Exhibits | Pages
1173 CBI-PL007554-69
1182 CBI-PL025260-5310
1184 CBI-PL033873-79; 882-92
1188 CBI-PL 059360; 62-66; 68-70; 72-79
1202 PDM-HOU1005332-48
1210 no bates #s
1212 no bates #s
1218 CBI-PL014282-88
1226 CBI-HWH 018200-28
1234 CBI-HWH 017191-93; 96; 201-11; 13-15
1256 CBI-HWH 007881-88
1277 CBI 031108-13
1279 CBI 031102-HOU - CBI 031106-HOU_
1280 CBI 031095-HOU - CBI 031097-HOU
1281 CBI 031039-HOU - CBI 031345-HOU
1282 CBI 031020-HOU - CBI 031029-HOU
1286 CBI 030571-72-HOU - CBI 030578-HOU
1291 CBI 002812-HOU - CBI 002822-HOU.
1292 CBI 002873-HOU - CBI 002917-HOU
1294 CBI 002943-HOU - CBI 002960-HOU
1295 CBI 002273-HOU- CBI 002978-HOU; 002980-85
1296 CBI 002927-HOU - CBI 002930-HOU
1302 CBI 031986-HOU - CBI 031992
1305 CBI 030191-HOU - CBI 030214-HOU
1306 CBI 030550-HOU - CBI 030563-HOU.
1310 CBI-E 007398 - 007400
1318 CBI-PL 030367-68
1321 CBI-PL069518-29
1323__| pp. 4-157
1346 ‘CBI-H007373-82
1353 CBI/PDM-H 4000514-522
1402 CBI-H001884-88
1406 All
1425 CBI/PDM-H 4007465-66
1432 CBI-HOU 7062-63; 65-67, 69-71; 70-77, 7120
1433 CBI-PL 1000048-64
1422 CBI-PL024707-15
1433 CBI-PL003792-94; 806
1473 CBI/PDM-H 4000422-437
1478 CBI 010191-HOU - CBI 010211-HOU
1486 CBI 059970-78; 80-81
1487 CBI-059991-92
1488 CBI-059894-902
1490 CBI 060050
1493 CBI060356-57
1494 CBI 060361-64



c. Certain information regarding customer information: CX 954.

d. Certain sales strategy documents: CX 130; CX 135; CX 169; CX 208; CX
242; CX 308; CX 364; CX 454; CX 455; CX 758; CX 781; CX 787; CX
788; CX 789; CX 834; CX 848; CX 888; CX 890; CX 921; CX 1159; CX
1163; CX 1173; CX 1202; CX 1218; CX 1295; CX 1296; CX 1346; CX
1353; CX 1433; CX 1442; CX 1477; CX 1490; CX 1493; CX 1494; CX
1495; CX 1505; CX 1535; CX 1542; RX 16; RX 62; RX 64; RX 148; RX
150; RX 207; RX 216; RX 230; RX 231; RX 241; RX 264; RX 287; RX
304; RX 320; RX 602; and RX 614.

ORDERED: D aa y| Na yak
D. Michael Chappel .

Administrative Law Judge

Date: December 3, 2002

10


Exhibits | Pages

304 CBI 025293-HOU

312 CBI 5509-5529; 5532-35; 5537-49

313 CBI 005551-59; 005562-71; 005573-606

319 CBI 007863-HOU; CBI 007866-HOU

320 CBI 007867-HOU - CBI 007868-HOU

322 CBI 007916-HOU - CBI 007921-HOU; CBI 007923-HOU

392 CBI 065704; 729-45

393 CBI 065753; 755-92; 794-826

394 CBI 065833-36

395 CBI 065865; 867-913

397 CBI 06517-83

400 CBI 066119-53; 55-58

403 CBI 066292-93

404 CBI 066294-301

406 CBI 066337-39

408 CBI 066695-729

409 CBI 066955-57; 60-70; 72-75

410 CBI 067063 - 67

414 CBI 067249-55

415 CBI 067325-41; 56-61

424 CBI 001150-PLA - CBI 001160-PLA

593 CBI 060751-823

594 CBI 060833-34

595 CBI 060846-50; 52-54

598 CBI 059309; 312-320

599 CBI 059389-97

601 CBI 059374-82; 059386-88

612 CBI 060197; 199-208; 210

614 CBI 060403

615 CBI 060496-501; 503-04

616 CBI 060000; 02-08

618 CBI061750-59

620 CBI 061888-905; 908-910

621 CBI 062003-08

622 CBI 062126-27

627 CBI 063050-51

628 CBI 063379-90; 94-96; 98-408

631 CBI 067590-602

633 CBI 068248-49

639 CBI 069093-122

640 CBI 069126-27

642 All

643 CBI 069172-9203

644 CBI 069204-214

645 CBI 69322-324

732 CBI 071499-513



Exhibits | Pages
1495 CBI 060365-66
1501 CBI 060496-504
1504 CBI 060833-34
1505 CBI 059412-45
1508 CBI 059645-57
1512 CBI 059330; 32-40; 52
1513 CBI 059383-88; 74
1515 CBI060181-96
1522 CBI 059609-13
1523 CBI 059615-16
1535 CBI-E 000097-98
1558 CBI 002944-HOU; 002946-60
RX 15 | CBI026825-HOU - CBI 026826; 28-29
16 CBI-E 009279-82
52 CBI 026805-HOU - CBI 1026809-HOU
53 CBI 026810
34 CBI 026812-HOU - CBI 026815-HOU
56 CBI-E 009500-0T
57 CBI-E 009509-510
62 CBI-E 009331-36
64 CBI 0260-67
67 CBI-PL055260; 055262-65
91 CBI-E 007391
92 CBI-E 007401-402; 406-411
93 PDM-CH 002720; 23-25
95 CBI-E 008095-96; 8010-16
98 CBI-E 007334-35
99 CBI-E 007270-74
100 CBI-E 008100; 03-05
147 CBI 069607
148 CBI 069749
150 CBI 069830-33
207 | CBI 071383
216 CBI-E 011399-402
217 CBI-E 011566-74
224 All
230 CBI-E 018365-68
231 CBI-E 018378-81
233 CBI-E 021801-13
241 CBI-E 014172-73
264 CBI-E 024510-15
273 CBI-E 005528
284
287 CBI-E 020549-52; 58-59
292 CBI 046602-NEW - CBI 046603-NEW _
302 CBI 037080-PLA - CBI037090-PLA

6



(9) International LNG projects: CX 727; CX 783; CX 784; CX 909;
CX 930; CX 939; CX 964; CX 1090; CX 1126; CX 1128; RX 147;
RX 319; RX 322; and RX 615.

Thermal vacuum chambers: CX 729; CX 1127; CX 1162; RX 302; and

RX 616.

Additional pricing information: CX 26; CX 817; CX 818; CX 822; CX

824; CX 932; CX 937; CX 1210; CX 1212; CX 1161; CX 1182; CX 1277;

CX 1280; CX 1282; CX 1291; CX 1292; CX 1305; CX 1306; CX 1321;

RX 217; RX 297; and RX 410.

CB&I’s best practices: CX 36; CX 553; CX 1019; CX 1406; RX 224; RX

228; RX 284; and RX 642.

Corporate strategy documents: CX 130; CX 143; CX 213; CX 217; CX

225; CX 434; CX 577; CX 627; CX 629; CX 642; CX 741; CX 758; CX

777; CX 839; CX 857; CX 902; CX 929; CX 949; CX 1066; CX 1226;

CX 1234; CX 1323; CX 1353; CX 1402; CX 1432; RX 67; RX 312; and

RX 313.

4. The following documents, all of which are listed in the above chart, will be given

in camera treatment for a period of three (3) years, to expire December 1, 2005:

a.

Certain pricing documents relating to LIN/LOX jobs: CX 219; CX 247;
CX 449; CX 456; CX 458; CX 771; CX 986; CX 1008; CX 1166; CX
1486; CX 1488; CX 1522; CX 1523; RX 91; RX 92; RX 93; RX 95; RX
98; RX 99; RX 100; RX 209; RX 273; RX 292; RX 293; RX 392; RX
393; RX 394; RX 395; RX 400; RX 408; RX 598; RX 627; RX 628; and
RX 645.

Certain pricing documents relating to LPG jobs: CX 963; CX 966; CX
1310; and CX 1473, ;


UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION

In the Matter of

CHICAGO BRIDGE & IRON COMPANY N.V.,
a foreign corporation,

CHICAGO BRIDGE & IRON COMPANY,

a corporation, Docket No. 9300
and

PITT-DES-MOINES, INC.,

a corporation.

NN Ne Ne

ORDER GRANTING RESPONDENTS' RENEWED MOTION
FOR IN CAMERA TREATMENT OF CERTAIN EXHIBITS

Pursuant to Commission Rule 3.45(b) and the November 5, 2002 Order on Respondents’
Motions for Jn Camera Treatment, Respondents, on November 15, 2002, filed a renewed motion
for in camera treatment of certain materials that the parties have listed on their exhibit lists as
materials that might be introduced at trial in this matter. On November 25, 2002, Respondents
filed a supplement to their renewed motion. The November 15, 2002 motion and the November
25, 2002 Supplement significantly narrow the number of documents for which Respondents seek
in camera treatment and significantly narrow the number of documents for which Respondents
seek indefinite in camera treatment. Further, where appropriate, Respondents have narrowed.
their request to specific page numbers containing confidential information rather than seeking in
camera treatment for entire documents. Complaint Counsel do not oppose Respondents’ motion,
as modified by the November 25, 2002 Supplement.

The November 5, 2002 Order set forth the standards by which Respondents’ renewed

motion for in camera treatment is evaluated. As described by the declarations of the Chief


2. The following documents relating to one specific “secret project,” all of which are
listed in the above chart, will be given indefinite in camera treatment: RX 216, RX 233, RX 414,
RX 424, and RX 631.
3. The following documents, all of which are listed in the above chart, will be given
in camera treatment for a period of ten (10) years, to expire December 1, 2012:
a Pricing
(1) _ Estimating methodologies: CX 1294.
(2) Memphis, Light, Water, and Gas projects: CX 43; CX 48; CX 323;
CX 326; CX 422; CX 423; CX 837; CX 906; CX 1109; CX 1117;
CX 1118; RX 56; RX 57; and RX 732.
(3) Yankee Gas: CX 363; CX 418; CX 420; CX 838; RX 15; RX 52;
RX 53; and RX 54.
(4) PG&E: CX 1512; CX 1513; RX 397; RX 599; RX 601; RX 618;
RX 621.
(5) Cove Point/Pine Needle: CX 226; CX 500; CX 539; CX 796; CX
865; CX 886; CX 908; CX 1112; CX 1160; CX 1281; CX 1425;
CX 1429; CX 1515; CX 1125; and RX 612.
(6) BP: CX 1017; CX 1020; CX 1501; RX 414; X 424; RX 633; RX
643; and RX 644.
(7) CMS (Lake Charles): CX 905; CX 1279; CX 1286; CX 1504; RX
593; RX 594; and RX 595.
(8) Other Domestic LNG Projects: CX 168; CX 176; CX 613; CX
779; CX 790; CX 865; CX 1131; CX 1188; CX 1478; CX 1508;
RX 403; RX 404; RX 406; RX 409; RX 415; RX 620; RX 622;
RX 639; and RX 640.



Exhibits | Pages
848 CBI-E 9331-36
888 CBI 069749-50
890 CBI069830-33

857 PDM-HOU 19506-19526

865 CBI/PDM-H 4015168-70; 72

886 CBI070420-22

902 CBI30408-12-HOU; 30418-19

905 CBI31081-HOU; 31088

906 CBI31073-80-HOU

908 CBI 31053-HOU - CBI 31060-HOU; CBI 31062-63 - HOU; CBI 31065-68

909 CBI31046-52-HOU

921 CBI3607-17-HOU _

929 CBI 001734; 001735; 001737-42, 1746-58; 1761-62, 1767-75, 1777-80; 1782-83;
1786-88; 1790-96; 1799-801; 1803; 1805-11; 1813-21

930 CBI31184-HOU - CBI31203-HOU

932 CB1031136-HOU - CBI 031137-HOU

937 CBI-PL 68386-407

939 CBI-PL 59897-98; 900; 901; 903-06; 908-09

949 CBI-PL 041125-041131; 041135-45; 041147-54; 041157-65, 041167-73; 041175-
92; 041194-200; 0411203-11; 0411213-35; 041127-32; 041134-50; 041152;
041154-59; 041161; 041163; 041165; 041166-71; 041173; 041175-76; 041180

954 CBI 1002095-106

963 CBI-PL 059381; 05383-97

964 CBI-PL 059407-16; 059418-28

966 CBEPL 001627; 001629-47; 001652

986 PDM-HOU015543

1015 CBI-E 000154-55

1017 CBLE 018361-62

1020 CBI-E 018309-12

1066 CBI-033727-ATL; 033750; 033753-59; 033762-63; 033766-67

1019

1109 CBI-HWH 041298-300; 041321; 041323-324

1076 CBI 001149-PLA - 001160

1090 CBI-H 4002688-91

1109 CBI-HWH 041298-345

1112 CBI-HWH 035504-16

17 CBLHWH 036537-62

1118 CBI-HWH 036576-88

1125 CBEHWH 035517-536

1126 CBI-HWH 054146-73

1127 CBI-HWH 052170-052249

1128 CBI-HWH 049185-91

1159 CBI/PDM-H 4001592-94

1160 CBI/PDM-H 4007485-86

1161 CBI/PDM-H 4008121-33

1162 ‘CBI-ATL 000937-39; 41-49; 51-53; 55-58

1163 CBI-HOO1108-20



Exhibits | Pages

422 CBI-E 9500

423 CBI-E 9509; 9510

449 CBI-E 7401-02

454 CBI-E 007250-51

455 CBI-E 007334-35

456 CBI-E 7270-74

458 CBI3702-HOU - CBI3744-HOU

500 CBI-H 8200-32

539 CBI/PDM-H 4019267-68

353 All

613 CBI-PL 10924-28

627 CBI-H006778; 788-791; 793-798; 801-805; 807-813; 816-824; 826; 828-834;
837; 840-45; 847-853; 855-856; 858-864; 866-872; 874-875; 877-880; 883-885;
887-893; 895-896; 898-904; 906-907; 910; 912; 914-915; 918-921; 923-924; 926-
932; 934-938; 939-940

629 CBI-PL033035-048; 050-061; 063-092; 094-095; 097

642 CBI-PL047419-25; 27

722 CBI 36325-CAN - CBI'36329-CAN

727 CBI35435-CAN - CBI 35442-CAN

729 CBI 37832-31-PLA - CBI 37835-PLA

T4l CBI-PL04123-11

738 CBI-PL 31546-49; 31554-59

7TH CBI-PLOII704

TIT CBI-PL044250-254; 256-259; 263-269; 271-280; 282-286; 288-297, 301-304;
306-309; 310-318; 320-330; 335-342; 344; 346; 348-352; 354-356; 359-362; 364-
368; 372-380; 382-387; 389-392; 395-399; 400-405; 409-414; 416; 418-421; 423-
426; 429-432; 434-437; 441-447; 449; 451-454; 456-459; 462-465; 467-468; 470-
476; 480; 482-486; 490-493; 495-498; 501-504; 506-510; 514; 518-529; 531-538;
540-551; 553; 557-561; 563-568; 569; 571-576; 578-581; 584-586; 588-592; 596-
602; 604; 606-608; 610-12; 615-617; 619-623; 627-632; 634; 636-639; 641-644;
647-650; 652-656

719 CBI -63966-73

781 CBI 064152-65

783 (All) CBI 64606-610

784 (All) CBI 64892-93

787 CBI 65241-46

788 CBI 025347-HOU - CBI 025351-HOU

789 CBI 026945-HOU - CBI 026948-HOU

790 CBI 25365-HOU; CBI 25367-74

796 CBI 24944-HOU - CBI 24950-HOU

817 Interrogatories 1,4,7,8

818 1,4,5,6, 7(b), 9, VI

822 page 3-14

834 CBI-E 013673

837 CBI-E 9500; CBI-E 9501

838 CBI-E 009442

839 CBE 24742-64



Engineer for Chicago Bridge & Iron (“CBI”), the Assistant General Counsel for CB&I, and the

Vice President of Sales for North America for CB&I, the documents for which in camera

treatment is sought contain competitively sensitive and confidential information, the disclosure

of which would cause the loss of business advantage and serious and irreparable injury to

Respondents. Respondents have demonstrated that public disclosure of the documents would

result in clearly defined, serious injury. Accordingly, Respondents’ November 15, 2002 motion

for in camera treatment, as modified by the November 25, 2002 Supplement, is GRANTED.

1.

The following documents, or portions thereof, will be given in camera treatment:

Exhibits | Pages
CX 26 (All) 277/01 Ltr. w/CBI PL69530-41

36 All

43 CBI 33830-ATL - CBI 33847-ATL

48 CBI 34346-84 ATL

130 (All) CBI 04440-HOU - 4474

135 CBI 009268-HOU

143 015711-015742

168 CBI-PL 007234-43

169 CBI-PL007554-83

176 CBI-PL 10922-28

208 (All CBI-PL 31513-15

213 CBI-PL 33035-97

217 CBI-PL034407; 09-11; 13-15; 17-19; 21-27; 29-31; 33-35; 38-47, 49-66; 66-75;
78; 82; 87-94; 497-500; 502-504

219 PL 036255-57

225 CBI-PL043498; 500-501; 505-513; 521-527; 529-531; 533; 535-538; 540; 542;
544; 546; 548-551; 553; 555-557; 559-560; 562-564; 566-572; 574; 576; 581-591;
594-604; 607-614; 617-646; 650-653; 666-669; 691-692; 693; 695-701; 703; 705;
707; 709-714; 716-730; 732-734; 736; 738; 740; 742; 744-746; 748; 754; 759-
772; 174-717; 719-782; 784-795; 797-802; 804-08; 810-811; 813

226 CBI-PL 044978-80

242 CBI-PL 4003340-44

247 CBI-PL 016229-42

308 CBY/PDM-H 4000782-83

323 CBI 034482-85-ATL

326 CBI 34623-32-ATL

363 CBI 26825-29-HOU

364 All CBI-E 9279-82

418 CBI 26805-09 HOU

420 CBI 26812; 13; 15-HOU