ORIGINAL 


FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 

WASHINGTON, D.C. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 20580 

CASE NAME 

of Ardagh Group S.A., Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., and No. 9356 IComo;~on.ie Saint-Gobain 

Pursuant to Section 4.1 of the Commission's Rules of Practice, I (we) am (are) <=>n1r<=>ronn·~r~,~~~!!!!~_.J[IIIIi 

proceeding the appearance of 

r counsel supporting the complaint (Complete Items 1, 3, 4, and 5 below) 

IX' counsel or representative for the respondent (Complete Items 1, 2, 4, and 5 below) 

r counsel or representative for a third party (Complete Items 1, 2, 4, and 5 below) 

1. COUNSEL OR REPRESENTATIVE 

Include the name, address, email address, and telephone number of each 

counsel or representative entering an appearance in the above proceeding, 

Sandra C. Goldstein (Attorney) 


Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 


Worldwide Plaza 


825 Eighth Avenue 


New York, NY 10019 


Phone: (212) 474-1000 


E-mail: sgoldstein@cravath.com 


Rory A. Leraris (Attorney) 


Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 


Worldwide Plaza 


825 Eighth Avenue 


New York, NY 10019 


Phone: (212) 474-1000 


E-mail: rleraris@cravath.com 


Athena N. Cheng (Attorney) 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

Worldwide Plaza 

825 Eighth Avenue 

New York, NY 10019 

Phone: (212) 474-1000 

E-mail: acheng@cravath.com 

Pierre N. Gemson (Attorney) 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

Worldwide Plaza 

825 Eighth Avenue 

New York, NY 10019 

Phone: (212) 474-1000 

E-mail: pgemson@cravath.com 

Sarah M. Colombo (Attorney) 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

Worldwide Plaza 

825 Eighth Avenue 

New York, NY 10019 

Phone: (212) 474-1000 

E-mail: scolombo@cravath.com 

3. ASSOCIATE/ASSISTANT DIRECTOR 

2. RESPONDENT(S) OR THIRD PARTY(IES) 

Include the address and telephone numbers of all persons, partnerships, 


corporations, or associations on whose behalf this Notice of Appearance 


is being filed. 


Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc. 

1509 S. Macedonia Avenue 

Muncie, Indiana 47302 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain 

"Les Miroirs" 18, avenue d' Alsace 

92400 Courbevoie 

France 

I 

4. SIGNATURE OF SENIOR COUNSEL 5. DATESIGNED 

Is/ Christine A. Varney !!July 24, 2013 

Return Federal Trade Commission this form to: 

Room H-113 

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. 

Washington, D.C. 20580 

FTC Form 232 (rev. 7/11) 

I 
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 

BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES . 

) 

In the Matter of ) 

) 

Ardagh Group S.A., ) 

a public limited liability company, and ) PUBLIC 

) 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., ) Docket No. 9356 

a corporation, and ) 

) 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, a corporation. ) 

) ________________________________) 

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that I, Sandra C. Goldstein, am a member ofthe law 

firm ofCravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, and hereby enters an appearance as counsel for SaintGobain Containers, Inc. and Compagnie de Saint-Gobain in the above-captioned action. In 

accordance with Rule 4.l(d) ofthe Federal Trade Commission's Rules ofPractice, I certify that I 

am a member ofthe bar ofthe State ofNew York (Attorney Registration No. 2198745) and am 

in good standing within the legal profession. 

Executed on July 24, 2013. 

sf Sandra C. Goldstein 

Sandra C. Goldstein 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

Worldwide Plaza 

825 Eighth A venue 

New York, NY 10019-7275 

(212) 474-1000 

sgoldstein@cravath.com 
PUBLIC 


CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that on July 24,2013, I filed the foregoing document 

electronically using the FTC's E-filing System, which will send notification of such filing to: 

Donald S. Clark 


Secretary 


Federal Trade Commission 


600 Pennsylvania A venue, NW, Room H-113 


Washington, DC 20580 


I also certify that a copy ofthe foregoing document has been delivered via 

electronic mail, and by overnight courier (Federal Express) for delivery on Thursday, July 25, 

2013 to: 

The Honorable D. Michael Chappell (oalj@ftc.gov) 

Administrative Law Judge 

Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Room H-110 

Washington, DC 20580 

I further certify that a copy ofthe foregoing document has been delivered via 

electronic mail to: 

Edward D. Hassi (ehassi@ftc.gov) 


James E. Abell Gabell@ftc.gov) 


Monica Castillo (mcastillo@ftc.gov) 


Steven A. Dahm (sdahm@ftc.gov) 


Joshua Goodman Ggoodman@ftc.gov) 


Sebastian Lorigo (slorigo@ftc.gov) 


Brendan J. McNamara (bmcnamara@ftc.gov) 


Angelike Mina (amina@ftc.gov) 


Catharine M. Moscatelli (cmoscatelli@ftc.gov) 


Angel Prado (aprado@ftc.gov) 


Kristian Rogers (krogers@ftc.gov) 


Danielle Sims (dsims1@ftc.gov) 


Eric M. Sprague (esprague@ftc.gov) 


Steven L. Wilensky (swilensky@ftc.gov) 


Thomas H. Brock (tbrock@ftc.gov) 


Michael B. Kades (mkades@ftc.gov) 


Michael A. Franchak (mfranchak@ftc.gov) 


Amanda Hamilton (ahamilton1@ftc.gov) 


Sean D. Hughto (shughto@ftc.gov) 


Victoria Lippincott (vlippincott@ftc.gov) 


Meredith Robinson (mrobinson@ftc.gov) 

PUBLIC 


U.S. Federal Trade Commission 


600 Pennsylvania A venue, NW 


Washington, DC 20580 


Counsel Supporting the Complaint 

Alan Goudiss (agoudiss@shearman.com) 


Dale Collins (wcollins@shearman.com) 


Richard Schwed (rschwed@shearman.com) 


Lisl Dunlop (ldunlop@shearman.com) 


Heather Kafele (hkafele@shearman.com) 


Shearman & Sterling LLP 


599 Lexington A venue 


New York, NY 10022 


Counselfor Respondent Ardagh Group S.A. 

CERTIFICATE OF ELECTRONIC FILING 

I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary ofthe Commission is a true 

and correct copy ofthe paper original and that I possess a paper original ofthe signed document 

that is available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

July 24, 2013 

sf Sandra C. Goldstein 

Sandra C. Goldstein 
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 


BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 


OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES 


) 

In the Matter of ) 

) 

Ardagh Group S.A., ) 

a public limited liability company, and ) PUBLIC 

) 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., ) Docket No. 9356 

a corporation, and ) 

) 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, a corporation. ) 

) ______________________________) 

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that I, Rory A. Leraris, am an associate ofthe law firm 

ofCravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, and hereby enters an appearance as counsel for Saint-Gobain 

Containers, Inc. and Compagnie de Saint-Gobain in the above-captioned action. In accordance 

with Rule 4.l(d) ofthe Federal Trade Commission's Rules ofPractice, I certify that I am a 

member ofthe bar ofthe State ofNew York (Attorney Registration No. 4728366) and am in 

good standing within the legal profession. 

Executed on July 24, 2013. 

s/ Rory A. Leraris 

Rory A. Leraris 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

Worldwide Plaza 

825 Eighth A venue 

New York, NY 10019-7275 

(212) 474-1000 

rleraris@cravath.com 
PUBLIC 


CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that on July 24, 2013, I filed the foregoing document 

electronically using the FTC's E-filing System, which will send notification of such filing to: 

Donald S. Clark 


Secretary 


Federal Trade Commission 


600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Room H-113 


Washington, DC 20580 


I also certify that a copy ofthe foregoing document has been delivered via 

electronic mail, and by overnight courier (Federal Express) for delivery on Thursday, July 25, 

2013 to: 

The Honorable D. Michael Chappell (oalj@ftc.gov) 

Administrative Law Judge 

Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Room H-110 

Washington, DC 20580 

I further certify that a copy of the foregoing document has been delivered via 

electronic mail to: 

Edward D. Hassi (ehassi@ftc.gov) 


James E. Abell Gabell@ftc.gov) 


Monica Castillo (mcastillo@ftc.gov) 


Steven A. Dahm (sdahm@ftc.gov) 


Joshua Goodman Ggoodman@ftc.gov) 


Sebastian Lorigo (slorigo@ftc.gov) 


Brendan J. McNamara (bmcnamara@ftc.gov) 


Angelike Mina (amina@ftc.gov) 


Catharine M. Moscatelli (cmoscatelli@ftc.gov) 


Angel Prado (aprado@ftc.gov) 


Kristian Rogers (krogers@ftc.gov) 


Danielle Sims (dsimsl@ftc.gov) 


Eric M. Sprague (esprague@ftc.gov) 


Steven L. Wilensky (swilensky@ftc.gov) 


Thomas H. Brock (tbrock@ftc.gov) 


Michael B. Kades (mkades@ftc.gov) 


Michael A. Franchak (mfranchak@ftc.gov) 


Amanda Hamilton (ahamiltonl@ftc.gov) 


Sean D. Hughto (shughto@ftc.gov) 


Victoria Lippincott (vlippincott@ftc.gov) 


Meredith Robinson (mrobinson@ftc.gov) 

PUBLIC 


U.S. Federal Trade Commission 


600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW 


Washington, DC 20580 


Counsel Supporting the Complaint 

Alan Goudiss (agoudiss@shearman.com) 


Dale Collins (wcollins@shearman.com) 


Richard Schwed (rschwed@shearman.com) 


Lisl Dunlop (ldunlop@shearman.com) 


Heather Kafele (hkafele@shearman.com) 


Shearman & Sterling LLP 


599 Lexington A venue 


New York, NY 10022 


Counselfor Respondent Ardagh Group S.A. 

CERTIFICATE OF ELECTRONIC FILING 

I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary ofthe Commission is a true 

and correct copy ofthe paper original and that I possess a paper original ofthe signed document 

that is available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

July 24, 2013 

sf Rory A. Leraris 

Rory A. Leraris 
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 


BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 


OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES 


) 

In the Matter of ) 

) 

Ardagh Group S.A., ) 

a public limited liability company, and ) PUBLIC 

) 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., ) Docket No. 9356 

a corporation, and ) 

) 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, a corporation. ) 

) 

------------------------------~) 

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that I, Athena N. Cheng, am an associate ofthe law 

firm ofCravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, and hereby enters an appearance as counsel for SaintGobain Containers, Inc. and Compagnie de Saint-Gobain in the above-captioned action. In 

accordance with Rule 4.l(d) ofthe Federal Trade Commission's Rules ofPractice, I certify that I 

am a member ofthe bar ofthe State ofNew York (Attorney Registration No. 4906244) and am 

in good standing within the legal profession. 

Executed on July 24, 2013. 

s/ Athena N. Cheng 

Athena N. Cheng 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

Worldwide Plaza 

825 Eighth A venue 

New York, NY 10019-7275 

(212) 474-1000 

acheng@cravath.com 
PUBLIC 


CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that on July 24, 2013, I filed the foregoing document 

electronically using the FTC's E-filing System, which will send notification ofsuch filing to: 

Donald S. Clark 


Secretary 


Federal Trade Commission 


600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Room H-113 


Washington, DC 20580 


I also certify that a copy ofthe foregoing document has been delivered via 

electronic mail, and by overnight courier (Federal Express) for delivery on Thursday, July 25, 

2013 to: 

The Honorable D. Michael Chappell (oalj@ftc.gov) 

Administrative Law Judge 

Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Room H-110 

Washington, DC 20580 

I further certify that a copy ofthe foregoing document has been delivered via 

electronic mail to: 

Edward D. Hassi (ehassi@ftc.gov) 


James E. Abell (jabell@ftc.gov) 


Monica Castillo (mcastillo@ftc.gov) 


Steven A. Dahm (sdahm@ftc.gov) 


Joshua Goodman (jgoodman@ftc.gov) 


Sebastian Lorigo (slorigo@ftc.gov) 


Brendan J. McNamara (bmcnamara@ftc.gov) 


Angelike Mina (amina@ftc.gov) 


Catharine M. Moscatelli (cmoscatelli@ftc.gov) 


Angel Prado (aprado@ftc.gov) 


Kristian Rogers (krogers@ftc.gov) 


Danielle Sims (dsims1@ftc.gov) 


Eric M. Sprague (esprague@ftc.gov) 


Steven L. Wilensky (swilensky@ftc.gov) 


Thomas H. Brock (tbrock@ftc.gov) 


Michael B. Kades (mkades@ftc.gov) 


Michael A. Franchak (mfranchak@ftc.gov) 


Amanda Hamilton (ahamilton1@ftc.gov) 


Sean D. Hughto (shughto@ftc.gov) 


Victoria Lippincott (vlippincott@ftc.gov) 


Meredith Robinson (mrobinson@ftc.gov) 

PUBLIC 


U.S. Federal Trade Commission 


600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW 


Washington, DC 20580 


Counsel Supporting the Complaint 

Alan Goudiss (agoudiss@shearman.com) 


Dale Collins (wcollins@shearman.com) 


Richard Schwed (rschwed@shearman.com) 


Lisl Dunlop (ldunlop@shearman.com) 


Heather Kafele (hkafele@shearman.com) 


Shearman & Sterling LLP 


599 Lexington A venue 


New York, NY 10022 


Counselfor Respondent Ardagh Group S.A. 

CERTIFICATE OF ELECTRONIC FILING 

I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary ofthe Commission is a true 

and correct copy ofthe paper original and that I possess a paper original ofthe signed document 

that is available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

July 24, 2013 

s/ Athena N. Cheng 

Athena N. Cheng 
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 


BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 


OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES 


) 

In the Matter of ) 

) 

Ardagh Group S.A., ) 

a public limited liability company, and ) PUBLIC 

) 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., ) Docket No. 9356 

a corporation, and ) 

) 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, a corporation. ) 

) _____________________________) 

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that I, Pierre N. Gemson, am an associate of the law 

firm ofCravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, and hereby enters an appearance as counsel for SaintGobain Containers, Inc. and Compagnie de Saint-Gobain in the above-captioned action. In 

accordance with Rule 4.l(d) ofthe Federal Trade Commission's Rules ofPractice, I certify that I 

am a member of the bar of the State ofNew York (Attorney Registration No. 4926325) and am 

in good standing within the legal profession. 

Executed on July 24,2013. 

sf Pierre N. Gemson 

Pierre N. Gemson 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

Worldwide Plaza 

825 Eighth A venue 

New York, NY 10019-7275 

(212) 474-1000 

pgemson@cravath.com 
• 

PUBLIC 


• I 

i 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that on July 24, 2013, I filed the foregoing document 

electronically using the FTC's E-filing System, which will send notification of such filing to: 

Donald S. Clark 


Secretary 


Federal Trade Commission 


600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Room H-113 


Washington, DC 20580 


I also certify that a copy ofthe foregoing document has been delivered via 

electronic mail, and by overnight courier (Federal Express) for delivery on Thursday, July 25, 

2013 to: 

The Honorable D. Michael Chappell (oalj@ftc.gov) 

Administrative Law Judge 

Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania A venue, NW, Room H-11 0 

Washington, DC 20580 

I further certify that a copy ofthe foregoing document has been delivered via 

electronic mail to: 

Edward D. Hassi (ehassi@ftc.gov) 


James E. Abell Gabell@ftc.gov) 


Monica Castillo (mcastillo@ftc.gov) 


Steven A. Dahm (sdahm@ftc.gov) 


Joshua Goodman Ggoodman@ftc.gov) 


Sebastian Lorigo (slorigo@ftc.gov) 


Brendan J. McNamara (bmcnamara@ftc.gov) 


Angelike Mina (amina@ftc.gov) 


Catharine M. Moscatelli (cmoscatelli@ftc.gov) 


Angel Prado (aprado@ftc.gov) 


Kristian Rogers (krogers@ftc.gov) 


Danielle Sims (dsims1@ftc.gov) 


Eric M. Sprague (esprague@ftc.gov) 


Steven L. Wilensky (swilensky@ftc.gov) 


Thomas H. Brock (tbrock@ftc.gov) 


Michael B. Kades (mkades@ftc.gov) 


Michael A. Franchak (mfranchak@ftc.gov) 


Amanda Hamilton ( ahamilton 1 @ftc.gov) 


Sean D. Hughto (shughto@ftc.gov) 


Victoria Lippincott (vlippincott@ftc.gov) 


Meredith Robinson (mrobinson@ftc.gov) 

PUBLIC 


U.S. Federal Trade Commission 


600 Pennsylvania A venue, NW 


Washington, DC 20580 


Counsel Supporting the Complaint 

Alan Goudiss (agoudiss@shearman.com) 


Dale Collins (wcollins@shearman.com) 


Richard Schwed (rschwed@shearman.com) 


Lisl Dunlop (ldunlop@shearman.com) 


Heather Kafele (hkafele@shearman.com) 


Shearman & Sterling LLP 


599 Lexington A venue 


New York, NY 10022 


Counselfor Respondent Ardagh Group S.A. 

CERTIFICATE OF ELECTRONIC FILING 

I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary ofthe Commission is a true 

and correct copy ofthe paper original and that I possess a paper original ofthe signed document 

that is available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

July 24, 2013 

sf Pierre N. Gemson 

Pierre N. Gemson 
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 


BEFORE THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 


OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES 


) 

In the Matter of ) 

) 

Ardagh Group S.A., ) 

a public limited liability company, and ) PUBLIC 

) 

Saint-Gobain Containers, Inc., ) Docket No. 9356 

a corporation, and ) 

) 

Compagnie de Saint-Gobain, a corporation. ) 

) _____________________________) 

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that I, Sarah M. Colombo, am an associate of the law 

firm ofCravath, Swaine & Moore LLP, and hereby enters an appearance as c<;mnsel for SaintGobain Containers, Inc. and Compagnie de Saint-Gobain in the above-captioned action. In 

accordance with Rule 4.l(d) ofthe Federal Trade Commission's Rules ofPractice, I certify that I 

am a member ofthe bar ofthe State ofNew York (Attorney Registration No. 5110408) and am 

in good standing within the legal profession. 

Executed on July 24,2013. 

sf Sarah M. Colombo 

Sarah M. Colombo 

Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP 

Worldwide Plaza 

825 Eighth A venue 

New York, NY 10019-7275 

(212) 474-1000 

scolombo@cravath.com 
PUBLIC 


CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 

I hereby certify that on July 24, 2013, I filed the foregoing document 

electronically using the FTC's E-filing System, which will send notification of such filing to: 

Donald S. Clark 


Secretary 


Federal Trade Commission 


600 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Room H-113 


Washington, DC 20580 


I also certify that a copy ofthe foregoing document has been delivered via 

electronic mail, and by overnight courier (Federal Express) for delivery on Thursday, July 25, 

2013 to: 

The Honorable D. Michael Chappell (oalj@ftc.gov) 

Administrative Law Judge 

Federal Trade Commission 

600 Pennsylvania A venue, NW, Room H -110 

Washington, DC 20580 

I further certify that a copy ofthe foregoing document has been delivered via 

electronic mail to: 

Edward D. Hassi (ehassi@ftc.gov) 


James E. Abell (jabell@ftc.gov) 


Monica Castillo (mcastillo@ftc.gov) 


Steven A. Dahm (sdahm@ftc.gov) 


Joshua Goodman (jgoodman@ftc.gov) 


Sebastian Lorigo (slorigo@ftc.gov) 


Brendan J. McNamara (bmcnamara@ftc.gov) 


Angelike Mina (amina@ftc.gov) 


Catharine M. Moscatelli (cmoscatelli@ftc.gov) 


Angel Prado (aprado@ftc.gov) 


Kristian Rogers (krogers@ftc.gov) 


Danielle Sims (dsims1@ftc.gov) 


Eric M. Sprague (esprague@ftc.gov) 


Steven L. Wilensky (swilensky@ftc.gov) 


Thomas H. Brock (tbrock@ftc.gov) 


Michael B. Kades (mkades@ftc.gov) 


Michael A. Franchak (mfranchak@ftc.gov) 


Amanda Hamilton ( ahamilton 1 @ftc.gov) 


Sean D. Hughto (shughto@ftc.gov) 


Victoria Lippincott (vlippincott@ftc.gov) 


Meredith Robinson (mrobinson@ftc.gov) 

PUBLIC 


U.S. Federal Trade Commission 


600 Pennsylvania A venue, NW 


Washington; DC 20580 


Counsel Supporting the Complaint 

Alan Goudiss (agoudiss@shearman.com) 


Dale Collins (wcollins@shearman.com) 


Richard Schwed (rschwed@shearman.com) 


Lisl Dunlop (ldunlop@shearman.com) 


Heather Kafele (hkafele@shearman.com) 


Shearman & Sterling LLP 


599 Lexington A venue 


New York, NY 10022 


Counselfor Respondent Ardagh Group S.A. 

CERTIFICATE OF ELECTRONIC FILING 

I certify that the electronic copy sent to the Secretary ofthe Commission is a true 

and correct copy ofthe paper original and that I possess a paper original of the signed document 

that is available for review by the parties and the adjudicator. 

July 24,2013 

sf Sarah M. Colombo 

Sarah M. Colombo