## PUBLIC NOTICE

and HEARING TRANSCRIPT

### This page intentionally left blank.CALIFORNIA AIR RESOURCES BOARD

NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING TO CONSIDER APPROVAL OF THE 2014 PROGRESS REPORT FOR THE CALIFORNIA REGIONAL HAZE MID-COURSE REVIEW The Air Resources Board (ARB or Board) will conduct a public meeting at the time and place noted below to consider approval ofthe California Regional Haze Plan 2014 Progress Report (RH Progress Report) for submittal to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA). DATE: May 22, 2014 TIME: 9:00 a.m. PLACE: California Environmental Protection Agency Air Resources Board Byron Sher Auditorium 1001 I Street Sacramento, California 95814 This item will be considered at a one-day meeting of the Board, which will commence at 9:00a.m., May 22, 2014. This item is scheduled to be heard on the Board's Consent Calendar. All agenda items on the Consent Calendar- unless removed upon the request of a Board member or if someone in the audience submits a request to speak card on that item- will be voted on by the Board at the beginning ofthe public meeting. BACKGROUND The federal Clean Air Act established a national policy of achieving visibility comparable to natural conditions at the most treasured federal lands and scenic areas ofthe country. In 1999, U.S. EPA adopted the Regional Haze Rule (RH Rule) to guide this process nationwide. The RH Rule sets requirements for states to follow for improving visibility at 156 specific national parks, forests, seashores, monuments, and wilderness areas across the United States, deemed "Class 1 Areas". To ensure continuous progress to natural conditions visibility by 2064, the RH Rule requires each state to develop a state implementation plan (SIP) that includes interim visibility goals every ten years. In 2009, ARB adopted the California Regional Haze Plan (RH Plan) setting Reasonable Progress Goals for 2018 (2018 RPG) for the 29 Class 1 Areas in California that were based on California's comprehensive emission control strategy. ARB submitted the RH Plan to U.S. EPA on March 16, 2009, which was approved on June 14, 2011. The next RH Plan SIP revision, due in 2018, will set RPGs for 2028. The RH Rule also requires each state to perform a mid-course progress review in themiddle of each ten-year planning cycle. The 2014 RH Progress Report has been prepared to meetthis requirement. Visibility is improving throughout California and is on track to achieve the 2018 RPGs for Class 1 Areas

. Control measures implemented in California since the baseline planning period of 2000-2004 have improved visibility by reducing emissions of controllable haze pollutants and their precursors. As a result, the 2018 RPGs already have been achieved at most locations, except for areas impacted by wildfires. The RH Plan identified wildfire smoke in the western U.S. as a natural source of haze that slows the rate of visibility improvement at some locations in some years, occasionally masking visibility improvement achieved by emission reductions. The RH Progress Report affirms that the control strategy in the RH Plan is effective for improving visibility to achieve the 2018 RPGs, and does not need to be amended prior to the next scheduled Sl P revision in 2018. ARB staff is recommending that the Board approve the RH Progress Report and direct staffto forward it to U.S. EPA. Copies ofthe report may be obtained from ARB's Public Information Office, 1001 I Street, First Floor, Environmental Services Center, Sacramento, California, 95814, (916) 322-2990, as ofApril 21 , 2014, not more than 30 days prior to the scheduled meeting. The report may also be obtained from ARB's website at http://www

.arb

.ca.gov/planning/reghaze/reghaze.htm Interested members ofthe public may present comments orally or in writing at the meeting and may provide comments by postal mail or by electronic submittal before the meeting. To be considered by the Board , written comments not physically submitted at the meeting , must be received no later than 5:00pm, Monday, May 19, 2014, and addressed to the following: Postal mail: Clerk ofthe Board, Air Resources Board 1001 I Street, Sacramento, California 95814 Electronic submittal : http://www.arb.ca.gov/lispub/comm/bclist.php Please note that under the California Public Records Act (Government Code section 6250 et seq

.), your written and verbal comments, attachments , and associated contact information (e.g., your address, phone, email, etc

.) become part of the public record and can be released to the public upon request. ARB requests that written and email statements on this i tem be filed at least 10 days prior to the meeting so that ARB staff and Board members have additional time to consider each comment. Further inquiries regarding this matter should be directed to Mr. Webster Tasat, Section Manager, (916) 323-4950 , or Ms. Tina Suarez

- Murias, Air Pollution Specialist, (916) 323-1495. ·



### 2SPECIAL ACCOMMODATION REQUEST Consistent with California Government Code Section 7296

.2 , special accommodation or language needs may be provided for any ofthe following :

• An interpreter to be available at the meeting ; • Documents made available in an alternate format or another language ; • A disability-related reasonable accommodation. To request these special accommodations or language needs, please contact the Clerk ofthe Board at (916) 322-5594 or by facsimile at (916) 322-3928 as soon as possible, but no later than 10 business days before the scheduled Board meeting

. TTY/TOO/Speech to Speech users may dial 711 for the California Relay Service. Consecuente con Ia secci6n 7296

.2 del C6digo de Gobierno de California, una acomodaci6n especial o necesidades linguisticas pueden ser suministradas para cualquiera de los siguientes: ·

• Un interprete que este disponible en Ia audiencia; • Documentos disponibles en un formate alterno u otro idioma; • Una acomodaci6n razonable relacionados con una incapacidad. Para solicitar estas comodidades especiales o necesidades de otro idioma, por favor llame a Ia oficina del Consejo al (916) 322-5594 o envie un fax a (916) 322-3928 lo mas pronto posible, pero no menos de 10 dias de trabajo antes del dia programado para Ia audiencia del Consejo

. TTY/TOO/Personas que necesiten este servicio pueden marcar el 711 para el Servicio de Retransmisi6n de Mensajes de California

.

CALIFORNIA AIR RESOURCES BOARD

Date: April 21, 2014

The energy challenge facing California is real

. Every Californian needs to take immediate action to reduce energy consumption. Fora list ofsimple ways you can reduce demand and cutyour energy costs, see ourwebsite at www.arb

.ca

.gov

.



### 3

### This page intentionally left blank.

### MEETING STATE OF CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AIR RESOURCES BOARD

CAL/EPA HEADQUARTERS BUILDING BYRON SHER AUDITORIUM SECOND FLOOR 1001 I STREET SACRAMENTO, CALIFORNIA 95814

THURSDAY, MAY 22, 2014

9:05 A.M.

JAMES F. PETERS, CSR, RPR CERTIFIED SHORTHAND REPORTER LICENSE NUMBER 10063

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171

### A P P E A R A N C E S

BOARD MEMBERS: Ms. Mary Nichols, Chairperson Dr. John Balmes Ms. Sandra Berg Mr. Hector De La Torre Mr. John Eisenhut Mayor Judy Mitchell Mrs. Barbara Riordan Supervisor Phil Serna Dr. Alex Sherriffs Professor Daniel Sperling

STAFF: Mr. Richard Corey, Executive Officer Dr. Alberto Ayala, Deputy Executive Officer Ms. Edie Chang, Deputy Executive Officer Ms. Lynn Terry, Deputy Executive Officer Ms. La Ronda Bowen, Ombudsman Ms. Ellen Peter, Chief Counsel Ms. Christina Morkner-Brown, Staff Counsel Mr. Steve Cliff, Assistant Chief, Stationary Source Division

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171

### A P P E A R A N C E S C O N T I N U E D

STAFF: Mr. Nesamani Kalandiyur, Manager, Transportation Analysis Section, Air Quality Planning and Science Division Ms. Kurt Karperos, Chief, Air Quality Planning and Science Division Ms. Karen Magliano, Assistant Chief, Air Quality Planning and Science Division Ms. Cynthia Marvin, Chief, Stationary Source Division Mr. David Mehl, Manager, Energy Section, Stationary Source Division Ms. Terry Roberts, Manager, Sustainable Communities Policy and Planning Section, Air Quality Planning and Science Division Ms. Marcelle Surovik, Air Pollution Specialist, Energy Section, Stationary Source Division Mr. Jon Taylor, Chief, Transportation Planning Branch, Air Quality Planning and Science Division Mr. Michael Tollstrup, Chief, Project Assessment Branch, Stationary Source Division

ALSO PRESENT: Mr. Lee Adams, Sierra County Supervisor Mr. Azibuike Akaba, Regional Asthma Management and Prevention Ms. Martha Argüello, Physicians for Social Responsibility Mr. Will Barrett, American Lung Association of California Ms. Danielle Blacet, Association of California Water Agencies Ms. Martha Ann Blackman

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171

### A P P E A R A N C E S C O N T I N U E D

ALSO PRESENT: Mr. Tony Boren, Fresno County Council of Governments Mr. Craig Breon, Sierra Club - Keru - Kaweah Mr. Jack Broadbent, Bay Area Air Quality Management District Ms. Julia Bussey, Chevron Corporation Mr. Frank Caponi, Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts Mr. Cesar Campos, Central California Environmental Justice Network Ms. Ann Chan, Natural Resources Agency Mr. Ralph Chandler, California Refuse and Recycling Council Ms. Pat Chen, South Coast Water District Mr. Andy Chesley, San Joaquin Council of Governments Mr. Ron Davis, Cal Desal Ms. Sarah Deslauriers, California Wastewater Climate Change Group Mr. Evan Edgar, California Compost Coalition Ms. Kelley Gage, San Diego County Water Authority Ms. Bonnie Holmes-Gen, American Lung Association Mr. Ahron Hakimi, Kern County Council of Governments Ms. Claire Halbrook, Pacific, Gas & Electric Mr. Jamie Hall, CalStart Mr. Bob Harding, Metropolitan Water District of Southern California Mr. Frank Harris, Southern California Edison

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171

### A P P E A R A N C E S C O N T I N U E D

ALSO PRESENT: Mr. Brad Heavner, California Solar Energy Industry Association Mr. Chuck Helget, Republic Services Mr. Curt Johansen, Council of Infill Builders Ms. Carey Knecht, Climate Plan Mr. Nick Lapis, Californians Against Waste Ms. Barbara Lee, California Air Pollution Control Officers Association Mr. Rey León, San Joaquin Valley Latino Environmental Advancement Project Mr. Howard Levenson, CalRecycle Mr. Bill Magavern, Coalition for Clean Air Mr. Paul Mason, Pacific Forest Trust Ms. Jerilyn Lopez-Mendoza, Southern California Gas Ms. Jeanne Merrill, California Climate and Agriculture Network Ms. Katherine Mitchell, Bioenergy Association of California Ms. Amy Mmgu, California Chamber of Commerce Ms. Erica Morehouse, Environmental Defense Fund Mr. Ed Murray, Aztec Solar, Inc. Mr. Brian Nowicki, Center for Biological Diversity Ms. Rachel O'Brien, Consumer's Union Mr. Daniel O'Connell, American Farmland Trust Mr. Rob Oglesby, California Energy Commission

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171

### A P P E A R A N C E S C O N T I N U E D

ALSO PRESENT: Ms. Michelle Passero, Nature Conservancy Ms. Mary Pitto, Rural Cities Ms. Betty Plowman Ms. Nancy Rader, California Wind Energy Association Mr. Eddy Reyes Ms. Katelyn Roedner, Diocese of Stockton Ms. Dorothy Rothrock, California Manufacturers and Technology Association Mr. Hank Ryan, Small Business California Ms. Phoebe Seaton, Leadership Council Mr. David Schonbrun, Transdef.org Ms. Sandy Schubert, Department of Food and Agriculture Mr. Mik Skvarla, California Council for Environmental and Economic Balance Ms. Lora Smith, RN, California Nurses Association Mr. Miguel Solorio, Comite ALMA Ms. Mari Rose Taruc, Asian Pacific Environmental Network Ms. Tara Thronson, Valley Vision Ms. Candida Vanegas Dr. Barry Wallerstein, South Coast Air Quality Management District Mr. Michael Wang, Western States Petroleum Association Mr. Chuck White, Waste Management

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171

### A P P E A R A N C E S C O N T I N U E D

ALSO PRESENT: Mr. V. John White, Center for Energy Efficiency and Renewable Technologies Ms. Kate White, California State Transportation Agency Ms. Ella Wise, Natural Resources Defense Council Mr. Carlos Yamzon, Stanislaus County Council of Governments

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171

### I N D E X PAGE

Consent Item 14-4-1 Chairperson Nichols 3 Motion 4 Vote 4 Consent item 14-4-2 Chairperson Nichols 5 Motion 5 Vote 5 Item 14-4-3 Chairperson Nichols 6 Executive Officer Corey 8 Staff Presentation 9 Mr. Harris 53 Sierra County Supervisor Adams 55 Ms. Mitchell 59 Ms. Pitto 63 Mr. Caponi 66 Ms. Morehouse 68 Ms. Thronson 70 Ms. Gage 72 Mr. Heavner 77 Mr. Davis 80 Mr. Harding 81 Ms. Blacet 83 Ms. Chen 84 Mr. Schonbrun 87 Ms. Halbrook 89 Ms. Rader 92 Mr. Chandler 93 Mr. Chuck White 96 Mr. Helget 100 Ms. Blackman 103 Ms. Mmagu 105 Ms. Rothrock 106 Mr. Mason 109 Mr. Murray 111 Mr. Edgar 113 Mr. Barrett 115 Mr. Ryan 118 Ms. Smith 119 Mr. Skvarla 121 Mr. Wang 124 Mr. Magavern 126 Ms. Deslauriers 128

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171

### I N D E X C O N T I N U E D PAGE

Item 14-4-3(Continued) Ms. Lopez-Mendoza 131 Ms. Bussey 133 Mr. Nowicki 135 Ms. Merrill 137 Ms. Passero 138 Mr. Hall 140 Mr. Lapis 143 Ms. O'Brien 145 Mr. Akaba 147 Ms. Plowman 148 Mr. John White 150 Discussion 153 Motion 162 Vote 168 Afternoon Session 170 Item 14-4-5 Executive Officer Corey 170 Staff Presentation 171 Ms. Roedner 205 Mr. Magavern 207 Ms. Holmes-Gen 209 Mr. Akaba 211 Ms. Knecht 212 Ms. Wise 214 Mr. Breon 216 Mr. Johansen 218 Ms. Seaton 220 Mr. O'Connell 222 Mr. Campos 224 Mr. León 226 Mr. Reyes 228 Ms. Vanegas 229 Mr. Solorio 229 Discussion 230 Adjournment 249 Reporter's Certificate 250

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171

### P R O C E E D I N G S CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Good morning. Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. People, if you'll -- this is not working. Well, he said it was.

Is it on now? Okay. Can you hear me? If you can, wave your hand. It doesn't sound like it's on.

There we go. Okay. Good morning, everybody. The May 22nd, 2014 public meeting of the Air Resources Board will come to order. We will start by rising and saying the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag.

(Thereupon the Pledge of Allegiance was recited in unison.) CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Madam Clerk, would you please call the roll.

BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Dr. Balmes? BOARD MEMBER BALMES: Here BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Ms. Berg? BOARD MEMBER BERG: Here. BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Mr. De La Torre? Mr. Eisenhut? BOARD MEMBER EISENHUT: Here. BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Supervisor Gioia? Mayor Mitchell?

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171 1

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

### BOARD MEMBER MITCHELL: Here. BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Mrs. Riordan? BOARD MEMBER RIORDAN: Here. BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Supervisor Roberts? Supervisor Serna? BOARD MEMBER SERNA: Here. BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Dr. Sherriffs? BOARD MEMBER SHERRIFFS: Here. BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Professor Sperling? Chairman Nichols? CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Here. BOARD CLERK JENSEN: Madam Chairman, we have a quorum. CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Great. And I know that two of our Board members are on their way, Mr. De La Torre, and Professor Sperling, so they will be joining us soon.

Okay. A couple of announcements before we get started. First of all, for anybody who isn't familiar with our procedures, if you want to testify, we need you to fill out a request-to-speak card. They're available in the lobby outside this room. And we appreciate it if you turn it into the Clerk. Shortly after we start an item, we would like all the cards to be collected. It's not helpful when people start -- you know, wait and then decide to testify at the end. Sometimes it's necessary,

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171 2

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

### but normally it just creates chaos. So I may announce at

some point that we're just kind of cutting off the list if we get to be -- if we get too many people.

Speakers need to be aware that we do impose a three-minute time limit. We appreciate it if you state your name when you come up to the podium, and then put your testimony in your own words, rather than just reading it, because we can listen better that way, and we will read whatever is submitted to us in writing. We get all the written testimony.

I'm required to point out the exits at the rear of the room and to the two sides here of the platform, the dais. If there is an alarm that sounds, we need to vacate the room immediately and go down the stairs, not the elevator, until we get the all-clear signal to come back. We do have fire drills from time to time, so appreciate your cooperation with that.

Okay. The first item on our agenda this morning is a consent calendar. And, Mr. Corey, would you present that? Actually, you don't have to present it. I just have to ask the Board Clerk if any witnesses have signed up to testify. No wonder you looked confused.

EXECUTIVE OFFICER COREY: I was prepared to anyway.

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171 3

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

### (Laughter.) CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: You could present it, I'm sure, but no, we don't need to. So I just have to ask the Clerk if any witnesses have signed up to testify.

BOARD CLERK JENSEN: (Shakes head.) CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: No. Okay. Do any Board members want to take this item off the consent calendar?

Seeing none. Then I will close the record on this agenda item. This is six research proposals, by the way, for the Board's consideration. We did receive the proposals in advance, and it's actually quite an impressive list, but we just decided not to take the time to go through them here at the meeting.

So if you've had an opportunity to review the proposals, may I have a motion and a second to adopt Resolution numbers 14-8 through 14-13?

BOARD MEMBER BALMES: So moved. BOARD MEMBER SHERRIFFS: Second. CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Okay. We have a motion and a second. And I think we can just do this by a voice vote then. All members who wish to vote for these proposals, please say aye.

(Ayes.) CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Opposed?

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171 4

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

### Abstentions? (Unanimous vote.) CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Okay. Great. We now move to another consent item, which is the Regional Haze Mid-Course Review. Did we have any witnesses sign up For this one?

BOARD CLERK JENSEN: (Shakes head.) CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Also, no. Okay. Then I can close this item unless anybody wants to hear it.

BOARD MEMBER RIORDAN: Madam Chairman, I would then move staff recommendation on this particular item.

CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Okay, number 14-15. And do we have a second? BOARD MEMBER SERNA: Second. CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: We have a second. All in favor, please say aye? (Ayes.) CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Any opposed? Any abstentions? (Unanimous vote.) CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: This is great actually. We are making progress on this.

(Laughter.) CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: Why don't we just do this

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171 5

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

### all the time. (Laughter.) CHAIRPERSON NICHOLS: If anybody wants to know, the Regional Haze Program is an excellent program that tries to get States to work on natural visibility conditions. And it's not necessarily the thing that we talk about the most, but it actually is of great value. So thank you.

J&K COURT REPORTING, LLC 916.476.3171 6

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 

### Remainder of Transcript of May 22, 2014 Board Hearing not included here.