

6

#

)

L

�

'

%

!

#

#

�

$

&

A

$

6

)

0



'

'

�

&

�

'

H

+

'

24

)

+

)

/

G

23#

D

/

�

4

�

'

+

/

1

�

,

)

A

4

�

!

$

,

#

�

/

!

�%�)

'

�+&�

� 

�ˇˆ ̇

 ̋

 ̨

�



O!%)'#4#/�Q+



8



)

%

.

.

,

:

�

�&'!5'



4

0

6

+

!

0

,

0

&

4

-

3

�

/

V

2'!

W

�0

 ̃

+

+

&

)

 ̆

#

�

'

#

ˆ

+

�

�

%



)

 ̨

(%�

 ̃

'

5

#

"

 ̨

$

%

'

X

4

'

)

�3%

+

,

&

'

2!�

+

'

+

#

4

6

&

#

'

�

)

/

+

0

#

'

.

0

�

�

'

,

!

�

�

"

!

%

�

)



0

�"%

'

)

+

0

5

'

'

�

!

,



0

�

�

#

6

!

!

)

"

�

�

3

,



+

0

4

'

/

+

,

�

%

#

)

�

!



#

�

%

$



%

"

4

0

�

+

+

#

%

-

)

'

+

#

)

%

%)�

"



&

�$

#

7

�

!



/

6

�

!

2+&

0

+

3

)

!

9

,

0

%



+

)

�

#



-

'

%

�

�

:

3

�

+



'

/

"

2'6

'),)

0

+

#

'

)

#

,

#

!

�

&

+



#

�

)

$

,

'

�

�

�ˇ�

°

� 



�







0'+

�



&6



0



'





0�!"��#$'�



)�%

�

#',��#+#'&





�

�



)



'



�6



)

�

,



0



',�

	%"

#

�



/

�

�





�

$

�



!6&+),

�

�



!

�4

+



0

�



&



�VW



 ̆ ̋�

�X�1$%($�+&� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 


















 


 




	 













'

� ( � � � �� 00

$ % % � + & ��

�

( �

(

(

'

� & �% % (%��)

)

&( & &� 3&� &� + *

% � + � � & � %� �

��

* * 0 *

�

* ! �� * ' & ��

& % �%& -

% *

( (% ( 0

(

� ̆ ̆ �

 ̆

�

(( %&

� & % & � & * - *$ & *& �

* *!

�

�

(

( , � � - % *

&� !� %%- �+ )��%��& $ � � %%

* ' � & ( % 4���

 ̆

*

# % � &� ( � -

% � %&� ) !

%� ! & %++& � ,,&

+ �

(

(

(

(

�

�

�

)

�

ˇ

ˇˇ

�

2� &�%� ((

�ˇ�

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 *&�(*)!�&*(!

Filed 07/14/23 "#!("!'�1!"0Page 9 of 20  ̆ !"#!"$%&�&'&()$%*�*%+#,-$%&%.&+"�,)&"*+/(&)0, -.- + ,#!*&�!%.&" ˇ %.$(�#$23&%�%!�-$+(%+'4,.�#23&(�3,*�5&�3$)&1+%.(�°�)$2*�!'�(%"2�!'%.+*�")&"�52 ˆ &-&0%"!+0�',()�%"$(*'&"�+(�$0!")$(0&�1+%.�+(*%",0%+!(*�#"&6+!,*-2�#"!6+)&)�52�$�"&#"&*&(%$%+6&� �

 ̇

 ̨

°

 ̃



 ̋

�

!

1

$

%

.

3!, '

.

+

&

�

*



&

�"-

(



&

$

�

(

3$&

+

)

(

0

%

,

�



%

%

*

&

+

+

#

4

!

(

�

'

,

&

(

)

4

0

(

�



&

�

+

)

"

#

'

�

+

-

!

&

,



"

'

(

)

�

*

�



�

�

%

%

+

.

,

.

(

&

5

&

�

%

�



&

*

�

:

&

,

"

,

&

6

0

)

5

*

%

&

/

*

+

%

(

!

�

&

3&0

%

0

(

!

%

�

+

.

3#,

9

(

!

$

%

�

(

�

%

$

+

�

�

5

*

%



.

%

�

!

&

�

&

6

,

$

)

�

&

*

5



�'#



!

�

"

!

&

%

!

6

"

.

(

3�&

#

)



!

�

&

&

-

%

"

&

)

.

(

$



&

%

�

*

&

+

*

"

�

)

�

,

&

$

$

�

(

5

:

%

&

2

:

,

'

&

�

)

&

0

#

!

/

(

%

$

'

�

3&)

"

%

&

!

%

$

(

+

�

$

%

(

.

-

"

%

*

�

2

&

#

5

'

�

$

!



$

&

2

'

+

0

,

-

�

3&!

%

�

5

%

.

*

!

+

&

(

�

*

3$0

�

%

*

�

%

#

+

+

!

"

"

7

33& )

&

(

&

&

6

*

�

"

%

�

+

.

5

4

!

&

&

�

)

,



�

-

+

*

"

$

-

#

&

1

2

%

8

!

&

�

4

,

3$(

-2+"*�

&

,

)

,

0

&

�

.

�

#

#

�

+

$

#

,

(

2

$

"

�

3

*

%

2

.

,

3&&

$

�

(

%

(

%

�

�

%

%



!

�

�

� ̆� :,)/3&%

4

�

�

+*&<#"

.

&

&�*

-2!�

33+ #"&3+*

*

+

&

!

)

(

�

;

,

*

#

�$!()��

.



&

-

�

$

%

+

"

(

,

%

%

+

.

';

,

*

-

�$&/"*&

�$3&0,(%"

�

$

%

0

!

2

�%.

�$&(

�*),

�

*#!&

3#(*+-

!

&%(&

�

(

!

&

'�#*$

�!"%'

�

�

!



'

!

�%".

#

&

!

�

"$%&� � ̆ˆ ̇

ˇ

� "&&

#

'

"&(*

)

&($%$%

*

+

 ̆

;

!

�*(1

*



?

!

@

.

"

�*(

&

,

�

�'5+

+

(

3+$

$

(

%

0

&

0

+

)

+

$

$

�

-

-

%

�

!

*



�

$

%.$

%

%

&

3&�3&!(

33+ (

%*%*�$�!(

'

)

*

��

+

"

!

&

!

(

-

"

$



#

�

%

(

!

&

$

)

"

3&$

�)%&!

-

0

2

,3& A

&

�

'&(()

%*$�

(

=

%

0

*

!

�-&+00&

%+"6

!

&

2

-

�

2

&�>')

+

+

(

$

$

�

(



0

!

+

-

$

,

-

%

�

+!*�$()�  ̋ !-%"!(�(%&"$0%+6&�!�$($"2�ˇ ̇$()ˇ ̨�ˇˇˆB$()�  ̆

 ̨



 ̆

 ̃

°

,

3$#

+*!0

%

(

&

-!"

�3!+

*

$

&

-�$3

%+(

4

4

!

�  �

+

2

�  ˇ

(

�

*

4

3$5

%

�

$

2





%

'

�

&

.

�

!

3&.

-

"

,

.

�

&

+

'

(

&

$

*

�

+

(



�

(

-

*

,

*

�

%

&

$

$

*

!

,

�

-

!

(

#

33+ *

4

*

�

"

0

&

#

�

&

+

(

!

&

$

%

*

(



3+-

�

+

�

*

3$!

)

*

+

(

!

!

+

*

!

�

0

(

%

+

(

&

,3&'

!

"

�!+

'

%

$

.

"

+

�

(

&

.

-

(



2

�

�

%

:

-

%

�

*

,

$

.

3+:

�

+

)

&

*

,

(

,

�

/

)

%

'

5

3&+

+

/

*

(

3+%

3&'

$

�%

(

(

&

.

0

(

%

)

�

&

+

&

1

%

�

$

)

�

%

+



-

.

+

�

*

5

&

"

�

-

!

-

2

&

�

�

+

5

,

6

#

�

'



&

"

%

$

"

%

&

-

�

!

-

,

'

*

"

+

'



&

#

(

�

%

�

(

%

&

!

)

!

.

%

"

*

'

$

&

$

�

%

�

$

$

%

%

:

+

.

*

&

(

,

!

�

$

�

2

)

(

%

!

�

/

*

$



&

�

3&$

+

'

)

!

(

*

&

&

"

2

(

#

%

�

)



%



!

�

�

$

+

!

5

"

'

!

(

$

"

&

+

"

�

%

%

0

3$#

*

&

)

�

!

�

%

�

3&

!

$

"

)

$

5

�

&



%

!

'

*

�

&

!

$

6

�

�

+

(

33+ &

33& )

2

4

&

�

$

'

!

(

&

%

(

.

*

)

*

)

�

&

+

+

'

!

$

"

$

�

(

%

(

+

&

-

%

�

&

-

�+2

)

'

�



�%!� �ˇˆ ̇

 ̋

� )

*

6

%

,

+!#

&

-

�

,

$

$

-

%

*

$

+

�

!

%&!

(

�

*

!



�

(

$

!

-2-

"

&

#

�

/

'!&

"

"

)

$%#

�+&

,

(

�

"

�%#.

&

!

&

'

*

�

&



(

*

)

!

�!$

3#'

(

�%*.

-$�+

*

(

�%



.

&

-

0

&

&

%

�$+!*3!,

�$�"&(#

%

"

�

$

&

*

2

*

#

&

3&(

0

%

+

*

'

(

�

+

%

&

�

.

#

)

&

"

�

+

$

(

6

3!�

+



!,5*

(

*

-

%

2

&0�

!

3$%

'

+

�

!

%.(

)

�

&



�

0

#

�

+

,

$

6

5

"

+

*

-

!

�

,

#

6

$

&

(

�%

$

1

�%-!

%

.

2

�

+

%

�

0

.

'

.

!

+*�

"

%

�

.



%.&

&

�

&

0

#

�

%

$

+!"%(

+&�*� �ˇ�

 ̃

 ̨

� 



#-



,



*



�

�



+(



%



&





"&*%��0!3#,

 �

%

�

&)�'"�!3�%



.

�

&



�)$%&



�!'



�&�(



%"2�!	'�%

�



.

�



+*�

�

�



")&"4�

�

�

�

�� ° �

� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 


  	
		
 









 





	 


	 





 




"

�

�

;

� �

: 9

0 � � ; 9 8 7

; 9

5

022; ; 0 ; � < ��: ?

7 0 �?� 5 � 99 5

; �9 ��0 ��

5 27� 055 :5 � ��

1

1

��

; C 6 � �

9 

;

� 7�0 �5 7 0� �

��

0� 55 0 � � ;�9� 0

�

122��

5 �0 �  �

G °

� ; � 50< 2 0� �?0 � 9 7� 0 ��

6 7 �



;

7 � ��

5

�

?

: 2 5?� 9 � 90 99; CC;

< @? 9

5 99 �: 9 � 8 7 00

58 �0 9 � 9 5��?��58 ��7 � 5 59 � 5 �01 8 99 �

�

ˇ

ˇˇ

�

�

�

�

7�

�

5 �

� � 8? 5 59; ? 7

8

�

5

5

�ˇ�

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 '( (*' �$& '! Filed 07/14/23 "/" '( �/

Page 10 of 20  !"#�$%%"&" $)� + ,-., ˇ �  � 01203� ˆ 4� 56572709�:5;<=><9�8?@<7<?7�278�2;;5A2;�2785=><2B;5:<A100<0;5�278�<705:590�  ̇ <7�2;�29509�0:2796:58�C>:9>2700? <9 :85:� 8@2D7?�9 E015�0>:7�?6�27D�29094�

�

 ̋

 ̨

°

 ̃

�

2

5

7

7

?

D

6

7

?

�

8

9

:

<

>

G

9

5

B

G

�

F



9

1

<

5

0

2

4

4

9

=

�

:

�

A

>

:<5

5

A

2

7

1

B





0

�

<

9

G

;

1

1

�

<

<

0

I

5

0

5

?

D

�

�

<

�

6

6

;

�

2

2

2

G

�;7

G

?

G

<

D

0

0

@C<

9

9

�

A

�

C

�22

0

D

2

;

;

<

5

5

?

<

@57

A

A

7

0

5

5

�

�

B

8

8

7

<7D

�

�

0

<

<

�

7

?

2

�

7

:

:

0

�

D

1

1

@??

�

5

5

7

B





�

2

7

B

7

5

?

?

E

0

@C@C1

2

:

2

>

:D;

C

6

;

�

2

2

0

J

?

G

<

<

>

7

7

6

D

8

�

0

0

A

�

�

G

1

H

5

@52

5

9

<

0

�

5



2

;

7

4

B

�

?

�

B

0

;

�

@@< 5

<

C

9

�

>

0

1

2

:

E

2

9>5

;

7

2

<

5

7

�

?

2

;

0

7

9

�0@5�?

0

<

:

�

7

>

0

G

1

5

0

;

<



9

>

9

�H�

�

8

7

<

5

7

0

:

G

1

8

A

5

?

5

�<>

:

7

9



0

2

�92

:

6

>

�

D

>

C

G

�

:

0

0

1

?

?

1

�

G

2

5

9

9

:

>

�

�

5

C

9

2

8

0

�

:

2

<7<

?

7

A

6

�

�



2

0

�

?

7

<7�� � ̆� 2

 ̋

G

ˇ

0

ˆ

<?K27

L

�

K

B

ˇ

D

L

�

K

0



15L�

�



2

?

7

@@< 8�01<9�9<?:7

8

�

5

C

:

>

�H:9<

>

;

27�I0?5�

�



G

5

?

G

;

0

2

<?057

:

�

2

 ̋

;

ˇ

�5ˆ9

K2?LKˇCL

5

K

;



�5L�6

?

5

6

G

�0165

?

�

:

F

�92>

7

G

E

1

:

�

>

C

C

>

0

:

G

C

D

?

�

9



5

?

948�

5��444�M� �ˇ

ˆ

 ̇

� 0?

1

�

5

0

:

156�

?

A

:

?

5

I



4

�

�

5

2

:

9

7

�0@5?

7

1

5

0

5

6

�

�

5

?



7

7

6�8

8

012

<I7

5

<

�

0



8

9�>2

7

2

A

<

;

0

:

585�0

6

1

5

0270

8

5

�02

9

1

7

�5

0

<

�

9

G



�

�

7

<

<

I

?

0

<

�

0

<

;

�

9

G

C

�

?

7

5

@C?

7

0

2

�

;

9

5

0

>

D

7

B

�

9

J

J

>

2

5

0

8

G

<

0

A

?

�

@57

0?�6�8?

7

<

:

0

9

�2G

:5G

1

C

0

2

>

:

:

2

5

A

;

9

5

�

5

C

�>7

5

7

0

G

9

8

>

�25

7

�

:

<

G

�

2

0

<

:

1

I

D

5

<

�

�

;

F

C

?

5

2

9

7

7



2

E

�2;

:

0

7

>

D

8

C

�?

0

�

G

H

D

5

�

8�  ̋ ?85�C>:9>270�0?��444�M� ̋ˇˆK2LK°L4  ̨ 4� 565782709�2GE7?H;58A5�120015<:�2NC2D5:�8570<<G20<?�>@B5:9�K?G<2; 

°

 ̃





015

?

<

G

9

@@< >

�

:<:0

8

D

5

�

9



:

<



?

�

>

<

@B7



�2@25G

:

D

9

?:?

B

8

:

5

2

�>G

@C98H;

�

?

6

<

?

D

01:

5

�

:

G

ˆ

�

?





8

�

;



5

7

G

40<64

7



<

A

G

4

2

M

0

7

<?8

°

7

�

 ̆

:



5



C

4

>

�

?

@B:0<75

A

:9�?L7�H�21

7

<

D

G

�

1

8

�

5;<57

6

=

5

>

7

5

8

7

2

0

7

�209@?�@>>790�92

>

:<B9

@<<7A0

�

0

?>�0

1

�?56�  ̆ 4� ;�@?75D�:5G<I58�BD�015�?@@<<?7�C>:9>270�0?�01<9 85:�@2D�B5�85C?<058 �ˇ

ˆ

 ̇

 ̋

�

<

2

:

<

:

7

@C9

C

@20

�

?

:

�

:

5

2

8

2

<

9

�

7

G

:

5

6

0

<

>

7

7

G

0

9

A

2

8

�

0

2

B

@?�

<

2

7

I

;58�

@<7

?

2

:

7

6

�

D

D

0

�

<

1

6

�

9

2

?

5

5

7

:

�

0



�

:

5

5

9

7

D

?

>

8

�

@@< G

�

:

B

2

1

5

7

D

@2�:0

5

�51

;

<

9

2

N

7

5

<

0

C

�

?

9

5



5

�

7

8

2

7

?

�

�

6

8

:

9

@@< 0

5;:

G

9

<

�

�

5

<

9

6

8

6

>

?

�

5

K

9

G

:

9

<

<

1

7

�

?

0

�

G

1

7

:

5

5

;

2

>

�

?

8

0

2

8

�

:

:

8

�

5

<

<

@<7

<

0

:

9

A

9

5

�

7

G

8

<

G

9

0

<

5

?

9

�

:

G

0

7

5

<

:

?

9

A

2

8

@C>

7

0

:

<

@55

?

5

7

;

9

5

:

0

�

?

05?

<

6

7

8

B

�

2

G

6



5

?

�

7

?

0

�

:

>

D

1

7

@29

�

5

9

:

>

�

5



@50

8

<

�

:

?

6

5

@@< ?

7

:

:

9

�:�

G

<

5

6

?

@5>

�H9

7

9

<

8

1

?

8

>

4

?

7

<

@5�

5



�

6

@29

;D�

L

:

2

�

�

2

?

:

D

9

5

:�;

2

<

<

0

5

�

2

6

C

:



0

;

�

<

D

9

2

>

�2G

;

7

D

1

D

�

�

�

�ˇ� ̃

°

 ̨

� 

@?

�

85



0



5

7



:

�



5

@<D





�



7





?

5

0

9

�>0

�

?

95�B8



5

�



6

:

?

5

:

2

�

�

�

:

9

5

?

;

7

<52

�

6



B

�<;



9

D



�0

:

?



5

�

�

;

B



2

5

05�



8



5

�0C



?



�

9



<

�

0



5

6



8

5

�

7

0



?

8

	�

2

0

7

1



0

5

�

 ̆



9

�

O

�





�C

4

�

�





:24G

�0<:

G

529

�

�

>

2

:



;

D

5



�

A

2

�

5

9



�

8

2

�



�



7

<7�



2

�01



8

5



<

�

0

�



<



?



7

@C�

2;�G;2<I<7<;0�

4

C



572D;

�

0D4� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 





  	
		
 
 
 







 










  
 




	




! � � / '

88 " '

�

�

& ! ##& & ",,& !

& � / &( � + � % # �

, ,

�

��

&

' �� ",, � '� ! � ' + ,

'

�� � � � � �

''

� $ '� � � � !

� � � ' , / $ '� ,

,

� ! � + � &(!� 11 #� 

�

! ,# !

#

#

#

"

# & # � ��/ ��

���

2 & � �%� � ! * � * # ! *+ + & � � & # , / � + � ( �&&

'

!& �

+

+



"

. ' �

% �

#

�

� � �

�

!

�

 ̆

 ̆ ̆

�

' # � $ , & � , �

! � , %

( ( � ̆�

�



� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 11, *�#*'*�!(&�

Filed 07/14/23 )&%&#!'!2!�'&�Page 11 of 20  !"#$%#&'�(%)!#*+,-(&�&*�.(%/!#-!�%#0�%.&,*#' , +, + + ,!'�1%0�  ̆ &%3!�24+'4%#&�&*�&(,'�45'!.&,*#6� ˇ 7 89�:;<=>?@A�8BC>A?D=8>B�

�

ˆ

 ̋

 ̨

°

 ̇

�

+

,

%

#

!

#

.

$

$

!

,

�

+

%

!

)

.

&

!

*

&

�





/

%

+



0

#

.

6

H

�

&

!



4

�

0



%

'

�

/



�#%



*

#

%

&

$

,



/

�

.

,

%

!

#



�

/

-

*

�*"

&

�

*

&(�

�

!

2

,

+

'

+*�

2

)

!

,

+

$

$

'

!

*

!

�

+

#

'



'

4

�%,+

"

#

!

,

&

.

�

(

%

2

,

.

%

!

!

&

#

+

,

�

1%)

&

!

.

�

4

"

#

.

!

'

*

!

&

#

*

$

&

.

1!/

%

!

0

#

+

�

&

+

+

'

�

�

!

*

,



'

#

�

+

&

�

"

+

2

*

%

!

+

,

"

#

1%+

!

&

!

#

,.$

$

&

,

�

,

%

2

%

*

#

%

#

#

&

$

'

,

&

*

�

E

*

!

�*�

#

!

�

G

F

#

"

*

%

,

.

&

#

5

!

(

!

/

+

�

!

$

%

'

�



�

#

&

�

"

(

%

0

+

!

-

*

�*!

1�

"

#

�

*

&

$

(

'

11, ,



!

+

�!!

112.&�

/

F

'

0

/

,

�

*

(

*

*

0

*

#

+��&!

*

'

�

� 

� ̃

 ̆

�

!

F+",&.,#!

*

-

#

�

K

&

%

/

#

0

6�0

�

,

%

�

$

,

'

#

,

1,*

"*L,#+1%,

F

'

&(&

,

!

&

+

,

#

(

*

�

�

,

.

ˇ

#

*

�

#

+



�

!

'

$

ˆ

/

4

%

�

%

$

1!0

&!%

'

$

0

�%+

�

'

&

"

J

+

*

&

!

!

�

�

$

+

+

!

+

+

!

$

!

+

.

'

!

6

,

'

�

2





"

�

&*%

!

�

"

+

�

"

F

!

2

#

+

,

$

!

%

&

'

!

#

!

#

&

#

'

�

&

$

�

%

14,

&

+

,

!

)

.

'

!

&

&

,

�

*

*

2

"

#

+

�

*

&(&

)

*

!

,

�

$

�

$



!

*

�

*

,

'

&

11, 

*

�,�#

"+�*

&('

1�!

,*�"%#

*

�

+

+

!

1�!

2

I

+

4

2

!

!

+

'

!

'

!

'

&

#

'

.

&

�

+

%

,

#

&

5

,

�

)

!$!��

*

5

"

0

�

�

�ˇˆ

 ̇

� &

%

&

(

(

!

%

$

�

&

+



�%!

*

!

'

11�



,

2

#

(

�

,

%

*

'

0

,

!

*

�

#

#



!

4

�""

15%

!#/,$

!

#

%

+

-



#

�

�

!

&

&

E

*

1%,

'

�

�

$

2

!

*

/

'

�%&

'

+*$0

+

'

�

!



*

*

'

)

�-

!

.

!

+

4

!

#

'

$

$

&*�

!



$

#

+0

"

�

*

$

�+

%

*

1%&

+

!

�.*

&

*

,

"

#

*

�5&

#

+

,

�

*

+&#

/

(

�

�

%

%

�#*

/

$

�

+

"

�F*

%#+

%

1'0

'�'*



4

5

�,+

&

#

)

%

.

!

,

/

#

0

4

�

$

I

$

,

4

�

#

2

!

-

+

'

�

,

&

*

,

(

*

+

!

�

#

&

�

*

#

�+�

%

!

1

'

#

2

&

!

+

*



0

�

#

�

'

*

!

"

'

�&(

�

,'�  ̋ +$!�,�.*#!.&,*#�F,&(�&(!�%$)!+,',#-�1%+3!&,#-�*+�2+*1*&,*�*"%#0!12*01!#& 

 ̨

 ̃



°

*

'

.

+!!

*

I

122

/

4

,

*

#

!

+

-

'

/0&

4



!



�

#

&

F

$

+

,

6

6

%

&

�

,

�

5

,

�
#

&

!

(

0

'

'

�

�

"





%

!

�

M

!

L,-

+

N

.

,

*

O

&

#

,

)

+

P

&

*

-

�

(

!

Q

%

#



R

+

,

#

�

#

*

S



0

�

1!+

R



 ̋

�



T

$

�

�U%

,

*

#

�

'

#

$

O

)

&

.

$

%

�

V

!

/

%

0

�

*

+

-

S



'

!

'

P

4

,

$

%

S

#

#

5

�

"

N

.



-

'

&



#

0

!

�

�

&

'

"

+

�

.

(

4

*

&

%

.

+

,

(

*

&

�

1%%

#

�

�

'

,

!

�

#

.



&

+

,

"

4

!

"

*

*

!

I

'

#

+

.

&



4

1%�

*

X

&

#

,

,

1!+

)

*

!

Y

&

!

$

,

�

*

+

*

$

�

$

E

"

5

#

!

'

�

0

/

&

(

!

,

!

�

*

#

%

&

,

�

!

'

�

*

�

"

%

/

�

*

$

"

%

#

�

+

�

F

&

2

1%0

+

(

4

$

�



,



�

+

!

'

&

'

!

!

�

+

,

4

J

+

*

-

�

'

%

#

4

+

*

#

$

�

/

#

#

&

%

!

�



+

&

�

,

*



!

4

*

�

�

$

"

#

#



%

�

/



#

4

,

!

�

/

*

5

,#'

+

&

'

�

�

-

!

.

5

.

*

!

&

!

&

*

4

�

,

$

"

*

H

+

!

�

!

&

#

/

*

�

!

$

K

+

&

%

$

!

�

#

*

$

!

&

"

+

�

'

&

J

�

&

*

"

(

,

&

+

(

'

'

�

!

&



�

�!!W

.&&,

!

*

#

#

&�� � ̆ˇˆ

� 



6

*

�

)+!$$

!

#"&*

,

+

"

1%0�!%&

.

*#�"+!*

+'1�*#%�

#

F

0

(

�

*�!"%

!

'

#

�

$

%.#!

&�F'!,&$(



*

�+4!

&

.

�

!

&(,)!

!

�.$*

�#*

'

+

4

�%1!.I+4

E

,

'

+

�

!



$�"%

,

�

+

.

1

*#

%

'

&,4)

1!!�+E'� � ̆�

°

 ̇

 ̨

 ̋

� 



�





�





�

$

 ̆



,

6



W

�

'

2

./+

�

*

�

!

'

'

!



�

$



�

�

!



&

*

*

#



�

&



!

,

'

"



%

!



0

.

#

�

�



(

&

F

J

�,

�



&

!

(



+

�

'



*

2



#

!



.

�

�

,



$

"



,

!

.

#

,

&



,

0

"

	�

,

F

!$�





(

�

�

%



,#&

�

�

�



.



%

4

&!5

-

'!*.

+



&

�

,

!

*

'



#

�*

�

"

�

�







X�



*

Y



)

�*

!

"



+

�

!

&



(

$



,

�

�

'





#

�"

�*

!.+1%&,*#&,J

*

�*#+�F%'� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 





	 
 	 


 
 

	 













 


 




	

	

& % � &% � � & � & / )

1 � �

/

� �

.

� �

* � /& �

)))�

�

.

� �

+

!� * ��(

�� )

( �&

�

�

��

��

(

/ & + � % � % 1 )

) ��&

&

��

! ) �

)

-

/ % ))� 0 & 0�� & � � � � &



/

5 % �

% � + / �

/

% % &

+ $'&% � & )1 � , &

�&&� ((& /

�

 ̆

 ̆ ̆

�

,

� � � � ̆�

� �

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 $' %�0%&0%�*%

Filed 07/14/23 432�)*1)#"Page 12 of 20  ˇ!� "#$%&�'�(%)&�*+�&,-�%.+*/ . -.+- . - . 2 ̆3�*+�&,%)�  ̆ -1&%*.�'.0�'�0-)1%5&%*.�*+&,-$-&,*0*(*6%-)�")-0�*�%0-.&%+7&,'�%.+*$'&%*.� ˇ &*8� #/%-+9+&!6*:*/�)-.&�#7�*:-/.%6,&�1*"/%-/�2.*&�&,-!!�*)&'(-/:%1-3�&*8� ˆ )*1%'&-�%/-1&/�*+�.+*/1-$-.&�;"/-'"�*+*.)"$-/�*-1&%*.-0-/'(

�

�



 ̨

 ̋

°

 ̃

 ̇

 ̆

�

� !� <%)





 ̆

'

$'. 



"

!

"

/

(

�

#

'

-

#

&

0

=

6

,

)

-

-

-

-

%

1

-

.

�

)

1

&



/

�

&

�





 ̃

(

%

&

*

,

%

*

,

/

.

*

$$%

'

*

.

'

�

-

&

0

:

�

%

�

2

�

'

+

$"%

G

7

0

7

-

�

-

3

'

)

-

+

2

�

)

-

'



'

%

&

�

*

.

1

�

"

+

�

3

#

1

&

.

�

,

0

.

-

*

-



�

'

+

/

�

)

+

6

5

'

 ̋

.

�

�

"

&

%

7

&

%

&

,

.

,

1

/

)

�

�

-

*

8

,

%

*

0

)

�

+

�

>



-

/



%





&

)

-

0

.

-

,

+

1

-

-

/

-

�

-

(

1

/

)

.

1

1

*

�

-

&

*



)

&

-

%

�

%

*

.

7

?

5

-

:

*

.

�

(

0

&

-

$5%

"

:

F

.

�

�

:

%



'

0

�

1

-

.

G

'

*

(

@

%

'

&

'

:

/

A

'

-

%

.

%



-

�

.

�

&



*

0

%

/

&

.

#

-

�

�

+

:

'

�

6

0

)

.

&

-

.

!

�

,

1

.

&



0

:

%

,

.

*

"

)

�

%

'

+

$�

*

-

*

&

�

(

�

/



/

'

&

0

/

�

$',

&

B

0

-

<

%

C

-

*

-

/

�

�

/

.

A

&

&



%

.

�

*

�

�

-

*

<'

*

+

"

�

0

.

'

+

$#-

%

�&*

(

/

)

,

%

�

'

+

,

.



-

-

�

(

%

6

1

-

�

�

/

.



*

�

D

/

&

6

E

)



.

/

*

*

&

F

'

)

8

*



0

.

�

"

.

�

-

)

$-



�

�

�

%



0

1

/

*

&

-



)

�

$$% .

'

�

�

&

.

&

 ̆

*

%

0

+%&

�

 ̇

-

,



°

0

)

-



%

�

$�"

*

!�.

.



F

%

0

�

�

.

,

-

�

-

'

/

�

�

�

�ˇˆ

 ̇

� ˇ

/-!�1-%:-0

'

.

��

)

*

&

/

/

�

"

'

1

1

&

H



�-"

,

'

%

'

/

1

-

,

(

0

�

�

.

)

�+"

*

/

1

&

*

�

,

$�#

�

-



�

-

"

/

-

)

-

+

*

-

0

.

.

�+�

0

%

*

.

'

/

�

.

�

G



&

-

/

�

%

(

5

&

-

%

/

$'.

%*6�/�

&

&

@

,

*

-

'

�

&

&

%

�

,

.



-

6

*

�-F

:-+-/-10

&%�:

.-+

�0*'

/$'&-�*&%+*

�&.,

�

%

'

)�1-/0)-

-

/

0

8��  ̋ #!� *�&,-�-I&-.&�)"1,�-/)*.�,')�.*&�7-&�")-0�&,-�*:-/-0� 

°

 ̃

 ̨ 1



'

.!

-

�

&

+

-

(

*

-

$5/

$'$'&

/



%

&

.

@

%

*

*

6

-

�

&

.

%

,

�

*

.

+

-

6

*

1

�-

/

*

�

�

I

$'

$5&--

.

(

7

-

&

�

7

$'#

)

�

-

G

"

�

1

/

%

@

-

,

,

&

-

�

'

�



&

)

%

-

&

.

.

'

/

-

6

)

&

0

-



*

�

�

$".

'

#

�

.

7

,

0

�

'

)

�

&

"

+

�

-

#

1

"

0

-

,

)

-

�

�

-



/

0

'

-

-

�

(

)

&

/

�

,

)

/

/

-

*

-

*

1

�

.

7



*

�

-

+

*

0

*

0

:

F

/

@

�

-

�

'

&

/

,

.

-

-

-

5

0

�

%

)

.



*

.

6

(

+

-

�

*

/

�

-

/

5

$'H

"

"

/5%

&%*

-

*

)

$-.

.

-�+*

*

+

&

/

�

)� � ̆

ˇ

ˆ

 ̇

 ̋

� G

)



G

"

*

,

/%:

-

+%&

/

-

1

-

-

/

%

.

�

-

-

)

�

0

.

'

"

1

�

&

*

1



�

5

.

,

+*

(

�

+

%

*

%

1

.

/

�&'

$')

,

#

&

-

/

(

"

�

-

&



%

1

�

*

*

-

&

*

.

%

/

.

*

�

)

�



&

.

*

%

,

0

-

�

.

'

)

(

-

�

,

-

&

&

.

�

$'*

'

&

�

%

(

+

-

�

0

%

/

%

�

-

-

@

.



0

.

-

1

-

�

&

&

(

/

%

%

"

.

)

+

.

0

*

7

�

6



-

.

�

F

&

"

�

�

,

'

,

#

-

�

'

(

�

%

)

-

/

)

�

-

&

1

1

�

&

*

*

%

*

*

$5+

/

�

.

0

.

�

)

'

(



%

$-�

-

2

&* ̆

0

6

3

�

)

G

�

-

*

*

&

%

+

,

/

&

�

�

,

&

-

*

�

/

&

&

%

�

,

,

)

G

-

-

�%

/

�

&

/

�

-

,

"

-

1

�

H

.

&

,

"

%

%

*

H

-

%/.

"

�

-

1

�

-

$-.

'

�

.

%

&

0

-

0

6

-

�

.

0

&

*

)

&

-

/

�

%

$'.

*

+

-

%

+

)

-

�

�

/

*

)

0

+

�

� ̆�°

 ̨

� 







�





�

ˆ





!



"

�

#)�

�

-1&%*/

�

*

.

:

�

%02

ˇ



-

3

�



'

*

�1+



*

�&

5

,

7



%)

�*



+

-

�

&

1

,



&

-

%*�



%

.

.

	F

)&�/

�



"1&



%

�

�



*.)�)-.

�

&�".



0

�

-



/��







"



#



)-1



&

�

%



*



.�2ˇ3�*+�&,%)� �  ̆� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 


	 
 	 
 


 	 
	 
 	 
 
 



 


	




  	
		
 
 






 


#%� %(� ! � �%# .$

.

$ &&

!

� . & �

� �

�

�

#

#

$

$

&��! % (

� 0 # ��&

&

)( (

� � ! %�%( 1 � .

(



�

�

�

��

.

�

� 4& )($ � $

�� (

#

�

�

�! & �� �

�

�

8

# " (! # � �# & .

��4 % 3&) &��

� . & �#0� !

!



& 3& � �!!

!! & � F ( ��

%FF! & # ))!

%3 3 %��(! ( 3 � � &� �((& �

) .$ 3 � % # # # .

!

!

�

�

( !

(

#

#

#

(

�

ˇ

ˇˇ

�

�ˇ�

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 1%"�#0$&(%�/'�

Filed 07/14/23 �!0#�#%&2(!$(Page 13 of 20  "#%& '($!)*)#"+,%-� .!&# - , ++ .34� ˇ (-$"!5#%�.%"$3#!� (!"#%(�)%(� )%("!6!&#�71(!31�%)�%&.16!(�%#!"#$%&�  ̆ !8!(34(38!�%66$.$%&� ̋ �!&./4-3&$3�-!&1!�993.0$&,#%&  �

ˆ

 ̋

 ̨

°

 ̃

 ̇

� ˇ



2



93 ̇

&

+

1

%

�

%

 ̇

'

&

#

.

°

.

�

.

0

#

!

1

0

$

"

+

&

6!!

�

#





,

�

$



%

#

(

0

(

%

&

%

+

!

�



&



�

-

�.

+

$

�

8

1

2

%



 ̆

!

'

#

%

!



5



:

�

.

!

"

E

%

�

#

"

#

ˇ

3

)

$

$

%

4

�

#

�

4

&

 ̇

0





°

$

!

&

�

.

!

(

�

-

 ̇



+

!

61. �

$

�

8



!

"

8

"

!

0

!

3

#

(

5

!

/

$

3

#

�

%

�

�

.

#

4

.

'

%

&

�

�

1



%

!

;

'

#

�

)

,

(



%

�

3

:

$

(

!

�

&

8

!

"

.

;

!

"

#

�

%

!

<

�



4

"

$



'

$

F

&

$

&

%

(

3

#

�

$

!

66$.



(

#

�

�

!

!

)

61.

�

�

*)3

=

"

$

1

0

(

#

#

$

�

!

"

�

$

E

"

'

"

%

+

>

,

#

!

(

&

?

%

$

,





(

�

-

#

$

%

 ̋

�

!

&

)

'

&

%

;

.

�

(

<

+

"

�

"

.





%

&

!

!

&

�

6(

)

#

!

$

%

�

&

�

'

�

(

=

63.

@

"

/

A

/

!

1

�

4

%

?

6!-

$

#

&

"

$

-

3

%

1

>

!

&

&

&

6'(

?

$

&



�

#

3

1



%

$

�

&

,



7

'

!

8

0

(

.

1

-

B

!

#

+

(

!

"

C

�"

!

&

%

D

�

%

3

1

6%

1

!

�

(

�

%

�

$



@

!

)

A

(

�

9?�

�ˇ

� $&+

�1'.!&



"

1

!

#

6'$

4

%

$

&

!

,

�

(



B

�#C

2

(



D

3

�

5

%

&

�%(

.

�

)

!

�#0($.&,

�%"(

#$�8%

$

&

.

�

"

1

4%4.

!

$&.,

�



!

%

)

-

!&!(8

!

3

8

&

�

#



.

&)0%

3

(

-

63!�)#

$(%.

&

#;#%�3&/�!(.%&�$8!&#$)$!8� � ̆ˆ

 ̇

� 



ˇ

+

+

1

�

�'.!"#

$%%

!

&

"

&

�

!

)

$

$

2

-

(

 ̆

6!!

5D8

)(�#%

0

6�!�#0!!

(.�%

!

&

(

G

.

.

%

�(&!

�

"

3

!

�E$F(

#

$

�%#!)���"!

%

�$&&

)

.

$

#

(

(

631"##

$

$

%

%

&

&

.

�%�F)�("

%

%

-

6F$8!4

8

$3�1&

&

"

8

!�!E

(�

$#0�#0%.!�  ̋ $&.#(1"#$%&.D�3&8� 

°

 ̃



 ̨

%

#

F

0

)

(

!

�

%



�

-

#

4

(

$

3

8

$

&

!



.

�

#

#



3

$

(

"

1

�

)



�

#



$

3

0

%

�

)

&

1

8

.



 ̆

4

#

�

%

+

3

0

�

&

!



�

8

#



0



�"!

%

%

�

66$.



%

6F%

�

"

6F1

4!#(

4

!

$

$

%

�

!

&

$

8

"

�

)

�

!

$

E

%

&

.

(

�

$

#

63#

H

0

0

I

3

�

$

�

#

.



#

J

0

�

�

$

!

"

3

� K %

3

"

3

(

#

&

!

�

#

.



$

!

�

%

#

!

�

0

!

&

3

-

LLM )

&

�

$

!

A

8

8

.

&

!

1

�

�

8

%

$

&

'

&

3

)

"

N

:

&

�

�

3

#

#

O

0

"



&

.

�

$

#

�

/

P

.

�

61.

%

�

�

$

Q

)

8

&

�

H

(

-

#

0

8

LR#

!

�

!

.

)

.

�

1

(

#

#



$

+

$

�

6%,

4

%

/

3

6F�

#

"

&

$%/

4

&

%

+

3

�

F

$



(

&

!

#

(

4

8

+

3

�

$

#

-

!

$

8

!

�

8

E

)

�

1

#

!

$

%

3

&

#

�

0

4

8

%

�

3

(

�

!

&

3

F

#

)

.

!

(

.

�

!

&

%

61.

8

"

!

$

3

&

3

.

#3!

�

.

#

8

�

$

61.

�

-

E

!.$#�

0

#

�

�ˇ ̆ ̇

ˆ

 ̋

 ̨

� 3



%

8

(

#

!

4

0

�

3

F

.

$

!

$

!

,

&

,

(

3

!

�

#

&

(

$

&

3

!

�3)

#

#

3

.

�

!

&

.

%

�



8

#

%

�

(

%

E

�

&



3

$#%

'

0

(

66$.

F

4

%

!

!

1

�

%

3

&

#

(

%

�

3

C

#0#

�

$

!

)

!

"

�

%

�

!

.

(

&



!

�

!

$

3

(

(

&

)

#

-

!

!

#

�

F

$

!

.

&

"

1

(

8

!

-

!

"

3

�

.

$

0

%

&

!

�

)

#

E

&

F

�

.

3

#

4

�

.

3

<

�



.

#

"

61.

�

1

$

8

!

-

'

$

.

!

.

F

�

"

3

#

63%

%

&

�"!

-

8

3

&

!

/

�

1

3

#

�

$

.

+

/

(

6!.

�

!

�30

.

!

%

�3&

)

(

.

!

3

$

�

&

3

'

8

�

,

4



/

3

.

4

�



&

3

(

#

!

$

(

.

&

S

$

G

3

#

1

�

$

%

4

!

.

)

.



)

�

#

%

$

3

�

"

1

(

&

!

�

F

8



(.�

%

3



&

�

66$.

!

� ̇/

6F�8%

3

#

4

0

/

%

!

$

.

/

%

(

�E&

F

!

�

.

(

$

%

!

�"

F

#

(

!

(

&

!

F

�

.

8

(

&

!

!

$

%

&

.!,

#

$

3

&

"

.

#

!

�

$

3

#

-



0

�

#

!

%

$

3

-

�

(

#

63!

�

3

.

�



/

�

�

�ˇ�°� 



�





�





�  �

� ��� 	

�

 ̆



�

�

�

 

�

�

�

�� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 


  	
		
 
 

	 
 




  



 



 





 
 





 


 
 




  	
		
 
   
 



 


1

2

3

4

5

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

2

3

4

5

6

3

4

5

6

7

8

3

4

5

6

7

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

5 ? 4

3

< 4 � B ���

8 �9� � � G 466�5 � B9 1 8

;; ? ? 9� ??

; B 4 �

��

1

�

1 ?

; �

;

� 3? 4 9B 67 ��

��

? 8

8 9 26 8 1 � � 6� AG <<<

B

6

3 �336

6

�

�

4 � 6 ��1 1 8 ;

;

��

E� 4 � ;J � 2 9 � ; 6 67 17 ��

� 1 7

8 5

88 4 4�

�

� A; 8

4�4 33B �

�

� 4 � 4 3�4 1 �C; � <<



B

��

ˇ

ˇˇ 8

8

4

4

� �

4 �? 3� �3? 4� 7 8 3

1 � 3

4

4

�ˇ�

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 #+)* &*%&

Filed 07/14/23 �0/Page 14 of 20  !"� #$%&$�'( , -. ˇ ��  � �1231�45467618�9:13;6�3<=69>?47@A4618�95�B4<4;C1�95�12;8� ˆ B74BD�  ̆ E� 2�456736�>;12;6� ̨�73F895�461F�951;8�B74B�AG81�8G:A;119�124� �

 ̇

 ̋

 ̨

°

 ̃

�



1

1

2

9

B

9

3

D�<

AA; 1

K

�

9



8

6

G

L

1

<

3

B

I

2

9

8

?

�

E

�

;

8

�

C

9

�

B

4

7

6

;

5

�

6

3

4

B

<

4

6

6

<

�

7

C

3

1

9

3

?

<

B

F

6

�

=

8

�

 ̇

1

9

6





�

�

B

F

9

9

;

�

6

4

>

;65

7

3

;

?

7

B

<

4

J

8

;

4

7

�3B

@

7

4

8

5

<

A4G



1

1

�

4

3

7

?

B

F

6

?

�

B



4

F

�

1

6

3

�

<

9

6

1

1

5

B

7

F

�

B

<

�

�

4

4

8

9

3

<



5

�

<

4

?

�

3

4

1

2

;

2

C

<

�

;

1



1

8

;

�

J

9



�

9

4

5

B



�

?

C

B

1

F



7

9

�

4

;

B

�

>

8

A33

B;

1

�

1

4

2

6

�

B

3

�

7

3

3

<

@

4

4

6

2

B

5

4

F

�B

8

�

6

6

8

9

>

�

7

7

129

;

3

6

J

4

B

6

7

;

6

B

1

7

�

�

�

A4A: G

AG6

3

4

?

7

5

�

8

4

4

1

6

B

�

4

7

�

7

4

C

5

4

B

3

4

8

?

6

;

M

J

1

�

7



K

4

�

ˇ

?

3

;

B

1

8

6

L

F

�

3

1

�

�

9

2

5

<

?

9

4

9

�

�

B

4

C

C

A3�

AC4

3

F

B

6

�

H

9

H

F

G

?

9

5

9

�

B

�

B

:

F

1

F

;

2

G

1

E

F

�

;

8

4

8

�

;

9

8

�

6

>

4

B

6

7

8

4

�

4

B

B

�

�

�� 2

@

3J46;618@�A376

B

3

4

@

CBB483?6

�B14

3

8

1

C

;J94

6

8

8;>:;?91

�

;

C

4

3

8

B

�51;9

<

B

;

�

C

<

3

9

1

6

4

7

�;G<�<1�9

B46?

7G14<

7

1

�

B

1

4

9

?

�

3

1247�8�G

9

:

�1H2

4<41

�

�A3G:H41

<

B

1

�9

A35�12144B

�

�9B5

7

�142

B

4

�

�

367B7�34B?

M

�

�

�ˆˇ

 ̆

� 

3

C

6

4

9

7

B

AC8

�

9

Kˆ?L

6

;

�

3

4

6

?

<

F

4

:

�

9

G

B

4

�

8

3

;

C

6

9

?

4

�

B

9

1

1

;

8

2

6

�4@6

B

E

8

�

1;1F7

4

�

4

?

B

;

?

J

484G

4

BF?

B

1

F

�

;6�AG@�85

1

8

B

�

1

9

A�9<G3

G

6

B�B

F

>

�

:

<

;123

9

;6B

@

4

� ̨�

4

1

�7;643

F

�

�

8

1

3

�

B

9

G

8

<

G

�

1

4

A4G

6

B

1

4

B

�

�

F

1

3

2

�

8

9

4

�

5

8

;

�

B

4

1

�

2

B

�

4

;88

9

�

C

B12B7�;8

4

6

;

B

:

�

1

;

5

2

?

9

;

4

1

B

;

�



4

<

8

4

G

E

<1

B

;

4

9

61�1;1?47�  ̇ E� B9A�43<2�;67;J7G3?�9B�41;1F19�>2;<2�3�454 36�4?;J4B4�3�<9CF�9512;8�  ̋ B74B123�446361�AG81�9:1;6�>;12;6�ˆ�73F8�3�8;@47�367�73147�3<=69>?47@A461�95�  ̨ B4<4;C1�95�12;8�B74BE� 

�ˇˆ

 ̆

 ̇

°

 ̃



�



B49C

AA; 9B1�8



>



8

E

;

�

�

9

9



B



6

6

D

�

�

G





3

B

6

4

E

7

�	C

7

4

B



B�

F

8

C

4

4

3

6

�

6

3

B

1

3

�

3

6

�

?

<

7

1

5

;

2

F

1

J

�14

4

9

!

B

8

?

�

5

4

N

�

9

C

C

6

5

"� ( 4

2

1

�

6

1

B

9

F

2

H

7

6

G

�

4

3

9

B

�

6

5

F



�

6

#.O,

�

1

1

D

1

2

�

9

G

2

AG3

AA; A:;

1

8

�

�

814

4

D

B

B

�

N

7



K

8

4

�

'

;

4

3

6

9

L

B

8

*

7



�

;

�

7

3

�

4

(

3

4

3

6

&

8

6

1

<

8

;

7

2

1

@

�

;

�

$

A3�

5



6

F

&

?

�

4

1

=

O

4

;

5

2

6

4

4

#$4

�

1

6

�

1

;

C

;

7

A49

5

B

3

/

�

;

A36

A36

N

1

?

1

*

�

F

8

AGF

�

B

�

-�8

9

F

�

G

G

5

8

C

�

:

<

1

2

�

9

8

F

1

6

G

8

1

:

;

�

8

3

<

A;;

3

9

9

1

?

AAG 

6

1

�>8

3

C

�

�

1

9

2

<

9

8

;

9

�

<

6

1

1

AC3

2

2

;

?

<

�

4



3

�

�

3

?

1

;

4

6

3

�

7

6

>

�

<

4

;

4

1

A32

�

;?� �ˇ�

°

 ̨

 ̋

� 



�





�





�

1



4



?45C

4

�

�

6

2

7

96364

�

�

1

6

M�

G

K



:

A:

L



�;�7

4B48

6



�1



3

;5

6

F



7

3



�C�

?



2

�



9

F

5

8

�

;



1

<

2

	3?

1

��

 ̆



C

�



9

4



5

�

1

�



4

3

6

?

7

�34

6

A31P

�

;

�

?

:





�

G

3



6

8

�

;

7



6



�

4



�



6



8

1



4B8



6

�



:

4



F

1

�

�3

?

7

�

�9B45�182

48;M

B

�K6<

3

L�A48� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 


 



 

 














  
 





















# , - �

/� �

�

�

, &/ /��#� �& �,��() ! ) � & 0 )

�

�

/ �

�

&� ( ) � �

& �

, , #

( # �

( 0

(

(

� +(&# � //

/

��

! 04 0 */(� !!/ �0 �

0 00� # # / �0

# #

��

% $ �

� "��# �/ ( � / � � ##

/

,

��

�## � -

� * 1 � %%

�

�

�

0 % - 0 / #� %

�

�

�

%4��()& )� / � * � * 0 �� ) /( �* /� //

(

� � ��% ��/ ! � & (((� , �/ /

/

( � /

�



0!

�

�

ˇ

ˇˇ

�

"

�ˇ� ! # � � �

(

, , (

/

/

,

,

%( & �/ � &$�! # ( %, & ##� # /)

�

�

� && / , ��

&( /

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 ")(�1/&!$/&�#"

Filed 07/14/23 $&%"#�!/*�#!1�Page 15 of 20  !"#$%&'"�)"*$(&&"�,-"*$)�'.#& . , + "#�,-"%"! 

�

 ̇

 ̨

 ̋

 ̆

ˇ

ˆ

� 3

9

$

(),

/

%

"

"

"

9

,

-

-

�

+

4

2""

"

6

&

/

/

�

,

�

!

.

-

*

*

*

.

�

#

"

/

/

0

"

#

*

4

(

$

�

�

&

5

,

#

)

#

6

-

.

�

�

(

&

*

'

)

/

!

2&&

"

%

�

$

+

$

!

&

)

%

,29 "

"

�

(

%

,

%



"

(

�

6

/

&

!



#

!

�

/

0

$

(

&

&

,

�

+

3

*

&

1

�

/

(



!

)

+

�

$

,

2*.

"

"

,

6

*

�

�

0



6

+

0

%

�

"

"

,22& 3

&

!

(

2""

)

"

1

(

-

�

2"&

"

"

/

*

1

(

$

!

7

/



#

)

8

�

*

(

*

&

�

5

/

,



!

(

/

!

'

"

7

#

:

�

(

$

!

#

*

2.�

(

*

"

&/,

0

#

"

"

/

$

#

!

(

%

�



�

,

&

�

!

'

9

*

-

"

�

"

/

.

(

#

�

)

!

%

$

#

/

&

�

%

(

.

#

&

)

�

!

'

*

"

"

/

%

�

(

*

&

!

�

/

-

(

&

"

+

,

�

0

(

%

�

,

�

)

6

8

(

0

�

)

"

*

+

4

&

/

"

#

"

�

!

2"�

3

()�

/

5

"

%

,

"

/

!

%

7

6

(

"

�

*

9

%

�

/

,



%

-

�

!

,

%

.

*

�

+

/

)

#

/

&

0

,

!

4

"

,

6

"

�

.

,

�

#

*

0

(

�

!

)

�

"

*

%

(� 

�°

 ̃

� ˇ

/

%":

.

�

#

2'&!""

/

%

$



#

"

�*#/

8

!

�

!

5

&('

�

&

*

7

,

�

/

0

&

�

!

*

9

"

)

0

/

4

(



&

#

�

-

&



4

$

/

�

*

!

*

&



+

0

9

�

&

'

!

,

.

.

#

(

*

&

*

/

0

�



"

�""

#

2*-

�*"$

/

&

(

0

!

&

�

+

*/&(!

&

#

"

�#

2./

�(&

"

/

#

%

$

(

/

;

0

"

�

.

5

(

!

*

�*7

&/�&1

!

�

"

%

*

"

/

(

4

#

&-"

�

4

'

#

.



*

�

#

&

&

0

/

�

$

(

"

0

"

.

0"#

!

�

9

&

-

/

)

,

1

,

%�/

*

6

"

0

)

�

&$)� �ˆˇ

 ̇

 ̆

� =:� !

#

"

%".

/

"

,

#

$

(

%

9

*

&

)

�

(



&

,

4

�

0

/

�#&

�

#

"

/

.

4

&

-

�

'

$

"

6

"

)

&

*

/

0

%

)

�

&

!

#

&

&

*

$

"

*

/

)

#

-

-

(

�

(

"



#

"

�

/

9

9

.

%

!

"

*

�

$

"

%

*

%

)

-

/

(

/

�

,

&

(

$

(

%

<

&

2##

"

9

�

-

*

,

&

"

/

(

�

-

&

#

+

�

,

"

!

/

%

*

0

+



/

+

#

&

*

(

"

$

�

.

2""

)

(

%

#

*

)

!

�

#

6

,

/

"

�*(

%

)

&

�



/

&

(

�

"

/

4

"

4

(

*

�



)

"

�

,

$

"

*

6

,

%

$

�

/

)

*

(

#

"

�

%

#

"

�

%

,

*

.

-

#

0

/

"

)

$

��

)

&

*

"

9

!

�

29'

*

&

!

.

/

/

�

#

(

(

*

0

"

&

,

/

2./

%

4

4

"

�,"

#

(

#

8

(

6



�

,

�

*

#

&

/

%

/

.

�

"

,

$

'

!

%

0

(

2&�

#

.

)

5

)

$

!

"

&

7

(

%

&

9

�

�

/

6

*

!

:

1

�

"

&

$

�

#

(

,

"

$

&

2

(

�

%

0

*

&

"

9

'

/



0

"

�

!

%

&

�

*

,

&

*

/

/

0"�

$

4



"

�

�

�



 ̋

°

 ̃



 ̨

/,(&$"�#6,%/�.$

*

2""



/

,

:

!

"

�	-

/

1

"

"

-

%

(

*

"

$

%

*

1

�

/

(

"

9

$

�

"

!

%

$

(

"



#

8

*

,29/

�

�

#

/

,

&

*

*

(

%

0

$

0

�

�

(

)

"

5

*

4

0

'



*

�

&

�

*

7

#

,

4

�

/

-

%

(

�

"

*

)

�

*

$

-

/

9

!

$

"

"

4

"

&

�

/

#

,

%

#

!

>

�

(

'

.

%

6

*

.

%

%

0

&

.

4

�

$

/

1

9

(



(

"

�

*

%

&

.

2.6

%

(

*

&

#

$

/

"

,

&

)

(

�

�

/

#

&

&

)

,

(

$

9

#

&

-

�

-

"

%

/

�

*

&

(

"

*

#

�

/

)

%



9

&

#

(

"

 ̇

#

,

4

"

.

�

&

%

�

%

�

"

'

!



"

(

/

�

>

1

*

#

*

"

,

(

(

�

4

&

/

$

.

%

&

#

9

4

4

/

�

,

�

,

!

�

$

%

-

"

)

%

*

�

�

*

(

*

$

"

(

/

/

&

,

)

�

4

#

1

4

/

&

�

�

"

$

(

"

#

�

%

)

&

-

.

%

,

/

"

*

!

'

0

%

;

/

/

#

"

!

#

�

1

�

%

&

"

5

!

:

!

*

"

%

�

&

&

/

�



7

%

&

*

�

�

"

(

/

&

*

%

�

/

$

,

4

�((

$

%



)

4

0

�

�

4

9

.

"

*

!

�

�

*

/

!

,

-

"

%

4

&

,

%

#

"

�

&

&

"

1

0

1

/

,

(

;

!



6

(

�

$

*

&

(

&

%

4

"

/

"

�

$

�

*

!

1

(

)

�

;

0

&

9

-

4

,

*

&

,

0

�

/

&

(

&

*

)



/

�

(

*

(

"

�

(

,

�

�

(

2*-

)

�

*(4�

�

�ˇˆ� ˇ:� *

*

!

*

& *04-�!&+&!.**0�'"-"!*"#�"2."#%"9"%�*"4

-

$

'

*

*

1""&

"-5*7

"

�*2"*� ' " " * " - * "

" " " " " " " " "  ̇  ̆  ̋  ̨

�ˇ�°� 







�





� 

, , ,

&//$0.!&/1/�0/#

,/#,(

%

,

&$/((,.(#� 2"�%�(%

(,/

#&(!

)

/$�(!%,(#8�/,%�5)7�(/&0,/;�%0

/

�&/�/4� �

#



.



"

%

#

+

-"&

/

�

�

/

$

!

#

*

�

/

6

�

(

$

�)(



&



*

+

(

#



)

&



�

(

*

�

4



%

/



�

4

*

&



#

/

�,�

$



*

6

0

/



.

/

�



!

"



&

29%

/

�

#



1

)



�

0

&

,

9

/

4



�

4

&

	/

�

(

�

"

,

.

�



%

#

"



�

&

#

,

/



(

�

�





)

�*#/

%

�

6

!

,

�&%

#

!

�



6

�

"

�

/

*

)



(

/

&

&

$



!

-4)

�

�



*

�

�



#

(

/

)

�

.



4

"



$

�

)



/

�



*

(

2"

&(4

�





&

�9/



!

�

)

�64

/

)

#

(

&

�

$

9

*

)

0

%

�

#

*

.

,

$

%

!

)

2#%

�

"

�

#�  ̆� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 








 

	

	

 
	 
 	 
 
 


 


  	
		
 
 









 	

# (

(

% (( % �

& &

�)��

�

�

5

5

2

' � �>>>> �

�

(

( � ( � � 2 � 0 � �

�

� �

�

��

(

( &� 0 �

# � ( 2

( ( �

( ) (

(

��

%

° � &

( " � � �

� !

) )

)

��

)

2

�� + & & ) �

2 * ( 2

0

0

2 �& ( /� (

�

) (( & ) 2 ) &&) �

& " ( ) & 5) �(

)

)

&& �

�

# ( 522

0 � /��

�

� &

& � �!#�&%! ���

�

��

ˇ

ˇˇ 

�ˇ�

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 � /$%%"&�')�(&"

Filed 07/14/23 Page 16 of 20  !"#�!"$�"%&'"&!#'& �)*�+&,-(. . ˇ /�	 !0+ &*&"#!"%1-(%�(-,1.%%%+&�)11.(.)"�")%.0&�)*�%+&�*.2."3�)*!"$� ˆ ,!"4'-5%0$�5&%.%.)"."()26&"0$�5')0&#."3�)'�(.1.2!'�5')0&#."3�,$�)'�!3!."(%�(-0+�&*&"#!"%� �

 ̇

 ̆

 ̨

°

 ̃

 ̋

�

7

5

0

%

*

+

-

)

&

.

!

"

%

2

%

+

�

!

0

"

%

.

2

+

"

!

%

-

$

&

�

1&#



�

�

.

)

*

 ̇

"

)

*

/



3

�

'

#

5

%

&

;

!

.

&

3

%

�

$

2

'

<

)

&

(

9



-

.

�

�

�



"

A

)

#

'

.

3

*

$

*

"

&

�

�

�

0

.

$

!

.

1-%

2

�

!

(

�

�

5

%

'

-

*

'

(

&

2

.

,1. -

.

2

%

�

0

.

-

&

"

,

!

�

"

3

!

&

,

#

"

�

/

2

%

(

�

&

&

#

'

.

'

-

B

)

�

�



0

&

5

"

�

)

!

�

&

!

"

%

"

)

"

'

!

&

�

#

�

%

2

0

(

�

+

%

%

!

.

$

/

&

3

�

�

�

)

"

0



*

!

-

)

=

�

%

'

5

-

11. &

!

&

'

0

%

'

&

&

-

9

/

�

-

%

!

&

'

"

#

$

(

#

�

.)

-

0

"

"

)

;

�

#

15'

�

&

&

'

8

�

2

-

%

$

+

.

�

'

&

7

&

>

�2#

.

?

!

%

�

�

7

+

,

!

�

$

"

(

ˇ

�

�

#

°

%

)

+

�

�

*



.

�

-

(

%+�

/&

5

/

�

'

2





$

#

/

.

&

"

�

"

'

:

.

3

%

�

%

&



�

)

%

#

 ̨

+

�,�

 ̇

&



&

 ̆

�

%

#

�

!



(

�

!

%

7

(

&

%

-

&

(

)

0



�

'

�

)

+

(

"

*

.

!

�

3

-



(

"

"

�

1&!

,

#

%

$

&

)

�

'

'

�

.

$

0

@

!

(

�

�

�ˇ

�

(

-

&",1.%�,$(./6

�

"

&

(

'"�%.

)

3

�



+

%+%

"

�

&

0

2

�

&

)



-

)

(

'

�

11. .

)

&

%

'

+

�

&

A"'7()

.

%

.

�

(

%

"

&

+

�

�

&

5

#

�

-

.



'

'

&

(

/0

-

%

/

!

&

�

"



#

%

)

�,

%

(

)

$

%

�

�

%

2

!

+

�

�



.



(

&

�

)

'611.'.

#

0&B'�%(

1-)

.);�"

(



�

%

'

�,&

(

5

&

)

�

'

0

&

&

.

1!.

(

!

&

%

"

�

%

2

!

&

%

#

.

.

'

6

�

&

%

&

)

0

�

�

%

.

)

"

'

�

�

7

*

,

)

'

'

.

'

.

%

�

&

."*

"

C*3

*



)

�!%

'02

/

&

�

3

1&)6�"

)

%

'

� �ˆ ̇

 ̋

 ̆

� D

E!ˇ-

ˇ

'

(

&

ˆ

+

!

.

-

"

�

°

3

)

/

%

*

)

�

�



")�

"(-1&�ˇ'

 ̋

�°')/%

�

&



0

+

%.&)

�

"

(-�,

H

9

&

&

#

I

0

J

&

%

� K �

'

2

!

.

2

"

�

&



�

'

1-L

!#M&

(

NK�

%



�,)&

O

11. 3.PL";�L(.

Q

)



I

"

R



�

�

6

 ̆

S�/�F�

-



.0&4G"

(

)

$

,

26(/!

0

".1!��!6&"%-

&

&

'

�E)/��

 ̨   � �%!%�&*"#!"%(�1-(%�0'&!%&�0'%!."�'&0)'#(�*'� $&!'(� ° !*%'�&"%'$�)*�%+& '#&'" ' ."&!0+�(-0+�'&0)'#�*)'� ̋$&!'(/�5&0.*.0!2$�)'5)'!%&� �



ˇ

 ̃



ˆ

 ̇

 ̋

 ̆

�

&

#

!

15(

!

&

�

%

%

*

&

+

&

(

2

'

"

�

)

#

$

-

*

!



D



�

3

"

(

/

+

/

&

%

�

�

)

(

'

!

6

�

'

1-

�

�

.

%

)

0

+

%

&

.

+





(

'

T

%

&

�

#

&

!

�

'

2

0

0

"

7

5

�

(

'

#

)

#

)

&

!

.

)

'

-

�

!

'

(

#

A

0

%

"

%

&

"

.

$

(

&

-

*

%



&



�

.

1&)

�

%

!

!

"

2

!

+

�

*

"

3

'

"

�

!

&

#

5

!

�

"

#

%

'

0

�

�

%

&

�

2

'

5

.

)

(

!

&

0

0

&

�

'

"

!

%

'

)

#

)

'

!

&

$

,

'

(

"

.

*

#

�

)

2

"

�

'

2

(

&

(

&

"

-

B

+

%

�

0

(

@

�

+

1&)

%

(

5

%

+

+

&

.

;

7

)

"

)

�

�

&

"

*

"

'

3

7

.

)

�

!

"

'

(

�

0

&



1&.

&

3

2

)

"

!

)

T



153

�

(

�

7

*

*

)

T

�

.

�

%

'

"

.

!

+

'

1!

"

2

�

�

!

*

&

3

#

.

�

)

!

'

"

%

'

'

'

&

0

.

%

&

�

6

6

(

+

%

0

&



&

&

�

(

�

)

5

'

7

�

"

&

1.'

(

-

#

+

'

=

T

&

(

�

&

"

5

%

;

)

%

&

!

�

'

+

"

*

2

&

%

&

&

'

.

�

)

5

'

(

�

1�'

"

+

�

'



T

&

)

�

6

0

!

)

"

.

&

"

&

#

2

.

�

�

(

6

.

"

3

"

&

&

-

"

3

#

1,)

%

�

�

(

�

#

#

0

&

(

.

)

'

&

'

�

6

&

)

'

2

.

(

0

&

'

0

T

�

%

0

(

�

&

2

9

%

$

&

(

)

&

'

�



#

,

)

�

6

7

�

�

'

.

!

%

�

0

.

+

.

(

%

"

�

2

(

'

&

#

%

&

�

+

�

(

.

)

8

'

&

&

'

-

'

2

�

0

.

#

5

!

'

%

T

)

2

&

$

�

(

#

!



.

�

�

%

"

-

(

.

�

)

-

"

"

0

#

+

T

&

�

�

'� �ˇ�

°

 ̨

�



�





-





,



(

�



&



0





%



.



)"��ABA�B

�

�."0�2-#



.



"



3

�

;�� 	

�

 ̆



�

�

�

 

�

�

�

�� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 

	

	

	

	

	

	




	 

	


 	






  	
		
 









* ,

.

,

! (

,

. � 7$ 7

&% �

. / �7# � +$ � $ ) �

�

) , .

, . �

�))#$ � $ � # � 52# $$

�

���

��

)$ . # � # , .'

, &% . �

�� !� ) )

 $

7 + �

!�� 777� * �) &% 0 � �  )



�

% #* 7

)

)

� +$ + + ) � (

���

�

* ��# $ � � . ( ( #( * # $ 777

. � ��7

. .

C

�

�



*

)� #

$ �* $ (% # % � � � # �. #

�

ˇ

ˇˇ

�

, '

�

�ˇ�

� �

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 &% 0/&+ 2�#"*�10�'#*

Filed 07/14/23 �4$'3)2�$)#Page 17 of 20  � "#�%&#%$'�()$*%*�+$,)- *+)$�. -. - ++ ,+-&%*+3#� ˇ -. . *6 ˆ ˇ!� �(21�),*"#�2/07+(8,%(+$4�/.#-+$*#-,%(#�()$*%++$4�*"#-#9/.*�,)-,+- *+3# �

 ̇

 ̨

 ̆

°

 ̃

 ̋

� 

ˆ

 ̇

,

!

5

5

)

�

-

2

2

&%$

-

-

.

#

#

#

*

$

�

.

.

+

*





�

�

$

6





"

�

:

7

)

)

#

�+�

$

$

"

2

.

.

+

/

,

(

#

#

)

-

"

$

$

2

-

�

*

*

&%)

+



6

*

.

+

�

�

:

$

#

*

�

(

+

)

,

)

7

)

/

$

-

7

'

�

�

'

4

:

+

�

$

%

0

"

*

4

#

"

+(�

%

#

2

"

-

-

7

#

�

#

�



'

-

.

�

#

)

9

,

$

-

+

/

*

-

�

+

(

#

&%-

)

'

#

�

'

*

7

*

)

#

�

+

'

3

(

�*+

#

*

"

.

#

�

(

#

'

7

�

�

5

)

2

,

2

.

-

#

/

-

-.#

&�-

)

#

.

.

$

*

�



"

�



2

&%#

)

-

�2$

3

+

#

.

$

+

-

#

'

*

.

$

%

+

*

$

$

�:4

�

#

2

�

'

%

*

-

"

.

�

)

+

�

#

$

-

3

�

#



+

*

9

'

"

/

+

#

,

$

#

+

�

4

-

.

.

&%%

�

*



#

&#'

*

�

,

+

%

+

�

3

&%-

$

#

&%'

�

�)*

5

$

0

+

2

3

#

*

-

%

#

-

#

�

+

�

%

$

$

.

#

�

'

'

�

6� �ˇ

�

-#9/+-#&# ̋

 ̨

!�

$*.�,)-

"

�

$



#

1

�

�

'

,

%

+

%

-

*

&%'

#

+

�

*+

"

*

)

+

%

3

$

*

#

�

%

*

�

7

"

�+#

5

$

�2

,

-#-

,

&%+-.�*+)

*+$3

�

.

$

#

#

�

#

$

(

*

5



#

�

2

%

.

.

-

%

#

�'-1#

.��

,



*

+

)

)

�

#

$

'

.

.

�

*

#

+

%

$

$

0

�

*

7

*

�

+

"

:

.

+

"

.

%

�

.�)#

-

0

'

,

*

#

%

$

-

+

6

'

$

�

%

#

$

'

*

6

.

�%;�$

(

'

)&2�7+%$(#�:+*"� �ˆ ̇

 ̋

� 

!

!

�

�� 77

�

�

(

:

-##

-

(

-

+

*

)

+

*

-

,

#

'

+

$

(

.

%

�

(

)

*+,)

�

$

$

,

$

.

+-�

1

)

�

0

&%*

*

%

+

-

)

$

>

$

#

.

'

�



)

�

�

%

0

.

#

*

�

%

"

-#+

%

$

9

3

#

/

+

'

)

+-�

-

/

#

%

'

$

7�

'

�

/

)

#

$

-�

'

2



#

.

/

-

1

�

0



.

"

/

#

)

0

(

7

.

*+#

4

(

$

+

*

(

+

�

)



%

$

�

�

-





#



<

.#<=%

<

-

ˆ

=

(

<

=

"

ˇ

6



=6)�

-�/.#-�

 ̨ (/.*)&#-�)-�/.%0+7+*1*#.*+$4 (7/'$4�%$1�?@�)-�&/7*+3%-%*#*#.*+$4�(21  ̆ #.*+$4�./-3#1.,)(/.�4-)/2.+$*#-3+#:.�(7+(>.*-%&�%%71.+.�#1#�)-�&)/.#� 

°

 ̃

 -'#-�+$(!�7/'+$*

.



4

-

/

�

%

%

0

(

�

A

>

-

7�#

+

.

$

(

/

*

)

4

�

0

&%-

�

&+.

.

'

*

.

/

�

*

'

$

#

B

+

#

-

+

#

)

�

(

)

.

C

#

$



,

D

.

� E �

"

.

*

�

"

*

#

%

)

%

+

-

.

�

1

*

*"�

FGH &%*

#

)

-

�

'



'

2

#

)

.

-



&)&&+.

6

I

�

)

%

C

-

J

$

�.'

.

K

#

�

*-E

+

%

.

)

+

*

L

)

$

#

$

!

�

,

GFK �

/

-#72

�(7%)

1

C

&2M

.�FN)

7+-%

�-$#

C

(

K

#

)

O��

-

:

'

+

+

*

$

"

4

�#.�%()"

$

�2(#-)-$3

+

+

$

.+4)

�

$

*"

�)#�,�*"+.� �ˇˆ ̇

 ̋

 ̨

�

:

./+.

*"2�

#

*

$

"

'

+





.

#



�

'

!

�

�



%

-



'

$

�

#

'

-

�



Q+

%

�

$

+

1

*



(

"

�

7

,



+

/

%

$

'

+

�

7



+

/

$

 ̇

-

4

�

#

'

�*%

"

)

1

#

�*.

�

-

,

�

%

)

+

$

,

%

�

.

-

$

,

#(-

+

#

�

�

%

+

*

7

2

"

$

�-*

%

1

#

�

*

)

2



%

�

,

-

,

�

#

)

%

.

.

#

�

-

:

�

*

*

.

$

"

-

�

*

+

%

#

.

�

*

*

2

#

�

+

-

)

/

$

#

$

-

�

9

-

2

.

#

/

)

�

9

/

+

.

-

/

2

#

#

)

�

'

.

$

�

*

,&) 0

�

�

:

,

1

-

�

)

"

*"&�+

$

(

+.+

"

*

%

�

)

�

2

-

-

%

-

#

+

'

$

-

2

*

4

#

-

�)-

#

�

P

.

,

�

#

#

*

$

"

,

*

#

%

$

�

*

A

'

+

/

3

%

'

#

$

4

�

*

)

&#.

,

;

�

�

*

(

$

"

)

*

#

�

&2:

�

%

7

.

+

�

%$(#� �ˇ�

°

 ̆

� 



�





7



%



+



$

�



*



+





,







�#%(�"�#,#�$

�

'%$�*



�&/.

*�

P



�./0



&+*



�%�'+*+)

	$



%7�

 ̆



�(�



)

�

&2�



7+%$(

�

#�-#



2

�

)



-*�



.



�)-



�)*



"

�

#



-



�-#9/#.*#'� 
	

	
 	 
 	 	 


 		 	


 

 


  


 


 
 










 
 
  	
		
 










1

-

#

#

$ / �/ $

($ �� �

(� (

�

ˆ

� , 1 �

�

�! �

/

/

/

0 �

- # 2

( � / - (# � (* - #( //� /% # � � // / �

/ / /

/

/

��

��

>

- � � -

2 ! % � �1 ( , / ( !! # -

1 ( � � �

� / �



�

AA � �

� $ � (

�

�

�

�

�

 (

SSSSSSSSSSSSSS SSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS $

( ( �

�

ˇ

ˇˇ

�

�ˇ�

�

� Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 �%'1'�53%4%1�#

Filed 07/14/23 "'�5"$!(!$10%$Page 18 of 20  !"#$%&'(!$"�)*!+*�&,-./�-) %"�,"0/%�1"'23�$ , - - 0�1%0,+/� ˇ 0$+,&/"(-�#$%�!"-1/+!"'"0�+$13!"67*/�$&&!-!$"�'"02'!"(!#�'%/�'2-$�',(*$%!8/0($� ˆ $.('!"�0!-+$9/%3)(*$,(�#,%(*%2/'9/�$#�+$%(�,-!"6�'"3�$#�(*�%$+/0,%/-�1%/-+%!./0.3  ̇ //%'2 ,2-�$#�!9!2�%$+0,%�ˇ ̃�ˆ�:!"+2,0!"6�(2/1*$"!+�0/1$-!(!$"-;�ˆ�ˆ�ˆ ̇�ˆ ̨� ̇ ̋�  ̋ '"0� ̨ ̃7� �

�



°

 ̨

 ̆

 ̃

�

�

+



1

$

%

$

/

&&, #

&&! -/"

"

0

(7'

"

<



�

"

-

!

7

7

+

!

(

�

�

$

�

'

)

"

(/�

*

'

�0$

"



!

�

0

*

%

$

*

/

�

'



%

+

-

�

�

2

(

&'�



'

2

'

3

!

6

$

"

�

%

)

&&! (

(

!

/

!

/

%

(

#

0

-

*

�

�

�

$

+

(

/

$

-

$

�

'

!

!

�

"

"

+

$

-

+

*

,

(

"

/

/

�

+

�

%

'

%

*

9

"

"

�

/

!

!

'

0

/

#

"

"

/

�

)

6



�

"

!

�

�

2

"

0

(

'

'

*

(

'

"

!

/

!

"

"

3

-

%

(

(

�

�

9

!

7

/

�

!

&1#

/

%

�

)

0

&'/#7

2

/

%

$

�



3

"



3

�(�

0

,

*

*

'

-

/

/

"

/

�

�

$



1

(�'

%

/

&,$

�

%

$

2

&&! -

�

(

$

$

*

-

(

"

/

(

*

�

�

%

1

/

!

�

"

1

/

%

-

�

(

%

!

2

/

$

&!'

%

-

"

)

9

$

�

(

!

'

#

�

"

/

%

,

"

�

)

/

'

0

1

�

/

&/�

%

#



0

/

!

2

2

�

-

'

!

&''

/

'

!

"

"

(/-

(

3



0

'

!

�

�

(

*

#

!

"

)

�

9

'

'

+

!

9

/

%

2

(

-

,

/

/

*

�

�

0

$

'

+

'

!

#

,

$

"

"

�

,

(

3

6

*

"

�

�

$

/

1

-

�

%

$

/

!

2

-

8

�

!

/

"

0

6

�(�$� 

�ˇ

ˆ

 ̇

 ̋

�

(

$

1

*

%

,

�

!

%

'

$

$

-

"

,

%

,

�

3

6

"

'

�

*

"

$

!"�

(

!

�

!

0

(

(

+

-

$

!

/

�

9

�

%

7



!

/

0

�

/

1



,

+

%

$

'

/

(!2

-

(

$

�

*

/

$

"

!

"

%

"

-

�

(

�

/

6

'

 ̃

"

(

�

!

!

(

'

"

9

!

"

(

�

/

3

(

0

-

*

�

�

'

!

'

ˇ

-

-

�

#

�

!

�

+

$

2

$

!

%

#

'

0

"

(

(

/

-

/

*

%

,&/ 0

/

�2�

�

!

)

&!

!

%

(

-



*

(-

�

�

-



*

,

/

+

/

#

(

�

1

/





�

"

2



!

$

0

/

 ̋

&&! '

%-

"



(

�

7

-

$





%

�

7

-

)



$

!$7

!

�

*

(

"

*

/

=

>

$

%

-

�

�

,

 ̇

!

2

(

"

'

 ̃

�

0

(

)



*

�

!

 ̋

#

9

/

,

°

�

!

"

0

2

.

�

/

,

?

+



'

-

/

7

2

/

�

-�-

$

$

!

#

(

%

�

3

�

+

/

�

$

$

"

&1,

#

(

�!(0/-

2

"

-

�$

(!$

%

#

3

!

�

+

�1'

/

(

%

!

#

$

$

/

+

"

/

�

0

$

'

-

%



"

�

�

(-� 



 ̨

 ̆

 ̃

°

1

N

,

J

%1C$

K

-

J

/



-



O

�$�

F



#



�

E

+

�

$

�E"



-

G�(%

,

K

+



E

(!A$

N

"

J

�&$P

@

O

0

E

A

!

B

#

A

!

GF�

+

C

'(D!

Q

$

�AE

�

"

(

E

*



D

�

'

A

F

(

"

K

�

E

(

0

�

*

K

�

A

/

!

G�GC GF-

"

�#$%�GH,

+/%

L

(

&/�

D

%

I

/

C

J

"

('(

D

C

!

�

"

$

L

A

-

#

K

�

B

(

4

L

*

,

�

!

%

A

-

!

M

-

�

0

E

!

%

+

A

0

(

GF/

!$%7"

�

$#�(*!-�&'(/%�#$%� 

�ˇ

 ̇

ˆ

 ̋

�

�

�

'(/R S� � � S





"

$

"

!

%(7

/

*

�

0

/

�

%



"

(

�

'(/!--

(

�

%!+!(

-

�$%#

!+�(�',2!0

#$6%

/

"

�

!'� S� �  ̨

�

�ˇ� ̆

°

� 



�





�





�  �

� ��� 	

�

 ̆



�

�

�

 

�

�

�

�� 
 

 

 1 

 2 

 3 

 4 

 5 

 6 

 7 

 8 

 9 

 10 

 11 

 12 

 13 

 14 

 15 

 16 

 17 

 18 

 19 

 20 

 21 

 22 

 23 

 24 

 25 

 26 

 27 

 28 

Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 Filed 07/14/23 Page 19 of 20 

SO STIPULATED AND AGREED: 

FOR PLAINTIFF: 

THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

BRIAN M. BOYNTON 

Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General 

Civil Division 

ARUN G. RAO 

Deputy Assistant Attorney General 

AMANDA N. LISKAMM 

Director 

Consumer Protection Branch 

RACHAEL L. DOUD 

Assistant Director 

Consumer Protection Branch 

ZACHARY L. COWAN (NCBN 53432) 

Trial Attorney 

Consumer Protection Branch 

U.S. Department of Justice 

450 5th Street, N.W. 

Washington, D.C. 20530 

Tel: 202-353-7728 

Fax: 202-514-8742 

Zachary.L.Cowan@usdoj.gov 

ISMAIL J. RAMSEY 

United States Attorney 

MICHELLE LO 

Chief, Civil Division

 /s/ Kenneth W. Brakebill 

KENNETH W. BRAKEBILL 

Assistant United States Attorney 

Northern District of California 

450 Golden Gate Avenue 

San Francisco, California 94102 

Telephone: (415) 436-7167 

Kenneth.Brakebill@usdoj.gov 

Date: 7/14/23

STIPULATED ORDER FOR CIVIL PENALTY JUDGMENT, PERMANENT INJUNCTION, 

AND OTHER RELIEF 

19 
	
	 


 
 
 	  
 

	
 
 


 

 


 
 	 
 	 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 	 
 
 	 
 	 	 
 	
 
 


 

  
 	 
  
 
 	   
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 


	 
 
 
 	 	 
 	
 
 


 

  
 	 
  
 
 	   
  
 


	 
 
 
 	 

 
	 
 
 
 
 
 

 



	 
 


 
 
	

 
 	 
  
 
  
  
 
 
 	 
 	
 


II 

DocuSign Envelope ID: 12C554B0-BAE4-40DE-8890-973E4C5E7FA6 

4/27/2023 

4/27/2023 

......... 0

......... 

ˇ

.........

......... C

 : 6

1

 ̆ ̆ a ̆bˆ ̇C :  

Case 3:23-cv-03516 Document 4 Filed 07/14/23 Page 20 of 20 ! # $%& $%# ()**+,,+)- ˇ  /012 . 7/13/2023 �3 4 ˆ 056718  ̇ 1916/:6/915;;<<57  ̋ 95A<BC0@3?5D  ̨

 ̃

!

>1,P)$RG0

O

1

#

VNR 67"!1M

"

?

N

-

<

T

5

#

7

%

�

-

/7',6

E

/

F

7@GH<

I

@

J

5

KL*IMGN,KOPQGKRS&&(TFKOQJKR+RQIJNHQGUI&&(TNRM �4  /012 . ˇ ̆





  



�









�

�







 ˇˇ    ˇ ˇˆ N

!

R

)$MWP#"LR!

X

"-'J#

N

%

R

-',EFGHIJKL*IMGN,KOPQGKRS&&(TFKOQJKR+RQIJNHQGUI&&(T ˇ ̇ /012 . ˇ ̋  ̨ˇ 



Y

















  











�









�

�







 ˇ    ˇ ̃  ̆ %ZZ$)F"#%,')
!)$*2 /012defgefhfi. ˇ /[6/ <\5=5/7 6[C=]3  >/41:1_

8

<7?065

8

7

1

/>/65[66

1



7

�



[



<01



 ̇ ̆ ̆ ˆ ˆ ̆ ̋ ̆4�0610>  ̇ >/_<7?05c ̃

7

 ̇



 ̆ ̆  ̆  ̋ a

:D/

 ̆

7



9

b

6

ˆ

[

 ̇

C



BA1 c ̃ ̇ ̋ˇ:1896813@5;  ̨ 

�

















�

4











C56

1



C17

�

9/7

Y

0















�







    ̃



�













     ̆