USA Banner
  U.S. flag
              An official website of the United States government Here's how you knowOfficial US Government Icon
              **Official websites use .gov**A **.gov** website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
            Secure Site Icon
              **Secure .gov websites use HTTPS**
                  A **lock** ( A locked padlock ) or **https://** means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. 
 U.S. Department of Transportation Icon United States Department of Transportation
 Search DOT
            Search
                        About FRAAbout FRA
  

        
              Overview
                Organization
                Program Offices
                Resource Center
                Web Policies and Notices
                Contact Us
                Communications
                Governmental AffairsFeatured
  

        
              Bipartisan Infrastructure Law Information from FRA
                Careers
                Leadership Profiles
                Organizational Chart
                Newsroom
                Press Releases
                Speeches
                Fact Sheets
                TestimonyRailroad SafetyFeatured
  

        
              Train Horn Rule/Quiet Zones
                Public Blocked Crossings Incident Reporter
                Drug & Alcohol
                Safety Data
                C3RS
                High-Hazard Flammable Train Route AssessmentRailroad Safety
  

        
              Overview
                Railroad Crossing Safety & Trespass Prevention
                Accident Data & Reporting, Investigations
                Divisions
                Partnerships & ProgramsRail Network DevelopmentFeatured
  

        
              High-Speed Rail
                Amtrak
                Environmental Reviews
                GIS Maps
                RuralRail Network Development
  

        
              Overview
                Passenger Rail
                Freight Rail
                Environment
                Planning
                International
                Maps & Data
                Training & GuidanceResearch & DevelopmentFeatured
  

        
              R&D Current Projects
                Positive Train Control
                Hazardous Materials
                Highway-Rail Grade Crossing
                Close Call Reporting
                Broad Agency AnnouncementResearch & Development
  

        
              Overview
                Program Areas
                R&D ReportsLegislation & RegulationsFeatured
  

        
              FAST Act
                National Rail Plan
                Proposed State Rail Plan
                Civil PenaltiesLegislation & Regulations
  

        
              Overview
                Legislation
                Regulations & Rulemaking
                Buy AmericaGrants & LoansFeatured
  

        
              FRA Discretionary Grant Program Tool
                Discretionary Grant Calendar
                Railroad Capital Project Guidance
                FRA Webinars
                DOT GrantsGrants & Loans
  

        
              Overview
                Grant Programs
                Applying for Grants
                Resources for Grant Recipients
                Training & GuidanceFRA eLibraryeLibrary
  

        
              Accidents & Fatalities
                Compliance
                Conferences & Presentations
                Emergency & Safety
                Enforcement & Litigation
                Publications & Policy
                Reports
                OtherMenu Home
                        Research & Development
                        Program Areas
                        Train Control
                        PTC


            
            In This Section
        Train Control
                Intelligent Grade Crossings
                Positive Train Control
                                Overview
                PTC Development
                PTC Analyses
                Incremental Train Control System
                PTC Testing & Evaluation
                
                Positive Train Control (PTC) Analyses
    

    
    
          The regulatory requirements to establish the standards for development and use of processor-based signal and train control systems are described in 49 CFR Part 236 Subpart H. This subpart, adopted on March 7, 2005 along with amendments to 49 CFR Parts 209 and 234, prescribes minimum, performance-based safety standards for safety-critical products, including requirements to ensure that the development, installation, implementation, inspection, testing, operation, maintenance, repair and modification of those products will achieve and maintain an acceptable level of safety. A major part of these requirements is the analyses for validation and verification.

Validation means the process of determining whether a product’s design requirements fulfill its intended design objectives during its development and life-cycle. The goal of the validation process is to determine “whether the correct product was built.” Analyses weigh heavily in this process. Besides the risk and hazard analyses which FRA requires for such validation purpose, other analyses in communication throughput, capacity limits, tracking accuracy requirement, and computer and electronics performance are parts of the validation process.

Verification means the process of determining whether the results of a given phase of the development cycle fulfill the validated requirements established at the start of that phase. The goal of the verification process is to determine “whether the product was built correctly. This process will involve heavily physical testing in the laboratory, in the field, as well as in revenue service.

Validation involves miscellaneous analyses to verify that the requirements would indeed provide the end-results that the developer is seeking, i.e. prevent train-to-train, train-to-vehicle, and train-to-worker collisions and over-speed derailments. A Railroad Safety Program Plan (RSPP) and a Product Safety Plan (PSP) are requirement to be submitted to FRA for approval to allow a PTC system operated in revenue service. The RSPP serves as a principal safety document for a railroad for all safety-critical products to be deployed on that railroad. The RSPP must establish the minimum PSP requirements that will ensure that the PTC system to be deployed complies with the regulatory requirements and undergoes the necessary analyses for such a safety-critical system. Along with a number of documents that describes the product and its operation, the types of analyses expected to be contained in the PSP are:

A hazard log consisting of a comprehensive description of all safety-relevant hazards to be addressed during the life cycle of the product
	A human factors analysis including an analysis of Human Machine Interface (HMI)
	A risk assessment that will evaluate the potential hazards and risks to the fullest extent possible to verify that the PTC system is equal to or better than the previous condition, referred to as the base case. Under special circumstances, abbreviated risk assessment may be used, but for most PTC systems, a full risk assessment would be required. Severity of the incidents is to be considered. Consequences must identify the total cost including fatalities, injuries, property damage and societal costs.
	To support the risk assessment, these analyses are expected to be included in the overall risk evaluation:
	Failure Mode & Effects Analyses
		Preliminary Hazard Analyses
		Functional Fault Tree
		Fault Tree Analyses
		Subsystem Hazard Analyses
		Operation & Support Hazard Analyses
		Hazard Mitigation Analysis.PTC developers should review 49 CFR Part 236, Subpart H for details of the documentation and analyses required for the approval of a PTC system.
              
      
    
          Last updated: Friday, October 25, 2019 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

**Federal Railroad Administration**

1200 NEW JERSEY AVENUE, SE

WASHINGTON, DC 20590

202-366-4000Subscribe to email updates
                    About Us
  

        
              About FRA
                Careers
                Contact Us
                FRA Civil Rights
                Doing Business with FRA
                Grants and Financial Assistance
                Safety Management TeamsAreas of Interest
  

        
              Bipartisan Infrastructure Law
                Safety Data
                Buy America
                Operation Lifesaver
                Railroad Safety Advisory Committee
                FRA Secure Area
                Proactive DisclosureI Am A...
  

        
              Railroad Traveler
                Railroad Inspector
                Reporter
                Educator/StudentPolicies, Rights, Legal
  

        
              About DOT
                Budget and Performance
                Civil Rights
                FOIA
                Information Quality
                No FEAR Act
                Office of Inspector General
                Privacy Policy
                USA.gov
                Vulnerability Disclosure Policy
                Web Policies and Notices
                Web Standards