FI L ED U.S. COURT OF APPEAL S EL EVENTHCI RCUI T OCTOB ER 18, 2011 J OHN L EY CL ERK [DO NOT PUBLISH] IN THE U

NITED STATE S COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE ELE VENTH CIRCUIT

__ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ No. 1 1- 10 70 4 Non -Arg um en t Ca le nd ar

__ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ D.C. Dock etNo. 1 :0 9- cv -0 09 65 -RWS JAC K GALARDI, RED EYED INC., d.b .a. Craz y

Hors e Sal oo n, WALLEYE , LLC, MIA LUNA, INC., d.b .a. Pin k P on y

So ut h, JG & P , LLC, ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll Pl ai nt iff s - Ap pe ll an ts , vers us CITY OF FOREST PARK, CORINE DEYTON, JOHN PARKER, CHIEF DWAYNE HOBBS, DEBORAH YOUMANS, et al ., ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll Defen da nt s - Ap pe ll ees , KAREN W ILLIAMS, etal., ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll ll Defen da nt s.__ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ App eal fro m

th e Uni te d S ta te s Di st ric t Co urt forth e North ernDis tri ctof Ge or gi a

__ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ __ (Oct ob er 1 8, 2 01 1) Befo re EDMONDSON, W ILSON an d KRAVITC H, Circ ui t J ud ge s. PER CURI AM: App el la nt s o wne d a ndop erat edtwo form er adul t en te rta in m en t es tabl is hm en ts inth e Ci ty of Fo res t Pa rk(“ th e Ci ty”). Both b us in es se s o pe rat edas adul t caba ret s o r nu de da nc e cl ub s t ha t s erv edalc oh ol . App el la nt s ap pe al th e di st ric t co urt’s o rd er d en y in g t he m a te m po rary restrai ni ng ord er an d p rel im in ary in jun ct io n t ha t wo ul d h av e p rev en te d t he Cit y fro m en fo rci ng it s adul t en te rta in m en t o rd in an ce ag ai ns t ei th er cl ub . For the fol lo win g re as on s, we fi nd th atApp el la nt s l ackst an di ng to bri ng th is ap pe al , andacco rd in gl y , we di sm is s. App el la nt s s ue d t he Cit y

inApri l 2 00 9, ch al le ng in g t he Cit y ’s 20 09 adul t en te rta in m en t o rd in an ce as un co ns ti tu ti on al . In M arch 20 10 , th e Ci ty ext en si ve ly ch an ge d i ts adul t en te rta in m en t o rd in an ce an d Ap pe ll an ts fil edanam en de d co m pl ai ntinOcto be r 20 10 ch al le ng in g t he rev is edord in an ce (“ th e Ord in an ce”) . InNov em

be r 20 10 , App el la nt s fi le d am ot io n fo r a t em po rary restrai ni ng ord er an d p rel im in ary in

jun ct io n, s eek in g t o e njo in th e Ci ty from ap pl y in g the 2Ord in an ce t o t he ir c lubs . In the m ean ti m e, on Decem be r 22 , 20 10 , th e Ci ty refu se d t o re ne w th e App el lant s’ adu lten te rta in m en t l ic en se s fo r 20 11 be cau se th e two clubs were n otinco nf orm an ce wi th a se ct io n o f th e Ord in an ce tha t p ro hi bi ts adul t en te rta in m en t es tabl is hm en ts fro m ha vi ng pri va te bo oths an d ro om s. On Ja nu ary 13 , 20 11 , th e d is tri ctco urt d en ie d Ap pe ll an ts ’ m ot io n, re as on in g t ha t App el la nt s wer e unl ik el y to pre va il on th e m eri ts . The Cit y ha s fi le d am ot io n t o d is m is s Ap pe ll an ts ’ ap pe al , ass ert in g t ha t 1 App el la nt s’ bu il di ng s s ti ll do no t co nf orm to th e requi rem en ts of t he Ordi nanc e, an d t ha t Ap pe ll an ts have ne ve r ch al le ng edth e Ord in an ce’s p ro hi bi ti on on pri va te bo ot hs an d ro om s. Thus , th e Ci ty argu es th atbe cau se App el la nt s n o l on ge r ha ve th e ri gh t t o e ng ag e in adul t en te rta in m en t— fo r rea so ns in de pe nd en t o f th os e ch al le ng edon ap pe al —the y ha ve no st an di ng to pro ceed . W e ag ree. St an di ng is a th res ho ldjuri sd ic ti on al qu es ti on th atwe m us t ad dr es s b efo re an al y zi ng th e m eri ts of a n app el la nt ’s con st itut io na l cl ai m s. CAMP Legal Defe ns e Fun d, In c. v. Ci tyof

Atlan ta , 45 1 F .3d12 57 , 12 69 (11 thCir . 20 06 ). To es tabl is h st an di ng , App el la nt s b ear t he bu rd enof s ho win g: “ ‘(1) anin jury in fa ct , m ean in g anin jury thatis co nc ret e an d p art ic ul ari zed , andactua l o r imm in en t, (2 ) a cau sa l co nn ect io n b etweenth e in jury andth e cau sa l co nduc t, an d (3 ) a l ik el ih oo d t ha t the On May 24, 2011, Appellee s filed a similar motion to dism iss beforethe district court. 1 3in

jury w il l b e redres se d b y a fav or ab le de ci si on .’ ” Id
. (qu ot in g Gra ni te Stat e Outdo or Adve r., In c. v. Ci tyof

Cle arwa te r , 35 1 F .3d11 12 , 11 16 (11 th Cir . 20 03 )). Ass um in g t ha t Ap pe ll an ts ha ve sh ownth atth e Ci ty’ s en act m en t o f th e Ord in an ce caus edth em

anin jury in fa ct , th ey

can no t es tabl is h re dr es sabi li ty. To do so , App el la nt s m

us t s ho w th atitis “ li ke ly, as op po se d t o m erel y sp ecu la ti ve , th atth e in jury w il l b e redres se d b y a fav or ab le de ci si on .” Lu ja n v . Defen de rs of W ildl if e , 50 4 U.S. 5 55 , 56 1 (1 99 2) (in te rn al qu ot at io n m ark s o m it te d) . Here, ev en if we were t o re ve rs e th e d is tri ctco urt’s o rd er, the App el la nt s wo ul d s ti ll be un ab le to en ga ge inadul t en te rta in m en t. The App el la nt s wer e d en ie d a du lten te rta in m en t li cen se s b as edup on a pr ov is io n i n t he Ordi na nc e th atth ey have no t ch al le ng ed

—the pro hi bi ti on on pri va te bo ot hs an d ro om s. A fav or ab le de ci si on can no t re dr es s Ap pe ll an ts ’ al le ge d i nju ry be cau se th e Ord in an ce re qu ire d t he Cit y to rejectApp el la nt s’ li cen se ap pl ic at io ns an d Ap pe ll an ts ha ve no t ch al le ng edth e pr ov is io n o f th e Ord in an ce tha t m an da te d t ha t re jecti on . Se e, e.g . , Mav er ic k Media Grp ., Inc . v. Hil ls bo ro ugh C nt y. , 52 8 F .3d81 7, 8 21 (11 th Cir . 20 08 ) (p er cu ria m) (ex pl ai ni ng be cau se “ th e Co un ty cou ldhave de ni ed[pl ai nt iff’s si gn pe rm it ] ap pl ic at io ns un de r analt ern at iv e, un ch al le ng edpro vi si on of i ts si gn or di na nc e,” p la in ti ff’s al le ge d i nju ry was n otredres sabl e b y

a fav or ab le de ci si on ); KH Outdo or

, L.L.C. v. ClayCn ty . , 48 2 F .3d12 99 , 13 03 –0 4 (1 1t h C ir. 2 00 7) 4(h ol di ng th ata pl ai nt iff di d n otha ve a redres sabl e in jury whe re i ts si gn pe rm it ap pl ic at io ns were d en ie d o n the ba si s o f on e p ro vi si on ina co un ty’ s s ig n or di na nc e b utco ul d h av e b een de ni edon th e b as is of s om e al te rn at e, bu t un ch al le ng ed , reg ul at io n) . Mo reo ve r, on Decem

be r 20 , 20 10 , th e p art ie s re ach edanag reem en t whe reb y th e Ci ty w ou ldst ay

th e en fo rcem en t o f certa in pro vi si on s o f th e Ord in an ce, n otin cl ud in g the ban o n p riv at e b oo th s an d ro om s. Inex ch an ge , App el la nt s s ti pu la te d t ha t the y wou ldno t s eekda m ag es in cu rreddu rin g a ny peri od pr eced in g t he ex ecu ti on of t he st ip ul at io n a s a r es ul t o f th e Ci ty’ s ad op ti on or en fo rcem en t o f th e Ord in an ce. Thi s fu rth er s tre ng th en s o urco nc lu si on th at 2 App el la nt s’ all eg edin

jury w ou ldno t b e redres se d b y a fav or ab le de ci si on by the di st ric t co urt—ne it he r in

jun ct iv e n orm on et ary rel ie f wou ldredres s Ap pe ll an ts ’ al le ge d i nju ry . AndApp el la nt s ca n n otin vo ke th e o ve rb read th do ctrin e in an at te m ptto ge t ar ou ndth is li m it at io n. CAMP , 45 1 F .3dat 1 27 0– 71 (ex pl ai ni ng th at th e o ve rb read th do ctrin e is anex cep ti on on ly to the pru de nt ia l s ta nd in g requi rem en t tha t a p la in ti ff m us t as se rt h is ownleg al rig ht s an d i nt eres ts , rathe r th anpu rs ui ng cla im s b as edonth e le ga l ri gh ts or i nt eres ts of o th ers ). Appellants also stipulated that they would not seek damag es for any acts oc curring 2 betwee n the execution of the stipulation agree ment and any time up throug h and including J anuar y 12, 2011. 5Acco rd in gl y , we gra ntth e Ci ty’ s m ot io n t o d is m is s, an d we v acat e an d

rem an d wi thin st ru ct io ns to di sm is s b ecau se App el la nt s l ackst an di ng to ch al le ng e th e Ord in an ce. VACATED an d REMANDED WI TH I NSTRUCTI ONS TO DISMI SS.

6