5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,213XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH (/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU)LOH 1DPH DS	

			



2*(52**6	

(55<2//,16
	

!!"#$%&
'%	%%()'(%'*%+%#%&	+%&)'(%'*%#&'%'*'%',---.		*/0'%&)'(%'*%1+22+345---)*''"3	!%$67---#3891	9'*+'%1+2( 	%+% '( 		
	  :8 9 
	 9

8 
 	
"+$6+( &' # !!""%  ;%  8%%$ 	 <
9
))
<
9))44
		
"+$6+(&'# !!""
	%+%'( 		
	  :8 9 
	 9

8 
 	
"+$6+( &' # !!""%  ;%  8%%$
 	 <
9
))
<
9))44
		
"+$6+(&'# !!""  
9  1	 '*+'% 1+2  (!%!!""%5""'(#%&*%'"(%'%+%'96&'!!"(%&'(%'*%*+%=(2%# <%'%' !!"" 2 < 22(=( > , &6(!%'%'%&(((%%&'0	 # #+%& !*'2( *('(%% 0'%& %&'(!'' 45 ? 77 #%  %05 %'" ' %& $(+%5 &' +% # $$ <"(  @+5 *A'*%22( # %& ! /'!'2  #"'+( ((+"% #"'B6%&$&*+%(%*22(%#'#%%%0%5#'A5(='$!'($%#!'2&%%#'#%5(= '$!'($% # #"'+( ((+"% % 6 (A*(*+%'A"522('(*+%"5'**%%%&*%'"
(%'%+%''96&'%%'"$%(%'#'%&%+'2&%'!$&'(%$(A7722(/*/&(/%+(&6%&$$2#%+('2%&6%&$22(!!*&&62$/'2(C+"A*( 	& #+(  (&'( A*(6*$$22(('A(&(*$D6+%#+%'$(""5"+E1 %- **'2%$22(%&&'%&%&('#%&&!+%!'""0A&#*%&%%/'""-
'HVSLWH RXU FRQFOXVLRQ WKDW WKH IDFWV RI WKLV FDVH GR QRW LPSOLFDWHWKH &RQIURQWDWLRQ &ODXVH WKH UHJLPH WKDW WKH 2KLR 6XSUHPH &RXUW HUHFWHGLQ6WDWH Y %RJJV  1(G  2KLR  PD\ ZHOO LPSOLFDWH WKH&RQIURQWDWLRQ&ODXVH LQRWKHU FLUFXPVWDQFHV $V H[SODLQHGVXSUD LI DGHIHQGDQW VHHNV WR VKRZ WKDW D SULRU IDOVH DFFXVDWLRQ EHDUV RQ D ZLWQHVV¶VELDV PRWLYH RU SUHMXGLFH D WULDO FRXUW PD\ EH FRQVWLWXWLRQDOO\ UHTXLUHG WRDOORZ D GHIHQGDQW WR FURVVH[DPLQH RQ WKDW DFFXVDWLRQ DV ZHOO DV WR DOORZWKH GHIHQGDQW WR 3PDNH D UHFRUG IURP ZKLFK WR DUJXHZK\ ́ WKHZLWQHVVZDV ELDVHG RU SUHMXGLFHG'DYLV  86 DW  ,Q D FDVH ZKHUH WKH&RQIURQWDWLRQ &ODXVH LV LPSOLFDWHG WKH%RJJVUHJLPH PD\ KDYH WR JLYHZD\ GHSHQGLQJ RQ WKH H[WHQW RI FURVVH[DPLQDWLRQ SHUPLWWHG DQG WKHLQWHUHVWEDODQFLQJ DQDO\VLV UHTXLUHGXQGHUFDVHV VXFK DV0LFKLJDQ Y/XFDV  86 DW  %XW WKDW LV QRW WKLV FDVH@+2$% # %& '(%'*% *+% 	# #+%&!*'2(*('(%%0'%&%&'(!''
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
*+%22(%&%A'2J*""5+/DK&L*$%$5('&0(%&#'"5$'%*$E1 % #%#+('2%"%&'$'(&%'A*06'*(&%+%&0'%(((%(%'#'%&%22(0(+/%&'2&%'I+(%'0&'"&'(!6%'##'*!+%5(&'##(!*%'A"5%(%'#'%&%22("%&%" %&$ %&% & 0( ( +/ %&% & 0+" D% 6(+!'( % 5%&'2E 1  %M %&%& *+"%$$60&%&&#+$6#5(22(=(*((C$'%'#$+*%&%(&0(!(%+2+(0&&"2&'(%5#$%"'""((& #+%& */0"2 %&% # $5 5( (& &+2 !(5*&'%'* %%$% # (*&'B!&'"'/*'%'(  !(('  %&% (& & C!'*D!(5*&%'*!'((E'0&'*&(&0+"D"(%+*&0'%&0&%=("0&%=(%"E1 %,7J
?,  -, -? G&' % !! H  	& &!A'+("56&(!'%"'B(A%'$(#%&(*'%'(%&"(%%'$6'2('C(A5(6#%&%'"G+7H	&&6%%#%&(*'%'(+26+(A('*0('!(5*&'%'*%&!5%%&%'$#%&%'"*((C$'%'$"((*'6&%%*/=(!!*&%0%%%(.&'((&+"&'(6*/&DKL/60&'K0(L"%6'22%&$E1 %	&'%$$6&0&0(((&'(#*'"&'&0&0&'(&'(%%'2%&%(&(%2""5%'*0&%&$'(6*"(&A	&%(%'#'%&%&%%*/'%($""#"*&"  ' % !! % 6 '%C'*%  	& "('%%%&%(&&(*$"+"5!'%%&%%*/*/0"2%&%&!%$%0""(0%&'(%'#5'2'&'(0#(22( (%%%&%&&6'$=(!%$%(A"%'$(!'%&'(%$(A77%&%&&(&0&&'(%%%(%&"((%%%&%&&(%!!65$=(('*%&5'I+(%'3D
(%!!K65L"'%&%$'2
0(
(+$22(@5!!%+'%5%!(%#+""$'2#+"#(%%&*'$(0'%&0&'*&&0(*&2 '%' % %& (%%2'( & !+(+ & !+% #%&*('6"A'*%%*/'2$=(*'6'"'%56(&&'(%5#$%"'""(((+6(%*6+(&&$$ %&'( %(%'$5 &$ % %& @+5 ' &'( *"('22+$%&'(*'*+$(%*'(%&+(+"'/,-	%-G&"'2%&%&$6(0('%&'2&%%!(%#(0&&0(#6'+%'2&%#$*((C$''2/50'%((+%%'I+%DA+*&E+" 0& %& %'" *+% ' % ""0 &'$ % *"" %&#A6"0'%(((H,M?
	%?-G&"'2%&%=('2&%%!(%#(0(%$$"0&0'%&A"'(%%@+(%'#'*%'&0(0&""56#$%(%'#5'2 6+% %& $ ' 0&'*& &'( *#((' 0(6%'H'""50%#'%&%%&6#'%%22( # !(%'2 A'* # %& ""2 !' #"(**+(%' *$!'(  '%(% ( 0'2&%5 %&% '% 0(*(%'%+%'""52+%
22(0'(&%(/%&@+5%$/%++(A'%'5'#*#$('%+%'%&% A %/ ( %+ A'% ('2'#'*%"5 #$ %&&'(%$(A%%*/&'"%&%'"*+%&'(*%'%""0'(+*&A'*%""0%'"#%&*(#%&A'2&%&%(%'$5#'%("#%&(%'%+%'(%I+''%%&A(&'" 22( (+2&% % *((C$' $  ""2#"(**+(%'#!&('%(%%%*/#+%&&2"*'6'"'%5

	%&% !+!( " ( % '$!"'*% %& #%%'"+(    %& #*%( # %&'( *( ' %& (%'*%'%$$" 22(=( *(%'%+%'" '2&% % $+%  #+"" $'2#+"#(%&( ((0%&7
%RJJV VXJJHVWHG LQ FORVLQJ DUJXPHQW WKDW SHUKDSV %HUPDQ¶VZRXQGV ZHUH VHOILQIOLFWHG 3HUKDSV VKH 3KDG D QLJKWPDUH DQG IHOO GRZQDQG VDLG VKH ZDV UDSHG,GRQ¶W NQRZ , GRQ¶W WKLQN \RX NQRZ ́ -$DW  7KLV VSHFXODWLRQ ZDV QRW VXSSRUWHG E\ DQ\ HYLGHQFH DQG WKHRQO\ PHGLFDO WHVWLPRQ\ DGGXFHG DW WULDO ZDV WKDW WKH ZRXQGV ZHUHFRQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKH SK\VLFDO DWWDFN WKDW %HUPDQ KDG GHVFULEHG&""0&!&5('*"A'*(&0(!(+('A"5%&%(&'%D$/+!E%&%%*/'""5%& C*"+('#%&!%'*+" A'*'%%$!" 22(=( '2&% % !(%  #( 2'A %&*('6""%'%+%&%'"*+%2%22('!+(+'2&'(%&5%&%$#6'*%%&!*&2+'!%%&&'(%5#$%"'""((+2+( (C!"'
 A %& 2A$%=( 6@*%'( %& %'" *+%""022(%*((C$'$&&'(%5#$%"'""(('*"+'2%&#*%%&%&*%(&#+&%"(%+*&0'%&"'%5%&%(&$''%&!50'%&!(5*&'%'(%%&%(&&6%%#(+6(%* +2 6+( 22( "( I+(%'$=( $%&C%('A"56+%&+2&%=(&'(%5#$%"'""(((+6(%*6+(
'%(*"('22+$%22(=(*+("$'%&@+5#%&'(%(%'$539'B $ $'%%"5 %(%'#' %&% %& "(% #+%5((&=((+##'2#$$%"'""((	&*'A(K(*'" (*+'%5L 6*+( (& '( $%""5 '""  	&=(6+(+2(&(*'A%%$%#%&%&%!%'*+""5 (&=( & (*&'B!&'  !(5*&%'*!'((J "(% %+*& 0'%& "'%5  	&=( %" %&'2&6( 6+% %0 $%&( 2 %&% (& &( &'2&%$(0%&%(=%$9'B$=(6!(+%'%(!+%($I+(%'&6'"'%5%$$6&0""#%&'(&!!%$'K('*L0&%&%&50"+"1 %-
$W WKDW WLPH %RJJV ZDV UHVLGLQJ ZLWK KLV PRWKHU DW WKH *OHQGDOH$SDUWPHQW FRPSOH[2Q FURVVH[DPLQDWLRQ WKH LQYHVWLJDWRU ZKR WHVWLILHG DV WR WKHDEVHQFH RI VHPHQ RU KDLU VDPSOHV DFNQRZOHGJHG WKDW PRUH RIWHQ WKDQ QRWKDLU VDPSOHV RI D UDSLVW DUH QRW3LQWHUFKDQJHG ́ ZLWK WKH YLFWLP -$ DW 6KH DOVR WHVWLILHG WKDW LI D UDSLVW HMDFXODWHG LQ WKHPRXWK RI D UDSHYLFWLP DV %HUPDQ WHVWLILHG %RJJV KDG GRQH VKH ZRXOG QRW EH VXUSULVHGQRW WR ILQG VHPLQDO IOXLG DW WKH FULPH VFHQH"A'2
!*/%&K%L('#85K%&0""&'(6(($=(65#'L&$'%'%"&0&85*$'N45&'(%$(=
0%$505E1 %MA%&$'#%&522(%(%'#'&/0'%&+$6#!!"%0(A'=*"*/%&%A'2&/%&'(6%&=(&+(0%%!%5%#'=(&+(D#$%&@+(% 0% "" A %& '2&6&E A'('%'2 '##%'2&6(=&$(1 %M #%'22(C!"'D
0(@+(% $'2E + 65 !%$% *$!"CD22A%'2A565'%&0&"0'0"E1 %7M  &'" 22(=( $%& '  !('%' (%% %&%22('A&$%%#'#%5%&%A'2&(%%%&%&*+"% $$60&%%'$&'A%&&+(1  %7M  "('&A'2 (A&'%%&%A'2&A'26%$=(!%$%%5%'$%&%'2&%'""5&'&A'2%"%&!+%5(&'##!6%'##'*%&%&0(%+/%$$6&'(*%'("%&+2&&'*/0"2%&%&%"&'($%&&'(%$(5%&%'#& D' K!$&L'=%$$6E1 %7-'%&&'G%&%&$=(H($0(#+$=(!(*"%&'250&'&!%$%%%'"22( (&0%&@+5%&%&& #+%"2%%%(*A'2&'(%'+!!%(C&'6'%('%+*+'2&'(%(%'$5"((&0%&%22(&#+""6% %& %'$ # %& ""2 %%*/  	A" # $=('2&6(%(%'#'%&%%&'2&%'I+(%'%&5'%& (*$( #$ & !%$%  	A" 0'%((( "(?
%(%'#'%&%%&5(0&'$%A'+(%'$(6%0+2&"5(A'!$3%&51%(%'#'%&%(&(0&'$#+%'$(6%0(A%&'%5'J !'"1((0&'$+(A#'#%J5)'2(%%%&%22((%!!65&'(&$#6+%%$'+%(6%0'2&%'=*"*/	$+" <+"" *& (%%%&%22( 0( % %&' ('* # 6+% #'#% $'+%(($%'$6%0'2&%%!$0'%&<+""(%'$%'2%&%'% 0( $(%"'/"5 6%0 '  '%&'%5#%&0'%(((*#'$22=(0'%%"'6'%&%&0(%#'(=&+((6%0%%#%5#'A1 %7,7&(0&0'%((&'$(%%%&%22(!! A5 +/ 0'%& ($%(%'#5'2%&%%&5 *+"($"""*&"&'$&'(!!"*%(%&%'"*+%=(*'('%"'$'%22(=(*((C$'%'#$	!*'#'*""522((+2&%%I+(%'$6+%#"(**+(%'#!%&%(&""2"5$2'(%%&$!!C'$%"5$%&6# (&**+(22(# !22("((+2&%%'%+*%&%(%'$5#%00'%((('"$!( %& !%$% $2  '*/ :B"" %&%%**'2%&!'#"(**+(%' **'2%22(!(0+"&A%(%'#'%&%$%"&%&%(&&6!65:B"":B""0+"&A%(%'#'%&%%&**+(%'0(+%+&%'"*+%&0A!&'6'%""I+(%''2**'2%&""2**+(%'&'"2+%%'"0((#""0(3K22(=(*+("L4'(($&A5+A**+(565"(#&A'2!5+'%&!(%OK<(*+%3L6@*%'5+&+%3	+(%'
M$'(('*+(!%'2%&'(2+$%0+"*A+%%+6"'2C*!%'%+A'%'5'*"'%'('"5%&(C+"((+"%!*%C%*$%%&%C*!%''% + '%!%%' # %& (%'%+%' 0 @*% &'(2+$%

!"7	- GC'$ !!---HG*'%'*'B'2 *+%*'('(!A''2  C*!%' % A'%'5 +"( # !' #"(**+(%'(#(C+"6+(H4A  *"( C$'%' %& !' **+(%'*&*%'B 65 22( '##( ' '$!%% 05( #$$=( **+% # %& %%*/ 65 22(  **'2 %22( $ ('$!"5 #6'*%  **+(%' 2'(%:B"" +% # 0&" *"%&  &'( 22( (+22(%( 0(*('(%%0'%&$=(&'(%5#$%"'""((!(%D"+('(&""+*'%'(E22(=(% 
%& 0( (& ('$!"5 D$ +!E %& A% D*5K'2L"#E
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
%&0(22(=((+22(%'%%'"%&%%&!'""2#6'*%'(&0(D(&=($'%+!2'E%&%D(&=($+!""#%&'(E('$!"5'2(?
(%%#"+"$/(&AD6"%'%+E+%&(%'%+%' % (%6"'(& +"( C*"+'2 A'* #$*'$'"%'"(#
$%%
	--7G7H%&	+!$+%&(%*#+""50&(((('20&%& %& C*"+(' # *%' A'* $+%( % *(%'%+%'"A'"%'+"(C*"+'2A'*D%6'2**+(=('2&%%!(%#(("2(%&5%N6'%5=N'(!!%'%%%&!+!(%&5('2%(A=E&GI+%'2$'
	',7
	,,? G7MHH&C*"+('#A'*'(6'%5'(!!%'%D"50&'%&('#'2+!0'2&%5'%(%#%&**+(E&J(
),G?%&'7H8'A%&((%(0%#'%&%%&C*"+('#%&%(%'$52'2%&!'!**+(%''$!"'*%22(=(*(%'%+%'"'2&%%!(%#('(%%&'(A'*0(%(&'2&"5!6%'A#%&*&2(2'(%22(((%6*(%'%+%'""5I+'22(0((/'2%&@+5%'#%&%%& ""2 !''*'% $% %&%$0("(**+('222(#"("5+%++"(#A'* 2""5 #0 +! +('2 A'* # !(%D02(ED*%(E%(&0D%&*&*%#!('%(&0*%''*#$'%5%&0'%&E"%**('  A' ,-,G6HJ &'  A' ,-,G6HJ *?,%M	'$'"**(*&+"?-7P(!&'6'%' # C%'('* A'* % !A DK(L!*'#'*'(%*(#%&*+*%#%&0'%((KL#%&!+!(#%%*/'2  (+!!%'2 %& 0'%((=( *&*% #%+%&#+"((E!"*'20'%&'%&'(*%'#%&%'"*+%0&%&%""0*((C$'%'(!*'#'**+*%0&'%'(D!6%'A#%+%&#+"((+%+%&#+"((EA'?-7G6HJ&'A'?-7G6H	+*&+"(('2%!A%'(%*%'2$''%'"(*""%"$%%(#
7G7%&' H  22( (/( +( % "5 % "/ !(% %&(/!%'*'($C!((%&+2&(+*&6*/+"(6+%%&"%&%$=(""2!(% #"(**+(%'# !0((!6%'A # 6%& & *'6'"'%5  %& "'6'"'%5 # &**+(%'2'(%22(%&%%&(%'%+%' I+''%(
MK22(=( *+("L3 :+ & 
 &A %(%'$5 %!(%%&%(&%"4(!(%&%'*/:B""!& !!C'$%"5  $%& 6#%&'(%'$ '*/:B""0'""%(%'#5%&%&'%K<(*+%3L	0&%OK22(=(*+("L3""(&=($'%+!2'%&%=(0&%
0%%#'+%'#(&=($+!""#%&'(&+%3&"5%&'20+"6%&*'6'"'%5(!*%5%0=2'2'2&%6*/'%&6*/K22(=( *+("L3 
=$ % (/'2 6+% & (C+"*%'A'%50'%&%&!!" ""
=$(/'2'('#(&A**+(($"(6#K&*+%(+(%'%&6@*%'L1 %??9%6#22(62'*%C$'%'#!(%&%%I+(%%&%%&*+%!*"+5I+(%'(6+%%&""2!' #"(**+(%'22(=(*+(" (!%&% D'# (&=( !A'+("5 *' N0"#= 
 %&'/ %&%=(!%'%K$L'#$%&'(0$%&%($65&!&6+%$%&"'%&0(%&'2&!!E1 %,&*+%20'%&%&	%%6C$'%'%&'((+6@*%#% %& @+5 *A'*% 22( 22( '( ('C(('2$%(#!!"'*"+'2%&%%&%'"*+%'$!!"5(%'*%*((C$'%'%&""2!'#"(**+(%'45&'=(+%&)'(%'*%+%# !!"(A(22(=(*A'*%'6(%&!'#"(**+(%''((+
 ,,9MG&'% !!H ((+$'2%&%%&%'"*+%&!*"+%&*((C$'%'!+(+%%&'=(! (&'" "0 &' A   > -M-G)H7
G (7H%&*+%**"+%&%#"(**+(%'#!(%#""0'%&'%&#''%'#D(C+"*%'A'%5E+%&!(&'""0(&+"%6C*"+%&%2+&*+%"(%%&%DK'L%'(0""(%%"%&%*'$'"#%(&A%&'2&%%*#%%&0'%(((2'(%%&$+6%&%&	'C%& $$%%%&
'%%%((%'%+%'+%&&'(%'%+%'E&%Q7''2%&%22(=(*A'*%'%+(+6(%%'""5$=( *'6'"'%5 %& *+% **"+ %&% '% 0(DN'$!%'A%&%%&#%62'A!!%+'%5%!"*6#%&@+5A'*(#+$%""5##*%'2%&*$!"'%=( *'6'"'%5=E & % QM GI+%'2
 
)'?G4'*&% !!M7HH&*+%(#+%&%&%D'%'('##'*+"%%'$2'$N'$!%'A= *%25##( A'*%&%&% 0&'*&(&0( %& !*"'A'%5 #  *$!"'% % $/ !**+(%'(E&''2'%(**"+('%*#"'*%0'%&%&%#%&&'!!""%*+%%&*+%*%'#'%&*(%%&&'	+!$+%&&'	+!$+%20'%&%&*+%#!!"(%&% #"( **+(%'( # ! 0&  (C+" *%'A'%5 '('A"A%#""0'%&'&'=(!(&'"(%%+%
7777?G&'H%&*((C$'%' #  ! A'*%'$ 2'2 !'**+(%'(#!'(2A65&'A'?-7GH&*+%%& (% #%&!*+ #%'"*+%(%#""0'(+*&('%+%'(3K
L##(*+("'I+'(#""2!A'*%'$(%0&%&(&&($5!'#"(**+(%'(#!%&A'*%'$(0(%&%'"*+%0+"&A%&'(*%'%%$' 0&%& % 0&%C%% #( *+(" * !* 0'%&*((C$'%'   0A '# %& ""2 A'*%'$(0('%&##'$%'A%&%'"*+%0+"&A%*+*%  $ &'2 % %$' 0&%&(C+" *%'A'%5 & 6 'A"A   
# %& %'" *+%%$'%&%%&**+(%'(0%'"5#"(G%&%'(%&% (C+" *%'A'%5&6'A"AH%&%'"
C!"'%'"$=($%"'(('%&*+%( ' $ % & +)'%	$ 
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	'C%& $$%=(#%%'"+(%&)+<*(("+(#%&+%%& $$%
,$',M?
	?7?-G7?HJ%!,?M
	,M,7G7,H
*'*+$(%*(0&!*+"+"(%'"*+%*'('(&AC*"+A'* '  05 %&% '(  #%  #' %'" %&+!$+%&(#+A'"%'#%&%#%=('2&%%!(%#(,M?
	%?-G#''2%&%%&%'"*+%A'"%=('2&%%!(%#(0&'% C*"+ A'* 6'2  %& *'6'"'%5 # &'(*#(('HJ,-
	%-G'A"'%'2(%%=(&(5+"6*+('%A'"%#%=('2&%%!(%0'%((('&'(0#(H %%&($%'$#''2%&%,
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
7KHUH LV QR UHFRUG RI WKLV KHDULQJ $Q DIILGDYLW VLJQHG E\ %RJJV¶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¶V FKDUJH KH KDG GHQLHG LW +H DOVR VWDWHG WKDW KH ZDV QHYHUTXHVWLRQHG E\ WKH SROLFH DERXW WKH DOOHJDWLRQ )LQDOO\ %HUPDQ WHVWLILHGDW WKH KHDULQJ 6KH FODLPHG WKDW VKH RQO\ WROG &RSDV WKDW <D]HOO KDGWKUHDWHQHG DQG VODSSHG KHU DQG QRW WKDW KH KDG UDSHG KHU!$'%%%'%+*C%'('*A'*#%&!' #"(**+(%'%%&$&'2
?,-,-7G&'% !!H
%$#0$&'2'(%+*%'2%&%'#%&!'**+(%'(0+#+'%'A"A(C+"*%'A'%522((&+"&A6!$'%%%*((C$'%&0'%((%&'( '((+ 6# %& @+5  %&%  0 %'" 0+" 6I+'%-2'222(=(*(%'%+%'"2+$%%&*+%**"+%&%'%0(6+65%&&'+!$+%=(**"+('%&%%&#%%'"+(0( % '$!"'*%  &'" %& %'" *+% &" (* $ &'2 !+(+%%%&'( $22(!!"%&*(%'%+%'"(!*%#%&+"'2%%&&'+!$+% +2+(%#%&A'2*+*%$&'2'0&'*&!(:B""%(%'#'%&%'"*+%' 22(=( I+(% #  0 %'"  ##'$ &'(*A'*%'(
%**"+%&%$&(&065*" *A'*'2 A'* %&% (& & % $ 5 !'**+(%'(#!1 %-22('%!!"%&'(*'('A$6,%&&' 	+!$+%*"'%&%&*(%'%+%'"'((+!!"#(*%'$
??M G&'+!%H
G%&'7H*+%(&"%&%%&*'('#0&%&%%""0'A'*#0'%((=($%"'""((#""(0'%&' %& 6 '(*%' # %'" *+%( ( %&5 6"*!(('6"!@+'*A(+(!6%'AA"+#
)-G(%'HG(%%'2%&%%&'(%'*%*+%D&(6'(*%'5+%&'%5%!&'6'%*((C$'%'E'*"+'2%&C%%%0&'*&'%""0( C$'%' 6+%  0'%((=( *'%' # $%"'(%6'"'%5HG5 1HJ#  
  M- ?M7MG'7,HG#''26+(#'(*%'0& %'" @+2 0+" % !$'% *((C$'%' 0'%((=( !' &(!'%"'B%' # (*&'B!&'HJ# 
  MM   ? G) ' ?H GD#*+(  &'(%5 # $%" '""(( '( % *(('"5$'(('6" ( '$!*&$% A'*EH  *%(  *+%(&+"*(''""0'2'(+*&A'*%&%+#%& !(5*&"2'*" !6"$ %& %$!" **5 $%((#%&*'%'0&%&%&0'%(((+###$%&*'%'%%&%'$#%&A%(%0&'*&(&'(%%(%'#5#
,,M,7G' H  ('(%% 0'%& %&( *(( 
 ($*+%(&A #+#%%'"+(A'"%'(0&0'%((=($%"*'%'0("A%%#(%&5# $%'A  6'(  0& %& *'%' 0( (+##'*'%"5(A(0""((*"("5%'%%&A%('I+(%'((%*(%+6%%&%0'%((=(6'"'%5%!*'A'%!%%& A%( ' I+(%'    ?7  %?-?,GA('2*A'*%'6*+(%&%'"*+%"'$'%*((C$'%'!&'6'%%&#(#$**(('2%&!(5*&'%'**(#%&2A$%=((%0'%((6*+(#(=(%&50(%&%%&0'%((=((A2'2$%"'""((&2'A&'$!!$%'A#**+('2 %& #% # 02'2HJ+ 
(-?,MMM?G%&'7HG2%'2&6( !%'%' 6*+( %'" *+% & % ""0 *((C$'%'  0'%((=( &'(%5 # $%" '""(( 0&'*&!&'6'%D5C!"%5'I+'565#(*+("'%K%& 0'%((=(L!(('6"6'($%'AEHJ# 
$%&+)'%	?,,?,?G,%&'MHG#''26+(#'(*%'0&'(%'*%
2XU FDUH LQ DGKHULQJ WR WKLV GLVWLQFWLRQ DULVHV LQSDUW IURP WKHJHQHUDOFRQFHUQ UDLVHG E\ WKH 2KLR 6XSUHPH &RXUW WKDW D FOHDUO\DUWLFXODWHG UXOH ZKHWKHU LW EH D UXOH RI FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ODZ RU RQH RIHYLGHQFH EH DSSOLHG FRQVLVWHQWO\6HH JHQHUDOO\ %RJJV  1(G DW VWDWLQJ WKDW HYLGHQWLDU\ UXOH VKRXOG QRW EH DSSOLHG GLIIHUHQWO\ 3PHUHO\EHFDXVHWKH FKDUJH LV RQH LQYROYLQJ D VH[XDO DVVDXOW ́ 7R DOORZ %RJJVWR SUHYDLO RQ KLV DUJXPHQW WKDW WKH &RQIURQWDWLRQ &ODXVH FRPSHOV FURVVH[DPLQDWLRQ HYHQ ZKHQ KLV SXUSRVH ZDV WR DWWDFN %HUPDQ¶V FUHGLELOLW\JHQHUDOO\ ZRXOG FDUYH RXW D WURXEOLQJ H[FHSWLRQ LQ WKH UDSH FRQWH[W WR DQRWKHUZLVH FOHDU DQG XQLIRUP UXOH6HH JHQHUDOO\'HQLVH 5 -RKQVRQ3ULRU)DOVH $FFXVDWLRQV RI5DSH )DOVXV LQ 8QR )DOVXV LQ 2PQLEXV<$/(-/ 	 )(0,1,60  H[DPLQLQJ WKH RULJLQV DQG LPSOLFDWLRQV RIFRXUWV¶ WUHDWLQJ SULRU DFFXVDWLRQV GLIIHUHQWO\ WKDQ RWKHU W\SHV RI FUHGLELOLW\HYLGHQFH%'*+"%'2%&5#$%'A!%'"'%5(%'$!"'*%%&'2&%(*#+""5+%"''
'""56%&22(%&$2'(%%*+%''*%%&%%&'%*((C$'%'0%%$=(D(%%#$'E'6'2'2%&!*&2(2'(%22(0(%&#*$!""65%&#%%'"+(1 %,? G(%%'2 %&% %& A'* #( *+(" (+2&% %"'*'%*((C$'%'D0(&'2&"5"A%%%&'((+(#%&A'*%'$=(*'6'"'%5&$%'A(%'6'2'2%&!*&2EHG$!&('(HJ22(=(%G*&'2%&$2'(%%*+%%&%%&@+5D0(%'%"%*('&$%'A(%'6'2'2%& !*&2(2'(%422(EHG$!&('(H
%'(%*"%+(&0%&'(+(!*'#'D(%%#$'E@+(%'#'*%'#'%(0'%&'%&*(%'%+%'""5('(I+'65
'%(!250A6%&%%'"!!"22(!'%%$=(&'(%5#$%"'""((% *(%+6%%&"'6'"'%5#&**+(%'(2'(%22(%&C%%%&%%&'(#*%$=(D(%%#$'E'(C%('# %&% 2+$% 0  % #'  #%%' "+(A'"%'&'"$%"'""((*'6"A%%0'%((=(*'6'"'%5#
MM7G(%'HJ#
?7,??,
) 4*& M , 22( 6+2&% %&'( &6( *!+(*%' !+(+% % 7 
	 > ,  $2 %&2+$%(&*%%&%&0('6%&&'(	'C%&$$%#%%'"+('2&%&'(*(%'%+%'"'2&%%!(%#( #%%&'(%'*%*+%'($'((%& !%'%' 0'%&+% !@+'* 6*+( 22( & %C&+(% &'( (%% $'( %&'( +% A( $ # *('%' # %& $'%(   
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	%%=(6@*%'(  !% %& $2'(%% *+%=( !% *$$%'&'(*+%A'0(
'(%'*%*+%=(2%#0'%#&6(*!+('
.'7?7MG?%&'HA'0%&'(%'*%*+%=(#''2(##*%#*")$/
$--G?%&'?H<'$5&'(%'*"#*%(#+65(%%*+%(D!(+$**%6+%%6""565*"
*A'*'2A'*E)

M,-7,G?%&'H)'(%'*%*+%#''2(##*%6(+!'%(A'0 # (%% *+% *(  0'%% *'('( *'A!"5A'0-
7MMG?%& ' H )%$'%'( # #" "0 %$'%'('A"A'2$'CI+(%'(# #*%"0*'A
A'0)
M%,	%%*+%'%!%%'(#(%%"02""56'%&#"A'0'2*+%-7%M?#"*+%$5'((+0'%#&6(*!+(%**% (%% %'" '# %& (%% !*'2 0( #+$%""5+#'65A'"%'#%&(%'%+%'%&"0(%&%%'(#%&
'%	%%(>7
	,GHJ0
)$+-
	??7GHJ$1,?,G?%&'7H&+($'%&$5*$!"'*%'20'/"('%&'(%'"(+'2!!""%!*'2( >, 0( + 'I+'5 %  *%"I+(%'3 0( %& (%'%+%' A'"% 0& 22( 0(!*"+#$*((C$''2$""2!'#"( **+(%' # !O  + 65 *" 	+!$ +%!*%0*(%'%&"%&%'%0(%&	'C%& $$%2+%(%&*'$'"#%%&'2&%D%6*#%0'%&%&0'%(((2'(%&'$E	(% $ F
  %%& * #%&#%%'"+('(%&'2&%#A5#%%%(%%&*'6'"'%5#0'%(((%&+2&*((C$'%'

	',
	-7?GM,HJ)
-?7-7G?%&'7-H&	+!$+%&($!&('B%&%*((C$'%''($%&('6"+"#%'"!*+J %& '% '( %& D!'*'!" $( 65 0&'*& %&6"'A6'"'%5#0'%((%&%+%&#&'(%(%'$5%(%E 
 , 
	 % ?J   
)

,-
	7,GM,HJ
!"7-	,--,-, G?H %%& ($%'$ %'" *+%&('(*%' % "'$'% %& (*! # *((C$'%' 
$W RQH LQVWDQFH DFFRUGLQJ WR %RJJV¶V FRXQVHO¶V DIILGDYLW GHVFULELQJWKH VHFRQGLQ FDPHUDKHDULQJ KH DVNHG %HUPDQ ZKHWKHU 3VKH DFFXVHG5LFN <D]HOO DQG 5RJHU %RJJV RI UDSH EHFDXVH >KHU ER\IULHQG@ *DU\5RWKZHOO KDG EHDWHQ DQG UDSHG KHU EXW VKH GLG QRW ZDQW WR JHW 0U5RWKZHOOLQ WURXEOH VR VKH EODPHG <D]HOO DQG %RJJV ́ -$ DW  6KHVDLG VKH KDG QRW $OWKRXJK WKLV TXHVWLRQ DGGUHVVHG D SRVVLEOH LPSURSHUPRWLYH LQ DFFXVLQJ %RJJV %RJJV GLG QRW SXUVXH WKLV WKHRU\ DWWULDO QRUGLG KH DGGXFH DQ\ HYLGHQFH LQVXSSRUW RI LW LQH[DPLQLQJ DQ\ RI WKHZLWQHVVHV 0RUHRYHU LQ WKHQXPHURXV DSSHDOV VLQFH WKH FRQYLFWLRQ KHGRHV QRW DSSHDU WR KDYH FODLPHG WKDW KH ZDV SXUVXLQJ VXFK D WKHRU\ RILPSURSHU PRWLYH%&$0&%&%"%'(&'!%%(&0$%'A%%(%'#5#"("5,77
	%
#

 M??  	+!! ? ,-- G) H 0&'*&22(%&"0*+%&A'"5"5%&#%%%$!% % (&0 %&% !' **+(%'( A" %&**+(=($%'A%$A&('*#$%&&$#!%%%&*+(%&#%0(%'%"D%(%6#%&@+5%&!##A'*#+"%'$%'A(#%& *$!"'%E %& %'" *+%=( 6  %&% A'*A'"% %& 	'C%& $$% &  &
 +%$!&('B%&%	%$!'%022"*'6'"'%5%%*/'$%(&0D!!('%5%#6'*%E6+%'(%(+2&%%A"!A'*#+"%'$%'A&%,-'$'""5 '( 
 	 %& '2&%& '*+'%'(!!A#%'"*+%=("'$'%%'##%=(##%% (&0 %&%  **+( D&  (%2 $%'A # #"("5**+('2"%E,7,M--G7%&'H
"'/(+*&*((""#0&'*&$'%&
+%=(#*+(%&D!%'"'%5 #  0'%((E  &'(  & D$%'A%' '%(%'#5'2E,
	%?0&'%&6'#(!'!&((#%&'(*(&(22(%'*+"%('$'"$%'A6( %&5  %& &'( 2+$% C!"'*'%"5 &'2( $=(2"*'6'"'%5	'$!"5"6"'2%&'(2"*'6'"'%5 2+$% % 6  # D$%'AE 0'%&+%-
DWWHPSWHG WRDUWLFXODWH D WKHRU\ RI ELDV RU SUHMXGLFH RQ DSSHDO 5DWKHUHYHQ DIWHU FURVVH[DPLQLQJ %HUPDQ DERXW WKH SULRU LQFLGHQW LQ ODWHUKHDULQJV %RJJV KDV HPSKDVL]HG RQO\%HUPDQ¶V JHQHUDO FUHGLELOLW\0RUHRYHU XQOLNH%XUU ZH GR QRW ILQG D ELDV RU PRWLYH WKHRU\ WR EH3DSSDUHQW ́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
 (%%#$''6'2'2%& !*&2(2'(%422(EHG$!&('(H+%(!'%%&'(($%'*'(%'*%'0(*&'A'#%&$2'(%%*+%22(%&A!A'C!"%'#$=($%'A%%(%'#5#"("5&'(('"*(%%&5#$%'A(&!"5'##%'%(%&'(*(#$%&(0&*+%(&A#+#%%'"+(A'"%'( (C!"'
%'*+"%%&5%&%0'%((&$%'A%#6'*%"5%%&&%#%&
 	#(( 	'$'""5'2%&+!$+%#+*(%'%+%'""5'$!!%&*+%=(#+("%""0%(%'$5#**+(=("%'(&'!0'%&
,Q WKH WULDO XQGHUO\LQJ WKH'DYLVDSSHDO 'DYLV FKDUJHG ZLWKEXUJODU\ ZDV EDUUHG IURP VKRZLQJ WKDW D NH\ ZLWQHVV DJDLQVW KLP ZDV RQSUREDWLRQ IRU EXUJODU\ 'DYLV DUJXHG DW WULDO WKDW KH ZDV QRW VHHNLQJ WRLQWURGXFH WKDW HYLGHQFH WR LPSHDFK WKH ZLWQHVV¶V FKDUDFWHU JHQHUDOO\5DWKHU KH DLPHG WR VKRZ WKDW WKH ZLWQHVV ZDV ELDVHG LQ WHVWLI\LQJ EHFDXVHKH ZDV WU\LQJ WR VKLHOG VXVSLFLRQV RI KLV RZQ LQYROYHPHQW LQ WKH FULPHDQG EHFDXVH KH PD\ KDYH IHDUHG WKDW KLV RZQ SUREDWLRQ ZDV LQ MHRSDUG\6HH LGDW -
	,M
	?M?MG7?H&'('*"+('(*%'%'$!("'$'%(6(**(6+%&(($%!@+'**#+('#%&'((+(0'%(((#%5'%2%'%&%'(!%'%'A"5$2'""5"A% J, 
 !

   M , G?%& 'HG*'%'2	,M
	%?MH
%&'(05%&#%%'"+(D2+%(

###*%'A*((C$'%'%*((C$'%'%&%'(##*%'A'0&%A 05  % 0&%A C%% %& #( $'2&%0'(&E - 
 3 ,M, 
	  -G7HG$!&('(''2'"H&+( "%&+2&
 %+$!%( %& A'%" " *((C$'%' * !"5 ' *(%'2 +6%   0'%((=(*'6'"'%5 % "" **'A6" $%&( # +$''2*'6'"'%5*(%'%+%'""52+%
!%'*+"%&
+%'(%'2+'(&6%0D2"%%*/E%&*'6'"'%5 #  0'%((.' 0&'*& %& *((C$'D'%(%##%&@+56('(%'#%&%%&0'%((=*&*%'((+*&%&%&0+"6"(("'/"5%&%&A2%+(%0%&5*'%'B%6%+%&#+"'&'(%(%'$5E.$ !%'*+" %%*/  *'6'"'%5 D'*% %0A"'2!(('6"6'((!@+'*(+"%'$%'A((%&5$5"%'*%"5%'((+(!("'%'('%&*(%&E,
	%?&+%**"+'2%&%DK%L&!%'"'%5#0'%(('("05("A%('(*'%'2%&0'%((##*%'2%&0'2&%#%&%(%'$5E#+%&'( "%% %5! # %%*/ % 6 !% # %& *(%'%+%'""5!%*% '2&% # *((C$'%' &  * 0'%& ('%+%'0&%'"*+%6*((C$'%'6'2  0'%((=( 6'(  $%'A % %(%'#5 %& +%,
**"+ %&% %& *+%A'"'2 (%% '%(%( D*%I+' 5'"'2 # ( A'%"  *(%'%+%'" '2&% ( %&##*%'A*((C$'%'#6'(#A(0'%((E&%-
**+*1+(%'*	%0%+(*%&%%&#%%'"+(0('$!"'*%"56*+()A'(0((/'2%(&06'(!@+'*DKL&+%'%&&"(  (+22(%(%&%%&(%'%+%' *#(  '2&%'A5 *(%'$!*&%& 2" *'6'"'%5 #  0'%((%&+2&*((C$'%'E6+%!(%*A'*%'(&%G	%0%1**+'2H	%&+%$!&('B%&%
!'*'('( *2'B %&% DN%& C!(+ #  0'%((=$%'A%''%(%'#5'2'(!!'$!%%#+*%'#%&*(%'%+%'""5!%*% '2&%#*(( C$'%'=E,M
	%?M7MGI+%'2
,
	%?MH
%%&"6%%&%D*'$'"#%(%%(A'"%'#%&#%%'"+(65(&0'2%&%&0(!&'6'%#$ 22'2' %&0'( !!!'% *((C$'%'('2%-

$%%%&!%#%&0'%((E&%?7-G$!&('(H&+%%&#*'%'*'B%&%'" *+%=( #+("%""0F (""%*((C$'/5!(*+%'0'%((6+%%&#*%%&%*&2( # !+6"'* +/(( & 6 '($'(( 'C*&2#&'(%(%'$5%?M&'("'$'%%'#*"( 'A(%'2%' '%  A% D%&%  @+5 $'2&%(6"5 &A #+ K% &AL #+'(& %& 0'%(( $%'A # #A'2%&!(*+%''&'(%(%'$5E%&#A'"%%&#%%'"+(&+%(#%
	&A&%%&'(%'*%'065%&(*((651+(%'*	%0%'&'(**+*.%&%*((C$'%' ( % 6'( $%'A  !@+'* '(*(%'%+%'""5!%*%6+%*((C$'%'(%2"*'6'"'%5'(%2
,$',77
	MG77HG#''2'%'"*+%=(#+("%""0*((C$'%'!A'*%'$=(C%$'%""%'(&'!0&%&% "%'(&'! 0+" &A (&0 %& A'*%'$=( 6'( $%'A%'HJ#
	,?
	,? G7,HG!$'%%'2 '$!*&$% A'* %&%  0'%(( 0( $$6 #%& 5 %' 0&'*& (&0 &'( !%%'"
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́'RUVH\ )G DW  3>7@KHGHIHQVH LV QRW UHTXLUHG WR EH DEOH WR VWDWH EHIRUHKDQG H[DFWO\ ZKDW IDFWVLW ZLVKHV WR HOLFLW    ́ 7KXV HYHQWKRXJK DGHIHQGDQW LQDUWIXOO\DUWLFXODWHG WR WKH WULDO FRXUW LWV SXUSRVH LQ FURVVH[DPLQLQJ D SURVHFXWLRQZLWQHVV -XGJH .HQQHG\ IRXQG WKH SRVVLELOLW\ RI ELDV RU SUHMXGLFH WR KDYHEHHQ 3DSSDUHQW ́ ODUJHO\ EHFDXVH WKH ZLWQHVV ZDV DQ DFFRPSOLFH ZKR KDGQRW EHHQFKDUJHGZLWK WKDW RU ODWHU FULPHV DQG FRQVHTXHQWO\ IRXQG D&RQIURQWDWLRQ &ODXVH YLRODWLRQ6HH %XUU  )G DW 8QOLNH FDVHV VXFK DV'DYLVDQG%XUU KRZHYHU %RJJV KDV QRW0+"6"(("'/"5%&%&A2%+(%0%&5*'%'B%6%+%&#+"'&'(%(%'$5E,
	%?+% %&'( $!&('(  $=( 2" *'6'"'%5A"/(%& #+$%"'(%'*%'0'
 	$%%&0*%"**+(=(*'6'"'%5'(%*(.'&*'6'"'%50'"""$(%"05(6%&*(%#!(C+"((+"%*(A'#%&'(!&5('*"A'*.%&(%'%+%'(%4%&%#%62'A%&!!%+'%5%022"%%*/ *'6'"'%5 65 !'%'2 % ''A'+" '(%*( # !(%*+*%
%&0(22(=(2+$%%&%*'6'"'%5'(*+*'"%%&'(*(%&%%A'*6'2%&%*'6'"'%5$+(%6""0'('$!"5(%#"*%'C%& $$%*("0

'%(!25%&'C%& $$% "5 *$!"( *((C$'%' '# %&%C$'%''$(%A"%&$%'A6'(!@+'*#0'%((R**+(  *+( & #'" % %'*+"% (+*& 2+$%'%&%%'"!!"6*+(%&'(%!"+('6"%&5#$%'A6'(!!%#$%&%'"* G'*"+'2 #$ %& $&'2(H  #$22(=(2+$%(!!"22(&(%$(%%#%%'"+('#*%'7
8'A%&(!*%(0$+(% @*%22(=(!'$52+$%6*+('%'$!!"56"+(%&!*'('(%'*%'(0'#%%'"+(@+'(!+*%&A'2%'*+"%2+$%(+'2'$%'A6'(!@+'*22( '(% (/( % "A% &'( !+!(.%%*/'2$=( 2" *'6'"'%5.'%  *(%'%+%'""5$%'2&%2+(%&%6*+($=(*'6'"'%5'(*%"%&'(*(%&	'C%& $$%I+'(%&%&6""0%*((C$'&'*'%6'2%&%*'6'"'%5*+(%&'(*%%'2(65%&*"(0!#%&#%%'"+(%*65
0*%**!%'%(2+ #&6( "'# * 0 **!% %& ('2 # %& "0 *+%( '2%'2%&0'%%&'(2+&*22(=(2+$%(!!"(&0%&%@+(%('*22(=(!+!(''%+*'2%& ""2 !' #"( **+(%' 0( % %%*/ $=(2" *'6'"'%5  %& % %'"   !!" 22(((%'""5*%%&%%&A'*0(*+*'"6*+('#$"'#6'*%*(&0+"(2' %%&('6+'2%&%'"22(=(*+("C!"'3DK	L&=($'%+!2'KL
0%%#'+%'#(&=($+!""#%&'(E  1  % ?  
 &'( 6'# 6# %&'( +% 22(!%"5+(*(%&'$!%*#%&!'**+(%'''$''(&'2$=(2"*'6'"'%522(=(%  GD& #( 0( ('$!"5 (/'2 % 2'A %& @+5'%'"A'*0'%&0&'*&%0'2&%&""2A'*%'$=(*'6'"'%5EHJ%?GDKL&/5'((+'%&'(%%*(0(%&**+(=(*'6'"'%5%""0'I+'5'%&!' '(%*( # +%+%&#+"(( '( %  %& #"*(%'%+%'" 2+% % *#%  *((C$'$'2"((EHJ%?GD&@+5(&+"66"%*'0&% 0'2&%  !' #"( **+(%' &(  %& ""2A'*%'$=( *'6'"'%5 % %& %'" @+2EH &+( 22(=(2+$%*&(%&
+%=(#''%'#2"%%*/*'6'"'%5.0&!%5D'%(%##%&@+5 6('(%'# %&%%& 0'%((= *&*%'( (+*&%&% &
6'( 2'(%  6"*/ #%HJ  #  

%%,,M7,7G?%&'7HG'(*+(('2
 	'%& *%C% # 0'%(( $%'A%' 6'(HJ 
 ' 7M  ? ?? G?%& '7HG%'2 %&% '
  '%( !25 *+%( &A'(%'2+'(&D6%0%&*A"+(#%&*#%%''2&%($!'!&"**(0&'*&$'0'%&'%&$6'%#%&%'"@+2=('(*%'EH& #*0'%&""2!'#"(**+(%'(#!#"*+%(&A&%%&#'"'0'
	#''2*((C$'%'*(%'%+%'""5*$!""0&'%A"(0'%((6'(!@+'*6+%%0& '% '( '$ (""5 % '$''(&  0'%((=( 2"*'6'"'%5  
* 
  ?,  M- G%& '7H %& %'" *+% #+( % ""0 #( *+(" %*((C$'""2!A'*%'$6+%""2!'#"( **+(%' # !  & '%& '*+'% "'  %&'(%'*%'0'
D6%0%%*/%&2"*'6'"'%5 # %& 0'%((   $ !%'*+" %%*/ *'6'"'%5E%&+2& A"'26'((!@+'*(+"%'$%'A( & % M  9/'2 *"("5 % %& #%=(!+!(#'%+*'2%&%(%'$5%&+%#+%&%%&#(0(('$!"5(/'2%&@+5%$/'#*D%&% 6*+( %& *$!"''2 0'%(( $  #"(**+(%' # %%$!% !   !' **(' &**+(%''%&'(*(0(#"(E&
%&0(%&'%*((C$'%'D0(%%(%6"'(&6'(2'(%%&#%#%&!(*+%'J'%$"50+"&A6%%%*/%&2"*'6'"'%5#%&0'%((%&6('(#+"%!''*'%E&

%&*+%**"+"'$'%'2*((C$'%'#%&%!+!('%A'"%%&#%%'"+(%M'$'""5'#
7?-MG7%&'77H!#%*&""2(+*(%'%+%'"%&'(%'*% *+%=( #+("% $'% A'*# A'*%'$=(""2!'#"(**+(%'#!9'/%&'%&'*+'%%& '2&%& '*+'% % %& '(%'*%' 6%0 *((?
C$'%' 2'2  0'%((R**+(=(!(('6" 6'((!@+'*(  +"%' $%'A(  *((C$'%' A'*'%+*('$!"5%%%*/&2"*'6'"'%5  % -777  & *+% #+ %&% %& "%%!+!(.%&'#*%&%D6*+(%&A'*%'$$#"( **+(%' ' %& !(% %& '(%% **+(%' '( "(#"(E % -7.#"" 6"0 %& 	'C%& $$%%&(&"*+('%&*(6#'%D%&A'*#%&""2!'#"(**+(%'#!0(##(""5%%%*/%&2"*'6'"'%5#E%&A'*%'$%&'(%'*%*+%=(#+(" % ""0 %& %%$!% *((C$'%' ' %A'"%%"%%=(*#%%''2&%(&%&*+%(&A*&%&('2#$**
*'M7GM%&'?HG%'2%&%
%&*(('%(+22(%%&%D%&"2(%'2+"( (%'*%'2%&+(# (!*'#'*'(%*(  C%'('*A'* % '$!*&  0'%((=( *'6'"'%5 !(*(%'%+%'"!6"$(EHJ#
'?,7M9?M--M%QG,%&'MHG+!+6"'(&!''HG#''2%&%""2!'#"(**+(%'&"'%%""A*D%%&**+(=(*'6'"'%5A*'%5(!*%'2%&*&26'2!(*+%EHJ-
,--  9 ?M,-, % Q G) " HG+!+6"'(&!''HG'2
	%(5%&% 0&'" %& *(%'%+%' !%*%( *((C$'%''#'%**(6'($%'A!@+'*D2"%%*/(%&*'6'"'%5 #  0'%((  % '( %& *(%'%+%'"**( 0&'*& %& *#%%' *"+( (((EHJ&'(%!& !(%
  -   3$$%
5!1%)%
%,192'(,G7HG%'2%&%0&%&""2#"(**+(%'#!$+(%6$'%%+%&#%%' "+( %+(  %& '(%'*%' 6%0!A'26'(!@+'*!A'22"*'6'"'%5H"%&+2&%'*%"5(('2%&#%%'"+(%&'(+%&%%&"2'*#* '#  
  M7  , G?%& ' 7?H'"0(*A'*%#!
'(A%'J!!"&*&""2%&'(%'*%*+%=(#+("!+(+%%
M%&#"!(&'""0A',%""0*((C$'%'$'%A'*%&%&'(%&'%5"**+(G'*H&!A'+("5!%'(%*(#(C+"((+"%65#$'"5$$6(6+%&"%0'%&0%&(**+(%'(%?'"2+%&%%&'(A'*(&+"&A6$'%%6*+('%0%%%&*$!"'%=( *'6'"'%5  %'2 %& D0' '(*%'E@565'(%'*%*+%((+*&A'%'5$%%(.C*!%' *(( 0& $'((' 0( D*(%'%+%'""5I+'E.%&'(+%'%#'%&"0*+%=(*'('%&A66+(#%&%'(*%'%?&'(**"+(' "( *(('"5 '$!"' %&% %& *((C$'%'  0( % *(%'%+%'""5 I+'  #
(-,M-MG7%&'---H#%'"*+%&(*+%'"*((C$'%'#$0&'*& @+5 *+" &A ((((  0'%((=( 6'( !@+'* $%'A % %(%'#5  *+% $+(% %/ %0 '%'" (%!('(%  A'0'2 *+% $+(% (((( 0&%& %& @+5 &+2&'#$%'(!'%%&"'$'%(!"*%&0'(!$'%%*((C$'%'%((((%&#(%&5#6'(  '$!! $%'A   7M  % ?MJ

'$M,?,,MG?%&'7,H*'#%&'('(%%&*(%&'(''"('2'#'*%'$'+%'#*((C$'%'%&%'$!"'*%(%&#%%'"+(%&+%!!"'(6"*'2%(%0'2&'2 %& A'"%' 2'(% %& *$!%'2 '%(%( %(%/,-
	%

%&+%#+%&%%&(%%=('%(%'!%*%'2%&5$'%5#@+A'"##0(%*$!6"%%&D!$+%E'%(%'%&'2&%%(&0%&6'(#A(0'%((&%
)$
$--
	,GH%&%&&%&+%+!&"4'*&'2!(&'"(%%+%=(%'*&'2 I+'$%%&% !%% 6 *((C$'%' ' %& *( ' I+(%'  "%&+2& %& +%**"+%&%%&+"*+"'$''(&#%=(6'"'%5%*#% A( 0'%((( '% #+ %&% %&'( ##*% 0(+%0'2&65*+%A'"'2(%%'%(%('!%*%'2!A'*%'$(#$(+!'(&(($%+*((5'A('(#!'A*5%,-