10/06/201 1 12:3 0 FA X 2023935U 2 FA A OM S 001/02 2

U.S . DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTA.TIO N

OFFIC EO FHEARING S FEDERA LAVIATIO N ADMINISTRATIO N

FEOeR-^ LAVIATIO N AOMINISTRATTON .

CumpliiinanL , vs . TITAN COATINGS , rM C P,i.-bpoi-ideni . xf^ . 

# KIlARfj^ G DOCKE T FA A Docke t

No . - FA A Cas e No . 2010SO70031 6 Judg e No t

Ve t Assigne d C D

— H 1 MOTIO N T O DISMIS S RESPONDENT' S REQUES T FO RA HEARIN G f T- , _ cm

ComplaiiiiUit . b y an dihroug hih e undersigne dcounsel , pursuan t t o Scciin n 13.2lS(t")(2)(i ) u f th e Rule s o f

Practic e (1 4 C.F.R . §13.2 1 S(f;(2)(i)) , hereb y move s t o disinis i Respondent': ; Reques t foi ' aHcitring . A s ground s fo r thi s Motion , CompJainan l state s th e following :

I . On Novembe r

24 , 2010 , Complainan i issue daNotic e o f Propose dCivi l Penall y (NOVCF i nllcgint ; violation s o f Hazardou s Material s Regulation s (4 9 CF.R . §171.11 ) t o Respondent. ' I

nrespons e t o th e NQPCP , th e Responden t requesie da

n Infoniia l Conferenc e that wa s hel don Marc h29 , 2011 . A s C i resu ho f

th e Informal Conference , o n o r abou t May 27 , 201 1 th e Complainan t

aiicmpic dt o resolv e th e matte r wii ha n offer o f settlement , whic hwa s rejecte d by ih e Respondent . A s aresult , pursuan t t o 1 4 C.F.R . ijl3.16{e)(l)(i) . Complainan t issue dit s

A cop y o f

th e NOPr r

Airiicho da s Exihi i "1 ". DM S 0002/02 ^ 10/06/201 1 12:3 0 FA X 202493514 2

Fina l Notic e oi ' Propose dCivi l Penalt y (FNOPCP ) t o Responden t vi aceitifie dmai l an dregular U.S . Mai l on .)une 8 , 20 1 i . * Th e \J.S . Posta l Ser^'ic c indicate s tha t th e certifie dmai l cop y o f th e FNOPC Pwa s proccii.se dthoug hit s sort facility o n Juit e 10 . 2011 . Th e FNOPC Psen t vi aregular mai l wa s no t

returned . A s aresult , o n .Augus t 18 , 2011 , th e Complainan t isstie dth e Orde r Assessin g Civi l Penalty." ' O n Septembe r 8 , 2011 , th e Respondent , throug hcounse l issue dvi a Firs t Clas s Mai l it s Reques t

for aforma l hearing. ' I n accordanc e wit h1 4 CF.R . ^13.16(e>(2) j no t latertha n 1 5 day s afte r

leeeip l o f

ih e fina l notic e o f propose dcivi l penalty . Responden t wa s require dt o submi t th e amoun t

o f th e propose d civi l penalt y or

reques t n hearing . Addin g liv e day s t o th e Jun e S , 20 1 1 mailin g dat e t o accoun t ib r deliver> \Respondent' s reques t fo r ahcitrin g shoul dhav e bee n submitte dn o late r than Jun e ]^ . 2011 . I

n accordanc e wit h1 4 C.F.R . §13.21Kh) . apresumptio n o f sei^'ic e wi| ] b e mad e wher e L \party o r person , v-'hr

> customaril y receive s mail , or receive s i t

i n th e ordinar y cours e o f busmess , meithe r

aperson' s residenc e o r th e person' s principa l plac e o f business , acknowledge s receip t o f th e document . P.€Spondent' s reques t fo r ahearin g come. s ove r

eighty-seve n (87 ) day s aftci ' di e FNOPC Pw^i

s maile dt

o Responden t

a t ilt ; principa l plac e o f

busines s b y Certifie dan d Heyular Fir^i Clas s l.'. S mail . Base do n th e foregoing , an dpursuan t l o di e Rule s n f

Practic e a pre.sumptio no f

servic e o t

th e FNOP(' Pi s created , an dth e Respondent' s reques t Ib v hearin g shoul db e deeme duntimely .

' A-LOji y uCiUf j FNOPC H i'-. nuache U a. ^ •"UxJiibi

t Z. " • . ^ c.npy o f

th e Orde i .As'^^eisin

g Civi l Penall y i s altnclici i i S "Kxliihi t 3. " ' A cop y o f

Rc-.spondcrii < Kcquts i fo r Hearin g Afuchc J a s "F.xJiibir 4. " ' .^lihou^ hth t

Adiiiint.'^T^ito

r Ija." ; hel dtha i the ''mailin g aile " prescribe di n U C.F.K . §I1V211(c ) doc s no i exten dth e riin c to r lilin g i \icqucfi i ['o

r licjrinc; , i t

ha s bee n use dt

o .iccouri i fo

r dclivciy . Se e I nth e Matte r o f Sida l TOITL-.'; . FA A Docke i Ni) . CP9.'iAL0."?n0{Fi;bniaryii , iy9f.) .- OM S 0003/02 2 lO/OG/201 1 12-3 0 FA X 202493514 2 FA ^

An untimel y reques t

for ahearin g wil l onl y b e excuse dfo r goo dcause . Injth e Matte r o f Ryan fntemationa l Airlines . FA A Orde r No . 2000- 2 (Fcbruan ' 3 , 2000) ; I n th e Matte r

o f Carl P. . Lan£ton , FAA Orde r

^o . 93-1 2 (Marc h25 , 1993) . \Vhe n decidin g whethe r goo dcaus e exist s fo r untimeliness . th e focu s shoul db e o n th e reaso n that th e documen t

wa s hie dlat e id , a

t 7 . Attorne y erro r

o r inadvertenc e i s generall y no t goo dcause , ^c e t

n (h e Mattcro f

Mar k Steve n Diamond . KA

A Orde r No . 95-1 0 a

t 3 (May 10 , 1995 ) (counsel' s inexperienc e an dunfamiliarit y wit hadministrativ e procedur e i s no t goo dcause) ; Lant^ton . supra , a t 7 (agenc y attorney' s failur e t o returnatelephon e cal l fromRespondent' s counse l doe s no t excus e Respondent' s counsel' s ("ailur e t o fil e . T timel y reques t

fo r hearing) ; hi th e Matte r

o f Michae l Joh n Costello . FA A Orde r N o 92- 1 a

t 5 (J.inaap,'9 . l'')92 ) (.niisimcrprciin g th e Rule ? o f Ri'actic e i s no t

goo dcause) . Responden t

ha s pre.scnle dn o goo dc^Tus e for it s failure l o timel y reques t ahearing . I

n fact Respondent' s counse l simpl y make s areques t for hearin g acknowledgin g tha t th e nonappealabl e Orde r

As.'^essing Civi l Penall y ha s bee n issued , bu t doe s no t giv e an y goo dcaus e fo r it s hu e filing . Th e FNOPC Prcmailed^'i dcertifie dan drei^ula

r U.S . Mai l l o th e Respondent' s principa l plac e o f busines s o n Jun e 8 , 2011 , containe dinformatio n regardin g th e 15-day lim e limitatio nfo r fiJint : / Treques t fo r hearing . Additionally , Responden t wa s provide d withacop y o f

FA R13.1 6 an dSubp^ir t Go f Pa n 13 , whic hdetai l th e apphcabl c rules , witJi ih e NOPC' PConscqaenrly . Respondent" > unfmiely reques t shoul dno t

b e excused . $u i I

n th e Matte r o f Ryan Internaiiona l Airlines . FA A Orde r No . 2000- 2 (Februar y 2 , 2000) . I n thi s matte r ih e Respondent'. s reques t fo r ahearin g come s ove r

eighty-seve n (87 ) day s after servic e o f

th e FNOPCP .10/06/201 1 12:3 0 FA X 202493514 2 FA, ^ ^ 0M 5 004/02 ^

Th e Rule s o f

Practic e d o no t

requir e Complainan t

t o sho w prejudice . In th e Matte r o f Larry' s F[ving_S€_D'ice , FA A Orde r No . 9S- 4 (Marc h12 . 1998) . V/hil e it i s tru e tha t

ih e law doe s no t favo r defaul t judgments , th e Rule s o f Practic e d o requir e Responden t t o show * goo dcause , wliic hi t ha s faile dt o do . Id , a

i M . WHEREFORE , Complainan t respectfull y request s (ha t a n Orde r b e entere ddismissin g Respondent' s reques t

fo r ahc;uing . Respectfull y submitte dthi s 16' ^ da y o f Septembe r

2011 .

KAS^HT M RIC H GEORG E\ J Atlonie y Offic e o f th e Regiona l Counse llO/OG/201 1 12:3 0 FAX 202493514 2 FA A - 0M 5 13005/02 2

CERIIFICAT EO FSERVIC E I hereb y certif

y tha t acop y o f

th e foregoin g Motio nt o Dismis s Respondent' s Reques t for Hoann ^ w.i s maile dvi; \Federa l Expres s to : C . Clar k Collier , Esq . La w Office s o f

C . Clark Collier , LL C 30 0 Roya l Towe r

Driv e Bimiingham , AL3520 9 an d Tiia nCoatings , Inc . Attn : Rube nllanna , Presiden t 202 5 Exchang e Plac e Bessemer , AL3502 2 an dth e origina l an don e cop y vi aFedera l Evpres s to : Hearin g Docke t FAA . AGC-430 . Wilbu r W ] ighi Building . Suit e 2W100 0 So O Lidependcnc e Avenue , S W Washington , D C 2059 1

'^ELL : P

### 1 6 

### 201 1 Date d10/06/201 1 12-3 0 FA X 202493514 2 FA A 

# © U.S . Departmen t o f Transportatio n Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Souther n Regio n Offic e o f th e Regiona l Counse l 

### NO V 2 4 

### 201 0 CERTIFIE D - RETURN ' RECEIP T R£0aE5TFl > S c REGULA RMAIL lita n Coatings . Inc . Attn : Presiden t 202 5 Exchang e Plac e Bessemer . A

L3052 2 • ^ DM S [2i00G/02 2



## FT M P . 0 . Bo.x2053 6 Atlanta , Georgi a 3032 0 (4tM ) 305-520 0 (404)30552: 3 FA

X 20I0SO70031 6

N O rrC EO FPROPOSE D ClVil - PENALT Y Base don arejio n o f

investigation , includin g th e IcUe r o f Davi dK. . Richie . Secreiary-Trca.'iurc r date dJul y 14 . 2010 . it

appear s that : 1 . 0\ t o r abou t Januar y 6 . 2010 . Tita n Coatings . Inc . (herinafte t Titan ) knowingl y offere dt o Federal Expres s Corporatio n (FedEx ) tw o shipment s consistin g o f fiberboar dboxe s cont/iinin g dangerou s good s fo r transportalio n b y air 2 . A t all time s meniione dherein , (h e above-mentione d.shipment s wer e accompanie d b y Shipper' s Certificatio n o r Occlaratior . o f

Dangerou s Cioodi ; tha t

indicate dTita n ha davaile d itsel f o f th e [CA O Technica l Instruction s fo r th e Transportatio n o f

Dangerou s Good s by Ai r (FCA O TI) , includin g .ill Unite dState s Variation s thereto . 3 . I he above-mentione dshipments , were assigne dth e followin g Ftrdera l Expres s air waybil l numbers :

a . 869 4 468 3 0322 , offere dby Titan , 202 5 E.thchang e Place , Bessemer , Alabam a35022 , for

aii transporlatin n t o th e consignee , Cciria , 53 0 North2"" ^ Street , Cambridi;e . Ohi o 43725 . h . 869 4 468 3 0300 . offere dby Titan , 202 5 Exhchang e Place , Bessemer . Alabam a35022 , fo r

ai r transportatio n l o (h

e consignee , Cetria , 53 0 North2"* * Street , Cambridge , Olii o 43725 - 4 . Th

e Shipper' s Certifieaiio n o r l)i;clLvraiio

n o f Dangerou s Good s describe dth e shipment s a.-

; "Paint , 3 , UNt263 , Ifl. " 5 . Th e Shipper' s Certificatio n o r Declaratio n o f

Dangerou s Good s ^a s signe db y Richar dCochurm . ri. O n o r

abou t Januar y 21 , 2010 , Tita n knowingl y offere dt o FedE x ashipmen t consistin g of

afiberboar dbo x containin g dangerou s good s fo r transportatio n b y air . 

## EXHIBr t,0B/20 n 1 2 3 0 FA . =0^««-^ ' FA A

7 A t al l time s mentione dherein , th e above-mentione dshipment s wer e accoinpanie d b y Shipper' s Ceilificaiio no r Declaratio n o f

Dangerou s Good s tha t

indicate dTita n ha davaile d itsel f i} i th e iCA O Technica l Instruction s fo r th e Transportatio n o { Dangerou s Good.' ; b y Air (ICA O T1) , includin g al l Unite dState s Vanation s thereto . H Th e shipmen t

describe da

t paragiap h6 , assigne dFedera l Expres s air waybil l numbe r S69 4 46S 3 0285 . wa.5 offere db y Titixn . 202 5 Exchang e Place , Be.ssemcr . Alabam a J5022 . for

ai r trajisportatio n l o th e consignee , Roge r Park , 1093 S Beec hAvenue , Foniana . Californi a92337 . 9 . Th e Shipper' s Certificatio n o r Doclauttio n o f

Ditngerou s Ciood s describe dth e ihipmeni s a s "Taint . 3,1.1N1263 . ID.' ' 10 . Th e Shipper' s Certificatio n or Dec!ar?iiio n o f

Dangerou s Good s wa s signe dh y Richar dCochurm . U . O no r

abou t Februar y 22 , 2010 , Tita n knowingl y offere dt o FedE x ashipmen t consistin g o f

afiberboar dbo x containin g dangerou s good s fo r traiihiportatio n b y ai r 12 . A t al l liine b mentione dherein , th e abovc-mcmione dshipment s wer e accompanie d b y Shipper' s Certificatio nor Declaratio n o f

Dangerou s Good s tha

t indicate dTita n ha davaile d Itsel f o f ih e ICA O Technica l Instruction s fo r th e Transportatio n o f

Dangerou s Good s b y Air (IC"A 0 TI K

includin g al l Uruie dState s Variation s theret o 13 . Th e shipmen t

describe da

t paragrap h12 , assif^e dFedera l Hxpros s ai r waybil l numbe r 86*^ 4 468 3 0274 . wa. s offere db y Titan , 202 5 ExchaTig e Pl.=jce , Bessemer , Alabam a 35022 . fo

r air ir.uisportalio n t

o th e consignee , Roge r Park . li)93i^ Beec h,'\vcnue . Funtana , Cahforui a•72337 , 14 . Th e Shipper' s Certificatio n o r Declaratio n o f

Dangerou s Good s describe dth e shipment s as 'Paint . 3 , UNI203 , lH. " 15 . Th e Shipper' s Certificatio n o r Declaratio n o f

Dangerou s Good s wa.- ; signe db y Richar dCochum i 16 . Ih e Shipper' s Certificatio n o r Declaratio n o f

Dangerou s Good s reference dabov e a l paragraph s 2 , 7 , an d1 2 wer e improperl y prepared . 17 . O no r

abou t Jun e 18 , 2010 , aspecia l age mu f th e Federa l Aviatiot i Administratio n attempte dt o conduc t

a n assessmen t

o f Titan . 18 . Upo narriva l t o conduc t th e assessmen t

th e specia l age mwa s denie dacces s t o th e employees ; o f

Tita n t o cntiduc i th e inspection .- OM S 01008/02 2 lO/Oe/201 1 12:3 1 FA X 202493511 2 FA A

IS) . B yreaso n o f th e foregoing , o n Jun e 22 . 2010 , Specia l Agen t sen t a lette ro f investigatio n t o Tita n requestin g copie s o f trainin g record s fo ral l employee s involve d i n th e preparatio n an d handlin g o f hazardou s matrial s shipment s from th e facility , an d a cop yo f th e hazardou s material.- ^ trainin g progra m curriculum . 2 0 O n o rabou t Jul y14 , 2010 , Tita n provide d informatio n tha t compan yha s provide d hazardou s communicatio n trainin g t o it s employees . 2 1 . fita n (aile d t o provid e hazardou s material s trainin g record s tha t indicat e tha i it s employeci ; ha d receive d function-specifi ctrainin g prio rt o th e above-retercnce d hazardou s miatcnal s shipments . B yreaso n o f ih e above , an d i n accordanc e wit h U.S . Variatio n I t o (h e ICA O TI , Tita n violate d Sectio n 171. 1 To f th e Depa/imen t o f Transportatio n Hazardou s Matenal s Regulation s (4 9 C.F.R . § 171.11 ) b yofferin g dangerou s good s fo riranspoiiario n b yai runde rth e ICA O Tl , tha t wa s i n violatio n o f th e ICA O TI , a s se t fort h below .

1 . fCA O 1 ; 1.2 ; i n tha t Tita n ofTere d dangcrou. s good s fo rinternationa l civi l transpor t b yai rwhe n thos e good s wer e no t properl yclassified , documented , certificated , described , packaged , marked , labelle d an d i n conditio n fo i shipmen t require d b ythes e Instructions . 2 . IC.A O 6 ; I.Ll(a ) an d 1,2.1 i n (ha t fitan . a shippe ro f dangerou s goods , offere d a packag e containin g dangerou s good s fo rtransportatio n b yair , an d faile d t o establis h an d maintai n initia l an d recurren t dangerou s good s trainin g programme s whic h includ e genera l familiarizatio n trainmg , function-specifi ctrainin g an d safet ytrainin g 3 . ICA O 6 ; 1.2. 4 i n th.i i Tita n offere d a packag e containin g dangerou s good s fo r (ransportatioi i b yair , an d faile d t o maintai n a recor d o f trainin g whic h included : a ) th e individuaf s name , b ) th e mos t recen t (rainin g completio n date ; c ) a description , co p o rreferenc e t o trainin g material s use d ( o mee t th e trainin g requirements ; d ) th e nam e an d addres s o f th e organizatio n providin g th e (raining ; an d e ) a cop yo f th e certificatio n issue d whe n th e individua l wa s trained , which.show s tha t a (es t ha s bee n complete d satisfactorily . I n accoidane t wit h Sectio n 5l23fa ) o i Chapte r51 . Titl e 4 9 o f th e Unite d State s Cod e o f Transportation . 4 9 U.S.C. § 5 1 23 , Ti(a n i s habl e fo ra civi l petudt yo f no t les s tha n $25 0 (S45( ) fo rtrainin g violations) , nor.greate rtha n $50,00 0 (J100,00 0 i f death , seriou s illness , sever e injury , o rsubstantia l propen ydamag e results) , fo reac h violatio n o f th e regulations . Afle rreviewin g ou rinvestigativ e file , w e propos e t o asses s a civi l penalt yi n th e amoun t o f S26,00 0 fo rthes e violations .c* » - OM S ©009/02 2 10/0G/20 n 12:3 1 FA X 2024935U 2 FA A

Enclose di s informatio no n Titan' s option s i n respondin g t o thi s Notice . Th e option s includ e participatin g i

n a ninforma l conferenc e wit ha n FA A attorney , an dsubmissio n o f informatio n t o th e FAA fo

r consideration . Tita n mus t submit , in writing , it s choic e o f ih e alternative s explaine d o n th e enclose dinformatio n form , o n o r befor e 3 0 day s after

Tita n receive s thi s Notice . I f Tita n 1'ai\ s t o subnii i it s choic e *uhi n tha t time , Tita n wi\

^ hav e n o further

ngh t t o participat e i

n ;h c int'onna l procedures . EDDI EL . THOMA S RECTIONA LCOUNSE L 

# By : mllOU^-^^^ ^ RASH.\W NRICHOEORG EC J Attorne y Offic e o f th e Regiona l Counse l Enclosures : Infonnaiio nShee t

Repl y Form FAR1 3 1 6 an dSubpar t

Go f Part 1 3f h K

70 2 493'/>*^ ^

.eiM^V^"^ ' fie d

LV.K I



### U.S . Posta l Service-. . CERTIFIE D MAIL. n RECEIP T fftomesff cJtto/ ' Or»/y ; N o truuranc e Covemg e ProviOed } Fo r(Mlvor yirtlerrriAiia n vbi l ou rtwpbsi u a ) iMW»^.usB$.eomi . 

# 1 OJi f ! C±i \

L

P S f c m 390 0 Augu-. ! SQ M Et e Benets e lO f InOTUtllon i10/0S/20 n 12.3 1 FA X 202493514 2 FA A ^ OM S 2)011/02 2 

# O (J.S . (departmen t o f Transportatio n Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Souther n Regio n Offic e o f th e Regiona

l Counse l P.O . Bo . 2063 6

Atlanta , Georgi a 3032 0 (•404 ) 305-5200 (401 ) 305-522 3 FA

X CERTIFIE D - RETUR NRECHIP T REOUESTE D & REGULA RMAI L 20I0SO70031 6 Tiiy n Coaling s Attn : Prci.idcn ( 202 5 Exchang e Plac e He.si.cmcr . A

L3052 2 IINA LNQTI C EO FPkOPOSK D CIVI LPENAL 1 V O n Novemhe i .74 . 2010 . yo u wer e advi.se dthroug haNotic e o f Propose dCivi l Penalt y tha t th e KA. A propose dt

o asses s acivi l penall y i n th e amoun t

o f S26.000 . .Afte r considenn g all (he evidenc e i n (hi s matler . includin g infonimio n submitte da i ih t infomia l conferenc e o

n - , i t appear s (hut : 1 . On o r

abou l Januarv ' 6 . 2010 , Titan Coadngs . Inc . (heiiuaAe r Titjn ) knowingl y offere dt o f'ederii l H>;pre5 S Corr'nratiu n (f'cdU.x) tw o shipment s consistin g o f flborhoir dboxe s cniiiMinin g dangerou. s &;ood< ; fo r trarisportiilio n b y air . 2 . A( al l tune s mentione dherein , th e above-mentione dshipment s wer e ;iecompanie db y Shipper'.' ; CuriiHealio n or Declaratio n u f

Dangerou s Good s (ha

t indicate dTita n ha

davaile ditsel f

o f (h e ICA O Technica l Instruction s fo r th e Transportatio n o f

Dangerou s Good s by Ai r {ICA O Tl) , including : all l imie dState s VariiUion s thereto . 3 Th e above-mentione dshipmenis , wer e assi^e dth e followin g federa l E.vpres s ai r waybil l number.'; :

^^ . S(» 4 4f>S ? 0322 , offere dby Titan , 202 5 Exchaiiu e Place . Bessemer , Alaban m 35022 . tor

;ij r transportatio n t

o th e consignee . Cerrni , 53 0 North2"^ ^ Street , Cambridge , Ohi o ^13725 . b . 36s>

4 4()^ 3 030O , offere db y Tiian , 202 5 Exchang e Plnce , Bessemer , Alabam a 35022 , fo r air ft^nsporiatio n t o th e consignee , Cetria , 53 0 North2"' ' S(ree( . Canihridt:c , Ohi o 43725 . 4 . Th e Shipper' s Ccriificatio n o i Declaratio n o f

Dangerou s (joud?

^ describe dth e shipment s as^Tiii[it , 3 . U N1263 , IK. " 

# EXHlBfl L10/0G/20 n 12:3 1 FA X 202493514 2 FA A^ OM S @0l2/02 2

.5 . Th e Shipper' s Ccrtificaiioi i o rDeclaratio n o f Dangerou s Oood s wa s signe d b y Richar d Cochur m 6 . O n o r<ibou ( Januai y21 , 2010 , Tita n knowingl yoffere d t o FedE. v; i shipmen t consistin.t ; o f a fiberboar d bo xcontainin g dangerou s good s fo rtransportatio n b yair . 7 . .A

t rd l time s mentione d herein , th e above-mentione d shipment s wer e aecompajiie d b y Shipper' s Ceriitkatio n o rDeclaratio n o f Dangerou s (Jood s tha t indicate d Tita n ha d availe d iisclfo f th e IC.A O fecluiicii l Instruction s fo rth e Transportatio n o f Dangerou s Good s b y.'^i r(ICA O II) , tneludin g al l Unite d State s Vanation s thereto . B . Th e shipmen t describe d a i paragrap h 6 , assigne d Federa l Expres s ai rwaybil l numbe r J?69 4 46S 3 02S5 , w.^ ^ offere d b yTitan , 202 5 E.^Lchang e Place . Hcssemer , Alabam a 35022 . fo rai r transporialio n t o th e consignee , Roge rPark , 1093 S I^eec h Avenue , Fontana , Californi a 02337 . '.> . Th e Shipper' s Cenificatio n o rDeclar3(ioi i o f Dangerou s Good s describe d th e shipment s as "Paint , 3 , LrNl263 , 111. "

1 0 Th e Shipper' s Certificatio n o rDeclaratio n o f Dangerou s (Jood s VV,'HS sijm'^ d b y Richar d C'*'-hi.ir m

1 1 O n o rabou t Fcbruao ' ^^ . ^"^'0 , Tita n knowint:l yoffere d t o FedE xa shipmen t Consistin g o f a fiberboar d bo xcontainin g dangeiou s good s fo riran.sportatio n b yair .

12 . A t jl l lime s mentione d herein , ih cabnve-meniione d shipment s wer e accompanie d b y Shipper' s Certificatio n o rDeclaratio n o f Dangerou s Good s tha t indicate d Tita n ha d availe d itsel f ol ' th e K.'A O Technica l Instruction s fo rth e Tr.insponatio n o f Dangerou s Good s b yAi r(ICA O 'II) , includin g al l L'nite d State s Variation s theret o

13 . Th e shipmen t descnbe d a i piiragiap h 12 , assigne d Federa l E.\pres s ai rwaybil l numbe r869 4 468 3 0274 , wa s offere d b yTitan , 202 5 Exchang e Place . Be.^.semcr , Alabam a 35022 , fo rai rtransportatio n t o th e consignee , Roge rPark . 1093 8 Hecc h .Avenue , Fontana , Californi a 92337 . 1 4 Th e Shipper' ^ Certificatio n n i Declaratio n o f Dani^erou s Gond. s describe d th e shipment s a

s "Paint , 3 . LrN12C>3 , 111. " 15 . Th e Shipper' s Certificatio n o rDeclaratio n o f Dangerou s Good s wa. s signe d b y Richar d Cochurm . 16 . Th e Shippei' s Certificatio n o rDeclaratio n o f Dangerou s Gootl s reference d abov e at paragraph s 2 , 7 , an d 1 2 wer e improperl yprepared .

17 . O n o rabou t Um e 18 , 2010 , a specia l agen t o f (h e Federa l Aviatiot i Administra(io n ailempte d t o conduc t a n assessmen t o f Titan .r* * - QM S 0)013/02 2 10/0e/201 1 12-3 1 FA K2024935U 2 FAP , ^" ^

I^ . Upo n arriva l t

o conduc t

th e assessmcii i th e specia l age mwa s denie dacces s (o Oi e employee s o f

Tita n( o conduc t

th e inspectio n 1 0 B y reaso no f

th e foregoing , o n Jun e 22 , 2fno , Specia l .Agen t sen t alette r o f investigatio n t

o Tita n requestin g copie s o f trainin g record s fo

r al l employee s involve di n th e propiiratio n an dhandlin g o f hazardou s material s shipnietU- s fro mth e facility , -dx-yi ^ acop y o f

th e ha;:ai"dou i material s trainin g progra mcurriculum . 2 0 On or

abou t Jul y 14 , 2010 , Titan provide dinformatio n iha t compan y ha s provide d hurardou s communicatio ntrainin g t o it s employees . 2 i Tii-.i

n faile dt o provid e hazardou s nialenat s trainin g record s thai indicat e thiii itb ' employee s ha

dreceive dfunction-specifi c namin g prio r t o th e above-reference dhasardoir i material s ^htpuKnts . B y reaso n o f

th e above , an di

n accordanc e wit

hU. S Variaiio n 1 l o th e ICA O T LI'iia n violate d Sectio n 171.1 1 o f

th e Departmen t

o f Transporiatio n Hazardou s Material s Regulation s (4 0 C.F.R . t j 171,[1 ) b y offerin g dangerou s good s fo r transportatio n b y air

unde r th e ICA O Tl , tl)a

t \.v:i 5 m violatio n o f

the IC.A<.

) TLa ^ set fon hbelow ; [ IC.A O 1 ; L2 : i

n tha t Tita n offere ddangerou b good s fo r uitemationa ! civi l transpori by air w-he nihn.s e good s w-cr

e no t properl y classified , documented , ee"r(inca(ed , described , p.3ckaged . marktjd , labelle dan di

n eoiidido n to r

shipmen t require dby thes e Instructions . 2 . IC.A O ti ; LLl(a ) an d1.2. 1 i n tha t Titan , ashippe r

o f dangerou s goods , offere da piickag e containin g dangerou s good s fo r transportatio nby air . an dfaile dt o establis han dmaintai n initia l an drecurren t

dangerou s good s trainin g programme s whic hinclud e genera l familiarizatio n (raining , fnnetion-.specifi c iiainni u an dsafety naming . 3 ICA O 6 ; L2. 4 inthat fita n offere dapackag e containin g dangerou s good s fo j ttansportatio nb y air , an dfaile d( o main(ai n arecoi do f trainin g w'hiehincluded : a ) th e individual s uame ; h i th e mos t

recen t irainin g completio n d.^to ; c ) adescription , co p o r referenc e t

o trymin e mnieti.^l.- : use dt

o mee t th e trainm g requirements ; d ) th e nam e an daddres s ci f rlie organiraiiui i providin g th e irainuAg ; in de ) : i cop y o f th e certificatio n is::.uedwhe n th e individua l wa s trained . whiL hshow s tlirt

i y tes t ha s bee n complete dSiitisfiietorily . Afte r reviewin g ou r

nneiiiligativ e file , w e propos e ( o asses s acivi l penalt y i n th e amoun t

o ( 526,00 0 io r

ihtjs e violations . Unles s you mai l o r

pcr-ionnll y deliver , i

n writing , you r

reques t for ahearin g i

n thi. s matter , on o r befor e fifteen (15 ) day s afle r yo u receiv e thi s Final Notice , w e wil l issu e a n Orile i As.sessin g (.•i*-'i l penall y ;m

dyou wil l hav e n o further right t o ahearing . I

f you d o no t

submi t awritte n reques t fo r aheanng , yo

u mus t pa y (he propose dcivi l penally .10/06/201 1 12:3 1 FAX 202493514 2 FA A - DM S 0014/02 2

Vou r reques t for ahearin g mus t

b e sen t

l o (he Federa l Aviatio n Administration . 60 0 Independenc e Avenu e SW , Wilbu r Wrigh t Building . Suit e 2WI0(KJ , Washington . D C 20591 , •Attentio nHeann g Docke t Clerk , .^00-43 0 (i f

deliver y i s in perso n o r vi aexpedite dcourie r service ) o r

Federa l .Aviatio n .Adminisnaiion , 80 0 Independenc e .Avenue SW , Wilbu r Wright Building . Suit e 2WI00(> , Wa.<:hingion , D C 20591 . Attention . Hearin g Docke t Clerk , AGC-43 0 (i f deliver y i s vi aU.S . Mail) , an dacop y mus t b e sent t o th e undersigne dKA

A a((omey . Your reques t rnus t b e date dan dsigned , i n accordanc e wit

hsectio n 13.1 0 o f

th e Federa l Aviatio n Regulations , sent

t o yo u withth e Notic e o f Propose dCivi l Penalt y (1 4 C.F.R . §13.16) . You may pay the propose dpenalt y b y submittin g acenifie dchec k o r mone y orde r

payabl e t

o th e •'Federal ,Avi;uio n Administralion " l O th e under.<;igned . FDDI EL . THOMA S REGIONA LCOl.iNSKI / " 

# BY : ^X^^O^ l Ho- ( 6^^ y R-ASH.A ) Aliorne v R-ASH.A\}' N FUC H GEORG E^ aiorne y Offic e o f th e Regiona l Counse l

CERTIFICAT EO FSERVJC E I hereb y comf

y tha t th e foregoin g Final Notic e o f Propose dCivi l Penalt y ha s bee n maile dby Cenifie dMai l i Regula r .Mai l tn . Tua n Cyaling s Attn Presiden t 202 5 Excliang e Plac e Bessemer , AI.3(.I52 2 r'/M . McDOW l Lcga T Assistan t Offic e olTn e Regiona l Counse l 

### W W0 8 

### ?P) ? Date d- OM S 1^015/0;^ ^ 10/06/201 1 1 2 3 1 FAX 202493511 2 FA A USPS.conV,p ; - "Irac k

A t Conf"^ ! Pag e 1 o f 1

i^rfliTi n /

ir-yMf l 

## t^USPSCO M Trac k & Confir m

Ju.li : 1* . Kii ! n 1 1 * • » n Th - .trr ^ < t C"j(T«mi ) i n innti l l o tn » ^eiimaiiD n h o fonhr r Me * DrtLr r Aifiiii.oni l Iiifuiniiiio n To r[|<i > nt ^ n iioiv d m iiic i sni^r, * is u ma rri^Mi < iiu * in e a3 a :.-i i inJciiiii.j n E C rcir1c>i>n ii-nrr , iri > <iL<i:>ci , i'l a IP> I .a * K.I J ,g u i re fnsi i •••' • i ; i f .-.CVS.J t r.v-.; . :/i i ^.•.3^.^5 t VO.; : ^/,-j ' Sl"i vS-,!.-!.".- . iCUIir-n s

Fin d Annilie rUe m '.V-^ l i ,uL F Lirii-iCi ' 'eccel j -^j-i.tjfi' '

'...•.;'•' • ••' 1 S . p • I » . ".L... ! 1 , Lf-'.- - "i'-i. . . '.'. , ••V:. . -.-fi x-^L'Jjn' . CVfV X 'j^ u J I'l . f' . v.-lJnrfi' . li-v- c:'.-i. . r.iir.|.i-.p IITE '

•"-•••• ' -.i n

h(tps://:ools.usps.com/'go/Ti-ackConfir m Action.actio n 8/18/201 1lO/OG/201 1 12.3 2 FA X 2024935U 2 FP,i , - DM S OlB/02 2 

# O Souther n Regio n Offic e o f th e Regiona l Counse l U.S . Departmen t o f Transportotior i Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 

### AO G 1 S 20t l CERI'IFLE D - RETUR^- J RECEfP T REQUEST£1 ) & REGULA RMAI L Tita nCoaling s .Arm : Presiden t 202 5 h;xch;ing e Plac e Mcs>emcr . Al . 3052: ' P.O . Bo x2063 6 Atlanra , Georgi a 3032 O (404 ) 305-520 0 (404 ) 305-522 3 F M 20[0SO7t"i03l 6

ORDE RASSESSIN GCIVI LPEN.ALT V O n Novembe r

24 , 2t.)10 , yo u wer e advjsc dihroug h;i Notic e o f Propose dCivi l Penalt y tha t th e FA A propose dt

u asses s acivi l penalt y i nth e amoun t o f .?26.0()0 - Afte r consideratio no f

al l o f th e ;ivailabl e infonnatiot i inthi s matter , it ha s bee ndetermine dthai : 1 O no r

abou t Januar y 0 . 2010 . Tita nCoatings , fne (hcrinarte r Titan ) knowjni^l y offere d( o Federa l Expres s Corporaiiofi tPedE.x. ) tw' o shipfneni s consistin g o f fiberboar dho.xe. s containin g d;ingefot; s good ^ fo r irarjsponario nb y air . 2 . .'\ ( al l time s mentione dherein , th e Hbove-rneniionc dshipment s wer e accompanie db y Shipper s ("eniflcaiio no r Deelnraiio no f

Dangerou s Good s tha t indicate dTita nha davaile ditsel f o f th e IC.A O lechnica l Instruction. s fo r th e Trans/'onatio no f O.tn|jerou s Good s b y .Ai r (ICA O 'I'D , includin g al l Unite dState. ^ Variation s thcielo . 3 . Th e above-mentione dshipments , wer e assigne d(h e follow-in g Federa l E.xpres s ai r waybil l riumbers ,

a869 4 40S 3 0322 , offere db y Titan . 202 5 E.xchang e Place , Rcssemer , Alabam a 35022 , fo r

a ntrunsportatio nt o th e consignee , Cetria , 53 0 Nort h2"' ' Street . Cambndgc , OIu u 4372! ^ b . S69 4 46? 3 0300 . offere db y Titan , 202 5 Exchang e Place , Bessemer , Alabam a 35t)22 . fo r

ai r transportatio nt o th e consignee , Cciria , 53 0 Non h2"' ^ Street . Cambridge , Ohi o 43725 . 4 . Th e Shipper' s Certificatio no r Declaratio no f

Dangerou s Oood. s de.'ictibc dth e shipment s a s "Paint..? , UN12{f3 , Ul. " 5 . Th e Shipper' s Certificatio no r Declaraiin no f

Dangerou s Good s wa s signe db y Richar dCochunn . 

## exHiBrt .. QM S ' 121017/02 2 10/06/201 1 12-3 2 FA X 2024935U 2 FA A

6 . O n o rabou t Januar y21 , 2010 . Tita n knowingl yoffere d ( o FedE. \ a shipmen t consistin g oi' ^

HberbOiu- d bo xcontainin g dangerou s good s fo rtransportatio n b yai r 7 . .'\ t al l time s mentione d herein , th e above-mentione d -shipincni s wer e accompanie d b y Shipper' s Certificaiio n o rDeclaratio n o f Dangerou s Good s tha t indicate d i i(; m ha d availe d itsel f o f th e IC.A O Technicr d Instniction s fo rth e Transportatio n o f Dangerou s Good s b yAi r(ICA O Tl) , includin g al l I iniu- J Slate s Variation s thereto . S . Th e shipmen t describe d a t paragrap h 6 . assigne d Federa l E.<pres s ai rwaybil l numbe r S69 4 465 3 0285 , wa ? offere d b yfitan . 202 5 Exchang e Place , Bessemer , Alabam a 35022 . fo rai r tran?;puriatio n t o th e consignee , Roge rPark , 10V3 S Beec h ,•^vemle . Foncina , Californi a 92337 . 9 . Th e Shipper' s Cenificatio n o rDeclaraiio n o f Dangerou s Good s describe d th e shipment s as-paint , 3 . LrN12o3 . I H " ' 10 . 'fh e Shipper' s Cenificatro n o rDeclaraiio n o f Dangerou s Good s wa s signe d b v Richar d Coehum\ . 11 . O n o rabou t Febiuar y22 . 2010 . Tita n knowingl yoffere d ( o f-edH. \ a shipmen i con.^i.iiin g o f a fiberhoar d bo xeoniainin g danueiou s good s fo rtrarisponado n b yair .

1 2 A l al l nine s mentione d herein , th e above-mentione d shipmenz s wer e accompanie d b y Shipper' s t'ertificatio n o rDeclaratio n o f Dangerou s Good s iha t indicate d Tita n ha d availe d itsel f o t th e ICA O lechnica l Instruction s fo rth e Transponatio n o f Dangerou s Good s h y.Ai r(IC.A O Tl) , includin g al l L/ni(e d Sfale s Varia(ion s ihereio . 13 . Th e sliipmei n describe d a t paragrap h 12 . assigne d Federa l Exprcs.- ; ai rwaybil l numbe r86*> 4 468 3 0274 , w^i . offere d b yTitan , 202 5 KA<.hang cPlace , Uesseniet , Alabam a 35i.'22 . til l Lu riranspotiaiie m t o th e consignee . Roge rPark , [O^-fS^f. Beec h .Avenue . Fontana . Californii \ 9233 7 U . Th e Shipper' s Cenificatio n o rDeclaratio n o f Dangerou s Good s describe d ih e .shipment s a

s "Paint . 3 , LrNl263 . RI. " 1 5 Ih e Shipper' s Ceidlieatio n o rffeclaratio n o ( Dangerou s Good s wa s signe d b y Richar d (."ixhumi . 16 . Th e Shipper' s Cenificatio n o rDeclaratio n o f Dangerou s Good s reference d abov e at paragraph s 2 , 7 . an d 1 2 wer e improperl yprepared . 17 . O n o rabou t .tun e IS , 20iO , a specia l :\ge m o f th e Federa l .Aviatio n Admini-itratio n atteittpie d t o conduc t a n assessmen t o f Ti(a n 18 . Upo n itrriva l t o conduc t th e assessmen t th e specia l agen t wa s denie d acces s t o th e employee s o f Tita n t o conduc t th e inspection .^ OM S @]01S/02 2 10/06/201 1 12-3 2 FAX 2024935U 2 FA A

19 . B y (ca.sono f

th e foregoing , o n Jun e 22 , 2010 , Specia l Agen t sen i aIciter

o f mvcstigatio n t

o Tita nrequestin g copie s of trainin g record s fo

r al l employee s involve di n th e preparatio n ;mc

l handlin g n f

hazardou s materiiil. s shipment s fromth e facility , an dacop y o f th e hazardou s marerial s trainin g progra mcurriculum . 20 . O no

r abou t Jul y 14 , 2010 , Tita n provide dinformatio n thai compan y ha s provide d hazardou s commumcriiio n trainin g t o it s employees . 2 1 Titanfaile dt

o provid e ha.^ardou s matenal s trainin g record s tha t indicat e tha

t it s employee s ha dreceive dfunction-specifi c trainin g prio r t o th e above-reference dha^'.ardou s material s shipments . B y reaso n o f

(he above , an di

n accordanc e wit

hU.S . Variatio n I t o th e IC.AO TI , fiiiu i violate d Sectio nI 7|.| ] o f

th e Dcpannicn t

o f Itarisportaiio n Ha:^ardou s Matenal s Regulation s (4 9 C.F.R . § [71. 1 [ ) by offerin g dangerou s good s fo r transportatio n b y ai r

unde r th e ICA O T

Ltha t wu s in vioiaiio n o f

th e ICA O TLa s set

fort hbelow ; 1 . ICA O 1 : L2 : i

n (ha t Tita n otTerc ddangerou s good s for internationa l civi l transport b y a nwhe nthes e good s wer e no t properl y ela.-^sified, documented , certificated , dc^ciibed , packaged , marked , labelle dan di

nconditio n to r

shipmen t require db

y thes e In.-^tructions . 2 . iCA O 6 ; i.LHa ) ja d1.2. 1 i n tha t fitan . ashippe r

o f dangerou s goods , ofl'ereda packag e containin g dangerou s good s fo r transportatio n by air , an dfaile dt o establis han dmaintai n initia l an drecurren t

dangerou s good s trainin g programme s whic hinclud e genera l familiarisatio n tf-aining . fiinction-specific trainin g an dsafel y training . 3 . IGA O 6 ; LZ. 4 i ntha t lita n offere dApackag e containin g dangerou s good s fo r iransponaiio nb y air , andfaile dt o manilai n arecordo f trainin g whicl i included : a) th e individual' s name ; b ) th e mos t

leecn t trdinm g completio n date ; c ) adescription , co p o r referenc e t o trainin g material s use dt

o mee l (he trainin g requirements ; d ) (h e nam e an daddrcs. s o f (he organiiialio n providin g th e training ; an de ) acop y o f th e certificatio n issue dwhe n th e individua l wa s trained , whic hshow s tha

t ates ( ha s bee n complete dsatisfactoril y NO WTHFR£FORr , I f I S ORDHR£D . pursuan t t o Seciio n 5123(.V) o f

Titl e 4 9 o f

(he Unite d State s Cod e ( 1 ransporta(ion ) ('4 9 U S. C i j 5l23(a}) . (h3 ( you b e an dhereb y i s assesse d^ civi l penalt y \ n th e amoun t

o f S26.0(.l0 . "^ov i ar e hereb y ordere dt o pay , immediately , th e assesse darnou mb y mailin g o r dclivenn g a certifie dchee k

or mone y orde r

i n tli c amoun ( o f

526,(jOO . payabl e l o th e "Federal Aviatio n Adniinistratioti, " to : rAA/AMZ-35 0

P.O . Bo x 2577 0 Oklahom aCity , OK

7312 510/06/201 1 12.3 2 FAX 202a935M 2 FA A-OM S ©019/02 2

Tli c amoun t

o f civi l penalt y assesse di n thi s Orde r

constitute. ^ adeb ( owe dl o Ihe Unite dStates . \'o u hav e no w exhauste dyou r right t o seek revie w o f

th e validit y o r

amoun t o f thi s debt . I

f thi s deb t i s itQ t pai din ful

l withi n 3 0 day s o f

you r receip t o f (hi s letter , (he deb t

i s considere d delinquent . Fo r

delinquen t

debts , federal regulatio n (4 9 C.F.R . {^89,23 } require s ur. t o charg e interest , from(h e dat e o f (hi s (!»rder

, ; u afixe dannua l rat e o f 1% , alon g witha

n administrativ e charg e o f S i 2.0 0 pe r

month , representin g ou r cost s o f administrativ e collection . Funhermore , i f (he ful l ainoun i assesse di s no t pai diii ful

l wnhi n 120 day s o f

you r receip t o f thi s letter , w-

e ar e require dt

o asses s a

nadditiona l penalt y a

t a n armual rat e o f

6% , accrttin g tVon

i (h e dat e of delinquenc y Eiclinquen l debt s ma y b e reporte dl o consume r reportin g agencie s o r

commercia l credi t bureaus , w-hic

hcoul dadversel y affect you r credi t rating . No

n paynie mo f

thi s deb t

may ultimatel y resul t

i nareferra l t

o acollectio n agency , Th e Litema' i Revenu e Service , o r t o th e Unite dState s Departnien i o f Justic e fo

r enforce dcollection . EDDI EL . THOMA S KFXJIONA

LCOUNSE L

, o RAS^I^V NRIC H GEORG EQ Atiovno ; Offic e o f th e Regiona l Counse llO/OG/201 1 12:3 2 FA X 202493511 2 FA A - OM S 020/02 2



### CERTIFICAT EO FSERVIC E I hereb ycemf ytha t th e forcgom g OTdt \ Assessin g Civj l Penalt yha s bee n maile d b yRegistere d Mai l an d Regula rMai l t o Tita n Coaling s A'tn : Presiden t 2(.i2 5 f-.-.Kehang e Plac e Be.ssemer , A L 3052 2 .•iJ^Ti^fl/I.^M^jD'OWCL l -Ltg^A'^Jtan i Offic e o f th e Regiona l Coun.se l AU G 1 8 201 1 D,ite .

r u

LT I c r • • i n O U.S . Posta l SGrviceT- 1 

### CERTIFIE D MAILr n RECEIP T (Domesti cMal l Only ; N o Insuranc e Covtroq * Provided ) Fo rdelivar vinformalio n VIGI I ou rwabsil a a l www.usps.comi ) 

## 0 f Vt'Il(lBO « Ceniri M F« o

Thl« rPiMtSQ * 1 C^r t 

## \

C ? / >. L « ~ 

## s 

## U S E

; • ^ MeT

O

i.<in f r;r- " 

# r3SZLXp..^.ti. v ^'^^ . O . suw . 7ir-- t P S Foi m aeao . Augu^ i ^EH G S » HSver^ f fo rInslruclion l10/08/201 1 12:3 2 FAX 202493514 2 FA A^ OM S ^021/ 0 

### LA WOFFICE

S O F C-CI.AR K

COLLIER , LL C 30 0 ROYA

LTOWF RORJV t BIRMINGHAM , A

l 3520 9 20 5 87-M9I 2 fa

x 205 874-|0| 5 ccc'i'i'cccliieriaw.cc m •-^]- \ 

# nv} - Sepiember8 , 20 1 I ^ CC D , - . • 

### i ot r 1 3 . 

# i 

# _

_, Attention ; Hearin g Docke t Clerk , AGC-43 0 - ' • I - ""- . Wilbu r Wrigh t Building-Roo m201 4 ' " ' " " ' Federa l Aviatio nAdmini.-^tratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenu e S W W^^shington . D C 2059 1 R£ : ORDE RASSESSIN GCIVI LriiNALT Y TITA N COATING S Dear si r or madam : Ou r firmrepresent s I itan(,!o<i(ing s whos e principa l addre.'^ s i s loea(e din Birmingham , Alabama . In tha t connection , we hav e bee n aske dt o assis t the mi n hiindlin g th e Orde r

Assessin g Civi l Penall y date dAugu.s i 18 , 20 1 I fromth e Federal Aviatio n Administration , U . S . Departmen t o f Transportation , Souther n Region , Offic e o f Regiona l Counsel . Tita n continue s t

o believ e tha t

th e document s pu t

foit hcombine dwit

hth e informatio n convoye da t an informa l telephoni c hearin g indicat e that th e propose dcivi l penalt y o f $26,0(» 0 i s unreasonabl e an dexcessiv e unde r

the circumstances . Th e penalt y lia s presumabl y bee n assesse dbase dsolel y upo n a n allege dfailure l o documen t trainin g o f

fitan personne l an dno t throug han y imprope r

shippiu t mcdiod.< ; o r

improperl y prepare ddocumentation . Base dupo n thi s assertion . Tita n request s ahearin g dat e I f fiiriher actio n o n ou r

part i s required , pleas e iidvise .

C . Olark Collie r CC/a o cc : Mr . Rd.shawnR . Georg e

OOOr)l75 8 

## eCHlBlt . 

# 1C . Clar k

Collier , LL C 30 0 Roya l ToNve r

Driv e Birminyham , A L3520 ? r..Li--.(''V 1 v.'vi„.,r,-f.i>,i\ i ^.\

_ ^^S'j'.r. i.~-f. : r. -



# - n Mr . Rashaw n R . Oeorg c Offic e o f (he Regiotia ! Counse l Federa l Aviatio n .AdminisinTtio n P.O . Bo. x 2063 6 Allanla, G

A 3032 0

i-(!>ilV-NiitM.i.'J!iM;lk-:,)Jur.|ln)L,.j)lM/)iJ.Ji /