FTC Form 232 (rev 7/11) 

FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 

WASHINGTON, DC 20580 

CASE NAME FILE/DOCKET NUMBER 

Pursuant to Section 4.1 of the Commission’s Rules of Practice, I (we) am (are) entering in the above 

proceeding the appearance of 

Ƒ counsel supporting the complaint (Complete Items 1, 3, 4, and 5 below) 

Ƒ counsel or representative for the respondent (Complete Items 1, 2, 4, and 5 below) 

Ƒ counsel or representative for a third party (Complete Items 1, 2, 4, and 5 below) 

1. COUNSEL OR REPRESENTATIVE 2. RESPONDENT(S) OR THIRD PARTY(IES) 

Include the name, address, email address, and telephone 

number of each counsel or representative entering an 

appearance in the above proceeding, 

Include the address and telephone numbers of all persons, 

partnerships, corporations, or associations on whose behalf 

this Notice of Appearance is being filed. 

3. ASSOCIATE/ASSISTANT DIRECTOR 

4. SIGNATURE OF SENIOR COUNSEL 5. DATE SIGNED 

Return this form to: Federal Trade Commission 

Room H-113 

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. 

Washington, D.C. 20580 

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

Ardagh Group S.A., et al.

Sebastian Lorigo (Attorney)

U.S. Federal Trade Commission

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

slorigo@ftc.gov

Washington, DC 20580

Phone: 202-326-3717

Brendan J. McNamara (Attorney)

U.S. Federal Trade Commission

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

bmcnamara@ftc.gov

Washington, DC 20580

Phone: 202-326-3703

Angelike Mina (Attorney)

U.S. Federal Trade Commission

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

amina@ftc.gov

Washington, DC 20580

Phone: 202-326-3119

Catharine M. Moscatelli (Attorney)

U.S. Federal Trade Commission

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

cmoscatelli@ftc.gov

Washington, DC 20580

Phone: 202-326-2749

Angel Prado (Attorney)

U.S. Federal Trade Commission

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW

aprado@ftc.gov

Washington, DC 20580

(Edward D. Hassi)

D09356

7/3/2013

Catharine M. Moscatelli

38%/,&

07 03 2013

ntering in the above

07 03 2013 07 03 20
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES

__________________________________________

 ) 

In the Matter of ) PUBLIC

 ) 

Ardagh Group S.A, ) 

 a public limited liability company, and ) DOCKET NO. 9356 

 ) 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., ) 

 a corporation, and )

 ) 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, a corporation. )

__________________________________________)

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

 Please note my appearance as Complaint Counsel for the Federal Trade 

Commission in the above-referenced matter. In accordance with Rule 4.1(d) of the 

Federal Trade Commission’s Rules of Practice, I certify that I am a member of the bar of 

the Commonwealth of Virginia (Bar No. 48508) and am in good standing within the legal 

profession.

 Respectfully submitted, 

 s/ Sebastian Lorigo_______ 

Sebastian Lorigo 

Counsel Supporting the Complaint 

 Bureau of Competition 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 Washington, DC 20580 

Dated: July 3, 2013

38%/,&
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that on July 3, 2013, I filed the foregoing document electronically 

using the FTC’s E-Filing System, which will send notification of such filing to: 

 Donald S. Clark 

 Secretary 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-113 

 Washington, DC 20580 

 I also certify that I delivered via electronic mail and hand delivery a copy of the 

foregoing document to: 

 The Honorable D. Michael Chappell 

 Administrative Law Judge 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-110 

 Washington, DC 20580 

 I further certify that I delivered via electronic mail a copy of the foregoing 

document to: 

Alan Goudiss 

Dale Collins 

Richard Schwed 

Lisl Dunlop 

Shearman & Sterling LLP 

599 Lexington Avenue 

New York, NY 10022 

(202) 848-4906 

agoudiss@shearman.com 

wcollins@shearman.com 

rschwed@shearman.com 

ldunlop@shearman.com 

Counsel for Respondent Ardagh Group S.A.

Christine Varney 

Yonatan Even 

Athena Cheng 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

825 Eighth Avenue 

New York, NY 10019 

(212) 474-1140 

cvarney@cravath.com 

yeven@cravath.com

38%/,&
acheng@cravath.com

Counsel for Respondent Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc.

CERTIFICATE FOR ELECTRONIC FILING 

 I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary of the Commission is a true 

and correct copy of the paper original and that I possess a paper original of the signed 

document that is available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

July 3, 2013 By: s/ Angelike Mina 

 Attorney 

38%/,&
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES

__________________________________________

 ) 

In the Matter of ) PUBLIC

 ) 

Ardagh Group S.A, ) 

 a public limited liability company, and ) DOCKET NO. 9356 

 ) 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., ) 

 a corporation, and )

 ) 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, a corporation. )

__________________________________________)

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

 Please note my appearance as Complaint Counsel for the Federal Trade 

Commission in the above-referenced matter. In accordance with Rule 4.1(d) of the 

Federal Trade Commission’s Rules of Practice, I certify that I am a member of the bar of 

the Commonwealth of Virginia (Bar No. 48560) and am in good standing within the legal 

profession.

 Respectfully submitted, 

 s/ Brendan J. McNamara_______ 

Brendan J. McNamara 

Counsel Supporting the Complaint 

 Bureau of Competition 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 Washington, DC 20580 

Dated: July 3, 2013

38%/,&
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that on July 3, 2013, I filed the foregoing document electronically 

using the FTC’s E-Filing System, which will send notification of such filing to: 

 Donald S. Clark 

 Secretary 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-113 

 Washington, DC 20580 

 I also certify that I delivered via electronic mail and hand delivery a copy of the 

foregoing document to: 

 The Honorable D. Michael Chappell 

 Administrative Law Judge 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-110 

 Washington, DC 20580 

 I further certify that I delivered via electronic mail a copy of the foregoing 

document to: 

Alan Goudiss 

Dale Collins 

Richard Schwed 

Lisl Dunlop 

Shearman & Sterling LLP 

599 Lexington Avenue 

New York, NY 10022 

(202) 848-4906 

agoudiss@shearman.com 

wcollins@shearman.com 

rschwed@shearman.com 

ldunlop@shearman.com 

Counsel for Respondent Ardagh Group S.A.

Christine Varney 

Yonatan Even 

Athena Cheng 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

825 Eighth Avenue 

New York, NY 10019 

(212) 474-1140 

cvarney@cravath.com 

yeven@cravath.com

38%/,&
acheng@cravath.com

Counsel for Respondent Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc.

CERTIFICATE FOR ELECTRONIC FILING 

 I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary of the Commission is a true 

and correct copy of the paper original and that I possess a paper original of the signed 

document that is available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

July 3, 2013 By: s/ Angelike Mina 

 Attorney 

38%/,&
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES

__________________________________________

 ) 

In the Matter of ) PUBLIC

 ) 

Ardagh Group S.A, ) 

 a public limited liability company, and ) DOCKET NO. 9356 

 ) 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., ) 

 a corporation, and )

 ) 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, a corporation. )

__________________________________________)

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

 Please note my appearance as Complaint Counsel for the Federal Trade 

Commission in the above-referenced matter. In accordance with Rule 4.1(d) of the 

Federal Trade Commission’s Rules of Practice, I certify that I am a member of the bar of 

the State of Maryland (no bar number assigned) and am in good standing within the legal 

profession.

 Respectfully submitted, 

 s/ Angelike Mina____________ 

Angelike Mina 

Counsel Supporting the Complaint 

 Bureau of Competition 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 Washington, DC 20580 

Dated: July 3, 2013

38%/,&
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that on July 3, 2013, I filed the foregoing document electronically 

using the FTC’s E-Filing System, which will send notification of such filing to: 

 Donald S. Clark 

 Secretary 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-113 

 Washington, DC 20580 

 I also certify that I delivered via electronic mail and hand delivery a copy of the 

foregoing document to: 

 The Honorable D. Michael Chappell 

 Administrative Law Judge 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-110 

 Washington, DC 20580 

 I further certify that I delivered via electronic mail a copy of the foregoing 

document to: 

Alan Goudiss 

Dale Collins 

Richard Schwed 

Lisl Dunlop 

Shearman & Sterling LLP 

599 Lexington Avenue 

New York, NY 10022 

(202) 848-4906 

agoudiss@shearman.com 

wcollins@shearman.com 

rschwed@shearman.com 

ldunlop@shearman.com 

Counsel for Respondent Ardagh Group S.A.

Christine Varney 

Yonatan Even 

Athena Cheng 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

825 Eighth Avenue 

New York, NY 10019 

(212) 474-1140 

cvarney@cravath.com 

yeven@cravath.com

38%/,&
acheng@cravath.com

Counsel for Respondent Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc.

CERTIFICATE FOR ELECTRONIC FILING 

 I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary of the Commission is a true 

and correct copy of the paper original and that I possess a paper original of the signed 

document that is available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

July 3, 2013 By: s/ Angelike Mina 

 Attorney 

38%/,&
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES

__________________________________________

 ) 

In the Matter of ) PUBLIC

 ) 

Ardagh Group S.A, ) 

 a public limited liability company, and ) DOCKET NO. 9356 

 ) 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., ) 

 a corporation, and )

 ) 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, a corporation. )

__________________________________________)

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

 Please note my appearance as Complaint Counsel for the Federal Trade 

Commission in the above-referenced matter. In accordance with Rule 4.1(d) of the 

Federal Trade Commission’s Rules of Practice, I certify that I am a member of the bar of 

the District of Columbia (Bar No. 418510) and am in good standing within the legal 

profession.

 Respectfully submitted, 

 s/ Catharine M. Moscatelli______ 

Catharine M. Moscatelli 

Counsel Supporting the Complaint 

 Bureau of Competition 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 Washington, DC 20580 

Dated: July 3, 2013

38%/,&
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that on July 3, 2013, I filed the foregoing document electronically 

using the FTC’s E-Filing System, which will send notification of such filing to: 

 Donald S. Clark 

 Secretary 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-113 

 Washington, DC 20580 

 I also certify that I delivered via electronic mail and hand delivery a copy of the 

foregoing document to: 

 The Honorable D. Michael Chappell 

 Administrative Law Judge 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-110 

 Washington, DC 20580 

 I further certify that I delivered via electronic mail a copy of the foregoing 

document to: 

Alan Goudiss 

Dale Collins 

Richard Schwed 

Lisl Dunlop 

Shearman & Sterling LLP 

599 Lexington Avenue 

New York, NY 10022 

(202) 848-4906 

agoudiss@shearman.com 

wcollins@shearman.com 

rschwed@shearman.com 

ldunlop@shearman.com 

Counsel for Respondent Ardagh Group S.A.

Christine Varney 

Yonatan Even 

Athena Cheng 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

825 Eighth Avenue 

New York, NY 10019 

(212) 474-1140 

cvarney@cravath.com 

yeven@cravath.com

38%/,&
acheng@cravath.com

Counsel for Respondent Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc.

CERTIFICATE FOR ELECTRONIC FILING 

 I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary of the Commission is a true 

and correct copy of the paper original and that I possess a paper original of the signed 

document that is available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

July 3, 2013 By: s/ Angelike Mina 

 Attorney 

38%/,&
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES

__________________________________________

 ) 

In the Matter of ) PUBLIC

 ) 

Ardagh Group S.A, ) 

 a public limited liability company, and ) DOCKET NO. 9356 

 ) 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., ) 

 a corporation, and )

 ) 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, a corporation. )

__________________________________________)

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

 Please note my appearance as Complaint Counsel for the Federal Trade 

Commission in the above-referenced matter. In accordance with Rule 4.1(d) of the 

Federal Trade Commission’s Rules of Practice, I certify that I am a member of the bar of 

the State of New Jersey (Bar No. 056962013) and am in good standing within the legal 

profession.

 Respectfully submitted, 

 s/ Angel Prado_____________ 

Angel Prado 

Counsel Supporting the Complaint 

 Bureau of Competition 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 Washington, DC 20580 

Dated: July 3, 2013

38%/,&
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that on July 3, 2013, I filed the foregoing document electronically 

using the FTC’s E-Filing System, which will send notification of such filing to: 

 Donald S. Clark 

 Secretary 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-113 

 Washington, DC 20580 

 I also certify that I delivered via electronic mail and hand delivery a copy of the 

foregoing document to: 

 The Honorable D. Michael Chappell 

 Administrative Law Judge 

 Federal Trade Commission 

 600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW, Rm. H-110 

 Washington, DC 20580 

 I further certify that I delivered via electronic mail a copy of the foregoing 

document to: 

Alan Goudiss 

Dale Collins 

Richard Schwed 

Lisl Dunlop 

Shearman & Sterling LLP 

599 Lexington Avenue 

New York, NY 10022 

(202) 848-4906 

agoudiss@shearman.com 

wcollins@shearman.com 

rschwed@shearman.com 

ldunlop@shearman.com 

Counsel for Respondent Ardagh Group S.A.

Christine Varney 

Yonatan Even 

Athena Cheng 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

825 Eighth Avenue 

New York, NY 10019 

(212) 474-1140 

cvarney@cravath.com 

yeven@cravath.com

38%/,&
acheng@cravath.com

Counsel for Respondent Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc.

CERTIFICATE FOR ELECTRONIC FILING 

 I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary of the Commission is a true 

and correct copy of the paper original and that I possess a paper original of the signed 

document that is available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

July 3, 2013 By: s/ Angelike Mina 

 Attorney 

38%/,&