07/28/201 0 15;5 8 FA X 202493514 2 FAA * DMS lglOOI/00 8



## ':, :, . '.,.. , -^^ J ;L-

_I V L Scor r R.MORRI S 

## FAAOi'MCM'Oi-REGIONA

LcoiJNsr.LJ'J l 2 7 2010
•JT.I.FPHONH : 425.227.141 7 FACSIMILI.- : ^125.227.100 7 

## UNITE D STATE S O FAMERIC A

DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N

OFFIC EO FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C
.
I n ih e Maile r

of: Sceni c Aviaiion , Inc
. F A A DOCKF T C F(.)9NM00 1 1 

### 1"A A Cas e Nfo
. 2009NM07006 6 ^

- -'- i DM S No
. FAA-2()()y.097 4 , 3 

### Judg e Goodwi n C D



### COMPLAINANT' S T ' SUI^PI.KMENTA L

### RESPONS ET O RKSPONDENT' S INHIA L 

### DISCOVER Y REQIJE S J Give n tii c conlinuanc c griinte din thi s case , an dpursuan t l o Rul e 13.22 0 an dcon.sislen l with I'.K. C ?
. 26 , th e Complainan t hereb y supplcmcni s it s res>pon.se t o Rcspondenl".' ? initia l discover y requcsi s a s follows : Interrogator y No.l : Idcnlify , b y providin g th e name , occupation , an dbu.siines. s address , o f eac h perso n ih e Complainan t intcnd. s l o cal l a s awitneii i i n thi s proceeding
. Answer : AS l Mik e Crunirinc , Denve r FSDO
. 2680 5 E
. 68" ' Ave , Suii e 200 , Denver
. C O 8024 9 Regiona l Spcciali.s l Chuci c Cox

- ANM-230 , 160 1 Lin dAve
. SW , Rcnion , W A ^JX05' 7 

### Regiona l Specialis t

Bria n Schoolcy , ANM-240 , 160 1 Lin dAve
. SW , Reiilun , W A 9805 7 Interrogatoi- y No.2 : Provid e th e substanc e o f th e testimon y t o b e olTcre db y eac ho f th e witnesse s ideniifie di n Intcrrogaior y No.l
. Answer : 

### A S ICrumrin c i s a n avionic s inspector
. H e wil l testif y a s an exper t

witnes s concernin g th e maintenanc e o f

airborn e electroni c equipmen t system s an dinstnjmcnis
. H e wil l icstif y t o th e regulator y requirement s regardin g th e Tes t an dCerlillcalio n o f

Altimcier.s/Hncndei. s an d Iran.sponders
. Ihes e area s ar e discusse di n InteiTOgatoi y Nos , 3 , 5 , 6 , an d7
. i l e wil l icsiil y concemin g ih e I'AA' s polic y o n ho w t o compl y wit h^9\ A 1 1 &
. §91,413
. Regiona l Specialis I Chuc k Co x wil l le.stil y a s an expor t witnes. s concernin g th e us e o f th e transponde r

in operation s an dth e impac t o f an unreliabl e transponde r ca n hav e i n AT C operation.?, I l e wil l als o testif y concernin g applicatio n o f I- A A Orde r

2150.3B
.07/28/201 0 15:5 8 FA X 202493514 2 FA A • > DMS 12002/00 8

1 2 3 4 5 c 7 a 3 1 0 :. i 1 2 1 3 14 1 5 I S 1 7 1 0 1 9 2 0 2 \ 2 2 2 3

.•>- l 2 6 2 7 2 9 2 9 3 0 3 1 3 2 3 3 3 4 3 b 3 5 3 7 3 S 3 9 4 0 1 1 4 2 4 3 -1- 1 4 i 4 6 -17 4 8 4 9 .= 5 0 S I 5 2 .S 3 

### Regional Specialis t

Bria nSchoole y wil l testif

y a s a nexpe nwitnes s concernin g FA A Order 2]50.3U> i

nparticula

r the determinatio no f

sanctio ni

nthi s case . interrogator y No.3 : Wit hrespec t t o eachexper

t tha t th e Complainan t

inlend. s to call a s a witne.'i s i nthi s proceeding , se

t Ibrlhth e subjec t

matter uponwhic heachexper t wilnes. s i s expecte dt o testify , the fact s andopinion s composin g th e testimony o f eachexper

t witness , anda summar y o f th e ground s for

eac hopinion
. Answer : Sec Complainaiit' s original answer andit s Respons e l o Interrogatoi y No
. 2 above
. interrogator y No.4 : Identif y an y andal l document s an

dother material s i

nth e possessio nof

th e Complainan t

tha t concern , refer

to , o r involv e th e circumstance s scl fort hi nthe Compiaii u tile d i nthi s maiter
. Answer : 1
. Copy o f

aCD sent

federa l expres. s t o Respondent' s counse l o nJun e 30 , 2010
. 2
. Extrac t

o f FA A Order 2150.3B , specificall y Chapter 7 an dAppendi x B
. REQUES T FO RPRODUC I IO N I^equcs t fo r Productio nof

Document s No.l : Produc e copie s o f all
. document s andother material s tha

t ih e Complainant

intend s t o introduc e into evidence
. Answer : Se c C D provide donJun e 30 , 201 0 a.s well a s I'A A Orde r 2150.3H
. i

nparticula

r Chapter 7 an dAppendi x B
. Reques t fo r Productio nof

Document s !So.4 : Produc e copie s o f current curricul avitae fo

r each expor t witnes s ihc Complainan t identifie dinInterrogator

y No.l , Answer : See belo w andattache dresume s o f Inspecio r

Cmmrin e an

dRegional Specialis t Scliooicy
. Concernin g Regional Specialis t Chuc k Co.\ : Regional Technical Specialis t 200 1 t o Present , 9 years . Revie w o f F.nforceincn

t cases , includin g recommendatio no f Sanctio n Revie w o f

tccluiical issue s inenforcement cases , andassistin g fieldinspector s wit hresolvin g technical qiieslion.s
. Safet y inspecto r

199 0 l o present , 2 0 years . Investigate accidents , incident s an dcomplaints
. Writ e enforcement

reports . Giv e Exper

t testimony i

nenforcement

cases , Conduc t Pilo t certificatio nandoversight of Designate dPilo t

Fxaminers , Regulatio no f

Ai r Caniers
. ConiplaiiiaiU' s 1' ' SuppIonmnUl RL-s^ponsL-l o Rciporidcni'. s Iniiial Disccwcr y Rc;i|ucsi Sceni c Avi^ilion , Inc
. - Ct'OWMOO ) 1 I'ip. c 2 o f 4 SroT T R
. Moi<Kis
. FA A AirORNL

Y TEL : 425.227.HIT : I'AX
. 42.'!.227
. 1(K) 707/28/201 0 15:5 8 FA X 202483514 2 

### FA A * DM S 0)003/00 8

1 2 3

- 1
6 7 S y 1 0 1 1 i:? . 1 1 1- 1 1 •- , •/« ) 1 7 1 9 1 $ 2 0 2 1 7 2 2 3 2 4 2 5

:>• / 2 8 J . 3 3 0 3 1 3 2 3 3 3 4 3." ; 3 K i 7 3 9 4 0 4 1 A 2 1 1 4 4 4 5 I S
^ 7 'I H 4 3 5 0 S I b 2 5 3 

### Ai r

Traffi c Controlle r

198 0 -199 0 1 0 year s I'A A Ai r Traffi c Controller , Anchorag e Ai r Rout e Iraffi c Contro l Center , Portlan dAi r Traffi c Contro l Towe r

an dapproac hcontrol , Troutdal e Ai r Traffi c Contro l 'I'owec
. Militar y Ai r

IVaffi c Controlle r

1980-198 2 Fligh t instructo r

19S 0 t o picscn t

3 0 year s Aiqilan e Single , Mult i engin e land , Instrumen t Airjilan e Pilo t 197 4 t o presen t

3 6 years , i n exces s o f

500 0 lligh t

hours
. Airlin e Transpor t

Pilo t Ratin g Multi-engin e lan d Commercia l Pilo t

Singl e lingin c Lan d Typ e raie di n HMI.M20
. an dDHC- 8 Reques t fo r Productio n o f

Document s No.6 : Provid e acop y o f al l handbooks , manuals , maintenanc e records , schematics , and/o r othe r source s tha t

th e Complainan t

ma y us e o r introduc e int o evidenc e at

th e hearin g o r

otherwi.s e rel y upo n t o determin e tha t th e altimctcr(s)/encoder(s ) reference di n th e Complain t ha dexperience ddat acorrespondenc e en'or(s)
. Answer : Se e fligh t

log s previousl y produce do r document s attache dt o thi s Respon.se
. Complainan t

ha s no i mad e adecisio n concernin g whethe r i t ma y us e an y suc hothe r documents , bu t i f i t opt s t o us e suc hthe y wil l b e provided
. Signe dihi s 2 1 s i da y o f

Jul y 201 0 '
Morri s FA A Attorne y

f,'onipl;iin:inl \l " .Supplementa l f^eipoii.si ; li
. Rcspondcni' s Inili'Li

l Discowtr

y Roquos i Sceni c Avmiion , Inc
. CPO'JNMOO I 1 I'ag c i o f 4 SCOl' T R
. MORHIS , I'A A ATIORNI'. Y TKL : 42,5.227.Ml7 ; I'.AX - •'1?.5.:'.37.100 707/28/201 0 15:5 8 FA X 202493514 2 FA A • ^ DM S 0004/00 8

1 2 3 4 b 6 7 ( J 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 ^ I S 1 5 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2

•:'.^ 2 b 2 7 3 8 2 9 3 0 3 1 3 2 i 4 3 5 3 S 3 7 3 9 4 0 1 1 -IV . 4 3 4 4 4 5 4 6 .17 4 U 4 9 2 0 5 1 5 2 S 3 

## CERTIFICATEO FSERVIC E 1 hereb y certif

y tha t the foregoin g Complainant' s T ' Supplemental Re.spons e t o Respondent' s Initia l Discover

y Reques t ha s beenserve dvi afacsimil e andcertifie dmail - Retur nReceipt Requeste dthi s date , to th e following :

Th e Honorabl e Richar

dC
. Goodwi n Offic e of hearings , M-2 0 1200 New Jersey Avenue , S.K
. Fas t Buildin g Groun dFloor , R mi ; 12-32 0 Washingion , D.C , 2059 0 TliL : 202.366.213 9 FAX ; 202.366-753 6 Federal Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenu e SW Washington , D.C
. 2059 1 Attn : Hearin g Docket

Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wrigh t Buildin g - Suite 2W10()() FAX ; 202.493.514 2 Gregor y S
. Winto n Aviatio nLa

w Experts , LL

C 33 0 Aviatio nWa

y Frederick , M

D 2170 1 TKL : 301,294.855 0 FAX : 301.294.252 5

Daie dthi s 2 1 s i da

y o l July , 2010
.
MOIFAIRCHI N Offic e of Regiona l Counse l (ANM-7 ) Federal Aviatio nAdministratio n 160 1 LindAve
. SW Renton , W A9805 7 425.227.216 0

Coiiiplaiiiiiiii ^ 1^

' Supplementa l Rcsixdis e uRusponik-nr s Iniiia

j Oistcovery Reques t .Sciiriic ; AvijKJon
. Inc
. CJ'()9NM00I I I*HJ; C 'I o f

' 1 SiL'OT T R
. MORRIS
. I'A A A rT<mNr; Y l £ l 425.227.1417 ; |-.A X •ir'.'5 ,''2 7 H>0

707/28/201 0 15:5 8 FAX 202483514 2 FA A* DM S 21005/00 8



## Bria n W
. Schoole y 160 1 Lin d Ave
. ioul h West Rcnion , W A97057 , 4?5-?27-2i69 , Brian.W..^c|-iooley&'kja.gov Experienc e Aviatio n Safet yInspecto r 200 4 throug h present , Federa l Aviatio n Administration , Fligh t Standard s Division , Rento n W A
• Progra m managemen t
' Enforcemen t review • Technica l suppor

t
Aviatio n Safet yInspecto r 200 0 throug h 2003 , Federa l Aviatio n Administration , Seattl e Fligh t Standard s District Offic e Renton , W A
• Oversigh t 1 4 CF R par t 12 1 ai rcarrier

s • Oversigh t 1 4 CF R par t 145 repai rstation s
Aviatio n Safet yInspector , 199 6 throug h 2000 , Federa l Aviatio n Administration , Va n Nuy s Fligh t Standard s Disirict Office , Va n Nuys , CA
" Oversigh t Emer

yWorldv^id e Airline s a 1 4 CF R par t 12 1 ai rearne r • Oversigh t Ai rWisconsi n a 1 4 CF R par t 12 1 ai rcarrie r
Aircraf t Maintenanc e Manage r 1992 throug h 1996 , 146' " Airlif t Wing , Ai rForce (Ai rTechnician) , Poin t Mugu , CA , • Responsibl e fo ral l maintenanc e performe d o n a squadro n of Lockhee d C-13 0 aircraft
" Responsibl e fo r14

0 aircraf t maintenance personne l Aerospac e System s Superviso r 198 9 throug h 1992 , 146" ' Airlif t Wing , Ai rForc e (Ai rTechnician) , Va n Nuys , CA , • Provide d superi'isor

yoversigh t o t th e hydraulic , electrical , ai rconditionin g an d repai ran d reclamatio n shop s • Responsibl e fo r3 0 subordinat e aircraf t maintenanc e personne l
Inspectio n Superviso r 198 5 throug h 1989 , 146"

^ Airlift Wing , Ai rForc e (Ai rTechnician) , Va n Nuys , CA
. • Responsibl e fo rheav ymaintenanc e inspectio n an d structura l repai rof Lockhee d C-13 0 Aircraf

t Responsibl e fo r2 0 subordinat e aircraf t maintenanc e personne l07/28/201 0 15:5 8 FA X 202483514 2 FA A+ DM S glOOG/OO B

Qualit yContro l Inspecto r 198 1 throug h 1986 , 146' " Airlif t Wing , Ai rForc e (Ai rTechnician) , Va n Nuys , C A
• Responsibl e fo rsecondar yinspectio n o f aircraf t maintenanc e actio n performe d b yother s • Performe d facilitie s inspection s
• Performe d OSH Acomplianc e inspection s Aircraf t Mechani c 197 1 throug h 1981 , 146' " Airlif t Wing , Ai rForc e (Ai rTechnician) , Va n Nuys , C A
• Aircraf t mechanic , inspectio n sectio n • Perfom n maintenanc e o n Boein g C-9 7 an d Lockhee d C-13 D aircraf t Aircraf t Mechani c(Airfram e an d Powcrplant ) 196 9 throug h 197 1 Unite d Ai rLines , Lo s Angele s C A

- Perfor m lin e maintenanc e o n Boein g 7;^7 , 737 , 747 , Dougla s DC- 8 serie s aircraf t

You rMam e Address , r^hone , lox , emol i07/28/201 0 15:5 8 FAX 202433514 2 FA A4 DM S gjOOT/OO S


# Michae l C
. Crumrine , Aviatio n Safet yInspecto r I edora l Aviaiio n Administration , Denve rcO/30 3 34 2 1192/mike,orumrlne@tacj.go v

Professiona l Accomplishment s Achievement s • Designed , developed , an d manage d a successfu l avionics/aircraf t electrica l system s departmen t fo ra 1 4 CF R 12 1 Ai rCarrie roperatin g a flee t o f (17 ) U 1900 D aircraft ; Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n (FAA ) Repairma n Certifical e hel d
• Manage d th e avionic s portio n o f a 1 4 CF R 14 5 Repai rStatio n (Airfram e Clas s 1 & 3 , Radi o Clas s 1 , 2 , 3) ; FA ARepairma n Certificat e hel d
• Manage d th e avionic s departmen t fo ra 1 4 CF R 121/13 5 Ai rCan-ie roperatin g a mixe d fleet o f ove r5 0 turbo-pro p aircraft ; FA ARepairma n Certificat e hel d
• Develope d an d provide d avionic s trainin g session s t o compan ymaintenanc e personne l wit h emphasi s o n aircraf t altimeter , pitot/stati can d ai rtraffi ccontro l transponde rsyste m certificatio n requirement s (1 4 CF R 91.411/91,413 , 1 4 CF R 43 , /Appendi xE & F ) an d associate d tes t equipmen t us e • Provide d compan yavionic s technica l suppor t vi a telephon e and/o ro n locatio n aroun d th e worl d t o aid e wit h avionic s syste m installations , a s wel l a s wit h th e retu m t o ser^/ic e o f un-airworth yaircraf t Technica l Achievement s

- Relie d upo n t o assis t wit h variou s technica l an d plannin g function s o t th e Rocky Mountai n Certificat e Managemen t Offic e - Certificat e Managemen t Team s
" Designe d & utilize d troubleshootin g tool s l o efficientl yan d accuratel yidentif y airborn e avionic s system/aircraf t electrica l syste m failures ; fabricate d benc h testin g tools/adapter s fo rus e o n variou s application s t o includ e printe d circui t boar d repair , airframe/engin e wirin g harnes s repair , an d integrate d avionic s equipmen t testin g & repai r • Performe d avionic s syste m installatio n an d equipmen t upgrade s wit h a hig h degre e o f quality ; ensure d appropriat e FA AApprova l wa s receive d (F/\ AFor m 33 7 - Fiel d Approval , Instruction s fo rContinue d Airworthiness )
• Develope d effectiv e tas k card s an d technique s tha t wer e implemente d an d use d t o ensur e manufacturer s dat a an d regulator yrequirement s wer e consistentl y me t durin g avionic s syste m maintenanc e Curren t Licenses/Credential s Hel d
" Federa l Communication s Commissio n - Genera l Radiotelepnon e Operator s Licens e wit h RADA R endorsemen t
• FA AForn i 110 A- Aviatio n Safet yInspector' s Credentia l (No
. 8907 ) Aviatio n Award s Receive d
• FA AFligh t Standards , Northwes t Mountai n Regio n 200 9 "Mento ro f th e Year "
• Montan a 200 2 "Avionic s Technicia n o f th e Year " • Recipien t o f (2 ) FA AAviatio n Maintenanc e Technicia n "Diamon d Awards "07/28/201 0 15:5 9 FA X 202483514 2 FA A ^ DM S 21008/00 8


# Michae l C
. Crunnrine , Aviatio n Safet yInspecto r Fedeio l Aviotlo n AcJmin;.<itrotion , Denver , CO/303-342- 1 IV2/rr)IKfc\ufumrinc(s'farj.go v

Skill s Proficien t a t airborn e an d benc h avionic s troubleshooting/repai r Technica l writing/maintenanc e recordkeepin g Abl e t o integrat e regulation s an d require d procedure s applyin g t o avionic s training , troubleshooting , repair , an d testin g Advance d compute rskill s wit h spreadshee t development , wor d processing , PowerPoin t presentations , a s wel l a s efficien t regulator yguidanc e retrieva l techniqu e • Skille d a t producin g effectiv e report s & briefing s an d disseminatin g t o an y audienc e • Abl e t o establis h an d maintai n controlle d manufacturer' s technica l publications ; abl e l o establis h an d maintai n a calibrate d too l progra m • Comprehensio n o f electrical/electroni c wirin g diagram s an d schematic s

Wori < Histor y Aviatio n Safet y

Inspecto r- Ai r Carrie rAvionic s Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Denver , C O 12/200 7 t o p.^esen t

Avionic s Manage rBi g Sk yAirline s (BSAA040A ) Billings , M T 7/200 6 t o 12/200 7
Avionic s Manage rCorporat e Ai r (HSYR817E)(HSYA817E } Billings , M T 1/199 9 t o 12/200 7

Educatio n Associat e

Degre e - Avionic s Communication s High-Tec h Institut e Phoenix , A Z December
. 199 8

Hig h Schoo l Diplom a Meridia n Senio rHig h Schoo l 199 4
Reference s Reference s ar e availabl e o n reques t