p.1 

OAR Box 1828 

Prepped by Ollie Stewart 

Document Number: 

278) ll-K- (I) -91 

Docket Number: 

A-83-27 

Printed 11/12/2008 11:12:58 AM Sheet 278 of 325 
1990 PROJECTED NEW INDUSTRIAL FOSSIL FUEL-FIRED BOILER 

AIR EMISSIONS, FUEL DEMAND, AND COSTS 

(5TH ROUND S02 NSPS ANALYSIS — REFERENCE CASE FUEL PRICES) 

PREPARED FOR: 

THE U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY 

PREPARED BY: 

ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS, INC. 

1655 NORTH FORT MYER DRIVE 

ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 22209 

07/26/8* 

I 

7* 

vO 

CO 

ho 
NOTES ON IFCAM PROJECTIONS 

************************** 

i. REVISED NATH SCRUBBER COSTS 

LSD FGD RESTRICTED TO LOW SULFUR COAL TYPES (B AND D ONLY) 

INCLUDES ESTIMATES OF INTEREST DURING CONSTRUCTION. 

2. BASE CASE 

- S02: CURRENT NSPS 

- PM: PROPOSED NSPS (49 FR 25103) 

- NOX: LEA OR SCA REQUIRED C> 100 MMBTU/HR) 

3. OPTION CASE 1 

- COAL TYPE B, 0.3 AND 0.8 PERCENT SULFUR RESIDUAL FUEL OILS ARE 

IN COMPLIANCE 

- AT LEAST 50 PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED ON NON-COMPLIANCE FUELS 

•>. OPTION CASE 2 

- NO COMPLIANCE COAL TYPES 

- 0.3 AND 0.8 PERCENT SULFUR RESIDUAL FUEL OIL ARE IN COMPLIANCE 

- AT LEAST 50 PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED ON NON-COMPLIANCE FUELS 

5. OPTION CASE 3 

- NO COMPLIANCE COAL TYPES 

- 0.3 PERCENT SULFUR RESIDUAL FUEL OIL IS IN COMPLIANCE 

- 70-90 PERCENT S02 REMOVAL REQUIRED ON NON-COMPLIANCE FUELS 

co 
P.4 

o 

I A 

CJ 

A 

LU Ui O 

Z Z 1*1 

o o • Z Z o 

U O O 

Z 9* ro 

O • • 

Z o o 

o o •* 

cr* 9* ro 

o o. . o . 

o ttt ttt o 

cr* o o r» 

ooo • • •o * 

Ui o ui u> 

Z o z co 

O • O • 

__ o z o IA 

UJ o uj o 

Z o z OJ 

o • o • 

Z o z -• 

in 

o 

Ul 

OJ 

o 

o 

OJ 

• UJ UJ o 

Z Z OJ 

o o • 

Z Z o 

Ul UJ o 

Z Z OJ 

O O • 

Z Z o 

Olllr t 

IT" Z IO 

• O • 

O z o 

o ut o o 

o o OJ -o 

OOO • . *O * 

Ui O UJ l/l 

Z o z <0 

o • o • 

Z o z o 

un 

Ul o tu o 

Z O Z OJ 

o • o • 

Z o z -t 

in 

z 

o 

M 

I -

n. 

m 

tn < 

in 

a 

CE 

< 

a 

z < 

r- ~ 

in 

UJ c j 

i_> i o 

z -* 

< o 

E cc 

a < 

o — 

u. 

CK - t 

UJ 

a. UJ 

V) 

iu < 

o u 

_.Z 

o o 

10 H 

3 a. 

Ui O 

3 

a 

z 

t-

< 

CC 

X 

N 

3 

>-

03 

E 

5-

a. 

o 

o 

uj 

rsi 

a: 

UJ 

o 

CO 

o 

o 

o 

IA 

o 

IA 

I 

o 

o 

o 

o 

I 

IA 

run 

o 

in 

o 

IA 

O 

ro 

o 

ro 

o 

Ul Ui o 

Z Z OJ 

o o • 

Z Z o 

Ul UJ o 

Z Z OJ 

o o • 

Z Z o 

Ul Ul o 

Z Z oj 

o o > 

z z o 

Ui Ul o 

Z Z OJ 

o o • Z Z o 

UJ Ui Ul 

Z Z Z 

O O O 

z z z 

Ul Ul Ul 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

Ui Ui Ul 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

Ui Ui Ul 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

Ul Ul Ui 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

Ui Ui Ui 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

Ui 111 Ul 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

Ui Ul Ul 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

• o • 

o z o 

O UJ - t 

o> z ro 

• o • 

o z o 

UJ Ul Ul 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

UJ UJ UJ 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

UJ Ui Ul 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

O IA O O 

CA O OJ •© 

OOO O 

O IA O O 

OOO O 

Ui Ui Ui Ul 

zzz z ooo o zzz z 

0 1 

z 

o 

(H 

Ui ui ui ui rz z z z < 

ooo o -• 

ZZZ Z 3 

(9 

Ul 

CE 

(9 

z 

U! Ul HI UJ M 

ZZZ Z CO 

OOO O 03 

ZZZ Z 3 

CE 

u 

OT CE 

Ui Ui Ul Ul o 

ZZZ Z Io o o o < 

zzz z | 

•< 

JE 

Ul O Ul IA Z O z <o 

o • o • 

Z O Z O 

IA 

Ul o ui un 

Z O Z CO 

o • o • 

Z O Z O 

IA 

Ul Ul Ul Ul 

zzz z ooo o zzz z 

Ul Ul Ul Ul 

zzz z ooo o zzz z 

Ui Ul Ul Ul 

ooo o 

zzz z 

Ul Ul Ui Ul 

zzz z ooo o zzz z 

Ul O Ul o 

Z o Z oj 

o • o • 

Z O z -i 

IA 

Ul o Ul o 

Z o Z oj 

o • o • Z o z -. 

IA 

Ui Ul Ui Ul 

zzz z ooo o zzz z 

Ul Ul Ul Ul 

zzz z ooo o zzz z 

Ul Ui Ul Ui 

zzz z ooo o zzz z 

Ui Ui Ul Ul 

zzz z ooo o zzz z 

o 

00 

(A 

3 

a 

z 

3 — 3 

i - 3 r03 Hr: oa OT E E 

< x E o oo X 

_ l 03 

_ l 1 

<CE —19 

3 z o 

1 - M z 

4 J H 

Z M - J 

Ul M 

( J Ui 

U 

OJ 

O JE 

OT a. 

m E 

E 

X 

CO 

- J 

w 

o 

M ^-. 

- 1 

M 

U i 

u 

X 

o 

z 

J 3 - 3 

Ui i- 3 r3 03 »-

______ _z _z 

ui \ l: 

hffl \ 

< - 1 03 

_ l — _> 

_ l — 

M 19 

r- Z O 

OT Hi Z 

H J H 

O M —1 

UJ M 

U Ui 

u OJ 

O JE 

OT a 

03 

E 

X 

00 

_ 1 

^ 

o 

z H t 

- 1 

M 

U i 

u 

X 

o 

z 

o 

—1 

UJ 

3 

u. 

_ 1 

•«-1 » 

o 

M 

OT 

U i 

CE 

3 — 3 

r- 3 rto y- oo 

i o n 

E Z E 

X E X 

03 X 03 

-1 03 -J 

w _ l w 

(9 ( w 9 

Z 19 Z 

l-l Z M 

- 1 M - I 

IH J M 

Ul M Ul 

u u u 

u 

OJ X 

o r o 

OT a z 

3 — 3 

r- 3 rCO r- 03 

E ca £ 

E E JS 

x r 3 x 

03 X U 03 

-I CO -I 

• I N — — o 

19 to (9 

-i Z 19 V Z 

< M Z l-l 

O JH K J 

U >-l - J O M 

Ui HH U. Ui 

U Ui U 

U • 

OJ X 

O S o 

OT a. z 

_ l 

M 

o ***• 

-1 3 Ul h3 03 

U. E 

E 

-1 X 

o UJ 

CE 

M 

3 

CO 

O E 

U i 

CE 

I-t 

3 

a 

UCE i 

_ i 

< •> 

o 

ar- z 

U l 

a 

- J 

< > o E 

UJ 

< CO CE 

3 -1 

O — 

t -t 

OT CE 

UJ o 

OJ 

o OT 

aoi -

_J 

u. 

OJ 

o OT 

z UJ 

(CE ) 

UJ 

a. 

U i 

CE 

OJ 

n 

OT 

rU"* i 

u 

rr 

U l 

a. 

E 

3 

M -. 

M ." 

E 

E 

X 

00 

__ — 

_ 1 

< o o 

K 

o 

u. 

z 

o M 

1 -

0. 

E 

U l 

X 

UJ 

CE 

3 

u. 

- J 

3 

OT 

3 

CJ 

_ l 

^3 » 

r03 

E 

E 

X 

03 

- J 

w 

-J 

< CE 

o o 

oo 

a E 

C E * 

M CO 

3 - 1 

U l 

CE - J 

a < ui -1 O 

CE < ( J 

M > 

3 O CE 

aU E o J UJ u. 

CE CE 

Z 

- I OJ O 

< O H 

> OT ro a E t- E 

ui Z UJ 

CE UJ X 

u ui 

OJ CE 

O UJ CE 

OT a 3 

u. 

O O 1 - E -1 

—1 

u. 

OJ 

O 

OT 

Z 3 3 

Ui E OT 

U l-l 

CE Z 3 

Ui t-t O 

a. E -J 
P.5 

o CO 

< 

M CK 

OT 

3 

o IA OJ 

UJ Ul o 

Z Z ro O o • Z Z o 

U O O Z - t ro O • • 

Z o o 

o o — 0> 9. IO 

o o . . o . 

O IA Ifl O 

»OO h 

OOO • • •O • 

u o u IA Z o Z <0 o . o • Z o z o IA 

u o u u Z o Z z o • o o Z o z z •A 

o IA OJ 

UJ u o 

Z Z OJ o o • Z z o 

Ul Ui o 

Z Z CJ O O • Z Z O 

o ui - * 

Cf z ro • O • 

O Z O 

O IA O O 

o o oj >o 

ooo * . •o . 

U O U IA Z O Z CO O • O • Z o z o IA 

u o u u z o z z O • O O Z o z Z 

Ifl 

OT 

z 

o trH - 0 . 

E 

3 

OT 

OT 

< RDS 

< § r< -

OT 

U 

u Z 

< E CE 

o l i- ce 

u 0 . 

— • ro ro —t 

o CE 

< w OJ 

u 

OT 

u < 

u S 

U 

Z 

o o OT M r- 3 CL 

u 

Z o 

99. -5 

a 

z 

M r-

< 

u 

X CE X= = • 03 

E 

E 

w >• GOR 

u r-

< 

o 

u N 

M 

OT CE 

u - i 

M 

o CO 

o 

o OJ 

1 

o IA - 4 

o IA 

I 

o 

O 9 * 

O 

O 

""* IA 

r>» •A r» i 

o LA 

O IA 

1 

O ro 

o ro 

i 

o 

u u o Z Z o j o o • Z Z o u i u o Z Z OJ o o • Z Z o Ui Ui uj 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z Ui Ui u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

u 

z 

o 

UJ o 

Z oj o • 

Z Z O 

u 

z 

o 

z 

u 

z 

o 

z 

u 

z 

o 

Ul o 

Z oj o • Z O Ui u z z o o z z Uj u i z z o o 

z z z 

u 

z 

o 

Ul u 

z z o o 

z z z 

u 

z 

o 

Ui Ui 

z z o o 

z z z 

o u 

cr- Z • o 

. H ro 

. 

o z o o u o> z • o O Z UJ u z z o o z z Ui u z z o o - 4 ro 

o • 

u 

z 

o 

z 

u 

__ o 

z z z u u 

__ __ o o z z u u z z o o z z 

u 

: o 

z 

u 

z 

o 

z 

o 

o 

• o 

o 

c 

o . 

u 

z 

o 

IA 

o 

o • IA 

o 

o * 

u 

z 

o 

o OJ 

o • 

o OJ 

o . UJ 

z 

o 

z z z 

u 

z 

o 

u 2 

o 

z z UJ 

z 

o 

z 

u 

u 

^ o -r 

u 

z z 

o o 

u _^ o 

z 

u 

_z 

o 

z 

u 2 ; 

o 

z z z 

o <o 

o . 

o 

•o 

o 

u 

z_\ 

o 

z 

u 

2 

o 

z 

u ^ o 

z 

u 

z 

o 

z 

OT 

z 

o 

M 1 -

< _ l 

3 19 

u CE 19 

z M 03 03 

3 CE 

u OT >• CE 

o r-

< a 

z 

u o U IA Z O Z CO o • o • Z o z o IA u o u IA Z O Z CO o • o • Z O Z O i n 

uuu u 

zzz z 

ooo o 

zzz z 

uuu u 

zzz z o o o o 

zzz z 

uuu u 

zzz z 

ooo o 

zzz z 

uuu u 

zzz z 

ooo o 

zzz z 

u 

z 

o 

o u u o z z • o o 

Z O z z 

u 

z 

o 

z 

u 

2 

o 

IA o u u o Z Z • o o o Z Z IA Ui u u 

z z z 

o o o 

zzz z 

u 

z 

o 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

zzz z 

u 

z 

o 

z 

u 

: o 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

zzz z 

^ 3 — 3 «* r- 3 r- 03 h- E ca OT E E < X E O 03 X - 1 03 _ l W _ l < 9_ 

IX 19 3 Z 19 

I-H : < - 1 tH Z tH - J U tH U u 

u 

OJ O E 

OT a. 

03 

9~ 

E 

X OQ - 1 

w ( 9 T" IH _ l •H 

u 

u 

X 

o 

z 

_ l tH 

o _ l UJ 

3 u. 

u r

-

J < _1 

M 

tOT 

M 

o 

~- 3 1 - 03 T~ 

E 

X 03 —1 

w 19 

T 

M 

J tH 

u I J OJ 

o OT 

« 3 t -

m E 

E 

X ca J 

w 

o 

: M _ l IH 

u 

u 

E a. 

3 « r- 00 

E 

E 

X oo J 

w 19 

: tH - J 

M 

u 

u 

X 

o 

z 

- J 

M O 3 ^» - 1 

u 

3 u . _ l 

< 3 

a tH 

OT 

u CE 

H-

03 T~ 

E C\ O _ l 

w 

o TT 

M —1 

•-* UJ 

u CJ 

o VI 

3 « 1 - 03 

E 

E 

X 03 - J 

w 19 T- IH _1 tH UJ 

l_> 

E a . 

^ 3 r- 0 ] 

E 

E 

X 0J 

__ 

._. 19 

z IH _ l tH 

U 

u 

X 

o 

z 

_ l 

< o 

o 

9 9 3 — 1 - 3 CO H- E 03 E E X E 03 X - J 0J w __ 19 w Z 19 tH Z - 1 M H - 1 U tH ( J U 

o 

OJ O E 

OT a 

3 

o 

N 

o ro 

V CE 

o u. 

i 

^ 3 r-oo E 

E 

X 03 —1 

w 19 

Z IH _ l 

M 

U 

U 

X 

o 

z 

- 1 tH 

o 

9 * 

-1 3 

u t~ 

IRED 

3 

VAL REQUIRED 

o 

COAL (LB/MMB CE 

O .E O 

u CE _ l 

3 03 > <

U. _ l 

< 3 a tH 

OT 

U CE 

E 

E 

X ca -_t 

._. 

tx 

o 

o _J u . OJ 

o OT 

O 

E 

u CE OJ 

O 

OT rT 

U 

u CE UJ CL 

u CE OJ 

o OT rT 

u 

0 a: 

u a . 

E 

3 

E tH 

z M 

E 

u . 

z O IH h- a. E 

u 

X 

u CE 

3 u. —J 

3 

OT 

3 

O - 1 

_ i 

< O 

O 

9 9 . 

3 r-CQ 

E 

E 

X 03 

_J 

^ CE 

O 

O 

_J U. OJ 

O 

OT 

IRED 

V AL REQUIRED 

COAL (LB/MMB' 

3 O CE 

a u 

a 

^ < > 0 

E 

u CE OJ 

O 

OT rZ LU 

O CE LU CL 

E O u u . CE 

Z 

OJ 0 O M 

OT 1-

CL 

H E Z U u X u u CE u CE CL 3 U. E - 1 3 3 E OT tH Z 3 M O E -< 
P.6 

OT 

z o t H r-0 . 

E 

3 

OT 

OT 

< RDS 

< 

2 r< -( 0 

u 

u 

z 

< E CE 

O u. CE 

u CL 

U 

U 

5 

o 

OT 

^ 

<»I O • 

H 

o CE 

< ro 

u 

OT 

< U 

Z 

o I H r3 CL u O 

z CC 

u _M ! 

o oa _ i 

M < CE r-1 0 

3 

1 

M 

_ r3 EAT INP 

Z CE 

X 

X 

3 r

-

0 3 

E 

E 

w 5

-GOR 

u rU < 

u 

M t H 

OT CE 

U - 1 

M 

o OJ 

o I A OJ 

A 

o I A 200-2 

o 

o 150-2 

o I A 9 * 

1 

o 

o 

H 

o 

o f H I A o » I A r» 

i 

o I A 

o I A 

1 

o ro 

o ( O 

1 

o 

H 

Ul u o 

Z Z ro O O • Z z o u i u o Z Z OJ O O • Z Z o ui u o Z Z o j o o • Z Z o 

UIUI O Z Z OJ o o • Z Z o 

u u u Z Z Z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z HM -IM 3 — 3 

1 -3 1-

33 r- 0 3 

E tO E 

OT E E E « t X E X t S CO X 0 3 - 1 

tx < 

3 f -

< Z 

-I CO - 1 

— _! _. 1 9 1 w 9 Z 1 9 Z I H Z M - J M - 1 S02 CEI PM CEIL NOX CEI 

OIL 

u o o Z — ro o • • 

z o o U i U i o Z Z OJ o o • z z o u u o Z Z OJ o o • z z o u u o Z Z O J o o • Z Z o 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

.—* M 

-13- 3 

u 

3 u. 

u r-_< i _ l 

M rOT I H 

o 

r -3 1-

03 K 0 0 

E 03 E 

E E E X E X CQ X 0 0 - i a j - J w _ J w 1 9 1 ._ 9 Z 1 9 Z I H Z t H - 1 t H - J S02 CEI PM CEIL NOX CEI 

O O 9M o j 9* r o -. o o O U <H OJ Z ro • O • — Z o 

OUIr i OJ z ro • o • -* Z o O U 99, OJ z ro • o • « z o 

u u u Z Z Z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

zzzzzz. 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

z z z 

o o o 

z z z 

_ l I H — — O 3 — 3 r - 3 1 - - 1 0 3 t - 0 3 u E CO E 3 E E E u . X E X CO X CO - 1 - 1 0 0 - 1 < 1 w 3 w a u 19 I H Z 1 9 Z 

OT IH Z I H 

UI-IH- I R S02 CEI PM CEIL NOX CEI 

o IA un o 

OJ o o r> 

-.oo o O I A o o OJ o OJ <o 

9* o o o o ttt o o o j o C J - o - 4 o o o O If l o o CJ O OJ . o 

... . 

.H o o o 

uuu u 

zzz z 

ooo o ZZZ Z 

uuu u ZZZ Z 

ooo o 

zzz z 

uuu u 

zzz z 

ooo o 

zzz z 

uuu u 

zzz z 

ooo o 

zzz z « <•* 3 — 3 r - 3 1 - 0 0 r - 0 0 E tO E E E E X E 3 X 0 3 X U CQ - 1 0 3 __ • 1 X ' w — o 19 ro o 

-1 Z 19 V Z 

< IH Z M 

O —1 IH CE - i 

c 

S02 CEI PM CEIL 

- F0 

NOX CEI 

W 

Z o I H r-

< _ l 

3 1 9 

U ce (9 

Z 

M 0 3 0 0 

3 CE 

U 

OT 5 - CE 

O r-

< a z < 

E 

_ i t H 

o - J 

u 

O O O I A 

•OO O 

O O O 

O O O 

•oo o 

o o o ON r» 

o o o 

4 0 0 

o o o ©• r» 

o o o 4) o o 

o o. . o . 

cr* r* 

u u u Z Z Z 

O O O 

ro 

o IA ro 

o I A ro 

o I A ro 

o • 

u 

z 

o ZZZ Z 

u u u Z Z Z 

o o o 

u 

: o 

zzz z 

u u u 

______ o o o 

z z z 

u u u 

u 

z 

o 

z 

u 

zzz z 

o o o o 

zzz z 

a 

~9 

3 r-0 0 

E 

u E CE 

M 

3 or 

u CE 

QUIRED MOVAL 

u u CE CE 

3 -J O J 

r- < O 

3 tO > OT 

u. _ l 

< 3 

O I H 

OT 

u CE 

E O E E I

-

X u Z t o CE u - i U — OJ CE O L U CE OT CL 

O S02 FLO 

PERCENT 

MINIMUM X CO - 1 

w _ l OR COA u. 

Z 

o I H r-a. 

E 

u 

X 

u CE 

3 u . 1 LOW SUL 

i 

o o o u •o o o z . . . o o o o z o o o u •o o o z . . . o o o o z o o o u 

•o o o z . . . o o o o z C f r » o o c u •o o o z . . . o o o o z ©» r * 

uuu u ZZZ Z 

OOO O 

zzz z 

uuu u ZZZ Z 

OOO O 

zzz z 

uuu u 

zzz z 

ooo o 

zzz z 

uuu u 

zzz z 

ooo o 

zzz z • ^ 

3 1 -

m 

o 5 u E CE X IH ca 3 - 1 

CT — 

u CE - 1 

QUIRED MOVAL OR COA 

uuu . tx tx 

— z 3 - I o j o r - < O M CO > OT r - E O CL E E t- E X u Z u 0 0 CE U X - J u u ~ OJ CK 

_l O u CE 

<t CE OT CL 3 

O O u . C S02 FLO PERCENT MINIMUM LOW SUL 
LIST OF TABLES 

DESCRIPTION OF TABLE TABLE NUMBER 

FUEL DEMAND 

- NUMBER OF UNITS 1 

- BTUS OF FUEL CONSUMPTION 2 

POLLUTANT EMISSIONS 3 

COSTS t, 

NOX ONLY 

- CONTROL COSTS 5 

- EMISSIONS 6 

NATIONAL IMPACTS BY SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

- 10-50 7 

- 50-75 8 

- 75-100 9 

- 100-150 10 

- 150-200 11 

- 200-250 12 

- > 250 13 

- > 100 14 

- 100-250 15 

- > 50 16 

- TOTAL 17 

Tl 
TABLE 1 — 1990 FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

10-50 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

"TOTAL* 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

NATURAL GAS 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

COAL 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

AND OIL 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

1 

2 

3 

1412 

1412 

1412 

1412 

1398 

1398 

1398 

1398 

14 

14 

14 

14 

577. 

577. 

577. 

577. 

556. 

556. 

556. 

556. 

21. 

21. 

21. 

21. 

271. 

271. 

271. 

271. 

265. 

267. 

270. 

271. 

135. 

135. 

135. 

135. 

134. 

134. 

135. 

135. 

62. 

62. 

62. 

62. 

58. 

62. 

62. 

62. 

4. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

136. 

136. 

136. 

136. 

130. 

130. 

132. 

124. 

6. 

6. 

4. 

12. 

2593 

2593 

2593 

2593 

2541 

2547 

2553 

2546 

52 

46 

40 

47 

Tl 

00 
TABLE 2 — 1990 FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

10-50 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

•TOTAL* 

THE BASE CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

NATURAL GAS 

THE BASE CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

1 

2 

3 

1 

2 

3 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

THE BASE CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

COAL 

THE BASE CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

OPTION CASE 

1 

2 

3 

1 

2 

3 

132. 

132. 

132. 

132. 

34. 

34. 

34. 

34. 

94. 

94. 

94. 

94. 

4. 

4. 

4. 

4. 

136. 

136. 

136. 

136. 

26. 

26. 

26. 

26. 

101. 

101. 

101. 

101. 

8. 

8. 

8. 

8. 

129. 

129. 

129. 

129. 

26. 

56. 

58. 

72. 

99. 

70. 

70. 

57. 

4. 

3. 

1. 

0. 

111. 

111. 

111. 

111. 

24. 

50. 

51. 

54. 

86. 

60. 

60. 

57. 

1. 

1. 

0. 

0. 

67. 

67. 

67. 

67. 

15. 

33. 

33. 

34. 

46. 

34. 

34. 

33. 

6. 

0. 

0. 

0. 

191. 

191. 

191. 

191. 

87. 

87. 

91. 

107. 

92. 

92. 

92. 

59. 

13. 

13. 

9. 

26. 

766. 

766. 

766. 

766. 

212. 

286. 

293. 

328. 

518. 

452. 

452. 

401. 

35. 

28. 

21. 

37. 

Tl 

CO 
TABLE 3 — 1990 EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

10-50 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

S02 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

PM 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

NOX 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

PMIO 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

1 

2 

3 

1 

2 

3 

1 

2 

3 

107. 

107. 

107. 

107. 

10. 

10. 

10. 

10. 

19. 

19. 

19. 

19. 

9. 

9. 

9. 

9. 

114. 

114. 

114. 

114. 

10. 

10. 

10. 

10. 

21. 

21. 

21. 

21. 

10. 

10. 

10. 

10. 

105. 

28. 

27. 

13. 

8. 

4. 

4. 

3. 

15. 

13. 

12. 

13. 

8. 

4. 

4. 

3. 

82. 

24. 

23. 

13. 

7. 

3. 

3. 

4. 

14. 

12. 

12. 

13. 

7. 

3. 

3. 

4. 

52. 

14. 

14. 

8. 

4. 

2. 

2. 

2. 

9. 

8. 

8. 

8. 

4. 

2. 

2. 

2. 

41. 

40. 

38. 

13. 

4. 

4. 

4. 

3. 

21. 

21. 

20. 

23. 

4. 

4. 

4. 

3. 

500 

327 

322 

268 

42 

33 

33 

32 

99 

93 

91 

96 

41 

32 

32 

31 

Tl 

o 
TABLE 4 — 1990 COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

10-50 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

ANNUALIZED COSTS - TOTAL 

THE BASE CASE 1215.4 

OPTION CASE 1 1215.4 

OPTION CASE 2 1215.4 

OPTION CASE 3 1215.4 

CAPITAL COSTS - TOTAL 

THE BASE CASE 1290.1 

OPTION CASE 1 1290.1 

OPTION CASE 2 1290.1 

OPTION CASE 3 1290.1 

1041.9 

1041.9 

1041.9 

1041.9 

1154.3 

1154.3 

1154.3 

1154.3 

900.9 

926.2 

927.0 

941.9 

812.6 

778.7 

749.7 

763.4 

728.5 

749.3 

749.2 

761.2 

511.5 

501.4 

485.7 

514.0 

445.3 

455.6 

455.6 

459.8 

359.4 

293.7 

293.7 

301.5 

1274.6 

1274.7 

1275.9 

1310.9 

904.8 

904.9 

861.6 

1073.5 

5606.6 

5663.2 

5665.0 

5731.2 

5032.7 

4923.1 

4835.2 

5096.7 
TABLE 5 — 1990 NOX CONTROL ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

10-50 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

•TOTAL* 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

NATURAL GAS 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

COAL 

THE BASE 

OPTION 

OPTION 

OPTION 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

AND OIL 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

CASE 

1 

2 

3 

1 

2 

3 

-2.3 

-2.3 

-2.3 

-2.3 

-2.3 

-2.3 

-2.3 

-2.3 

-0.0 

-0.0 

-0.0 

-0.0 

-5.2 

-5.2 

-5.2 

-5.2 

-5.3 

-5.3 

-5.3 

-5.3 

8.0 

-1.2 

-1.4 

-1.6 

7.8 

-1.4 

-1.4 

-1.6 

0.2 

0.2 

0.0 

0.0 

4.9 

-1.1 

-1.3 

-0.9 

4.9 

-1.2 

-1.3 

-0.9 

0.1 

0.1 

0.0 

0.0 

1.1 

6.0 

6.0 

5.6 

1.5 

6.0 

6.0 

5.6 

0.4 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

-19.9 

-19.9 

-20.7 

-18.6 

-20.6 

-20.6 

-21.2 

-20.0 

0.7 

0.7 

0.5 

1.4 

-15.7 

-35.8 

-36.9 

-34.4 

-17.1 

-36.8 

-37.4 

-35.8 

1.4 

0.9 

0.5 

1.4 
TABLE 6 — 1990 NOX EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

10-50 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

50-100 100-150 150-200 200-250 > 250 TOTAL 

*TOTAL* 

THE BASE CASE 

OPTION CASE 1 

OPTION CASE 2 

OPTION CASE 3 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

THE BASE CASE 

OPTION CASE 1 

OPTION CASE 2 

OPTION CASE 3 

COAL 

THE BASE CASE 

OPTION CASE 1 

OPTION CASE 2 

OPTION CASE 3 

18.8 

18.8 

18.8 

18.8 

18.2 

18.2 

18.2 

18.2 

0 . 6 

0 . 6 

0 . 6 

0 . 6 

20.8 

20.8 

20.8 

20.8 

18.7 

18.7 

18.7 

18.7 

2 . 1 

2 . 1 

2 . 1 

2 . 1 

15.2 

12.5 

12.2 

12.6 

14.1 

11.8 

12.0 

12.6 

1.1 

0 . 7 

0 . 2 

0 . 0 

13.6 

12.0 

11.8 

12.9 

13.3 

11.7 

11.8 

12.9 

0 . 3 

0 . 3 

0 . 0 

0 . 0 

9.4 

7.8 

7.8 

8.0 

7.8 

7.8 

7.8 

8.0 

1.6 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

20.8 

20.8 

20.0 

22.9 

17.2 

17.2 

17.6 

15.7 

3.6 

3.6 

2.4 

7.2 

98.6 

92.7 

91.3 

96.0 

69.4 

85.4 

86.1 

86.2 

9.2 

7.3 

5.2 

9.8 
TABLE 7 INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

10-50 THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL* 

1398. 

14. 

1412. 

1398. 

14. 

1412. 

1398. 

14. 

1412. 

1398. 

14. 

1412. 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

34. 

0. 

94. 

4. 

132. 

34. 

0. 

94. 

4. 

132. 

34. 

0. 

94. 

4. 

132. 

34. 

0. 

94. 

4. 

132. 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

107.2 

9.5 

18.8 

9.0 

107.2 

9.5 

18.8 

9.0 

107.2 

9.5 

18.8 

9.0 

107.2 

9.5 

18.8 

9.0 

EMISSIONS 

{Y. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

*TOTAL* 

571.2 

1.8 

-2.3 

644.7 

1215.4 

571.2 

1.8 

-2.3 

644.7 

1215.4 

571.2 

1.8 

-2.3 

644.7 

1215.4 

571.2 

1.8 

-2.3 

644.7 

1215.4 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

17. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

"TOTAL* 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

*TOTAL» 

1255. 

4. 

31. 

1290. 

1255. 

4. 

31. 

1290. 

1255. 

4. 

31. 

1290. 

1255. 

4. 

31. 

1290. 

Tl 
TABLE 8 — INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

50-75 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL* 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

EMISSIONS 

{•/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982)' 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

*TOTAL* 

THE BASE 

CASE 

390. 

12. 

402. 

16. 

0. 

62. 

4. 

63. 

70.2 

6.1 

12.7 

5.9 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

251.1 

3.9 

-3.1 

395.6 

647.5 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

390. 

12. 

402. 

16. 

0. 

62. 

4. 

83. 

70.2 

6.1 

12.7 

5.9 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

2511ll 

3.9 

-3.1 

395.6 

647.5 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

390. 

12. 

402. 

16. 

0. 

62. 

4. 

83. 

70.2 

6.1 

12.7 

5.9 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

O.O 

251.1 

3.9 

-3.1 

395.6 

647.5 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

390. 

12. 

402. 

16. 

0. 

62. 

4. 

83. 

70.2 

6.1 

12.7 

5.9 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

251.1 

3.9 

-3.1 

395.6 

647.5 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(X CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

«TOTAL* 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

•TOTAL* 

712. 

9. 

10. 

731. 

712. 

9. 

10. 

731. 

712. 

9. 

10. 

731. 

712. 

9. 

10. 

731. 
TABLE 9 — 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

75-100 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS ANO OIL 

COAL 

* TOTAL* 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL* 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

EMISSIONS 

{•/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

•TOTAL* 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

{•/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

•TOTAL* 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

•TOTAL* 

INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

THE BASE 

CASE 

166. 

9. 

175. 

11. 

0. 

39. 

4. 

54. 

43.3 

4.3 

8.1 

4.2 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

138.8 

2.8 

-2.2 

255.0 

394.4 

0.0 

413. 

6. 

5. 

424. 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

166. 

9. 

175. 

11. 

0. 

39. 

4. 

54. 

43.3 

4.3 

8.1 

4.2 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

138.8 

2.8 

-2.2 

255.0 

394.4 

0.0 

413. 

6. 

5. 

424. 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

166. 

9. 

175. 

11. 

0. 

39. 

4. 

54. 

43.3 

4.3 

8.1 

4.2 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

138.8 

2.8 

-2.2 

255.0 

394.4 

0.0 

413. 

6. 

5. 

424. 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

166. 

9. 

175. 

11. 

0. 

39. 

4. 

54. 

43.3 

4.3 

8.1 

4.2 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

138.8 

2.8 

-2.2 

255.0 

394.4 

0.0 

-

413. 

6. 

5. 

424. 
TABLE 10 INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

100-150 THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL« 

265 . 

6 . 

271 . 

267 . 

4 . 

271 . 

270 . 

1. 

271 . 

271 . 

0 . 

271 . 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

26. 

0. 

99. 

4. 

129. 

56. 

0. 

70. 

3. 

129. 

58. 

0. 

70. 

1 . 

129. 

72. 

0. 

57. 

0. 

129. 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

104. 8 

8 . 1 

15. 2 

8 . 1 

27. 9 

3 . 5 

12. 5 

3 . 5 

26. 8 

3 . 5 

12. 2 

3 . 5 

12. 8 

3 . 4 

12. 6 

3 . 4 

EMISSIONS 

VA CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

-73.4 

-56.8 

-17.8 

-56.8 

-74.4 

-56.8 

-19.7 

-56.8 

-87.8 

-58.0 

-17.1 

-58.0 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $19821 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

*TOTAL« 

253.6 

8.1 

8.0 

631.1 

900.9 

249.8 

9.2 

-1.2 

668.4 

926.2 

244.2 

8.3 

-1.4 

675.9 

927.0 

242.1 

19.8 

-1.6 

681.7 

941.9 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(Z CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

•TOTAL* 0.0 2.8 2.9 4.6 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

*TOTAL« 

760 . 

2 0 . 

3 2 . 

813 . 

743 . 

2 2 . 

14. 

779 . 

717. 

18. 

1 4 . 

750 . 

707 

42 

14 

763 

TJ 
TABLE 11 INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

150-200 THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL* 

134. 

1. 

135. 

134. 

1. 

135. 

135. 

0 . 

135. 

135. 

0 . 

135. 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIOUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

2 4 . 

0 . 

8 6 . 

1. 

111 . 

5 0 . 

0 . 

6 0 . 

1. 

111 . 

5 1 . 

0 . 

6 0 . 

0 . 

111 . 

5 4 . 

0 . 

5 7 . 

0 . 

111. 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

81.6 

6 . 5 

13.6 

6 . 5 

23.9 

3 . 1 

12.0 

3 . 1 

23.4 

3 . 1 

11.8 

3 . 1 

13.4 

3 . 5 

12.9 

3 . 5 

EMISSIONS 

f/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

0 . 0 

0 . 0 

0 . 0 

0 . 0 

-70.7 

-52.3 

-11.8 

-52.3 

-71. 3 

-52. 3 

-13.2 

-52. 3 

-83.6 

-46.2 

-5.1 

-46.2 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982)' 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

•TOTAL* 

160.3 

6 . 0 

4 . 9 

555.2 

728.5 

160.1 

9 . 2 

-1.1 

581.2 

749.3 

156.7 

8 . 6 

-1. 3 

585.1 

749.2 

156.7 

22.2 

-0.9 

583.3 

761.2 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

iV. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

•TOTAL* 0.0 2.9 2.8 4.5 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

•TOTAL* 

471. 

2 0 . 

2 0 . 

512. 

470. 

2 1 . 

10. 

501. 

456. 

1 9 . 

10. 

486. 

456. 

4 8 . 

10. 

514. 

TJ 

00 
TABLE 12 — INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

200-250 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL« 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL* 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

EMISSIONS 

{•/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

•TOTAL* 

THE BASE 

CASE 

58. 

4. 

62. 

15. 

0. 

46. 

6. 

67. 

52.1 

3.5 

9.4 

3.5 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

115.3 

6.9 

-1.1 

324.2 

445.3 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

62. 

0. 

62. 

33. 

0. 

34. 

0. 

67. 

13.7 

2.2 

7.8 

2.2 

-73.7 

-37.1 

-17.0 

-37.1 

101.4 

8.6 

-6.0 

351.5 

455.6 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

62. 

0. 

62. 

33. 

0. 

34. 

0. 

67. 

13.7 

2.2 

7.8 

2.2 

-73.7 

-37.1 

-17.0 

-37.1 

101.4 

8.6 

-6.0 

351.5 

455.6 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

62. 

0. 

62. 

34. 

0. 

33. 

0. 

67. 

7.9 

2.3 

8.0 

2.3 

-84.8 

-34.3 

-14.9 

-34.3 

101.4 

12.7 

-5.6 

351.3 

459.8 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

{•/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

*TOTAL* 0.0 2.3 2.3 3.3 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

*TOTAL* 

328. 

18. 

14. 

359. 

267. 

18. 

8. 

294. 

267. 

18. 

8. 

294. 

267. 

25. 

9. 

302. 

Tl 

CO 
TABLE 13 — INOUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

> 250 THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS ANO OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL* 

130. 

6. 

136. 

130. 

6. 

136. 

132. 

4. 

136. 

124. 

12. 

136. 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL* 

87. 

0. 

92. 

13. 

91. 

87. 

0. 

92. 

13. 

191. 

91. 

0. 

92. 

9. 

191. 

107. 

0. 

59. 

26. 

191. 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

40.9 

4.3 

20.8 

4.3 

40.4 

4.3 

20.8 

4.3 

37.9 

4.2 

20.0 

4.2 

13.0 

3.1 

22.9 

3.1 

EMISSIONS 

{•/. CHANGE 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

•TOTAL* 

FROM BASE CASE) 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

306.1 

8.4 

-19.9 

980.0 

1274.6 

-1.2 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

306.1 

8.5 

-19.9 

980.0 

1274.7 

-7.3 

-2.3 

-3.8 

-2.3 

297.2 

8.0 

-20.7 

991.4 

1275.9 

-68.2 

-27.9 

10.1 

-27.9 

332.1 

38.8 

-18.6 

958.6 

1310.9 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

f/. CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

•TOTAL* 0.0 0.0 0.1 2.9 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

*TOTAL* 

863. 

23. 

19. 

905. 

863. 

23. 

19. 

905. 

823. 

20. 

19. 

862. 

973 

81 

19 

1074 
TABLE 14 INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

> 100 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS ANO OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

EMISSIONS 

VA CHANGE 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $19821 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

•TOTAL* 

FROM BASE CASE) 

THE BASE 

CASE 

587. 

17. 

604. 

152. 

0. 

323. 

23. 

498. 

279.4 

22.4 

59.0 

22.4 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

835.3 

31.5 

-8.1 

2490.5 

3349.2 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

593. 

11. 

604. 

225. 

0. 

257. 

17. 

498. 

105.9 

13.1 

53.1 

13.1 

-62.1 

-41.5 

-10.0 

-41.5 

817.5 

35.5 

-28.2 

2581.1 

3405.8 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

599. 

5. 

604. 

232. 

0. 

257. 

9. 

498. 

101.8 

13.0 

51.8 

13.0 

-63.6 

-42.0 

-12.2 

-42.0 

799.6 

33.6 

-29.3 

2603.9 

3407.7 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

592. 

12. 

604. 

267. 

0. 

206. 

26. 

498. 

47.1 

12.3 

56.4 

12.3 

-83.1 

-45.1 

-4.4 

-45.1 

832.3 

93.5 

-26.8 

2574.9 

3473.9 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

VA CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

*TOTAL* 0.0 1.7 1.7 3.7 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

*TOTAL* 

2422. 

82. 

84. 

2588. 

2343. 

84. 

51. 

2479. 

2264. 

76. 

51. 

2391. 

2404. 

196. 

52. 

2652. 

Tl 
TABLE 15 INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

100-250 THE BASE 

CASE 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

457. 

11. 

468. 

463. ifl 

468. 

467. 

1. 

468. 

468. 

0. 

468. 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

65. 

0. 

231. 

11. 

307. 

138. 

0. 

165. 

4. 

307. 

141. 

0. 

165. 

1. 

307. 

160. 

0. 

147. 

0. 

307. 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

238.5 

18.1 

38.2 

18.1 

65.5 

8.8 

32.3 

8.8 

63.9 

8.8 

31.8 

6.8 

34.1 

9.2 

33.5 

9.2 

EMISSIONS 

VA CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

72.5 

51.4 

15.4 

51.4 

-73.2 

-51.4 

-16.8 

-51.4 

-85.7 

-49.2 

-12.3 

-49.2 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

•TOTAL* 

529.2 

23.1 

11.8 

1510.5 

2074.7 

511.3 

27.0 

-8.3 

1601.1 

2131.1 

502.4 

25.6 

-8.6 

1612.5 

2131.8 

500.2 

54.7 

-8.2 

1616.3 

2163.0 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

VA CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

*TOTAL« 0.0 2.7 2.8 4.3 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

•TOTAL* 

1559. 

59. 

66. 

1664. 

1480. 

61. 

32. 

1574. 

1441. 

56. 

32. 

1529. 

1431 

115 

33 

1579 
TABLE 16 — INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

> 50 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

•TOTAL* 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

EMISSIONS 

VA CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

*TOTAL* 

THE BASE 

CASE 

1143. 

38. 

1161. 

178. 

0. 

425. 

32. 

634. 

392.9 

32.8 

79.8 

32.5 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

1225.2 

38.2 

-13.3 

3141.1 

4391.1 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

1149. 

32. 

1181. 

251. 

0. 

358. 

25. 

634. 

219.4 

23.5 

73.9 

23.2 

-44.2 

-28.4 

-7.4 

-28.6 

1207.3 

42.2 

-33.5 

3231.6 

4447.7 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

1155. 

26. 

1181. 

258. 

0. 

358. 

17. 

634. 

215.3 

23.4 

72.6 

23.1 

-45.2 

-28.7 

-9.0 

-28.9 

1189.4 

40.3 

-34.6 

3254.4 

4449.6 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

1148. 

33. 

1181. 

293. 

0. 

307. 

34. 

634. 

160.6 

22.7 

77.2 

22.4 

-59.1 

-30.8 

-3.3 

-31.1 

1222.1 

100.2 

-32.0 

3225.5 

4515.8 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

VA CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

*TOTAL* 0.0 1.3 1.3 2.8 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

*TOTAL* 

3547. 

97. 

99. 

3743. 

3466. 

99. 

65. 

3633. 

3389. 

91. 

65. 

3545. 

3529. 

212. 

67. 

3807. 

ro 

co 
TABLE 17 — INDUSTRIAL BOILER NSPS NATIONAL IMPACTS BY BOILER SIZE, 1986-1990 

BOILER SIZE (MMBTU/HR) 

TOTAL 

FUEL DEMAND 

(NUMBER OF UNITS) 

NATURAL GAS AND OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL* 

FUEL DEMAND 

(10**12 BTUS) 

NATURAL GAS t 

DISTILLATE FUEL OIL 

RESIDUAL FUEL OIL 

COAL 

*TOTAL» 

EMISSIONS 

(10**3 TONS) 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

EMISSIONS 

VA CHANGE 

S02 

PM 

NOX 

PMIO 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

(10**6, $1982)* 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

FUEL 

•TOTAL* 

FROM BASE CASE) 

THE BASE 

CASE 

2541. 

52. 

2593. 

212. 

0. 

518. 

35. 

766. 

500.1 

42.4 

98.6 

41.4 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

0.0 

1796.4 

40.0 

-15.7 

3785.8 

5606.6 

OPTION 

CASE 1 

2547. 

46. 

2593. 

286. 

0. 

452. 

28. 

766. 

326.6 

33.0 

92.7 

32.1 

-34.7 

-22.2 

-6.0 

-22.5 

1778.6 

44.1 

-35.8 

3876.3 

5663.2 

OPTION 

CASE 2 

2553. 

40. 

2593. 

293. 

0. 

452. 

21. 

766. 

322.4 

33.0 

91.3 

32.0 

-35.5 

-22.2 

-7.4 

-22.7 

1760.7 

42.2 

-36.9 

3899.1 

5665.0 

OPTION 

CASE 3 

2546. 

47. 

2593. 

328. 

0. 

401. 

37. 

766. 

267.9 

32.3 

96.0 

31.3 

-46.4 

-23.8 

-2.6 

-24.4 

1793.4 

102.1 

-34.4 

3870.1 

5731.2 

ANNUALIZED COSTS 

VA CHANGE FROM BASE CASE) 

•TOTAL* 0.0 1.0 1.0 2.2 

CAPITAL COSTS 

(10**6, $1982) 

BOILER 

FGD AND PM 

NOX 

*TOTAL* 

4803. 4724. 

101. 103. 

130. 96. 

5033. 4923. 

4645. 4784. 

94. 215. 

96. 97. 

4835. 5097.