U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE

WASHINGTON : 

For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office

Internet: bookstore.gpo.gov Phone: toll free (866) 512–1800; DC area (202) 512–1800

Fax: (202) 512–2104 Mail: Stop IDCC, Washington, DC 20402–0001

45–240 PDF 2008

S. HRG. 110–584 

[ERRATA] 

RESTORING THE RULE OF LAW 

HEARING 

BEFORE THE

SUBCOMMITTEE ON THE CONSTITUTION 

OF THE

COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY 

UNITED STATES SENATE 

ONE HUNDRED TENTH CONGRESS 

SECOND SESSION 

SEPTEMBER 16, 2008 

Serial No. J–110–119 

Printed for the use of the Committee on the Judiciary 

( 

On page IV insert the following new section. Delete allmark on page 319 

and insert new 319 and pages 320 through 611. Errata Jacket Number 

45-477. 

ADDITIONAL SUBMISSIONS FOR THE RECORD 

Aftergood, Steven, Director, Project on Government Secrecy, Federation of 

American Scientists, Washington, D.C., statement ........................................... 320 

Agrast, Mark D., Senior Fellow, Center for American Progress Action Fund, 

Washington, D.C., statement .............................................................................. 330 

American Civil Liberties Union, Caroline Fredrickson, Director, Washington, 

Legislative Office, Washington, D.C., statement ............................................... 335 

American Library Association and Association of Research Libraries, Washington, D.C., joint statement ............................................................................... 344 

Bill of Rights Defense Committee, Nancy Talanian, Executive Director, Northampton, Massachusetts, statement .................................................................... 348 

Center for Democracy & Technology, Gregory T. Nojeim, Director, Project 

on Freedom, Security & Technology, Washington, D.C., statement ................ 357 

Center for National Security Studies, Kate Martin, Director and Lisa Graves, 

Deputy Director, Washington, D.C., statement ................................................. 363 

Center for Strategic & International Studies, Sarah E. Mendelson, Director, 

Human Rights and Security Initiative, Washington, D.C., statement ............ 377 

Center for Victims of Torture, Douglas A. Johnson, Executive Director, Washington, D.C., statement ........................................................................................ 386 

Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, Washington, D.C., 

statement .............................................................................................................. 392 

Common Cause, Sarah Dufendach, Vice President for Legislative Affairs, 

Washington, D.C., statement .............................................................................. 402 

Constitution Project, Washington, D.C., statement .............................................. 407 

Cutler, Leonard M., Professor of Public Law, Siena College, New York, New 

York, statement .................................................................................................... 410 

Farber, Daniel, Sho Sato Professor of Law, and Anne Joseph O’Connell, 

Assistant Professor of Law, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, 

California, statement ........................................................................................... 423 

Fein, Bruce, Washington, D.C., statement ............................................................ 433 

Fisher, Louis, Specialist in Constitutional Law, Law Library of the Library 

of Congress, Washington, D.C., statement ......................................................... 437 

Frost, Amanda, Associate Professor of Law, American University Washington, 

College of Law, and Justin Florence, Associate, O’Melveny & Myers, LLP, 

Washington, D.C., statement .............................................................................. 450 

Holtzman, Elizabeth, a former Representative in Congress from the State 

of New York, statement ....................................................................................... 475 

Kitrosser, Heidi, Associate Professor, University of Minnesota Law School, 

Minneapolis, Minnesota, statement .................................................................... 479 

Kreimer, Seth F., Kenneth W. Gemmill Professor of Law, University of Pennsylvania Law School, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, statement ......................... 493 

Morrison, Alan B., Visiting Professor, Washington College of Law, American 

University, Washington, D.C., statement .......................................................... 513 

Nader, Ralph, Cambridge, Massachusetts, statement .......................................... 519 

National Religious Campaign Against Torture, Linda Gustitus, President, 

and Rev. Richard Killmer, Executive Director, Washington, D.C., statement ...................................................................................................................... 536 

National Security Archive, Meredith Fuchs, General Counsel, Washington, 

D.C., statement .................................................................................................... 543 

OpenTheGovernment.org, Patrice McDermott, Director, Washington, D.C., 

statement .............................................................................................................. 551 

Pearlstein, Deborah N., Program in Law & Public Affairs, Princeton University, Princeton, New Jersey, statement .............................................................. 560 

Rutherford Institute, John W. Whitehead, Founder and President, Charlottesville, Virginia, statement ..................................................................................... 571 

Scholars’ statement of principles for a new President on U.S. detention policy, 

statement .............................................................................................................. 580 

Shane, Peter M., Jacob E. Davis and Jacob E. Davis II Chair in Law, Ohio 

State University Moritz College of Law, Columbus, Ohio, statement ............. 593 

Stone, Geoffrey R., Edward H. Levi Distinguished Service Professor, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, statement ...................................................... 600 

319 


45240.269
320 


45477.001
321 


45477.002
322 


45477.003
323 


45477.004
324 


45477.005
325 


45477.006
326 


45477.007
327 


45477.008
328 


45477.009
329 


45477.010
330 


45477.011
331 


45477.012
332 


45477.013
333 


45477.014
334 


45477.015
335 


45477.016
336 


45477.017
337 


45477.018
338 


45477.019
339 


45477.020
340 


45477.021
341 


45477.022
342 


45477.023
343 


45477.024
344 


45477.025
345 


45477.026
346 


45477.027
347 


45477.028
348 


45477.029
349 


45477.030
350 


45477.031
351 


45477.032
352 


45477.033
353 


45477.034
354 


45477.035
355 


45477.036
356 


45477.037
357 


45477.038
358 


45477.039
359 


45477.040
360 


45477.041
361 


45477.042
362 


45477.043
363 


45477.044
364 


45477.045
365 


45477.046
366 


45477.047
367 


45477.048
368 


45477.049
369 


45477.050
370 


45477.051
371 


45477.052
372 


45477.053
373 


45477.054
374 


45477.055
375 


45477.056
376 


45477.057
377 


45477.058
378 


45477.059
379 


45477.060
380 


45477.061
381 


45477.062
382 


45477.063
383 


45477.064
384 


45477.065
385 


45477.066
386 


45477.067
387 


45477.068
388 


45477.069
389 


45477.070
390 


45477.071
391 


45477.072
392 


45477.073
393 


45477.074
394 


45477.075
395 


45477.076
396 


45477.077
397 


45477.078
398 


45477.079
399 


45477.080
400 


45477.081
401 


45477.082
402 


45477.083
403 


45477.084
404 


45477.085
405 


45477.086
406 


45477.087
407 


45477.088
408 


45477.089
409 


45477.090
410 


45477.091
411 


45477.092
412 


45477.093
413 


45477.094
414 


45477.095
415 


45477.096
416 


45477.097
417 


45477.098
418 


45477.099
419 


45477.100
420 


45477.101
421 


45477.102
422 


45477.103
423 


45477.104
424 


45477.105
425 


45477.106
426 


45477.107
427 


45477.108
428 


45477.109
429 


45477.110
430 


45477.111
431 


45477.112
432 


45477.113
433 


45477.114
434 


45477.115
435 


45477.116
436 


45477.117
437 


45477.118
438 


45477.119
439 


45477.120
440 


45477.121
441 


45477.122
442 


45477.123
443 


45477.124
444 


45477.125
445 


45477.126
446 


45477.127
447 


45477.128
448 


45477.129
449 


45477.130
450 


45477.131
451 


45477.132
452 


45477.133
453 


45477.134
454 


45477.135
455 


45477.136
456 


45477.137
457 


45477.138
458 


45477.139
459 


45477.140
460 


45477.141
461 


45477.142
462 


45477.143
463 


45477.144
464 


45477.145
465 


45477.146
466 


45477.147
467 


45477.148
468 


45477.149
469 


45477.150
470 


45477.151
471 


45477.152
472 


45477.153
473 


45477.154
474 


45477.155
475 


45477.156
476 


45477.157
477 


45477.158
478 


45477.159
479 


45477.160
480 


45477.161
481 


45477.162
482 


45477.163
483 


45477.164
484 


45477.165
485 


45477.166
486 


45477.167
487 


45477.168
488 


45477.169
489 


45477.170
490 


45477.171
491 


45477.172
492 


45477.173
493 


45477.174
494 


45477.175
495 


45477.176
496 


45477.177
497 


45477.178
498 


45477.179
499 


45477.180
500 


45477.181
501 


45477.182
502 


45477.183
503 


45477.184
504 


45477.185
505 


45477.186
506 


45477.187
507 


45477.188
508 


45477.189
509 


45477.190
510 


45477.191
511 


45477.192
512 


45477.193
513 


45477.194
514 


45477.195
515 


45477.196
516 


45477.197
517 


45477.198
518 


45477.199
519 


45477.200
520 


45477.201
521 


45477.202
522 


45477.203
523 


45477.204
524 


45477.205
525 


45477.206
526 


45477.207
527 


45477.208
528 


45477.209
529 


45477.210
530 


45477.211
531 


45477.212
532 


45477.213
533 


45477.214
534 


45477.215
535 


45477.216
536 


45477.217
537 


45477.218
538 


45477.219
539 


45477.220
540 


45477.221
541 


45477.222
542 


45477.223
543 


45477.224
544 


45477.225
545 


45477.226
546 


45477.227
547 


45477.228
548 


45477.229
549 


45477.230
550 


45477.231
551 


45477.232
552 


45477.233
553 


45477.234
554 


45477.235
555 


45477.236
556 


45477.237
557 


45477.238
558 


45477.239
559 


45477.240
560 


45477.241
561 


45477.242
562 


45477.243
563 


45477.244
564 


45477.245
565 


45477.246
566 


45477.247
567 


45477.248
568 


45477.249
569 


45477.250
570 


45477.251
571 


45477.252
572 


45477.253
573 


45477.254
574 


45477.255
575 


45477.256
576 


45477.257
577 


45477.258
578 


45477.259
579 


45477.260
580 


45477.261
581 


45477.262
582 


45477.263
583 


45477.264
584 


45477.265
585 


45477.266
586 


45477.267
587 


45477.268
588 


45477.269
589 


45477.270
590 


45477.271
591 


45477.272
592 


45477.273
593 


45477.274
594 


45477.275
595 


45477.276
596 


45477.277
597 


45477.278
598 


45477.279
599 


45477.280
600 


45477.281
601 


45477.282
602 


45477.283
603 


45477.284
604 


45477.285
605 


45477.286
606 


45477.287
607 


45477.288
608 


45477.289
609 


45477.290
610 


45477.291
611 

Æ 


45477.292