Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, Less than 6000 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15%

0 Baseline 8.23 $372 $0 $372.03 $0 378.51 $27.82 $677.04 $611.89 $525.17

1 0 + Evap/Cond Enhanced Fins 8.70 $373 $0 $372.64 $0 358.31 $26.34 $661.38 $599.70 $517.61

1 2 1 + PSC Fan Motor 9.32 $378 $0 $377.57 $0 334.43 $24.58 $647.07 $589.50 $512.88

DOE 2a DOE 9.70 $382 $0 $382.41 $0 321.26 $23.61 $641.30 $585.99 $512.39

2 3 2 + Evap/Cond Grooved Tubes 9.71 $383 $0 $382.55 $0 320.90 $23.59 $641.14 $585.90 $512.38

3 4 3 + Add Suhcooler 10.00 $390 $0 $389.51 $0 311.69 $22.91 $640.68 $587.02 $515.62

4 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil

4 5 Area 10.38 $440 $0 $440.24 $0 300.19 $22.06 $682.14 $630.47 $561.69

6 5 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 10.57 $560 $0 $560.46. $0 294.85 $21.67 $798.06 $747.30 $679.75

5 7 6 + **Variahle Speed Compressor 11.74 $796 $0 $796.18 $0 265.36 $19.50 $1,010.02 $964.34 $903.55

U.

C^

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, Less than 6000 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides 

Imaalled Annual Annual Annual . Life-Cycle Cost~ 

Effc 'y Design EER Retail InstalL COJl5u.rner Maint. Elec. Energy 

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense 

BtulW-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15% 

0 Baseline 8.23 $372 $0 $372.03 $0 378.51 $27.82 $677.04 $611.89 $525.17 

1 0+ Evap/Cond Enhanced Fins 8.70 $373 $0 $372.64 $0 358.31 $26.34 $661.38 $599.70 $517.61 

2 I + PSC Fan Motor 9.32 $378 $0 $377.57 $0 334.43 $24.58 $647.07 $589.50 $512.88 

DOE 23 DOE 9.70 $382 $0 $382.41 $0 321.26 $23.61 $641.30 $585.99 $512.39 

2 3 2 + Evap/Cond Grooved Tuhes 9.71 $383 $0 $382.55 $0 320.90 $23.59 $64l.l4 $585.90 $512.38 

3 4 3 + Add Suhcooler 10.00 $390 $0 $389.51 $0 311.69 $22.91 $640.68 $587.02 $515.62 

4 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil 

4 5 Area 10.38 $440 $0 $440.24 $0 300.19 $22.06 $682.14 $630.47 $561.69 

6 5 + Bru.~hless D.C. Fan Motor 10.57 $560 $0 $560.46 $0 294.85 $21.67 $798.06 $747.30 $679.75 

5 7 6' + **Variahle Speed Com~ressor 11.74 $7% . $0 $796.18 $0 265.36 $19.50 $1,010.02 $964.34 $903.55 
Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, 6000 to 7999 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15%

0 Baseline 8.46 $404 $0 $403.82 $0 471.06 $34.62 $783.42 $702.33 $594.41

1 0 + Evap/Cond Enhanced Fins 8.80 $405 $0 $405.25 $0 452.75 $33.28 $770.09 $692.15 $588.43

1 2 1 + PSC Fan Motor 9.38 $410 $0 $410.13 $0 424.89 $31.23 $752.52 $679.38 $582.04

2 3 2 + Add Suhcooler 9.66 $417 $0 $416.89 $0 412.31 $30.30 $749.14 $678.17 $583.71

DOE 3a DOE 9.70 $418 $0 $418.10 $0 410.69 $30.19 $749.05 $678.35 $584.26

3 4 3 + Evap/Cond Grooved Tubes 9.91 $425 $0 $424.73 $0 402.03 $29.55 $748.70 $679.50 $587.39

4 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil

4 5 Area 10.33 $478 $0 $477.78 $0 385.68 $28.35 $788.58 $722.19 $633.83

6 5 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 10.50 $599 $0 $598.82 $0 379.26 $27.88 $904.44 $839.15 $752.27

5 7 6 + **Variable Speed Compressor 11.67. $830 $0 $830.48 $0 341.33 $25.09 $1,105.54 $1,046.78 $968.58

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, 6000 to 7999 Btu/h, Witho~t Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides 

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs 

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy 

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use . Expense 

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% .15% 

0 Baseline 8.46 $404 $0 $403.82 $0 471.06 $34.62 $783.42 $702.33 $594.41 

I o + Evap/Cond Enhanced Fins 8.80 $405 $0 $405.25 $0 452.75 $33.28 $770.09 $692.15 $588.43 

I 2 I + PSC Fan Motor 9.38 $410 $0 $410.13 $0 424.89 $31.23 $752.52 $679.38 $582.04 

2 3 2 + Add Suhcooler 9.66 $417 $0 $416.89 $0 412.31 $30.30 $749.14 $678.17 $583.71 

DOE 3a DOE· 9.70 $418 $0 $418.10 $0 410.69 $30.19 $749.05 $678.35 $584.26 

3 ·4 3 + Evap/Cond Grooved Tuhes 9.91 $425 $0 $424.73 . $0 402.03 $29.55 $748.70 $679.50 $587.39 

4 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil 

4 5 Area 10.33 $478 $0 $477.78 $0 385.68 $28.35 $788.58 $722.19 $633.83 

6 5 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 10.50 $599 $0 $598.82 $0 379.26 $27.88 $904.44 $839.15 $752.27 

5 7 6 + **Variahle Sneed COID(!reSSOr 11.67.·. $830 . $0 $830.48 $0 341.33 $25.09 $1,105.54 $1,046.78 $968.58 
Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, 8000 to 13,999 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15%

0 Baseline 9.32 $495 $0 $495.06 $0 694.12 $51.02 $1,054.41 $934.92 $775.90

0 + Incr Compressor EER to

1 1 10.82 9.71 $506 $0 $505.83 $0 666.46 $48.98 $1,042.89 $928.16 $775.48

DOE la DOE 9.80 $508 $0 $508.41 $0 660.34 $48.53 $1,040.54 $926.86 $775.58

2 2 1 + Add Subcooler 9.85 $510 $0 $509.76 $0 657.19 $48.30 $1,039.35 $926.21 $775.66

3 3 2 + Evap/Cond Grooved Tubes 10.11 $518 $0 $518.17 $0 640.03 $47.04 $1,033.93 $923.75 $777.12

3 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil

4 4 Area 10.97 $577 $0 $576.63 $0 590.02 $43.37 $1,052.09 $950.52 $815.35

5 4 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 11.15 $697 $0 $697.06 $0 580.28 $42.65 $1,164.67 $1,064.78 $931.84

5 6 5 + **Variable Speed Compressor 12.39 $929 $0 $929.44 $0 522.25 $38.39 $1,350.29 $1,260.39 $1,140.74

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, 8000 to 13,999 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides 

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Cost<; 

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy 

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense 

BtulW-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15% 

0 Baseline 9.32 $495 $0 $495.06 $0 694.12 $51.02 $1,054.41 $934.92 $775.90 

o + Incr Compressor EER to 

10.82 9.71 $506 $0 $505.83 $0 666.46 $48.98 $1,042.89 $928.16 $775.48 

DOE la DOE 9.80 $508 $0 $508.41 $0 660.34 $48.53 $1,040.54 $926.86 $775.58 

2 2 1 + Add Suhcooler 9.85 $510 $0 $509.76 $0 657.19 $48.30 $1,039.35 $926.21 $775.66 

3 3 2 + Evap/Cond Grooved Tuhes 10.11 $518 $0 $518.17 $0 640.03 $47.04 $1,033.93 $923.75 $777.12 

3 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil 

4 4 Area 10.97 $577 $0 $576.63 $0 590.02 $43.37 $1,052.09 $950.52 $815.35 

5 4 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 11.15 $697 $0 $697.06 $0 580.28 $42.65 $1,164.67 $1,064.78 $931.84 

5 6 5 + **Variahle Speed Com~ressor 12.39 $929 $0 $929.44 $0 522.25 $38.39 $1,350.29 $1,260.39 $1,140.74 

". 
Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, 14,000 to 19,999 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense

Btu/W-hr ( 6%) kWh 2% 6% 15%

0 Baseline 9.00 $613 $0 $612.76 $0 1062.76 $78.11 $1,469.17 $1,286.23 $1,042.75

0 + Incr Compressor EER to

1 1 10.78 9.70 $632 $0 $632.48 $0 986.80 $72.53 $1,427.68 $1,257.81 $1,031.74

DOE la DOE 9.70 $633 $0 $632.61 $0 986.29 $72.49 $1,427.40 $1,257.61 $1,031.66

2 2 1 + Condenser Grooved Tubes 9.98 $640 $0 $639.63 $0 958.91 $70.48 $1,412.35 $1,247.28 $1,027.60

3,4 3 2 + Add Subcooler 10.15 $648 $0 $647.54 $0 942.93 $69.31 $1,407.39 $1,245.07 $1,029.05

3 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil

4 Area 10.74 $812 $0 $811.82 $0 890.62 $65.46 $1,529.51 $1,376.20 $1,172.16

5 4 + Incr Compressor EER to 11.3 11.08 $870 $0 $870.27 $0 863.06 $63.43 $1,565.75 $1,417.18 $1,219.46

6 5 + Incr Compressor EER to 11.4 11.18 $897 $0 $897.30 $0 856.11 $62.92 $1,587.18 $1,439.81 $1,243.68

7 6 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 11.50 $1,039 $0 $1,038.75 $0 832.28 $61.17 $1,709.43 $1,566.16 $1,375.49

5 8 7 + **Variale Speed Compressor 12.77 $1,295 $0 $1,294.53 $0 749.05 $55.06 $1,898.14 $1,769.20 $1,597.59

* * ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~/ ..

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, 14,000 to 19,999 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides 

Imaalled Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Coste; 

Effc'y Design EER Retail Ine;tall. Cone;wner Maint. Elec. Energy 

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense. 

BtulW-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15% 

0 Baseline 9.00 $613 $0 $612.76 $0 1062.76 $78.11 $1.469.17 $1,286.23 $1,042.75 

o + Incr Compressor EER to 

1 10.78 9.70 $632 $0 $632.48 $0 986.80 $72.53 $1,427.68 $i,257.81 $1,031.74 

DOE la DOE 9.70 $633 $0 $632.61 $0 986.29 $72.49 $1,427.40 $1,257.61 $1,031.66 

2 2 1 + Condenser Grooved Tuhes 9.98 $640 $0 $639.63 $0 958.91 $70.48 $1,412.35 $1.247.28 $1,027.60 

3,4 3 2 + Add Suhcooler 10.15 $648 $0 $647.54 $0 942.93 $69.31 $1,407.39 $1,245.07 $1,029.05 

3 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil 

4 Area 10.74 $812 $0 $811.82 $0 890.62 $65~46 $1,529.51 $1,376.20 $1,172.16 

5 4 + Incr Compressor EER to 1 1. 3 11.08 $870 $0 $870.27 $0 863.06 $63.43 $1,565.75 $1,417.18 $1,219.46 

6 5 + Incr Compressor EER to 11.4 11.18 $897 $0 $897.30 $0 856.11 $62.92 $1,587.18 $1,439.81 $1,243.68 

7 6 + Bru.e;hless D.C. Fan Motor 11.50 $1,039 $0 $1,038.75 $0 832.28 $61.17 $1,709.43 $1,566.1,6 $1,375.49 

5 8 . 7 + **Variahle Speed Com~ressor 12.77 $1,295 $0 $1,294.53 $0 749.05 $55.06 $1,898.14 $1,169.20 $1,597.59 

/ 
Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, Greater than 20,000 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15%

0 Baseline 8.22 $859 $0 $859.47 $0 1572.75 $115.60 $2,126.85 $1,856.11 $1,495.80

0 + Incr Compressor EER to

1,2 1 10.89 8.38 $871 $0 $871.31 $0 1542.55 $113.38 $2,114.35 $1,848.81 $1,495.42

DOE la DOE 8.50 $880 $0 $879.78 $0 i521.68 $111.84 $2,106.00 $1,844.05 $1,495.44

3 2 1 + Add Suhcooler 8.51 $880 $0 $880.29 $0 1520.43 $111.75 $2,105.51 $1,843.77 $1,495.45

4 3 2 + Incr Compressor EER to 11.5 8.88 $960 $0 $960.00 $0 1457.38 $107.12 $2,134.41 $1,883.53 $1,549.65

3 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil

4 Area 9.42 $1,071 $0 $1,071.41 $0 1372.63 $100.89 $2,177.52 $1,941.23 $1,626.77

5 4 + Incr Compressor EER to 11.7 9.84 $1,112 $0 $1,111.79 $0 1314.73 $96.63 $2,171.24 $1,944.92 $1,643.72

6 5 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 10.03 $1,291 $0 $1,291.24 $0 1289.56 $94.78 $2,330.41 $2,108.42 $1,812.99

5 7 6 + **Variahle Speed Compressor 11.14 $1,653 $0 $1,653.06 $0 1160.60 $85.30 $2,588.32 $2,388.53 $2,122.64

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, Greater than 20,000 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides 

Inc;talled Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Coste; 

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy 

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense 

BtulW-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15% . 

0 Bae;eline 8.22 $859 $0 $859.47 $0 1572.75 $115.60 $2,126.85 $1,856.11 $1,495.80 

o + Jncr Compressor EER to 

1,2 10.89 8.38 $871 $0 $871.31 $0 1542.55 $113.38 $2,114.35 $1,848.81 $1,495.42 

DOE la DOE 8.50 $880 $0 $879.78 $0 1521.68 $111.84 $2,106.00 $1,844.05 $1,495.44 

3 2 1 + Add Suhcooler 8.51 $880 $0 $880.29 $0 1520.43 $111.75 $2,105.51 $1,843.77 $1,495.45 

4 3 2 + Incr Compressor EER to 11.5 8.88 $960 $0 $960.00 $0 1457.38 $107.12 $2,134.41 $1,883.53 $1,549.65 

3 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil 

4 Area 9.42 $1,071 $0 $1,071.41 $0 1372.63 $100.89 $2,177.52 $1,941.23 $1,626.77 

5 4 + Incr Compressor EER to 1 L 7 9.84 $1,112 $0 $1,111.79 $0 1314.73 $96.63 $2,171.24 $1,944.92 $1,643.72 

6 5 + BrusWess D.C. Fan Motor 10.03 $1,291 $0 $1,291.24 $0 1289.56 $94.78 $2,330.41 $2,108.42 $1,812.99 

5 7 6 + **Variahle Speed COlllflressor 11.14 $1,653 $0 $1,653.06 $0 1160.60 $85.30 $2,588.32 $2,388.53 $2,122.64 
Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, 6000 to 7999 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and Without Louvered Sides

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15%

0 Baseline 8.86 $447 $0 $447.01 $0 382.02 $28.08 $754.85 $689.09 $601.57

DOE Oa DOE 9.00 $450 $0 $450.17 $0 375.86 $27.63 $753.05 $688.35 $602.24

0 + Incr Compressor EER to

1,2 1 10.76 9.10 $452 $0 $452.23 $0 371.94 $27.34 $751.95 $687.92 $602.71

3,4 2 1 + Add Subcooler 9.23 $456 $0 $455.96 $0 366.62 $26.95 $751.39 $688.28 $604.29

3 2 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 9.65 $599 $0 $599.35 $0 350.65 $25.77 $881.92 $821.56 $741.22

4 3 + **Variahle Speed Compressor 10.72 $873 $0 $872.95 $0 315.59 $23.20 $1,127.26 $1,072.94 $1,000.64

5 5 4 + **Incr Evap/Cond Coil Area 11.52 $1,014 $331 $1,344.94 $0 293.75 $21.59 $1,581.65 $1,531.09 $1,463.79

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner,.6000.to 7999 Btu/h~ Without Reverse Cycle and Without Louvered Sides . 

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Coste; 

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Con<;lUller Maint. Elec. Energy 

Level No. Design Option Price Cost . Cost Cost ' Use Expense 

BtulW-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15% 

0 Baseline 8.86 $447 $0 $447.01 $0 382.02 . $28.08 $754.85 $689.09 $601.57 

DOE Oa DOE 9.00 $450 $0 $450.17 $0 375.86 $27.63 $753.05 $688.35 $602.24 

o + Incr Compressor EER to 

1,2 10.76 9.10 $452 $0 $452.23 $0 371.94 $27.34 $751.95 $687.92 $602.71 

3,4 2 1 + Add Suhcooler 9.23 $456 $0 $455.96 $0 366.62 $26.95 $751.39 $688.28 $604.29 

3 2 + Bru"Wess D.C. Fan Motor 9.65 $599 $0 $599.35 $0 350.65 $25.77 $881.92 $821.56 $741.22 

4 3 + **Variahle Speed Compressor 10.72 $873 $0 $872.95 $0 315.59 $23.20 $1,127.26 $1,072.94 $1,000.64 

5 5 . 4 + **Incr Eval2/Cond Coil Area 11.52 $1,014 $331 $1,344.94 $0 293.75 $21.59 $1,581.65 $1,531.09 $IA63.79 
Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, 8000 to 13,999 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and Without Louvered Sides

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15%

DOE Oa DOE 8.50 $554 $0 $554.10 $0 677.29 $49.78 $1,099.88 $983.29 $828.13

1 0 Baseline 8.80 $558 $0 $558.35 $0 654.42 $48.10 $1,085.71 $973.05 $823.13

2 1 0 + Add Suhcooler 9.04 $562 $0 $561.89 $0 636.48 $46.78 $1,074.79 $965.22 $819.41

1 + Incr Compressor EER to

3,4 2 11.09 9.12 $569 $0 $569.09 $0 631.59 $46.42 $1,078.05 $969.33 $824.63

3 2 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 9.44 $714 $0 $713.85 $0 610.04 $44.84 $1,205.44 $1,100.43 $960.67

4 3 + **Variable Speed Compressor 10.49 $992 $0 $992.19 $0 549.04 $40.35 $1,434.62 $1,340.11 $1,214.33

5 5 4 + **Incr Evap/Cond Coil Area 11.08 $1,139 $331 $1,469.75 $0 519.39 $38.18 $1,888.29 $1,798.88 $1,679.89

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, 8000 to 13,999 Btu/h, Without Reverse Cycle and. Without Louvered Sides 

In .. talled Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Cost .. 

Effc'y Design EER Retail In<;tall. Conswner Maint. Elec. Energy 

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense 

8tu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15% 

DOE Oa DOE 8.50 $554 $0 $554.10 $0 677.29 $49.78 $1,099.88 $983.29 $828.13 

I 0 Baseline 8.80 $558 $0 $558.35 $0 654.42 $48.10 $1,085.71 $973.05 $823.13 

2 I o + Add Suhcooler 9.04 $562 $0 $561.89 $0 636..48 $46.78 $1,074.79 $965.22 $819.41 

I + Incr Compressor EER to 

3,4 2 11.09 9.12 $569 $0 $569.09 $0 631.59 $46.42 $1,078.05 $969.33 $824.63 

3 2 + BrusWess D.C. Fan Motor 9.44 $714 $0 $713.85 $0 610.04 $44.84 $1,205.44 $1,100.43 $960.67 

4 3 + **Variable Speed Compressor 10.49 $992 $0 $992.19 $0 549.04 $40.35 $1,434.62 $1,340.11 $1,214.33 

5 5 4 + **Incr Eva[!/Cond Coil Area 11.08 $1,139 $331 $1,469.75 $0 519.39 $38.18 $1,888.29 $1,798.88 $1,679.89 
Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, With Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs

Effc'y Design ,EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15%

0 Baseline 8.92 $690 $0 $689.83 $0 750.16 $55.14 $1,294.34 $1,165.20 $993.34

DOE Oa DOE 9.00 $693 $0 $693.09 $0 743.49 $54.65 $1,292.22 $1,164.23 $993.90

1,2 1 0 + Add Suhcooler 9.05 $695 $0 $695.16 $0 739:30 $54.34 $1,290.92 $1,163.65 $994.28

1 + Incr Compressor EER to

3,4 2 10.82 9.27 $708 $0 $707.54 $0 721.61 $53.04 $1,289.04 $1,164.82 $999.50

2 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil

3 Area 9.83 $788 $0 $787.80 $0 680.65 $50.03 $1,336.29 $1,219.12 $1,063.19

4 3 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 10.04 $952 $0 $952.26 $0 666.15 $48.96 $1,489.07 $1,374.39 $1,221.78

5 5 4 + **Variable Speed Compressor 11.16 $1,270 $0 $1,269.68 '$0 599.53 $44.07 $1,752.81 $1,649.60 $1,512.25

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Life Cycle COsts and· Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, With Reverse Cycle and With Louvered Sides 

Im::talled ADnual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs 

Effc'y Design -.EER Retail Inc;taII. Conc;umer Maint. Elec. Energy 

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense 

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15% 

0 Baseline 8.92 $690 $0 $689.83 $0 750.16 $55.14 $1,294.34 $1.165.20 '$993.34 

DOE Oa DOE 9.00 $693 $0 $693.09 $0 743.49 $54.65 $1,292.22 $1,164.23 $993.90 

1,2 1 o + Add Suhcooler 9.05 $695 $0 $695.16 $0 739:30 $54.34 $1,290.92 $1,163.65 $994.28 

1 + Incr Compressor EER to 

3,4 2 10.82 9.27 $708 $0 $707.54 $0 721.61 $53.04 $1,289.04 $1,164.82 $999.50 

2 + Increase Evap/Cond Coil 

3 Area 9.83 $788 $0 $787.80 $0 680.65 $50.03 $1,336.29 $1,219.12 $1,063.19 

4 3 + Bruc;hless D.C. Fan Motor 10.04 $952 $0 $952.26 $0 666.15 $48.96 $1,489.07 $1,374.39 $1,221.78 

5 5 4 + **Variahle Speed Com[1ressor 11.16 $1,270 $0 $1,269.68 . $0 599.53 $44.07 $1,752.81 $·1,649.60 $1,512.25 
Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, With Reverse Cycle and Without Louvered Sides

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Costs

Effc'y Design EER Retail Install. Consumer Maint. Elec. Energy

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% 15%

DOE Oa DOE 8.50 $700 $0 $699.93 $0 711.64 $52.31 $1,273.40 $1,150.89 $987.86

1,2 0 Baseline 8.72 $704 $0 $704.13 $0 693.92 $51.00 $1,263.32 $1,143.86 $984.89

3,4 1 0 + Condenser Enhanced Fins 8.86 $707 $0 $706.90 $0 682.72 $50.18 $1;257.06 $1,139.54 $983.13

2 1 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 9.20 $884 $0 $883.61 $0 -657.85 $48.35 $1,413.73 $1,300.49 $1,149.77

3 2 + **Variable Speed Compressor 10.22 $1,225 $0 $1,225.04 $0 592.07 $43.52 $1,702.15 $1,600.23 $1,464.59

5 4 3 + **Incr Evap/Cond Coil Area 10.87 $1,405 $331 $1,735.77 $0 556.54 $40.91 $2,184.25 $2,088.44 $1,960.94

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Life Cycle Costs and Payback Periods of Room Air Conditioner, With Reverse Cycle and Without IAmvered Sides 

Installed Annual Annual Annual Life-Cycle Cost'i 

Effc 'y Design EER Retail In'itall. Con'iumer Maint. Elec. Energy 

Level No. Design Option Price Cost Cost Cost Use Expense 

Btu/W-hr (@6%) kWh 2% 6% . 15% 

DOE Oa DOE 8.50 $700 $0 $699.93 $0 711.64 $52.31 $1,273.40 $1,150.89 $987.86 

1,2 0 Baseline 8.72 $704 $0 $704.13 $0 693.92 $51.00 $1,263.32 $1,143.86 $984.89 

3,4 1 o + Condenser Enhanced Fins 8.86 $707 $0 $706.90 $0 682.72 $50.18 $1",257.06 $1,139.54 $983.13 

2 1 + Brushless D.C. Fan Motor 9.20 $884 $0 $883.61 $0 ·657.85 $48.35 $1,413.73 $1,300.49 $1.l49.77 

3 2 + **Variahle Speed Compressor 10.22 $1,225 $0 $1,225.04 $0 592.07 $43.52 $1,702.15 $1,600.23 $1,464.59 

5 4 3 t- **Incr Eva[!/Cond Coil Area 10.87 $1,405 $331 $1,735.77 $0 556.54 $40.91 $2,184.25 $2,088.44 $1,960.94 
Room Air Conditioner, Less than 6 KBtu/h, with Louvered Sides

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage)

Installed Annual

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999

Level No. Cost use Exepnse @ 6% Distribution

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$)

0 372.03 378.51 27.82 611.89 .70.9%

1 372.64 358.31 26.34 599.70 9.6%

1 2 377.57 334.43 24.58 589.50 9.0%

DOE DOE 382.41 321.26 23.61 585.99 1.0%

2 3 382.55 320.90 23.59 585.90 5.2%

3 4 389.51 311.69 22.91 587.02 2.7%

4 -5 440.24 300.19 22.06 630.47 1.6%

6 560.46 294.85 21.67 747.30 0.0%

5 7 796.18 265.36 .19.50 964.34 0.0%

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards

Standard Level 1 DOE 2 3 4 5

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 372.10 372.65 372.75 373.29 373.74 374.83

Annual OperatingCost (1990 $) 27.64 2734 27.30 27.09 26.98 26.90

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 610.44 60835 608.11 606.89 606.34 606.74

Energy Use (kWh./a) 376.11 371.94 371.40 368.62 367.06 365.97

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (Years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%)

Standard Level 1 DOE - 2 3 4 5

LCC Difference 20.94 2235 22.20 19.86 -24.12 -357.60

Payback (year)

Field 1.8 2.6 2.6 3.9 13.5 57.0

Existing Test Proc. 1.3 1.9 1.9 2.8 9.6 40.5

CCE (centlkWh) 1.5 2.2 2.2 3.3 11.5 48.6

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Room Air Conditioner, Less than 6 KBtulb, with Louvered Sides 

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage) 

Installed Annual 

Standard Design Consumer EIec. Operating LCC 1999 

Level No. Cost use Exepnse @6% Distribution 

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$) 

0 372.03 378.51 27.82 611.89 . 70.9~ 

1 372.64 358.31 26.34 599.70 9.6% 

1 2 377.57 334.43 24.58 589.50 9.0% 

DOE DOE 382.41 321.26 23.61 585.99 1.0% 

2 3 382.55 320.90 23.59 585.90 5.2% 

3 4 389.51 311.69 22.91 587.02 2.7% 

4 5 440.24 300.19 22.06 630.47 1.6% 

6 560.46 294.85 21.67 747.30 0.0% 

5 7 796.18 265.36 .19.50 964.34 0.0% 

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards 

Standard Level DOE 2 .3 4 5 

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 372.10 372.65 372.75 373.29 373.74 374.83 

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 27.64 27.34 27.30 27.09 26.98 26.90 

Life-Cycle Cost at 6%(1990 $) 610.44 608.35 608.11 606.89 606.34 606.74 

Energy Use (kWh.la) 376.11 371.94 371.40 368.62 367.06 365.97 

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%) 

Standard Level DOE 2 3 4 5 

LCC Difference 20.94 22.35 22.20 19.86 -24.12 -357.60 

Payback (year) 

Field 1.8 2.6 2.6 3.9 13.5 57.0 

Existing Test Proc. 1.3 1.9 1.9 2.8 9.6 40.5 

CCE (centlkWh) 1.5 2.2 2.2 3.3 11.5 48.6 
Room Air Conditioner, 6 to 8 KBtu/h, with Louvered Sides

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage)

Installed Annual Annual

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999

Level No. Cost use Expense @ 6% Distribution

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$)

0 403.82 471.06 34.62 702.33 48.5%

1 405.25 452.75 33.28 692.15 14.8%

1 2 410.13 424.89 31.23 679.38 23.5%

2 3 416.89 412.31 30.30 678.17 9.9%

DOE DOE 418.10 410.69 30.19 67835 1.6%

3 4 424.73 402.03 29.55 679.50 0.5%

4 5 477.78 385.68 28.35 722.19 0.4%

6 598.82 379.26 27.88 839.15 0.8%

5 7 830.48 341.33 .25.09 1046.78 0.0%

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards

Standard Level 1 2 DOE 3 4 5

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 404.15 405.77 406.91 407.09 407.18 409.11

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 34.31 33.47 33.15 33.10 33.09 33.02

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 699.94 694.38 692.72 692.49 692.43 693.80

Energy Use (kWh./a) 466.8 455.4 451.0 450.4 450.1 449.3

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (Years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%)

Standard Level 1 2 DOE 3 4 5

LCC Difference 20.57 16.21 14.37 12.99 -29.76 -352.98

Payback (year)

Field 1.9 3.5 3.8 5.0 14.9 53.1

Existing Test Proc. 1.4 2.5 2.7 3.5 10.6 37.7

CCE (cent/kWh) 1.7 3.0 3.2 4.2 12.7 45.3

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Room Air Conditionllr, 6 to 8 KBtuIh, with Louvered Sides 

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage) 

Installed Annual Annual 

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999 

Level No. Cost use Expense· @6% Distribution 

(1990$) kWhlyr (1990$) (1990$) 

0 403.82 47l.06 34.62 702.33 48.50/[ 

1 405.25 452.75 33.28 692.l5 14.8% 

1 2 41O.l3 424.89 31.23 679.38 23.5% 

2 3 416.89 412.31 30.30 678.17 9.9% 

DOE DOE 418.10 410.69 30.19 678.35 1.6% 

3 4 424.73 402.03 29.55 679.50 0.5% 

4 5 477.78 385.68 28.35 722.19 0.4% 

6 598.82 379.26 27.88 839.15 0.8% 

5 7 830.48 341.33 25.09 1046.78 0.0% 

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards 

Standard Level 2 DOE 3 4 5 

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 404.l5 405.77 406.91 407.09 407.18 409.11 

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 34.31 33.47 33.15 33.10 33.09 33.02 

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 699.94 694.38 692.72 692.49 692.43 693.80 

Energy Use (kWh.la) 466.8 455.4 451.0 450.4 450.1 449.3 

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%) 

Standard Level 2 DOE 3 4 5 

LCC Difference 20.57 16.21 14.37 12.99 "29.76 -352.98 

Payback (year) 

Field l.9 3.5 3.8 5.0 14.9 53.1 

Existing Test Proc. 1.4 2.5 2.7 3.5 10.6 37.7 

CCE (centlkWh) 1.7 3.0 3.2 4.2 12.7 45.3 
Room Air Conditioner, 8-14 KBtu/h, with Louvered Sides

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage)

Installed Annual Annual

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999

Level No. Cost use Expense @ 6% Distribution

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$)

0 495.06 694.12 51.02 934.92 52.0%

1 1 505.83 666.46 48.98 928.16 14.5%

DOE DOE 508.41 660.34 48.53 926.86 6.2%

2 2 509.76 657.19 48.30 926.21 7.9%

3 3 518.17 640.03 47.04 923.75 12.6%

4 4 576.63 590.02 43.37 950.52 4.4%

5 697.06 580.28 42.65 1064.78 0.5%

5 6 929.44 522.25 38.39 1260.39 1.9%

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards

Standard Level 1 DOE 2 3 4 5

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 495.06 497.40 498.34 499.47 501.99 506.36

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 51.02 50.58 50.40 50.20 49.77 49.44

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990$) 934.92 933.45 932.89 932.23 931.09 932.65

Energy Use (kWh./a) 694.12 688.10 685.73 682.93 677.15 672.71

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (Years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%)

Standard Level 1 DOE 2 3 4 5

LCC Difference 6.76 6.59 6.67 8.48 -19.43 -327.74

Payback (year)

Field 5.3 5.4 5.4 5.9 11.7 38.3

Existing Test Proc. 3.8 3.8 3.9 4.2 8.3 27.2

CCE (cent/kWh) 4.5 4.6 4.6 5.1 9.9 32.6

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Room Air Conditioner, 8-14 KBtu/h, with Louvered Sides 

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage) 

Installed Annual Annual 

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LeC 1999 

Level No. Cost use Expense @6% Distribution 

. (1990$) kWhlyr (1990$) (1990$) 

0 495.06 694.12 51.02 934.92 52.0% 

1 505.83 666.46 48.98 928.16 14.5% 

DOE DOE 508.41 660.34 48.53 926.86 6.2% 

2 2 509.76 657.19 48.30 926.21 7.9% 

3 3 518.17 640.03 47.04 923.75 12.6% 

4 4 576.63 590.02· 43.37 950.52 4.4% 

5 697;06 580.28 42.65 1064.78 0.5% 

5 6 929.44 522.25 38.39 1260.39 1.9% 

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards 

Standard Level DOE 2 3 4 5 

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 495.06 497.40 498.34 499..47 501.99 506.36 

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 51.02 50.58 50.40 50.20 49.77 49.44 

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 934.92 933.45 932.89 932.23 931.09 932.65 

Energy Use (kWh./a) 694.12 688.10 685.73 682.93 677.15 672.71 

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%) 

Standard Level DOE 2 3 4 5 

LCC Difference 6.76 6.59 6.67 8.48 -19.43 -327.74 

Payback (year) 

Field 5.3 5.4 5.4 5.9 11.7 38.3 

Existing Test Proc. 3.8 3.8 3.9 4.2 8.3 27.2 

CCE (centJkWh) 4.5 4.6 4.6 5.1 9.9 32.6 
Room Air Conditioner, 14 to 20 KBtu/h, with Louvered Sides

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage)

Installed Annual Annual

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999

Level No. Cost use Expense @ 6% Distribution

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$)

0 612.76 1062.76 78.11 1286.23 60.2%

1 1 632.48 986.80 72.53 1257.81 15.8%

DOE DOE 632.61 986.29 72.49 1257.61 0.5%

2 2 639.63 958.91 70.48 1247.28 8.8%

3,4 3 647.54 942.93 69.31 1245.07 12.5%

4 811.82 890.62 65.46 1376.20 2.3%

5 870.27 863.06 63.43 1417.18 0.0%

6 897.30 856.11 62.92 1439.81 0.0%

7 1038.75 832.28 61.17 1566.16 0.0%

5 8 1294.53 749.05 55.05 1769.20 0.0%

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards

Standard Level 1 DOE 2 3 4 5

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 612.76 616.86 616.96 619.30 619.30 627.17

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 78.11 76.95 76.92 76.26 76.26 75.15

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 1286.23 1280.32 1280.18 1276.78 1276.78 1275.08

Energy Use (kWh./a) 1062.76 1046.96 1046.60 1037.54 1037.54 1022.43

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (Years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%)

Standard Level 1 DOE 2 3 4 5

LCC Difference 28.42 22.70 32.90 31.71 31.71 -494.12

Payback (year)

Field use 3.5 3.5 3.5 4.1 4.1 33.2

Existing Test Proc. 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.9 2.9 '23.6

CCE (cent/kWh) 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.5 3.5 28.3

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Room Air Conditioner, 14 to 20 KBtulh, with Louvered Sides 

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage) 

Installed Annual Annual 

Standard . Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999 

Level No. Cost use Expense @6% Distribution 

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$) 

0 612.76 1062.76 78.11 1286.23 60.2% 

1 632.48 986.80 72.53 1257.81 15.8% 

DOE DOE 632.61 986.29 72.49 1257.61 0.5% 

2 2 639.63 958.91 70.48 1247.28 8.8% 

3,4 3 647.54 942.93 69.31 1245.07 12.5% 

4 811.82 890.62 65.46 1376.20 2.3% 

5 870.27 863.06 63.43 1417.18 0.0% 

6 897.30 856.11 62.92 1439.81 0.0% 

7 1038.75 832.28 01.17 1566.16 0.0% 

5 8 1294.53 749.05 . 

55.05 1769.20 0.0% 

Weighted A verage of Units Sold below Standards 

Standard Level DOE 2· 3 4 5 

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 612.76 616.86 616.96 619.30 619.30 627.17 

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 78.11 76.95 76.92 76.26 76.26 75.15 

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 1286.23 1280.32 1280.18 1276.78 1276.78 1275.08 

Energy Use (kWh.la) 1062.76 1046.96 1046.60 1037.54 1037.54 1022.43 

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (years), and Cost .. of Conserved Energy (at 6%) 

Standard Level DOE 2 3 4 5 

LCC Difference 28.42 22.70 32.90 31.71 31.71 494.12 

Payback (year) 

Field use 3.5 3.5 3.5 4.1 4.1 33.2 

Existing Test Proc. 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.9 2.9 '23.6 

CCE (centlkWh) 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.5 3.5 28.3 
Room Air Conditioner >20 KBtu/h, with Louvered Sides

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage)

Installed Annual Annual

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999

Level No. Cost use Expense @ 6% Distribution

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$)

0 859.47 1572.75 115.60 1856.11 55.5%

1,2 1 871.31 1542.55 113.38 1848.81 4.2%

DOE DOE 879.78 1521.68 111.84 1844.05 10.7%

3 2 880.29 1520.43 111.75 1843.77 7.9%

4 3 960.00 1457.38 107.12 1883.53 18.4%

4 1071.41 1372.63 100.89 1941.23 1.1%

5 1111.79 1314.73 96.63 1944.92 2.2%

6 1291.24 1289.56 94.78 2108.42 0.0%

5 7 1653.06 1160.60 85.30 2388.53 0.0%

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards

Standard Level 1 2 DOE 3 4 5

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 859.47 859.47 86030. 863.27 864.98 890.18

Annual Operating Cost(1990$) 115.60 115.60 115.44 114.89 114.58 112.66

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 1856.11 1856.11 1855.60 1853.84 1852.83 1861.48

Energy Use (kWh./a) 1572.75 1572.75 1570.63 1563.16 1558.87 1532.75

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (Years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%)

Standard Level 1 2 DOE 3 4 5

LCC Difference 7.30 7.30 11.54 10.06 -30.71 -527.05

Payback (year)

Field use 5.3 5.3 5.4 5.4 12.7 27.9

Existing Test Proc. 3.8 3.8 3.8 3.8 9.0 19.8

CCE (cent/kWh) 4.5' 4.5 4.6 4.6 10.9 23.8

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Room Air Conditioner >20 KBtulh, with Louvered Sides 

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage) 

Installed Annual Annual 

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC ·1999 

Level No. Cost use Expense @6% Distribution 

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) . (1990$) 

0 859.47 1572.75 115.60 1856.l1 55.5% 

1,2 1 87l.31 1542.55 113.38 1848.81 4.2% 

DOE DOE 879.78 1521.68 111.84 1844.05 10.7o/(l 

3 2 880.29 1520.43 111.75 1843.77 7.9% 

4 :3 960.00 1457.38 107.l2 1883.53 18.4% 

4 107l.41 1372.63 100.89 1941.23 1.1% 

5 1111.79 1314.73 96.63 1944.92 2.2% 

6 129l.24 1289.56 94.78 2108.42 0.0% 

5 7 1653.06 1160.60 .85.30 2388.53 0.0% 

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards 

Standard Level 2 DOE 3 4 5 

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 859.47 859.47 860.30. 863.27 864.98 890.l8 

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 115.60 115.60 115.44 114.89 114.58 112.66 

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 1856.11 1856.11 1855.60 1853.84 1852.83 186l.48 

Energy Use (kWh./a) 1572.75 1572.75 1570.63 1563.16 1558.87 1532.75 

Life-Cycl~ Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%) 

Standard Level 2 DOE 3 4 5 

LCC Difference 7.30 7.30 11.54 10.06 -30.71 -527.05 

Payback (year) 

Field use 5.3 5.3 5.4 5.4 12.7 27.9 

Existing Test Proc. 3.8 3.8 3.8 3.8 9.0 19.8 

CCE (centlkWh) 4.5' 4.5 4.6 4.6 10.9 23.8 
Room Air Conditioner, 6 to 8 KBtu/h, without Louvered Sides

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage)

Installed Annual Annual

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999

Level No. Cost use Expense @ 6% Distribution

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$)

0 447.01 382.02 28.08 689.09 53.8%

DOE DOE 450.17 375.86 27.63 68835 0.0%

1,2 1 452.23 371.94 27.34 687.92 9.8%.

3,4 2 455.96 366.62 26.95 688.28 11.1%

3 599.35 350.65 25.77 821.56 25.2%

4 872.95 315.59 23.20 1072.94 0.0%

5 7 1344.94 293.75 21.59 1531.09 0.0%

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards

Standard Level DOE 1 2 3 4 5

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 447.01 447.01 447.01 447.82 447.82 486.92

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 28.08 28.08 28.08 27.96 27.96 27.30

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 689.09 689.09 689.09 688.91 688.91 722.28

Energy Use (kWh./a) 382.02 382.02 382.02 380.46 380.46 371.41

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (Years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%)

Standard Level DOE 1 2 3 4 5

LCC Difference 0.74 '1.17 1.17 0.63 0.63 -808.80

Payback (year)

Field use 7.0 7.0 7.0 8.0 8.0 150.3

Existing Test Proc. 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.7 5.7 106.7

CCE (cent/kWh) 5.9 6.0 6.0 6.8 6.8 128.1

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Room Air Conditioner, 6 to 8 KBtuIh, without Louvered Sides 

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage) 

Installed Annual Annual 

Standard Design Consumer EIec. Operating LeC 1999 

Level No. Cost use Expense @6% Distribution 

(1990$) kWhlyr (1990$) (1990$) 

0 447.01 382.02 28.08 689.09 53.8% 

DOE DOE 450.17 375.86 27.63 688.35 0.0% 

1,2 1 452.23 371.94 27.34 687.92 9.8% 

3,4 2 455.96 366.62 26.95 688.28 11.1 % 

3 599.35 350.65 25.77 821.56 25.2% 

4 872.95 315.59 .23.20 1072.94 0.0% 

5 7 1344.94 293.75 2159 1531.09 0.0% 

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards 

Standard Level DOE 1 2 3 4 5 

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 447.01 447.01 447.01 447.82 447.82 486.92 

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 28.08 28.08 28.08 27.96 27.96 27.30 

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 689.09 689.09 689.09 688.91 . 688.91 722.28 

Energy Use (kWh.la) 382.02 382.02 382.02 380.46 380.46 371.41 

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (years) .. and Costs "f Conserved Energy (at.6%) 

Standard Level DOE 2 3 4 5 

LCC Difference 0.74 '1.17 1.17 0.63 0.63 -808.80 

Payback (year) 

Field use 7.0 7.0 7.0 8.0 8.0 150.3 

Existing Test Proc. 

I 

5.0 5.0 5.0 5.7 5.7 106.7 

CCE (centlkWh) 5.9 6.0 6.0 6.8 6.8 128.1 
Room Air Conditioner, 8 to 14 KBtu/h, without Louvered Sides

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage)

Installed Annual Annual

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999

Level No. Cost use Expense @ 6% Distribution

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$)

DOE DOE 554.10 677.29 49.78 983.29 8.9%

1 0 558.35 654.42 48.10 973.05 51.8%

2 1 561.89 636.48 46.78 965.22 9.7%

3,4 2 569.09 631.59 46.42 969.33 12.2%

3 713.85 610.04 44.84 1100.43 17.1%

4 992.19 549.04 40.35 1340.11 0.2%

5 7 1469.75 519.39 38.18 1798.88 0.0%

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards

Standard Level DOE 1 2 3 4 5

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) N/A 554.10 557.73 558.30 558.30 587.23

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) N/A 49.78 48.35 48.13 48.13 47.34

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) N/A 983.29 974.56 973.27 973.27 995.39

Energy Use (kWh./a) N/A 677.29 657.78 654.84 654.84 644.09

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (Years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%)

Standard Level DOE 1 2 3 4 5

LCC Difference N/A 10.24 9.33 3.94 3.94 -803.49

Payback (year)

Field use N/A 2.5 2.7 6.3 6.3 96.3

Existing Test Proc. N/A 1.8 1.9 4.5 4.5 68.4

CCE (cent/kWh) N/A 2.2 2.3 5.4 5.4 82.1

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Room Air Conditioner, 8 to 14 KBtUlb, without Louvered Sides 

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage) 

Installed Aimual Annual 

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LeC 1999 

Level No. Cost use Expense @6% Distribution 

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$) 

DOE DOE 554.10 677.29 49.78 983.29 8.9% 

1 0 558.35 654.42 48.10 973.05 51.8% 

2 1 561.89 636.48 46.78 ' 965.22 9.7% 

3,4 2 569.09 631.59 46.42 969.33 12.2% .. 

3 713.85 610.04 44.84 1100.43 17.1% 

4 992.19 549.04 40.35 1340.11 0.2% 

5 7 1469.75 519.39 38.18 1798.88 0.0% 

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards 

Standard Level DOE 1 2 3 4 5 

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) N/A 554.10 557.73 558.30 558.30 587.23 

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) N/A 49.78 48.35 48.13 48.13 47.34 

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) N/A 983.29 974.56 973.27 973.27 995.39 

Energy Use (kWh.la) N/A 677.29 657.78 654.84 654.84 644.09 

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (Years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%) 

Standard Level DOE 2 3 4 5 

LCC Difference N/A 10.24 9.33 3.94 3.94 -803.49 

Payback (year) 

Field use N/A 2.5 2.7 6.3 6.3 96.3 

Existing Test Proc. N/A 1.8 1.9 4.5 4.5 68.4 

CCE (centlkWh) N/A 2.2 2.3 5.4 5.4 82.1 
Room Air Conditioner, with Reverse Cycle with louvered sides

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage)

Installed Annual Annual

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999

Level No. Cost use Expense @ 6% Distribution

(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$)

0 689.83' 750.16 55.14 1165.20 68.4%

DOE DOE 693.09 743.49 54.65 1164.23 1.7%

1,2 1 695.16 739.30 54.34 1163.65 1.6%

3,4 2 707.54 721.61 53.04 1164.82 3.1%

3 787.80 680.65 50.03 1219.12 23.1%

4 952.26 666.15 48.96 1374.39 2.0%

-5 7 1269.68 599.53 44.07 1649.60 0.0%

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards

Standard Level DOE 1 2 3 4 5

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 689.83 689.91 689.91 690.03 690.03 718.46

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 55.14 55.13 55.13 55.11 55.11 53.74

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 1165.20 1165.18 1165.18 1165.15 1165.15 1181.83

Energy Use (kWh./a) 750.16 750.00 750.00 749.76 749.76 731.21

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (Years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%)

Standard Level DOE 1 2 3 4 5

LCC Difference 0.97 1.53 1.53 0.33 0.33 -467.77

Payback (year)

Field use 6.6 6.7 6.7 8.5 8.5 57.0

Existing Test Proc. 4.7 4.7 4.7 6.0 6.0 40.4

CCE (cent/kWh) 5.7 5.7 5.7 7.2 7.2 48.6

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Room Air Conditioner, with Reverse Cycle with louvered sides 

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage) 

Installed Annual Annual 

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LeC 1999 

Level No. Cost use Expense @6% Distribution 

(1990$) kWhlyr (1990$) (1990$) 

0 689.83 . 750.16 55.14 1165.20 68.4% 

DOE DOE 693.09 743.49 54.65 1164.23 1.7% 

1,2 1 695.16 739.30 54.34 1163.65 1.6% 

3,4 2 707.54 721.61 53.04 1164.82 3.1% 

3 787.80 680.65 50.03 1219.12 23.1% 

4 952.26 666.15 48.96 1374.39 2.0% 

5 7 1269.68 599.53 44.07 1649.60 0.0% 

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards 

Standard Level DOE 2 3 4 5 

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) 689.83 689.91 689.91 690.03 690.03 718.46 

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) 55.14 55.13 55.13 55.11 55.11 53.74 

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) 1165.20 1165.18 1165.18 1165.15 1165.15 1181.83 

Energy Use (kWh.la) 750.16 750.00 750.00 749.76 749.76 731.21 

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6 %) 

Standard Level DOE 2 3 4 5 

LCC Difference 0.97. 1.53 1.53 0.33 0.33 -467.77 

Payback (year) 

Field use 6.6 6.7 6.7 8.5 8.5 57.0 

Existing TestProc. 4.7 4.7 4.7 6.0 6.0 40.4 

CCE (centlkWh) 5.7 5.7 5.7 7.2 7.2 48.6 
Room Air Conditioner, with Reverse Cycle without louvered sides

Cost (1990 $) and Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage)

Installed Annual Annual

Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999

Level No. Cost use Expense @ 6% Distribution

-(1990$) kWh/yr (1990$) (1990$)

DOE DOE 699.93 711.64 52.31 1150.89 27.4%

1,2 0 704.13 693.92 51.00 1143.86 32.6%

3,4 1 706.90 682.72 50.18 1139.54 19.2%

2 883.61 657.85 48.35 1300.49 20.8%

3 1225.04 592.07 43.52 1600.23 0.0%

5 4 1735.77 556.54 40.91 2088.44 0.0%

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards

Standard Level DOE 1 2 3 4 5.

Installed Consumer Cost (1990$) N/A 699.93 699.93 702.21 702.21 740.79

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) N/A 52.31 52.31 51.60 51.60 50.65

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) N/A 1150.89 1150.89 1147.08 1147.08 1177.49

Energy Use (kWh./a) N/A 711.64 711.64 702.02 702.02 689.14

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (Years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%)

Standard Level DOE 1 '2 3 4 5

LCC Difference N/A 7.03 7.03 7.54 7.54 -910.95

Payback (year)

Field use N/A N/A N/A 3.3 3.3 102.1

Existing Test Proc. N/A N/A N/A 2.3 2.3 72.5-

CCE (cent/kWh) N/A N/A N/A 2.8 2.8 87.0

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Room Air Conditioner, with Reverse Cycle without louvered sides 

Cost (1990 $) a~d Energy-Use Summary (Field Usage) 

Installed Annual Annual - Standard Design Consumer Elec. Operating LCC 1999 

Level No. Cost use Expense @6% Distribution 

-(1990$) kWhlyr (1990$) (1990$) 

DOE DOE 699.93 711.64 52.31 1150.89 . 27.4% 

1,2 0 704.13 693.92 51.00 1143.86 32.6% 

3,4 1 706.90 682.72 50.18 1139.54 19.2% 

2 883.61 657.85 48.35 1300.49 20.8% 

3 1225.04 592.07 43.52 1600.23 0.0% 

5 4 1735.77 556.54 40.91 2088.44 0.0% . 

Weighted Average of Units Sold below Standards 

Standard Level DOE 2 3 4 5. 

Installed Consumer Cost (1990 $) N/A 699.93 699.93 702.21 702.21 740.79 

Annual Operating Cost (1990 $) N/A , 52.31 52.31 51.60 51.60 50.65 

Life-Cycle Cost at 6% (1990 $) N/A 1150.89 1150.89 1147.08 1147.08 1177.49 

Energy Use (kWh.la) N/A 711.64 711.64 702.02 702.02 689.14 

Life-Cycle Cost Difference (1990$), Payback Periods (years), and Costs of Conserved Energy (at 6%) 

Standard Level DOE '2 3 4 5 

LCC Difference N/A 7.03 7.03 7.54 ' 7.54 -910.95 

Payback (year) 

Field use N/A N/A N/A 3.3 3.3 102.1 

Existing Test Proc. N/A N/A N/A 2.3 2.3 72.5 ' 

CCE (centlkWh) N/A N/A N/A 2.8 2.8 87.0 
LCC Sensitivity to 1995 State Energy Prices for

Room A/C, 8000 to 13,999 Btu/hr (with louvered sides) in 1990$

Sensitivity Scenarios

Efficiency Level Design No. Reference Low State Elect. Price High State Elect. Price

0 $934.92 $746.55 $1,213.59

1 1 $928.16 $747.29 $1,195.73

2 2 $926.21 $747.86 $1,190.06

3 3 $923.75 $750.06 $1,180.70

4 4 $950.52 $790.40 $1,187.40

5 $1,064.78 $907.30 $1,297.75

5 6 $1,260.39 $1,118.66 $1,470.06

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

LCC Sensitivity to 1995 State Energy Prices for 

~oom Ale, 8000 to 13,999 Btulhr (with louvered sides) in 1990$ 

Sensitivity Scenarios 

Efficiency Level Design No. Reference Low State Elect. Price High State Elect. Price 

0 $934.92 $746.55 $1,213.59 

$928.16 $747.29 $1,195.73 

2 2 $926.21 $747.86 $1,190.06 

3 3 $923.75 $750.06 $1,180.70 

4 4 $950.52 $790.40· $1,187.40 

5 $1,064.78 $907.30· $1,297.75 

5 6 $1,260.39 $1,118.66 $1,470.06 
Net Present Value to Consumers for Room A/C purchased from 1999 to 2030 based on

1995 AEO fuel price projections

(billion 1990$ discounted to 1990 at 7%)

Fuel Savings 0.76

Equipment Cost 0.25

Net Present Value 0.51

Net Present Value to Consumers for Room A/C purchased from 2000 to 2030 based on

1997 AEO fuel price projections

(billion 1990$ discounted to 1990 at 7%)

Fuel Savings , 0.74

Equipment Cost 0.29

Net Present Value 0.45

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Net Present Value to Consumers for Room AlC purchased from 1999 to 2030 based on 

1995 AEO fuel price projections 

(biUion 1990$ di .. counted to 1990 at 7%) 

Fuel Savings 0.76 

Equipment Cost 0.25 

Net Present Value 0.51 

Net Present Value to Consumers for Room AIC purchased from 2000 to 2030 based on 

1997 AEO fuel price projections 

(biUion 1990$ diScounted to 1990 at 7%) 

Fuel Savings < 0.74 

Equipment Cost 0.29 

Net Present Value 0.45 
Room Air Conditioner Energy Consumption as a Percent of Total Consumption

Year Fuel Price Total RAC Residentail Total Residential RAC Percent of Total

Projection Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption

(Quads) (Quads)

1995 AEO 1995 0.368 10.884 3.38%

1996 AEO 1996 0.367 10.880 3.37%

1997 AEO 1997 0.379 11.081 3.42%

4 ' ' *~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

Room Air Conditioner Energy Consumption as a Percent of Total Consumption 

Year 

1995 

1996 

1997 

Fuel Price 

. Projection 

AEO 1995 

AEO 1996 

AEO 1997 

Total RAC Residentail 

Electricity Consumption 

(Quads) 

0.368 

0.367 

0.379 

Total Residential 

Electricity Consumption 

(Quads) 

10.884 

10.880 

11.081 

RA C Percent of Total 

Electricity Consumption 

3.38% 

3.37% 

3.421k; 
ELECTRICITY POLLUTANT REDUCTIONS BASED ON AEO 1995 FUEL PRICE PROJECTIONS

S02 Emissions

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total

kt short tons kt short tons kt short tons Residential

000's 000's 000's Emissions

2000 1.14 1.26 0.00 0.00 1.14 1.26 0.03

2005 2.68 2.95 0.00 0.00 2.68 2.95 0.09

2010 3.57 3.94 0.00 0.00 3.57 3.94 0.13

2015 3.04 3.35 0.00 0.00 3.04 3.35 0.13

2020 2.57 2.83 0.00 0.00 2.57 2.83 0.13

2025 1.97 2.17 0.00 0.00 1.97 2.17 0.12

2030 1.65 1.81 0.13 0.15 1.78 1.96 0.13

Cumulative S02 reduction, 79 kt = 87,000 short tons

NOx Emissions

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total

kt short tons kt short tons kt short tons Residential

000's 000's 000's Emissions

2000 0.85 0.94 0.05 0.05 0.89 0.99 0.03

2005 .2.15 2.37 0.00 0.00 2.15 2.37 0.08

2010 3.10 3.42 0.00 0.00 3.10 3.42 0.12

2015 2.81 3.10 0.00 0.00 2.81 3.10 0.12

2020 2.57 2.83 0.00 0.00 2.57 2.83 0.11

2025 2.16 2.38 0.00 0.00 2.16 2.38 0.11

2030 2.02 2.23 0.10 0.11 2.12 2.34 0.11

Cumulative Nox redution, 74 kt = 82,000 short tons

C02 Emissions

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total

Mt short tons Mt short tons Mt short tons Residential

000's 000's 000's Emissions

2000 0.32 0.35 0.05 0.05 0.37 0.40 0.03

2005 0.88 0.97 0.00 0.00 0.88 0.97 0.07

2010 1.37 1.51 0.00 0.00 1.37 1.51 0.10

2015 1.44 1.59 0.00 0.00 1.44 1.59 0.10

2020 1.52 1.67 0.00 0.00 1.52 1.67 0.10

2025 1.50 1.66 0.00 0.00 1.50 1.66 0.10

2030 1.65 1.82 0.12 0.13 1.77 1.95 0.11

Cumulative C02 reduction, 41 Mt = 45,000,000 short tons

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

ELECTRICITY POLLUTANT REDUCTIONS BASED ON AEO 1995 FUEL PRICE PROJECTIONS 

S02 Emissions 

Abated from Abated' from Total Reduction Reduction as 

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total 

kt short tons kt short tons kt short tons Residential 

OOO's OOO's Ooo's Emissions 

2000 1.14 1.26 0.00 0.00 1.14 1.26 0.03 

2005 2.68 2.95 0.00 0.00 2.68 2.95 0.09 

2010 3.57 3.94 0.00 0.00 3.57 3.94 0.13 

2015 3.04 3.35 0.00 0.00 3.04 3.35 0.13 

2020 2.57 2.83 0.00 0.00 2.57 2.83 0.13 

2025 1.97 2.17 0.00 0.00 1.97 2.17 0.12 

2030 1.65 l.81 0.13 0.15 1.78 l.96 0.13 

Cumulative· S02 reduction, 79 kt = 87 ,000 short tons 

NOx Emissions 

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as 

Year . Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total 

kt short tons kt short tons kt short tons Residential 

ooo's ooo's ooo's Emissions 

2000 0.85 0;94 0.05 0.05 0.89 0.99 0.03 

2005 .2.15 2.37 0.00 0.00 2.15 2.37 0.08 

2010 3.10 3.42 0.00 0.00 3.10 3.42 0.12 

2015 2.81 .3.10 0.00 0.00 2.81 3.10 0.12 

2020 2.57 2.83 0.00 0.00 2.57 2.83 0.11 

2025 2.16 2.38 0.00 0.00 2.16 2.38 0.11 

2030 2.02 2.23 0.10 0.11 2.12 2.34 0.11 

Cumulative Nox redution, 74 kt = 82,000 short tons 

C02 Emissions 

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as 

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total 

Mt short tons Mt short tons Mt short tons Residential 

ooo's OOO's OOO's Emissions 

2000 0.32 0.35 0.05 0.05 0.37 0.40 0.03 

2005 0.88 0.97 0.00 0.00 0.88 0.97 0.07 

2010 1.37 1.51 0.00 0.00 l.37 1.51 0.10 

2015 l.44 l.59 0.00 0.00 l.44 1.59 0.10 

2020 l.52 l.67 0.00 0.00 l.52 1.67 0.10 

2025 l.50 l.66 0.00 0.00 1.50 1.66 0.10 

2030 1.65 l.82 0.12 0.13 l.77 1.95 0.11 

Cumulative C02 reduction, 41 Mt = 45,000,000 short tons 
ELECTRICITY POLLUTANT REDUCTIONS BASED ON AEO 1997 FUEL PRICE PROJECTIONS

S02 Emissions

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total

kt short tons kt short tons kt short tons Residential

000's 000's 000's Emissions

2000 0.57 0.63 0.00 0.00 0.57 0.63 0.02

2005 2.68 2.95 0.00 0.00 2.68 ,2.95 0.08

2010 4.20 4.63 . 0.13 0.15 4.34 4.78 0.14

2015 4.22 4.65 0.00 0.00 4.22 4.65 0.16

2020 3.65 4.02 0.00 0.00 3.65 4.02 0.17

2025 2.91 3.20 0.13 0.15 3.04 3.35 0.17

2030 2.43 2.68 0.00 0.00 2.43 2.68 0.17

Cumulative S02 reduction, 100 kt = 110,000 short tons

NOx Emissions

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total

kt short tons kt short tons kt short tons Residential

000's 000's 000's Emissions

2000 0.42 0.47 0.00 0.00 0.42 0.47 0.01

2005 2.15 2.37 0.00 0.00 2.15 2.37 0.08

2010 3.65 4.03 0.10 0.11 3.75 4.14 0.13

2015 3.91 4.31 0.00 0.00 3.91 4.31 0.15

2020 3.65 4.02 0.05 0.05 3.69 4.07 0.15

2025 3.18 3.51 0.10 0.11 3.28 3.62 0.15

2030 2.99 3.29 0.05 0.05 3.03 3.34 0.15

Cumulative Nox redution, 95 kt = 105,000 short tons

C02 Emissions

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total

Mt short tons Mt short tons Mt short tons Residential

000's 000's 000's Emissions

2000 0.16 0.18 0.00 0.00 0.16 0.18 0.01

2005 0.88 0.97 0.00 0.00 0.88 0.97 0.06

2010 1.61 1.78 0.12 0.13 1.73 1.91 0.12

2015 2.01 2.21 0.00 0.00 2.01 2.21 0.13

2020 2.16 2.38 0.05 0.05 2.21 2.43 0.14

2025 2.22 2.44 0.12 0.13 2.34 2.57 0.14

2030 2.43 2.68 0.05 0.05 2.48 2.73 0.14

Cumulative C02 reduction, 54 Mt = 59,000,000 short tons

EE-RM-93-801-RAC COMMENT 13

-. 

ELECTRICITY POLLUTANT REDUCTIONS BASED ON AEO 1997 FUEL PRICE PROJECTIONS 

S02 Emissions 

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as 

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total 

kt short tons kt short tons kt short tons Residential 

OOO's OOO's OOO's Emissions 

2000 OS? 0.63 0.00 0.00 0.57 0.63 0.02 

2005 2.68 2.95 0.00 0.00 2.68 _ 2.95 0.08 

2010 4.20 4.63 . 0.13 0.15 4.34 4.78 0.14 

2015 4.22 4.65 0.00 0.00 4.22 4.65 0.16 

2020 3.65 4.02 0.00 0.00 3.65 4.02 0.17 

2025 2.91 3.20 0.13 0.15 3.04 3.35 0.17 

2030 2.43 2.68 0.00 0.00 2.43 2.68 0.17 

Cumulative S02 reduction, 100 kt = 110,000 short tons 

NOx Emissions 

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as 

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total 

kt short tons kt short tons kt short tons Residential 

OOO's OOO's OOO's Emissions 

2000 0.42 0.47 0.00 0.00 0.42 0.47 0.01 

2005 2.15 2.37 0.00 0.00 2.15 2.37 0.08 

2010 3.65 4.03 0.10 0.11 3.75 4.14 0.13 

2015 3.91 4.31 0.00 0.00 3.91 4.31 0.15 

2020 3.65 4.02 0.05 0.05 3.69 4.07 0.15 

2025 3.18 3.51 0.10 0.11 3.28 3.62 0.15 

2030 2.99 3.29 0.05 0.05 3.03 3.34 0.15 

Cumulative Nox redution, 95 kt = 105,000 short tons 

C02 Emissions 

Abated from Abated from Total Reduction Reduction as 

Year Power Plant in House in Emissions % of Total 

Mt short tons Mt short tons Mt short tons Residential 

OOO's OOO's OOO's Emissions 

2000 0.16 0.18 0.00 0.00 0.16 0.18 0.01 

2005 0.88 0.97 0.00 0.00 0.88 0.97 0.06 

2010 1.61 1.78 0.12 0.13 1.73 1.91 0.12 

2015 2.01 2.21 0.00 0.00 2.01 2.21 0.13 

2020 2.16 2.38 0.05 0.05 2.21 2.43 0.14 

2025 2.22 2.44 0.12 0.13 2.34 2.57 0.14 

2030 2.43 2.68 0.05 0.05 2.48 2.73 0.14 

Cumulative C02 reduction, 54 Mt = 59,000,000 short tons