Plaintiff, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”), for its Complaint alleges: 

1. The FTC brings this action under Section 13(b) of the Federal Trade 

Commission Act (“FTC Act”), 15 U.S.C. § 53(b) to obtain permanent injunctive relief, 

rescission or reformation of contracts, restitution, the refund of monies paid, disgorgement of 

ill-gotten monies, and other equitable relief for Defendants’ acts or practices in violation of 

Section 5(a) of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 45(a). 

2. Defendants market their Thermo-Shield roof and wall coatings using 

deceptive energy savings claims and claims related to R-values. R-value is a measurement of 

the insulating ability of materials, including home insulation. 

FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 

 Plaintiff, 

 v. 

SPM THERMO-SHIELD, INC., a 

corporation, 

PETER J. SPISKA, individually and as an 

officer of SPM THERMO-SHIELD, INC., 

and 

GEORGE P. SPISKA, individually and as 

an officer of SPM THERMO-SHIELD, 

INC., 

 Defendants. 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 1 of 14 PageID 1 

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 

FOR THE MIDDLE DISTRICT OF FLORIDA 

FORT MYERS DIVISION 

Case No. 2:20-cv-542 

COMPLAINT FOR PERMANENT 

INJUNCTION AND OTHER 

EQUITABLE RELIEF 

1 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 2 of 14 PageID 2 

3. Defendants claim that their Thermo-Shield Roof Coat, Thermo-Shield 

Exterior Wall Coating, and Thermo-Shield Interior Wall Coating (collectively “ThermoShield Coatings”) provide significant energy savings for consumers when applied to a home 

or other building. They also claim those products have R-values and R-value equivalents of 

R-20, R-21, R-22, and R-40, and consequently, also provide significant energy savings for 

consumers when applied to a home. 

4. However, these claims are false. Therefore, Defendants cannot substantiate 

them. In fact, SPM Thermo-Shield’s Coatings have R-values that are substantially less than 

one when applied as Defendants instruct, and Defendants’ purported substantiation 

demonstrates their products do not provide the claimed energy savings. 

JURISDICTION AND VENUE 

5. This Court has subject matter jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331, 

1337(a), and 1345. 

6. Venue is proper in this District under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391(b)(1) and (c)(2). 

PLAINTIFF 

7. The FTC is an independent agency of the United States created by statute. 15 

U.S.C. §§ 41-58. The FTC enforces Section 5(a) of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 45(a), which 

prohibits unfair or deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce. 

8. The FTC is authorized to initiate federal district court proceedings, by its own 

attorneys, to enjoin violations of the FTC Act and to secure such equitable relief as may be 

appropriate in each case, including rescission or reformation of contracts, restitution, the 

refund of monies paid, and the disgorgement of ill-gotten monies. 15 U.S.C. § 53(b). 

2 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 3 of 14 PageID 3 

DEFENDANTS 

9. Defendant SPM Thermo-Shield, Inc. (“SPM Thermo-Shield”) is a Florida 

corporation with its principal place of business at 4876 Sedgewood Lane, Naples, Florida 

34112. SPM Thermo-Shield transacts or has transacted business in this District and 

throughout the United States. At all times material to this Complaint, acting alone or in 

concert with others, SPM Thermo-Shield has advertised, marketed, distributed, or sold 

Thermo-Shield Coatings to consumers throughout the United States. 

10. Defendant Peter J. Spiska is the President of SPM Thermo-Shield. At all 

times material to this Complaint, acting alone or in concert with others, he has formulated, 

directed, controlled, had the authority to control, or participated in the acts and practices of 

SPM Thermo-Shield, including the acts and practices set forth in the Complaint. Defendant 

Peter Spiska resides in this District and, in connection with the matters alleged herein, 

transacts or has transacted business in this District. 

11. Defendant George P. Spiska is the President of Global Sales for SPM 

Thermo-Shield. At all times material to this Complaint, acting alone or in concert with 

others, he has formulated, directed, controlled, had the authority to control, or participated in 

the acts and practices of SPM Thermo-Shield, including the acts and practices set forth in the 

Complaint. Defendant George P. Spiska resides in this District and, in connection with the 

matters alleged herein, transacts or has transacted business in this District. 

3 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 4 of 14 PageID 4 

COMMERCE 

12. At all times material to this Complaint, Defendants have maintained a 

substantial course of trade in or affecting “commerce,” as “commerce” is defined in Section 

4 of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 44. 

DEFENDANTS’ BUSINESS PRACTICES 

13. Defendants manufacture and market coatings designed for residential, 

industrial, and commercial applications. 

14. Coating products are marketed for application on homes and buildings and 

include paint, paint with additives (such as ceramic spheres), varnishes, and lacquers, and 

products that incorporate such coatings. 

15. Defendants’ coatings include Thermo-Shield Roof Coat, Thermo-Shield 

Exterior Wall Coating, and Thermo-Shield Interior Wall Coating. 

16. Since at least January 2014, Defendants have disseminated or caused the 

dissemination of advertising, packaging, and promotional materials for Thermo-Shield 

Coatings, including through advertisements on their website and marketing materials for its 

distributors. 

17. In these materials, Defendants describe Thermo-Shield Coatings’ performance 

in terms of R-values and R-value equivalents. For example, they advertise that ThermoShield Coatings have “an insulation equivalent to an R-22 against solar heat.” See Exhibit A 

at no. 10. 

18. R-value is a measurement of resistance to heat flow. See FTC’s Trade 

Regulation Rule Concerning the Labeling and Advertising of Home Insulation (“R-value 

4 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 5 of 14 PageID 5 

Rule” or “Rule”), 16 C.F.R. Part 460 (initially issued in 1980 and last amended in 2019). 

The greater the R-value, the greater the reduction in heat flow, and the more energy may be 

saved to heat or cool a building. 70 Fed. Reg. 31258 (2005). 

19. Different products have different R-values. For example, fiberglass batt is 

among the most common insulating materials in the United States. It generally has an Rvalue of R-3.0 to R-3.8 per inch. Other popular insulation materials, polyisocyanurate or 

polyurethane foam, have R-values of R-5.6 to R-8.0 per inch. Consumers typically apply 

these materials several inches thick to provide the desired level of insulation. By 

comparison, hardwood has an R-value of R-0.9 per inch. Poured concrete has an R-value of 

about R-0.08 per inch, making it a poor insulator. 

20. The U.S. Department of Energy recommends levels of insulation for homes. 

It divides the country into eight climate zones and lists R-values for each zone. The Middle 

District of Florida is in Zone 2. The Department recommends homes in this zone have R-30 

to R-60 insulation in the attic and R-13 to R-15 insulation in the walls. Thus, if such a home 

uses fiberglass batt (at R-3.8 per inch), it should have at least 8 inches of the batt in its attic. 

By comparison, Miami, Florida is in Zone 1 where the Department recommends R-30 to R49 for attics. For the coldest zone, Zone 8, the Department recommends attic insulation of R49 to R-60. 

21. On April 12, 2019, the FTC informed Defendants of its investigation into their 

R-value and energy savings claims and requested substantiation for the claims. 

5 
 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 6 of 14 PageID 6 

22. On October 1, 2019, the FTC informed Defendants that it intended to file a 

lawsuit against them. In response, Defendants removed certain claims from their website, 

but certain energy savings claims still appear. 

23. Defendants’ conduct is ongoing as of the filing of this Complaint. 

24. Based on the facts and violations of law alleged in this Complaint, the FTC 

has reason to believe that Defendants are violating or are about to violate laws enforced by 

the Commission. 

DEFENDANTS CLAIM THERMO-SHIELD COATINGS 

HAVE AN R-VALUE OR R-VALUE EQUIVALENT OF R-20, R-21, R-22, R-40 

25. Defendants’ website, for example, included a summary of test results, 

including ones reporting an R-value of 22 for Thermo-Shield Roof Coat and an R-value of 21 

for Thermo-Shield Exterior and Interior Wall Coatings. Exhibit B at 4, ref. 5. 

26. Brochures on Defendants’ website reported results of “R=22” from a test on a 

five mil (i.e., .005 inches) thick sample of Thermo-Shield Roof Coat. Exhibits C at 1, D at 1, 

E at 1, F at 1. 

27. A brochure called “Thermoshield Insulating Value” reports R-values of 20 

and 40 for the Thermo-Shield Coatings. Exhibit G. 

28. Defendants’ website included a webpage called “THE THERMO-SHIELD 

DIFFERENCE” that describes Thermo-Shield Coatings as having “a thermal barrier that is 

reluctant to conduct heat and reflects as well as dissipates heat away from the surface. This 

has an insulation equivalent to an R-22 against solar heat.” Exhibit A at no. 10. 

6 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 7 of 14 PageID 7 

29. A promotional flyer called “Rocket Science” states that Thermo-Shield Roof 

Coat has “HEAT BLOCKING PERFORMANCE EQUIVALENT TO AN R-22.” Exhibit H 

at 2. 

30. For coverage, Defendants instruct consumers to apply Thermo-Shield Roof 

Coat at a thickness of 27 mils (700 microns) (i.e., .027 inches) on flat roofs and 15 mils (380 

microns) (i.e., .015 inches) on sloped roofs. They instruct consumers to apply ThermoShield Exterior and Interior Wall Coatings on walls at a thickness of 8 mils (190 microns) 

(i.e. .007 inches). Exhibits I, J, K.

 DEFENDANTS CLAIM THAT THERMO-SHIELD 

COATINGS SAVE CONSUMERS MONEY 

31. Defendants claim that using Thermo-Shield Coatings creates “energy 

savings,” is “energy efficient,” and will “save on energy costs.” See, e.g., Exhibits C, I, J, 

and K. 

32. Informational flyers Defendants posted on their website and shared with 

customers contain Defendants’ R-value test results and statements about how the insulating 

performance of Thermo-Shield Coatings save consumers money. 

33. For example, brochures for Defendants’ Roof Coat and Exterior Wall Coating 

include statements that just using Thermo-Shield “CAN SAVE UP TO 50% ON YOUR 

HEATING AND COOLING COSTS.” Exhibits D at 2, E at 2; see also Exhibit F at 2 

(stating that Thermo-Shield Interior Coating “CAN SAVE YOU BIG $$ ON YOU 

HEATING AND COOLING COSTS”). 

34. Other informational flyers advertise: 

A. “[Roof Coat] SAVE ENERGY➠30%.” Exhibit L. 

7 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 8 of 14 PageID 8 

B. “Reports from customers of energy savings up to 40% are not unusual with an 

application of THERMO-SHIELD Roof System.” Exhibit M at 2. 

C. “[A]pplied no thicker than a fingernail [Exterior and Interior Coatings] can give 

savings equal to inches of other type of insulation.” Exhibit N at 1. 

35. Defendants include testimonials about the purported energy-saving benefits 

of Thermo-Shield Coatings on their website. 

36. Defendants’ website, for example, includes a testimonial from homeowners in 

Sandy City, Utah who used Defendants’ Roof Coat and report “[w]e also enjoy savings on 

our cooling costs, which we expected, but we have also cut our heating costs in the winter, 

totally un-expected . . . . I used 30% less gas to heat my home the winter following the 

application.” Exhibit O at 2, 5. 

37. A testimonial on the website from a Las Vegas, Nevada homeowner who used 

Defendants’ Roof Coat on her patio roof states that her “cooling bills have been reduced 25% 

just by painting my patio roof.” Exhibit P at 4. 

38. In emails with their customers and potential customers, Defendants also claim 

that the R-values and R-value equivalents associated with their Thermo-Shield Coatings 

result in energy savings. 

39. For example, in response to a customer’s question about the “indicated R-22 

value” of Defendants’ Thermo-Shield Coatings, Defendant Peter Spiska responded that “[i]t 

is like having a R 40 insulation during the summer.” He also advised that “[w]ith a complete 

Thermo-Shield protection, Roof, Exterior and Interior you can expect 20%-40% reduction on 

heating expense” and that “it is like having a R 21 insulation in the winter.” Exhibit Q at 1. 

8 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 9 of 14 PageID 9 

40. In another email related to the R-value of Defendants’ Thermo-Shield 

Coatings, Defendant Peter J. Spiska told a customer that “during the summer heat, as much 

as 50% can be saved on AC, during the winter the Thermo-Shield Interior with combination 

of Exterior can save 20-30% of energy.” Exhibit R at 5. 

41. Defendants post several videos on their website in which Defendant George 

Spiska touts the benefits of Thermo-Shield Coatings, including their insulating and energy 

savings attributes. His father, Defendant Peter Spiska, copies him on email to customers, 

including the emails described in Paragraphs 39 and 40. 

DEFENDANTS CLAIM THAT TESTING 

ESTABLISHES THEIR R-VALUES 

42. Defendants expressly claim that testing supports their R-value claims of 20, 

21, and 22. 

43. Their website, for example, included a “Summary of Official Test Reports” 

including reports that Defendants’ Roof Coat has “R=22” and that their Exterior and Interior 

Wall Coatings have “R=21.” Exhibit B at 4, no. 5. 

44. Thermo-Shield brochures posted on Defendants’ website reported test results 

of “R-Value 22” from testing on a five mil thick sample (i.e., .005 inches) of Defendants’ 

Thermo-Shield Roof Coat. Exhibits C, D, E, and F. Defendants’ purported test results, 

however, do not support Defendants’ R-value claims. 

45. Defendants tested five mil thick (i.e., .005 inches) samples of Thermo-Shield 

Coatings, which yield R-values significantly less than one. In order to achieve the claimed 

R-values, consumers would need to apply at least one inch worth of Thermo-Shield Coatings 

to their roofs or walls. 

9 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 10 of 14 PageID 10 

 DEFENDANTS’ R-VALUE, R-VALUE EQUIVALENT, AND ENERGY SAVING 

CLAIMS ARE FALSE OR UNSUBSTANTIATED 

46. Thermo-Shield Coatings do not significantly restrict heat flow, let alone to the 

extent claimed by Defendants, and do not provide the advertised energy savings. Indeed, the 

R-value of Thermo-Shield Coatings applied as Defendants instruct are considerably less than 

one. 

DEFENDANTS CLAIMS ARE MATERIAL 

47. Defendants tout their products’ purported R-values, insulating benefits, and 

energy saving capabilities to consumers as a basis of superiority over paints and other 

coatings. 

48. Defendants state in marketing materials, for example, that: 

A. “Just using Thermo-Shield Exterior in place of paint can save you up to 50% 

on your heating and cooling costs.” Exhibits D at 2, E at 2. 

B. “Using THERMO-SHIELD Interior, in place of paint, can save you big $$ on 

your heating and cooling costs.” Exhibit F at 2. 

C. “Unlike some coatings that make minor insulation claims based solely on 

reflectivity, THERMO-SHIELD creates a thermal barrier that is reluctant to 

conduct heat and readily dissipates heat.” Exhibit S at 1. 

DEFENDANTS PROVIDED THE MEANS AND 

INSTRUMENTALITIES FOR THE COMMISSION OF DECEPTION 

49. Defendants provided their promotional materials—which alone or in 

combination make all the claims listed above—to independent builders, dealers, installers, 

and building supply stores (“Resellers”). 

10
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 11 of 14 PageID 11 

VIOLATIONS OF THE FTC ACT 

50. Section 5(a) of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 45(a), prohibits “unfair or deceptive 

acts or practices in or affecting commerce.” Misrepresentations and unsubstantiated claims 

constitute deceptive acts or practices prohibited by Section 5(a) of the FTC Act. 

COUNT I 

False or Unsubstantiated Performance Claims 

51. In numerous instances in connection with the advertising, promotion, offering 

for sale, or sale of Thermo-Shield Coatings, as described in Paragraphs 13 to 48, Defendants 

have represented, directly or indirectly, expressly or by implication, that: 

A. Thermo-Shield Coatings have insulation values or insulation equivalent 

values of R-20, R-21, R-22, and R-40 when applied as Defendants instruct. 

B. Using Thermo-Shield Coatings will save consumers money, including, for 

example, by saving them up to 50% on heating and cooling costs. 

52. The representations set forth in Paragraph 51 are false and misleading and 

were not substantiated at the time the representations were made. 

53. Therefore, the making of the representations as set forth in Paragraph 51 

constitute deceptive acts or practices in violation of Section 5(a) of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 

45(a). 

COUNT II 

False Establishment Claim of R-Values 

54. In numerous instances in connection with the advertising, promotion, offering 

for sale, or sale of Thermo-Shield Coatings, as described in Paragraphs 13 to 48, Defendants 

11 
 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 12 of 14 PageID 12 

have represented, directly or indirectly, expressly or by implication, that testing establishes 

R-values and R-value equivalents of R-20, R-21, and R-22 for Thermo-Shield Coatings. 

55. In truth and in fact, testing does not establish these R-values. 

56. Therefore, the representations set forth in Paragraph 54 are false or misleading 

and constitute deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce in violation of Section 

5(a) of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 45(a). 

COUNT III 

Means and Instrumentalities 

57. By furnishing Resellers with promotional materials for Thermo-Shield 

Coatings, including printed materials such as brochures, that make false or misleading 

representations, Defendants have provided the means and instrumentalities that constitute 

deceptive acts or practices in or affecting commerce in violation of Section 5(a) of the FTC 

Act, 15 U.S.C. § 45(a). 

CONSUMER INJURY 

58. Consumers are suffering, have suffered, and will continue to suffer substantial 

injury as a result of Defendants’ violations of the FTC Act. In addition, Defendants have 

been unjustly enriched as a result of their unlawful acts or practices. Absent injunctive relief 

by this Court, Defendants are likely to continue to injure consumers, reap unjust enrichment, 

and harm the public interest. 

THIS COURT’S POWER TO GRANT RELIEF 

59. Section 13(b) of the FTC Act, 15 U.S.C. § 53(b), empowers this Court to 

grant injunctive and such other relief as the Court may deem appropriate to halt and redress 

violations of any provision of law enforced by the FTC. The Court, in the exercise of its 

12 
 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 13 of 14 PageID 13 

equitable jurisdiction, may award ancillary relief, including rescission or reformation of 

contracts, restitution, the refund of monies paid, and the disgorgement of ill-gotten monies, to 

prevent and remedy any violation of any provision of law enforced by the FTC. 

PRAYER FOR RELIEF 

60. Wherefore, Plaintiff FTC, pursuant to Section 13(b) of the FTC Act, 15 

U.S.C. § 53(b), and the Court’s own equitable powers, requests that the Court: 

A. Award Plaintiff such ancillary relief as may be necessary to avert the 

likelihood of consumer injury during the pendency of this action and to 

preserve the possibility of effective final relief, including a preliminary 

injunction; 

B. Enter a permanent injunction to prevent future violations of the FTC Act by 

Defendants; 

C. Award such relief as the Court finds necessary to redress injury to consumers 

resulting from Defendants’ violations of the FTC Act, including but not 

limited to, rescission or reformation of contracts, restitution, the refund of 

monies paid, and the disgorgement of ill-gotten monies; and 

D. Award Plaintiff the costs of bringing this action, as well as such other and 

additional relief as the Court may determine to be just and proper. 

13 
 

 

 

 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 14 of 14 PageID 14 

Dated: July 28, 2020 

Respectfully Submitted, 

ALDEN F. ABBOTT 

General Counsel 

 s/ Philip Z. Brown 

MICHELLE L. SCHAEFER 

 D.C. Bar No. 478773 

 PHILIP Z. BROWN

 Florida Bar No. 0076439 

 Federal Trade Commission

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW 

Maildrop CC-9528 

Washington, DC 20580 

Tel: 202-326-3515 (Schaefer), -2979 (Brown) 

Fax: 202-326-3197 

mschaefer@ftc.gov, pbrown1@ftc.gov 

Counsel for Plaintiff Federal Trade Commission 

14 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 1 of 75 PageID 15 

EXHIBIT A 
Energy S.1ving Paine & Coacings s,,,cr mu 

'Ilic lHERMO.SHIElDI!> DIFFERENCE 

THE lHER/,1O-SHIEl.D® DlfTIRENCE 

Thermo-ShieldG, tS an ela.stoffl!'ric acryhc ~lsion with ene"IY saving, ceramic · ... It is. made of totally Synthetic 

state-of-the-art materials., so it i! net wbject to rapid breakdown il1ld ~tencntion l~ traditional pa.int:s. & coati~. The 

followina is a list of advantages I benefits obtained when you "!'Ply Thenno-Shi~ld® Paint & Coatines: 

lHERMO-sHIEI..D '!HERMA.I. PROPERTIES 

1.Red'uca crereY conswnption / C0Sb. in ell typ:!'J of dimates. 

2.Excellent adhesion to mart wtntrate-s inducfinz s.t:eel, bn. unprime-d or 2a.tvamz.ed metal, wood, concrete, stone, ble-, 

foam, nA>ber, plastic and o~en ~t can be app~ed to asphalt and tar with Thenro-Shield AcrytJc flex-Ta<: M • ba<..e 

coat). 

3.Pro,idea Ii"', .....,u.,, "'5istant and lle,oble coatinii lhol can ...duce~ costs up to-41X_ 

. W.terproofi nz: the n>Ofina will withstand pondinff I standinii ""'ter. 

S.Varii!b(e Pmnc,ability: Pol= shrink when dry wni<h oliaw-; the substrate to bre•the ond evapontion to OCXU", 

however, the pclymo" expand when wet oftenni: =ce llent pn,u,ction Offail"<U damaeini: moi,run, penetration. 

6.Them11>-Shiel~ lntenor -lly beats the Class t rah"¥ of 25 or I= fl.am• 'lpn,ad lnd<!x and SO or I= s.-. 

Developed lndu. Actual re,ults fa< The<mo--ldl'l Interior.,.., a flame Spread Index of aily 6.3 and Smoke 

Developed Index of only 1.9. 

7.lJnd...,,r;t.,,- La'-atones Ce<tihed Thenno-Shi•ld:.l Roof Coatin& UL ClanA fire r-..istanL 

8 .lonfi life· wts 2 to l times longe-lhln a,nv.,ntion>I paints & a,alinzs: it is not damal;Cd by ultra viotrl twit, cb,> 

not~ hord or aad<, does not get chalky ond eliminat.,. U,. 4-6 year pa;nt cycle. 

9. Remains fleXJble al minus. so· F and maintlil'l:i its strenath at ,;oo· f; etimini:tes th!nnal•thock cS&Nae. 

10.Cre•l<!s • thermal barn« that i> nolucunt to «>nduct heat and rell«ts a> ....ti"" <!=pa~ neat away from lhe 

surface. ilris has an insulation cqlJ\valent to an R-22 eeamst solar heaL 

11.H.ll excell~nl elongation, fiexib~lty ,ind t'K<Ivey properti~ allowina in~rior and exterior surface cracks ta be 

repaired and pre,,ents future cracl:s. The elastic ,...f coatine """"'w,lh the t,.,il<lillJ? rnowments p"'"'entire.,.., 

aacks. 

1~0iminab!-! warm air to ~d surface contact and mduae5 ~ te,,pernt11e diff~nt:iz! ~~by redLlcine or 

eti minatini cor.derGatian. 

13.Coot &ffective: wiU poy for ilSelf in• !llort period of time lh~h e,,erey sa•Jine, and lone life. 

14. Be-comes a monohthic1 flexlble, membrane-t11te1 mating aver the eobre ana with no !.eams or adhestCI'\ problems; 

eil.iminatine virtually all air infiltration whlc:h can be a major soun::.e of heat transfN in buildines, 

15.lt is. w•tm" sollbte, eas-J to app•.y and easy lo dNn up; nc e-tabont.te>equipnt!nt n,,qui, ed. 

16. Wate<-ba!M and non-toxic in liquid and a,...d state· OMRONMEMTAW' GREEN PROOUCT. 

17.INrj bo tinted to deslred color, excellent fade resistance. 

1 B. Hail resistant. 

19.f"tre~nt. 

20.Mold and IAildew resistanL 

21.fasny Washable. 

22. Wind and salt abrasion resist....nt. 

23.R.eflects scund bad tc the source, not allowif'tl lM s.urface to conduc.t sound, then!fore1 reduansi: not~ Leve-ls. 

24. w;- air1>ome pollutants. 

25. Variable -•lllhty: whei the coat1n2 a dry the pclyme" 5hrir.k to let trapped moistu1, ~the Ot.t, but whet, 

wet th,e, polymers SW'l:'il Bnd become Vl.'ot~;ht. This ~b bhst.L!rir,i and morst\Jre build~up 1~ the stnaure. 

26.Provido, • !tie), doe= of comfort in the b'1ild1ne by reducing no,,., and rnuntmrM2 the rnside """'" temperatuno at 

.a lllOl"e mble level. 

27. Very low mainumanc:,, costs. 

28. The fioi"1ed mombran~ is very liEhtw.eieht; only 30 lbs. per 1D0 sq. fL (tar and i,-a,,el is t);>icalty a.be<.~ 600 lb>. per 

100 sq. fL). 

29. Resistant to nctm11\ foot tn,ff,c. 

JO.Labor savini roof appl,cation I cart eff...:tive to apply. 

JI.MAD£ IN ll.S.A. 

ropofPage • 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 2 of 75 PageID 16 

([KLELW$
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 3 of 75 PageID 17 

EXHIBIT B 
SUMMARY OF OFFICIAL TEST REPORTS 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 4 of 75 PageID 18 

ϮϬϭκ  ([KLELW%
TABLE OF CONTENTS 

Manufactured by: SPM Thermo-Shield® Inc. (USA)Tel.: 001-239-234-5832 Email: spm@thermoshield.comFax: 001-239-236-6767 www.thermoshield.com Thermal Performance Tests and Coating Performance Tests: - ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials) - UL (Underwriters Laboratories) - JIS (Japanese Industrial Standards) 

 ([KLELW%

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 5 of 75 PageID 19 
REF. NR. TEST CRITERIA STANDARD LABORATORY REF. NR. REPORT 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 6 of 75 PageID 20 d, Kd'>sE/ ^DW> , 64% LESS HEAT TRANSFER d,Ed,hEͲ Kd ^DW>͘ d,ZDKͲ^,/> ,d dZE^&Zс1.163 BTU/hr/Sq.-Ft2 d,Kd^DW>,84% LESS HEAT TRANSFER d,Ed,&/ZKZ ^DW>͘d,ZDKͲ^,/>,d dZE^&Zс6.1 BTU/hr/Sq.-Ft2 d,Kd^DW>,25% LESS HEAT TRANSFER d,Ed,W>E</E ^DW>͘d,ZDKͲ^,/>,d dZE^&Zс0.871 BTU/hr/Sq.-Ft2 REFLECTANCE = 70% EMMITTANCE = 90% K& td,ZKd/E'͘

EEh>,d&>hyZh&ZKD145,317 BTU PER M2 TO 48,439 BTU/M2 

ΘϳͲϬΘϯεΘϳͲϬΘϯεΘϳͲϬΘϯε

ϳ͘ϬϬнεϭ

HAUSER

LABORATORIES 

HAUSER

LABORATORIES 

HAUSER

LABORATORIES 

OAK RIDGE

NATIONAL

LABORATORY 

^dDͲϭϳϳ

^dDͲϭϬκρ

^dDͲϭϳϳ

^dDͲϭϬκρ

^dDͲϭϳϳ

^dDͲϭϬκρ

͘K͘͘KK>ZKK&

>h>dKZ

,d&>hy;KDWZ/^KEt/d,hEͲ ηϬϭ Kd'>sE/^,d^d>Ϳ,d&>hy;KDWZ/^KEt/d,>< ηϬϮ ^W,>dKd&/ZKZͿ,d&>hy;KDWZ/^KEt/d, ηϬϯ W>E</EKd/E'KE&/ZKZͿϯzZd^dͲ^K>ZZ/d/KEKEdZK>&KZ>KtͲ^>KWZKK&^

ηκ ;^K>ZZ&>d/KE͕/E&ZZ

D/ddE͕^hZ&dDW͘Θ,d&>hyͿE'/E'&&d

 ([KLELW%
REF. NR. TEST CRITERIA STANDARD LABORATORY REF. NR. REPORT 

d,ZD>Z^/^dEE^dz^dd,d&>hyEd,ZD> ZKK&Kd/E'͗ K = 0.0454 / R = 22 dZE^D/^^/KEWZKWZd/^͘d,/^d^d ^dDϭϭϳ CALCOAST ηρ ηϬκϮςͲϭͬεϭ ydZ/KZKd/E'͗K = 0.04761 / R = 21 EKDW^^^Kd,^/E'>Ed, ^dDϭϬκρ ANALYTICAL-ITL /EdZ/KZKd/E'͗K = 0.04761 / R = 21 Kh>^/DKK&

D^hZDEd

CALIFORNIA

ZKK&KdϭκͲϭρD/>^&d͗tͬŵ͘<= 0.0538 INSTITUTE OFZKK&KdϯϯͲϯκD/>^&d͗tͬŵ͘< = 0.0515 ης d,ZD>KEhd/s/dzd^d ^dDϭϮϮρ ELECTRONICS & ςϮϬεϯϬϯϮϮ ydZ/KZKdΘD/>^&d͗tͬŵ͘< = 0.0579 MATERIALS /EdZ/KZKdεD/>^&d͗tͬŵ͘<с 0.0556 SCIENCE 

SPECIALIZED

TESTING:

ACCREDITED BY

INTERNATIONAL Z&>dEEd,ZD> ACCREDITATION sZ'/E/d/>Z&>dE= 0.882 D/ddEK&ε^DW>^K&ZKK& SERVICES, A ^d/YρϬϬϭΘͬZ/K ηϬϳ Kd͗h^/E'Yh/WDEd MEMBER OF THE ͲϭϬϳϯͲϬρ sZ'/E/d/>D/^^/s/dz = 0.793 DEh&dhZzs/^E INTERNATIONAL ^Zs/^KDWEzDK>^^ZͲ ACCREDITATION

FEDERATION -

SANS

MEMBERSHIP 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 7 of 75 PageID 21 

 ([KLELW%
REF. NR. TEST CRITERIA STANDARD LABORATORY REF. NR. REPORT 

R&D SERVICES:

ACCREDITED BY

INTERNATIONAL

ACCREDITATION sZE'Z&>dEс0.888 SERVICES, A ^K>ZZ&>dEEd,ZD> ^dDϭρκεͲϬε Zϭϭϭεϳϯ^Z ηΘ MEMBER OF THE DD/dED^hZDEd^ ^dDϭϯϳϭͲϬκĂ Zϭϭϭεϳκ, /ZD/ddE с0.844 INTERNATIONALACCREDITATION

FEDERATION -

SANS

MEMBERSHIP 

,D/^W,Z/>^WdZ> йZ&>dEZ&>dED^hZDEd^ hs s/^ E/Z ^dDεϬϯͲΘϮ DSET ηϬε WZ&KZDt/d,<DEρϮκϬ ΘεƌϭϮϭεͲϬϭ 15.5 86.2 82.8 ^dDΘεϮͲΘϮ LABORATORIES ^WdZKW,KdKDdZhd/>//E'E 15.7 89.2 84.7 /Ed'Zd/E'^W,Z

15.7 88.6 84.7 

ATLAS

WEATHERING

SERVICES GROUP;

ACCREDITED BY

Z&>dE D/d

d



E

 THE AMERICAN

dKd>DD/ddEZWKZdK&ϭy ASSOCIATION FORydZ/KZKdEϮyZKK&Kd ydZ/KZ 0.07 0.93 LABORATORY

ηϭϬ KEtKK^DW>^h^/E''Z/Z ^dDκϬΘͲϳϭ ϭεϳϯρͲϬ ACCREDITATION, A hE<>/E^dZhDEd^/E&ZZ ZKK& 0.06 0.94 MEMBER OF THE

Z&>dKDdZ INTERNATIONAL ZKK& 0.06 0.94 ACCREDITATION

FEDERATION -

SANS

MEMBERSHIP 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 8 of 75 PageID 22 

 ([KLELW%
REF. NR. TEST CRITERIA STANDARD LABORATORY REF. NR. REPORT 

dE^/>^dZE'd,dϮρй>KE'd/KEс525 psi. 

ηϭϭ dE^/>WZKWZd/^ ^dDͲκϭϮ COLUMBINE LAB dE^/>^dZEd,dZ<с615 psi. 

h>d/Dd>KE'd/KEс70%.

dE^/>^ddϮρй>KE'd/KEс10% 

Z/dd>E^^d^dh^/E'^dZ/</E' PASSED:

ηϭϮ s/d,dKE&KZD^dKd, ^dDͲϳκς COLUMBINE LAB 

^dEZ εϬϬEd^dd-37 CO 

dE^/>^dZ^^dϮρй>KE'd/KEͲ/E/d/>515 psi͕,E'/E'&dZ'/E'Ͳ15%. dE^/>^dZE',dZ<Ͳ640 psi dZ/KZd/KE z,d/E'/E /Z͘,E'&dZ'/E'Ͳ20%͘ ηϭϯ WZKE/d/KE/E'ϭt<dϮρ

K ^dDͲΘςρ COLUMBINE LAB 

h>d/Dd>KE'd/KEͲ85% ρϬйZ,͘,d'/E'Ϯϭz^ϭρϬK,E'&dZ'/E'Ͳ15%͘dE^/>^d&dZͲ25% >KE'd/KEͲ/E/d/>15% ,E'&dZ '/E'Ͳ35% tdZsWKhZdZE^D/^^/KE4.7 

GRAINS PER SQ. FT. PER HR͘

tdZsWKhZWZD//>/dzh^/E' sZ'WZDE310 PERMS͘ ηϭκ ^dDϭςρϯ COLUMBINE LAB 'ZEZWZ<WZD//>/dzhW sZE'WZD//>/dz8.8 PERM IN͘

;dsZE'd,/<E^^K&ϮΘ͘κD/>Ϳ͘

/EZ^/Et/',d31%.^K>h>DddZ>K^d2.8%. tdZ^KZWd/KEͲ^dhZd/KE ηϭρ ^dDͲρϳϬ COLUMBINE LAB tdZ^KZ34%. K&ρt<^

EK,E'^/EWWZEK&DdZ/>&dZZKE/d/KE/E'͘

 ([KLELW%

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 9 of 75 PageID 23 
REF. NR. TEST CRITERIA STANDARD LABORATORY REF. NR. REPORT 

sZE'WZDE310 PERMS͘

ηϭς tdZh^/E''ZEZhWͲες ^dDͲες COLUMBINE LAB sZ'WZD/>/dz8.8 PERM IN. 

^hZ&KKEZ</E'͕dKd> NO FAILURE OBSERVED /EhZd/KE ηϭϳ ^dDͲϭϭκε COLUMBINE LAB K&ϳϬz^d^d͘ K&d^d͘,D/>Z^z^dE/Eϭς,KhZ CALCOAST ANALYTICAL- Z^h>d^s/>>KEKZ/'/E> ηϭΘ ^dDͲϭϯΘϬ ^WKdd^d ITL ZWKZd͘

JOHNS MANVILLE 

LABORATORY Yh>/&/^^A CLASS 1 RATING͘

ACCREDITED BY dhEE>d^dK&^hZ&hZE/E' ηϭε ^dDΘκ NATIONAL VOLUNTARY &εϳͲΘρ &>D^WZс6.3 KEDEdKZ LABORATORY

ACCREDITATION

PROGRAMME USA ^DK
KWDEdс1.9 

>^^&/Zd^d/E';d^d^&KZ&/Z &>z/E'ZE^ ͲNONE͘ h>ϳεϬ UNDERWRITERS ηϮϬ Z^/^dEK&ZKK&KsZ/E' ΘςE<ϮΘκϬε <yWK^hZ ͲNONE. ^dDͲϭϬΘ LABORATORIES INC. DdZ/>^Ϳ >dZ>&>D^WZͲNONE. 

PASSED:

>KtdDW͘^d/>/dzd^d͗/EdZ/KZ :/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ ZYh/ZDEd^͗^,Kh>EKd ηϮϭ MIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϮ Kd/E' ρ͘ρ ^WZd͘/E'Z/Ed^^,Kh>EKd

^WZd͕EKd:K/EddK'd,Z͘

Z^/^dEK&Z</E'd/E/d/> PASSED: :/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ ηϮϭ Zz/E'^d'd^d͗/EdZ/KZ MIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϮ ZYh/ZDEd^͗^,Kh>EKd,s ρ͘ϳ Kd/E' KhZZEK&Z<^͘

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 10 of 75 PageID 24 

 ([KLELW%
REF. NR. TEST CRITERIA STANDARD LABORATORY REF. NR. REPORT 

,^/KE^dZE'd,;EKZD> ηϮϭ KE/d/KEͿd^d͗/EdZ/KZKd/E'

t^,/>/dzd^d͗ ηϮϭ /EdZ/KZKd/E'

/DWd͕^,K<Z^/^dEd^d͗ ηϮϭ /EdZ/KZKd/E'

ηϮϭ ><>/E/dzd^d͗/EdZ/KZKd/E'

/^K>KhZd/KEd^d͗ ηϮϭ /EdZ/KZKd/E'

:/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ

ρ͘Θ

:/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ

ρ͘ϭϭ

:/^ςεςε;ϭεΘκͿ

ρ͘ϭϮ

:/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ

ρ͘ϭϯ͘Ϯ

:/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ

ρ͘ϭϳ

MIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϮMIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϮMIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϮMIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϮMIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϮ

PASSED:sZ'с158.8 N/cm2D/E/DhD^dEZс29.4 N/cm2 

PASSED:ZYh/ZDEd͗^,Kh>EKdW>EKZZhK&&͘PASSED:ZYh/ZDEd͗^,Kh>EKdZ<͕,/W͕W>EKZKs/Kh^,E'^,WKZ&KZD͘PASSED:ZYh/ZDEd͗^,Kh>EKdZ<͕>/^dZ͕W>͕EKZ'hDD/E'͕^,Kh>EKd,sEKd/>K>KZ,E'EKZh>>E^^PASSED: ;'Zz^>ηκͲρͿZYh/ZDEd͗^,Kh>EKdZ<͕W>͕^,Kh>/^K>KhZKs'Zz^>ηϯ

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 11 of 75 PageID 25 

 ([KLELW%
FUSION: PASSED:

ZYh/ZDEd͗^,Kh>EKd&h^d,dKd>d,/<E^^K&d,d^d/E'Kz͘FISSION: PASSED͗ZYh/ZDEd^͗^,Kh>EKd,st/d,K&Zs/^EKDKZd,EϭͬϭϬK&d,/<E^^dd,ZsZ^^/͘TRANSFORMATION: PASSED: ZYh/ZDEd^͗^,Kh>EKd,sKs/Kh^,ZD&h>^,WKZ&KZD&dZ,d/^yd/E'h/^,͘FLAME RETENTION: PASSED: ZYh/ZDEd^͗&>D^,Kh>EKdZD/EKsZϯϬ^KE^&dZ,d/E'^dKWW͘BOW AT COOLED TEMP: PASSED: ZYh/ZDEd^͗d,Kt^,Kh>EKdyd,KtdEKZD>dDW͘COMBUSTION COEFFICIENT OF AREA UNIT: PASSED:D^hZDEd^ZΘ͕ε͕ΘZYh/ZDEd ^,Kh> EKd y ϯϬPASSED:ZYh/ZDEd^͗^,Kh>EKd^WZd͘/E'Z/Ed^^,Kh>EKd^WZd͕EKd:K/EddK'd,Z͘PASSED:ZYh/ZDEd^͗^,Kh>EKd,sKhZZEK&Z<^͘

REF. NR. TEST CRITERIA STANDARD LABORATORY REF. NR. REPORT 

,dZ^/^dEd^d͗/EdZ/KZ :/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ ηϮϭ MIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϯ Kd/E' ρ͘ϭΘͬ:/^ϭϯϮϭ>KtdDW͘^d/>/dzd^d͗ ηϮϮ :/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿρ͘ρ MIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϯ ydZ/KZKd/E'Z^/^dEK& Z</E'd

ηϮϮ /E/d/>Zz/E'^d'd^d͗ :/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿρ͘ϳ MIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϯ

ydZ/KZKd/E'

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 12 of 75 PageID 26 

 ([KLELW%
REF. NR. TEST CRITERIA STANDARD LABORATORY REF. NR. REPORT 

,^/KE^dZE'd,;EKZD>

ηϮϮ KE/d/KEΘ&dZ^dhZd/KEͿ

d^d͗ydZ/KZKd/E'Z^/^dEdKZWddDW͘ ηϮϮ ,E'd^d͗ydZ/KZKd/E'tdZWZKK&;WEdZd/KEͿd^d͗ ηϮϮ ydZ/KZKd/E'

t^,/>/dzd^d͗ ydZ/KZ ηϮϮKd/E'

/DWd͕^,K<Z^/^dEd^d͗ ηϮϮ ydZ/KZKd/E'

><>/E/dzd^d͗ ydZ/KZ

ηϮϮ

Kd/E'

Z^/^dEdKtd,ZΘ

ηϮϮ >/Dd d^d͗ ydZ/KZ

Kd/E'

:/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿρ͘Θ:/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿρ͘ε

:/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ

ρ͘ϭϬ

:/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ

ρ͘ϭϭ

:/^ςεςε;ϭεΘκͿ

ρ͘ϭϮ

:/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ

ρ͘ϭϯ͘Ϯ

:/^ςεϬε;ϭεΘκͿ

ρ͘ϭκ

MIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϯMIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϯMIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϯMIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϯMIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϯMIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϯMIYAHARA & CO. LTD. ςϯϭρϯϯ

NORMAL CONDITIONS: PASSED 

sZ'с138.2 N/cm2D/E/DhD^dEZс49.0 N/cm2 AFTER SATURATION: PASSED 

sZ'с234.2 N/cm2D/E/DhD^dEZс29.4 N/cm2 

PASSED͗ZYh/ZDEd͗^,Kh>EKdW>͕Z<͕>/^dZEKZEKd/>/^K>KhZd/KE͕h>>E^^KEd,^hZ&͘

PASSED͗Z^h>dс0.1 cmD/E/DhDZYh/ZDEdс1.0 cm 

PASSED͗ZYh/ZDEd͗^,Kh>EKdW>EKZZhK&&͘PASSED͗ZYh/ZDEd͗^,Kh>EKdZ<͕W>EKZKs/Kh^,E'^,WKZ&KZD͘PASSED͗ZYh/ZDEd͗^,Kh>EKdZ<͕>/^dZ͕W>͕EKZ'hDD/E'͕^,Kh>

EKd,sEKd/>K>KZ,E'EKZh>>E^^

PASSED͗;'Zz^>ηκͲρͿ

ZYh/ZDEd͗^,Kh>EKdZ<͕W>͕^,Kh>/^K>KhZKs

'Zz^>ηϯ

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 13 of 75 PageID 27 

 ([KLELW%
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 14 of 75 PageID 28 

EXHIBIT C 
Tlul- tll•t re•ult• actually •how Tlulrmo-ahleld roof coating 

to get •tronger anti IIIOIW durable with aging. 

(K-Value .0514) ( R-Val- 22 ) • 

Both t..t. .,,ow Thermo-ahleld roof c-t with 8.8 perm 

rating, till• I• excellent, 1110 x a• much aa one of our main 

competltora, claiming the -me JINIPlllty. 

Maximum to pa.a t..t I• 1.0 CM rating, 

Therm_,,leld -• 0.1 CM, 10 ti-better than required 

Did -t crack, peel, or dlllt:0/or to minimum IICllle of #3, Therm~ .,,,.,d maintained a #4 - #5 •cale, rating Excellent, bed of any 

paint te.t.d by the Japaneae National T-tlng Laboratort-. 

After 3 year t.d, Tlulrm.ahleld Roof Coat maintained 

70'}(, reflectivity and reduced heat flux by 111/'X,. 

The be•t performance of all white and aluminum coating• 

te.ltHI. 

You can't get a bBtttlr ,.,.,.nee than that! 

~h/11/d Interior c-t, white .0871 BTUIHR sq ", 

Normal paint, white 1.163 BTUlHR sq It. 

Normal paint a/lo- 37'}(, mon, heat to pass through. 

Thllnno-ahlsld Exterior Coating out preformed 2" of 

Fiberglass In tbs _,,. and 3" In cellln1111 In keeping tbs 

Interior cooler, building al•o cooled off much quicker 

Tbs Thllrm04hlsld hou•• had BIHllflY c-ts that _,. 42 

ptll'CIHlt lBIIII, .. v1n1111 summer and winter, totaling $71/0.00 

peryr,ar 

THERMO

original 

developed 

the 1970's

worked clo

who deve

and Rohm 

unique p

resins. The

7 years t

coatings 

products 

and aro

the har

Thermo-shield has been widely tested in 

accredited Laboratories, under private and 

Government sponsorship, and in actual field 

tests. Here are some of those results: 

America’s ASTM testing . . . 

ASTM D-412 Tensile Strength and 

ASTM D-865 Deterioration By Heating In Air, 

ASTM C-177 Steady State Heat Flux and 

ASTM C-1045 Thermal Transmission Properties, Roof Coating 

At 5 Mil. Thickness. 

ASTM D-1653 Water Vapor Permeability and 

ASTM E-96 Permeability. 

Japanese JIS (Industrial Standards) testing. . . 

JIS A 6909 5.12 Test For Waterproofing 

. 

JIS A 6909 5.14 Resistance To Weather &Climate 

US Dept of Energy tests at Oakridge National Labs, Long term 

Heat Flux tests on roofing systems. 

Hauser Laboratories test comparison of heat transfer through 

Thermo-shield vs. other common coatings. 

Tests at a certified lab on metal storage buildings 

St. Louis comparison tests on 3 houses, one painted with 

Thermo-shield Exterior. 

. 

*Note some specialists say the ASTM formula for R-Value in this test “R = 

1/K” is oversimplified . 

7KHUPRVKLHOG %HQHILWV

Beautiful Finish - Blocks Heat Gain or Loss -

Waterproofing - Variable Permeability -Humidity 

Control - Noise Absorption - Non Toxic in Liquid or 

Cured Form - No Joints or Seams - Low VOC / No 

Harmful Emissions - Washable, Scrubable -

Eliminate Condensation - Environmentally Friendly -

Easy to Insulate Existing Buildings - Foot Traffic 

Resistant - Remains Flexible - Mold, Mildew, Fungus 

Resistance - Stain Resistant -

Energy Savings/Quick ROI - Easy to Apply - High 

Fade Resistance - Long Life Performance - Chemical 

Resistant - Crack Bridging - Improves Air Quality -

Long Factory Warranty - Un Effected by UV Exposure - Fire Resistance - Blocks Sound Transmission -

Competitive Price -

Over 25 Years of Testing and History 

EXTERIOR WALL COAT, INTERIOR WALL COAT, 

ROOF COAT, TEXTURE COAT, TANK SHIELD, 

CLEAR WOOD AND DECK COAT 

ZZZWKHUPRVKLHOGFRP



ROCK

ROCK

FOR HO

AGR

AN

HOW 

Over 2
WET 

PAINT 

E\'AP C".\TICN 

IP l'CCE56 

CRY 

PAINT 

Weatherresislant 

Energy savings 

Great Science. 

&HUDPLFVDUHNQRZQWREHD

JUHDWQRQFRQGXFWRURIKHDWDV 

VKRZQKHUH7KHFHUDPLFFXEH

JORZVDWGHJUHHVI LQWKH 

FHQWHU\HWFDQVDIHO\EHKDQGOHG 

E\EDUHKDQG3K\VLFVODZVWDWHV 

QRWKLQJFDQPRYHE\FRQGXFWLRQ 0LFURVSKHUHVDUH

WKURXJKDYDFXXPVLQFHLWUHSUHVHQWVDQDEVHQFHRI SRXUHGLQWREDUHKDQG

PDWWHU,QSODLQ(QJOLVKLW¶VLPSRVVLEOHIRUKHDWRU DQGSURSDQHWRUFKLV VTIWVFKRR

VRXQGWRWUDYHOE\FRQGXFWLRQWKURXJKDYDFXXP6SDFH LJQLWHG KHDWLQJELOOVWKDWDY

6KXWWOHWHFKQRORJ\FRPELQHVFHUDPLFWLOHVZLWKD RQO\SHUPR

YDFXXPHGFHQWHUWRSURWHFWWKH6SDFH 6KXWWOHDJDLQVW UHFRUGFROGZLQWHU

WKHLQFUHGLEOHKHDWDWUHHQWU\

MRLQHGZLWKWKH0&RPSDQ\DQG5RKP	 

KDQGIURPLQFUHGLEOH 

,QWKHHDUO\¶V*HQHUDO,QGXVWULHV&RUS 0LFURVSKHUHVSURWHFW +DDVWRGHYHORSWKLVWHFKQRORJ\LQWRDV\VWHP KHDWRIWKHWRUFK

7KH0&RPSDQ\VXSSO\WKH All of the ingredients are synthetic. Most other FHUDPLFPLFURVFRSLFKROORZVSKHUH¶V paints and coatings use organic materials as fillers. RI WKH7KHUP

Natural materials that are readily broken down by 

LQHIIHFWPLQLDWXUHWKHUPRVERWWOHV nature: Thermal Shock, Extreme Heat or Cold, 

WKDWDUHDOVRYDFXXPHG5RKP	

WKDWFRXOGEHXVHGRQKRPHVDQGEXLOGLQJV

$IWHU\HDUVRIUHVHDUFKDQG GHYHORSPHQW

7KHUPRVKLHOGZDVERUQ

Chemicals, Ultra Violet Radiation, Ozone Decay, +DDVKHOSHGGHYHORSWKHVSHFLDOSXUH 

crack, peel, fade, decay and turn chalky, or simply 

Blistering, and Weather such as Wind, Rain, Snow, DFU\OLFUHVLQVDQGXQLTXHSRO\PHUV Hail, or sand abrasion. Other coatings get hard, WKDWNHHSWKHFHUDPLFVROLGVLQXQL IRUPVXVSHQVLRQXQWLODSSOLHG7KHVH VSHFLDOSRO\PHUVDQGUHVLQVDOVRJLYHLWWKHODVWLQJIOH[L decompose. The ceramic vacuum micro-spheres are 

the filler in Thermo-shield. The coating protects its 

ELOLW\H[FHOOHQWDGKHVLRQDQGWKHXQLTXHDELOLW\WR DFKLHYHDORQJODVWLQJSURWHFWLYHEDUULHUEXWZLWKQRQH

RIWKHUHSRUWHGGDPDJLQJVLGHHIIHFWVZLWKVRPH(,)6

V\VWHPV:DWHUSURRILQJZKHQ\RXQHHGLWEUHDWKDEOH

ZKHQ\RXGRQ¶WQHYHUWUDSSLQJPRLVWXUHLQ

7KHUPRVKLHOGSURGXFWVDUH

IOXLGDSSOLHGDQGGU\WRIRUPD

VHDPOHVVPRQROLWKLFPLFUR

VWUXFWXUHYLUWXDOO\HOLPLQDWLQJ

DLULQILOWUDWLRQDQGKHDWWUDQV

IHU6XUIDFHVFRDWHGDUHQRW

RQO\UHOXFWDQWWRFRQGXFWKHDW

EXWUHIUDFWDQGGLVVLSDWHKHDW

DZD\IURPWKHVXUIDFH7KLV

self as well as the substrate it covers, this makes 

Thermo-shield last and last. The first applications 

done back in the early 1980’s still look sharp, 

bright, and like new. 

7KHVSHFLDOSRO\PHUVZLOOUHPRYHWKH

Historic home tur

quarters of Manag

has been restore

shield Exterior. J

National Histo

(owner also has In

8QLYHUVLW\RI1HYDGD/D

YHU\HIIHFWLYH7+(50$/ PRLVWXUHWKDWKDVEXLOWXSLQZDOOVRYHUWLPHDQG /DERUDWRU\ WRWHVWQHZ

%/$1.(7EORFNVKHDWIURP GHPDQG7KH\FRQVWUXF

YDULRXVFRQGLWLRQV7KLVPDNHVWKHZDOOVPRUH DQG FRROLQJ V\VWHPDQ

HQWHULQJLQWKHVXPPHUEXW ILUVWWHFKQRORJ\ WHVWHG

DOVRKHOSVNHHSWKHKHDWLQGXULQJWKHZLQWHU HIILFLHQW ,WVKDUGWRVWD\ZDUPLQDZHWFRDWDQG 2QHFKDPEHUFR

WKHVDPHLVWUXHZLWK\RXUZDOOV FHUDPLFVVDYHGRQ

 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 17 of 75 PageID 31 

EXHIBIT D 
7KHUPRVKLHOG KDVEHHQZLGHO\WHVWHGLQ

DFFUHGLWHG/DERUDWRULHVXQGHUSULYDWHDQG

*RYHUQPHQWVSRQVRUVKLSDQGLQDFWXDOILHOG

WHVWV+HUHDUHVRPHRIWKRVHUHVXOWV

$PHULFD·V$670WHVWLQJ

$670' 7HQVLOH6WUHQJWKDQG

$670''HWHULRUDWLRQ%\+HDWLQJ,Q$LU

7KHVHWHVWUHVXOWVDFWXDOO\VKRZ 7KHUPRVKLHOG URRIFRDWLQJWR

JHWVWURQJHUDQGPRUHGXUDEOHZLWKDJLQJ

$670&6WHDG\6WDWH+HDW)OX[DQG

$670&7KHUPDO7UDQVPLVVLRQ3URSHUWLHV5RRI&RDWLQJ

$W0LO7KLFNQHVV

.9DOXH  59DOXH  


$670':DWHU9DSRU3HUPHDELOLW\DQG

$670( 3HUPHDELOLW\

%RWKWHVWVVKRZ 7KHUPRVKLHOG URRIFRDWZLWKSHUPUDWLQJ

WKLVLVH[FHOOHQW[DVPXFKDVRQHRIRXUPDLQ

FRPSHWLWRUVFODLPLQJWKHVDPHSURSHUW\

-DSDQHVH-,6 ,QGXVWULDO6WDQGDUGVWHVWLQJ

-,6$7HVW)RU:DWHUSURRILQJ

0D[LPXPWRSDVVWHVWLV&0UDWLQJ

7KHUPRVKLHOG ZDV&0WLPHVEHWWHUWKDQUHTXLUHG

-,6$5HVLVWDQFH7R:HDWKHU	&OLPDWH

'LGQRWFUDFNSHHORUGLVFRORUWRPLQLPXPVFDOHRI

7KHUPRVKLHOG PDLQWDLQHGDVFDOHUDWLQJ([FHOOHQW

EHVWRIDQ\SDLQWWHVWHGE\WKH-DSDQHVH1DWLRQDO7HVWLQJ

/DERUDWRULHV

86'HSWRI(QHUJ\WHVWVDW2DNULGJH1DWLRQDO/DEV/RQJWHUP

+HDW)OX[WHVWVRQURRILQJV\VWHPV

$IWHU\HDUWHVW 7KHUPRVKLHOG5RRI&RDWPDLQWDLQHG

UHIOHFWLYLW\DQGUHGXFHGKHDWIOX[E\

7KHEHVWSHUIRUPDQFHRIDQ\FRDWLQJWHVWHG

<RXFDQ·WJHWDEHWWHUUHIHUHQFHWKDQWKDW

+DXVHU/DERUDWRULHVWHVWFRPSDULVRQRIKHDWWUDQVIHUWKURXJK

7KHUPRVKLHOGYVRWKHUFRPPRQFRDWLQJV

7KHUPRVKLHOG ,QWHULRU &RDWZKLWH %78?+5VTIW

1RUPDOSDLQWZKLWH %78?+5VTIW

1RUPDOSDLQWDOORZVPRUHKHDWWRSDVVWKURXJK

7HVWVDWDFHUWLILHGODERQPHWDOVWRUDJHEXLOGLQJV

7KHUPRVKLHOG ([WHULRU&RDWLQJRXWSUHIRUPHGμRI)LEHUJODVV

LQWKHZDOOVDQGμLQFHLOLQJVLQNHHSLQJWKHLQWHULRUFRROHU

EXLOGLQJDOVRFRROHGRIIPXFKTXLFNHU

6W/RXLVFRPSDULVRQWHVWVRQKRXVHVRQHSDLQWHGZLWK

7KHUPRVKLHOG([WHULRU

7KH 7KHUPRVKLHOG KRXVHKDGHQHUJ\FRVWVWKDWZHUH

SHUFHQWOHVVVDYLQJVVXPPHUDQGZLQWHUWRWDOLQJ

SHU\HDU


1RWHVRPHVSHFLDOLVWVVD\WKH$670IRUPXODIRU59DOXHLQ

WKLVWHVW ́5 .μLVRYHUVLPSOLILHG

7KHUPRVKLHOG %HQHILWV

%HDXWLIXO)LQLVK  %ORFNV+HDW*DLQRU/RVV 

:DWHUSURRILQJ  9DULDEOH3HUPHDELOLW\ +XPLGLW\

&RQWURO  1RLVH$EVRUSWLRQ  1RQ7R[LFLQ/LTXLGRU

&XUHG)RUP  1R-RLQWVRU6HDPV  /RZ92&1R

+DUPIXO(PLVVLRQV  :DVKDEOH 6FUXEDEOH 

(OLPLQDWH&RQGHQVDWLRQ  (QYLURQPHQWDOO\)ULHQGO\ 

(DV\WR,QVXODWH([LVWLQJ%XLOGLQJV  )RRW7UDIILF

5HVLVWDQW  5HPDLQV)OH[LEOH  0ROG0LOGHZ)XQJXV

5HVLVWDQFH  6WDLQ5HVLVWDQW 

(QHUJ\6DYLQJV4XLFN52,  (DV\WR$SSO\  +LJK

)DGH5HVLVWDQFH  /RQJ/LIH3HUIRUPDQFH  &KHPLFDO

5HVLVWDQW  &UDFN%ULGJLQJ  ,PSURYHV$LU4XDOLW\ 

/RQJ)DFWRU\:DUUDQW\  8Q(IIHFWHGE\89([SRVXUH

 )LUH5HVLVWDQFH  %ORFNV6RXQG7UDQVPLVVLRQ 

&RPSHWLWLYH3ULFH 

2YHU<HDUVRI7HVWLQJDQG+LVWRU\

(;7(5,25:$//&2$7,17(5,25:$//&2$7

522)&2$77(;785(&2$7 7$1.6+,(/'

&/($5:22'$1''(&.&2$7

www.thermoshield.com 



5

2

&

.(76&,

(

1

&

(

)25+20(6%86,1(66

$*5,&8/785$/

$1',1'8675<

522)

THERMO-SHIELD products are the

original ceramic fortified coatings

developed in Colorado Springs, CO. in

the 1970’s. General Industries Corp.

worked closely with the 3-M company

who developed the correct ceramics,

and Rohm + Haas, who formulated the

unique polymers and pure acrylic

resins. These industry leaders worked

7 years to develop the “PERFECT”

coatings system. THERMO-SHIELD

products are the result! Proven here

and around the world, in some of

the harshest climates on Earth, 

2YHU<HDUVRI6HUYLFH

([KLELW'

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 18 of 75 PageID 32 
• 

JUST USING THERMO-SHIELD CAN 

SAVE YOU UP TO 50 % ON YOUR 

HEATING AND COOLING COSTS. THESE

COATINGS CAN PAY FOR THEMSELVES

MANY TIMES OVER DURING THEIR

GUARANTEED LIFE 

Author

ized

D

istr

ibutor:

Roof ... Roof ... Roof ...

Thermo-shield roof coat is much more than a simple surface

treatment, when applied according to manufacturers directions, it is a 10 year warranted roof system, at 10 years the

roof is reconditioned by applying 1\2 the amount of original

and the warrantee extends another 10

years. Able to water proof even flat,

problem roofs, prone to ponding of water.

It’s ease of application and low cost per

square foot make it the easy choice.

Thermo-shield Roof Coating has been applied on all kinds of

roofs beginning in 1980, with a success record that will give

peace of mind to customer and contractor alike.

The ceramic component, a key ingredient in all Thermo-shield

coatings not only protects whatever surface it is applied to,

but the ceramics also protect the coating itself, making

Thermo-shield the toughest, best performing, long lasting,

waterproofing solution available today. Testing done for the

Department of Energy, at the prestigious Oak Ridge National

Laboratories, in a 3 year study of leading reflective coatings,

and effect on heat gain shows Thermoshield out performs every other coating

tested. You can’t get a better reference 

than that .

No hot tar, no 1200 degree torch, no

solvents, glues, or noxious fumes. And no specialized training

is required. Thermo-shield applies as easy a coat of paint. The

system can be applied by anyone, home owners, contractors,

business and property owners, home owner associations, facilities management and maintenance departments, etc, etc.

And with the Comfort Level inspection and certification serUSE ON: VKLQJOHV ZRRGVKDNHVUROO URRILQJWLOHVODWHPHWDOWRUFKGRZQ FRPSRVLWHV ILEHUJODVVDVEHVWRV

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 19 of 75 PageID 33 

vice, everyone can receive the peace of PRGLILHGELWXPHQ
V(3'0 FRQFUHWHDQG

mind that comes with a full, 10 YEAR HYHQEXLOWXSWDU DQGJUDYHO 

manufacturers warranty. GREAT FOR AND THERMO-SHIELD PRODUCTS

RV’S , TRAILERS, AND BOATS! LAST 3 TO 5 TIMES LONGER

 ([KLELW'
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 20 of 75 PageID 34 

EXHIBIT E 
TIHIMI test ,rgu/ts actually shaw TIHlnno-shhlld ,_, t:aat/1111 to 

get.,,,,,,.., and more thlrabUI with t111i1111. 

(K-Va/1111 .0514) ( R -Va/1111 22 ) • 

Both tests show '11ulnno-shhlld ITH1' coat with 8.8 perm rating, 

this is ext:tlllent, 160 x .. much .. - or our main 

coav-tltors, ,:/aiming ttu, _,,,. prop,uty. 

MIIXlmum to paBB test,. 1.0 CM rating, 

Thtlrmo-shit1ld -• 0.1 CM, 10 times better than required 

Did -t t:l'llt:k, JHHI/, or d/Jlt:olor to minimum_,.,,, or #3, 

TIH!mno-rlJhitlld maintailHHI II #4. #5 Haiti, rating l!xrnllltlnt, 

NSI or any paint tested by tlHI Japant11111 National Tasting 

Laboratoritls. 

Attt,r 3 YfNIT t.111, ~hi Roor Coat maintaillfHI 

TO" ntllat:ttvlty and radut:#111 luMt flux by tlll". The,,,,_, performam:e of any ,:-ting ,_,_,, 

Y-t:1111'1 gal II better~-than that/ 

71NHmo-shlllld In,.,,,,,. c-~ wllNrl .0871 BTUIHR sq ff, 

Normal paint, wllHe 1.163 BTIIIHR sq ft. 

Normal paint allows 37'K, motw haat to paBB through. 

TIHlnno-shiehl Exttlrior C-ting out pnmH'IIHHI 2• 0, Fibergl._ 

In IIHI wall• and 3• 1n t:1111/,,,,. In kaaplng IIHI Interior t:oolar, 

IHl/hllng al•o t:00/ed off much qult:ker 

The Thenno-sh/eld house had tl"'"f/T costs that _,. 42 

p#ll't:#l#lt hus, saw,,,,. summer and winter, totaling $TIHJ.OO psr 

YfNIT 

THERMO

original 

developed 

1970's. 

worked clo

who deve

and Rohm 

unique p

resins. The

7 years t

coatings 

products 

and aro

the har

7KHUPRVKLHOG KDVEHHQZLGHO\WHVWHGLQ

DFFUHGLWHG/DERUDWRULHVXQGHUSULYDWHDQG

*RYHUQPHQWVSRQVRUVKLSDQGLQDFWXDOILHOG

WHVWV+HUHDUHVRPHRIWKRVHUHVXOWV

$PHULFD·V$670WHVWLQJ

$670' 7HQVLOH6WUHQJWKDQG

$670''HWHULRUDWLRQ%\+HDWLQJ,Q$LU

$670&6WHDG\6WDWH+HDW)OX[DQG

$670&7KHUPDO7UDQVPLVVLRQ3URSHUWLHV5RRI&RDWLQJ

$W0LO7KLFNQHVV

$670':DWHU9DSRU3HUPHDELOLW\DQG

$670( 3HUPHDELOLW\

-DSDQHVH-,6 ,QGXVWULDO6WDQGDUGVWHVWLQJ

-,6$7HVW)RU:DWHUSURRILQJ



-,6$5HVLVWDQFH7R:HDWKHU	&OLPDWH

86'HSWRI(QHUJ\WHVWVDW2DNULGJH1DWLRQDO/DEV/RQJWHUP

+HDW)OX[WHVWVRQURRILQJV\VWHPV

+DXVHU/DERUDWRULHV WHVWFRPSDULVRQRIKHDWWUDQVIHUWKURXJK

7KHUPRVKLHOGYVRWKHUFRPPRQFRDWLQJV

7HVWVDWDFHUWLILHG ODERQPHWDOVWRUDJHEXLOGLQJV

7KHUPRVKLHOG %HQHILWV

%HDXWLIXO)LQLVK  %ORFNV+HDW*DLQRU/RVV 

:DWHUSURRILQJ  9DULDEOH3HUPHDELOLW\ +XPLGLW\

&RQWURO  1RLVH$EVRUSWLRQ  1RQ7R[LFLQ/LTXLGRU

&XUHG)RUP  1R-RLQWVRU6HDPV  /RZ92&1R

+DUPIXO(PLVVLRQV  :DVKDEOH 6FUXEDEOH 

(OLPLQDWH&RQGHQVDWLRQ  (QYLURQPHQWDOO\ )ULHQGO\ 

(DV\WR,QVXODWH([LVWLQJ%XLOGLQJV  )RRW 7UDIILF

5HVLVWDQW  5HPDLQV)OH[LEOH  0ROG0LOGHZ )XQJXV

5HVLVWDQFH  6WDLQ5HVLVWDQW 

(QHUJ\6DYLQJV4XLFN52,  (DV\WR$SSO\  +LJK

)DGH5HVLVWDQFH  /RQJ/LIH3HUIRUPDQFH  &KHPLFDO

5HVLVWDQW  &UDFN%ULGJLQJ  ,PSURYHV$LU4XDOLW\ 

/RQJ)DFWRU\:DUUDQW\  8Q(IIHFWHGE\89([SR

VXUH  )LUH5HVLVWDQFH  %ORFNV6RXQG7UDQVPLVVLRQ 

&RPSHWLWLYH3ULFH 

2YHU<HDUVRI7HVWLQJDQG+LVWRU\

(;7(5,25:$//&2$7,17(5,25:$//&2$7

522)&2$77(;785(&2$7 7$1.6+,(/'

&/($5:22'$1''(&.&2$7

www.thermoshield.com 

5

2

&

.

)RU+

$

D

(

6W/RXLVFRPSDULVRQWHVWVRQKRXVHVRQHSDLQWHGZLWK

7KHUPRVKLHOG([WHULRU




1RWHVRPHVSHFLDOLVWVVD\WKH$670IRUPXODIRU59DOXHLQ

WKLVWHVW ́5 .μLVRYHUVLPSOLILHG



2YHU
USE ON: 

AND THERM

5 TIMES L

-XVW XVLQJ 7+(5026+,(/' ([WHULRU  $//7+(6

(;7(5,25,13/$&(2)3$,17&$1 &2

6$9(<288372 21<285

+($7,1* $1' &22/,1* &26767+,6 ,Q,QVXVXOODDWH5H

WH5H

THERMO-SHIELD Exterior Wall coatings will not crack, chip, peel, 

&2$7,1*:,//3$<)25,76(/)0$1< or fade. Even deep, rich colors will stay vibrant and bright, Blues 6RXQG 3UR

7,0(629(5'85,1*7+(

<($5*8$5$17(('/,)(

stay blue, Yellows stay yellow, Reds won’t fade and 

wash out, even in the harshest climates. The flexible, 

seamless, monolithic system will bond to almost any 

clean surface, filling cracks and gaps and also prevents new one from forming. It is 100% waterproof 

when you need it, yet absolutely breathable, never 

trapping moisture, mold, mildew, or dry rot in your walls. The 

unique nature of this remarkable coating will remove moisture 

that has built up in walls for years, preparing the wall for winter. 

You can’t stay warm in a wet coat, and the same is true with 

walls. 

THERMO-SHIELD is tintable to any color you can imagine, or it 

can be matched to your existing color. The longest lasting fade 

resistance available allows you to phase your project to suit your 

budget and not end up with a patch work look. The coatings are 

produced from 100% synthetic materials. This is important 

because paints and other coatings use fillers (a polite word for 

various clay, or silt, OTHERWISE DIRT) , organic materials that 

are readily broken down by nature. The vacuumed ceramic 

micro-spheres are the filler in THERMO-SHIELD. 

These ceramics make the coating an excellent insulator, 

performing like inches of other insulation. That’s just the 

+HDOWK\ +HDOWK\5

6

ceramics, factor in that 67((/ 25$/

Authorized Distributor: THERMO-SHIELD forms a seamless, +$5',%2$

beautiful, crack free surface, and then ),%5(*/$66

remains flexible, even in the harshest of 

conditions, this can dramatically re- 7,/(*/$669

duces air infiltration and can lead to 

savings of up to 50% 

of your heating and cooling costs. 

 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 23 of 75 PageID 37 

EXHIBIT F 
The•• t•Bt 19BU/ttl at:tually llhow ThlH7ffO-llhleld roo, t:01dlng 

to 11ft lltnlngtlr and man, dun,bhl with aging. 

{IC-Val,_ .0514) ( R-Valu• 22 ) • 

Botll tflllts Bhow .,,,.,,,,...,,,.,,, roo, coat with 8.8,,.,,,, rating, 

thi• isl t1Xt:41/18fft, 160 x - mllt:h .. - ,,,_,main 

competiton, claiming the ume property. 

Maximum to,-.. tflst i• 1.0 CM n,ting, 

Thenntl4hield -• 0.1 CM, 10 times better than required 

Did not ,::n,,:k, ,,_J, or d/Bt:Olor to minimum •cahl a, #3, 

Thermo-shield maintained a 1114 - #5 scale, n,ting Excellent, 

beBt a, any paint tested by the Japanese Nati-I Testing 

Labondode .. 

Alfer 3 year te.t, Thernl04hie/d ROM c-t maintained 

TO" n,f/e,:tlrlty and was •till reducing heat flux by 66"· 

The b8Bt performam:fl a, any i:oatlng tfl•trHI. 

Y- can't g,,t a INlttflr ~• than that/ 

Tlulrm-"18/d Interior Coat, llllhltll .0871 BTIIIHR sq If, 

Normal paint, white 1.163 BTUIHR Bil ff. 

Normal paint a/lo-"" more heat to,,... through. 

T,,,,,,,,_,,hlld Extrlrlor C-tlng out fHWO'mtld 2• 0, Flbwgl•­

in the -II• and 3• in ceilings in keeping the interior t:aaler, 

building al•o t:00/ed olT much quicker 

The T~ield house had energy coat. that_,., 42 

perr:-t ltl-, .. ring• -mmer and winter, totaling $760.00 per 

year 

THERMO

orlglnal 

developed 

19701s. 

worked clo

who devel

and Rohm 

unique p

resins. The

7 years t

coatings 

products 

and aro

the har

7KHUPRVKLHOG KDVEHHQZLGHO\WHVWHGLQ 

DFFUHGLWHG/DERUDWRULHVXQGHUSULYDWHDQG 

*RYHUQPHQWVSRQVRUVKLSDQGLQDFWXDOILHOG 

WHVWV+HUHDUHVRPHRIWKRVHUHVXOWV 

$PHULFD·V$670WHVWLQJ

$670' 7HQVLOH6WUHQJWKDQG

$670''HWHULRUDWLRQ%\+HDWLQJ,Q$LU

$670&6WHDG\6WDWH+HDW)OX[DQG

$670&7KHUPDO7UDQVPLVVLRQ3URSHUWLHV5RRI&RDWLQJ

$W0LO7KLFNQHVV

$670':DWHU9DSRU3HUPHDELOLW\DQG

$670( 3HUPHDELOLW\

-DSDQHVH-,6 ,QGXVWULDO6WDQGDUGVWHVWLQJ

-,6$7HVW)RU:DWHUSURRILQJ

 

-,6$5HVLVWDQFH7R:HDWKHU	&OLPDWH

86'HSWRI(QHUJ\WHVWVDW2DNULGJH1DWLRQDO/DEV/RQJWHUP

+HDW)OX[WHVWVRQURRILQJV\VWHPV

+DXVHU/DERUDWRULHVWHVWFRPSDULVRQRIKHDWWUDQVIHUWKURXJK

7KHUPRVKLHOGYVRWKHUFRPPRQFRDWLQJV

7HVWVDW DFHUWLILHGODERQPHWDOVWRUDJHEXLOGLQJV

7KHUPRVKLHOG %HQHILWV

%HDXWLIXO)LQLVK  %ORFNV+HDW*DLQRU/RVV 

:DWHUSURRILQJ  9DULDEOH3HUPHDELOLW\ +XPLGLW\

&RQWURO  1RLVH$EVRUSWLRQ  1RQ7R[LFLQ/LTXLGRU

&XUHG)RUP  1R-RLQWVRU6HDPV  /RZ92&1R

+DUPIXO(PLVVLRQV  :DVKDEOH 6FUXEDEOH 

(OLPLQDWH&RQGHQVDWLRQ  (QYLURQPHQWDOO\ )ULHQGO\ 

(DV\WR,QVXODWH([LVWLQJ%XLOGLQJV  )RRW 7UDIILF

5HVLVWDQW  5HPDLQV)OH[LEOH  0ROG0LOGHZ )XQJXV

5HVLVWDQFH  6WDLQ5HVLVWDQW 

(QHUJ\6DYLQJV4XLFN52,  (DV\WR$SSO\  +LJK

)DGH5HVLVWDQFH  /RQJ/LIH3HUIRUPDQFH  &KHPLFDO

5HVLVWDQW  &UDFN%ULGJLQJ  ,PSURYHV$LU4XDOLW\ 

/RQJ)DFWRU\:DUUDQW\  8Q(IIHFWHGE\89([SR

VXUH  )LUH5HVLVWDQFH  %ORFNV6RXQG7UDQVPLVVLRQ 

&RPSHWLWLYH3ULFH 

2YHU<HDUVRI7HVWLQJDQG+LVWRU\

(;7(5,25:$//&2$7,17(5,25:$//&2$7

522)&2$77(;785(&2$7

7$1.6+,(/'&/($5:22'$1''(&.&2$7

www.thermoshield.com 

5

2

&

.

)25+2

$*5

$1

,

6W/RXLVFRPSDULVRQWHVWVRQKRXVHVRQHSDLQWHGZLWK

7KHUPRVKLHOG([WHULRU

 2YHU


1RWHVRPHVSHFLDOLVWVVD\WKH$670IRUPXODIRU59DOXHLQWKLVWHVW ́5 .μLV

RYHUVLPSOLILHG

 
86,1*

7+(5026+,(/' Interior Interiors . . . s . . . ,QIUDUHG,PDJLQJ VKRZVKHDWIURPKDQG

,17(5,25,13/$&(2)3$,17 7+(5026+,(/' Interior Wall Coatings provide a beautiful UDGLDWLQJEDFNLQWR 7KHUPRVKLHOG URRPZKLOHKHDWMXVW &$1

6$9(<28%,* 21<285 “satin-like” finish that changes tones as the light changes. The

+($7,1* $1' &22/,1* &26767+(6(

&2$7,1*6&$13$<)257+(06(/9(6

0$1<7,0(6'85,1*7+(



 

<($5*8$5$17(('/,)( 

Authorized Distributor:

ceramics reflective ability will brighten even a dark hallway ,

using the same existing light. Lab tests show 37% less heat

loss through THERMO-SHIELD white interior, compared to

white paint, and that’s just the ceramics at work! Factor in a

seamless, monolithic, crack free ceiling and wall system and

air infiltration is dramatically reduced! This can lead to savings of up to 50% on heating and cooling costs! 

7+(5026+,(/' products are totally breathable, never trapping moisture, mold, or mildew in your walls. In fact the special

polymers and resins in the coatings will take excess moisture

from the from the substrate, preparing the wall for winter,

making it more efficient, it also helps keep humidity levels at

optimum conditions. No toxins, emissions, or fumes, dirt and

dust levels are significantly reduced.

Heated molecules strike the ceramics and bounce away, staying in constant motion. Molecules in motion cause a phenomenon called “ mean radiant heat “, which is like standing in

the sun or standing in the shade. The temperature will be the

same but feels much warmer in the sun because of the

molecules in motion striking the skin. This happens in a

THERMO-SHIELD room, customers tell us they “set their thermostats 4-6 degrees cooler and experience the same CO

MFORT LEVEL! Durable, scrubable, stain resistant, easy to clean.

Class A fire resistance rated.

The ceramics also improve

sound quality, muffling echoes,

improving acoustics and

reducing sound transmission. 



GLVDSSHDUVLQWRZDOOZLWKRUGLQDU\ SDLQWCase 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 25 of 75 PageID 39 86(21DQ\LQWHULRUZDOORUFHLOLQJ

VXUIDFH

([KLELW)
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 26 of 75 PageID 40 

EXHIBIT G 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 27 of 75 PageID 41 

Thermoshield Insulating Value 

Radiant Barrier 

A radiation control coating is analogous to a radiant barrier. Its resistance 

to heat flow or “R” value increased tremendously with the increase in the 

reflectivity of the surface. This ultra-thin barrier and its ability to reflect the 

heat from its surface was later known as “Radiant Barrier”. 

ASHRAE is aware of the unique property of the thin film of still air on the surface 

of a radiant barrier, where as the radiant barrier itself could be metallic and a 

heat conductor. But as long as there is no physical contact or “conduction” the 

radiant barrier can increase the insulating value “R” of the still air against it. 

Most ceiling and wall insulations are now sold with radiant barrier surfaces to 

take advantage of this phenomenon. 

+LJKO\UHÁHFWLYHVXUIDFHOLNHDEULJKWDOXPLQLXP

IRLOFDQLQFUHDVHWKHUPDOUHVLVWDQFHRU ́5μYDOXH

LQDQHQFORVHGVSDFHXSWRIRXUWLPHVDV

FRPSDUHGWRDQRQUHÁHFWLYHVXEVWUDWH

7KLFNQHVVLVQRWDIDFWRULQWKHLQFUHDVHRIWKH

LQVXODWLQJYDOXH

Ashrae handbook of Fundamental (1972) 

Chapter 20, P. 357 - “Surface Conductances and Resistances for Air” 

These “R” values were derived from controlled ideal laboratory conditions 

utilising ASTM Standard C236, Guarded hot box or the ASTM Standard C976, 

Calibrated hot box procedures. 

Whereas Radiant Barrier is used in enclosed ceiling space and walls to 

improve its overall insulation value, a Radiation Control Coating is used on 

the surface to re-radiate or reflect and dissipate radiant heat. 

A Radiation Control Coating must have the following re-radiation properties to 

be effective as an exterior radiant barrier: 

1. Low solar absorbance ( will absorb less solar energy ) 

2. High emittance value ( will radiate more heat away from surface ) 

3. High convection coefficient ( will convect more heat to the ambient air as 

surface temperature increases ) 

4. Very low thermal conductivity ( “R” value reciprocal ) 

40 Singapore Institute of Standards 

and Industrial Research 

30 

TSL Professional Services 

20 

TSL Professional Services 

10 

Insulation Value Equivalent 

Material Testing facilities, TRW and Singapore’s SISIR are both world renown 

in their standard of performance. We have relied heavily on their test results in 

evaluating the thermo physical properties of ceramic coatings. 

The Department of the US Air force performed an independent test of their 

own for their interest in using the coating in lieu of insulation on expansive 

aircraft hangar buildings. Lowering down the surface skin temperature of 

the metal roofing will drastically reduce thermal expansion at peak afternoon 

temperature. Reducing thermal shock or roof movement will reduce water 

leaks and corrosion. 

This is evident in large metal roofs coated with ceramic coating where water 

leaks had stopped and a much cooler inside temperature is experienced. 

The Christian Testing Lab is the closest test in determining the actual R-value 

equivalent of the ceramic coating. SISIR K-value will give us an R-value of 

40 per 2.54cm. But our coating does not function as an insulation alone as 

exhibited in the TRW tests. Having a similar property as a radiant barrier, the 

thickness is of minor consequence. 

The surface thermo physical characteristic plays a major role in its ability to 

provide high reflectivity and drastically reduces inward radiation of exterior 

heat. The unique property of ceramic coatings has proved in an actual 

controlled test that it is equivalent to 10.15cm thick of Styrofoam (extruded) 

insulation of R-20 value. 

Ceramic Coating True R-Value 

Acting as Pure Insulation = R-40 per inch ( see figure 1 ) 

Incorporating three independent test results produced an almost linear line 

proving that this generated curve will give us an accurate R-value of the 

Ceramic Coating. 

However, we must remember that if we use this product as a Radiation 

Control Coating, its other thermo physical properties will come into play and 

will give a much higher R-value equivalent. 

Metric conversions: For R-values to metric format of R-value, multiply 

as per following example. 

R-value 40 x 0.1761 = R-value 7.044 

Referring to the above R-value of 40 per inch as per test ASTM C518-85 of the 

Singapore institute of Standards and Industrial Research, one must take into 

consideration that this value reflects only a comparison of pure insulation and 

is not truly representative of the coating’s ability as referred to in the Results 

Summary under point number 3 in this document. 

Our ceramic coating’s effective efficient capability to re-radiate, i.e. reflect 

solar spectrum energy, e.g. UV, Visible, Near infra-red and Far Infra-red wave 

lengths will increase the usable R-value with which to calculate heat loads for 

all buildings to R-20 

0.1” 0.25” 0.50” 0.75” 1.00” 

Last updated 28/03/2013 

 ([KLELW*
Ill 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 28 of 75 PageID 42 

Thermoshield Insulating Value contued 

Radiation Control Thermal Test I 

TRW Space and Technology 

Engineering and Test Division 

One Space Park, Redondo Beach CA, 90278 

Test Performed 

Solar Absorbance And Emittance Radiation Control Ceramic coating 

samples. July 1986 

Result Summary 

Low solar absorbance as (0 .18 - 0.20) 

comparable to spacecraft coating. 

High emittance value eb (0 .90 - 0.97). 

High convection coefficient h 

(1.2 @ 32°C ambient air) 

(1.26 @ 44°C ambient air) 

Radiation Control Thermal Test II 

Department of the Airforce 

15th Air Base Wing ( PACAF ) 

Hickam Air Force Base Hawaii, 96853-5000 

Test Radiation Control 

Ceramic coating of Bldg. 1209 

Hickham AFB, Hawaii 96853 April 1997 

Result Summary 

Warehouse temp. before ceramic coating = 38°C average peak 

Inside skin temp. of metal roof surface = 46°C 

Warehouse temp. after ceramic coating = 30°C (decrease of 8°C) 

Inside skin temp. of metal roof surface = 34°C (decrease of 12°C) 

The conclusion of the test proved that the ceramic coating provides 

a highly heat reflective insulation that decreases the inward radiation 

of exterior heat. The coating is unquestionably an effective and cost 

efficient way to insulate buildings. 

Radiation Control Thermal Test III 

Christina Test Laboratories Inc 

2625 Lower Wetumpka Road 

Montgomery, Alabama, 36110 

Thermal Performance Tests 

of Two Similar Structures 

( Similar to ASTM C236 ) July 1978 

Result Summary 

Two test buildings of 183m x 2.44m x 2.35m high were constructed 

with all walls fully insulated. After determining that both buildings 

have the same thermal characteristic, one was coated with ceramic 

coating on the bare metal roof. Hourly temperatures were taken on both 

buildings and underside Styrofoam roof insulation was added to the 

non-coated roof until the hourly inside room temperature equalised. 

It required a total of 10.16cm thickness of the 

( extruded ) Styrofoam insulation extruded before the room temperature 

was brought down to equal the building with the ceramic coating. 

Therefore, with Styrofoam R-Value of 5, the equivalent value 

of 20 equals the thermal insulating performance of two coats of ceramic 

coating @ approx. 381 micron DFT. 

Last updated 28/03/2013 

Radiation Control Thermal Test VI 

Singapore Institute of Standards & Industrial Research 

Ref. No. GC/12/3/1713SISIR/FP 

July, 1990 

ASTM C518-85 Thermal 

Conductivity Test on Radiation 

Control ceramic coating. 

Result Summary 

Two pieces of concrete slabs, each on nominal size of 300 x 300 x 

30mm thick, one with a thin coat of ( approx. 0.5mm ) of ceramic 

coating on the surface of the slab. 

The ASTM C518-85 “Steady-State Thermal Transmission Properties by 

means of the heat Flow Meter” was performed on both specimen. 

Using standard fibreglass insulation for flow meter calibration thermal 

conductivity reading on 25.4mm thickness was 0.03556@/m Deg K at 

mean temperature of 31°C. 

The K-value of the 0.5mm ceramic coating was 0.00345W/m Deg K or 

theoretically ( 10 ) ten times better than fibreglass. 

Combining the very low thermal conductivity of the ceramic coat, and 

its low solar absorbance, complemented by its high emittance value and 

high convection coefficient has made Radiation Control Coatings a very 

simple, efficient and cost effective way to insulate buildings. 

 ([KLELW*
THERM . HIEL~ 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 29 of 75 PageID 43 

Thermoshield Insulating Value contued 

The Effects of Colour on Temperature 

Tests were conducted to determine the effect of colours on the temperature of a roof system. Coatings were 

applied over 2” of polyurethane foam. Small thermo probes were embedded in or under the coating material. 

The following graph shows the difference between coloured coatings and other roofing materials when exposed 

to sunlight. 

Temperatures of Coatings and Other Materials in Sunlight 

90oC These numbers were measured in north central 

Texas with an ambient temperature of 32°C. Higher 

altitudes or ambient temperatures above 32°C 80 

will result in even hotter surface temperatures 

than those measured. From the graph it may be 

seen that even light coloured coatings raise the 70 

temperature somewhat. Radiation control coatings 

reflect sunlight very well. Unfortunately, aluminium 

filled coatings by contrast are good absorbers of 60 

solar energy. 

Aluminium coatings and galvanised steel both 50 

exceed 77°C while black single ply exceeds 88°C. 

Radiation control coatings are obviously more 

productive in repelling extreme heat. 40 

30 

Radiation Tar and Gravel Galvanized Steel Aluminum Coating Black Single Ply Control Coating 

Thermoshield re-radiates heat off a substrate 

and reflects damaging ultraviolet light. 

The ceramic thermal barrier properties of Thermoshield are due 

to millions of hollow micro-ceramic beads that cluster together 

and create dead air space. The success of Thermoshield is due to 

its ability to counter ‘radiant heat’ transfer. Thermoshield remains 

effective when it becomes tarnished and addresses the full solar 

spectrum. 

Thermoshield is unique as it has the ability to offer year round 

energy savings due to its high insulation properties. 

A University of Melbourne study proved that Thermoshield has 

an additional benefit unseen in other products. This benefit is the 

ability of the product to improve the retention of heat within a 

building during colder weather. 

Thermoshield Hollow Ceramic Beads Substrate 

Last updated 28/03/2013 

 ([KLELW*
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 30 of 75 PageID 44 

EXHIBIT H 
ROOF COATINGS SPECIFICATIONS

DESCRIPTION * * * THERMO-SHIELD® ROOF COATING IS A HIGHLY EFFICIENT ENERGY-SAVING FLEXIBLE COATING.THERMO-SHIELD® ROOF COATING IS A WATER-BASED, PURE ACRYLIC RESIN SYSTEM FILLED WITH HOLLOW SODIUM BOROSILICATE CERAMIC MICROSPHERES. EACH MICROSPHERE ACTS AS A SEALED CELL AND THE ENTIRE MASTIC ACTS AS ATHERMALLY EFFICIENT BLANKET COVERING THE PROTECTED STRUCTURE. THERMO-SHIELD® ROOF COATING IS HIGHLYREFLECTIVE AND DISPLAYS EXCELLENT DIRT PICK-UP RESISTANCE. IT ALSO RETAINS ITS FLEXIBILITY AT LOW TEMPERATURESTYPICAL USES* * * PRIMARILY USED AS A ROOF COATING, IT MAY BE UTILIZED WHEREVER A WEATHER RESISTANT, FLEXIBLE, MEMBRANE LIKE COATING IS REQUIREDPRIMERS*** NO PRIMER IS USUALLY REQUIRED. FOLLOW INSTRUCTIONS FOR PROPERAPPLICATION REGARDING WARRANTED SYSTEMS ON BITUMEN ROOFS. OUR FLEX-TAC BARRIER & BONDING COAT IS REQUIRED TO OBTAIN GOOD ADHESION BETWEEEEN THE OIL BASED SUBSTRATE AND OUR WATER BASED ROOF COATING.FLEX-TAC IS USUALLY USED WITH POL-E-FORCE REINFORCING FABRIC. SEE APPLICATIONS INSTRUCTIONS FOR DETAILS.RUSTY METAL WILL REQUIRE A RUST INHIBITOR AND A METAL PRIMERSURFACE PREPARATION*** ALL SURFACES MUST BE CLEAN AND FREE FROM DUST, DIRT, OIL AND GREASE. MINIMALLY,SURFACES SHOULD BE CLEANED WITH A POWER WASHER PRIOR TO COATING PROVIDING THIS WILL NOT DAMAGE THEROOF OR CAUSE LEAKINGCOLOR* * * TINTING MAY BE ACHIEVED WITH THERMO-SHIELD® ROOF COATINGS BY THE ADDITION OF UNIVERSAL COLORANTS. DARKER COLORS WILL GIVE A CORRESPONDINGLY LOWER REFLECTIVITY TO THE COATING SYSTEMSPERCENT NONVOLATILE*** 51.67% BY VOLUME / 51.14% BY WEIGHTTHEORETICAL COVERAGE*** 33.3 SQUARE FEET PER GALLON AT 27 MIL DRY FILM THICKNESS AND NO LOSS (TO BE APPLIEDIN 2 OR MORE COATS). (27 MIL = 686 MICRON)DRYING TIME TO SET: 45 MINUTES TO RE-COAT: 12 HOURS TO THROUGH: 12HOURS(AT 75 DEG. FAHRENHEIT AND 50% RELATIVE HUMIDITY.)AFTER 45 MINUTES THERMO-SHIELD® ROOF COATING HAS SURFACE SET TO THE POINT WHERE IT IS NO LONGER SUSCEPTIBLE TO AIRBORNE DUST AND WILL NOT RUN IN THE PRESENCE OF INCREASED HUMIDITY (AT 75 DEG. F. AND 50% RELATIVE HUMIDITY.) DO NOT APPLY THERMO-SHIELD® COATING IF PRECIPITATION IS IMMINENT OR IS LIKELY TO OCCUR BEFORE THERMO-SHIELD® ROOF COATING IS DRIED THROUGH, OR IF TEMPERATURE IS EXPECTED TO DROP BELOW 40 DEG.FAHRENHEIT.FLEXI BI LITY* * * WILL PASS 180 DEG BEND AT 34 DEG F AFTER 6-MONTH EXPOSUREADHESION * * * EXCELLENT ADHESION TO A WIDE VARIETY OF SUBSTRATES: WOOD, URETHANE FOAM, GALVANIZEDSTEEL, ALUMINUM, ASPHALT ROOF SHINGLES, CONCRETE, ASBESTOS AND OTHERS.ACCELERATED WEATHERING*** ASTM G-53, Q-UV, 3000+ HOURS. NO EVIDENCE OF CHALKING, DELIMITATION OR LOSS OFFLEXIBILITY.RESISTANCE TO WATER PONDING*** THERMO-SHIELD® ROOF COATING DISPLAYS EXCELLENT RESISTANCE TO PONDINGWATER. THIS IS A RESULT OF CAREFUL BALANCING OF THE FOLLOWING PROPERTIES:PASSAGE OF BULK WATER AT 50 HOURS 40-55 mglm2 PERMEABILITY (ASTM E-96-80) 8.8% PERMSFILM SWELLNG (AT EQUILIBRIUM) 10-17%

7HQVLOH6WUHQJWKDW(ORQJDWLRQ .JFP

6WURQJDQG(ODVWLF$670' 7HQVLOH6WUHQJWKDW%UHDN .JFP

8OWLPDWH(ORQJDWLRQDW%UHDN 

%UHDWKLQJWUDSSHGZDWHUYDSRU$670 3HUPHDELOLW\ZDWHUYDSRUWUDQVPLVVLRQ JUDLQVPKRXU 

*RRGUHVLVWDQFHWRORQJWHUPSRQGLQJ 1RWPRUHWKDQPJP KRXUV RIZDWHU

1RFKDONLQJGHODPLQDWLQJRUORVVRI 895HVLVWDQFH$670* 489KRXUV IOH[LELOLW\

5HVLVWDQFHWR2]RQHVXUIDFHFUDFNLQJ 1RVLJQRIIDLOXUH $670&KHPLFDO5HVLVWDQFH$670WRKRXUVSRWWHVWVRQVDOWVROXWLRQVDFLGV SHWUROHXPSURGXFWVDQGRWKHUKDUVK 1RKDUPIXOHIIHFW FKHPLFDOV FKHPLFDOV

6RODU5HIOHFWDQFH$670( 6RODUS5HIOHFWDQFHZKLWHFRORU 

6RODU(PLVVLYLW\ ,QIUDUHG 

)LUH5HVLVWDQFH8/	$670( &ODVV$UDWLQJ7KHUPDO&RQGXFWLYLW\$670(  .

5HGXFHGVXPPHUKHDWIOX[WKURXJK

2DNULGJH1DWLRQDO/DERUDWRULHV \HDUWHVWLQJSURJUDP LQVXODWHGELWXPHQSDQHOE\WKHEHVW

RXWRISURGXFWVWHVWHG

Authorized Distributor:



Fluid Applied Ceramics

Roof System 

Date: 00/00/00 

Rocket Science For Home, Business,

Industry And Agriculture.

• Tremendous Energy Savings * A Coating That Insulates• Long Lasting Performance * 10-20 Year Factory Warranty

• Promotes A Healthy Environment * Always Low VOC• Proven Results ... Impressive ROI * In Service For 25 Years

• Made In The USA * Energy Star Compliant 

([KLELW+

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 31 of 75 PageID 45 
Ceramics are a well known non-conductor of heat, as shown in this

remarkable picture where the ceramic cube glows from an interior

temperature of 2200 degrees f, yet can be safely held by a bare hand.

Space Shuttle science use’s a ceramic composite tile system

that is over 90% void. These voids contain a complete 

vacuum. In Physics Law it states that nothing can move 

by conduction through a vacuum. In the late 1970’s 

General Industries Corp, a specialty chemical company, along with Rohm and

Haas, who developed the special resins and polymers and the 3-M Company, who developed

a practical way to use this Space Shuttle technology here on Earth in the form of vacuumed

ceramic micro-spheres (less than 100 microns). These spheres are 60% void and in that void

there is a complete vacuum. This picture shows just a thin layer of the vacuum ceramic micro- spheres protecting a hand from the incredible heat of this propane

torch. This heat blocking protection can now be applied in a practical

long lasting system to just about any substrate or surface, as a complete 

stand alone roof system, top coat, or repair.

Thermo-shield Fluid Applied Ceramic Roof System

contains over 50% by volume of these special

vacuum ceramic micro-spheres.

Thermo-shield formula’s are complex combinations of Acrylics, Elastomerics, Mastics,

Weather-proofers, Dispensers, Reflector Materials, Mildew Inhibitors, Fungicides, Bonding Resins, Anti-shrink Materials, and other Materials Heretofore Unavailable. The resins are made up

of very complex polymers that can hold onto huge amounts of solid particles and still have

great adhesion. Normal resins loose much of their adhesion as solids are added. We add huge

amounts of our vacuum ceramic micro-spheres, which should float to the surface, but are held

in fluid suspension by the polymers. When applied, and the coating has cured, (water evaporates) these micro-spheres pack closely together forming a very effective heat blocking microstructure. Special polymers also allow the substrate to breath. Under wet conditions they

swell allowing no moisture to penetrate, but when dry, the substrate is allowed to vent off any

trapped or built up moisture with an impressive 8.8 perm rating. Thermo-shield Roof forms a

solidly bonded, seam free, highly flexible system that has an effective use range of

–50 degrees f to +400 degrees f .

Hemispherical Spectral Reflectance testing shows excellent reflectivity in the spectrums that account for heat transfer by radiation: 88% in the Visible Light spectrum, and 84% in the Infrared Light (hot) spectrum. It also directly reflects 16% of the harmful UV radiation. Independent Lab tests show UV exposure actually makes the coating strongerand more flexible. This high overall reflectance qualifies Thermo-shield Roof System for Energy Star

status. As a matter of fact, Thermo-shield Roof is a charter memberof the Energy Star program. In testing performed at the Dept. of Energy’s, Oakridge National Laboratory along with the National Roof Coating Manufacturers Association, over 25 leading white and silver coatings where exposed to

real world weathering for 3 years. The Oakridge scientists determined that aproducts reflectivity can drop as much as 50% during this relatively short time.They also calculated that, after the 3 years, reflectivity levels will remain the same

until failure of the coating system. Thermo-shield Roof maintains70% reflectance, the best performance of any producttested, beating the next closest competitor by14%.

Thermo-shield’s high emmitance means that 90% of theradiation not directly reflected is emitted back into the

atmosphere as infrared energy, not heat in roof. This

leaves less than 2% radiant energy to be absorbed as heat. 

Thermo-shield Roof also has a very low conductivity value. To put it in perspective, let’s look at the

conductivity or K-value of other common building materials.

(Taken from the 2005 ASHRAE Standards Handbook)

Clay Fired Brick 2.50-10.20,....Stucco 9.70, ....Hardwood, Oak 1.25, Wafer Board 0.63,... 

Fiberboard Acoustical Tile 0.42, ...Loose Fill Cellulose 0.27...

Thermo-shield Roof has a K Value of 0.05

This radiant barrier technology can even cut heating costs during cold weather, keeping more heat in your

home, building, or facility. 

As a stand alone Roof

On OSB Wafer Board... 

... On Rigid Fiberboard

Insulation/Taper System

...On Concrete. ..

As a top coat or repair over an existing system

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 

Steel,Wood, Galvanized, Shingles,Aluminum, EPDM, Composition,Tile,Modified Bitumen, Fiberglass, Urethane Foam, Canvas, Stone, Etc, Etc.

Page 32 of 75 PageID 46 At 33.3 sq. ft. per gallon coverage (27 mils DFT) Thermo-shield Roof is guaranteed not to leak, even with ponding water, 100% for a full 10 years. Thermo-shield is being used in fountains and water features for a remarkable non-toxic waterproof liner. After !0 years apply 1/2 the amount of original application and qualify for extended 10 year factory warrantee. LOW VOC, Non-Toxic in liquid or cured state. No noxious fumes. Water based, easy clean up. Incredible Fire Resistance with Type 1 Rating. UL Class A Type 1 Fire Resistance Rating is also available. Completely Washable. Resists many harsh chemicals including oils, gasoline and acids.

Energy Star Charter Member. Qualifies for LEED points. Qualifies for State, Local, and Utility rebates.

Vacuum Ceramic Microspheres block sound transfer and add improved acoustics.

HEAT BLOCKING PERFORMANCE EQUIVILENT TO AN R-22 !

Thermo-shield Roof can be tinted to any color you choose!  ([KLELW+
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 33 of 75 PageID 47 

EXHIBIT I 
WATER-BASED

NON-HAZARDOUS 

COLOR: THERMO-SHIELD® Roof-Coat is available in manycolors.SURFACE PREPARATION: 5HPRYHDOOORRVHPDWHULDOV6XUIDFHVPXVWEHFOHDQGU\DQGIUHHRIGLUWZD[JUHDVHORRVHRUSHHOLQJSDLQWDQGRWKHUIRUHLJQPDWHULDO5HSDLUFUDFNVDQGRWKHUKROHVZLWKVSDFNOLQJFRPSRXQG6SRWSULPHDOOSDWFKLQJZRUNAPPLICATION: $SSO\E\VSUD\RUUROOHU'RQRWDSSO\DWWHPSHUDWXUHVEHORZ)&6WLUULQJPD\EHUHTXLUHGCOVERAGE0LQLPXPJDOORQVVTXDUHIHHW/LWHUV

6TXDUH0HWHUIRU)ODW5RRIVDSSOLHGLQFRDWVZLWKDWRWDOGU\

ILOPWKLFNQHVVRIPLOOVPLFURQV0LQLPXPJDOORQV

VTXDUHIHHW/LWHUV6TXDUH0HWHUIRU6ORSHG5RRIVDSSOLHGLQ

FRDWVZLWKDWRWDOGU\ILOPWKLFNQHVVRIPLOOVPLFURQV

CLEAN-UP: &OHDQDOODSSOLFDWLRQHTXLSPHQWZLWKZDUPVRDSDQGZDWHU

&867200,; &2/256 0$< 127 '5< 72 $1 (;$&7 0$7&+ 72 7+(

6$03/(&+,3&+(&.7+(&2/25%()25(3$,17,1*72'(7(50,1(,),7,6<285&+2,&(%<$33/<,1*7+(3$,1772$60$//7(67$5($

:$51,1* ,I\RXVFUDSHVDQGRUUHPRYHROGSDLQW\RXPD\UHOHDVHOHDGGXVW LEAD IS TOXIC. EXPOSURE TO LEAD DUST CAN CAUSE SERIOUS ILLNESS,

SUCH AS BRAIN DAMAGE, ESPECIALLY IN CHILDREN. PREGNANT WOMEN SHOULDALSO AVOID EXPOSURE. :HDU DSSURYHG UHVSLUDWRUWRFRQWUROOHDGH[SRVXUH &OHDQXS

FDUHIXOO\ ZLWK D YDFXXP DQG D ZHW PRS 8VH RQO\ ZLWK DGHTXDWH YHQWLODWLRQ 7R DYRLG

RYHUH[SRVXUHRSHQZLQGRZV DQGGRRUVRUXVHRWKHUPHDQV WRHQVXUHIUHVKDLU

HQWU\ GXULQJ DSSOLFDWLRQ DQG GU\LQJ ,I \RX H[SHULHQFH H\H ZDWHULQJ

KHDGDFKHVRUGL]]LQHVV LQFUHDVH IUHVKDLURUZHDUUHVSLUDWRU\ SURWHFWLRQRU

OHDYHWKH DUHD$YRLG FRQWDFWZLWK H\HV DQGVNLQ:DVKKDQGV DIWHUXVLQJ.HHS FRQWDLQHU

FORVHG ZKHQ QRW LQ XVH ),567 $,' ,Q FDVH RI H\H FRQWDFW IOXVK WKRURXJKO\ ZLWK ODUJH

DPRXQWV RI ZDWHU *HW PHGLFDO DWWHQWLRQ LI LUULWDWLRQ SHUVLVWV ,I VZDOORZHG JHW PHGLFDO

DWWHQWLRQLPPHGLDWHO\

Do not take internally. KEEP OUT OF REACH OF CHILDREN.DO NOT FREEZE. Close container after each use.

0$18)$&785('%<

6307+(5026+,(/',1&

1DSOHV)ORULGD86$

7HO)D[

ZZZWKHUPRVKLHOGFRP

7KLVSURGXFWFRQWDLQVOHVVWKDQ

*UDPV/LWHU92&

ROOF COAT

5962

White 

5 Gallons (US) 19 LITERS 

Product Warranty 5 Year Extendable Limited Warranty

(Extendable to 10 or 15 Years) 

SPM THERMO-SHIELD® (Hereinafter called SPM) warrants that the THERMO-SHIELD®ROOFING PRODUCTS, when properly applied, will retain their water tight integrity from the date of validation on the face thereof for a period of 5 years. This Extendable Limited Warranty maybe extended for up to 15 years from the date of validation by proper re-application of the ROOF 

Coat at 5 year intervals commencing with the validation date. SPM SHALL HAVE NOOBLIGATIONS UNDER THIS Extendable Limited Warranty and such shall be of no force of effect, 

unless and until validated by an SPM distributor after the THERMO-SHIELD® ROOF PRODUCTS

are applied. Such validation shall be evidenced by a document, signed and dated by an authorized representative of SPM THERMO-SHIELD®. This Extendable Limited Warranty 

does not apply to failure due to improper application or reapplication. Proper application or reapplication includes, but is not limited to, the requirement that the THERMO-SHIELD® 

ROOFING PRODUCTS be applied (a) according to the SPM Application Manual; (b) By an SPM

Authorized Representation; (c) To a clean, dry, sound surface. Dirt or other substances foundon the back side of failed product shall be deemed conclusive as to the fact that the THERMOSHIELD® ROOFING PRODUCTS were improperly applied to an unsound or unsuitable surface,

free from cracking, chipping or peeling paint that is compatible to THERMO-SHIELD® ROOF

COATINGS. It shall be the responsibility of the applicator to do a test patch to determine that the COATINGS are compatible. Dirt, old paint, petroleum products or other substances found on

the back side of failed product shall be deemed conclusive as to the fact that the THERMOSHIELD® ROOF COATINGS were improperly applied to an unsound or unsuitable surface.Applications during inclement weather, including, but not limited to precipitation, fog, dew,

wet surfaces, cold temperatures, application in areas of ponding water, or applying additional coats before the previous coat or coats are thoroughly dry will be considered improperapplication. The obligation of SPM under this Extendible Limited Warranty shall be limited to the 

replacement (FOB factory) of that portion of the material which fails to retain its integrity. ThisWarranty applies to the ROOFING PRODUCTS material only. This shall be the exclusive remedy

and SPM’s sole liability on contract or under this Extendible Limited Warranty or otherwise for anyTHERMO-SHIELD® ROOFING PRODUCTS. In no event will SPM be liable for any lost profits or 

other consequential damage from any cause whatsoever, even if such damages were foreseeable.

SPM shall not be liable for any loss resulting from natural disasters, including, but not limited to, lightning, hurricanes, tornadoes, hail, and earthquakes, any acts of negligence, accidents, or misuse with respect to the THERMO-SHIELD® ROOFING PRODUCTS or to the surface to which 

such products are applied, including but not limited to vandalism, civil disobedience or acts of waror negligence of owner or owner’s agents or contractors, any alterations or modifications to the

roof not approved by SPM in writing, or any failure in the structure to which the roofing system is attached. THIS WARRANTY IS EXPRESSLY IN LIEU OF ANY AND ALL

OTHER WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING THE IMPLIEDWARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR

PURPOSE AND, OR LIABILITIES ON THE PART OF SPM OF ANY NATURE WHATSOEVER. SPM NEITHER ASSUMES NOR AUTHORIZES ANYONE TOASSUME FOR IT ANY OBLIGATIONS OR LIABILITIES NOT EXPRESSLYSTATED HEREIN. THIS EXTENDIBLE LIMITED WARRANTY IS MADE 

ONLY TO THE ORIGINAL PURCHASER OF THE THERMOSHIELD®ROOFING PRODUCTS AND CANNOT BE EXTENDED TO ANY OTHER ENTITY. PURCHASERS OF CONSUMER PRODUCTS SHOULD NOTE THAT SOME STATES DO NOT ALLOW FOR THE EXCLUSION OFCONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES OR THE LIMITATIONS THE DURATION OF IMPLIED WARRANTIES, SO THE ABOVE EXCLUSION AND LIMITATIONSMAY NOT BE APPLICABLE. THIS WARRANTY GIVES THE ORIGINALPURCHASER SPECIFIC LEGAL RIGHTS AND THE PURCHASER MAY ALSOHAVE OTHER RIGHTS WHICH MAY VARY FROM STATE TO STATE. ANYADDITIONAL WARRANTY GIVEN BY THE APPLICATOR/DEALER IS SOLELYTHE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE PERSON DOING THE WORK. 

([KLELW,

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 34 of 75 PageID 48 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 35 of 75 PageID 49 

EXHIBIT J 
WATER-BASED 

NON-HAZARDOUS

COLOR: THERMO-SHIELD® ([WHULRULVDYDLODEOHLQPDQ\

FRORUV

SURFACE PREPARATION: 5HPRYH DOO ORRVH PDWHULDOV6XUIDFHVPXVWEHFOHDQGU\DQGIUHHRIGLUWZD[JUHDVHORRVHRU SHHOLQJ SDLQW DQG RWKHU IRUHLJQ PDWHULDO 5HSDLU FUDFNV DQG

RWKHU KROHV ZLWK VSDFNOLQJ FRPSRXQG 6SRW SULPH DOO SDWFKLQJ

ZRUN

APPLICATION: $SSO\ E\ VSUD\ RUUROOHU 'R QRW DSSO\ DW

WHPSHUDWXUHVEHORZ)&6WLUULQJPD\EHUHTXLUHG

COVERAGE:  JDOORQ   VTXDUH IHHW  /LWHU  VTXDUH

PHWHUSHUFRDW7ZRFRDWVUHTXLUHG$WRWDOGU\ILOPDSSOLFDWLRQ

WKLFNQHVVRIPLOOVPLFURQV

CLEAN-UP: &OHDQ DOO DSSOLFDWLRQ HTXLSPHQW ZLWK ZDUP VRDS

DQGZDWHU

&867200,; &2/256 0$< 127 '5< 72 $1 (;$&7

0$7&+ 72 7+( 6$03/( &+,3 &+(&. 7+( &2/25%()25( 3$,17,1* 72 '(7(50,1( ,) ,7 ,6 <285

&+2,&( %< $33/<,1* 7+( 3$,17 72 $ 60$// 7(67

$5($

0$18)$&785('%<

6307+(5026+,(/',1&

1DSOHV)ORULGD86$

7HO)D[

ZZZWKHUPRVKLHOGFRP

This product contains less than

 grams/ 39.5 Liter VOC (0.33 lbs / gal) 

EXTERIOR 

WALL COATING 

5961

White 

5 Gallons (US) 19 LITERS 

WARNING! ,I \RX VFUDSH VDQG RU UHPRYH ROG SDLQW \RX PD\UHOHDVHOHDGGXVW/($',672;,&(;32685(72/($''867&$1 &$86( 6(5,286 ,//1(66 68&+ $6 %5$,1 '$0$*(

(63(&,$//< ,1 &+,/'5(1 35(*1$17 :20(1 6+28/'

$/62 $92,' (;32685( :HDU D UHVSLUDWRU WR FRQWURO OHDG

H[SRVXUH &OHDQ XS FDUHIXOO\ ZLWK D +(3$ YDFXXP DQG D ZHW

PRS 8VH RQO\ ZLWK DGHTXDWH YHQWLODWLRQ 7R DYRLG

RYHUH[SRVXUH RSHQ ZLQGRZV DQG GRRUV RU XVH RWKHU PHDQV WR

HQVXUH IUHVK DLU HQWU\ GXULQJ DSSOLFDWLRQ DQG GU\LQJ ,I \RX

H[SHULHQFHH\HZDWHULQJKHDGDFKHVRUGL]]LQHVVLQFUHDVHIUHVKDLURUZHDUUHVSLUDWRU\SURWHFWLRQRUOHDYHWKHDUHD$YRLGFRQWDFW

ZLWK H\HV DQG VNLQ :DVK KDQGV DIWHU XVLQJ .HHS FRQWDLQHU

FORVHG ZKHQ QRW LQ XVH ),567 $,' ,Q FDVH RI H\H FRQWDFW

IOXVK WKRURXJKO\ ZLWK ODUJH DPRXQWV RI ZDWHU *HW PHGLFDODWWHQWLRQ LI LUULWDWLRQ SHUVLVWV ,I VZDOORZHG JHW PHGLFDO DWWHQWLRQ

LPPHGLDWHO\

DO NOT FREEZE. Do not take internally. KEEP OUT OF REACH OF CHILDREN

First Aid: ,I VZDOORZHG'2127LQGXFH YRPLWLQJ

&RQWDLQVDFU\OLFODWH[DQGVLOLFD*LYHPLONRUZDWHUDQGFDOODGRFWRURU3RLVRQ&RQWURO&HQWHULPPHGLDWHO\,QFDVHRIFRQWDFWZLWKH\HVIOXVKWKRURXJKO\ZLWKZDWHU&DOODGRFWRU

Close container after each use. 

LIMITED WARRANTY & DISCLAIMER:7KLVSURGXFWLVEHOLHYHGWREHRIJRRGTXDOLW\,IWKHSURGXFWSURYHVWREHGHIHFWLYHZLWKLQGD\VIURPWKHGDWHRIVDOHWKHSURGXFWZLOOEHUHSODFHG LQ DFFRUGDQFH ZLWK PDQXIDFWXUHU¶V ZDUUDQWLHV 6XFKUHSODFHPHQW LV DQG VKDOO EH WKH RQO\ OLDELOLW\ RI WKH PDQXIDFWXUHU 7KHPDQXIDFWXUHUVKDOOQRWEH UHVSRQVLEOHIRUODERUFRVWVRIDQ\NLQGRUDQ\RWKHUFRVWVUHODWLQJWRLQVWDOODWLRQDSSOLFDWLRQRUUHDSSOLFDWLRQRURI DQ\ GDPDJHV UHVXOWLQJ WKHUH IURP 7+,6 :$55$17< ,6

(;&/86,9( $1' 7+(5( $5( 12 27+(5 :$55$17,(6 (,7+(5(;35(66('25,03/,(',1&/8',1*:$55$17,(62)),71(6625 0(5&+$17$%,/,7< )25 '(7$,/6 3/($6( 5()(5 72 7+(

0$18)$&785(5¶6/,0,7(':$55$17<

([KLELW-

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 36 of 75 PageID 50 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 37 of 75 PageID 51 

EXHIBIT K 
rs&&MO,-SHIElfJ 

FLUID APPLIED CERAMIC COATINGS 

WATER-BASED NON-HAZARDOUS 

COLOR: THERMO-SHIELD® ,QWHULRULVDYDLODEOH

LQPDQ\FRORUV

SURFACE PREPARATION: 5HPRYHDOOORRVHPDWHULDOV6XUIDFHVPXVWEHFOHDQGU\DQGIUHHRIGLUWZD[JUHDVHORRVHRUSHHOLQJSDLQWDQGRWKHUIRUHLJQPDWHULDO5HSDLUFUDFNV DQG RWKHU KROHV ZLWK VSDFNOLQJ FRPSRXQG 6SRWSULPHDOOSDWFKLQJZRUNAPPLICATION: $SSO\E\ VSUD\RUUROOHU'RQRWDSSO\

DW WHPSHUDWXUHV EHORZ ) & 6WLUULQJ PD\ EH

UHTXLUHG

COVERAGE: JDOORQVTXDUHIHHW/LWHUVTXDUHPHWHU SHU FRDW 7ZR FRDWV UHTXLUHG $ WRWDO GU\ ILOPDSSOLFDWLRQWKLFNQHVVRIPLOOVPLFURQVCLEAN-UP: &OHDQDOODSSOLFDWLRQHTXLSPHQWZLWKZDUPVRDSDQGZDWHU

&867200,;&2/2560$<127'5<72$1(;$&70$7&+72

7+( 6$03/( &+,3 &+(&. 7+( &2/25 %()25(3$,17,1* 72

'(7(50,1(,),7,6<285&+2,&(%<$33/<,1*7+(3$,1772$60$//7(67$5($

0$18)$&785('%<

6307+(5026+,(/',1&

1DSOHV)ORULGD86$

7HO)D[

ZZZWKHUPRVKLHOGFRP

7KLVSURGXFWFRQWDLQVOHVVWKDQ

JUDPV/92&OEVJDO

INTERIOR 

WALL COATING 

5977 

White 

5 Gallons (US) 19 LITERS 

:$51,1* 

UHOHDVHOHDGG&$1&$86(

(63(&,$//<$/62$92,'

OHDG H[SRVXU

ZHW PRS 8

RYHUH[SRVXUHHQVXUH IUHVKH[SHULHQFHH\DLURUZHDUUHZLWK H\HV DQ

FORVHGZKHQWKRURXJKO\ZL

LUULWDWLRQSHUVL

DO NOT KEEP OU

First Aid: 

&RQWDLQVDFFDOODGRFWRFDVHRIFRQ&DOODGRFWR

Close con

LIMITED WARR7KLVSURGXFWLVEHGHIHFWLYHZUHSODFHG LQ 

UHSODFHPHQWLVPDQXIDFWXUHU DQ\ RWKHU FRVW

RI DQ\ GDP

(;&/86,9($(;35(66('25 0(5&+$0$18)$&78
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 39 of 75 PageID 53 

EXHIBIT L 
THE O~SHIELD ROOF C 

Thermo-Shleld Roof Coats are hlghly eft'ldent, eriergysavlng, flec:lble coatings, made from a water-based pure 

acryllt resin aystem filled with hollow c.enmlc micro 

spheres. Each micro sphere ICU u a sealed cell and the 

endre mutlt acts u a thermally efficient blanket 

eowrfng 'the endre rnrutture. They are i:ornpletely 

washable and redst many harsh chemicals.Thermo-Shield 

Roof Caw hoe high reflecance and high emittance as 

well u a very low canductMty wlua. Therma--Shield 

R.oof Coats graady raduca thannal shade and heat 

panatndion by kl!llping roof surfaces much molar in hat 

summer weather: They offer UV pratection, low VOC's, 

and exc:111ll111nt dirt pick-up resistance ar'K:I retain their 

flexibility long after aging. 

Solar Reflective Index: I I 0 

Ct, Recluctlon of energy used and coolrng costs 

(Ji Dawnsizlng of all"<Ondltlanlng equipment 

CC) CALL US NOW! 

<X>OLROOP' 

~ WATERPROOF10D% 

~ REDUCE HVAC LOAD 

~ SAVE ENERGY, .. 38% 

Thermal b littame: tlie 1?ki!li'e oomiy of 

lf1ll roof wrioc~ to 

rodill~ 005()~ lieo1 

RATING COUNCIL ® 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 40 of 75 PageID 54 

7+(5026+,(/'

239-234-5832 COOL ROOF COOL ROOF

ZZZWKHUPRVKLHOGFRP

 ([KLELW/
THE HIELD E E I 

Thermo-Shield Exterior Wall Coats are highly 

efflclenti energy-saving, flexible coatings designed 

to Insulate and waterproof exterior walls. They 

are non-toxic, friendly to the environment, and 

fonn a seamless membrane that bridges hairline 

cracks. They are completely washable and resist 

many harsh chemlcals and dirt pick-up. These 

wateri-based coatings are made fn>m an acrylic 

resin system fllled wtdi vacuumed ceramic micro 

spheres that acts as a thennally efficient blanket. 

Thermo-Shield Exterior Wall Coats put a stop to 

the "frequent painting cycle" - they outlast other 

paints several times over. 

~ Solar Reflective Index: 110 * 

r Reduction of energy used and cooling costs _, 

. Downsizing of alr-c:ondldonlng equipment 

* WHTE COLOUR. 

CC) CALL US NOW! 

Sn11111 lletll 11 a!I!111biμI by 11~ uiol 

fillt t111111/111Nid to 11\ri b\iltrling Maw 

OOOLROOF 

RATINGCOONCIL ® 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 41 of 75 PageID 55 

7+(5026+,(/'

239-234-5832 COOL WALL

ZZZWKHUPRVKLHOGFRP

 ([KLELW/
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 42 of 75 PageID 56 

EXHIBIT M 
'•. '' "· ~ I ,, 

\ 11 , 

.· \ ..... • ,,~ ) 

' 

' I ,~.' 

. 1 _\ .,, 

. 

. ., . - •' 

. *.::: .,. . . "' :.-, - r· 

07500COM 

Buyline 5314 

THERMB·BHIElB'· 

A different kind 

of roof system 

for a tougher kind 

· of environment . 

..... .___.,. 

_....,..._.,.. ~ ....... ~ ........ ---,MalCI ...... ..,... .ttl -=-C-..-•1.,......., ....... .... ~ .,,. .... (11111.,(..,._, .... .,, ~•1--nlllr1.l1~Nm.1) .. _.-.,.. 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 43 of 75 PageID 57 

 ([KLELW0
THERIB-BHIELB~LUID APPLIED CERAMIC ROOF SYSTEM 

~IIUUUCI l'llE9e"4 1~1lUN 

.&n ffltu,v huD 1nol no 

tcthn•lh m' ,.-cm, 11nfn9 Gl,.,.,,:lffi 

" Ill• I rlt1 ..,, ,icn '" 

11,ttic,11 .tt II su Uun 

'fht: fllJilc..\Ul--illUiUJI» Ro,i( Sy,tcm 

t'tJnS1,1s cil lluuJ·upplic,d l\cryhc 

chuto1u1:lftc.: CU4Uill)l\ wl1h:l11,..-on1uin 

Lt111mlt"" Micm,rh.-rc.!i.. 

Once II\ fll"ce. lhe TUER.\10,.Sllll!JJl Roar 

Sytllcm 1~11\do 4 •e:taml~. 1;.11"1flhf1U(,U!, 

mflllntHh•r membrane IJTTpCTVtc.iu-' m 

ndvl!IK wt1.Lthc:1 comtiuom1. isitt>u,,1c 

._"11111uninunL,. nnd aln:mc lcmr1-emlure 

011('1Ulili()n). 

A'3 1hown by u.ccc.leru1cd ageing tc5a. the 

TIU!J\.'10-.SIIIEI.O s)IJiltrn l11$H IOJ1£ff than 

t.OU\l\!IIU01H1) ,oors~ Jt IS '-"Old-.&pplicd, SO 

11'" -.nfcr gmng o n. 111.s non•tn:(lc m 

lh.1ulJ or cu1td ronn~ co, uoume11t11Uy 

c.Jca.n.cr. e.Jimuuumg n.Oxiou, hlmcs, 

Olh<r lmj)MW\I TIIEIWO,SIIIW\ Rool 

SyJ1lc1n hcucfib i11cluJc. 

Waterproofs roo·fs, even low sloped 

A high degree of pun01urereslstance due lo Its outstanding 

tensile strength 

Exceptlonal elongation 

charMterlsllcs 

Absolute bondabillty lo a wide 

variety of substrates 

Stability under an extrema range of 

temperature f1uctuotlons 

High resistance to atmosphorlo 

pollulion 

High rcslstnnoe lo UV degr:,dotlon 

r \c '"o~~ 

"' v ,n "1-

Thc 1111.:Jt.MO-.SIObl n R.i'kll Sys«cm (lm"~ 

ttn cxdwivr. ruofiog formti.Lt fel1lllntig 

hollow ct:rnmtr bo1"051ll.:ntc­

"ticr01i-plv:r~. 111c~ 111lc-r0!t(>he1cs un: 

!lmil:i.r to thole used in the in111l:nini!' .:and 

,o.nccti\lc. t.'t:ldJniC files I.Lied 011 the 

NASA sp.,rCI \hU1tlc 

TI1e,c unique nuid 11pplicd C'Cr11mlt 

«J,Hlng.1o, c;in he .!lprJyeJ (Ir mlled on m 

fon11 Ii ,icumlc.ss manollth11J .st:.al over iU'I) 

rlfl,-"'U.'l'C-OaffWtllll""c!tt,r~5fmip,CU ~ '""'W111'111111t1Dll,••'-!,)'ltll"lllt-~l .. otll-•,.." ... ,i... .. ~1111-11, 

~41~ta,•14f118f-S6ttaaldh't•ll.o••'t"-•ofJl&M..n••••f ''If'!",,...,.~ 

,i1.c or • h•P., roo(. TIit TilllMICHUllll.l) Jrotll<Ally rcuucing solo.1 IO>dl»g, • 

.Rnnf S)'llhlm c((~d\'cdy di~!ip:ucs -and ~rith:al (gctor in lowcrini uir cunJitioning 

rcflc:-tu. solar ,odlalion buck ln10 the co.ts. 

1,1.1.muiphc.n:. rouhmp in g_n .imp:r~ive 

rC'Juct1011 or ~IIV toodme: 

Tiu-. ffllll.M(J-SlflFlD Ruof SV5itc.•.1u LUU l1f! 

applied dln:cll) tu moJt clean, dry. •<><111<1 

:rnbstrota,. ioclud.lng met.Al, com:retc, 

Wnod, a,pholl •hln&IU. ule, 11.<bc.sto.\, 

Ul<UtRno f04l11. ,n~ l!POM 

VurlDblc pennC!l)biUty. Thu polyn1cn. 

usrd In 1h~ ntt:RMO-"lJl'bll• Roof Sy,lcm 

c-Ap;a11U when wet. uffcrlng uue,.1.:cUeJ 

rr-,1C'C'tion ag1a1n.n d1m11iu,g mni.svr~ 

ptoc.lfiltiou. The pol)lmcrS 1hd11l Whtn 

dry. allnw1n1 any tral'JlCd mniA"turc 

hulJJup tu i:ufcly e1crapc to tJ)c 

11mo~.phcrc. this hcJps rrtvc:nr bhstenng 

Ttn\()tM\lufes 011 1hc-tttOf stn.Y with in 

al, C ot umhhint nJr rhi.\ lnwen 

ti:rupctJIUres undtr 1he roof by~ much 

as 2.~"C- Rcroru· from ctl~l)mtrr-t 11( 

<'ll~Y i.a~In~ u1> w aO'i, 1.1.tt! not unusuul 

wuh ru, upplk:11ion nl 'UGIO,lO.,SIUl:U• 

Roor Sy,1<111. A TIICRMO·SIIIW111)0( , •• 

pJy for itscl( through cnc.rgy s:11v1ug, b} 

• A TIJIIU' • q,.,-1,110illi11,cu~i;.,&11 lir.J11 )'\Ill 

-n11im ~It' hr'4 1)111r "' Tilf'IIW>ue'Ui ill'flllDIIOJt 

fw )utqwtlaiLll ptajDa. 

Etteot of THERMO-SHIELD 

on surface temperature 

1MlpfFJ 

150 

"" 

"" 

"" iliERMO.SHIElD rool 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 44 of 75 PageID 58 

 ([KLELW0
tlr,llo\'I 1h<t1t0 mir.,.,,r 

11.r"' o ,111r 

The h(1)1nw &l~SS mlcro,J111Cll's In llll'RMl>­

SIIICU) ~llngs •r• pUr< ..idiunl botullliWc. 

.tot.I JJe le.'>. LhJn 100 11t1L,vn in Jimnctct 

e.ac:11 Clf~ r.cll llCI" 35 an effiCICI\I rnsuhunr 

Ork-c t1J1plled. w,uer cV!IJltll'lltcs (mm the: 

1111 ,;i..-o-~11111 n u~i,mt~ .w;ryllr tmnbt()n mid 

\he hQl\ow ttraJnlc sphms •p~h coch 

Olli<r, c:,·cnt1.uilly touc,h. then fuse into 11 

c::0"1i11uom: memmnt 

AnU ~l'lc-e llie 11u.:rospbcrtl we ove, ti).ty 

pc.rcc111 ,•end, lhe cnoro 111ou.1,1-s1110 .u Noor 

Stswn wo,glu, ,bou1 U 73 l i f'Ct ,q. mete, 

0 000000 0 0 

0000000°0 0 

Ceram,c SJ)he1e acrylic emuls10n on surlaco 

•••••••••••••••••••••••••••• I:•:•:•:•:•:•:•:. :•:•:•:•:. :• ~·~·~•:•:•~•:•:•~•:•..;.•;.•~•.;.•: 

llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll 

h~ ,, ! LU fl 

m 

Lc~mu: Is II poor ctmdU"1(W' ~,, t)c111 .111(11~ a 

llll ""''° <lrcctJ1t lruul11or lll•n 1hc ~ull,y 

m:\l<n•I• J<nendly ,..,d fm 1hL, pu111u,e. The 

nl8'M~IIIELD Roc-,r Sy,ttm ii IJlli-Ulp-Ultd 

'" il!.-nbllit) hl lff.ulpalc ltci.t ft rcn«~ rOCKl 

SOIIU CQCIJ-1 so u Ol'Vr:f ~elS mm the SUUClUrc 

io bcn>mt n hc:11 prT\hlrm, there a,, no hent 

l!(llllg< !lillld up RS 11,1\h bulk 1n111l111on 

TII< hldt rcrrort11.\ll.,. Till'.8_\tO•SIIIEIJJ 

Ct11u1Uc ('Oallll~ uls.o 1nsuJu1~ Uj~jl\~I tool 

~•~In!flcm 11nrt n-,nIme1mn Thitdr.11111ct1ll} 

r«hln:.> 1hc P<J .. ,~1111~ ~f rQQ( 1""'-' (Oll>t•I 

by \Jn:rn11d ~ho1,:l 1mJ ~~u1.:c) mitlutt11.1u1i.c 

C'o.m :1«01dln&,ly. 

uses ~Prlll-~Tli.>'~ 

TUt:Dt,lrt-SHI ..11 

J, f I I 11 

The- TIIEJL\fQ/41UfiU) R"';r S_y.\tcn1 L"I an uJal 

chttl~ fof 'fl-Ah ni:w omi;trud1on "'"'I n:-troJil 

..rppltcantins 11rERMo-sm1w ts c.-.ll,y 10 nprl} 

tnd nn be u~ with conndtncc over nwl 

S1Jb!U11lc.\. 

llilll'>IO-Slllll.O h:u ,upcrb >dlle!IOfl 10 

Lvll1.-tete - unpnmcd Of tt,:U\l.11u1tJ ,ucw.J 

W<MJd - tbph1111 ,ihiriilru; - lit~ - urtlh•~ 

fa,m - El'l>M - -,bci101 

1J1111mh1ous/libeti:ws rel! rlll)(s ~• IISl>hlllt 

0<>J111><11i1IM ,oor• rtquLc Iii< Fl<.< T,._ •11J 

P<'IY«lct bucKl,ng cn.11. 

• 'I II\' flt .,.,, ,. The 11lllltMIH111tW Root Sy,1tu1 fj nukl­

•11plicd. cm111n3 • ,...mlc,.,, lc•l11n•1f 

mooulu~•• m""1br:tne. 11tC11> .,,, ~ 

m«honk~I (,u1e,,crs ihul <11n cooic IOru< ova- lime. l11i, chmm:tlb i 11111,Jt,. 1,otc.:ullal 

rur root f11011rt'. 

Mnre TifCII\IO•sma.o bent.flu 

Labor savings.~• ,Jvoru:ct.1 .. 11,c 

Tlff.ll)ttrsinr.u, Roof Sy~cm n , II is ,hu ooc 

,1f lhc ca~iot a1tJ ,oo~t \'."1i-ctrn.1.l\·c •~ 

;ippJ)', Only :1 lbn:c-~n pew 1-. nrcdtd ror ii 

1ypinl nn,11.-,0,silll!I n •1>plk•llu11. •• Of!olk)std 10 1ht nine to twelve mun crew u.Kd 

(v1 ii 1XtlWCnU1 IJlid h"' four f'h1,c.:L Tine J.od 

l!abor .. a,in~, cm l,r.UU.~le ,,,h,,, the l11w~I 

, • .,,, per >qllllrt m<l<r UJl1)1lcd 

·n,r llltill\H$1Ut.J.u Rouf S)'~klll J1.1 ... dop, u rn,tN:li\'e. .).ilrf11cc f'ilm W11h1n 4~ lnUIIIIUli of 

.Appllc,itlon on , ._-c-ro.1c, Wind blown d,1,1 will 

1101 ,u!bcrc- 1n the surface. n<>r will ~ light min 

l,1,w1..-r CUITtf'fl•!m.l,c the 1..vahup, •, i111e-1trity 

Noise Reduction lllf rt,<ln,, •nd uramlr., m»k, u nollttnbh! rtdudiOu from uul~ldt 

-nolst, ~ptclnlly on mellll bulldlu~ • 

U_ghlwelghl Tht1t1ENM~l---$H1t:an !tool 

Sy>1c,11 dlmln•I<> lht 11<~ !or b,1tloJ1. 

ccd~•ni $tludu1-u.l Jtflc:cLJort, e1 nbJ\lf c4.U..~ ()f 

J1!1ntl111g, Al <>nly 0.7S kg. pa "fl'"" 111'1ct, Ill< 

weigh\ (..c-tor on a, new mar d~\ign Is nnnlln;il 

Superior flexibility ot oxtremely low 

tempe.ralutes. Tlll,J!\jt).-\Ulf..lJJ 11WliC\ tC'UliD 

1hflr 11roprn1•• ~• 1ampcr>1uro.< 11<11111- -IO"C 

411d 11.1 high ;u I 50"<-

Excellant elongatlon and rttovery 

prope rll0$, fllo 'n1>,'111•,111u 11 RMI Sy,"111 

crco1"1 • pro«<11V< h.imer whh prov<n h1;h 

n::)i~tance: h) h11i1 11nd wind d.;unagc. 'Mlc cliU1i1-

\"0,1ting mo"\-C.S with IJuil.J.ing muvc:roc:nl-1 

><lUIIIJ: hairline mcknnd prov"11mg "'"' 

rn(ks. 

,·..-n 

,f ·~ 

n1fWMl),li11JfU1 tr.uucJ .uw.l ccrtlf1cJ i:ontr.1,tors 

-arc: 11vml11blr lo work on -your mnf.,,)'1lur 

1U•u1 tma: ur • p1orosi'IJ111l. ntt-.RM0-,u1ru 

•PJlfOVC<i Job. Add lh< 1111 R>!C>SHIIJ.U 

Wammt)', .1.uJ )\IU li.J\ ca wa1c:Hlght c..ue (o, 

U5Jl1~ lhc he~ ltlERMr>-5.ICl!I.LD 

The ·ruEKMO---,HIEt.O R\;11( Sy~em c.-<c-cts in ercn1ing o 1igh,. w~ihcr•prnot 

seal •round all types ol roor pro1m,1,)n, 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 45 of 75 PageID 59 

 ([KLELW0
Other Tests 

nn~ltOO!nlm!.11 l.othtng N\l "l'Oll11ilt ClfYUllC'I '!\'CIC' dctc:c-~d Q!Jt.:Ulbl 1\!'.it 

Ltli<h>blC! .,. ll(lC>-1®<. 

RFJ>U<'Tl(JN OF llliAT11<1\N~l'l!R Tt!.STS Of II•..., I.ab, 

I ltlt U&lmfor of (ial~-'Oi:tcd tifft ~ G:tlViliOI~ 1.tctl C<XII.C'd 'f',11!1 111 ~ IMci:nOlro• ot 

TH~!\;':;!<) SIIIEUl 

RQulh J 1Ull~l),'\lllflJ)MDJC1lc.&!J(t.1• lt)'\IIC,ilh11!11(c:1 

Ct1m('Clrnoa ol llpft21, <.•o,udJ libctbcwd ,,.-ll:f£1ai0.Si:IIELO 

Rcwfl-. flll!i.M~ umpk: bll.l 849.i ku hell.I tnsiufet 

TtJeRMt~Sllll!Lll u"••~ .,,,o 

OTHER THERMO-SHIELD PRODUCTS AVAILABLE 

11,1 l ,ti 141111 11 1 I, f ~! l' Wutab..bl."<lel11st0mena 

corrunlr lilted ro>llng., nr)· 1n ,-,.11111111, much lnn~<r '""'"' flni,ll nn •II lyJlC$ uf 

wrt:~C$- tn,l1Jitlm_f. pn:,pem~ 113)' fur die appl1L"tl!llln tn cncry,y i11vlnp.. 

111 t \1 UH 1 I I'\ I I JI , 1 ' I Wu.J.t, h-:l\b.1 clA:>tu1ncnc_ t'tt'l\J1.\1C. 

Oiled etw.tinf!,.-1(, J.,y 10 t1 ~Ml.n ftul.sh th..,1 d.1An9t.s 1ont.$ \~l1h ch:invc of lij$1 Seils 

l\llUllnc c-nacks and help$ prevent new v1•c• RWuces ech1,c5 :uuJ .,1111nJ l:,c1wccn f11UII\.\. 

('.cr:imi0 ,i:1.Juo: hcnl h~, ~«p,, tt:rupc.rau..u.d n,nrc-c\:tt1 calJnii- u, O<kw, 11nd make a 

room mu~ tomfunablc: 

• .,,n, HI , , , 11 '\n cJa.st,,mtm. uuc(o 1bn.1 lo1,b. ~ '°' c:afW 10 .JfiPI)\ 

'""' rcs1'i1!'t. md"lng, whdc p,o'fading cmc:,iy ~\!Ogs, 

u 1, 111 I co3.llng!> ore il\lilll3.hle ln ,.i ~ 11Ue 11U1gc of colo1-s 

lllRMIHll/8.11" 

1'5SFl,\OI V INSTALl-4TI0tt 

111r 

I '" I I •• 

i\pr1ly111i 3 llltl<M(HIUEJ.l} "' ro-OI I> ,ompilCllY 

In ll1<1f, fl<rt'l All d\ill ·••d• l~ ~ done 

M:1kc: ~urt 111 fl~'lhlns" 11.nd/nr (:t.\11:ncrs 

lllC tn,anllcd nntl pmperl}' .sccUlcJ 

z. Sweep. clcon. and pr<p"1< surface. 

;, Rtht(Oll\t ilJJ rnda and Jo1n1s wl1h nUlk 

nmj polyc,101 fohric ,tnp; (brand nomc ot 

Po~E-FurccJ, embedded ,n mi:mo-sttUJ.V 

4, Apply lh• TIIElt\10·5111EIJl Rool Co>tlni: 

with an n1rles~ $pr.Iyer or rollc:r al a mfe 

o( l.ll lilcn J u,1 tu mo i:tiill.s n(0,tt7l 

111,r I m1

, Alluw ~4 hour, b<<w«n oo."s 

qr un11I the tir!il «,;U 11 complc.1cly Jry hl 

,he wuch i\f1or fir,t co"' has c,,n:d, apply -:1 .... cronJ C1.J;U .11 &he ~Uc r,uc ()t 

11ppllC:.Uon, 

T 

lD 

Jnd~pendcnt l11b tuts lllld mcRS~1rcm-:n1:1 

,how the .c.(fcttl't'CIIC.\~ nr 111EK.'40·.SHJCW tu 

rcduel~ lnl<Mor ttm()<nuures. Copies llf< 

av3.1lab.lc 11Jl ft''-!i~l 

OfVfLO IEJ,IT 

The. IIIFM\ll'fl-111 u, l~nr,1 'iy"'tc:m W:t.'( 1hr 

ilevclupmcnl urvENf!R/\L lNDUS-1 ltll:S 

CORI' t'olo~lo Srn"g.,, ro II rhcmusd 

ll,c~wlty 1."0m1,.u1y o( uvtr 2S years 

•~ptrlcn<< To<y spcn< sc"•n Y<~ 

<kv,lop,ng rnmu,10.s111m.o into n rt•lf 

tualiur th.t ~ould ><1h·c A.LL the J'(ubltrn;o 

,ommc,o 10 roormg sy,;;t('m:!t- Smtc 19!s4 

l'HERMO-SHIELO ROOF COAT ho, b<cn 

,uLcessfully sn1vmg our ctl'I.IOmcr·~ ruohna 

prot,lrrn•. fJO :i h:,ntt fem, bai,.i.s:. in :I.II !ypt.".\, 

or cllm1ur ;di :ttnund the wnrld 

fLl/10 APPUED CfAAMIC IIOOF 1110 WALL COATlll&S 

SPM TI JERMO-SHIELD, INC, 

i 915 R~nle•nnkc lfomm,,ck Rtl3d #266, Naples, Florido J4JU USA 

Td,; 2.39-2.1⁄4-5fl:l2 1'11:c 239-2.36-6767 

~pmft, therm11•hi•J1l.c<!!lJ 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 46 of 75 PageID 60 

 ([KLELW0
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 47 of 75 PageID 61 

EXHIBIT N 
Space Age Technology provides 

A revolutionary new way to INSULATE, 

repair, maintain and preserve 

1_. interior and 

~ exterior walls! 

• s~,,,,., s 

r. 

Tintable in many colors. 

THERMD·BHIElB 

For industrial, commercial, agricultural, and residential use. On 

interior or exterior surfaces, including unprimed and galvanized 

metal, in any climate. A coat of THERMO-SHIELD· LIQUID SIDING 

applied no thicker than a fingernail can give savings equal to 

inches of other types of insulation. 

Unlike some paints that make minor insulation claims based solely 

on reflectivity, THERMO-SHIELD· LIQUID SIDING creates a 

thermal barrier and dissipates heat. 

THERMO-SHIELD ' LIQUID SIDING bonds to surfaces other 

products cannot, such as unprimed or galvanized metal, tile, 

asphalt, bituminous or composition roofs, and wood that is subject 

to swelling and shrinking. 

THERMO-SHIELD' LIQUID SIDING Insulates itself as well as the 

surface it protects from weather damage, and it can last 2 to 3 

times longer than conventional products. 

The temperature insulation properties unique to THERMO-SHIELD " 

LIQUID SIDING also makes it a noise insulator. 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 48 of 75 PageID 62 

 ([KLELW1
HOW THERMO-SHIELD® 

THERMO.SHIEL[)\!> LIQUID SIDING 

Thermal Control 

THERMO-SHIELDI> Is a proven superior insulating material. 

l<ey among the advanced features of THERMO-SHIELD"' is 

the placement of a newly developed hollow ceramic 

micro-sphere es a component specfally formulated with a 

acrylic mastic that keeps the borosilicate ceramic spheres 

In uniform suspension. Surfaces that are coated With 

THERMO-SHIEL~ are reluctant to conduct heat and 

refract as well as dissipate lleat away from tile surface. 

Because ft Is fluid applied, It forms a seamless monollthls 

seal, ellmlna1Ing vfrtually ell air lnflftratlon wtllch can be a 

major source of heat transfer In buildings. Tllese factors 

equate to substantial reductions In energy usage and costs. 

THERMO-SHIELD® LIQUID SIDING 

Noise Control 

THERMO-SHIEL01• Is Ideal wherever sound level reductions 

are required. Unlike olher products that absorb sound and 

thereby transmit noise, THERMO-SHIELD"' reflects sound 

back to tile source, not allowing the surface to conduct 

sound. This makes the product an excellent choice for some 

applications such as motel and hotel rooms and other 

public buildings wllere excessive noise levels occur. 

THERMO-SHIELD® LIQUID SIDING 

Condensation and 

Water Penetration Control 

THERMOSHIEL!)i'l has excellent elongallon and recovery 

properties. This property yields a protective barrier resistant 

to hall, water and wind damage. The hollow ceramic 

miorospheres used In THERMO-SHIELD" are over 60 

percent void. Tiley are bonded directly to the surface 

forming a searnless blanket, This eliminates any warm air to 

cold surface contact and reduces the temperature 

dlHerentlal thereby reducing or ellmtnatlng condensation. In 

areas where excessive moisture Is present It Is necessa,ry lo 

provide adequate ventilation. 

Contaol Your Local Dealer 

LIQUID SIDING WORKS 

©(O) D(O 0©) (j) O_o 

, ©~ oO©o ©a~ 

lo an acryllc otastometlc emul!!IIOn systems, as the water 

nvapo,atea the hollow cerarn,c sphere• approach eao'1 other, 

evenlUally toucll •nd luu 1"'0 a continuous mm. 

oi!lh1~1c1• wall c91t1no~ l>(ov1a, ,n e,oell•"' oound 

Gfln1tol Wti•n ulij)(j ,on condos. molllta, ~nv "'"" w~•·· .,..o,;•lve n\lle& level~ ~n oecu1, ~nn ;il ll'e """'" Um~ -••UII•~ Jncl p101eot.li, 

TIie product Is excelloot to, Insulating from tne outside whlle at tno 

aume lime stopping mol&tun, ponelrallon end 111e resulting orac~lng 

that rnkes place. su,race cred<S an, completely hldd.,,. 

--

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 49 of 75 PageID 63 

 ([KLELW1
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 50 of 75 PageID 64 

EXHIBIT O 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 51 of 75 PageID 65 

This home in Sandy City, Utah had

a 25 year old

3 tab black

shingles that were due to be torn off and replaced

 ([KLELW2
I t 

f 

“We saw the Thermo-shield system at

a home show and liked

the environmentally friendly system. No filling of the land fill

with our

2 layers of roof. No energy or oil to produce or install

new asphalt shingles. We also enjoy savings on our cooling

costs, which we expected, but we have also cut our heating

costs in the winter, totally un-expected, but totally

appreciated ! Thank You Thermo-shield !”

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 52 of 75 PageID 66 

 ([KLELW2
AprH 13. 2006 

Dear Stu. 

We would like to ta.k.e .a moment and express our happiness with the nc\\.· coating 

of" Thenno-Shjeld that we h;,\d put on our roof in April of 2005. 

Our roof has a 12 fool pitch in our dinning r om and in our living room.. Both o

these rooms were ve

_ry cold duriog the winter w1d hot in the swnmer. The air-conditione

usually lurnt:d on by I 0:00 A.M. and nm unlit late: in ·Lfhe evening on a hot day. 

We h.3⁄4ve had the coating oo our roof for a year now and we arc able to make a 

good comparison to the changes. We have found that duiirig the winter and the summer

that all rooms are now comfortable. 

In the summer we found a wonderful change as the air-conditioner did uot tun1 o

some days WltiJ 3:00 P.M. "fbl.! house stayed cool. We were amazed at bow much 

difference it made. Our power bill went down. as we were using less power to stay cool

Anu on ,cold days th"' rooJDB were no longer cool like they use to be. 

The workers did an excellent job with their work and teft our yard clean. U" we 

ha<l any problems, they were fix.ed at once. 'The roof is attractive. It seems. to be far 

~lter than shingles. We arc very happy tbat we ,chose 'fnem10-Shicld. We are glad to 

recommend this product to others. 

inc-erel 

· tu and ·lli • 

 
Low sloped Aluminum shingle roof was leaking and

had faded from red to washed out pink. Thermoshield Roof was installed, leak and color issues

solved.

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 54 of 75 PageID 68 

 ([KLELW2
Happily surprised owner

reports “I used 30% less

gas to heat my home the

winter following the

application”

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 55 of 75 PageID 69 

 ([KLELW2
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 56 of 75 PageID 70 

EXHIBIT P 
Patio roof on this Las Vegas home runs entire

length of the house. It is framed in such

a way that

the heat that developed inside this shell was being

transferred to the living space inside.

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 57 of 75 PageID 71 

 ([KLELW3
This low slope modified bitumen (torch down) roof absorbs

huge amounts of solar radiation. This heat builds up in the

space between the roof sheeting and the soffit. This

extreme heat then radiated into the home.

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 58 of 75 PageID 72 

 ([KLELW3
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 59 of 75 PageID 73 On

a typical Las Vegas summer day of 100 degrees, this roof is

over 170 degrees even with the light tan granules.

 ([KLELW3
Here temperature of

the roof coated with

Thermo-shield is

taken on day with 109

degree temps. Its

within degrees of the

air temperature,

reducing previous

heat build up of 60 80 heat build up of 60-80

degrees over outside

air temp. The owner

of this home says

“her cooling bills have

been reduced 25%

just by painting my

patio roof.”

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 60 of 75 PageID 74 

 ([KLELW3
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 61 of 75 PageID 75 

EXHIBIT Q 
- -

- --------------

---------------

 Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 62 of 75 PageID 76 5H$LUSRUW

6XEMHFW 5H$LUSRUW

'DWH $0(DVWHUQ6WDQGDUG7LPH

)URP 76KLHOG([SRUW#

7R

&F WKHUPRVKLHOGJHRUJH# WVKLHOGH[SRUW#

'HDU6KDKUXNK



'85,1*6800(5KLJK6RODU5HIOHFWLYLW\,QGH[RI65,WR65,ZKLFKIXQFWLRQVRQWKHEDVLVRI5HIOHFWLYLW\RIWKHEHVW

ZKLWHVXUIDFHDQG7KHUPDO(PLWWDQFHRIWKHEHVWEODFNVXUIDFHSUHYHQWVWKHH[WHULRUZDOOVXEVWUDWHIURPKHDWLQJXS7KLV

SUHYHQWVH[FHVVLYH+HDW%XLOW8SDURXQGWKHEXLOGLQJHQVXULQJORZHUWHPSHUDWXUHRIDLUWKDWLVWDNHQLQ65,YDOXHRI

PHDQV=(526RODU+HDWJDLQ

7KH+LJK(PLVVLYLW\RI7KHUPR6KLHOGZLOODOVRPHDQIDVWHUGLVVLSDWLRQRIKHDWUHGXFLQJWKHWHQGHQF\IRUWKHXQLWWREHD+RW

/XQFK%R[

$FFRUGLQJWRWKH$670&WHVWSHUIRUPHGE\WKH&RRO5RRI5DWLQJ&RXQFLO7KHUPR6KLHOGZLOOHPLWDZD\RIWKH

RIWKHVXQ
VHQHUJ\WKDWZDVQRWUHIOHFWHGDZD\DOUHDG\7KLVPHDQVWKDWDQDGGLWLRQDORIWKHVXQ
VHQHUJ\RQWRSRI

WKHWKDWZDVUHIOHFWHGLVQRORQJHUEHLQJDEVRUEHGE\WKHVWUXFWXUHDVKHDW

6REDVLFDOO\DQDVWRXQGLQJRIWKHVXQ
VHQHUJ\LVQRWDOORZHGWREHFRPHKHDWLQWKHEXLOGLQJ7KLVLVZK\

7KHUPR6KLHOG
VVXUIDFHLVFRROWRWRXFKRQH[WUHPHO\KRWVXQQ\GD\V

,WLVOLNHKDYLQJD5LQVXODWLRQGXULQJWKHVXPPHU

'85,1*:,17(5

,IZLQGGULYHQUDLQKLWVWKHH[WHULRUZDOODQGURRISURWHFWHGE\7KHUPR6KLHOGSRO\PHUVVZHOODQGEHFRPHZDWHUWLJKW9DULDEOH

3HUPHDELOLW\FRDWLQJPHPEUDQHEUHDWKLQJZKHQGU\:LWKRUGLQDU\SDLQWZKLFKGRHVQRWSUHYHQWPRLVWXUHWRSHQHWUDWH

WKHH[WHULRUZDOOHYHQPRLVWXUHFRQWHQWLQWKHZDOOZLWKRUGLQDU\LQVXODWLRQ6W\URIRDPURFNZRROHWFFDQUHGXFHWKH

5YDOXHE\DVPXFKDVZKRSSLQJ

:LWKDFRPSOHWH7KHUPR6KLHOGSURWHFWLRQ5RRI([WHULRUDQG,QWHULRU\RXFDQH[SHFWUHGXFWLRQRQ

KHDWLQJH[SHQVH

,WLVOLNHKDYLQJD5LQVXODWLRQLQZLQWHU

,QJHQHUDO7KHUPR6KLHOGLVQRWLQWHQGHGWRUHSODFHWKHFXUUHQWLQVXODWLRQWKDWWKHVHEXLOGLQJVKDYHEXWUDWKHUWR

FRPSOLPHQWZKDWLVH[LVWLQJDQGPDNHWKHEXLOGLQJPXFKPXFKPRUHHIILFLHQW7KLVLQWXUQZLOODOORZV\RXUFOLHQWWR

VLJQLILFDQWO\UHGXFHWKHNLORZDWWVFRQVXPHGWRNHHSWKHEXLOGLQJVLQWKHWHPSHUDWXUHUDQJHUHTXLUHG

 VHHDERYH

 \RXPXVWDSSO\DVSRWSULPHUWRWKHUXVWHGDUHDRWKHUZLVHUXVWPD\EOHHGWKUXDWVRPHSRLQWODWHUDQGEHFRPHVD

FRVPHWLFLVVXH3ULPLQJWKHHQWLUHVXEVWUDWHLVDZD\WRJRRWKHUZLVHWKHEOHHGWKUXPD\KDSSHQRQPLVVHGVSRWV2XU

0HWDO3ULPHURU5XVW&RQYHUWHUZRXOGGRWKHMRE

 GHSHQGVZKDW76SURGXFWRQZKDWVXEVWUDWHLVLQWHQWWRDSSO\

,WVRXQGVOLNHWKLVLVXQGHURXUWUDGHQDPH7KHUPR6KLHOG""

EU

3HWHU

,QDPHVVDJHGDWHG30(DVWHUQ'D\OLJKW7LPH ZULWHV

'HDU3HWHU

+RSH\RXDQGWKHIDPLO\DUHZHOO,KDGDYHU\SURGXFWLYHPHHWLQJZLWK%RVWRQ/RJDQ,QWHUQDWLRQDO

$LUSRUWZKRDUHLQWHUHVWHGWRPRYHZLWKXVRQWHVWLQJDQGKRSHIXOO\EODQNHW32

7KH\KDGDIHZWHFKQLFDOTXHVWLRQVZKLFK,FRXOGQRWDQVZHUEXWZDQWHGWRILHOGWR\RX

([KLELW4 
4/26/2019 Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Re: Airport Page 63 of 75 PageID 77 

1. What is the the indicated R- Value 22? Does it mean R22 is per coat? Per 3 coats or per inch? 

2. Can the product replace Insulation? 

3. Can there be small traces of Rust left on the surface after it has been prepped? 

4. Is primer required for all prepping prior to painting? 

I know many of these are indicated in the installation and summary of tests but they were digging a bit

deeper. 

Also we could like to register Massport, Government of the State of Massachusetts. They are going to

start inputting our specs into their procurement and likely contact you, Thermacote, Truco etc and the

top management wants to make sure we are covered before proceeding. 

My best, 

Shahrukh 

ription: cid:image001.jpg@01C8E0F2.86E87D70

 1Attached Images 

Exhibit Q 2/2 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 64 of 75 PageID 78 

EXHIBIT R 
-

---

 Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 65 of 75 PageID 79 5H/DPEGD5DQG8

6XEMHFW 5H/DPEGD5DQG8

'DWH $0(DVWHUQ6WDQGDUG7LPH

)URP 76KLHOG([SRUW#

7R

&F WKHUPRVKLHOGJHRUJH#  VSP#WKHUPRVKLHOGFRP

+L2PDU

 /DPEGDLVSURYLGHGWRXVE\&DOLIRUQLD,QVWLWXWHRI(OHFWURQLFVDQG0DWHULDO6FLHQFHWHVWLQJVDPSOHV([WHULRU,QWHULRU

DQGVDPSOHVRI5RRI&RDW7KHVDPSOHVVSHFLILHVWKHWKLFNQHVVLQPLOOV')7PLO PLFURQV

)RU\RXUKDQG\UHIHUHQFHDWWDFKHGLVWKH7HVW5HSRUW

 59DOXHLVOLVWHGRQWKH7HVW5HSRUWIURP&DOFRDVW$QDO\WLFDOIRU5RRI&RDWLQJ([WHULRUDQG,QWHULRU

)RU\RXUKDQG\UHIHUHQFHDWWDFKHGLVWKH7HVW5HSRUW

,DPDOVRDWWDFKLQJRXU6800$5<2)2),&,$/7(675(325763HUWLQHQWWHVWVDUHXQGHU,WHPDQG

:HDUHDOZD\VGHSHQGLQJRQWKHDFFUHGLWHGWHVWLQJLQVWLWXWLRQVWKHUHIRUH,KDYHQRFRPPHQWWR$\WDFFDOFXODWLRQV

%HVW5HJDUGV

3HWHU

1RWH2PDU,KDYHQRWHGRQP\6N\SHWKDW\RXFDOOHGODVW)ULGD\DW$0P\WLPHDQGWRGD\DW$0P\WLPH3OHDVH

UHPHPEHUWKDW,DPPLQXVKRXUVIURP*HUPDQWLPH

,QDPHVVDJHGDWHG$0(DVWHUQ6WDQGDUG7LPH ZULWHV

+L3HWHU

WKDQNVIRUWKHYDOXDEOHH[SODQDWLRQV,XQGHUVWDQGQRZPRUHDERXWWKHWKHRU\1RZLWVKRXOGEHHDV\WRDQVZHU

WKHIROORZLQJTXHVWLRQV

ϭͿ tŚĂƚŝƐŽƵƌ>ĂŵďĚĂʄsĂůƵĞ;tͬŵ<ͿĨŽƌdžƚĞƌŝŽƌ͕/ŶƚĞƌŝŽƌĂŶĚZŽŽĨŽĂƚ͍

ϮͿ tŚĂƚŝƐŽƵƌZsĂůƵĞ;ŵϮ<ͬtͿĨŽƌdžƚĞƌŝŽƌ͕/ŶƚĞƌŝŽƌĂŶĚZŽŽĨŽĂƚ͍

/ŶƚŚĞĂ͘ ĂĐŚĞĚĮůĞ;LJƚĂĐͿLJŽƵǁŝůůƐĞĞƐŽŵĞĐĂůĐƵůĂŽŶƐŽĨƚŚĞƐĞs ĂůƵĞƐ;>ĂŵďĚĂĂŶĚZͿ͕ĐĂŶLJŽƵƉƵƚ

ŽƵƌĮŐƵƌĞƐŝŶƚŚŝƐĂƩĂĐŚĞĚĐĂůĐƵůĂŽŶƐĂŶĚƐĞŶĚ ŵĞĂŶĞdžĂŵƉůĞ͘WĞŽƉůĞŚĞƌĞĂƌĞŵĞĂŶǁŚŝůĞ

ǀĞƌLJĨĂŵŝůŝĂƌǁŝƚŚƚŚĞƐĞŶŐŽĨƚŚŝƐĐ ĂůĐƵůĂŽŶ͕ƐŽŝĨǁ ĞĐĂŶƉƵƚŽƵƌŽǁŶĮŐƵƌĞƐŝŶƐŝĚĞƚŚŝƐĐĂůĐƵůĂŽŶƐ

ǁĞŵŝŐŚƚĞŶĚƵƉǁŝƚŚďĞƩĞƌƌĞƐƵůƚƐ͕ƚŚƵƐďĞƩĞƌĂƌŐƵŵĞŶƚƐ͘

ƌ

KŵĂƌ

76KLHOG([SRUW# KDWDP0lU]XPJHVFKULHEHQ

'HDU2PDU\RXUTXHVWLRQ,DPVWLOOORRNLQJIRUZDUGRI\RXUWKH/DPEGD9DOXHH[SODQDWLRQV

$QVZHU7KHUPDOFRQGXFWLYLW\DOVRNQRZQDV/DPEGDGHQRWHGE\WKH*UHHNV\PEROLVWKH

PHDVXUHRIKRZHDVLO\KHDWIORZVWKURXJKDVSHFLILFW\SHRIPDWHULDOLQGHSHQGHQWRIWKHWKLFNQHVV

RIWKHPDWHULDOLQTXHVWLRQ,WLVPHDVXUHGLQ:DWWVSHU0HWUH.HOYLQ:PN

2XU&DOLIRUQLDWHVWVKRZVWKH/DPEGDIRURXU([WHULRU,QWHULRUDQG5RRI&RDW

59DOXHLVDPHDVXUHRIUHVLVWDQFHWRKHDWIORZWKURXJKDJLYHQWKLFNQHVVRIPDWHULDO+LJKHUWKH5

9DOXHWKHPRUHWKHUPDOUHVLVWDQFHWKHPDWHULDOKDVDQGWKHUHIRUHWKHEHWWHULWVLQVXODWLQJSURSHUWLHV

5 //DPEGD

/LVWKHWKLFNQHVVRIWKHPDWHULDOLQPHWUHVDQG/DPEGDLVWKHWKHUPDOFRQGXFWLYLW\LQ:P.

7KH5YDOXHLVPHDVXUHGLQPHWUHVVTXDUHG.HOYLQSHU:DWWP.:

([KLELW5 
-----

 Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 5H/DPEGD5DQG8 Page 66 of 75 PageID 80 

7KH89DOXHRIDEXLOGLQJHOHPHQWLVWKHLQYHUVHRIWKHWRWDOWKHUPDOUHVLVWDQFHRIWKDWHOHPHQW7KH

89DOXHLVDPHDVXUHRIKRZPXFKKHDWLVORVWWKURXJKDJLYHQWKLFNQHVVRIDSDUWLFXODUPDWHULDOEXW

LQFOXGHVWKHWKUHHPDMRUZD\VLQZKLFKKHDWORVVRFFXUVFRQGXFWLRQFRQYHFWLRQDQGUDGLDWLRQ7KH

ORZHUWKH89DOXHLVWKHEHWWHUWKHPDWHULDOLVDVDKHDWLQVXODWRU

+HUHDUHVRPHH[SODQDWLRQVZKLFKZLOOPDNHLWHDVLHUIRU\RXWRXQGHUVWDQGKRZWKHWHFKQRORJ\

ZRUNV

<RXFRXOGUHDGWKURXJKWKHEORJKWWSEORJFRROURRIPHZKLFKH[SODLQVWKHVFLHQFHEHKLQG&RRO

5RRIV65,6RODU5HIOHFWDQFH,QGH[LVH[SODLQHGLQFOHDUWHUPV3OD\WKHYLGHRZLWKWKLVEORJ

KWWSFRROURRIVRUJLVWKHRIILFLDOZHEVLWHRIWKHRUJDQLVDWLRQLQWDQGHPZLWK(QHUJ\6WDUWKDWUDWHV

&RRO5RRISURGXFWVOLNH7KHUPR6KLHOGWKURXJKDFWXDOILHOG7HVWVUXQRYHUWKUHH\HDUV



$OO5HVLVWDQFHRIKHDWLQFRQGXFWLRQLVSURSRUWLRQDOWRWKHWKLFNQHVVRIWKHUHVLVWDQFHEDUULHU

:LWKKLJK65,FRDWLQJOLNH7KHUPR6KLHOGZHDUHQRWGHDOLQJZLWK&RQGXFWDQFHRIKHDW7KHVXUIDFH

GRHVQ
WEHFRPHWKDWKRWZLWKWKH6XQ
VUD\VE\QHJDWLQJWKH89DQG,5

6XQOLJKWE\LWVHOILVQRWKRWKHDWLVJHQHUDWHGZKHQ89DQG,5JHWVDEVRUEHG7KHUPR6KLHOG

UHIOHFWVLW

,DPDOVRDWWDFKLQJDGRFXPHQW&RRO5RRI$QDO\VLVZKLFKZLOOJLYH\RXDEHWWHUSLFWXUHRIKRZ65,

ZRUNV

3OHDVHUHDGDJDLQWKHHDUOLHUHPDLOVEHORZDVZHOOWKH3ROLVK6WXG\SURYLGHGHDUOLHU

)URP76KLHOG([SRUW#

7R

&&WKHUPRVKLHOGJHRUJH#

VSP#WKHUPRVKLHOGFRP

WVKLHOGH[SRUW#

6HQW$0(DVWHUQ6WDQGDUG7LPH

6XEM5H59DOXH.9DOXHDQGWKHUPDOFRQGXFWLYLW\

'HDU2PDU

KHUHLVVRPHPRUHDQDO\VLV7KHUPR6KLHOGZRUNVVXPPHUZLQWHU

'85,1*6800(5

7KHUPR6KLHOGGXHWRKLJK6RODU5HIOHFWLYLW\,QGH[RI65,WR65,ZKLFK

IXQFWLRQVRQWKHEDVLVRI5HIOHFWLYLW\RIWKHEHVWZKLWHVXUIDFHDQG7KHUPDO(PLWWDQFH

RIWKHEHVWEODFNVXUIDFHSUHYHQWVWKHH[WHULRUZDOOVXEVWUDWHIURPKHDWLQJXS7KLV

SUHYHQWVH[FHVVLYH+HDW%XLOW8SDURXQGWKHEXLOGLQJHQVXULQJORZHUWHPSHUDWXUHRI

DLUWKDWLVWDNHQLQ65,YDOXHRIPHDQV=(526RODU+HDWJDLQ

7KH+LJK(PLVVLYLW\RI7KHUPR6KLHOGZLOODOVRPHDQIDVWHUGLVVLSDWLRQRIKHDW

UHGXFLQJWKHWHQGHQF\IRUWKHXQLWWREHD+RW/XQFK%R[

'85,1*:,17(5

,IZLQGGULYHQUDLQKLWVWKHH[WHULRUZDOO7KHUPR6KLHOGSRO\PHUVVZHOODQGEHFRPH

ZDWHUWLJKW9DULDEOH3HUPHDELOLW\FRDWLQJPHPEUDQHEUHDGLQJZKHQGU\:LWK

RUGLQDU\SDLQWZKLFKGRHVQRWSUHYHQWPRLVWXUHWRSHQHWUDWHWKHH[WHULRUZDOO

HYHQPRLVWXUHFRQWHQWLQWKHZDOOZLWKRUGLQDU\LQVXODWLRQ6W\URIRDPURFNZRRO

HWFFDQUHGXFHWKH5YDOXHE\DVPXFKDVZKRSSLQJ

,KRSHWKLVKHOSV

0\%HVW

3HWHU

,QDPHVVDJHGDWHG$0(DVWHUQ6WDQGDUG7LPH

ZULWHV

+L3HWHU

([KLELW5 
----

 Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 5H/DPEGD5DQG8 Page 67 of 75 PageID 81 

PDQ\WKDQNVIRUWKHGHWDLOHGH[SODQDWLRQLWZDVYHU\KHOSIXO

D&RXOGZHVD\WKDW7KHUPR6KLHOGSURGXFWVFDQEHPRVWO\VROGLQ

ZDUPHUDQGKXPLGDUHDVZHVWDQGVRXWKFRDVWLQ7XUNH\UDWKHUWKDQ

WKHFROGDUHDVPLGGOHQRUWKDQGHDVWEHFDXVHRILWVVXSHULRUSURSHUWLHV

UHJDUGLQJUHIOHFWDQFHDQGHPPLWDQFH

$V\RXNQRZZHZDQWWRPDNHDSURVSHFWWDUJHWLQJWKHPRVWDSSURSULDWH

FXVWRPHUVZKHUHWKHGLIIHUHQFHRIWKH7KHUPR6KLHOGLVXQGLVSXWDEOH

7KLVGRHVQRWPHDQWKDWZHFRPSOHWHO\OHDYHRXWPLGGOHQRUWKDQG

HDVW7XUNH\RXWRIWKHHTXDWLRQEXWUDWKHUFRQFHQWUDWLQJRQWKHPDLQ

WDUJHW

3OHDVHOHWPHNQRZLIP\DSSURDFKLVZURQJ"

E-XVWRXWRIDWHFKQLFDOFXULRVLW\GRQ
W\RXWKLQNWKDWLQDGLUHFW

FRPSDULVRQ7KHUPR6KLHOGFDQKDYHEHWWHU.9DOXHWKDQ6W\URIRDP

(36"&DXVHWKLVPDWHULDOLVMXVWWREHG,I\HVFDQZHVRPHKRZSURYH

LWLQDGLUHFWFRPSDULVRQ"&RXOG\RXSOHDVHJLYHPHDKLQW"

%U

2PDU

76KLHOG([SRUW# KDWDP1RYHPEHUXP

JHVFKULHEHQ

7KHUPR6KLHOGLVQRWLQWHQGHGWRUHSODFHWKHFXUUHQW

LQVXODWLRQEXLOGLQJVKDYHEXWUDWKHUWRFRPSOLPHQWZKDWLV

H[LVWLQJDQGPDNHWKHEXLOGLQJPXFKPXFKPRUHHIILFLHQW

E\UHIOHFWLQJDQGGLVVLSDWLQJRYHURIWKHVXQ
VHQHUJ\

EDFNLQWRWKHDWPRVSKHUHUDWKHUWKDQKDYHLWDEVRUEHGE\

WKHVWUXFWXUH7KLVLQWXUQZLOODOORZ\RXUFOLHQWWR

VLJQLILFDQWO\UHGXFHWKHNLORZDWWVFRQVXPHGWRNHHSWKH

EXLOGLQJVLQWKHWHPSHUDWXUHUDQJHUHTXLUHG

)<,%HORZ,KDYHSURYLGHGDQH[SODQDWLRQRIKRZ

7KHUPR6KLHOGZRUNVDQGKRZLWLVGLIIHUHQWIURPRWKHU

SURGXFWV,7,6,03257$177+$7(9(5<21(

([KLELW5 
--------------------

---------------------------

 Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 5H/DPEGD5DQG8 Page 68 of 75 PageID 82 

81'(567$1'67+(&21&(372)+2:7+(502

6+,(/'352'8&(67+(75(0(1'286(1(5*<

6$9,1*67+$7,7'2(6,1$'',7,21727+(0$1<

27+(5%(1(),766HH7+(7+(5026+,(/'

',))(5(1&(RQRXUZHEVLWH

2QHRIWKHNH\LQJUHGLHQWVLQ7KHUPR6KLHOGLVRXU

SURSULHWDU\EOHQGRIKROORZFHUDPLFPLFURVSKHUHVDQG

KROORZJODVVEXEEOHV7KHUHDVRQWKHVHDUHVXFKNH\

LQJUHGLHQWVLVWKDWWKH\KDYHDYDFXXPHGFHQWHU

VXUURXQGHGE\DQRQFRQGXFWLYHPDWHULDOZKLFKXOWLPDWHO\

GRHVQ
WDOORZKHDWWRSHQHWUDWH

:KHQWU\LQJWRXQGHUVWDQG7KHUPR6KLHOGWKHUHDUHWZR

SURSHUWLHVWKDWRQHPXVWXQGHUVWDQG7KHILUVWLVWKDWRI

VRODUUHIOHFWDQFHDQGWKHVHFRQGLVWKHUPDOHPLWWDQFH

7KHVHDUHWKHWZRSURSHUWLHVWKDWDOORZ7KHUPR6KLHOGWR

UHIOHFWDQGHPLWWKHVXQ
VKHDWEDFNWRWKHVN\LQVWHDGRI

WUDQVIHUULQJLWLQWRWKHEXLOGLQJEHORZ5HIOHFWDQFHLVDQ

HDV\FRQFHSWWRXQGHUVWDQG%DVLFDOO\WKHVXQ
VUDGLDWLRQ

KLWVWKHVXUIDFHRIWKHEXLOGLQJDQGUHIOHFWDQFHLVWKH

SHUFHQWDJHRIWKHVRODUHQHUJ\WKDWLVUHIOHFWHGDZD\

$FFRUGLQJWR$670WHVW&SHUIRUPHGE\5	'

6HUYLFHVIRUWKH&RRO5RRI5DWLQJ&RXQFLO7KHUPR6KLHOG

UHIOHFWVRIWKHVXQ
VUDGLDWLRQ7KLVOHDYHVRQO\RI

WKHVXQ
VHQHUJ\WKDWFRXOGEHDEVRUEHGE\WKHEXLOGLQJ

+RZHYHUKHUHLVZKHUHWKHUPDOHPLWWDQFHFRPHVLQWRSOD\

7KLVLVDFRQFHSWWKDW
VDOLWWOHKDUGHUWRXQGHUVWDQGEXW

H[WUHPHO\LPSRUWDQWEHFDXVHLWWUXO\VHSDUDWHV7KHUPR

6KLHOGIURPSURGXFWVRQWKHPDUNHWWKDWRQO\GHDOZLWKVRODU

UHIOHFWDQFH

%DVLFDOO\HPLWWDQFHLVWKHUHODWLYHDELOLW\RIWKHVXUIDFHWR

UDGLDWHDZD\DEVRUEHGKHDW6RLQWKHFDVHRI7KHUPR

6KLHOGLWZRXOGEHWKHDELOLW\WRUDGLDWHDZD\WKHRIWKH

VXQ
VHQHUJ\WKDWZDVQ
WUHIOHFWHGDZD\DOUHDG\

$FFRUGLQJWRWKH$670&WHVWSHUIRUPHGE\WKH5	'

6HUYLFHVIRU&RRO5RRI5DWLQJ&RXQFLO7KHUPR6KLHOGZLOO

HPLWDZD\RIWKHRIWKHVXQ
VHQHUJ\WKDWZDVQRW

UHIOHFWHGDZD\DOUHDG\7KLVPHDQVWKDWDQDGGLWLRQDO

RIWKHVXQ
VHQHUJ\RQWRSRIWKHLVQRORQJHUEHLQJ

DEVRUEHGE\WKHVWUXFWXUHDVKHDW

6REDVLFDOO\DQDVWRXQGLQJRIWKHVXQ
VHQHUJ\LV

QRWDOORZHGWREHFRPHKHDWLQWKHEXLOGLQJ7KLVLVZK\

7KHUPR6KLHOG
VVXUIDFHLVFRROWRWKHWRXFKRQH[WUHPHO\

KRWVXQQ\GD\V

7KHIDFWWKDW7KHUPR6KLHOGLQFRUSRUDWHVHQRXJKRIWKHVH

KROORZFHUDPLFPLFURVSKHUHVDQGJODVVEXEEOHVWREHFRPH

RIWKHILQLVKHGSURGXFWZKHQFXUHGLVZKHUH7KHUPR

6KLHOGLVWUXO\DVXSHULRUSURGXFWDVIDUDVHQHUJ\VDYLQJV

DQGSURWHFWLRQ

,QDPHVVDJHGDWHG30(DVWHUQ

6WDQGDUG7LPH ZULWHV

+L3HWHU

([KLELW5 
 Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 5H/DPEGD5DQG8 Page 69 of 75 PageID 83 

,XQGHUVWDQGWKHVWXGLHVEXWZKDWFDQ,VD\WR

WKHVLPSOHSHRSOHDERXWWKH.9DOXHHWF1RW

DOOWKHWXUNLVKSHRSOHFDQXQGHUVWDQGHQJOLVK

YHU\ZHOOQHLWKHUWKHYHU\WHFKQLFDOVWXGLHV

ZLWKGLIIHUHQWDSSURDFKHVRQWKHWRSLF

'R\RXKDYHPRUHVLPSOHDQGSUDFWLFDO

DQVZHUWRWKHWRSLFV

D5YDOXHRU.YDOXH

E7KHUPDOFRQGXFWLYLW\SURYLGHGDQGQHHGWR

EHXVHGIRUFDOFXODWLRQ

LQFRPSDULVRQEHWZHHQ7KHUPR

6KLHOGSURGXFWVDQGIROORZLQJLQVXODWLRQ

SURGXFWVVXFKDV6W\URIRDP(36JODVVZRRO

DQGURFNZRROQRGLUHFWFRPSDULVRQWKDWLV

ZK\,JLYH\RXWKH3ROLVK6WXG\WRIXUWKHU

XQGHUVWDQGEHVLGHP\H[SODQDWLRQDERYH,I

ZLQGGULYHQUDLQKLWVWKHH[WHULRUZDOO7KHUPR

6KLHOGSRO\PHUVVZHOODQGEHFRPHZDWHUWLJKW

:LWKRUGLQDU\SDLQWHYHQPRLVWXUH

FRQWHQWLQWKHZDOOZLWKRUGLQDU\LQVXODWLRQ

URFNZRROHWFFDQUHGXFHWKH5YDOXHE\DV

PXFKDVZKRSSLQJ

6RGXULQJWKHVXPPHUKHDWPXFKDVFDQEHVDYHGRQ

$&GXULQJWKHZLQWHUWKH7KHUPR6KLHOG,QWHULRUZLWK

FRPELQDWLRQRI([WHULRUFDQVDYHRIHQHUJ\

$WWDFKHLVDSUDFWLFDOVWXG\RIWZRLGHQWLFDOKRXVHVVHH

EHORZIRUDPRQWKV\HDUURXQG.:FRQVXPSWLRQ

$WWDFKHGLVDOVR)LHOGWHVWUHSRUWFRPSDULQJWZRLGHQWLFDO

KRXVHVEXLOWRQHFRDWHGZLWK76([WHULRU7DQGWKHRWKHU

RQHZLWKDFRPPHUFLDOSDLQW&7DEOH,,VKRZLQJHQHUJ\

H[SHQGHGLQ.:EHWZHHQKRXVH&DQGKRXVH7

HOHFWULFDOO\KHDWHG$&KRXVHV7KHKRXVH&XVHGD

WRWDORI.:\HDUDQGKRXVH7XVHGD.:

\HDU7KHVLPSOHFDOFXODWLRQEHWZHHQWKH.:H[SHQGHG

EHWZHHQWZRKRXVHVIRUWKHPRQWKVSHULRGVKRZLQJWKH

WRWDOVDYLQJVRI.:HTXDOWRRIHQHUJ\

VDYLQJVIRUWKH\HDU

%HVW5HJDUGV

3HWHU

<RXUDQVZHULVPXFKDSSUHFLDWHG

%U

2PDU

([KLELW5 
 Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 70 of 75 PageID 84 5H/DPEGD5DQG8

([KLELW5 
Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 71 of 75 PageID 85 

EXHIBIT S 
Based on these comments imagine 

what THERMO-SHIELD' Fluid Applied 

Ceramic Coatings will do for you: 

"We have raised rabbits for the past six years and 

heat Inside the hutches has always boon~­

problem. We applied THEAMO,SHIELo• to the 

hutches and within flltoon mlnutes the Inside 

temperature dropped from 102 lo 74 degrees F 

Needless to say, we are Impressed." -Marilyn c., 

Denver, Colorado 

"We have always had lo repair our building's root 

every year and still Ille leaks would come back. 

our tenants were becoming very Irritated an<! 

threatening lo move out. Your product has totally 

stopped all our problems, which Is quite an 

amazing feat." -J.W,H., Aberdeen, South Dakota 

"As you know, we had a number of !fat roof 

buildings Wllh severe, constant leakfng problems, 

We had tried everything and ournht step wa5 to 

build pitched roots over them. About that lime we 

bec.,meaware ot THERMO-SHIELD• and I am 

pleased to say - It has solved all our problems. 

coole<l lhe building&, and saved the city a 

i.lgnlficant amount of money." -Dale 0 .. City of 

Colorado Springs 

" Thank you for your technfcal and practical 

suppQrt. I ~m pleased with the ease ol appllcatlon 

without having to rent any expensive equ1pmenl 

Our energy research building i s a polyurethane 

dome shaped bulldlng and coating II wltll 

THERMO,SHIELO'" couldn'I hoveboen easier. I 

will be happy to infotm anyone about your very 

fine product," ~Leooard G., Physics OepL, Univ, 

ot Colorado 

"I t,ave Just llnlshod painting the e.,orior walls ot 

my house and I am very Impressed as lo how 

much cooler the tnsldeot our house ls. Friends 

comment that they are amazed how cool It ls and 

can hardly believe we don't have an air 

conditioner. Outside temperatures can be In the 

90'saod 100'sand our house stays In the 70's." 

-Larry K., Eureka, Sou th oa~o1a 

"Our Arizona weather gets very hot and we Just 

had a chance to see Immediately wMt your 

product would do In turning back heat. I must 

say. II did a powerful Job, Our THERMO-SHIELD" 

roof seems destined 10 help solve a big heal 

problem. We will keep you lnlormed." -Robert S., 

Mesa, Arizona 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 72 of 75 PageID 86 

 ([KLELW6
THERMO-SHIELD • means 

Thermal Control 

THERMO-SP-ii ELD• ls a proven superior lnsulatrng material. 

Key among the advanced fealures of THERMO-SHIELD• Is 

the placement of a newly developed hollow ceramic 

micro-sphere as a oomponant specfally formulated with a 

acrylic mastic that keeps lhe 1>orosilicate ceramic spheres 

in uniforrn suspension. Surfaces lhal are ooated wllh 

THERMO-SHIELD· are re1uc1ant 10 conouct f'leat and 

refraoc as well as dlslllpate heat away from the surface. 

Because It 1s fl uid applied, II forms a seamless monollthis 

seal, ellmlnatlng virtually all air lnllllratlon which c.an be a 

ma1or source of heal transfer in bu tidings. These fac1ors 

equate lo substantlal reductions In energy usage and cost.s. 

THERMO-SHIELD · means 

Noise Control 

THERMO-SHIELD• Is Ideal wherever sound level reductions 

are required, Unli~i;, other products I hat absorb sound and 

thereby transmit noise, THERMO-SHIELD• rellects sound 

back to the source, not allowing the surface to conduct 

$OU no. This makes the proouct an excellant choice for some 

epr;>licallons such a~ motel and hotel rooms and 01her 

public buildings where excessive no1se levels occur. 

THERMO-SHIELD means 

Condensation and 

Water Penentration Control 

7'HEAMO-SH1ELO • has excellent elongation and recovery 

properties This property yields a protective barrier resistant 

to hall, wal&r and wind oama,ge. TM hollow ceramic 

mlcrospheres used In THERMOSHIELD · are over60 

p11roen1 volQ 1 hey are bonded directly to the surface 

!arming a seamless blanket. This eliminates any warrn air to 

cold surface conlac t and reduces the temperature 

dl!lerenllal thereby reducing or ellmlnallng condensation. In 

areas where excessive moisture Is ptesent It Is necessary to 

provide adequate ventilatlon. 

SPM T.Him.MO-SHlELO, LNe. 

4?15 lbulemakc t-1:unmook Ro:ld #2~ 

Napl<>, Plurl<I• .'4113 USA 

Tel1 239-23-1-5832 Fw<: 239-2.16-6767 

@ltllk.tbrriuowh•tlO,tPUI w~ 1r.rl tm11mh1!:!rl,1·w 

ln-41.tt acrylic. eleiuomerlcerl'lul!llon ayateml, •.s tt1e Wilt tu 

evaporales the- hollow ca,amle 1pf1eru ap"toaCh each otmu, 

evontu•lly 1ouch on(! tuse 1n100 contllluOu• lilm, 

.Anf$1,, • w•n C0111U\QC.1>J"0\11d~1'" •'(t:sa&nl -.t\l,n(I 

~nlrol Wl'Uln UNO on OOnt>o!i, UIQlOJ:i'; On)' ilfrta .,,,tu.a 

ox~tva t,d\!H! Jevot5 c•n OGC).lr 'ilfld at th~ 3amt lime .... beoull!lo» ijOd' o•Qlemo. 

rn .. p,~i,c;t lS exceUonl tor lnsula1h"W Uotn th!! oulsld!t wnile ill the 

samo lime iuopplltg m(.>l!=tu,u peocrrotlun and tho 1\115.Uftlng orncklng 

thin 1iikea ptut\.' Surface Cfms ato gomplelety hkklen 

,- ____ ... 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 73 of 75 PageID 87 

 ([KLELW6
Thofm0,Sh1e1.1._. ,oor oooungs prov,oe a fire.ano waall'lor 

,es,~la-nt tlnilhle t.()aHng 1h;u can reduc:.e eneroy eo!III up to O'f, 

ftnu1mi•Sh111lli • ,oot coB11ngs 11a w1lu.rp,ool. da&oen 

:.Ound. p(OvOnl$ ,ct.If lflo..iornont anQ ve hailt 11"11:1 n,e 

retl•1,n1 

How the Fluid Applied Ceramic 

Coating System Works 

THERMO·SHIELD • dlffets from other methods of ln$ula1,on 

beoause of It's unique formvla thal takes advantal)e of 

3 LAWS OF PHYSJCS'. 

1 . THERMO·SHIELD • provides a curable therrnat bat(ier, 

The insulating hollow ceramic beads incorporated In the 

THERMOSHIELD • formula behave much like glass but even 

more eltlalen1. Glass canoe hea1ed tly a torch until It melts 

and yet It can be satety held In hand at lhe same lime. 

2. THERMO-SHIELD• dissipates heat, Within 10 seconds 

of removing a blowtorch llama from a glass rod or the hollow 

ceramic beads, they can be safely handed rrom one hand to 

another, TI1al means lhat over 2000 degre,;,s of heat have 

been dlssfpated in less than 10 secon<ls. 

3. The hollow ceramic mlcrospheres reflecllve quality 

affects the warming phenomenon called " Mean Radiant 

Temperature." where heat waves from a source such as 

direct sunlight cause a person to feel warmer even though 

the actual air temperature Is no different between a shady 

and a sunny location. It ls the molecular fliction within the 

skin which makes the body reel warmer, So the surroundlnq 

air can be cooler bUI the body will feel warmer in the 

presence of THERMO-SHIELD• , 01eur1ing thermostats oan 

be set lower lor the same degrne ol comfort 

Hcnt kept our of the building 

doesn't have to be remove(/! 

Fluid Applied Ceramic Roof 

and Wall Coatings 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 74 of 75 PageID 88 

 ([KLELW6
Heat Loss or Gain 

Reduce Noise levels 

Condensation Control 

m'>·" ·rJ'll• 1 '" 111 ui,, rt'"'·"'" ,urrrpp 1,, •h ,m, .11n 1J: n nh 

L9L9"'X?•GfZ ""'.:I Z£llS-trz·6£Z ' 'l>.L 

VSO ( II tt" "Jlf'Ol,j '» 1dnN 

9YG# irnoH >t:tuw1ur.H -"tr,u.Q:.11rnH Sl6t 

":)Nl '073TI-£S·OWlJITRL WdS 

Insulates with a beautiful 

finish 

Repairs Interior and 

Exterior Surface Cracks 

Restores Appearance of 

Old Surfaces 

Protects Substrate from 

Sun's Ultraviolet Rays 

Excellent Adhesion to a 

Variety of Substrates 

Superior Flexibility at 

Extremely Low 

Temperatures 

Case 2:20-cv-00542 Document 1-1 Filed 07/28/20 Page 75 of 75 PageID 89 

 ([KLELW6