west virginia department of environmental protection

Appendix H.1

Cost Effectiveness Curve Design

Promoting a healthy environment.
[This page intentionally left blank.]
List provides all controls as applied to every source

First record includes current controlled unit with existing CE value (if available)

Yellow highlighted source is used in next sheet examples

FIPSST FIPSCNTY Plantid Plant Name Point ID Segment SCC PLLT Source meas Control CE nox_ann nox_red cpt totcost

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 222.73 997 222,057

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 445.45 222.73 4,706 1,048,144

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 445.45 267.27 3,113 832,012

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 289.54 827 239,452

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356.36 2,711 966,092

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns 29.99 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30% 29.99 9.00 559 5,029

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0582S LNB 30% 29.99 9.00 681 6,127

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50% 29.99 15.00 936 14,035

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0584S SNCR - NH3 Based 50% 29.99 15.00 1,034 15,505

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80% 29.99 23.99 4,098 98,315

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns 61.40 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30% 61.40 18.42 559 10,297

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0582S LNB 30% 61.40 18.42 681 12,544

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50% 61.40 30.70 936 28,735

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0584S SNCR - NH3 Based 50% 61.40 30.70 1,034 31,744

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80% 61.40 49.12 4,098 201,294

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns 55.00 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30% 55.00 16.50 555 9,158

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0582S LNB 30% 55.00 16.50 676 11,154

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50% 55.00 27.50 929 25,548

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0584S SNCR - NH3 Based 50% 55.00 27.50 1,026 28,215

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80% 55.00 44.00 4,066 178,904

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 1 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 357.81 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 1 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 357.81 178.91 997 178,368

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 1 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 357.81 178.91 4,706 841,927

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 1 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 357.81 214.69 3,113 668,318

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 1 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 357.81 232.58 827 192,341

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 1 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 357.81 286.25 2,711 776,018

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 2 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 357.81 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 2 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 357.81 178.91 997 178,368

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 2 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 357.81 178.91 4,706 841,927

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 2 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 357.81 214.69 3,113 668,318

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 2 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 357.81 232.58 827 192,341

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 2 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 357.81 286.25 2,711 776,018

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 3 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 320.50 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 3 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 320.50 160.25 989 158,487

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 3 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 320.50 160.25 4,669 748,207

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 3 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 320.50 192.30 3,089 594,015

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 3 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 320.50 208.33 820 170,827

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 3 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 320.50 256.40 2,691 689,972

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 4 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 320.50 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 4 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 320.50 160.25 989 158,487

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 4 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 320.50 160.25 4,669 748,207

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 4 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 320.50 192.30 3,089 594,015

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 4 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 320.50 208.33 820 170,827

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 4 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 320.50 256.40 2,691 689,972

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns 47.98 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30% 47.98 14.40 559 8,047

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0582S LNB 30% 47.98 14.40 681 9,803

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50% 47.98 23.99 936 22,456

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0584S SNCR - NH3 Based 50% 47.98 23.99 1,034 24,807

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80% 47.98 38.39 4,098 157,306

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns 98.24 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30% 98.24 29.47 559 16,475

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0582S LNB 30% 98.24 29.47 681 20,070

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50% 98.24 49.12 936 45,976

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0584S SNCR - NH3 Based 50% 98.24 49.12 1,034 50,790

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80% 98.24 78.59 4,098 322,070

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns 88.00 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30% 88.00 26.40 555 14,652

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0582S LNB 30% 88.00 26.40 676 17,846

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50% 88.00 44.00 929 40,876

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0584S SNCR - NH3 Based 50% 88.00 44.00 1,026 45,144

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80% 88.00 70.40 4,066 286,246

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 1 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas 13.60 0.00 0 0

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 1 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0171S LNB 50% 13.60 6.80 997 6,780

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 1 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0175S SNCR 50% 13.60 6.80 4,706 32,001

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 1 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0172S LNB + FGR 60% 13.60 8.16 3,113 25,402

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 1 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0173S OT + WI 65% 13.60 8.84 827 7,311

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 1 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0174S SCR 80% 13.60 10.88 2,711 29,496

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 2 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas 12.50 0.00 0 0

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 2 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0171S LNB 50% 12.50 6.25 989 6,181

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 2 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0175S SNCR 50% 12.50 6.25 4,669 29,181

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 2 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0172S LNB + FGR 60% 12.50 7.50 3,089 23,168

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 2 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0173S OT + WI 65% 12.50 8.13 820 6,663

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 2 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0174S SCR 80% 12.50 10.00 2,691 26,910

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 1 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil 22.56 0.00 0 0

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 1 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0161S LNB 50% 22.56 11.28 1,435 16,187

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 1 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0164S SNCR 50% 22.56 11.28 5,642 63,642

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 1 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0162S LNB + FGR 60% 22.56 13.54 3,028 40,987

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 1 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0163S SCR 80% 22.56 18.05 3,380 61,002

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 2 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil 21.90 0.00 0 0

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 2 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0161S LNB 50% 21.90 10.95 1,424 15,593

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 2 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0162S LNB + FGR 60% 21.90 13.14 3,004 39,473

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 2 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0163S SCR 80% 21.90 17.52 3,354 58,762

WV Regional Haze SIP Appendix H.1 - 1
This sheet shows incremental steps taken to estimate controls for final solution

Each group of six (6) rows is for same unit just with next step applied -- comments at end of row

Remove control strategies which do not show incremental benefit

FIPSST FIPSCNTY Plantid Plant Name Point ID Segment SCC PLLT Source meas Control CE nox_ann nox_red cpt totcost inc_reduction inc_cost marginal remove reason for decision

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 223 997 222,057

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 445.45 223 4,706 1,048,144

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 445.45 267 3,113 832,012

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 290 827 239,452

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356 2,711 966,092

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 223 997 222,057 223 222,057 997 N Reduction and cost are both positive compared to previous strategy

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 445.45 223 4,706 1,048,144

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 445.45 267 3,113 832,012

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 290 827 239,452

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356 2,711 966,092

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 223 997 222,057 223 222,057 997 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 445.45 223 4,706 1,048,144 0 826,087 Y No additional reduction for higher cost

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 445.45 267 3,113 832,012

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 290 827 239,452

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356 2,711 966,092

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 223 997 222,057 223 222,057 997 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 445.45 223 4,706 1,048,144 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 445.45 267 3,113 832,012 45 609,955 13,693 N Reduction and cost are both positive compared to previous strategy

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 290 827 239,452

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356 2,711 966,092

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 223 997 222,057 223 222,057 997 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 445.45 223 4,706 1,048,144 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 445.45 267 3,113 832,012 45 609,955 13,693 Y Now remove because next strategy gets better reduction for less cost

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 290 827 239,452 22 -592,559 -26,604 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356 2,711 966,092

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 223 997 222,057 223 222,057 997 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 445.45 223 4,706 1,048,144 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 445.45 267 3,113 832,012 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 290 827 239,452 67 17,395 260 N Recalculate and shows that reduction and cost are both positive compared to previous strategy

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356 2,711 966,092

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 223 997 222,057 223 222,057 997 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 445.45 223 4,706 1,048,144 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 445.45 267 3,113 832,012 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 290 827 239,452 67 17,395 260 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356 2,711 966,092 67 726,640 10,875 N Reduction and cost are both positive compared to previous strategy

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 223 997 222,057 223 222,057 997 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0615S SNCR 50% 445.45 223 4,706 1,048,144 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0612S LNB + FGR 60% 445.45 267 3,113 832,012 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 290 827 239,452 67 17,395 260 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356 2,711 966,092 67 726,640 10,875 N Final options leave four (4) options available for solution

WV Regional Haze SIP Appendix H.1 - 2
This sheet shows incremental steps taken to estimate controls for final solution from remaining four (4) strategies

Determine if incremental strategies are off the cost effectiveness curve and if so, delete outliers

Remove control strategies which do not show incremental cost effectiveness

FIPSST FIPSCNTY Plantid Plant Name Point ID Segment SCC PLLT Source meas Control CE nox_ann nox_red cpt totcost inc_reduction inc_cost marginal remove reason for decision

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0.00 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 222.73 997 222057 222.73 222057 997 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 289.54 827 239452 66.82 17395 260 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356.36 2711 966092 66.82 726640 10875 N Final options leave four (4) options available for solution

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0.00 0 0 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 222.73 997 222057 222.73 222057 997 Y Next highest strategy is more cost effective

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 289.54 827 239452 66.82 17395 260

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356.36 2711 966092 66.82 726640 10875

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0.00 0 0 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 222.73 997 222057 222.73 222057 997 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 289.54 827 239452 289.54 239452 827 Recalculate marginal cost

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356.36 2711 966092 66.82 726640 10875

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0.00 0 0 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 222.73 997 222057 222.73 222057 997 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 289.54 827 239452 289.54 239452 827 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356.36 2711 966092 66.82 726640 10875 N Strategy is less cost effective than previous strategy

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces 445.45 0.00 0 0 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0611S LNB 50% 445.45 222.73 997 222057 222.73 222057 997 Y

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65% 445.45 289.54 827 239452 289.54 239452 827 N

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80% 445.45 356.36 2711 966092 66.82 726640 10875 N Now left with three (3) options for final solution

WV Regional Haze SIP Appendix H.1 - 3
This sheet shows remaining incremental cost effectiveness for all strategies from all sources in first sheet

Sort entire list on marginal cost and decreasing reduction (lowest CPT and highest reduction)

Run down list until user defined marginal CPT limit is met or until emission reduction cap (or limit) is attained

Take last identifed control strategy from each source; note that some sources may be so cost ineffective to control that the "No Control" option is chosen.

Two examples provided here. Go to line that matches highlight color:

1. Want to achieve domainwide reduction of 1,800 tons per year NOx

2. Want to reduce emissions until marginal CPT value exceeds $1,500/ton reduced

FIPSST FIPSCNTY Plantid Plant Name Point ID Segment SCC PLLT Source meas Control CE nox_ann nox_red cpt totcost inc_reduction inc_cost marginal Reduction Cost

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces None 0 445 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 1 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces None 0 358 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 2 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces None 0 358 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 3 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces None 0 321 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 4 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces None 0 321 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns None 0 98 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns None 0 88 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns None 0 61 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns None 0 55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns None 0 48 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns None 0 30 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 1 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil None 0 23 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 2 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil None 0 22 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 1 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas None 0 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 2 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas None 0 13 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30 88 26 555 14,652 26 14,652 555 26 14,652

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30 55 17 555 9,158 17 9,158 555 43 23,810

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30 98 29 559 16,475 29 16,475 559 72 40,285

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30 61 18 559 10,297 18 10,297 559 91 50,582

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30 48 14 559 8,047 14 8,047 559 105 58,629

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0581S Mid-Kiln Firing 30 30 9 559 5,029 9 5,029 559 114 63,658

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 3 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65 321 208 820 170,827 208 170,827 820 323 234,485

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 4 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65 321 208 820 170,827 208 170,827 820 531 405,312

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 2 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0173S OT + WI 65 13 8 820 6,663 8 6,663 820 539 411,975

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65 445 290 827 239,452 290 239,452 827 829 651,427

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 1 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65 358 233 827 192,341 233 192,341 827 1,061 843,768

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 2 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0613S OT + WI 65 358 233 827 192,341 233 192,341 827 1,294 1,036,109

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 1 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0173S OT + WI 65 14 9 827 7,311 9 7,311 827 1,302 1,043,420

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 2 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0161S LNB 50 22 11 1,424 15,593 11 15,593 1,424 1,313 1,059,013

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 1 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0161S LNB 50 23 11 1,435 16,187 11 16,187 1,435 1,325 1,075,200

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50 88 44 929 40,876 18 26,224 1,490 1,342 1,101,424

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50 55 28 929 25,548 11 16,390 1,490 1,353 1,117,814

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50 98 49 936 45,976 20 29,501 1,501 1,373 1,147,315

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50 61 31 936 28,735 12 18,438 1,501 1,385 1,165,753

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50 48 24 936 22,456 10 14,409 1,502 1,395 1,180,162

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0583S SNCR - Urea Based 50 30 15 936 14,035 6 9,006 1,502 1,401 1,189,168

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 2 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0163S SCR 80 22 18 3,354 58,762 7 43,169 6,571 1,407 1,232,337

01 003 0007 UNIROYAL CHEMICAL 002 1 10200502 NOx ICI Boilers - Distillate Oil N0163S SCR 80 23 18 3,380 61,002 7 44,815 6,622 1,414 1,277,152

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80 88 70 4,066 286,246 26 245,370 9,294 1,441 1,522,522

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 3 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80 55 44 4,066 178,904 17 153,356 9,294 1,457 1,675,878

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80 98 79 4,098 322,070 29 276,094 9,368 1,487 1,951,972

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 2 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80 61 49 4,098 201,294 18 172,559 9,368 1,505 2,124,531

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 017 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80 48 38 4,098 157,306 14 134,850 9,368 1,519 2,259,381

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 012 1 30700106 NOx Lime Kilns N0585S SCR 80 30 24 4,098 98,315 9 84,280 9,369 1,528 2,343,661

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 2 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0174S SCR 80 13 10 2,691 26,910 2 20,247 10,798 1,530 2,363,908

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 3 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80 321 256 2,691 689,972 48 519,145 10,799 1,578 2,883,053

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 4 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80 321 256 2,691 689,972 48 519,145 10,799 1,626 3,402,198

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 010 1 30700104 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80 445 356 2,711 966,092 67 726,640 10,875 1,693 4,128,838

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 1 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80 358 286 2,711 776,018 54 583,677 10,875 1,747 4,712,515

01 001 0001 UNION CAMP CORPORATION 015 2 30700110 NOx Sulfate Pulping - Recovery Furnaces N0614S SCR 80 358 286 2,711 776,018 54 583,677 10,875 1,801 5,296,192

01 003 0006 INTERNATIONAL PAPER 002 1 10300603 NOx ICI Boilers - Natural Gas N0174S SCR 80 14 11 2,711 29,496 2 22,185 10,875 1,803 5,318,377

Running Values

Totals

WV Regional Haze SIP Appendix H.1 - 4