5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//

3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUF

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )

)LOH 1DPH D

	


	




%8/, %'85$+0$1

	




	





,&.< (// 


	




	



$$%&'()
*(	(

&().*%+*(*,(&

!001 023'

5-63-7

+,**%6	$

&6	
99+

3-5






	  :  	';:9
.
)/*%%&$$%%
	9+=>+
8 	  !"! #!"!

3HWLWLRQHU ZDV RULJLQDOO\ QDPHG -DPHV /HH -RQHV EXW KH FKDQJHG

KLV QDPH WR $EX$OL $EGXU¶5DKPDQ

*%%*' ? *,@ 3 )*( @  &$$%%
:	'*();:9
.
93
	
+
<
	
)/*%%&$$%%(%7.,9
	9+=>+;)/*%%*%%*'?*,@3)*(@*>A* 9 = 99 )/*%%  &$$%%

	
9 3 %*/ () $** & () ,-(

9+ 3 B$$ 1CCD %*/  $(,,-*5 $**  9 3 B$$ C8"0D %*/ $($**,,-*5*$(*(*5*$(







	
9*,-*(3-5$(*,@7%%

BE	((FD$$%()*-,&G*(&)4,$-(?(*(*4-%*4-)'BE?(*(*FD/,(*5

?(*(*(,&()&&*(5'-()5-&*&&,(*/*(,&,-%(()(,*5$) & ?(*(* (*%  *(*%%7 ?(*(* ,$$%()*%&)*$(*(*&G*(&)4,$-@*5 %*& &' )* ,/*,(* & &*(5 '- / () *(*,( ,-( &**5 ()( ?(*(* G$H-*,47)*(*%,-%&*,*($&',(()(,*5(5/,(()$(*&()*(*,(,-(H-5'(5(*5()$(*(*&G*(&)4,$-(()()(,*(*%%7G&&*'()$(*&()*(*,(,-(H-5'(7*5()$(*(*&G*(&)4,$-((),/*,(*
"0 	  !"! #!"!

 ,-% I-(%7 $&' () H-7 G*5)*5

G)()()(,G$$$*($-*)'(&4-)'G-%)/)$((*/$*,(-&()$()7G(,*5*(&()*,,-(-$ G)*,)()74()*,**9*@()$(*(*,(%74&()	-$'-(4-)')E,(*(-(*%%7$(,(*5)(($/*()H-7G*()()'*(*5(*5 /*, ()( )* (*% ,-% *() &*% (*,/ &*%(&&F80	(("1

:*/ () ((% %,@ & '*(*5(*5 /*, $( (4-)'(,*5)*5E,-%,-,(-'*()$$&-,(**5&()/*%$,()(()J(,*5)*5K,(4%*)/*5$-,H-(-%(FC!!
	(! !L

	8!1( C L !M180C80

B!()*!D
$,(&-%%7*(

 !"! #!"! 	

	


?(*(*G(*,/*,(

-%(G*()*(((,''*('-,*/()()$%(7&()',,-(*/%*&('&(),)) () (, G *'$&**5&()55/(*5,*,-'G $/*-%7 ,/*,( & ((-(7%'(*/%/()-B8D()'-G$,*%%7)*()(*(*/%/((-*-$,7 ( $-, ()L ,''*((G)*%()&(GG,,'$%*,*(),''*(,''*(G&%*5&(,,''*( 7 &*(5 '-4-5%7()&(@*$*5?(*-(&&&()(,,-*

4-7! !?(*(*

& '*H- &' ?(*,@ +*+*%%*/*)/*%%+/%%.*%%%(5(4?(*(*((()-$%N--5$-,)(G)*,)$*(.*%%() -$%N  E4F 4() +*)(5-()(?(*(*)-$$%N,-()G/ .*%%4,()-5)G*()*(?(*(*()&4+*%()*(*'-*5@*&*

4-7M !?(*(*

.*%%'G*()-%-()$(N(&'@*5-5.*%%*$%7()* &*' 5*%&*''(()&%+*%'G*()-,(($7  '-()  &( (%*
C 	  !"! #!"!

?(*(*&,+*%(/%)*?
-'4?(*(*%,)())-&-''*H-*'&,-)*

?(*(* () (% +*% ()( ) ) 4 ( &'

)*,5(E,%-$/7()*5F()()G()((,)+*%%?(*(*4(*4-(,)@*&&'()@*(,)(44+*%*N(*'*(),)($((*5 )* )( &- (*'  ?* (  -*5 ()(44*5+*%G,7*5455*5?(*(*(()-( 7 &( +*%4,''(*% ?(*(*(44'*()4,@/%(*'4-(.*%%$-%%?(*(*G7()(G'&%%/*5()@*&*'4,@+*%*()-%(&)*G-4-('-/*/?(*(*.*%%%(@O100&'4N*'4'

((*%?(*(*5-()(()%'(*/(*&()

,*'G4-(&()*&%-,&)*''4)*$*EI-*%*5*-$'*%*(75-$F,%%()	-()(:$%.**(7BE	:.FD?(*(*)%5,*'*%)*(7*,%-*5,/*,(*&,5'-*M8,/*,(*&-%(G*()5-G$B@*&D*M0%%G*5)**,,(*&()&&)'/()%&G7)-*)/*%%)*%%*/*5(())%&G7)-)G@&5*A(*,%%()$(*(?-4%*)*5/(-%%7'(%%7&()G7,*(*%%*'7G()%&()	:.L.*%%G%''4&()	:.&()%%55%&()	:.G(,%()4%,@,''-*(7&-5%()-*4%%'(7%%5%7&-*)())(5---*5()&&*(?(*(*.*%%&(()&&*,%-*55*/*5.*%%''7(&%

?(*(*G**(*%%7$(47%.,%$*G)

G @ 47 7 ( (@  () $((*  7%%5%7 **,( ( .,%$* ()( ) G-% 4 $7*5?(*(*((7&G/.,%$*-4I-(%7

 !"! #!"! 	& ,-% ()(  $7,)*()-4

+$*()*,)*%)4-

)*(74-)'G4%,*(%'(55*$&'&*,P4-(G)')*&G)',-%&*%(,(,(%@G)*'* 14-)',%%5/%-(G*()Q-)-*5$H,(	)((()((5(%$G)*,%7)

)*% ,@G%5*5()( '

)/4'*(*5(*5()'H*(7((,-(&$$%()(()/*&*%(*/(*5($( %/*%( ,-,(  (*,*% ,)*(('(&()/*,47('$)*47(),-(()(/*,()$&,*5()(,5((N(($*4%(*-47()H-7"#"0 B 8D  -() () 'H*(%7)'-,)&()*/*,,-,( 4& *(  ()( () $%/( /*, ( (,*5 G4-)'(*(*%(()'*(*5(*5%'(&()*/*(($(()H-7 G*() $*,(-&()$()7G&  ,$*(% (,*5 )*5  *5()'*(*5(*5$((*%&/*,()&,(()('&&*%(*/(*5($()'&-%4)/*474-)'80 	(C""C B8000D B-&/4%,*(H-(*&(),'$(*/%7/%-'*-'$@*J$(*(*K&/FD
C 	  !"! #!"!

7KH IDFW WKDW $EGXU¶5DKPDQ ZDV IRXQG FRPSHWHQW WR VWDQG WULDO

GRHV QRW RI FRXUVH DOWHU WKH IDFW WKDW KLV PHQWDO KHDOWK SUREOHPV VKRXOGEH FRQVLGHUHG E\ WKH MXU\ DW VHQWHQFLQJ 6HH %ODQR Y 6LQJOHWDU\  )G

  WK &LU 

(*,*%$%*(7F4-)'$*,%**,(()(4-)'G&I-(%7)/*%7'*,(-*5(%('&)*(*'*$*()()4()*)5*(()G%%G)*%*$*,&' () G 37 +$('( & -' 	/*,,-'( )* !M (7 G)*%  7-() ( () (?7,)*(*, $*(% G) ) G *5 G*() ,*$()*, $%*(7 *(-4,  (*,*% ,(*G*() $*  , &' () +/* -(7	)*&&+$('()G()(4-)'4()*)5*(  G%% &( )* ( ()  -() () ,**,(()(()*4-)'&'*%7)'(%)%()$4%'.7&() ,G /*%4%(&,-%()-5)()..
$($$&()$-$&('**54-)','$(,(((*%L)G/,-%&*%(*/(*5($(7&()* '*(*5(*5 *&'(* ( () H-7   * ,-%$((()H-7 '(%)%() N$(G) ,-%)/((*&*5*54-)''(%)%()$4%'

-() ((*'7 &' () (*% & 4-)'

,/*,(* & ,5 '- & () @*%%*5 & &%%G *'( R  ,/*,(* ()( -$$(  & ()55/(*5,*,-'(,R**,(*()$**&N$( ()( 4-)' )  4%* $%*(7*,)*A*$%*(7)*/*,,-%)/4'*(*5(*5G*()$,((()$(*(*'(%)%()G%%G*()$,((()$*'-

4-)'G*&,-%)/)$%4/(*

4-()*'(%)%()*,%-*5()&,(()())-4),/(*G*()$$%G)*(N*(45)*)5*(()G%%4%*/()((),-$%G-%5*/4*() ( () N( .*)  	) % (( ()( ) (%

 !"! #!"! 	

('*()(7G''74*5()-,&)*&*/%/*(),*'.,%$*&N*( G*()*()()*$(7 &,-% ( ,(*- () $,*( & 7 () I-$(?(*(*((5&O"000O"000& G)*,) G()-5) ) / *I-*  ( ((  () ((7 	-?(*(*((*%

?(*(*%%5()(()* $

()-5)-(()(*%*,%-*54(,*5$)((((*&*()&*(O"000&()(*)$&'7G@(),-(*%()(*&4%,()(G,%*'()((($&'&*% $(*% '(*  ?(*(*$&',,-%G*&&*/(*5(LB8D$($((*%%7B1D$('*(*5(*5/*,(

* ,/*,(*  (,

	-$'-(*BDC 
	0 ,/*,(* %*&*() (((*%)*5'&**5*&&*'*&0

9 M"C8M B *' $$ 	-$'-(*	-$'-(*$(*(* &!"!
	8&*%()*$(*(*&G*(&)4)*,/*,(*(,&($(*%-''7H-5'(G /*(*7 )*5( $(*(*)*(*,(,-(5(,%*'&*&&,(*/*(,&
! 	  !"! #!"!

 86&  G UHSHDOHG LQ HIIHFW ZKHQ WKH LQVWDQW SHWLWLRQ

ZDV ILOHG VWDWHV

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

 WKDW WKH PHULWV RI WKH IDFWXDO GLVSXWH ZHUH QRW UHVROYHG

LQ WKH 6WDWH FRXUW KHDULQJ

 WKDW WKH IDFWILQGLQJ SURFHGXUH HPSOR\HG E\ WKH 6WDWH

FRXUW ZDV QRW DGHTXDWH WR DIIRUG D IXOO DQG IDLU KHDULQJ

 WKDW WKH PDWHULDO IDFWV ZHUH QRW DGHTXDWHO\ GHYHORSHG DWWKH 6WDWH FRXUW KHDULQJ WKDW WKH 6WDWH FRXUW ODFNHG MXULVGLFWLRQ RI WKH VXEMHFW

PDWWHU RU RYHU WKH SHUVRQ RI WKH DSSOLFDQW LQ WKH 6WDWH FRXUWSURFHHGLQJ

(5-(,-%&*%-($('*(*5(*5/*,$*(*( /*%4*%*(7 G/()*(*,( ,-(*?(*(*,%*'&*&&,(*/*(,&,-%(()5-*%((5)%*5()(%()-5)()$&',&(( '$ G &*,*( ?(*(* -&&  $H-*,()47	   	-$$0M1 B.+

 D)**$$%&'()(,**




		 
 !"#$% 

  &'&%(% &')*
&%"&

+

,%"$ &&'
&%%+#%-.
/--01

) 	(( 5- ()( () *(*,( ,-( *'$$%7

*$G*()()$-'$(*&,,(()(*(4,, ( (( ,-( &**5 & &,( - 8  
	S88"CBDG*()-($/**5(('(&*(&

 !"! #!"! 	

*/(5 4,@5-  ($4%''74%,-%$4%()-,)N,-F
'(B 3 ,,-*5D  )&(),*((%74$4(*/ *&'(* ( G)*,) '@*5%*&(),**1 "  B!() * 8000D B&**$H-*, 47 ,-% &*%- ('*(*5(*5/*,((,*5DL

10180C1B()*"D()*5 ( (,*5 5*5 )%())*(7


 () , 4& - G )

	'-%,@G)G$(4-)' &() (( & ,'$(,7 ( ( (*%   G*()-(@G%5&)*)*(7((*&* ()( )A*  ?$,*4&4-)'*$$7,)(*,'*,(*G)*,)*G '(%%7 *%%  ()( () 4-)'G%*@()&$%*(7 *  + +* *54-)'G*()$$*4%4%*$	&&&&*'*%*5*


,%-*(),4&()

,*%/*, $( &'()(()( 4-)' )  E$E$%*(7$((*LF ?)G)*,)*,%-I-(&$7,),*,%-*5$7,)*(*,N'()( 4-)'  ( )$7,)* 4-(  )/  )*((('$('G)*,)**,(*5 G*() () *$7,)$()*,$%*(7E$7
C! 	  !"! #!"!

0V /DQFDVWHU WHVWLILHG WKDW VKH DQG WKH 3HWLWLRQHU VKDUH D

FRPPRQ PRWKHU ZKR DEDQGRQHG 0V /DQFDVWHU DQG KHU WZREURWKHUV ZKHQ VKH ZDV DQ LQIDQW 3HWLWLRQHU¶V PRWKHU SXW KHUWKUHH FKLOGUHQ LQ D WD[L GURYH WKHP WR WKH ZRRGV DQG OHIW WKHP3HWLWLRQHU¶V PRWKHU ODWHUPDUULHG 3HWLWLRQHU
V IDWKHU -DPHV -RQHV6U 7KUHH PRUH FKLOGUHQ ZHUH ERUQ RI WKDW PDUULDJH  -DPHV3HWLWLRQHU 0DUN DQG 6\OYLD

3HWLWLRQHU¶V VWDWHPHQWV WR PHQWDO KHDOWK SURYLGHUV >RYHU WKH

FRXUVH RI KLV OLIH@ SURYLGH D YLYLG GHVFULSWLRQ RI WKH DEXVH3HWLWLRQHU VXIIHUHG DW WKH KDQGV RI KLV IDWKHU 3HWLWLRQHU UHFHLYHGUHJXODU EHDWLQJV ZLWK D OHDWKHU VWUDS IURP KLV IDWKHU 3HWLWLRQHU¶VIDWKHU PDGH KLP WDNH RII KLV FORWKHV SODFHG KLP KRJWLHG LQ DORFNHG FORVHW DQG WHWKHUHG KLP WR D KRRN ZLWK D SLHFH RI OHDWKHUWLHG DURXQG WKH KHDG RI KLV SHQLV 3HWLWLRQHU¶V IDWKHU VWUXFN

3HWLWLRQHU¶V SHQLV ZLWK D EDVHEDOO EDW 7R SXQLVK KLP IRUVPRNLQJ 3HWLWLRQHU¶V IDWKHU UHTXLUHG KLP WR HDW D SDFN RIFLJDUHWWHV DQG ZKHQ KH YRPLWHG ZDV PDGH WR HDW WKH YRPLW1RQH RI WKLV H[WUDRUGLQDU\ DEXVH ZKLFK FRQVWLWXWHV UHOHYDQWPLWLJDWLQJ HYLGHQFH ZDV KHDUG E\ WKH MXU\

$EGXU
5DKPDQ Y %HOO  ) 6XSS   0' 7HQQ 

IRRWQRWH DQG FLWDWLRQV WR UHFRUG RPLWWHG

3HWLWLRQHU¶V EURWKHU VXEVHTXHQWO\ FRPPLWWHG VXLFLGH

()*(*,(,-(((()(4-)'E**5-%%7()G(,&4-
)/,',*8"74*5,'*,$7,)%5*( 
,(/*'7''7''47()*5()('(%7,',%('&()()*5
F

)*4-G((((47()$(*(*()$(*(*

)%&*( G) G ( ,(,( 47 ,-% 4-( G/*%4%(((*&7()$(*(*4().@3G)%*@G*G(,(,(47,-%4-(((*&&*/*(()()G-%)/4G*%%*5(((*&7((*%)*4-G)*%(H-(*&*,(*&$(*(*,*'*%,-,( * %/( '*(*5(*5 /*, ()( )-% )/4$((()H-7

4-)' )  $*(( )*(7 & $7,)*(*,

*'(%)%()$4%'E&(JKG),''*(JK ,*'*% ,( ()(  ((*4-(4% ( 

 !"! #!"! 	

 WKDW WKH DSSOLFDQW ZDV DQ LQG

GHSULYDWLRQ RI KLV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ULJKWR UHSUHVHQW KLP LQ WKH 6WDWH FRXUW SU

 WKDW WKH DSSOLFDQW GLG QRW 

DGHTXDWH KHDULQJ LQ WKH 6WDWH FRXUW S

 WKDW WKH DSSOLFDQW ZDV RWKHUZ

ODZ LQ WKH 6WDWH FRXUW SURFHHGLQJ

 RU XQOHVV WKDW SDUW RI WKH 

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

UHVW XSRQ WKH DSSOLFDQW WR HVWDEOLVK EWKH IDFWXDO GHWHUPLQDWLRQ E\ WKH 6WDW

*5I-*47**C1"M$ ()( ,%*' & *&&,(**/%/'*NI-(*&%G() $-'$(* & ,,("C!!
	!! B CD

)$(,/*,(*(*%,-(

,-% ) &*% ( I-(%4,@5-'(%)*(7'&**5*()$,6

(*'7&*%&(*%,G*( G */(*5( $(*(*T4,@5-'
 	  !"! #!"!

8(*'7&*%&(*%,-%)G()(()7&*% ( */(*5(  4(* /*%4% *&'(*,,*5$(*(*T$*$7,)%5*,%,-%((*(58(CG)*%((	)&(G**1(*'7&*%&(*%,-%)G()(()7&*% ( */(*5(  4(* *%7 /*%4%*&'(* ,,*5 $(*(*T $7,)%5*,%'( ( 5 C 47 () ,)% $7,)%5*( (+-$(3*5)	,)%((9G*)*5(C(*'7&*%&(*%,-%)G()(()7&*% ( */(*5(  4(* /*%4% *&'(*,,*5$(*(*TH-/*%*,,(*&4*5$7,)$()*, %*I-( ( ( 	(( $*(% *,')*5(

 "(*'7&*%&(*%,-%)G()(()7

&*% ( */(*5(  4(* /*%4% *&'(*,,*5 () $(*(*T ,)% , *?)*%%$)*G).78C!"()GI-(&$7,)%5*,%/*,47	7*5)	,)%!(*'7&*%&(*%,-%)G()(()7&*% ( */(*5(  4(* /*%4% *&'(*,,*5$(*(*T ,)% ,* ?)*%%$)*G)3-M)G&&	$,*%-,(*

 M(*'7&*%&(*%,-%)G()(()7

&*% ( */(*5(  4(* /*%4% *&'(*,,*5 $(*(*T *,,(* ( () %
(*(-( & 7 G 37 G) ) G " )*4*5$%,$7,)*(*,G(,)*3-7&!M)*&%($7,)%5*,%N'*(*(()G37	((J?7,)*(*,K)$*(%((*4-7&!M (*'7&*%&(*%,-%)G()(()7&*% ( */(*5(  4(* /*%4% *&'(*,,*5$(*(*T'7,(5M G*()((*5*5)*UI-(*4%'(%((-U4*A 4)/*  $7,)*(*, $( %*5-%(*'(%7(*,)5(*'7&*%&(*%,-%)G()(()7&*% ( */(*5(  4(* /*%4% *&'(*,,*5 $(*(*T $7,)*(*, N'*(* ( 	(

 !"! #!"! 	

$V WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW VWDWHG

'XULQJ WKH KHDULQJ LQ WKLV 

3HWLWLRQHU¶V KDOIVLVWHU WHVWLILHG DERX3HWLWLRQHU H[SHULHQFHG GXULQJ KLV FKLWKH LQIRUPDWLRQ 0V /DQFDVWHU UHODWHPDGH E\ RWKHU IDPLO\ PHPEHUV WKH ZLWK 0V /DQFDVWHU¶V FUHGLELOLW\ DQG 

7$,(&&(,),(,*,-'(,&()&&()((4*&(,%()()
	1081MB DBI-(*5+!0CBM DB'$)***5*%DD

%()-5) () H-7 &- ()

(,*5*()()*5(G*5*(*--$**5()(,'$*5(()&'*(*5(*5/*,()(()(,4-)'''(I-*H-7(,() ,*'  () &( 4-*5()(,*5$)&,8! 1 C1 C  B!() * ,*'*(*5(*5/*,E*@()()(,F*,%-

CC8B0DBI-(*5#"$

VB3,,-*5DD 
4@G( ( () H-7 (&( '*(*5(*5 /*, N*($((* ( )* (,*5 )$&'I-(%7()H-7,4-)'))*(7&(()( ) )  %5 )*(7 & '(('(&*%%7()(4-4$-,(*/''4&,*

)4--&&,)*%47

())&)*&()'*%*(7),@*5+7'*
CC 	  !"! #!"!

) 'H*(7 -55( ()( ' G*() ()* /*,

& ,-% ,-% )/ '  %5*(*'( (,(*,%,** (( $(() /*, G)*,) * G*(),4-(G($((()H-7()(G)-%& ( ()* ,**  
&(-(%7 & ,-%E(,(*,% ,**F * ()* , G ( ( $$ & (),$*(% (,*5)*5&()*,%*(EJK-,%GH,(()(*()(W((5*,,**,44%G)()((7) &*%(*/(*5()*$(*'@4%,)*,4(G()'F).

C8CCC!8B()*D

-()  ' *'$((%7 
 *5 G*() ()

'H*(7&**5()(4-)'G($H-*,47,-%&*%-'(($H-*,4-)'E'-()G()(()*4%$44*%*(7()(4-(&,-%-$&*%()-%(&()$,*5G-% )/ 4 *&&(   4% $44*%*(7 * $44*%*(7 -&&*,*( ( -'* ,&*, * ()-(,'FC!!
	(!C()G()(,-%$&','%*@%7()(&&,(()-(,'&(),(!1C
(EJGK)

&(,)%%5() (,()I-(**G)() () *  4% $44*%*(7 ()( 4( ()() (,R*,%-*5  $$%%( ,-((()N((*(*$(%7G*5)()/*,RG-%)/,,%- ()( () 4%, & 55/(*5  '*(*5(*5,*,-'(,*(G(()F/(!!

-% &*%- ( */(*5(  $$%7 $$ &

(,*5 -%( * () $((* & (*%%7 '*(*5(*5 /*, ( () H-7 ( () (,*5 $)+$*(,-%(**)*$*5(('(()()G-%$-(()G*(4-)')*G*&G () % G*( ( (,*5  ()* ((*'7%(((),*,-'(,&()&&&G)*,))G&-5-*%(7
(*(4-)')*(7&4-)*'(%)%()(('(()%/($,(&)*%*&)** $*(() &,(()(()H-7 )-%EW(4$,%-&',**5""'

 !"! #!"! 	

%*A4()T $*(%)*5(*,,(* & -%(  *,)5&'()'7$*(*&'(* G ( ( ...(%%()
(*(-(K$()0(*'7&*%&(*%,&*% ( */(*5(  4(*,,*5$(*(*T*(*(-(*&%$*7('

 (*'7&*%&(*%,

&*% ( */(*5(  4(*,,*5$(*(*T$7,)*($(*(*T M8 @*%%*5 &  *,,( & () -%( &4/

 8*%,-%)%*((%@G

(()$(*(*TM8'-,

 1 )7 &*% ( *(/*

$7,)%5*(G),-,(().&(()(*%45

	  	-$$ ( & ( () &**5 * *( )4 %*& 4-( * ( ,,(()( 5-4%7 $$%*S88"C
(,*(*5

!! ! B CD0

B!()*!D*('%7(()&G)()?(*(*,*/&&*'*NI-(*&%G &/F		-$

)*G,,-((('(

,-(()-5)(  ,'$%(%/($(*&**,

I-(* & *&&,(*/ *(,I-(*&%G&,(()&,(--%7*5-,)%7*,,,(6
0 	  !"! #!"!

	&"  +&"% ' #  &' '+ $#  +&"%&'#+ #  ''+ 2+ $%"*3+&  #'%+ %4" %$ &' / --015#6 

%()-5)*(*,(,-(&**5-4H,(((),%%7-(&%-%&*/*%?,-"8BD 4() () $&',  () $H-*,,'$( & () *&&,(*/ *I-*7  '*NI-(*&%G&,(

C!!
	(! B'$)*D)-()((

$(,/*,(*(*% ,-( &**5& &,(-%7*5*(*&&,(*/*I-*7)-%)/4$-',,(

)*$-'$(**('(74,-*(*,(,-(

'7$,%-*($$%*,(*-$()&**5&7&()%*(N,$(**8 
	S88"CBDG/*(E)4,-()-%*,%-**($**5(*5()G*(()*5G)*,)%*((,,%-()(7&()&*(/&,(G$(()*5G)*,)%*((,,%-()(()((&**5GW(&*%7-$$(47(),FCC
	(""
()

,($****()*,-(*,-()*

I-*'(

45*G*()()$$%*,(*&8 
	S88"CBD

G)*,) (4%*)  $-'$(* & ,,( &&,(-%('*(*'47()((,-(G)H-5'(  ,)%%5 47 () &% )4$(*(*)	-$'-(**)%

()( S 88"CBD '( ()( () $-'$(* &,,(4$$%*47())4,-((&**5&() (($$%%(,-(()(EW() &,(&()$(, * ( I-(%7 -$$( $( ,%*'F)-(G((%7G()-%()(U)4,-()-%*,%-**($**5(*5()G*(()*5G)*,)%*((,,%-()(7&()&*(/&,(G$(()*5G)*,)%*(( ,,%- ()( () (( &**5 G W( &*%7-$$( 47 () ,F  )  & ()*I-*'( () -( N$%* * ()( UJK ,-(

 !"! #!"! 	

, XVH $EGXU¶5DKPDQ¶V SUHVHQW QDP

KLP HYHQ LQ WKH FRQWH[W RI HYHQWV WKDW 

ZKHQ WKH SHWLWLRQHU ZHQW E\ WKH QDPH RI 

/(! M(47()'HI-(*&%G&,(/

""%11081B!()

) *(*,( ,-(  4() 

,-( ()( N'* ()* 4-)',-%$&((  ( ,)%%5 ()* ,-%&*,*,*)4,-*%%-'*(G)74-)'&'4@G*()/-%(-%*4%FC!!

-%$&',*(%

$((*(()(,*5)*I-(EJK),%*(&,(() -% ,-%4(* '*(*5(*'**'% ( I*

%M1C0 C8!

!C"1"0"8B& ,-% G 4%*5( '(%)%()/*,&(,()(*%,-((,%4-(),-(&&-&*/(*5(**$('(%)%()N$(-&4-)'$*, $( /*%4% G*(4-)'&'*%7((4-)' -'- '-,(*%'*%*(7$*4-(,5*5)%()4,@5-*(-,(,*5 )*5  
 -' ,-*/(*5(  $( 4-)*(7)**(*(-(*%)*(7
C8 	  !"! #!"!




	7	



 :
; 9 3 *,-*( 3-5 ,,-*5 * $(

*(*5*$(,-
G-%&&*'()*(*,(,-(('*(* ()( 4-)' ,-% G,(*(-(*%%7 *&&,(*/ ( (,*5  ()( () G*()-%45((()**-
$,(&-%%7*(&'()($(*&3-5	*%$**

**(*%'((
5G*()3-5	*%()(()*(*,(

,-( $$%7   /*(*7 )*5 - *(*,(* (    $$%7 ,* () /*,$((()*)*5
%(()((),,-,*/,(*&()4-54&/,)*5&%,-(( &%,( () %*(7 & &% )4 /*G   

('(5$/

28576

	78'<

200,77(( 

25.,1*

?$3(56

$1'

	8%&200,77((

(32576C 8B0DB$(*5()(*

 M    %7 X & )4 ,$- $(*(*,*/&-%%)*5(()*(*,(,-(D

4-)',-%G,(*(-(*%%7*&&,(*/

((,*5-(,-%-((&*%-(*/(*5($( /*%4% '*(*5(*5 /*,  
  ( $/*&&,(*/*(,&,-%4-)''-(&-%&*%%() &'*%* (G$5 I-*'( &  "C!!
	!! B CD

*( () &( '-( )G ()( ,-%$&',G&*,*()* I-*)G*5()(,-% '   *- ()( ,-% G (&-,(**5()E,-%F5-(()&(47()	*N()''(	,()&('-()G()(()&*,*($&',$H-*,()&)* I-* )G*5 ()( ,-%  G *-($*/()&(&&*(*%(*%G)-%(*%*4%

 !"! #!"! 	

/*G*5()5(&$$%*,)-%4%&((5-(())5(*5 %*& (G*()(*S 88"CBDF   *  &(N$%* ()( E() !! 'S88"CBDG*(47()N,*&J&%,-(KH-+ 2 -  


$(%7*,&&*'W*(*(  ( *( ()( () H-**,(*G)*,) * &*  %*'*(N,F   
( G  ()& &*$G*()()$-'$(**S88"CBD(/*$/**5G*(((('(&(*(( ,,%-()( 7&() $(()*5G)*,)%((&**5GW(&*%7-$

*C1("M"MMB,*(*(*,( ,-( ,''*(( () *$*5 G*() () $-'$(*(('(&*(&5(*5$/**&S88"CBD

%7*5 %%7 -$ () 

$-'$(* & ,,( ,/*,(* (*% ,-( &**5 5- ()( 7  & () %*( $$%*  I-* ()( () $-'$(* & ,,(  S 88"CBDB D G-% (*(% )*' ($*(*5(/*,*(),*(,*/&-%%&*)-*5$(,/*,(*$,*55-()(-(?(*(*&'(*%  $$%%( ,-( )* 4*()G*$(/*,)$$%),(4)(,%*'
8 	  !"! #!"!

&-%%&*)*5)*$*(**,,(	(
81!8!B"()*CDB(*5()(()$$(-*(7($(/*,($(G*((&-%%7 ,N'* $,-(* G*( -$$( ()&**5&&-%%&*)*5DLCC
	("C!B((*5()(EJK*,()(,-(J(($$%%(,-(KG I-( ( ('* () *- 47 $( J(),/*,('-KG(()*@)'7G4)(( ()( *( $,*5 G (  W)*5 G*()* ()'*5&S88"CBDFD)-4,-?(*(*,*/&-%%&*)*5()$-'$(*&,,($$%*


( * ,% ()( () ,-(  * ( *5 ()

$-'$(*&,,(I-*47

*G/*(*-,%(G)()()*(*,(,-()%()(()$-'$(*&,,(*($$%7)*'4*5-*(7*4,-()*(*,(,-(/*(*7 )*5  ,*/ /*, ()( G ($(*7&()((,-($,*5*(*%%7*( ,* () G /*, * *( $** $(*%%75(*5)4%*&(?(*(*7(&*%(N$%*,*(%7&*G)()()G/*,,(*,($*4%74-((()$-'$(*&,,('%7-$$%'(()$(,/*,(*(*%,-(&**5&&,(

?-'4%7)G/4,-(),-(*'$%7N,*

//*G-*('*(@*($((*&*(**$G*()()$-'$(*&,,()-()*(*,( ,-(  47 &*%*5 ( ,5*A ()( ()$-'$(*&,,($$%*(()$(,/*,(*(*%,-(&**5&&,(47&*%*5(*,%-**($**()*5G)7()$-'$(*&,,(*( $$%7  
%*@ * )G/ ()*   (

I-*  ' 4,- G )% ()( () *(*,( ,-($$%7   /*(*7 )*5  $$%7,*()/*,*()

 !"! #!"! 	((7,-%)/)G-,)',)*%)4-*-'(%*%5I-%*(*


 *5  () *(*,( ,-( 

,% *() *(*,( /*(*7)*5-(*%4-&*%-(/%$()&,(-%,**%7GG-%/,(()G*( & )4 ,$-  () )*5*C1("M

()*(*,(,-((&&4-4*5 &G /*, (4%*),%  !%% "0C 


)G/-,)*$*(**-4-)'-,(()&$%*%7 *-&&*,*( ( -'*(,B CD3-5	*%$*(-$((())4,-('%&**5'47()$(,/*,((,-(**")%(-N$,( () H-7 ( ,)5 () 4-(()$(*(*(-4%4,@*()&,&$*'-,/*,*(*% 55/(*5 ,*,-')*-&()@*%%*5F
()5(*5 () G*(  ( 4-)-%4/
C0 	  !"! #!"!




  $(,/*,(* ,-( $(*(*

4-)',%*'()()*(*%,-%) *&&,(*/ *(, 47 &*%*5 ( */(*5( )* '(%)%()  ,*'*% )*(* -&&*,*(%7 ( $*( 7'$()(*,$*,(-&)*4-*/,)*%) -%(*5*- '(% *%% ( (,*5  ) (( ,-(,-,(/*(*7)*5(G)*,)*(,*()((*'7 &  + 7 -,'4L 4-)',)% '*%*(7  $* ,L () (,*$( & $/*-(*%L,&().*%.(%%()
(*(-(L,&,*%/*,$('(L()&&*/*(&.@34-)'4()L5(%&()/*,((),,%-*&())*5(),-()% ()( 4-)' (*% ,-% ) 4,(*(-(*%%7&*,*(24%((7G-%)/*/(*5( () ,,- '(% )%()  ,*'*%)*(*),-(,,%-)G/()(,-%&-%(7$&',*($H-*,4-)')/*,*(-,(())*5(),-((,(*N(*/,-'((* ()( 4-)' ) )  $( &$&-/*%,4-(*-'(%*%%+,**5()(()**&'(* E%@%*@ '* &*% & 7(*%((7((*$(()-5)F(),-(*$(,/*,(*%*&


 )* $(*(* & &% )4 %*& 4-)'

G )* ,((* ()( (*% ,-% &*,*($&',((,*5)-%(*$H-*,/()	((4H,(*()*(*,(,-(,-,(/*(*7)*5 ()*&&,(*/ *(, ,%*'  %()-5)()	(( ,&(()*(*,( ,-(G*()*() ,-(

,*(-$-4%*)*(*,(,-(&()$$*(*()(()5(*5&/*(*7)*5**,(*7)*(*,(,-($,(,**5*&*,(/%-'&/*,*,%-*5()((*'7&/%*/G*(()(G($((()((,-(95%7()4*& ()* /*, () *(*,( ,-( ,,%- ()(4-)' ) 4 $H-*, 4,- )* (*%

 !"! #!"! 	

-% +% &&%#%

$$%7*5()$-'$(*&,

*  (*%7 $(  *(**(*,( ,-( '7  * I-*)*5( ((% %%5%7*$-(G/$,(*,%'((G)()$-'$(*&,,(() %*( N,$(* * S 88"CBG(   *,- 4%G*$(&G)())4/*(*7 )*5  )* %(( *(($$%4,-()*(*,(/*(*7 )*5 $--( ( -()*(7

)*(*,(,-(/*

()-'-,'$%N &,(-%)	((5-()(()*(*,(,*5  /*(*7 )*5 4%%G&-,))*5*()4()S88"CBD&,(%((*/*((*(%(/*(*7))G*(),-$H-*,&&,( * () (( $,*5 '*,*5&H-(*,G-%-&*%-()%/*(*7)*(('$(*5 ( *(*5-*) *

*(*,(,-()*)(-()*)*5(((%,%*'&*&&,(

()4/I-($(*&

))%()(*(*,(,-(/*(*7)*5G)G*()()$-'$(*&,,(-,,*,(%7*,-(),-$()	((5-%/((()*

,- S 88"CBD *  N

*(*,( ,-(T H-**,(*  -()*(7()%/*(*7
C 	  !"! #!"!

3HWLWLRQHU DWWHPSWVWR GLVWLQJXLVK 0LWFKHOO E\ DUJXLQJ WKDW WKH%DWVRQ

Y .HQWXFN\  86   FKDOOHQJH LQYROYHG WKHUHLQ ZDV EDVHGVROHO\ XSRQ IDFWXDO VWDWH FRXUW ILQGLQJV ZKHUHDV WKH LQVWDQW FDVH LQYROYHVDQ LQHIIHFWLYHQHVV RI FRXQVHO FODLP WKDW ZDV FOHDUO\ D PL[HG ILQGLQJ RIIDFW DQG ODZ ,Q WXUQ 3HWLWLRQHU DUJXHV WKDW EHFDXVH WKH SUHVXPSWLRQ RIFRUUHFWQHVV GRHV QRW DSSO\ LQ WKH LQVWDQW FDVH 0LWFKHOO LV QRW DSSOLFDEOH

DQG WKHUHIRUH QRW FRQWUROOLQJ +RZHYHU DV WKH DERYHVWDWHG FRQFOXVLRQVKRZV WKH SUHVXPSWLRQ RI FRUUHFWQHVV GRHV DSSO\ WR WKH SRVWFRQYLFWLRQWULDO FRXUW¶V ILQGLQJV RI IDFW 7KXV 3HWLWLRQHU¶V DWWHPSW WR GLVWLQJXLVK0LWFKHOO LV HUURQHRXV

G)*,)()((,-()'&**5-%&()&,( ,(* * S 88"CBD $$%* 
( G ()& & () *(*,( ,-( ( *$ G*() ()$-'$(*&,,('4**S88"CBD(/*(*7)*5G*()-($/**5G*(((('(&()U*5G)*,)%*((,,%-()(7 & () &*( / &,( G $(  ()*5G)*,)%*((,,%-()(()((&**5GT(&*%7-$$(47(),TU

,*(*,(,-()$$%7('*()(*(

'7 *$ G*() () $-'$(* & ,,('(47S88"CBD(),-()'*,(**('**5 G)() ( )%  /*(*7 )*5G/  J*,K )4 $(*(* G) ) (/%$ () , * (( ,-( * (*(% ( /*(*7)*5%7*&))GBDE,-&)*&*%-(/%$()&,(*((,-($,*5,(-%$H-*,-%(*5&'()(&*%-FB8DE()(&-'(%'*,*5&H-(*,G-%-%(&'&*%-()%&%/*(*7)*5F)&*(*,(,-(4-*(*,(*47*5-,))*5G*()-(&*(I-**5()$(*(*('@()I-**()G*5

*C1("MMB,*((*'*((D)-(*,(%7

()4*&*4,-()*(*,(,-(*(&*

()(&() &,( ,(**S88"CBD$$%*(),-(%,@()-()*(7(/*(*7)*5

 !"! #!"! 	&,(*()((,-($,*5/*(*7)*5G-%-%(*&H-(*,*C1"M*(*,( ,-( 4- *( *,(*-,))*5G*()-(&*(I-*()I-**()G*5F/("MM()*-(*547(%(.M"8C1CMB()

--(*5*4-((

	-$' -( H-( ()* ' 

 () -( *($( 8 ((-( ,( &- 7 &( 	,(*88"CBDB8D$/*6E
&&*%(/%$()&,(-%4*$,*5(),-()(),%*'-%()$$%*,(F8 
	S88"CBDB8DB'$)*%/% & &-%( ,( 47 ()('* ()( () $*5 ,%(*%%7,*&*,(*&())%*(($/(%($*G)(&-%(&(), '-( (*&7  )*5)(/*(*7)*5F

%5-5 -55(() 	-$',%  ,**5 G)  $/*(*7 )*5L () () $(*(*'-(*(4(*BEI-*()$*J*,$H-*,N,-*5()&-%(

)*5)*,%*'FB'$)

,% *  

$(*(*G))(/%$H-(*&7)*&*%-(()-5$H-*, 4& ) '7 $()4,-(
1 	  !"! #!"!

7R WKH H[WHQW WKDW 0LWFKHOO VXJJHVWHG WKDW D GLVWULFW FRXUW LV ZLWKRXW

DXWKRULW\ WR KROG DQ HYLGHQWLDU\ KHDULQJ ZLWKRXW ILUVW ILQGLQJ WKDW RQH RIWKH IDFWRUV OLVWHG LQ  86&  G DSSOLHV , DJUHH ZLWK -XGJH 6LOHUWKDW LWV VWDWHPHQW LV 3RYHUEURDG ́ 6HH .HHQH\  86 DW  Q

QRWLQJ WKDW  G 3LQGLFDWHV QR DVVXPSWLRQ WKDW WKH SUHVHQFH RUDEVHQFH RI DQ\ RI WKH VWDWXWRU\ H[FHSWLRQ ZLOO GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU D KHDULQJLV KHOG ́

& &,(-%I-(**() &*(*(,!(,(E*,(*/&()&%&&,(&**5(%(&%,-($,*5F2G)*,) , %7 E5 () ,,-,7 &&*,*,7&H-*,*%$,*5F/(

	*'*%%7 () ,% -( ( *( )%*5  

7''(74(G()H-*$-,&$,-%&-%(()(5/*5&,(&**5*())4,-(E)* 5  ( '*(* *   & )4 %G (()()4 H,(*()*G)*,)*(G$*,*$%%7-,*(FG(()-(E%*((%,4*&)%*5)4$(*(*((&&*%*5(4*5  ,%*'* (( ,-(  N,-*5()$(*(*- () %G ( & &*%*5 ( /%$ ()&,(-%4*&()(,%*'*()'&-'F/(0

55&*%*(7(!(*-$(()*7''(74()G*5&,-$H-*,)4,-(G-%)/*,(*(((*,%*'()()4$,-%%7&-%(*((,-(4-(G-%)/*,(*(,-,( /*(*7)*5  ,%*' *4-(*-&&*,*(%7/%$*((,-(/G)()$(*(**()G,-$H-*,&)*&*%-(/%$()&,(-%, * () (( ,-(  :*/ () *'$(, ()( (),%-( ,*4( -*&'*(7*()%G & )4,$-()(,(4,,(*5&(),

)*-(),5*A()(,%*'$%*,*(%7G*()G

() *,(* ()( !( ) 5(  
 * 

G/*(*,(,-(&*5/*(*7

)*5   )4 $(*(* ,)%%5 G*()-(

I-**5 () $(*(* ( (4%*) *() BD ,- $H-*,&)*&*%-(I-(%7/%$()'(*%

 !"! #!"! 	

?(*(* 5- ()(* 

	-$'-(-()*(7()()**,-*(G)*,),5*A()(()*)(-()*(7(/**$-(*-&'(*%&,(?!(1M8
	81B

!%%"0C
	B

E()$G&*I-*7&%)/(18%()-5)!(G

*,-4%G()-((-*(*,( ,-(  )4 /*G )*5/(11C*(*

J(K)$-$&()((*(*G)*,) () )%*5 &  '(7
%%(),G)* *$-( () )%*5 & -,*,(*&()*(*,(H-5)4$$%*,(G&&()((,-(-%(*5*%*4**%7 )-% ,,$( () )*5  -( )  (  
$G ,(* %7 47 ),*/ /*, 4*5 -,(*(-(*%,%*'

/(1 )-*('()($

*(*,(,-()/()*)/*(*7)*5/*&()&,()*54(

)**-G&-()*,-

/-%!(47)%*5()

(($$%*()4$(*(*&,((()((,-(%/%,)%*5 () -( *,- *4(G()*(,%*(*!,-('-()%/*(*7)()$-'$(*&,,(%*(
! 	  !"! #!"!

*( *( * /*( ()( S 88"CBD  ( ,*&7!(3$,*&*,(*&G))*5*I-*!( ,*4 ,(5* & , * G)*,)/*(*7)*5G-%4I-*	,(*88"CBD)G/  ( $-$( ( 5/ () I-(* &G))*5I-*L()*(%*(N,$(*(() '% $-'$(* & ,,( & ((,-(&**5  % G*() () 4- & $& G))*5)%)(G*-*(*,(()((-( **,(  -'$(* ()( () $, 4,&7&()((-(7N,$(*G*%%('*G)())*5*)%

/ ( 0 "  )-()* $5**,(() ,(*-*5/*4*%*(7&!((('(()(*(*,(,-('7

  /*(*7 )*5 ( ((% *$-( *- &'(*%&,(/&%%G*5()$(*&()N,$(*(()$-'$(*&,,(%*(*S88"CBD

)-*(('(()(*(*,(,-(*G*()-(

-()*(7(/*(*7)*5*()4,&&()N,$(*%*(*S88"CBD*/4*()(*(&*%(,5*A()*)(-()*(7()(*(*,(,-(%G7)*)4,(/*(*7)*5(((% *$-( *- & '(*% &,(  )* ,-( )$/*-%7,5*A()*$*,*$%+%M08"M""MB!()*8DBI-(*5!(&()

$$*(*()(*(*,(H-5$G(,*//*,  )4 $(*(* ,(*(-(*% ,%*' * %7,(*47)* -*,(*D ()*,-*()/%*@G* ,5*A()**)(*,(* *C!1M"0M"C""B()* DL
48C1CC"8B ()*MDL", C

8!!1!"B8*1D

&,-,5*A*5*(*,(,-(*)(*,(*

(/*(*7)*5**-()(*$(*(*,( &' G)()  )4 $(*(* *  ( /*(*7 )*5   ?(*(* ,,(%7 $*( -(,%*(&()$$*(*()(6

 !"! #!"! 	

),%-(5(,(*

(&N,-*5)4$('(*%&,(*((,-($,("
%(*'(%7()-(('$H-*, ( '4* ()4(G () ,'$(*5 ,,,-()4$GF/(M()*5 * () -( &'*5 %-(* & ()( I-(* -55(*,(*5 *( )%*5 ( () ,)4$(*(**E(*(%F(

. *'$((%7 () %5*, ()

*/((),-$H-*,-,),(-,(*)-(4&/%-'4*-&H-*,*% ,'7 ,)%*5 & &-'-*&'*(7*()%G0  
( * *&&*,-%( ( -( G-%4/477('()(/*(*7 )*5 %7 -$ $H-*,4-(/()%*/(4(('%*,(*()I-*  	-,)  7(' (*%% G$$(-*(7(,,(()*G,'-%(*$%7()$$(-*(*(%*(*5,-',,H-*,*%-,

& $(*,-% ,, * () *

$$ &-' %%,(*  -*&-/*/% & () !( ,(*%*@() &'/%-(() (*56E3-(()	(('-(&&&*)*5)*&%,%*'()	((&-%%&*$$(-*(7,%*'()'*(F/ (0)4 ,-( ( ,-,(  /*$(*(*)G*()-(,-&*%,-(5*()*(GG7(()-5)()((,-(*()$$$
1! 	  !"! #!"!

I-((($,-%-%&%)4/*G&(),%*'*-%()$*,'((,-

&()&-%(,(-%$H-*,-%(&()%%5/*%(* & &% %G  '(( ()( &*%- (,*(),%*'G*%%-%(*&-'(%'*,*5&H-(*,F/(M"0B'$)*-$$%*D
/*G&()*5*&*,()'-&&47	((G)&%,-(&*%($,((($,-%-%&%,-(E*,(*F(,*  )4 $(*(* &% ,%*' G*$$$*( G) () $(*(* ) $*/ () ((,-(&$$(-*(7((),%*'*()&*(*(,

!()%*5G*()$,((/*(*7)*5

(G/-%3-(*(*,(,-()*,(*( ,* &% ,%*'()( )4$(*(*)(-4'*(((()((,-(*(),-%*()/*,(*(%%G$(*(*(/%$&,(()()(4&*%7$((()((,-(,%!%%

"0C 
	  M  B8D B((*5 ()( *( * E*(*% (*(*5-*)4(G&*%*5($$%7(&%,%*'*((,-( &*%*5*((,-(($$%7/%$-,)  ,%*'FD  )- * ,%  !%% ()

	-$'-($$%*(),-$H-*,((('*G)()(($*G))&*%(/%$'(*% &,(* (( ,-( G (*(%(  /*(*7)*5)4,$-/(

,%G,*G)*,)$(*(*-5)(&%

/*(*7 )*5 4-( * ( ,*/    ( C

@*5)*,-&'()*&,(3-5	*%*($(,%('()()G*5&,-$H-*,5)4

,-((,-,(/*(*7)*54-(()(/*()4,&-,))G*5(),-((**,(*()%)*5(
'7/*G*()()%5-5()*5&,%G*%%-$$(()**($((*
*(*()	-$'-(,($-,'(*  !% 80 	 ( CM B8000D (5%7,4(*5&,%()(%*'*(()-()*(7&

)4,-((/*(*7)*5

 !"! #!"! 	

)4$(*(*G))(((,-(*(*(%(/*)GBDE,-&)*&*%-((,-( $,*5  ,&'()(&*%-FB8DE()(&& H-(*, G-% -%( &' &/*(*7)*5F

*C1("MMBI-(*8D  ,- () *(*,( ,-/*(*7)*5$--((*(()*-&G)()?(*(**)*5**%/(G*%%(4

%%G*5 () % 5-'( 

-(,*!%G)*,)*(*($(()&-%(I-*(*(*'&&,(*/+()	((8CBE+?FD)$,*-((()(EJ*K&()$$%*,&,(-%4*&,%*'*	((,)%%()%/*(*7)*$$%*,()GJ()N*(,&8 
	S88"CBDB8D)*%()()* $/** '7 /*, ()'/  *(*,( ,-( *)/*(*7)*5*()4,N,$(*()*$/**(4,-?(*(*&*%)*)4(),('(&+?+180 18!8M BMD B)%*5 ()($(*(*&*%&(()(&*('7(47*)(*,(*)*5&%%G*5(),('($,*&*,%%7 ('* G)() %G(()&()*(*,(,-(4%G

*(*%%7%()-5)

,**EI-*J*5K()$*
 	  !"! #!"!

$H-*, N,-*5 () &-%( 4& ) ,-% ,*/ )*5  )* ,%*'F   ( C  () - & () G

E,-%F  (*'$%7()(*&() *(*,( ,-(  )*54-$*(*)(*,(**()-()*(*,(*4(GG)$(*(**(*(%()*5G)*,)G(*-*,%/-G)()*(*,(,-(

)()*)(*,(*()*5*(*%%*(,(&%%G*5

9''+ 2	 +&'
&"

,5*A*5()(*)4,*(*,(,-()()

*)( -()*(7(   /*(*7)*5( ((%*$-(*-&'(*%&,(4/*-%7*()*-&)G 7 /*, ,*/ 47 () *(*,( ,-( * ( 4,* *& () ,-( )% ()( () $-'$(* &,,(-S88"CBD$$%*)$(,/*,(*(*%,-(,,%-()(?(*(*(*%,-%$&',G&*,*(-*5()(,*5$)-(()&*%-(*/(*5(  4(* *&'(* 4-( ?(*(*4,@5-'(%)%()G/*(G(()%()(?(*(*-&&$H-*,(()(,*5(54,-()/*,()()G-%)/&&(-$$(&**5 & '*(*5(*5 ,*,-'(, G 4() )%$&-% )'&-%()(*(G-%()/4$-(((57($( () /*,  )  -( & *'*%$$%&&*'()(,**&"9M"C8M

(V8)	((5-()(*()4,&()/*,$( (() /*(*7 )*54%G() (( ,-(&**5& &,( )G&*,*($&',()$(&?(*(*(*%,-%4-(()G7$H-*,&'()(&*,*($&',?(*(*$475-*5()( () (( ,-( &**5 & &,(  )G ()( ) G$H-*,47(*%,-%&*,*($&',

 ( &() () (( & ('**5 G) ()

*&&,(*/*(,&,-% $H-*,&(()()*(,'-(4(**(E7&*,*,**,-%$&','-(4$H-*,*%(()&*(,(*(-(*&&,(*/*(,&,-%-()

 !"! #!"! 	*()*5%747I-**5())%-*N,*,-'(,()(G*(5*(7&((,-(&,(&**5

)5(*&%%G*56%

,)5*()%G&)44$-47*,((&,'*(7()/%-&E-&!
 "0 
	 M88 M1 

$*,(*&6%!((

'*&-%&()*%*,(%*(&%((%(*G-%(-4/(()*(5*(7&((,*'*G5!(1M8
	(1 

C11B-55(*5()(()$%7$)4,$-G-%(,(*G*())%,%*'*(($,*()$$-%$,)G*(),%%H-*,*7 ( *( &' &-(',(*, $, $(*,-%%7"% 7 *' 
7 4''% &
%M1;
9() )*(7 & () ,-('H*()':%'*()	!*"
8000(B(*5,-(,%%&%*(*,(,-(H-5()4*5*(()()$%(7'@*G)*,)*(*&,(D6%G%C11
	M8 M BMM

,5*A*5()(*&%7(

()&*($$(-*(7($*&%*5)(()(*'$(( *(( / 47 (	-$'-($%,6%EG*(),-$H-*,*I-*M1M"0E
%%,*G)*,))*&%,%*'*((,-($
1C 	  !"! #!"!








9
 . 9+ *,-*( 3-5 ,,-*5

))4,-(*()*,4%*/()(*()(*%%7-%*'*(*,(*(,-,(/*(*7)*5()$(*(* *&&,(*/ *(, & ,-% ,%*'  	-,)*,(**)G/(*&,(&475()*,-( ,5*A**()'	-$'-()-4((*%%7$4,@()4*%*(7&&%,-(( (7 , %7 (* * () (( ,-(  
 G-%()&)%()(()*(*,(,-(*()*,*'$/*(%75(()$(*(*/*(*7)*5
,,-*%%()$(&3-5	*%$**




!1()	-$'-(*/(&%)4,-(

G*()4*,(**'($,(&,%%(%/*G&((,*'*%H-5'((*5()((),''%G,,*/&():(*( '7/*%4% &7@*&5/'(%((*,(7(&-'(%%G() -( * 6%  - ,% ()( E&% ,-(

H-**,(* * ,& 47 () %%5(* & -,(*(-(*%(*(*(&(477()*5()('7,,-*((,-($,*5F6%1M8
	1C8!B!1D)*4,,$(*%()-(()%()(/$(*(*G))$,-%%7&-%()*,%*'*((,-(,-%4(*)4%*&-4H,((()*(*,(,-(E*,(*F(7%*&G)()%7$,-&()((,-()4%*4(%747$/(C1CC1 
$%%%&)*()-('$G&%)4,-((,-,(/*(*7)*5/G)$(*(*)&*%(/%$()&,(*((,-($,*5E
/7,F()	-$'-(G(*!(() *(*,( H-5 E) () $G ,(* %7 47 )*- *,(* ( ,*/ /*, 4*5 -$ ()$$%*,(,(*(-(*%,%*'F!(1M8
	811 B!1D!(%*'*(()*,(*&)4,-(

 !"! #!"! 	

1HLWKHU SDUW\ DUJXHV WKDW DQ\ HUURU 

UHVSHFW WR WKH SHUIRUPDQFH SURQJ RI WKH 6(*(-(*FC!!
'-()G()(()*4,-%-$&*%()G-% )/ 4 *&&(   $44*%*(7 -&&*,*( ( -'-(,'F/(!C*(*%%

JGK)&(,)%%5I-(**G)()()*4(()() (,,-( ( () N(( *( *$/*,G-% )/ ,,%-55/(*5'*(*5(*5,*,-'()

/ ( !"  *%%7 EJGK)  &$,*5**5/-4(4-&%%G)W-4((*%**('**5()H-7T/*,(()$(*(*'-(G*F$-

C18C1!B"D

& ,-  (( 4/ ()

((* '*NI-(*/*G//()%

&,()-%4,,()$-'S 88"CBD  ) $(,/*,(*?(*(*(*%,-%)&*%?(*(* 4,@5-  '&,(-%&**5(&()4/*()&**5&&,(()$(,()(?(*(**(-&&7$$&',)%*5()(()$$%&&*'6


& () (*% ((7 ) */

G-%)/&-()(()$$%%
80 	  !"! #!"!

/*%( 4)/*  (*,*% $%*(7 *5G*()()(*%H-5T&**5()((*%,-%G *&&,(*/ * &*%*5 ( &-() */(*5( ()4,@5-&(),,--(),*,-'(,4-(G%5G*().((T((*'7()(*%H-5T,,%-*()(*($44%7G-%()/4()'($-((*%((57(-$&&$$%%(T)*(7 & /*%( 4)/*  (*,*% $%*(7*(*()()5-*%(*,,$)(()(,*5$)&()(*%()	-$'-(&()
*(	(((*"C!!


	 !!  M00 B CD E:*/ () /G)%'*555/(*5 &,(()*  4% $44*%*(7()( () '*(( /*, G-% )/ ,)5 (),,%-* ()( () 55/(*5 ,*,-'(,-(G*5)()'*(*5(*5,*,-'(,),()(, *'$F  
 $& & () $$%%($7,)%5*,%)*(7*%%$44*%*(7G-%()/,)5 () -%( $,*%%7 * %*5)( & $$%%(,/*,(*&$*'%*,*-@*%%*5G)*%*&%$*((*7  () () 55/(*5 &,(  ,** & ,-% %(*5 (  ,)*, & (*% $$%%(((57/*&*(G$/*'$/*(,-%(&'()4*&*&&,(*/*(,&,-%,%*'

&"9M"C8M(V8

?(*(*5-()(()*,,%-*G*,*(*5

+$C1 
	" !!0CBM D&()$$*(*()( () ,$*(% (, '7 E( 4 $,%- &',**5'*(*5(*5&,(7$,(&&(,),(  ,  7 & () ,*,-'(, & ()&&()(()&($&&4*&(,&%()()F/?(*(* %*,-$+*

'*$%,  *( */%/ () $((* & /*, &'*(*5(*5,*,-'(,()(G'((&*(G*()*)*G()$%(7((-(("C"
()*(,,?(*(**(E$&&F7/*,()(() H-7 G $,%- &' ,**5  ?(*(* %

 !"! #!"! 	+*$H-*,)*'(()5-*(*,(,-()%()(()*GG  /*, ()( ?(*(* N$( ( ((*&7 ()( ) G *(44*5/*&*()/4&&,(*/%7,-(47 .(% %() 
(*(--()*A$*((*%()(()G( */@  **(7 &  ,-'()G()(*(G-%4,7**(7&)-?(*(**4%$44*%*(7()(() 4%-4( $,(*55-*/(*5($(/*

)*(*,(,-(*(*

-&&$H-*,(()5-*%(&*,*($&',




)*(*,(,-(&**5&$

(5*<	+()H-5&G*(&)4,$-(?<+  ) *(*,( ,-($(*(* &  G*( & )4 ,,/*,(**.+
18 	  !"! #!"!

-G)() ,-%G*&%-,*)*4*, ((5*,,**47()*((&()'$%7G))*)*'F/( 8M8  
 () *(( $$% () , 4%G  (,'$% () ' ,,%-*  :*/ () *(*,( ,-(,,%-*()(((*($(,(()*((&7()	:.?(*(*,()G()(((G,(*/%7$(*5,&%*,(*5*((()()*()&((*(%($-'$(*&$H-*,(()5-*%((5

-%3"# +

?(*(*5-()(()*(*,(,-(*,,%-*5

()( ) * ( -&& 7 $H-*, 47 )* (*% ,-%&*,*($&',&%7*5)*$$(*&(*%47()&*%-($(&*,/*,47()&*%-($(/*,,,*5?(*(*'(%)*(7

*(?(*(*5-()(((,**((G@

 () , -(*% ) ,*/ () 4%, & () (*$H-*,)*'47()%,@& 7'*5&-% G@4*5$&'47$*/*5)*'&$((*-*5)*$7,)%5*,%/%-(*G/?(*(*$*(($,*&*,/*,()(G-% * 4%$44*%*(7()( () &,(&* G-% )/ )  4% -4($,(*55-*%(*()4,&()*%7

	,?(*(*5-()()G$H-*,47)*(*%

,-% &*%- ( */(*5(  $(  %4 $()G*5 ()(  4% G &-  () ,%() ) G%%5%7 G*5 -*5 () &&  ) *(*,( ,-(,,(%7)%()(-,)/*,G-%()/,(4% -4( 4-( 5-*%( 4,- %()-5) () G((*'7()(?(*(*GG*5%5@,(()*5)(&()&&()G/*,()((()(*'&())'*,*?(*(*GG*5(),%()*A%(&' )* $('(   	  	-$$ (

0!

*%%7 ?(*(* 5- ()( (*% ,-% &*%- (

*/(*5( )* '(% )*(7 $,*%%7 )* *5 &?(-'(*,	(+*%* ?%*(7

 !"! #!"! 	%*-$ !M1& () $$*(* ()( EJK- **&&*,-%(7 * &**5 $H-*, *G),-%&*%($($)*(7'(%,$,*(7F/

?(*(* * ( -&& $H-

4%$44*%*(7()((),,%- ()( () 4%, & 5&,(*(G((),**5()/*,$(4%G  )  *(*,( ,-( */*(*7)*5(((%*$-$--((*(*)(-()*(7(4&&&/*(7&$-$$-'4%7G-%4(4-(()$,,(((,-(&**510 1!!1!C B!(E&% ,-( '-( & ( (,,*5$-'$(*&,,(4-(%7G*(),%,/*,** () *(( , () *(*&**5 ' 47 () *(*,( ,&,(-% &**5 ' 47 () $

	0C08
(()*(*%-$$%'(()&,(-%&**5'(*%,-(9#! 0DB%%G*5/*,4(*(-$$%'(()(*%(,*$(

/,**5()-$$%'

*(*,(,-(-(%***(-&& $H-*, ( () (,*,-%&*,*($&',()-$$%'(%/*,,(*(,'*5)(&*(4,'$%*@G*)$,(()(G-%455/(*5,*,-'(,
$/*,,(*,*$(*
88 	  !"! #!"!

@*%%*5  &%%G $* *'(   )*(7 & /*%(,),((*()&G5G*()()$(,/*,(*(*%,-(()-(&*'*%$$%()(4,- () '*(*5(*5 /*, ()( ,-% )/ 4*(-,%,(*)'&-%*&'(*?(*(**( -&& $H-*, -&&*,*( ( ,(  4%$44*%*(7()(()(,*5H-7G-%)/,,%-()(() 4%, & 55/(*5  '*(*5(*5 &,( * (G(())-(),**&()*(*,(,-(()(?(*(*G$H-*,(()(,*5(5-()*,-%&*,*($&',*/

1) &"7	%&+ &"7&%
%"%"+ &

 ,$$% ?(*(* 5- ()( () E)*-

(,*-,-%F55/(*5,*,-'(,*(-,(*()(G5*/(()(,*5H-7G-,(*(-(*%%7/5-/4%7*5-$
!1180B!()*  D )  4 "0 1 1  B!() *

"D  ) *(*,( ,-( ,,%- ()( / *& ()*(-,(*G/5-7,-()47G,-47()	-$'-($$%*,(*&,(*(-(*%G*5,(-,(*(()55/(*5,*,-'(,)	(( 5- ()( *& () *(-,(* G -,(*(-(*%%7/5-7G)'%-(()H-7 &**5&()55/(*5,*,-'(,


*%
("C !
	1"!B D()-(

()/5-&*'*%*(-,(*(&()()&%%G*5(('$%76

<5- ,)%%5( ((-( ( ()(*5 *(''(*((N'**%*5)(&()&,(&(),()L()((-(*H-5$$%*4*  %*' & /5- *,( ( 55/(*5,*,-'(,&**,$*(%$-*)'(((-(%7A - () *5)() ''( ,),(*(*,%%7 ( ()( () ,)%%5 $/**&*%I-(%7(*&'H-*G)(()7'-(&*(*'$()()$%(7-%(%/()'$$%%(,-(G*()()@*&$*,(*

 !"! #!"! 	/(?(*(*.((,*(( & 	:.  . (,*5F  	 

*(*,(,-((()(((%	:. &'   ,N?(*(* ,,(* G*() () 5-'(*--4$&(()(*%)-*(,(4*$(*5,&%*,(*5*((

?(*(*%*,-$

B D*'*$%,*/,)%%5(()*'$*'(&(&()**4*%*(7('@*(%%'-(*( %/()**-4('*(*&G)(),&%*,()*$(7$75'('$%7&-%('/*()(4,/*,(&*(*4-(*54,-(47?(*(*()-((()*)*/7-,)*(-(*J$(47%G7)*$**)(%7G5($(4'$%7*(*%*)(%7G$(%7()'$%7(, G) ,*'*% %*4*%*(7 '7((*'7F/(8M"


%*@ () *(( , * 

$(*54()()'$%7*(G()*,**J(($7()$%,$(*(**()*$($,-%),(()5(&($*47()'$%7()*@&*(-(**/*(F/(8!M&'  -$ G)*,) ?(*(*

,(**&(((()($*&()-(,**('(('*G)(),&%*,(&()-(((()(EJK(),
10 	  !"! #!"!

) $H-*, $5 &  %(*5 (

*&&,(*/&,-%(()5-*%($)@E()I-(*G)()()*4%$44*%*(7()(4(() () &,(&* G-% )/ )  4% -4($,(*5 5-*%(F   C!! 
	 ( !"   ((4/()$H-*,$5&*'*NI-(*&%G&,(-4H,((/ /*G(! ?(*(* ,%*''-(4/%-(@$*5*'*(),'$%%*5 *,*'*(*5 ((*'7 & 4() .*%% '*(*%%7?(*(*,&((),*'(() (,*5 (5   	 0 	-$$ (0 !

,
&' +&'%

?(*(*5-()()()G7$H-*,

&*474,--
%CC!
	11"B 0DE&(G))G()(,&%*,(&*((,(-%%7&&,(()I-,7&)*$((*('(($H-*,*(4(*J)4K%*&F/(1C"0?(*(*5-()(()()*$(7& 5'( ,(  ,&%*,( & *(( & )* (*%,-%4,-7()-,&$7'(G*/%/*(),*'-()/*5%%5%7-$$%*())(5--47 ?(*(*  G/ () N( (, * 
% **$*(*/&?(*(*,%*'
%(*,(%7I-*()(E-(*%&()G()()*,-%,(*/%7$(,&%*,(*5 *(( ) ) ( (4%*)  ,%*' &*&&,(*/ *(,    JK) $*4*%*(7 & ,&%*,( **-&&*,*((*'$-5,/*,(*F/(1"0

?(*(*&*%()G()()*(*%,-%G,(*/%7

$(*5,&%*,(*5*((('(?(*(*(*%,-%%7()$$(*&)*, &(%5*(*,*$(* & ,*/*5 () 4%, & )* (* &)-5)?(*(*5-()()G/%7&&,(47(),&%*,(&*(()(%%5()()*(*%,-%G,(*/%7$(*5,&%*,(*5*((*(*%%7?(*(* ,-% ( '@ -,)  )G*5 4,-  ()*(*,( ,-( ( E/ *& . 7 *(( G

 !"! #!"! 	

G)*,)G)%*/%**681 8	(8M8!1198

6)%()(:5*T(

$-*)'(((-(G4*5$,$*,*- 'L () G$/*(*(*5-*)()()&'()()(*(	*,6**( ()( () ,)%*5 (,T*,(***'$*&-'(%,(*(-(*%I-'**'*A*5() *@&G)%%7,(*

/(1!!8B,*((*$(*%%7'

)()$%(7*(-,(** () $%(7 )%% 4 -*'-%7&*()(()	((-*5 () (,*5 )*54%-4('((-(755/(*5,*,-'(

 VVVVVV B8D()'-G$,*%%7)*

*()(*(*/%/((-$

 VVVVVV


 ('**5 G)()  55/(*5 ,*,-'(, -'45/ 47 () &%%G*5 *(-,(()(()G)*- $)*4% 4'*4%'N('%7/*%,-%'44'*4%-%'-&&*5 ,-*5 -&&*-&&*5N,- '$*&-%*&%*,(* & / $)7*,% /*,(*' G)*% )  ) '*+$/*(7''%,-$(*B*,D,(

	0	-$$( 
8C 	  !"! #!"!

37HQQHVVHH LV D μZHLJKLQJ¶ VWDWH2WKDW LV WKH MXU\ GHWHUPLQHV

ZKHWKHU DQ\ DJJUDYDWLQJ FLUFXPVWDQFHV KDYH EHHQ HVWDEOLVKHG EH\RQG DUHDVRQDEOH GRXEW E\ WKH 6WDWH DQG WKHQ EDODQFHV WKLV DJDLQVW DQ\PLWLJDWLQJ FLUFXPVWDQFHV IRXQG E\ WKH LQGLYLGXDO MXURUV ,I WKH MXU\

XQDQLPRXVO\ ILQGV WKDW WKH DJJUDYDWRUV RXWZHLJK WKH PLWLJDWRUV GHDWK

PXVW EH LPSRVHG ́ +RXVWRQ Y 'XWWRQ  )G   WK &LU 


*%()-()%()(*(-,(**,%-*5

55/(*5&,(()(()'-GE$,*%%7)*-(,*-,-%FG-,(*(-(*%%7/5-()-5)()-( %&( $ () $*4*%*(7 ()( ,(* %*'*(*5,(-,(* & ()( *(-,(* G-% 4 ,(*(-(*%%7,,$(4%/(1!C!"*(*%%7*((()(E'@*&((-*-$)7*,%4-F%*'*(*5*(-,(*'7$,(*(-(*%'-(%%G*5*%

()*,-()%-,(*(-(*%%7/5-*(-,(*((*5 $,*&* ((-(7 55/(*5 ,*,-'(, 6 EJ(K)'-G$,*%%7)*-(,*-,-%*()(*(*/%/((-$/*(7&'*F)"01(1 M

 ,%* ( $  () ,(*(-(*%*(7 & ()

*(-,(* * ()* , 4,- 7  ()* G)'%  EJK)/  55/(*5 &,( ) 4*/%*( *  G*5)*5 (( () (, '-( 4

G*5)%7A&)'%*&()(,*(4&&*'F
!1(11C)
,-(G(

(((()(6


G*5)*5((G),-(*/%*(&()55/(*()'/'&'*&() ,%  ) *  G7 ( @G *& () H-7%7*2)G () 55/(*5  '*(*5(*5,*,-'(,4%,2G-%)/,)()'-%(/G*()-(()*/%*&,(J
K(*%7G)()E()(,)4*&,(47 ,(*(-(*%%7   */%* 55/(*5 &,(F()(((G*5)*5*I-*($/()/*,(7&**(* ()-5)   ()( * )'%  (

 !"! #!"! 	

$GGLWLRQDOO\ DV WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW 

HYLGHQFH SUHVHQWHG WKDW WKHMXU\ ZRXOG KDYFRQVLGHULQJ HYHQ LI WKH LQVWUXFWLRQV ZXQDQLPLW\ DV WR WKH H[LVWHQFH RI D PLWLJDW

3HWLWLRQHU DUJXHV WKDW KH LV HQWLWOHG W

GXH WR KLV WULDO FRXQVHO¶V LQDGHTXDWH SHUIRSUHMXGLFH XQGHU 8QLWHG 6WDWHV Y &URQ

5LFNPDQ Y %HOO  )G  WK &SRLQWV WR QR IDFWV VXSSRUWLQJ D FODLP RI ZK


 ! 1 ( 11   ) *(-,(**()*((,*(I-*-*'*(7(()&,(
?(*(*'%7()('E-*'-FE'*(*5)/%()H-7('**($(()-5)(,(4%%*@%() ,)%%5 *(-,(* *  ,*(*&,(*(-(*%%7

  &%
%&:	


   &'&%(% &')


&2 + &

,$$%?(*(*5-

,,%-* ()( ) -&&  ,-% &*,*( $&',-  *( ?(*(* 5,-% ,&%*,( & *(( $((*$H-*,,4$

(4)G	,?(*(*-&&$H-*,47(*%,-%(*%47()&*%-($(&&*%- ( $( /*, ,,)*(7
$()	((5-,&%*,(&*((()(?(*(*4,- ) ,( )G  -%( & () $,*5 G-% )4,&(*%,-%&*,*
8 	  !"! #!"!

) H-7 '-( *,%-  -, ( G*(*5 ()

$,*&*, ((-(7  55/(*5 ,*,-'(, ,*,-'(,&--()()H-7'-(*,%-**(&**5()(()((-(755/(*5,*,-'(, ,*,-'(,  &- -(G*5) 7 '*(*5(*5,*,-'(,  
$ -,) -*'- &**5 ,)''4&()H-7)%%&&*N)*)*5(-(()*G*((&**5()(-*G*((/*,((()-(

 
&()H-7-*'-%7('*()(((-(7

55/(*5 ,*,-'(,  ,*,-'(, )/ 4$/47()	((474%-4(L*&()H-7 -*'-%7 ('* ()( () ((-(755/(*5 ,*,-'(,  ,*,-'(, )/ 4$/47()	((474%-4(4-(()(()*,*,-'(,,*,-'(,(-(G*5)7'*(*5(*5,*,-'(,()$-*)'()%%4%*&*'$*'(

	0	-$$(1*(*%%7(()&()*(-,(*()(*% ,-( ((()( EJ(K) /*,('-( $(() ,*H-5'( & ,)H-  
((-/*,(*(*,7()(,)H-5()(;-/*,('-(4-*'-F/(1C


 * *$*(*/ & ()* *-  
 
 () H-7 G

*'*%%7(%()((*'$()() (,*(/*,('-(4-*'-
!1(11M)*,-()%6

&*()(()*(-,(*,)%%547(

/*%(.*%%)*%5-5I-*-*'*(7(() -%( & () G*5)*5 4-( ()* *  & *&&('((()I-**5-*'*(7(()$,&'*(*5(*5 &,(  ()*5 * ()* %5-5 ,-%4%7 4 (@ ( I-* -*'*(7  ( ()$, &  '*(*5(*5 &,(  ) *(-,(* 7,%%7,,(%7()(*(4(*-*'-/*,(,)H-'-(,,%-()(()'*(*5((-(G*5)()55/(

 !"! #!"! 	

E*&,(F()(,()(((-()&(%7A()) I-(* G '-( @ * -4((*%  *H-*- &('**5()H-7/*,(F

/(11C1"

()G() H-7 ' () G &**$,*%%7)*-(,*-,G) *( ) 4 ,)5 ( &E$,*%%7 )*- (,*- ((-$/*(7&'*F/


&(-(%7()H-7/*,

G ( $/  G/'()&,(-%&**5() 55/(*5 ,*,-'(, ,@5-,(*&

B 0D  ) &,(-% &*$-'$(*&,,(-

CC
	("C!B((*5*(*,(*4(G()&,(-%(,-(()&(($$%%?(*(*)*()&& 7$-'$(*)-%($$%7*(&*()()55/(*5

()	((,,(%7$*(-(

(-$$(()55/(*5,*,-'4$/*-%7,/*,(&()-()(&/*%,(()'-G,''*((G)*%(),''*((*5(('$(*5(,''447&M ()(EJ(K)*-4(()(()-&&*,*((-$$(,)&()&-47()H-7FDI-(4()( '/*5  55/(*5
8! 	  !"! #!"!

7KLV FRQFOXVLRQ LV QRW DIIHFWHG E\ RXU KROGLQJ WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW

SURSHUO\ FRQVLGHUHG WKH HYLGHQFH LW REWDLQHG GXULQJ WKH HYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJ EHFDXVH DOWKRXJK WKDW HYLGHQFH FRQWDLQHG PLWLJDWLQJ

FLUFXPVWDQFHV WKDW FRXOG KDYH EHHQ RIIHUHG DW WKH VHQWHQFLQJ VWDJH

3HWLWLRQHU GRHV QRW DUJXH WKDW D UHZHLJKLQJ LV QHFHVVDU\ RQ WKLV EDVLV7KXV LQ WHUPV RI SRVVLEOH UHZHLJKLQJ ZH ORRN RQO\ WR WKH HYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHG DW WKH VHQWHQFLQJ VWDJH

(,*5 ,%,-%- *  G*5)*5 (( '%%7 G-%I-*  G*5)*5 & () 55/(*5  '*(*5(*5&,(
!1(11CG/*()*((,  () *(*,( ,-( &- EJ(K)* *  , & '*(*5(*5/*,4*5&&(()H-7$*(*(/*%4*%*(74-,F		-$$( 0  )- / *& () )*- (,*-  ,-%55/( * '/ &' () ,%,-%- () * '*(*5(*5 /*, ( G*5) 5*( () '**5 $*&%7,/*,(*&%7'-55/()&()G)'%*()(*(*()/-4((*%*H-*-&&,(*&%-,*('**5()H-7/*,(

0  &% $ 8*3+ &&+ 

%"+ &

?(*(* 5- ()( () (,*5 *(-,(*

*'$$%7 % () H- ( 4%*/ ()( ()7 ) (-*'-%7&*7'*(*5(*5,*,-'(,*($,*&*,%%7 *(-,( ()' ()G*  %()-5)  *,(*(-,(* G 5*/ I-**5 ()( () H- &* ()N*(,&,)'*(*5(*5&,(-*'-%7?(*(*5- ()( () H-7 G $(%7 *&' ()( ()*,**)(4-*'-4-(G(*(-,(()(()7 * ( )/ ( 4 -*'-  ( '*(*5(*5,*,-'(,)*(*,( ,-()%()( E()*( 4%%*@%*)()(()H-7*($(()*(-,(*(I-*-*'*(7('*(*5(*5,*,-'(,J(K)*-(*($-()(*%,(&**5'*(*5(*5,*,-'(, G-% %*@%7 % () H-7 ( 4%*/ ()(-*'*(7GI-**()*,F	0

	-$$(C)*)%*5G,,(

 !"! #!"! 	


**%C !
	1

()((,*5*(-,(*()(,()( 4% H- '*5)( ()*&',**57'*(*5(*5-*'*(7,(*(-(*%%7*/( & /*G*5 -,) *(-,(*E*G)()()*()H-7)$$%*(),)%%5$/( () ,*(* & /*,F%
'C


 () *(( , () -4(

,-(*(-,(*G6

- ((-(7 %G $/* 

$-*)'( &(  $( ('*G)()()&()  %*& *'$*'(  -*'-(*()&'&$

 VVVVVV   () $%(7 )%% 4

-*'-%7&*()(()	((-*5 () (,*5 )*54%-4('((-(755/(*5,*,-'(

 VVVVVV 
*/*5(()$-*)'(

 )(& **,( 7 'G)*,))%%*,%-4-((4%

 VVVVVV 
&()H-7-*'-%7(

((-(755/(*5,*,-'(55/(*5,*,-'(,)/47  4% -4( ,*,-'(,,*,-'(,,*,-'(,()(,)$%(7*(),**&()H-7)%%(),'$%(()((,)

 ?-*)'(&+() I-(