DIRECT DIAL

7 I 3-655-5 I 60

DIRECT FAX

888-329-2286

SKADDEN, ARPS, SLATE, MEAGHER Oc FLOM LLP

1600 SMITH STREET. SUITE 4400

HOUSTON. TEXAS 77002-7348

TEL: (713) 655-5100

FAX: (713) 655-5200

www.skadden.com

EMAIL ADDRESS

SCHWAR1(gSKADDEN. COM

March 10, 2005

(Via Federal Express)

Charles R. Fulbruge III Clerk

United States Cour of Appeals

for the Fifth Circuit

600 Camp Street

New Orleans, LA 70130

FIRM/AFFILIATE OFFICES

BOSTON

CHICAGO

LOS ANGELES

NEWARK

NEW YORK

PALO ALTO

RESTON

SAN FRANCISCO

WASHINGTON, D.

WILMINGTON

BEIJING

BRUSSELS

FRANKFURT

HONG KONG

LONDON

MOSCOW

PARIS

SINGAPORE

SYDNEY

TOKYO

TORONTO

VIENNA

No. Chicago Bridge Iron Company

V. and Chicago Bridge and Iron Company v. Federal

Trade Commission; In the United States Cour of

Appeals for the Fifth Circuit

RE:

Dear Mr. Fulbruge:

Enclosed for filing in the above-referenced matter, please find an original and

four (4) copies ofthe following documents:

Petition for Review of the Order and Opinion of the Federal Trade

Commission (3 additional service copies of the Petition for Review

are also enclosed.

Service Instrctions for Respondent, pursuant to FED. R. APP. P.

15(c);

Certificate of Interested Paries; and

Our firm s check in the amount of $250. 00 for the fiing fee.

Pursuant to FED. R. APP. P. 15(c), please serve the Respondent and

Respondent' s counsel as indicated on the enclosed Service Instrctions.
Charles R. Fulbruge, III, Clerk

March 10, 2005

Page 2

The Federal Trade Commission issued both a public version of its opinion

and an in camera version of its Opinion dated December 21 2004.

Petitioners have attached a copy of the public version of the Opinion to their

Petition for Review.

Enclosed in the attached envelope are four copies of the in camera version of

the Commission s December 21 , 2004 Opinion.

Please file stamp the extra copies of the enclosed documents and retu them

to me in the enclosed self-addressed and stamped envelope.

Sincerely,

AS. kvcAr

Charles W. Schwarz

Enclosures

cc: Nada Sulaiman

Winston & Strawn

1400 L Street, NW

Washington, DC 20005

Jeffrey A. Leon

Duane M. Kelley

Winston & Strawn

315 W. Wacker Drive

Chicago, IL 60601-9703
ORIGINA

IN THE'UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEAL

FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

NO.

:Db bO .

CHICAGO BRIDGE & IRON COMPANY N.V., a foreign corporation; and

CHICAGO BRIDGE & IRON COMPANY, 

Petitioners,

V. .

FEDERA TRAE COMMISSION,

Respondent.

PETITION FOR REVIEW

Chicago Bridge & Iron Company N.V. and Chicago Bridge & Iron

Company, hereby petition the Cour for review of the Order and Opinion of the

Federal Trade Commission entered in In re Chicago Bridge Iron Company, 

a/. Docket No. 9300, on December 21 2004.

Pursuant to Local Rule 15. , a copy of the public version of the Order and

Opinion to be reviewed are attached as Exhibits A and B, respectively.
Dated: March 11 , 2005

Respectfully submitted

LJAS. 

Charles W. Schwarz

SKADEN , SLATE, MEAGHER

& FLOM LLP

1600 Smith, Suite 4400

Houston, TX 77002-7348

Telephone No. : 713-655-5160

Facsimile No. : 888-329-2286

OF COUNSEL:

Clifford H. Aronson

SKADEN , SLATE, MEAGHER

& FLOM LLP

Four Times Square

New York, NY 10036-6522

(212) 735-2644

(917) 777-2644 - fax

ATTORNEYS FOR CHICAGO BRIDGE

& IRON COMPANY N.V. AND CHICAGO

BRIDGE & IRON COMPAN
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Pursuant to FED. R. APP. P. 15(c), I hereby certify that on March 10

2005, a tre and correct copy of the foregoing was served on the following persons

who were admitted to partcipate in the Agency proceedings by first class mail:

Nada Sulaiman

Winston & Strawn

1400 L Street, NW

Washington, DC 20005

Jeffrey A. Leon

Duane M. Kelley

Winston & Strawn

315 W. Wacker Drive

Chicago, IL 60601-9703

eJs. fc,

Charles W. Schwartz
IN THE UNTED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

NO.

CHICAGO BRIDGE & IRON COMPANY N.V., a foreign corporation; and

CHICAGO BRIDGE & IRON COMPANY,

Petitioners,

FEDERAL TRAE COMMISSION,

Respondent.

SERVICE INSTRUCTIONS

Pursuant to FED. R. APP. P. 15(c), the Circuit Clerk must serve a copy of the

Petition for Review on the following:

Donald S. Clark Secretary 

Federal Trade Commission

Room H- 159

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.

Washington, D.C. 20580

Rhett R. Krlla, Esq.

Assistant Director

Bureau of Competition

Federal Trade Commission

Room S-3602

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.

Washigton, D.C. 20580

Steven L. Wilensky, Esq.

Federal Trade Commission

601 New Jersey Avenue, N.

Room NJ-6l20

Washington, D.C. 20001
OF COUNSEL:

Clifford H. Aronson

SKADEN, ~s, SLATE, MEAGHER

& FLOM LLP

F our Times Square

New York, NY 10036-6522

(212) 735-2644

(917) 777-2644 - fax

Respectfully submitted

eA"s. 

Charles W. Schwarz

SKADEN, ARs, SLATE, 11EAGHER

& FLOM LLP

1600 Smith, Suite 4400

Houston, TX 77002-7348

(713) 655-5160

(888) 329-2286 - fax

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Pursuant to FED. R. APP. P. 15(c), I hereby certify that on March 10

2005 , a tre and correct copy of the foregoing was served on the following persons

who were admitted to participate in the Agency proceedings by first class mail:

Nada Sulaiman

Winston & Strawn

1400 L Street, NW

Washington, DC 20005

Jeffrey A. Leon

Duane M. Kelley

Winston & Strawn

315 W. Wacker Drive

Chicago, IL6060 1-9703

eA1I5. 

Charles W. Schwarz
f' J

. )

IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT

NO.

CHICAGO BRIDGE & IRON COMPANY N.V., a foreign corporation; and

CmCAGO BRIDGE & IRON COMPANY,

Petitioners,

FEDERA TRAE COMMISSION,

Respondent.

CERTIFICATE OF INTERESTED PERSONS

Pursuant to FED. R. APP. P. 26. , Petitioners state that Chicago Bridge &

Iron Company is a wholly-owned subsidiar of Chicago Bridge & Iron Company

V. Chicago Bridge & Iron Company N.V. is a publicly-held corporation, and no

publicly-held corporation owns 10% or more of its stock.
Respectfully submitted

eA A

. ) 

c. 

Charles W. Schwarz

SKADEN, ARs, SLATE, MEAGHER

& FLaM LLP

1600 Smith, Suite 4400

Houston, TX 77002-7348

(713) 655-5160

(888) 329-2286 - fax

OF COUNSEL:

Clifford H. Aronson

SKADEN, ARs, SLATE, 11EAGHER

& FLaM LLP

Four Times Square

New York, NY 10036-6522

(212) 735-2644

(917) 777-2644 - fax

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Pursuant to FED. R. APP. P. l5(c), I hereby certify that on 11arch 10

2005, a tre and correct copy of the foregoing was served on the following persons

who were admitted to participate in the Agency proceedings by first class mail:

Nada Sulaiman

Winston & Strawn

1400 L Street, NW

Washington, DC 20005

Jeffrey A. Leon

Duane M. Kelley

Winston & Strawn

315 W. Wacker Drive

Chicago, IL 60601-9703

C1lIf 

Charles W. Schwartz
01 RECT DIAL

713-655-5160

01 RECT FAX

888-329-2286

EMAIL ADDRESS

SCHWAR1(gSKADDEN . COM

SKADDEN, ARPS, SLATE:, rI- 1600SMITHSTREE: LJI1E: 

HOUSTON. TEXAS -; 2-'7 -:40 ..4 a 

TEL: (713) E5.5.! -.= 

FAX:(713) E5.5

.

www.skadde - C:

FlOfv

arch 10 

AAL TRADE COAt

.. 

P!3Ct: '1"'S,.

D DOCIJMENrs

MAR 

/ 

?,i

. ""',1

Donald S. Clark

Secretary

Federal Trade Commission

Room H- 159

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.

Washington, D.C. 20580

Rhett R. Krlla

Assistant Director

Federal Trade Commission

Bureau of Competition

Room S-3602

600 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.

Washington, D.C. 20580

Steven L. Wilen

Federal Trade ky 

60 1 New. 

erse UUlsSiol1 Roo NJ-612 -A\Tel1ue

W- N. ashington DC

. 20001

RE: No. Chicago B '

V. and Chicago Bridge ;: ge 

&: 

Iron Trade Commissi n; In the U C071PQny l1any

eals for the FIfth Circuit Ilted 

States 

Pederal

oll 

Gentlemen:

Enclosed are courtesy copies of the docl1 

attachments) in the Fifth Circuit Cour of Appeals. 

el1 S We

filed WIthout

Under FED. R. CIY. P. 15(c), the Clerk of the C 

service of the Petition for Review and related documel1ts. 

o1l W11l 

effect ol1al

Sincerely,

CAAS. 

Charles W. Schwarz

Enclosures