### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 02/20


# .... 

# • ..... EICHENBERGER .Q..ASSOCIATES

.**-~~~** A legal professional association



### .


## Federal AviationAdministration 800Independence Avenue, S.W. Washington, 

## DC 20591 Attn: 

## Hearing Docket Clerk AGC-430, Wilber WrightBuilding Suite 2Wl000

To the Hearing Docket Clerk, October 1, 20!5

Re: EAJAApplication 

## DocketNo.: FAA-2014-0119 CaseNo.: 2012-GL-07-0056
Please fmd the following docmnents enclosed: 

## 1. Application for an 

## Award OfAttorney Fees And Other Expenses Pursuant to The Equal Access To Justice Act (EAJA); and 2. Motion to Exclude Confidential Informationfrom Public Record. Exhibit A has been withheld from the Docket's copy ofthe filing pending the outcome ofthe MotiontoExclude.

Enclosures CC: Kate Barber, Esq. Lauren Hoyson, Esq. Judge J.E. Sullivan Sincere

# atri~~

6037Frantz Road, Suite 107! Dublin, Ohio43017! 

# T/ 614-798-1600 

# I F/6:t,k798-t6oo 

# Iwww.ehlawyers.com

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 03/20



## UNITED STATES OF AMERICA DEPARTMENT OFTRANSPORTATION OFFICE OF HEARINGS

WASHINGTON,D.C. ) 

## SpiritAvionics, LTD., ) ) 

## Applicant, ) ) 

## v. ) ) 

## MichaelP. Huerta, ) Administrator ) Federal AviationAdministration, ) ) 

## Respondent. ) ) 

## __ EAJA __ _ DocketNo. FAA-2014-0119 Case No.

## 2012-GL-07-0056 JudgeJ.E. Sullivan

APPLICATION FORANAWARD OFATTORNEYFEES AND OTHEREXPENSES PURSUANT TO THE EQUAL ACCESS TOJUSTICEACT (EAJA). Pursuant to 5 U.S.C. §504 and 14 CFR §14.01 et seq., Spirit Avionics, Ltd. (hereinafter, the "Applicant"), through its undersigned counsel, hereby applies for attorney fees and other expensesincurred inthe matterofAdministrator v. SpiritAvionics. Ltd., FAADocketNo. FAA2014-0119. Thefollowingpoints aremade in

## supportofthis application: (Al

## Tfle Oftlcial Record ofthisMatterDiscloses That: I. 

## On or about May 8, 2014, the Federal Aviation Administration ("FAA") Regional Counsel for the Great Lakes Region filed a Complaint against Applicant with the U.S. DepartmentofTransportation, Office ofHearings. 2. In its Complaint, the FAA generally alleged that on or about February 24, 2011, Applicant had committed a minimmn often (10) violations of 14 C.P.R. § 

## 21.9(b) when it sold 22 fabricated brackets and 22 fabricated lanyards to Lane Aviation, a subcontractor of Applicant, and represented inthe sale ofsuch articles that they were suitable for installation 1

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 04/20



## ontype certificated, FAAaircraft. 1 

## 3. OnJune 1,2015, Applicantfiled a Motion forDecision("Motion"). 4. On 

## July 1, 2015, the FAA filed a combined Response to Respondent's Motion for Decision ("Response") and Complainant's Motion for Decision in Favorofthe Complainant ("FAAMotionfor Decision"). 5. On July 13, 2015 Applicant filed a Motion to Strike the FAA's Response and a Motion for Extension of Time to Respond to Complainant's Motion Pending the Decision of Respondent'sMotionto Strikefiled on 7-1-2015. 6. On July 31, 2015 Judge J

## .E. Sullivan issued an Order Granting the FAA's Motion to File a Late Response and Granting Applicant's Motions for Extension andto StrikeFAA Motion forDecision. 7. On 

## Augast 11, 2015, the parties appeared by telephone for a Motion Conference, and presented oral argument onApplicant's Motion. 8. On Augt!St 27, 2015, an Order Granting Applicant's Motion for Summary Judgment, Cancellingthe Hearing, and DismissingtheProceedingwas filed byJudgeJ.E. Sullivan. 

## (B) Applicantis a PrevailingPartyofan EligibleProceeding. 9. Complainantfiled 

## its Complaint againstApplicantpursuantto 49 U.S.C. 46301. 10. 14 C.F.R. §14.02 provides that this subpart applies to proceedings initiated under 49 

# u.s.c. 46301. 11. Points 1-8 above clearlyestablish that Applicantis a prevailingparty. 

## (C) ThePosition ofthe FAA

## was NotSubstantiallyJustified. 12. 14 C.F.R. §14.04 provides that a prevailing applicant mayreceive an award for attorney fees and other expenses incurred in connection with a proceeding, or in a significant and 1

### Compl. 2. 

## 2

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 05/20



## discrete substantive portion ofthe proceeding, unless the position ofthe agency over which the applicanthasprevailedwas substantiallyjustified. 13. §

## 14.04(a) further provides that the burden ofproofthat an award should not be made to an eligible prevailing applicant is on the agency counsel, who may avoid an award by showing thatthe agency'sposition was reasonable in law and fact. 14. In 

## its Complaint, the FAA generally alleged that on or about February 24, 2011, Applicant had committed a minimum often (10) violations of 14 C.F.R. § 

## 21.9(b) when it sold 22 fabricated brackets and 22 fabricated lanyards to Lane Aviation, a subcontractor of Applicant, and represented in the sale ofsuch articles that they were suitable for installation ontype certificated,FAA aircraft. 15. The onlysupport for this assertionwas aninvoice issued to'Lane Aviation byApplicant. 16. Applicantnever "sold" anything to its subcontractor, Lane Aviation. 17. At all relevant times, the FAA was aware of the business relationship between Lane Aviation and Applicant as it was specifically stated in the agreement Applicant signed with theFAA. 18. Despite multipleinformal conferences, explanation ofthe facts material to thetransaction in question, and connnunications with both FAA inspectors and stair counsel, the FAA continuedtopursueits enforcement proceeding. 19. Applicant filed a Motion for Decision on the basis that Applicants transaction with its subcontractorwas not a "sale'' undereveryapplicable definition oftheterm. 20. Applicant's Motionwas subsequently grantedin its 

## favor and tl1e case was dismissed. 21. In lightofthe foregoing, the FAA'spositionwas not reasonable inlaw orfact.



## 3

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 06/20


## (D) Applicantis an 

## Eligible PartyUnder 14C.F.R. §14, etseq. 22. Spirit Avionics, Ltd. is an 

## Ohio limited liability company that is in the business of providing services to aircraft pursuant to its Operations Specifications under its Approved Repair StationCertificate. 23. Applicant's net worth at the initiation ofthese proceedings did not exceed $7,000,000.00. A detailed exhibit showing the net worth of the Applicant at the initiation of these proceedings is attached as 

## EXHIBITA.2 

## 24. At the initiationofthe proceedings, Applicant did not employmorethan 500 employees. (E) 

## Totalfees forwhichanaward 

## is sought: 25. 

## Thetotal fees for which an award is sought: $19,819.90 26. Documentationofattorney fees is attached as "EXHIBITB."Further, Applicantreserves the right to amend this exhibit to retlect additional fees incurred in pursuit of this Application. 27. Documentation ofexpenses related to the defense ofthe action is attached as "EXHIBIT C."

## Wherefore, Applicant respectfully requests thai it be granted an award in the amount of $19,819.90, which represents the amount of Applicant's attorney's fees and other expenses, pursuant to the Equal Access to Justice Act, as well additional fees for the pursuit ofthis award and other fees incurred by Applicant in defending this matter as the FAA's position was not reasonableinlaw orfact. I 

## hereby certify underpenalty ofperjurythat the informationprovided in this application istrue

## and correct.

2 

### Applicant has filed a Motion to Exclude this information from the public record simultaneously with this Application. This information, however, hasbeen provided to FAA Counsel. 

## 4

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 07/20


## Respectfully submitted,

"ckJ. Moro 

## Jerry A Eichenberger Eichenberger & 

## Associates, Co. LPA 6037Frantz Road, Suite 107 Dublin, Ohio 43017 Phone: 614-798-1600 Facsimile: 614-798-1620 

## Counsel forApplicant

5

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 08/20



## CERTIFICATE OFSERVICE 

## I hereby certify that a copy ofthe foregoing was served upon the following parties by facsimile this 1stday ofOctober, 2015.

**FAA.O~:armg** 

## Docket 

## 800

**Ind~p·endence** 

## Ave, S.W. Washil):gton, D.C. 20591 Attn: HearingDocketClerk AGC-430,WilberWrightBuilding Suite 2Wl000 Fax: 202-267-1293 The IJonorableJ.E. Sullivan 

## U.S. AdministrativeLaw Judge Office ofHearings, M-20 U.S. DepartmentofTranspm1ation 1200NewJerseyAve, S.E. (Ell-310) Washington, D.C. 20590 Fax: 202-366-7536 KllteBarber LaurenBoyson 

## FederalAviationAdministration Office ofRegional Counsel, AGL-7B 2300EastDevonAvenue Des Plaines, Illinois 60018 Fax: 847"294-7862



## 6

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 09/20 

# jOMMITTED:

''EXHIBITA''

* Pending outcome ofMotionto Exclude ConfidentialFinancial Information filed: 10-1-15

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 10/20

Eichenberger & 

### Associates A Legal Professi-onal Association 6037 Frantz Road, Suite 107 Dublin, ·ohio 43017 Tax m: 31-17$7586 Invoices

**Sllb-mlt~ed** to; Spirit Avionics, Ltd. Attn-: Ric-k Ochs 4808 East Fifth Street Columbus, Ohio 432.19 Date: Re: FAA v. Spirit Avionics, ltd. King.Air Case OuT File No.1016-10742 Professional Services Pate Initials Description 3/8/2013 JAE Telephone call from Rick Ochs JAE Letter to Kate Barber 3/25/2013 JAE Letterto Rick Ochs 4/1/2013 JAE Telephone call from Kate Barber 4/2/2013 JAE Emat! from and to Kate Barber 

### " JAE Emall to Rick Ochs 4/8/2013 JAE Telephone call from client 4/11/2013 JAE Meeting with client. Informal conference with FAA. 4/23/2013 JAE Telephone Call from Rick ochs. 4/26/2013 JAE Emailto Rii;:k Ochs 4/29/2013 JAE Telephone call from Rick Ochs. 5/9/2013 JAE Emaltto RickOchs. Hours 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.2 0.1 0.2 3.2 0.3 0.1 0.3 0.1 

### $ $ $ 

### $ $ $ $ 

### $ $ 

### $ $ 

### $ 

# EXHIBIT 

# B

Rate Amount 250.00 

### $ 75.00 250.00 

### $ 75.00 250.00 

### $ 75.00 250.00 

### $ 75.00 250.00 

### $ 50.00 250.00 

### $ 25.00 250.00 

### $ 50.00 250.00 

### $ 800.00 250.00 

### $ 75.00 250.00 

### $ 25.00 250.00 

### $ 75.00 250.00 

### $ 25.00

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Data: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 11/20

5(13/201;! JAE Telephone call to Rick Ochs. 0.2 

### $ 250.00 

### $ 50.00 5/14/2013 JAE Meetingwith Rick Ochs and Conducted Informal Conference with Faa. 2.8 

### $ 250.00 

### $ 700.00 7/25/2013 IAE Telephone call from Kate Barber 0.3 

### $ 250.00 

### $ 75.00 3/11/2014 JAE Email from and to Kate Barber 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 JAE Review notice ofproposeddvll penalty. Email to Kate Barber. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 3/12/2014 JAE Email to Kate Barber. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 3/14/2014 JAE Email to Kate Barbee Q.l 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 JAE Email from andto Kate Barber. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 3/18/2014 JAE Telephone call to client. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 JAE Ematl to Kate Barber 0.1 

# s 275.00 

### $ 27.50 JAE Telephone call from Kate Barber. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 3/26/2014 JAE Telephone call from Rick Ochs. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 4/11/2014 JAE Ematl from Kate Barber. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 JAE Telephone call to Kate Barber, 

### 0.3 $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 4/23(2014 JAE Telephone call to Kate Barber. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 4/24/2014 JAE Telephone call from Rick Ochs. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 

### " JAE Telephone call from Kate Barber. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 4/29/2014 JAE Emaif from and to dient. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 JAE Review offinal notice of proposed civil penalty. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 $ 55.00 JAE Review of letterfrom clienttoStan Barnes, 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 12/20

JAE RevewFAA Rvles of Practice -civil penalty cases. 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 110.00 4/30/2014 

### JAE Prepare Request for Hearing. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 

### JAE Letterto Kate-.Barber. 0.3 $ 275.00 $ 82.50 

### JAE Letterto Hearing DocketClerk. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 $ 82,50 5/5/2014 

### JAE Telephone call from client. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 5/12/2014 

### JAE Review of letter from Kate Barber 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 

### JAE lnitlal Review of FAA Complaint. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 5/22/2014 

### JAE Review Orderfrom Judge Sullivan. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 5/27/2014 

### JAE Initial draftanswertoComplaintand certificate o-fservice. 0.8 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 220.00 

### JAE Review oforderfrom FAA Heartng DocketOffice. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 Revtse initial draftofAnswer,letters to FAA headng docket Kate 5/28/2014 

### JAE Barber1 and Judge Sullivan. 0.7 

### $ 275.00 $ 192,50 6/9/2014 

### JAE Initial review oforder fromJudge Sullivan re: scheduling. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 7/9/2014 

### JAE Review ofOrderfrom Judge Su!!lvan and Email to Kate Sarbe-r. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 7/15/2014 

### JAE Email from and to Kate Barber. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55,00 

### JAE Prepare for conference with Kate Barber. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82,50 

### JAE Rule 26 conference with Kate Barber. Call toJudge Sullivan crerk. 0.5 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 137,50 7/18/2014 

### JAE Review orderfrom Judge Su!llvan. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 7/23/2014 

### JAE Prepare- initial draft of reportfrom Rule 26 Meeting. 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 110.00 

### JAE Email to Kate Barber. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 7/25/2014 

### JAE Email from Kate Barber. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 7/28/2014 

### JAE EmaHfrom and to Kate Barber. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 13/20

8/10/2014 JAE Review file. PrepareforScheduling conference. 0.8 $ 275.00 

### $ 220.00 8/11/2014 JAE Scheduling conferencewithJudge Sullivan. 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 110.00 JAE Telephone call to Kate Barber. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 JAE Revise proposed case schedule. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 JAE Email from and to Kate Barber. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 JAE lettertoJudge Sullivan. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 JAE Review orderfrom Judge Su!llvan. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 8/27/2014 JAE RevieW file. Prepare for conferencewith Judge Sullivan. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 JAE Scheduling conference call 

### withludge Sullivan. 0.5 

### $ 275,00 

### $ 137.50 JAE Review order from Judge Sui!Jvan. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 10/23/2014 JAE Telephone call from Kate BarbeL 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 11/12/2014 JAE letterto Rick Ochs. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 11/14/2014 JAE Telephone call from Rick Ochs. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 11/18/2014 JAE Telephone call from Rick Ochs. 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 110.00 JAE Revtew documents received from client. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 JAE Di<.tate response to interrogato-ries, 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 110.00 Anish initial draft ofanswersto lnterrogatorles and responses to 11/21/2014 JAE document requests. 0.5 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 137.50 JAE Review and revise initial draftsof responses to discovery requests. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 JAE Ema·11 to client. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 $ 27.50 12/8/2014 JAE Email from client. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 1/20/2015 JAE Emailto Kate Barber. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 1/21/2015 JAE Email from and to Kate Barber. 0.2 $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 1/27/2015 JAE Emailto Kat-e Barber, 0,1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 JAE Email from and to Kate Barber. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 JAE EmaH from and to Rick Ochs. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 JAE !nibal review Of FAA's response to discovery. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 14/20

3/5/2015 

### JAE

**Emai~to** Kate Barber. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 

### PJM Review of Discovery provided by FAA. 1 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 210.00 Review ofScheduling Ordersfor upcoming dates. NotifyJAE ofthe 

### PJM same<md suggestmoving dates. 0.3 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 63.00 Review ofmattertoidentify partiesthatwill be deposed in defense of 3/12/2015 

### PJM the matter. 1 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 210.00 Memorandum toJAE regarding depositions to be taken in matter 3/17/2015 

### PJM before FAA. 0.2 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 42.00 4/6/2015 

### JAE Email to Kate Barber. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 4/7/2015 

### JAE Email from and to Kate Barber. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 $ 55.00 

### JAE Email from and to Rick Ochs. 2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 550.00 

### JAE

**Em~tl** to, from <.:md to Kate Barber. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 $ 55.00 4/8/2015 

### JAE Emailfrom and to Kate Barber. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 

### JAE Emallfrom and to Rick Ochs. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 4/9/2015 

### JAE Email from and to Kate Barber. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 4/20/Z015 

### JAE Emafl to Kate Sarber. 0,1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 

### JAE Email to Rick Ochs. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 

### JAE Email from and to Rick Ochs. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $

**55~00** 

### JAE Review file. Prepare for Deposition ofStan Barnes, 2.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 605.00 

### JAE Telephone call from client. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 

### JAE Assemble documents for deposition· of Stan Barnes. 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 110.00 4/21/2015 

### JAE

**~position** ofStan Barnes.. 3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 825.00 

### JAE Emailto client. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 

### JAE legal research -definition ofhsale" 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 110-00 4/22/2015 

### JAE Email to Kate Barber. 0.1 

### $ Z75.00 

### $ 27.50 4/23/2015 

### JM Telephone call to Kate Barber. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 4/27/2015 

### JAE Email from and to Rick Ochs. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 4/28/2015 

### JAE Email from and to Rick Ochs. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 5/7/2015 

### PJM Cal! & ema'1l to Rick Ochs re: former Lane Aviation employee. 0.3 

### $ 210.00 

### $

**63~00** 5/13/2015 

### JAE Telephone call to Rick Ochs. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Data: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Paga: 15/20

5/17/2013 

### PJM Review of rules for FAA

**proceedings~** SummaryJudgment, 0,5 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 105.00 5/18/2015 

### PJM Begin initial draft of motionforsummaryjudgment. 2,5 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 525.00 5/19/2015 

### PJM Draft of Rick Ochs Affidavit. 1.5 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 315.00 5/28/2015 

### PJM Review of 1st draft of motion..for summaryjudgment. 1.5 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 315.00 5/29/2015 

### JAE Re-view and revise inlt'1al draftofmotlon for

**d~clslon.** 0,6 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 165,00 

### PJM Review revisions and comments ofJAE, revisions re: the same. 1.5 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 315.00 

### PJM Finalize Motion forfiling; prepare document exhibits. 0.5 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 105.00 6/1/2015 

### PJM File motion for decision via fax and U.S. Mall. 1.5 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 315.00 

### JAE Final review of motionfordecision. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 6/30/2015 

### JAE Brelf review of FAA response to motion for decision. 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 110.00 7/1/2015 

### PJM Receipt and review of FMresponse to motion for decision. 0.5 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 105.00 

### PJM Prepare Motion to Strike FAA Response. 1 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 210.00 

### PJM FHe motionto strike with a!I partfes, 0.5 $ 210.00 

### $ 105.00 

### JAE

**Pr~p<~re** initial points; of response to FAA response. 0.5 

# s 275.00 

### $ 137.50 

### JAE Email from Kate Barber. 0.1 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 27.50 

### JAE Review and revise motion tostrike FAA response. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 7/6/2015 

### PJM Prepare and file motion for leaveto respond to FAA resporu;e. 1 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 210.00 7/7/2015 

### PJM Receipt and review of FAA response to motion to strike. 0.3 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 63.00 3j;l(Z015 

### PJM Revfew of FAA response toSpirit's motion for 1 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 210.00 

### PJM Start draftreply to FAA response. 6 $ 210.00 $ 1,260.00 8/6/2015 

### PJM Revisions tofinal draft. 1.5 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 315.00 

### PJM Prepare and file reply with FAA and DOT. 0.5 $ 210.00 

### $ 105.00 

### JAE Review and revise draft of reply. 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 

### uo.oo 8/10/2015 

### PJM Prepare fororal argume:nt before Judge Sullivan. 1 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 110.00 

### JAE Review flle. Prepare for oral argument on motion for decision. 2.8 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 770.00 

### JAE Conferencewith PJM regarding oral argument. 0-3 

### $ 275,00 

### $ 82.50 8/11/2015 

### PJM Oral a_rgument on Motion for Decision. 1.2 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 252.00 

### PJM Email to

**~::!lent** regarding supplemental affidavit. 0.1 

### $ 2l0.00 

### $ 21.00To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 16/20



### JAE Final preparation for oral arugment on motionfor decision. 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 110.00 

### JAE Oral argument on mot-ion. 1.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 330.00 

### JAE Review and revise supplementaf documents of Rick Ochs. 0.3 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 82.50 

### JAE Review of4/lSietterfrom client to David Halman. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 

### PJM Draft of supplemental affidavitfor clients review. 

### 1 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 210.00 8/12/2015 

### JAE Revi·ew ofOrderfromJudge Sullivan. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 

### " JAE Reviewfax from Lauren Hoyson, FAA attorney. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 

### PJM Review ofJudge Sullivan's Order. 0.2 

### $ 200.00 

### $ 40.00 

### PJM Review FAA amer1ded complaint. 0.3 

### $ 200.00 

### $ 60.00 $/13/2015 

### PJM Reviewsupplemental affldvaittoJudges orderfor accuracy. 0.3 

### $ 200.00 

### $ 60.00 8/14/2015 

### PJM Draft answertoamended complaint filed by FAA; file the same. 0.5 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 137.50 

### PJM FHe supplement! declaration and answer to amended cmp. 0.4 

### $ 200.00 

### $ 80.00 B/24/2015 

### PJM Ema-il to client regarding mailing ofink signed declaration. 0.2 

### $ 200.00 

### $ 40.00 8/27/2015 

### JAE Review ofJudge Sullivan's ordergranting summaryjudgment. 0.4 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 110.00 

### JAE Email from and to dlent. 0.2 

### $ 275.00 

### $ 55.00 9/2/2015 

### PJM Research re: Equal access tojustice claims (no charge). 0 

### $ 210.00 

### $ PJM Memoraundum to file regarding limits of EAJA claims. 1 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 210.00 9/4/2015 

### PJM Prepare EAJA Appllc:atio,-, for fees a,-,d expenses. 0.5 

### $ 210.00 

### $ 105.00 TOTAL 

### $ 19,099.00

### To: 12022671293 From: 16147981620 Date: 10/01/15 Time: 1:47 PM Page: 17/20

**Eichenb.erger-~,A.ssociates** A L.egal

**Prof¢_s~i9oal** Association 6037"Fraritz R_Oad, Suite 107 Dublin, Ol'llo43017 Tax ID: 31-1757586 lnv<Jkes submitted to: SpiritAvionics, Ltd. Attn:- Rick Ochs 4808'East F1fth Street Columbus, Ohlo'43219 Date: Re: FAA v. SpiritAvionics, Ltd. King Air Case OUr File No. 1016-10742

**O.::~te** Description 3/1/2013 Copies 4/1/2013 Copies S/1/2013 Copies 6/1/2013 Copies. 7/1/2013 Copies 4/1/2014 Copies 5/30/2014 Copies 7/30f2014 Copies. 8/29/2014 Cop-ies 

### EXPENSES

9/10/2014 DepositlonTranscriptfrom Veteran Reporters 9/30/2014 Copies 11/1/2014 Copie-s 3/31/2015 Copies 4/30/2015 Copies 5/31/2015 Copies

6/1/2015 lrwolce from

**~;Curt** reporter Stan Barnes Deposition 6/30/2015 Copies 7/31/2015 Copi-es 8/31/2015 Copies 9/30/2015 Coples 

# ""' 

# ..... 405 $ 0.15

4 $ 0.15 6 $ 0.15 6 $ 0,15 2 $ 0.15 75 $ 0.15 20 $ 0.15 3 $ 0.15 4 $ 0.15 1 $ 193.00 1 $ 0.15 43 $ 0.15 4 $ 0.15 34 $ 0.15 55 $ 0.15 1 $ 365.00 

## 2n 

## s 0.15 59 $ 0.15 83 $ 0.15

TOTAL Amount $ 60.75 $ 0.60 $ 0.90 $ 0.90 $ 0.3Q $ 11.25 $ 3.00 $ 045 $ 0.60 $ 193.00 $

**o.l~** $ 6.45 $ 0.60 $ 5.10 $ 9.75 $ 365.00 

## s 40.60 $ 8.85 $ 12.45

$ 720.90 

# EXHIBIT 

# c