# Based on intermediate analysis workbook comparing 2011NEIv1 and 2008 NEI and 2008-based projected values: # OECA_2011v6_vs_2007v5_interediate_analysis.xlsx # Goal was to have future 2011-based emissions match 2008 projections. Not ideal, but short of recomputing CD based on... # several hundred pages of web links (some are below), feel that consistency w/ 2008 is best short-term goal. # Long-term: go through CDs (including NUMEROUS amendments) at UNIT-level for each one.

# References: # http://media.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/11/06/102732U.pdf

# http://yosemite.epa.gov/opa/admpress.nsf/2467feca60368729852573590040443d/f36d6abac73ce5de 8525706f006819d3!OpenDocument # http://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/2005/September/05_enrd_448.html # http://www2.epa.gov/sites/production/files/documents/fourthamendedsunoco-cd.pdf # http://www2.epa.gov/enforcement/cases-and-settlements # Probably most useful link: http://www2.epa.gov/enforcement/petroleum-refinery-national-case-results

# THIS PACKET EXPORTED FROM: /garnet/home/rhc/2011v6/mk_CONTROL_OECA_consent_decrees_from_JoshD_2011v6.sas 13139,,CO,,97.07,100,100,,,Y,A,553611,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 13139,,NOX,,13.36,100,100,,,Y,A,553611,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 1350 tons per year. 13139,,SO2,,11.74,100,100,,,Y,A,553611,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined SO2 emission over multiple facilities reduced by 2250 tons per year. 17119,,NOX,,89.02,100,100,,,Y,A,3954911,,,,,! Facility Group=CONOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10000 tons per year. 17119,,NOX,,14.31,100,100,,,Y,A,7940411,,,,,! Facility Group=CONOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10000 tons per year. 18089,,CO,,98.37,100,100,,,Y,A,8163611,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 18157,,CO,,96.51,100,100,,,Y,A,4917411,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 19083,,CO,,98.18,100,100,,,Y,A,5384011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 19083,,NOX,,62.35,100,100,,,Y,A,5384011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 1350 tons per year. 19113,,CO,,99.09,100,100,,,Y,A,3939911,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 19113,,CO,,97.76,100,100,,,Y,A,3941711,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 19113,,NOX,,34.4,100,100,,,Y,A,3941711,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 1350 tons per year. 19113,,SO2,,21.37,100,100,,,Y,A,3941711,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined SO2 emission over multiple facilities reduced by 2250 tons per year. 19135,,CO,,94.32,100,100,,,Y,A,12806011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 19135,,NOX,,25.6,100,100,,,Y,A,12806011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 1350 tons per year.19153,,CO,,97.59,100,100,,,Y,A,8120911,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 19153,,NOX,,29.76,100,100,,,Y,A,8120911,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 1350 tons per year. 19153,,SO2,,94.38,100,100,,,Y,A,8120911,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined SO2 emission over multiple facilities reduced by 2250 tons per year. 19193,,CO,,97.23,100,100,,,Y,A,2943011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 19193,,NOX,,0.18,100,100,,,Y,A,2943011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 1350 tons per year. 20173,,CO,,95.9,100,100,,,Y,A,5603511,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 22075,,NOX,,54.91,100,100,,,Y,A,7203711,,,,,! Facility Group=CONOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10000 tons per year. 22089,,SO2,,88.3,100,100,,,Y,A,7449311,,,,,"! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined SO2 emissions over multiple facilities, reduced by 16000 tons per year." 22097,,NOX,,16.6,100,100,,,Y,A,8240011,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 4000 tons per year. 22097,,SO2,,60.19,100,100,,,Y,A,8240011,,,,,"! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined SO2 emissions over multiple facilities, reduced by 16000 tons per year." 34015,,PM10,,58.35,100,100,,,Y,A,7201311,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 34015,,PM10-PRI,,58.35,100,100,,,Y,A,7201311,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 34015,,PM25-PRI,,58.35,100,100,,,Y,A,7201311,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 34015,,PM2_5,,58.35,100,100,,,Y,A,7201311,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 34039,,NOX,,0.07,100,100,,,Y,A,7903711,,,,,! Facility Group=CONOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10000 tons per year. 37051,,CO,,96.22,100,100,,,Y,A,8073211,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 37183,,CO,,96.83,100,100,,,Y,A,7776711,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 39095,,NOX,,41.62,100,100,,,Y,A,7319811,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 4500 tons per year. 39095,,PM10,,27.26,100,100,,,Y,A,7319811,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 39095,,PM10-PRI,,27.26,100,100,,,Y,A,7319811,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 39095,,PM25-PRI,,27.26,100,100,,,Y,A,7319811,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 39095,,PM2_5,,27.26,100,100,,,Y,A,7319811,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year.39113,,CO,,99.75,100,100,,,Y,A,7996011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 39113,,NOX,,11.93,100,100,,,Y,A,7996011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 1350 tons per year. 39113,,SO2,,44.23,100,100,,,Y,A,7996011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined SO2 emission over multiple facilities reduced by 2250 tons per year. 39149,,CO,,96.76,100,100,,,Y,A,7420311,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year. 39149,,NOX,,7.49,100,100,,,Y,A,7420311,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 1350 tons per year. 40019,,NOX,,29.81,100,100,,,Y,A,8071911,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 4000 tons per year. 40143,,NOX,,67.24,100,100,,,Y,A,8402711,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 4500 tons per year. 40143,,PM10,,45.99,100,100,,,Y,A,8402711,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 40143,,PM10-PRI,,45.99,100,100,,,Y,A,8402711,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 40143,,PM25-PRI,,45.99,100,100,,,Y,A,8402711,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 40143,,PM2_5,,45.99,100,100,,,Y,A,8402711,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 42045,,NOX,,82.49,100,100,,,Y,A,4724811,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 4500 tons per year. 42045,,PM10,,76.29,100,100,,,Y,A,4724811,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 42045,,PM10-PRI,,76.29,100,100,,,Y,A,4724811,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 42045,,PM25-PRI,,76.29,100,100,,,Y,A,4724811,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 42045,,PM2_5,,76.29,100,100,,,Y,A,4724811,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 42101,,NOX,,21.38,100,100,,,Y,A,6652211,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 4500 tons per year. 42101,,PM10,,52.86,100,100,,,Y,A,6652211,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 42101,,PM10-PRI,,52.86,100,100,,,Y,A,6652211,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 42101,,PM25-PRI,,52.86,100,100,,,Y,A,6652211,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 42101,,PM2_5,,52.86,100,100,,,Y,A,6652211,,,,,! Facility Group=SUNOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissionsover multiple facilities reduced by 300 tons per year. 47157,,CO,,97.78,100,100,,,Y,A,5723011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined CO emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10900 tons per year.47157,,SO2,,33.94,100,100,,,Y,A,5723011,,,,,! Facility Group=CARGILL: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined SO2 emission over multiple facilities reduced by 2250 tons per year. 48039,,NOX,,60.24,100,100,,,Y,A,5019011,,,,,! Facility Group=CONOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10000 tons per year. 48167,,PM10,,28.88,100,100,,,Y,A,4033811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48167,,PM10-PRI,,28.88,100,100,,,Y,A,4033811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48167,,PM25-PRI,,28.88,100,100,,,Y,A,4033811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48167,,PM2_5,,28.88,100,100,,,Y,A,4033811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48167,,SO2,,62.67,100,100,,,Y,A,4033811,,,,,"! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined SO2 emissions over multiple facilities, reduced by 16000 tons per year." 48233,,NOX,,16.38,100,100,,,Y,A,4861611,,,,,! Facility Group=CONOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10000 tons per year. 48341,,PM10,,60.62,100,100,,,Y,A,4030511,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48341,,PM10-PRI,,60.62,100,100,,,Y,A,4030511,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48341,,PM25-PRI,,60.62,100,100,,,Y,A,4030511,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48341,,PM2_5,,60.62,100,100,,,Y,A,4030511,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48355,,NOX,,23.02,100,100,,,Y,A,4929811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 4000 tons per year. 48355,,PM10,,20.82,100,100,,,Y,A,4929811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48355,,PM10-PRI,,20.82,100,100,,,Y,A,4929811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48355,,PM25-PRI,,20.82,100,100,,,Y,A,4929811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48355,,PM2_5,,20.82,100,100,,,Y,A,4929811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 48355,,SO2,,57.2,100,100,,,Y,A,4929811,,,,,"! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined SO2 emissions over multiple facilities, reduced by 16000 tons per year." 53073,,NOX,,38.48,100,100,,,Y,A,4958311,,,,,! Facility Group=CONOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10000 tons per year. 6013,,NOX,,2.09,100,100,,,Y,A,6480811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 4000 tons per year. 6013,,PM10,,36.2,100,100,,,Y,A,6480811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6013,,PM10-PRI,,36.2,100,100,,,Y,A,6480811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year.6013,,PM25-PRI,,36.2,100,100,,,Y,A,6480811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6013,,PM2_5,,36.2,100,100,,,Y,A,6480811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6037,,NOX,,52.74,100,100,,,Y,A,5682211,,,,,! Facility Group=CONOCO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 10000 tons per year. 6037,,PM10,,34.53,100,100,,,Y,A,6500811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6037,,PM10-PRI,,34.53,100,100,,,Y,A,6500811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6037,,PM25-PRI,,34.53,100,100,,,Y,A,6500811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6037,,PM2_5,,34.53,100,100,,,Y,A,6500811,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6095,,NOX,,25.03,100,100,,,Y,A,14217311,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined NOx emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 4000 tons per year. 6095,,PM10,,41.51,100,100,,,Y,A,14217311,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6095,,PM10-PRI,,41.51,100,100,,,Y,A,14217311,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6095,,PM25-PRI,,41.51,100,100,,,Y,A,14217311,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6095,,PM2_5,,41.51,100,100,,,Y,A,14217311,,,,,! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined PM emissions over multiple facilities reduced by 526 tons per year. 6095,,SO2,,70.96,100,100,,,Y,A,14217311,,,,,"! Facility Group=VALERO: OECA consent decree information compiled by Josh 3/24/09: Combined SO2 emissions over multiple facilities, reduced by 16000 tons per year."