UNITED STATES OF AlRICA 

FEDERAL TRADE COMMSSION
 

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUGES
 

) 

In the Matter of ) 

) Docket No. 9327 

POLYPORE INERNATIONAL, INC., ) 

Respondent. ) 

) 

ORDER ON NON-PARTIES' MOTIONS FOR IN CAMERA TREATMENT 

Several non-paries filed motions for in camera treatment. By Orders dated May 6,2009, 

May 13, 2009, May 15, 2009, May 18,2009, June 4,2009 and June 23, 2009, each of the 

motions for in camera treatment submitted by non-paries were ruled upon. The May 6, 2009 

Order and an Order on Respondent's Second Motion for in Camera Treatment, entered on May 

13,2009, set fort the standards used to evaluate and the rationale for ruling on the motions. 

The Orders on non-paries' motions directed the paries to provide a list that identifies by 

exhibit number, the non-paries' documents that have been offered into evidence and were 

granted in camera treatment, and the expiration date of such in camera treatment. On July 10, 

2009, Complaint Counsel provided the required list, which is appended to this Order as 

Attachment A. 

In camera treatment is hereby GRANTED to the documents listed on Attachment A for 

the period of time listed therein. 

ORDERED: :DfM ~
 

D. Michael Chappell 

Chief Administrative Law Judge 

Date: July 10, 2009 
ATTACHMENT A
 

Polypore International, Docket 9327 

List of Non-Parties In Camera 

Documents Admitted in Evidence 

EXHIBIT PARTY TIME PERIOD EXPIRATION 

PX0011/RX00382* H&V 5 years June 1,2014 

PX0014/RX00381* H&V 5 years June 1, 2014 

PX0672 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014 

PX0738 Warburg 3 years June 1,2012 

PX0745 Warburg 3 years June 1,2012 

PX0746 Warburg 3 years June 1,2012 , PX0751 Warburg 3 years June 1,2012 

PX0916 Amer-Sil/Moore 5 years June 1, 2014 

PX0917 H&V 5 years June 1,2014 

PX0925 H&V 5 years June 1,2014 

PX0980 Warburg 3 years June 1, 2012 

PX0984 Warburg 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1007 Exide 1 year June 1,2010 

PX1026 Exide 1 year June 1,2010 

PX 1027 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1028 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1029 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1030 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX 1033 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1034 Exide 3 years June 1, 2012 

PX1035 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1036 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1037 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1040 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1046 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1049 Exide 1 year June 1,2010 

PX 1050 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1053 Exide 1 year June 1,2010 

PX 1054 Exide 1 year June 1,2010 

PX1063 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX1076 Exide 1 year June 1, 2010 

PX 1097 Exide 1 year June 1,2010 

PX1200 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1201 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1203 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

PX 1204 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1211 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX 1224 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

PX 1225 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

PX1234 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

PX 1248/RX00222* EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX 1256/RX00199* EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

PX1259 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1261 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1263 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1264 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1265 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

PX1268 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1270 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

PX1276 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1279 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1289 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1501 JCI 5 years June 1,2014 

* Exhibit numbers of duplicate documents are paired together. - 1 ­
Polypore International, Docket 9327 

List of Non-Parties In Camera 

Documents Admitted in Evidence 

EXHIBIT PARTY TIME PERIOD EXPIRATION 

PX1502 JCI 5 years June 1,2014 

PX1503 JCI 5 years June 1,2014 

PX 1505/RXOO045* JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX 1506/RXOO075* JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX1507 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX 1509/RXOO043* JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX1510/RXOO037* JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX1514 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX1515 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX1516 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX 1521 /RXOO059* JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX 1522/RXOO065* JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX1654 Trojan 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX1668 Trojan 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX1672 Trojan 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX1715 WarburQ 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX 1726 WarburQ 3 years June 1, 2012
 

PX1800 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

PX1801 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX 1802 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

PX 1809 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX1811/RX00134* ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX1815 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX 1817 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX1818 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX 1820 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX1821 ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

PX1823 ENTEK 1 year June 1, 2010
 

PX 1830 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX1831 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX 1832/RX00259* ENTEK 1 year June 1, 2010
 

PX1833/RX00114* ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

PX1900 Exide 1 year June 1,2010
 

PX 1902/RXOOO02* Exide 3 years June 1,2012
 

PX21 09 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

PX2111 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX2112 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX2113/RX00044 * JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX2115 Trojan 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX2117 Trojan 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX2118 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX2135 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX2252/RX00133* JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX2259 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX2260 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX2261 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX2262 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX2263 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX2264 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX2267 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1,2014
 

PX2268 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX2269 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1, 2014
 

PX2273 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1, 2014
 

* Exhibit numbers of duplicate documents are paired together. - 2­
Polypore International, Docket 9327 

List of Non-Parties In Camera 

Documents Admitted in Evidence 

EXHIBIT PARTY TIME PERIOD EXPIRATION 

PX2295 Exide 3 years June 1,2012 

PX2296 Exide 3 years June 1,2012
 

RXOOO02/PX1902* Exide 3 years June 1,2012
 

RXOO012 Exide 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RXOO023 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO024 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO025 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX00026/RX00061 * JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX00027/RX00061 * JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO028 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO029 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO030 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO032 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO035 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO036 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX00037/PX1510* JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO038 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO039 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO040 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO041 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO042 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO043/PX1509* JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO044/PX2113* JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO045/PX1505* JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO046 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO048 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO050 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO052 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO053 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO054 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO057 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO058 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX00059/PX1521 * JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO060 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO061 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO062 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO063 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO064 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX00065/PX 1522* JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO066 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO067 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO069 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO070 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOOO72 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO073 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO074 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO075/PX1506* JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO076 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO093 H&V 5 years June 1,2014
 

RXOO094 H&V 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO095 H&V 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO096 H&V 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RXOO097 H&V 5 years June 1, 2014
 

* Exhibit numbers of duplicate documents are paired together. - 3­
Polypore International, Docket 9327 

List of Non-Parties In Camera 

Documents Admitted in Evidence 

EXHIBIT PARTY TIME PERIOD EXPIRATION 

RXOO098 H&V 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00102 H&V 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00103 H&V 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00104 H&V 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00105 H&V 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00106 H&V 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00107 H&V 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00114/PX1833* ENTEK 

(RX001141 ENTEK 000197-ENTEK 000208 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012 

RX00114 ENTEK 000218-ENTEK 000271 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012 

RX00114 ENTEK 000272-ENTEK 000277 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010 

RX00114 ENTEK 000278 ENTEK 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00114 ENTEK 000597 -ENTEK 000598 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012 

rRX00114 ENTEK 000901-ENTEK 000903 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012 

rRX00114 ENTEK 000924-ENTEK 000925 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012 

RX00115 ENTEK 1 year June 1, 2010
 

RX00116 ENTEK 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX00117 ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RX00118 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00119 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00120 ENTEK 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX00121 ENTEK 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX00122 ENTEK 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX00123 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00124 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

RX00125 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

RX00126 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00127 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

RX00128 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00129 ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RX00130 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00131 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RXOO 132 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00133/PX2252* JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX00134/PX1811* ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00135 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

RX00136 ENTEK 1 year June 1, 2010
 

RX00138 ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RX00139 ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RX00140 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

RX00141 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

RX00142 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RXOO 143 ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RX00144 Exide 1 year June 1, 2010
 

RX00145 Exide 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RX00146 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00147 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00148 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

RX00150 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00152 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00157 Trojan 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX00158 Trojan 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX00159 Trojan 5 years June 1,2014
 

* Exhibit numbers of duplicate documents are paired together. - 4­
Polypore International, Docket 9327
 

List of Non-Parties In Camera
 

Documents Admitted in Evidence
 

EXHIBIT PARTY TIME PERIOD EXPIRATION 

RX00161 Trojan 5 years June'1,2014 

RXOO 162 Trojan 5 years June 1, 2014 

RXOO 163 Trojan '5 years June 1,2014 

RX00167 Trojan 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00170 Trojan 5 years June 1,2014 

RXOO171 Trojan 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00172 Trojan 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00174 Trojan 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00175 Trojan 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00176 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00177 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00178 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00179 JCI 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00180 JCI 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00183 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00185 JCI 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00197 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00199/PX1256* EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00200 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00202 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00203 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00205 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00206 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00212 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00214 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00215 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00216 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00220 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00221 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00222/PX 1248* EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00223 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00228 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00233 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00235 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00239 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00252 JCI 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00253 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00254 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00255 JCI 5 years June 1,2014 

RX00257 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX00259/PX 1832* ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010 

RX00260 ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012 

RX00261 ENTEK 1 year June 1, 2010 

RX00264 Exide 1 year June 1, 2010 

RX00265 Exide 1 year June 1, 2010 

RX00269 Exide 3 years June 1, 2012 

RX00301 Exide 2 years June 1,2011 

RX00303 Exide 2 years June 1, 2011 

RX00309 Exide 1 year June 1,2010 

RX00313 Exide 2 years June 1,2011 

RX00317 Exide 3 years June 1, 2012 

RX00334 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012 

RX00335 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010 

* Exhibit numbers of duplicate documents are paired together. - 5­
Polypore International, Docket 9327
 

List of Non-Parties In Camera
 

Documents Admitted in Evidence
 

EXHIBIT PARTY TIME PERIOD EXPIRATION
 

RX00337 ENTEK 1 year June 1,2010
 

RX00339 ENTEK 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX00340 ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RX00341 ENTEK 1 year June 1, 2010
 

RX00342/PX00819* ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RX00351 ENTEK 1 year June 1, 2010
 

RX00353 ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RX00355 ENTEK 1 year June 1, 2010
 

RX00356 ENTEK 1 year June 1, 2010
 

RX00363 H&V 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX00364 H&V 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX00365 H&V 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX00381 H&V 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX00382 H&V 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01012 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01017 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX01020 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01203 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX01206 EnerSys 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX01208 EnerSys 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01506 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01507 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01508 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01509 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01514 ENTEK 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01522 ENTEK 1 year June 1, 2010
 

RX01523 ENTEK 3 years June 1, 2012
 

RX01528 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01529 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX01530 JCI 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX01531 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01532 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01533 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01534 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01535 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01536 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01540 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01542 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01543 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01544 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01545 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01554 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01556 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01602 JCI 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01606 Amer-Sil 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX01607 Amer-Sil 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX01608 Amer-Sil 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX01609 Amer-Sil 3 years June 1,2012
 

RX01612 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX01613 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1,2014
 

RX01614 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01615 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1, 2014
 

RX01619 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1, 2014
 

* Exhibit numbers of duplicate documents are paired together. - 6­
Polypore International, Docket 9327 

List of Non-Parties In Camera 

Documents Admitted in Evidence 

EXHIBIT PARTY TIME PERIOD EXPIRATION 

RX01620 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1,2014 

RX01621 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1,2014 

RX01622 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1,2014 

RX01623 Amer-Sil 3 years June 1,2012 

RX01624 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX01625 Amer-Sil 3 years June 1,2012 

RX01628 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1, 2014 

RX01629 Amer-Sil 5 years June 1,2014 

* Exhibit numbers of duplicate documents are paired together. - 7­