FTC Docket No. 9356 

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSI 

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE 

In the Matter of 

Ardagh Group S.A., 

a public limited liability company, and 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, 

a corporation, and 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., 

a corporation. 

) 

) 

) 

) 

) 

) 

) PUBLIC VERSION 

) 

) 

) DOCKET NO. 9356 

) ____________________________ ) 

RESPONDENTS' UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR IN CAMERA TREATMENT 

OF PROPOSED TRIAL EXIDBITS 

Respondents Ardagh Group S.A., Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, and Saint-Gobain 

Containers, Inc., hereby move pursuant to 16 C.F.R. § 3.45 and Paragraph 7 of the Scheduling 

Order for in camera treatment of certain proposed trial exhibits and deposition testimony listed 

in Appendix A and Appendix B to this Motion. 

In supp01t of their motion, Respondents provide their accompanying memorandum of law 

and the Declarations of Patrick Eamon King, Jim Wam er, and David W. Knight. 

WHEREFORE, Respondents respectfully request that this Comt grant in camera 

treatment to the documents designated in Appendix A and Appendix B. 

Dated: December 9, 2013 Respectfully submitted, 

SHEARMAN & STERLING LLP 

By: Is/ Richard F Schwed 

Richard F. Schwed 

Alan S. Goudiss 

Wayne Dale Collins 

Lisl Joanne Dunlop 

SHEARMAN & STERLING LLP 

PUBLIC 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public 

 PUBLIC 

599 Lexington Avenue 

New York, NY 10022 

Telephone: (212) 848 4000 

Facsimile: (212) 848 4173 

agoudiss@shearman.com 

rschwed@shearman.com 

wcollins@shearman.com 

ldunlop@shearman.com 

Heather L. Kafele

SHEARMAN & STERLING LLP 

801 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W. 

Washington, DC 20004 

Telephone: (202) 508 8000 

Facsimile: (202) 508 8100 

hkafele@shearman.com 

Counsel for Respondent Ardagh Group 

S.A.

CRAVATH, SWAINE & MOORE LLP, 

 by 

/s/ Yonatan Even

 Christine A. Varney 

 Sandra C. Goldstein 

 Yonatan Even 

 Members of the Firm 

 

 Attorney for Defendants 

Worldwide Plaza 

825 Eighth Avenue 

New York, NY 10019 

(212) 474-1000 

cvarney@cravath.com 

Counsel for Respondent Compagnie 

de Saint-Gobain and Saint-Gobain 

Containers, Inc. 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

APPENDIX A 

Appendix A-1 

Exhibit Number Applicable Pages Length of In

Camera

Treatment

Expiration of

In Camera

Treatment

Category

DX 103 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX 104 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX 167 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX103 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX104 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX124 DX pg. 018, 026, 029, 031, 034 - 

036, 038 - 040 

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX134 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-2 

DX151 DX pgs. 004, 007, 017 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX163 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX165 DX pgs. 76, 81, 90, 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX167 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX168 DX pgs. 002, 004, 018 - 019, 025, 

029

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX169 DX pgs. 004, 007, 010 - 012 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX220 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations

DX229 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX254 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX255 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX303 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX306 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX311 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-3 

DX318 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX324 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX327 DX pgs. 27 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX330 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX335 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX336 DX pgs. 12 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX341 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX354 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX357 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX379 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX396 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX403 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX411 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX417 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-4 

DX418 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX425 DX pg. 020 - 027 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX429 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX448 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX455 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX462 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX464 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX469 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX477 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX481 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX482 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX485 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX486 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX489 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-5 

DX491 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX498 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX504 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX514 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX521 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX523 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX542 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX544 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX564 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX568 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX572 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX573 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-6 

DX574 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX577 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX581 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX584 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX585 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX586 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX588 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX595 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX596 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX597 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX600 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX602 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX605 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX606 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-7 

DX614 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX615 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX618 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX620 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX626 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX633 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX636 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX661 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX662 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX664 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-8 

DX669 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX670 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX671 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX674 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX675 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX686 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX687 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX688 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX689 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations

DX691 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX692 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX693 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX694 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-9 

DX701 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX704 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX705 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX706 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX707 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX708 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX710 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX712 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX717 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX718 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX719 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX720 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX721 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX728 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-10 

DX729 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX730 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX731 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX732 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX736 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX737 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX738 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX754 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX77 DX pgs. 005 - 006, 010, 025 - 026, 

028, 059 - 060, 062, 065, 067, 069, 094 - 095, 098, 106, 108 - 109, 112, 114, 133, 137, 139, 141, 143, 145, 148

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX789 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX790 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-11 

DX791 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX792 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX793 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX794 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX795 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1000 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1001 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1003 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations

PX1007 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1011 PX1011-008; -013; -014; -017; -018 

through -044 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-12 

PX1014 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1019 PX pg. 009 - 011 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1021 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1022 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1023 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1024 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1026 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-13 

PX1027 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1029 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1029 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1033 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1036 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1043 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1048 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1053 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1056 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-14 

PX1067 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1068 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1075 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations

PX1077 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1082 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1083 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1085 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1087 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1096 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-15 

PX1098 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1110 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1116 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1120 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1121 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1124 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1131 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1134 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1138 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1142 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1146 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1148 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1154 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-16 

PX1155 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1162 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1164 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1165 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1166 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1167 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1168 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1169 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1171 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1172 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1173 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1177 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1182 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-17 

PX1183 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1185 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1192 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1193 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1194 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1195 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1198 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1199 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-18 

PX1203 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1204 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1207 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1212 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1214 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1215 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-19 

PX1216 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1218 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1219 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1220 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1223 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1224 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1226 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1232 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-20 

PX1233 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1235 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1238 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1240 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1242 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1243 PX pg. 018, 025 - 042 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1244 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-21 

PX1245 PX pg. 008, 010, 012 - 013 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1246 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1247 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1249 PX pg. 003, 005, 009 - 012 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations

PX1250 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1253 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-22 

PX1259 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1260 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1261 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1263 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1264 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1265 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1270 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1271 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-23 

PX1272 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1273 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1274 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1276 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1278 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1280 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1281 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1282 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1283 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1288 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1291 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1296 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-24 

PX1297 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1298 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1299 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1308 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1337 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1338 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1339 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations

PX1341 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1344 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-25 

PX1346 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1347 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1350 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1351 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1352 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1356 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1361 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1362 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1366 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1369 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-26 

PX1378 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1389 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1393 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1394 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1406 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1417 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1418 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations

PX1423 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1424 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1428 PX pg. 031 - 032, 036 - 043 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1479 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations

PX1491 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-27 

PX1504 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1505 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1511 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1518 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1519 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1527 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1528 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1531 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1534 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1535 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-28 

PX1536 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1537 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1540 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1541 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1542 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1543 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1547 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1548 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1549 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1550 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1551 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1571 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1572 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-29 

PX1581 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1598 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1599 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1600 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1603 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1610 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1611 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1620 PX pg. 020 - 022 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1621 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1624 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1625 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-30 

PX1629 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1633 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX1638 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1639 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1640 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1641 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1642 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1643 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1644 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX1651 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1657 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1658 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1672 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1682 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-31 

PX1684 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1687 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1691 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1702 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1708 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2355 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2385 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2401 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2449 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4003 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4004 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-32 

PX4010 Spreadsheet tabs entitled "Capacity", 

"CapacityPlan", and "Tons Packed" 

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX4022 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX4030 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4031 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4032 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4211 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4236 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4414 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Plant Capabilities and Operations

PX4417 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4421 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4425 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-33 

PX4434 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4507 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4543 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4545 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4546 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4547 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4551 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4553 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4554 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4554 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4555 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-34 

PX4598 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4721 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4727 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4729 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4740 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4771 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4816 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4826 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4827 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX5013 PX pg. 002 - 005 (paras. 9, 14 - 18) 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX5020 PX pg. 007 (para. 30) 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-35 

Expert Report of Dr. Frederick WarrenBoulton

Paragraphs 75 (including accompanying table and note 67), 76, 136, Page 47. 

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Terms and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Expert Report of H. Gabriel Dagen 

All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

Investigational Hearing of Samuel Wilson - 4/23/2013

45:3-11; 125:19-133:11; 134:12-136:21; 188:8-193:12; 197:6-198:14

20 years December 9, 2033 Contacts and Related 

Negotiations

36:3-23; 59:6-60:14; 74:23-77:16; 83:1-12; 83:24-84:4; 85:2-89:23; 90:21-91:7; 91:24-93:12; 97:10-98:3; 111:16-25; 112:1-25; 142:25-143:22; 144:13-145:5; 145:12-148:6; 152:16-158:14; 177:17-179:12; 184:11-185:16; 186:9-188:7 

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

159:4-161:11; 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Investigational Hearing of Gordon Love - 4/25/2013

 32:5-25; 33:22-36:18; 75:8-25; 78:5-80:25; 82:9-83:15; 88:5-88:20; 93:16-94:3; 94:18-96:5; 99:8-25; 100:9-15; 100:22-101:21; 115:12-117:7; 136:7-18; 139:14-140:25; 166:1-167:4; 175:13-176:13 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contacts and Related 

Negotiations

25:13-26:3; 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Investigational Hearing of Thomas Wieclaw - 4/29/2013

164:13-165:4; 218:1-219:20 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-36 

Investigational Hearing of Kenneth Wilkes - 5/1/2013

22:6-25:1; 47:25-49:4; 72:13-76:25; 125:1-7; 129:17-130:20; 139:15-143:21; 195:24-196:23; 218:19-221:2; 223:3-224:25; 229:6-230:10;230:14-237:5; 243:4-245:20; 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

61:7-8; 61:11-22; 62:1-63:21; 98:13-100:6; 104:3-111:1; 120:25-121:13;126:20-127:8; 159:13-160:16; 161:3-162:17; 164:7-166:5; 200:4-201:23; 205:10-209:4; 212:8-215:23; 239:1-240:6; 245:21-246:8; 256:21-261:7; 264:1-25 

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

156:21-25 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Investigational Hearing of James Fredlake - 5/3/2013

173:12-175:4; 242:10-25; 248:20-249:25; 250:1-25; 266:21-25; 267:1-16; 288:4-295:18; 305:10-306:22 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

190:4-193:3; 193:19-196:22; 197:14-198:18; 236:9-237:10; 296:19-302:9

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

129:8-133:25; 137:11-138:1; 234:1-21; 239:6-25; 240:1-241:2; 257:5-21

3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-37 

Deposition of John Riordan - 5/7/2013 

10:25-11:15; 31:14-32:25; 33:3-37:1-2; 39:22-47:1; 48:24-54:1; 59:1-62:22; 64:11-71:17; 71:23-73:10; 78:23-80:16; 81:18-83:20; 84:25-85:14; 86:21-87:2; 87:6-88:15; 90:19-23; 91:2-92:6; 94:18-96:2; 98:1-13; 99:1-100:3; 101:19-102:3; 113:18-115:13; 115:19-117:5; 119:18-120:2; 120:22-123:1; 123:16-124:4; 129:17-131:17; 133:11-135:19; 136:23-137:15; 145:20-146:8; 153:19-155:14; 158:5-159:1; 159:23-161:14; 162:10-20; 166:13-23; 168:9-170:5; 173:2-174:10; 179:24-181:17; 185:22-187:25; 189:1-191:6; 192:14-194:13; 195:10-198:17; 200:8-202:9; 202:25-204:2; 206:17-208:5; 209:14-211:14; 215:24-216:11; 220:18-225:17; 228:6-230:24; 231:25-233:25; 234:9-237:3; 244:12-245:5; 245:24-246:25; 248:22-249:24; 277:24-279:4

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

Investigational Hearing of Niall Wall - 5/9/2013 

58:24-59:10; 64:1-65:14; 166:4-183:15; 190:18-191:16; 194:5-15; 201:10-202:1; 204:18-205:6; 233:17-234:16;

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

52:13-54:3; 94:17-95:2; 95:10-21; 98:8-15; 99:4-106:10 

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-38 

 78:8-81:21; 264:13-266:5; ;268:14-269:10

3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Investigational Hearing of Herbert Sachs on behalf of Saxco International - 5/9/2013 

90:21-91:14 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Thomas Wieclaw - 8/1/2013 

69:5-70:16; 81:23-84:1; 89:25-93:15; 99:15-103:16; 277:6-280:4; 281:14-284:7; 292:1-293:1 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

95:16-97:6 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Deposition of Gordon Love - 8/6/2013 

17:12-17; 18:7-12; 18:22-24; 21:17-20; 22:5-8; 23:23-24:9; 24:22-25:2; 39:3-40:18; 53:8-55:8; 56:13-57:25; 64:22-65:5; 67:9-24;71:4-9; 74:12-15; 74:21-75:21; 77:21-78:8; 85:13-87:24; 89:7-91:7; 92:13-93:8; 93:24-95:12; 95:24-97:24; 99:2-17; 100:23-103:11; 105:1-5; 105:24-107:22; 115:8-24; 117:23-119:11; 125:21-126:18; 127:10-128:4; 131:14-132:25; 138:10-19; 152:21-153:12; 153:23-154:13; 156:22-157:4; 163:7-164:18; 176:17-177:6; 178:10-16; 180:15-182:2; 182:20-183:8; 193:2-20; 194:20-195:12; 215:19-216:12; 221:1-12; 228:20-230:5; 230:17-234:19 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-39 

Deposition of Alfred Matt on behalf of F.X. Matt Brewing Company - 8/12/2013 

55:22-56:7; 84:2-5; 88:6-89:3 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Brad Stevenson on behalf of Founders Brewing Company - 8/13/2013 

15:4-16:5; 51:13-53:13 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of David Blossman on behalf of Abita Brewing Company - 8/15/2013 

140:9-11 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of John Horan on behalf of The Gambrinus Company - 8/16/2013

124:5-11 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of James Fredlake - 8/16/2013 

12:5-22; 19:25-20:3; 20:17-21; 39:9-20; 46:9-13; 47:14-48:3; 66:20-67:22; 73:15-25; 74:17-76:22;

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

65:10-12; 139:10-141:19; 144:20-145:6; 145:11-146:3; 151:3-11; 177:15-178:9; 178:11-179:7; 179:9-16; 207:6-210:24; 213:18-214:5 

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-40 

90:9-16; 108:10-17; 108:19-109:10; 166:20-22;

3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Deposition of Patricia Pelzer on behalf of US Distilled Products - 8/16/2013

22:22-25; 77:15-78:8 20 years December 9, 2033 Contacts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Timothy Nall on behalf of BrownForman Corporation - 8/19/2013

96:7-10; 97:1-4; 98:6-7 20 years December 9, 2033 Contacts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Kenneth Edwards on behalf of Beam Inc. - 8/19/2013

70:8-19; 71:14-18; 116:18-20; 116:22-117:7; 125:9-127-7; 127:9-14; 127:17-19; 143:13-19; 147:13-15; 148:1-149:18; 160:10-12 

20 years December 10, 2033 Contacts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Rick Thielen on behalf of Diageo North America - 8/20/2013 

46:7-47:15; 51:13-55:11; 89:17-90:11; 91:2-4; 91:6-7; 91:10-21; 94:2-8; 94:20-95:11 

20 years December 11, 2033 Contacts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-41 

Deposition of John Riordan - 8/20/2013 

348:12-350:20; 352:21-353:21; 358:23-360:2; 386:10-387:3; 387:19-389:18; 389:25-390:13; 392:15-19; 395:5-17; 396:21-397:1; 397:8-398:1; 398:22-24; 399:3-400:1; 400:6-402:3; 402:23-403:3; 403:22-405:1; 405:12-25; 410:14-18; 411:7-10; 414:10-13; 415:6-419:7; 419:17-421:8; 423:14-425:13; 425:22-428:25; 429:7-430:18; 430:23-433:18; 434:1-22; 435:2-16; 439:16-20; 439:24-442:-7; 450:22-451:3; 454:11-455:14 

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

Deposition of John Riordan - 8/20/2013 

321:18-323:15; 324:10-18 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Deposition of Adam Gelles on behalf of Pernod Ricard U.S.A., LLC - 8/21/2013

102:4-25; 210:15-211:7 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Phillip Cissell on behalf of Sazerac - 8/22/2013 

84:24-85:16 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of S. Lee Keathley on behalf of Anheuser-Busch Companies - 8/23/2013 

83:11-84:16; 118:19-119:5; 130:7-9; 130:18-21; 185:5-185:15; 190:3-191:22; 193:3-19; 194:1-11; 194:13; 225:1-9; 225:11-16; 225:18-21; 225:23-226:8; 226:22-24; 227:4-228:7; 233:2-5; 270:17-22 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-42 

Deposition of Max Shapira on behalf of Heaven Hill Distilleries, Inc. - 8/26/2013

18:24-20:24; 23:24-24:13; 108:1-9; 109:16-24; 115:3-117:18; 127:14-128:25

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Judy Embree on behalf of Boston Beer Co. - 8/27/2013

78:20-22; 92:23-93:14; 93:16-23; 97:15-23; 99:11-15; 101:8-21; 103:2-9; 104:13-20; 107:1-7; 107:14-108:9; 111:22-112:9; 145:8-19

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Warren Dibble on behalf of Harpoon - 8/28/2013 

31:3-13; 31:16-32:15; 33:14-18 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Kenneth Gamer on behalf of Gamer Packaging - 8/29/2013

49:3-15; 50:20-51:12; 65:1-5; 84:1-15; 85:20-86:12; 86:16-22; 87:9-23; 89:3-25

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Reiner Brand - 9/4/2013 

13:8-15:5; 15:19-20:4; 21:4-24:11; 26:8-29:17; 32:14-33:6; 34:14-35:5; 39:3-40:2; 53:6-56:22; 58:13-59:18; 60:22-61:3; 82:1-12; 86:11-87:19; 88:8-23; 90:2-10; 93:6-15; 103:16-104:10; 107:18-108:6 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-43 

Deposition of Niall Wall - 9/12/2013 

8:11-18; 11:9-12:11; 28:5-36:15; 38:1-39:20; 40:4-42:20; 44:20-46:5; 46:11-48:17; ; 49:14-24; 50:19-21; 52:4-53:4; 58:7-59:2; 59:7-65:4; 67:17-69:6; 70:19-72:23; 73:5-17; 75:10-25; 76:3-78:22; 82:1-12; 85:1-86:6; 86:19-87:5; 87:11-19; 89:18-23; 106:12-109:11; 110:3-5; 111:16-24; 112:4-23; 114:6-10; 114:25-115:6; 115:19-116:12; 116:15-117:21; 118:4-20; 119:13-120:14; 121:11-122:13; 122:17-23; 124:9-14; 124:16-125:12; 125:14-126:2; 126:15-20; 128:10-129:22; 130:1-10; 134:10-16; 156:18-19; 159:5-14; 188:6-25; 239:19-240:4; 243:21-25 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

138:19-140:16; 142:3-144:7; 194:22-195:2; 232:22-233:2; 237:5-13

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

Deposition: H. Gabriel Dagen – 9/19/2013 

All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

Deposition of Paul Coulson – 9/19/2013 

104:24-108:24; 109:10-22 20 years Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

65:23-66:12; 71:15-72:11 5 years Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-44 

62:25-64:18; 64:22-65:22; 74:3-76:10; 76:17-77:24; 78:1-12; 78:14-79:21; 80:12-82:8; 82:14-18; 82:20-83:12; 83:14-84:20; 84:23-24; 85:2-22; 85:24-87:8; 87:10-90:19; 90:22-91:20; 91:23-93:6; 93:8-94:23; 95:3-24; 97:1-98:9; 98:12-20; 98:22; 99:4-21; 100:1-4; 100:8-19; 100:21-102:7; 102:10-23; 103:5-15; 103:19-104:1; 104:3-23; 108:25-109:9; 111:4-112:12; 113:10-114:1; 116:17-19; 116:21-117:10; 117:13-118:20

3 years Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Deposition: Dr. Frederick WarrenBoulton – 9/20/2013 

248-255, 258-262, 266-269 20 Years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-45 

Deposition of Mick Leahy – 9/26/2013 

15:21-16:14; 17:8-21:21; 23:7-19; 23:24-24:5; 24:8-30:6; 30:8-33:1; 35:4-36:15; 37:6-38:7; 38:22-39:3; 40:2-42:13; 43:1-11; 43:20-47:24; 48:13-52:17; 53:1-56:11; 56:18-59:5; 60:9-61:5; 62:3-15; 64:10-65:6; 65:11-66:16; 67:1-24; 68:5-8; 68:10-17; 68:19-22; 68:24-70:21; 70:24-25; 71:9-72:3; 75:2-76:10; 77:12-78:9; 78:21-79:2; 79:22-80:25; 81:3-82:19; 84:22-86:18; 86:21-87:6; 87:8-88:4; 88:8-19; 88:22-89:20; 90:5-17; 91:2-96:16; 96:20-97:3; 98:24-100:4; 100:16-102:8; 102:11-103:18; 104:11-105:25; 107:6-109:3; 109:5-7; 109:10-17; 109:18-110:7; 113:6-8; 114:15-19; 115:7-117:4; 117:22-118:16; 125:18-126:5; 126:8-127:6; 127:8-15; 128:2-8; 129:11-132:3; 132:6-8; 133:11-134:3; 135:8-14; 135:16; 135:18 

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

Deposition of Kenneth Wilkes Part I - 10/25/2013

59:12-60:12; 112:8-19; 121:18-122:6; 157:1-158:17 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

47:17-19; 142:2-18; 143:5-144:21 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix A-46 

Deposition of Kenneth Wilkes Part II - 10/25/2013

33:16-39:25; 41:24-42:20; 46:10-47:22; 48:17-50:13; 51:2-52:3; 53:17-54:1; 54:3-20; 56:14-57:4; 57:14-58:1; 70:3-16; 75:20-76:18; 77:6-18; 82:10-83:10; 88:10-23; 96:1-23; 100:10-101:6 

5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

APPENDIX B 

Appendix B-1 

Exhibit Number Applicable Pages Length of 

In Camera

Treatment

Expiration of

In Camera

Treatment

Category

DX077 PX pg. 005 - 008, 010, 025 - 026, 

028, 042, 059, 060, 067 - 069, 094 - 095, 098, 106, 109, 128, 133, 135, 139, 141, 143, 145, 147 - 148 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX083 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX103 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX104 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX134 DX pg. 014 - 016, 018 - 019 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

DX140 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-2 

DX151 DX pg. 004, 007, 014, 016, 017 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX165 DX pg. 052, 053, 054, 092 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX168 DX pg. 003, 004, 025 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX169 DX pg. 004, 005, 007, 010 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX229 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX241 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX249 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX319 DX pg. 10 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX327 DX pg. 27 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX329 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-3 

DX336 DX pg. 12 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX344 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX346 DX pg. 2 - 3 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX352 DX pg. 005, 009, 014 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX353 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX357 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX367 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX390 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX391 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX412 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX431 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX432 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX465 DX pg. 28 - 29 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-4 

DX468 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX478 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX490 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX495 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX497 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX509 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX513 DX pg. 16, 22, 27, 29, 36 -37, 40, 

42, 44, 46, 48, 50, 52, 54, 56, 58 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX518 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX531 DX pg. 056 - 061 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX539 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX540 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-5 

DX557 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX628 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX629 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX630 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX634 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX663 DX pg. 164 - 65 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

DX723 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX750 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

DX751 DX pg. 4 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX1340 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2000 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2001 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-6 

PX2007 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2009 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2013 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2019 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2022 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2025 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2026 PX pg. 007 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2038 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2040 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2043 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2047 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2048 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-7 

PX2049 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2055 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2063 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2069 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2078 PX pg. 059 - 069 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2080 PX pg. 003, 006, 028, 030 - 032, 

034

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2082 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2093 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2094 PX pg. 010 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2110 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2115 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Proprietary bottle 

design
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-8 

PX2116 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2120 PX pg. 003 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2121 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2126 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2136 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2142 PX pg. 005, 009, 014 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2143 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2149 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2151 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2152 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2164 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2167 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2168 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2169 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-9 

PX2173 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2178 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2180 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2184 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2185 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2186 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2187 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2188 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2211 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-10 

PX2213 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2219 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2222 PX pg. 008 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2224 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2237 PX pg. 056 - 061 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2243 PX pg. 066, 068 - 071 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX2244 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-11 

PX2245 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2246 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2253 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2257 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2266 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-12 

PX2284 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2287 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2289 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2292 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2293 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2296 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2311 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2312 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-13 

PX2314 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2318 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2319 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2321 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2334 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2342 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2343 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2354 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2355 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-14 

PX2365 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2366 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2367 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2368 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2369 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2370 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2371 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-15 

PX2372 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2373 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2381 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2385 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2401 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2409 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2418 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2434 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-16 

PX2435 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX2436 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX2437 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX2439 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

PX2443 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2444 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2445 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX2446 PX pg. 050, 052 - 054, 056 - 062 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX2449 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4028 PX pg. 028 - 029 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-17 

PX4030 PX pg. 016, 022, 027, 029, 036 - 

037, 040, 042, 044, 046, 048, 050, 052, 054, 056, 058 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4031 PX pg. 003, 004, 025 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4032 PX pg. 004, 007, 014, 016, 017 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4065 PX pg. 006 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4206 PX pg. 028 - 029 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4236 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4278 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-18 

PX4284 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4287 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4404 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4429 PX pg. 007 - 008 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4435 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4447 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4465 PX pg. 004, 007 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4493 PX pg. 006, 009 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-19 

PX4507 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4511 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4512 PX pg. 006, 100 - 101, 106 - 107, 

113 - 115 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4513 PX pg. 004, 010, 011 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4514 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4549 All 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4551 PX pg. 003, 004, 006, 009 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4553 PX pg. 002, 003, 009, 010, 011 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-20 

PX4554 PX pg. 002, 004, 007, 009, 010, 015, 

016

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4555 PX pg. 002, 004, 007, 009, 010, 015, 

016

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4598 PX pg. 003 - 012, 019 - 022, 030 - 

035, 041 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations; Financial Information and Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

PX4669 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4702 All 5 years December 9, 2018 Proprietary bottle 

design

PX4721 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4725 PX pg. 003 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4735 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX4827 All 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

PX5020 PX pg. 007 (para 31) 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-21 

Deposition of David Blossman on behalf of Abita Brewing Company - 8/15/2013 

143:10-17; 144:9-12; 145:3-7; 145:11-146:14; 148:3-5; 148:19-149:4; 149:8; 152:3-153:4; 153:11-22; 158:15-20; 170:7-171:9; 172:18-173:1; 173:14-23; 178:13-25 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Timothy Nall on behalf of BrownForman Corporation - 8/19/2013

97:9-10; 98:23-99:13 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Kenneth Edwards on behalf of Beam Inc. - 8/19/2013

117:10-14; 118:8-11; 134:14-135:10; 137:7-22; 139:11-17 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Adam Gelles on behalf of Pernod Ricard U.S.A., LLC - 8/21/2013

43:6-20; 103:10-104:13; 105:10-23; 108:4-19;

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of S. Lee Keathley on behalf of Anheuser-Busch Companies - 8/23/2013 

35:17-19; 55:17-21; 57:12-25; 67:5-7; 82:22-25; 108:22-109:2; 109:8-22; 110:13-16; 116:13-117:4; 119:9-18; 184:17-19; 184:21-24; 185:1; 185:17-22; 185:24-187:4; 187:24-188:14; 188:16-23; 220:21-24; 229:2-8; 229:13-230:1; 230:5-231:7 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Judy Embree on behalf of Boston Beer Co. - 8/27/2013

25:20-26:15; 27:9-15; 40:16-25; 86:24-87:4; 97:15-23; 105:1-15; 109:13-110:12; 113:2-5; 141:14-142:4; 143:24-144:17 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-22 

Investigational Hearing of Jarrell Reeves - 5/8/2013

64:8-14; 105:7-14; 156:24-157:20; 167:2-8; 167:13-25; 175:22-176:4;

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

128:18-21; 132:15-23; 133:22-24; 134:14-16; 153:25-154:7; 154:15-16; 158:7-16; 160:11-25; 184:15-25; 214:4-215:9;

3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Deposition of Jarrell Reeves - 9/17/2013

64:8-9; 64:11-14; 116:24-118:9 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Investigational Hearing of Robert Shanteau - 5/14/2013

23:25-24:3; 26:25-28:18; 29:6-20; 30:11-32:12; 33:1-34:18; 43:3-45:10; 45:14-21; 49:8-50:10; 58:14-59:4; 60:2-9; 60:18-22; 74:19-75:1; 75: 11-20; 77:17-23; 78:6-80:3; 122:6-19; 122:23-123:19; 124:13-25; 143:16-6; 146:1-147:20; 167:21-168:7; 174:8-175:14; 179:6-11; 186:12-187:4; 194:8-25; 197:18-199:3; 199:17-21; 207:6-22; 208:1-8; 208:12-209:2; 231:2-13; 235:11-236:21; 265:1-6; 267:23-268:10; 269:15-271:3; 286:25-287:2;291:17-292:6; 293:11-294:9 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-23 

38:17-23; 42:1-17; 46:20-47:10; 47:22-49:5; 50:25-51:13; 80:14-84:9; 84:14-5; 85:21-24; 89:25-90:15; 90:19-92:11; 93:18-94:22; 110:8-111:16; 117:19-117:16; 157:5-158:7; 170:17-20; 182:25-183:19; 214:8-18; 226:20-227:22; 229:10-230:22; 238:22-241:19; 243:21-246:4; 248:22-254:21; 256:23-258:15; 258:18-20; 258:22-259:13; 259:22-260:3; 260:4-24; 262:3-263:24; 281:19-282:1; 286:14-23;

3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Deposition of Robert Shanteau - 8/2/2013 

15:16-21; 18:22-25; 19:25-20:9; 20:11-16; 21:19-20; 25:9-24; 26:14-17; 29:12-14; 29:16-24; 33:5-7; 34:10-11; 34:25-35:7; 35:21; 36:21-37:5; 39:3-10; 41:7-9; 41:11-42:10; 46:10-12; 48:4-20; 49:16-20; 50:6-8; 50:12-13; 51:7-12; 52:2-53:12; 53:20-54:20; 54:22-24; 63:22-64:10; 66:13-70:16; 77:24-79:7; 79:21-80:2; 80:5-9; 83:3-13; 83:15-84:9; 84:24-85:18; 87:4-10; 87:12-88:4; 88:5-16; 88:20-89:11; 89:24-90:3; 90:6-16; 90:18-25; 91:12-92:24; 93:4; 93:6-7; 119:5-120:21; 121:11-123:1

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

14:20-15:1; 15:5-12; 24:6-25:6; 95:6-96:8

3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Investigational Hearing of Steven Rhea - 

155:15-23; 250:1-9; 252:3-253:2; 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-24 

5/16/2013 53:1-54:19; 61:4-62:6; 62:11-63:6; 

76:10-77:3; 92:12-93:9; 94:21-95:11; 161:1-162:1; 255:16-256:14;

3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

255:2-4; 267:1-20; 5 years December 9, 2018 Plant Capabilities and 

Operations

Investigational Hearing of Philip McPherson - 5/13/2013

257:21-258:6 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Investigational Hearing of Robert Ganter - 5/15/2013

42:17-43:19; 45:1-46:25; 64:20-22; 65:12-19; 82:3-16 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

47:2-14; 47:17-48:11; 103:15-18 3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Investigational Hearing of Joseph Grewe - 5/17/2013

7:22-8:15; 9:17-10:11; 32:3-33:1; 63:14-18; 66:14-68:2; 143:1-16; 143:22-144:9; 161:5-167:21; 169:15-170:1; 174:1-175:13; 193:8-12; 218:17-219:10; 226:8-232:18 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

27:18-29:19; 61:17-62:16; 71:18-72:13; 135:20-140:18; 151:24:154:11; 214:22-215:24; 221:22-25

3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 

Deposition of Joseph Grewe - 7/31/2013 

39:5-43:4; 48:12-49:5; 51:11-53:4; 56:17-20; 69:4-71:16; 85:24-89:18; 90:1-92:8; 96:7-14; 120:13-25; 121:9-12; 124:17-125:8; 193:24-194:15; 197:7-199:9; 201:19-21; 201:23-203:6; 217:2-7; 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

26:8-16; 26:18-27:19; 28:4-29:6; 29:10-15; 133:5-8; 134:9-135:10; 149:25-151:10;

3 years December 9, 2016 Financial Terms and 

Current/FutureBusiness Strategy 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public Version 

Appendix B-25 

Deposition of Jeffery Krum on behalf of Boulevard Brewing Co. - 8/5/2013 

15:5-8; 18:2-12; 18:2-12; 19:2-8; 19:23-20:3; 72:15-21; 102:22-24; 103:11-23

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Peter Lijewski on behalf of Constellation - 8/16/2013

59:9; 59:17-1; 60:23-67:17; 68:6-16 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Warren Dibble on behalf of Harpoon - 8/28/2013 

18:2-4; 31:3-13; 31:16-32:15; 33:14-18; 35:5-9; 45:20-46:2 

20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Leon Sharyon on behalf of Lagunitas - 8/13/2013 

15:21-25; 17:1-4; 27:16-25; 61:4-5; 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Investigational Hearing of Herbert Sachs on behalf of Saxco International - 5/9/2013

88:1-5; 89:1-6; 94:24-95:14 20 years December 9, 2033 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations

Deposition of Philip Cissell on behalf of Sazerac - 8/22/2013 

77:18-78:14; 96:14-97:4; 108:9-109:5; 157:22-158:8; 164:21-25; 165:5-166:22; 166:24 

 Contracts and Related 

Negotiations
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public 

 PUBLIC 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I, Jason M. Swergold, an associate at Shearman & Sterling LLP, hereby certify that on December 

9, 2013, I caused the foregoing document to be filed using the FTC’s E-Filing System, which 

will send notifications of such filing to: 

Donald S. Clark 

Secretary 

Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-113 

Washington, DC 20580 

I also certify that I delivered via electronic mail and hand delivery a copy of the foregoing 

document to: 

The Honorable D. Michael Chappell 

Administrative Law Judge 

Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-110 

Washington, DC 20580 

I further certify that I delivered via electronic mail a copy of the foregoing document to: 

Edward D. Hassi 

Catharine M. Moscatelli 

Brendan J. McNamara 

Sebastian Lorigo 

Victoria Lippincott 

Meredith Robinson 

Devon Kelly 

James Abell 

Teresa Martin 

Amanda Hamilton 

U.S. Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW 

Washington, DC 20580 

ehassi@ftc.gov

cmoscatelli@ftc.gov 

bmcnamara@ftc.gov 

slorgio@ftc.gov

vlippincott@ftc.gov

mrobinson@ftc.gov 

dkelly2@ftc.gov

jabell@ftc.gov

tmartin@ftc.gov 

ahamilton1@ftc.gov 
FTC Docket No. 9356 Public 

 PUBLIC 

Complaint Counsel

December 9, 2013 By: /s/ Jason M. Swergold

 Jason M. Swergold 

CERTIFICATE FOR ELECTRONIC FILING 

I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary of the Commission is a true and correct 

copy of the paper original and that I possess a paper original of the signed document that is 

available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

December 9, 2013 By: /s/ Jason M. Swergold

 Jason M. Swergold