Page 1 of 67
Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Issuance Date: _?_
Effective Date: Expiration Date:



### National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Waste Discharge Permit No. WA0000 76 1

State of Washington Department o f Ecology Olympia, Washington 98504

- 7600

In co mpliance with the provisions of The State of Washingto n Water Pollution Control Law Chapter 9 0.48 Revised Code of Washington and The Federal Water Pollution Control Act (The Clean Water Act) Title 33 United States Code, Section 1251 et seq.

Tesoro Refining & Marketing Company LLC

PO Box 7 00
Anacortes, Washington 98221

is authorized to discharge in accordance with the special and general conditions which follow.

Facility Location : West March Point Road Anacortes, Washington Receiving Water : Fidalgo Bay

Latitude Longitude

Outfal l 001 48.508333 122.566667

Outfall 003 48.5 122.561389 Industry Type : Petroleum Refinery

Garin Schrieve, P.E. Industrial Section Manager Waste 2 Resources ProgramPage 2 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1



### TABLE OF CONTENTS

SPECIAL CONDITIONS

................................ ................................ ................................ ............ 7

S1. DISCHARGE LIMITS

................................ ................................ ................................ ....... 7
A. Process Wastewater Discharges

................................ ................................ ............... 7

B. Ballast and Stormwater Allocations (Outfall 001)

................................ ................... 9
C. Emergency Overflow (Outfall 003)

................................ ................................ ....... 11

D. Mixing Zone Authorization

................................ ................................ ................... 12

E. Tesoro Logistics Operations LLC (TLO) Wastewater

................................ .......... 12

S2. MONITORING REQUIREMENTS

................................ ................................ ................. 13

A. Monitoring Schedule

................................ ................................ .............................. 13

B. Sampling and Analytical Procedures

................................ ................................ ..... 13
C. Flow Measurement, Field Measurement, and Continuous Monitoring Devices

... 13

D. Laboratory Accreditation

................................ ................................ ....................... 14

S3. REPORTING AND RECORDKEEPING REQUIREMENTS

................................ ........ 14

A. Reporting

................................ ................................ ................................ ................ 14

B. Records Retention

................................ ................................ ................................ .. 16
C. Recording of Results

................................ ................................ .............................. 16

D. Addition al Monitoring by the Permittee

................................ ................................ 17

E. Reporting Permit Violations

................................ ................................ .................. 17

F. Other Reporting

................................ ................................ ................................ ..... 18
G. Maintaining a Copy of this Permit

................................ ................................ ......... 19

S4. O PERATION AND MAINTENANCE

................................ ................................ ............ 19

A. Operations and Maintenance Manual

................................ ................................ .... 19

B. Bypass Procedures

................................ ................................ ................................ . 20
C. Duty to Mitigate

................................ ................................ ................................ ..... 22

S5. FACILITY LOADING

................................ ................................ ................................ ..... 22

A. Design Criteria

................................ ................................ ................................ ....... 22

B. Plans for Maintaining Adequate Capacity

................................ ............................. 23

S6. NON

- ROUTINE AND UNANTICIPATED DISCHARGES

................................ .......... 24

S7. ACUTE TOX ICITY

................................ ................................ ................................ .......... 24

A. Effluent Limit for Acute Toxicity

................................ ................................ .......... 24

B. Compliance With the Effluent Limit for Acute Toxicity

................................ ....... 25
C. Compliance Testing for Acute Toxicity

................................ ................................ 25

D. Response to Noncompliance with the Effluent Limit for Acute Toxicity

............. 25

E. Sampling and Reporting Requirements

................................ ................................ . 27

S8. CHRONIC TOXICITY

................................ ................................ ................................ ..... 28

A. Test ing when there is No Permit Limit for Chronic Toxicity

................................ 28

B. Sampling and Reporting Requirements

................................ ................................ . 29Page 3 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

S9. WASTEWATER TREATMENT EFFICIENCY STUDY AND UPDATED
ENGINEERING REPORT

................................ ................................ ................................ ............ 30

S10. SEDIMENT MONITORING

................................ ................................ ............................. 30

S11. POLLUTION PREVENTION

................................ ................................ ........................... 31

A. Pollution Prevention Plan Update and Implementation

................................ ......... 32

B. Specific Plan Update Requirements

................................ ................................ ....... 32
C. Stormwater Inspections

................................ ................................ .......................... 33

D. Biennial Reporting

................................ ................................ ................................ . 33

E. Continuous Improvement

................................ ................................ ....................... 34

S12. DIOXIN STUDY

................................ ................................ ................................ ............... 34

A

. Wastewater Sampling

................................ ................................ ............................ 34

B. Dioxin Study Report

................................ ................................ .............................. 34

S13. DANGEROUS WASTES

– PERMIT BY RULE REQUIREMENTS

............................. 35

S14. OUTFALL EVALUATION

................................ ................................ .............................. 35

S15

. APPLICATION FOR PERMIT RENEWAL

................................ ................................ .... 35

S16. CERTIFIED OPERATOR

................................ ................................ ................................ . 36

GENERAL CONDITIONS

................................ ................................ ................................ ........... 36
G1. SIGNATORY REQUIREMEN TS

................................ ................................ .................... 36
G2. RIGHT OF INSPEC TION AND ENTRY

................................ ................................ ........ 37
G3. PERMIT ACTIONS

................................ ................................ ................................ .......... 38
G4. REPORTING PLANNED CH ANGES

................................ ................................ ............ 39
G5. PLAN REVIEW REQUIRED

................................ ................................ .......................... 39
G6. COMPLIANCE WITH OTHE R LAWS AND STATUTES

................................ ............ 39
G7. TRANSFER OF THIS PER MIT

................................ ................................ ...................... 40
G8. REDUCED PRODUCTION F OR COMPLIANCE

................................ ......................... 40
G9. REMOVED SUBSTANCES

................................ ................................ ............................ 40
G10. DUTY TO PROVI DE INFORMATION

................................ ................................ .......... 41
G11. OTHER REQUIREMENTS O F 40 CFR

................................ ................................ .......... 41
G12. ADDITIONAL MONITORIN G

................................ ................................ ....................... 41
G13. PAYMENT OF FEES

................................ ................................ ................................ ....... 41
G14. PENALTIES FOR VIOL ATING PERMIT CONDITI ONS

................................ ............ 41
G15. UPSET

................................ ................................ ................................ .............................. 41
G16. PROPERTY RIGHTS

................................ ................................ ................................ ....... 42
G17. DUTY TO COMPLY

................................ ................................ ................................ ....... 42
G18. TOXIC POLLUTANTS

................................ ................................ ................................ .... 42
G19. PENALTIES FOR TAMPER ING

................................ ................................ .................... 42
G20. REPORTING REQUIREMEN TS APPLICABLE TO EXI STING MANUFACTURING, COMMERCIAL, MINING, AND SILVICULTURAL DI SCHARGERS

....................... 43
G21. COMPLIANCE SCHEDULES

................................ ................................ ........................ 43Page 4 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

APPENDIX A

................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ 44

APPENDIX B

................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ 46

APPENDIX C

................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ 56Page 5 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

SUMMARY OF PERMIT RE PORT SUBMITTALS Refer to the Special and General Conditions of this perm it for additional submittal requirements.

Permit
Section Submittal Frequency Report Submittal/ Activity Date

S1.A.

S1. C

. Priority Pollutant Testing

Emergency Overflow Results Annually

As necessary Within 6 0 days of each sampling event

With DMR

S3.A. D ischarge Monitoring Report (DMR) Monthly The 15 th of each month

S3.D. Additional Monitoring by Permittee As necessary With DMR

S3.E. 24

- hr Noncompliance Notification As necessary Within 5 days and/or
with DMR

S3.F. Other Noncompliance Notification As n ecessary With DMR

S4.A. Review and Update Operations and
Maintenance Manual As necessary

S4. A

. Updated Treatment System Operating
Plan 1/permit cycle 180 days prior to permit expiration

S4.B. Reporting Bypasses As necessary With DMR

S 7

. C

. Acute To xicity Tests Quarterly Within 60 days after completion of the test

S 8 .A. Chronic Toxicity Tests 2/permit cycle With the permit renewal application

S 9

. Wastewater Treatment System Study
Plan If material and
substantial
alterations to refinery W ithin 90 da ys of
material or substantial
alterations to refinery coming on line

S 9

. Updated Engineering Report If material and
substantial
alterations to refinery Within 180 days of completion of

T reatment E fficiency

S tudy

S1 0 .A. Sediment Sampling and Analysis Plan 1/permit cycle Within one year of permit effective date

S1 0

. C

. Sediment Data Report 1/permit cycle Within 180 days of completion of sampl ing

S1 1 .A. Updated Pollution Prevention Plan 1/permit cycle Within 18 months of the permit effective
datePage 6 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Permit
Section Submittal Frequency Report Submittal/ Activity Date

S1 2 .B

S 1 3

. Dioxin Study Report

Summary of off

- site DW accepted and treated by permitee 1/permit cycle

1/permit cycle With the permit renewal application

With the permit renewal application

S1 4

. Outfall Evaluation Report 1/permit cycle Within 9 0 days of conducting the outfall
evaluation but no later
than with the permit renewal application

S1 5

.

G1.C. Application for Permit Renewal

Notice of Change in Authorization 1/permit cycle

As necessary 180 days prior to permit expiration

G4. Permit Application for Substantive Changes to the Discharge As necessary

G5. Engineering Report for Construction or
Modification Activities As necessary

G 7

.
G10. Notice of Permit Transfer

Duty to Provide Information As necessary

As necessary

G2 0

. Notificat ion of Discharge of Toxic
Pollutants As necessaryPage 7 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1



### SPECIAL CONDITIONS

S1. DISCHARGE LIMITS

A. Process Wastewater Discharges

All discharges and activities authorized by this permit must be consistent with the

terms and conditions of this permit.

The disc harge of any of the following pollutants more frequently t han, or at a level
in excess of that identified and authorized by this permit violates the terms and conditions of this permit.

Beginning on the effective date of this permit and lasting through the expiration date, the Permittee is authorized to discharge wastewater treatment plant effluent at the permitted location subject to complying with the following limits :

Parameter Units Effluent Limits:
Outfall #001 Monitoring Frequency Sample Type

Average Monthly a Maximum Daily b
Biochemical Oxygen Demand (5

- day) lbs/day 760 1,390 1/wk d 24 hr comp c

Chemical Oxygen
Demand lbs/day 5,280 10,230 3/wk d 24 hr comp c

Total Suspended Solids (TSS) lbs/day 620 960 Daily 24 hr comp c

Oil and Grease lbs/day 220 420 Daily Grab

Oil and Grease mg/l The concentration of oil and grease in the discharge must at no time exceed 15 mg/l and must not exceed 10 mg/l more than three days per month.

Phenolic Compounds lbs/day 5.0 10.2 1/wk 24 hr comp c

Ammonia as N lbs/day 480 1,070 1/wk 24 hr comp c

Sulfide lbs/day 4.0 9.0 1/wk Grab

Hexavalent
Chromium 0.050 mg/l
and 1.52 lbs/day Semi

- annually 24 hr comp c

pH e Daily minimum is equal to or greater than 6.0 and the daily
maximum is less tha n or equal to 9.0 Continuous c,f Continuous c,fPage 8 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Parameter Units Effluent Limits:
Outfall #001 Monitoring Frequency Sample Type

Average Monthly a Maximum Daily b

Fecal Coliform Colonies/
100mls 200 400 Weekly Grab

Temperature oC

-- -- Continuous c Continuous c

Feedstock Rate g bbls/day

-- -- Daily

Ballast Water Flow gallons
received -- -- Daily

Rainfall inch /day

-- -- Daily

Average monthly flow
across the WWT
system for the
maximum month MGD

-- -- Annually

Flow from Secondary Clarifier

*** MGD

_ _ Continuous Continuous

COD loading to the Primary Clarifier Lbs/day

-- -- Annually Composite

Final Effluen t Flow MGD

-- -- Continuous c Continuous c

Priority Pollutants (PP) h μg/L; ng/L for

mercury

-- -- Once /year

(results due within 60 days of sampling
but no later
than March 1 st

of the following year) Grab

Stormwater Monitoring

– See Permit Condition S1 .C.

Acute Toxicity Testing

– See Permit Condition S7.

Chronic Toxicity Testing

– See Permit Condition S8.

Herring Toxicity Study

– See Permit Condition S9.

Wastewater Treatment Efficiency Study

– See Permit Condition S10.

Sediment Monitoring

– See Permit Condition S11.

Dioxin Monitoring

– See Permit Condition S13.

*** Tesoro must install a flow meter at the effluent from the Secondary Clarifier by August 31, 2015.Page 9 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

a The average monthly effluent limit means the highest allowable average of daily

discharges over a calendar month . To calculate the discharge value to compare to the limit, you add the value of each daily discharge measured during a calendar month and divide this

sum by the total number of daily discharges measured

. Additional alloc ation may be permitted for stormwater runoff and ballast water according to Permit Condition S1.B.

b The maximum daily effluent limit means the highest allowable daily discharge. The daily

discharge means the discharge of a pollutant measured during a ca lendar day. For pollutants with limits expressed in units of mass, the daily discharge is calculated as the total mass of the pollutant discharged over the day. For other units of measurement, t he daily discharge is the average measurement of the polluta nt over the day. Additional allocation may be permitted for stormwater runoff and ballast water according to Permit Condition S1.B.

c Continuous means uninterrupted except for brief lengths of time for calibration, for power

failure, or for necessary equ ipment repair or maintenance. With the exception of pH, the Permittee must sample every 4 hours when continuous monitoring is not possible. 24

- hour composite means a series of individual samples collected over a 24

- hour period into a single container and analyzed as one sample. Grab means an individual sample collected over a fifteen (15)

- minute or less period.

d The monitoring frequencies for these parameters have been reduced as a result of consistent

performance well below the permit limits. Should the treatment performance deteriorate Ecology may increase the monitoring frequencies to the levels required in the previous permit (COD 7/7 and BOD 2 /7). Ecology will notify the Permittee by letter to increase monitoring upon determination of deteriorat ing performance.

e Indicates the range of permitted values. Any excursions below 5.0 and above 10.0 at any

time are violations. The instantaneous maximum and minimum pH must be reported in the monthly. Do not average pH values. When pH is continuo usly monitored, excursions between 5.0 and 6.0, or 9.0 and 10.0 are not considered violations provided no single excursion exceeds 60 minutes in length and total excursions do not exceed 7 hours and 30 minutes per month.

f If pH data from the continuo us monitor is unavailable, pH monitoring must consist of hourly

grab samples

.

g The average daily crude throughput must be reported in the monthly DMR.

h The Permittee must sample the final effluent (Outfall 001) annually and analyze the samp le

for the priority pollutants and other pollutants listed in Appendix B. See Appendix B for required detection (DL) or quantitation (QL) levels. The detection limit and the method must conform to those listed. The Permittee must submit the results of t hese analyses to Ecology within 90 days of each sampling event. List the data in tabular form with the method, detection limit, and the measured value including units. The PCBs and pesticides listed in Appendix B are not required to be tested for unless they are used at the refinery.

B. Ballast and Stormwater Allocations (Outfall 001)

The Permittee is authorized to discharge additional amounts of the following parameters based on stormwater and ballast water flow through Outfall 001. The
Permittee must determine ballast water volume by gauging the ballast water storage
tanks. Report the cumulative monthly ballast water volume with the DMR if thePage 10 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

ballast allocation is not used. If the ballast water allocation is used then the
Permittee must submit with the DMR a report showing the daily volume of ballast
water released to the w astewater system for treatment.

The Permittee must determine the storm water flow rate as the difference between total measured effluent through Outfall No. 001 and the sum of ball ast water plus the average dry weather flow rate . The average dry weather flow is hereby
established as 2 .7 MGD

. The Permittee may only use the maximum daily storm water allocation on those storm water flow days when the base limits from S1
above are exc eeded. During the summer months of June through October the
Permittee may only claim the storm water allocation for the maximum daily
value when it can demonstrate that measurable rainfall has occurred at the refinery site during the previous 10 calendar days

. If rainfall data on

- site is unavailable due to equipment malfunction, data from nearby rainfall gauging
stations can be used. Report the stormwater allocation for each day it is used for the parameters below.

Parameter Ballast Water Allocation: O utfall #001 Stormwater Allocation: Outfall #001

Average Monthly Maximum Daily Average Monthly Maximum Daily

Pounds/Million Gallons

Biochemical Oxygen Demand (5

- Day) 210 400 220 400

Chemical Oxygen Demand 2000 3900 1500 3000

Total Suspended Solids 1 70 260 180 280

Oil and Grease 67 126 67 130

Phenolic Compounds N/A N/A 1.4 2.9

Storm water flow is equal to the amount of flow in excess of the established dry weather flow plus ballast water. For the months of June through October, qualifying storm w ater flow days are only those days when measurable rainfall occurred at the refinery site during the previous 10 calendar days. Average Monthly Stormwater Allocation (AMSWA) is defined as the sum of storm water flows from qualifying storm water flow days sampled divided by the number of qualifying days times the average monthly allocation for that parameter. The Total Average Monthly Limit (T) is the sum of the base average monthly limit (B) (listed in Condition S1

. A

. ) plus the Average Monthly Stormwater Allocation (listed
in Condition S1.B

. ) T = B + AMSWA

. (An example calculation is shown in Appendix B )

.Page 11 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

C

. Emergency Overflow (Outfall 003)

Beginning on the effective date of this permit, the Permittee is authorized to discharge treated waste water from Outfall 003 during extreme rainfall events when the capacity of the retention pond is exceeded. The treated waste water must be monitored for the parameters at the frequencies listed below.

The Permittee must notify Ecology of any discharges under thi s subsection within 24 hours of such an event and submit the results of monitoring in the monthly discharge monitoring report. Outside of normal working hours, voice mail notification of the Industrial Section responsible engineer, shall meet the requirem ent

.

The discharge shall not violate Chapter 173

- 201A WAC Water Quality Standards for Surface Waters of the State of Washington. The sum total of the monitoring
results for discharges from O utfalls 00 1 and 00 3 for any given day or month shall
not violate t he effluent limits specified in C ondition S1 .A. of this permit.

Parameter Outfall 003

(final effluent) Monitoring Frequency Sample Type a,b

pH X Once/event grab

Total Suspended Solids X Once/event composite

Biochemical Oxygen Demand (5

- day) X Once/event composite

Chemical Oxygen Demand X Once/event composite

Oil & Grease X Once/event grab

Phenols X Once/event composite

Flow measurement X Once/event Engineering
Estimate

a S torm water and/or final effluent samples shall be collected from the outfall or an active

representative d rain acce ss point nearest the outfall.

b Composite means samples collected with a composite sampler or one sample collected

every hour of discharge into a single container and analyzed as one sample

. Grab means an individu al sample collected over a fifteen (15)

- minute or less period.

c Volatile organics include benzene, naphthalene, 1,2,4

- trimethlybenzene, isopropylbenzene,

p

- isopropylbenzene, ethylbenzene, propylbenzene, 1,3,5

- trimethylbenzen e, toluene, and total xylenes.

d BNAs include phenanthrene, fluorene, naphthalene, 2

- methylnaphthalene, 2

- methylphenol,

benzyl alcohol, 2,4

- dimethylphenol, and 4

- methylphenol.Page 12 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

D

. Mixing Zone Authorization

MIXING ZONE FOR OUTFALL 001:

The following paragraphs define the maximum bounda ries or flow

- volume restriction of the mixing zones:

Chronic Mixing Zone

The mixing zone is a circle with radius of 225 feet measured from the center of each discharge port. The mixing zone extends from the seabed to the top of the
water surface. The con centration of pollutants at the edge of the chronic zone must meet chronic aquatic life criteria and human health criteria

.

Acute Mixing Zone

The acute mixing zone is a circle with radius of 2 3 feet measured from the center of each discharge port. The mixi ng zone extends from the seabed to the top of the
water surface. The concentration of pollutants at the edge of the acute zone must meet acute aquatic life criteria

.

Available Dilution

Acute Aquatic Life Criteria 1 8 Chronic Aquatic Life Criteria 9 1
Human Health Criteria

- Carcinogen 9 3
Human Health Criteria

- Non

- carcinogen 9 1

E

. Tesoro Logistics Operations LLC (TLO) Wastewater

The Permittee is authorized to receive untreated wastewater from the Tesoro Logistics Operations LLC Crude Rai l Off

- loading Facility ( CROF ), LPG Railcar Rack, Light Products Truck Rack, and Shore Crude Storage Tanks for treatment in the Permittee’s wastewater treatment system. The untreated wastewaters must consist only of:

• C ROF unloading platform drain sump wate r

• CROF rail car wash water

• TLO LPG Railcar and Truck Rack oily water /stormwater drain system

• Crude Storage Tank water draws and secondary containment stormwater

The permit does not authorize the Permitee to treat s anitary wastewater from TLO
at the Permitt ee’s wastewater treatment facility or the discharge of these wastewater
streams in to the Permittee’s outfall line.Page 13 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

The discharge from TLO to the Permittee’s wastewater treatment system is subject
to the terms and conditions of S tate W aste D ischarge P ermit No. ST0045528

.

S2. MONITORING REQUIREMENTS

A

. Monitoring Schedule

The Permittee must monitor in accordance with the schedules specified for the final effluent and stormwater discharges in Permit Condition S1 and the requirements specified in Appendix B.

B

. Sampling and Analytical Procedures

Samples and measurements taken to meet the requirements of this permit must represent the volume and nature of the monitored parameters, including representative sampling of any unusual discharge or discharge conditio n, including bypasses, upsets, and maintenance

- related conditions affecting effluent quality.

After a portion of the daily sample is removed for the Permittee’s analysis, the remainder, 2

- 3 gallons (minimum) must be retained until 3:00 pm of the following day. The composite sample must be kept refrigerated at or below 6 o C in the dark during collection and storage. On days when the discharge occurs over a period of time too short to collect sufficient sample for testing and retainage, hourly grab samples can be used to provide sufficient volume for testing and retainage

.

Sampling and analytical methods used to meet the monitoring requirements specified in this permit must conform to the latest revision of the Guidelines Establishing Test Procedures for the Analysis of Pollutants contained in 40 CFR

Part 136

.

C

. Flow Measurement , Field Measurement

, and Continuous Monitoring Devices

The Permittee must:

1. Select and use appropriate flow measurement, field measurement, and continuous monitoring devices and met hods consistent with accepted scientific practices.

2. Install, calibrate, and maintain these devices to ensure the accuracy of the measurements is consistent with the accepted industry standard and the manufacturer’s recommendation for that type of device.

3. C alibrate continuous monitoring instruments weekly unless it can be demonstrated a longer period is sufficient based on monitoring records. The Permittee must calibrate continuous pH measurement instruments using a grab sample analyzed in the lab with a pH meter calibrated with standard buffers and analyzed within 15 minutes of sampling.

4. If the Permittee uses micro

- recording temperature devices known as thermistors it must calibrate the devices using protocols from Ecology’s Quality Assurance Project Plan D evelopment Tool ( Continuous TemperaturePage 14 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Sampling Protocols for the Environmental Monitoring and Trends ). This
document is available online at : http://www.ecy.wa.gov/programs/eap/qa/docs/QAPPtool/Mod6%20Ecology% 20SOPs/Protocols/ContinuousTemperatureSamplin g.pdf. Calibration as specified in this document is not required if the Permittee uses recording devices which are certified by the manufacturer.
5. Use field measurement devices as directed by the manufacturer and do not use reagents beyond their expiration dates.

6. Calibrate these devices at the frequency recommended by the manufacturer.

7. Calibrate flow monitoring devices at a minimum frequency of at least one calibration per year.

8. Maintain calibration records for at least three years.

D

. Laboratory Accredita tion

The Permittee must ensure that the laboratory it uses to perform analyses required by Ecology is registered or accredited under the provisions of chapter 173

- 50 WAC, Accreditation of Environmental Laboratories. Flow, temperature, settleable solids, c onductivity, pH, and internal process control parameters are exempt from this requirement. The Permittee must obtain accreditation for pH if it must receive accreditation or registration for other parameters. Crops and soils data are process control para meters which do not require preparation by an accredited laboratory. However, the Permittee must obtain this data from a reputable agricultural test lab that is an active participant in a nationally recognized agricultural laboratory proficiency testing p rogram.

S3. REPORTING AND RECORDKEEPING REQUIREMENTS

The Permittee must monitor and report in accordance with the following conditions. Falsification of information submitted to Ecology is a violation of the terms and conditions of this permit.

A. Reporting

The first monitoring period begins on the effective date of the permit. The
Permittee must:

1. Summarize, report, and submit monitoring data obtained during each monitoring period on the electronic Discharge Monitoring Report (DMR) form provided by Ecology within W Q WebDMR. Include data for each of the parameters tabulated in Special Condition S2 and as required by the form. Report a value for each day sampling occurred (unless specifically exempted in the permit) and for the summary values (when applicable ) in cluded on the
electronic form.

To find out more information and to sign up for W Q WebDMR go to: http://www.ecy.wa.gov/program s/wq/permits/paris/webdmr.htmlPage 15 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

2. Enter the “no discharge” reporting code for an entire DMR, for a specific monitoring point, or f or a specific parameter as appropriate, if the Permittee did not discharge wastewater or a specific pollutant dur ing a given monitoring period.

3. Report single analytical values below detection as “less than the detection level (DL)” by entering < followed b y the numeric value of the detection level (e.g. < 2.0) on the DMR. If the method used did not meet the minimum DL and quantitation level (QL) identified in the permit, report the actual QL and
DL in the commen ts or in the location provided.

4. Report the test method used for analysis in the comments if the laboratory used an alternative method not specified in the permit and as allowed in Appendix B or S2.

5. Calculate average values (unless otherwise specified in the permit) using:

a. The reported numeric value for all parameters measured between the

agency

- required detection value and the agen cy

- required quantitation
value.

b. One

- half the detection value (for values reported below detection) if the lab detected the parameter in another sample for the reporting pe riod.

c. Zero (for values reported below detection) if the lab did not detect the parameter in another sample for the reporting period.

6. Report single

- sample grouped parameters (for example priority pollutants, PAHs, pulp and paper chlorophenolics, TTOs) on th e W Q WebDMR form and include: sample date, concentration detected, detection limit (DL) (as necessary), and laboratory quantitation level (QL) (as necessary). The Permittee must also submit an electronic PDF copy of the laboratory report using W Q WebDMR.

T he laboratory report must include the following information: date sampled, sample location, date of analysis, parameter name, CAS number, analytical method/number, detection limit (DL), laboratory quantitation level (QL), reporting units, and concentration detected.

The contract laboratory reports must also include information on the chain of custody, QA/QC results, and documentation of accreditation for the
parameter.

7. Ensure that DMRs are electronically submitted no later than the dates specified below, unless other wise specified in this permit.

8. Submit DMRs for parameters with the monitoring frequencies specified in S2 (monthly, quarterly, annual, etc.) at the reporting schedule identified below.
The Permittee must:

a. Submit monthly DMRs by the 15 th day of the following month.Page 16 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

b. Submit semi

- annual DMRs, unless otherwise specified in the permit, by July 15 and January 15 of each year. Semiannyal sampling periods are January through June, and July through December.

c. Submit annual DMRs, unless otherwise specifie d by the permit, by January 15 for the previous calendar year. The annual sampling period is the calendar year.

9. The Permittee must use the Water Quality Permitting Portal

– Permi t Submittals application to submit all other written permit

- required letter

, plans

, and reports by the date specified in the permit.

When another permit condition requires submittal of a paper plan or report, the Permittee must ensure that is postmarked or received by Ecology no later than the date specified by the permit. Sen d these paper plans or reports to Ecology at:

Department of Ecology
Industrial Section

PO Box 47600 Olympia, WA 98504

- 7600

B. Records R etention

The Permittee must retain records of all monitoring information for a minimum of three (3) years. Such inf ormation must include all calibration and maintenance records and all original recordings for continuous monitoring instrumentation, copies of all reports required by this permit, and records of all data used to complete the application for this permit. Th e Permittee must extend this period of retention during the course of any unresolved litigation regarding the discharge of pollutants by the Permittee or when requested by Ecology.

C. Recording of R esults

For each measurement or sample taken, the Permitt ee must record the following
information:

1. The date, exact place, method, and time of sampling or measurement

2. The individual who performed the sampling or measurement

3. The dates the analyses were performed

4. The individual who performed the analyses

5. The anal ytical techniques or methods used

6. The results of all analysesPage 17 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

D. Additional M onitoring by the Permittee

If the Permittee monitors any pollutant more frequently than required by Special Condition S2 of this permit, then the Permittee must include the resul ts of such monitoring in the calculation and reporting of the data submitted in the Permittee's DMR unless otherwise specified by Special Condition S2.

E. Reporting Permit V iolations

The Permittee must take the following actions when it violates or is unab le to comply with any permit condition:

1. Immediately take action to stop, contain, and cleanup unauthorized discharges or otherwise stop the noncompliance and correct the problem.

2. If applicable, immediately repeat sampling and analysis. Submit the results of any repeat sampling to Ecology within thirty (30) days of sampling.

a. Immediate reporting

The Permittee must immediately report to Ecology and the Department of Health, Shellfish Program (at the numbers listed below), all:

• Failures of the disinfection system.

• Collection system overflows discharging to marine surface waters.

• Plant bypasses discharging to marine surface waters.

Northwest Regional Office 425

- 649

- 7000 Department of Health, Shellfish Program 360

- 236

- 3330 (business hours)

360

- 789

- 8962 (aft er business hours)

The Permittee must also notify the Ecology In dustrial Section permit manager by telephone for any of the above situations. Outside of normal working hours, a voice mail notification to the Industrial Section permit manager or their designated backup will meet this requirement.

b. Twenty

- four

- hour reporting

The Permittee must report the following occurrences of noncompliance by telephone, to Ecology at the telephone numbers listed above , within 24 hours
from the time the Permittee be comes aware of any of the following
circumstances:

1. Any noncompliance that may endanger health or the environment, unless previously reported under immediate reporting requirements.

2. Any unanticipated bypass that causes an exceedance of any effluent
limit in the permit (See Part S4.B., “Bypass Procedures”).

3. Any upset that causes an exceedance of an effluent limit in the permit (See G.15, “Upset”).Page 18 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

4. Any violation of a maximum daily or instantaneous maximum discharge limit for any of the pollutants in Section S1 .A of this permit.

5. Any overflow prior to the treatment works, whether or not such overflow endangers health or the environment or exceeds any effluent limit in the permit.

c. Report within five days

The Permittee must also submit a written report within f ive days of the time that the Permittee becomes aware of any reportable event under subparts a or b, a bove. The report must contain:

1. A description of t he noncompliance and its cause.

2. The period of noncompliance, including exact dates and times.

3. The estima ted time the Permittee expects the noncompliance to continue if not yet corrected.

4. Steps taken or planned to reduce, eliminate, and prevent recurrence of the noncompliance.

5. If the noncompliance involves an overflow prior to the treatment works, an estimate of the quantity (in gallons) of untreated overflow.

d. Waiver of written reports

Ecology may waive the written report required in subpart c, above, on a

case

- by

- case basis upon request if the Permittee has submitted a timely oral
report.

e. All other perm it violation reporting

The Permittee must report all permit violations, which do not require immediate or within 24 hours reporting, when it submits monitoring reports for S3.A ("Reporting"). The reports must contain the information listed in subpart

c, a bove. Compliance with these requirements does not relieve the Permittee from responsibility to maintain continuous compliance with the terms and conditions of this permit or the resulting liability for failure to comply.

f. Report Submittal

The Permittee must submit report s to the address listed in Condition S3.

F. Other R eporting

1

. Spills of Oil or Hazardous Materials

The Permittee must report a spill of oil or hazardous materials in accordance with the requirements of RCW 90.56.280 and chapter 173

- 303

- 1 45. You can obtain further instructions at the following website: http://www.ecy.wa.gov/programs/spills/other/reportaspill.htm.

2

. Failure to submit relevant or correct factsPage 19 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Where the Permittee becomes aware that it failed to submit any relevant facts

i n a permit application, or submitted incorrect information in a permit application, or in any report to Ecology, it must submit such facts or information promptly.

3

. Submitting a new application

The Permittee must submit a new application or supplement at least one hundred eighty (180) days prior to commencement of discharges, resulting from the activities listed in the following, which may result in permit violations. These activities include: any facility expansions, production increases, or other plann ed changes, such as process modificatio ns, in the permitted facility.

4

. Process modifications

The permitee must, as soon as possible, but no later than thirty (30) days prior to the proposed changes, give notice to ecology of a process modification
which will result in the installation of process units or new equipment in existing process units that could cause material change in the quantity or composition of the influent processed by the waste water treatment system.

G. Mainta ining a Copy of this P ermit

The Permittee must keep a copy of this permit at the facility and make it available upon request to Ecology inspectors.

S4. OPERATION AND MAINTE NANCE

The Permittee must , at all times, properly operate and maintain all industrial wastewater
and stormwater facilities or systems of treatment and control (and related appurtenances) which are installed to achieve compliance with the terms and conditions of this permit. Proper operation and maintenance includes adequate laboratory controls and appropriate qual ity assurance procedures. This provision requires the operation of
back

- up or auxiliary facilities or similar systems, which are installed by a Permittee when the operation is necessary to achieve compliance with the conditions of this permit.

A. Operations and Maintenance Manual

The Permittee must:

1. Maintain and follow the Operations and Maintenance (O&M) Manual for the wastewater treatment plant

. 2. Review and update the O&M Manual when changes occur at the refinery that significantly affect the volume or char acter of the wastewater processed by the wastewater treatment plant.

3. Confirm this review by letter to Ecology

. 4. Keep the approved O&M Manual at the permitted facility

.Page 20 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

In addition to the requirements of WAC 173

- 240

- 150, the O&M manual must
include:

1. Emerg ency procedures for plant shutdown and cleanup in event of wastewater system upset or failure.

2. Procedures to maintain treatment efficiency during scheduled maintenance operations at the w astewater treatment plant.

For the purposes of this NPDES permit, a Treatment System Operating Plan (TSOP) is a concise summary of specifically defined elements of the O&M
Manual. The TSOP must not conflict with the O&M Manual and must include the following information:

1. A baseline operating condition, which describes the operating parameters and procedures, u sed to meet the effluent limits in Condition S1 at the production levels used in developing these limits.

2. The plan must describe the operating procedures and conditions needed to maintain treatment efficiency at less t han design loading conditions.

3. In the event of an upset, due to plant maintenance activities, severe stormwater events, start ups or shut downs, or other causes, the plan must describe the operating procedures and conditions e mployed to mitigate the
upset.
4. A description of any regularly scheduled maintenance or repair activities at the facility which would significantly affect the volume or character of the wastes discharged to the wastewater treatment system and a plan for treating/controlling the discharg e of maintenance

- related materials (such as cleaners, degreasers, solvents, etc.).

The Permittee must submit an updated Treatment System Operating Plan to Ecology with the permit renewal application . This pla n must be updated and
submitted to Ecology, as necessary during the permit term, to include requirements for any major modifications to the wastewater treatment system.

B. Bypass Procedures

This permit prohibits a bypass which is the intentional diversion of waste streams from any portion of a treatme nt facility. Ecology may take enforcement action against a Permittee for a bypass unless one of the following circumstances (1, 2, or 3) applies.

1. Bypass for Essential Maintenance without the Potential to Cause Violation of
Permit Limits or Conditions.

Bypass is authorized if it is for essential maintenance and does not have the potential to cause violations of limitations or other conditions of this permit, or adversely impact public health as determined by Ecology prior to the bypass.Page 21 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

The Permittee m ust submit prior notice, if possible, at least ten (10) days before the date of the bypass. Notice is not required where redundant equipment is available to perform the functions of equipment scheduled for bypass during maintenance.

2. Bypass Which is Una voidable, Unanticipated, and Results in Noncompliance
of this Permit.

This bypass is permitted only if:

a

. Bypass is unavoidable to prevent loss of life, personal injury, or severe property damage. “Severe property damage” means substantial physical damage to property, damage to the treatment facilities which would cause them to become inoperable, or substantial and permanent loss of natural resources which can reasonably be expected to occur in the absence of a bypass.

b. No feasible alternatives to the by pass exist, such as:

• The use of auxiliary treatment facilities.

• Retention of untreated wastes.

• Stopping production.

• Maintenance during normal periods of equipment downtime, but not if the Permittee should have installed adequate backup equipment in the

exe rcise of reasonable engineerin g judgment to prevent a bypass.

• Transport of untreated wastes to another treatment facility or preventative maintenance), or transport of untreated wastes to another treatment facility.

c. Ecology is properly notified of the bypa ss as required in condition S3E of this permit.

3. If bypass is anticipated and has the potential to result in noncompliance of this permit.

a. The Permittee must notify Ecology at least thirty (30) days before the planned date of by pass. The notice must contai n:

• A description of the bypass and its cause.

• An analysis of all known alternatives which would eliminate, reduce, or

m itigate the need for bypassing.

• A cost

- effectiveness analysis of alternatives including comparat ive

resource damage assessment.

• The mini mum and maximum duration of bypass under each alternative.

• A recommendation as to the preferred alterna tive for conducting the

bypass.

• The proje cted date of bypass initiation.Page 22 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

• A sta tement of compliance with SEPA.

• A request for modification of water quality standards as provided for in

WAC 173

- 201A

- 410, if an exceedance of any water q uality standard is anticipated.

• D etails of the steps taken or planned to reduce, eliminate, and prevent

reoccurrence of the bypass.

b. For probable construction bypasses, the Perm ittee must notify Ecology of the need to bypass as early in the planning process as possible. The Permittee must consider the analysis required above during preparation of the engineering report or facilities plan and plans and specifications and
must inc lude these to the extent practical. In cases where the Permittee determines the probable need to bypass early, the Permittee must continue to analyze conditions up to and including the construction period in an effort to minimize or eliminate the bypass.

c. Ecology will consider the following prior to issuing an administrative order for this type of bypass:

• If the bypass is necessary to perform construction or maintenance

- related activities essential to meet the requirements of this permit.

• If feasible altern atives to bypass exist, such as the use of auxiliary treatment facilities, retention of untreated wastes, stopping production, maintenance during normal periods of equipment down time, or transport of untreated wastes to another treatment facility.

• If the Permittee planned and scheduled the bypass to minimize adverse effects on the public and the environment.

After consideration of the above and the adverse effects of the proposed bypass and any other relevant factors, Ecology will approve or deny the requ est. Ecology will give the public an opportunity to comment on bypass incidents of significant duration, to the extent feasible. Ecology will approve a request to bypass by issuing
an administra tive order under RCW 90.48.120.

C. Duty to Mitigate

The Perm ittee is required to take all reasonable steps to minimize or prevent any discharge or sludge use or disposal in violation of this permit that has a reasonable likelihood of adversely affecting human health or the environment.

S5. FACILITY LOADING

A. Design Criteria

The f lows or waste loads for the permitted facility must not exceed the following design
criteria :Page 23 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Process Wastewater treatment plant capacity (prior to commingling with non

process area stormwater)

Average monthly flow for the maximum
month 1 4 .3 MGD

Average monthly COD for the maximum
month 2 1700 mg/l

1 as measured at the secondary clarifier

2 as measured at the primary clarifier

B. Plans for Maintaining Adequate Capacity

The Permittee must submit to Ecology a plan and a schedule for continuing to maintain capacity when:

1. The actual flow or waste load reaches 85 percent of any one of the design criteria
in S 5 .A for three consecutive months; or

2. The projected increase would reach design capacity within five years,
whichever occurs first.

If such a plan is required, it must contain provisions and a schedule for continuing to maintain capacity. The capacity as outlined in this plan must be sufficient to achieve the effluent limitations and other conditions of this permit. The plan must address th e following actions and any others necessary to meet the objective of maintaining capacity.

1. Analysis of the present design including the introduction of any process modifications that would affect the ability of the existing facility to achieve
effluent l imits and other requirements of this permit at levels in excess of the existing design criteria specified in paragraph A, above.

2. Reduction or elimination of excessive infiltration and inflow into the sewer
system.

3. Limitation on future additional waste lo ads.

4. Modification or expansion of facilities necessary to accommodate increased flow
or waste load.

Engineering documents associated with the plan must meet the requirements of WAC

173

- 240

- 060, "Engineering Report," and be approved by Ecology prior to any construction.Page 24 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

S 6

. NON

- ROUTINE AND UNANTICI PATED DISCHARG ES

A. Beginning on the effective date of this permit, the Permittee may discharge non

routine wastewater or clean water such as storage tank hydro test water or fire
system test water from outfalls 001, 002, 003, or 004 on a case

- by

- case basis if approved by Ecology . Prior to any such discharge, the Permittee must contact Ecology and at a minimum provide the following information:

1. The proposed discharge location.

2. The nature of the activity that wil l generate the discharge.

3. Any alternatives to the discharge, such as reuse, storag e, or recycling of the

water.

4. The total volume of water it expects to discharge.

5. The results of the chemical analysis of the water. The Permittee must analyze
the water fo r all constituents normally monitored for the discharge. The analysis must also include hardness, any metals that are limited by water quality standards, and any other parameter deemed necessary by Ecology. All discharges must comply with the effluent li mits as established in Condition S1. of this permit, water quality standards, and any other limits imposed by Ecology

.

6. The date of proposed discharge.

7. The expected rate of discharge discharged, in gallons per minute. The Permittee must limit the discharg e rate so it will not cause erosion of ditches or structural damage to culverts and their entrances or exits.

B. The discharge cannot proceed until Ecology has reviewed the information provided and has authorized the discharge by email/ letter to the Permittee or by an
Administrative Order.

S 7

. ACUTE TOXICITY

A. Effluent Limit for Acute Toxicity

The effluent limit for acute toxicity is:

No acute toxicity detected in a test concentration representing the acute critical effluent concentration (ACEC).

The ACEC means the maximum concentration of effluent during critical conditions at the boundary of the acute mixing zone, defined in Section S1.G of this permit. The ACEC equals 5 % effluent.Page 25 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

B. Compliance With the Effluent Limit for Acute Toxicity

Compliance with the effluent limit for acute toxicity means the results of the testing specified in subsection C. show no statistically significant difference in survival
be tween the control and the ACEC.

If the test results show a statistically significant difference in survival between the control and the ACEC, the test does not comply with the effluent limit for acute toxicity. The Permittee must then immediately conduct the additional testing described in subsection D. The Permittee will comply with the requirements of this section by meeting the requirements of subsection D.

The Permittee must determine the statistical significance by conducting a hypothesis test at the 0.05 level of significance (Appendix H, EPA/600/4

- 89/001).
If the difference in survival between the control and the ACEC is less than 10%, the Permittee must conduct the hypothesis test at the 0.01 level of significance.

C. Compliance Testing for Acute Toxicity

The Permittee must:

1. Begin quarterly compliance testing by _____________(within 90 days of permit
effective date . Perform the acute toxicity tests with 100% effluent, the ACEC, and a control, or with a full dilution series using each of the species and protocols listed below on a rotating basis

. (Quarters: January

- March, April

June, July

- Septemb er, October

- December)

2. Submit a written report of all test results to Ecology through the Water Quality Permitting Portal

– Permit Submittals application within sixty (60) days after each sample date.

Acute Toxicity Tests Species M ethod

Topsmelt 96

- hour st atic

- renewal test Atherinops affinis EPA

- 821

- R

- 02

- 012

Mysid 48

- hour static test Americamysis bahia EPA

- 821

- R

- 02

- 012

D. Response to Noncompliance with the Effluent Limit for Acute Toxicity

If a toxicity test conducted under subsection C. determines a s tatistically significant difference in response between the ACEC and the control, using the statistical test described in subsection B., the Permittee must begin additional testing within one week from the time of receiving the test results. The Permittee

must:

1. Conduct one additional test each week for four consecutive weeks, using the same test and species as the failed compliance test.Page 26 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

2. Test at least five effluent concentrations and a control to determine appropriate point estimates. One of these effluent con centrations must equal the ACEC. The results of the test at the ACEC will determine compliance with the effluent limit for acute toxicity as described in Subsection B.

3. Return to the original monitoring frequency in Subsection C. after completion of the additional compliance monitoring.

Anomalous test results : If a toxicity test conducted under subsection C. indicates noncompliance with the acute toxicity limit and the Permittee believes that the test
result is anom alous, the Permittee may notify Ecology that they believe the compliance test result is anomalous. The Permittee should conduct one additional test then wait for notification from Ecology before completing the additional testing required above. The Permit tee must submit the notification with the report of the compliance test result and identify the reason for considering the complianc e test
result to be anomalous.

If Ecology determines that the test result was not anomalous, the Permittee must complete all of the additional monitoring required in this subsection. Or,

If the one additional test fails to comply with the effluent limit for acute toxicity, then the Permittee must complete all of the additional monitoring required in this subsection. Or,

If Ec ology determines that the test result was anomalous, the one additional test result will replace the anomalous test result.

If all of the additional testing complies with the permit limit, the Permittee must submit a report to Ecology on possible causes an d preventive measures for the transient toxicity event, which triggered the additional compliance monitoring. This report must be based upon a review of all pertinent and recent facility records, including:

1. Operating records

2. Monitoring results

3. Inspection records

4. Spill reports
5. Weather records

6. Production records

7. Raw material purchases

8. Pretreatment records, etc.

If any toxicity test conducted under subsection D .1. shows a statistically significant difference in response between the ACEC and the control, usin g the statistical test
described in subsection B ., then the test result is a violation of the permit. The Permittee must submit a Toxicity Identification/Reduction Evaluation (TI/RE) plan to Ecology within 60 days after the sample date [WAC 173

- 205

- 100(2)]

.Page 27 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

E

. Sampling and Reporting Requirements

1

. The Permittee must submit all reports for toxicity testing in accordance with the most recent version of Department of Ecology Publication # WQ

- R

- 95

- 80, Laboratory Guidance and Whole Effluent Toxicity Test Revie w Criteria. Reports must contain bench sheets and reference toxicant results for test
methods. In addition, the Permittee must submit toxicity test data in electronic format (CETIS export file preferred) for entry into Ecology’s database

.

2. The Permitte e must collect 24

- hour composite effluent samples or grab samples for toxicity testing. The Permittee must cool the samples to 0

- 6 degrees Celsius during collection and send them to the lab immediately upon completion. The lab must begin the toxicity t esting as soon as possible but no later than 36 hours after sampling was completed.

3. The laboratory must conduct water quality measurements on all samples and test solutions for toxicity testing, as specified in the most recent version of Department of E cology Publication # WQ

- R

- 95

- 80, Laboratory Guidance and Whole Effluent Toxicity Test Review Criteria

.

4. All toxicity tests must meet quality assurance criteria and test conditions specified in the most recent versions of the EPA methods listed in subsect ion C. and Ecology of Ecology Publication # WQ

- R

- 95

- 80, Laboratory Guidance and Whole Effluent Toxicity Test Review Criteria . If Ecology determines any test results to be invalid or anomalous, the Permittee must repeat the testing with freshly collected e ffluent.

5. The laboratory must use control water and dilution water meeting the requirements of the EPA methods listed in subsection C

. or pristine natural water of sufficient quality for good control performance.

6. The Permittee must conduct whole efflu ent toxicity tests on an unmodified sample of final effluent.

7. The Permittee may choose to conduct a full dilution series test during compliance testing in order to determine dose response. In this case, the series
must have a minimum of five effluent c oncentrations and a control. The series of concentrations must include the acute critical effluent concentration (ACEC). The ACEC equals 5 % effluent.

8. All whole effluent toxicity tests, effluent screening tests, and rapid screening
tests that involve hypothesis testing must comply with the acute statistical power standard of 29% as defined in WAC 173

- 205

- 020. If the test does not meet the power standard, the Permittee must repeat the test on a fresh sample with an increased number of replicates to inc rease the power.Page 28 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

9. Reports of individual characterization or compliance test results must be submitted to Ecology within 60 days after completion of the test

.

S 8

. CHRONIC TOXICITY

A. Testing when t here i s No Permit Limit for Chronic Toxicity

The Permitt ee must:

1. Conduct chronic toxicity testing on final effluent once in the last summer
and once in the last winter prior to submission of the permit renewal application

.

2. Submit the results to Ecology through the Water Quality Permitting Portal

– Permit Submit tals application by __________( with the permit renewal application )

.

3. Conduct chronic toxicity testing on a series of at least five concentrations of
effluent and a control. This series of dilutions must include the acute critical effluent concentration (A CEC). The ACEC equals 5 % effluent.

4. Compare the ACEC to the control using hypothesis testing at the 0.05 level of significance as described in Appendix H, EPA/600/4

- 89/001.

5. Perform chronic toxicity tests with all of the following species and the most

recen t version of the following protocols:

Saltwater Chronic Test Species Method

Topsmelt 7

- day survival and growth Atherinops affinis EPA/600/R

- 95/136

Echinoderm embryo

- larval development test Strongylocentrotus Purpuratus or Dendraster
excentricus EPA/600/R

- 95/136

The laboratory must conduct the sea urchin and sand dollar (echinoderm) test in
accordance with EPA/600/R

- 95/136 and the echinoderm development test conditions in the most recent version of Ecology Publication No. WQ

- R

- 95

- 80, Laboratory Guidance and Whole Effluent Toxicity Test Review Criteria . The laboratory must use whichever one of the two species that will give a valid result in each particular test.Page 29 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

B

. Sampling and Reporting Requirements

1. The Permittee must submit all reports for toxicity testing in accordance with the most recent version of Ecology Publication # WQ

- R

- 95

- 80, Laboratory Guidance and Whole Effluent Toxicity Test Review Criteria . Reports must
contain bench sheets and reference toxicant results for test methods. In addition, the Permittee must submit toxicity test data in electronic format (CETIS export file preferred) for entry into Ecology’s database

.

2. The Permittee must collect 24

- hour composite effluent samples or grab samples
for toxicity testing. The Permittee must c ool the samples to 0

- 6 degrees Celsius during collection and send them to the lab immediately upon completion. The lab must begin the toxicity testing as soon as possible but no later than 36 hours after sampling was completed.

3. The laboratory must co nduct water quality measurements on all samples and test solutions for toxicity testing, as specified in the most recent version of Ecology Publication # WQ

- R

- 95

- 80, Laboratory Guidance and Whole Effluent Toxicity Test Review Criteria

.

4. All toxicity test s must meet quality assurance criteria and test conditions specified in the most recent versions of the EPA methods listed in subsection A

. and Ecology Publication # WQ

- R

- 95

- 80, Laboratory Guidance and Whole Effluent Toxicity Test Review Criteria . If Ecol ogy determines any test results to be invalid or anomalous, the Permittee must repeat the testing with freshly
collected effluent.

5. The laboratory must use control water and dilution water meeting the requirements of the EPA methods listed in subsection A . or pristine natural water of sufficient quality for good control performance.

6. The Permittee must conduct whole effluent toxicity tests on an unmodified sample of final effluent.

7. The Permittee may choose to conduct a full dilution series test durin g characterization in order to determine dose response. In this case, the series
must have a minimum of five effluent concentrations and a control. The series
of concentrations must include the Chronic Critical Effluent Concentration ( CCEC ) and the ACEC. The CCEC and the ACEC may either substitute for the
effluent concentrations that are closest to them in the dilution series or be extra
effluent concentrations. The CCEC means the maximum concentration of effluent during critical conditions at the bound ary of the mixing zone, defined in
Section S1. F . of this permit. The CCEC equals 1.1 % effluent. The ACEC equals 5 % effluent.Page 30 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

8. All whole effluent toxicity tests that involve hypothesis testing must comply with the chronic statistical power standard of 3 9% as defined in WAC 173

- 205

- 020. If the test does not meet the power standard, the Permittee must repeat the test on a fresh sample with an increased number of replicates to increase the

power.

9. Reports of individual characterization or compliance test results must be submitted to Ecology within 60 days after completion of the test.

S 9

. WASTEWATER TREATMENT EFFICIENCY STUDY AND UPDATED
ENGINEERING REPORT

Ecology will require a wastewater treatment efficiency study if the Permittee proposes
material and s ubstantial alterations to the refinery that could cause a material change in the quantity or composition of the influent processed by the wastewater treatment system. In the event that Ecology requires a treatment efficiency study, the Permittee
must prep are and submit a study plan for Ecology’s review and approval. The
Permittee must submit the plan within 90 days of startup of the material and substantial
alterations to the refinery.

In addition, the Permittee must update the engineering report for the wastewater treatment system to reflect the information from the new treatment efficiency study and compare the new conditions to predicted design capacities. The Permittee must submit
the update to Ecology for review and approval within 180 days after co mpletion of the treatment efficiency study

.

S1 0

. SEDIMENT MONITORING

The Permittee must submit a Sediment Sampling and Analysis Plan to recharacterize
sediment toxicity in the vicinity of Outfall 001 to Ecology for review and approval

. The Permittee must prepare the Sediment Sampling and Analysis Plan following the guidance provided in the Sediment Source Control Standards User Manual, Appendix B: Sediment Sampling and Analysis Plan (Ecology, 200 8 ) and current Puget Sound Estuary Program Protocols

.

A. The P ermittee must submit the Sediment Sampling and Analysis Plan (SAP) to Ecology for review and approval through the Water Quality Permitting Portal

– Permit Submittals application by ___________(within one year of the permit effective date). The Permittee m ust also submit two paper copies of the plan as required by Permit Condition S3.A.

B. The Permittee must perform sediment sampling during the first stable period (mid

August through mid

- September) following Ecology’s approval of the plan.

C. The Permittee must submit a Sediment Data Report containing the results of the sediment sampling and analysis no later than 180 days after completion of sampling but no later than _________(with the permit renewal application)

. The SedimentPage 31 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Data Report must also include ele ctronic copies of the sediment chemical and /or biological data formatted according to Ecology’s Environmental Information Management (EIM) System templates

.

S1 1

. POLLUTION PREVENTION

Pollution prevention planning and activities at the facility include t he :

• New pollution prevention projects identified for the upcoming permit cycle in the plan update

.

• Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs), Best Management Practices (BMPs), and work practices developed and updated from previous permit pollution plans,

stormw ater pollution prevention plans (SWPPPs), solid waste control plans, and spill plans.

The Permittee must continue to ensure proper operation and maintenance of the refinery process units and wastewater treatment system by following existing SOPs, BMPs, and work practices. The Permittee must continue or maintain these procedures and other

measures and / or facilities currently employed at the refinery to prevent or minimize the potential for release of pollutants to the wastewater treatment system, stormwater

, and/or waters of the state unless modified by the pollution prevention plan update required below.

Stormwater

Stormwater BMPs must:

• Provide all known, available, and reasonable methods of prevention, control, and treatment (AKART) of stormwater pollution

.

• Ensure the discharge does not cause or contribute to a violation of the Water Quality Standards.

• Comply with applicable federal technology

- based treatment requirements
under 40 CFR 125.3.

• Be consistent with the Stormwater Management Manual for Western

Wa shington (20 12 edition) or provide an equivalent level of pollution prevention approved by Ecology.

Solid Waste

The Permittee must handle and dispose of all solid waste material in such a manner as to prevent its entry into state ground or surface water. The Permittee must not allow leachate from its solid waste material to enter state waters without providing all known, available and reasonable methods of treatment, nor allow such leachate to cause violations of the State Surface Water Quality Standards, Chapter 173

- 201A WAC, orPage 32 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

the State Ground Water Quality Standards, Chapter 173

- 200 WAC. The Permittee must apply for a permit or permit modification as may be required for such discharges to state ground or surface waters.

Storage Tank Wastewater

The Perm ittee must remove wastewater from oil, product, and intermediate distillate storage tanks in a manner and with facilities as required to prevent the wastewater from draining or spilling onto the ground.

A. Pollution Prevention Plan Update and Implementatio n

The Permittee must update its Pollution Prevention Plan and submit it to Ecology for review and approval by ___________( within 180 days of the permit effective
date ) . The Permittee must implement the approved pollution prevention plan update and any app roved modifications to the plan and abide by the timeframes
identified thr oughout the term of the permit.

The objective of this update is to identify any new sources of pollutants, to reevaluate previously identified pollution prevention opportunities and to identify any new opportunities and implement those that are technically and economically achievable. Previously identified opportunities include those identified by the facility in their current Pollution Prevention plan and those identified in Ecology
Publication 02

- 07

- 017 (Water Pollution Prevention Opportunities in Petroleum Refineries). The update must also include an evaluation of the existing SOPs, BMPs, and work practices developed under previous pollution prevention planning/activities.

Specifi cally, the Permittee should evaluate the following pollution prevention opportunities: 1) lining the wastewater and stormwater treatment ponds, 2) increasing the removal efficiency of TSS in the wastewater and stormwater treatment trains, and 3) evaluating the potential to remove mercury, copper, and dioxin from the process wastewater.

B. Specific Plan Update Requirements

The P ermittee must update the following plan elements as necessary to address changes : the policy statement and signature, employee invol vement, training and awareness, descriptions of current pollution prevention activities, and the description of potential pollutants and sources. Appendix C includes references to guidance documents, specific items to be included in the plan, and procedur es for identifying, evaluating and prioritizing pollution prevention opportunities. Other information available to the Permittee may also be used in preparing the plan.

The updated plan must include a schedule for implementation of each newly selected oppo rtunity. If a detailed analysis of technical and economical feasibility for any pollution prevention opportunity will extend beyond the deadline for submitting the updated plan, the Permittee must include a schedule for completingPage 33 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

the analysis in the plan submittal. The timeframe for implementing any opportunities scheduled for further evaluation and then selected must be p rovided in the biennial report.

The Permittee must modify the plan if the Permittee or Ecology determine during inspections or inve stigations, that existing BMPs are, or would be, ineffective in eliminating or significantly minimizing pollutants in stormwater discharges from the site. The Permittee must modify the plan as necessary to include additional or modified BMPs designed to c orrect problems identified.

The Permitee must modify the plan whenever there is a change in design, construction, operation, or maintenance at the facility that significantly changes the nature of pollutants in wastewater or stormwater from the facility, s ignificantly increases the quantity of pollutants discharged, or causes the pollution prevention plan and existing SOPs, BMPs, or work practices to be less effective in controlling pollutants. The Permittee must provide for implementation of any modificat ions to the pollution prevention plan in a timely manner.

C

. Stormwater Inspections

The Permittee must conduct two stormwater inspections per year; one during the wet season (October 1

- April 30) and the other during the dry season (May 1

- September 30).

The Permittee must conduct the wet season inspection during a rainfall event and

must include observations of the presence of any floating materials, suspended solids, oil and grease, discolorations, turbidity, odor, etc. in stormwater runoff throughout t he refinery that could contr ibute to a discharge off

- site.

The dry season inspection must determine the presence of unpermitted non

stormwater discharges such as sanitary wastewater, non

- contact cooling water, process wastewater, and drainage from raw mate rial/product/waste storage to the stormwater drainage system . If an unpermitted, non

- stormwater discharge is discovered, the Permittee must immediately notify Ecology

.

Inspections must be conducted by personnel who are knowledgeable and trained in the app lication of BMPs and pollution prevention activities at the refinery. Results from the stormwater visual inspections must be reported in the pollution prevention plan biennial update reports.

D

. Biennial Reporting

The Permittee must periodically evaluate and modify, as necessary, the pollution prevention plan and existing SOPs, BMPs, and work practices to ensure that it has been updated or otherwise modified to reflect current conditions, that measures to reduce or eliminate pollutant loadings selected in the plan are adequate and are being properly implemented in accordance with the terms of the permit, and whether any a dditional controls are needed.Page 34 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

The Permittee must submit a biennial progress report by September 1 st (within 2 years after submittal of th e updated Pollution Prevention Plan required in Condition S12.A.) and every two years thereafter. The report must identify the implementation status of each pollution prevention opportunity selected, the benefits or other results of implementation actions completed, and any modifications or updates to the plan. The report must also include a summary of
the res ults of stormwater inspections.

E

. Continuous Improvement

In maintaining, implementing, and updating the pollution prevention plan, the
Permittee sh ould employ continuous improvement principles, including the systematic and ongoing identification, evaluation, and implementation of pollution prevention opportunities in all decisions having environmental consequences.

S1 2

. DIOXIN STUDY

A. Wastewater Sam pling

The Permittee must :

1. Sample the final effluent ( Outfall 001) and the upstream wastewater stream from the catalytic reformer unit for chlorinated dioxin and furan (2,3,7,8

- Cl
substituted tetra

- through octa

- congeners) concentrations twice during the

p ermit cycle.

2. Collect a grab sample of the caustic wash from the reformer unit during two different catalyst regeneration events

.

3. Conduct the analysis including sample containers and QA/QC in accordance
with Method 1613: Tetra

- through Octa

- Chlorinated Dio xins and Furans by Isotopic Dilution HRGC/HRMS, USEPA Office of Water, Engineering and Analysis Division, Revision A. The Minimum Level (ML) of detection for 2,3,7,8

- TCDD/TCDF must be 10 parts per quadrillion or less.

4. Report the lowest detected concentrat ions of all 2,3,7,8

- Cl substituted dioxins and furans that meet the quality assurance specifications of Method 1613, including all detected concentrations below the calibration limits of Method

1613

.

B. Dioxin Study Report

The Permittee must submit to Eco logy a Dioxin Study Report including the resul ts of the sampling and analysis by ___________( with the permit renewal application )

.

The wastewater data report to Ecology must include: date sampled, total flow for each wash, and the concentration of the 2,3, 7,8

- Cl substituted tetra

- through octa

dioxin and furan congeners from each caustic wash. The Permittee must requirePage 35 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

the laboratory to report and maintain on file for each sample set: the analytical holding times, summary of internal precision and recove ry, calibration data, analysis sequence (run logs), daily checks (ongoing precision and accuracy standards, blanks, instrument checks), QA/QC data (duplicates, matrix spikes/labeled analog spikes), and raw data (chromatograms).

S1 3

. DANGEROUS WASTES

– PERM IT BY RULE REQUIREME NTS

The P ermittee is authorized to treat dangerous wastes, generated on or off

- site, at the wastewater treatment facility under the permit by rule provisions of Chapter WAC 173

- 303

- 802(5). This authorization is limited to the onsite an d off

- site wastestreams identified on the permit application and application amendments as approved by Ecology. The P ermittee must maintain records of the off

- site wastestreams treated at the wastewater facility. The origin, volume, known waste constitue nts, any analytical data, and date of addition, must be recorded. This information must be available to an authorized representative of Ecology per General Condition G2. A summary of the off

site dangerous wastes accepted and treated by the P ermittee mus t be submitted with permit renewal application

.

S1 4

. OUTFALL EVALUATION

The Permittee must inspect
, the submerged portion of the outfall line and diffuser to document its integrity and continued function

, once per permit cycle but no later than __________( 270 days prior to permit expiration) . If conditions allow for a photographic verification, it must be included in the report. T he Permittee must submit
the inspection report to Ecology w ithin 90 days of conducting the evaluation but no
later than

_________( with the permit renewal application )

. The Permittee must submit hard copies of any video files to Ecology as required by Permit Condition S3A. The Portal does not support submittal of video files.

The inspector must at minimum:

• Assess the physical c ondition of the outfall pipe, diffuser, and associated couplings.

• Determine the extent of sediment accumulation in the vicinity of the diffuser.

• Ensure diffuser ports are free of obstructions and are allowing uniform flow.

• Confirm the physical location (la titude/longitude) and depth (at MLLW) of the
diffuser section of the outfall.

• Assess physical condition fo the submarine line, including side sewer laterals up to the ordinary high water line.

• Assess the physical condition of the an chors used to secure the submarine line.

S1 5

. APPLICATION FOR PERM IT RENEWAL

The Permittee must submit an application for renewal of this permit 180 days prior to permit expiration

.Page 36 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

S1 6

. CERTIFIED OPERATOR

An operator certified for at least a Class II plant by the state of Washi ngton must be in responsible charge of the day

- to

- day operation of the wastewater treatment plant by ____________ ( within 180 days of the effective date of the permit ) and there after

. All operators in responsible charge of facilities that treat domestic wastes combined with commercial or industrial waste must be certified in accordance with the provisions of Chapter 70.95B RCW and Chapter 173

- 230 WAC.

GENERAL CONDITIONS

G1. SIGNATORY REQUIREMEN TS

A. All applications, reports, or information submitted to Ecology must be signed and
certified.

1

. In the case of corporations, by a responsible corporate officer. For the purposes of this section, a responsible corporate officer means: ( a ) A president, secretary, treasurer, or vice

- president of the corporation in charge of a principal business function, or any other person who performs similar policy

- or decision

- making functions for the corporation, or ( b ) the manager of one or more manufacturing, production, or operating facilities, provided, the manager
is a u t horized to make management decisions which govern the operation of the regulated facility including having the explicit or implicit duty of making major capital investment recommendations, and initiating and directing other comprehensive measures to assu re long term environmental compliance with environmental laws and regulations; the manager can ensure that the necessary systems are established or actions taken to gather complete and accurate information for permit application requirements; and where aut hority to sign documents has been assigned or delegated to the manager in accordance with corporate procedures.

2. In the case of partnership, by a general partner.

3. In the case of sole proprietorship, by the proprietor

.

4. In the case of a municipal, st ate, or public facility, by either the principal executive officer, or ranking elected official.

Applications for permits for domestic wastewater facilities that are either owned or operated by, or under contract to, a public entity must be submitted by th e public entity.

B. All reports required by this permit and other information requested by Ecology

must be signed by a person described above or by a duly authorized representative of that person. A person is a duly authorized representative only if:Page 37 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

1. T he authorization is made in writing by a person described above and
submitted to Ecology

.

2. The authorization specifies either an individual or a position having responsibility for the overall operation of the regulated facility, such as the position of p lant manager, superintendent, position of equivalent responsibility, or an individual or position having overall responsibility for environmental matters. (A duly authorized representative may thus be either a named individual or any individual occupying a named position.)

C. Changes to authorization: If an authorization under paragraph B.2 above is no longer accurate because a different individual or position has responsibility for the overall operation of the facility, a new authorization satisfying the requirements of paragraph B.2 above must be submitted to the Ecology prior to or together with any reports, information, or applications to be signed by an authorized representative.

D. Certification: Any person signing a document under this section must ma ke the following certification:

I certify under penalty of law, that this document and all attachments were prepared under my direction or supervision in accordance with a system designed to assure that qualified personnel properly gathered and evaluated the information submitted. Based on my inquiry of the person or persons who manage the system, or those persons directly responsible for gathering information, the information submitted is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, true, accurate, and compl ete. I am aware that there are significant penalties for submitting false information, including the possibility of fine and imprisonment for knowing violations.

G2. RIGHT OF INSPECTION AND ENTRY

The Permittee must allow an authorized representative of E cology , upon the presentation of credentials and such other documents as may be required by law:

A. To enter upon the premises where a discharge is located or where any records must be kept under the terms and conditions of this permit.

B. To have access to and copy

- at reasonable times and at reasonable cost

- any records required to be kept under the terms and conditions of this permit.

C. To inspect

- at reasonable times

- any facilities, equipment (including monitoring
and control equipment), practices, methods , or operations regulated or required under this permit.Page 38 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

D. To sample or monitor

- at reasonable times

- any substances or parameters at any location for purposes of assuring permit compliance or as otherwise authorized by
the Clean Water Act.

G3. PERMIT ACT IONS

This permit may be modified, revoked and reissued, or terminated either at the request of any interested person (including the permittee) or upon the Department’s initiative. However, the permit may only be modified, revoked and reissued, or terminat ed for the reasons specified in 40 CFR 122.62, 122.64 or WAC 173

- 220

- 150 according to t he procedures of 40 CFR 124.5.

A. The following are causes for terminating this permit during its term, or for denying a permit renewal application:

1. Violation of any permi t term or condition.

2. Obtaining a permit by misrepresentation or failure to disclose all relevant facts.

3. A material change in quantity or type of waste disposal.

4. A determination that the permitted activity endangers human health or the
environment or contri butes to water quality standards violations and can only be regulated to acceptable levels by permit modification or termination [40 CFR part 122.64(3)].

5. A change in any condition that requires either a temporary or permanent
reduction or elimination of an y discharge or sludge use or disposal practice controlled by the permit [40 CFR part 122.64(4)].

6. Nonpayment of fees assessed pursuant to RCW 90.48.465.

7. Failure or refusal of the permittee to allow entry as required in RCW 90.48.090.

B. The following are cause s for modification but not revocation and reissuance except when the permittee requests or agrees:

1. A material change in the condition of the waters of the state.

2. New information not available at the time of permit issuance that would have justified the app lication of different permit conditions.

3. Material and substantial alterations or additions to the permitted facility or activities which occurred after this permit issuance.

4. Promulgation of new or amended standards or regulations having a direct bearing up on permit conditions, or requiring permit revision.Page 39 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

5. The Permittee has requested a modification based on other rationale meeting the
criteria of 40 CFR P art 122.62.

6. Ecology has determined that good cause exists for modification of a compliance schedule, and the modification will not violate statutory deadlines.

7. Incorporation of an approved local pretreatment program into a municipality’s permit.

C. The following are causes for modification or alternatively revocation and reissuance:

1. Cause exists for termination for reasons listed in A1 through A7 of this section
and Ecology determines that modification or revocation and reissuance is appropriate.

2. Ecology has received notification of a proposed transfer of the permit. A permit may also be modified to reflect a t ransfer after the effective date of an automatic transfer (General Condition G8) but will not be revoked and reissued after the effective date of the transfer except upon the request of the new permittee.

G4. REPORTING PLANNED CH ANGES

The Permittee must

, as soon as possible, but no later than thir ty ( 3 0) days prior to the proposed changes, give notice to Ecology of planned physical alterations or additions to the permitted facility, production increases, or process modification which will result in: 1) th e permitted facility being determined to be a new source pursuant to 40 CFR 122.29(b); 2) a significant change in the nature or an increase in quantity of pollutants discharged; or 3) a significant change in the Permittee’s sludge use or disposal practices . Following such notice, and the submittal of a new application or supplement to the existing application, along with required engineering plans and reports, this permit may be modified, or revoked and reissued pursuant to 40 CFR 122.62(a) to specify and limit any pollutants not previously limited. Until such modification is effective, any new or increased discharge in excess of permit limits or not specifically authorized by this permit constitutes a violation.

G5. PLAN REVIEW REQUIRED

Prior to constru cting or modifying any wastewater control facilities, an engineering report and detailed plans and specifications must be submitted to Ecology for approval in accordance with Chapter 173

- 240 WAC. Engineering reports, plans, and specifications must be subm itted at least thirty ( 3 0) days prior to the planned start of construction unless a shorter time is approved by Ecology. Facilities must be constructed and operated in accordance with the approved plans.

G6. COMPLIANCE WITH OTHE R LAWS AND STATUTES

Nothin g in this permit must be construed as excusing the Permittee from compliance with any applicable federal, state, or local statutes, ordinances, or regulations.Page 40 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

G7

. TRANSFER OF THIS PER MIT

In the event of any change in control or ownership of facilities fr om which the authorized discharge emanate, the Permittee must notify the succeeding owner or controller of the existence of this permit by letter, a copy of which must be forwarded to Ecology

.

A. Transfers by Modification

Except as provided in paragraph B below, this permit may be transferred by the Permittee to a new owner or operator only if this permit has been modified or revoked and reissued under 40 CFR 122.62(b)(2), or a minor modification made under 40 CFR 122.63(d), to identify the new Permittee a nd incorporate such other requirements as may be necessary under the Clean Water Act.

B. Automatic Transfers

This permit may be automatically transferred to a new Permittee if:

1. The Permittee notifies Ecology at least 30 days in advance of the proposed

tr ansfer date.

2. The notice includes a written agreement between the existing and new Permittee’s containing a specific date transfer of permit responsibility, coverage, and liability between them.

3. Ecology does not notify the existing Permittee and the propo sed new Permittee of its intent to modify or revoke and reissue this permit. A modification under the subparagraph may also be minor modification under 40 CFR 122.63. If this notice is not received, the transfer is effective on the date specified in the written agreement.

G8

. REDUCED PRODUCTION F OR COMPLIANCE

The Permittee, in order to maintain compliance with its permit, must control production and/or all discharges upon reduction, loss, failure, or bypass of the treatment facility until the facility is restored or an alternative method of treatment is provided. This requirement applies in the situation where, among other things, the primary source of power of the treatment facility is reduced, lost, or fails.

G 9

. REMOVED SUBSTANCES

Collected screening s, grit, solids, sludges, filter backwash, or other pollutants removed
in the course of treatment or control of wastewaters must not be resuspended or
reintroduced to the final effluent stream for discharge to state waters.Page 41 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

G10

. DUTY TO PROVIDE INFO RMATIO N

The Permittee must submit to Ecology , within a reasonable time, all information which Ecology may request to determine whether cause exists for modifying, revoking and reissuing, or terminating this permit or to determine compliance with this permit. Th e Permittee must also submit to Ecology upon request, copies of records required to be kept by this permit.

G11

. OTHER REQUIREMENTS O F 40 CFR

All other requirements of 40 CFR 122.41 and 122.42 are incorporated in this permit by
reference.

G12

. ADDITIONAL MONITORING

Ecology may establish specific monitoring requirements in addition to those contained in this permit by administrative order or permit modification.

G13

. PAYMENT OF FEES

The Permittee must submit payment of fees associated with this permit as assessed by Ecology

.

G14

. PENALTIES FOR VIOLAT ING PERMIT CONDITION S

Any person who is found guilty of willfully violating the terms and conditions of this permit is deemed guilty of a crime, and upon conviction thereof shall be punished by a fine of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) and costs of prosecution, or by imprisonment in the discretion of the court. Each day upon which a willful violation occurs may be deemed a sep arate and additional violation.

Any person who violates the terms and conditions of a waste discharge permit m ay incur, in addition to any other penalty as provided by law, a civil penalty in the amount of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for every such violation. Each and every such

violation is a separate and distinct offense, and in case of a continuing violation, every day's continuance must be deemed to be a separate and distinct violation.

G15

. UPSET

Definition

– “Upset” means an exceptional incident in which there is unintentional and temporary noncompliance with technolog y

- based permit effluent limitations because of factors beyond the reasonable control of the Permittee. An upset does not include noncompliance to the extent caused by operational error, improperly designed treatment facilities, inadequate treatment facili ties, lack of preventive maintenance, or careless or improper operation.Page 42 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

An upset constitutes an affirmative defense to an action brought for noncompliance with such technology

- based permit effluent limitations if the requirements of the following

paragrap h are met.

A Permittee who wishes to establish the affirmative defense of upset must demonstrate, through properly signed, contemporaneous operating logs or other relevant evidence that: 1) an upset occurred and that the Permittee can identify the cause(s ) of the upset; 2) the permitted facility was being properly operated at the time of the upset; 3) the Permittee submitted notice of the upset as required in condition S3.E; and 4) the Permittee complied with any remedial measures required under S4.C of th is permit.

In any enforcement preceding the Permittee seeking to establish the occurrence of an upset has the burden of proof.

G16

. PROPERTY RIGHTS

This permit does not convey any property rights of any sort, or any exclusive privilege.

G17

. DUTY TO COMP LY

The Permittee must comply with all conditions of this permit. Any permit noncompliance constitutes a violation of the Clean Water Act and is grounds for enforcement action; for permit termination, revocation and reissuance, or modification;
or denial o f a permit renewal application.

G18

. TOXIC POLLUTANTS

The Permittee must comply with effluent standards or prohibitions established under Section 307(a) of the Clean Water Act for toxic pollutants within the time provided in the regulations that establish those standards or prohibitions, even if this permit has not yet been modified to incorporate the requirement.

G19

. PENALTIES FOR TAMPER ING

The Clean Water Act provides that any person who falsifies, tampers with, or knowingly renders inaccurate any moni toring device or method required to be maintained under this permit shall , upon conviction, be punished by a fine of not more than $10,000 per violation, or by imprisonment for not more than two years per violation, or by both. If a conviction of a person is for a violation committed after a first conviction of such person under this Condition, punishment shall be a fine of not more than $20,000 per day of violation, or by imprisonment of not more than four (4) years, or by both.Page 43 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

G20

. REPORTING REQUIREMEN TS APPLICABLE TO EXI STING MANUFACTURING, COMME RCIAL, MINING, AND S ILVICULTURAL
DISCHARGERS

The Permittee belonging to the categories of existing manufacturing, commercial, mining, or silviculture must notify Ecology as soon as they know or have reason to
b elieve:

A. That any activity has occurred or will occur which would result in the discharge, on a routine or frequent basis, of any toxic pollutant which is not limited in this permit, if that discharge will exceed the highest of the following “notification l evels”:

1. One hundred micrograms per liter (100 μ g/l).

2. Two hundred micrograms per liter (200 μ g/l) for acrolein and acrylonitrile; five hundred micrograms per liter (500 μ g/l) for 2,4

- dinitrophenol and for 2

- methyl

4,6

- dinitrophenol; and one milligram per li ter (1 mg/l) for antimony.

3. Five (5) times the maximum concentration value reported for that pollutant in the permit application in accordance with 40 CFR 122.21(g)(7).

4. The level established by the Director in accordance with 40 CFR 122.44(f).

B. That any act ivity has occurred or will occur which would result in any discharge, on

a non

- routine or infrequent basis, of a toxic pollutant which is not limited in this permit, if that discharge will exceed the highest of the following “notification
levels”:

1. Five hun dred micrograms per liter (500 μ g/L).

2. One milligram per liter (1 mg/L) for antimony

.

3. Ten (10) times the maximum concentration value reported for that pollutant in the permit application in accordance with 40 CFR 122.21(g)(7).

4. The level established by the Di rector in accordance with 40 CFR 122.44(f).

G21

. COMPLIANCE SCHEDULES

Reports of compliance or noncompliance with, or any progress reports on, interim and final requirements contained in any compliance schedule of this permit must be
submitted no later th an fourteen (14) days following each schedule date.Page 44 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1



## APPENDIX A

Calculati ng Stormwater asnd Ballast Water Allocations

S1.A effluent limitations in the Tesoro NPDES permit are base permit limits that apply to process water flow

– these values are fixed.

S1.C. effluent limitations in the Tesoro NPDES permits are used to calculate incremental
limits that apply to storm water and ballast water

– the S1.C. limitations are actually multipliers. The incremental limit calculated using one of the multipliers is added to the base permit limit for commingled discharges.

Storm water flow is calculated by the subtraction of an estimated dry weather flow and ballast water flow from the total flow discharged each day.

Ballast water flow is measured by gauging t he tanks at the refinery dock.
The ballast and storm water allocations in the Tesoro NPDES permit are based on guidelines in 40 CFR 419.12(c) and 419.22(e). The allocations for storm water are intended to apply to runoff
from areas associated with industria l activity, not outlying areas such as parking lots and surrounding acreage.

Daily maximum s torm water and ballast water allocations must only be used on an individual parameter basis when mass loading in the effluent exceeds daily maximum base permit
lim itations and when measurable rainfall has occurred within the timeframes established in the NPDES permit. The Tesoro NPDES permit states that during specified summer months, the permittee will only be allowed to claim the storm water allocation when it ca n be demonstrated that measurable rainfall has occurred at the refinery site during the previous 10 calendar days.

In calculating storm water allocations, look at the days where total effluent flow exceeds the established dry weather flow. The difference is flow due to storm water. If the storm water allocation can be claimed per the conditions of the previous paragraph, multiply the additional flow (in million gallons per day, MGD) by the appropriate allocation provided in the NPDES permit. This is an incrementa l permit limit in lbs per day.

Evaluating compliance with the maximum daily permit limitation

- on a day by day basis compare the maximum discharge for a parameter to the base permit limitation plus the storm
water allocation and/or ballast wat er allocation calcu lated for that parameter.

Example Calculation 1.

Dry weather flow: 1 MGD Date: March 15, 1997 Parameter: Oil and Grease (O&G) O&G maximum daily base permit limitation: 100 lbs/day Maximum daily O& G discharge: 177 lbs/day
Total effluent flow: 2.2 MGDPage 45 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Flow rate due to rainfall: 2.2

– 1 = 1.2 MGD O&G maximum daily storm water alloca tion: 130 lbs/million gallons
O&G incremental limit due to storm water: 1.2 x 130 = 156 lbs/day O&G maximum daily permit limitation for 3/15/97: 100 + 156 = 256 lbs/day

Note: Since 177 is less than 256, the permittee is in compliance with the oil and grease maximum daily permit limitation on the day evaluated. If ballast water had also been a factor on 3/15/97, an addit ional oil and grease allocation due to ballast water could have been calculated and added into the maximum daily permit
limitation.

Evaluating compliance with the monthly average permit limitation

- determine the days where
effluen t flow exceeds dry weather flow and sampling occurred. Add up the excess flow for these days and divide the result by this number of days. Multiply by the monthly average storm water
allocation.

-- this is the incremental storm water allocation. Compar e the monthly average discharge for a parameter (total mass loading for the month divided by the days in the month) to the base permit limitation plus the storm water allocation and/or ballast water allocation calculated for that parameter.

Ex ample Calculation 2.

Dry weather flow: 1 MGD
Month: November 1997 Parameter: Total Suspended Solids (TSS) TSS average monthly base permit limitation: 120 lbs/day Average monthly TSS discharge: 216 lbs/day During the 5 sampling days the total storm water flow excess was: 2.5 million gallons TSS average monthly storm water allocation: 180 lbs/million gallons
TSS incremental limi t due to storm water: 2.5/ 5 x 180 = 90 lbs/day TSS average monthly permit limitation for November 1997: 120 + 90 = 21 0 lbs/day

Note: Since 216 is greater than 210, the TSS average mo nthly permit limit is exceeded.

If ballast water had also been a factor in Example Calculation 2 , the average monthly permit
limit would not have been exceeded.

Ballast water flow for Nov ember 1997 (1 day): 50,000 gallons or 0.05 million gallons TSS average monthly ballast water allocation: 170 lbs/million gallons
TSS incremental limit due to ballast water: 0.05/ 1 x 170 = 8.5 lbs/day TSS average monthly permit limitation for Novembe r 1997: 120 + 90 + 8.5 = 218.5 lbs/dayPage 46 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1



## APPENDIX B

List of Pollutants w ith Analyt ical Methods, Detection Limits a nd Quantitation

Levels

The Permittee must use the specified analytical methods, detection limits (DLs) and quantitation levels (QLs) in t he following table for permit and application required monitoring unless:

• Another permit condition specifies other methods, detection levels, or quantitation levels.

• The method used produces measurable results in the sample and EPA has listed it as an

EPA

- approved method in 40 CFR Part 136.

If the Permittee uses an alternative method, not specified in the permit and as allowed above, it must report the test method, DL, and QL on the discharge monitoring report or in the required
report.

If the Permittee is unable to obtain the required DL and QL in its effluent due to matrix effects,
the Permittee must submit a matrix

- specific detection limit (MDL) and a quantitation limit (QL) to Ecology with appropriate laboratory documentation.

When the permit require s the Permittee to measure the base neutral compounds in the list of priority pollutants, it must measure all of the base neutral pollutants listed in the table below. The list includes EPA required base neutral priority pollutants and several additional polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). The Water Quality Program added several PAHs to the list of base neutrals below from Ecology’s Persistent Bioaccumulative Toxics (PBT) List. It only added those PBT parameters of interest to Appendix A that did no t increase the overall cost of analysis unreasonably.

Ecology added this appendix to the permit in order to reduce the number of analytical “non

detects” in permit

- required monitoring and to measure effluent concentrations near or below
criteria values w here possible at a reasonable cost.



### CONVENTIONAL PARAMETERS

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1 μg/L
unless specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified

Biochemical Oxygen
Demand SM5210

- B 2 mg /L

Chemical Oxygen Demand SM5220

- D 10 mg/L Total Organic Carbon SM5310

- B/C/D 1 mg/L Total Suspended Solids SM2540

- D 5 mg/L Total Ammonia (as N) SM4500

- NH3

- B and 20Page 47 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1 μg/L
unless specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified

C/D/E/G/H

Flow Calibrated device Dissolved oxygen SM4500

- OC/OG 0.2 mg/L Temper ature (max. 7

- day avg.) Analog recorder or
Use micro

- recording

devices known as
thermistors 0.2o C

pH SM4500

- H + B N/A N/A



### NONCONVENTIONAL PARAMETERS

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1 μg/L

unless specifi ed Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified Total Alkalinity SM2320

- B 5 mg/L as
CaCO3 Chlorine, Total Residual SM4500 Cl G 50.0

Color SM2120 B/C/E 10 color units

Fecal Coliform SM 9221E,9222 N/A Specified in
method

- sample aliquot dependent Fluoride (16984

- 48

- 8) SM4500

- F E 25 100 Nitrate + Nitrite Nitrogen (as N) SM4500

- NO3

- E/F/H 100

Nitrogen, Total Kjeldahl (as N) SM4500

- N org B/C
and SM4500NH 3 -

B/C/D/EF/G/H 300

Soluble Reactive Phosphorus (as P) SM4500

- PE/PF 3 10

Phosphorus, Total (as P) SM 4500 PB followed by
SM4500

- PE/PF 3 10

Oil and Grease (HEM) 1664 A or B 1,400 5,000 Salinity SM2520

- B 3 practical salinity units or

scale (PSU or PSS)

Settleable Solids SM2540

- F 100Page 48 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1 μg/L

unless specifi ed Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified Sulfate (as mg/L SO 4 ) SM4110

- B 200 Sulfide (as mg/L S) SM4 500

- S 2 F/D/E/G 200 Sulfite (as mg/L SO 3 ) SM4500

- SO3B 2000

Total Coliform SM 9221B, 9222B,
9223B N/A Specified in
method

- sample aliquot dependent

Total dissolved solids SM2540 C 20 mg/L

Total Hardness SM2340B 200 as CaCO3 Aluminum, Total (7429

- 90

- 5) 200.8 2.0 10

Barium Total (7440

- 39

- 3) 200.8 0.5 2.0 BTEX (benzene +toluene + ethylbenzene + m,o,p xylenes) EPA SW 846
8021/8260 1 2

Boron Total (7440

- 42

- 8) 200.8 2.0 10.0 Cobalt, Total (7440

- 48

- 4) 200.8 0.05 0.25 Iron, Total (7439

- 89

- 6) 200.7 12.5 50 Magnesium, Total (7439

- 95

- 4) 200.7 10 50

Molybdenum, Total (7439

- 98

- 7) 200.8 0.1 0.5

Manganese, Total (7439

- 96

- 5) 200.8 0.1 0.5

NWTPH Dx Ecology NWTPH

Dx 250 250

NWTPH Gx Ecology NWTPH

Gx 250 250

Tin, Total (7440

- 31

- 5) 200.8 0.3 1.5 Titanium, Tot al (7440

- 32

- 6) 200.8 0.5 2.5



### PRIORITY POLLUTANTS

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1 μg/L
unless specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified

METALS, CYANIDE & TOTAL PHENOLS Antimony, Total ( 7440

- 36

- 0) 200.8 0.3 1.0 Arsenic, Total (7440

- 38

- 2) 200.8 0.1 0.5Page 49 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1 μg/L
unless specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified Beryllium, Total (7440

- 41

- 7) 200.8 0.1 0.5 Cadmium, Total (7440

- 43

- 9) 200.8 0.05 0.25 Chromium (hex) dissolved (18540

- 29

- 9) SM3500

- Cr EC 0.3 1.2

Chromium, Total (7440

- 47

- 3) 200.8 0.2 1.0

Copper, Total (7440

- 50

- 8) 200.8 0.4 2.0 Lead, Total (7439

- 92

- 1) 200.8 0.1 0.5 Mercury, Total (7439

- 97

- 6) 1631E 0.0002 0.0005 Nickel, Total (7440

- 02

- 0) 200.8 0.1 0.5 Selenium, Total (7782

- 49

- 2) 200.8 1.0 1.0 Silver, Total (7440

- 22

- 4) 200.8 0.04 0 .2 Thallium, Total (7440

- 28

- 0) 200.8 0.09 0.36 Zinc, Total (7440

- 66

- 6) 200.8 0.5 2.5 Cyanide, Total (57

- 12

- 5) 335.4 5 10 Cyanide, Weak Acid
Dissociable SM4500

- CN I 5 10

Cyanide, Free Amenable to Chlorination (Available Cyanide) SM4500

- CN G 5 10

Pheno ls, Total EPA 420.1 50

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1 μg/L
unless specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified

ACID COMPOUNDS

2

- Chlorophenol (95

- 57

- 8) 625 1.0 2.0 2,4

- Dichlorophenol (12 0

- 83

- 2) 625 0.5 1.0

2,4

- Dimethylphenol (105

- 67

- 9) 625 0.5 1.0

4,6

- dinitro

- o

- cresol (534

- 52

- 1) (2

- methyl

- 4,6,

- dinitrophenol) 625/1625B 1.0 2.0

2,4 dinitrophenol (51

- 28

- 5) 625 1.0 2.0

2

- Nitrophenol (88

- 75

- 5) 625 0.5 1.0

4

- nitrophenol (100

- 02

- 7) 625 0.5 1.0Page 50 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1 μg/L
unless specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified Parachlorometa cresol (59

- 50

- 7) (4

- chloro

- 3

- methylphenol) 625 1.0 2.0

Pentachlorophenol (87

- 86

- 5) 625 0.5 1.0 Phenol (108

- 95

- 2) 625 2.0 4.0 2,4,6

- Trichlorophenol (88

- 06

- 2) 625 2.0 4.0

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1
μg/L unless

specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified

VOLATILE COMPOUNDS Acrolein (107

- 02

- 8) 624 5 10 Acrylonitrile (107

- 13

- 1) 624 1.0 2.0 Benzene (71

- 43

- 2) 624 1.0 2.0 Bromoform (75

- 25

- 2) 624 1.0 2.0

Carbon t etrachloride (56

- 23

- 5) 624/601 or
SM6230B 1.0 2.0

Chlorobenzene (108

- 90

- 7) 624 1.0 2.0 Chloroethane (75

- 00

- 3) 624/601 1.0 2.0

2

- Chloroethylvinyl Ether (110

- 75

- 8) 624 1.0 2.0

Chloroform (67

- 66

- 3) 624 or SM6210B 1.0 2.0

Dibromochloromethane (124

- 48

- 1) 624 1.0 2.0

1,2

- Dichlorobenzene (95

- 50

- 1) 624 1.9 7.6

1,3

- Dichlorobenzene (541

- 73

- 1) 624 1.9 7.6

1,4

- Dichlorobenzene (106

- 46

- 7) 624 4.4 17.6

Dichlorobromomethane (75

- 27

- 4) 624 1.0 2.0

1,1

- Dichloroethane (75

- 34

- 3) 624 1.0 2.0 1,2

- Dichloroethane (107

- 06

- 2) 624 1.0 2.0

1,1

- Dichloroethylene (75

- 35

- 4) 624 1.0 2.0

1,2

- Dichloropropane (78

- 87

- 5) 624 1.0 2.0Page 51 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1
μg/L unless

specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified

VOLATILE COMPOUNDS 1,3

- dichloropropene (mixed isomers) (1,2

- dichloropropylene) (542

- 75

- 6) 3 624 1.0 2.0

Ethylbenzene (100

- 41

- 4) 624 1.0 2.0 Methyl bromide (74

- 83

- 9) ( Bromomethane) 624/601 5.0 10.0

Methyl chloride (74

- 87

- 3) (Chloromethane) 624 1.0 2.0

Methylene chloride (75

- 09

- 2) 624 5.0 10.0

1,1,2,2

- Tetrachloroethane (79

- 34

- 5) 624 1.9 2.0

Tetrachloroethylene (127

- 18

- 4) 624 1.0 2.0

Toluene (108

- 88

- 3) 624 1.0 2.0 1,2

- Trans

- Dichloroethylene (156

- 60

- 5) (Ethylene dichloride) 624 1.0 2.0

1,1,1

- Trichloroethane (71

- 55

- 6) 624 1.0 2.0

1,1,2

- Trichloroethane (79

- 00

- 5) 624 1.0 2.0

Trichloroethylene (79

- 01

- 6) 624 1.0 2.0 Vinyl chloride (75

- 01

- 4) 624/SM6200B 1.0 2.0

Pol lutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1
μg/L unless

specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified BASE/NEUTRAL COMPOUNDS (compounds in bold are Ecology PBTs) Acenaphthene (83

- 32

- 9) 625 0.2 0.4 Acenaph thylene (208

- 96

- 8) 625 0.3 0.6 Anthracene (120

- 12

- 7) 625 0.3 0.6 Benzidine (92

- 87

- 5) 625 12 24 Benzyl butyl phthalate (85

- 68

- 7) 625 0.3 0.6

Benzo( a )anthracene (56

- 55

- 3) 625 0.3 0.6

Benzo(b)fluoranthene (3,4

- benzofluoranthene) 610/625 0.8 1.6Page 52 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Pol lutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1
μg/L unless

specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified BASE/NEUTRAL COMPOUNDS (compounds in bold are Ecology PBTs) (205

- 99

- 2) 4
Benzo(j)fluoranthene (205

- 82

- 3) 4 625 0.5 1.0

Benzo(k)fluoranthene (11,12

- benzofluoranthene) (207

- 08

- 9) 4 610/625 0.8 1.6

Benzo(r,s,t)pentaphene (189

- 55

- 9) 625 0.5 1.0

Benzo( a )pyrene (50

- 32

- 8) 610/625 0.5 1.0 Benzo( ghi )Perylene (191

- 24

- 2) 610/6 25 0.5 1.0

Bis( 2

- chloroethoxy) methane (111

- 91

- 1) 625 5.3 21.2

Bis( 2

- chloroethyl )ether (111

- 44

- 4) 611/625 0.3 1.0

Bis( 2

- chloroisopropyl )ether (39638

- 32

- 9) 625 0.3 0.6

Bis( 2

- ethylhexyl )phthalate (117

- 81

- 7) 625 0.1 0.5

4

- Bromophenyl phenyl ether (101

- 55

- 3) 625 0.2 0.4

2

- Chloronaphthalene (91

- 58

- 7) 625 0.3 0.6

4

- Chlorophenyl phenyl ether (7005

- 72

- 3) 625 0.3 0.5

Chrysene (218

- 01

- 9) 610/625 0.3 0.6 Dibenzo (a,h)acridine (226

- 36

- 8) 610M/625M 2.5 10.0

Dibenzo (a,j)acridine (224

- 42

- 0) 610M/625M 2.5 10.0

Dibenzo(a

- h )anthracene (53

- 70

- 3)(1,2,5,6

- dibenzanthracene) 625 0.8 1.6

Dibenzo(a,e)pyrene (192

- 65

- 4) 610M/625M 2.5 10.0

Dibenzo(a,h)pyrene (189

- 64

- 0) 625M 2.5 10.0

3,3

- Dichlorobenzidine (91

- 94

- 1) 605/625 0.5 1.0

Diethyl phthalate (84

- 66

- 2) 625 1.9 7.6 Dimethyl phthalate (131

- 11

- 625 1.6 6.4Page 53 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Pol lutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1
μg/L unless

specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified BASE/NEUTRAL COMPOUNDS (compounds in bold are Ecology PBTs) 3)

Di

- n

- butyl phthalate (84

- 74

- 2) 625 0.5 1.0

2,4

- dinitrotoluene (121

- 14

- 2) 609/625 0.2 0.4

Di

- n

- octyl phthalate (117

- 84

- 0) 625 0.3 0.6

1,2

- Diphenylhydrazine ( as Azobenzene ) (122

- 66

- 7) 1625B 5.0 20

Fluoranthe ne (206

- 44

- 0) 625 0.3 0.6 Fluorene (86

- 73

- 7) 625 0.3 0.6 Hexachlorobenzene (118

- 74

- 1) 612/625 0.3 0.6

Hexachlorobutadiene (87

- 68

- 3) 625 0.5 1.0

Hexachlorocyclopentadiene (77

- 47

- 4) 1625B/625 0.5 1.0

Hexachloroethane (67

- 72

- 1) 625 0.5 1.0 Indeno( 1,2, 3

- cd )Pyrene (193

- 39

- 5) 610/625 0.5 1.0

Isophorone (78

- 59

- 1) 625 0.5 1.0

3

- Methyl cholanthrene (56

- 49

- 5) 625 2.0 8.0

Naphthalene (91

- 20

- 3) 625 0.3 0.6 Nitrobenzene (98

- 95

- 3) 625 0.5 1.0

N

- Nitrosodimethylamine (62

- 75

- 9) 607/625 2.0 4.0

N

- Nitrosodi

- n

- pr opylamine (621

- 64

- 7) 607/625 0.5 1.0

N

- Nitrosodiphenylamine (86

- 30

- 6) 625 0.5 1.0

Perylene (198

- 55

- 0) 625 1.9 7.6 Phenanthrene (85

- 01

- 8) 625 0.3 0.6 Pyrene (129

- 00

- 0) 625 0.3 0.6 1,2,4

- Trichlorobenzene (120

- 82

- 1) 625 0.3 0.6Page 54 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1
μg/L unless

specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified

DIOXIN 2,3,7,8

- Tetra

- Chlorodibenzo

P

- Dioxin (176

- 40

- 16) (2,3,7,8 TCDD) 1613B 1.3 pg/L 5 pg/L

Pollutant & CAS No. (if available) Recommended Analytical Protocol Detection (DL) 1
μg/L unless

specified Quantitation Level (QL) 2
μg/L unless

specified

PESTICIDES/PCBs Aldrin (309

- 00

- 2) 608 0.025 0.05 alpha

- BHC (319

- 84

- 6) 608 0.025 0.05

beta

- BHC (319

- 85

- 7) 608 0.025 0.05

gamma

- BHC (58

- 89

- 9) 608 0.025 0.05

delta

- BHC (319

- 86

- 8) 608 0.025 0.05 Chlordane (57

- 74

- 9) 5 608 0.025 0.05 4,4’

- DDT (50

- 29

- 3) 608 0.025 0.05 4,4’

- DDE (72

- 55

- 9) 608 0.025 0.05 10
4,4’ DDD (72

- 54

- 8) 608 0.025 0.05 Dieldrin (60

- 57

- 1) 608 0.025 0.05 alp ha

- Endosulfan (959

- 98

- 8) 608 0.025 0.05

beta

- Endosulfan (33213

- 65

- 9) 608 0.025 0.05

Endosulfan Sulfate (1031

- 07

- 8) 608 0.025 0.05

Endrin (72

- 20

- 8) 608 0.025 0.05 Endrin Aldehyde (7421

- 93

- 4) 608 0.025 0.05

Heptachlor (76

- 44

- 8) 608 0.025 0.05 Heptachl or Epoxide (1024

- 57

- 3) 608 0.025 0.05

PCB

- 1242 (53469

- 21

- 9) 6 608 0.25 0.5

PCB

- 1254 (11097

- 69

- 1) 608 0.25 0.5

PCB

- 1221 (11104

- 28

- 2) 608 0.25 0.5

PCB

- 1232 (11141

- 16

- 5) 608 0.25 0.5

PCB

- 1248 (12672

- 29

- 6) 608 0.25 0.5

PCB

- 1260 (11096

- 82

- 5) 608 0.13 0.5

PCB

- 1016 (12674

- 11

- 2) 6 608 0.13 0.5 Toxaphene (8001

- 35

- 2) 608 0.24 0.5Page 55 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

1. Detection level (DL)

- or detection limit means the minimum concentration of an analyte (substance) that can be measured and reported with a 99% confidence that the analyte

conce ntration is greater than zero as determined by the procedure given in 40 CFR part 136, Appendix B.

2. Quantitation Level (QL)

- also known as Minimum Level of Quantitation (ML)

– The lowest level at which the entire analytical system must give a recognizable signal and acceptable calibration point for the analyte. It is equivalent to the concentration of the lowest calibration standard, assuming that the lab has used all method

- specified sample weights, volumes, and cleanup procedures. The QL is calculated b y multiplying the MDL by 3.18 and rounding the result to the number nearest to (1, 2, or 5) x 10 n , where n is an integer. (64 FR 30417).

ALSO GIVEN AS: The smallest detectable concentration of analyte greater than the Detection Limit (DL)
where the accu racy (precision & bias) achieves the objectives of the intended purpose. ( Report of the Federal Advisory Committee on Detection and Quantitation Approaches and Uses in Clean Water Act Programs Submitted to the US Environmental Protection Agency December 20 07).

3. NWTPH Dx

- Northwest Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons Diesel Extended Range

– see http://www.ecy.wa.gov/biblio/97602.html

4. NWTPH Gx

- Northwest Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons Gasoline Extended Range

– see http://www.ecy.wa.gov/biblio/97602.html

5. 1, 3

- dichl oroproylene (mixed isomers)

- You may report this parameter as two separate parameters: cis

- 1, 3

- dichlorpropropene (10061

- 01

- 5) and trans

- 1, 3

- dichloropropene (10061

- 02

- 6).

6. Total Benzofluoranthenes

- Because Benzo(b)fluoranthene, Benzo(j)fluoranthene an d Benzo(k)fluoranthene co

- elute you may report these three isomers as total
benzofluoranthenes.

7. Chlordane

- You may report alpha

- chlordane (5103

- 71

- 9) and gamma

- chlordane (5103

- 74

- 2) in place of chlordane (57

- 74

- 9). If you report alpha and gamma

- chlordan e, the DL/PQLs that apply are 0.025/0.050.

8. PCB 1016 & PCB 1242

- You may report these two PCB compounds as one parameter
called PCB 1016/1242.Page 56 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1



## APPENDIX C

Refinery NPDES Pollution Prevention Plan

– General and Specific Requirements

Guidance Document s

Guidance documents that must be used when developing or updating a pollution prevention plan
include the Stormwater Management Manual for Western Washington published August 2012 by Ecology (Publication number 12

- 10

- 030), the ‘Pollution Prevention and B est Management
Practices’ section of the Ecology Permit Writer’s Manual, Chapter XII. (Publication number 92

- 109), EPA's Organizational Guide to Pollution Prevention , 2001 available at http://www. p2ric.org/CachedPages/printguid.pdf , the methodologies of pollution prevention planning references available at http://www.ecy.wa.gov/programs/hwtr/p2/p3.html , and other information provided b y the Ecology Permit Manager.

Plan Requirements

A. General Requirements

1. Policy Statement and Signature:

The pollution prevention plan must include a policy statement articulating management and corporate support for the plan and a commitment to implement t he plan and to continued pursuit of pollution prevention opportunities. The plan, plan updates, and modifications must be signed in accordance with Permit Condition G1.

2. Employee Involvement, Training, and Awareness:

The pollution prevention plan must in clude a description of personnel training and employee involvement programs that emphasize pollution prevention and solicit employee ideas about pollution prevention opportunities and other environmental issues. Staff training records must be maintained o nsite and be available for inspection.

3. Other Pollution Prevention Plans

The Permittee may incorporate applicable portions of plans prepared for their facility for other purposes. Plans or portions of plans incorporated into t he Pollution
Prevention Plan become enforceable requirements of this permit.

B. Specific Requirements

The Pollution Prevention Plan must contain a site map, detail ed assessment of the facility, detailed description of BMPs, spill prevention and emerg ency cleanup procedures, and sampli ng requirements.Page 57 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

1. The site map must identify:

a. The scale or include relative distances between significant structures and drainage
systems.

b. Significant features.

c. The stormwater drainage and discharge structures.

d. The stormwater drainage areas for each stormwater discharge point off

- site (including discharges to groundwater) and identifying number for each discharge point.

e. Each sampling location by identifying number.

f. Paved areas and buildings.

g. Areas of pollutant contact (actual and potential) associa ted with specific industrial
activities.

h. Surface water locations (including wetlands and drainage ditches)

i. Areas of existing and potential soil erosion (in a significant amount).

j. Vehicle maintenance areas.

k. Lands and waters adjacent to the site that may be helpful in identifying discharge points or drainage routes.

2. The facility assessment must include a description of the facility; an inventory of facility activities and equipment that contribute to or have the potential to contribute any pollutants to the wastewater treatment system, stormwater, and/or waters of the state; and an inventory of materials that contribute to or have the potential to contribute pollutants to the wastewater treatment system, stormwater, and/or waters of the state.

a. The facili ty description must describe:

i. The industrial activities conducted at the site.

ii. Regular business hours and seasonal variations in business hours or industrial
activities.

iii. The general layout of the facility including buildings and storage of raw
materials , and the flow of goods and materials through the facility.Page 58 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

b. The inventory of industrial activities must identify all areas associated with industrial activities that have been or may potentially be sources of pollutants, including, but not limited to, the following:

i. Loading and unloading of dry bulk materials or liquids.

ii. Outdoor storage of materials or products.

iii. Outdoor manufacturing and processing.

iv. On

- site dust or particulate generating processes.

v. On

- site waste treatment, storage, or disposal.

vi. Vehic le and equipment fueling, maintenance, and/or cleaning (includes washing).

vii. Roofs or other surfaces exposed to air emissions from a manufacturing building or a process area.

viii. Roofs or other surfaces composed of materials that may be mobilized by

stormwater (e.g., galvanized roofs, galvanized fences, etc.).

c. The inventory of materials must list:

i. The types of materials handled at the site that potentially may be exposed to precipitation or runoff and could result in stormwater pollution.

ii. A short narrative f or each material describing the potential of the pollutant to be present in stormwater discharges. The Permittee must update this narrative when data become available to verify the presence or absence of these pollutants.

iii. A narrative description of any p otential sources of pollutants from past activities, materials and spills that were previously handled, treated, stored, or disposed of in a manner to allow ongoing exposure to stormwater. Include
the method and location of on

- site storage or disposal. L ist significant spills and significant leaks of toxic or hazardous pollutants.

3. The Pollution Prevention Plan must identify specific individuals by name or title within the organization (pollution prevention team) whose responsibilities
include: Pollution Prevention Plan development, implementation, maintenance,
and modification.Page 59 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

4. Best Management Practices (BMPs)

a. The Permittee must describe each BMP selected to eliminate or reduce the potential to contaminate stormwater and/pr waters of the state and prev ent violations of water quality standards.

b. The Permittee must include each of the following mandatory BMPs in the Pollution Prevention Plan and implement the BMPs. The Permittee may omit individual BMPs if site conditions render the BMP unnecessary, infe asible, or the Permittee provides alternative and equally effective BMPs, if the Permittee clearly justifies each BMP omission in the Pollution Prevention Plan. The
Permittee must document in the Pollution Prevention Plan that the BMPs selected
are demons trably equivalent to practices contained in stormwater technical manuals approved by Ecology.

i. Operational Source Control BMPs

1) The Pollution Prevention Plan must include Operational Source Control BMPs listed as “applicable” in the Stormwater Management M anual for Western Washington (2012) or other guidance documents or manuals approved by Ecology.

2) Good Housekeeping : The Pollution Prevention Plan must include BMPs that define ongoing maintenance and cleanup, as appropriate, of areas which may contribute pollutants to stormwater discharges. The Pollution Prevention Plan must include the schedule/frequency for completing each housekeeping task, based upon industrial activity, sampling results, and observations made during inspections. The Permittee must:

a) Vacuum paved surfaces with a vacuum sweeper (or a sweeper with a vacuum attachment) to remove accumulated pollutants a minimum of
once per quarter.

b) Identify and control all on

- site sources of dust to minimize stormwater contamination from the deposition of dust on areas exposed to precipitation.

c) Inspect and maintain baghouses monthly to prevent the escape of dust from the system. Immediately remove any accumulated dust at the base of exterior baghouses.

d) Keep all dumpsters under cover or fit with a lid that must remain
closed when not in use.

3) Preventive Maintenance : The Pollution Prevention Plan must include BMPs to inspect and maintain the stormwater drainage, source controls,Page 60 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

treatment systems (if any), and plant equipment and systems that could fail
and result in contamination of stormwater. The Pollution Prevention Plan must include the schedule/frequency for completing each maintenance
task. The Permittee must:

a) Clean catch basins when the depth of debris reaches 60% of the sump depth. In additi on, the Permittee must keep the debris surface at least 6 inches below the outlet pipe.

b) Inspect all equipment and vehicles monthly for leaking fluids such as oil, antifreeze, etc. Take leaking equipment and vehicles out of service or prevent leaks from s pilling on the ground until repaired.

c) Immediately clean up spills and leaks (e.g., using absorbents, vacuuming, etc.) to prevent the discharge of pollutants.

4) Spill Prevention and Emergency Cleanup : The Pollution Prevention Plan must include BMPs to prev ent spills that can contaminate stormwater. The Pollution Prevention Plan must specify BMPs for material handling procedures, storage requirements, cleanup equipment and procedures, and spill logs, as appropriate. The Permittee must:

a) Store all chemical liquids, fluids, and petroleum products, on an impervious surface that is surrounded with a containment berm or dike that is capable of containing 10% of the total enclosed tank volume or 110% of the volume contained in the largest tank, whichever is
great er.

b) Prevent precipitation form accumulating in containment areas with a roof or equivalent structure or include a plan on how it will manage and dispose of accumulated water if a containment cover is not practical.

c) Locate spill kits within 25 feet of all stationary fueling stations, fuel transfer stations, and mobile fueling units. At a minimum, spill kits
must include:

i) Oil absorbents capable of absorbing 15 gallons of fuel.

ii) A storm drain plug or cover kit.

iii) A non

- water containment boom, a minimum of 1 0 feet in length
with a 12

- gallon absorbent capacity.

iv) A non

- metallic shovel.Page 61 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

v) Two five

- gallon buckets with lids.

d) Not lock shut

- off fueling nozzles in the open position. Do not “top off” tanks being refueled.

e) Block, plug, or cover storm drains that rece ive runoff from areas where fueling, during fueling.

f) Use drip pans or equivalent containment measures during all petroleum transfer operations.

g) Locate materials, equipment, and activities so that leaks are contained in existing containment and diversion systems (confine the storage of leaky or leak

- prone vehicles and equipment awaiting maintenance to protected areas).

h) Use drip pans and absorbents under or around leaky vehicles and equipment or store indoors where feasible. Drain fluids from equipment an d vehicles prior to on

- site storage or disposal.

i) Maintain a spill log that includes the following information for chemical and petroleum spills: date, time, amount, location, and reason for spill; and date/time cleanup completed, notifications made,
and staff involved.

5) Employee Training : The Pollution Prevention Plan must include BMPs to provide pollution prevention plan training for employees. At a minimum, the training plan must include:

a) The content of the training:

i) An overview of what is in the Po llution Prevention Plan.

ii) How employees make a difference in complying with the Pollution Prevention Plan and preventing contamination of stormwater
and/or waters of the state.

iii) Spill response procedures, good housekeeping, maintenance requirements, and ma terial management practices.

b) How the Permittee will conduct the training.

c) The frequency/schedule of training. The Permittee must train employees annually, at a minimum.

d) A log of the dates on which specific employees received training.Page 62 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

6) Inspections and Recordkeeping : The Pollution Prevention Plan must include documentation of procedures to ensure compliance with permit requirements for inspections and recordkeeping. At a minimum, the
Pollution Prevention Plan must:

a) Identify facility personnel who will inspect designated equipment and facility areas as required by Condition S12.

b) Contain a visual inspection report or checklist that includes all items required by Condition S12.

c) Provide a tracking or follow

- up procedure to ensure that a report is

prepare d and any appropriate action taken in response to visual inspections.

7) Illicit Discharges : The Pollution Prevention Plan must include measures to identify and eliminate the discharges of process wastewater, domestic

wastewater, non

- contact cooling water, and other illicit discharges, to stormwater sewers, or to surface waters, or ground waters of the state. The Permittee can find BMPs to identify and eliminate illicit discharges in
Volume IV of the Stormwater Management Manual for Western Washington (2012 ).

Water from washing vehicles or equipment, steam cleaning and/or pressure washing is considered process wastewater. The Permittee must not allow this process wastewater to commingle with stormwater or enter
storm drains.

ii. Structural Source Control BMPs

1) The Pollution Prevention Plan must include Operational Source Control BMPs listed as “applicable” in the Stormwater Management Manual for Western Washington (2012) or other guidance documents or manuals approved by Ecology.

2) The Pollution Prevention Plan must include BMPs to minimize the exposure of manufacturing, processing, and material storage areas (including loading and unloading, storage, disposal, cleaning, maintenance, and fueling operations) to rain, snow, snowmelt, and runoff by either locating these industrial materials and activities inside or protecting them with storm resistant coverings.Page 63 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

The Permittee must:

a) Use grading, berming, or curbing to prevent runoff of contaminated
flows and divert run

- on away from these areas.

b) Perform all clea ning operations indoors, under cover, or in bermed areas that prevent stormwater runoff and run

- on and also that capture

any overspray.

c) Ensure that all wash water drains to a collection system that directs wash water to further treatment or storage and no t to the stormwater drainage system.

iii. Treatment BMPs

The Permittee must:

1) Use Treatment BMPS consistent with the Stormwater Management Manual for Western Washington (2012) or other guidance documents or manuals approved by Ecology.

2) Employ oil/water separ ators, booms, skimmers, or other methods to eliminate or minimize oil and grease contamination of stormwater discharges.

3) Obtain Ecology approval before beginning construction/installation of all treatment BMPs that include the addition of chemicals to pro vide

treatment.

iv. Stormwater Peak Runoff Rate and Volume Control BMPs

1) Facilities with new development or redevelopment must evaluate whether flow control BMPs are necessary to satisfy the state’s AKART requirements and prevent violations of water quality s tandards. If flow control BMPs are required, they must be consistent with the Stormwater Management Manual for Western Washington (2012) or other guidance documents or manuals approved by Ecology.

v. Erosion and Sediment Control BMPs

The Pollution Preventi on Plan must describe BMPs necessary to prevent erosion of soils and other earthen materials (crushed rock/gravel, etc.) and prevent off

- site sedimentation and violations of water quality standards. The Permittee must implement and maintain:Page 64 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

1) Sediment con trol BMPs such as detention or retention ponds or traps, vegetated filter strips, bioswales, or other permanent sediment control BMPs to minimize sediment loads in stormwater discharges.

2) Filtration BMPs to remove solids from catch basins, sumps, or other stormwater collection and conveyance system components (filter socks, modular canisters, sand filtration, centrifugal separators, etc.).

5. Sampling Plan

The Pollution Prevention Plan must include a stormwater sampling plan. The plan

must:

a. Identify points of discharge to surface water, storm sewers, or discrete ground water infiltration locations such as dry wells or detention ponds.

b. Include documentation on why each discharge point is not sampled (if applicable):

i. Location of which discharge points the P ermittee does not sample because pollutant concentrations are substantially identical to a discharge point being sampled.

ii. Reasons why the Permittee expects the discharge points to discharge substantially identical effluents.

iii. General industrial activitie s conducted in the drainage areas of each discharge point.

iv. Best Management Practices conducted in the drainage area of each outfall.

v. Exposed materials located in the drainage area of each discharge point that are likely to be significant contributors o f pollutants to stormwater discharges.

vi. Impervious surfaces in the drainage area that could affect the percolation stormwater runoff into the ground (e.g., asphalt, crushed rock, grass, etc.).

c. Identify each sampling location by its unique identifying numb er.

d. Identify staff responsible for conducting stormwater sampling.

e. Specify procedures for sample collection and handling.

f. Specify procedures for sending samples to a laboratory.Page 65 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

g. Identify parameters for analysis, holding times and preservative, laborato ry quantitation levels, and analytical methods.

h. Specify the procedure for submitting results to Ecology.

C. Identifying and Evaluating Pollution Prevention Opportunities

1. Description of Current Pollution Prevention Activities

The plan must include a desc ription of preventive measures and facilities already employed at the refinery to prevent, reduce, eliminate, or control releases of pollutants to influent wastewater streams, storm water, and/or waters of the state.

2. Description of Potential Pollutants an d Sources

The pollution prevention plan must include a detailed description of the processes or activities that contribute or potentially contribute pollutants to the treatment plant influent, storm water, groundwater, and wetlands. Influent wastewater st reams must include those having daily average flow rates equal to or greater than 30 gpm at the point where the wastewater stream enters the collection system, the catalytic wash water, spent caustic, and wash water waste streams. Minor in cidental waste s treams

to storm water, such as landscaping fertilizers, do not have to be included. The plan must identify the materials used, processed, stored, treated, or disposed of at the facility and the pollutants that are generated or potentially generated or rele ased. The level of detail provided in the plan should be sufficient to help identify and understand how and why materials are used and pollutants generated or released. Process flow diagrams and/or material input/output information must be included on

a p rocess unit basis.

The Permittee must include in the plan all materials which may become pollutants or cause pollution upon reaching state waters, including, but not limited to:

1. persistent bioaccumulative and toxic chemicals (PBTs),

2. O il and petroleum p roducts, and

3. M aterials which, when spilled or otherwise released into the environment, would be designated Dangerous Waste (DW) or Extremely Hazardous Waste (EHW) by the procedures set forth in WAC 173

- 303

- 070.

In determining which sources and pollutants to address in the plan, the Permittee must use available sampling data, as well as knowledge of processes and materials, and available information on the relative toxicity or hazard of materials. Sources of PBTs must be included in the analysis. The Perm ittee must not be required to sample each stream analytically and may use engineering judgment to assess and quantify material inputs and outputs on a process unit basis.Page 66 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

3. Identification & Preliminary Evaluation of Pollution Prevention Opportunities

The plan must identify pollution prevention opportunities and provide a detailed analysis of each opportunity’s technical (including safety considerations) and economic feasibility. Opportunities determined to be technically and economically
feasible will be considered as known, available, and reasonable and therefore are required to be selected and scheduled for implementation. For each pollution prevention opportunity selected, the plan must identify the process(es) or activities it affects, an estimate of the amount of pollutants reduced, and the environmental or
other benefits that will be achieved.

The Permittee must concentrate on opportunities that reduce or eliminate PBTs, priority pollutant metals, and methyldiethanolamine (MDEA) to influent and

ups tream flows to the oily water sewer. Solids and hydrocarbon loadings to the oily

water sewer must also be evaluated. Storm water must be evaluated for oil and grease and solids loading as well as toxics.

In identifying and evaluating pollution preventi on opportunities, the Permittee must consider the following:

• All reasonably expected activities and conditions, such as normal operations, maintenance, and other ancillary activities; equipment failure; improper operation; upsets, accidents, spills, leak s; and natural events such as rainfall, snowfall, etc.

• All areas of the refinery with potential to generate water pollutants including process units, raw material and product storage, handling and transfer facilities, material handling areas, maintenance areas, solid and hazardous waste storage,

tre atment, and disposal, and storm water systems.

The following are examples of pollution prevention strategies that may warrant
evaluation:

• Improving and/or establishing new management practices and standard oper ating procedures addressing: increased training or supervision; improvements in inventory control, materials and waste handling, general operations, and housekeeping; preventive maintenance; and remedial measures

• Process or equipment modifications, includ ing re

- engineering processes to use less toxic input materials or to utilize by

- products

• Material substitution

• Reducing material inputs

• Recycle/reuse of refinery waste, by

- products, or process materials and fluidsPage 67 of 67 Permit No. WA0000 76 1

• Application of water conservation meth ods, including water reuse

• Waste segregation and separation

• Alternative and/or enhanced treatment technology, including upstream treatment of pollutants

Cross

- media shift of pollutants should be avoided, unless a clear net environmental
benefit results a nd compliance with standards applicable to other media or management programs would be maintained.

4. Prioritization & Selection of Pollution Prevention Opportunities

The plan must prioritize pollution prevention opportunities. The Permittee must provide t heir rationale for how the pollution prevention opportunities are prioritized. In addition to technical and economical feasibility, other factors may influence ranking of opportunities and should be included in the discussion. These factors may
include c apital projects planned or ongoing at the refinery that will provide a benefit to environmental media other than water, corresponding reduction in safety risks, etc. Projects that achieve the highest environmental benefit must have greater priority.

In p rioritizing and selecting pollution prevention opportunities, the Permittee must give preference first to those that eliminate, avoid, or reduce the generation of water pollutants at the source, second to those that recycle or reuse the pollutants, and thi rd to those that provide at

- source or near

- source treatment to remove pollutants or render them less toxic or harmful. In ranking opportunities, the Permittee must also consider pollutant loading and toxicity and the potential to achieve the greatest redu ction with respect to time and costs.

The Permittee is expected to establish reasonable priorities and schedules for implementation to achieve the greatest reduction in pollutant quantity and toxicity, as well as for management and fiscal necessity.