# RECEIVED FEB 062017 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION OFFICE OF HEARINGS 

## HEARING DOCKET WASHINGTON, DC 

## ***************************** In the Matter of: 

## * Airpac Enterprises, Inc. 

## * DocketNo. FAA-2016-8494 

## * Case No. 2016WP910042 

### * ALJ-RAWALD 

## * 

## ***************************** TO: Honorable Douglas M. Rawald and Respondent COMPLAINANT'S MOTIONFORDECISION 

### COMES NOW, Complainant, by counsel, pursuant to 14 

### C.P.R.§ 13.218(±)(5), files this Motion for Decision. This motion is made on the basis that the pleadings, and matters that the administrative lawjudge has officially noticed show that there is no genuine issue ofmaterial fact andthatthe Complainant is entitledto a decision as amatter oflaw. FNPCP and Respondent's written request for a hearing to the Hearing Docket Clerk. 

### On August 12, 2016, Complainant issued a Final Notice of Proposed Civil Penalty ("FNPCP") against Respondent, and advised Respondent to either submit the proposed civil penalty or mail orpersonally deliver a writtenrequest for ahearing to the Hearing Docket Clerk. On August 26, 2016, by electronic transmission to the undersigned, Respondent copied its written request for ahearing. Inresponse, onAugust 26, 2016, by electronic transmission, the undersigned acknowledged receipt ofthe appeal and noticed Respondent that the undersigned would be filing the complaint. See attached, Exhibit A, 

### Respondent's August 26, 2016, electronic transmission with attached letter requesting a hearing and subsequent exchange of electronic transmissions between Complainant and Respondent.

### August 30, 2016, complaint (Respondent received on September 1, 

### 2016). 

### OnAugust 30, 2016, pursuantto 14 C.P.R. 13.208, Complainant filed, by certified mail, return-receiptrequested, the complaint. Counsel for Respondent received the complaint on September I, 2016. (Respondentreceived the complaint on September 2, 2016.) See attached Exhibit B, the complaint andreferenced certifiedmail receipts and corresponding return-receipts.

Respondent advised ofthe need to file an answerwithin 30 days ofservice ofthe complaint. 

### Although, within the complaint, Complainant did not advise Respondent ofthe need to file an answer within 30 days ofservice ofthe complaint, Complainant advised Respondent by electronic transmissions on September 27, 2016, and again, on September 29, 2016, ofthe need to file an answer within 30 days of service of the complaint in accordance with 14 C.F.R. § 

### 13.209(a). See attached Exhibit C, the September 27, 2016, email, and see attached Exhibit D, the September 29, 2016, email with its referenced attachments (Hearing Docket Clerk letter of September 8, 2016, and 14 C.F.R. 13.209). Respondent failed to file an answer in 

### accordancewith 14 C.F.R. § 

### 13.209. 

### Respondent, onOctober 7, 2016, by electronic transmissionto the undersigned, attached its answerto the complaint. See attached Exhibit E, the October 7, 2016, email with attached
answerto the complaint. Respondent failed to file an answer in accordance with 14 C.P.R. § 

### 13.209. Respondent's
answer is a "General Denial" and was filed afterthe required deadline for filing an answer. Even iftimely, Respondent's "General Denial" on October 7, 2016, does not qualifY as an answer. "A general denial ofthe complaint is deemed a failure to file an answer." 14 C.P.R.§ 13.209(c). 2

### Show Cause Order. 

### OnOctober 17,2016,yourHonor issued an Orderto Show Cause and Provide Answer ("Show Cause Order"). The Show Cause Orderrequiredthe Respondent, byNovember 16, 2016, to file a written statement explainingthe cause ofRespondent's failure to timelyfile its written answerto the complaint (or a written motionto dismiss the complaint). Further, the Show Cause Order advised Respondentthat ifit fails to file a written statement explainingthe
cause ofits failure to timelyfile its written answerto the complaint, yourHonor may issue a subsequent order finding the Respondent has "constructivelywithdrawnthe request for hearing and, pursuantto 14 C.F.R. 13.215, dismiss the case with prejudice." Order at 3. To date, Respondenthas failed to respond to the Show Cause Order. Order Setting Prehearing ConferenceforJanuary 5, 2017. 

### OnNovember 22, 2016, your Honor issued an Order Setting Prehearing Conference. The orderrequired the parties to appear by telephone for aprehearing conference with your Honor on January 5, 2017, at 2:00pmEasterntime. The order advised Respondent that ifRespondent fails to attend the prehearing conference, your Honor may issue a subsequent order fmding the Respondent has constructively withdrawn its request for a hearing and, pursuant to 14 C.F.R. § 13.215, dismiss the case withprejudice. January 5, 2017 Prehearing Conference. 

### On January 5, 2017, your Honor held the prehearing conference. The undersigned cotmsel for Complainant attended the conference telephonically. Counsel for the Respondent failed to appear and therefore Respondent waived the right to participate in the discussion of matters, including Respondent's answer and schedule for motion for decision. 3

### Argument. 

### Respondent failed to file awritten answer to the complaint (or awrittenmotionto dismiss the complaint) within 30 days ofservice ofthe complaint. 14 C.P.R.§ 13.209(a). Failure to file a written answer within 30 days without good cause shall

### be deemed an admission ofthe truth ofeach allegation contained in the complaint. 14 C.P.R.§ l3.209(f). Thus, under the Rules ofPractice inFAA Civil PenaltyActions, 14 C.F.R. §§ 13.201-13.235, a showing of good cause is mandatory. Without it, failure to file an answerbythe deadline may not be excused. Atlantic WorldAirways, 

### FAA OrderNo. 1995-28 (Dec. 19, 1995). In its answerRespondentprovided no reasons for its delayin filing it. Respondent failed to respond to the Show Cause Order, which ordered Respondent to file awritten statement explainingthe cause ofits failure to file its written answer. Respondent filed alate answer and failed to present good cause for the delay. Even ifRespondent's answer was timely, Respondent failed to specifically admit or deny each numbered paragraph of the complaint. 14 C.F.R. § 13.209(e). Respondent's "General Denial" does not qualifY as an answer. A general denial ofthe complaint is deemed a failure to file an answer. 14 C.F.R. § 13.209(e). The Show Cause Order advised Respondent that if it fails to file a written statement explaining the cause ofits failure to timely file its written answer to the complaint, your Honor may issue a subsequent order finding the Respondent has constructively withdrawn the request for hearing and, pursuant to 14 C.F.R. 13.215, dismiss the case with prejudice. Counsel for the Respondent failed to file a written statement explaining the cause ofits failure to timely file its written answerto the complaint. 4

### The Order Setting Prehearing Conference advised Respondent that ifRespondent fails to attend the prehearing conference, your Honor may issue a subsequent order fmding the Respondent has constructively withdrawn its request for a hearing and, pursuant to 14 C.F.R. § 13.215, 

### dismiss the case with prejudice. Counsel for the Respondent failed to appear at the Prehearing Conference. Accordingly, Respondent is indefault in this case. Respondent's request for hearingmust be dismissed and an order assessing civil penalty inthis mattermustbe issued. WHEREFORE, the Complainant respectfully requests this Court grant Complainant's Motion for Decision. There is no genuine issue ofmaterial fact and Complainant is entitled to a decision as amatter oflaw. Respectfully submitted, Naomi Tsuda Assistant ChiefCounsel For Enforcement By:



# ~r{~ Lis Toscano, Attorney Enforcement Division, Western Team email: Lis

### a.M.Toscanolalfaa.gov Telephone: (310) 725-7100 

### (main) (310) 725-7110 

### (direct) (310) 725-6816 

### (fax)

5

### DOCKETNO. FAA-2016-8494
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Ihereby certifY that onthis date Ihave sent byUnited States First-Class mail, the COMPLAINANT'S MOTION FOR DECISION, withExhibits A- E, addressed as follows: Hearing Docket Federal Aviation Administration Wilbur WrightBuilding, Suite 2Wl000 Attn: Hearing Docket Clerk, AGC-430 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. Washington, DC 20591
The Honorable Douglas M. Rawald Administrative LawJudge U.S. Department ofTransportation Office ofHearings, M-20 1200 NewJersey Avenue, S.E. (Ell-310) Washington, D.C. 20590 CourtesyFacsimile: (202) 366-7536 Reza Sina, Esq.
Courtesy email: Counsel for Airpac Enterprises, Inc. 1

07 WestValenciaAvenue Burbank, CA 91502 reza@sinalawgroup.com
Dated: January 31, 2017

**/"~!** 

# J

**~** /

... .



# ~'YU~-.&+~ Antonia Garcia, ProgramAnalyst Enforcement Division, Western Team Lawndale, CA

6

### Toscano, lisa M (FAA) From: Sent: To: Subject: Attachments:
DearMs. Toscano: Reza Sina <reza@sinalawgroup.com> Friday, August 26, 2016 1:26PM Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042 Lto FAA re Airpac ·Request for Hearing.pdf

Please 

### see attached request for hearing. Thank you and have a wonderful weekend. 

### Reza
Reza Sina 

### S!NA LAW GROUP 

### 107West Valencia Ave. Burbank, CA 91502 001untow11 

### Office 888 West 6th Street Los Angeles, CA 90017 Tel: (310) 957-2057 reza'(i:sinala'-Vgroup.corn I.Y\Y\Y.sinalavvgroup .con1 This transmittal may contain privileged and confidential information, and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above. Ifyou are neither the intended recipient(s)_ nor a person responsible for the delivery of his transmittal to the intended recipient(s), you are hereby notified that any distribution orcopying ofthis transmittal is prohibited. Ifyou have received this transmittal in error, please notify SinaLaw Group immediately.

Exhibit A 1

# SINALAWGROUP 107WESTVALENCIA AVENUE BURBANK, CALIFORNIA 91502 Telephone: 310.957.2057 E-mail:

**rp;t~l~nsindldwc,wur.rnm** 

### August26, 2016 Via US Mail and Email 

### fLisa.M.Toscano@faa.gov) LisaM. Toscano, AWP-7.13 EnforcementDivision, WesternTeam POBox 92007 L.A., 

### CA 90009-2007 Re: REQUESTFORHEARING ViaUSMail Federal Aviation Administration 800 IndependenceAvenue, S.W. Washington, D.C. 20591 Attn: HearingDocketClerk, AGC-430 WilburWrightBldg- Suite2W1 000 Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042 DearMs. Toscano: Pleaseallow me to introducemyselfas counsel for Airpac Enterprises, Inc. Please direct all future inquiries regarding this matter to my firm. We are requesting a hearing on the civil penalty accessed. This letter shall constitute our requestfor hearing. Please call me if

### you have any questions. I look forward to working with you to resolve this matter.

Exhibit A 2

### Toscano, lisa M (FAA) From: Sent: To: Subject:

Lisa 1';;_ Tosca;-i,J i-J.-\;'\ Enfor·cenl2i1l ,:,ttorne'-1 ;310) 725-71L) Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Friday, August 26, 2016 2:33 PM 'Reza Sina' RE: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042

From: Reza Sina [mailto:reza©sina!awqroiJQ.com] Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 2:31 PM To: Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Subject: Re: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042 Thanks, Lisa. I will be out oftown for the next 2 weeks and would like to speak with you about the matter when I get back. Reza Sent from 

### my iPhone

:\lr Sina

;-:

;3101 "7.2S·'il_iC) From: Reza Sina [mailto: rezarrusinalaworoup.cqm] Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 1:26PM To: Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Subject: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042 Dear Ms. Toscano: Please see attached request for hearing. Thank you and have a wonderhrl weekend.

Exhibit A 3

### Reza


### Reza Sina 

### SINA LAW GROUP 107 West Valencia Ave. Burbank, CA 91502 Oowlltown 

### Office 888 

### West 6thStreet Los Angeles, CA 90017 Tel: (310) 957-2057 reza;6Jsi

### nala.vvgroup.(()l1l \\"\V\V.sinalavvgrottp.con1 This transmittal may contain privileged and confidential information, and is intended only for the reclpient(s) listed above. Ifyou are neither the intended recipient(s), nor a person responsible for the delivery ofhis transmittal to the intended recipient(s), you are hereby notified that any distribution or copying of this transmittal is prohibited. Ifyou have received this trnnsmittal in error, please notifySina Law Group immediately.

2 Exhibit A 4U.S. DE\portrnent o.i Transpo1otion Federal Aviation Administration Office ofthe Chief Counsel



### U.S. CERTIFIEDMAIL. RETUR.t'\1-RECEIPT REQUESTED August 30,2016 Hearing Docket federal Aviation Administration 800 Independence Avenue, SW Washington. DC 20591

Attn: Hearing Docket Clerk, AGC-430 Wilbur Wright Building- Suite 2Wl000 RE: 

### ln the matter ofAirpac Enterprises, Inc. Enforcement Otvision Western Team. Mail StopAWP-7.13 PO Box 92007 LA, CA 90009-2007

FAADocketNo. CP-Not Assigned: Case No. 20 16WP910042 Enclosed are the original and one copy ofthe complaint in the above-referenced case. The Complainant requests that the hearing be held in Los Angeles, California and expects that the hearing in this case will last one (I) day. All cmTespondence to the Complainant in this matter should be directed to Lisa 

### M. Toscano at: Enforcement Division. Western Team. 

### A WP-7.

### 13 PO Box 92007, Los Angeles, CA 90009-2007 email: Lisa.M.Toscanolalfaa.gov Telephone: (31 0) 725-7100 (main) (3 10) 7:25-7110 (direct) 

### (31 0) 725-6816 (fax) Respectfully,



# Lis~Jtr:J:~- Enforcement Division. WesternTeam Enclosure
cc: Reza Sina. Esq.. Sina Law Group AAM-850

Exhibit B 1

### U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION FEDER>\L AVIATION ADMINISTRATION

In the matter of: 

### AIRPAC ENTERPRISES,INC.
JUDGE NOT ASSIGNED FAA Docket No. CP- Not Assigned Case No. 2016WP910042



### COMPLAINT The Complainant hereby files its Complaint. pursuant to Rule 208 ofthe Rules of Practice in FAA Civil Penalty Actions (14 C.F.R. 

### § 13.208), and states as follows: 

### I. Respondent Airpac Enterprises, Inc., was advised through a Notice ofProposed Civil Penalty dated June 14, 2016 and by a Final Notice ofProposed Civil Penalty dated August 12. 2016, that the FAA proposed to assess a civil penalty in the amount of$10,075.00. 

### By a letter dated August 26, 2016, Respondent requested a hearing. The Enforcement Division, WesternTeam received Respondent's writtenrequest for a hearing on August 26. 2016. 

### II.
1. Aiq)ac Enterj)rises, Inc. (Airpac) is now. and at all times relevant herein was. the holder ofAir Agency Certificate No. Xl3R131Y. authorized to operate as an approved Repair Station under 14 Code ofFederal Regulations (C.F.R.) part 145 of rbe Federal Aviation Regulations.
') At all times rclev·ant herein, Airpac held appropriate Operations Specifications (OpSpecs) certifying 

### it would complv with the requirements of 14 

### Code of Exhibit B 2

### 2
Federal Regulations (C.F.R.) part 120 ancl49 C.F.R part 40 for its drug and alcohol testing program.

3. 

### Random selections were made fi·om Airpac·s Department ofTransportation (DOT) random drug and alcohol testing pools on the first clay ofevery month for the year 2015.

4. Airpac did not add Lisa Rajic to Airpac·s DOT random drug and alcohol testing pool until January 2016.

5. Ms. Rajic performed safety-sensitive work on behalfofAirpac on October 5, 2015, by signing on block 14b. ofan 8130-3, Airworthiness Release Certificate, related to work order# W0214562, for HorizonAir (Certificate No. QXEA002A) authorizing a Return to Service ofSeat Assembly SN 48-1407.

Ill. 1. 

### By reason ofthe foregoing, Respondent violated:
a. 14 C.F.R.

**~** 

### 120.105. which states: Each

**employ~e.** 

### including any assistant. helper. or individual in a training status. who performs a safety-sensitive function listed in this section directly or 

### by contract (including by subcontract at am tier) for an emplover as detined in this subpart must be 

### subject to drug

Exhibit B 3testing under a drug testing program implemented in accordance withthis subpart. This includes fi.lll-time, part-time, temporary. and intermittent employees regardless ofthe degree ofsupervision: and

b. 14 C.F.R. § 120.215(a), which states: Each employee. including any assistant. helper, or individual in a training status, who performs a safetysensitive function listed in this section directly or by contract (including by subcontract at any tier) for an employer as defined in this subpart must be subject to alcohol testing under an alcohol testing program implemented in accordance with this subpart. This includes fi_rll-time. part-time. temporary, and intermittent employees regardless ofthe degree ofsupervision.

2. Pursuant to 

### 49 U.S.C. 

### §46301(a)(5)(A), Respondent is subject to a civil penalty
not to exceed $11,000.00 for each violation ofthe Federal Aviation Regulations.

3. Under the facts and circumstances ofthis case and in accordance with the Administrator's Sanction Guidance in FAA Order 

### 2150.38, Appendix B, a civil penalty of $10.075.00 is appropriate for the violation(s) in this case.

Exhibit 8 4 ·'4

WHEREFORE. the Complainantrespectfully requests that the Administrative Law Judge
enter an order that Respondent be assessed a civil penalty in the amount of$10.075.00.
Respectfully submitted. Naomi Tsuda Assistant ChiefCounsel for Enforcement By 

# dvH..

**ffl':J~** Lisa 

### M. Toscano Enforcement Division, Western Team PO Box 92007, Los Angeles, CA 90009-2007 email: Lisa.!vl.Toscano@faa.E:ov Telephone: (310) 725-7100 (main) (310) 725-7110 (direct) (31 0) 725-6816 (fax) Date: August 30,2016

Exhibit B 5

### CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE


### Ihereby certify that onthis date, 

### Ihave sent

### by U.S. Cer1ilied Mail- return receipt requested. 

### a copy ofthe foregoing complaint in the matter ofAirpac Enterprises. Inc., FAA Docket No. CP- not assigned, Case No. 2016WP910042 to:
Lisa Rajic. President/CEO Airpac Enterprises, Inc. 12611 Encinitas Ave Sylmar, CA 91342 And Reza 

### Sina, Esq. Sina Law Group 107 West Valencia Avenue 

### Burbank, CA 91502
In addition, I hereby certify that onthis date, I have sent by U.S. Certified Mail- return receipt requested. the original and one copy 

### ofthe foregoing documentto: Hearing Docket Pederal Aviation Administration 

### 800 Independence Avenue. 

### SW Washington, DC 20591 Attn: Hearing Docket Clerk, AGC-430 Wilbur Wright Building- Suite 2Wl000 /. 

### / ! < 

# 1/t' Lcj. jl..f
.. - I ·· .. ! .·

**.~>11**j'?t.(/

# v./iL.p:.,;..c..,; AntoniaGarcia. Paralegal Enforcement Division. Western 

### Team Lawndale. 

### C A 90261
Date: August 30. 2016

Exhibit B 6 

### 5Com-plete Items 1, 2, and complete item 4 if Restricted Delivery ls desired. !Ill Print your name and address on the reverse

so that we can return the card to you. Iii Attach this card to the back ofthe mai!piece,

or on the front if space permits. D. Is delivery address different from item i. Article Addressed to: IfYES, enter delivery address below: 0 No Lisa Rajie/l'resident/CEO Airpac Em€rprises, Inc. 12611 Encinitas Ave Sylmar, CA 91342

2. Article Number

(Transferfrom service tal PS Form 3811, July 2013 

### 7015 0920 0001 5090 8993 Domestic Return Receipt

Po·>:HJf:**~** S ;--··---i r-"1**CC>:11f1~Cl** Fe:= ,!--------:

# ~**~~;;:~~~~::,~:~~**

# 1------"·-----1**~** 

## i :'; r""' P'tisa Rajic, President/CEO Ul :-sz.:-TrcA.irpac Enterprises, Inc.**~ :.!o'lr~o:y,r;c·,J·2611**  Encinitas Ave
"- ,""05."$ylmar; CA 91342 i Ci';.'. SW!e, I

Exhibit B 7 I

_____] ' i

.... I ISENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION m Complete items 1, 2, and 3. Also comrlete

item 4 lf Restricted Delivery iS desired. l!ll Print your name and address on the reverse

so that we can return the card to you. Iii Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,

or on the front if space permits. 1. Article Addressed to:

Reza Sina, Esq. s-ma Law Group 11'l7 WestValencia Avenue Burbank, CA 91502**·~-------!** COMPLETE THIS SECTIONON DELIVERY ) ' ll I '
. 1

### B.t?/fl-J of Dehver I 

### I I 

### I A. Received by (Please Print Clearly) I D Agent D Addresse• D. Is delivery address different from item 1? DYes 0**~Jo** If YES. enter delivery address belov,.:

0 Registered 0 Insured Mail 0 Return Receipt !or Merchandis< 0 C.O.D. Restricted Delivery? (Extra Fee) 0 Yes 2. Article Number (Copy from servt

### ~~~~~~~~~-7_0_1_5~0920 0001 5090 9006 PS Form 3811, July 1999 Domestic Return Receipt

Exhibit B 8

### Toscano, Usa M (FAA) From: Sent: To: Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Tuesday, September 27, 2016 3:21 PM 'Reza Sina' Subject: RE: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042; FDMS No. FAA-2016-8494

!jjJ r-.-;. TosC2'l0 310.'

**715~7110** •, From: Reza Sina [mai)to:reza@sinalawaroup.com] Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 2:31 PM To: Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Subject: Re: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042 

### Thanks, Lisa. I will be out oftown for the next 2 weeks and would like to speak with you about the matter when I get back. Reza Sent from my iPhone On Aug 26. 2016. at 1:48 PM. <Li"\.1\ 

### !.Toscano" Lu.

**~c11>** 

### <Lisc].l\1. 

### lcbcano it

**Ln~lll:>** 

### wrote:

From: Reza Sina [mailto:rezij@sinalaworouo.com] Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 1:26 PM To: Toscano, Lisa M(FAA) Subject: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042 

### Dear iVfs. 

### Toscano: Please sec attached request for hearing. Thank you 

### and hal'e a 1\0mkrful 

### weekend. Exhibit C 1

### Reza


### Reza Sina SINA LAWGROUP 107WestValenciaAve. 

### Burbank, CA 91502 DolPiltown Office 

### 888 West 6thStreet Los Angeles, CA90017 Tel: (310) 957-2057

**reza·~_l:si11alJ.**

### vvgroup.con1 \V\\'\V.sinala

**~.-vgroup**

### .con1 This transmittal may contain privileged and confidential information, and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above. Ifyou are neither the intended recipicnt(s), nor a person responsible for the delivery ofhis transmittal to the

**i~tended** recipient(s), you are hereby notified that any distribution or copying ofthis transmittal is prohibited. Ifyou have received this transmittal in error, please notify Sina Law Group immediately.

2 Exhibit C 2

### Toscano, lisa M (FAA) From: Sent: To: Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Thursday, September 29, 2016 3:00 PM 'Reza Sina' Subject: Attachments: RE: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042; FDMS No. FAA-2016-8494 scan_2016_09_29_17_34_56_067.pdf; 14 CFR 13.209.pdf**th~** i:F.12JCS cf

lisa :\'!. TosC?.iD (310) 725-7110 From: Reza Sina [mailto:reza(cilsinalawgroup.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 2.7, 2016 5:20 PM To: Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Subject: Re: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042; FDMS No. FAA-2016-8494 Hi Lisa: 

### I'm in trial in federal court in Downtown all week. Can 

### I gel an additional 

### 10 days? Reza Sent from my iPhone 

### On Sep 27,2016. at3:21 PM. <Lisa.i'd.**J'o:-~cano·(j-l~l~t.on\->** <Lisa.lvl.Tnscan(HI**!~l<:l.!lO\">** 

### wrote:

:::,: \:0,

'.- '-' r



# ..**~:~--~,_~.;-. ·--~,**  :I.

From: Reza Sina [mailto:reza:il•sinalawqroup.com] Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 2:31 PM To: Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Subject: Re: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 20 16WP910042 Exhibit D 1

### Thanks. Lisa. I will be out oftown for the next 2 weeks and would like to speak with you about the matter when 

### I get back. Reza Sent fi·om 

### my iPhone On Aug 26, 2016. at 1:48 PM. 

### <Lisa.iVI.Toscanc1 ,; Lw.

**~ov> <Lisa.~** 

### I. ruscano•,/

**LliL~ov>** 

### wrote: \I; Sin;J,

From: Reza Sina [mailto:reza\a!sinalawgroup.com] Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 1:26PM To: Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Subject: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042 

### Dear Ms. Toscano: Please see attached request 

### for hearing. Thank you 

### and have 

### a wonderful weekend. Reza


### Reza Sina S!NALAW GROUP 

### 107West Valencia Ave. Burbank, CA 

### 91502 

### Oown/muJI Olji'ce 888 West 6thStreet Los Angeles, CA 

### 90017 Tel: (310) 957-2057 

### rez;:-1·rtsi

### naL:-t

### \\'g:roup.cu111 \\'\\'\\'.S

### i!l<:l

### la\\'£l'()U

### p.Cl)111 This transmiltdlmay contain privileged and confidential information, and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above. Ifyou arc neither the intended r('Cipient(s), nor a person responsible for the delivery ofhis transmittal to the intended recipient(s), you arc hereby notified thc1l any' distribution or copying of this transmittal is

**~1rohibited.** If_vou 2 Exhibit 0 2have received this transmittal in error, please notify Sina Law Group immedintely.

J Exhibit D 3Federal A•Jiation Administration Office of Adjudication 11.1\S\1.\II

l.i-:':1 \!. l'tl::-;Cilllll. E.-;q_ h
.

'Lk:·;!) :\\ i:Hi1111 .·\dministratinn t:n!lwccnh:nt J)i,·i:-;i\•1\. \\"cs!l'rn l'c<Ull. :\\\'P- :.l::; P.U. !{,n 9:::0il-:- !.zls .-\n_l2<.:k·s. C.-\ l)()OtJl)-:::uo: R.:1.a Sina. Lsq Sin:1 l_a,, (jr,_,up 10-:' \\"est Vakncia .\\L'!ltl\.' Burbanl-.. C.-\ l) i

**~U~**

\\c il<t\C

**:tssign~.:d** the abu\c-ro.:l"cr<..'I1Ccd

**l:cd~...·ral** ]),li..:Lct \\anagcmcnt

**S~st~...·m** (FD\-IS) numb'-'!" tu thi'=' nutter.

**Pk·~tSI...'** includt..· this FD\lS number

**~.)tlall** ctltTcspnndl..'th.:c and t•n L'ach dtlCUtlh:nttll:!t

**~** LHI !ilc \\·ith thl.'

**llc~ning 1\H.:L~..:t**  ir1 thi-;

**pru~.;L'cding..** \tll)lht..·r dlh.·h·t nllmhcr \\ill be ;Js:->ig.nl..'d.

1·:\.\

**~.:i**\ il

**pt..•nalt~** a...:tilm_-..; :Jt"t..' g1)\ l'I"I1t..'d h,;. the Rules 

## ,,r

**Practic~...·.** 1-l C.F.It

## <) 13.16 <nH.I IJ.:::n l-!3.23:". l'ht..·

**l~uk:~** 

## ,)r Pr:\ctJcc. ;1-.; ''ell <h nthLT thcful inl"mlllaliun

**~th1ut** L'i\ il pt..·twlt:· pr,l<..:t..'i...'dillgs and inlk.\cs

## c,r dc-:i-;i\llb issllt..'d b; the

**.'\dmini.~tratt11'. m~t~**  bt..' flntnd at: hup:_· \\\\\\ ._Lt:t.gu\

**·~Jlh**1l!l '1!li...:c-

**_l.•t:gJl_','_<Ld_q~l-~_lflCI)_'.IIft....:t..'_-,__<]_g_,_;j1t_l**l_:i\ljudi<..::tli!il1

**':tg_~_:l il!J._s;_j_~i)_pt;.tl<i_l_t)**  !k <llh i:-it..'d that dlxlltllt..'lll:i riled\\ith !hi.'!

**karin~** Dt)t..'hct \\ill he :1Y:1ilabk puhlic!:

**thr,lll~h** th.__· !d\,1\\

**in~** \\L'b->itc· i)_llp:

**\\_\\_\~J.:_~gltl<tL[0_1l_-;_g,)~** I!" )Lili lllc a ducutnl..'llt

**(\_ rH:tinin~**  inl.lll"l11i\li(1Jl th:11 •dJt'luld tlt'l ht..· nwdc publici) :1\·ail:thk. :uu ;-;l1l1\Jld lik <1 rlltllion undL'r 1-·l C.F.R.

**~ 13.2~(1,** 

'-;h;!ric_:,__- .ld·fl-r.-,1111 Ik::ri:12! [)
...,.:Ll'l C'k·rL_ \Cr!.·--tt

Exhibit D 4Federal Aviation Administration, DOT dg('I\C,\' ,lll<llll<'\ j;,',\l<'rl il llUiiC<" UJ jll'll rm<,Pd ci\'il P''li.dt\· 111 tlw n''>jliJIHh•nl

(II .-\11 ;gfitlilli'-11'<11i\<' II\\ Judgt' 111<1\ Jl<JI**~1"<1111** till'**111<~fi<~:l** ;ttHI cli'>lllh" illl'**t'Oiltj~Ltirtl** <ll' p:tll t.d tlH· C(ltllplairlt if 1!11· :tdlltilthll'<tfi\<' !:1\\ _juclg1' find:-, rll.p111<' <lg<'ll<'\ lid'-, <.,)111\\'1\ !}.<lOll C<l\1'>(' lin dll\ d1·ld_\ i11**h~uill,C!** iiH· 11()1 in• ol" j.li'<J pu-,vd civil jll'!l<lil_\**I~)** 11" tlw**~~-~<'lltY** 1";\iJ.., ro '>110\\ gcmd r•;_ill'<' fOI' :111\'**lit']~\\** ;t!l ild!llil\hl!''-\l[\\ J;m _jttdgr· nt.t\ di__:tni--,._, till' ('<lltlpldiiH. 1a·**l'l1;~r** Jlill't ,,J' 1lw ,·ln!lpl;.Jilll cdlv;..;irt_c;**~~** \'i•>l<tr itnt**rh;~r** 111 curn·d 1non· t·hdll**~** \('ill"'> JwrO!'<• ill\ :tc_;l'IIC\ 'Ill 01"!\l"_\· i.-.,Sil<'d IIH• 1\0li<'l' ot prnpt)';f'd d\·il j)l'tl<tll\ Ill I !tr• 1'1'.'-;jlUild<•lll.

(:\) .\**jl~H'!\** 111;1\ iljljl\",\1 d\1' illllllil\1'; 11-dliU·**)~1\\** jtH)_c;<··-., I'U)illg ()Jl r-]1,. 11111 tiun l<t dhnli---;c; 1iw curnp!aint or iltl\ p<trt of rill' <'1\illpLiinl in iiCCilrd;uwl'**~~-** 11 11 !;;**u.~** I'HhJ <)r ,hi.,_ '-lthp<lt·r
_ [.\tln1t u-n -,_J 1·- k :'Ill.! Juh :;**1!1~111,** ,JIII<'!Hi<·d IJ\ \dill! : ; ..**~~-** _-,_) J-'1\ :1Jiilj, -\<1:: 1'1'111)**~** 1:t2n9 Answer•.

(;\)**\\'r·itill~** tt•quill'd
. .-\**l"t·~pu1Hivllt** ·,iJ.J)I filt·**<~** 1\t·it·tf·n dlh\'<'t· to tlw cuJtl pl:tinr Ill 11\il\ fij,• <I \\l'illt'fl lll<Hi<ll\ pur;;u.Jnl tu**~U.LWHd)** c!l <jl:l.2!XIfJ(\ -ll ll)- I]Ji..., -...11iJpcH I ill'>il';tl] ,)j·**!"iJiw~** ill I ill\ '>\1'1'1 !lUI L-11<"1" tltill\ :w dil\;; ,JI'tl'!' :c-.t'l'\ i1 r· oi' tll1• C•lltipLtiiJI rlw <lll'>l\'t'l nl;J\ IJ, ill tilt' J'<ll-111 or·;; [,•tilT Inti 11\T_J';( l;p ddio•d ;Hid -.,j_'-.\JI<'d !J\ till' pt'l"'-,(0!\ II' ';jl011ili11g Ito tf\l" 1 <lll'!Ji,lilll. --\11 :lll'-,1\i'l JILl\ lw 1\jll'\\lill;'ll <II l!tl\ IH· l•·gi\Jh lldl!d\\ l'ill<'ll

till hlirrg :.II H.)**~1ddr''"~** --\ pt'I':>!Jit I il**i11.~2** <Ill ;\11'>\1'1'1-**.._))~!!]** jH'I'-IHI<I]]\ tiv)i\'l'l Ill IIUiJ I]H' Ill i;J;iltid <llld Iilii' ("<I)!\ l!f' 1)\t' ,\\1..,'-l•'t I'< II I**ili11~** I\ itlr TIP• lw;lr'illg d<ICb·t t'll"t'k lllol ];Ill'! th,tll :lll d,!\'-., dflt'l --,1'1'\iCt· 1!1 tilt· l"<JIItjll.drlt", !11 liJ,•**1-lvdlilt_~** l)<lt kt:l [-,•tl••l,i! .-\\"i,tlillll \d 111i1ti---t r;11 i•1:1. sno lltdt·p•·JJd('lln· .\\'<'1\IH· '-.\\ h:•H\11\**)~-L\.** \\;1-.,ilitt,'..;l.tlll. L)( :!(]_'i\1\ \llt'Hli<lli**)]t•;Hill.~** ))fll_')-;t•[ l'il't-h_ !l!t' l''·r-...J!It li!ing <111 dll..,\\<'1-**~liuuld** -..;u'-'-.'-'-''"r

1<1< :r< i•JII l1n' 1i:•·**)t,.,~, in~**  \'.lli'll fi li11c.> f! I< d!h\'.• 'I

'1 1 '1,•( \ i1 I -.,IJ;J!i ';<'I \ 1 wr ...,, 111 n1litC.: :ur :t\1';\'-''' ' up·, td d ltl· dlh\l<·r· f>ll ill<' .111 <)I I 11 ,, ,,_I !l) IiI'·d I ill (-,I ill jd.1i1H

«' ( t<lil<·i II'> \it .llh' .\'1 '- t.rli '>jh'l il i '-,l[!', -.,1 .II< • '' ,. ,l)f ii 11\.11 \ (· d< ·f t'! I'-<
:)/ § 13.211
dl ril<' li•.-dl"i!t:-;
..\ pt·I'<,Otl 1"\Jitlg dll dll '>l'.'<·r lttd\' in··ludr· d ht·it·l '>l<tl'l'llll'llf ":· :111\· rt·lit•l n•qtt('';\('tl i11 till· dll..,\\'1'1

i<'l Sj!l'!'i!k ri<'lli;ll <II**<tlk_~<.JtiO!I\** ,.,, qtlitt•d ,\ pt'!"'>t'll J'ilitl.!--', <ill dtl..,\\l'l '>IJctll ;:d1nit d,•rn·. 11r c,t:trt·**ril<~r** r-lJ,. jli'I'>IJil h \\'ili!tl!ll ';ltf'J'i,_-j,'l\( !:.lllll'.']t•d'.!,(' 111'**ill~-.,1.** lltilf i<HI 1<J cidJIIi I l)] dt•ll\" I'Cll"il lilllil lh·rt--d**p-tl'd~l-~I)Jil** 11f rh•• <'(JJltjJI;Hill. ·.-\11\**---r~lfl.'ll\<'111** or**<~llvg.ttiort** nHtl':litH·t) irt tfl,. t"UIIljiLdtll. 1)\,i! h Jt<ll' ':>jWtifi<,d!\ dl'llit·d ill rlil' ,\JIS\\"\'l" I lid_\- IH· dt't'lll•'d <.ill ;tdmio.,'>illll <lf 1.111· (Tlllli \d. r!J.11 ;i)h·!-'-d 1 irn1 \ g•·lll'r<tl dt•IJi<d 

### nr rll\'**co1npl~ti111** h dt'\'llH·d :1 i'i.iiltil'l' ro filv .111 ;ltt;;\\',·r.

II'J 1-'ctilur•• ftJ l"i!t•**dll~I\'Pr** .\ pt•rc,olt·-, !':tilur<• 111 filt· .tit**~Hl'>\\'t·t·** ll[l'illnlr gur1d l';_)ll;-,1'
...)l:lll h·· ,j,.,.lll<'d .ill .tdltli-.,':>illll ,J! lltt· [1-LHil ot' i'ill'll ;l]]t•g;llit!ll ('(JI)f.titl<'d i I 1 till' o_'(Jilljl] dIll!'.**~** I:t:!lO Filinl:{ of documents.

loll Add\'!''>'> and llWihlld tll' filitt.l2,
. .-\ )11'1 ';UII l'1'11dt•J'ill_:._: il diJClllll<'llt i'tlf'**ii!i11~** -.,lt:tll jll'l'';lllldll\ dt•li\'('1" <)\' llldil lllt· -.,lglll'd**origi11~:l** iiiHl Dlh' C:Ojl_\- <II <':tCII duCUlllt'Ill (IJ 1lw I**lt'i.ll-ill~** Ll()<.·kct. l·i·tl I'I'Cd .-\\-iilr i<JI\ :\dmilthl PII io11. XI){! lnd,• jH'llliL-Il<T ,\\\'lltll' S\\. J.:.:uolll**~)~-L\ \\ii'>ilin~IUIL**  IX. :!lh!ll
..\IU'Jtliun: l-11';\r iti,C: lltH_.kt<t Cl1•rk. \ jli'l''•llt**'>ilc~ll** ;-,i'l'\<" <I i'llj.l.\- ol t·<J(_ II dl:t"lltl\•'111 <lll t>;rr It p.lrl \ i11 ,1('\"IJI"d<tll<C' \1\I!J**~I:\.~]** I <JJ" ([lj..,**~\!~~** p.n·t

(IJI [l,til' of lili11g .\ d<l• llilll'lll**_c,l1~1!1** iJ•· tlllhidt•n·d 111 IJo rilt•d till 1111' !bit· nl 1'('1-'>tnl:i! di•[i\·1'1'\ · ur il tn:lilt-d 1lw tlliiiliti_C: dctt1· -.,ilut\ 11 <Ill rlw ,.,,1·1 ili.-:111' II( ',('1\ i«· til<' d.tl_t• ';iJ<l\\"1\ <))1 I ill' j!t•'>J [[l;trk if' tiH'tl j.., tlU n•ni!'ir<JII' ,d-'>1"1"\ ii'••. 111 Ill llt•J 111; li I i 11_c; d.ttt· '>II< l\\ II h'. ,tlh·r •·1it!<·t1n· if' !hl'lt' h 11<1 <"t·rtiiit-<11< ,,j ..,,.t 1 in· 111 P' I'> I llli.tl'k

II') [--'ul Ill ) :;II"] 1 t h 11 t:ll I<' III --,ju i I In· t\"jlV\Ititi\·IJ <JI 1,·!-!iiJl\ l:;t;Hl'.'.ritl<'ll

id: {iillll'lil.., llli<'"'- ••111<'1\'.h<· 'JH'< i ii.·d Ill 1jjj_.., ';\!hp.i! I "It <ill• Ll!\lt'lll 111\1'-l t I !It I ,'I i 11 .[ '-I!"!" I j':, II I 1 ._,!; ili'l 1i<·tll ll( till' 1'.1< I'- <>11 \l·]:i,)l lilo•**j!<'l"'>lll\-~** I'd',(· 1<·-...IC, dill: hi• :·**-,l,il<'ll~<'tll** ol til•' .1< ll''llll."'i'l''"!'dl- ilwdti•!lllll\ll \1 «II**~'I.:'** I.; f' 1' i**~ ~**  '!'II'I

\.(']<l'i':ll \ !I' l'Elil
.... ll<il! "'I' o(Jp\· i\1 <til\ I:<HIIIIlt'lll JjJ,•d \'.ii:l I L- 'l \! i'.C: !I,_,-:. ' ·''· !: I!· ll'l \ '1:

Exhibit 0 5

### Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) From: Sent: To: Reza Sina <reza@sina!awgroup.com> Friday, October07, 2016 3:08 PM Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Subject: Attachments: RE: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042; FDMS No. FAA-2016-8494 Answer of Airpac.pdf
Hi Lisa; 

### Attached is the Answer to the Complaint. l reviewed the docket and the code and based the response on the September 8, 20l6 letter ti·om FAA. Thank you for your assistance. 

### Reza
Reza Sina SINA 

### LAW GROUP 107

### West Valencia Ave. Burbank, CA

### 91502 Downtown Office 

### 888 West6thStreet 

### Los Angeles, CA 

### 90017 Tel: (310) 

### 957-2057

**rcZt.l'C:~~sina.la**

### \Ygroup.cun1 vvwvv.sinZtlav\·grou

### p.n)nl This transmittal may contain privileged and confidential information, and is intended onlyfor the recipient(s) listed above. Ifyou arc neither the intended recipient(s), nor a person responsible for the delivery ofhis transmittal to the intended recipient(s), you are hereby notified that any distribution orcopying ofthis transmittal is prohibited. Ifyou have received this transmittal in error, pleas(' notify Sina Law Group immediately

--------- Originnl Message
--------- Subject: RE: Airpac Enterprises. lnc
.. 

### Case No. 

### 20l6WP9l0042: FDMS 1'\o. FAA-20l6-8494 From:

**LiscL~·l.lusc:.mo uJa~l.\.!.0\"**  

### Date; 9/29/16 2:)9 pm To: rcza 

### ·u sinabt\Y!2rOU[).com
.)

Exhibit E 1' '**~** C, 'I·)·';: :: ') ',' -. -, '·'.

From: Reza Sina [mailto:reza\alsinalawgroup.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 27, 2016 5:20 PM To: Toscano, Usa M (FAA) -.-**~-** '·· .• t;_,._, ,._.**~ ~**  -' '

Subject: Re: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042; FDMS No. FAA-2016-8494



### Hi Lisa:

I'm in trial in federal court in Downtown all week. Can I get an additional 10 days"

Reza
Sent ti·om my iPhone

,. '**~**

2 Exhibit E 2From: Reza Sina [mailto:rezacmsinalawgroup.com] Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 2:31 PM To: Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Subject: Re: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042

Thanks. Lisa.

I will be out oftown tor the next 2 weeks and wou1cl1ike to speak with you about the matter when 1get back.



### Reza Sent [rom my iPhone
On Aug 26. 2016. at 1:48 PM, <L.isa.\l.Toscarw'u**iCHL~O\>** <Lisa.i\L llbCano 

### u**rcn~m** 

### > wrote:

i (: .-::' ,-·).I

- -· _.

3 Exhibit E 3From: Reza Sina [mailto:reza@sinalawgroup.com] Sent: Friday, August 26, 2016 1:26 PM To: Toscano, Lisa M (FAA) Subject: Airpac Enterprises, Inc., Case No. 2016WP910042

Dear Ms. Toscano:

Please see attached request for hearing.

Thank you and have a wonderful weekend.



### Reza

Reza Sina 

### SINA LAW GROUP 107 West Valencia Ave. Burbank, CA 91502 Oowutowu 

### Office 888 West 

### 6th Street Los Angeles, CA 90017 Tel: (310) 957-2057 rcza,u:s

### inab

### iYgroup.corn 

### \\'\\'\\'.sin;;1la\Yg-rou p.cotll

This transmittal may contain privileged and confidential information, and is intended only for the recipient(s) listed above. Ifyou are neither the intended rccipicnt(s), nor a person responsible for the delivery of his transmittal to the ,intended recipient(s), you are hereby notified that any distribution or copying of this transmittal is prohibited. Ifyou hove received this transmittal in error, please notify Sind Lnv Group immediately.

4 Exhibit E 4

### 3 4 5 

### 6 7 

### 8 

### 9 10 11 12 

### 13 

### 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 

### 22


### 24 

### 25 26 27 

### 28 Reza Sina (SBN 250428) .SINA LAW GROUP

107 Airpac ValenciaAvenue Burbank. California 9I502 Tel: (3 10) 957-2057 reza@sinalawgroup.com Attorneys for Respondent, AIRPAC ENTERPRISES, INC.


### fEDERALAVIATION ADMINISTRATION OFFICE OFADJUDICATION


### In the Malter ofAirpac Enterprises, Inc., FDMS No. F AA-20 16-8494 Case No. 20 16WP91 0042 

### ANSWER Of AIRPAC ENTERPRISES, INC.

- I - A"SWER Exhibit E 5

### Defendant Airpac Enterprises, Inc. ("Airpac'') submits his answerto the 2 Complaint (''Complaint") ofFederal Aviation Administration: 3 GENERAL DENIAL 4 By virtue ofthe provisions ofCode ofCivil Procedure section 431.30, Airpac 5 denies each and every allegation contained in the Complaint and each purported 6 cause ofaction contained therein, and further denies that Plaintiffsustained c!amage 7 in the sums alleged, or in any sum, or at all, by reason ofany act, breach, or omission 8 on the part ofAirpac or on the part of any agent, servant, representative, employee, 9 predecessor, or successor ofAirpac. 10 Airpac raises the following affirmative defenses 111 

### connection with his 11 Answer: 12 FIRSTAFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE 13 

### (Failure to State a Cause ofAction) 14 

### 1. 

### The Complaint fails to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of 15 action upon which relief can be granted against Airpac. The Complaint also seeks 16 relief against Airpac that is not properly recoverable by Plaintiff. and Plaintiff is 17 therefore barred from any recovery against Airpac. 18 SECOND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE 19 (Compliance) 

### 20 2. Plaintiffs Complaint and the allegations contained therein is barred or 21 22 ?" 

### --' 24


### 26 27 

### 28 diminished, in whole or in part, by Airpac's compliance with the C.F.R. THIRD AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE (Reasonable Belie1) At all times. Airpac operated with a reasonable beliefthatdirectors and officers were not required to be a part ofthe mandatory drug testing.

- 2- ,\'\SWER Exhibit E 6

### PRAYER 2 WHEREFORE. Airpac respectfully prays for entry ofjudgment in its favor 3 and against Plaintiffas follows: 4 

### 5 6 7 8 9 10 

### 1 1 12 13 14 15 

### 16 17 

### 18 19 

### 20 21 

### 22
24


### 26 27 

### 28 I. 7


### 4. That Plaintifftake nothing by way ofhis Complaint; Thatthe Complaint be dismissed with prejudice; Forthe costs ofsuit, including reasonable attorneys· fees; and For any other and further reliefas the Court may deemjustand proper.
Dated: October 7, 2016 Respectfully submitted, 

### SINA LAW GROUP By: /s/ Reza Sina Reza Sina Attorneys for Airpac Enterprises, Inc.

- 3

-**------------------~~-** Exhibit E**A~SWER** 7

### PROOF OF SERVICE 2 I am employed in the County of Los Angeles. State ofCalifornia in the oftlce ofa member ofthe bar ofthis Court at whose direction the service \Vas made. Iam ovet· the age of 18, and not pat1y to 3 the within action. My business address is I07 West Valencia Ave. Burbank. CA 91502. 

### 4 5 6 

### 7 8 9 10 

### 1 1 

### 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 

### 22 )' 

## --' 24 

### 25 26

28 On 10/7/16.! served a copy ofthe following document(s) described as ANSWER TO COMPLAINT on the interested patty(ies) in this action as follows: Lisa M. Toscano, AWP-7.13 Enforcement Division, Western Team PO Box 92007 

### L.A., CA 90009-2007 Federal Aviation Administration 800 Independence Avenue, S.W. Washington, D.C. 20591 Attn: Hearino- Docket Clerk, AGC-430 Wilbur Wrigj';t Bldg- Suite 2Wl 000



### X By Mail: By placing a true copy thereofenclosed in a sealed envelopc(s) addressed as above. and placing each for collection and mailing on that date following ordinary business practices. I am ..readily familiar
.. with this business's practices tor collecting and processing correspondence for mailing. 

### By Overnight Delivery: 

### I enclosed the documents in an envelope or package provided by an overnight delivery carrierand addressed as above. I placed the envelope orpackage for collection and overnight delivery at an ofllce or a regularly utilized drop box of'the overnight delivery carrier. By Facsimile: Based on an agreement ofthe parties to accept service by 

### t:1x transmission. I t'axed the documents to the persons at the fax numbers listed above. _X_ By E-Mail or Electronic Transmission: I caused the documents to be sent to the persons at the e-mail addresses listed above. Idid not receive. within a reasonable time after the transmission. any electronic message or other indication that the transmission was unsuccessful.

X State: I declare under penalty ofperjury under the laws ofthe State ofCalifornia that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on the above date at Los Angeles. California. /S/ Reza Sina

Reza Sina**~~------~------------------~4_-** 

### ____________________________ _ ,-\'\SWER Exhibit E 8