UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 

____________________________________ 

 ) 

In the Matter of ) 

 ) 

ECM BioFilms, Inc., ) Docket No. 9358 

a corporation, also d/b/a ) 

Enviroplastics International ) PUBLIC DOCUMENT 

 ) 

JOINT STIPULATIONS ON ADMISSIBILITY OF EXHIBITS 

 The parties hereby stipulate and agree: 

1. The exhibits listed hereto in Attachment A are admitted without objection. 

Exhibit A reflects the parties’ best efforts to remove duplicates from the joint list and to reinclude documents removed inadvertently at earlier stages. Exhibit A does not include 

documents that the Court admitted at trial notwithstanding an objection made on the record. 

2. A document need not be admissible to be used solely to impeach. 

3. The exhibits cited in the withdrawn expert report of Alexander Volokh (“Volokh 

Report”) are not in evidence to the extent that they have no independent basis for admissibility. 

The parties agree that all such documents are listed on Exhibit B hereto. Certain other exhibits 

cited in the withdrawn Volokh Report are in evidence by agreement, and they are included on 

Exhibit A hereto. 

4. Exhibit A contains RX-717, which is a composite exhibit of multiple documents 

originally entitled “[c]ertain docs considered by Volokh.” The parties agree that only those 

portions of RX-717 that are business records produced by third parties in response to a subpoena 

or document request are in evidence. 

5. As with all documents in evidence, the parties reserve their right to argue that 

documents not used at trial and cited in the withdrawn Volokh Report should receive no weight, 

or substantial weight, depending on any consideration the Court finds relevant to determining 

their probative value. 

09 04 2014
PUBLIC DOCUMENT 

2 

Dated: September 4, 2014 Respectfully submitted, 

 /s/ Katherine Johnson 

 Katherine Johnson (kjohnson3@ftc.gov) 

Jonathan Cohen (jcohen2@ftc.gov) 

Arturo DeCastro (adecastro@ftc.gov) 

Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W. M-8102B 

Washington, DC 20580 

Phone: 202-326-2185; -2551; -2747 

Fax: 202-326-2551 

And 

/s/ Jonathan W. Emord 

Jonathan W. Emord (jemord@emord.com)

Peter A. Arhangelsky 

(parhangelsky@emord.com)

Eric J. Awerbuch (eawerbuch@emord.com) 

Bethany R. Kennedy 

(BKennedy@emord.com) Emord & Associates, P.C.

11808 Wolf Run Lane, Clifton, VA 20124

Phone: (202) 388-8899

Fax: (202) 466-6938

 
PUBLIC DOCUMENT 

3 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

 I hereby certify that on September 4, 2014, I caused a true and correct copy of the 

foregoing document to be served as follows: 

One electronic courtesy copy and one hard copy to the Office of the Secretary: 

Donald S. Clark, Secretary 

Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Room H-159 

Washington, DC 20580 

Email: secretary@ftc.gov 

One electronic and one paper courtesy copy to the Office of the Administrative Law Judge: 

The Honorable D. Michael Chappell 

Administrative Law Judge 

600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Room H-110 

Washington, DC 20580 

One electronic copy to Counsel for the Respondent:

Jonathan W. Emord

Emord & Associates, P.C. 

11808 Wolf Run Lane 

Clifton, VA 20124 

Email: jemord@emord.com 

Peter Arhangelsky 

Emord & Associates, P.C. 

3210 S. Gilbert Road, Suite 4 

Chandler, AZ 85286 

Email: parhangelsky@emord.com 

Eric J. Awerbuch Bethany R. Kennedy 

Emord & Associates, P.C. Emord & Associates, P.C. 

3210 S. Gilbert Road, Suite 4 3210 S. Gilbert Road, Suite 4 

Chandler, AZ 85286 Chandler, AZ 85286 

Email: eawerbuch@emord.com Email: BKennedy@emord.com 

Date: September 4, 2014 /s/ Katherine Johnson 

 Katherine Johnson (kjohnson3@ftc.gov) 

Jonathan Cohen (jcohen2@ftc.gov) 

Arturo DeCastro (adecastro@ftc.gov) 

Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania Ave., N.W. M-8102B 

Washington, DC 20580 

Phone: 202-326-2185; -2551; -2747 

Fax: 202-326-2551 
Exhibit No. Description Date BegBates EndBates Admissibiity 

CCX-0 Mug with ECM leaf logo No Date ECM-FTC-0000065 ECM-FTC-0000065 3.43(b) & (e) 

CCX-00

Cobs Bread: ECM Website listed on plastic bag No Date ECM-113045 ECM-113045 3.43(b) 

CCX-0001 ECM BioFilms Certificate (Redacted) 6/16/2007 ECM-FTC-000015 ECM-FTC-000015 3.43(b) & (e) CCX-0002

Certificate of Assurance of Minimum Loading Rate 9/22/2011 ECM-FTC-000016 ECM-FTC-000016 3.43(b) & (e) 

CCX-0003

ECM BioFilms Flyer (9 months - 5 years) (Complaint Exhibit 2) No Date ECM-FTC-000017 ECM-FTC-000017 3.43(b) & (e) 

CCX-0004

ECM BioFilms Mechanism for the Biodegradation of Products No Date ECM-FTC-000044 ECM-FTC-000044 3.43(b) & (e) 

CCX-0005

ECM BioFilms Life Expectancy of Master Pellets No Date ECM-FTC-000053 ECM-FTC-000053 3.43(b) & (e) 

CCX-0006

ECM BioFilms - Our Technology for Biodegradation of Plastic Products No Date ECM-FTC-000058 ECM-FTC-000058 3.43(b) & (e) 

CCX-0007

ECM Biofilms Brochure: Are YOU thinking about Sustainability? (Complaint Ex. 3) No Date ECM-FTC-000062 ECM-FTC-000074 3.43(b) & (e) 

CCX-0008 ECM BioFilms Logo No Date ECM-FTC-000066 ECM-FTC-000066 3.43(b) & (e) CCX-0009 ECM BioFilms Leaf No Date ECM-FTC-000067 ECM-FTC-000067 3.43(b) & (e) CCX-0010

ECM BioFilms Letter to Interested Parties 1/16/2007 ECM-FTC-000481 ECM-FTC-000482 3.43(b) & (e) 

CCX-0011 ECM BioFilms Letter to Interested Party 12/3/2008 ECM-FTC-000488 ECM-FTC-000489 3.43(b) & (e) CCX-0012

ECM BioFIlms Comparison of Competing Biodegradable Plastics Chart 6/16/2008 ECM-FTC-000492 ECM-FTC-000492 3.43(b) & (e) 

CCX-0013 ECM BioFilms Logo No Date ECM-FTC-000551 ECM-FTC-000551 3.43(b) & (e) CCX-0014

ECM Biofilms Certificate of Biodegradability (Redacted) 1/26/2013 ECM-FTC-000552 ECM-FTC-000552 3.43(b) & (e) 

CCX-0015 ECM BioFilms Flyer (some period) No Date ECM-001882 ECM-001882 3.43(b) & (e) CCX-0017

ECM BioFilms Comparison of competing biodegradable plastics chart 2/11/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0018

Certificate of the Biodegradability of Plastic Products Made by SL Plastic Co. LTD that Incorporate the ECM MasterBatch Pellet Technology (Complaint Exhibit 4) 2/8/2011 3.43(b) 

CCX-0019

ECM Website Excerpt (PDF) (Complaint Exhibit 1a) 8/9/2011 3.43(b) 

In the Matter of ECM Biofilms, Inc., No. 9358

Joint Exhibit List:JX-1-A - September 4, 2014

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 

1
CCX-0020

ECM Website Excerpt (PDF) (Complaint Exhibit 1b) 3/21/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0021 ECM PowerPoint Presentation No Date ECM-FTC-000553 ECM-FTC-000583 3.43(b) & (e) CCX-0022 ECM Interactive Website Capture 9/12/2012 3.43(b) CCX-0023 ECM Interactive Website Capture 3/21/2013 3.43(b) CCX-0024 ECM Website Capture (PDF) 8/9/2011 3.43(b) CCX-0025 ECM Website Capture (PDF) 3/21/2013 3.43(b) CCX-0029

It's Not Easy Being Green . . . Webpage 

Printout from American Plastic Manufacturing Website apmbags.com No Date ECM-112313 ECM-112315 3.43(b) 

CCX-0030

Printout of Webpages from American Plastic Manufacturing Website apmbags.com 8/10/2012 3.43(b) 

CCX-0031

Advertisement for American Plastics Manufacturing Biodegradable Bags No Date 3.43(b) 

CCX-0032

"Biodegradable" Bag for Organic Apples with ECM logo Distributed by CF Fresh Inc. No Date ECM-114289 ECM-114289 3.43(b) 

CCX-0033

Automated Packaging Systems, Inc.'s advertisement for EarthAware Films AirPouch Feb-09 APS-FTC 008676 APS-FTC 008676 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0034

Automated Packaging Systems, Inc.'s Airpouch Sales & Marketing Alert Oct-08 APS-FTC 008916 APS-FTC 008917 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0035

Automated Packaging Systems, Inc.'s EarthAware Biodegradable Film FAQs No Date APS-FTC 009291 APS-FTC 009292 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0036

Automated Packaging Systems, Inc.'s Guidelines for using the EarthAware Trademark on Bags and in Marketing Materials Feb-09 APS-FTC 009431 APS-FTC 00942 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0036A

Automated Packaging Systems, Inc.'s EarthAware Advertising for Biodegradable Low Density Polyethylene (ECLE) Mar-09 ECM-112331 ECM-112333 3.43(b) 

CCX-0037 BioPVC Website biopvc.com (PDF) 10/21/2011 3.43(b) CCX-0038

Buckeye Packaging Brochure for "Buckeye Bio" No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0039

Printout of Webpages on Zarma FLYtee from CHAMP Website champspikes.com 8/10/2012 3.43(b) 

CCX-0040 Cosmetic Essence FAQs No Date CE003 CE004 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0041

Crayex Advertising for TerraGuard - Biodegradable Film and Bags No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0042

Crayex TerraGuard Ad - Biodegradable what should I know? No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 

2
CCX-0043

D&W Finepack Advertising for Enviroware 2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0044

Print of Down to Earth Bag with ECM Logo No Date ECM-114511 ECM-114511 3.43(b) 

CCX-0046 Green Natura Bottle with ECM Website No Date ECM-113079 ECM-113079 3.43(b) CCX-0047 SolTerre Shampoo Label with ECM logo No Date ECM-113080 ECM-113080 3.43(b) CCX-0048

Product Information and Advertising for EcoSmart Plastics 2010 ECM-112385 ECM-112390 3.43(b) 

CCX-0049

Biodegradable Advertising for Epsilon Plastics, Inc. No Date ECM-114313 ECM-114313 3.43(b) 

CCX-0050

Biodegradable Advertising for Flambeau Products No Date ECM-113035 ECM-113042 3.43(b) 

CCX-0051

Flexible Plastics Inc: Biodegradable Advertising for Film 2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0052

Labels for FP International Inc.'s Biodegradable Black Liners No Date FPI-FTC00000027 FPI-FTC00000027 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0053

The Gilman Brother's Company Biodegradable Letter and Brochure Apr-08 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0054

The Gilman Brother's Company: Biodegradable Label 2/6/2008 ECM-113763 ECM-113763 3.43(b) 

CCX-0055

The Gilman Brother's Company: Certification of Biodegradability No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0056

Island Plastics: Brochure with ECM website No Date ECM-113268 ECM-113268 3.43(b) 

CCX-0057

Kappus Plastic: BioRigidBinyl Advertisement Sep-10 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0058

Kappus Plastic: BioRigidBinyl Product Certification No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0059

Excerpt from Medical Arts Press advertising describing "Biodegradable Supply Bags" 2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0060

Excerpt from Medical Arts Press advertising describing "Biodegradable Supply Bags" 2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0061

Parker Hannifin: Biodegradable Label (Umbra) No Date P42 P42 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0062

Perfect Line, LLC (Perfect Promotional LLC): Certificate of Biodegradability 12/7/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0063

Polar Tech Advertising for Biodegradable Pouch No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0064

Polar Tech Advertising for Biodegradable Mailers No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0065 Umbra Family Circle Excerpt 6/1/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0066 Umbra EcoPlastics Advertisement No Date 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0067 Winpak: Compliance Statement for 2011 1/20/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 

3
CCX-0068 Winpak: Compliance Statement for 2013 2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0069

Plastic printed with Cheesecake Factory by Shields No Date Shields000019 Shields000019 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0070

Plastic bag printed with Sentry by Shields No Date Shields000022 Shields000022 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0071 Dragonberry produce bag by Shields No Date Shields000013 Shields000013 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0072 Viva Tierra produce bag with ECM logo No Date Shields000025 Shields000025 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0073 Island Plastic Bags yard bag No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0074 Island Plastic Bags bag BD85163T No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0075 Island Plastic Bags bag No Date 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0076

Discover Credit Card labeled "Biodegradable" No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0077 Transilwrap Plastic Sheet No Date 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0078

Buckeye Packaging bag for BEAUTY.COM No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0079

Eaton Biodegradable Zipper Advertisment 7/30/2012 EA000098 EA000098 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0080

ASTM : D5338 -11 Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining Aerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under Controlled Composting Conditions IncorporatingThermophilic Temperatures) 4/1/2011 3.43(b) 

CCX-0081

ASTM : D5210 - 92 (Reapproved) Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining the Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials in the Presence of Municipal Sewer Sludge) 10/1/2007 3.43(b) 

CCX-0082

ASTM : D5338 - 98 (Reappoved) Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining Aerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under Controlled Composting Conditions) 12/1/2003 3M00000182 3M00000187 3.43(b) 

CCX-0083

ASTM : D5511 - 11 Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under High-Solids Anaerobic-Digestion Conditions) 2/1/2011 3.43(b) 

CCX-0084

ASTM : D5511 - 12 Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under High-Solids Anaerobic-Digestion Conditions) 8/14/2012 FTC_Prod_00265 FTC_Prod_00271 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 

4
CCX-0085

ASTM : D5511 - 94 Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under High-Solids Anaerobic Digestion Conditions) 2/15/1994 3.43(b) 

CCX-0086

ASTM : D5526 - 94 (Reapproved 2002) Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under Accelerated Landfill Conditions) 3/15/1994 3.43(b) 

CCX-0087

ASTM : D5526 -12 Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under Accelerated Landfill Conditions) 5/1/2012 3.43(b) 

CCX-0088

ASTM : D6340 - 98 Standard Test Method (Standard Test Methods for Determining Aerobic Biodegradation of Radiolabeled Plastic Materials in an Aqueous or Compost Environment) 11/10/1998 3.43(b) 

CCX-0089

ASTM : D6776 - 02 Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining Anaerobic Biodegradability of Radiolabeled Plastic Materialsin a Laboratory-Scale Simulated Landfill Environment) 3/10/2002 3.43(b) 

CCX-0090

ASTM : WIN 29802 Standard Specification (Standard Specification for Aerobically Biodegradable Plastics in Soil Environment in the Temperate Zone) 12/2/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0091

ASTM : D6400 - 12 Standard Specification (Standard Specification for Labeling Plastics Designed to be Aerobically Composted in Municipal or Industrial Facilities) 5/15/2012 3.43(b) 

CCX-0092

ASTM : D7475 - 11 Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining Aerobic Degradation and Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under Accelerated Bioreactor Landfill Conditions) 1/1/2011 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 

5
CCX-0093

ASTM : WIN WK41850 Standard Test Method (Standard Test Method for Determining the Rates and Rate Constants for Plastics Biodegradation in an Anaerobic Laboratory Environment Under Accelerated Conditions) 12/4/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0094

Report on Research Conducted by Synovate on Behalf of EcoLogic LLC 2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0095

Report on Research Conducted by American Plastics Council 2006 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0096 Photo of Enviroware Flex Straws 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0097

Photo of Enviroware Biodegradable Cutlery 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0098

Photo of Enviroware Biodegrable Foam Products 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0099

Photo of Enviroware Biodegradable Straws 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0100 Photo of Green Natura Biodegradable 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0101

Photo of Three Straws Labeled Biodegradable and One Plastic Fork 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0102 Photo of Arbor BioMugs 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0103

Photo of SAFE Biodegradable Plastic Frisby 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0104 Photo of Generation e Garbage Bags 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0105

Photo of Plascon Films Biodegradable Products Innovation Statement 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0106

Photo of Plascon Films Statement with 9 Months to 5 Years Claim 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0107

Photo of Plascon Films Tubing, Bags, and Biodegradable Products 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0108

Photo of Plascon Films Statement with Certified Biodegradable Supplier Claim 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0109 Photo of 100% Biodegradable Logo 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0110

Photo of Cobsbreads.com Biodegradable Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0111 Photo of ECM Biofilms Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0112 Photo of Cobs Bread Biodegradable Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0113

Photo of Generation e 100% Biodegradable Recyclable Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0114 Photo of ECM Biofilms Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0115

Photo of I Hardt Foodies Biodegrable Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0116 Photo of Biodegradable Clear Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0117

Photo of ECM Biodegradable 100% Recyclable Logo on Clear Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 

6
CCX-0118

Photo of Sunlight Detergent Bag with ECM Logo 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0119

Photo of 100% Biodegradable Logo on Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0120

Photo of Sage's Apples Bag with 100% Biodegradable Claim 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0121

Photo of Bag with ECO-Friendly 100% Reusable ECM Claim 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0122

Photo of ECM Biodegradable 100% Recyclable Logo on Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0123

Photo of ECM Biodegradable Claim on Triangle Highlighter 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0124

Photo of ECM Biodegradable Claim on Pen 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0125

Photo of Elsinore Valley Municipal Water District with BIOPRO Biodegradable Plastic Claim 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0126 Photo of BIORIGHT Drimark Highlighter 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0127

Photo of Sanctum and Organic Spa Bottles 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0128

Photo of Two Organic Spa Bottles with 100% Biodegradable Claim 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0129

Photo of Three Bottles with ECM Biodegradable Claim 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0130 Photo of ECM Biodegrable Plastic Film 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0131

Photo of Carquest, Canyon, EcoChoice Bottles 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0132 Photo of EcoChoice Bottle 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0133

Photo of EcoChoice Bottle with ASTM D5511-02 Reference 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0134 Photo of ECM Additive Black Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0135 Photo of Trim Tray 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0136 Photo of Champ Golf Tee Packaging 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0137

Photo of BioMugs Card with Biodegrable in 1-5 Years Claim 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0138 Photo of NatureTex Ultra Kids Shoe 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0139 Photo of Go! Zero Sole 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0140 Photo of AAkron Line Sample 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0141

Photo of Hotel and Conference Center Card with 18 Months to 5 Years Biodegradable Claim 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0142 Photo of Earthware Air Pouch 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0143

Photo of ECM Biodegradable Logo on Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 

7
CCX-0144

Photo of Biodegradable Packaging Logo on Made in Canada Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0145

Photo of ECM Biodegradable Logo on Blue Packaging 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0146

Photo of 100% Biodegradable Logo on Eden Restaurant Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0147

Photo of Biodegradable Bag with ECM Logo 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0148 Photo of Oregon Tilth Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0149 Photo of Oregon Tilth Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0150 Photo of For Life! Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0151

Photo of100% Biodegradable Logo on White Bag 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0152

Article Published by Crain's Cleveland Business entitled Head of ECM BioFilms 

Says FTC Has 'Sullied Our Name' by J. 

Carroll 11/24/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0153

Final Report: Compostability Testing of Polypropylene and Polyethylene Plastic Blended with "MasterBatch Pellets" Biodegradation Enhancement Additive, conducted by 3M Environmental Laboratory 1/20/2012 3M00000191 3M00000218 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0154 3M General Project Outline 4/8/2010 3M00000117 3M00000133 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0155 Excerpt of 3M data - Screenshots No Date 3M-FTC0000827 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0156

Compilation of emails involving various O.W.S. Inc. employees and J. Young at American Profol regarding Update 7 HSAD-Test

5/23/2008-5/13/2008 OWS001631 OWS001693 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0157

Covidien O.W.S. Inc. Final Report - High Solids Anaerobic Digestion (HSAD) Test 5/10/2010 ECM-114733 ECM-114740 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0158

Covidien Powerpoint summarizing O.W.S. Inc. testing on ECM plastic No Date COV000011 COV000025

3.43(b) & (c); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0159

O.W.S. Final Report - Biodegradation Testing Aerobic Biodegradation Under Controlled Composting Conditions for 40 Gal Trash Bags Study PFR-5 3/3/2000 ECM-FTC-000124 ECM-FTC-000162 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0160

Advanced Materials Center, Inc.: Lab Report 6/19/2000 ECM-112225 ECM-112239 3.43(b) 

CCX-0161

O.W.S. Inc. Final Report - Biodegradation Testing Aerobic Biodegradation Under Controlled Composting Conditions for 5% Load Black Film 5% ECM Load Natural Film Study PFR-1 8/13/1998 ECM-112026 ECM-112079 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 

8
CCX-0162

O.W.S. Inc: Final Report - Biodegradation Testing Aerobic Biodegradation Under Controlled Composting Conditions for 50% Load ECM Pellets, 5% Load ECM Film, and 10% Load ECM Film Study PFR-2 10/5/1998 ECM-112080 ECM-112131 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0163

Masternet LTD: High Solids Anaerobic Digestion of Plastic Netting Study PH-1 8/26/2009 ECM-113608 ECM-113625 3.43(b) 

CCX-0164

Article entitled Biodegradability of 

Conventional and Bio-Based Plastics and Natural Fiber Composites During Composting, Anaerobic Digestion and Long-Term Soil Incubation by Eddie F. 

Gomez and Frederick C. Michel Jr., in the Journal of Polymer Degradation and Stability 10/1/2013 ELS_ECM000001 ELS_ECM000009 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0165

Email from T. Iwata (Editor, Polymer Degradation and Stability) to F. Michel (Ohio State University) Regarding Your Submission PDST-D-13-00655 9/21/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0166

Manuscript: Biodegradability of 

Conventional and Bio-Based Plastics and Natural Fiber Composites During Composting, Anaerobic Digestion, and Long-Term Soil Incubation No Date ELS_ECM000013 ELS_ECM000013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0167

PDST-D-13-00655: Biodegradability of 

Conventional and Bio-Based Plastics and Natural Fiber Composites During Composting, Anaerobic Digestion, and Long-Term Soil Incubation No Date ELS_ECM000172 ELS_ECM000172 3.43(b) 

CCX-0168

T. Iwata Faculty Bio from University of Tokyo Website 5/19/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0169

O.W.S. Final Report for Gary Plastic Packaging Corporation: Review of Several Documents, Reports, and Statements on Biodegradation ECM Masterbatch Pellets Study GLH-2 4/30/2010 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0170

O.W.S. Final Report: Aerobic Biodegradation Under Controlled Composting Conditions of Biodegradable Plastic Bag and Normal Plastic Bag Study BRB-1 2/23/2007 OWS001325 OWS001334 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0171

O.W.S. Final Report: High Solids Anaerobic Degradation Test (HSAD) of Film Sample Study SMG-1/1 1/12/2012 ECM-114219 ECM-114233 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 

9
CCX-0172

Email from G. Yazdani (Poly-Flex, Inc.) to G. Hall Regarding ECM Biofilms Reports 5/22/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0173

Advanced Material Centers, Inc. Laboratory Report for Poly-America, L.P. Project # 09P1145 - ASTM D 12/18/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0174

Project Report #1870 for FP International: Biodegradation Testing of a Loose Fill Product - Prepared by Stevens Ecology 8/18/2008 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0175

Project Report #2028 for FP International: Biodegradation Testing of a Plastic Film Product - Prepared by Stevens Ecology 12/8/2008 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0176

Project Report #2028-Revision A for FP International: Biodegradation Testing of a Plastic Film Product - Prepared by Stevens Ecology 12/8/2008 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0182

Email exchange involving ECM employees and Italcom regarding "Critical Updates" 2/2/2011 ECM-054440 ECM-054441 3.43(b) 

CCX-0183

Modification Agreeement between ECM and Italcom S.r.l. 7/27/2010 ECM-044578 ECM-044583 3.43(b) 

CCX-0184

Letters from Porter Wright to R. Sinclair regarding Italcom S.r.L. emergency request for information relating to ECM MasterBatch Pellets and resolution of outstanding business issues 7/2/2010 ECM-044565 ECM-044573 3.43(b) 

CCX-0188

Executed Business Record Declaration - SPEED France 5/19/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0189

Email from Speed France to J. Cohen (French email translated) 5/12/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0190

Email from J. Le Roux to C. Radtke regarding ECM Biofilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products (German email translated) 6/20/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0191

Email exchange involving R. Sinclair, S. Duval (Speed France), J. Le Roux, C. Radtke 5/12/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0192

Translation Certification: Affidavit of Accuracy regarding French translations 5/23/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0193

Translation Certification: Affidavit of Accuracy regarding German translations 5/23/2014 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 10
CCX-0194

Translation Certification: Affidavit of Accuracy regarding Italian translations 5/28/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0195

World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) Patent Application WO 2013/057748 A1 (Authenticated) 4/25/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0196

Database entry summarizing communications with Colplast SRL

10/8/2012 - 1/29/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0197

Certificate of the Biodegradability of Plastic Products Made by Colplast SRL 10/9/2012 3.43(b) 

CCX-0198

Email from F. Berton (Colplast) to R. Sinclair regarding ECM Biofilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Products 10/10/2012 ECM-094497 ECM-094499 3.43(b) 

CCX-0199

Email from J. Sweigert to R. Sinclair regarding Proposed email to Francesco Berton of Colplast 10/9/2012 ECM-097169 ECM-097169 3.43(b) 

CCX-0200

Email from R. Sinclair to F. Berton (Colplast) regarding ECM Biofilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Products 10/10/2012 ECM-097181 ECM-097182 3.43(b) 

CCX-0201

Email from S. McGregor (Shields) to R. Sinclair regarding Important news about Italcom SRl and ECM Biofilms 1/24/2013 ECM-100378 ECM-100384 3.43(b) 

CCX-0202

Email from C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) to R. Sinclair regarding ECM in Italy - request of copy of test of biodegradability for poliammide 1/24/2013 ECM-100381 ECM-100384 3.43(b) 

CCX-0203

Email from C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) to R. Sinclair regarding ECM in Italy - report test of Colplast - formal notice received from Luon court France

1/24/2013 - 1/25/2013 ECM-100428 ECM-100429 3.43(b) 

CCX-0204

Email from C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) to R. Sinclair regarding Test from ECM Biofilms' - legal action colplast/speed France

1/29/2013 - 1/30/2013 ECM-100551 ECM-100569 3.43(b) 

CCX-0205

Email from K. Marineau to J. Sweigert regarding Test from ECM Biofilms' - legal action colplast/speed France

1/29/2013 - 1/30/2013 ECM-100576 ECM-100595 3.43(b) 

CCX-0206

Email from R. Sinclair to C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) regarding ECM in Italy - report test of Colplast - formal notice received from Lyon court France

1/24/2013 - 1/28/2013 ECM-100617 ECM-100619 3.43(b) 

CCX-0207

Email from C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) to R. Sinclair regarding Speed France / Colplast 

1/25/2013 - 1/29/2013 ECM-100622 ECM-100632 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 11
CCX-0208

Email from C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) to R. Sinclair regarding Test from ECM Biofilms' - legal action colplast/speed France

1/29/2013 - 1/30/2013 ECM-100637 ECM-100655 3.43(b) 

CCX-0209

Email from T. Braithwaite (Automated Packaging Systems) to R. Sinclair regarding Eye Irritation

1/29/2013 - 2/5/2013 ECM-100858 ECM-100863 3.43(b) 

CCX-0210

Email from C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) to R. Sinclair regarding Request for update for legal action Colplast/SpeedFrance

1/29/2013 - 2/6/2013 ECM-100860 ECM-100863 3.43(b) 

CCX-0211

Email from C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) to R. Sinclair regarding Request for update for legal action Colplast/SpeedFrance

2/11/2013 - 7/2/2013 ECM-100958 ECM-100960 3.43(b) 

CCX-0212

Email from K. Marineau to J. Sweigert regarding Test from ECM Biofilms' - legal action colplast/speed France

1/29/2013 - 1/30/2013 ECM-103124 ECM-103135 3.43(b) 

CCX-0213

Email from R. Sinclair to C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) regarding ECM in Italy - report test of Colplast - formal notice received from Lyon court France

1/24/2013 - 1/26/2013 ECM-103151 ECM-103153 3.43(b) 

CCX-0214

Email from R. Sinclair to C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) regarding ECM in Italy - report test of Colplast - formal notice received from Lyon court France

1/28/2013 - 1/29/2013 ECM-103162 ECM-103163 3.43(b) 

CCX-0215

Email from R. Sinclair to C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) regarding request of update for legal action Colplast/SpeedFrance

2/6/2013 - 2/7/2013 ECM-103350 ECM-103351 3.43(b) 

CCX-0216

Email from R. Sinclair to C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) regarding request of update for legal action Colplast/SpeedFrance

2/6/2013 - 2/12/2013 ECM-103459 ECM-103462 3.43(b) 

CCX-0217

Email from C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) to R. Sinclair regarding ECM Biofilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Products 

5/7/2013 - 6/5/2013 ECM-105225 ECM-105227 3.43(b) 

CCX-0218

Email from C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) to R. Sinclair regarding ECM Biofilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Products 

5/9/2013 - 6/5/2013 ECM-105262 ECM-105265 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 12
CCX-0219

Email from C. Busato (Arcopolimeri SRL) to R. Sinclair regarding ECM Biofilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Products 

5/14/2013 - 6/5/2013 ECM-105301 ECM-105304 3.43(b) 

CCX-0220

Email from S. Duval to Biodeg regarding Informations 5/29/2013 ECM-105497 ECM-105498 3.43(b) 

CCX-0221

Email from R. Sinclair to T. Nealis regarding Speed France Order

5/29/2013 - 6/20/2013 ECM-105684 ECM-105689 3.43(b) 

CCX-0223

Email from R. Sinclair to T. Nealis regarding Speed France Order

5/29/2013 - 6/20/2013 ECM-106903 ECM-106919 3.43(b) 

CCX-0224

Letter from Lamy Associates enclosing Writ of Summons for Colplast SRL 1/25/2013 ECM-112269 ECM-112299 3.43(b) 

CCX-0225

Registered Letter from E. Baroin (on behalf of Speed France) to F. Berton with acknowledegement of receipt 9/20/2012 ECM-112640 ECM-112641 3.43(b) 

CCX-0226

Letter from R. Conte regarding Fradulent Communications by Ecologia Applicata srl/dr.Paolo Broglio 12/18/2012 ECM-112653 ECM-112654 3.43(b) 

CCX-0227

Email from M. Tweedle (Sijovy) to R. Sinclair regarding Biodegradability of Plastics Materials Test

10/2/2009 - 1/10/2012 ECM-114142 ECM-114155 3.43(b) 

CCX-0228

Conference call agenda and minutes for call between Colplast and ECM 5/5/2010 ECM-114429 ECM-114466 3.43(b) 

CCX-0229 Sample of ECM MasterBatch pellets No Date ECM-FTC-0000014 ECM-FTC-0000014 3.43(b) CCX-0230

Memo from B. Gohill at Covidien regarding Scope Biodegradable Additive project/ECM Biofilms 12/15/2009 COV000312 COV000313 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0231

Letter from Federal Trade Commission staff to Robert Sinclair at ECM regarding inquiry into ECM's marketing and promoting of additives 8/30/2011 3.43(b) 

CCX-0232

ECM comments (No. P084200) regarding FTC's Green Packaging Workshop 5/19/2008 3.43(b) 

CCX-0233

White paper entitled "The Effect of the Biodegradability of Plastics Made with ECM on Landfills and Greenhouse Gases" 4/15/2009 ECM-113444 ECM-113447 3.43(b) 

CCX-0234

ECM International Customer List (with revenue information) for 2009-2013 2009-2013 ECM-026373 ECM-026375 3.43(b) 

CCX-0235 ECM customer list 1/14/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0236

Powerpoint presentation entitled "LongTerm Biodegradation Testing of ECM - amended Plastics" by Timothy R. Barber at ENVIRON International Corp. No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 13
CCX-0237 Agendas for prospective customers 10/5/2010, ECM-112318 ECM-112320 3.43(b) 

CCX-0238

Letter from R. Sinclair to H. Peckhaus at JonPac Manufacturing regarding AquaBiodegradation Certification for Plastic Products Manufactured with ECM MasterBatch Pellets as an Additive 3/13/2014 ECM-112913 ECM-112913 3.43(b) 

CCX-0239

Letter from Office of the District Attorney, County of Solano, CA to Bart E. Greenhut (PetPro Products, Inc.) regarding Sales of Dispoz-A-Scoop Violate California Public Resources Code 1/6/2012 ECM-115010 ECM-115012 3.43(b) 

CCX-0240

Curriculum Vitae of Frederick C. Michel, Jr. No Date 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0241

License Agreement between ECM Biofilms, Inc. and Microtech Research, Inc. with addendum

Agreement 6/2/1999; Addendum 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0242

Marietta presentation entitled "Leaders in Sustainability" No Date ECM-113351 ECM-113390 3.43(b) 

CCX-0243

Curriculum Vitae of Todd Owens Stevens No Date 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0244 Stevens Ecology Overview No Date 3.43(b); Parties' Stipulation 

CCX-0245

Winpak Films, Inc. Presentation entitled "ECM Biofilms Biodegradable Additive" No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0246

Email to F. Santana from B. Jay FW: Inquiry with 11 Attachments 6/19/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0246A

Attachment 1-Biodegradation Cert_Sample 070116 1/16/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0246B

Attachment 2-Biodegradation Mechanism 051028 10/28/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0246C

Attachment 3-Customer Certificate 070821 No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0246D Attachment 4-ECM Flyer 070429 No Date 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0246E

Attachment 5-ECM_General Presentation 070531 PPT No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0246F Attachment 6-Life Expectancy 070116 1/16/2007 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0246G

Attachment 7-MSDS ECM6_0701 070710 7/10/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0246H

Attachment 8-Pricing Sheet ECM6_0701_D 070412 4/12/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0246I

Attachment 9-Pricing Sheet ECM6_0701_G 070321 3/21/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0246J Attachment 10-TDS ECM6_0701 0703 No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 14
CCX-0246K

Attachment 11-Manufacturers for Majestic 080604 6/4/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0247

Email to F. Santana from D. Hong regarding Anaerobic Claim, Logo 11/25/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0248

Email to F. Santana, R. Sinclair, D. Hong, L.Yamauchi from A. Poje regarding Down to Earth: Draft News Release Re. Switch to Biodegradable Bags 4/8/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0249

Email to F. Santana from S. McCarthy regarding Compostable Plastic Bag with 4 Attachments 9/26/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0249A

Attachment 1-APR and NAPCOR degradables release final[1] (doc) 2/12/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0249B

Attachment 2-APR Degradable Additives Statement[1] (doc) 12/3/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0249C

Attachment 3-FTC Dyne Letter Sept 09[1] 9/21/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0249D

Attachment 4-Narayan comments on ECM claims[1] 3/10/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0250

Email to F. Santana and R. Sinclair from A. Poje regarding ECM Claims for Biodegrability Have Been Challenged 10/1/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0251

Email to F. Santana from A. Poje regarding ECM Claims for Biodegradability Have Been Challenged with 2 Attachments 10/2/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0251A

Attachment 1-Narayan Summary S 081112 (doc) 11/1/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0251B

Attachment 2-Mojo Summary 081111 (doc) No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0252

Email to F. Santana from A. Poje regarding Help! 2/3/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0253

Email to F. Santana from A. Poje regarding ECM Claims for Biodegradability Have Been Challenged in Hawaii 7/10/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0254

Email to G. Kaynor from B. Finnestad regarding Standards for Test Methods for Biodegrading Plastic Material with 1 Attachment 2/9/2010 COV000128 COV000129 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0255

Email to B. Gohill from B. Finnestad regarding 2/2/2010 COV000258 COV000259 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0256

Email to G. Kaynor and B. Finnestad from B. Gohill Subject: ECM Biofilms 12/10/2009 COV000412 COV000412 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 15
CCX-0257

Email to C. Osterberg from C. Stempka Subject: Biodegradable Certification with 1 Attachment 9/11/2009 EA000067 EA000068 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0257A

Attachment 1-ECM Biodegradable Certificate 7/30/2007 EA000068 EA000068 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0258

Email to C. Melville from C. Stempka Subject: Biodegradable Zipper Information with 3 Attachments 8/6/2010 EA000073 EA000076 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0258A Attachment 1-PM 7171 BDC Q3387 1/23/2006 EA000074 EA000074 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0258B

Attachment 2-ECM Biodegradable Certificate 7/30/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0258C Attachment 3-ECM Flyer 070429 No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0259

Email to D. Rucker from T. Nealis Subject: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products with 1 Attachment 1/8/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0259A Attachment 1-ECM Flyer 100414 No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0260

Email to Flexible Plastics Inc from City Clerk regarding Bags 10/14/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0261

Email from D. Dancks regarding where can I call you with 2 Attachments (Redacted) 1/28/2013 FPI-FTC00000076 FPI-FTC00000079 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0261A

Attachment 1-Biodegradation Cert_Fortune Plastics 060726 7/26/2006 FPI-FTC00000080 FPI-FTC00000080 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0261B

Attachment 2-FPIEnviroplasBiograde2010 No Bates FPI-FTC00000081 FPI-FTC00000081 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0262

Email to D. Rucker from T. Nealis FW: ECM BioFilms Pics 1 of 10 with 2 Attachments 3/28/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0262A Attachment 1-Wild Finch Bird Seed jpg No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0262B Attachment 2-Earth Aware Air Pack jpg No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0263

Email to kevin@patriotsigns and dunderwood@putnamplasticsinc Subject: EFEI Information on our "Biodegradeable" Additive 6/22/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0264

Email to R. Decaire from M. Ross regarding ECM BioFilms'Test Results 9/25/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0265

Email to scimmnin@danafilms from R. Brunell regarding Biodegradability Certificate 6/16/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0266

Email to D. Rucker from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products with 5 Attachments 3/28/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 16
CCX-0266A

Attachment 1- ECM vs Alternatives 080617 6/16/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0266B

Attachment 2-Biodegradation Cert_Sample 070116 1/16/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0266C Attachment 3-ECM Flyer 070429 No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0266D

Attachment 4-Time Elapse biodegradation pictures PPT 1/6/1997 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0266E

Attachment 5-McLaren Ecological Assessment 060526 2/16/1999 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267

Email to D. Rucker from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms' Basic Info with 12 Attachments 1/5/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267A Attachment 1-TDS ECM6_0701 0806 (2) No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267B

Attachment 2-Biodegradation Cert Sample 070116 1/16/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267C

Email regarding ECM BioFilms' Basic Info Attachment 3-Biodegradation Mechanism 051028 10/28/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267D

Attachment 4-Customer Certificate 070821 (doc) 7/10/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267E

Email regarding ECM BioFilms' Basic Info Attachment 5-ECM Flyer 070429 No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267F

Attachment 6-ECM Gen_Explanation 081203 (2) 12/3/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267G

Attachment 7-ECM Gen_Explanation 081203a (3) 12/3/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267H

Attachment 8-ECM vs Alternative 080617 6/16/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267I Attachment 9-Life Expectancy 070116 1/16/2007 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0267J

Attachment 10-MSDS ECM6_0701 070710 7/10/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267K

Attachment 11-Pricing Sheet ECM6_0701_D 070412 (3) 4/12/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0267L

Attachment 12-Pricing Sheet ECM6_0701_G 070321 (2) 3/21/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0268

Email to D. Rucker from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms' Independent Tet Results with 2 Attachments 1/5/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0268A

Attachment 1-McLaren Ecological Assessment 060526 2/16/1999 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0268B

Attachment 2-Litt_Morton report 000612b No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0269

Email to D. Rucker from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms with 1 Attachment 1/17/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 17
CCX-0269A

Attachment 1-MSDS ECM6_0701 070710 7/10/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0270

Email to D. Rucker from T. Nealis regarding Sample Testing with 2 Attachments 5/13/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0270A

Attachment 1-Biodegradation Cert_Sample 070116 1/16/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0270B

Attachment 2-Customer Certificate 070821 (doc) 7/10/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0271

Email to M. Bissett from A. Mithal FW: Biodegradable Additive with 10 Attachments 6/25/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0271A

Attachment 1-Biodegradation_Cert_Sample 070116 1/16/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0271B

Attachment 2-Biodegradation Mechanism 051028 10/28/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0271C

Attachment 3-Customer Certificate 070821.doc 7/10/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0271D Attachment 4-ECM Flyer 070429 No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0271E

Attachment 5-ECM_General Presentation 070531 PPT No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0271F Attachment 6-Life Expectancy 070116 1/16/2007 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0271G

Attachment 7-MSDS ECM6_0701 070710 7/10/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0271H

 Attachment 8-Pricing Sheet ECM6_0701_D 070412 4/12/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0271I

Attachment 9-Pricing Sheet ECM6_0701_G 070321 3/21/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0271J Attachment 10-TDS ECM6_0701 0703 No Bates 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0272

Email to A. Madonna and C. Heverly from A. Mithal FW: Certificate of Biodegradation with 1 Attachment 9/8/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0272A

Attachment 1-Biodegradation Cert_Waddington North America_WNA 080625 6/25/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0273

Email to R. Sinclair from T. Albert regarding Ecorite Imaging accused of GREEN WASHING. 4/23/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0274

Email to charles@g3s from M. Howard regarding CONFIDENTIAL - Copy of Certificates 11/26/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0274A

Attachment 1-ECM Life Expectancy 051028.pdf 10/28/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0274B

Attachment 2-ECM BioFilms Biodegradation Mechanism 051028.pdf 10/28/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 18
CCX-0274C

Attachment 3-Cert.ofBiodegrad. 11-09.pdf 3/27/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0275

Email to M. LaFauci from A.Poje regarding re additive 4/13/2009 ECM-014011 ECM-014013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0276

Email to G. Milham from T. Nealis regarding Freight Quote 8/25/2009 ECM-016433 ECM-016435 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0277

Email to T. Nealis from G. Milham regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 8/10/2009 ECM-018942 ECM-018946 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0278

Email to D. Rucker from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms' Basic Info 4/8/2010 ECM-035391 ECM-035397 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0279

Email to T. Nealis from D. Rucker regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 4/11/2011 ECM-059846 ECM-059850 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0280

Email to D. Galloway from R. Sinclair regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable* Plastic Products 1/18/2013 ECM-102621 ECM-102623 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0281

Email to M. Svoboda from T. Nealis FW: New ECM BioFilms Web Inquiry with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 4/30/2013 ECM-106361 ECM-106362 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0282

Email to T. Nealis from Sylvia AirBag regarding Bio-films questions from AIRBAG 10/25/2013 ECM-109871 ECM-109873 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0283

Email to R. Sinclair from D. Mattair regarding Biodegradable Materical 10/3/2013 ECM-111128 ECM-111129 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0284

Email to J. Michalakis from T. Nealis regarding FFT Update with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 8/2/2012 ECM-091569 ECM-091571 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0285

Email to T. Nealis from J. Michalakis Subject FFT Update 12/5/2012 ECM-096267 ECM-096267 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0286

Email to T. Nealis from J. Michalakis regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable* Plastic Packaging andProducts 5/1/2013 ECM-105159 ECM-105159 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0287

Email to T. Nealis from J. Michalakis regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging andProducts with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 11/6/2013 ECM-109943 ECM-109943 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 19
CCX-0288

Email to T. Adante from T. Nealis regarding ASTM Tests 10/6/2010 ECM-049115 ECM-049115 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0289

Email to R. Sinclair from K. Rockhill regarding Various Test Docs 6/24/2009 ECM-011377 ECM-011378 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0290

Email to A. Poje from T. Brooks regarding Thank you for posting on Umbra! 5/21/2009 ECM-012962 ECM-012967 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0291

Email to A. Poje from S. Vance regarding Question on Viability of Biodegradable Additives 5/27/2009 ECM-013056 ECM-013057 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0292

Email to F. Santana and R. Sinclair from A. Poje regarding ECM Claims for Biodegrability Have Been Challenged 10/1/2009 ECM-024326 ECM-024327 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0293

Email to T. Nealis from R. Thompson regarding Michigan State Univ. Contact 3/8/2010 ECM-028517 ECM-028518 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0294

Email to R. Sinclair from D. Hong regarding FTC 8/2/2010 ECM-039445 ECM-039446 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0295

Email to P. Hartman from R. Sinclair regarding ASTM Landfill Standard 12/6/2010 ECM-050913 ECM-050914 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0296

Email to '???' from T. Nealis regarding Inquiry for MasterBatch Pellets with 3 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 1/31/2011 ECM-057533 ECM057543 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0297

Email to S. McGregor from R. Sinclair regarding Final reports SMG-1 1/27/2012 ECM-080804 ECM-080805 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0298

Email to RANDYBAGMAN@aol from R. Sinclair regarding Master Batch additive testing 2/12/2009 ECM-006948 ECM-006949 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0299

Email to R. Ikin from A. Poje regarding Biodegradability testing 7/24/2009 ECM-019897 ECM-019899 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0300

Email to S. Williams from T. Nealis FW: ECM BioFilms Information 10/13/2009 ECM-021671 ECM-021673 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0301

Email to T. Nealis from J. Barbieri regarding RV: Samples 10/22/2009 ECM-022596 ECM-022599 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0302

Email to T. Nealis from D. Rucker regarding Sample Testing 5/5/2010 ECM-033083 ECM-033085 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0303

Email to sjoseph1@mmm from T. Nealis regarding Update 8/16/2010 ECM-043352 ECM-043353 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0304

Email to R. Sinclair from S. McGregor regarding ASTM 5511 duration 12/6/2011 ECM-074339 ECM-074340 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0305

Email to R. Sinclair from L. D'Angelo FW: A Holiday Message from ECM BioFilms with 1 Attachment 12/28/2011 ECM-075396 ECM-075399 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0306

Email to D. Galoob from R. Sinclair Subject: Testing 2/2/2012 ECM-081029 ECM-081031 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 20
CCX-0307

Email to F. Santana from A. Poje regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 2/3/2009 ECM-007986 ECM-007993 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0308

Email to colin@cfmachinery from R. Sinclair regarding Modern Plastics - close to first success 10/13/2011 ECM-075621 ECM-075623 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0309

Email to C. Farrant from R. Sinclair regarding Modern with 5 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 1/13/2012 ECM-080448 ECM-080449 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0310

Email to A. Poje from arcinc@arc-inc regarding Radiolabeled Polymer 7/27/2009 ECM-017259 ECM-017260 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0311

Email to A. Poje from M. Barlaz regarding ASTM D 6776 Standard Test Method for Determining Anaerobic Biodegradability ofRadiolabeled Plastic Materials in a Laboratory-Scale Simulated Landfill Environment 7/31/2009 ECM-017463 ECM-017464 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0312

Email to A. Poje from R. Covington regarding ECM BioFilms - Radiolabeled Polymer 9/2/2009 ECM-018140 ECM-018142 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0313

Email to A. Poje from M. Barlaz regarding [Fwd: regarding Polymer Synthesis Opportunity] 11/1/2009 ECM-022732 ECM-022733 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0314

Email to A. Poje from L. Barnes regarding Quote # 11130945 12/14/2009 ECM-023965 ECM-023968 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0315

Email to Bill H from R. Sinclair regarding ECM nomenclature 1/14/2010 ECM-029613 ECM-029615 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0316

Email to dtapia@xynyth from T. Nealis Subject ECM BioFilms Logo 6/29/2010 ECM-037746 ECM-037746 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0317

Email to T. Nealis from G. Shah regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging andProducts 3/5/2012 ECM-079367 ECM-079369 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0319

Email to 'POLYC' from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging andProducts with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 7/26/2012 ECM-091380 ECM-091381 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 21
CCX-0320

Email to A. Grozdeva from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives For Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging andProducts with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 8/2/2012 ECM-091567 ECM-091568 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0321

Email to P. Camilleri from T. Nealis regarding Biodegradable testing 7/23/2013 ECM-108193 ECM-108199 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0322

Email to 'Mike AirBag' from T. Nealis regarding FW: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging andProducts with 4 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 8/16/2013 ECM-110295 ECM-110305 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0323

Email to M. Pollard from R. Sinclair regarding ECM additive. 8/24/2010 ECM-043546 ECM-043548 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0324

Email to G. Hellinger from R. Sinclair RE; A Holiday Message from ECM BioFilms 12/28/2011 ECM-077409 ECM-077410 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0325

Email to B. Hemming and S. Blamey from B. James FW: KLH- ECM Pellets with 3 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 2/8/2012 ECM-113600 ECM-113602 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0326

Email to 'Adam' from R. Sinclair regarding More information on Biodegradable Grocery Bags with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 3/30/2009 ECM-007876 ECM-007877 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0327

Email to R. Sinclair from T. Brooks FW: Bio Claim on plastics---URGENT 6/4/2009 ECM-011154 ECM-011155 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0328

Email to R. Sinclair from S. Mckye FW: Emailing: BIOflexTM_WhitePaper with 4 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 4/22/2009 ECM-010479 ECM-010481 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0329

Email to dowin@sunnyamericas from T. Nealis Subject: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 11/28/2011 ECM-053171 ECM-053171 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0330

Email to primaplastic@email from T. Nealis regarding BIODEGRADABLE test result for P-Life 2/8/2011 ECM-057832 ECM-057833 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0331

Email to P. Barutis from R. Sinclair regarding New ASTM for landfill biodegradation 6/20/2013 ECM-106910 ECM-106911 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0332

Email to T. Nealis from N. Kirschner regarding ECM BioFilms Information 2/22/2010 ECM-028156 ECM-028156 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 22
CCX-0333

Email to T. Nealis from J. Richards regarding ECM BioFilms Third Party Independent Test Results 8/18/2010 ECM-040159 ECM-040160 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0334

Email to T. Adante from T. Nealis Subject: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 2/4/2010 ECM-045401 ECM-045401 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0335

Email to sjoseph1@mmm from T. Nealis Subject: regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 2/4/2010 ECM-045405 ECM-045406 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0336

Email to 'Giovanna Cruz' from T. Nealis Subject: Test - ECM BioFilms 11/4/2010 ECM-050085 ECM-050085 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0337

Email to E. Halter from T. Nealis Subject: ECM BioFilms 11/16/2010 ECM-050425 ECM-050425 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0338

Email to dennisc@preformsolutions from T. Nealis Subject: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 11/22/2010 ECM-050569 ECM-050570 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0339

Email to M. Tschantz from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging andProducts with 3 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 1/15/2013 ECM-102554 ECM-102555 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0340

Email to E. Dover-Roll from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable* Plastic Packaging andProducts with 2 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 1/24/2013 ECM-102999 ECM-103002 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0341

Email Compilation from Customer Service to Various Customers Regarding Certificate of Biodegradation 1/12/2009 ECM-006349 ECM-109415 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0342

Email to S. Shin from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 10/6/2009 ECM-024493 ECM-024494 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0343

Email to Customer Service from M. Graham regarding QVC 1/19/2010 ECM-026942 ECM-026942 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0344

Email to Customer Service from R. Anderson regarding Certificate of Biodegradation 1/19/2010 ECM-026944 ECM-026944 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 23
CCX-0345

Email to T. Nealis from D. DeChynne regarding CERTIFICATE OF BIODEGRABILITY FOR ANDERSON DIE & MANUFACTURING 2/17/2010 ECM-028015 ECM-028016 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0346

Email to david@copolinternational from Customer Service Subject: Certificate of Biodegradation with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 1/14/2010 ECM-029634 ECM-029634 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0347

Email to italcom.amministrazione@gmail from Customer Service Subject: Certificate of Biodegradation with 2 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 1/22/2010 ECM-029829 ECM-029829 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0348 

Email to scottlocks@polyfirst from Customer Service Subject: Certificate of Biodegradation with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 1/22/2010 ECM-029832 ECM-029832 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0349

Email to T. Nealis from G. Loyola regarding Consult 7/21/2010 ECM-038848 ECM-038849 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0350

Email to V. Saab from A. Poje regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products with 6 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 10/12/2010 ECM-049229 ECM-049231 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0351

Email to J. Sweigert from R. Sinclair FW: Biodegradable Certification with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 1/25/2012 ECM-078253 ECM-078255 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0352

Email to T. Nealis from A. Meinerts regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 2/14/2012 ECM-078864 ECM-078864 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0353

Email to A. Poje from J. Heinrich Subject: Request your logo for client newsletter... 6/3/2009 ECM-013147 ECM-013147 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0354

Email to J. Sweigert from J. Cohen regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 6/4/2010 ECM-034086 ECM-034088 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0355

Email to R. Sinclair from R. Hurwitz regarding ECM Biodegradable Logo 6/24/2010 ECM-034902 ECM-034903 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0356

Email to J. Sweigert from R. Sinclair FW: LOGO 10/28/2010 ECM-046975 ECM-046975 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 24
CCX-0357

Email to 'Dwight de Leon' from J. Sweigert regarding LOGO with 3 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 10/28/2010 ECM-049799 ECM-049800 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0358

Email to V. Power from J. Sweigert Subject: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products with 5 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 11/2/2010 ECM-049950 ECM-049950 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0359 

Email to andrea@biostarfilms from J. Sweigert Subject: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products with 4 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 11/30/2010 ECM-050802 ECM-050802 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0361

Email to C. Crowley from T. Nealis Subject: regarding ECM Additive - update with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 7/25/2012 ECM-091366 ECM-091368 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0362

Email to J. Zeiger from R. Sinclair regarding ECM Logo Question with 1 Attachment 8/22/2012 ECM-092120 ECM-092121 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0363

Email to R. Sinclair from K. Lau regarding about customer certificate 11/2/2012 ECM-095265 ECM-095267 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0364

Email to K. Lau from R. Sinclair FW: about customer certificate with 3 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 11/1/2012 ECM-097710 ECM-097711 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0365

Email to P. Fiori from J. Sweigert FW: request with 5 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 1/31/2013 ECM-103169 ECM-103171 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0366

Email to M. Cenicola from R. Sinclair regarding Follow up - and a few questions with 5 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 8/12/2009 ECM-FTC-020316 ECM-FTC-020318 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0367

Email to S. Desai from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms Web Contact Form 6/29/2010 ECM_FTC-037749 ECM_FTC-037755 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0368

Email to T. Adante from T. Nealis regarding ECM Flyer 4/9/2010 ECM-035448 ECM-035449 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0369 

Email to R. Sinclair from T. Wu regarding Certificate with 3 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 5/4/2011 ECM-060788 ECM-060790 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 25
CCX-0370

Email to bewasko@berplastics from T. Nealis Subject: ECM BioFilms' Increased Purchases with 2 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 1/31/2012 ECM-080963 ECM-080963 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0371

Email to 'POLYC' from T. Nealis regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging andProducts with 5 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 12/11/2012 ECM-099091 ECM-099094 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0372

Email to james@itbplastics from A. Michaelides Subject: Product Benefits of EarthCure Additive with 1 Attachment (Attachment not provided) 4/4/2013 ECM-104673 ECM-104673 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0373

Email to A. Zoller from T. Nealis Subject: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable* Packaging and Products (1of2) with 11 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 12/13/2013 ECM-110680 ECM-110680 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0374

Email to jasmine@henglongplastic from T. Nealis Subject ECM BioFilms 7/20/2012 ECM-085546 ECM-085552 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0375

Email to R. Sinclair from P. Hartman Subject: Testing 10/22/2009 ECM-022560 ECM-022560 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0376

Email to R. Sinclair from P. Hartman Subject: Tests 10/27/2009 ECM-022654 ECM-022654 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0377

Email to A. Poje from P. Hartman regarding ECM BioFilms' #4 10/28/2009 ECM-022675 ECM-022676 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0378

Email to R. Sinclair from C. Rempe (no subject) 3/10/2011 ECM-056095 ECM-056095 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0379

Email to N. Shenoy from T. Nealis regarding Unicoms with 9 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 4/17/2013 ECM-106082 ECM-106082 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0380 

Email to mintosabu@ymail from T. Nealis regarding New ECM BioFilms Web Inquiry with 11 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 5/8/2013 ECM-106503 ECM-106503 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0381

Email to R. Sinclair from A. Poje Subject: FTC Complaints - Kmart & Tender 7/21/2009 ECM-017088 ECM-017095 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0382

Email to T. Nealis from R. Thompson FW: ECM BIO RESIN 4/8/2010 ECM-032036 ECM-032042 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 26
CCX-0383

Email to T. Nealis from M. Brosch regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 4/9/2010 ECM-032069 ECM-032070 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0384

Email to T. Nealis from R. Thompson regarding ECM Test Report 10/19/2010 ECM-046344 ECM-046346 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0385

Email to T. Nealis from sjoseph1@mmm regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 11/30/2010 ECM-048077 ECM-048078 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0386 

Email to T. Nealis from D. Hojlo Subject: Dell Said NO & ASTM 6400 Guideline Must be Met with 2 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 2/1/2013 ECM-100735 ECM-100739 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0387 

Email to theiden@pkgprod from T. Nealis FW: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable* Plastic Packaging andProducts with 3 Attachments (Attachments not provided) 7/9/2013 ECM-108039 ECM-108039 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0388

Database entry summarizing communications with Covidien

11/11/2009 - 12/27/2011 ECM-FTC-000869 ECM-FTC-000874 3.43(b) 

CCX-0389

Database entry summarizing communications with Down to Earth All Vegetarian

6/20/2008 - 2/4/2010 ECM-FTC-000926 ECM-FTC-000934 3.43(b) 

CCX-0390

Database entry summarizing communications with FabriTRAK Systems, Inc.

9/9/2008 - 12/3/2009 ECM-FTC-000985 ECM-FTC-000988 3.43(b) 

CCX-0391

Database entry summarizing communications with Gary Plastics

9/18/2009 - 10/31/2011 ECM-FTC-001052 ECM-FTC-001055 3.43(b) 

CCX-0392

Database entry summarizing communications with Geneva Watch Group

5/18/2009 - 12/18/2011 ECM-FTC-001063 ECM-FTC-001078 3.43(b) 

CCX-0393

Database entry summarizing communications with Green Packaging 5/13/2011 - 10/12/2011 ECM-FTC-001100 ECM-FTC-001102 3.43(b) 

CCX-0394

Database entry summarizing communications with Hercules Poly

2/15/2008 - 12/22/2011 ECM-FTC-001121 ECM-FTC-001123 3.43(b) 

CCX-0395

Database entry summarizing communications with IMEX Vinyl Packaging 

8/15/2007 - 12/27/2011 ECM-FTC-001157 ECM-FTC-001162 3.43(b) 

CCX-0396

Database entry summarizing communications with JohnPac Manufacturing 

6/17/2008 - 9/1/2010 ECM-FTC-001195 ECM-FTC-001197 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 27
CCX-0397

Database entry summarizing communications with Kessler Hayden

8/20/2010 - 9/7/2010 ECM-FTC-001214 ECM-FTC-001214 3.43(b) 

CCX-0398

Database entry summarizing communications with Notemarks LLC

12/5/2008 - 12/27/2011 ECM-FTC-001342 ECM-FTC-001351 3.43(b) 

CCX-0399

Database entry summarizing communications with Nu Methods Plastics, Inc.

3/9/2011 - 12/15/2011 ECM-FTC-001353 ECM-FTC-001357 3.43(b) 

CCX-0400

Database entry summarizing communications with PakSher

5/12/2010 - 12/27/2011 ECM-FTC-001388 ECM-FTC-001393 3.43(b) 

CCX-0401

Database entry summarizing communications with Palmetto Industries International Inc. 5/13/2009 ECM-FTC-001394 ECM-FTC-001394 3.43(b) 

CCX-0402

Database entry summarizing communications with Poly-America L.P

4/15/2009 - 10/12/2011 ECM-FTC-001454 ECM-FTC-001457 3.43(b) 

CCX-0403

Database entry summarizing communications with STMicroelectronics and Storm Innovations Inc. 7/20/2006 - 7/26/2006 ECM-FTC-001688 ECM-FTC-001688 3.43(b) 

CCX-0404

Database entry summarizing communications with ThermoPod

5/18/2011 - 5/25/2011 ECM-FTC-001734 ECM-FTC-001735 3.43(b) 

CCX-0405

Database entry summarizing communications with TreeWell Technologies, Inc.

5/2/2006 -5/4/2006 ECM-FTC-001750 ECM-FTC-001751 3.43(b) 

CCX-0406

Database entry summarizing communications with Tyco ElectronicsTechnology Group 9/17/2008 - 7/27/2009 ECM-FTC-001760 ECM-FTC-001762 3.43(b) 

CCX-0407

Database entry summarizing communications with Umbra LLC

12/19/2007 - 6/17/2009 ECM-FTC-001763 ECM-FTC-001767 3.43(b) 

CCX-0408

Database entry summarizing communications with American Plastic Mfg. Inc.

1/5/2009 - 1/14/2013 ECM-002001 ECM-002016 3.43(b) 

CCX-0409

Database entry summarizing communications with Be satori LLC

1/7/2009 - 4/16/2009 ECM-002115 ECM-002127 3.43(b) 

CCX-0410

Database entry summarizing communications with Bio-Tec Environmental, LLC

1/29/2009 - 5/23/2013 ECM-002175 ECM-002214 3.43(b) 

CCX-0411

Database entry summarizing communications with Bloomer Plastics, Inc.

1/20/2009 - 11/1/2013 ECM-002239 ECM-002261 3.43(b) 

CCX-0412

Database entry summarizing communications with Command Packaging

1/6/2009 - 10/29/2013 ECM-002305 ECM-002337 3.43(b) 

CCX-0413

Database entry summarizing communications with EcoSmart Plastics 10/17/2012 - 1/15/2011 ECM-002585 ECM-002587 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 28
CCX-0414

Database entry summarizing communications with Flexible Plastics, Inc.

1/5/2009 - 1/17/2014 ECM-002621 ECM-002639 3.43(b) 

CCX-0415

Database entry summarizing communications with Gilman Brothers

4/14/2009 - 1/10/2014 ECM-002670 ECM-002707 3.43(b) 

CCX-0416

Database entry summarizing communications with Hi-De Liners, LLC

2/20/2009 - 10/5/2012 ECM-002729 ECM-002740 3.43(b) 

CCX-0417

Database entry summarizing communications with Myers Group 

1/11/2010 - 10/10/2012 ECM-003260 ECM-003273 3.43(b) 

CCX-0418

Database entry summarizing communications with PolyFusion LLC

6/25/2010 - 1/2/2014 ECM-003610 ECM-003619 3.43(b) 

CCX-0419

Database entry summarizing communications with Sealed air 

3/4/2009 - 11/14/2013 ECM-003834 ECM-003865 3.43(b) 

CCX-0420

Database entry summarizing communications with Automated Packaging Systems (Excerpt)

10/2/2013 - 10/4/2013 ECM-004503 ECM-004503 3.43(b) 

CCX-0421

Database entry summarizing communications with Bemis Group

3/17/2009 - 1/14/2014 ECM-004510 ECM-004543 3.43(b) 

CCX-0422

Database entry summarizing communications with Shields Bag and Printing Company

1/5/2009 - 1/8/2014 ECM-005553 ECM-005638 3.43(b) 

CCX-0423

Database entry summarizing communications with Westchem Group

1/31/2013 - 11/12/2013 ECM-005731 ECM-005739 3.43(b) 

CCX-0424

Database entry summarizing communications with Americover 

6/28/2011 -12/12/2011 ECM-FTC-000700 ECM-FTC-000701 3.43(b) 

CCX-0425

Database entry summarizing communications with Am-Source LLC

3/12/2009 - 4/24/2009 ECM-FTC-000702 ECM-FTC-00703 3.43(b) 

CCX-0426

Database entry summarizing communications with Behr Industries Corporation

10/19/2007-12/27/2011 ECM-FTC-000745 ECM-FTC-000747 3.43(b) 

CCX-0427

Database entry summarizing communications with Cleanwaste

6/8/2009 -11/28/2011 ECM-FTC-000812 ECM-FTC-000815 3.43(b) 

CCX-0428

Database entry summarizing communications with Colonial Bag Corp. 2/21/2008 - 3/14/2008 ECM-FTC-000832 ECM-FTC-000834 3.43(b) 

CCX-0429

Database entry summarizing communications with Contempo Card Company

3/11/2006 - 12/27/2011 ECM-FTC-000848 ECM-FTC-000852 3.43(b) 

CCX-432

Email from T. Barber (Environ) to L. Heise (Environ); S. Hall (Environ) Regarding test end 9/19/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-436

Table - Values for Control and BioPVC Over Time 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-437

Email from T. Barber (Environ) to S. Hall (Environ) Regarding bioPVC Chlorides - Good News 10/5/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 29
CCX-440 BER Plastics, Inc. Deposition Subpoena 4/15/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-441

BER Plastics, Inc. Certification of Compliance and Records 3/19/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-442

BER Plastics, Inc., ECM BioFilm Customers 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0443

Article entitled Additive Masterbatches 

Make Polyolefins Degrade from Plastics 

Technology Website ptonline.com 5/31/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0449

Email from R. Sinclair (ECM) to B. Ewasko (BER Plastics) Regarding Marketing ECM Bio 

11/17/2013 - 11/10/2013 ECM-111329 ECM-111330 3.43(b) 

CCX-0450

D&W Fine Pack, LLC Deposition Subpoena 4/24/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0451

Email from J. Sweiger (D&W Fine Pack) to R. Fleming (D&W Fine Pack) Regarding "Questions & Answers for Robert Sinclair" 8/28/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0452

Document entitled "Questions for Robert Sinclair" No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0453 Glossary of Green Terms No Date DWFP000000378 DWFP000000383 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0455

ECM Certificate of Biodegradability for Dispozo-Products, Inc. 5/20/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0458

ECM Certificate of Biodegradability for Enviroware - Certified by Dispoz-o Products 1/4/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0459

Certificate of Biodegradability for Enviroware - Certified by Dispoz-o Products 1/4/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0460

Certificate of Biodegradability for Enviroware - Certified by Dispoz-o Products 1/4/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0462

Enviroware Biodegradable Straws, Cutlery, and Foam Products Pamphlet 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0463

Letter from G. Cilver (Dispoz-o) to M. Yost (Grand Canyon USD) Regarding Enviroware Biodegradable Samples 2/25/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0465

Email from G. Culver (Dispoz-o) to: B. Griffith (Dispoz-o) Regarding Envirofoam

3/13/2008 - 4/14/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0466

Summary of D&W Meeting with Robert Sinclair No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0467

Letter from B. Hackler (Dispoz-o) to D. Mallen (NAD) Regarding Challenge to Dispoz-o's "Enviroware" advertising claims 10/9/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 30
CCX-0468

Letter from D. Eveleigh (Solo-Cup) to D. Mallen (NAD) RE: Challenge to Dispozo's "Enviroware" advertising claims 9/23/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0469 Response to Solo/Nad No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0470

NAD Case #4990: Dispoz-O Products, Enviroware Plastic Utensils and Tableware 3/27/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0471

Email from A. Poje (ECM) to J. Swoger (Dispoz-o) Regarding NAD Ruling Conference Call 4/24/2009 ECM-014337 ECM-014337 3.43(b) 

CCX-0472 Dispozo Biodegradation Test Design Nov-08 ECM-114586 ECM-114587 3.43(b) CCX-0473

Dispozo- Biodegradation Study T-2 Months 1/21/2009 ECM-114588 ECM-114589 3.43(b) 

CCX-0476

Email from D. Kizer (Dispoz-o) to: R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding Draft Month 4 Interim Report 

4/6/2009 - 7/31/3009 ECM-017459 ECM-017460 3.43(b) 

CCX-0477

Email from D. Kizer (Dispoz-o) to R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding Interim Report, Month 6 7/31/2009 ECM-017457 ECM-017458 3.43(b) 

CCX-0478

Email from B. Hackler (Dispoz-o) to R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding Biodegradation testing scope of work and budget estimate

9/22/2008 - 8/14/2009 ECM-017843 ECM-017844 3.43(b) 

CCX-0479

Attachment B: Scope of Work for Testing Protocol to Demonstrate Biodegradation of Plastics Samples 9/18/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0480

Email from A. Leiti (Dispoz-o) to R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding Enviroware Testing

8/14/2009 - 8/17/2009 ECM-017819 ECM-017821 3.43(b) 

CCX-0481

Email from B. Hackler (Dispoz-o) to R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding Environ Testing

12/1/2009 - 12/3/2009 ECM-023704 ECM-023705 3.43(b) 

CCX-0482

Email from M. Staton (D&W Fine Pack) to A. Leiti (D&W Fine Pack) Regarding Enviroware claims 7/11/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0483

Email from: A. Leiti (D&W Fine Pack) to M. Staton (D&W Fine Pack) Regarding Enviroware claims

7/11/2011 - 7/12/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0485

Sustainability Update PowerPoint Presentation 12/5/2012 DWFP000004255 DWFP000004260 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0486

Email from R. Davis (D&W Fine Pack) to R. Griffith (D&W Fine Pack) Regarding Sustainable Items

12/3/2012 - 12/20/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0487

Enviroware Transition Plan (Containers, Cutlery & Straws) - PowerPoint Presentation 6/13/2013 DWFP000006190 DWFP000006201 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 31
CCX-0488

Letter from D. Eveleigh (NAD) to J. Lancia (Dispoz-o) Regarding Advertising for "Enviroware" 8/13/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0489

Letter from B. Hackler (Dispoz-o) to A. Levine (NAD) Regarding Complaint by Solo Cup against Dispoz-o Products, Inc. 9/4/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0490 Down to Earth Deposition Subpoena 4/15/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0491

Email: from D. Hong (Island Plastics) to F. Santana (Down to Earth) Regarding Biodegradable Plastic Bags 5/29/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0492

Emails (and attachments) from B. Jay to: F. Santana (Down to Earth) Regarding Inquiry 

6/2/2008 - 6/19/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0494 Down to Earth Biodegradable Bag No Date 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0496

Email from R. Sinclair (ECM) to F. Santana (Down to Earth) Regarding ECM Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastics Packaging and Products 3/27/2009 DTE00001 DTE00002 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0497

Emails from A. Poje (ECM) to: F. Santana (Down to Earth) Regarding Help

4/7/2009 - 2/3/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0498

Emails from A. Poje (ECM) to: F. Santana (Down to Earth) Regarding Help

4/7/2009 - 2/3/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0499 Copy of CD No Date 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0500

Down to Earth Press Release entitled Down to Earth to Switches to 

Biodegradable Plastic Bags on Earth Day April 22nd 4/9/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0501

Printout of Webpages from Down to Earth Website downtoearth.org 2/3/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0502

Pacific Business News Article entitled Down to Earth Switches to 

Biodegradable from bizjournals.com 4/9/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0503

Article entitled Down to Earth Will Switch 

to Biodegradable Plastic Bags from 

honoluluadvertiser.com 4/9/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0504

Article entitled Down to Earth Switches 

to Biodegradable Plastic Bags on Earth Day April 22nd from hawaiireporter.com 4/10/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0505

ECM Database Summary Entry from: R. Sinclair to: F. Santana (DTE) Redacted No Date ECM-FTC-000930 ECM-FTC-000930 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 32
CCX-0507

Email from A. Poje (ECM) to F. Santana (Down to Earth) Regarding ECM Claims for Biodegradability Challenged in Hawaii

9/25/2009 - 7/10/2012 ECM-090869 ECM-090878 3.43(b) 

CCX-0508

Eagle Film Extruders Inc., Deposition Subpoena 4/30/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0511

ECM Mechanism for Biodegradation Letter 10/28/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0512

Email from G. Collins (Eagle Film Extruders) to M. O'Malley (Eagle Film Extruders) ; E. Jordan (Eagle Film Extruders); Regarding Putnam Plastics Response to requested information in regard to ECM "Biodegradable" Additive 6/24/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0513

Email from M. O'Malley (Eagle Film Extruders) to G. Collins (Eagle Film Extruders) Regarding Putnam Plastics Inc.; Follow-up by ECM on Patriot Sign Request. 

4/15/2010 - 4/20/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0514

Email from M. O'Malley (Eagle Film Extruders) to C. Warren (Putnam Plastics) Regarding Putnam Plastics Inc.: More Information on our "Biodegradable" Additive 3/19/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0515

Email from M. O'Malley (Eagle Film Extruders) to K. Schmidt (Custom Poly) Regarding EFEI Information on our "Biodegradable" Additive 1/18/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0516

Email from G. Collins (Eagle Film Extruders) to J. Conrad (Custom Poly) Regarding Custom Ploy Packaging Earthworm Inquiry 6-10-11 6/10/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0517

Eden Research Laboratory Deposition Subpoena 4/29/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0518

Eden Research Labaroty Website Screenshot 3.43(b) 

CCX-0519

Eden Research Laboratory Update Regarding FPI Samples (55 days) 5/12/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0523

Email from T. Poth (Eden) to: ECM BioFilms Regarding ECM BioFilms Web Contact Form 10/8/2010 ECM-045862 ECM-045862 3.43(b) 

CCX-0524

Eden Research Laboratory Proposal from T. Poth to R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding Pricing 1/11/2012 1022 1022 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 33
CCX-0525

Email from R. Sinclair (ECM) to T. Poth (Eden) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Request from 1/24/13 3/1/2013 1009 1009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0526

Email from T. Poth (Eden) to R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding ECM BioFilms Web Contact Form 4/24/2013 1010 1011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0527

Email from R. Sinclair (ECM) to T. Poth (Eden) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Request from 1/24/13 3/12/2013 1006 1006 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0528

Email from R. Sinclair (ECM) to T. Poth (Eden) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Request from 1/24/13

3/1/2013 - 4/23/2013 1004 1005 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0529

Printout of Webpage on Plastics Environmental Council Technical Advisory Board from Website pec-us.org 8/31/2011 3.43(b) 

CCX-0530

Email from C. Lancelot to R. Sinclair (ECM); T. Poth (Eden) Regarding Opposition Letter 3/24/2011 FP00004027 FP00004027 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0535

Summary Report - 30 Day to Samsill - 

ASTM D5511-02 Standard Test Methods 

to Determining Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under HSAD Conditions DWFP00000022 DWFP00000025 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0536

Email from T. Poth (Eden) to S. McGregor (Shields) Regarding Update 3/28/2012 ECM-082656 ECM-082658 3.43(b) 

CCX-0537

Eden Research Laboratory Update Regarding ASTM D5511-11 Update on Clear Films 476 & 477 (75 days) 5/1/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0538

Email from S. McGregor (Shields) to T. Poth (Eden) 7/9/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0539

Email from P. Kelly (Smithers Oasis) to T. Poth (Eden) Regarding Biodegradation testing costs 2/20/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0540

Email: from: T. Poth (Eden) to: R. Alire (FP International) Regarding Updated Final Report

10/28/2011 - 11/1/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0541

Email from T. Poth (Eden) to R. Alire (FP International) Regarding Testing of FP International Products 3/19/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0542

Email from T. Poth (Eden) to J. Blood (FP International) Regarding Update

8/27/2013 - 11/20/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0543 Eden Production Response to Subpoena 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 34
CCX-0544

Email from S. Alkin (Fellows) to T. Poth (Eden) Regarding Fellows Inc. - Biodegradation Testing 6/15/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0545

Eden Research Laboratories Biodegradability Certificate 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0549 Deposition Subpoena - Elsevier Inc. 5/19/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0555

Biographical Sketch of Tadahisa Iwata, Ph. D No Date 3.43(b) 

CCX-0556

Flexible Plastics, Inc. Deposition Subpoena 4/30/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0557

Flexible Plastics, Inc. Certification of Compliance and Records 3/25/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0559

Email from A. Hassoldt-Fenoff (Flexible Plastics) to D. Sandry (Fleible Plastics) Regarding Flexible Plastics - ECM BioFilms' Product Logo 10/7/2009 ECM-024505 ECM-024506 3.43(b) 

CCX-0561

Email from D. Sandry (Flexible Plastics) to T. Nealis (ECM) Regarding Flexible Plastics - ECM BioFilms' Product Logo

10/7/2009 - 10/14/2009 ECM-022389 ECM-022390 3.43(b) 

CCX-0562A

Email from: R. Sinclair (ECM) to D. Sandry (Flexible Plastics) Regarding Question

12/30/2008 - 1/5/2009 ECM-006251 ECM-006252 3.43(b) 

CCX-0564

Biodegradable Super 8 Loosefill Data Sheet 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0565

FP International Flyer - We Care about the Environment No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0566

FP International Reusable Biodegradable Seal No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0567

ECM Certificate of the Biodegradability of Plastic Products made by Free-Flow Packaging International, Inc. 6/6/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0568

Email from J. Nezwek (FP) to R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding Update 7/17/2009 ECM-017042 ECM-017042 3.43(b) 

CCX-0570

Email from R. Alire (FP) to R. Sinclair Regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 7/14/2010 ECM-038499 ECM-038506 3.43(b) 

CCX-0575

Email from R. Alire (FP) to R. Sinclair Regarding Third party test of our film

2/9/2009 - 2/10/2009 ECM-008779 ECM-008780 3.43(b) 

CCX-0577

Email from R. Alire (FP) to R. Sinclair Regarding Specific Questions for Starch Tech Response 7/14/2010 ECM-038520 ECM-038520 3.43(b) 

CCX-0578

Westlaw: Hall v. Clifton Precision, 150 F.R.D. 525 7/29/1993 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 35
CCX-0579

Email from R. Alire (FP) to T. Barber Regarding Safco Demo

8/28/2010 - 8/30/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0580

Email from R. Alire (FP) to R. Sinclair Regarding Dispozo Contact

7/27/2010 - 7/28/2010 ECM-039130 ECM-039131 3.43(b) 

CCX-0581

Email from R. Alire (FP) to T. Barber (Environ) Regarding Biodegradation Study - M12 Preliminary Report 9/7/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0582

Letter from T. Barber (Environ) to R. Alire (FP) Regarding Biodegradation Testing - Preliminary Final Report 11/3/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0586

Letter from M. Barlaz (NCSU) to: R. Alire (FP) Regarding BMP Report 12/5/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0587

Microbiology of Solid Waste Book Excerpts 1996 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0589

FP International Interoffice Memo from R. Alire to Executive Staff; R. Green Regarding Long Term Bio-Degradation Study Update 4/7/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0590

Memo from R. Alire (FP) to J. Blood (FP) Regarding Summary of Testing of FP International Products Containing Biodegradation Additive 11/22/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0592

Email from R. Alire (FP) to J. Goebel (FP) Regarding Bio plank

1/11/2011 - 1/12/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0593

Email from J. Janicki to R. Alire (FP) Regarding Testing of FP International Products

3/19/2013 - 3/22/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0595

Eden Research Laboratory Report Regarding 120 days testing of FP International Samples - ERL# 122-124 9/25/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0597

FP International Biodegradable Products Information Sheet 3/14/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0598

Email from J. Blood to C. Daigle Regarding Best generic D5511 and other results outside of Eden Lab

11/6/2012 - 11/7/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0600

Email from R. Alire (FP) to: T. Barber (Environ) Regarding Letter to use with response to NAD 7/19/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0601

Email from J. Blood (FP) to C. Lancelot RE: NAD Decision re Advertising Claims 11/22/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0602

Email from C. Lancelot to multiple recipients Regarding SB 1454 Coalition Letter

8/9/2010 - 8/10/2010 ECM-045254 ECM-045255 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 36
CCX-0603

Email from C. Moriyama to multiple recipients Regarding SB 1454 Coalition Letter

8/6/2010 - 8/9/2010 ECM-039708 ECM-039715 3.43(b) 

CCX-0605

Email from J. Blood (FP) to R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding Lunch 6/8/2009 ECM-011221 ECM-011221 3.43(b) 

CCX-0606

Email from R. Sinclair (ECM) to J. Blood (FP) Regarding 1991 Article on ASTM and Narayan

4/21/2009 - 4/22/2009 ECM-011760 ECM-011761 3.43(b) 

CCX-0607 Privilege Log from FP International 3/28/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0608

Email from R. Alire (FP) to T. Barber (Environ) Regarding Letter for use with response to NAD 7/19/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0609

Letter from M. Barlaz (NCSU) to R. Alire (FP) Regarding BMP Report 11/14/2010 FP00000132 FP00000133 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0611

Island Plastic Bags, Inc. Deposition Subpoena 3.43(b) 

CCX-0612

Email from D. Hong (IPB) to A. Hong (IPB) Regarding ECM Testing

3/4/2013 - 3/5/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0613

ECM Certificate of the Biodegradability of Plastic Products made by Island Plastic Bags, Inc. 1/23/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0614

Email from A. Hong (IPB) to F. Sanyana (DTE) Regarding Subpoena from FTC re ECM Bio Films 2/3/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0618A

Email from A. Hong (IPB) to Ohana Sales and Marketing Inc. Regarding Times Supermarket 10/18/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0619 Copy of CD - Image No Date 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0620

Island Plastic Bags, Inc., Response to Subpoena 3/24/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0621

Screenshot: Island Plastic Bags, Inc., Kitchen Bags No Date 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0623

Sansei Seafood Restaurant and Sushi Bar Bag with ECM logo 11/28/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0626

Island Plastic Bags, Inc., Biodegradable Cutlery Fact Sheet 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0627

Island Plastic Bags, Inc., Bio Ultra Blend Liners Fact Sheet 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0632

Email from T. Nealis to D. Rucker (Geneva) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Basic Info 

12/17/2009 - 4/8/2010 3.43(b) 

CCX-0634 Tom Nealis LinkedIn Full Profile 2/27/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0639

Email from T. Nealis to D. Rucker (Geneva Watch Group) RE: ECM BioFilms Pics 1 of 10

3/2/2011 - 3/28/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 37
CCX-0640

Email from T. Nealis to D. Rucker RE ECM BioFilms Pics 2 of 10 - Amenity Bottle and Bag

3/28/2011 - 3/29/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0641

Email from T. Nealis to D. Rucker Regarding ECM BioFilms Pics 4 of 10 - Paint Tray and Cups

3/28/2011 - 3/29/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0642

Email from T. Nealis to D. Rucker Regarding ECM BioFilms Pics 5 of 10 - Marker and Mug

3/28/2011 - 3/29/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0645

Email from T. Nealis to D. Rucker (Geneva Watch Group) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging andProducts 1/8/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0649

Email from T. Nealis to V. Lim (Clorox) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products

11/11/2009 - 12/1/2009 ECM-025900 ECM-025902 3.43(b) 

CCX-0650

Email from T. Adante (Flambeau) to T. Nealis Regarding NewsFeed: A scientist questions 'biodegradability' (Oct. 5) - Rotten Timing For Flambeau 10/5/2010 ECM-045731 ECM-045736 3.43(b) 

CCX-0651

Email from C. McCann (Sondor) to T. Nealis Regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 11/12/2010 ECM-047519 ECM-047521 3.43(b) 

CCX-0654

Email from I. Buckley (Sanner) to T. Nealis Regarding Biodegradation in Water 

 10/5/2009 - 10/7/2009 ECM-022097 ECM-022101 3.43(b) 

CCX-0655

Email from G. Milham (Cawarra) to T. Nealis RE: Biodegradability of plastics

12/6/2010 - 12/7/2010 ECM-048249 ECM-048250 3.43(b) 

CCX-0657

Email from R. Sinclair (ECM) to D. DeChynne RE: Pricing Sheets

8/5/2010 - 12/16/2010 ECM-048611 ECM-048614 3.43(b) 

CCX-0658

Email from J. Richards (Waytek) to T. Nealis Regarding ECM BioFilms PVC Testing 

10/27/2010 - 11/1/2010 ECM-047101 ECM-047103 3.43(b) 

CCX-0663

Northeast Laboratories, Inc., Deposition Subpoena 4/30/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0664

Printout of Webpages from Northeast Laboratories, Inc. Website 5/5/2014 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 38
CCX-0665

Northeast Laboratories Report Summary ASTM: D5511-02 Standard Test Method for Determining Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastics Materials Under High-Solids Anaerobic-Digestion Conditions DWFP00000008 DWFP00000013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0666

ASTM: D5511-02 Standard Test Method for Determining Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastics Materials Under High-Solids Anaerobic-Digestion Conditions 8/10/2002 FTC_Prod_000094 FTC_Prod_000100 3.43(b) 

CCX-0669

Northeast Laboratories Analytical Report to National Tree Co. ASTM D5511 Determining Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under HSAD Conditions 4/23/2012 ECM-112240 ECM-112243 3.43(b) 

CCX-0670

Northeast Laboratories Analytical Summary ASTM: D5511-02 Standard Test Method for Determining Anaerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials Under High-Solids Anaerobic-Digestion Conditions DWFP00000003 DWFP00000007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0671

Email from P. Kelley (Smithers Oasis) to A. Ullmann (Northeast Labs) Regarding Biodegradation Testing 

5/6/2011 - 1/14/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0672

Northeast Laboratories Analytical Report to MiniGrip ASTM D5511 Extension Test 5/19/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0676

Email from L. De La Mora (Prodigy) to A. Poje Regarding Technical Questions

3/26/2009 - 4/3/2009 ECM-012291 ECM-012295 3.43(b) 

CCX-0681

Email from A. Poje to R. Ikin (BPT) Regarding Palace Testing 6/16/2009 ECM-015566 ECM-015568 3.43(b) 

CCX-0686

Email from K. Rockhill (Notemark) to A. Poje Regarding Tech Questions

 11/9/2009 - 11/10/2009 ECM-022997 ECM-022998 3.43(b) 

CCX-0689

Email from A. Poje to L. Bentley (Springs) Regarding Questions 

5/21/2009 - 5/22/2009 ECM-014971 ECM-014973 3.43(b) 

CCX-0690

Email from J. Alvis (ERG) to A. Poje Regarding LMOP landfill and project database, sorted by state, project status, and landfill name 5/24/2010 ECM-033559 ECM-033561 3.43(b) 

CCX-0691

Email from A. Poje to K. Reddy (UIC) Regarding Certified Landfill Leachate 9/8/2009 ECM-020665 ECM-020665 3.43(b) 

CCX-0692

Email from S. Parandoosh (Labplas) to A. Poje Regarding landfill leachate

9/8/2009 - 9/9/2009 ECM-018280 ECM-018281 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 39
CCX-0694

FTC Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims #534743-00025 5/19/2008 3.43(b) 

CCX-0695

Email from J. Kohm (FTC) to A. Poje Regarding Green Guide Status

3/10/2009 - 3/15/2010 ECM-028744 ECM-028750 3.43(b) 

CCX-0696

Email from J. Swiger (Dispoz-o) to A. Poje Regarding NAD Ruling 4/27/2009 ECM-012588 ECM-012589 3.43(b) 

CCX-0698

NAD News: Solo Cup Challenges Advertising Claims for Dispoz-o "Enviroware" Products 4/2/2009 3.43(b) 

CCX-0701

Letter from R. Narayan (Michigan State University) to S. Mojo (Biodegradable Products Institute) Regarding Analysis and Comments on ECM’s brochure, titled Ecological Assessment of ECM Plastic, dated Feb. 16, 1999 - biodegradation in landfills 3/10/2005 ECM-00000(1) ECM- 3.43(b) 

CCX-0703

Narayan's summary - A Case Study on commercializing Starch- based biodegradable plastics 11/1/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0704

Email from A. Poje to F. Santana (Down to Earth) via S. McCarthy (American Chemistry) Regarding ECM Claims for Biodegradability Have Been Challenged

9/25/2009 - 10/2/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0705 Plastic News: Biomyths muddle up facts 3/27/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0706

Email from G. Swift to A. Poje; R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding ASTM Landfill Std. 5/26/2010 ECM-033669 ECM-033669 3.43(b) 

CCX-0710

Email from A. Poje to T. Brooks (Umbra) Regarding D5511 Testing 

 6/9/2009 - 6/17/2009 ECM-015599 ECM-015600 3.43(b) 

CCX-0712

Email from A. Poje to C. Rempe (Automated Packaging Systems, Inc.) Regarding ASTM Testing 2/6/2009 ECM-008003 ECM-008005 3.43(b) 

CCX-0715

Email from F. Shields (Compost Lab) to A. Poje Regarding Biodegration of your product

 6/29/2009 - 7/2/2009 ECM-016622 ECM-016627 3.43(b) 

CCX-0718

Email from M. Ross to R. Decaire (Costco) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Test Results

9/18/2009 - 9/25/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 40
CCX-0722

Email from R. Pocius (TekPak Solutions) to R. Sinclair (ECM) Regarding CKF

5/27/2010 - 5/28/2010 ECM-033762 ECM-033763 3.43(b) 

CCX-0723 Alan Poje Deposition Subpoena 1/28/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0724

Quest Plastics, Inc. Deposition Subpoena 4/15/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0725

Printout of Webpages from ECM BioFilms Website 1/16/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0727 Quest Plastics Inc. Invoice 

1/14/2013 3/15/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0728

Quest Plastics, Inc. Certification of Compliance and Records 3/24/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0729

Complaint Counsel's Notice of Rule 3.33(c)(1) Deposition 1/24/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0730

Answer and Affirmative Defense of Respondent ECM BioFilms, Inc. 11/15/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0738 SEM Examination of ECM Plastic No Date ECM-FTC-000206 ECM-FTC-000225 3.43(b) CCX-0741

Report about biodegradability of a plastic artefact - Ecologia Applicata 11/19/2010 ECM-FTC-000226 ECM-FTC-000229 3.43(b) 

CCX-0742

Northeast Laboratories Analytical Report ASTM D5511-11 Report - redacted 12/30/2009 ECM-FTC-000497 ECM-FTC-000500 3.43(b) 

CCX-0743

Northeast Laboratories Analytical Report ASTM D5511 Extension Testing 9/30/2011 ECM-FTC-000503 ECM-FTC-000505 3.43(b) 

CCX-0746

Letter from W. Burton (FTC) to D. Rosenfeld of Kelley Drye & Warren Regarding Fourth Submission Related to Inquiry Letter 5/7/2012 3.43(b) 

CCX-0747

Respondent's Supplemental Response and Objections to Complaint Counsel's First Set of Interrogatories 1/16/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0748

Plastic News article: CEO says FTC's Claims degrade his firm by Jeremy Carroll 11/20/2013 3.43(b) 

CCX-0756 ECM Certificate of Biodegradability 1/16/2007 3M00000015 3M00000015 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0757

Email from C. Lenge (3M) to S. Joseph (3M) Regarding Biodegradable Materials and Related 1/26/2010 3M00000007 3M00000009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0758

ECM Technology Overview, Biodegradation Mechanism Letter, and Technical and Material Data Sheets

10/28/2005 - 7/10/2007 3M00000099 3M00000107 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0763

Email from S. Joseph (3M) to Customer Service (ECM) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 2/3/2010 3M00000071 3M00000071 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 41
CCX-0764

Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) Comments on Background on Biodegradable Additives 6/9/2009 3M00000066 3M00000070 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0766

ECM PowerPoint Presentation - Italcom S.R.L 3M00000032 3M00000053 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0768

Screenshots: Study Notes and Composter Information

3/24/2010 - 5/10/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0771

Biodegradation Study Report: The Aerobic Biodegradation of N-EtFOSE Alcohol by the Microbial Activity Present in Municipal Wastewater Treatment Sludge 12/2/2000 ECM-113803 ECM-113858 3.43(b) 

CCX-0772

Email from R. Sinclair (ECM) to: C. Cybulski (3M) Regarding ECM BioFilms Web Contact Form 10/27/2011 ECM-075919 ECM-075920 3.43(b) 

CCX-0773

Letter from S. Giese-Bogdan (3M) to Federal Trade Commission Regarding Proposed Revised Green Guides 12/10/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0781

Email from T. Barber (Environ) to R. Lichtle Regarding Final Report 9/20/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0782

Environ Final Test Report Biodegradation Testing to R. Lichtle (Dolco Packaging) 10/21/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0784

Email from D. Kizer (Dispoz-o Products) to B. Hackler (Dispoz-o Products); T. Barber (Environ) Regarding Enviroware Testing 8/14/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0791

Email from T. Barber (Environ) to J. Sulano (Bio-Tech Products) Regarding Message for Timothy R. Barber, PhD from www.environcorp.com 12/16/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0792

Email from T. Barber (Environ) to P. Kappus (bioPVC) Regarding Biodegradation Study, Update for Month 2 9/26/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0796

Email from R. Alire (FP International) to T. Barber (Environ) RE: Safco Demo

8/28/2010 - 8/30/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0799

Transcript of deposition of Timothy Barber, Ph. D on behalf of Environ 3/7/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0800

Transcript of Deposition of Robert Ringley on Behalf of BER Plastics, Inc. 5/8/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0801

Transcript of deposition of Donald Kizer on Behalf of D & W Fine Pack, LLC 5/5/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0802

Transcript of Deposition of Ashley Leiti on Behalf of D & W Fine Pack, LLC 5/5/2014 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 42
CCX-0803

Transcript of Deposition of Frank Santana on Behalf of Down to Earth 3.43(b) 

CCX-0804

Transcript of Deposition of George Collins on Behalf of Eagle Film Extruders Inc. 5/14/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0805

Transcript of Deposition of Thomas Poth on Behalf of Eden Labs 5/19/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0806 Eden Errata 3.43(b) 

CCX-0807 Poth Declaration 5/27/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0808 Transcript of Deposition of Elsevier 3.43(b) CCX-0809

Transcript of Deposition of David Sandry on Behalf of Flexible Plastics, Inc. 5/15/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0810

Transcript of Deposition of James Blood on Behalf of FP International 5/1/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0811

Transcript of Deposition of Adrian Kawika Bu Ung Hong on Behalf of Island Plastics Bag, Inc. 3.43(b) 

CCX-0812

Transcript of Deposition of Annette Gormly on Behalf of Kappus Plastics Company, Inc. 5/6/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0813

Transcript of Deposition of Thomas Nealis 5/5/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0814 ECM Flyer 3.43(b) 

CCX-0815

Transcript of Deposition of Alyssa Ullmann on Behalf of Northeast Laboratories, Inc. 5/9/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0816 Transcript of deposition of Alan Poje 5/6/2014 3.43(b) CCX-0817

Transcript of Deposition of James Bean on Behalf of Quest Plastics, Inc. 5/7/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0818

Transcript of Deposition of Robert Sinclair (as ECM corporate designee) - Volume one 2/18/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0819

Transcript of Deposition of Robert Sinclair (in his individual capacity) - Volume two 2/19/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0820

Transcript of deposition of Kenneth Sullivan 2/20/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0821 

Transcript of Deposition of Stephen Joseph on Behalf of 3M Plastics 5/16/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0822

Transcript of Deposition of Ramy Samuel on Behalf of ANS Plastics Corp. 5/5/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0823

ANS Plastics Corp. Deposition Subpoena 4/15/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 43
CCX-0824

ECM Certificate of Biodegradability of Plastic Products - redacted 1/16/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0825 ECM MasterBatch Pellets Flyer 3.43(b) & (c) CCX-0826

ECM Certificate of Assurance of Minimum Loading Rate When Using ECM MasterBatch 5/2/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0827

Reprint of Letter to an Interested Party - Life Expectancy of ECM Products 1/16/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0828

ECM Mechanism of Biodegradation Letter, Pricing Sheets, and Certificate of Assurance (with Green Guide Excerpts) 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0829 ECM Logo ECM-FTC-000066 ECM-FTC-000066 3.43(b) CCX-0830

ANS Plastics Corp. Certification of Compliance and Records 4/10/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0831

Kappus Plastic Company, Inc. Deposition Subpoena 4/15/2014 3.43(b) 

CCX-0832

Fax from T. Kappus (Kappus) to ECM BioFilms' Regarding Certificate of Assutrance of Minimum Loading Rate When Using ECM MasterBatch Pellets 2/3/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0834

Letter from R. Sinclair (ECM) to T. Kappus (Kappus) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Biodegradable Plastic Products 2/2/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0835

Email from R. Sinclair (ECM) to T. Kappus (Kappus) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 3/20/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

CCX-0836

Email from A. Poje (ECM) to T. Kappus (Kappus) Regarding ECM BioFilms' Additives for Biodegradable Plastic 1/28/2009 ECM-007959 ECM-007960 3.43(b) 

CCX-0859

A. Tversky, Kahneman, D. 1974. Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Science. 185 1124-1131. 9/27/1974 

CCX-0860

Dr. Shane Frederick Amended Report 07.05.2014 7/5/2014 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 44
CCX-0861

B. Englich, Mussweiler, T., Strack, F. 2006. Playing dice with criminal sentences: The influence of irrelevant anchors on experts' judicial decision making. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 32(2) 188-200. 2/1/2006 

CCX-0862

U.S. Census Bureau American FactFinder 2013 Population Estimates 6/27/2014 

CCX-0863 Concatenated_Native File 

CCX-0864

D. Mochon, Frederick, S. 2013. Anchoring in sequential judgments. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. 122(1) 69-79. 5/25/2013 

CCX-0865

Expert Rebuttal of Dr. Shane Frederick 06.30.2014 6/30/2014 

CCX-0866

G.B. Chapman, Johnson, E.J. 1999. Anchoring, activation, and the construction of values. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. 79(2) 115-153. 8/1/1999 

CCX-0867

Google Consumer Surveys Product Overview 

CCX-0868

Google Inc., P. McDonald, Matt Mohebbi & B. Slatkin, Comparing Google Consumer Surveys to Existing Probability and Non-Probability Based Internet Surveys. 

CCX-0869

Webpage: Google Consumer Surveys_Home

CCX-0870

K.E. Jacowitz, Kahneman, D. 1995. Measures of anchoring in estimation tasks. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. 21(11) 1161-1166. 11/1/1995 

CCX-0871

N. Schwarz. 1999. Self-reports: How questions shape the answers. American Psychologist. 54(2) 93-105. 2/1/1999 

CCX-0872

N. Silver, FiveThirtyEight, THE NEW YORK TIMES (Nov. 10, 2012). 11/10/2012 

CCX-0873

Webpage: National Journal - Americans Continue to Drop Their Landline Phones 12/18/2013 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 45
CCX-0874

Pew Research Center, A Comparison of Results from Surveys by the Pew Research Center and Google Consumer Surveys at 3 (Nov. 7, 2012). 11/7/2012 

CCX-0875

PEW Research Center, Who's not online and why K. Zichuhr 09.25.2013 9/25/2013 

CCX-0876

S. Frederick, Mochon, D. 2012. A scale distortion theory of anchoring. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. 141(1) 124-133. 7/18/2011 

CCX-0877

Schwarz, Norbert, Hippler, H.J., Deutsch, B, & Strack F. Response Scales: Effects of Category Range on Reported Behavior and Comparative Judgments, PUBLIC OPINION QUARTERLY 49.3 (1985): 388-395. 1985 

CCX-0878

Donald T. Campbell & Donald W. Fiske, “Convergent and discriminant validation by the multitrait-multimethod matrix,” Psychological Bulletin, Vol 56(2), 81-105 (Mar. 1959). 3/1/1959 

CCX-0879

APPLIED AND ENVIRONMENTAL MICROBIOLOGY 6076–6084, “Biodegradation of Polyester Polyurethane by Endophytic Fungi,” (Sept. 2011).

7/15/2011 

CCX-0880

E. Gomez & F. Michel, Biodegradability of conventional plastics and natural fiber composites during composting, anaerobic digestion and long term soil incubation, 98 JOURNAL OF POLYMER DEGRADATION & STABILITY 2583-91 (2013). 9/21/2013 

CCX-0883

42 USC 85 Air Pollution Prevention and Control 

CCX-0884

Wang, Y.-S., Byrd, C. S. and M. A. Barlaz, 1994, “Anaerobic Biodegradability of Cellulose and Hemicellulose in Excavated Refuse Samples,” Journal of Industrial Microbiology, 13, p. 147- 53. 1994 

CCX-0885 CFR Title 40 Part 63 CCX-0886 CFR Title 40 Part 239 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 46
CCX-0887 CFR Title 40 Part 258 7/1/2011 

CCX-0888

EPA Report - Guidance on Environmental Data Verification and Data Validation 11/1/2002 

CCX-0889

Solid Waste Disposal Act 42 USC 6901-6992k 

CCX-0890 Expert Report of Dr. Shane Frederick 6/4/2014 CCX-0891 Expert Report of Dr. Stephen McCarthy 6/4/2014 CCX-0892

Rebuttal Expert Report of Dr. Stephen McCarthy 6/30/2014 

CCX-0893 Expert Report of Dr. Thabet Tolaymat 6/4/2014 CCX-0894

Rebuttal Expert Report of Dr. Thabet Tolaymat 6/30/2014 

CCX-0895

Rebuttal Report by Dr. Frederick C. Michel No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0896 Dr. Frederick C. Michel CV No Date No Bates No Bates CCX-0897

Albertsson-Biodegradation of synthetic polymers. III. The liberation of 14CO2 by molds 1978 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0898

Biodegradation of Synthetic Polymers. II. A Limited Microbial Conversion of 14C in Polyethylene to 14C02 by some Soil Fungi 1978 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0899 Kinetics of Biodegradation in Soil 1989 No Bates No Bates CCX-0900

Development and Analysis of Anaerobic Biofilms onto Hydrophobic and Hydrophylic Surfaces 4/27/2004 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0901

Specific and non-specific interactions in bacterial adhesion to solid substrata 2/11/1987 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0902

Quantitative analysis of adhesion and biofilm formation on hydrophilic and hydrophobic surfaces of clinical isolates of Staphylococcus epidermidis 3/11/2005 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0903

Determination of Monod Kinetics of Toxic Compounds by Respirometry for Structure—Biodegradability Relationships 1990 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0904

Erikson-Microplastic pollution in the surface waters of the Laurentian Great Lakes 2013 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0905

Gomez-Michel-Polymer Degradation and Stability 2013 2013 No Bates No Bates 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 47
CCX-0906

Size fractionation and microbial community structure of soil aggregates 7/11/2013 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0907

Characterization of Microbial Diversity by Determining Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphisms of Genes Encoding 16S rRNA 8/15/1997 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0908

Bioremediation of a PCB-Contaminated Soil via Composting 2001 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0909

Microbial Degradation and Humification of the Lawn Care Pesticide 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic Acid during the Composting of Yard Trimmings 5/1/1995 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0910

Role of Managese peroxidases and lignin peroxidases of Phanerochaete chrysosporium in the decolorization of kraft bleach plant effluent 5/28/1991 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0911 Biodegradation and Bioremediation 1997 1997 No Bates No Bates CCX-0912

Bacterial Community Structure During Yard Trimmings Composting No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0913

Assessing the areobic biodegradibility of 14 hydrocarbons in two soils using a simple microcosm-respiration method 12/5/2002 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0914

Biodegradation of Biaxially Stretched Polyethylene-Starch Composite Films 2/5/2002 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0915

Degradable Polyethylene: Fantasy or Reality 4/15/2011 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0916

Strategies to evaluate biodegradability: application to chlorinated herbicides 8/30/2013 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0917

Priming Effect of Substrate addition in soil-based biodegradation tests 1/18/1996 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0918

Microbial diversity and function in soil: from genes to ecosystems 5/13/2002 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0919

Bacterial community composition and abundance in leachate of semi-aerobic and anaerobic landfills 3/1/2011 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0920

Article: The Biodegradation of Blends of PCL and PE Exposed to a defined consortium of fungi 1993 No Bates No Bates 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 48
CCX-0921 Biodegradation of PE and PP Article 5/22/2007 EL00062081 EL00062081 

CCX-0922

Science Direct Article: Biological degradation of plastics: A comprehensive review 12/26/2008 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0923

An overview of Degradable and Biodegradable Polyolefins 12/23/2010 EL00062987 EL00063021 

CCX-0924

Email from W. Walsh to K. Johnson Subject: ECM - Subpoena to Ecologic Solutions, LLC 3/18/2014 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0925 Environmental biodegradation of PE 3/25/2013 EL00063228 EL00063239 

CCX-0926

Enzymatic degradation of plastics containing PCL 1994 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0927

Enzymatic degradation of plastics containing Polycaprolactone 1994 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0929

Final Report: Aerobic Biodegradation Test of ECM-Treated EPS Foam 10/9/2008 DWFP00000030 DWFP00001995

CCX-0930

Barlaz and Mojo work together on ASTM Subcommittee D20.96 - Draft Agenda 11/17/2008 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0931

Barlaz works with Narayan at ASTM Subcommittee Minutes D20.96 4/17/2012 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0932

Draft Minutes ASTM Subcommittee D20.96 on Environmentally Degradable Plastics 11/11/2007 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0933 FP Intl BMP Report 11-14-10 11/14/2010 No Bates No Bates CCX-0935 Hercules ClickZip No Date ECM-113016 ECM-113016CCX-0936 Mojo recommends Barlaz 8/23/2007 BPI000076 BPI000076CCX-0937 Mojo uses Barlaz Lab 7/24/2007 BPI000352 BPI000352CCX-0939 PEC Announcement No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0941 Google Consumer Survey Video No Date No Bates No Bates CCX-0942 McCarthy Exhibit A No Date No Bates No Bates CCX-0943 Barlaz Final Deposition Transcript 7/14/2014 No Bates No Bates CCX-0945

Barlaz Exhibit 2 - The Microbiology of Extreme and Unusual Environments - Microbiology of Solid Waste, edited by Dr. Barlaz No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0946

Barlaz Exhibit 3 - NC State - Barlaz testing FP International #10-441-Biodegradable Super-8 Loosefill 12.5.2010 12/5/2010 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0947

Barlaz Exhibit 4 - NC State - Barlaz testing FP International #10-441-Biodegradable Super-8 Loosefill 12.5.2010 12/5/2010 No Bates No Bates 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 49
CCX-0948

Barlaz Exhibit 5 - Test of Biodegradable Materials Under simulated Landfill Conditions No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0950

Barlaz Exhibit 7 - Plastics Environmental Council to Develop Biodegradation Standard for Plastics Additives and New Certification Seal 10/24/2011 FTC_Prod_001438 FTC_Prod_001438 

CCX-0951

Barlaz Exhibit 8 - NC State - Barlaz testing Ecolab Methane Yields from BMP samples 2.18.2012 2/18/2012 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0952

Barlaz Exhibit 9 - NC State - Barlaz testing StarchTech 3.4.2010 3/4/2010 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0953

Barlaz Exhibit 10 - Email from Barlaz to Mithal Re: FW: Anaerobic Degradation Testing of ECM Additive 8.10.2009 8/10/2009 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0954

Barlaz Exhibit 11 - Email from Mithal to Sinclair Subject: Anaerobic Degradation Testing of ECM Additive with NCSU Test Results Attachment 8.7.2009 8/7/2009 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0955

Barlaz Exhibit 12 - Spreadsheet of Reports No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0956

Barlaz Exhibit 13 - Respondent's Final Proposed Witness and Exhibit List 6.25.2014 6/25/2014 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0959

ECM List of Client names from 2/2011-4/2011 Feb-11 ECM-003779 ECM-003779

CCX-0960

Email from Joe P. Reis to Sinclair Re: Bob Sinclair: ASTM certifications 5.27.2010 5/27/2010 ECM-033738 ECM-033738

CCX-0961

Web Screenshot - Plastic Shopping Bags: Ecozel, Inc. "Going Green" No Date FTC_Prod_013640 FTC_Prod_013640

CCX-0963

Email from Adante to Nealis Subject: Question 9.8.2010 (Narayan Email) 9/8/2010 ECM-040997 ECM-041003

CCX-0964

Email from Hartman to Sinclair (no subject) 2 attachments re Masternet 10.26.2009 10/26/2009 ECM-022655 ECM-022655

CCX-0965

Email from J. Blood to Sinclair and Lancelot Subject: NAD Decision with 2 attachments 2.11.2011 2/11/2011 ECM-055000 ECM-055000

CCX-0966

Email from Hartman to Sinclair Re: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 2.14.2011 2/14/2011 ECM-055006 ECM-055006

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 50
CCX-0967

Email from P Hartman to S Hartman, L Duvall, Sinclair FW: with 3 attachments 10.28.2009 10/28/2009 ECM-022694 ECM-022694

CCX-0968

Email from P Hartman to Sinclair FW; with 2 attachments 11.2.2009 11/2/2009 ECM-022842 ECM-022842

CCX-0969 Barber Deposition Excerpt 3/7/2014 No Bates No Bates CCX-0970

Microtech Research Inc: Combined Tests 8/22/1998 ECM-111823 ECM-112007

CCX-0971

Marketing Materials that say "Independent" No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0972

Compilation of Emails regarding "Independent Tests" No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0973

Compilation of Emails regarding "Independent Tests" with Certificate Attachments (30 Pages) No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0974 Clear Report of Patrick Riley - Redacted 7/11/2014 No Bates No Bates CCX-0975 Riley House via Google Maps No Date No Bates No Bates CCX-0976

Example of Google Surveys - Powerpoint by Dr. Frederick No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0977

Frederick, Lee, Baskin - American Marketing Association 2014 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0978

Letter from EcoLogic, LLC to Chairman Jon Leibowitz (FTC) 12.10.2010 12/10/2010 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0983

Stewart 4 - Life Expectancy of Products Manufactured with ECM MasterBatch Pellets - Online Article 1/16/2013 FTC_Prod_001869 FTC_Prod_001870 

CCX-0984

Stewart 5 - Sample Claims by ECM Biofilms No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0987

Stewart 8 - Brandsavant: Google Customer Surveys-Are you feeling lucky? 10/3/2012 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0994

Sahu 1 - CC Amended Notice of Asserted Expert Depositions 5/19/2014 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0998

Sahu 5 - Article 11 Analytical Methods for Monitoring Biodegradation Processes of Environmentally Degradable Polymers 2011 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-0999

Sahu 6 - Online Article - Polylactic Acid Polymer and Copolymer with Polyesters 5/29/2014 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1000

Sahu 7 - Heat Generation in Municipal Solid Waste Landfills by Yesiller No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1001

Sahu 8 - EPA Operational Projects: Landfill Methane Outreach Program 6/26/2014 No Bates No Bates 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 51
CCX-1002

Sahu 9 - Review Article of Text: Biodegradability of Plastics by Y. Tokiwa 8/26/2009 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1004

Sahu 11 - Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology Research: Biodegradation of LDPE by fungi isolated from municipal landfill area 2011 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1047

Tolaymat 1 - CC Supplemental Expert Witness List 3/19/2014 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1048 Tolaymat 2 - Resume of Dr. Tolaymat No Date No Bates No Bates CCX-1050

American Bioreactor Landfills I. Leachate Hydrology and Waste Settlement 8/2010 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1051

Tolaymat 4B - Performance of North American Bioreactor Landfills II. Chemical and Biological Characteristics 8/2010 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1052

Tolaymat 4C - Elevation of Lanfill Gas Decay Constant for MSW Landfills Operated as Bioreactors 1/2010 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1054

Tolaymat 6 - Anaerobic biodegradability of cellulose and hemicellulose in excavated refuse samples using a biochemical methane potential assay 1/10/1994 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1057

Tolaymat 9 - EPA Biodegradability of Plastics Under Anaerobic Environment 9/30/2012 FTC_Prod_064758 FTC_Prod_064782 

CCX-1060

Tolaymat 12 - NSF International to S. Mojo Re. Testing Completed per D5511 1/5/2011 FTC_Prod_063650 FTC_Prod_063657 

CCX-1063

Tolaymat 15 - Email from J. Powell to T. Tolaymat RE: Question 4/1/2014 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1069

Tolaymat 21 - International Standard ISO 14855-1 12/1/2012 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1070

Tolaymat 22 - Ecologia Applicata - Italy Test 180 Days 1/10/2012 ECM-112365 ECM-112377 

CCX-1071

Tolaymat 23 - Eden Report D5511-11 Test 070312C - Shields Bag and Printing 7/3/2012 ECM-113977 ECM-113983 

CCX-1072

Tolaymat 24 - Estimate of the decay rate constant of hydrogen sulfide from drywall in a simulated bench-scale study Apr-13 No Bates No Bates 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 52
CCX-1073

Tolaymat 25 - Assessment of the anaeobic degradation of 6 active pharmaceutical ingredients 2/15/2010 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1074 Google News Blog Video 7/28/2014 7/28/2014 No Bates No Bates CCX-1075

Transcript of Deposition of Ryan Burnette 7/2/2014 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1077

Burnette 2 - Additive Technology for Polyolefin Biodegradation by Robert Sinclair of ECM BioFilms No Date No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1078

Burnette 3 - Paper entitled Agricultural Application and Environmental Degradation of Photo-Biodegradable Polyethylene Mulching Films 2004 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1081 Burnette 6 - Handwritten drawing No Date No Bates No Bates CCX-1089 Burnette 14 - CV of Burnette No Date No Bates No Bates CCX-1091 Database Excerpt Cosco 12/22/2013 ECM-FTC-000858 ECM-FTC-000864CCX-1092 Database Excerpt 3M Group 1/21/2014 ECM-001905 ECM-001916CCX-1093

Email from R. Sinclair to 'Pam" RE: Biodegradable plastic film 2/10/2009 ECM-006874 ECM-006874

CCX-1094

Email from Pam (pdonova1@comcast.net) to biodeg@ecmbiofilms.com Subject: Biodegradable plastic film 2/8/2009 ECM-006875 ECM-006875

CCX-1095

Email from S. Hayden to R. Sinclair Re: Anerobic certification 2/9/2011 ECM-054796 ECM-054797

CCX-1096

Eden Labs Update to FP International From T. Poth regarding FPI Samples 120 Days 8/30/2011 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1097

Eden Labs Report ASTM D5511-11 Test - 092511B to FP International From T. Poth regarding 120 days testing of FP International Samples - ERL# 119-124 9/25/2011 No Bates No Bates 

CCX-1099 Affidavit of Robert Sinclair 8/13/2007 BPI 001976 BPI 001977CCX-1100

Email from P. Hartman to R. Sinclair RE: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products 2/14/2011 ECM-055006 ECM-055006

CCX-1101

Email from J. Blood to R. Sinclair and C. Lancelot Subject: NAD Decision and 2 Attachments (Decision and Press Release) 2/11/2011 ECM-055000 ECM-055001

CCX-1102 Database Excerpt Mayorga Firm, Inc 1/21/2014 ECM-003120 ECM-003220CCX-1103

Email from S. Deoras to R. Sinclair RE: Meeting with Bob Sinclair - ECM BioFilms 10/4/2010 ECM-045706 ECM-045708

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 53
CCX-1104

Email from R. Sinclair to agh@rti.org Subject: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products with 4 Attachments 4/23/2009 ECM-011786 ECM-011786

CCX-1105

Email from R. Sinclair to mellis@humphreyline.com Subject: ECM BioFilms' Email 1 of 3 with 8 Attachments 5/2/2009 ECM-011837 ECM-011838

CCX-1106

Email from R. Sinclair to George Collins Subject: RE: Earthworm Health/Safety with 3 Attachments 6/10/2011 ECM-065049 ECM-065051

CCX-1107

Email from R. Sinclair to J. Presnell Subject: RE: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging and Products with 9 Attachments 4/27/2009 ECM-011787 ECM-011789

CCX-1108

Email from R. Sinclair to BurgeTr@dwfinepack.com Subject: ECM BioFilms' Additives for Manufacturing Biodegradable Plastic Packaging with 5 Attachments 11/3/2012 ECM-097790 ECM-097791

RX-00 AMPAC Advertisement 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-01 AMPAC Living Green 3.43(b) & (c) RX-02 SENTRY Green Advertisement 3.43(b) & (c) RX-03 Buckeye/Beauty.com Advertisement 5/2/2013 3.43(b) & (c) RX-04 Covidien e-mail chain 1/5/2010 COV00314 COV000318 3.43(b) & (c) RX-06 Document with OWS 2/26/2014 COV000096 COV000096 3.43(b) & (c) RX-08 Covidien e-mail chain 1/8/2010 COV000290 COV000290 3.43(b) & (c) RX-09

Command Packaging promotional materials 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-10 Letter from SNR Denton 4/15/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-11 Muthu Article 3.43(b) & (c) RX-12 Live Report 3/11/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-13 Geneva Watch Group e-mail chain 3/28/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-15 Island Plastic Bags Flier 3.43(b) & (c) RX-17 Plastic bag 3.43(b) & (c) RX-18 Lancelot Compendium of References 9/22/2011 ECM-FTC-517 ECM-FTC-521 3.43(b) RX-19 TJ's biodegradable bag 3/20/2014 3.43(b) & (c) RX-20 GOMMUS E-mail 3/11/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-21 7/20 Environ internal e-mail chain 7/20/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-22 Umbra advertisement 3.43(b) & (c) RX-23 ECM letter to Poly-America 12/21/2000 3.43(b) & (c) RX-24 Umbra e-mail chain 2/6/2014 3.43(b) & (c) RX-25 Umbra Catalog 3.43(b) & (c) RX-26 Eaton Flier 9/16/2006 EA000071 EA00071 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 54
RX-27 Enviroware label 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-28 Sansei bag 11/28/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-31 Eaton e-mail chain 8/3/2010 EA000069 EA000070 3.43(b) & (c) RX-32 Flexible Plastics Inc.: Logo 12/27/2013 3.43(b) & (c) RX-33 FP International website screen capture 3/24/2014 3.43(b) & (c) RX-34 FP International press release 11/9/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-35 e-mail to Aladina Oct-12 ECM-093688 ECM-093689 3.43(b) 

RX-36 e-mail to American Plastics 10/5/2012 ECM-094350 ECM-094352 3.43(b) 

RX-37 e-mail to Americo Mfg 10/5/2012 ECM-094298 ECM-094299 3.43(b) 

RX-38 e-mail to Bodyglovemobile 10/5/2012 ECM-094316 ECM-094318 3.43(b) RX-39 e-mail to Brooks Sports 10/5/2012 ECM-093459 ECM-093460 3.43(b) RX-40 e-mail to Clark Container 10/5/2012 ECM-095525 ECM-095527 3.43(b) 

RX-41 e-mail to Contempo Card 10/5/2012 ECM-094264 ECM-094265 3.43(b) RX-42 e-mail to Dole and Bailey 10/5/2012 ECM-099000 ECM-099001 3.43(b) 

RX-43 e-mail to Down to Earth 10/5/2012 ECM-094465 ECM-094466 3.43(b) 

RX-44 e-mail to Eaton 10/5/2-12 ECM-094353 ECM-094355 3.43(b) 

RX-45 e-mail to Eco Golf 10/5/2012 ECM-094368 ECM-094370 3.43(b) 

RX-46 e-mail to Ecorite Imaging 10/5/2012 ECM-094274 ECM-094276 3.43(b) RX-47 e-mail to Epsilon Plastics 10/5/2012 ECM-096038 ECM-096039 3.43(b) 

RX-48 e-mail to E-Z Products 10/5/2012 ECM-094284 ECM-094285 3.43(b) RX-49 e-mail to Gilman Bros 10/5/2012 ECM-095331 ECM-095333 3.43(b) RX-50 e-mail to Global Garden Friends 10/5/2012 ECM-094462 ECM-094463 3.43(b) RX-51 e-mail to Global Resource International 10/5/2012 ECM-094262 ECM-094263 3.43(b) RX-52 e-mail to Gommus 10/5/2012 ECM-094266 ECM-094268 3.43(b) 

RX-53 e-mail to Green Packaging 10/5/2012 ECM-094502 ECM-094503 3.43(b) 

RX-54 e-mail to Howard Packaging 10/5/2012 ECM-094432 ECM-094435 3.43(b) 

RX-55 e-mail to Hunter Amenities Oct-12 ECM-094500 ECM-094501 3.43(b) 

RX-56 e-mail to Island Plastic Bags 10/5/2012 ECM-094345 ECM-094347 3.43(b) 

RX-57 e-mail to Italcom 10/5/2012 ECM-094309 ECM-094310 3.43(b) 

RX-58 e-mail to JL Clark 10/5/2012 ECM-094483 ECM-094484 3.43(b) 

RX-59 e-mail to Kleertech Oct-12 ECM-094491 ECM-094492 3.43(b) 

RX-60 e-mail to Ladycare Amenities 10/5/2012 ECM-094470 ECM-094471 3.43(b) 

RX-61 e-mail to Marietta Corp 10/5/2012 ECM-094505 ECM-094506 3.43(b) RX-62 e-mail to McNeil Engineering Corp. 10/5/2012 ECM-094435 ECM-094437 3.43(b) RX-63 e-mail to minigrip 10/5/2012 ECM-094428 ECM-094430 3.43(b) RX-64 e-mail to Odorno 10/5/2012 ECM-094290 ECM-094291 3.43(b) RX-65 e-mail One2Products 10/5/2012 ECM-094374 ECM-094375 3.43(b) RX-66 e-mail to Opiline 10/5/2012 ECM-099065 ECM-099066 3.43(b) 

RX-67 e-mail to PAC Worldwide 10//5/2012 ECM-094637 ECM-094639 3.43(b) RX-68 e-mail to PrimexPlastics 10/5/2012 ECM-094293 ECM-094294 3.43(b) RX-69 e-mail to Regal Lager 10/5/2012 ECM-094287 ECM-094289 3.43(b) RX-70 e-mail to Selan Bioscience 10/5/2012 ECM-094301 ECM-094302 3.43(b) RX-71 e-mail to Shell Packaging Corp 10/5/2012 ECM-094341 ECM-094242 3.43(b) RX-72 e-mail to Shields Bag 10/5/2012 ECM-094304 ECM-094305 3.43(b) RX-72 e-mail to Sigma Plastics 10/5/2012 ECM-094366 ECM-094367 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 55
RX-73 e-mail to SL Plastics 10/5/2012 ECM-094572 ECM-094574 3.43(b) 

RX-74 e-mail to Sondor 10/5/2012 ECM-094634 ECM-094635 3.43(b) RX-75 e-mail to Sunway Kordis 10/5/2012 ECM-094611 ECM-094612 3.43(b) RX-76 e-mail to TekPak Solutions 10/5/2012 ECM-095075 ECM-095077 3.43(b) RX-77 e-mail to Victory Plastic 10/5/2012 ECM-094640 ECM-094641 3.43(b) 

RX-78 1/22 3M e-mail chain 1/22/2010 ECM-027039 ECM-027040 3.43(b) RX-79 2/4 3M e-mail chain 2/4/2010 ECM-027531 ECM-027532 3.43(b) 

RX-80 6/4 3M e-mail chain 6/4/2010 ECM-34104 ECM-34104 3.43(b) 

RX-81 8/12 3M e-mail chain 8/12/2010 ECM-043279 ECM-043279 3.43(b) 

RX-82 8/16 3M e-mail chain 8/16/2010 ECM-043351 ECM-043352 3.43(b) RX-83 10/5 3M e-mail 10/5/2010 ECM-045730 ECM-045730 3.43(b) RX-84 10/28 3M e-mail 10/28/2011 ECM-075952 ECM-075952 3.43(b) RX-85 5/5 BER and customer e-mail 5/5/2009 ECM-012704 ECM-012704 3.43(b) RX-86 9/16 Dispozo e-mail 9/16/2009 ECM-018388 ECM-018389 3.43(b) RX-87 10/21 Dispozo e-mail 10/21/2009 ECM-022565 ECM-022566 3.43(b) RX-88 11/2 Dispozo e-mail 11/2/2009 ECM-022845 ECM-022846 3.43(b) RX-89 1/9 D&W Fine Pack e-mail chain 1/9/2012 ECM-077865 ECM-077866 3.43(b) RX-90 1/11 D&W Fine Pack e-mail chain 1/11/2012 ECM-077877 ECM-077878 3.43(b) RX-91 2/6 D&W Fine Pack e-mail 2/6/2012 ECM-78606 ECM-78606 3.43(b) RX-92 11/3 e-mail to D & W Fine Pack 11/3/2012 ECM-97790 ECM-97791 3.43(b) RX-93 11/16 e-mail to D & W Fine Pack 11/16/2012 ECM-98382 ECM-98382 3.43(b) RX-94 Dispozo Brochure ECM-114535 ECM-114572 3.43(b) RX-95 7/1 Eagle e-mail 7/1/2011 ECM-70442 ECM-70442 3.43(b) RX-96 6/27 Eagle e-mail chain 6/27/2012 ECM-84965 ECM-84965 3.43(b) RX-97 10/8 Eagle e-mail 10/8/2012 ECM-94348 ECM-94348 3.43(b) RX-98 4/23 Flexible Plastics e-mail 4/23/2009 ECM-10448 ECM-10448 3.43(b) RX-99 2/10 FP e-mail chain 2/10/2009 ECM-6881 ECM-6882 3.43(b) RX-100 2/12 FP e-mail chain 2/12/2009 ECM-6952 ECM-6953 3.43(b) RX-101 4/4 FP e-mail chain 4/4/2009 ECM-11535 ECM-11536 3.43(b) RX-102 9/18 FP e-mail chain 9/18/2009 ECM-18459 ECM-18459 3.43(b) RX-103 8/10 FP e-mail chain 8/10/2010 ECM-45244 ECM-45245 3.43(b) RX-104 11/3 FP e-mail chain 11/3/2010 ECM-47151 ECM-47152 3.43(b) RX-105 11/8 FP e-mail chain 11/8/2010 ECM-47321 ECM-47322 3.43(b) RX-106 11/22 FP e-mail chain 11/22/2010 ECM-47762 ECM-47763 3.43(b) RX-107 4/22 FP e-mail chain 4/22/2011 ECM-69289 ECM-69289 3.43(b) RX-108 8/2 FP e-mail chain 8/2/2012 ECM-89587 ECM-89588 3.43(b) RX-109 12/13 FP e-mail 12/13/2012 ECM-96563 ECM-96563 3.43(b) RX-110 4/10 FP e-mail chain 4/10/2013 ECM-105970 ECM-105971 3.43(b) RX-111

FP's The Science of Biodegradable Plastics ECM-113957 ECM-113966 3.43(b) 

RX-112 1/27 Island Plastic Bags e-mail chain 1/27/2009 ECM-8488 ECM-8488 3.43(b) RX-113 9/28 Island Plastic Bags e-mail chain 9/28/2009 ECM-21120 ECM-21120 3.43(b) RX-114 7/20 Island Plastic Bags e-mail chain 7/20/2010 ECM-38764 ECM-38764 3.43(b) RX-115 1/5 Island Plastic Bags e-mail chain 1/5/2012 ECM-77792 ECM-77782 3.43(b) RX-116 7/4 Island Plastic Bags e-mail chain 7/4/2012 ECM-88471 ECM-88471 3.43(b) RX-117 10/8 Island Plastic Bags e-mail chain 10/8/2012 ECM-94345 ECM-94345 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 56
RX-118 1/22 Island Plastic Bags e-mail chain 1/22/2013 ECM-100178 ECM-100178 3.43(b) 

RX-119 1/21 Island Plastic Bags e-mail chain 1/21/2013 ECM-100248 ECM-100249 3.43(b) RX-120 Barber letter to Kappus 1/25/2007 ECM-114860 ECM-114860 3.43(b) RX-121 3/22 Kappus e-mail chain 3/22/2009 ECM-9738 ECM-9738 3.43(b) RX-122 9/12 Kappus e-mail chain 9/22/2010 ECM-41136 ECM-41136 3.43(b) RX-123 10/22 Kappus e-mail chain 10/22/2010 ECM-46678 ECM-46678 3.43(b) RX-124 11/23 e-mail from Sigma Plastics 11/23/2009 ECM-23456 ECM-23456 3.43(b) RX-125 11/4 e-mail chain from Green Genius 11/4/2010 ECM-47266 ECM-47267 3.43(b) RX-126

Collection of e-mails from ECM customers inquiring about ECM's Masterbatch's ingredients 3.43(b) 

RX-127

Collection of e-mails from ECM customers inquiring about whether ECM plastics biodegrade in water 3.43(b) 

RX-128

Collection of e-mails from ECM customers inquiring on environmental friendliness of ECM products 3.43(b) 

RX-129

Collection of e-mails from ECM customers inquiring on whether ECM Master is FDA approved and/or safe for food products 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

RX-130

Collection of e-mails from ECM customers asking questions on manufacturing process or other practical questions 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

RX-131

E-mail from Island Plastic Bag; customers want to know if foam products are biodegradable 6/25/2009 ECM-13712 ECM-13712 3.43(b) 

RX-132

Collection of e-mails from ECM customers asking ECM multiple questions not about rate of biodegradation 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

RX-133

Collection of e-mails from ECM customers asking about shelf life of ECM products 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

RX-134

Collection of e-mails from ECM customers asking if ECM products are biodegradable 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

RX-135 Collection of e-mails wherein ECM qualifies or refuses to provide rate of 5/13/2014 3.43(b) 

RX-136 3/28 Geneva Watch Group e-mail chain 3/28/2011 ECM-59848 ECM-59849 3.43(b) RX-137

2/20 e-mail to Green Tech Partner Solutions 2/10/2012 ECM-078972 ECM-078973 3.43(b) 

RX-138 ECM Marketing Materials ECM-1882 ECM-1893 3.43(b) RX-139 10/27 e-mail chain with S. Patrick Morgan 10/27/2011 ECM-75914 ECM-75915 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 57
RX-140 12/28 e-mail chain with Pueri Elemental 12/28/2011 ECM-77410 ECM-77413 3.43(b) 

RX-141 Guide for RONA Suppliers ECM-77640 ECM-77641 3.43(b) 

RX-142 7/21 e-mail to Earth Cure 7/21/2012 ECM-88092 ECM-88093 3.43(b) RX-143 9/13 e-mail chain with Transilwrap 9/13/2012 ECM-92587 ECM-92589 3.43(b) RX-144 7/5 e-mail chain with Nu-Methods 7/21/2012 ECM-88503 ECM-88505 3.43(b) RX-145 1/2 e-mail chain with Begg & Co. 1/2/2013 ECM-102176 ECM-102177 3.43(b) RX-146 10/3 e-mail chain with Westchem 10/3/2013 ECM-5739 ECM-5739 3.43(b) RX-147 12/8 e-mail from BPI to Michel 12/8/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-148 12/15 e-mail from BPI to Michel 12/15/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-149

11/20 e-mail chain between Mojo and Michel 11/20/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-150 Proposal to BPI 11/21/2008 3.43(b) RX-151 10/23 e-mail from Mojo to Michel 10/22/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-153 9/6 e-mail from Michel to Wilshire 9/6/2013 3.43 (c) RX-154 3/5 PPC e-mail 3/5/2013 PPC0643 PPC0643 3.43 (c) 

RX-155 8/20 PPC e-mail 8/20/2010 PPC0351 PPC0351 3.43(b) & (c) RX-156 11/24 PPC e-mail 11/24/2010 PPC0646 PPC0646 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-157 9/13 PPC e-mail 9/13/2010 PPC0184 PPC0184 3.43(b) & (c) RX-158 3/30 PPC e-mail 3/30/2013 PPC0655 PPC0655 3.43(b) & (c) RX-159 6/1 Pregis e-mail chain 6/1/2010 PPC0674 PPC0677 3.43(b) & (c) RX-160 Dispozo Enviroware Advertisement 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-161 Lagasse Sweet Advertisement 3.43(b) & (c) RX-162 Ohio's Country Journal Article 2/14/2014 3.43(b) 

RX-163 Licking County Article 2/17/2014 3.43(b) RX-164 1/29 e-mail from Mojo to Michel 1/29/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-165

11/13 e-mail chain between Mojo and Michel 11/13/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-166

12/10 e-mail chain between Mojo and Michel 12/10/2008 ELS_ECM000172 ELS_ECM000172 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-167

6/25 e-mail chain between Michel and Malaree 6/25/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-168

4/18 e-mail chain between Mojo and Michel 8/1/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-169 Who is the BPI BPI 2692 BPI 2692 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-170 11/10 e-mail from Buzz to Mojo 11/10/2010 BPI 2549 BPI 2549 3.43(b) & (c) RX-171 BPI Comments on Marketing Guides 1/30/2008 BPI 2674 BPI 2680 3.43 (c) RX-172 BPI comments on Green Guides 12/7/2010 BPI 3072 BPI 3075 3.43(b) & (c) EX-173 Excerpt from Green Guides BPI 3595 BPI 3595 3.43(b) & (c) RX-174 2/27 BPI letter to FTC 2/27/2002 BPI 2961 BPI 2963 3.43(b) & (c) RX-175

Collection of e-mails between Mojo and Frankle 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-176

Collection of e-mails between Mojo and McCormick 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-177

Collection of e-mails between Mojo and Koss 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 58
RX-178 BPI presentation 4/21/2011 BPI 3992 BPI 4032 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-179

Collection of e-mails between Mojo and Davis 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-180 FTC Green Packaging Claims 3.43(b) RX-181 2/7 letter from Mojo to FTC 2/7/2002 BPI 2955 BPI 2957 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-182 7/10 letter from Mojo to FTC 7/10/2002 BPI 2964 BPI 2964 3.43(b) & (c) RX-183 3/30 letter from Mojo to FTC 3/30/2010 BPI 2777 BPI 2778 3.43(b) & (c) RX-184

Collection of e-mails between Narayan and Mojo 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-185 10/14 e-mail from Narayan to Mantri 10/14/2011 BPI 1249 BPI 1249 3.43(b) RX-186

4/30 e-mail from Narayan to Russo and Sheets 4/30/2012 BPI 1253 BPI 1253 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-187 10/21 e-mail from Mojo to Stromberg 10/21/2008 BPI 239 BPI 239 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-188 8/29 e-mail from Narayan to Fine 8/29/2011 BPI 1269 BPI 1270 3.43(b) & (c) RX-189

7/28 e-mail chain between Mojo and Vernon 7/28/2008 BPI 1193 BPI 1194 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-190 BPI FAQ 3.43(b) 

RX-191 7/17 Mojo e-mail to Cal Gov't 7/17/2007 BPI 156 BPI 157 3.43(b) & (c) RX-192 9/21 letter from Mojo to FTC 9/21/2009 BPI 3353 BPI 3355 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-193 9/12 letter from Mojo to FTC 9/12/2003 BPI 2975 BPI 2976 3.43(b) & (c) RX-194 FTC goals and proposed agenda items BPI 2745 BPI 2745 3.43(b) & (c) RX-195

FTC: The Green Guides Statement of Basis and Purpose 3.43(b) 

RX-204 Aguirre Article 3/31/2010 3.43(b) RX-207 Collection of McCarthy's patents 3.43(b) RX-209 Umass-Lowell Press Release 3/14/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-211 6/26 e-mail from Igoe to FTC 6/26/2008 BPI 143 BPI 143 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-213 11/15 e-mail from Wilshire to Michel 3.43(b) & (c) RX-214

11/18 e-mail chain between Shah and Michel 11/18/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-215 2/2 Letter from Shah to Michel 2/2/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-216 2/26 e-mail from Shah to Michel 2/26/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-217

2/23 e-mail chain between Shah, Michel, and Thomas 2/23/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-218

Biodegradability and Life Cycle Analysis of Plastic and Bioresin Nursery Pots 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-219

8/18 e-mail chain between Shah and Michel 8/18/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-220 Grant application 2/6/2012 3.43(b) & (c) RX-221 7/27 Shah and Michel e-mail chain 7/27/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-222 10/21 e-mail from Gomez to Shah 10/21/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-223 Gomez PHD Proposal 6/29/2012 3.43(b) & (c) RX-224

7/7 e-mail chain between Gomez and Shah 7/7/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-225 10/10 Gomez and Michel e-mail chain 10/19/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 59
RX-226

2/26 e-mail chain between Michel and Shah 2/26/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-227

5/19 e-mail chain between Gomez and Shah 5/19/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-228 6/9 Gomez and Shah e-mail chain 6/9/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-229

6/14 e-mail chain between Gomez and Michel 6/14/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-230

7/28 e-mail chain between Gomez and Shah 7/28/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-231

8/6 e-mail chain between Gomez and Shah 8/6/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-232

8/16 e-mail chain between Gomez and Michel 8/16/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-233

10/27 e-mail chain between Gomez and Shah Oct-10 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-234

1/8 e-mail chain between Gomez and Shah 1/8/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-235

1/31 e-mail chain between Gomez and shah 1/31/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-236 2/1 Gomez e-mail to Shah 2/1/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-237

4/1 e-mail chain between Gomez and Shah 4/1/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-238

5/9 e-mail chain between Gomez and Shah 5/9/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-239

5/27 e-mail chain between Gomez and Michel 5/272011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-240

12/28 e-mail chain between Gomez and Michel 12/18/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-241 6/29 e-mail from Gomez to Michel 6/29/2012 3.43(b) & (c) RX-242 4/25 e-mail from Shah to Michel 4/25/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-243 Presentation by Michel and Gomez 3.43(b) & (c) RX-244

1/31 e-mail chain between Gomez and Michel 1/31/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-245 Gomez Dissertation Draft 10/9/2013 3.43(b) & (c) RX-246 Draft report for Myers 12/5/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-247 Draft article by Gomez and Michel 3/12/2013 3.43(b) & (c) RX-248 Eden 9/25 test to FP 9/25/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-249 120 day test analysis 12/8/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-250 ATSDR Chapter 2: Landfill Gas Basics 7014 7020 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-251 Eden Manual 7007 7013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-252 Eden Inoculum manual 6022 6026 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-253 Article by Yagi et al produced by Eden 9/2/2009 6003 6010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-254 Environ report for BIOPVC 8/12/2008 ECM-FTC-69 ECM-FTC-88 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-255 Letter from Environ to Kappus 3/11 3/11/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-256 Bodycote Test cert 8/8/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-257 Bodycote Test cert 10/31/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 60
RX-258 Memo for Warner to Advent Environ 9/17/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-259 Letter from Environ to Kappus 8/12 8/12/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-261 OWS protocol for study PFR-4 9/8/1998 ECM-111748 ECM-111761 3.43(b) RX-262 OWS Protocol for study PFR-3/1 9/2/1998 ECM-111774 ECM-111786 3.43(b) RX-264

OWS final Report; Composting test, followed by ecotoxicity tests 3.43(b) 

RX-265

OWS Final Report; High solids Anaerobic Digestion (HSAD) Test 2/22/1999 ECM-112008 ECM-112025 3.43(b) 

RX-267 OWS Final Report Infrared Analysis 3/8/2000 ECM-112216 ECM-112219 3.43(b) RX-269 

ChemRisk Ecological Assessment of ECM Plastic 2/16/1999 ECM-FTC-106 ECM-FTC-122 3.43(b) 

RX-270 UNM 12/12 test 12/12/2006 ECM-FTC-186 ECM-FTC-197 3.43(b) RX-271 UNM 3/6 test 3/6/2007 ECM-FTC-163 ECM-FTC-205 3.43(b) 

RX-272 SSCCP Italcom test 2/26/2009 ECM-114094 ECM-114991 3.43(b) RX-272A SSCCP Italcom test translated 2/26/2009 ECM-114984 ECM-114989 3.43(b) RX-273 Ecologia Report 11/19/2010 ECM-FTC-226 ECM-FTC-241 3.43(b) RX-274 Biofoam Degradation Test ECM-114059 ECM-114080 3.43(b) RX-275 Environ Letter to FP 3/2 3/2/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-276 Ecologia Test to 180 days 1/10/2012 ECM-112504 ECM-112516 3.43(b) 

RX-277 Intertek Isoe Printpack 7/4/1905 ECM-113313 ECM-113317 3.43(b) RX-278 SEM Examination of ECM Plastic Ecm-FTC-206 ECM-FTC-225 3.43(b) 

RX-279 12/3 Letter from ECM to 3M 12/3/2008 3M29 3M30 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-280

BPI's Background Biodegradable Additives to 3M 3M66 3M70 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-281 3M internal notes and e-mails 3M92 3M96 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-282 1/27 e-mail from Joseph to Baker 1/27/2010 3M174 3M174 3.43(b) & (c) RX-283 BER Plastic's faxes 11/6/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-284 The Truth About Biodegradable Plastics 3/7/2008 DWFP1168 DWFP1169 3.43(b) & (c) RX-285 Dispoz-o Press Release 4/2/2009 DWFP1367 DWFP1370 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-286 Enviroware Premier Contract PP-DI-427 DWFP1405 DWFP13406 3.43(b) & (c) RX-287 Enviroware Stages of Degradation DWFP1422 DWFP1422 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-288 dispoz-o products enviroware DWFP1482 DWFP1485 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-289

Questions you may concerning enviroware DWFP1489 DWFP1490 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-290 Enviroware FAQ DWFP1491 DWFP1491 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-291 enviroware leading the Drive to "Green" DWFP1494 DWFP1496 3.43(b) & (c) RX-292

Enviroware answering FAQ and other green issues DWFP1516 DWFP1516 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-293 Enviroware slideshow DWFP1539 DWFP1551 3.43(b) & (c) RX-294 NACUFS newsletter 8/1/2008 DWFP1736 DWFP1736 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-295 5/23 e-mail chain 5/23/2008 DWFP3626 DWFP3629 3.43(b) & (c) RX-296

10/13 e-mail chain between Swiger and Epstein 10/13/2008 DWFP3874 DWFP3875 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-297 4/26 e-mail from Leiti to Ellsworth 4/26/2010 DWFP4045 DWFP4045 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 61
RX-298 2/23 D&W internal e-mail chain 2/23/2012 DWFP4143 DWFP4143 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-299

8/4 e-mail chain between Leiti and Swiger 8/4/2008 DWFP5642 DWFP5644 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-300 8/19 e-mail from Leiti to Hartman 8/19/2008 DWFP5680 DWFP5680 3.43(b) & (c) RX-301 5/10 e-mail from Glymph to Beecroft 5/10/2011 DWFP5783 DWFP5783 3.43(b) & (c) RX-302

7/11 e-mail chain between Schultz, Leiti, and Staton 2/2/2010 DWFP5802 DWFP5804 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-303 3/20 internal D&W e-mail chain 3/20/2013 DWFP6109 DWFP6113 3.43(b) & (c) RX-304 Enviroware facts DWFP6313 DWFP6313 3.43(b) & (c) RX-305 Reprint of a letter to an Interested Party 10/28/2005 DTE10 DTE11 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-306 5/19 Letter to Councilman Molina 5/19/2009 DTE71 DTE71 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-307 1/19 Letter to Yoshimoto 1/19/2010 DTE76 DTE77 3.43(b) & (c) RX-308

5/25 e-mail chain between Sinclair and Santana 5/25/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-309 4/23 e-mails from Collins to Mathias 4/23/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-310 4/23 e-mail from Collins to Mathias 4/23/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-311 6/23 e-mail chain from Eagle 6/23/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-312 4/16 e-mail chain from Eagle 4/16/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-314

1/23 Letter from Flexible Plastic to Customer 1/23/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-315 Flexible Plastic Advertisement 7/3/1905 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-316

10/18 e-mail from Hong to Ohana Sales and Marketing 10/18/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-317 3/14 e-mail from Hong to Flynn 3/14/2014 3.43(b) & (c) RX-318 3/20 e-mail from Hong to Sumira 2/20/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-320 3/5 e-mail from Hong to bby 3/5/2013 3.43(b) & (c) RX-321

9/29 e-mail chain between Blood and Ghosh 9/29/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-322

e-mail chain between NE Labs and Dansko 8/2/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-323

e-mail chain between NE Labs and Masternet 8/23/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-324

9/5 e-mail chain between NE Labs and Sweettape 9/5/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-325 6/23 e-mail from NE Labs to ECM 6/23/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-326 ECM Pricing Sheets ECM-FTC-2 ECM-FTC-7 3.43(b) 

RX-327 ECM Material Safety Data Sheet 7/10/2007 ECM-FTC-8 ECM-FTC-12 3.43(b) RX-330 ECM 6.0701 pricing sheet 1/15/2010 ECM-FTC-18 ECM-FTC-18 3.43(b) RX-331 ECM 6.0404 pricing sheet 1/15/2010 ECM-FTC-19 ECM-FTC-19 3.43(b) RX-332 ECM web capture ECM-FTC-22 ECM-FTC-22 3.43(b) RX-333 About ECM web capture ECM-FTC-34 ECM-FTC-34 3.43(b) RX-334 Green Impact web capture ECM-FTC-38 ECM-FTC-39 3.43(b) 

RX-335 ECM Comparison web capture ECM-FTC-48 ECM-FTC-48 3.43(b) 

RX-336 Barber Biography 9/3/2008 ECM-FTC-89 ECM-FTC-91 3.43(b) RX-337 Barber C.V. ECM-FTC-92 ECM-FTC-105 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 62
RX-338 9/3 e-mail from Nealis 9/3/2008 ECM-FTC-242 ECM-FTC-243 3.43(b) 

RX-340

Standard Mutual Confidentiality Agreement ECM-FTC-352 ECM-FTC-355 3.43(b) 

RX-341 

9/23 e-mail chain between Sinclair and Tyrone 9/23/2010 ECM-FTC-372 ECM-FTC-373 3.43(b) 

RX-342 Schwarzenegger veto ECM-FTC-383 ECM-FTC-383 3.43(b) RX-343 Interoffice Memorandum 9/29/2010 ECM-FTC-384 ECM-FTC-384 3.43(b) RX-344 9/29 e-mail from Tim to Nealis 9/29/2010 ECM-FTC-385 ECM-FTC-385 3.43(b) RX-345 Levis and Barlaz article ECM-FTC-510 ECM-FTC-516 3.43(b) RX-346 Barlaz declaration 10/5/2011 ECM-FTC-550 ECM-FTC-550 3.43(b) RX-347 Green Guides 3.43(b) 

RX-348

Green Guide's statement of basis and purpose 3.43(b) 

RX-349 Article by Gattin et al 1/1/2001 ECM-113046 ECM-113052 3.43(b) 

RX-350 Environ letter to Albert 3/10/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-351 12/20 e-mail from Barber to Langen 12/20/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-352 ETC Report ECM-112391 ECM-112407 3.43(b) 

RX-353 Article by Shen and Bartha 4/1/1996 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-354 Article by Albertsson et al x/x/1976 3.43(b) & (c) RX-355 Article by Albertsson et al x/x/1978 3.43(b) & (c) RX-356 Designation: D5511-12 3.43(b) RX-357 Designation: D5511-12 3.43(b) 

RX-358 Designation: D5526-12 3.43(b) 

RX-359 Designation: D5526-12 3.43(b) 

RX-360 Article by Tokiwa et al 8/26/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-361 Article by Iwamoto & Tokiwa x/x/1994 3.43(b) & (c) RX-362 199 Patent 3/16/199 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-363 Article by Fontaine et al 2/27/2003 3.43(b) & (c) RX-364 Sahu white paper 5/13/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-365 Article by Tilstra and Johnsonbaugh x/x/1993 3.43(b) & (c) RX-366 10/16 Hall and Barber e-mail chain 10/16/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-367

Standard test method for determining mass loss from plastics exposed to activated aerobic and anaerobic compost and landfill environments 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-369 7/19 e-mail chain Alire and Barber 7/19/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-371 Report by Sinclair 3.43(b) 

RX-372 11/20 Environ internal e-mail chain 11/20/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-373 11/17 Environ internal e-mail chain 11/17/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-374 7/23 Barber and Kappus e-mail chain 7/23/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-375 3/1 e-mails from Kappus and Pennington 3/1/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-376 6/5 e-mails from Kappus and Barber 6/5/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-377 3/1 Kappus e-mail 3/1/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-378 Environ terms and conditions 7/10/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-379 US Greenhouse Gas Emissions ECM-113097 ECM-113115 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 63
RX-380

Chapter IX to Monitored Natural Attenuation ECM-112800 ECM-112869 3.43(b) 

RX-382 FP Web Capture ECM-113938 ECM-113938 3.43(b) RX-383 FP Web Capture ECM-113936 ECM-113937 3.43(b) RX-384 Plastics & Packaging News ECM-114513 ECM-114516 3.43(b) RX-386

4/21 e-mail chain between Young and Barber 4/21/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-387 Eden response to Subpoena 9001 9033 3.43(b) & (c) RX-388 Clemson Test Results Phase I DWFP5155 DWFP5180 3.43(b) & (c) RX-389 Clemson Test Protocol DWFP109 DWFP116 3.43(b) & (c) RX-390 Clemson Test Conclusion DWFP837 DWFP837 3.43(b) & (c) RX-391 Clemson Test Results DWFP534 DWFP1001 3.43(b) & (c) RX-392 NE Labs Report # 1048036 4/20/2011 ECM-112244 ECM-112247 3.43(b) RX-394 NE Labs Report # 1150851 10/7/2011 ECM-114412 ECM-114414 3.43(b) RX-395 NE Labs Report # 1150851 9/30/2011 ECM-114359 ECM-114361 3.43(b) RX-396 NE Labs Report # 1048819 12/14/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-397 NE Labs Report #N0946510-02 12/30/2009 ECM-113535 ECM-113548 3.43(b) RX-398 NE Labs Report #N0946510-01 12/30/2009 ECM-113084 ECM-113087 3.43(b) RX-399 NE Labs Report #N0843980 12/30/2008 ECM-114004 ECM-114005 3.43(b) RX-400 Eden Labs ASTMD5511-12 7000 7006 3.43(b) & (c) RX-401 Eden Test to Smithers Oasis 8/31/2013 1023 1041 3.43(b) & (c) RX-402 Eden test to FP 2/7/2014 1042 1047 3.43(b) & (c) RX-403 Eden test to Fellows 10/9/2012 1048 1053 3.43(b) & (c) RX-404 Eden test to Shields 3/22/2012 5001 5012 3.43(b) & (c) RX-405 NE Labs Report # 1048742-01 11/17/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-406 10/21 letter and test results from Environ 10/21/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-407 6/2 Letter and test from Environ to Kizer 6/2/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-408 OWS test for Shields 1/12/2012 ECM-114227 ECM-114233 3.43(b) RX-410 Environ Dispozo test data 5/21/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-412 OWS report for Funsam 2/23/2007 ECM-114968 ECM-114977 3.43(b) RX-413 11/3 Letter from Environ to FP 11/3/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-414 P.C. Richardson advertisement 3.43(b) & (c) RX-416 Article by Ruiz ECM-113091 ECM-113095 3.43(b) RX-417 FP Super 8 Loosefill ECM-113023 ECM-113024 3.43(b) RX-418 FP Cell-O Air cushions ECM-113021 ECM-113022 3.43(b) RX-419 FP Speed Feeder ECM-113019 ECM-113020 3.43(b) RX-420 FP Pillow Pack ECM-113017 ECM-113018 3.43(b) RX-422

Biodegradable Plastic Packaging Material by Alire 7/22/2009 ECM-112940 ECM-112952 3.43(b) 

RX-423 Earth Aware Promotional Materials ECM-112332 ECM-112333 3.43(b) RX-424 Anderson Die & Mfg Article 3/19/2010 ECM-112316 ECM-112317 3.43(b) RX-426 12/17 e-mail from Barber to Sulano 12/17/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-427

10/3 e-mail chain between Barber and Ranyi 10/3/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 64
RX-428 

9/25 e-mail chain between Barber and Ranyi 9/25/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-429 10/16 Barber and Shahar e-mail chain 10/16/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-430 12/8 Barber and Walters e-mail chain 12/8/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-431 7/20 e-mail from Alire to Barber 7/20/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-432 2000 article by ECM 12/20/2000 3.43(b) & (c) RX-434 Barber Affidavit 6/16/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-435 10/17 Environ internal e-mail chain 10/17/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-436 2/17 Barber e-mail to Porter 2/17/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-437 Dansko and Ecologic Gas Production 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-438 Dansko and Ecologic Gas Totals 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-439

Minigrip, Ecologic, Lather, Polimernet Gas Totals 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-440 Minigrip Continued Gas Totals 3.43(b) & (c) RX-441 Minigrip Data 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-442

Minigrip, Ecologic, Lather, Polimernet Gas Production 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-443 PP Chart 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-444 PPC Gas Totals 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-445 PPC Gas Totals Continued 545 + Days 3.43(b) & (c) RX-446 PPC Sheets 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-447 PPC-Ecologic-Transil Gas Production 3.43(b) & (c) RX-448 PPC-ECO-TRAN Gas Totals 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-449 ppc-transil-eco 108 day totals 3.43(b) & (c) RX-450 Tycoplas and Sweettape Gas Production 3.43(b) & (c) RX-451 Tycoplas Gas totals 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-452 Narayan's Summary 11/1/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-453

3/14 e-mail chain between Katherine Johnson and Dana Rosenfeld 3/14/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-454 EPA Facts and Figures for 2008 FTC_Prod_519 FTC_Prod_530 3.43(b) 

RX-455 Initial prehearing Conference excerpt 11/21/2013 3.43(b) RX-456 Green Guides Excerpt 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-457 Statement of Basis and Purpose excerpt 10/1/2012 3.43(b) & (c) RX-460 Methane Generation in Landfills 4/15/2006 ECM-114622 ECM-114636 3.43(b) RX-462 Environ Dispozo Test Results 11/1/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-463 Environ Dispozo Test Results II 11/1/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-465 SSCCP Test Report 75/2 2/26/2009 ECM-114988 ECM-114991 3.43(b) 

RX-466 SSCCP Test Report 9 1/8/2013 ECM-114329 ECM-114338 3.43(b) RX-469 SSCCP Test Report 10 1/8/2013 ECM-114329 ECM-114329 3.43(b) RX-470

Translation certificate from Day Translations 3/21/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-471 Orders by customer 3.43(b) 

RX-472 Summary of Testing Data 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 65
RX-473 e-mail from Barlaz to Poth on 5/13 5/13/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-474 e-mail chain between Barlaz and Alire 9/11/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-475 e-mail chain between Barlaz and Alire 8/17/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-475A attachment to Barlaz 8-17 e-mail to Alire 8/17/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-476 e-mail chain between Barlaz and Alire 11/10/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-477 e-mail chain between Barlaz and Alire 10/21/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-478 Letter from Barlaz to Poth 9/16/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-479 BMP FP International data 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-480 Letter from Barlaz to Khalil 2/18/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-481 FP International Data Summary 9/30/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-482 Letter from Barlaz to Alire 11/14/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-483 Letter from Barlaz to Alire 12/5/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-484 e-mail chain between Barlaz and Alire 11/13/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-485 Letter from Barlaz to Pech 3/4/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-486 Baldwin et al 12/1/1998 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-487 Bareither et al 8/1/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-488

Performance of N. Am. Bioreactors Landfills II 8/1/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-489

Forest products decomposition in municipal solid waste landfills 11/18/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-490

Methane production from municipal refuse: A review of enhancement techniques and microbial dynamics 1/1/1990 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-491

Bacterial Population Development and Chemical Characteristics of Refuse Decomposition in a Simulated Sanitary Landfill 1/1/1989 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-492 Levis and Barlaz 3/23/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-493 Deipser and Stegmann 1/1/1994 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-494 De La Cruz and Barlaz 4/22/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-495 Vermont Waste Composition Study 5/1/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-496 Eleazer et al 1/1/1997 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-497 Finlay and Fenchel 11/24/1990 3.43(b) & (c) RX-498 Hanson et al 8/1/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-499 Hilger and Barlaz 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-500 Solid Waste Disposal 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-501 Kjeldsen et al 1/1/2002 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-502 LandGEM Version 3.02 5/1/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-503 Levis and Barlaz 5/13/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-504 Levis and Barlaz 7/27/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-505 Levis and Barlaz 6/1/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-506 Mormile et al 5/1/1996 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-507 Pohland and Gould 1/1/1986 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-508 Ress et al 1/1/1998 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 66
RX-509

Wake County Waste Characterization Study 5/1/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-510 Shelton and Tiedje 1/1/1984 3.43(b) & (c) RX-511 EPA Facts and Figures for 2011 5/1/2013 3.43(b) & (c) RX-512

Inventory of US Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks 1990-2010 4/15/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-513

Inventory of US Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks 1990-2011 4/12/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-514 Wang et al 7/4/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-515 Wang et al 1/10/1994 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-516 Wang et al 3/7/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-517 Yesiller et al 11/1/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-518 Ecology of Methane Formation 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-519 Physiological Ecology of Methanogens 3.43(b) & (c) RX-520

ECM article entitled Biodegradable Plastic products 12/20/2000 3.3(b) 

RX-521

ECM technology for the biodegradation of plastic products 3.43(b) 

RX-522

Life expectancy of Products manufactured with ECM 3.43(b) 

RX-523 Environ BioPVC Final Summary 3.43(b) & (c) RX-524 Letter from Barber to Kappus 3/2/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-525 Letter from Barber to Kappus 11/29/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-526 Letter from Barber to Kappus 11/30/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-527 Half life calculations 3.43(b) & (c) RX-529 e-mail from Scott Hall 10/2/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-530 e-mail from Scott Hall 9/24/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-531 e-mail from Kappus to Barber 2/8/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-532 e-mail from Hall to Barber 9/21/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-533 e-mail from Hall to Barber 5/20/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-534 e-mail between Kappus and Barber 10/29/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-535 e-mail between Barber and Kappus 2/10/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-536

e-mail chain between Kuykindall, Barber, and Hall 2/20/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-537 Barber and Kappus e-mail chain 7/23/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-538 Barber and Kappus e-mail chain 2/22/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-539 Letter from Barber to Kizer 4/6/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-540 e-mail chain between Kizer and Barber 4/3/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-541 e-mail chain between Barber and Hall 8/18/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-542 e-mail chain between Barber and Hall 7/20/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-543 Ramirez, Barber, and Grove e-mails 8/24/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-544

e-mail chain between Barber and Ramirez 10/3/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-545 e-mail chain between Lichtle and Barber 2/11/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 67
RX-546

e-mail chain between Hall, Sutton, and Moore 2/26/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-547 Image of Aerobic Condition 3.43(b) & (c) RX-548 Image of Anaerobic Condition 3.43(b) & (c) RX-549 Standard Test Method document 3.43(b) & (c) RX-550 e-mail from Scott Hall 8/1/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-551 OWS Final Report PFR-3 2/15/1999 3.43(b) & (c) RX-552 PC Analysis 12/28/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-553 Heterephobic Plate Count Summary 5/28/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-554 e-mail chain between Barber and Hall 2/5/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-555 Barber e-mails 11/17/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-556 Dolco test data 4/22/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-558 Letter from Barber to Alire 9/7/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-559 NAD Finding on Masternet 10/2/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-561 e-mail chain between Barber and Zhu 1/4/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-562 e-mail chain between Barber and Green 4/6/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-563 e-mail from Harty to Barber 4/10/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-564

e-mail chain between Clayton and Barber 7/2/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-565 e-mail chain between Curren and Barber 7/13/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-566 e-mail chain between Curren and Barber 9/5/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-567 e-mail chain between Barber and Zhu 9/25/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-568 e-mail chain between Barber and Albert 10/15/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-569 e-mail chain between Barber and Zhu 12/3/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-570

e-mail chain between Barber and McGregor 12/8/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-571

e-mail chain between Barber and McGregor 12/8/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-572 e-mail chain between Sulano and Barber 12/17/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-573

e-mail chain between Barber and Langen 12/20/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-574 e-mail chain between Barber and Albert 3/19/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-575 Additives in Plastics 6/1/1975 3.43(b) & (c) RX-576 Demir et al 4/19/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-577 EM 200 1 10 6/30/2005 3.43(b) & (c) RX-578 EPA G8 Final 11/1/2002 3.43(b) & (c) RX-579 Ling et al 1/1/1998 3.43(b) & (c) RX-580 Pramila and Ramesh 1/1/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-581 Shah et al 1/1/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 68
RX-583

Intro to Polymer Additives and Stabilization 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-584 Chap. 11 by van der Zee 1/1/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-586 Arutchelvi et al 1/1/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-587 Bhardwaj et al 8/30/2012 3.43(b) & (c) RX-588 EPA web capture 3.43(b) & (c) RX-589 Plastipedia web capture 6/20/2014 3.43(b) & (c) RX-590 Tilstra and Johnsonbaugh 1/1/1999 3.43(b) & (c) RX-591

e-mail chain between Johnson and Rosenfeld 3/27/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-592

e-mail chain between Johnson and Rosenfeld 3/14/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-593 e-mail from Johnson to Rosenfeld 7/19/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-594 Letter from Narayan to Mojo 3/10/2005 3.43(b) & (c) RX-595 E-mail from Narayan to Monica 8/31/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-596 APCO Study 9/1/2006 FTC_Prod_533 FTC_Prod_564 3.43(b) 

RX-597 APCO questions 1/1/2006 FTC_Prod_614 FTC_Prod_537 3.43(b) RX-598 APCO data FTC_Prod_639 FTC_Prod_639 3.43(b) 

RX-599 APCO survey FTC_Prod_644 FTC_Prod_651 3.43(b) 

RX-600 Survey responses FTC_Prod_660 FTC_Prod_660 3.43(b) 

RX-601 Appendix A to Stewart Report 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-602 Appendix B to Stewart report 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-603 Appendix C1 to Stewart Report 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-604 Appendix C2 to Stewart Report 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-605 Appendix D to Stewart Report 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-606 Appendix E to Stewart Report 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-607 Appendix F1 to Stewart Report 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-608 Appendix F2 to Stewart Report 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-609 Data for survey 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-610 Codes 4/8/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-611 Manufacturers Survey 5/14/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-612 Verbatim answers 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-613 Environment Questionnaire 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-614 Environment Tabs 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-615 Read et al 1/1/2012 CC-SF-66-1 CC-SF-66-10 3.43(b) RX-616 Frederick and Mochon 1/1/2011 CC-SF-67-1 CC-SF-67-10 3.43(b) RX-617 Mochon and Frederick 1/1/2013 CC-SF-68-1 CC-SF-68-11 3.43(b) 

RX-618 Automated Choice Heuristics CC-SF-69-1 CC-SF-69-11 3.43(b) 

RX-619 Lee et al 1/1/2006 CC-SF-70-1 CC-SF-70-5 3.43(b) RX-620 Frederick and Shafir 10/24/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-621

Cognitive Reflection and Decision Making Fall 2005 CC-SF-72-1 CC-SF-72-18 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-622 Frederick and Loewenstein 1/1/2008 CC-SF-74-1 CC-SF-74-15 3.43(b) & (c) RX-623 Read et al 8/6/2012 CC-SF-75-1 CC-SF-75-17 3.43(b) & (c) RX-624 Read et al 9/1/2005 CC-SF-76-1 CC-SF-10 3.43(b) & (c) RX-625 Frederick et al CC-SF-77-1 CC-SF-77-1 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 69
RX-626 Simmons et al 12/2/2010 CC-SF-78-1 CC-SF-78-16 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-627 Kahneman and Frederick 12/22/2006 CC-SF-79-1 CC-SF-79-2 3.43(b) & (c) RX-628 Frederick et al 12/7/2009 CC-SF-80-1 CC-SF-80-3 3.43(b) & (c) RX-629

Valuing future life and future lives: A framework for understanding discounting 5/9/2006 CC-SF-81-1 CC-SF-81-14 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-630 Persuasive Power of Opportunity Costs

Jan. to Feb., 2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-631 Hedonic Adaptation CC-SF-83-1 CC-SF-83-28 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-632 Hedonic Treadmill 7/24/2007 CC-SF-84-1 CC-SF-84-2 3.43(b) & (c) RX-633 Frederick et al CC-SF-85-1 CC-SF-85-17 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-634 Mochon and Frederick CC-SF-86-1 CC-SF-86-17 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-635 Frederick et al 6/1/2002 CC-SF-87-1 CC-SF-87-51 3.43(b) & (c) RX-636 Fischoff et al 1/1/1999 CC-SF-88-1 CC-SF-88-26 3.43(b) & (c) RX-637

Measuring Intergenerational Time Preference 1/12003 CC-SF-98-1 CC-SF-89-15 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-638 Kahneman and Frederick 9/10/2011 CC-SF-90-1 CC-SF-90-33 3.43(b) & (c) RX-639 Frederick et al CC-SF-91-1 CC-SF-91-56 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-640 Soman et al 1/1/2005 CC-SF-92-1 CC-SF-92-14 3.43(b) & (c) RX-641 Kahneman and Frederick CC-SF-93-1 CC-SF-93-24 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-642 Frederick and Read CC-SF-94-1 CC-SF-94-23 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-643 Frederick et al 4/22/2009 CC-SF-95-1 CC-SF-95-9 3.43(b) & (c) RX-644 Loewenstein and Frederick CC-SF-96-1 CC-SF-96-21 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-645 Songer et al 5/1/2004 CC-SF-97-1 CC-SF-97-7 3.43(b) & (c) RX-646 Weaver and Frederick 1/1/2012 CC-SF-98-1 CC-SF-98-12 3.43(b) & (c) RX-647 Frederick et al CC-SF-99-1 CC-SF-99-33 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-648 Frederick and Fischoff 1/1/1998 CC-SF-100-1 CC-SF-100-15 3.43(b) & (c) RX-649 Kahneman and Frederick 3/5/2002 CC-SF-101-1 CC-SF-101-10 3.43(b) & (c) RX-650 Time Preference & Personal Identity CC-SF-102-1 CC-SF-102-22 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-651 Redden and Frederick 1/1/2011 CC-SF-103-1 CC-SF-103-9 3.43(b) & (c) RX-652 Frederick and Peterman 7/14/1994 CC-SF-104-1 CC-SF-104-16 3.43(b) & (c) RX-653

Overestimating Others' Willingness to Pay 6/1/2012 CC-SF-105-1 CC-SF-105-22 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-654 Of Frogs and men 4/12/2010 CC-SF-106-1 CC-SF-106-2 3.43(b) & (c) RX-655 ACC survey CC-SF-9-1 CC-SF-9-8 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-657 Lead Customer Contacts 3.43(b) RX-658 Ecologic Sustainability Study Data 12/1/2010 3.43(b) & (c) RX-659 Ecologic Sustainability Study Data 12/1/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-670 Ecologic Sustainability Study Data 12/1/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-671

Saeed, Meyer and Frederick e-mail chain 5/31/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-671A attachment 1 5/31/2004 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-671B attachment 2 5/31/2014 3.43(b) & (c) RX-673 Synovate study 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-674

E-mails and documents considered by Stewart 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 70
RX-675 Reduced customer list 1/14/2014 3.43(b) 

RX-676 Reprint of a Letter to an Interested Party 1/16/2007 ECM-FTC-481 ECM-FTC-482 3.43(b) RX-678 ECM Marketing Materials 3.43(b) 

RX-679 ECM Sample Claims 3.43(b) 

RX-680 ECM web capture 1/16/2013 FTC_Prod_1869 FTC_Prod_1870 3.43(b) RX-681 ECM web capture 2/19/2013 FTC_Prod_1491 FTC_Prod_1651 3.43(b) RX-682 ECM web capture ECM-FTC-58 EC-FTC-58 3.43(b) RX-683 ECM Technical Sheet ECM-FTC-1 ECM-FTC-1 3.43(b) 

RX-684 Coding 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-685 Coding 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-686 Gelman article 9/16/2013 3.43(b) 

RX-687 Morgan Article 10/16/2012 3.43(b) RX-688 Busby Article 7/23/2013 3.43(b) RX-690 Kahan article 7/8/2013 3.43(b) RX-691 Kahan article II 7/10/2013 3.43(b) RX-692 Partial manufacturing data 5/20/2014 3.43(b) RX-693 Wilshire to Michel e-mail 12/14/2012 3.43(b) & (c) RX-694 Pessalano and Merenda e-mails 12/13/2012 3.43(b) & (c) RX-695 e-mail from Michel to Wilshire 11/1/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-696 e-mail from Wilshire to Michel 3/18/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-697 e-mail from Thompson to Michel 12/3/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-698 e-mail from Michel to FTCPayment 5/2/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-699 e-mail from Wilshire to Michel 8/21/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-700

e-mail from Michel Thompson and Wilshire 4/26/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-701 e-mail from Pessalano to Michel 12/18/2012 3.43(b) & (c) RX-702

e-mail chain between Wilshire and Michel 11/15/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-703

e-mail chain between Michel and Wilshire 12/12/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-704

e-mail chain between Wilshire and Michel 11/7/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-705

e-mail chain between Wilshire and Michel 12/4/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-706 OSU Compost Research group 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-708 Article by Knebusch 2/12/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-709 Umass Lowell Faculty and Staff 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-710

Center for biodegradable Polymer Research 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-711 Center for Sustainable Research 8/17/2007 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-712 Center for Sustainable Research 7/28/2008 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-713 Center for Green Chemistry excerpt 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-714 OWS biogas plants 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-715 OWS Household Waste 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-716 US Patent 5883199 A 3/16/1999 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 71
RX-717 Certain Docs considered by Volokh 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-718 e-mail from Mojo to Davis 8/29/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-719 e-mail from Mojo to Davis 9/6/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-720 e-mail from Mojo to Koss 12/19/2013 3.43(b) & (c) RX-721 e-mail from Mojo to Frankle 4/22/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-722 e-mail chain between Frankle to Mojo 2/19/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-723 e-mail chain between Koss and Mojo 7/30/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-724 e-mail chain between Frankle and Mojo 2/5/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-725 e-mail chain between Frankle and Mojo 10/15/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-726 e-mail chain between Frankle and Mojo 9/25/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-727 e-mail chain between Frankle and Mojo 2/19/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-728 e-mail chain between Frankle and Mojo 8/15/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-729 e-mail chain between Frankle and Mojo 2/4/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-730 e-mail chain between Frankle and Mojo 1/30/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-731 Letter from FTC to Mojo 12/15/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-732 e-mail chain between Koss and Mojo 7/24/2008 3.43(b) & (c) RX-733 e-mail chain between Frankle and Mojo 8/9/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-734 Article by Aguirre 9/23/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-735 Submission # 00334 12/10/2010 FTC_Prod_442 FTC_Prod_443 3.43(b) RX-736 Song et al 6/15/2009 FTC_Prod_416 FTC_Prod_441 3.43(b) RX-737

E-mail chain between De Wilde and Mojo 6/29/2010 OWS4 OWS4 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-738 OWS Comments 9/12/2010 OWS779 OWS783 3.43(b) & (c) RX-740 Aliphatic-aromatic copolyester FTC_Prod_63934 FTC_Prod_63936 3.43(b) 

RX-741

e-mail chain between Johnson and Narayan 11/18/2013 FTC_Prod_64282 FTC_Prod_64285 3.43(b) 

RX-742

e-mail chain between Johnson and Brookover 3/5/2914 FTC_Prod_64148 FTC_Prod_64148 3.43(b) 

RX-743 e-mail from Narayan to Johnson 11/14/2013 FTC_Prod_64322 FTC_Prod_64337 3.43(b) RX-744 Letter from Mojo to Frankle 4/25/2005 FTC_Prod_64468 FTC_Prod_64471 3.43(b) RX-745 e-mail from Mojo to FTC 8/19/2008 FTC_Prod_64557 FTC_Prod_64559 3.43(b) RX-746 e-mail from Mojo to Koss 7/29/2008 FTC_Prod_64517 FTC_Prod_64517 3.43(b) RX-747 e-mails from Johnson 12/20/2013 FTC_Prod_64275 FTC_Prod_64275 3.43(b) RX-748 FTC Green guides for BioPlastics 6/12/2014 FTC_Prod_64304 FTC_Prod_64315 3.43(b) RX-749

e-mail chain between Johnson and Narayan 1/10/2014 FTC_Prod_64296 FTC_Prod_64303 3.43(b) 

RX-750 Compilation of McCarthy Patents 3.43(b) & (c) RX-751 Luckachan and Pillai 6/29/2011 3.43(b) & (c) RX-752

Considerations affecting biodegradability of PVC 1/1/2006 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-753 McCarthy declaration 9/22/1997 3.43(b) & (c) RX-754 Response to Action 4/3/1997 3.43(b) & (c) RX-756 Patent Number 5,883,199 3/16/1999 3.43(b) & (c) RX-757 Metabolix steps up for UML 3/19/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 72
RX-758 EASTER BIO news release 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-759

Center for biodegradable Polymer Research 05 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-760 BPI and Metabolix web capture 5/1/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-761 Metabolix affiliations 5/30/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-762 Solutia becomes Eastman 6/16/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-763 Warner Lambert and BPI 10/22/2007 3.43(b) & (c) RX-764 Zheng et al 1/1/2005 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-765 Iwamoto and Tokiwa 1/1/1994 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-766 Roy et al 4/7/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-767 Shin et al 1/1/1997 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-768 Linos et al 1/17/2000 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-769 Russell et al 6/21/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-770 Vandevivere et al 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-771 McCarthy et al 1/1/1992 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-772 Tutorial on Biodegradable Plastics 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-773 Gu et al 1/1/1993 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-774 Gross and Gu 1/1/1995 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-775 McCarthy et al 1/1/1999 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-776 Farrell et al 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-777 Sheth et al 12/6/1996 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-778 Gu et al 1/1/1994 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-779 McCarthy et al 1/1/1994 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-780 Kemnitzer et al 7/13/1992 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-781 Wang et al 7/12/1997 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-782 Koroskenyi and McCarthy 6/6/2001 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-783 Shaked et al 1/1/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-784 Bhalakia et al 4/1/1990 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-785 Parandoosh et al 4/1/1995 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-786 Li and McCarthy 11/7/1997 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-787 Biodegradable Polymers 1/1/2003 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-788 Koroskenyi and McCarthy 7/1/2002 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-789 Dave et al 5/1/1990 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-790 Gross et al 1/1/1993 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-791 Smith et al Fall 1990 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-792 Rios et al 3/19/2006 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-793

e-mail chain between Meyer and Frederick 5/30/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-794 Pew Research report 11/7/2012 3.43(b) & (c) RX-795 e-mail from APCO to FTC 6/19/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-796

e-mail chain between Meyer and Frederick 6/3/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-797 5/12/14 survey results 5/12/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-798 2/14/14 survey results 2/14/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-799 3/23/14 survey results 3/23/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-800 5/12/14 survey results 5/12/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 73
RX-801 3/23/14 survey results 3/23/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-802 5/15/14 survey results 5/15/2014 3.43(b) & (c) RX-803 Ecologic Comments 12/10/2012 CC-SF-53-1 CC-SF-53-46 3.43(b) & (c) RX-804

e-mail chain between Meyer and Frederick 5/21/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-805

e-mail chain between Meyer and Frederick 6/1/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-806 e-mail from Saeed to Frederick 6/2/2014 3.43(b) & (c)

RX-807

e-mail chain between Meyer and Frederick 6/3/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-808

Compilation of e-mails between Frederick, Meyer, and Saeed 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-809

e-mail chain between Meyer and Frederick 6/1/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-810

e-mail chain between Meyer and Frederick 6/3/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-811 e-mail from FTC to APCO 5/29/2009 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-812 5/12/14 survey results 5/12/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-813 Google Consumer Surveys overview 6/13/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-814 e-mail from Klein to Frederick 2/3/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-815

e-mail chain between Meyer and Frederick 5/22/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-816

e-mail chain between Meyer and Frederick 5/13/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-817 5/15/2014 survey results 5/15/2014 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-818 Chapman and Johnson 8/1/1999 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-819 Tversky and Kahneman 9/27/1974 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-820 Jacowitz and Kahneman 11/1/1995 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-821 Englich et al 2/1/2006 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-822 How the Questions Shape the Answers 2/1/1999 3.43(b) & (c) RX-823

Compilation of articles Critiquing Google Surveys 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-824 Tolaymat notes RX-825 Tolaymat notes RX-826 Tolaymat notes RX-827 ISO 14855-1 12/1/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-828 Tolaymat et al 10/1/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-829 Tolaymat et al 4/1/2013 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-831 Barlaz et al 8/1/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-832 Musson et al 11/22/2009 3.43(b) & (c) RX-833 EPA Presentation 9/30/2012 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-834 Tolaymat et al 1/1/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-835 Final Report for 3M test 1/20/2012 3M-FTC106 3M-FTC133 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-836 NE Labs Report # N1048340 9/2/2010 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-837 Colplast test 1/10/2012 ECM-112365 ECM-112377 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 74
RX-838 NE Labs Report # 1149980 5/19/2011 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-839 Eden report to Shields 7/3/2012 ECM-113977 ECM-113983 3.43(b) RX-840 Deposition transcript of Ryan Burnette 7/2/2014 3.43(b) RX-0841 Deposition Transcript of Dr. McCarthy 6/27/2014 No Bates No Bates RX-0842 Deposition Transcript of Dr. Sahu 6/30/2014 No Bates No Bates RX-0843 Deposition Transcript of Dr. Stewart 7/1/2014 No Bates No Bates RX-0844 Survey Data No Date No Bates No Bates RX-0844A Subset of Survey Data RX-844 No Date No Bates No Bates RX-0845

Progress Report CSRS #32240 Environmental Study to D. Stewart from Y. Linares 5/1/2014 No Bates No Bates 

RX-0846 Table of Contents No Date No Bates No Bates RX-0847

Environment Study Screenshot CSRS #32240 No Date No Bates No Bates 

RX-0848

Manufacturers' Survey Screenshot CSRS #32241 No Date No Bates No Bates 

RX-0849 Data from Manufacturers' Survey No Date No Bates No Bates RX-0850

Progress Report CSRS #32241 Environmental Study to D. Stewart from Y. Linares 5/20/2014 No Bates No Bates 

RX-0851 Deposition Transcript of Dr. Tolaymat 6/24/2014 No Bates No Bates RX-0852

Exhibit 4 to Frederick Deposition - Table of Survey Characteristics No Date No Bates No Bates 

RX-0853 Expert Report of Dr. Morton Barlaz 6/15/2014 No Bates No Bates RX-0854 Expert Report of Dr. Ryan Burnette No Date No Bates No Bates RX-0855 Expert Report of Dr. Ranajit (Ron) Sahu 6/18/2014 No Bates No Bates RX-0856 Expert Report of Dr. David Stewart 6/17/2013 No Bates No Bates RX-0857 Expert Report of Dr. Alexander Volokh 6/20/2014 No Bates No Bates RX-0858

Deposition Transcript of Dr. Shane Frederick 6/23/2014 No Bates No Bates 

RX-859 Eden Report to FP 2/8/2014 3.43(b) 

RX-860 Eden Report to FP 11/17/2013 3.43(b) RX-861 Eden Report to MicroTek 5/11/2012 3.43(b) RX-862 Eden Report to EcoLab 3/31/2013 3.43(b) RX-863 NE Labs Report to Dansko 8/19/2010 3.43(b) RX-865

E-mail chain between Katherine Johnson and Mark Leen 6/6/2013 FTC_Prod_891 FTC_Prod_894 3.43(b) & (c) 

RX-866 Article by Brown and Marlar 10/3/2013 3.43(b) 

RX-867 US Census Bureau page 1/1/2012 3.43(b) RX-868 Article by Hamilton 7/25/2014 3.43(b) RX-869 Report by Keeter, et al 5/17/2010 3.43(b) RX-877

Feature or Bug? Google Consumer Surveys pre-fills in the Answer for You 8/7/2012 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 75
RX-878

4 mos after launch, pitiful Google Consumer Surveys struggles to find its footing 8/3/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-879 Google fixes 5 problems 7/30/2012 3.43(b) RX-880

Cure for Color Blindness Being Explored on Google Consumer Surveys 7/23/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-881

Google Consumer Surveys Begins to Hit Stride Locating Low-Incidence Populations 7/20/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-882

BBB Latest Group to Throw Away Money on Google Consumer Surveys 7/18/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-883

If we Deliver the Garnet Hill Catalog to you in Microfiche, would you think less of us then? 5/18/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-884

Obsession with Junk Clicks Continues to Dog Google Consumer Surveys 7/17/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-885

Throw away all of these questions and start over... 7/12/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-886

Google Consumer Surveys Hidden Revenue Stream 7/11/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-887

Intuit Labs using Google Consumer Surveys 7/10/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-888

Google Consumer Surveys Allows DIY

Researchers to confuse check one and 

check all that apply 7/2/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-889

If at first you don’t succeed with google consumer surveys, fail fail again 6/28/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-890

Harris Poll using Interns to analyze Google Consumer Surveys 6/4/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-891 Jobs? Did someone say job? 5/17/2012 3.43(b) RX-892

How many GCS are being taken by Google 5/11/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-893 All things being equal... 5/11/2012 3.43(b) RX-894 What part of Yes don’t you understand? 5/10/2012 3.43(b) RX-895

The essence of DIY Google Consumer Surveys 5/8/2012 3.43(b) 

RX-902 Tolaymat Depo Exhibit 5 3.43(b) 

RX-905 Tolaymat Depo Exhibit 8 3.43(b) 

RX-923 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 1 3.43(b) 

RX-924 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 2 3.43(b) 

RX-925 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 3 3.43(b) 

RX-926 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 4 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 76
RX-927 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 5 3.43(b) 

RX-928 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 6 3.43(b) RX-929 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 7 3.43(b) RX-930 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 8 3.43(b) RX-931 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 9 3.43(b) RX-932 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 10 3.43(b) RX-933 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 11 3.43(b) RX-934 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 12 3.43(b) RX-935 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 13 3.43(b) RX-936 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 14 3.43(b) RX-937 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 15 3.43(b) RX-938 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 16 3.43(b) RX-939 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 17 3.43(b) RX-940 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 18 3.43(b) RX-941 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 19 3.43(b) RX-942 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 20 3.43(b) RX-943 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 21 3.43(b) RX-944 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 22 3.43(b) RX-945 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 23 3.43(b) RX-946 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 24 3.43(b) RX-947 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 25 3.43(b) RX-948 McCarthy Depo Exhibit 26 3.43(b) RX-949 Frederick Depo Exhibit 1 3.43(b) RX-950 Frederick Depo Exhibit 2 3.43(b) RX-951 Frederick Depo Exhibit 3 3.43(b) RX-952 Frederick Depo Exhibit 4 3.43(b) RX-953 Frederick Depo Exhibit 5 3.43(b) RX-954 Frederick Depo Exhibit 6 3.43(b) RX-955 Frederick Depo Exhibit 7 3.43(b) RX-956 Frederick Depo Exhibit 8 3.43(b) RX-957 Frederick Depo Exhibit 9 3.43(b) RX-958 Frederick Depo Exhibit 10 3.43(b) RX-959 Frederick Depo Exhibit 11 3.43(b) RX-960 Frederick Depo Exhibit 12 3.43(b) 

RX-961

Metabolix 2006 – Fee for Service Agreement 3.43(b) 

RX-962 Metabolix 2008 – License Agreement 3.43(b) 

RX-963 Metabolix 2012 - Letter 3.43(b) 

RX-964 Metabolix 2014 - Letter 3.43(b) 

RX-965 Umass-Metabolix License execution 3.43(b) RX-966 Metabolix e-mails 3.43(b) 

RX-967 EPA web page 3.43(b) 

RX-968

The attached excel sheet (can call ECM Anaerobic Degradability Analysis Summary Data) 3.43(b) 

RX-970 Michel Deposition Transcript 3.43(b) 

P

ATTACHMENT A PAGE 77
Exhibit 

No. Description Date BegBates EndBates Admissibiity

Confident

ial?

Expert 

Ex?

RX-196 BEPS History 3.43(b) No

RX-197 BEPS Awards 3.43(b) No

RX-198 BEPS Call for Papers 3.43(b) No

RX-199

Final Report of the Office of Naval 

Research 3/21/199 3.43(b) No

RX-200

7th Annual Meeting of the 

Bio/Environmentally Degradable 

Polymer Society

8/19-

22/1998 3.43(b) No

RX-201 Automotive Composites Conference

9/19-

20/2001 3.43(b) No

RX-202 Document from UNT 9/10/2012 3.43(b) No

RX-203 CIPET 2010 Moments

2/20-

22/2010 3.43(b) No

RX-205 CIPET International Relations 3.43(b) No

RX-206

Australian Government Bioplastics 

Supply Chains 11/1/2004 3.43(b) No

RX-208 Metabolix's BPI approved products 3.43(b) No

In the Matter of ECM Biofilms, Inc., No. 9358

Attachment B - September 4, 2014

PUBLIC DOCUMENT ATTACHMENT B PAGE 1