1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1

1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 SCOT T R . MORRI S FA A OFFIC E O FREGIONAL COUNSEL 160 1 LiN D AVE. , S W RENTON , WASHINGTO N 9805 7 TELEPHONE : 425/227-141 7 FACSIMILE : 425/227-1007 

### :PARTM£WTO F

^ C -' 0 P 2

^ f i 4 

### UNITE D STATE S O F AMERIC A DEPARTMEN T O F TRANSPORTATIO N OFFIC E O F HEARING S J . RANDOLP H BABBITT , Administrator , Federa l Aviatio n Administration , COMPLAINAN T

vs . SCENI C AVL^TION , INC. , RESPONDEN T FA A DOCKE T CP09NM001 1 FA A Cas e No . 2009NM07006 6 DM S No . FAA-2009-097 4 MOTIO N T O COMPE L DISCOVER Y an d MOTIO N T O SHORTE N TIM E T O RESPON D Judg e GOODWI N TO : Judg e Goodwin : Motio n t o Compe l Discover y Complainant , throug h hi s undersigne dcounsel , pursuan t t o Rule s o f

Practic e 13.220(1)(1) , hereb y move s tha t

th e Request s fo

r Admission s file db y th e Complainan t o n Septembe r

23,201 0 b e deeme dadmitted . Additionally , Complainant , throug h hi s undersigne dcounsel , hereb y move s th e Administrativ e La w Judg e t o impos e sanction s o n Responden t fo r failin g t o compl y with th e procedura l order

i n thi s cas e unde r

Rule s o f Practic e 13.220(n ) b y prohibitin g Responden t from introducin g a s evidenc e at th e hearin g any materia l no t provide di n discovery a s o f th e dat e o f

thi s motion . Complainan t

als o move s that

Responden t

b e preclude dfromraisin g certai n defense s (i.e . th e financial hardshi p defense ) a s th e requeste ddiscovery pertain s t o material s relate dt o thos e affirmativ e defenses . Complainan t move s tha t

Responden t

b e preclude dfromchallengin g certai n portion s o f

th e Complaint . In th e alternative , Complainan t request s th e ALJ t o ente r an order compellin g discovery unde r Rule s o f Practic e 13.220(m) . However , i f th e ALJ issue s a

n order Motio n t o Compe l Discover y Pag e 1 o f 10" ' -eni c Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 SCOT T R . MORRIS , FA A ATTORNE Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.100 7compellin g discovery , an dResponden t complie s i n atimel y maimer . Complainan t reluctantl y ask s th e AL J t o conside r

acontinuanc e because , give n tha t th e hearin g start s i n on e week . Complainan t doubt s tha t

i t can revie w th e requeste dmaterial s an dprepar e with th e additional material s i n tim e t o adequatel y presen t

it s case . 

### Statemen t o f Salien t Facts ^ 1 . O n Augus t

16,2010 , th e ALJ Amende dth e Procedural Orde r requirin g th e partie s t o complet e discovery b y Novembe r 29,2010 . DM S Docke t

No . FAA200—0974-0020 .

' Th e prio r

discover y histor y o f

thi s cas e i s a s follows : 1 . O n Marc h 2 , 2010 , Complainan t serve dResponden t

wit h Complainant' s Initia l Discovery Reques t b y facsimil e an dcertifie dmail . A respons e t o that reques t wa s du e Apri l 2,2010 . Se e DM S Documen t FAA-2009-0974

- 0008 . 2 . Responden t

faile dt o respon dt o tha t

reques t unti l Apri l 9 , 2010 . However , Responden t di das k fo r mor e tim e whic h Complainan t

counse l granted . 3 . O n Marc h 26,2010 , Complainan t serve dResponden t

wit h Complainant' s Firs t

Supplemental Discover

y Reques t b y facsimil e an dcertifie dmail . A respons e t o tha t reques t wa s du e Apri l 26,2010 . Se e DM S Document FAA

2009-0974-0011 . 4 . Th e Procedura l Order i n thi s case , entere do n Februar y 24,2010 , require dth e partie s t o conclud e discover y b y Ma y 1 , 2010 . Se e DM S Documen t FAA-2009-0974-0007 . 5 . O n Ma y 13,2010 , undersigpe dcounse l sen t counse l fo

r responden t

alette r vi aregular

mai l ande-mai l inquirin g int o th e statu s o f th e respons e t o Complainant' s Firs t Supplemental Discovery Request . Th e letter requeste da respons e t o tha

t request , an dasupplemental respons e t o Complainant' s Initial Discovery Request , a s th e initia l respons e state dtha t "investigatio n continues " fo r many o f th e initial discover

y requests . 6 . Responden t

faile dt o respon dt o Complainant' s Firs t Supplemental Discovery Reques t unti l Ma y 18,2010 . Again , Respondent' s counse l requeste dan dComplainant' s counse l grante dthi s extensio n o f tim e t o comply . 7 . O n Ma y 27,2010 , Responden t supplemente dit s discover y respons e b y addin g document s an dwitoesse s fo r th e afBrmativ e defens e o f financial abilit

y t o pay . 8 . On Jun e 30,2010 , Complainant' s counse l discovere dthat i t ha dno t provide dRespondent s counse l wit h a CD . Thi s C D containe dth e photograph s o f th e logbook s previousl y provide dwherea s th e prio r discover y respons e ha d onl y provide dphotocopie s o f thos e photographs . 9 . O n Jul y 1,2010 , Respondent' s counse l fileda n unoppose dmotio n fo r

acontinuanc e fo

r th e hearin g se t

to begi n o n Jul y 13 , 2010 . I n thi s motio n Responden t claime dprejudic e b y no t

havin g receive dpicture s o f th e logbook s a s oppose dt o tiie previousl y provide dphotocopie s o f thos e pictures . A s par t

o f thi s reques t

"Responden t

respectfully request s acontinuanc e o f

tiie schedule dhearin g i n orde r t o conduc t

meaningfii l discovery i n thi s matter , includin g bu t no t limite dt o th e opportunity t o identif y expert witnesse s wit

h regardt o th e newl y discovere ddocuments. " Se e DM S Documen t

FAA-2009-0974-0016 . para . 9 . 10 . O n Jul y 2,2010 , th e ALJ grante dRespondent' s Motio n for aContinuance . Se e DM S Document FAA

2009-0974-0014 . 11 . On Jul y 21,2010 , Complainan t supplemente dit s discover y response . Se e DM S Documen t FAA-2009

- 0974-0017 . 12 . O n Augus t

16.2010 , Responden t

filedit s secon dse t

o f interrogatories , reques t

fo r productio n o f document s an dreques t

for admissions . Complainant' s response s wer e du e Septembe r 17,2010 . However , Respondent' s counse l grante dComplainan t a n extensio n unti l Septembe r 24,2010 . 13 . O n Septembe r

23,2010 , Complainan t

responde dt o Respondent' s Secon dSe t o f Discovery Requests . Motio n t o Compel Discover y Page 2 o f 1 0 Scenic Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 SCOT T R , MORRIS , FA

A ATroRNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.10071 0

1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 . O n Septembe r 23,2010 , Complainan t

serve dResponden t

with Complainant' s Secon d Supplementa l Discovery Reques t b y fa x an dcertifie dmail . Se e Exhibi t 1 . 3 . Complainant' s Secon dSupplementa l Discover y Reques t containe dth e followin g Request s fo

r Admission : a . REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N N O 1 : Admi t tha t Sceni c Aviatio n wa s no t acertificate drepai r

statio n (per

1 4 C.F.R . Part

145 ) durin g th e perio d1 Jul y 200 7 throug h an dincludin g 3 0 Marc h 2009 . b . REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N NO . 2 : Admi t that , durin g th e perio d1 Jul y 200 7 throug h an dincludin g 3 0 Marc h 2009 , Sceni c Aviatio n was no t authorize dt o performmaintenanc e pe r acontinuou s airworthines s maintenanc e progra m(CAMP) . c . REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N NO . 3 : Admi t that , durin g th e perio d1 Jul y 200 7 throug h an dincludin g 3 0 Marc h 2009 , Sceni c Aviatio n was authorize d t o perfor mmaintenanc e pe r

a n approve daircraf

t inspectio n program approve dunde r

1 4 C.F.R . § 135.419 . d . REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N NO . 4 : Admi t that , durin g th e perio d Augus t 7,200 7 - January 28,2008 , whe n Sceni c Aviatio n operate d N3221 M i n controlle dairspace , i t use dth e transponde r

aboardth e aircraft . e . REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N NO . 5 : Admi t that , durin g th e perio dJul y 10,200 7 - Decembe r

10,2008 , whe n Sceni c Aviatio n operate dN558S A i n controlle dairspace , i t

use dth e transponde r

aboar dth e aircraft .

Motio n t o Compe l Discover y Pag e 3 o f 1 0 Scenic Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 SCOT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.100 71 0

1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 f

. REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N NO . 6 : Admi t that , durin g th e perio d Octobe r 19,200 7 - Marc h 25,2009 , whe n Sceni c Aviatio n operate d N617MM i n controlle dairspace , i t use dth e transponde r

aboardth e aircraft . 4 . I n accordanc e with Rule s o f Practic e 13.220(d) , arespons e was du e n o late r tha n October 23,2010 . 5 . Complainan t

receive dafacsimil e confirmatio n showin g "2 0 pages " sen t "ok " o n Septembe r

23,201 0 at

10:5 6 am . Se e Exhibi t

2 . 6 . Th e certifie dmaiUng o f Complainant' s Secon dSupplemental Discovery Reques t wa s returne db y th e U.S . Postal Servic e t o Complainant' s offic e o n October 19,201 0 a s "unclaimed. " However , th e regula

r mai l wa s no t

returned . Se e Exhibi t

3 . 7 . O n Septembe r

30,2010 , th e AL J re-schedule dthi s hearin g for 1 3 - 1 5 December , 2010 . DM S Docke t

No . FAA-2009-0974-0023 . 8 . O n October

21 , 2010 , Responden t

wa s re-serve dwit

h Complainant' s Secon d Supplemental Discovery Reques t o n Octobe r

21 , 201 0 b y overnight

courie r - Federal Expres s an d facsimile . S'e

e Exhibi t 4 . 9 . O n October

28,2010 , undersigne dcounse l requeste dthat Respondent' s counse l provid e an updat e o n th e statu s o f

Respondent' s respons e t o Complainant' s Secon dSupplemental Discovery Request . Se e Exhibi t 5 , at 5-2 . 10 . O n Novembe r

1 , 2010 , Respondent' s counse l aske dthat athir dse t

o f Complainant' s supplementa l discover

y request s b e sen t

t o him . Se e Exhibi t

5 , a t 5-2 . 11 . Pe r th e reques t

o f Respondent' s coimse l i n respons e t o tha t inquiry . Complainant' s counse l serve dResponden t with Complainant' s Secon dSupplemental Discovery Reques t b y e-mai l o n Novembe r

1,2010 . Se e Exhibi t

5 , at 5-1 . Motion to Compe

l Discover y Page 4 o f 1 0 Scenic Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 SCOT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.100 71 0

1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 12 . O n Novembe r 15,2010 , Respondent' s counse l represente dthat thei r discovery respons e woul db e sen t

i n th e mai l tha t

day . Se e Exhibi t

5 , at 5-1 . 13 . O n Decembe r

1 , 2010 , settlemen t

discussion s ha dno t

bee n finitfiil an dComplainant' s counse l notifie dRespondent' s counse l that h e ha dunti l Decembe r

3,201 0 t o produc e th e requeste d discover y o r h e woul db e force dt o file amotio n t o compel . Se e Exhibi t 6 . Als o o n Decembe r

1 , 2010 , Responden t

wa s abl e t o supplemen t

it s discovery respons e notifyin g Complainan t o f it s inten t t o us e 3 photograph s no t

previousl y disclose . Se e Exhibi t 7 . 14 . A s o f

Decembe r

3,2010 ; 7 1 day s afte

r th e initia l service , 3 2 day s afte r th e thir d service , an dfour

day s afte r th e dat e set

b y th e Procedura l Orde r

i n thi s cas e t o conclud e discovery ; Responden t

ha s not responde dt o Complainant' s Secon dSupplemental Discovery Request .

Discussio n Request s fo rAdmissio n Sectio n 13.220(1)(1 ) o f

th e Rule s o f

Practic e states : (1 ) Time . A party' s failure t o respon dt o areques t for admission , i n writin g an dsigne db y th e attorne y o r th e party , no t

late r tha n 3 0 day s afte r servic e o f

th e request , i s deeme dan admissio n o f th e truth o f th e statemen t

o r statement s containe di n th e reques t for admission.. . Responden t

ha s ye t t o respon dt o th e Request s for Admissio n serve do n Responden t o n Septembe r

23 , 2010 . Unde r

th e rule , arespons e t o th e Request s for Admissio n wa s du e b y October 23,2010 . Eve n grantin g Responden t th e benefi t

o f th e doub t that Responden t

di dno t actuall y receiv e Complainant' s requestunti l th e thir dservic e b y e-mai l o n Novembe r 1,2010 , arespons e woul dhav e bee n du e December 1,201 0 at

th e latest . B y any reasonabl e measure , th e deadlin e fo r Respondent' s respons e ha s lon g passed , an dtherefore , thos e matter s addresse di n Complainant' s Request s fo

r Admissio n serve do n Septembe r 23,201 0 shoul db e deeme dadmitte dunde r 13.220(1)(1) , a s n o respons e t o thos e request s wa s receive db y Decembe r 1 , 2010 . Motio n t o Compe l Discovery Pag e 5 o f 1 0 Sceni c Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 SCOT T R . MORRIS , FA A ATTORNE Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.100 71 0

1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 Failur e t o Respon d t o Discover y

Sectio n 13.220(1 ) o f

th e Rule s o f

Practic e states : (1 ) Failur e to comply wit

h adiscovery orde r

o r orde r t o compel . I f aparty fail s t o compl y with adiscovery orde r o r an orde r t o compel , th e administrativ e la w judge , limite dt o th e exten t o f th e party' s failure t o compl y with th e discovery orde r o r motio n t o compel , may : (1 ) Strike tha t

portio n o f

aparty' s pleadings ; (2 ) Preclud e prehearin g o r discovery motion s b y tha t party ; (3 ) Preclud e admissio n o f tha t portio n o f

aparty' s evidenc e at th e hearing ; o r (4 ) Preclud e that

portio n o f

th e testimon y o f

that party' s witnesse s a

t th e hearing . Complainan t

ha s bee n mor e tha n accommodatin g o f Respondent' s unwillingnes s t o timel y compl y with thei r

discovery obligations , a s show n b y letter s an de-mail s fi-omth e undersigne d counse l t o responden t

requestin g update s o n th e statu s o f Respondent' s response s an drernindin g Responden t

o f th e deadline s for

discovery . Responden t

ha s no t timel y responde dt o an y o f Complainant' s discovery requests . Respondent' s respons e t o Complainant' s Initial Discovery Reques t wa s seve n day s late . Respondent' s respons e t o Complainant' s Firs t Supplementa l Discovery Reques t

wa s 2 2 day s late , an dwas complete d1 7 day s afte r th e deadlin e i n th e procedura l order the n i n effec t

t o complet e discovery . Thu s far , Responden t ha s faile dt o respon dt o Complainant' s Secon dSupplemental Discovery Reques t at all , an di s thu s ove r

4 0 day s delinquen t i n respondin g t o tha t

request . Althoug h generall y sanction s ar e ordinaril y onl y impose dwher e aparty fail s t o compl y wit h an orde r t o compel , th e rul e provide s that sanction s ma

y als o b e impose di n som e circumstance s before an order

t o compe l ha s bee n issue d- whe n adiscovery order ha s bee n issue dan dno t complie dwith . In thi s case , th e Procedural Orde r issue do n Februar

y 24,2010 , a s amende do n Motion to Compel Discover y Pag e 6 o f 1 0 Scenic Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 SCOT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.10071 0

1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 Augus t

16 , 2010 , require dth e conclusio n o f discovery n o later

tha n Novembe r

29,2010 . Responden t

ha s faile dt o compl y with tha t deadline , thus , responden t ha s faile dt o compl y with a discovery order . I t

follow s that

sanction s may therefor e b e impose dunde r 13.220(1) . Althoug h sanctio n ma

y b e an extrem e remedy , i t i s an appropriat e on e wher e aResponden t ha s no t compUe dwith adiscovery order , "particularl y i n th e contex t o f it s patter n o f

failure t o voluntaril y compl y wit

h Complainant' s discover y requests. " I n th e Matte r o f American Aviation , Inc. , FA A Docke t

No . CP06NM0006 , DM S FAA-2006-2587 6 (2007) . Respondent' s failure t o timel y compl y with any o f Complainant' s discover

y requests , an deve n the n onl y whe n cajole db y counse l for

th e Complainant , constitute s suc h apattern . Th e requeste dinformatio n i n Complainant' s discover y request s ar e i n direc t

respons e t o certai n aspect s o f

thi s case . In particular , th e Interrogatorie s an dseveral o f th e Request s fo

r Productio n ar e request s t o provid e informatio n concernin g Respondent' s affirmativ e defense s raise di n it s Answe r

t o th e Amende dComplaint , date dAugus t 6,2010 . DM S Docke t

No . FAA

2009-0974-0021 . Th e requeste ddocument s an dInterrogatorie s ar e essentia l t o mee t several o f thos e affirmativ e defenses ; specificall y affirmativ e defens e 1,3,5 , an d6 . Responden t canno t b e allowe dt o rais e thes e defense s i f i t wil l no t answe r th e requeste dInterrogatorie s o r produc e th e requeste ddocuments . Th e response s t o thes e request s ar e necessary t o evaluat e th e merit s o f thos e defenses . A s Responden t ha s faile dt o respon dt o discover y tha t woul dallo w th e probin g o f thos e defense s i t

shoul db e barre dfi"omassertin g thos e defense s a t th e hearing . Th e remainin g request s for productio n ar e necessar

y t o corroborat e an dsuppor t th e Complainant s cas e i n chief . Complainan t

ha s agoo dfait

h basi s t o beUev e tha t

thes e document s existe da t th e tim e o f

th e reques t an dthei r productio n woul dsuppor t it s factua l allegations . Th e refusa

l t o produc e thes e

Motio n t o Compe

l Discover y Page7ofl 0 Scenic Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 SCOT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.100 75

6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 record s potentiall y weaken s th e Complainant' s case . A s i t ha s th e burden , th e denial o f thi s evidenc e prejudice s it s case . Shoul dth e Judg e b e disincline dt o orde r sanctions , sectio n 13.220(m ) o f th e Rule s o f Practic e states : (m ) Motio n t o compe l discovery . A party may mak e amotio n t o

compe l discovery i f

aperso n refiise s t o answe r aquestio n dtirin g a deposition , aparty fail s o r refiise s t o answe r

an interrogatory , i f

a perso n give s an evasiv e o r incomplet e answe r

durin g adepositio n o r whe n respondin g t o a n interrogatory , o r aparty fail s o r

refiise s t o produc e document s o r

tangibl e items.. . I n th e alternative , Complainan t move s th e Judg e t o ente r a n Orde r t o Compe l Discover

y with adeadlin e fo r

productio n n o late r

tha n December

8 , 2010 , i n accordanc e wit h thi s Rul e o f Practice . Ftirther , Complainan t can n o longer

represen t tha t eve n i f th e discover

y i s produce db y Decembe r 8,2010 , tha t

i t wil l hav e adequat e tim e t o prepar e it s cas e adjustin g for th e produce d document s an dmay wel l hav e t o reques t acontinuance . 

### Conclusio n THEREFORE , Complainan t move s th e Administrativ e La w Judg e t o ente r an order finding that th e si x Request s for

Admissio n containe di n Complainant' s Secon dSupplemental Discover y reques t b e deeme dadmitted . Complainan t als o move s th e Administrativ e Law Judg e t o impos e sanction s o n Responden t

fo r failin g t o compl y with th e procedura l order i n thi s cas e under

Rule s o f Practic e 13.220(n)(l ) b y strikin g Respondent' s defense s 1 , 3, 5 an d6 . Further , Complainan t move s th e Administrativ e La w Judg e t o prohibite dth e introductio n int o evidenc e o f any material b y th e Responden t

o f an y materia l not

provide db y th e Responden t i n discovery . I n th e altemative , Complainan t move s than an orde r

b e entere dcompellin g Responden t t o respon dt o Complainant' s Secon dSupplemental Discovery Reques t b y Decembe r

8,201 0 an dt o

Motion to Compe

l Discover y Page 8 o f 1 0 Sceni c Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 SCOT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.10076

7

1 0 1 2 ( 1 3 favorabl e conside r

grantin g aComplainan t

reques t fo r continuanc e i f

afte r revie w o f

th e produce d document s i t

believe s tha t

i t need s mor e tim e t o prepare . GIVEN tha t

thi s hearin g i s schedule dt o begi n i n te n days . Complainan t als o Move s that Responden t

hav e unti l CO B o n Decembe r 7,201 0 t o respond , an dtha t th e ALJ orde r

aconferenc e cal l t o addres s th e issu e an dhi s ruling . DATE D thi s 3r dday o f

December , 2010 . MORRI S ^A A Attorne y

Motion t o Compel Discover y Page 9 of 1 0 Sceni c Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 ScoT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.10071

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 2 9 3 0 3 1 3 2 3 3 3 4 3 5 3 6 3 7 3 8 3 9 4 0 4 1 4 2 4 3 4 4 4 5 4 6 4 7 CERTIFICAT E O FSERVIC E I hereb y certif

y tha t th e foregoin g Complainant' s Motio n t o Compe l ha s bee n serve dvi a facsimil e an dCertifie dMai l - Retur n Receip t Requeste dthi s date , t o th e following : Th e Honorabl e Richar dC . Goodwi n Offic e o f hearings , M-2 0 120 0 Ne w Jerse y Avenue , S.E . Eas t Buildin g Groun dFloor , R mEl2-32 0 Washington , D.C . 2059 0 TEL : 202.366.213 9 FAX : 202.366.753 6 (an db y email ) Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenu e S W Washington , D.C . 2059 1 Attii : Hearin g Docke t

Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wrigh t Buildin g - Suit e 2W100 0 FAX : 202.493.502 0 Gregor y S . Winto n Aviatio n La w Experts , LL C 33 0 Aviatio n Wa y Frederick , M D 2170 1 TEL : 301.294.855 0 FAX : 301.294.252 5 (an db y email )

DATE D tills 3r dda

y o f December , 2010 .

MOIFAI RC I Offic e o f Regiona l Cotmse l (ANM-7 ) Federa l Aviatio n Admiiustratio n 160 1 Lin dAve . S W Renton , W A 9805 7 (425)227-216 0

Motio n t o Compe l Discover y Pag e 1 0 of

1 0 Scenic Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 ScoT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.10071

2 3 4 5 5 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 2 9 3 0 3 1 3 2 3 3 3 4 3 5 3 6 3 7 3 8 3 9 4 0 4 1 4 2 4 3 4 4 4 5 4 6 4 7 4 8 4 9 5 0 5 1 5 2 5 3 SCOTTR . MORRI S FA A OFFIC E O FREGIONA L COUNSEL 160 1 LIN D AVE. , S W RENTON , WASHINGTO N 9805 7 TELEPHONE : 425.227.141 7 FACSIMILE : 425.227.100 7

I n th e Matte r

of : Sceni c Aviation , Inc . 

### UNITE D STATE S O FAMERIC A

DEPARTMEN T O FTRANSPORTATIO N OFFIC E O FHEARING S WASHINGTON , D.C .

FA A DOCKE T C P 09NM001 1 FA A Cas e No . 2009NM07006 6 DM S No . FAA-2009-097 4 Judg e Goodwi n

COMPLAINANT' S SECON D SUPPLEMENTA L DISCOVER Y REQUES T To : Responden t I n accordanc e wit h 1 4 CFRSection s 13.22 0 an dth e Federa l Rule s o f Civi l Procedure , pleas e respon dt o th e followin g Interrogatories , Request s for Productio n o f

Documents , an d Reques t for Admissions , separatel y an dfully unde r oath b y Octobe r

23,2010 . Thes e discovery request s are intende dt o discove r informatio n and/o r

document s no t

onl y withi n you r

persona l knowledg e or

obtainabl e b y you , bu t

als o informatio n i n th e possessio n o f o r obtainabl e b y you r

attorneys , investigators , representatives , employees , agents , o r anyon e actin g o n you r behal f o r o n thei r behal f Thes e discovery request s ar e continuin g i n natur e an dany informatio n whic h may b e discovere db y yo u subsequen t t o th e servic e an dfiling o f you r answer s mus t

b e brough t

t o th e attentio n o f

th e agenc y attorne y throug h supplementa l answer s whe n i t become s availabl e t o you , a t areasonabl e tim e prio r

t o th e hearin g i n thi s matter . I f ther e ar e an y additions , deletion s or change s i n th e answer s o r

informatio n provide dat

any tim e prio r

t o hearin g th e Responden t i s specifically requeste dt o s o immediatel y uifor mth e agenc y attorney . I f suc h informatio n i s no t

fiimished, th e agenc y attorne y a t

th e time o f

th e hearing wil l mov e t o exclud e fromevidenc e suc h informatio n requeste dan dno t

furnished . Th e agenc y attorne y fiirther request s tha t

th e Responden t

produc e th e document s identifie d an ddesignate dherei n fo r inspectio n an dcopyin g at th e FA A Offic e o f

Regiona l Counsel , Suite 570,160 1 Lin dAvenue , SW , Renton , Washingto n 98057 , b y Ocfobe r 23,2010 . PRIVILEG E If , i n respondin g to , or

failin g t o respon dt o thes e interrogatories , request s fo r admissio n an d request s for

productio n yo u invok e o r rel y upo n an y privileg e o f any kind , stat e specificall y th e Complainant' s Secon

dSupplementa

l Discover y Reques t Sceni c Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 Pag e 1 o f 6 ScoT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.1007 

### f - l1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 2 9 3 0 3 1 3 2 3 3 3 4 3 5 3 6 3 7 3 8 3 9 4 0 4 1 4 2 4 3 4 4 4 5 4 6 4 7 4 8 4 9 5 0 5 1 5 2 5 3 statutory o

r decisiona l reference ; an didentif y al l document s o r

othe r information , includin g contact s an

dcommunication s whic h yo u believ e t o b e embrace db y th e privileg e invoked . DATE D thi s 23r dda

y o f Septembe r

2010 .

SCOTTR . MORRI S FA A Attorne y

Complainant' s Secon

dSupplementa

l Discover y Reques t Scenic Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 Pag e 2 o f 6 SCOT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.100 71

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 2 9 3 0 3 1 3 2 3 3 3 4 3 5 3 6 3 7 3 8 3 9 4 0 4 1 4 2 4 3 4 4 4 5 4 6 4 7 • 4 8 4 9 5 0 5 1 5 2 S 3 INTERROGATORIE S Interrogatory No . 1 : Identif y an y facilities , equipment , spar e parts , suppUe s an dmaterials , o r aircraf t purchase dor

lease db y Sceni c Aviatio n o r it s affiliate s (i f

any ) sinc e 1 Jul y 2007 . Interrogatory No . 2 : Stat e wit h specificit y what methods , techniques, o r

practice s Sceni c Aviatio n (o r it s agents ) use dt o compl y with th e requirement s o f FA R91.41 1 an d91.41 3 concernin g N588SA , N617MM , an dN3221 M durin g th e period s reference di n th e Complaint . Interrogatory No . 3 : Stat e th e nvimbe r o f employee s tha t

wer e o n th e payrol l o f

Sceni c Aviatio n o n Augus t 1,2007 . Interrogatory No . 4 : State th e numbe r o f employee s tha t

are cxirrentiy o n th e payrol l o f Sceni c Aviatio n an dal l o f

th e companie s o r

affiUate s i t

ha s acontrollin g interes t

in . REQUEST S FO RPRODUCTION . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 1 : Provid e acop y o f al l aircraf

t equipmen t

list s fo r N3221M , N588SA , an dN617M M tiiat wer e i n effec t

durin g tiie perio d1 Jul y 200 7 tiirough an d includin g 3 0 Marc h 2009 . (Thi s reques t exclude s th e origina l equipmen t lis t alread y provided. ) REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 2 : Provid e acop y o f an y document s concernin g Sceni c Aviation' s purchas e o f

Hawai i Ai r

• Ambulanc e an dit s purchas e o f aircraf t fi-omHawai i Ai r Ambulanc e Aircraft . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 3 : Provid e acop y o f any document s concernin g Sceni c Aviation' s purchas e pric e an dterm s o f an y compan y sinc e 1 Jul y 2007 . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 4 : Provid e acop y o f an y document s concernin g Sceni c Aviation' s purchas e o r

leas e o f an y aircraf

t siric e 1 Jul y 2007 . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 5 : Produc e th e underlyin g record s o f receipt s o r

sale s t o suppor t th e amoun t

entere di n th e 200 8 Incom e Ta x Return For m1120S , a t ite mla , for

Eagl e Ai r Me dCorporatio n submitte db y Responden t i n it s Secon dSupplementa l Response s t o Complainant' s Initial Discover y Request . Thi s reques t specificall y includes , but i s not limite dto , th e dispatc h recor dform s reference di n Scenic' s Genera l Operation s Manual , pag e A-6 , fo r th e aircraf t reference di n th e Complain t an dwer e t o b e forwarde dt o Scenic' s billin g departmen t and/o r th e dispatc h recor ddat aelectronicall y transmitte dt o th e Sceni c Billing Departmen t I f thos e dispatc h record s are no t

available , the n th e billin g record s for th e flight s tiiat

occurre dusin g th e aircraf t reference di n th e Complaint . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 6 : Produc e copie s o f tiie document s describin g th e metiiods , technique s an dpractice s reference di n Interrogatory No . 2 above . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 7 : Produc e copie s o f tiie applicabl e section s o f any manual s Sceni c Aviatio n (or

it s agents ) use dwhe n i t

replace dth e altimeter/encode r i n N3221 M durin g th e maintenanc e performe do n Augus t 7,200 7 reference di n th e Amende dComplaint . Complainant' s Secon

dSupplementa

l Discover y Request Scenic Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 Pag e 3 o f 6 SCOT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.1007



# /- S1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 2 9 3 0 3 1 3 2 3 3 3 4 3 5 3 6 3 7 3 8 3 9 4 0 4 1 4 2 4 3 4 4 4 5 4 6 4 7 4 8 4 9 5 0 5 1 5 2 5 3 

### REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 8 : Produc e copie s o f the apphcable section s of

an y manual s Sceni c Aviatio n (or

it s agents ) use dwhe

n i t replacedth e altimeter/encode r i n N588S A durin

g the maintenanc e performedon Jul y 10,200 7 referencedi n th e Amende dComplaint . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 9 : Produc e copie s o f the apphcable section s of

an y manual s Sceni c Aviatio n (or

it s agents ) use dwhe

n i t replacedth e altimeter/encode r i n N588S A durin

g the maintenanc e performedon Februar y 17,200 8 referencedi n the Amende dComplaint . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 10 : Produc e copie s o f the applicabl e section s o f an y manual s Sceni c Aviation (o r it s agents ) use dwhe

n it replacedthe altimeter/encode r in N617M

M durin g the maintenanc e performedo n Octobe r 19,200 7 referencedin th e AmendedComplaint . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 11 : Produc e copie s o f tiie apphcabl e section s o f an y manual s Scenic Aviation (o r it s agents ) use dwhe

n i f replacedth e altimeter/encode r i n N617M

M durin g the maintenanc e performe do n Ma y 27,200 8 referencedin the AmendedComplaint . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 12 : Produc e copie s of tiie apphcabl e section s o f an y manual s Sceni c Aviation (o r it s agents ) usedwhe

n it replace dthe altimeter/encode r an dtransponde

r contro l in N617MM durin

g the maintenanc e performedon Decembe r 22 , 200 8 referencedi

n the AmendedComplaint . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 13 : Produc e copie s of N3221M' s loa

dmanifes t and/o r flight trackin g form s fo

r th e perio d1 Jul

y 2007 through andincluding 3 0 March 2009 . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 14 : Produc e copie s o f N588SA' s loa

dmanifests and/o

r fhgh t trackin g forms fo

r the perio d1 Jul

y 2007 through an

dincluding 3 0 Marc

h 2009 . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 15 : Produc e copie s o f N617MM' s loa

dmanifests and/o

r fhgh t trackin g forms fo

r the perio d1 Jul

y 200 7 through an

dincluding 3 0 March 2009 . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 16 : Produc e acop y o f tiie lo g page s fi-omN771P D fo r maintenanc e tha

t occurredt

o i t concerning aCTL-9 2 during the perio d1 Decembe r 200 8 - 3 1 Januar y 2009 . REQUES T FO RPRODUCTIO N NO . 17 : Produc e copie s o f tiie documents relie dupo n t o respon d to Interrogator

y No . 1 above . REQUES T FO RADMISSIONS Unde r 1 4 C.F.R . 13.220(b) an

dRul e 3 6 o

f th e Federa

l Rule s o f Civil Procedure , yo

u ar e requested t o admit th e trut h of the followin

g matters . A matte

r i s admittedunles s respondedto i n a reasonabl e time . The Rule s o f Practic e in FA

A Civil Penalt

y Actions , 1 4 C.F.R , 13.220(d) , define s areasonabl e time t o be 3 0 days . The agenc y request s tha

t a n answe r i s servedupo n th e agenc

y attorne y eithe r admitting the matter , specificall y denyin g th e matter , stating wh

y the matte

r canno t b e admittedor

denied , o r objectin g t o the request , wit

h reason s fo

r the objection state dwithin 3 0 day s o f the dat e o f servic e upo

n you , to wit : Octobe r

23,2010 .

Complainant' s Secon

dSupplementa

l Discover y Reques t Sceni c Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 Pag e 4 o f 6 SCOT T R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.1007



## l-H -1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 28 ' 2 9 3 0 3 1 3 2 3 3 3 4 3 5 3 6 3 7 3 8 3 9 4 0 4 1 4 2 4 3 4 4 4 5 4 6 4 7 4 8 4 9 5 0 5 1 5 2 5 3 REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N N O 1 : Admi t tiiat Sceni c Aviatio n wa s no t

acertificate drepai r statio n (pe r

1 4 C.F.R . Part

145 ) durin g th e perio d1 Jul y 200 7 throug h an dincludin g 3 0 Marc h 2009 . REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N NO . 2 : Admi t tiiat, durin g tiie perio d1 Jul y 200 7 tiirough an d iticludin g 3 0 Marc h 2009 , Sceni c Aviatio n wa s not authorize dt o perfor

mmaintenanc e per

a continuou s airworthines s maintenanc e progra m(CAMP) . REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N NO . 3 : Admi t tiiat, durin g tiie perio d1 Jul y 200 7 tiirough an d includin g 3 0 Marc h 2009 , Sceni c Aviatio n was authorize dt o perfor mmaintenanc e pe r

a n approve d aircraf t inspectio n progra mapprove dunde r 1 4 C.F.R , § 135.419 . REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N NO . 4 : Admi t tiiat, durin g tiie perio dAugus t 7,200 7 - Januar

y 28 , 2008 , whe n Sceni c Aviatio n operate dN3221 M i n controlle dairspace , i t use dth e transponde r aboar dth e aircraft . REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N NO . 5 : Admi t tiiat, durin g tiie perio dJul y 10,200 7 - Decembe r 10 , 2008 , whe n Sceni c Aviatio n operate dN558S A i n controlle dairspace , i t use dth e transponde r aboar dth e aircraft . REQUES T FO RADMISSIO N NO . 6 : Admi t tiiat, durin g tiie perio dOctobe r 19,200 7 - Marc h 25 , 2009 , whe n Sceni c Aviatio n operate dN617M M i n controlle dairspace , i t use dth e transponde r aboar dth e aircraft .

Complainant' s Secon

dSupplementa

l Discover y Reques t Scenic Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 Page s of 6 Scor r R . MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.1007 ,1

2

. 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 2 9 3 0 3 1 3 2 3 3 3 4 3 5 3 6 3 7 3 8 3 9 4 0 4 1 4 2 4 3 4 4 4 5 4 6 4 7 4 8 4 9 5 0 5 1 5 2 5 3 

### CERTIFICAT E OFSERVICE I hereb y certif

y tha t th e foregoin g Complainant' s Secon dSupplementa l Discovery Reques t ha s bee n serve dvi afacsimil e an dcertifie dmai l - Retur n Receip t Requeste dthi s date , t o th e following : Th e Honorabl e Richar dC . Goodwi n

Offic e o f hearings , M-2 0 120 0 Ne w Jerse y Avenue , S.E . Eas t Buildin g Groun dFloor , R mEl2-32 0 Washington , D.C . 2059 0 TEL : 202.366.213 9 FAX : 202.366.753 6 Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n 80 0 Independenc e Avenu e S W Washington , D.C . 2059 1 Attn : Hearin g Docke t

Clerk , AGC-43 0 Wilbu r Wri^ t Buildm g - Suit e 2W100 0 FAX : 202.493.514 2 Gregor y S . Winto n Aviatio n La w Experts , LL C 33 0 Aviatio n Wa y Frederick , M D 2170 1 TEL : 301.294.855 0 FAX : 301.294.252 5

Date dtiiis 23r dda y o f

September , 2010 .

MOIFAI RCHI N Offic e o f Regiona l Counse l (ANM-7 ) Federa l Aviatio n Admiiustratio n 160 1 Lin dAve . S W Renton , W A 9805 7 425.227.216 0

Complainant' s Secon

dSupplementa

l Discover y Reques t Sceni c Aviation , Inc . - CP09NM001 1 Page 6 o f 6 ScoT T R , MORRIS , FA

A ATTORNE

Y TEL : 425.227.1417 ; FAX : 425.227.100 7



## l - h

# w

- / . / / / y "ft^ANSM ; ISSIO NVERIFICATIO NREPOR T 

# g ^

TIM E NAM E FA X TE L SER. « 09/23/2Bi a 11:8 5

ANM 7 425227169 7 BR0L9J99572 1 DATE,TIM E FA X NO./NAM E DURATIO N PAGE(S ) RESUL T MOD E ^ ^^2 3 IfllS S VJ12012942525— ^ 

# k - 'O K -ST i EC M



# <h-M': :^''•'If o iTliilllll M .11' ' V !

CO u- > u- > C M t o r O l 

### O 

# o 1 - L U

• ^ 0 0 < f O a . 3 j3|se H

( 4 P4 M H ;< » 

## gQg g o»<o o O P Qt 3 » Z » P i Pft S

3 - 'y<ii-l^ai,«af,

- mr - •^Jjgll-U —"*'''"i' ^



## l i i ; 

# i

3 ' ^

### 3- 3'' ^



### U.S . Departmen

t Of Transportatio n Federa l Aviatio n Administratio n Office of Regional Counse l Octobe r 21,201 0 Northwes t Mountai n Regio n Colorado , Idaho , Montana , Oregon , Utah , Washington , Wyoining \ 1 

### 160 1 Lin dAvenue S.W . Renton , Washington 9805 7 Tel : (425)227-216 0 Fax:(425)227-100 7 MOIFAJR.CHIN@FAA.GO V 

### Vi aovernigh

t courie r - Federa l Expres s andfacsimile t o 301.294.252 5 Gregor y S . Winto n Aviatio n La

w Experts , LL

C 33 0 Aviatio n Wa

y Frederick , M

D 2170 1 Re : . 2009NM070066 , Scenic Aviation , Inc . Complainant' s SecondSupplementa l Discover y Reques t andComplainant' s Respons e T o Respondent' s Secon

dSet o f Discover y Request s Dea r Mr . Winton : On Septembe

r 23,201 0 ou

r office sent

yo u vi afacsimile an

dcertifie dmail Complainant' s SecondSupplementa

l Discover y Reques t andComplainant' s Respons e T o Respondent' s Secon

d Se t o f Discover y Requests . W

e receive dafacsimil e confirmatio n clearly showing "2 0 pages " transmitte dand"ok " fo

r th e transmissio n sen

t o n Septembe

r 23,201 0 a

t 10:5 6 a.m . The certifie dmailin g t o you r office wa s returne dt o ou

r offic e o n Octobe

r 19,201 0 a s "unclaimed. " I hav e enclose dathirdcopy o f th e Complainant' s Secon

dSupplementa

l Discover y Reques t and Complainant' s Respons e T o Respondent' s SecondSe

t o f Discover y Request s an

dfacsimile confirmatio n per

you r recent reques t to Scot t Morris . / 

### Moifai r Chin Enclosur e MC/m c



## v - y# #



## SAirbil l FfldE K Tuckin g 

### flbMb 373f i 3fib T ;?7 ^ Sander' s FedE x Accoun t

Numbe r / ^ ^ 1855-5156- 3 4 aExpres s Packsg e Servic e {sTj^fldEx P t;j^=edE x Priorit

y Overnigh t snumwrMMiy k Phon g • FedE x Stander dOvernigh t IMIaalnMtrimtMV * SAinliyMvMyNOTndiUi . /Move s lylefS rOx . [— I ftdBtRretOwmight SAnlwMHiyNETMilb k EGIONA L COUNSE L • FedE x Expres s Seve r IMilbiatonidor * j>_n.Ki.i.^.u « SnnliyMiwivNaTinblili . FwEi&wlBniil«MtiwhMt.MWm«icliw8rOn>finmtffMf c ' 

# ft

LIN D AV E S W 4b Expres s Freigh t Seivic e ^ FedB(lDavft»ight * r—, FedEx ZDsyFreiah t ri^nmallicMnndaiMinlK' '— ' <^«»igrtilmlJwniliiiiMinili y •taiSnUHUirlWnrrkiilKa i •-—"""1-"- ' "Hi-'iilii f ^cytoCnfinMSM i —^ __ _ nult«f « om r fS D AI L • FedBcSOay Freigh t TIMtainmli^

- UutkyMorNOTanU* . sa w W A a p 98Q57-335 6 5 y Packagin g /-Nnvel o nBVBTQItC

v ^C^.i^~ 7 h^^r-^lcTC ^ krU/nODl ^ SpecialHandlin g n FedEx Pak * [ 1 FedE x n FedE

x ' - ' Tub e • othe

r *0j^n^n*i>MIS9 n iBctudsFtdExBddmtinSaclin l ' 

## wh^^|yW4z M r - | UTURDAYDelhw y Phone ( NQTAvaBaUehr MbcFkatOvrntglx , 

## ,>- f nw - L/ W 'V^.y^? ^ ^ » p- | HOUWaekdo y I I S t FedE x Locatc n NOTAinilalilefii r FtdG xAl t IhwiHSh t goatk ? • HDUSSataria v a t FedEx LpCBtia

n AwihMeMttYfa r Fwn t PitanQ rOwrnU t n d MEicZOiyt o HlKtlDcflian . N o n Ye s WBWi»BO«teftxiu<hBiiTYic>yttWi«fat«Wpr«dhF«dEi(fiiclBfl>'B .

riYes OffdtfMx A Ktnqun d • Dr y ic e i>rr)ct,(iUNn« . Q ] Carg o Aircref t Onl y 

# 12 - U±tz i ^^1M

_U / D«ptAo(«Siik«inDa m qitdfl c FtdEKlKiliof

k ^mFtdE K

iddtM t htn . 7 Paymen t fiWte Ei*rME]<AatNa.arCi<«Cwlllo.lMloii . Sende r V \Recipien t rNa.)nStclfa

n btVbi L • ThirdPart y • Credi t Car dQ Cash/Chec k 

## J^ D ^p^/%>

/ weital.fl a 038248571 4 Tota l Backage s Tota l Weigh t Tota l Declare dVhiocl

t tOvUaiV'>MMKtiaiirt«vi»iM»iiN#>r««k«.SMlailili > dak . •(>*«« * A M twignikt a

f-ir'-U inplHy^pnrJIilflpDrng:^^^ 8 Residentia l Deliver y Signatur e Option s lys . N o Signatur e • Require d fidugimyfatW l

- atdaMli i inlnrdmw ^ raqtin aiJenatti ^ dwef c Qkve t O f tadnd Direc t Signatur e • SaM«it«tnc%)M( h IndkBCtSignatiir a ISCViC A iddnH ; MMM

M • t I faiohtarin p iiUrn t RM w 

## s nPag e 1 o f 1

Espahc d ] CustoinB rSuppor

t I FedE > Locabon s Searc h : G o P>eklo«/Env«[op « Freiah t : Expedite d : Offlceff>rin l Service s ^ Ship » Track * Manag e I BusinessSotutjon a > Detaile d Result s Pitnler-Friendi vg? l Ul> i JEntartractanf l numbe r Hel p

Detaile d Result s Tracl(in g no. : 86463738386 9 Select tim e (omal : la j | 24

H g-mai l nolilicaHor a Delivere d

Shipmen t Oste a Iniljate d Picke d u p I n transi t Delivere d Delivere d Signe d fo rby : B.BRACKE N

Shi p dat e I2

> Oc t 21 , 201 0 Deliver ydat e 3 > Oc t 22 , 201 0 8:3 7 A M Shipmen t Option s Destlnalior i Stonatur e Proo f n t CHttver vi2 >

Hel p i : Hol d a t FedE xLocatio n Hol d a t FedE xLocatio n sarvic e i t no t avaltabi e forthi s shipment . Shipmen t Fact s hsl E Servic e typ e Priorit yEnvelop e Delivere d t o Referenc e Shipplnf^Receivin g SENI Z AWI Z 2Q0 9 N M0770 6 Shipmen t Trave l Histor

y Hel p , Selec t tim e zone: ; Loca l Sca n THn e Al l shipmen t trave l activit yi s displaye d i n loca l tim e fo rth e locatio n Date/Tlm a Oct22,2010«.'37A M Ort22.2010J;52A M Oc t 22,20101:1 9 A M Oc t 22 , 201 0 52 3 A M Oc t 22 . 201 0 3:1 9 A M 0022 , 201 0 12:5 5 A M O a 21.201 0 5:5 6 P M Oc t 21.201 0 2:4 7 P M AcflvK y Delivare d O n FedE xvehlel a fo rdeiver y A t loca l FedE xfadit y A t dea l sort fadlt y Departe d FedE xk>CBDo n Amva d a t FedE xkicatlo n Let t FedE xorigi n fadDty Picke d u p Locatio n IHAGERSTOWN.M D IHAGERSTOWN.M D DULLES , V A MEMPHIS . T N MEMPHIS . T N ,KEfjr,VK A .KENT,W A

FedE xDesktop : Trackin g a t you rfingertips . •^> . "v^-^s : ^^'^i^^^r- ^

/ Sig n u p to rFedEx * Billin g Onlin e Plu s 1 0 sav e paper , sav

e lim e (o ra chanc

e l o wi n

Oloba l Hom e { Smal l Buainet a Crnra r| Servic e Inf o | Abou t FedE xi investo rReralion s I Carear a (fede xcan i Tarm f o rLise ( Prrvacy - Poiie vI Sit e Map Thi s sit e i s protacta d b ycopyrigh t an d trademar k law s unde rU S an d Intametiona t law . Al l right s rasanred . C1995 - 201 0 FedE x

U-H-n-/UxniTw rfpAp vpnmArrar.Vinc r 12/3/201 0TRANSMISSIO NVERIFICATIO NREPOR T TIM E NAM E FA X TE L SER.t t lB/21/201 0 13:.3 3

ANM 7 425227100 7 BROL9J99572 1

DATE,TIM E FA X NO./NAM E DURATIO N PAGE<S > RESUL T MOD E 10/2 1 13:2 4 91301294252 5 00:09:1 9 2 2 O K STANDAR D EC M



# y v^ ^ RE : Sceni c Aviatio n - CP09NM001 1 - Respons e t o m ydiscover yrequest s Q Scot t Morri s to : Gre g Winto n 11/15/201 0 09:0 2 A M ANM-007 , Offic e o

f Regiona l Counse l Ok , I wa s goin g t o cal l yo u i f the yweren' t i n today' s FedEx . Whe n d o yo u wan t t o tal k abou t th e possibilit yo f settlement ? Scot t R . Morri s FAA Enforcemen t Attorne y Northwes t Mountai n Regio n Offic e o f Regiona l Counsel , ANM-7 H 160 1 Lin d Ave . S W Renton , W A 9805 7 (425 ) 227-141 7 (ph ) (425 ) 227-100 7 (fax ) scott.morris@faa.go v "GregWinton " Response s wil l b e sen t toda yThanks , Gre g Gr.. . 11/15/201 0 08:55:2 5 A M From : "Gre g Winton " <greg@aviationlawexperts.com > To : Scott Morris/ANM/F/\A@F/^ A Date : 11/15/201 0 08:5 5 A M Subject : RE : Sceni c Aviatio n - CP09NMQ01 1 - Respons e t o m ydiscover

yrequests Response s wil l b e sen t today . Thanks , Gre g Gregor yS . Winton , Esq . Th e Aviatio n La w Fir m 3 3 0 Aviatio n Wa y 2n d Floo r Frederick , M D 2170 1 mailto:GregOAviationLawExperts.co m Tol l free : 1-877-4-AI R LA W Local : (301 ) 294-855 0 Cell : (301 ) 529-566 0 Fax : (301 ) 294-252 5 Origina l Messag e From : Scott.Morris@faa.go v [mailto:Scott.Morris@faa.gov ] Sent : Monday , Novembe r 01 , 201 0 11:0 9 A M To : Gregor yWinto n Subject : Re : Sceni c Aviatio n - CP09NM001 1 - Respons e t o m ydiscover y request s Importance : Hig h Greg : Pe r you r reques t her e i s anothe r cop yo f thi s discover yrequest . Wit h ou r hearin g dat e rapidl yapproachin g I nee d a respons e a s quickl ya s possible . Scot t (Se e attache d file : Sceni c - ou r 2 d supp l dis c req.pdf )Scot t R . Morri s

FA AEnforcemen t Attorne y Northwes t Mountai n Regio n Offic e o f Regiona l Coimsel , ANM-7 H 160 1 Lin d Ave . S W Renton , W A9805 7 (425 ) 227-141 7 (ph ) (425 ) 227-100 7 (fax ) scott.morris@faa.go v

From : Gregor yWinto n <greg@aviationlawexperts.com >

To : Scot t Morris/ANM/FAA@FA A

Date : 10/29/201 0 11:1 8 A M Subject : Re : Sceni c Aviatio n - CP09NM001 1 - Respons e t o m ydiscover y request s

I' mtakin g deposition s i n Munic h thi s week . Pleas e emai l you r discover y request an d I'l l ge t yo u a response . Thanks , Greg . Sen t fro mmyiPhon e Gregor yS . Winton , Esq . Th e Aviatio n La w Fir m On e Researc h Cour t Suit e 45 0 Rockville , M D 2085 0 Tel : 1-877-4-AIR-LA W Cell : 301-529-566 0 Fax : 301-294-252 5 www.AviationLawExperts.co m

O n Oc t 28 , 2010 , a t 11:2 2 PM , Scott.Morris@faa.go v wrote : > Greg : You r response s t o m ymost recent discover yrequest s wer e du e Octobe r > 25th . Pleas e advis e m e about th e statu s o f you r respons e t o them . > > Scot t 

# r' ^> Scot t R . Morri s

> FA AEnforcemen t Attorne y > Northwes t Mountai n Regio n > Offic e o f Regiona l Counsel , ANM-7 H > 160 1 Lind Ave . S W > Renton , WA9805 7 > (425 ) 227-141 7 (ph ) > (425 ) 227-100 7 (fax ) > scott.morris@faa.go v



# r- aPag e 1 o f 6 RE : Sceni c Aviatio n - CP09NM001 1 - Settlemen t Agreemen t Scott Morri s ANM-007 , Offic e o f

Regiona l Counse l to : gre g 12/01/201 0 12:5 8 P M Sho w Detail s

addition , I nee d tha t discover y tha t i s nov / a mont h overdu e immediatel ys o I ca n prepare . Sinc e w e hav e no t bee n abl e t o resolv e this , I nee d thi s discover y i n han d b y Frida y o rI wil l b e force d t o fil e a motio n t o compe l wit h a motio n fo rshortene d tim e o f response . Scot t Scot t R . Morri s F/\ A Enforcemen t Attorne y Northwes t Mountai n Regio n Offic e o f Regiona l Counsel , ANM-7 H 160 1 Lin d Ave . S

W Renton , W

A 9805 7 (425 ) 227-141 7 (ph ) (425 ) 227-100 7 (fax ) scott.morris@faa.go v "Gre g Winton " wrote ; To : Scot t Morris/ANM/FA A From : "Gre g Winton " <greg(§)aviationlawexperts.com > Date : 12/01/201 0 10;29A M Subject : RE : Sceni c Aviatio n - CP09NM001 1 - Settlemen t Agreemen t Scott : Sorr yfo rth e delay . Attache d please fin d m y client' s respons e t o th e FAA's settlemen t offer . Regards , Gre g Gregoi y S . Winton , Esq . Th e Aviatio n La w Fir m 33 0 Aviatio n Wa y 2n dFloo r Frederick , M D 2170 1 mailto : GTeg(2)AviationLawExperts . co m

f- 1 . . //r^.\T ^ .~ A o»*+;„„c.\c,.r,tt\/rrirr^c\ T Ara l Sp.ttinPR\Temr)\notesC7A056\~web25. . 12/3/201 0RE : Sceni c Aviatio n - CP09NM001 1 - Propose d Settlemen t Greg Winto n to : Scot

t Morri s 12/01/201 0 11:3 1 A M History : Thi s messag e ha s bee n fonArarded . Scott : I a mno t sur e whethe r I provide d th e attache d photograph s t o yo u previously . I f w e canno t settl e th e case , I intend t o introduc e thes e photo s o f th e High Reliabilit yStyl e Connector s int o evidence .

Regards , Gre g Gregor yS . Winton , Esq . Th e Aviatio n La w Fir m 3 3 0 Aviatio n Way 2n d Floo r Frederick , M D 2170 1 mailto:Greg@AviationLawExperts.co m Tol l free : l-e77-4-AI R LA W Local : (301 ) 294-855 0 Cell : (301 ) 529-566 0 Fax : (301 ) 294-252 5



# T l