UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 


FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 


OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES 


) SECRETARY

In the Matter of ) 

) 

McW ANE, INC., ) 

a corporation, and ) DOCKET NO. 9351 

) 

STAR PIPE PRODUCTS, LTD., ) 

a limited partnership, ) 

Respondents. ) 

------------------------------~) 

ORDER ON STAR PIPE PRODUCTS, LTD.'S 

MOTION FOR IN CAMERA TREATMENT 

By Order dated August 17,2012, the motion for in camera treatment filed by non-party 

Star Pipe Products, Ltd. ("Star"), was ruled upon. (August 17,2012 Order). The August 17, 

2012 Order set forth the standards used to evaluate and the rationale for ruling on that motion. 

The August 17, 2012 Order further directed Complaint Counsel to provide a list that identifies by 

exhibit number, the Star documents that are being offered into evidence and were granted in 

camera treatment by the August 17, 2012 Order. On August 30,2012, Complaint Counsel 

provided a proposed order, pursuant to that directive. 

In camera treatment, for a period offive years, to expire on September 1,2017, is 

GRANTED for the following documents: 

Exhibits: 

CX-0015 CX-0604 CX-1712 

CX-0016 CX-0736 CX-1714 

CX-0017 CX-0739 CX-1715 

CX-0018 CX-0773 CX-1716 

CX-0020 CX-0784 CX-1717 

CX-0042 CX-0794 CX-1722 

CX-0528 CX-0796 CX-1801-A 

CX-0541 CX-0797 CX-1872 

CX-0542 CX-0869 CX-1971 

CX-0545 CX-1706 CX-2307 

CX-0546 CX-1707 CX-2334 

CX-0561 CX-1709 CX-2337 

CX-0593 CX-1710 CX-2366 

CX-0602 CX-1711 CX-2368 
CX-2375 

CX-2381 

CX-2385 

CX-2389 

CX-2391 

CX-2392 

CX-2393 

CX-2470 

CX-2471 

CX-2472 

RX-066 

RX-067 

RX-143 

RX-160 

RX-161 

RX-162 

Transcript Excerpts 

CX-2526 

CX-2533 

RX-165 

RX-166 

RX-170 

RX-177 

RX-183 

RX-184 

RX-197 

RX-204 

RX-206 

RX-221 

RX-222 

RX-231 

RX-235 

RX-236 

RX-238 

RX-239 

20:3 to 20:8 

21:4 to 21 :24 

19:1 to 20:16 

20:18 to 20:19 

21:6 to 22:9 

23:12 to 23:22 

26:5 to 27:19 

29:24 to 30:24 

37:17 to 37:24 

38:9 to 39:1 

39:11 to 42:12 

44:8 to 47:6 

47:11 to 47: 20 

52:21 to 53:8 

53: 11 to 54:7 

55:1 to 55:13 

65:21 to 66:18 

66:23 to 68:19 

70:18 to 71:3 

93:8 to 93:20 

101 :15 to 101:20 

102:25 to 103:10 

118:14 to 118:25 

119:10 to 120:5 

RX-243 

RX-244 

RX-249 

RX-253 

RX-254 

RX-258 

RX-264 

RX-271 

RX-275 

RX-372 

RX-531 

RX-578 

RX-585 

CX-2534 11: 14 to 14:8 

2 

i 

14:20 to 16:12 

45:13 to 48:19 

51 :22 to 52:24 

74:11 to 78:4 

80:20 to 82: 11 

83:10 to 92:2 

-:1 

CX-2535 11:10 to 12:19 

55:16 to 56:15 

57:6 to 59:12 

59:17to61:15 

68:9 to 69:1 

72: 11 to 76:5 

76:7 to 76: 14 

79:3 to 80:12 

83:21 to 84:5 

84: 11 to 85:3 

91:4 to 93:1 

107:4 to 111:16 

118:2 to 120:5 

126:9 to 131:9 

134:6 to 135:20 

136:2 to 136:4 

136:25 to 141:4 

141:6 to 142:1 

144:11 to 146:19 

156:10 to 157:3 

CX-2536 117:5 to 118:7 

CX-2537 85:1 to 86:22 

87:25 to 87:24 

92:1 to 95:4 

108:20 to 109:24 

110:16 to 111:16 

158:22 to 164:14 

166:2 to 166:5 

166:15 to 168:7 

179:22 to 181 :23 

187:9 to 189:13 

203:15 to 204:9 

CX-2538 404:15 to 406:4 

406:25 to 408:16 

CX-2539 15:6 to 15:13 

145:1 to 146:24 

3 
CX-2540 44:1 to 44:13 

RX685 

RX692 

RX693 

RX694 

RX696 

RX697 

RX698 

ORDERED: 

20:3 to 20:8 

21:20 to 21:24 

26:16 to 27:1 

52:18 to 53:2 

65:21 to 66:18 

101 :15 to 10 1 :20 

30:20to31:16 

36:20 to 37:8 

41:5 to 42:12 

11:10 to 12:19 

55:16 to 56:15 

57:6 to 58:4 

60:15 to 60:19 

59:17 to 60:10 

68:9 to 69:1 

80:12 to 80:12 

107 :20 to 111: 16 

87:19 to 87:24 

109:25 to 11 0: 15 

164:15 to 164:24 

166:6 to 166:14 

181:24 to 182:7 

183:4 to 184:3 

305: 12 to 307:6 

375:17 to 376:11 

406:5 to 406:24 

15:9 to 15:13 

145:7 to 145:22 

Date: August 31, 2012 

4